We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

SELECT COMMITTEE ON SOCIAL AND FAMILY AFFAIRS

Social Welfare and Pensions Bill 2007: Committee Stage.

Contributions 147–295 of 295. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Social Welfare and Pensions Bill 2007
Enacted

No. 13 of 2007 ›

It was a totally outdated and outmoded concept. It goes back to the idea in the Constitution that a woman's place is in the home rearing a family. The Constitution was very much at fault because, obviously, somebody decided this was how this would apply. I support the campaign by the National Women's Council; I supported this long before it was mentioned. I have always spoken about this issue. What happened was unconstitutional. Recourse was through Articles 45 and 46. There were also the family-based arguments.

This would not stand up to any scrutiny now on a constitutional basis. A discrimination case would be very interesting if the National Women's Council embarked on one. It has indicated that it will do so. The Minister is carrying out a review of pensions. This problem must be central to that review, otherwise we may be faced with a situation where the legal ramifications and the associated costs might outstrip the cost of tackling it now or as soon as possible.

This matter relates to bank employees and many other workers, not just to civil servants. Many of those to whom I spoke indicated that they had felt like non-persons when they were removed from the system. When they tried to return, they were met with a number of obstacles designed to trip them up. It behoves us to try to tackle this problem because it is a relic of a time when equality was not a central issue. The equality agenda only came into focus later. It is crazy that people in the late 1960s and early 1970s were compelled to leave work. We have made great progress in the interim and people would never hark back to such authoritarian times.

In the review of pensions being undertaken by the Minister, I hope the question of how we might redress the wrong visited upon these people — in our name and in that of the State — many of whom do not have pensions will be addressed. The State was responsible for creating this situation and I hope the Minister will give an undertaking that it will be examined in the context of the review of pensions.

Comment on this

The Minister indicated that 88% of women over the age of 66 are receiving some payment in their own right. This implies that 12% of women are not in receipt of payments. Will the Minister indicate the exact figure for women who are not receiving payments at all?

On the marriage bar, I understand that during the period in question women in the public service were obliged to leave their employment. If they returned to employment in later years, the averaging rule kicked in. Has the Minister considered whether this rule is fair? The Statute of Limitations would probably debar the taking of an action in respect of this matter within the State. However, a case relating to discrimination may be brought to the European Union. Does the Minister have a view on whether the Government might enter into discussions with the National Women's Council on this issue in order to avoid the latter being obliged to take an action at European level?

As the Chairman stated, the dominant thinking in Ireland during the period in question was that the place for a woman was in the home. Even the Constitution seemed to imply this. Such thinking was obviously wrong. Women in the public service, because of the marriage bar and the then legal position, were compelled to give up work. However, others felt obliged to do so on foot of the social norms that prevailed. Therefore, this matter does not merely relate to those who worked in the public service. The Minister stated that some 1,400 gratuities were paid. Is he in a position to indicate the number of women who were affected by this matter and who are still alive?

Comment on this

I agree with the concept put forward by the Chairman and others that this type of thinking would not be acceptable today. Nevertheless, it is part of our social history and we must move on from it. As stated earlier, 88% of older women receive support through the social welfare system. This means that 231,000 of these women are in receipt of payments, while an estimated 31,000 fall outside the social welfare system. If one was to provide a full rate pension to this group, one would be talking about approximately €340 million plus the cost of increasing the pensions of those on reduced rates, which would be considerable. Those excluded are more than likely former public servants, self-employed persons, or the spouses of such people.

Some 68,000 women get the contributory State pension and an additional 45,000 get a reduced rate contributory State pension. Some 49,000 women receive the non-contributory State pension. Therefore, quite a large number of the people in question have moved on, through different mechanisms, to receive contributory or non-contributory State pensions. These people may have gone on to other employment or had their means reduced to a point where they would qualify for a non-contributory pension. I have not discussed the legal case with the National Women's Council as I am not sure it would be appropriate for me to do that. However, it has informed us of its thinking on the issue. We are looking at the broader issues in the context of the Green Paper on pensions which will be published some time in April.

Comment on this

I am not happy, but I know I will not make further progress this afternoon. The anomaly must be addressed. There is no use in the Minister for Finance putting his head in the sand and saying there is not a problem. There is a problem. I hope the issue will be given priority by the new Government when it comes to discuss pensions.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 9:

In page 5, before section 1, but in Part 1, to insert the following new section:

1. — The Minister for Social and Family Affairs shall, within 3 months of the commencement of this Act, lay before each House of the Oireachtas, a report on the introduction of a second-tier, employment-neutral, child income support payments to target child poverty levels.".

We have discussed this issue many times with the Minister and he has himself raised the idea of a second-tier, employment-neutral child income support payment to target child poverty levels. Perhaps he will now give us an update on the current state of play in that regard.

Comment on this

I am still committed to a second-tier payment and have commenced the process by increasing the qualified child allowance, formerly called the child dependant allowance, CDA. We have standardised all three of those payments to a single higher rate of €22 per week. As a result, we now have approximately one third of all children in receipt of additional CDAs as well as child benefit. Also, there has been a substantially higher increase in payments, amounting to €60 million this year, for the one third of children on the lower income scales. In that manner we have started the concept of a second tier.

The formalisation of a second tier is being looked at in the context of Towards 2016. The NESC has not yet formally signed off on its work in this area, but I hope that work will be finalised. The issue has proved more complicated than I first thought. The most recent budget provided €60 million extra to benefit 340,000 children by a new standard weekly increased CDA, bringing them all up to €22. This is in addition to the €140 million in child benefit. I have done what I can do for now. The CDAs had not been changed since 1994. I made the changes in response to the groups I met who argued strongly for such a change. I finally rejected the suggestion that it was a substantial disincentive to employment, a view I had accepted initially. Arguments pointed to the need for a second tier. We were able to cast these increases in a way that ensured they did not represent a disincentive to employment by increasing disregards, which had been the objection to increasing them since 1994.

Comment on this

When will we see something concrete given that tens of thousands of children are living in consistent poverty, regardless of the other measures that we have discussed at length in this committee? At a time of more wealth than any time in our history it is a national scandal that so many children suffer from consistent poverty. The proof of the pudding is that organisations like the Society of St. Vincent de Paul must step in so often to bail out families with small children to provide them with the basics to survive. I urge the Minister to target children and families experiencing severe deprivation. All of us see such families in our clinics. Last Saturday I met a woman in my clinic who only had €50 to buy food for two small children for a week. There was nowhere else for her to go — all other avenues were exhausted. Surely there should be a way for such a woman to get assistance. Even the community welfare officers are limited in what they can do in some of these cases. Her husband had a very low income, most of which went on rent. The woman is expecting another baby this week. Such families are experiencing extreme poverty and we do not seem to have a way to deal with it.

Comment on this

I have said dozens of times in the House and at this committee that child poverty is totally unacceptable at this stage of Ireland's development. For three years I have tried to target the available money at low-income families. In the recent budget, we allocated an additional €140 million to child benefit, which has doubled in six years and is now the second highest in the European Union. For the first time since 1994, I allocated an additional €60 million, which in previous years would have been pooled with the €140 million and gone to all children, to the bottom one third. While the top two thirds got €10, the bottom one third got €22. That is an attempt to target those funds and arguably that policy should have been pursued long ago.

Comment on this

Those of us on this side of the House have argued for it for years.

Comment on this

I take the point. However, the argument against it during those years was that people going back to work lost their CDA, which reduced the incentive to find work. That has now been dealt with through disregards, limits etc. It is no longer such a disincentive as it was in the past. I acknowledge that the Deputy, the Chairman and Deputy Seán Ryan have argued for it in my three years as Minister for Social and Family Affairs.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for his thoughts on the matter.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:

In page 5, before section 1, but in Part 1, to insert the following new section:

1.—The Minister for Social and Family Affairs shall, within 3 months of the commencement of this Act, lay before each House of the Oireachtas, a report on the introduction of direct payment of the qualified adult allowance to all qualified adults.".

When will the direct payment of the qualified adult allowance to all qualified adults be introduced?

Comment on this

A person in receipt of social welfare payment may claim an increase in respect of a dependent spouse or partner. The payment made in such circumstances, which is known as the qualified adult allowance, is normally paid as a single amount to the claimant. It has been possible for many years to split the payment and pay the spouse or partner separately, if the recipient so wishes or in cases of difficult family circumstances. The question of paying the qualified adult allowance directly to the qualified adult as the norm has been raised in a number of reports in recent years. The Deputies opposite have raised it with me on many occasions. It is argued that such a system would give the qualified adult a level of economic freedom. Significant changes have been made to the social welfare code over the years to ensure that as many people as possible qualify for social welfare payments in their own right. In the recent budget, I announced significant improvements in the rate of payment for qualified adults on State pensions, as well as important changes in the way such payments will be made in the future. The existing arrangements will be amended to provide that, in the case of new claimants to the State pension schemes, the qualified adult increases will be paid directly to the qualified adults. Customers who wish to be paid their pensions jointly will continue to be facilitated. The revised arrangements will apply to all new applicants to the State pension scheme, with effect from 24 September 2007.

The position regarding payments to people of working age is less straightforward. A separate payment may not be appropriate for certain schemes. Dependent spouses or partners can claim payments such as jobseeker's allowance in their own right, however, as long as they satisfy certain means requirements and conditions. The decision that was announced in the budget, which is provided for in this Bill, applies to the State contributory pension, the State transition pension and the State non-contributory pension. No decision to extend direct payments to other schemes has yet been taken, although the matter is being kept under constant review in the Department.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:

In page 5, before section 1, but in Part 1, to insert the following new section:

1.—The Minister for Social and Family Affairs shall, within 3 months of the commencement of this Act, lay before each House of the Oireachtas, a report on the progress to date in replacing the One Parent Family Payment with the new parental allowance for all low income families.".

We have been working on this proposal for some time. We are still waiting for the new parental allowance, which was first proposed a number of years ago, to be brought into operation. We note that the children of one-parent families, in particular, suffer higher levels of poverty. The substantial cost of child care also affects single parents who want to work because it makes it harder for them to access high-quality, affordable and accessible child care. Such people need support and assistance. Can the Minister update the committee on the proposed new parental allowance? The difficulties with the new allowance were outlined in the report that was published by the Minister last year.

Comment on this

Deputy Stanton's amendment, which relates to the impact of replacing the one-parent family payment with the new parental allowance, is worth considering. I am in favour of the abolition of the cohabitation restriction. We are providing for a new payment, but it is important that we do not create a host of poverty traps. As we introduce the new payment and abolish the cohabitation restriction, we should simultaneously address the other important programmes of assistance, such as the FÁS retraining and reskilling scheme. We need to remind lone parents and many other people that the best way out of poverty is to get a job.

As the cost of child care is prohibitive, we have to have a flexible and adaptable child care policy. FÁS needs to ensure that some of its programmes are available early in the morning or late in the evening so that lone parents can participate in them. A myriad of ancillary issues, such as transport services, have to be considered. We cannot make progress in this regard if we do not address these issues in unison. We should not try to introduce new provisions until we have examined in minute detail the impact of replacing the one-parent family payment with the new parental allowance. If we are taking one jump, we will have to take several jumps to ensure we do not create inequities and poverty traps within the system. We have to ensure that lone parents can make the productive contribution to society that many of them want to make.

Comment on this

Last year, we published a discussion document on proposals for supporting lone parents, which was broadly welcomed by Members. The paper made recommendations in education, training and child care. I concur with the Chairman that one must move on all these fronts at the same time. The paper also proposed the abolition of the cohabitation rule, an anachronism which will be addressed.

One of the proposals was to set the upper limit for the new social assistance payment, which is being developed, at €400 per week. To make progress on the proposals in the paper the upper limit on the one parent payment was increased from €293 to €375 in budget 2006. This marked substantial progress towards the limit recommended in the discussion document. I completed this element of the proposal by increasing the upper limit to €400 per week, as provided for in the Bill. As such, one of the key recommendations of the discussion document has been met.

A new social assistance payment is being developed by officials in my Department. It is my long-term aim to assist people to achieve financial independence. The payment is being prioritised and work on it is at an advanced stage. The Government recently requested the senior officials group on social inclusion to draw up an implementation plan focusing on the non-income recommendations in the discussion paper, including child care, training and education, and other parallel support systems which will be required.

The Department, in co-operation with FÁS, the National Children's Office and the Department of Education and Science, has agreed to test these proposals in an urban and a rural setting. The tests will focus on identifying and resolving practical and administrative issues, including the potential for creating new traps referred to by the Chairman. They will be carried out in advance of the scheme being rolled out nationwide and will allow for operational and logistical co-ordination between the relevant Departments and agencies to be considered and developed. They will also will facilitate the development of the new scheme. The overall reform is at an advanced stage.

Comment on this

How will the tests be administered? Will individuals be selected to take part?

Comment on this

The tests will be carried out on a voluntary basis. People will be asked to co-operate and a version of the new rules will be applied to existing claimants who have been invited to take part in the scheme. The Department would then determine how the rules impact on individual circumstances in a rural and an urban setting. The tests will have to be worked out professionally in consultation with FÁS, the Minister of State with special responsibility for children, my Department and other Departments with an input in child care and access to training and education.

The test will also focus on ensuring we do not create new traps. The overall objective is to remove the concept of lone parenthood from the social welfare system and replace it with income supports for children who live in low income families. This approach will cost much more than the current policy for the first years. This will be a progressive way to support children in low income families without the designation of lone parenthood or cohabitation. We have moved a long way and I hope the tests will deliver a positive outcome which will allow us to proceed.

Comment on this

When will the tests be carried out and how many people will be involved?

Comment on this

I am unable to give figures. Given that it will take the rest of the year to get the tests up and running, I will not rush into the Dáil with a Bill before the election.

Comment on this

Perhaps Deputy Stanton will introduce the legislation as Minister.

Comment on this

I understand the concept of income support is already standard in the UK. Is that where the Minister got his ideas?

Comment on this

The Deputy probably has it all on file somewhere. I made some speeches in my early days in this Department about cohabitation and how outdated it is.

Comment on this

I remember them. They were the Sunday speeches.

Comment on this

As a result, we ordered a discussion paper to be drawn up, and that is now the seminal document on lone parenthood. All the ideas are now contained in that.

Comment on this

We have moved a long way in three years.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 12:

In page 5, before section 1, but in Part 1, to insert the following new section:

1.—The Minister for Social and Family Affairs shall, within 3 months of the commencement of this Act, lay before each House of the Oireachtas, a report on the introduction of targeted social and community supports for young carers.".

I wish to put on record the need for support for young carers. The Minister will tell us there will be a discussion, a forum and God knows what else to do with carers. It will all come out in the wash. In the meantime, approximately 3,000 young carers need to be supported. I do not suggest giving them money, as the Minister indicated. Other supports are required. Many of these children are going to school and living in situations with parents, grandparents or peers. They are providing a lot of care and attention but they are not recognised by any Department in the State.

On more than one occasion, I asked the Minister for Education and Science and the Minister for Social and Family Affairs to get together and see if they can do anything to recognise or support these children and to put some form of programme in place so they could discuss their situation. To date, nothing appears to have been done. There was no reference to them in the budget nor is there in this Bill. The Minister will tell us they will be included in the big report on carers later in the year, to add to the reports on pensions, one-parent family payments and whatever other reports will be done. We await them with bated breath. In the meantime, these children are under pressure. Has the Minister advanced his thinking in any way on this issue?

Comment on this

The Minister will need a wheelbarrow to bring in that report on its own.

Comment on this

The Deputy has made some progress on this issue. He has been almost alone in fighting on this for a long time and he has not got much progress from me on it. However, in Towards 2016, there is a signed commitment between the Government and the social partners to undertake a study of the extent to—

Comment on this

Another study.

Comment on this

—which children undertake inappropriate care roles and to establish the degree to which the issue arises, and the level of impact it has on the lives of children concerned. The report, Caring Before Their Time, suggests there are 300 carers between the age of 15 and 17 years. That is too many. That is about as much progress as we have made on it.

In terms of income support for young carers, the respite care grant is payable from the age of 16 and a carer's allowance is payable from the age of 18. Some support is provided through the respite grant and the carer's allowance. The issue has been addressed by the social partners in Towards 2016.

Comment on this

It is amazing that in other countries they have gone way ahead of us in this area and have provided supports through social welfare, education and many other agencies that work together to provide an envelope of support around these children at a time they need it most. Having raised this issue over many years, I am disappointed that virtually nothing has been done, other than a commitment to another report. We know what is the problem, and it should not take that long to produce a report. A policy statement or some kind of action is required. The models are evident in other countries where it has already been done. I rest my case.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 14:

In page 5, before section 1, but in Part 1, to insert the following new section:

1.-The Minister for Social and Family Affairs shall, within 3 months of the commencement of this Act, lay before each House of the Oireachtas, a report on the success of the rent supplement and rental accommodation schemes.".

I note the number of people who have been accommodated under the rental accommodation scheme is quite small. It is considerably less than the numbers expected. The amount of money handed over by the Department of Social and Family Affairs to the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government is substantial but it does not appear to have been spent in recent years. It is just sitting there. Does the Minister plan to keep shovelling money into this Department? Nothing appears to have been done.

I wish to raise one other issue with the Minister. I do not know whether this has been discussed previously, namely, that some landlords refuse to take on tenants who are in receipt of a rent supplement. They do not want to know them and as good as tell them to go away. This is wrong and unfair because money is money. Perhaps the Minister has some thoughts on this. Will he state the position on the rental accommodation scheme? We should provide proper accommodation rather than pump more money into the private rental sector.

Comment on this

Will the Minister send committee members the most up-to-date documentation, including the current regulations, sent to superintendent community welfare officers in respect of the rental accommodation scheme? Will he outline in his response the current disregards for those seeking rent supplement and engaged in low-income work? At one stage, if one was working, one was not entitled to a rent supplement. Will the Minister outline the current position in this regard?

The rental accommodation scheme is an effort to try to accommodate people in rented accommodation rather than building local authority houses and providing houses for those in need. This is the proper approach. However, in my area, the northern end of Fingal, the scheme has not been a success. People are not prepared to make the commitments and, to a certain extent, responsibility to find accommodation rests with the applicant rather than the local authority. The scheme has not worked and the message should go to the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government that there are other ways of dealing with this. Ultimately, we want more local authority social housing.

Comment on this

Currently, 59,000 households are in receipt of rent supplement. There is a view that the scheme has developed beyond the original objective, which was to provide short-term assistance with accommodation.

Rental assistance arrangements are in operation in all local authority areas. The Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government has indicated that, at the end of January 2007, 3,006 tenants had been accommodated under the rental accommodation scheme, and a further 2,300 persons have been accommodated in social housing. When fully implemented, the rental accommodation scheme will enable the rent supplement scheme to meet its original objective, that is, providing short-term income supports.

Recent developments have given the rental accommodation scheme further impetus by providing additional units. The procurement of an additional 1,000 private units under the social partnership agreement, Towards 2016, is under way. The Affordable Homes Partnership is undertaking the procurement of up to 1,000 units of accommodation through public private partnership on long-term contracts on a regional basis. It is projected that, by the end of 2007, up to 10,000 tenants will have transferred from the rent supplement list to accommodation provided by local authorities either through the scheme or some other type of social housing. This should have an impact on the substantial number, 59,000, in the scheme at present.

To finance the initiative, €19 million was transferred from my Department to the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government in 2005. A further €19 million was transferred in 2006 and €24 million has been transferred in 2007. We pay the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government for the rent allowance scheme.

Comment on this

Not all the money is being spent by the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government. It is not spending anything near that much.

Comment on this

It is getting there.

Comment on this

What was the cost last year for the 59,000 people on rent supplement?

Comment on this

For 2006 the cost was €388 million. The 2007 figure is slightly more. I will get it for the Deputy.

Comment on this

What about the disregard? Will the Minister provide information on that?

Comment on this

I will get that for the committee.

Comment on this

Housing, especially emergency housing, is a major issue, with very small numbers of officers carrying out housing assessments. In my county, it can take months for a housing officer to go from one area to another and people claim rent supplement as they wait, often in poor accommodation. Housing is a major issue for lone parents of small children. We have all encountered people living in deplorable conditions.

I asked the Minister for his views on people refusing rent supplement but he did not respond. Are there any studies on why people might refuse rent supplement? Is there a social stigma or is it a fear of the taxman?

Comment on this

If someone has a legitimate expectation of getting a home for his family, why is it being decided that someone should go on the rent allowance scheme instead of getting a local authority house?

Comment on this

The rent allowance scheme was always meant to be temporary. It is not meant to be a permanent solution to housing needs. It is a rental support scheme. It is a way to move people from that temporary arrangement to a permanent one where accommodation can be secured for them.

Comment on this

They are still in rented accommodation.

Comment on this

Yes, but the accommodation is in the ownership of the local authority or on lease to it. It is a permanent solution. The person can stay in the house for a long time. The average period on rental support is three to four years. This is a more permanent solution and will secure permanent homes for people so that they can reside in them for as long as they wish.

Comment on this

People on the rental accommodation scheme in my local authority area are being forced off the housing list. Many have a long-term aspiration to have a home of their own. However, as they are they not retained on the local authority list, they will not be able to apply for suitable social housing if it arises.

Comment on this

The local authorities must manage this system. A person in receipt of rent allowance can apply to a local authority to get on the social housing list—

Comment on this

Persons are being taken off it.

Comment on this

—and in that way secure social housing.

Comment on this

There is no objection to going on the rental accommodation scheme provided that one is left on the local authority social housing list. The rental accommodation scheme only assures landlords of a continuing supply of money via a contract. The landlord is, therefore, in the dominant position.

A person on the rental accommodation scheme should be left on the local authority social housing list and considered for suitable accommodation if it arises. This measure must be rectified. Those on a housing authority list will never fulfil the dream of having their own home if it is not.

Comment on this

It is massaging the figures.

Comment on this

It should not be used for that. That would be a disgrace and no local authority should be allowed get away with that. I know my local authority would not be.

Comment on this

It is a condition of any claimant's entitlement to a rent supplement that he or she has not refused, in any continuous 18-month period, a third offer of accommodation provided by either a housing authority or a body approved by the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Authority, including accommodation provided under the rental accommodation scheme.

An individual on rent allowance can refuse three offers of either social—

Comment on this

These people are not refusing anything.

Comment on this

—housing or rental accommodation scheme housing.

Comment on this

For instance, a local authority secures several houses by way of contract with a landlord. If a person is put into such accommodation because he or she was on the list for 18 months or more, then he or she should be allowed to stay on the list.

Comment on this

Is the Chairman's point that if one is in receipt of rent supplement, one should not be required to move on to the rental accommodation scheme but stay on the ordinary housing list?

Comment on this

No. A person can go on the scheme after 18 months but should be left on the local authority housing list so that if a house becomes available, the person can be considered as a suitable applicant for that house.

Comment on this

The person would stay on both lists.

Comment on this

Take the example of where a person is on rental supplement or living at home with parents. The local authority enters into agreement with a landlord for renting 20 houses. The local authority can then inform that person that he or she is off the local authority housing list and must go on the rental allowance scheme. That person may have aspired to having a house but under this rule, he or she will never fulfil it.

Comment on this

I will take advice on that matter. If the point being made is that those receiving rent allowance from the Department of Social and Family Affairs should remain on both lists and be able to choose whichever comes up first, that sounds like an administrative nightmare. However, I will seek counsel on the matter.

Comment on this

Assuming that one has accepted an RAS house and entered into a contract with a private landlord for a certain number of years, would the other party not be left high and dry if one decided to opt out and take a local authority house halfway through the contractual period? That might pose difficulties as the scheme is constituted. I am not saying that it is the right way to proceed, but it might pose difficulties.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister might consult the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government, Deputy Roche, and ascertain the position. That might be the way forward.

Comment on this

We will have a report on the matter.

Comment on this

I will give further information on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 15 to 18, inclusive, are in the name of the Minister.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 15:

In page 16, line 31, to delete "qualified adult" and substitute "spouse".

This amendment is tactical in nature. In the case of a non-contributory State pension, an increase is payable in respect of a spouse, but not a qualified adult, and the amendment recognises this. In the case, for example, of a blind person an increase is also payable in respect of a spouse but not a qualified adult. The treatment here is similar to the SPNC. Both schemes are historically derived from the now defunct OAP arrangements. It is largely technical in nature, introducing changes to ensure people get the benefit of the increases.

Comment on this

I am sure the Minister is up to speed in this area. He has expert legal advice all around him.

Comment on this

I move amendment No.16:

In page 16, line 33, to delete "qualified adult" and substitute "spouse".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 17:

In page 16, line 35, to delete "qualified adult" and substitute "spouse".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 18:

In page 16, lines 37 and 38, to delete "qualified adult" and substitute"spouse".

Comment on this

Is this section providing for the insertion of the regulations in primary legislation?

Comment on this

Yes. It provides for the deletion of an obsolete reference in the Social Welfare Consolidation Act 2005 to "rules of behaviour" in respect of invalidity pension.

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain the changes to the bereavement grants scheme?

Comment on this

Changes to the scheme were made in the budget. The bereavement grant is a once off payment based on PRSI contributions. It is payable on the death of an insured person, or the spouse or partner of an insured person. The amount of the grant was set at €635 when it was introduced to replace the death grant in 1992. In budget 2007 it was increased by €215 to €850, which represents an increase of 34%. The cost of the scheme for a full year is €5 million. This section provides for an improvement by providing that for the purposes of the scheme, a qualified child shall include a person aged between 16 and 22 years who is in receipt of disability allowance.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 19:

In page 19, before section 21, to insert the following new section:

21.--Section 149 of the Principal Act is amended--

(a) in subsection (1), by substituting the following for paragraph (c)(iii)(II):

"(II) carer's allowance, but—

(A) has ceased to be entitled to carer's allowance by virtue of no longer being regarded as a carer within

the meaning of section 179(1), or

(B) was in receipt of pre-retirement allowance immediately before receiving carer's allowance.",

(b) in subsection (7) (inserted by section 15 of the Act of 2006), by substituting “subsections (8) and (9)” for “subsection (8)”,

and

(c) by inserting the following after subsection (8) (inserted by section 15 of the Act of 2006):

"(9) Subsection (7) shall not apply to a person who--

(a) was in receipt of carer’s allowance immediately before the date prescribed for the purposes of subsection (7), and

(b) was in receipt of pre-retirement allowance immediately before receiving carer’s allowance.“.”.

This is a positive measure, the purpose of which is to ensure that where a current recipient of carer's allowance had been in receipt of pre-retirement allowance immediately before becoming a carer such a person will be able to revert to a retirement allowance and retain half of his or her personal rate of carer's allowance if it is beneficial for him or her to do so.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 20

In page 21, to delete lines 24 to 31 and substitute the following:

"(i) in subsection (1)(b), by inserting “a payment under section 186A,” before “supplementary welfare allowance”,

(ii) by inserting the following after subsection (3):

"(3A) Notwithstanding subsections (1) and (2) and subject to subsection (3B), where disablement benefit and any benefit described in section 39(1) (including any increase thereof) or assistance described in section 139(1) (including any increase thereof) would be payable to or in respect of a person in respect of the same period, both such payments may be paid to or in respect of that person in respect of that period.

(3B) For the purposes of subsection (3A), disablement benefit shall not include an increase--

(a) on account of incapacity by virtue of section 77,

(b) in respect of a qualified adult or a qualified child, by virtue of section 76,

(c) in respect of constant attendance by virtue of section 78, other than where a benefit, as described in section 39(1), is

payable.",

and

(iii) by inserting the following after subsection (5):

"(5A) A payment under section 186A shall not be payable where a person is in receipt of more than one payment by virtue of

regulations made under subsection (4).".".

This is a positive measure to ensure that where a person in receipt of disability benefit and another social welfare payment is also providing someone with full-time care and attention, he or she will not be prohibited from receiving a partial rate carer's allowance, subject to the means test and other qualifying conditions.

Comment on this

That is—

Comment on this

It was part of the earlier discussion.

Comment on this

It is ensuring somebody will——

Comment on this

These are specific areas where somebody is on welfare and we do not want to close off his or her options.

Comment on this

There would not be too many available.

Comment on this

Other issues that arise may be of interest. I was in contact with a gentleman whose wife is in receipt of a disability allowance. He receives a carer's allowance. He pointed out that as he is at home, he might be entitled to a qualified adult payment on his wife's disability allowance. He gave up his full-time employment to care for her. He asked me to raise this today. He wanted to know if he would be eligible to receive the qualified adult payment and the half rate carer's allowance. I am not sure if the Minister has thought about this, or whether this amendment would deal with that.

Comment on this

I am advised that he could be eligible, but we should probably look at the case.

Comment on this

This will not come into effect until September.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 21:

In page 22, to delete lines 15 to 21.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 23:

In page 22, line 52, to delete subsection (2).

This is a controversial subsection. It relates to the transfer of the community welfare service from the HSE to the Department of Social and Family Affairs. Community welfare officers provide a unique personal service that has developed over time. Some of their functions might be transferable, but they feel strongly that they have not been consulted on the transfer. The Minister said he was including the relevant provision in the legislation and would consult them afterwards. This is putting the cart before the horse. He should have consulted them beforehand to learn from their experience.

The transfer will affect approximately 1,000 people working in the health sector and 100,000 recipients of SWA payments. Those using services provided directly by the HSE, including domiciliary care allowances, are affected. The Government's justification for transferring the functions involves an organisational arrangement, allowing the HSE to focus on core responsibilities. Community welfare officers are under considerable pressure and the assistance they receive is a very important safety net. They build important relationships with welfare recipients. It is crucial to acknowledge that this is not just a question of money. The officers offer personal support, very often by listening like a counsellor or advocate. They link in with other services in the health sector, such as psychiatric and psychological services, as well as the public health nursing services. They fear this link will be broken if responsibility is transferred from the HSE to the Department of Social and Family Affairs and they will become mere financial administrators. Their role is much greater than this. They believe the proposed move reflects a lack of understanding of the type of service they offer.

The CWOs were given an opportunity to express a formal view for the first time during committee proceedings in June 2006. They believe the transfer will have a profound adverse effect on the service, ultimately undermining the quality and range of services they provide, to the detriment of some of the most vulnerable citizens. There has been no public debate on the issue and they have not been properly consulted by Departments. The officers are afraid the Department will not continue to devote resources to functions for which it is not responsible. They believe their ability to make discretionary payments will be undermined, but we should enhance their powers in that regard. We have all encountered cases where the discretionary payment is useful and important. Many Deputies must ring the Society of St. Vincent de Paul to obtain help for constituents because no one else can help. CWOs should have their roles expanded to do this task.

The issue has not been debated fully, CWOs have not been listened to or consulted and there has been no debate in the House. Given the level of need in the country, particularly among children, lone parents and so on, it is an important function. Community welfare officers believe the important link to the HSE could be cut. They do not just give out money; as anyone who interacts with them knows, they play vital roles as listeners. I oppose this section, as there should have been more debate on the issue.

Comment on this

The Minister will not be surprised to hear my opinion, which was set out comprehensively on Second Stage. If a machine is not broken, one should not set about dismantling it, as is being done in the Bill. Someone has an agenda in this respect. I have an opinion on who and why, but I will oppose the section.

If the Labour Party is ever in government, I would like to see this matter unscrambled. The community welfare officers are doing excellent jobs with the discretion to which we referred previously and there is no reason to disturb them, but their discretion will be removed by the Bill. The late Frank Cluskey established the system for a good reason. He did not come out of the sky in 1976 or 1977 and say that something must be done. Rather, a great deal of thought was given to the matter. I do not know why this idea is being pursued with thunder and zeal. If we set about tackling some of the other issues with the same zeal, including the replacement of the one-parent family payment and the abolition of the cohabitation rules, we would solve them. I have never seen this zeal displayed previously.

There was very little consultation. When the Department tells people what it will do, it does not consult them. Rather, it imposes its opinion on them. New facts emerged at a meeting of the committee last June. The union representatives who were making their case at the meeting were surprised. The Minister stated that this matter must be triggered by a regulation, statutory instrument or commencement order, but when does he intend that to happen? Has there been full consultation and, if not, why has this provision been included in the Bill? We signalled that we would oppose the measure tooth and nail because it is not the right way to go and is a retrograde step. To be fair to the Minister, he stated that the CWOs would not be inhibited and would have the same discretion to deal with issues once under his ambit.

During the debate on Second Stage, Deputy Stanton and I pointed out that there is more to CWOs than being money administrators. Through years of working with people, they have built up a detailed and intimate knowledge regarding particular health issues. They would have an even greater role in the implementation of the health strategy. Why is there a rush? Will I be able to telephone a community welfare officer at 4 p.m on a Saturday in an emergency? Who will fill that void? If they are doing the same job as before, why should they be subsumed within the Department, which does not have the role they have? The Minister told us he wishes to remove responsibility for payment of the rent supplement from his Department because it comes within the remit of the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government. In this case, however, the Department is subsuming a job that is not its own. Is there a contradiction here? It will burn my brain trying to figure out why this should be done.

Comment on this

I fully support the Chairman's comments. This is a retrograde step as far as those who avail of the service are concerned, particularly those who require it on an emergency basis, and in terms of the ease of contact between the general public and the superintendent community welfare officer and his or her staff. If the Department is to assume this role, will the existing degree of flexibility remain? Perhaps the Minister and his senior officials fear the power and responsibility of community welfare officers. The reality, however, is that they merely operate within the legislation. The flexibility they display is never exercised without justification and usually relates to emergencies.

I appeal to the Minister to review this situation and consider the merits of the case brought to his attention on Second Stage and again today. Perhaps he will be willing to amend this on Report Stage.

Comment on this

There is no undue haste in regard to this amendment. This proposal was first put forward in the report of the Commission on Social Welfare 21 years ago, in 1986. It may even have been included in Frank Cluskey's document but I am not certain about that.

Comment on this

The Minister is incorrect.

Comment on this

I am not certain.

Comment on this

We are certain. That document was thrown in the bin.

Comment on this

I am too young to remember. It was also recommended in the review of supplementary welfare allowances by the Combat Poverty Agency in 1991. In 1996, the report of the Commission on the Status of People with Disabilities recommended the transfer of certain schemes. This issue was also examined by the Commission on Financial Management and Control Systems in the Health Service in 2003. It was considered in depth in the Brennan report, which suggested that health sector management should concentrate on health issues and that HSE functions that were not core functions of the health service should be transferred to more appropriate bodies.

I did not get a rush of blood to the head in putting forward this proposal; it is well founded and there is a long history to it. The word "welfare" in the title, community welfare officer, is significant. That is what it is all about. Community welfare officers administer supplementary welfare allowances, diet supplements, exceptional needs payments, back to school allowances, footwear allowances and so on. They implement legislation and monitor such issues as limits and disregard. There are 700 community welfare officers and they administer a budget of some €800 million.

Comment on this

That says much.

Comment on this

Approximately half of that is accounted for by rent allowance.

I have the highest regard for community welfare officers, who work on the front line and do a fantastic job in our welfare system. I stress there is nothing in this Bill that will change their duties. Their flexibility will not be reduced. The same staff will administer the schemes providing the same personal service under the legislation with the guidelines that obtain at present. The only change is that, technically, they will be employed by the Department of Social and Family Affairs rather than by the Health Service Executive, HSE. There is no other difference.

Comment on this

Why make the change in the first place?

Comment on this

I have made clear it is because the weight of all expert advice states they play a solid role in the administration of our welfare system. They are welfare officers, not health officers, and their place is within the welfare system as they look after people's welfare. When one considers the HSE's future, community welfare officers do not really have a role in developing a health strategy as such because their quotidian job pertains to welfare. The overall health strategy is a different issue.

Moreover, this scheme is fully funded by the Department of Social and Family Affairs and not by the HSE. Consequently, this is a simple change and there is no need for any community welfare officer to fear being employed technically by the Department of Social and Family Affairs, which employs approximately 5,000 people, all of whom do a magnificent job. The welfare officers have nothing to fear from this Department and their work will not be interfered with by a single iota. This constitutes a tidying-up exercise that has been recommended for years in order that the HSE can focus on essential matters.

Comment on this

Will they be entitled to a disturbance allowance?

Comment on this

Ongoing dialogue and consultation has taken place with trade unions and staff in respect of implementation issues. In this regard, a communication and consultation strategy has been devised that allows for ongoing dialogue with all stakeholders. A series of regional meetings has been organised by the HSE and my Department for all staff in the HSE's community welfare service and the first such meeting will take place this month. They will provide the opportunity for further constructive engagement and feedback on the implementation programme.

A document outlining the high level proposals of the Department and the HSE has been sent to the SIPTU and IMPACT unions, which represent staff in the community welfare service, and to the unions in my Department. The first meeting of the joint liaison group involving management of the Departments of Social and Family Affairs and Health and Children, the HSE, IMPACT and SIPTU is set to be held later this month. A meeting will also take place with the unions in my Department to brief them further on the matter and the provisions of the Bill are subject to a commencement order. They will not come into effect until we have made some progress with regard to the ongoing consultations.

There is no hidden agenda in this regard. The welfare officers are just that because they look after people's welfare. For example, they administer the diet supplement scheme and the back to school clothing and footwear allowance, which are standard welfare schemes that are paid for by the Department of Social and Family Affairs. This is a purely technical issue and no substantive or fundamental matter is at stake. It is probably unfair to community welfare officers to suggest in any way they would not retain their flexibility, independence and determination. Their technical employment by my Department or the HSE will not change the professional, caring and determined manner in which they have always carried out their role. I am certain they will continue to perform such work.

They work for the State, the Government of the day and the Civil Service. In previous posts I held, I was criticised for removing people from the Civil Service and transferring them to an agency. Were I to remove people from the Department and place them in an agency, I could write the speeches that would be made by my colleagues in Leinster House. Were I in opposition, I would make them myself. In a sense however, I am moving people in the other direction, that is, from an agency to the Department where they will be able to help us in a broad range of activities.

Welfare support is now more integrated than was the case at the outset of the scheme. All the schemes must be integrated with each other because when someone is in receipt of rent allowance on foot of action by the community welfare service, we must know what is happening in respect of housing, pensions and income. We need some fairly good, solid and joined-up thinking if we are to administer a welfare system that hits the spot, helps people and tackles poverty. There is nothing to fear here. It is a purely technical change. There is no substantive change in the work. There is nothing in this legislation which changes one iota of it, other than a technical issue relating to the actual employer.

Comment on this

The Minister says that the same staff, schemes and guidelines are involved and that there is nothing to fear. Yet, community welfare officers have contacted us. One such individual who rang me yesterday was extremely concerned and annoyed about this because there had been no consultation, discussion or information. She was worried not only for herself, but for the people with whom she works. She outlined her specific role to me, which did not just involve dishing out money. She said she often works with people who are suicidal and often almost assumes a counselling a role. I could put it to the Minister that——

Comment on this

So does the rest of the Department of Social and Family Affairs.

Comment on this

Maybe not to the same extent.

Comment on this

The role is not confined to the community welfare officer. We have officers in every office up and down the land who are excellent individuals, many of whom report to me occasionally. People with issues around suicide visit their offices and these officers take them aside. Our officers, regardless of whether they are community welfare officers or departmental staff, help people all over the country, day in, day out. Their thinking does not change.

Comment on this

We were amazed that up to now, there had been virtually no consultation or discussion with them. The Minister talks about matters such as national partnership. They visited us last year and made this point. Would it not be better to sit down and talk to community welfare officers and their superintendent organisations and come to some understanding and agreement with them?

Comment on this

I have a note here which states that the Department met the entire cadre of superintendent community welfare officers in July and November of 2006. A briefing on the programme was also given to the Department's senior management team in May 2006 and February 2007. I have mentioned all the documents. Everybody in the system knows what is happening here.

Comment on this

Can we leave the history behind and look at the current situation? Do the community welfare officers and their organisations, unions and representatives agree with this? Have the Minister and his officials listened to their views and concerns? Are they fully in agreement with what is happening?

Comment on this

The only way I can answer the Deputy is to tell him that I do not have formal disagreement. Like the Deputy, I have received expressions of concern.

Comment on this

Serious concerns.

Comment on this

Many of these concerns are about what people read in newspaper headlines and hear casually. As I have laid out today, they do not have anything to fear. There is nothing to worry about here. I am confident that as we explain our position and negotiate with SIPTU, IMPACT and the joint liaison group, their concerns will be allayed and dispelled. I have spoken to the Deputy about all the meetings that are lined up. I acknowledge that they have concerns.

Comment on this

They have very serious concerns.

Comment on this

These concerns are based mainly on what they think we are doing rather than what we are actually doing.

Comment on this

Would it not be better to allay those concerns before we pass any legislation? At what point——

Comment on this

There is a commencement order.

Comment on this

That depends on passing this legislation today. There will be another social welfare Bill next year. Why not use the interim period to sit down with these people, let them explain their fears, explain what is going to happen, get their agreement and then bring forward the agreed changes instead of doing it now? I am surprised this is happening.

Comment on this

I have spent a sufficiently long period in the electoral cycle to know what time of year it is and what is going on here. I am happy to make it quite clear that the commencement order will not be signed until we make substantial progress on all outstanding issues. This is the Social Welfare and Pensions Bill and it is appropriate to include the change in the Bill. There are many commencement orders in the system in many Departments which await signing. They are not signed until certain issues are sorted out. I am confident the remaining concerns of the community welfare officers can be fully allayed before any commencement order is signed.

Comment on this
Division

The Committee divided: Tá,

Tá 3
·
Níl 7
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Amendments Nos. 24 and 25 are related and will be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 24:

In page 29, to delete lines 42 to 47 and in page 30, to delete lines 1 to 8 and substitute the following:

"(I) an amount equal to any additional income, where that income arises from any employment or training that may be prescribed and is not in excess of €75, or an amount equal to 25 per cent of any such additional income in excess of €75 and subject to a minimum disregard of €75, when such additional income has been reduced by the aggregate of—".

Section 35 gives effect to a number of improvements to the SWA rent supplement scheme as part of the overall scheme I announced in the budget, including an easing of the rent supplement means test. The key objectives of the changes are to simplify the means test in order that a rent supplement recipient can judge the impact of an offer of work and to address the disincentives faced by rent supplement recipients in seeking to increase their hours of work. In the Bill, as published, rent supplement recipients will retain half of any additional income over and above the maximum social welfare rate for their circumstances.

Comment on this

Will the Minister repeat what he stated?

Comment on this

I will summarise it. We had a number of discussions on rent supplement recipients and I propose to amend the provisions of section 35 to disregard the first €75 of additional income and assess additional income above €75 at 75%. This will treat the first €75 of additional income over and above the basic social welfare rate in the same manner as provided for in the Bill, as published. A person can still have up to €75 of additional income without experiencing a reduction in rent supplement. It is now proposed to treat further additional income in a manner more favourable to the rent supplement recipient. Under the original proposal, a rent supplement recipient would have retained €75 in cases where he or she had up to €150 of additional income and up to a maximum of €100 where the additional income was more than €150. Under the amendment, rent supplement recipients will retain one quarter of any additional income over and above €75, as well as retaining all of the €75. The amendment seeks to provide for a more favourable situation for rent supplement recipients and ensure the disincentive to work is reduced.

Comment on this

Will the Minister clarify how this will apply to a person who earns €150, is in receipt of €75 in maintenance payments and receives a one-parent family payment of €160?

Comment on this

The Deputy could come to my clinic on Saturday.

Comment on this

I presume this person's total income of €375 will be taken into consideration in an assessment.

Comment on this

I will try to calculate the sum for the Deputy. We are trying to ensure that recipients are able to retain any additional income they earn before it interferes with their allowances. It is merely a tapering device to allow them to have additional income without interfering with their benefits. Nothing else is involved. It is tapered so that the withdrawal system is more a slope than a cliff.

Comment on this
Dan Wallace Mr. D. Wallace Fianna Fáil

I certainly welcome the measure.

Comment on this

We can calculate the sums for Deputy Seán Ryan if he wishes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 25:

In page 31, to delete lines 13 to 22 and substitute the following:

"(b) the weekly value of so much of the housing costs actually incurred and paid by a liable relative as exceeds €4,952 per annum but does not exceed €8,852 per annum, shall be disregarded;

(c) the weekly value of so much of the housing costs actually incurred and paid by a liable relative as exceeds €8,852 per annum shall be assessed at 75 cent per each €1.”.

Comment on this

This matter has already been discussed. Is Deputy Seán Ryan withdrawing his opposition to Schedule 1?

Comment on this

We dealt with my concerns under a previous section, so I withdraw my opposition to the section.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 26 and 27 are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 26:

In page 46, column (2), to delete lines 44 and 45, and substitute the following:

" "(fa) to perform the functions conferred on the Board by this Act;

(fb) give balanced and impartial information to consumers regarding pension products, including, not limited to -

(i) tax relief,

(ii) operators' charges,

(iii) tax implications of leaving a sum of money in place, and

(iv) the commutation of tax-free sums of money on point of retirement;".".

I am aware a Green Paper is being prepared on pensions, and I look forward to its publication. My amendment pertains to the powers of the Pensions Board, a matter on which my colleague, Senator Terry, has done a great deal of work. We contend that the Pensions Board has an obligation to provide balanced and impartial information to consumers when they take out pensions products or retire. The issue is particularly pertinent given that the Pensions Board has organised a pensions awareness campaign for this week. That campaign is oriented towards getting people to take out pensions but does not point out the down sides.

Issues that arise include tax relief which is actually tax deferral, lack of guarantees for outcomes and the possible absence of indexation. If a worker pays tax at the low rate, he or she will only benefit from tax relief at the low rate. A pension fund will be depleted by the operator's charges, so such charges should be clear. Research by WIT established that pension fund management charges can absorb up to 26% of pension fund assets in contributions and as much as twice that figure in small schemes. If a worker opts to take a tax-free lump sum, his or her pension fund is reduced, resulting in a decreased income stream during retirement. When considering whether one should take the tax-free lump sum, commutation factors, that is, the cost of taking a lump sum compared with borrowing the same amount from a bank, should be explained. An individual who opts to take a lump sum of €60,000 will forfeit an annual income of €7,000 from his or her pension, whereas a pensioner could borrow €60,000 from a bank at a cost of €3,000 at current interest rates. It is therefore cheaper to leave the pension fund intact and borrow from the bank. However, that has not been pointed out.

The Minister might tell us the number of people who have paid into funds over the years but have not applied for their pensions. I understand the Pensions Ombudsman has estimated this number at many thousands. Is there any point in having an awareness campaign on that issue? These are some of the issues I want to bring to the Minister's attention.

Comment on this

Senator Terry and I have spent many hours debating these issues in the Seanad and I am very aware of her strong views. The amendment proposes a statutory way of collecting information but it is not necessary because we can collect the information on a voluntary basis. The issue of deferred members has been before the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Social and Family Affairs and the Pensions Board is currently finalising a survey of occupational pension schemes, in which it is seeking data in that regard from at least 1,000 active members, the results of which the board expects to provide to the joint committee by the end of this month. That will provide much of the information the Senator is looking for.

I could give a long, technical response but I am satisfied that the survey to which I referred will yield useful information, which we do not, in any case, have any difficulty obtaining from the industry on a daily basis.

Comment on this

Last November, Mr. Brendan Kennedy, the chief executive of the Pensions Board, told the Joint Committee on Social and Family Affairs that he would provide information on members with deferred benefits in the top 55 defined pension schemes by the end of January 2007. On 28 February he wrote as follows to Senator Terry outlining why he had not done so, stating:

I refer to your letter of 13 February 2007 requesting an update on the current position in relation to the information which you have sought on frozen benefits. As you are aware, the Pensions Board does not have the authority to compel organisations to provide this information but we have issued a request to the relevant companies.

He will forward the replies but the companies do not have to send out the information. Accepting the amendment would facilitate the Pensions Board in securing that information and any other information necessary to the board. It will enable us to get some idea of what is happening in regard to frozen benefits. The Pensions Board should not have its hands tied behind its back because of an anomaly in the legislation. The board wants to provide the information to the committee but it needs the authority to do so, which it does not have at the moment, and this amendment would give it that authority. Companies should be accountable to the board so I ask the Minister to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

Mr. Kennedy does not say he cannot get the information because he does not have the power. He points out that he does not have the power but says it is possible to obtain the information and he is receiving full, voluntary co-operation. He is finalising a survey of 1,000 active members seeking data on their deferred members and I am assured he is receiving that information and will present a report to the joint committee with the results at the end of the month.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 28 to 31, inclusive, are related and will be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 28:

In page 47, column (2), to delete lines 30 to 33.

This amendment endeavours to remove the gag on the chief executive of the Pensions Board, who has been prevented from commenting on Government policy. It is totally unacceptable that the chief executive, who is required to come before the Joint Committee on Social and Family Affairs to answer questions on Government policy, is gagged by legislation. The deletion of the lines in question would lead to greater transparency in the operations of the Pensions Board.

Comment on this

I see what the Deputy is trying to do with the amendment but this is a standard provision in statutes governing the accountability of chief executives of State bodies to the Committee of Public Accounts. It relates only to the giving of evidence before the committee. It should be clear that it does not apply to other committees of the Oireachtas such as this committee, for example. The amendments are based on section 19 of the Comptroller and Auditor General (Amendment) Act 1993 which provides for an identical restriction on Secretaries General commenting on the merits of Government or ministerial policies. It will operate within those narrow confines; it is a standard provision which has operated successfully for many years.

Comment on this

I regret the Minister's reluctance to take on board the principle of transparency, given that it is a minor aspect of the Bill. It is nonetheless required, even in the limited areas it needs to be dealt with.

Comment on this

No new policy is being made. This relates to the Committee of Public Accounts which was founded many years ago on the concept that it should try to deal with the facts of a matter and not get into policy opinions from public officials. There is no attempt to gag anybody in any way. Officers can come before this committee and answer any questions asked of them. This provision will operate purely within the narrow confines of the Committee of Public Accounts and relates to the aspect of the Comptroller and Auditor General (Amendment) Act 1993 dealing with Secretaries General of Departments appearing before that committee.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 29:

In page 50, column (2), to delete lines 32 to 35.

This amendment relates to the potential to gag the Pensions Ombudsman who is prevented from commenting on Government policy. This amounts to extraordinary interference with the ombudsman's right to comment on policy. In this context, there is a need for the amendment which I ask the Minister to accept.

Comment on this

The Pensions Ombudsman can come before this or any other committee of the Oireachtas and express all the opinions he or she likes about policy. There is a structure that at the Committee of Public Accounts senior officials and Secretaries General confine themselves to factual information.

Comment on this

Therefore, this only applies to the Committee of Public Accounts?

Comment on this

It only applies to that committee; it does not apply to this one.

Comment on this

Agreeing to the amendment would not interfere with the current arrangement at the Committee of Public Accounts.

Comment on this

This provision adds the Pensions Ombudsman to the list of Secretaries General, if he or she appears before the Committee of Public Accounts. It adds to the list of Secretaries Generals accountable to that committee. That is a bigger debate which it may be worth having at some stage. In this case the people in question are Accounting Officers accountable to the Committee of Public Accounts for the administration of funds within their Departments. I take the Deputy's point. Some day a bigger debate on the role of that committee and who gives evidence before it may be useful. For now all we are doing is adding other senior officials to the list of Secretaries General.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister and his officials for attending and my colleagues for co-operating and ensuring we dealt with this important business in a comprehensive and timely way.

Comment on this