We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

SELECT COMMITTEE ON SOCIAL PROTECTION

Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions)(No. 2) Bill 2010: Committee Stage

Contributions 149–290 of 290. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Social Welfare and Pensions Bill, 2010
Enacted

No. 51 of 2010 ›

Is that the intention?

Comment on this

I presume over time as this rolls out, but we have to put the card in place first.

Comment on this

I do not think that is the right approach. We have had umpteen examples in this country of technology being introduced and being found to be completely and utterly inadequate. Perhaps the most glaring example was the electronic voting machines. It is important we get this right. It is a very expensive scheme. What is the estimated total cost?

Comment on this

I can provide the Deputy with a detailed brief on the scheme. The technical systems will cost approximately €1.5 million to €2 million and it will cost approximately €24 million for a population of 3 million. At the moment, when a person needs to engage with my Department, we have no proper system of identification.

Comment on this

No one is arguing with that. My point is if there is going to be something like €26 million spent on a new system, we want to be pretty sure it will work and do the job it is intended to do.

Comment on this

Of course it is. I have a sample card to show the Deputy. The card has a lady's name and photograph. If I go in to claim a payment, that card is practically impossible to use to defraud, unlike anything available today. For the first time, the social services card carries a photograph. For instance, if Deputy Michael Ring purports to be that lady, I think we will know very quickly by visual inspection that he is not that lady and, therefore, no dice. Up to now, if he came in with a PPS card, we would not know because even though the card shows a girl's name, we would not know because it has no photograph. This new card has a secure photo ID and this in itself is a significant step forward. It means that anyone interacting with the system will have this card and so long as the person in the photograph is the person presenting, one can be satisfied that is the genuine person. The only thing that could possibly fool the system is a case of identical twins or two other people who look exactly alike and whom it is not possible to differentiate by visual inspection.

Comment on this

I am sure the former Ministers for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government, Deputy Noel Dempsey and former Deputy Martin Cullen, both said that electronic voting was impossible to defraud. All those assurances were given. The Minister told me this was a chip and PIN system.

Comment on this

Yes, it is a chip and PIN system. I am not saying it has a PIN number but it is a chip and PIN system.

Comment on this

How can it be a chip and PIN system if there is no PIN number?

Comment on this

It is a technical term. I will supply the Deputy with the details of the card.

Comment on this

This does not exactly inspire confidence.

Comment on this

The public service card will have a multiple protection mechanism to prevent and detect tampering with the physical card and its contents. We are not giving the full details because we do not wish to tempt anyone but they will be to the highest current international standards. The internal fraud prevention and detection incorporates photographic identification and signature and introduces important control benefits.

Comment on this

I suggest that the committee be provided with a full briefing on the card from the technical people.

Comment on this

Certainly. It is meant to be an identity card.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 12:

In page 8, line 12, after "number" to insert "and a tax clearance certificate".

This amendment relates to the payment of rent supplement. More than €500 million is paid to private landlords annually. Concern has been identified by the Committee of Public Accounts that the Department of Social Protection has traditionally wiped its hands of any responsibility for ensuring the people receiving this large amount of public money are tax compliant. An efficient system for ensuring this compliance is still not in place.

The Minister is making some stab at it in this section but, in my view, his proposal is inadequate. As a minimum, he should require landlords to be tax compliant if they are to receive rent supplement from the State. Anyone who wants to do any work for the State or even do grant work for the local authority, such as bathroom conversions, is required to produce a tax clearance certificate. There is no excuse, in my view, for not requiring landlords to produce a tax clearance certificate. This should be a basic requirement and my amendment proposes this. The amendment proposes that any landlord who is paid by the State is required to be tax compliant.

Comment on this

I do not propose to accept the amendment, but I have considerable sympathy.

Comment on this

That is not good enough. Why does the Minister not accept it?

Comment on this

A number of issues would need to be addressed before accepting it. The first step is what we are doing, which is to get the Revenue number. Two main issues would need to be addressed. First, the Department's relationship is with the tenant and not the landlord, which is a fundamental issue. In the current amendment, that took quite a bit of work to address. Second, seeking tax clearance involves considerable extra bureaucracy. I believe this is a significant step forward. By virtue of having a PPS number for every landlord, it will be very simple for us to provide all that information to the Revenue and for it to check it is getting a record of every tenancy. One of the requirements is that a landlord with five tenancies will be required to give the number five times. We will know of each tenancy and it is not a kind of bulk thing. Given the issues that would remain outstanding, it is not for this Bill but if I am around in the future, it is certainly something I would consider.

Comment on this

That is just not good enough. The Minister has responsibility now to deal with this and he is suggesting that he will gradually work his way through it. Why does he not just deal with it and stop dragging his heels?

Comment on this

That is because----

Comment on this

Just a second, Minister.

Comment on this

The Department's performance has been abysmal in this area. Has he looked at what has happened in recent years? Has he considered, for example, the report the Committee of Public Accounts prepared on it? Has he looked at the report of the Comptroller and Auditor General? The Department has ignored the issue completely and his predecessors did not see themselves as having any responsibility to the taxpayer to ensure landlords were tax compliant. When landlords were asked previously to supply their PPS numbers and Revenue went about matching that PPS number to landlords' tax identities, I believe it matched approximately one third of them. A huge number of PPS numbers given were falsified. Is the Minister aware that happened? He should be aware and if he is, he should not just take the easy approach he proposes to take. There is no argument for not requiring landlords to produce tax clearance certificates and the Minister is being remiss in his responsibility to the taxpayer by not requiring that.

The Minister made the point that the rent supplement is paid to the tenant in the majority of cases. The next amendment deals with that. He knows that Threshold and other groups have been lobbying for years to try to get the payments made directly from the Department to the landlord and cutting out all this nonsense of how to get around the Department's responsibility to the tenant. The way to do it is to make the payments directly to the landlord. Later I will outline many reasons this makes sense for the State in terms of saving money. I cannot imagine any defence for not doing this and I propose to press the amendment.

Comment on this

When I became Minister for Social Protection I raised the issue of the PPS numbers. Funnily enough, some of the groups the Deputy mentioned were opposed to insisting on getting a PPS number.

Comment on this

That is because insisting on getting a number does not work.

Comment on this

Some of the groups were very reluctant to go as far as I propose, which is to insist on getting a PPS number because they felt it might discommode tenants and put them under pressure. Having weighed up the issue, I believe they were wrong and that as the Deputy has said, it is vital we would get a PPS number for every landlord, but that is not the unanimous view of all the different housing groups I have met which represent the tenant side.

Looking at the totality of the issue and given all the issues that would need to be resolved, it would not be possible to have introduced an amendment such as the one the Deputy proposes by Christmas of this year. What we are doing is an essential first step. Obviously, it would be a serious offence for someone to falsify the number and that would need to be dealt with.

Comment on this

They have been falsified on a widespread basis and they know no action can be taken.

Comment on this

Since I became Minister for Social Protection, I have taken the view that regardless of what happened before I came in - I cannot speak for that - it is vital to get a correct number. Obviously a landlord is now breaking the law by not providing the correct number. Up to now there was no legal obligation to provide the number and therefore it was not possible to take sanction against a person who provided the wrong number, including providing no number.

Comment on this

Will the Minister now devote stretched departmental resources to chasing people's PPS numbers?

Comment on this

They have to provide them or otherwise-----

Comment on this

Or otherwise what?

Comment on this

-----they will be subject to the fact that we will not continue with the tenancy.

Comment on this

How will the Department know if the number is valid?

Comment on this

We pass all these numbers on to the Revenue.

Comment on this

How long will it take for Revenue to check?

Comment on this

That is done regularly and there are already data.

Comment on this

How long will it take Revenue to check out the numbers?

Comment on this

They are all automatic so it will just put it into the computer and match the number.

Comment on this

What happens if they do not match?

Comment on this

Obviously the person who gave us the number is breaking the law.

Comment on this

What will the Department do then?

Comment on this

The tenancy is no longer valid.

Comment on this

The Department will devote a considerable amount of time to dealing with that when it could be done much more neatly.

Comment on this

A person could send in someone else's tax clearance certificate just as easily.

Comment on this

They do that all the time.

Comment on this

That does not solve the Deputy's problem. Given the time constraint and all the issues that would need negotiation, it would not have been possible between last April and now to go further than we are going. It is a significant first step and people can build on this basic building block I have put in place.

Comment on this

It is not a significant first step. I will bet any money that another committee will be back here in 12 months' time talking about how we can ensure landlords are tax compliant because the Minister's proposal will not work. I cannot understand his reticence in moving to ensure landlords are tax compliant. He has said he could not have put everything in place to introduce a new system by Christmas. It does not need to be in by then as he knows perfectly well. He could provide for it in the legislation, move to make the necessary arrangements and then commence the section at that point.

Comment on this

As the Deputy will find if she ever gets into this position, it takes time to put all the different parts of the jigsaw in place.

Comment on this

I am not denying that.

Comment on this

If the Deputy is trying to imply that in some way I am soft on people who are not complying with paying their tax-----

Comment on this

The Minister is being so if this is all he is prepared to do.

Comment on this

I am not. I am taking the first step to insist on the PPS number being given. The only one that is valid is the correct PPS number of the person. With the data matching we have with the Revenue, the Revenue will very quickly be able to ascertain whether a person is making the appropriate declarations on income from rental sources.

I hear what the Deputy is saying on general tax compliance and whether a person should be able to get a rental payment indirectly from the Department. That raises other issues that would need to be examined in full. Legally we are not paying the landlord, which is a valid point. That issue should and will be considered in the future. Regardless of what the Deputy thinks, the time constraints did not allow for all the legal and other issues it raises to be resolved by now. It took considerable work to get this far. Many issues were raised in the Office of the Attorney General and there were many difficulties with it. This very important first step is in place in the Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister has been in the job long enough to tackle the issue.

Comment on this

I have not been there that long.

Comment on this

It has been well flagged by the Comptroller and Auditor General and the Committee of Public Accounts. The Minister knows there is a glaring gap in the information system and he could have moved to tackle it this time.

Comment on this

When the Deputy gets to this side of the House, if she ever does, I think she will find that-----

Comment on this

It is regrettable that he did not do so. He should have been more proactive in this area.

Comment on this

I was hugely proactive.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 13:

In page 11, between lines 10 and 11, to insert the following subsection:

"(4) A payment of rent supplement under the Principal Act shall be made directly to the landlord and not to the tenant.".

This amendment could have been grouped with the last amendment as the subject matter of both amendments is related. The big problem with rent supplement is that it is not directly paid to the landlord. That raises all kinds of difficulties. I refer, for example, to the lack of tax compliance, which we have just been talking about. Tenants sometimes pocket these moneys. Landlords often demand illegal top-up payments. Quite often, the State does not get the best value for the money it is spending in this regard. If payments were made directly to landlords, it would be possible to negotiate with them and drive down the rents being sought. Some 50% of the rental market is taken up with rent supplement. It is playing a part in increasing rent levels and therefore distorting the market to an extent. It seems incredible that there is no provision for the State to decide, across the board, to cut the rents of 50% of the market. The Minister has suggested that cannot be done because it would affect tenants.

The reductions in the level of rent supplement in the last two budgets have not caused rents to go down. The decreases resulted in tenants having to pay more, thereby impoverishing themselves. Many of those who depend on rent supplement are paid the lowest levels of income and live in poor quality accommodation. They are often quite vulnerable. As the Minister is aware, they are not in a position to negotiate with their landlords. The cuts that have taken place over the past two budgets have had a direct impact on the individual tenants, rather than the landlords. This amendment is necessary to make the system more streamlined and, most of all, to make savings for the State. It would eliminate all the illegal activity in the rent supplement system. It makes absolute sense that payments should be made directly to landlords. That is why I propose this amendment.

Comment on this

I do not propose to accept this amendment. Rent supplement is administered on behalf of the Department by the HSE as part of the supplementary welfare allowance scheme. The purpose of rent supplement is to provide short-term income support to eligible people living in private rented accommodation whose means are insufficient to meet their accommodation costs and who do not have accommodation available to them from any other source. The tenant makes an application for rent supplement. The Department's relationship is with the tenant in all cases. The payment made to the tenant is the property of the tenant. It is provided specifically for the benefit of the tenant, to assist him or her with accommodation needs. As with other social welfare payments, a recipient of rent supplement may nominate an agent to receive payment on his or her behalf. There are almost 97,000 rent supplements in payment. Some 20% of rent supplement payments are paid to a person other than the recipient. These payments can be made to the landlord, an agent of the landlord or another person designated by the recipient, such as a sibling.

Under the current arrangements, even with direct payment landlords still have to collect a tenant contribution of a minimum of €104 a month towards rent. The amount of rent supplement payable depends on the tenant's income. In some cases, tenants only pay the minimum contribution. In other cases, the tenant makes an additional contribution to the rent, based on his or her financial circumstances. For example, if a person has a part-time income and receives just 10% of his or her rent directly from the State, the landlord will receive 10% directly and have to collect 90% from the tenant. The efficiency of the scheme would be significantly affected if this arrangement were changed. For example, community welfare officers would potentially have to create a formal relationship with some 97,000 additional clients - the landlords. Greater complexity and significant resources would be necessitated to deal with a new set of third parties. Community welfare officers would be drawn into disputes between landlords and tenants. There may be financial and control implications in cases where a tenant moves address and neither the landlord nor the tenant informs the Department. Similarly, where a tenant is no longer eligible for rent supplement and the Department ceases paying the landlord, the Department may find itself involved in eviction proceedings.

The supplementary welfare allowance scheme, which includes the rent supplement scheme, has a clear role to play in providing support to individuals and families and alleviating poverty and social exclusion. The scheme is designed to enable immediate and flexible assistance to be provided. The advantage of the current arrangements for the payment of rent supplement, particularly in the short term, is that it gives recipients a degree of flexibility in terms of location. They have the freedom to move to a different location. At the same time, they can seek an alternative long-term housing solution from the local authority.

Even if the payment were assigned to the landlord, the landlord would have to collect the balance. If the full amount due to the landlord was paid to him or her by the community welfare officer under the supplementary welfare scheme, it would not deal with this problem. As the Deputy said, some landlords are allegedly demanding money over and above that which they are entitled to claim. I cannot understand how paying the landlord part of the payment would stop that from happening. In all cases, the tenant would still have to make some payment to the landlord. Landlords are not allowed to charge more. It is clearly wrong and illegal. The Deputy's proposal would not deal with that. I understand that the opposite is happening in some cases. One hears stories of landlords accepting the amount minus the local contribution. They are not bothering to collect the rest of the money from the tenant. That is not meant to happen either. In such circumstances, obviously, the landlord has given the wrong sum for the rent. If the Deputy knows of any cases-----

Comment on this

It is widespread. The Minister should not stick his head in the sand.

Comment on this

-----where landlords are looking for top-up payments, she should report it immediately to the appropriate authorities because it is illegal.

Comment on this

As there is a vote in the Dail, I propose to suspend the meeting.

Comment on this

The Minister is like an ostrich.

Comment on this

This morning we indicated we may take a break at 1 p.m. I will leave the decision to members and the Minister. Deputy Shortall was in possession.

Comment on this

Whatever about the theory of rent supplement being a short-term scheme, it has developed into something entirely different. On the issue of savings, approximately €7 million is lost annually through deposits. This money could be saved immediately if the payment was made directly to the landlord. Such a change would also make it much easier to tackle anti-social activity by tenants. The principle of direct payment has been established under the successful residential accommodation scheme, RAS. There is no reason not to accept the proposal.

Comment on this

Does the Minister wish to have a final word on the matter?

Comment on this

I thought I had the final word on the amendment.

Comment on this

Should I not allow the Minister to have a final word, as is customary?

Comment on this

The difference between the RAS and the rent supplement scheme is that the relationship is with the landlord and relates to locally authority approved accommodation. Local authorities have the resources to operate in the manner sought by the Deputy but our system does not operate in such a manner because the scheme is short term in nature.

My position is not far from that of the Deputy. I share her belief that rent supplement should not be provided in the long term. I am engaging with the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government and, through it, with local authorities to ensure the scheme fulfils its original function of serving as a temporary arrangement to facilitate people in securing temporary accommodation of their choice, subject to certain criteria.

Questions were asked about numbers and so forth. The obligation on landlords to provide a PPS number only came into force on 28 October 2008. The full year date file for 2008 sent to Revenue contained 107,000 records. However, only 4,285 of these records were in respect of tenancies registered after 28 October 2008 where a PPS was requested. Of these, 3,373, or 79% of the records, also had the relevant landlord PPS or tax reference number recorded.

The 2009 data are being validated by the Health Service Executive and will be returned to the Revenue Commissioners in the coming weeks. Revenue has advised that, following enhancement of its automated matching process, it successfully identified the landlord PPS numbers in an average of 72% of rent supplement records for the years 2002-08. When the 2009 file is forwarded to the Revenue Commissioners in the coming weeks, it will contain the landlord PPS number where it has been provided.

I do not propose to read the full details in respect of the records. In 2008, the number of matched records was 75,836 with a matched value of €305 million, while the number of unmatched records was 31,390 with an unmatched value of €121 million. The total number of records was 107,000. To provide anything other than a correct PPS number is illegal. I stress that we expect there to be a perfect match.

Revenue has further advised that in 2007 it undertook compliance checks to test if rents being paid by the Department of Social and Family Affairs were being declared to Revenue. A sample of 215 cases was chosen from a number of categories and gross rents declared on the income tax returns were cross-referenced with the amounts on the Department's file. All cases of discrepancies underwent further investigation. The sample, in the case of larger cases, was 50 and the compliance rate was 88%. The sample of unmatched cases was 115 and the compliance rate was 95%. There appears, therefore, from the checks to be a high level of compliance.

A tax clearance certificate does not prove that rent has been declared because certificates are post factum and a person may receive a tax clearance certificate and not declare all income. Data matching is the only effective way of ensuring that rent earned is declared. We need greater automation in the system of data matching. The Department’s computer systems have been upgraded for the purpose of matching its data with Revenue data.

Comment on this

The Minister's contribution supports my point. We are in the last month of 2010 yet the 2009 figures have not yet been validated.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 14 is out of order.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 15:

In page 11, between lines 10 and 11, to insert the following subsection:

"(4) A payment of rent supplement under the Principal Act shall be suspended where the Minister has reasonable grounds to believe that the tenant has engaged in anti-social activity.".

Amendment No. 14 proposed to address the issue of non-resident landlords who currently escape the tax net. There is a ridiculous practice whereby, in theory, tenants are supposed to withhold 20% of their rent payment for the purpose of the payment of taxes by a non-resident landlord. The purpose of the amendment was to ensure non-resident landlords paid a withholding tax. Owing to the ridiculous rules of this House, which prevent Members from tabling amendments that result in either a charge on the Exchequer or on taxpayers, my amendment has been ruled out of order. It is madness and indicative of the arcane nature of many of the rules of the House that a proposal that would have resulted in savings for the State has been ruled out of order.

On amendment No. 15, if a properly functioning rent supplement system were in place, it would be possible to deal with anti-social activity on the part of some tenants. All Members know how difficult it is to address problems associated with anti-social activity by tenants in receipt of rent supplement. The issue in terms of local authority tenants is a lot more satisfactory in so far as the legislation is in place to enable local authorities to address anti-social activity. There is no such provision in the rent supplement system.

I propose in the amendment that we should give the power to withhold payment of rent supplement in the event of a tenant engaging in anti-social activity. That is reasonable. It would help to ensure proper behaviour on the part of tenants in receipt of considerable amounts of taxpayers' money in rent supplement. It would also equalise the situation between rent supplement tenants and local authority tenants. For that reason I urge the Minister to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

Existing legislation provides the Health Service Executive with the authority to refuse, suspend or terminate payment of rent supplement in the case of a person who has been required to deliver up possession of a dwelling provided by a housing authority or an approved body where the reason for that requirement includes anti-social behaviour or the interests of good estate management.

If a landlord is dissatisfied with a tenant owing to anti-social behaviour, he or she has the normal recourse of the Private Residential Tenancies Board, PRTB, or the Garda. There are enough powers in place. I do not know what the answer is to all the challenges that exist. I accept there are neighbours from hell. I know all about them from listening to people. On the other hand, people have to live somewhere. There are powers to deal with the issue under a number of headings but it is a very tricky issue in its broadest sense.

Comment on this

I accept what the Minister says, that people must live somewhere, but if they are provided with the vast bulk of their rent by the State, conditions should attach.

Comment on this

There are conditions.

Comment on this

The minimum conditions should include that they behave themselves, respect the property and their neighbours.

Comment on this

Those principles have been accepted for local authority tenants. It is possible to take action against the minority of tenants who engage in anti-social activity. The same could be the case with tenants receiving rent supplement if the Minister had a will to ensure it happened.

Earlier the Minister referred to cases where rent supplement can be denied where tenants are evicted from local authority housing. That is true in those circumstances but it does not help the situation where a person in receipt of rent supplement engages in anti-social activity. A community welfare officer should have the right to refuse to continue to provide rent supplement if the tenant insists on engaging in anti-social activity in the community. To suggest that the PRTB can deal with this is nonsense. We all know the long delays that exist in that regard. Such cases then get caught up in the courts. It is a straightforward issue. If a substantial sum of money is being provided to a tenant weekly or monthly, conditions should be attached to that and there should be an expectation that people who are housed by the State would behave themselves and respect their neighbours. That is the purpose of the amendment.

Comment on this

I agree with Deputy Shortall about the direct payment to the landlord. It should be done and the Government should move on that immediately.

On the tax clearance certificate, it is very important that these people are paying their taxes in the State or outside it. I agree with what Deputy Shortall said about the amendment that was ruled out of order. There should be a withholding tax for such people. They should pay the same contributions as people who live in this country. It is up to them to get their tax affairs in order in the State. It is not up to me or the Minister to do that.

I am on the policing board in County Mayo. Like all my colleagues we must attend a number of such meetings. This issue has arisen in every area where I have attended meetings. Two things must happen. In future, when people seek rent allowance from community welfare officers, a check should be carried out in cases where they have moved from a property, whether it is inside or outside the jurisdiction, inside the county, outside the county, or in another country. Checks should be carried out to ensure they are no longer in receipt of rent allowance from a previous allocation to ensure people are not being paid rent allowance in more than one place at a time. I am aware of one case where a person got it in both Dublin and Mayo.

In some cases the level of anti-social behaviour was outrageous. It is wrong that local authorities and community welfare officers do not make checks. In one situation a woman was dying of cancer and tenants disrupted her family life but no one was prepared to do anything about it. The State is handing out money in rent allowance to the person responsible for such behaviour. The Minister said people must live somewhere. They have to live the same as everyone else. If people want rent allowance and to live in a house, they must behave like everyone else. The laws are in place but the local authorities and the Garda are not dealing with the issue. It is left to residents to deal with the matter, as happened in my area. The situation was dealt with. In fairness, the Garda supported the residents because it was known the problem was serious and that the woman affected was very sick. If a person is getting rent allowance, it should be subject to certain criteria. Such people must live like everyone else. We accept they must be provided with accommodation but they must behave themselves.

This is the most serious issue facing the private sector. People were buying houses for the past 20 years which led to the current problem with the economy. They were renting out the houses and they did not care who was living in them once they got their payment. They do not look after the houses, cut the grass, clean them up or paint them. They hand them over to tenants who do not behave themselves and the people who own their houses and could not move were caught on either side of such tenants. Something must be done. The Minister should accept the amendment. It is a good one. He might wish to return to it on Report Stage but it should be introduced to address the problem. Something must be done. It is the one issue that comes up in the policing fora in Ballina and Westport and with the county council. People want to know what they can do about the anti-social behaviour of certain tenants.

Comment on this

I support the sentiments expressed in the amendment tabled by Deputy Shortall and what Deputy Ring said. The problem is much more serious than the Minister seems to appreciate. Tenants in certain situations are making life a living hell for their neighbours. They have no responsibility to anyone. The landlord may have no responsibility and he may refuse to take any action. It is irresponsible of the State to support that kind of situation, to give carte blanche to what is clearly undermining society in a particular area. All one needs is three or four such tenants in a block of houses to ruin life for everyone else.

In one case with which I am familiar the Garda had to provide protection to the neighbour of an unruly tenant who deliberately went out of his way to intimidate his neighbours at every opportunity. The Garda had to escort the neighbours to and from their houses. It is crazy stuff that we should be at this juncture. Under the legislation, community welfare officers are due to come under the jurisdiction of the Department of Social Protection. It is time to jump ahead of the posse instead of running around in circles as has been the case.

We fully accept that people need rent supplement. They readily apply for it and are glad to get it. We strongly support the need to have applications dealt with quickly, efficiently and effectively. We also strongly support the need to ensure the poor unfortunate applicant is not hanging on for months waiting for approval, up to six months in some cases, as has happened in the past year. We must also draw the line that where a tenancy is being abused, to the merriment of the people who are the beneficiaries - admittedly a minority - it must be addressed as a matter of urgency.

It is all very fine to say that certain amendments are not acceptable because they involve a charge on the Exchequer. Money is at stake in the context of this amendment, from the point of view of the Exchequer and the taxpayers' expectations of what they are paying their taxes for. I strongly urge the Minister to accept the amendment. One will always get much advice from various sections in the Department as to why one should not do that. There is a natural tendency for officials to do this. This should be changed but there is a combined wisdom that refuses to do so because it is easier not to take it on. A time comes, however, when one has to bite the bullet and be done with it.

Comment on this

Despite what Deputy Shortall believes about the tax clearance issue and PPS numbers, this was as far as I could get in the timescale available. The issue is worthy of consideration in the next part of the long process of putting in place the total reform of the supplementary welfare allowance and also, in consultation with my colleague, the Minister of State, Deputy Finneran, of having greater integration at policy level between the supplementary welfare allowance scheme, the rental accommodation scheme, RAS, and the local authorities. We are committed to going back to the point where rent allowance is a temporary scheme and get away from the idea that people can be on it for years.

On the direct payment to a landlord, are Members suggesting a tenant should not have the right to receive a payment if he or she so wanted? The current system allows the tenant to decide. For example, it would be very easy for a landlord to work out a single tenant's income because he or she would know what proportion of the payment was paid directly.

Comment on this

All the landlord has to do is look at the guidelines for the payment of rent supplement to know what the tenant is earning.

Comment on this

Deputy Shortall is wrong. On a rent of €100, for example, the State could be paying €90 or as little €76 of it. If the €100 was a direct payment to the landlord, the landlord will not know if the Department contributed a major or a minor part of that. The tenant has a right to privacy. Many issues would arise if the tenant was forced into allowing the payment directly to the landlord.

I will examine the withholding of tax. I do not believe, however, we can do anything about it in the time available. It is a valid point and in principle I have no objection to the proposal. I thank the Deputies for the suggestion.

I am in the process of trying to reform the social housing element in the social welfare system. This amendment has several weaknesses. For example, it only refers to the tenant, not the tenant's family or partners. In other words, the neighbour from hell may not be the tenant but his or her partner. While I accept the basic thrust of the Deputies' arguments in this respect, I do not have the time between now and Report Stage to deal with this issue in a fair and balanced way. I will, however, ensure further work on it is done and it is prioritised in the work on reforming the rent supplement system.

Comment on this

The Minister is talking in the long term which may not necessarily apply to him.

Comment on this

He needs to go now.

Comment on this

When Deputy Shortall is in my place, she can introduce it.

Comment on this

I look forward to that.

Comment on this

I will be working until the last day I am in office.

Comment on this

I will not spend ten years talking about doing it, however.

Comment on this

I have always taken the view in life that none of us can be certain about tomorrow but we have to plan as if we will be there for the long term. If I thought I might not be here tomorrow, then there would be no point in doing anything in life.

As long as I am in this office, I will keep working on this matter. I will leave a good legacy of work in hand to whoever comes after me.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 16 and 17 are cognate and will be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 16:

In page 11, line 16, to delete "where required,".

This amendment relates to fraudulent applications for PPS numbers. A person applying for a PPS number must provide various proofs of identity. This should apply to people outside of the State who may be claiming State benefits.

A fingerprint machine costing €20 million now lies idle in Garda headquarters. It was to be used to identify people outside the State defrauding the benefit system. Will the Minister work with the Minister for Justice and Law Reform on getting this machine online? The union problems that exist should be resolved. Every euro saved is a euro less that the Government will have to find. People feel there is much social welfare fraud taking place, particularly with people outside of the State.

Amendment No. 16 aims to ensure the same rules apply to benefit recipients inside as well as outside the State.

Comment on this

Section 262(3) of the Social Welfare Consolidation Act 2005 requires that a photograph and a signature be submitted for any customer registering for a PPS number. This does not align with lower levels of authentication such as for birth registrations and the allocation of PPS numbers via non-face to face channels such as non-resident, deceased or probate cases. Obviously, it is not practicable to ask for a signature in a case involving a deceased person.

Comment on this

I am talking about people outside the State.

Comment on this

This is a technical matter. We accept everyone must have a photograph and a signature when applying for a PPS number. There are probate cases, however, where a deceased person cannot provide a photograph or a signature. Not insisting on the photo and signature gives us a little out on this one because a dead person cannot give us their signature or photograph.

Comment on this

Is the Minister sure?

Comment on this

Yes, I am bloody sure.

Comment on this

Is the Minister really sure?

Comment on this

I would love if the people in Mayo could tell me how to get around that one.

Comment on this

Will the Minister comment on the fingerprinting machine?

Comment on this

I shall certainly take up the issue being raised by the Deputy, as it is very serious. As we are discussing identification and all the rest, I hope to have the first card at the end of the month, and am satisfied that this will be an enormous step forward. For example, a Bus Éireann inspector told me recently that people were swapping invalidity passes and other free passes and travelling on the buses around the country. Unlike in Dublin no photograph is required.

I have looked into this matter in considerable detail and I am satisfied that the card is a major step forward, way ahead of anything we have had up to now in terms of authentication within the system. If one swipes the card one gets all the details regarding the person. Another advantage, as the system is being rolled out, is this. If a person goes in to a social welfare office and the officials there are satisfied as to his or her identity, they can swipe the data and give people access to the personal files of the individual concerned. This could be extended in time as regards free travel and the HSE using it as proof of identity for giving access to medical records and so on. The card does not hold the details. The system holds the details, but the card is the key to the system.

I can get a briefing for Deputies, which I believe would be worthwhile, on how this would work, the roll-out details and so on. We shall have the technical people in to give a detailed briefing.

Comment on this

I am somewhat worried at some of the things the Minister said. The Data Protection Act is there for a purpose. We, as Members of the Oireachtas, are subject to the Data Protection Act. If we make representations to the Revenue Commissioners, for example, they will not talk to us unless we get a letter. There is nothing in the law that says that, but it is, nonetheless, a new dimension that has taken over the lives of public representatives.

What worries me about what the Minister has just said relates to the amount of personal data that will be maintained and can be made available to a variety of people.

Comment on this

The Deputy has got it wrong.

Comment on this

I have not got it wrong. I am worried about to whom the information will be made available.

Comment on this

I am concerned for a number of reasons. If a card is lost with all this information on it-----

Comment on this

There is no information on the card. I need to say this, because the Deputy is going off on a-----

Comment on this

The Chair has no real control over where people go. Perhaps the Deputy might ask a question and I shall get the Minister to reply.

Comment on this

I have not finished, and I am entitled to speak. I am worried about it and I would like the Minister to clarify exactly what is being proposed. The Minister refers to the extent of the information that will be made available to the individual, only. Unfortunately, such information that was supposed to be for an individual only has been made available to many other people in recent years. I want to know whether this is in compliance with the Data Protection Act.

Comment on this

The card has on it only the date of birth, PPS number, photograph and so on. Essentially, it is just an identity card and does not hold any information about the individual apart from that. However, if a person presents it in a social welfare office, the officials will have to presume that he or she is the individual to whom the card refers. There will be a photograph on the card to authenticate such a claim. That is much more secure that the way people's details are being accessed at the moment, is it not?

Comment on this

At that point they swipe the card, and being satisfied as the identity of the client they can access the details and deal with the request. At the moment if one wants to access one's medical details from the HSE, how do the people dealing with the request confirm one's identity? If one has the card they can confirm the identity. Then it is a matter of them swiping the card and accessing their own files. Such information would not be on the card per se but rather is within the system, and this amounts to a double check. We are still some way off, but it is possible in the future, for example, for someone’s medical records to be readily accessed if he or she has been involved in an accident, say, many miles from home to check on allergies, medication and so on after being admitted to an accident and emergency department. In the event they can use the card to identify the individual and then get the file. In this way before a file is accessed this will enable people to be absolutely sure they are dealing with the individual whose name is on the card.

Comment on this

On a point of order, we either need to take a break soon for lunch or else wrap up quickly.

Comment on this

I am in the members' hands.

Comment on this

I shall not delay the proceedings other than to say I am still concerned, and I should like an opportunity to return to this again. For instance, why were we able to deal with issues such as this in the past? Was it because we did not know the people? Has the system grown so amorphous that it is now a question of numbers only and names and numbers. I recall when the community welfare officers knew all the people and where they lived.

Comment on this

That is not the way it is now.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 18:

In page 13, before section 11, but in Part 2, to insert the following new section

11.—(1) The Principal Act is amended in the manner specified in Schedule 2*.

(2) Schedule 1 to the Social Welfare and Pensions Act 2008 is amended by—

(a)substituting the following paragraph for paragraph (c) of the amendment to section 200 of the Principal Act set out in column (2) of that Schedule opposite the mention of section 200 in column (1):

"(c) In subsection (3), substitute ‘by a designated person’ for ‘by the Executive’.”,

(b) substituting the following amendment for the amendment to sections 206 and 207 of the Principal Act:

"

Provision affected | Amendment

(1) | (2)

Section 207 | Repeal this section.

",

and

(c) substituting the following subparagraph for subparagraph (ii) of paragraph (a) of the amendment to section 300 of the Principal Act set out in column (2) of that Schedule opposite the mention of section 300 in column (1):

"(ii) substitute the following for paragraph (b):

‘(b) Part 3 (social assistance), being a question other than one relating to supplementary welfare allowance (unless it relates to a category of claim specified in subsection (3A) or section 195, 200, 201, 202, 203, 204 or 205),’.”.

(3) The amendments (effected by subsection (2)) to Schedule 1 to the Social Welfare and Pensions Act 2008 are deemed to have been included in each of those provisions with effect from the passing of the Social Welfare and Pensions Act 2008 and each of those provisions (amended by subsection (2)) shall come into operation in accordance with section 1(6) of that Act.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 19:

In page 13, before section 11, but in Part 2, to insert the following new section:

12.—(1) Part 2 of the Principal Act is amended by inserting the following Chapter after Chapter 8:

"CHAPTER 8A

Partial Capacity Benefit

46A.—(1) Subject to this Act, a person shall be entitled to partial capacity benefit where the person—

(a) has applied for that benefit,

(b) is assessed by a medical assessor as having a profound restriction on his or her capacity for work in relation to the capacity for work of a person of the same age who has no restriction on his or her capacity for work,

(c) on the day immediately before the day for which benefit is claimed—

(i) was in receipt of—

(I) illness benefit for at least 26 weeks in a period of interruption of employment,

or

(II) invalidity pension,

or

(ii) other than in the case of a person to whom section 46C(3)(a)(ii) applies, has exhausted the period of entitlement to partial capacity benefit provided for

in section 46C or regulations made under that section,

and

(d) is under pensionable age.

(2) For the purposes of—

(a) the assessment required under subsection (1)(b), the Minister may prescribe the conditions for which a person shall be assessed as having a profound restriction on his or her capacity for work in relation to the capacity for work of a person of the same age who has no restriction on his or her capacity for work, and

(b) the assessment referred to in subsection (4), the Minister may prescribe the conditions for which a person shall be assessed as having a mild restriction on his or her capacity for work in relation to the capacity for work of a person of the same age who has no restriction on his or her capacity for work.

(3) Notwithstanding subsection (1), where subsection (1)(b) is not satisfied a person may, subject to subsections (4) and (5), be entitled to partial capacity benefit.

(4) A person who is assessed by a medical assessor as having a mild restriction on his or her capacity for work in relation to the capacity for work of a person of the same age who has no restriction on his or her capacity for work shall not be entitled to partial capacity benefit.

(5) Where partial capacity benefit is provided pursuant to subsection (3)—

(a) the rate of that benefit shall be payable at a rate, or rates, less than that provided for in section 46B(1)(a), and

(b) the Minister may prescribe the reduced rate or rates.

(6) Regulations made by the Minister for the purposes of subsection (5) shall provide for the reduced rate, or rates, of partial capacity benefit pursuant to subsection (3), and the reductions in the rate, or rates, of partial capacity benefit shall relate to the extent to which subsection (1)(b) is not satisfied, but

such reduction shall not affect any entitlement to an increase in respect of a qualified adult or qualified children or an increase where the beneficiary is ordinarily resident on an island.

(7) Where a person qualifies for partial capacity benefit by virtue of subsection (1)(c)(i)(I), each day for which that benefit is paid shall be—

(a) treated as a day of incapacity for work, and

(b) deemed to be a day for which illness benefit is paid for the purposes of Chapter 8.

(8) In this Chapter, ‘medical assessor' means an officer of the Minister who is a registered medical practitioner.

46B.—(1) Subject to this Act, the weekly rate of partial capacity benefit payable shall—

(a) in the case of a person to whom section 46A(1)(c)(i) applies, be the weekly rate of illness benefit or invalidity pension that was being paid to that person on the day immediately before the day for which partial capacity benefit is awarded, including any increase in that benefit or pension, where payable, and

(b) in the case of a person to whom section 46A(1)(c)(ii) applies, be prescribed in regulations.

(2) Notwithstanding subsection (1)—

(a) any change in circumstances that would have resulted in a variation in the rate of illness benefit or invalidity pension payable, if that person had continued receiving the said benefit or pension, or

(b) any general variation in the weekly rates of benefits, pensions, allowances or supplements under this Act, shall have similar effect in relation to the rate of partial capacity benefit payable in that case.

(3) For the purposes of subsection (2) a change in circumstances shall include a situation where a person, who initially qualifies for partial capacity benefit by virtue of section 46A(1)(c)(i)(I), subsequently continues to qualify for partial capacity benefit by virtue of being deemed to satisfy the qualifying conditions for invalidity pension in accordance with section 46C(3)(b).

(4) Subsections (2) and (3) shall apply to the weekly rate prescribed in regulations under subsection (1)(b), and the regulations may provide for a change in circumstances referred to in subsections (2) and (3) and a general variation referred to in subsection (2).

46C.—(1) Subject to this Chapter, partial capacity benefit shall be paid for a maximum period of 156 weeks.

(2) Subject to subsection (3), where partial capacity benefit is paid in accordance with regulations made under section 46A(6), the Minister may by regulations provide that partial capacity benefit shall be paid for a period, or periods, less than that specified in subsection (1) and the duration of such lesser period, or periods, shall relate to the extent to which section 46A(1)(b) is not satisfied.

(3) Notwithstanding subsections (1) and (2), where a person qualifies for partial capacity benefit by virtue of section 46A(1)(c) (i)(I)—

(a) the duration of partial capacity benefit shall be limited to—

(i) the period specified in subsection (1) or in regulations made under subsection (2) as appropriate to the circumstances, or

(ii) the remaining period of entitlement to illness benefit in the period of interruption of employment concerned that would have been paid if the person had continued to claim illness benefit, whichever is the shorter period, and

(b) subject to subsection (4), payment of partial capacity benefit may continue beyond the period specified in paragraph (a)(ii) where immediately on the termination of the entitlement of the person entitled to partial capacity benefit under paragraph (a)(ii) the person is deemed to satisfy the qualifying conditions for invalidity pension.

(4) Where a person is paid partial capacity benefit for a period referred to in subsection (3)(a)(ii) and such payment is continued in accordance with subsection (3)(b), the total period for which partial capacity benefit shall be paid under paragraphs (a)(ii) and

(b) of subsection (3) shall not exceed 156 weeks or such lesser period as may be provided for in regulations under subsection (2).

46D.—(1) The Minister may make regulations to provide for—

(a) disqualifying a person for receiving partial capacity benefit where the person fails without good cause to—

(i) attend for, or submit to, any medical or other examination or treatment,

(ii) comply with medical advice and instructions provided by a registered medical practitioner that relates to his or her incapacity, and

(iii) make himself or herself available to meet with an officer of the Minister in respect of his or her claim for partial capacity benefit, and

(b) subject to subsection (2), the circumstances and conditions in which a person may relinquish entitlement to partial capacity benefit and subsequently reclaim that benefit.

(2) Where a person has been paid partial capacity benefit and the person relinquishes entitlement to that benefit and subsequently reclaims that benefit, the total duration for which that benefit shall be paid in respect of both the period prior to the relinquishment and the period in which it is reclaimed shall not exceed 156 weeks or such lesser period as may be provided for in regulations under section 46C(2).".

(2) The Principal Act is amended—

(a) in section 39(1) (amended by section 4 of, and Schedule 1 to, the Act of 2006), by inserting the following paragraph after paragraph (a):

"(aa) partial capacity benefit,”,

(b) in section 46 by—

(i) substituting the following subsection for subsection (1A) (inserted by section 5 of the Act of 2007):

"(1A) Subject to subsection (1B), a person in receipt of or entitled to illness benefit shall not engage in work.",

and

(ii) inserting the following new subsection after subsection (1A):

"(1B) A person shall not be disqualified for receipt of illness benefit while engaging in such class or classes of employment or training and

subject to such circumstances and conditions as may be prescribed.",

and

(c) in section 118 by inserting the following subsection after subsection (3) (amended by section 16 of the Act of 2007):

"(3A) Subject to subsection (4), a person in receipt of or entitled to

invalidity pension shall not engage in work.".".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 20:

In page 13, before section 11, but in Part 2, to insert the following new

section:

13.—Section 91 of the Principal Act is amended by—

(a) substituting the following subsection for subsection (1A) (inserted by section 11 of the Act of 2007):

"(1A) Subject to subsection (1B), a person in receipt of or entitled to injury benefit or an increase of disablement benefit under section 77 shall not engage in work.",

and

(b) by inserting the following new subsection after subsection (1A):

"(1B) A person shall not be disqualified for receipt of injury benefit or an increase of disablement benefit under section 77 while engaging in such class or classes of employment or training and subject to such circumstances and conditions as may be prescribed.".".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 21:

In page 13, to delete lines 42 and 43.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 22:

In page 13, before section 12, to insert the following new section:

12.—The Minister shall, within 3 months of enactment of this Act, publish a strategy on how he or she will reform the practices of An Foras to assist people to

get back to work.".

We are all very concerned about the changeover from FÁS to the Department of Social Protection. We want to ensure that this is working while being happy to wait three months to see what progress the Government has made in this regard. There is a good deal of public concern and we want to see what is happening with the changeover of staff. Customers, that is people who are unemployed, are frustrated at the fact that there is not a one-stop-shop to facilitate them in social welfare offices. We want to see these people being interviewed on a regular basis so that they may be assisted in any way possible, to try and get back into the workplace.

At present they go in and may be called back again in six or seven months. Fine Gael wants to see such people being interviewed on a regular basis and given every assistance to try to get them retrained and back into the workplace. My reason for tabling this amendment is that we want a report before the Dáil every three months, to be able to see what is happening in relation to the changeover.

Comment on this

The spirit of it is fine. Foras Áiseanna Saothair will not exist as it will be part of the Department. The plans the Deputy mentions should be in the statement of strategy. It will be under one Department and there will be no more FÁS. The Deputy is referring to the employment service at FÁS. That will be an integral part of the Department. The Department will integrate this with its existing work with job facilitators. Therefore, the way to approach this would be through an amendment to the statement of strategy of the Department, which will outline how we will implement this. I cannot disagree with where the Deputy wants to go. That is exactly the purpose of all this change. A person goes in and gets a quick, comprehensive and attractive service that assists him or her through training, work and education, and that has been my mantra since I came into the Department.

The Government announced last week, as part of its four year plan, that there will be extra activation places available. That is important.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 23 to 26, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 23:

In page 15, lines 14 to 17, to delete subsection (1) and substitute the following:

"(1) The Minister for Education and Skills may, with the consent of the Minister, designate by instrument in writing any contract or commitment (express or implied) entered into by An Foras before the designation for transfer to the Minister.".

These are technical amendments relating to the transfer of FÁS to the Department and allowing me to appoint different transfer days for different purposes and different provisions.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 24:

In page 15, subsection (4), lines 29 and 30, to delete paragraph (b) and substitute the following:

"(b) For the purposes of paragraph (a), the Minister may appoint different transfer days for different purposes and different provisions.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 25:

In page 16, subsection (6), lines 7 and 8, to delete paragraph (b) and substitute the following:

"(b) For the purposes of paragraph (a), the Minister may appoint different transfer days for different purposes and different provisions.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 26:

In page 17, subsection (13), lines 28 to 30, to delete paragraph (b) and substitute the following:

"(b) For the purposes of paragraph (a), the Minister may appoint different appointment days in respect of different classes of person designated under this section.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 27:

In page 19, before the Schedule, to insert the following new section:

"PART 4*

TRANSFER OF CERTAIN EMPLOYEES, PROPERTY, ETC. OF HEALTH SERVICE EXECUTIVE

19.—(1) The Executive may, with the consent of the Minister and the Minister for Health and Children, designate by instrument in writing any contract or commitment (express or implied) entered into by the Executive before the designation for transfer to the Minister.

(2) All rights and liabilities arising by virtue of any contract or commitment so designated shall, on the transfer day, stand transferred to the Minister.

(3) Every right and liability transferred by subsection (2) may, on and after the transfer day, be sued on, recovered or enforced by or against the Minister in the name of the Minister and it shall not be necessary for the Minister to give notice to the person whose right or liability is transferred by that subsection of such transfer.

(4) (a) The Minister shall, by order, appoint a day (in this section referred to as the “transfer day”) for the purposes of this section.

(b) For the purposes of paragraph (a), the Minister may appoint different transfer days for different purposes and different provisions.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 28:

In page 19, before the Schedule, to insert the following new section:

20.—(1) For the purposes of this section, the Executive may, with the consent of the Minister and the Minister for Health and Children, designate by instrument in writing lands that immediately before being so designated were vested in the Executive.

(2) On the transfer day all lands designated under subsection (1) and all rights, powers and privileges relating to or connected with such lands shall, without any conveyance or assignment, stand vested in the Commissioners.

(3) For the purposes of this section, the Executive may, with the consent of the Minister and the Minister for Health and Children, designate in writing property other than land, including choses-in-action, that immediately before being so designated was the property of the Executive.

(4) All property other than land, including choses-in-action, designated under subsection (3) shall, on the transfer day, stand vested in the Minister without any assignment.

(5) Every chose-in-action vested in the Minister by virtue of this section may, on and after the transfer day, be sued upon, recovered or enforced by the Minister in the name of the Minister and it shall not be necessary for the Minister to give notice to any person bound by the chose-in-action of the transfer effected by that subsection.

(6) (a) The Minister shall, by order, appoint a day (in this section referred to as the “transfer day”) for the purposes of this section.

(b) For the purposes of paragraph (a), the Minister may appoint different transfer days for different purposes and different provisions.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 29:

In page 19, before the Schedule, to insert the following new section:

21.—(1) The Minister may, with the consent of the Executive and the Minister for Health and Children, designate a person who, immediately before the designation, is an employee of the Executive (other than a fixed-term employee) for appointment to an unestablished position in the Civil Service.

(2) A person designated under subsection (1) shall, on the appointment day, stand appointed to such unestablished position in the Civil Service as is specified in the designation.

(3) The Minister may, with the consent of the Executive and the Minister for Health and Children, designate a person who, immediately before the designation, is a fixed-term employee of the Executive for appointment to an unestablished position in the Civil Service for the period remaining unexpired under the contract of employment under which he or she was employed by the Executive.

(4) A person designated under subsection (3) shall, on the appointment day, stand appointed to such unestablished position in the Civil Service as is specified in the designation for the period remaining unexpired under the contract of employment under which he or she was employed by the Executive.

(5) A designation under this section shall be in writing.

(6) Save in accordance with a collective agreement negotiated with any recognised trade union or staff association concerned, a person appointed under this section shall not, on the appointment day, be brought to less beneficial conditions of remuneration than the conditions of remuneration to which he or she was subject immediately before the appointment day.

(7) The previous service with the Executive of a person appointed under this section shall be reckonable for the purposes of, but subject to, any exceptions or exclusions in:

(a) the Redundancy Payments Acts 1967 to 2007;

(b) the Protection of Employees (Part-Time Work) Act 2001;

(c) the Act of 2003;

(d) the Organisation of Working Time Act 1997;

(e) the Terms of Employment (Information) Acts 1994 and 2001;

(f) the Minimum Notice and Terms of Employment Acts 1973 to 2005;

(g) the Unfair Dismissals Acts 1977 to 2007;

(h) the Maternity Protection Acts 1994 and 2004;

(i) the Parental Leave Acts 1998 and 2006;

(j) the Adoptive Leave Acts 1995 and 2005;

(k) the Carer’s Leave Act 2001.

(8) The rules of a superannuation scheme, or superannuation schemes, that at the appointment day govern benefits applicable to or in respect of a person appointed under this section shall continue to apply to or in respect of that person after the appointment day, save in accordance with a collective agreement with a recognised trade union or staff association and the approval of the Minister for Finance.

(9) Where the rules of a superannuation scheme, or superannuation schemes, referred to in subsection (8) provide for the exercise of discretion, the Minister for Finance shall, on and after the appointment day, exercise any such discretion.

(10) The pension payments and other superannuation liabilities of the Executive in respect of its former employees who have been appointed under this section become, on the appointment day, the liabilities of the Minister for Finance.

(11) A person appointed under this section shall undertake such duties as the Minister may from time to time direct.

(12) A person appointed under this section shall be subject to and employed in accordance with the Civil Service Regulation Acts 1956 to 2005 and the Ethics in Public Office Acts 1995 and 2001.

(13) (a) The Minister shall, by order, appoint a day (in this section referred to as the “appointment day”) for the purposes of this section.

(b) For the purposes of paragraph (a), the Minister may appoint different appointment days in respect of different classes of person designated under this section.

(14) In this section:

"Act of 2003" means the Protection of Employees (Fixed-Term Work) Act 2003;

"Act of 2004" means the Public Service Management (Recruitment and Appointments) Act 2004;

"Civil Service" has the meaning assigned to it by the Act of 2004;

"contract of employment" has the meaning assigned to it by the Act of 2003;

"fixed-term employee" has the meaning assigned to it by the Act of 2003;

"recognised trade union or staff association" means a trade union or staff association recognised by the Minister for the purposes of negotiations which are concerned with the remuneration or conditions of employment, or the working conditions of employees;

"unestablished position" has the meaning assigned to it by the Act of 2004.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 30:

In page 19, before the Schedule, to insert the following new section:

22.—Section 208 of the Principal Act is amended—

(a) in subsection (1), by substituting “Subject to subsection (4), all property” for “All property”,

(b) in subsection (2), by substituting “Subject to subsection (4), every chose-in- action” for “Every chose-in-action”,

(c) in subsection (3), by substituting “Subject to subsection (4), every bond” for “Every bond”, and

(d) by inserting the following subsection after subsection (3):

"(4) This section shall not apply to any property, chose-in-action, bond, guarantee or other security of a continuing character that is designated and transferred under Part 4* of the Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions)(No. 2) Act 2010.”.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 31:

In page 19, after line 26, to insert the following new schedule:

SCHEDULE 2

AMENDMENTS RELATING TO SUPPLEMENTARY WELFARE ALLOWANCE

No. | Provision affected | Amendment

(1) | (2) | (3)

1 | Section 198(3F) | Substitute “a designated person” for “the Executive”

2 | Section 198(4A)(a) and(b) | Substitute “a designated person” for “the Executive”

3 | Section 198(4B) | Substitute “a designated person” for “the Executive”

4 | Section 198(4B)(b)(i) | Substitute “a designated person” for “the Executive”

5 | Section 198(5B) | Substitute “a designated person” for “the Executive”

6 | Section 198(9) | Substitute “a designated person” for “the Executive”

7 | Section 198A | Substitute “a designated person” for “the Executive”in each place it occurs

8 | Section 198B(b) | Substitute “a designated person” for “the Executive”

9 | Section 241(1A) | Substitute “a designated person” for “the Executive”

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 32:

In page 3, to delete lines 13 to 22 and substitute the following:

"TRANSFER OF CERTAIN ASSETS, LIABILITIES, PROPERTY AND STAFF OF AN FORAS ÁISEANNA SAOTHAIR, TO PROVIDE FOR THE CONTINUANCE OF CERTAIN SCHEMES PROVIDED BY AN FORAS ÁISEANNA SAOTHAIR AND FOR THE PROVISION BY THE MINISTER FOR SOCIAL PROTECTION OF THOSE SCHEMES; TO PROVIDE FOR

THE TRANSFER OF CERTAIN ASSETS, LIABILITIES, PROPERTY AND EMPLOYEES OF THE HEALTH SERVICE EXECUTIVE; TO AMEND THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE (THEFT AND FRAUD OFFENCES) ACT 2001; AND

TO PROVIDE FOR RELATED MATTERS.".

Comment on this

I indicated on Second Stage that changes in social welfare legislation, arising from the provisions of the Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Act 2010, would be introduced on Committee Stage of the Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) (No.2) Bill 2010. These will now be introduced on Report Stage of this Bill, as drafting work on these amendments is ongoing. There are also possible Report Stage amendments relating to the minimum wage. The Government has indicated that we intend to introduce an internship programme and we might have to introduce amendments on Report Stage in respect of this programme. I might also introduce amendments on Report Stage to assist pension schemes.

Comment on this

Is the amendment to the minimum wage to provide for a reduction in the minimum wage?

Comment on this

Yes. There is no certainty that I will, but there might be such a change.

Comment on this

That is a real back door way of doing it.

Comment on this

I am not saying it will happen, but there might be a change.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister and his officials. I also acknowledge the co-operation of members.

Comment on this