Aviation Regulation Bill, 2000 [Seanad]: Committee Stage.
Contributions 1,004–1,252 of 1,252. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 5 parts.
No. 24 of 2000 ›
I move amendment No. 56:
In page 20, paragraph (d), line 31, after “authority” to insert “at the regulated airports”.
The paragraph provides for the operating and other costs incurred by the airport authority at the airport and my amendment proposes that the wording should be "operating and other costs incurred by the airport authority at the regulated airports".
Comment on this
All we need do is insert the word "regulated" before the word "airport". I am sure the Deputy is aware there can be only the regulated airports.
Comment on this
Yes and abroad. The Bill does not state it is a national one. The wording "at the regulated airports" would cover the position perfectly.
Comment on this
This Part applies to any airport in the State open to commercial traffic and having an annual passenger——
Comment on this
There is nothing wrong with it, as the Bill states that Part 3 applies to any airport in the State.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 57:
In page 20, paragraph (f), line 34, to delete “its” and substitute “the”.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 60 is an alternative to amendment No. 59 and they may be taken together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendmentNo. 59:
In page 20, paragraph (i), line 42, after “such” to insert “national and”.
One amendment proposes the insertion of the words "national and" and the other proposes the insertion of the words "national or".
Comment on this
The words "national and" are correct as they apply to national and international obligations.
Comment on this
Yes. The suggestion for this amendment has come from Aer Rianta on the basis that it has many ceremonial functions.
Comment on this
I move amendmentNo. 61:
In page 20, between lines 42 and 43, to insert the following:
"(j) the contribution of the airport to balanced regional development,
(k) the provision of adequate and proper facilities for disabled passengers using the airport, and
(l) the promotion and development of air traffic at airports under the aegis of the Commission.”.
We are adding to the regulatory objectives of the airports.
Comment on this
Yes and I have included those words in the amendment. I accept Deputy Stagg's amendment. We cannot include that wording often enough in the Bill. Paragraph (k) provides for the provision of adequate and proper facilities for disabled passengers using theairport.
Comment on this
Paragraph (l) provides for the promotion and development of air traffic at airports under the aegis of the commission, in other words, to give it a promotional role, which is understood, but it is important that it be inserted. Given that we have included paragraph (c) which provides for the efficient and effective use of all resources by the airport authority, why can the provisions of paragraphs (k) and (l) not be included?
Comment on this
Aer Rianta has adopted by-laws in regard to facilities for disabled passengers or for proper facilities, which empowers the airlines to provide them.
Comment on this
Yes, but the inclusion of paragraph (k) would enable the regulator to go down and see——
Comment on this
The inclusion of that provision would cut across Aer Rianta's remit. We have included a provision in regard to balanced regional development.
Comment on this
Ensuring there are adequate and proper facilities for disabled passengers using the airport is Aer Rianta's job. We would cut across its remit if we included the provision in paragraph (k). It is its job to adopt by-laws in that respect, which it has done. I get letters from people who have travelled with a particular airline, which I shall not name——
Comment on this
I did not say that name, the Deputy did. He will be issued with a writ next week. Aer Rianta has large ads in the newspapers stating that it has adopted such by-laws.
Comment on this
It has adopted the by-laws, but the provision in paragraph (k) should be included to ensure the supervision and implementation of them.
Comment on this
That is not part of the regulator's remit. We must bear that in mind. The regulator's remit relates to airport charges, licences for travel agents and so on. The provision in paragraph (k) is proper and a fine thought, but it comes under the remit of Aer Rianta not the commission.
Comment on this
For example, let us look at the other aspirations such as the efficient and effective use of all resources.
Comment on this
That is the job of Aer Rianta because it is running the airport. Where is the difference?
Comment on this
The others are not covered in this Bill; they are covered in Aer Rianta's business. The other matter, the efficient and effective use of resources, is economic. One can say what one likes about Aer Rianta but it has certainly put up a show with regard to facilities——
Comment on this
It has with its by-laws which are strictly enforced. I keep getting letters and I send them back to the airlines concerned. With regard to airport users, the word is not "equal"; people who are disabled are less equal. It is Aer Rianta's business and that is why I am not inclined to put this in. Aer Rianta is doing a good job so why double up on what is already the task of the airport management?
Comment on this
I will withdraw the amendment and the Minister might take a look at where it might conflict.
Comment on this
There have been instances where there have been differences between airlines and the airport authority about disabled people on board aircraft.
Comment on this
I mean where there are people in transit. I was at an airport on one occasion when the incapacitated person was left on board for nearly two hours. All other passengers were in the terminal building. That is one of the problems that would——
Comment on this
The airline denied it had responsibility. It said it was the responsibility of the airport authority. That is what I heard from officials of the airline.
Comment on this
However, if the airport has a charge, as the Minister suggests, and the commissioner will have that charge, he is charging for facilities for the airport. The airline will pay a charge to use the airport. Therefore, the airport will have continuing responsibility for a disabled person's comfort.
Comment on this
We are getting mixed up. When one is on the airplane, be one able bodied or disabled, one is the responsibility of the airline that owns the airplane. When one is on the ground in the airport, Aer Rianta has by-laws regarding how one should be treated. Let us say there is a company called Smart Flight - I use that name because there is no such company - and one is a disabled person using one of its airplanes, it is up to the airline, under the by-laws introduced by Aer Rianta, to see that one is properly brought to or from one's airplane.
Some firms impose a fee. I received a letter last Wednesday or Thursday from somebody who was asked to pay a fee for a wheelchair to be provided to bring her to the airplane. She would not pay it and I believe she was right. There was an altercation about it. It is on the basis of such incidents that Aer Rianta made the by-laws. Now the airlines must provide wheelchairs, walking frames or whatever else one might need.
Comment on this
It is still not clear. While Aer Rianta might have introduced by-laws to suit itself, it still imposes a charge on the airline or the user.
Comment on this
No, it does not. It is the airline. To date, the complaints I have received have been about a particular airline which seeks to impose a charge. That is regrettable. It is a charge for the use of the wheelchair.
Comment on this
The amendment deserves a little more consideration that simply saying the matter is already dealt with. I have received a number of complaints from people——
Comment on this
——who have, with the best will in the world, encountered difficulties. Often the difficulties are caused by lack of forethought and any opportunity to remind those who are fortunate enough to have full use of their faculties that there are people who need additional facilities is worth taking. It is worth taking the opportunity to make that point, particularly with regard to Dublin Airport where so much renovation and expansion is taking place and where there is great pressure to meet deadlines of one type or other. Unfortunately, there have been problems.
I had the opportunity to escort a man in a wheelchair to England for treatment. The contrast between Dublin Airport and Gatwick was marked. In Gatwick there were motorised vehicles——
Comment on this
They were provided by the airport. There were helplines everywhere. If one arrives at any point of access to the airport one simply uses one of the red telephones. The person on the other end asks one's location and then says: "We will be with you in a minute". Then a trolley arrives. I felt grandly looked after because I was with the person who was in the wheelchair. I was given the lift as well, of course, to escort the person.
I could see there were staff employed simply to look after people with disabilities who arrived at the airport and needed extra help. The people might just be aged and not have enough energy to walk the necessary distance or they might rely on a wheelchair or a crutch. The assistance was so much part of the policy that the difference struck me forcibly when we returned. We were just given a wheelchair when we arrived at Dublin Airport. That was all. It was grand in so far as it would have been extremely difficult if we had not been given the wheelchair but there was a big difference between that and the attitude I encountered across the water. Over there one was provided with what was basically a car - there was a fleet of them - which were driven around the airport by drivers who were well trained in assisting people with different disabilities.
Any opportunity that is taken to remind people of that standard should be grasped in this Bill or in the by-laws.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would give the committee a short summary of the section. The words used in it refer to the single airport. Subsection (d) refers to the level of income of an airport authority from airport charges at the airport. Deputy Stagg and the Minister agreed that costs would be shared by the airports.
Comment on this
I understand that, but the "level of income. . . from airport charges at the airport" is a stark phrase in the section.
Comment on this
It refers to each particular airport as it arises. I understand the Deputy's point but there is nothing untoward, devious or complicated in the provision. It refers to the charges at each particular airport as it arises.
Comment on this
I am delighted the Minister said that is her intention. I wanted to find out her intention in this area.
Comment on this
I note the section refers to the operation of cost effective airports which meet the requirements of users. There was an attempt to insert "users" earlier.
Comment on this
A question mark still hangs over it. People will want to know if this development will help or hinder individuals who may no longer be airport users, such as retired staff of Aer Lingus and particularly Aer Rianta. Will the regulator take any cognisance of the financial needs of retired staff who lobbied the Minister?
Comment on this
I do not know if it will exacerbate the position, but it is not relevant to this Bill. The regulator will regulate charges.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 62:
In page 21, subsection (1), line 2, to delete "the".
These textual amendments were suggested by the Parliamentary Counsel.
Comment on this
I move amendment No 63:
In page 21, subsection (3)(b), line 11, after “of” to insert “such”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 65:
In page 21, subsection (4)(b), line 21, after “otherwise” to insert “or”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 66:
In page 21, subsection (5)(c), line 32, to delete “order” and substitute “determination”.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 70 is related to amendment No. 69 while amendment No. 71 is an alternative and amendment No. 72 is consequential. Therefore, amendments Nos. 69 to 72, inclusive, may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendmentNo. 69:
In page 23, before section 38, to insert the following new section:
"38.-An airport authority or an airport user shall be entitled to appeal to the High Court against any determination or decision of the Commission, or any party thereof, on a point of law or fact.".
As it stands, the Aviation Regulation Bill, 2000, only provides for a limited appeal mechanism based on judicial review. The point has been made that it is recognised in many other jurisdictions that where independent economic regulation applies, subjecting a regulator's decision to judicial review alone is not satisfactory and does not provide adequate safeguards for protecting the interests of the regulated entity and the airport users.
Comment on this
Correct. The provision of a statutory appeal would provide the affected parties with a forum to resolve any issues in relation to representations if they feel the commission has not addressed these representations adequately. There is precedent for such a course of action in Ireland and elsewhere. An appeal on merit is provided in similar legislation regulating other Irish business sectors. For example, there is such a provision in section 29 of the Electricity Regulation Act, 1999.
Comment on this
Yes. Another point put in support of the amendment is that in the UK the regulatory procedure provides——
Comment on this
Yes. In the UK, the regulatory procedure provides the Monopolies and Mergers Commission, a body equivalent to the Irish Competition Authority, with an important role in the regulatory framework. In circumstances where regulators and utility companies cannot agree a licence modification, that is, to give effect to a new charge or price control, the matter is referred to the MMC for adjudication.
Comment on this
I know. There is no reason that aviation regulation should not be treated differently, particularly because of the importance of economic regulation, its impact on airport authorities' income and the costs incurred by airline users. Provision should be made in the Aviation Regulation Bill for an administrative appeal by way of a High Court hearing.
Most importantly, a statutory provision for an administrative appeal process is consistent with the Minister's recommendation in her White Paper on Government and accountability, to which she referred earlier. It categorically states that, in certain circumstances, an appeal on merits may be desirable.
Comment on this
This does not concur with the framework of the legislation which does not contain any provision for an appeal on its merits.
Comment on this
Deputy Higgins covered most of the important points. I suggest that putting a final decision making process in place without a form of appeal is open to challenge. A judicial review is not an appeal. It only allows one to ascertain that a decision was made in accordance with law. It is not about the decision itself. The Bill does not allow any form of appeal and my advice is that our airports and their users would be unique in Europe in that they could not appeal in any way a regulator's decision. I am conscious of the danger of a wide open merit appeal system.
Comment on this
In such circumstances, the courts would become the regulator because every case would be referred to the courts. Most of the users we are discussing are well heeled and articulate. They would be capable of going to the courts on every case and we do not want that to happen. However, our limited proposal would meet the case without creating such a situation, although it may need more consideration.
Comment on this
This issue was the largest debating point in the Department. I was for many years a member of urban and county councils and I am aware that if a person cannot pay his or her water rates, he or she can appeal. There is an appeal system in most areas and that is correct. That is because one is dealing with ordinary consumers. If a person does not get a medical card, he or she can appeal to the chief executive officer of the health board. That is the way the appeal system works. It does little good much of the time, but at least there is an appeal mechanism. The same applies to social welfare and one goes to the appeals officer with one's case.
Comment on this
It can be for one house or 400 houses. There is an appeal mechanism. That is very much geared to the person making the appeal, the consumer, who wants his or her rights. It is usually a small consumer. Of course, it can be a large one if it is a large planning application but with social welfare, water rates or any of those things, it is a small consumer. Generally, the appeal concerns the right of the consumer to his or her civic rights.
We are not dealing with that type of person here but with entities, to use the Deputy's word, which are well funded and have an amount of finance. They are not hardship cases with which most appeals deal. In addition, this is not a consumer Bill.
Those points were on my mind when I read all this and when I went back to the Bill. We included an appeals panel in the electricity regulation Bill. It was included in the Bill from the start. The panel operates in a relatively limited way. It is circumscribed. The concern I have about the whole appeal system is that on the one hand, I am concerned about the right to appeal, as a basic right. When I think of appeals, I think of people who are being hard done by and people who have not got their rights. I do not think of people who do not want to pay.
How does one then circumscribe and limit it? How do we ensure there is not a run to the courts by people who can well afford to pay each time a determination is made? I dare not mention names but the Deputy knows what I am talking about. That is what would happen. How does one combine all of that?
Comment on this
Yes, but the fact they are big, or large - there are many words to describe them, although small or weak would not be two——
Comment on this
Because they are big, strong or powerful, we would be wrong to take away what is nearly seen as a natural right to a forum to which they can appeal. The electricity one is a type of forum for appeal. The British model where they go to the equivalent of our——
Comment on this
We have the Irish Competition Authority which is almost exactly the same as their Mergers Commission. It is strange that the Mergers Commission, given its name, is the body to which one has to go in England. The Irish Competition Authority is a better named authority for an appeal body. Our Irish Competition Authority is not set up in the same complicated and detailed way as the British Mergers Commission. We need to find some mechanism because I think the Bill will be challenged if we do not. I am not saying we should do things because we are afraid of a challenge but I do not want to see the Bill fall or held up.
Comment on this
I share the natural justice theme about which the Deputy speaks but my concern is that that outlet would be used forever.
Comment on this
That would be my concern. I remember having the same debate in the Department about how to manage an appeal.
Comment on this
For those who just do not want to pay. That is a big worry. This came up last week, before Christmas, yesterday and today.
Comment on this
The experience has been that once they go through the appeal process once or twice, do not win and have to pay a lot of money, the boards of such organisations will say "stop doing this".
Comment on this
It does not stop some people who are always running to the courts. It is a very dicey business.
Comment on this
We have bandied the word "big" about because airlines and the airline business tends to be big by its nature but one should look, for example, at how vulnerable they are. We think of the big two in this country and so on. One should look at how volatile the industry is. Only a few weeks ago, Trans Aer went wallop.
Comment on this
TWA went into bankruptcy for a third time today. It is amalgamating with American Airlines.
Comment on this
There have been three casualties in the United Kingdom in the past ten weeks alone. From the point of view of what we are dealing with here and given that many of these are big and vulnerable, charges and other related issues can be crucial to their existence.
Comment on this
They can also be crucial to keeping Aer Rianta commercial so that it would not become a basket case.
Comment on this
I fully agree with the Minister. She made the argument that we have many appeal mechanisms running across the spectrum and yet this area is devoid of any mechanism or forum which adds substance to the point made by Deputy Stagg.
Comment on this
Going back to what Deputy Stagg said, one does not want every decision to go the appeals——
Comment on this
There are two issues there. First, one does not want to completely hamstring the regulator and, second, one does not want to clog up the courts. There should be some formal mechanism. That is the reason we put down the amendments.
Comment on this
The amendments, as put down, are very detailed. We read them all. Both the officials know that I have wrestled with this because I am a believer in an appeal system but that would be based on my record in dealing with hardship cases rather than endowed ones.
Comment on this
Is the Minister at liberty to say how strong were the representations she received from different airport users, for example, Aer Rianta and Aer Lingus?
Comment on this
Yes, it stated the case strongly for an appeal because it was afraid the Bill would be blocked.
Comment on this
That is a danger. I did not get representations but they could have been made to the Department. I came to this purely from the point of view of being concerned about the natural justice right of an appeal system. That is the way I approached it. I even sat down again at lunch time and thought it through again. The courts do not want to be the regulator.
Comment on this
It has been suggested by some groups that maybe the Committee of Public Accounts, or a committee which has the extensive powers it has, would be in a position to examine an appeal. I know that might sound far-fetched to the Minister.
Comment on this
I would not bring it to the Committee of Public Accounts, but I thank the Deputy for the suggestion.
Comment on this
No. I was trying to wrestle with the need for an appeal and how one would frame an appeal system.
Comment on this
The decision making there was huge in terms of licenses to supply energy and power. It is of major importance.
Comment on this
Yes. It is of major concern. By contrast, this is more modest. In view of what has been said, we must look more widely at what is involved. We will look at the ESB, the ODTR and UK practice.
Comment on this
We mentioned the accountability of the regulator, the regulatory system and the democratic deficit. If we do not allow an appeal in this instance we are granting huge authority.
Comment on this
That will happen if we simply provide for an open merit test. Other models can be used.
Comment on this
This is a very weighty matter. It was important to hear the views of people. They accord with mine. However, it is difficult to devise a satisfactory format.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would look at the Competition Authority to see if it could play a role.
Comment on this
There is a need to provide for some kind of appeals mechanism. The Department of Agriculture, Food and Rural Development is considering the possibility of drafting a separate Bill to deal with appeals arising in agriculture. The first question to be decided is to whom does one appeal?
Comment on this
An independent body was established in respect of social welfare appeals. Should an appeal to that kind of body be provided for and how independent can it be, given the different interests involved? Should an appeal be allowed to the Minister? If so, the way to proceed is by providing for it under certain sections of the Bill.
Comment on this
There is no point in establishing a regulator if everybody is going to appeal to the Minister.
Comment on this
That is the point. If a regulator is to be established there is no need for judicial provisions. In that regard I would delete sections 38 and 39 because judicial review can occur in any event. It is not a question that people will not have the opportunity to raise objections. The Bill provides for procedures in that regard prior to the making of a determination. The commissioner must take views and accept or reject them. People will be afforded the opportunity to make their views known. It is for the Minister to decide if it is necessary to provide that another person may examine an issue where there is no agreement. I am not sure if it would be wise to interfere in this aspect.
Comment on this
We will reconsider the whole appeals mechanism and take account of the Chairman's point of view. Following that we will introduce further proposals.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 73:
In page 23, subsection (1), lines 13 and 14, after "determination" to insert ", a review of a determination".
In the drafting of page 24, line 31, unusual English is used.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 74:
In page 24, subsection (1)(e), line 31, after “considers” to insert “that”.
This is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 75:
In page 25, subsection (3)(b), line 17, before “aviation” to insert “airport or”.
The substitute term reflects more accurately the responsibility of the commission to both Aer Rianta and the IAA.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 76:
In page 25, subsection (3)(c), line 25, after “records” to insert “relating to the provision of airport or aviation services”.
This again refers to the position of Aer Rianta and the IAA.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 77 and 78 are related and both may be taken together. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 77:
In page 25, subsection (3)(d), lines 28 and 29, to delete “books, documents and records” and substitute “such books, documents or records”.
This is a technical amendment to include the word "such" before "books".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 78:
In page 25, subsection (3)(e), line 32, to delete “the said records” and substitute “such books, documents or records”.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 79 is consequential on amendment No. 80 and both may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 79:
In page 25, between lines 33 and 34, to insert the following:
"(f) require the person to maintain such books, documents or records for such period of time, as may be reasonable, as the authorised officer directs,”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 81:
In page 25, lines 45 to 47, and in page 26, lines 1 and 2, to delete subsection (4) and substitute the following:
"(4) This section applies to the following persons:
(a) an airport authority,
(b) a supplier of aviation terminal services,
(c) any person responsible for the carriage of passengers, mail or freight by air or from an airport,
(d) a supplier of ground handling services,
(e) a tour operator or a travel agent,
(f) an organiser.”.
This is regrouping of earlier textual amendments. The wording of paragraph (c) is similar to the user interpretation mentioned earlier.
Comment on this
It is related to a summary conviction in the District Court. The next step up involves a big increase in monetary terms.
Comment on this
I move amendmentNo. 82:
In page 27, line 19, after "regulations." to insert "Such regulations shall not be made earlier than one month prior to the commencement of civil aviation operations at the relevant aerodrome.".
I do not wish to detain the committee, but the Minister will recall that on Committee Stage in the Seanad there was a long debate involving Senator Costello and Senator Taylor-Quinn in relation to Eircom Park and the objections by the Minister for Defence to it.
Comment on this
Correct. I tabled the amendment at the behest of the FAI. Since then there was a debate in the Seanad on the Government's intentions in relation to Baldonnel etc. The issue also arose at Question Time.
Comment on this
Effectively, I am trying to meet the anxieties of the FAI if a decision is made to go ahead with civil aviation operations at Baldonnel
Comment on this
I recall the debate in the Seanad. The issue had only emerged that day. We met the residents and I said I would reflect on what they said. I also said I would do one of two things, either reflect on Gormanstown or reflect on deletion. I considered the matter and I opted for deletion. Therefore, I propose the deletion of section 46.
Comment on this
I said I would oppose the section if it was not deleted as it was the cleanest move to make. It is the right thing to do. If there is a need to consider Gormanstown some time in the future, I am sure that can be done. I thank the Minister for listening to the people who spoke about this issue inside and outside the House and also for making the decision we requested at the time.
Comment on this
I also thank the Minister for keeping her commitment to revise the section. As I am sure she was aware from the debates in the Seanad and Dáil, it caused some concern. What provision can be made now for Gormanstown?
Comment on this
If Gormanstown is required, as I am sure it will be at some stage, it can be facilitated through amendment of one of the aviation Acts.
Comment on this
On 19 October, the Minister said the question remains whether this should be done by way of deletion of section 46 or confirmation that refers only to the potential introduction of pilot training at Gormanstown. I welcome the Minister's decision to delete the section. She promised in October to consider or reflect.
Comment on this
"Reflect" is a lovely word. I could see myself praying, although the Deputy obviously could not.
Comment on this
I have some difficulty putting the Minister in the role of Madonna, but I will take her word for it that it is what she aspires to. I am glad her reflection brought her to the decision she made. However, to some extent, the Minister for Defence beat her to it when he informed the Baldonnel airport liaison committee on 1 November that he would not consider the use of Baldonnel for civil aircraft "in the immediate future". I assume the Minister, Deputy O'Rourke, will not use any such phrase.
Comment on this
I told that committee I would write to it when a decision was made, but the Deputy can tell its members.
Comment on this
The Minister could write to the local Deputy and say that, arising from his strong representations, this decision has been made.
Comment on this
Will the Minister write to me, saying that in response to my strong representations and despite what her nephew said——
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 83:
In page 27, before section 47, to insert the following new section:
47.-Subsection (11) of section 5 of the Irish Aviation Authority Act, 1993, is repealed".
The section being repealed obliges the Irish Aviation Authority to reproduce in full in Iris Oifigiúil the text of any statutory instruments which are made. However, the IAA fully complies with the criteria laid down in the Statutory Instrument Act, 1947, as regards publication and circulation. It was an unnecessary duplication to publish the text again in Iris Oifigiúil. My view is that it did not want the expense of putting it into Iris Oifigiúil. However, I will not lose any sleep over it. The opportunity is being taken in the Bill to address the situation. The authority wants to put in a notice, but not the full text which it circulates.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 84:
In page 27, line 20, after "amended" to insert ", in paragraph 1(2) of the First Schedule, by the addition of 'the Commission for Aviation Regulation' and".
The purpose of the amendment is to bring the commission within the scope of the Freedom of Information Act.
Comment on this
The Department of Finance will do that. It already did it with the electricity regulator and the ODTR. It is the lead Department for the Freedom of Information Act.
Comment on this
Positive. The issue arose with regard to the electricity regulator. As soon as the Bill is enacted, the Department of Finance will make an order and it will be brought to Cabinet.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 86 is an alternative to amendment No. 85 and they are to be taken together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendmentNo. 85:
In page 27, before section 49, to insert the following new section:
49.-Section 23 of the Air Navigation and Transport (Amendment) Act, 1998, is amended by the substitution of the following for subsection (1)(b):
'(b) (i) to take all proper measures for the safety, security, management, control, regulation and operation of its airports,
(ii) to take all proper measures for the marketing and development of its airports having due regard to the contribution of the airports to the regions in which they are located, and
(iii) to promote investment in its airports having due regard to the contribution of the airports to the regions in which they are located,'.".
This amendment effectively seeks to insert a new section 23 with the substitution of the following for subsection (1)(b): to take all proper measures for the safety, security, management, control, regulation and operation of its airports, to take all proper measures for the marketing and development of its airports having due regard to the contribution of the airports to the regions in which they are located and to promote investment in its airports having due regard to the contribution of the airports to the regions in which they are located. Again, this is repetition of what we have already included in the Bill but it might be worthwhile to allay people’s fears.
Comment on this
It is definitely repeating for the third or fourth time what we either had in the Bill or inserted by way of amendment. It definitely cuts across Aer Rianta because that body has a corporate role in marketing and developing the State airports. This amendment may be well meaning but this is Aer Rianta's business and it does that work. We have already included the regional remit and other matters, so this is repeated. I am aware of Deputy Higgins's intentions but we have already included versions of this in a re-emphasised way and it is not needed in this regard.
Comment on this
This is such a dramatic change that people want, in the case of Shannon Airport, a continuation of the marketing fund because, after all, they are trying to increase services and use of the airport in the global market. That is distinct from Dublin Airport, which is totally full. Shannon is trying to get a major international freight service operating and that is expensive; to do so it needs the reassurance that is emphasised by this amendment.
Comment on this
It is Aer Rianta's business. We have included the regional remit and the contribution of the airport to its environs. That has already been included.
Comment on this
I take the Minister's point. We have dealt with this in practically every aspect of what we have addressed. It is a kind of Donnelly's sausages approach with the wrappers; those were the wrappers in this case. It is unnecessary in the context of the Bill now. I am not sure, even if we were to do this, that this is the appropriate place anyway. We were not sure where to put this in and the advice we got from the official side was that this was the appropriate place but the representation came in very late and it is the wrong place.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 87:
In page 27, paragraph (a), to delete lines 29 and 30 and substitute the following:
"subsections:
'(3A) (a) A person who contravenes this section shall be liable in damages to the operator of the aircraft for any losses including the costs of diversion occasioned by such contravention.
(b) Where a person is convicted of an offence under this section the court shall order him or her to pay to the operator of the aircraft the costs if any referred to in paragraph (a) of the subsection.
(3AA) Where an aircraft lands on the territory of the".
These amendments are well thought out. Although they are taken separately I will deal with them jointly because they all concern air rage. The Minister has met with those most directly affected by air rage, the pilots and cabin crews, and there is some indication of specific legislation. If we could get something definite on that I would be happy to withdraw the remaining amendments.
Comment on this
When this was mooted in June Deputies Stagg and Yates were emphatic about that. In early autumn I met IAPA, the Irish Airline Pilots Association, and a member of IMPACT about air rage. There was an article in the newspapers the following Sunday about it. Mr. Frank Feeney of IAPA wrote to me after that and said that IAPA was no longer looking for changes to the aviation Bill regarding aviation security because the IACO, an international body which deals with air regulation, will meet next April and will deal with air rage. I told the group which I met that the issue was so serious - in a recent incident a person broke into a cockpit - that I will wait for that meeting's deliberations and then come forward with a short Bill dealing with air rage.