Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions)(No. 2) Bill 2010: Committee Stage
Contributions 1–148 of 290. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 51 of 2010 ›
This meeting has been convened for the purpose of consideration by the committee of the Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions)(No. 2) Bill 2010, a Bill which was referred to the select committee on 1 December 2010. The arrangements for taking the Bill have been circulated.
I welcome the Minister for Social Protection, Deputy Éamon Ó Cuív, and his officials. I am anxious to get the advice of members in the following regard. It is suggested that we consider the Bill until 1 p.m. with a break until 2 p.m., if necessary, and continue until we conclude Committee Stage. Is that agreed?
Comment on this
Perhaps we should have a cut-off point, because of the adverse weather conditions members may wish to be in a position to leave at some stage but I suspect we will finish our deliberations. The Bill is not that long.
Comment on this
I am supposed to leave at 1 o'clock because of the weather conditions but Deputy Durkan will take over from me, if necessary, but we might get our business done.
Comment on this
Yes, we will aim to do that. If we keep contributions short-----
Comment on this
We will not be delaying the proceedings.
Comment on this
There are two votes due in the House this morning so we will have to suspend.
Comment on this
That is on the Order of Business so we will have to leave.
Comment on this
We proceed to consideration of the Bill. Apologies have been received from Deputy Jackie Healy-Rae.
SECTION 1
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 1, 18 and 27 to 32, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 3, lines 28 and 29, to delete subsection (2) and substitute the following:
"(2) The Social Welfare Acts and Parts 1, 2 and 4, section 12 and Schedules 1 and 2 shall be read together as one.”.
These amendments provide for the transfer of the community welfare service of the Health Service Executive to the Department of Social Protection and also provide for technical amendments to the principal Act associated with this transfer. The Government decided in February 2006 to transfer the community welfare services of the Health Service Executive, which currently administers a supplementary welfare allowance, to my Department. This initiative has been mooted several times in the past, including in the report of the Commission on Social Welfare in 1986, the report of the Commission on the Status of People with Disabilities 1996 and the Commission on the Financial Management and Control of Systems in the Health Service 2003.
Since 2006 the Health Service Executive has been in negotiations with unions representing community welfare officers on the detailed implications of the transfer, including terms and conditions of employment. Recently, during talks under the auspices of the Labour Relations Commission, the unions agreed to the management offer to their members. This offer provides for the transfer of the full cohort of staff of the community welfare service to the Department of Social Protection with effect from 1 January 2011 on a secondment basis, initially for a period of nine months, until September 2011. During this period of secondment, staff will remain employees of the Health Service Executive and as such will retain their existing terms and conditions and will be represented by SIPTU and IMPACT. The unions and management side are committed to working together to resolve the outstanding industrial relations issues and ensure these dates are met, using the existing auspices of the LRC.
Legislation to enable the Department to administer the supplementary welfare allowance scheme was introduced to the Social Welfare and Pensions Acts 2007 and 2008. This legislation is subject to a commencement order. Legislation will be required also to provide for the transfer of community welfare staff, as civil servants, to the Department and, where relevant, of buildings to the Commissioners of Public Works. Committee Stage of the Bill will commence next Thursday.
Comment on this
How many community welfare officers will transfer to the Department of Social Protection? Will they remain in the health centres in which they are located or will they be located in new offices? I raised this issue at the committee meeting last week. Will the discretionary payments be at the same level or will they have to comply with legislation? It is very important for us to know that today because that is the whole point of having them. The Minister said he is in negotiations with the Labour Relations Commission in regard to the transfer. What is the up-to-date position?
Comment on this
There are some outstanding issues to be teased out when staff are seconded over the nine months. As the Deputy might remember, this has been going on for a long time and allowing for everything working according to plan, the secondment period will begin with effect from 1 January. There are some issues regarding grades as this involves interacting two different systems, the HSE, a semi-State system with the Department one. We need nine months to tease out the final issues. I do not have the numbers to hand.
The second issue concerns outreach services, which are the services to which I believe the Deputy was referring, as opposed to the services provided by centralised offices. Obviously in time they will be Department offices. It is my intention that the outreach element of services will continue to be delivered. That is a vital part of the services, which involves going out to the people rather than people coming into the office and having to travel long distances. The nature of the service is local.
There will be no change in any of the schemes we administer because of this change. It seems to be overlooked at times that the scheme is discretionary not because of the HSE but because our Department has made it a discretionary scheme. There is no intention to change that. Community welfare officers, CWOs, have asked me this question. I have said time and again that the social welfare system, as we know it, would be destroyed if we did not have the ability to make emergency payments and to pay supplementary welfare allowance as a fall-back payment based on need.
Comment on this
There is some concern about the change in terms of the grading of the staff moving over. I do not know if the Minister has the overall figures to hand. With the grading system being different in the HSE from that in the Civil Service, I understand CWOs will become either executive officers, EOs, or higher executive officers, HEOs. A few CWOs have contacted me expressing concern that the proposal on the table was that their conditions would not be as good as those they currently enjoy. It would be completely unacceptable if that was the case. Is the Minister prepared to give an undertaking here that nobody will suffer a loss of conditions with the transfer? It makes sense to bring the CWOs over to the Minister's Department but it would not be acceptable that somebody would suffer a deterioration in his or her conditions of employment.
Comment on this
There were talks recently under the auspices of the Labour Relations Commission and the unions have agreed to put a management offer to their members. There are issues outstanding. We want to resolve those with the use of the normal labour relations machinery. There are also implications for staff in the Department in that they have to be part of all this change and we want to ensure that everybody is in agreement on matters. The intention is to do everything by agreement. I understand there are issues, although they are not the ones the Deputy mentioned, around staff in acting up positions that need to be resolved. All these issues need to be teased out.
Having got agreement with the unions in principle, rather than concluding all the issues that need to be teased out and often they are not that simple to tease out, the proposal is to second staff which will give us nine months to get agreement on the finer issues. I would like all the issues to be resolved by agreement. In terms of staff operating in the Department, I hope that during the secondment period staff will be reassured about issues, not related to pay and conditions but to the work they do, and about the fact that there will not be any change in the fundamental role they play in terms of discretionary payments and their ability to do their jobs properly. There are two issues. The secondment period will resolve the second issue and we will then work our way through the finer issues of labour relations. I do not want to pre-empt those discussions. What has been done so far is that negotiations are taking place with the unions and they are recommending the arrangements. That is the ideal place we would like to go, particularly in the spirit of the Croke Park agreement.
Comment on this
Does the Minister accept, in principle, that people should not suffer a deterioration in their conditions?
Comment on this
Obviously, and that is one of the reasons for the extra time being provided. There were issues that were not resolved and we need to get those resolved in a satisfactory way. As the Deputy will appreciate, because we are marrying two systems that were not exactly the same, we have to make sure that the mesh does not create other consequential issues. The issues have to be teased out carefully. The best way of doing so is for people to sit down and work through them and come to a fair and equitable arrangement. The objective is that, with goodwill on both sides, a situation will be arrived at that is acceptable to the union and to the management side.
Comment on this
With regard to Deputy Ring's question, will the CWOs continue to work out of health centres?
Comment on this
The answer is "Yes" in terms of the health centres. Some of them are working in larger numbers in buildings in centralised offices. Obviously those will transfer to the Department because there is no point in having a building owned by the HSE but, effectively, being totally staffed by Department staff. On the other hand, a major issue, particularly in rural areas, is the outreach element of services delivered from health centres. The outreach element of the services is important because it means that people do not have to travel inordinate distances to access CWOs. In other words, accessibility must be a key provision.
Comment on this
Deputy Shortall was correct in what she said. The Minister does not seem to be certain whether the CWOs will or will not be operating from where they are now and I would have a concern about that. People should not have to travel long distances to access CWOs.
Another issue of concern relates to where the superintendent will be based. Some community welfare officers make decisions in cases and some of them are correct and in other cases we and the people concerned may be of the view there should be an appeals mechanism in place to enable them appeal the decision made. In the past people could make their case to the superintendent and, if they were unsuccessful, they could take it further and that system worked. Will that situation pertain now, or what will be the situation?
Comment on this
I do not envisage any significant change in those arrangements. The Deputy asked a specific question regarding buildings. Where community welfare officers, a superintendent and whoever are operating from a HSE building, that will be transferred over to the Department because it would be strange to have Department staff in a building that was not under the auspices of the OPW. On the other hand, staff in other areas delivering outreach services are using State facilities. This issue has been raised with me in a number of other cases recently. I am keen on the principle of those delivering State services sharing buildings, one-stop-shops and so on. Recently, for example, Teagasc provided a service in Galway in a privately rented building and I suggested that it should talk to Department of Community, Equality and Gaeltacht Affairs or Údarás na Gaeltacht to ascertain if they had a building and in that way we would be renting from ourselves as a State rather than renting private buildings. I do not want to hamstring ourselves on the buildings issue but, in principle, the architecture we have is that which should remain in place in terms of the service. If we are providing a service that is 80% or 90% a social welfare service, it would be better to provide that service from the Department of Social Protection.
Comment on this
I will finish on this point as I note Deputy Burton wants to speak. I am concerned about the delivery of services in rural Ireland. The Minister is well aware of the position in rural Ireland and how people find it difficult to access services, but at least there are health centres in most parts of rural Ireland.
Comment on this
The Department would still use them for the delivery of services.
Comment on this
I said they would be used for the outreach element of the services. I am differentiating between the outreach and the central elements of services. In the case of CWOs and superintendents operating out of offices in Castlebar in County Mayo, over time if that service could be consolidated into one building from which the Department of Social Protection operates, that would be the obvious place to which to move those staff. On the other hand, if they were operating out of the health centre in Gob an Choire, Achill Sound, or wherever the health centre is there, we would not withdraw that service because the Department of Social Protection does not have a centre in Achill, if that answers the Deputy's question. The outreach element of the services there is incredibly important. It is provided in health centres and other centres and that must remain the position. It is an essential part of the services. This service goes to the people and within reason, we must continue to ensure it goes to them.
Comment on this
I presume community welfare officers will retain all their duties, including in respect of the clothing allowance, the dietary allowance and so on.
Comment on this
All those services will be retained and brought under the remit of the Department.
Comment on this
Will any of those services be moved to different sections in the Department?
Comment on this
The peculiar thing is that all those services are funded by my Department and come from my Vote. Most services provided by my Department are administered by departmental officials. Here we had a huge swathe of services totally funded by the Department, which set the rules, but where delivery was by a third party agency. What we are saying now is that the funder and deliverer of the service will be the same organisation, that is, the Department. Our argument is that it is much easier from a management point of view if one's own staff provide the services rather than staff of another agency.
On Deputy Shortall's question about moving around, if a vacancy or a promotional opportunity arises, the community welfare officer is perfectly entitled to apply for it. If that person applies and is successful, the vacancy created as a result would be filled by someone at the appropriate grade. Departmental staff could get these jobs and community welfare officers could progress along the career path. There is nothing to stop people doing that in the HSE anyway.
Comment on this
Is the Minister suggesting that once the changeover takes place, community welfare officers could be promoted to positions in the Department which are not within that service and that existing departmental staff could become superintendents?
Comment on this
Yes. They will all be civil servants.
Comment on this
Okay. I just wanted to clarify that.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying the community welfare officers in Inchicore, Kilmainham, Ballyfermot, Crumlin and Drimnagh will remain in the health centres there and will not have to move anywhere else?
Comment on this
Amendment No. 2 is consequential on amendments Nos. 19 and 20. Therefore, amendments Nos. 2, 19 and 20 will be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In page 3, subsection (4), line 32, to delete "Section 4 and Part 3” and substitute the following:
"Sections 4, 11(1), 12 and 13 and Parts 3 and 4”.
The purpose of the partial capacity scheme is to address a critical limitation of the current social welfare code which categorises people with long-term illnesses or disabilities as fit for work or unfit for work. The focus within the welfare system on incapacity rather than capacity carries negative consequences for people with disabilities and their families who may be trapped in welfare dependency.
The majority of people who take up long-term disability payment are very unlikely to return to work. This is entirely understandable in the case of those who have no residual work capacity but, as Deputies will know, a significant proportion of claimants of long-term illness benefit and invalidity pension have partial capacity to work. As the OECD commented recently, disability benefit systems can have a disabling affect on people steering them into welfare dependency and labour market exclusion.
We are going to move from measuring people's disability to measuring their ability. If one is on one of these payments and one wants to take up employment, a medical assessment of one's ability will be carried out and we will adjust the personal payment. It will not have any affect on adult or child dependant allowances. We will adjust a person's payment in line with what we believe is that person's ability and he or she can work as many hours and earn as much money as he or she wants.
For short-term rehabilitative training or work, the existing arrangement of the exemption will apply. If one takes this up and subsequently loses the job, gives it up or feels unable for it, one will be able to return to one's full invalidity pension. The current arrangement where we give people an exemption for one year and they look for another year and we say they are either in or out is very unfair because many have a partial capacity to work. In such a situation, the hours constraint can be an unnecessary impediment to people who might want to work longer hours. We should measure people's ability and say they need some support and are free to go to work. As I said, there is the safety net. If one falls back in, one gets back one's full payment.
Comment on this
I welcome this in principle and I hope it works. This is a different scheme from the previous one where people looked for an exemption. Will that scheme still be available?
Comment on this
This is for the long term. Will it be voluntary?
Comment on this
Who will conduct the medical assessment? That will be the big issue. What are the different categories of capacity for work? How will this impact on the payments? Will it be 70%, 50%, 30% or 20%? If the person's capacity changes, can it be reviewed? If a person's condition worsens, can it be increased, decreased or whatever the case may be? For how long will this partial capacity be paid?
Comment on this
The person who wishes to take up an employment opportunity will be required to undertake a partial capacity assessment by the Department medical assessor and the rate will be adjusted. We discussed the domiciliary care allowance the other day and the idea of asking in the chief medical officer. He has done much work and is very experienced on classifying ability, disability and so on. The reduction payment rates will be applied to the personal rate only. If one has an adult or child dependant, it will not affect the rate one gets for them.
An employment capacity of less than 25% will mean 75% incapacity. In other words, someone who has a severe disability will continue to receive a full rate payment. A person assessed as between 25% and 55% employment capacity would have a reduction in the weekly rate of €50.40. A person assessed as between 50% and 80% would have a reduction in the weekly rate of approximately 50%, which is about €100. Approximately one quarter or one half goes.
A person will only apply for this if he or she has an offer of employment as there would be no point otherwise. One will continue to get one's child dependant allowance and so on. The system will work on that basis. If it is less than 80%, one will get no personal rate but I understand one will get the child and adult dependant allowance.
Comment on this
If it is less than 20%. Let us consider the issue of capacity. There is no personal rate for those with 0% to 20% disability, a half rate applies in respect of those with 21% to 50% disability, those with 51% to 75% disability receive three quarters of the rate and those with 76% disability or greater obtain the full rate.
Comment on this
Absolutely. If someone loses his or her job, he or she will get his or her full payment back.
On the other question the Deputy posed, there will be a time duration on both sides. When a person is examined and assessed, he or she is given the derogation for one or two years. Thereafter, he or she will be reassessed. If there has been a deterioration, the payment could be increased, whereas if there has been an improvement, the payment might be reduced. In many cases, the level of disability either remains the same or deteriorates. There are not too many instances where people with permanent disabilities become what I would term "totally enabled". That was the idea with the old system. People underwent rehabilitation therapy, were suddenly deemed 100% fit for work and were then meant to either compete in the labour market or go on invalidity pension. The position in this regard was unsatisfactory.
Many individuals have permanent disabilities which are likely to become worse. It is unlikely that these people's circumstances will improve significantly and, therefore, they require permanent support from the State. However, they can work. Some cases may involve mental disability but where there is a purely physical disability involved, working will not, in itself, cure such a disability. However, a person's well-being will certainly improve if he or she is capable of and wants to work. People wanting to work is the important aspect.
Comment on this
Will people be allowed to earn as much money as possible?
Comment on this
They can earn as much as possible and work for as many hours as they desire.
Comment on this
Will the personal payment from the Department of Social Protection be exempt from tax?
Comment on this
No, I do not believe so. Invalidity pension is already taxable.
Comment on this
I have an open mind on this matter. From where did the proposal come? Are there similar schemes in operation elsewhere from which the Department drew inspiration?
It is difficult to assess whether a person's capacity is 25%, 75% or whatever. It all depends on the type of work involved. A person could have a 75% capacity for doing very light work but might only have a 25% capacity for heavier work. It will, therefore, prove difficult to make assessments. What are the implications for staff with regard to the assessment process? I presume medical officers will make assessments. Given that an entirely new approach will be involved, will these people be provided with additional training? In many cases, it is possible to predict the progress of someone's physical disability. Some disabilities become progressively worse in a relatively short period, while the rate of progression in other cases is much slower. In the area of mental health, there would be peaks and troughs with regard to a person's ability. How will this be dealt with in the context of the assessment?
What does the Minister regard as being short term? If a person wants to remain on an existing scheme, what constitutes a short term? If the new scheme does not work for a person and if he or she wishes to revert to his or her original payment, will there be delays involved? There are delays with regard to processing claims at present. Will people be stuck on schemes which are not suitable to their needs while they await medical assessment? If the scheme is voluntary, what is the incentive for people to take it up?
Comment on this
We are referring to people who are on illness benefits for over six months and to those in receipt of invalidity pension. Many of these individuals are anxious to work and therein lies the incentive. A large number of those who are already in receipt of the derogation are coming to the end of their time and want to remain on the scheme. These people are in no man's land because they cannot obtain the full derogation on a continual basis. Many of the members have written to me about such individuals. On the other hand, they do not, as the Deputy pointed out, possess sufficient capacity or ability to take up full commercial employment to sustain themselves. As a result, they are faced with a Hobson's choice as to whether they should go back on invalidity pension on a full-time basis or to leave the system entirely and receive no payment.
I understand that what we are doing here is part of an international approach focused on ability being the measure which applies and on encouraging people to use their abilities, rather than classifying individuals as being disabled and stating that they cannot engage in work. It represents a general move toward trying to facilitate people in achieving whatever they desire. I stress that the scheme is completely voluntary in nature.
When the scheme was first mooted, like the Deputy I was extremely wary about it. I informed my officials in the spring that they should take their time in respect of it. I am not saying that I was responsible for initiating the scheme - I was not - but I wanted to assess whether it would be good or bad and whether we could operate it. When I considered the various issues involved, I reached the conclusion that, properly operated, this scheme represents a fantastic opportunity for many people who feel trapped and who are completely dependent on social welfare payments. These individuals feel they are disconnected from society and from the workplace. Many of those to whom I refer believe they have the capacity to work but they cannot do so without support from the State.
The Deputy inquired with regard to people reverting to their original payments if they do not continue with the scheme. If a person presents his or her P45, this is a clear indication that he or she is no longer working and he or she should then have his or her full payment restored. The waiting period should not be too lengthy.
There is no doubt that there are challenges involved. That is why we are limiting the scheme to those on invalidity pension and long-term illness benefits. There is no question that an additional burden will be imposed and this will have to be dealt with by the Department. I am of the view that this scheme will open up new possibilities. One of the difficulties with the current system is that it operates on an almost winner-takes-all basis. People either enter the system fully and then become trapped or they are rejected. What is being attempted will allow us, over time, to nuance payments so they will fit better with people's individual requirements.
I have given this matter a great deal of consideration. If one compares what is envisaged to that which currently exists - that is, a person gets the derogation for one or two years and then returns to the system - the new scheme will allow people to continue as they are on an ongoing basis but subject to periodic review. The idea is to encourage people, if they so desire, to engage in work. The second aspect is that people will not be constrained in terms of the hours they work or the amount they receive in wages. That is important because it will create stability in people's lives.
I accept the Deputy's point regarding the assessment of physical disability. In certain ways, such disabilities are easier to measure. As the Deputy will be aware, in the context of assessing a person for illness benefit, invalidity pension, and so on, endless arguments arise not only regarding the nature of the illness or ailment but in respect of whether it affects that person's ability to work. I continually come across cases where the person involved, who has a very low level of educational attainment, should be paid invalidity pension. However, the same person might be able to function if he or she had a high educational attainment and was working in an office and, therefore, if one's skills are in physical work and one has a serious physical ability, it might put one out of a job that one could do if one was working in an office. Even in the present assessment of illness benefit, account has to be taken of people's training, skills and the work they have done or are likely to secure. The same assessment has to be conducted for partial capacity and that is key to invalidity pensions and illness benefit. They are all connected to one's ability to work and not simply to the condition one has.
Mental illness is tricky to measure for eligibility for illness benefit and invalidity pension but this gives us opportunities. It is important that medical evidence is provided and that the Department assesses it in a fair and equitable manner taking into account the ups and downs of mental illness. I fully accept that people who have mental illnesses have good times and bad times. It has to be taken as a mean and it must be sustainable and, therefore, in such circumstances, one cannot expect people to be under too much pressure.
Comment on this
If people on the scheme lose their job, which is possible in the present climate, and they hope to return to employment, what payment do they receive?
Comment on this
I presume they go back on the invalidity payment and when they get a new job, they are assessed again or I presume if they get a job three weeks later, their previous assessment will be accepted and they will be put back on the payment. People can only do this once or twice and we will have to examine the regulations. However, a person within reason should be facilitated if he or she loses a job and needs a payment because he or she might not get a new job for six months or a year. We should continue to facilitate people within reason.
Comment on this
It is cumbersome for the person who wants to work half a week and then loses the job. He or she has to go back on the invalidity payment and then apply for the partial incapacity scheme if he or she has an opportunity to work. There is a great deal of interaction with the Department.
Comment on this
Yes, but what other way can this be done? If somebody is being given a long-term rolling payment because of incapacity and that is to be graded according to the disability and he or she was without work, he or she would have to be reinstated. However, that is a simple reinstatement of the existing invalidity pension. He or she will be on the invalidity pension or illness benefit all the time and, therefore, the full payment will be reinstated. Every week we have people on jobseeker's allowance and jobseeker's benefit who go on and off the payment for a day or two and we manage to control that through the maintenance section and this is no more complicated.
Comment on this
But the payment remains the same. If someone is in the labour market trying to secure an alternative job, there should be a facility for a full rate payment under this scheme.
Comment on this
One is still on the same payment, invalidity pension, but one is only paid a partial rate. All that happens is one stays on the same scheme and one gets the full rate.
Comment on this
I understand. I thought this was the new scheme.
Comment on this
We are tailoring illness benefit and invalidity pension payments to people's requirements. Under the same scheme, they will get part of the individual rate if they are working but if they stop working, we will give them the full rate. We do not expect people, like those on the dole, to be in and out every second week because that would be too cumbersome. However, if a person has worked for a year, lost a job and is out of work for six or eight weeks, it is reasonable for us to put him or her back on the full payment on the same scheme and then take him or her off once he or she starts work again.
Comment on this
No. There will be regulations that will give us an opportunity to develop secondary legislation that can be tweaked without primary legislation in the future to make this work. We live in a world where we are suspicious of what people are doing but I assure the committee I would not have gone along with this if I did not think it would facilitate many people doing what they wanted. People who have underlying disabilities want to participate in the workforce and I want to facilitate that.
A number of schemes operated by FÁS and my Department help people with disabilities into employment through employability centres around the country and so on. There is also a scheme through which FÁS pays employers. I attended a meeting recently where it was stated that everything relating to disability schemes will be brought together in one Department to facilitate these people. The dissemination of information on all the options has not been as good as it should be. I had a meeting a few weeks ago and it was agreed a simple leaflet would be prepared to outline the options for those with a disability who want to work and the options for employers in order that they can be paid to take on employees with long-term disabilities. This is important.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 3 is consequential on amendment No. 6 and, therefore, both will be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:
In page 4, between lines 1 and 2, to insert the following:
" "Act of 2006" means the Social Welfare Law Reform and Pensions Act 2006;".
These are technical amendments to provide for the definition of the Social Welfare Law Reform and Pensions Act 2006 as "the Act of 2006".
Comment on this
Amendment No. 4 is consequential on amendment No. 21 and, therefore, both will be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:
In page 4, between lines 6 and 7, to insert the following:
" "Commissioners" means the Commissioners of Public Works in Ireland;".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:
In page 4, subsection (1), lines 11 and 12, to delete "Social Welfare Law Reform and Pensions Act 2006" and substitute "Act of 2006".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:
In page 5, line 7, after "amended" to insert the following:
", for a period of 2 years from the passing of this Act, and in respect only of such sample or pilot cases as are prescribed by the Minister,".
When changes were proposed earlier this year, we were informed that a system would be introduced using voice recognition to identify whether a claimant was in or out of the country and so on. I am all in favour of using technology to streamline services but I am concerned about the proposal that claimants can send a text message to sign on. Given there is so much pressure on budgets and on staff, I am a little concerned that control standards might slip and, for that reason, I suggest the Minister's proposals should be piloted and he should come back to us within two years to get the go-ahead to extend it. It is a safeguard. We need to remain vigilant due to the pressure on budgets and the potential for fraud. Given this is such a new proposal, I am sceptical about it and for that reason, the Minister should tread carefully.
Comment on this
There are two parts to this and the other part has resulted in no debate whatsoever. We were to bring in an electronic signature pad. This is an enabling section to allow us to use secure electronic means and to prevent people from challenging us if we do so.
The second consideration is the technology we might examine. The first technology is simple. Instead of people signing physically in front of an officer, they would sign on an electronic signature pad. In other words, they would have signed their names previously and they would physically sign their names on a electronic pad and if the signatures tallied, we would accept them as being the valid person who has signed. If the signature did not tally, the person would have to go to an officer, produce identification and sign manually and the process would be done in the old fashioned way. I am told it is not as easy as one would think to forge another person's signature on an electronic signature pad.
Comment on this
What are the advantages of that?
Comment on this
If there was a queue of 100 people outside a building waiting to access an officer at a hatch, the officer would have to note that each person signs his or her name for the benefit.
Comment on this
Therefore, it would mean that an officer would not have to be there ensuring they did that.
Comment on this
No, the people would sign their names on an electronic pad. If it is not the valid person, that person would not be able to sign that valid person's signature because it is difficult to forge another person's signature accurately. If a person signs on the electronic pad and the system is not satisfied the valid person has signed because it does not recognise the signature as being correct because the person has signed his or her name a different way - I can envisage problems arising in Gaeltacht areas with people forgetting whether they signed their names in Irish or English - it will refuse the person and he or she will then have to queue.
The purpose of using electronic systems in any service is to achieve the benefit that is derived from having an ATM machine. An ATM machine will allow a customer to withdraw money without, as one would have had to do 30 years ago, physically having to go to a bank and requesting the money over the counter. It is considered that the system is sufficiently secure and that the advantages far outweigh the staff costs involved in making the service available by means of human interaction in every case. That is the first system we want to run at least as a pilot project.
The second is a system involving phones but it is not a texting system. The system will involve a person receiving an automatic phone call from the Department whereby one will be asked a random selection of questions. This voluntary scheme has voice recognition and it will be run on a pilot basis. The system will have a recording of the person's voice. This is sensitive electronic equipment. If the system notes the person contacted is not the valid person, the call will be automatically switched off. Unless the valid person answers, the system will not work. The system will ask random questions. One could not have a prerecording of one's voice on one's phone to answer the questions posed because one would not know the sequence of questions that would be posed. If the answers given do not match the questions posed, the system will switch off and the person will be sent for. This system will establish that the person contacted is in the country and if that person is the valid person.
A person might say that he or she was working on a building site, which might be true, but if rumours we hear are true, many people are reputed to take the appropriate one day or half day off a month to go and sign on, although I am not saying that happens. This is not a deterrent either to working and drawing benefit. This system is worth operating on a trial basis. We cannot operate any such systems even on a trial basis without certification of a right to use electronic methods, as we propose here. This is an enabling measure. I fully agree with the Deputy that we must be careful in trying out this system. We do not want to waste a great deal of money until we are fairly sure this system works and delivers what we want it to deliver, which is to free up staff for more important work.
Comment on this
Are either of those systems operated anywhere else?
Comment on this
I understand the voice system is not operated elsewhere. We are at the cutting edge in initiating it, but it is to be operated on a trial basis and it is only when the findings of that have been evaluated in terms of proof that a decision will be made on it which could have wider implications. We are at the front line with this system but someone has to go first.
Comment on this
What is the extent of the trial the Minister is proposing?
Comment on this
It would be fairly limited at the beginning to ensure it works.
Comment on this
I find this difficult to accept because in recent years the Department has been trying to collect PPS numbers, for example, on rent supplement forms. It took it three years to ensure a box to be ticked was inserted on that form, which is difficult to understand. Given that the technology is at that very early stage in the Department, it is difficult to accept that the Minister would be in a position to operate this type of technology satisfactorily at a safe level. I am very sceptical about it. For that reason I propose we operate it for a two year period as a pilot project with a small sample and that the Minister would revert to us and let us know the findings on it.
Comment on this
This system will not be rolled out on a widespread basis unless it works. Part of what is proposed is to use any electronic means to improve the position and part of that involves the use of electronic signature pads. As Deputy Shortall will appreciate, that is a much easier aspect to control because people go to social welfare offices to sign their names and if a signature does not match, then the facility will not work.
Comment on this
I am not saying that the Minister should not try it on a pilot basis but there should be limits on it. I am pressing the amendment.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 9 to 11, inclusive, are related to amendment No. 8 and, therefore, all will be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In page 5, line 32, to delete "declarations" and substitute "a declaration".
The purpose of the amendments is to ensure declarations of unemployment given in electronic form have the same legal standing in court proceedings as declarations given in written form. The amendments also provide for textual amendments to the Bill as published. I accept Deputy Shortall's comments about piloting this proposal. We need to be careful. If it does not work, there is no point flogging a dead horse.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:
In page 5, line 39, to delete "declarations" and substitute "a declaration".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:
In page 6, lines 3 and 4, to delete "make declarations" and substitute "make a declaration".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:
In page 6, to delete lines 8 to 52 and in page 7, to delete lines 1 and 2 and substitute the following:
"(a) a certificate signed by an officer of the Minister, authorised by the Minister in that behalf, stating—
(i) that he or she has examined the record relating to the proving of unemployment and the making of a declaration for that purpose by the person by means of the electronic communication in the prescribed manner,
(ii) that a record of that electronic communication has been made, and
(iii) the date on which that electronic communication was made,
shall be admissible in evidence in any proceedings (whether civil or criminal) before a court and shall be evidence of those facts unless the contrary is proved in any such proceedings, and
(b) it shall be presumed, unless the contrary is proved in any such proceedings, that—
(i) a declaration that purports to have been made by a person by means of an electronic communication, was made by that person,
(ii) a declaration which purports to have been made by a person by means of an electronic communication in respect of a particular period, was made in respect of that period,
(iii) any equipment used to make the electronic communication operated effectively, and
(iv) the method of electronic communication used for the purpose of making a declaration operated effectively.
(2) Any declaration made by means of an electronic communication in accordance with this Act shall be deemed to be a declaration made in the prescribed manner under section 62 or 141.
(3) Any declaration made by means of an electronic communication in accordance with this Act shall be deemed to be a statement or representation for the purposes of section 251.
(4) A document purporting to be a certificate referred to in subsection (1)(a) shall be deemed to be such a certificate and to have been signed by the person purporting to have signed it and to have been signed in accordance with an authorisation referred to in subsection (1)(a) unless the contrary is proved.”.”.
Comment on this
I am concerned about this proposal for signing on. I am more concerned having read the Sunday newspapers. Have the departmental officials signed up to this or will there be more union disputes? Fingerprinting equipment costing more than €20 million is lying idle in Garda headquarters and this was intended to help the Minister and his Department identify whether people are legally in the State and not defrauding the State of social welfare payments. I have great concerns about the Minister's proposal and I will not support it.
He referred to ATM machines but they are not safe or foolproof. I attended a wedding in Portugal last year and I only used my card once. The next thing it was used in Holland and €2,500 was taken out of my account. I am concerned about electronic signing in and I will oppose it on all Stages of the legislation. It is not right. The Minister's predecessor, Deputy Hanafin, said she wanted people to sign in physically and be accountable. I am concerned about the measure in question in this section because it is too open to fraud. It frightens me. We are not ready for electronic signing in, even at this stage. We will not know whether people are in or out of the country. I am concerned about it and I will oppose it.
Comment on this
It is the Deputy's call if he wants to rush to oppose the section. He should recall that all this is not specific to mobile telephony. The much simpler idea, which the Deputy is blocking, is the idea of a signing pad within the employment exchange where one must physically attend. Rather than having queues of people at the hatch, all that would be necessary would be to sign the pad and for the signature to match up. That would be quite basic technology and if the signature did not match up, the person would have to go to the hatch. If a system such as this relieved the queues and the time staff need to put in to attend to them, it would seem reasonable to choose that option. These people would be preselected and would not be selected if they were high risk claimants. What we seek here is the enabling power to use electronic means to identify people in order that if there is a challenge in the courts, the system will stand up to that. The ruling out of all electronic systems, whatever the doubt one might have about the mobile telephony system, would constrain the Department and require it to use labour intensive means to ensure people physically sign in.
The change made by the former Minister, Deputy Hanafin, was simple and was a good idea, namely, that all new applicants should physically collect their payment at the post office. One of the big changes in this regard is the public services card and this is another piece of gadgetry for which we have had to provide through legislation. The card will be of great use to those in the post offices to ensure the right claimant is collecting the payment, which must be collected weekly in person. The introduction of the card will prevent what people alleged was happening, for which there is no evidence on any scale, that people outside the jurisdiction were collecting welfare payments.
I respect the Deputy's right to oppose any section of the Bill, but what he is trying to stop is the use of any electronic means and not just the specific use of one piece of technology. I believe that technology is worth a try and that any technology that will free up staff and make a greater saving compared with the risk is worthwhile. Having visited many employment social welfare offices and looked at the situation and what we do objectively, I believe the most effective control when properly organised is for the claimant to collect the payment using the public services card. One could question whether signing in serves any great purpose because currently it is on a predetermined date. The new technology would not work from a predetermined date and could catch people any day. Many people would argue it is easy enough for people to organise their lives to be free on the one day per month on which they must sign in and that all the time and effort the Department spends on it does not provide a gain. That said, I would be reluctant to do away with that system without careful consideration. Having witnessed the amount of time taken for signing on in welfare offices, however, I agree it is inordinate and disproportionate to the benefit we get from it.
Comment on this
What concerns me is the significant fraud that exists, as evidenced by the significant savings made in the Department last year. I am not convinced the new system will work and am concerned that people working in the black economy can sign on and make themselves available on whatever day required to collect their payment. I do not believe we are ready for this new system.
The Minister did not comment on the fingerprinting system that was to be at Garda headquarters. When will that be up and running? If that were operational, it might be possible to consider the Minister's proposal. We have expensive equipment lying idle, which has cost the State some €20 million. It has been in place since 2006 but has not yet been used because staff want extra funding to implement it. I am concerned about the proposed system and am not happy about it because the Minister has not convinced me.
Comment on this
I have no problem with those, provided people must come in and sign them.
Comment on this
The Deputy would prevent that by opposing the section.
Comment on this
I cannot make a distinction as both are part of the same section. I intend to oppose the provision I am opposed to.
Comment on this
Will the Minister confirm there will be photographic identification on the public services card?
Comment on this
When is that expected to be rolled out and how soon will it be up and running?
Comment on this
I understand that late this month the first cards will be ready and the roll-out will begin next year. It will take a long time for a complete roll-out.
Comment on this
Will all of them have photos on them?
Comment on this
They will have a photo and a microchip and PIN number. It is similar security to a passport. The card is fine and can have all the features one wants. We must allow, however, that there are two ways to use the card. I can go in with my card and show it, and if the office does not have the matching technology, the person to whom I have handed it can examine the card, see it has not been forged and identify me from the photograph. If the person has the matching technology, the card can be swiped and the electronic technology can check whether the photograph matches the person presenting, which would be more accurate than visual identification.
Comment on this
It is like at the airport. Normally when one hands in one's passport at the airport, the officer just looks at it and checks whether the photo looks like the passenger. There is technology available which allows people to scan the photos to check whether they match the passenger.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying that technology will be available?
Comment on this
No, but it could be used to verify photos. The card just has a photograph.
Comment on this
What system will operate with the card?
Comment on this
It is a chip and PIN card that will work just like a passport does.
Comment on this
Okay, but one does not claim money with a passport. Will the Minister explain what will happen?
Comment on this
I am looking at all angles. The person has a card and the card states it belongs to the person who is named on the card. What determines whether an officer thinks the person holding the card is the same person as the one in the photograph on the card is a visual inspection of the person.
Comment on this
One could go further if one had major doubts and have a photograph taken of the person and compare it electronically with the photo on the card, but that system would not be disseminated to every post office in the country. We could not do that.
Comment on this
What will happen when the new system is introduced in the new year?
Comment on this
People will get their cards with their photograph embedded in it and with chip and PIN technology that is similar to that in a passport.
Comment on this
Okay. What happens then? Does the person then go to the post office and swipe the card?
Comment on this
Do they then enter their PIN number?
Comment on this
Yes, if the technology is available at the post office.
Comment on this
Assuming the technology is available, must they enter their PIN number?
Comment on this
Yes, they will have to use their PIN number.
Comment on this
What must the post office staff check with regard to the claimant? Obviously, the card must be swiped and the PIN number entered. What else is required?
Comment on this
Obviously, the claimant must look like the person on the card.
Comment on this
Must that check be done always?
Comment on this
Yes, that is understood. In the beginning we may not necessarily have the technology everywhere for swiping, so some verification might be needed as in-----
Comment on this
What is the plan for rolling out the technology? When and where will it start?
Comment on this
It will begin in January and continue throughout the year.
Comment on this
How will it begin? Will it begin with machines being installed in all the post offices?
Comment on this
First we must install the machines to take the photographs and issue the cards and must require the claimants to come forward for that. This will be done automatically for people getting a new card and PPS number. For the major cohort of existing claimants, however, we must set up facilities throughout the country to provide for them to have their photographs taken, etc. that all comply with the system. This is being rolled out currently.
Comment on this
Following that, a machine that recognises the card must be installed in post offices.
Comment on this
What I am saying is that the new cards, even if post offices do not have a machine that can read them, are still far more accurate than any of the previous cards we have had because the photograph on them cannot be falsified. Therefore, a visual inspection of the card and of the person presenting the card that satisfies the officer the presenter is the person in question is adequate to suggest it is the proper card. Once one is satisfied that Éamon Ó Cuív is the person and it is Éamon Ó Cuív's photograph, then it is the proper card. I could not take Michael Ring's card, take out his photograph and put Éamon Ó Cuív's picture on it because it is embossed and it is not possible to do that.
Comment on this
What would stop Deputy Shortall taking my card and just swiping it for me?
Comment on this
No, because I would know that Deputy Shortall does not look like Deputy Ring.
Comment on this
No, one is not swiping into a machine. One has to have a person there. For instance, the Garda check at the airport will always check the photograph. The issue of concern is whether a person has falsified the passport but it is very difficult to falsify a modern passport compared with an older passport which had a stick-on photograph. The security features on the modern passport mean it cannot be falsified. The Garda security will do a visual inspection of the person and the passport photograph and decide the two are the same.
Comment on this
When does the Minister expect the system to be fully operating so that everyone has a card with a photo identification and every post office has a swipe machine?
Comment on this
Three million cards will have to be issued to people. I think it will take more than a year to have everyone registered. There are some very low risk groups, such as pensioners. All the new numbers will be issued with a card. The free travel pass will be attached to the card in future and the card will become the free travel pass. I believe there will be a significant demand and people will want to get the card. One of the problems will be to ensure everyone seeks the card. Those who need the card will seek the card as opposed to those who do not use the card. I do not think I have ever used my PPS card as I have never interacted with social welfare with identification.
Comment on this
Is the figure of 3 million all adults?
Comment on this
The card is a chip and PIN card with regard to its security features. I am not sure whether everyone will be issued with a PIN number. I can clarify that for the Deputy. It contains a photograph and a signature but it is a secure card and it is not open to falsification.
Comment on this
Will they have to be swiped in a machine?
Comment on this
My understanding is that in certain cases they will need to be swiped to avail of services but in other cases it will be just a visual inspection.
Comment on this
When the scheme is fully up and running is it the intention that every post office would have a swipe machine?