We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

SELECT COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORT

Output Statement for the Department of Transport.

Contributions 1–127 of 257. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The purpose of today's meeting is to consider the Revised Estimates for Vote 32 — Transport, which was referred to the select committee by the Dáil on 22 February 2007. In line with the expanded budgetary process, an output statement has also been provided. Members will be aware that as part of the budgetary process, reforms initiated by the Minister for Finance in his Budget Statement 2005 this year see the publication by Departments of annual output statements for consideration by Oireachtas committees for the first time. This important initiative is intended to facilitate greater parliamentary involvement in the budget and Estimates process.

The clerk of the committee has circulated a draft timetable for consideration. I have no problem if members wish to deviate from that timetable.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

I suggest we do what we did last time we had Estimates when we amalgamated them and commented as we went through.

Comment on this

That is true, but the procedure is that we must take it subhead by subhead for the question and answer session.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

Can we raise the issues subhead by subhead or must we stop and allow time for a response on each subhead?

Comment on this

We can take them by subhead. For example, A1 to A8 is administration, B1 to B3 is roads, C1 to C3 is public transport, D1 to D5 is civil aviation, E1 to E3 is maritime transport. What I suggest is we should not tie ourselves to a particular time. If we find we reach something sooner, we should not wait if that is agreed.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

I do not think there is a need for significant opening statements, apart from a statement from the Minister.

Comment on this

That is up to Deputy Mitchell and Deputy Shortall. On behalf of the select committee I welcome the Minister for Transport, Deputy Cullen, and his officials, Mr. Maurice Mullen, Assistant Secretary, Mr. Dan Commane, principal officer and Mr. Padraig McGogarty, accountant. Ms Anne Walsh, assistant principal and Ms Denise Keoghan from the Department are also in attendance. I invite the Minister, Deputy Cullen, to make his opening remarks.

If the Minister wishes to synopsise his speech, the members will have no objection.

Comment on this
Martin Cullen Minister for Transport (Mr. Cullen) Fianna Fáil

If the Chairman wishes my speech to stand part of the full record of proceedings I have no problem.

I will synopsise the speech to the key points. The Estimates for 2007 is €2.266 billion which is a 21.6% increase on 2006. A further €305 million will be provided from the private sector in toll road PPP funding. This is a significant jump but very much in keeping with Transport 21. More than €700 million is being provided for public transport this year, the largest single-year expenditure ever. It begins to map out the change and balance between the roads infrastructure and investment in public transport throughout the country, a large element of which is planned for Dublin, our capital city and which we all want to see in place, whether one is from Dublin or from around the country or whether one is a regular visitor to the country.

We all want to see the roads programme in place and it is progressing exceptionally well. Work will commence on seven new projects this year, totalling 200 km of high quality national roads. Nine other projects will be completed and a further 12 projects will be under construction during the year. This amounts to more than €1.525 billion of the roads programme which is focused on completing the five major interurban motorways between the Border and the extension to Newry which is being built in co-operation with our Northern Ireland colleagues and is well under way to completion. With regard to the Galway, Limerick, Cork and Waterford motorways, 50% to 70% of those motorways are either under construction or completed so we are well on target to complete the five interurban motorways up to 2010 and as I set out in Transport 21.

The other major change has resulted from the national development plan. This has allowed us to move forward about €400 million which will be primarily focused on the Atlantic road corridor. The Ennis bypass has been opened and this has made a significant contribution to the west of Ireland. It is very important in the context of the developments at Shannon Airport and the key infrastructure for the populace in the area, particularly the Galway — Limerick access, to allow for the usage and development of the airport. Those in the region believed correctly that it was important to keep up the momentum by continuing, once the Ennis bypass was open, to complete the entire route to Galway. This Limerick — Galway section will be high quality motorway when completed. I am very pleased this was possible under the national development plan. Construction will begin next year and the process will continue until the entire route on that part of the Atlantic road corridor is completed as well as all the roads around Galway. This should be in line with the completion of all the major national motorways to which I have referred.

The M50 development is well under way. It will provide for a 50% increase in capacity and a free flow of traffic on the major interchanges which is significant. We are also moving to barrier-free tolling for which the tendering process has been completed. I met with the NRA recently when it outlined the timeframe and progress. The NRA is hoping to achieve a world record by completing the project in three years which would be well ahead of the best. The biggest project similar to the M50 is in Canada and it will take a year longer to complete.

Comment on this

The Minister is the master of spin.

Comment on this

I am only citing the experts. With regard to the usual interruption from Deputy Shortall——

Comment on this

I thought Deputy Shortall wanted to finish the meeting in a hurry.

Comment on this

I would take that as a compliment.

Comment on this

The advice from the best international deliverers of these projects is that it should be a four-year project but we are completing it in three years. All the best international companies tendered for the project and were incentivised on a timeframe to see if they could complete it any quicker but none came in under three years. I am very pleased the work is under way.

Traffic on the West Link will be freed up by the removal of the barrier tolling system. This will allow us to proceed with the barrier-free tolling regime. We have a binding contract with NTR but a very good deal has been negotiated by the NRA which will see NTR taken off the pitch from next year. It will receive a payment in lieu of its contract over the remaining term which is from 2008 to 2020. All the benefits of the increased capacity on the M50 will come to the State and not to NTR and this is a tremendous benefit for taxpayers. The resources coming in will clearly be of benefit and will prevent more moneys going unnecessarily to a company which had an excellent contract from its point of view. All the benefits of the upgrade and the increased capacity will accrue to the State.

The Dublin Port tunnel has opened, in spite of the naysayers who said this would be a disaster and a white elephant. They are all now jumping on board to tell us how tremendous it is. It has made a significant impact on Dublin, our capital city, in terms of the movement of traffic in and around the city centre. It has already had a direct impact on assisting public transport movement particularly from the north side of the city on the bus routes into the city centre. The quays have been freed up and the tunnel is functioning very well. The developments on the M50 mean that problems can arise from time to time but given the scale of the infrastructural development on the M50 it has been a case of so far, so good, on the project.

We have been very active on road safety. This year we launched the new Rules of the Road booklet which is an ambition of mine since I came into office. I am glad it has happened even though it is 12 years since the previous booklet was published. It has been recognised as one of the most comprehensive and modern in Europe and I congratulate the Road Safety Authority.

Comment on this

Without a blush; the Minister is unbelievable.

Comment on this

There is no need for blushes here.

Comment on this

The only unbelievable party around here which is so cynical about everything is the Labour Party.

Comment on this

It is 12 years late.

Comment on this

Every time I come to this committee the Deputy waffles on about things. I answer for what I do in this Department. Some day the Deputy might be lucky enough to have a Department and I hope she achieves one tenth of what I have achieved in the Department since I came in. Laughing and bluster does not achieve anything; decision-making and making a difference do.

I will not embarrass the Deputy by putting her party's record on transport before the committee during the time it was last in power. I hope it will be a long time before it sees office again.

With regard to the Road Safety Authority I am happy to point out that an extra €10 million was given in the Estimate this year and a tendering process is under way to continue a very substantial outsourcing of all the testing that has been so successful since we introduced it. More than 100,000 tests will also be outsourced. I wish to compliment the RSA on its efforts in that regard as the average waiting time has been halved. It is going in the right direction to achieve the outcome I set out at the end of the year for a more meaningful application and completion time for testing.

The essential major railway safety programme is continuing. More than €1 billion has already been spent which is unseen by the travelling public in many respects as it has been invested in track, the signalling system and the removal of many of the level crossings. This has allowed us to use the new rolling stock on the Cork — Dublin route and the first of the new 167 carriages for the other major interurban lines have arrived and will be rolled out, beginning on the Sligo route.

Obviously I am very pleased the other developments in Transport 21, including the Luas and metro, are all meeting the timeframes we set out. We expect to see excellent progress in those areas in the future. All the new buses for Dublin Bus have been introduced and Bus Éireann's are starting to arrive. Those new buses are assisting Dublin Bus and the public transport users in Dublin to get much more frequent and a wider range of services. I am happy that we are rolling out the new bus plans for Cork, Galway, Waterford and Limerick. These will provide important on-street services for the people living in those areas. I hope to complete the review on the Midleton rail line and sign the order to approve it shortly.

There is much more I could add. I am glad that Dublin Bus and Bus Éireann will introduce a 5% biodiesel blend into their fleets and I hope the blend will be 30% for their newer buses to be introduced. I have also given approval to Dublin Bus to evaluate one of the hybrid buses from Wrights in Ballymena, one of which is in operation in London. I expect such a bus to make a substantial contribution.

We recently announced the new programme for investment in regional airports under the Transport 21 capital investment programme. I urge all the regional airport authorities to complete their plans and to start to draw down the necessary resources to complete the major investment which will be of enormous benefit to the regions.

The maritime section, which came under the auspices of the Department in the past 18 months, is now being bedded in and includes investment in the Irish Coast Guard, the maritime safety directorate, etc.

A budget of almost €2.8 billion is substantial and demonstrates the Government's approach to the area of transport on land, sea and air. Investments are unparalleled in the history of the State. Such investment is appropriate and will underpin the competitiveness of the economy, improve the quality of life of all our citizens and allow us to sustain what we have achieved under Fianna Fáil-led Governments in recent years. It will sustain and increase employment and ensure we remain one of the most dynamic economies in the world, which we have achieved in recent years.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

I was just saying to my colleague here that I was glad we only got the synopsis.

Comment on this

Good news is hard to take.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

I suspect the self-accolade could have continued all day. Have we decided to go through the entire Vote?

Comment on this

The Deputy has ten minutes to make her opening statement, as has Deputy Shortall.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

I understood we were to amalgamate the opening statement with the questions.

Comment on this

We can do that if it is agreeable with Deputy Shortall. Does the Deputy want to start straight into questions and answers and forgo the opening statements?

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

We do not want to forgo the opening statements. We want to incorporate questions into the opening statement.

Comment on this

That is acceptable.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

Does the Chairman want me to approach it section by section?

Comment on this

That would be most appropriate.

Comment on this

Will we cover subheads A1 to A8, inclusive as a group?

Comment on this

Basically, the Deputies want to move into the question and answer session.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

As Ihave no issues with subhead A, I will move quickly to subhead B.

Comment on this

I have some items to raise under subhead A.

Comment on this

Let Deputy Olivia Mitchell put her questions and then Deputy Shortall can speak.

Comment on this

Are we not going to stick with subhead A?

Comment on this

I have no problem doing so if it is agreeable with Deputy Olivia Mitchell.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

The only question I had on that section related to the transfer of the Road Safety Authority staff, which results in a significant reduction in the cost of running the Department. Why is the grant to the Road Safety Authority considerably in excess of the saving to the Department? There is a difference of approximately €14 million.

Comment on this

That reflects the total budget and not just the administration budget. The extra €10 million I got in the budget goes into that. What is reflected here is just the total figure. The reduction in the subhead reflects the movement in staff. The increase on the other side reflects the total budget for the RSA.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

Does it represent a significant increase on what went before?

Comment on this

It is not increased staff. Other resources have been allocated, for example, for the outsourcing.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

It includes the outsourcing of the testing.

Comment on this

The €10 million is included in it.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

That is fine.

Comment on this

Under subhead A1 on salaries, I wish to ask the Minister about the adequacy of the legal advice available to the Department. In the past three years, the legislation the Minister has introduced has been quite problematic, starting with the Driver Testing and Standards Authority Bill which involved a complete change of direction and became the Road Safety Authority Bill. The Road Traffic Act 2006 needed to be amended as soon as it was passed. The Minister has made promises on other legislation which I had understood would be available before the end of last year. There is no sign of it yet.

When we discussed the Road Traffic Bill in the middle of last year, members raised a number of outstanding issues that needed to be addressed. On Committee Stage, the Minister gave a commitment that he would introduce a second Road Traffic Bill before the end of last year to deal with several issues raised, including the question of increasing the powers of local authorities to introduce parking schemes to deal with problems such as those associated with Croke Park and Lansdowne Road, and to allow residents-only parking in housing estates, etc. Where is that promised legislation? The Minister promised specifically to have it before the end of 2006.

On the long-promised Dublin transport authority, I am very mindful that 81% of the Department's budget is allocated to building infrastructure, which is welcome as we are playing catch-up on transport infrastructure. However, only a small proportion of the Department's budget is spent on the governance of transport, including taking an overview, planning, etc. For some time all parties have recognised the need for a Dublin transport authority. Approximately this time last year, the Minister promised that the legislation would be ready shortly. We are in the middle of March 2007 and there is still no sign of the Dublin transport authority Bill. Why has it been delayed? Is there any possibility of it being published or taken before the general election?

We also need an overseeing authority outside Dublin. Has the Minister any proposals to introduce overarching transport authorities to take the global view required in transport outside the Dublin area? I do not suggest we need one in every county or anything like that. Has the Minister given any consideration to how he might organise the governance of transport outside Dublin?

On promised legislation, I refer to the reform of the bus licensing system, for example. The Minister made a great play last year of his announcement that he would sanction the use of 100 additional buses by the private sector. There does not seem to be any prospect of the 100 buses being available this year.

Comment on this

That is not relevant to subhead A.

Comment on this

I am asking about the staff of the Department.

Comment on this

The Deputy was talking about buses, rather than staff.

Comment on this

I ask the Chairman to allow me to finish my point.

Comment on this

We agreed at the start that we would——

Comment on this

I am not asking about buses. Will the Chairman listen to me? The Minister announced last year that the private sector would benefit from an additional 100 buses. It is clear, as the Minister confirmed recently in response to a parliamentary question, that it will not be possible to make the buses available to the private sector until the bus licensing system has been reformed. Does the Minister have any plans to introduce legislation soon to reform the system? Are problems being caused by the lack of legal advice within the Department? Is that holding up the three major Bills that are needed, but are long overdue?

On subhead A7, which relates to consultancy services, the privatisation of Aer Lingus and the break-up of Aer Rianta have been the two major institutional changes made by the Minister since he took office. Does he have a global figure for the consultancy charges incurred by the Department of Transport and each of the semi-State agencies in those cases? Does the Minister have a figure for the cost to date of the Department's decentralisation plans?

Comment on this

I presume we are not sticking to what we agreed, which was to deal with——

Comment on this

No, that is definitely not——

Comment on this

That seems to have been blown out the window, even though I agreed to it.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I will carry on anyway. Like all Departments, the Department of Transport uses the services of the staff of the Office of the Attorney General, including the Attorney General himself. That system works extremely well. The Department recruited a legal adviser in December to add to the in-house expertise in that area. That was necessary in light of the volume of work being done. I think it will work very well.

I assume Deputy Shortall is aware that the Roads Bill 2007, which has been published, is being dealt with in the Seanad.

Comment on this

I was talking about the road traffic Bill the Minister promised.

Comment on this

Yes, it is already——

Comment on this

The Roads Bill 2007 relates to tolling. I read in the newspapers that the Minister proposes to include in that Bill a provision relating to residents' parking. The principal purpose of the Roads Bill 2007, as I understand it, is to provide for barrier-free tolling.

Comment on this

Yes. Is the Deputy suggesting that every Bill should deal with one issue and nothing else?

Comment on this

No. The Minister promised to introduce a road traffic Bill.

Comment on this

The Bill has been published and is being debated. It has finished Committee Stage in the Seanad.

Comment on this

All the things the Minister promised to include in the Bill have not been included in it.

Comment on this

I have published the Bill. When I spoke on Second Stage in the Seanad, I referred specifically to the issue of parking near major sporting facilities such as Croke Park, which has been mentioned by Deputy Shortall. I said I intended to introduce an amendment to the Bill on Committee Stage. There is nothing unusual in that. It is perhaps somewhat unusual that the Deputy does not seem to like the decisions I make when I try to get something done.

Comment on this

It is unusual that the provision was not included in the Bill.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister interrupted Deputy Shortall.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt the Deputy. When she spoke, she gave the impression that she did not know where the legislation was or when it would be published. She did not seem to know the first thing about it. The Bill has been published and it has been debated in the Seanad. Committee Stage has been completed in that House and Report and Final Stages will be completed next week. That is the position with that Bill. I will publish the DTA Bill in the next couple of weeks. It will be brought to the Dáil in this session. I hope it will receive the support of the Opposition. We will debate the Bill and get the process under way. I have already appointed an interim chairman-designate of the DTA. He is also the new chairman of the RPA. I am delighted that he is very busy at present on all the issues relating to the DTA. On the reform of the bus licensing system, the reform of the 1932 Act has almost been completed. We need to address a number of technical issues relating to the legislation. I hope to publish the Bill as soon as possible. The DTA Bill will be published and debated in the Dáil and the Seanad in this session. All of those issues are being dealt with.

Comment on this

Is the Minister seriously saying the Bill will be brought to the House in the next two and a half weeks?

Comment on this

The Dáil can sit until July. The Deputy seems to know something I do not know. I know it might suit the Labour Party to have the election in the next two and a half weeks, but that will not happen. The election will be called when the Government has fulfilled the various elements of the programme for Government and its five-year term has been completed. That is what we will do. We will run to the scheduling of this Fianna Fáil-led Government, rather than that of the Labour Party and the rest of the Opposition.

Comment on this

We need to move on to subheads B1 to B3.

Comment on this

I asked the Minister about consultancy costs.

Comment on this

The total cost of the initial public offering was €18 million, which is pretty much in line with the standard cost of such a transaction. The Government's share was €6.3 million. Those figures are already a matter of public record.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give a figure for the consultancy costs in relation to the break-up of Aer Rianta?

Comment on this

I do not have a figure here. If I can get it for the Deputy, I will do so.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister.

Comment on this

I ask Deputy Mitchell to speak to subheads B1 to B3.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

A great deal of money is being spent on road projects. The delivery by construction firms on the contracts for these projects is laudable. Many of them are being finished on time, etc. We need to assess the Estimate, however. Transport 21, which is the capital investment framework we are working from, as the Minister said, is very sparse in detail. It is difficult for Opposition Deputies and everyone else to use Transport 21 as a benchmark for performance because it does not give us anything to go by. It does not give us orders of priorities, start-up dates or costings. It gives us a mélange of information on a stand-alone basis. There is no way of judging whether we will get value for money.

I have several questions in response to the Minister's comments. Will any element of the Estimate serve to hasten the provision of service areas on our motorways? The provision of such facilities is a matter of significant importance in the interest of road safety. As the Road Safety Authority can explain——

Comment on this

The National Roads Authority explained at a recent meeting of the joint committee that it is in the process of providing service areas. That point was made after the Deputy left the meeting.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

I understand the NRA considers itself to be in the process of providing these services, but it has been saying that for several years. Will they be available this year? No location is available at which the Road Safety Authority can check tachographs, for example, to ensure that heavy goods vehicles comply with the law. Figures supplied by the Garda suggest that such vehicles are not in compliance with the law in the vast majority of cases, thereby presenting a significant road safety risk. It is completely unacceptable that there is no place where vehicles can be tested. People on long journeys need a place where they can pull over. It is becoming problematic to get petrol, for example. I recently worked out that seven or eight petrol stations in my constituency have closed down. The need to ensure that service areas are available on our motorways is becoming an important issue within the transport system. The Minister will have to be much more proactive in ensuring that such facilities are delivered quickly. It is not good enough to say they will be rolled out over time, because they are needed now.

The Minister mentioned that many dual carriageways will be redesignated as motorways. Other than facilitating people to drive at 120 km/h, what will be the implications of that change? Will there be implications in terms of the constitutionality of deeming to be motorways, roads which were planned as dual carriageways, when they were the subject of public inquiry? If a farmer disposed of land in the belief that it would be used for a dual carriageway, but now finds that the road is to be a motorway, he or she might be concerned about access issues or development issues. Is the Department concerned that constitutional issues in this regard could lead to court cases? I am in favour of the redesignation because the standard of many of our dual carriageways is better than the standard of some motorways in other countries. While I do not oppose this change, I wonder whether it will have implications like those I have mentioned.

The Minister referred to barrier-free tolling. I am not sure of the capital costs associated with that. Is it in the region of €100 million? That is an enormous sum of money to create a bureaucracy to toll a single point on one road. The question should be asked whether it provides value for money or if there is a better way of collecting that money. This major project will take three years to install and create a significant annual bill. Perhaps the Minister can offer a better way of collecting that money.

It was also stated that barrier-free tolling represents wonderful benefits to the taxpayer. If I was the Minister, I would not say that out loud. Nothing relating to the M50 could be considered good value to the taxpayer. However necessary it may be, buying it out represents the least good value for taxpayers.

According to the Minister, the port tunnel is a wonderful success. I find it difficult to agree with that statement. I appreciate the tunnel has resulted in traffic improvements on the quays, which I hope will be capitalised on in terms of public transport provision. However, I see no sign of that yet. Benefits have also accrued to parts of the north inner city, but nobody has carried out any appraisal of whether the benefits are outweighed by the costs borne by people travelling on the M1, for instance, where there is a traffic jam at some times of the day from the portal of the tunnel as far as Balbriggan. I doubt whether people who use the M50 consider it good value for money.

The port tunnel cost almost €1 billion and has a significant capacity. A total of 12,500 vehicles use it daily but the capacity is a multiple of that. I accept it is not desirable for roads to reach capacity on the day they open, but where is it expected the growth will come from? There are no predictions of significant additional numbers of trucks going in and out of the port, especially as the port is currently at capacity. I do not know from where the additional use will come. Can one really say this offers value for money? For instance, not a single bus is using the tunnel.

In spite of the long period when the tunnel was under construction, it is still not fully open. It was closed today due to a single electrical fault. When I inquired about that, I was told we can expect electrical faults as there are 18,000 different electrical components involved. If one can expect faults, surely there should be a plan in place to deal with them? Not a single garda was available. Total gridlock resulted from a simple electrical fault. If one invests €1 billion in infrastructure, surely one has to make that extra investment in Garda traffic corps patrols to ensure total gridlock does not result when a fault occurs in the system?

Comment on this

Subhead B2 relates to road safety agencies. How does the Minister envisage the testing of heavy goods vehicles proceeding and what is his view of the existing system? Last week the media covered a story about road authorities in the UK. On testing 2,000 Irish HGVs, it was found that 55% of them had such significant technical faults they were prevented from continuing on their journeys. It is difficult to understand how that could arise given that we have a system in place that claims to be adequate and ensures proper testing. Will the Minister comment on the fact that in those tests, more than 50% of Irish trucks were deemed to be unsuitable for use? Does this not raise serious questions about the testing system we have in place? Where is the road safety strategy? I thought we would have it long before now. What is the reason for the delay and when is it likely to be published?

Subhead B1 refers to roads. The Minister made great play of the number of road projects under construction and how many of them are coming in ahead of schedule, etc. It is great to see decent roads being built, and built quickly, but I am concerned about the cost to the taxpayer of these roads. Has any study been commissioned or are figures available from the NRA on whether we are getting value for money in this regard? We all want to see roads finished as quickly as possible but I would like to hear the cost per kilometre.

Recent media reports indicated the NRA is paying more per kilometre for the tolled sections of motorways, where public private partnerships, PPPs, are involved, than those sections procured conventionally. Does the Minister have any information in this regard or comparative figures for projects procured in different ways? Apart from the initial cost of procurement with PPP projects, when one factors in that drivers will be paying tolls for 30 years, or 45 years in one case, one can well ask whether we are getting value for money. It is nice for the Minister to be able to cut the ribbon on these new sections of motorway but in the longer term, will we be paying through the nose for them for an extended period? Has the Minister carried out any studies or does he have any comparative figures on the costs associated with different methods of procurement?

I have questions on barrier-free tolling. The Minister stated it will be introduced in three years. The Department has had ten years notice that the port tunnel would open and spill out extra trucks on to the M50. It is difficult to understand why so little preparation was done for that. Why do we have to wait at least a year and a half after the opening of the port tunnel for barrier-free tolling to be in place? Surely the sensible thing would have been to plan ahead and have that system in place for the opening of the port tunnel?

The Minister referred to the port tunnel relieving the situation on the north side. I welcome the removal of the trucks from the north side of Dublin but am concerned about the kind of congestion created on the M50. Recently, I happened to be on the M50 at 6.30 a.m., and I saw buses which were leaving the depot to start serving Blanchardstown were caught up in the congestion. That is one of the problems. Nothing moves on the approach roads in the early morning or the evening time. It is all very well for the Minister to say he is doing this that and the other, but why was the barrier-free tolling system not in place when the port tunnel opened?

I would welcome a comment from the Minister on the incredible gridlock experienced through the north side of Dublin this morning. What appeared to be a minor computer problem took two and a half hours to fix, which resulted in congestion and delays of over an hour for most people travelling in that area. In a modern economy it is not acceptable for a minor fault to cause that level of distress and disturbance to so many. Has the Minister received any report from the port tunnel authorities on that incident and why it took so long to sort out the problem?

Comment on this

On the similarly themed questions from both Deputies on the roads programme and value for money, the system we use is open and transparent and the competitiveness in the marketplace is dictating the best value for money. We came out extremely well in a recent international benchmarking process carried out on the cost of new roads in Ireland compared to the UK and other countries. I was surprised the costs here were substantially cheaper than in the UK. Given the cost of land here I thought the costs in both countries might have been at least the same if not higher here. However, when the overall package is taken into consideration, we are doing exceptionally well. Unlike in other countries, we have probably developed the best pan-European construction industry in Europe. That is a European view. The smartness of the construction industry in Ireland, particularly of the major companies, was such that it realised the capacity of expenditure and initial difficulties with construction inflation were not sustainable from anybody's perspective. Therefore, the amalgamation of many of the different skills of European companies with those of Irish companies has worked exceptionally well. The international view was that we were getting very good value for money. We have very strict and much better contracting regimes in place and the shifting of the risk largely to the construction industry from the State certainly sharpened the approach of the sector. There are great incentives for the sector to ensure it delivers value for money. The development of the Naas dual carriageway, for instance, was the first case in which the construction industry was liable to huge penalties if it failed to keep two lanes open at all times in both directions. Moreover, if it had not delivered the project on time, it would have been subject to massive penalties.

We all acknowledge that the system has evolved into a far better one than the one that obtained heretofore. Clearly, the indications are such that value for money is very good by any measure, particularly by international measures and standards. The NRA has spoken about this in public recently.

Deputy Olivia Mitchell should note that dual carriageways in question are built to motorway standard and are therefore configured with the proper interchanges in terms of traffic flow. They are motorways and it was felt we should designate them accordingly. Some were designated as "motorway" and others as "motorways/high-quality dual carriageway". This was brought to my attention by the NRA because proper designation has implications for servicing and planning along the roads. We took advice from the Office of the Attorney General on the issue and I have addressed it in a Bill which is before the Seanad.

The Attorney General also advised that there should be a consultation process after the legislation is passed. I have no problem with this because public support and buy-in are good. The result will be fine because many people have been touch with me about differences in speed limits on two sections of what they perceive to be the same road. It is appropriate to correct this and designate the roads appropriately. I would not designate every dual carriageway but there is no question that the five interurban routes are motorways, and they will be designated as such. This is to achieve clarity and prevent the existence of long stretches of motorway with sections of high-quality dual carriageway in-between. There are no constitutional issues involved in doing this.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

Are there issues with landowners?

Comment on this

No. That is my information and I am happy enough with it.

It took me a long time to understand all the issues involved in barrier-free tolling, including the financial and technical implications. Like many Deputies, I asked whether the barrier could be lifted within six months. I believed the matter was that simple but it is not. Having spoken to operators and seen many of the systems abroad, and having noted the time taken to test and put such systems in place, I realise the process is very complex. Some cutting-edge systems are now in place internationally and we therefore do not need to reinvent the wheel. This is one of the clear messages that I, on behalf of the Government, gave to the NRA. The cutting-edge systems are being considered for Ireland but much of the technical detail in terms of the link-up with the driver file and the programmes to be designed by the companies in question is very significant. This work is taking place.

It is pretty straightforward to erect the gantry itself and the camera technology will be at the cutting edge. Many systems with cameras require the driver to slow down to approximately 30 km/h or 40 km/h so photographs can be taken but the system to be installed here will enable drivers to pass by without having to do so. The testing and work in progress will be completed next year. The back-up office is very significant, given the many thousands of cars that pass through the tolling station each day. I hope the vast majority of cars using the new system will have the relevant tag but, if not, an invoice system can be used. Running the system is like running a major financial house and that is how it should be.

On comparative timeframes, one should consider the Golden Ears Bridge, Vancouver. The contract therefor was signed in January 2007. The time allowed for design, development, factory acceptance testing and construction of the gantry is from 2007 to 2009. Access to the gantry site will be in January 2009 and system installation and testing will also be in that year. Tolling will not begin until the end of 2009. Our contract is dated March 2007 and development, factory acceptance testing and construction of the gantry will take from March 2007 to November 2007. This is only allowing six months whereas 23 months are being allowed in Vancouver for an identical process. Access to the M50 site will be in November of this year and system installation and testing will run for six months from the end of December 2007 until June 2008. Tolling will begin in the middle of next year. The fastest and best comparable system being installed is the one in Vancouver and one can see from the figures how successful is our process. It is worth saying to ourselves that we can do things very well at times.

We have good companies and good people running good agencies and they are really up for the challenge. The NRA has always said a lot was being asked of it and it would prefer if it had more time to deliver the project. However, it has considered it in detail with the relevant market players and believes it can deliver.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am not questioning the fact that it is quite complex to put such a system in place, as we know from the committee members' trip to Australia. We know it is very sophisticated technically and accept it will take longer than the average person might predict. However, are there not easier ways of collecting money? We are putting in place a huge, expensive system to collect a single toll on a single road.

Comment on this

An operator will always prefer barriers.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am talking about alternatives to tolls.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy talking about complete alternatives to tolls?

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

The barriers must go. Why are we opting for barrier-free tolling when we could raise the money in some other way? It is so expensive to make the change and involves such a lengthy process.

Comment on this

The cost to the road user will not change significantly under a barrier-free tolling system. There will not be a significant jump in the cost of using the M50, except that arising from inflationary changes. We wanted to ensure this when entering the process.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

There is an initial capital cost and an added running cost.

Comment on this

There is, but the position on the M50 has not been recognised. Maybe I have not made myself clear but will try to do so now. NTR had control not only of the toll bridge but also of a fair amount of road structure on either side of it. We had choices and it was quite clear we should either stick with NTR and give it responsibility for barrier-free tolling, thus raising all sorts of questions over the public procurement process, or choose an alternative approach. Why should a company that is doing and has done exceptionally well reap all the extra benefits, in purely financial terms, of moving to barrier-free tolling? We are to increase the capacity of the M50 by 50% and the substantial growth in traffic will clearly continue. By taking NTR off the pitch, I have ensured all that extra revenue will not go to——

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Minister is making our case. We know NTR must be taken off the pitch. My question is whether there is a cheaper way of raising money other than by introducing this expensive system that must be installed over three years. Have other options for raising the money been considered, such as raising it through the tax system or via road tax or increased VAT on petrol, for example? Was a decision simply made to impose tolling on this road? We all agree that the barriers must be lifted and NTR taken off the pitch. My question is whether this is the best way to raise money. Does it offer good value?

Comment on this

There is no doubt it offers good value for money. The money raised is being ring-fenced for direct re-investment into the €1 billion upgrade of the M50. Doing it this way means we can build in the west, south east, north west, midlands and elsewhere. Tolls have been established in Waterford, Limerick and the midlands to accelerate the programme and bring great added value to it. Depending entirely on the Exchequer would not allow us to implement the road development programme in full. More than 650 road projects are under my control, either in planning, design or construction. All are included in the NRA programme and are progressing at different levels.

Tolling would not be necessary if we had all the money in the world. On balance, however, it represents the best and fairest way of using the resources available to us. Almost every First World country employs the use of tolls to realise the resources to invest in road infrastructure. It is the right approach to take. It is strange that there were calls for this to happen for years but, since it has been done, I have been subject to much criticism. In fairness to the NRA, it got as good a deal as anybody could have secured.

Comment on this

How long does the Minister envisage continuing the tolling regime on the West Link?

Comment on this

NTR's contract, which includes a half-year next year and a half-year in 2020, will run out in that year. There is not a full year at either end. There is some confusion in this regard in terms of the figures being discussed. I will have to verify what is involved in the new contract on barrier-free tolling. It may run longer than that, perhaps until 2035.

Tolling regimes vary under the various programmes in different parts of the country. Some run longer because the traffic volume is not as high and it takes longer to secure a return. Traffic volumes must be balanced against delivery and the cost of putting the road infrastructure in place. Development can be more expensive in some places depending on the types of roads put in place.

Comment on this

The Minister mentioned studies that indicates Ireland's road construction record compares well with that of other jurisdictions. However, is it not the case that the cost of the tolls is not factored in over a 30-year period? Instead, these studies simply compare the initial construction costs of different road schemes in different countries.

Comment on this

If tolls were taken into consideration, our position would be even better. It tends to be forgotten that companies that engage in public private partnerships bear the significant responsibility of the maintenance costs for the lifetime of these programmes. Maintenance costs for motorways, for example, are huge. Under these programmes, these costs are increasingly borne by private sector partners rather than the taxpayer. It all balances out. The up-front cost, which runs to several hundred millions of euro in some cases, is also borne by the private partner.

Comment on this

Are there any studies showing comparative figures?

Comment on this

The NRA has put those figures into the public domain.

Comment on this

We have not seen them.

Comment on this

The Deputy should get in contact with the NRA. I understand its representatives were questioned by members at a meeting of the committee.

Comment on this

A delegation from the NRA gave a presentation to this committee 12 months ago on direct contracting vis-à-vis public private partnerships.

Comment on this

The delegates did not provide comparative figures.

Comment on this

They did.

Comment on this

No, they did not.

Comment on this

The contract, which is valued at €113 million, is a fixed service contract that includes the design, construction and operation of the system for eight years.

Comment on this

Is the Minister saying the tolls will be lifted in 2020?

Comment on this

I am not. To ensure we retain the best value for money arrangement, NTR may have to compete for the contract once more. It was important to ensure the NRA did not give somebody carte blanche in the operation of the new system on the M50 for the next 30 years. The contract must remain competitive and we must never again end up in the situation we did recently, rightly or wrongly. It is sometimes forgotten that in 1987, after the Labour Party and Fine Gael had been in office for five years, the country was bankrupt.

Comment on this

The Minister does not mention who signed the contracts and what became of them subsequently.

Comment on this

I accept that Liam Kavanagh and Pádraig Flynn were the two principals. I berate neither of them.

Comment on this

That is not true. The Minister knows perfectly well it was Pádraig Flynn and George Redmond.

Comment on this

Pádraig Flynn signed the contract. I am not trying to make a point of this.

Comment on this

The Minister started off by making a point.

Comment on this

Pádraig Flynn and Liam Kavanagh did a good job at the time. Everyone thought they were mad to take such a risk.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

To clarify, does the figure of €113 million represent the initial cost? Is there also an annual cost?

Comment on this

That is the set-up cost. NTR will also receive its fee. The port tunnel, which was built for a specific purpose, is working well. I have always maintained that we will only get the best out of individual projects when all the road infrastructure and public transport developments are completed. In a perfect world with unlimited resources, we could have taken a different approach ten years ago. The reality, however, is that we did not have all the money in the world. We tried our best, as various Governments did, even through Labour and Fine Gael's time in office in the mid-1990s, to manage a process as well as possible in a given set of circumstances and with limited resources.

In a perfect world, the M50 would have been fully built with three lanes before the port tunnel was constructed. We have the tunnel now, however, and I would hate to imagine where we might be in the future without it. It is sometimes forgotten that the tunnel and other road infrastructure developments will give value for decades to come. It is not about the value today or next week, as is presented by some. These projects will bring value for many decades. I spoke recently to the head of the entire public transport network in Canada. Deeply frustrated at being often asked this question about value for money, his response is that nobody ever asked how much the pyramids cost.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

That answer is not good enough.

Comment on this

He was demonstrating the point that these types of infrastructure projects will have value for generations to come. It is legitimate to ensure one delivers the best value for money in the given circumstances.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

That is the point we are making.

Comment on this

We are doing that. In addition, however, the additional value in social and economic terms for future generations is immeasurable.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

Does the Minister accept that 12,500 vehicles per day is a pathetic amount of capacity to be using considering the overall capacity of the tunnel? What is the plan to ensure we receive value for money? Not a single bus goes through the tunnel. When will buses be allowed to use it? The capacity of the tunnel is a huge multiple of what is currently being accommodated.

Comment on this

I can understand the Deputy shifting the goalposts. She spent the previous 12 months berating me that this disaster, as she called it——

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

It has been a disaster.

Comment on this

The Deputy described it as a disastrous project — disastrous this, disastrous that.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

It came in at twice the original projected cost.

Comment on this

Deputy Olivia Mitchell should allow the Minister to reply.

Comment on this

It is the same as the Fine Gael approach to the Luas. The party predicted it would be disastrous, would never work and so on.

Comment on this
Olivia Mitchell Ms O. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Minister is rewriting history. My party never said the Luas would be a disaster. It was Fine Gael that initiated the Luas project.

Comment on this

We are not discussing the Luas.

Comment on this