Output Statement for the Department of Transport.
Contributions 128–257 of 257. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I am talking about value for money and that is a legitimate question to ask. What is the plan for the port tunnel? Will it ever provide any additional relief? Given that some £1 billion has been spent on it, we are entitled to know whether we are getting value for money.
Comment on this
The Deputy is incorrect. It has cost €750 million. A figure of £1 billion equates to some €1.4 billion euro.
Comment on this
It has the same capacity as the M50 and yet the use is only a fraction of that. What was the plan for it? Were alternatives considered? Was there a reappraisal of the spending when it was decided to drop the south-eastern——
Comment on this
When are the buses going to go into it? When will it be properly managed? When will it be fully open?
Comment on this
I am not interrupting the Deputy to tell her that she cannot ask questions but she is making speeches and not allowing the Minister to reply.
Comment on this
The Minister wants to reply to the Deputy's question regarding the port tunnel. The Deputy started to say it cost €1 billion when in fact it cost €700 million. When the Minister replied to that the Deputy tried——-
Comment on this
If Deputy Mitchell had read the Estimates and the various subheads before she came in here she would understand what is going on. She is trying to change the agenda.
Comment on this
The Chairman should not patronise me. I understand this much better than many people. The tunnel is not yielding value for money.
Comment on this
I asked the Minister to make a short statement on what happened this morning. Has he received any information from the port tunnel about the computer glitch?
Comment on this
No and I am not happy that it took so long to correct what I understand was an electrical signalling fault. I received a preliminary report to that effect but have not received any further detailed report since coming into this committee meeting.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister is pursuing the matter because it is not acceptable that commuters from the north side of the city had to put up with that.
Comment on this
I agree that it is unacceptable but the tunnel is in an early phase and testing is continuing. The capacity of, and access to, that tunnel will improve significantly as we roll out the system but we need to get it right first.
Comment on this
I will start with subhead C1 which deals with subventions. I raise this issue every year. The overall amount of the subsidy is pathetic relative to the amount we should spend on public transport in Dublin if we had any hope of solving our congestion problems. The sum of €330 million is a great deal of money and is being paid almost exclusively to one protected monopoly.
State monopolies can be good but they are nevertheless subject to all the difficulties, inefficiencies and potential abuses that beset monopolies in the private sector. It is incumbent on any Government maintaining and subsidising such a monopoly to demand the most exacting standards for transparency and accountability. We are not achieving that standard.
It is also incumbent on Government to ensure that such a company does not exercise its monopoly power to thwart public policy or subvert the public interest, which is not happening. The public sector gets licences, for want of a better word, to operate new routes the private sector does not if the public sector is using that route. There is complete abuse of the system whereby the monopoly company, whether Bus Éireann or Dublin Bus, applies for licences for services for which it does not have the buses and so thwart the private sector's applications. It is reprehensible that the Minister has not taken a stand on this because it is happening all around the country. I can cite chapter and verse.
It is incumbent on the Government most of all to ensure performance criteria are established and targets met and any subsidy paid must be related to performance. I say this every year. The subsidy must be structured in such a way that it depends on attracting additional passenger numbers. That is completely lacking in the current regime under which €330 million will be handed over with no performance-related criteria apart from going through the motions of pretending that there are targets to be met. We do not know the cost of any bus route in Dublin or anywhere else, which make profits or losses, or what subsidies are required. The previous year's subsidy is repeated and maybe after a couple of years it is increased based on no criteria whatsoever.
Within the public company there seems to be no accountability or appraisal of why the subsidy goes to one place rather than another. Every DART passenger receives a subsidy of over €6, the subsidy on the trains is higher but buses have a pathetically low subsidy. There is no public accountability. The company would get the same subsidy if its buses carried ten passengers as if they carried 10 million. We do not know whether we are getting value for money. This committee examines this matter but no accountability is demanded of this company that receives €330 million in public money. Neither I nor the Minister know how it is being spent, why it is being spent in certain ways and if there are better ways of doing it.
Subhead C2 deals with the public transport investment programme which I am pleased to see is increased this year. There was virtually no activity last year in delivering any of the major projects in Dublin. The Luas was to be extended to Cherrywood, and the Kildare and Cork commuter services were to go ahead. Some have now started.
I am worried that the joining up of the two Luas lines seems to have gone off the boil or been dropped. Where is the Dublin transportation authority that was promised to drive all these projects? It was to knock heads together and ensure that projects went ahead. There is no bridge being built over the Liffey and there is a row with Dublin Bus over who owns the road space, and whether the buses or Luas are entitled to it. There is not enough road space and if the transport authority had been in place those bridges would have been built long ago. I am not even going to discuss integrated ticketing because it is such a pathetic story. A further €9 million is being spent this year, and the €12 million that was spent is dead. When will we see something for that €9 million? The overall budget is €42 million and God knows whether we will ever see anything in return for that.
The Minister's figures for park and ride have gone from €12 million to €1 million. His excuse is that the money was not drawn down. Is he surprised? Why would anybody draw down money for a park and ride system when all he or she can provide is the park? The Minister has command of the ride. Nobody can get business, not Dublin Bus, not Bus Éireann and the private sector will never get buses because the Taoiseach has decided not to rock any union boats between now and an election so there will be no Dublin transport authority or private buses. There is no point providing a park and ride site if there is to be only parking and no buses.
The transport authority would be essential to drive and co-ordinate that kind of business. It has been promised for years but there is no sign of it. What does the Minister expect in terms of draw down this year for the park and ride scheme? South Dublin County Council had several sites in mind and assured me it had applied for bus licences to service these sites but I have not heard whether it has received these licences. Is it the case that it will not get them now given the small sum allocated?
Comment on this
Under subhead C1, the public service provision payments amount to €327 million. This is a tiny payment compared with those made in other EU member states. The current level of subvention to Dublin Bus is 26%, the lowest of 25 major European cities comparable to Dublin. Most of these cities have subventions of 50% to 70%. We know there is a large undersupply of public transport. The public transport companies cannot afford to meet the demand that exists, but the level of subvention from central government is the lowest in Europe. In addition, the entire subvention for Dublin Bus and Bus Éireann is being eaten up by the cost of congestion.
What are the Minister's views on State funding of public transport? It cannot be done on the cheap, yet Ireland's subvention stands at 26%. I know progress has been made to get the figure to 26%. Does the Minister intend to get the subvention figure closer to the European average? We are only fooling ourselves if we pretend we can provide a modern transport public system without a commitment from the Government to fund it adequately.
Regarding funding for Transport 21, my concern and that of the travelling public is that the one project that needs an early go-ahead is the Dublin rail interconnector. That is the single project that will deliver the greatest return, allowing for a fourfold increase in the rail capacity in the greater Dublin area. Why has it been put to the end of the Transport 21 timetable? It will be 2015, at best, when it comes on stream. It should have been frontloaded. With the new rail station opened at Spencer Dock, is it the Minister's intention that Iarnród Éireann would start using the Phoenix Park tunnel? The company has said that once the Spencer Dock station was open, it would enable it to open the Phoenix Park tunnel to commuter services on the Kildare-Newbridge line.
The metro north project is a major part of Transport 21, and one of particular concern to me as a north side Dublin Deputy. The proposal, as it stands, is to bring the metro overground from Glasnevin on to Ballymun. A high speed train service will run through the Ballymun estate in which much public and private moneys have been spent on regeneration. There is no local support for such a service. People are demanding it is kept underground in a cut-and-cover tunnel. The Rail Procurement Agency, however, claims it cannot run it as such through Ballymun within the existing financial envelope the Minister provided. There is a large amount of investment in the metro north project but it will be downgraded if it is run overground. It will not only destroy Ballymun's regeneration but cause havoc to traffic movements on Dublin's north side. The area has more than enough problems with the West Link bridge and the Dublin Port tunnel. If the Minister insists it is run through Ballymun, the system will never reach its capacity of a high speed train every 90 seconds. Is the Minister prepared to review this?
Under subhead C3, will the Minister indicate the future of the Dublin Transportation Office? Is it his intention that it will be subsumed into the new Dublin transportation authority?
Comment on this
There are significant monitoring and auditing units in the Department of Transport, which spend much time ensuring value for money on capital projects. They also ensure memoranda of understanding in the development of the bus companies are in place.
The Deputies may have a different opinion but I believe Dublin Bus and Bus Éireann have done a bloody great job in recent years. They have done it on maximising the resources available to them. Some claim more money should go to subsidising public transport. The alternative is to let the private sector run it on tight public service obligation contracts, keeping the cost to the public purse as minimal as possible.
Having examined this over the years and going by international experience, I believe there is a roll-back in the public sector delivery of the public transport model. The UK's deregulation of the rail networks has been an abject failure. It will move to make its rail companies public because the network has fallen apart. The private sector cherry-picked the best networks and drove the costs of public transport subsidies through the roof. Overall it has been a bad experience for the UK. That is not to say there is not room for a mix of private and public sector companies in the delivery of public transport.
There is more private sector involvement on the long-haul express routes. There are archaic licensing conditions under the 1932 Act which we are all agreed is out of date and needs to be updated.
Comment on this
It is an issue with which most parties have not been able to grapple. I have decided to tackle it.
Comment on this
I am not. The Deputy's remarks were unfair to the staff of Dublin Bus, Iarnród Éireann and Bus Éireann.
Comment on this
The point is that I do not know whether we are getting it because the Minister does not know either, and he will never know until he introduces competition. He has picked the UK, yet it is the only example where such competition has failed.
Comment on this
If the Minister looks at Europe and London, he will see that regulated competition has delivered a far better system.
Comment on this
Deputy Olivia Mitchell is talking to herself without realising it, since her microphone was switched off for approximately five minutes. She should at least allow the Minister to reply. If she has supplementary questions, we will take them afterwards. Let us not get into any argy-bargy. We are trying to pass an Estimate.
Comment on this
The Deputy has no patience and she is not allowing the Minister to reply. Perhaps she might now do so and if she has supplementary questions, we will take them.
Comment on this
In another context, Deputy Shortall takes the quite legitimate view that one should invest greater subsidies in public transport. However, the issue is not whether one invests more or less but that one secures the best value for what one invests. That is what we are striving to achieve. I agree that the DTA can bring a great deal of value to that as we proceed with investment in the public transport system. The DTA legislation, which will be published shortly and the legislation to reform the 1932 Act will allow for private sector involvement in the delivery of public transport by bus in this country. That is the right route to take, and the mix of the two will deliver the best outcomes.
I do not believe what Deputy Shortall said. I am not sure of the measurement that we use or the context of that measurement if other countries carry 60% or 70% of the cost, while we cover only 26%. One must examine how things are run. Ireland has a very centralised, subsidised system, whereas most bus companies in European cities are run in a very different manner by local authorities, being under their control.
Comment on this
There is no point in our comparing apples with oranges. We must compare like with like on this issue. So far, all the measurements indicate we are securing very good value for money. If anything, judging from what Deputy Shortall had to say, we are not investing enough, meaning that we must be getting tremendous value for money in what is being delivered.
The Deputy can rest assured that the issue of the Luas lines has not been dropped because it is crucial and I set out to achieve something. The RPA has had serious discussions with Dublin City Council, and there are clearly major problems regarding its view on managing traffic in Dublin. The agency has also had discussions with the bus companies, particularly Dublin Bus. I would have liked to have seen the issue resolved before now. They are in discussions, and I have asked all sides to reach a conclusion on the issue because the travelling public wishes to see the two Luas lines joined. We know that simply joining them will automatically generate an additional 6 million or 7 million passenger journeys a year. The consequence of their being joined is that, when we extend the network out of O'Connell Street to Lucan and other areas, we will have the full benefit of those lines too.
I have supported all the claims and business cases submitted to me by Bus Éireann and Dublin Bus. I would not like Deputy Shortall to think that I am somehow refusing them what they have asked for, since they have received it on the basis of their own business plans.
Comment on this
The Deputy has decided to discount the fact that we have increased the capacity of Dublin Bus by 40% in recent years, which was what it wanted.
Comment on this
There has been a massive improvement, not to mention the quality of the buses and security systems for the travelling public, which have also made a great difference. The DTO's future is clearly to be absorbed into the DTA. I have made that perfectly clear, and the staff know the agency will be absorbed, so there is no problem in that respect.
Deputy Shortall has made her views known on metro north and the issue at Ballymun. The RPA has been having extensive discussions with local elected representatives and groups to come to a resolution. I know that the preferred option is cut and cover, and my colleagues seem to wish the same thing. I happen to think that they are all wrong, although it is neither here nor there. The on-street system looks fabulous and has proven the best option in other countries. I would certainly prefer to have a first-class, world-beating system delivered in that way.
An overground system is much safer and more secure than a cut and cover system, but I am not ruling it out. I am waiting instead for the RPA to produce a solution after the discussions and recommendations. However, I am well aware that it is not merely the Deputy's view and that a consensus has emerged in Ballymun that people do not want an overground system. That is the people's choice, and I respect that. The debate became very distorted, but that is the current situation and we want to find a resolution to allow us to go to tender. I said publicly and the RPA stated that we would reach the tendering process on metro north for a preliminary weeding out this year, and I want to meet that deadline.
The only outstanding issue is to resolve this, which I hope we can do in the next few weeks. Once a decision has been taken that I hope everyone will favour, we can move on. However, I understand the issue and locals' strongly held view as expressed by the Minister of State, Deputy Noel Ahern, Deputy Carey and others.
Comment on this
The Deputy will be aware that we must electrify the route from Kildare to Dublin, and that has now begun in the form of the four-tracking process. We must get electrified trains through that system, since we cannot bring diesel trains through the interconnector. We must work our way in from outlying areas. The scheduling of everything that Iarnród Éireann and we wanted, which we married with the plans of the RPA and other developments in Dublin, is laid out in Transport 21. Iarnród Éireann has done a fantastic job in delivering the new station. No one would have believed the project would already be open, having been started only last year. That is part of the programme it wishes to roll out.
The Phoenix Park tunnel has been presented as a sort of Holy Grail. I recently went down there and rode in a train through it. The tunnel is very narrow and is used constantly by Iarnród Éireann to move rolling stock. However, it does not represent a solution for Dublin. If capacity and usage can be improved, I would urge Iarnród Éireann to do that given the new station now open in the docklands. However, I understand regarding its connectivity and operation that it will not afford the great increase in capacity that has been suggested. I am not sure whether the new station will allow Iarnród Éireann to do much with it.
Comment on this
Are there cost implications of bringing it into use in conjunction with Spencer Dock station, and have there been any proposals in that regard?
Comment on this
I cannot answer the question, and I do not wish to speculate. Nothing has landed on my desk. I have gone down the tunnel in a train, and it functions every day. Iarnród Éireann uses it daily for significant movements of rolling stock throughout the system. It provides a very beneficial additional stream by allowing traffic to be removed, thus reducing the burden on the system. I have not received any specific proposal regarding work on the Phoenix Park tunnel, but that is not to say Iarnród Éireann does not have such plans in its budgets. I do not know the answer at present.
Comment on this
I have received communications from Iarnród Éireann stating many reasons it could not, should not and would not ever open the Phoenix Park tunnel. I was surprised to read in the newspaper that the chairman of CIE, Mr. John Lynch, had written to the head of the HSE to say that not alone would the opening of the Phoenix Park tunnel to service the children's hospital in the Mater be investigated, but a special station would be opened to service the hospital. I found this somewhat strange.
I want to emphasise this point about the Phoenix Park tunnel which I have raised a number of times. I know CIE has its heart set on the interconnector, but this is years away as yet. If a metro through Dublin is to be built enormous portions of that area just north of the Liffey will have to be dug up. Surely it makes sense to take all the traffic that currently comes from Heuston station and let it go into the Phoenix Park tunnel, thus avoiding the congestion that will be created. If the Minister plans to manage that project that will be an absolutely crucial element that could be availed of.
Comment on this
I am not an engineering expert, no more than the Deputy. I went into the tunnel because many people, including the Deputy, have been saying it is a fantastic facility. However, when one looks at its configuration, size and scale there is very little room and traffic would therefore be very slow in getting through. As it is today, it does not provide an engineering solution in terms of the Heuston and Connolly stations, given the volumes that exist. Neither does it provide a solution in terms of the volume of commuter as well as intercity traffic. When everything is reconfigured to bring it into the mix, there is very little added value in terms of the numbers of people getting into stations, which is the reason for doing this in the first place. We opted for the interconnector precisely for that reason.
The tunnel as it exists — or even an expanded tunnel in the same location — ultimately gives very little, even with a great deal of investment. What is really needed is to reconfigure the entire system to bring an entirely different perspective to the network. That is why the interconnector is crucial, and I agree with both Deputies in that regard. It is not just crucial to Iarnród Éireann. It will be crucial to the whole movement of people in terms of the metro, Luas connectivity and the interconnector. When all the routes are electrified, we will be able to bring what are effectively all the electrified DART systems from the north side through the city into St. Stephen's Green and out. There can be a continuous flow in both directions. The huge amount of work involved and the cost involved of the foretracking which has now started in Kildare is significant in terms of the value of the interconnector and Iarnród Éireann's programme was to roll it out that way.
Comment on this
I want to go back for a moment to the whole question of metro north and its design. The Minister has disagreed with the local people there who said they wanted it kept underground. It is important to appreciate the distinction between metro and Luas. This is not Luas, it is a metro, and if it is to run up the centre of Ballymun's main street it will effectively sever the area because there will be high protective walls on both sides.
Comment on this
That is true. One cannot have a high-speed train running through a highly residential area.
Comment on this
That is the design we are told we will have to have if it is on the surface. There will have to be high protective walls so that even pedestrians cannot cross.
Comment on this
How are pedestrians or traffic to cross the road then? There are major difficulties. The RPA is now telling the public that it cannot look at the option of putting it underground as a cut and cover tunnel because the funding envelope the Minister has provided will not allow it. The RPA recognises that what local people want is a cut and cover tunnel, but the funding will not allow that.
Comment on this
I have not had a final or definitive proposal from the RPA as to what it wants to do.
Comment on this
From my perspective the RPA must produce the best system and the best value for money. It does not agree that that there would be any benefits by the cut and cover system, with the huge additional costs. The Deputy may disagree with the RPA viewpoint on this — I will not argue that with her. From my perspective it has certainly provided for contingencies in the sense that traffic and everything configures. We have the experience at the Red Cow roundabout and everyone said that Luas would bring the world to an end, traffic would fall into the ground, etc. None of this happened. It now works without any bother, giving one some degree of confidence that with a significantly lesser scale of traffic metro north will function well overground. There will be little or no impact on the movement of metro north coming in from Swords to the city centre by having it overground there — almost none. I have to accept that as a statement of fact.
On the other side of the argument, however, I accept the view locally is that people would prefer to see this system underground as opposed to overground, and I respect that.
Comment on this
The agency is saying the constraints the Minister has placed on it will not allow it to recommend that it be put underground.
Comment on this
I never gave the RPA a particular budget for Ballymun, if that is what the Deputy is asking me about. I never said it had a certain amount of money to spend there. I want to be clear about the position here, not disingenuous. The RPA, with all its experts, was asked to design a system from the centre of Dublin to Swords, to get the best value for money and to marry that with the best delivery time and the best system. Its view is that it is utterly unnecessary to incur an enormous extra cost in going underground at Ballymun. That is the point the RPA is making publicly, and it has made me aware of that. I am equally aware of the other side of the equation, the public view.
In a general sense there is the purest misnomer abroad that a metro is underground and something else is overground. The world has moved on dramatically from that old-fashioned way of looking at light rail systems. Modern systems are a mixture of many different elements because the proper technology is available. The highly efficient and successful modern systems comprise a mixture of overground and underground.
Comment on this
It is not an issue of overground and underground. What defines the metro is that it is an uninterrupted route—
Comment on this
—that runs continuously. If a system has the capacity to run trains every 90 seconds in either direction, one is then talking about 45 second intervals, and therefore one cannot have traffic crossing that, either pedestrian or anything else.
Comment on this
I accept that is the Deputy's view, but the RPA says this is nonsense and not the case. It has done all the modelling, etc. and found that running it overground will have no effect. There will not be any more trains coming through, whether the metro is underground or overground. The same amount of trains will be travelling at the same level of speed — and with the same effort.
Comment on this
I should like to cite the RPA directly, to the effect that it is not able to recommend a cut and cover underground system within the financial envelope that the Minister has provided. It is tailoring the project to meet the financial envelope the Minister has provided.
Comment on this
I want to be clear on this because I do not want to be misquoted. There is not a specific figure put by me in Transport 21 for Ballymun. It is clear, in the terms of delivery of the entire metro north, that what the RPA is being charged with is the delivery of a first-class system that embraces all the highest qualities involved but gets the best value for money. In its original planning, and currently, part of the metro goes overground and part goes underground. We have hit a block in Ballymun, where the strongly held view is that the project should be cut and cover and underground. That has a cost implication. It is substantially more expensive to put that system underground than overground in Ballymun, and the RPA is articulating that point.
Comment on this
This is a decision which will be with us for another 100 years and there are other costs involved in terms of safety, segregation of the community, chaos to local traffic movements, as well as destroying the environment.
Comment on this
I have been very calm on this issue. I will not get into a row with the Deputy about it. I await the final report. I made it perfectly clear that I understand the issues. My two colleagues have spoken to me about the view——
Comment on this
I am not the engineer. I am accused of things being gold-plated and so on. I am simply saying that from an engineering point of view and in an efficient system, there will be no difference between it being overground and underground. The difference is a substantial increased cost to put it underground. These are the facts, as opposed to all the other things that have been said about it. We have not come to any conclusion on the issue as I speak.
Comment on this
We are running way behind time. We will now move on to subheads D1 to D5, inclusive, which relate to civil aviation. Does anybody have any queries?
Comment on this
Does this heading include anything about the break-up of the old Aer Rianta, the DTA and the separation of the State airports? I was pleased this morning to hear that we are edging towards a solution in Shannon. However, the problem in Cork persists. It has been said that company law strictures apply in this case and that unless the company has distributable assets equal to the value of the assets it is disposing of, it cannot do so. That rule is to protect shareholders because one cannot sell an asset when one owes money to someone else. If these company law rules apply in this case, how is it that a company like the DAA, which has net debts, can dispose of Cork Airport and yet retain €100 million debt? If it can retain €100 million, why can it not retain it all? Can it legally retain the debt? Do these provisions of company law actually apply? I think I may have caught the Minister out.
Comment on this
It is complex. Is there any chance that we could get the report that determined that the Cork Airport Authority could carry the €100 million and that the DAA would hold onto €120 million? Will the Minister publish that report? It does not make sense that the authority must have distributable assets to dispose of Cork Airport when we know that it does not have any. How can Cork Airport be disposed of and some of the debt retained?
Comment on this
This is a very complex issue about which someone should have informed the former Minister for Transport, Deputy Brennan. The fact remains that people were promised that Cork Airport would start with a clean balance sheet. Either the Minister has welshed on his word or else he did not know what he was talking about. Which is it?
Comment on this
I am glad that both Deputies understand it is a complex issue. It is not easy when we get into distributable reserves, assets and the break-up of a company, be it a public or private company. When I came into office, I met the Cork board and I was asked if there was any possibility to facilitate its move to independence much more quickly than was originally anticipated under the State Airports Act. I said I would look into it but that I did not know the answer in the first instance. I knew, as was correctly set out by my predecessor, that the distributable reserves to do that had to be in place. In other words, the cash value of the asset had to be held in reserves by the Dublin Airport Authority to do it. Since the Cork board wanted to move ahead of schedule to become independent, I promised to look at that.
I informed the board members that I thought what they were doing was the right decision. I said that if I was in their position, I would like to be master of my own destiny. This was a very significant asset with a new terminal, which is effectively a new airport. I thought I could facilitate that. We then entered a process on how that could be done. If the CAA was to move ahead of the original timeframe, it would have to do so on the basis that one of the distributable reserves would not be available in the short term to Dublin Airport to separate Cork. To do it, there would be some cost involved.
On the one hand, what could Dublin Airport bear by losing a very significant asset that was part of its overall bond and loan structure on the financial markets? On the other hand, what debt could Cork Airport realistically bear, taking into the account the value of the asset, the investment profile of the company, its plans for the next few years and its passenger charging regime? I have had just about every expert that one could find to look at this, including Aviation Economics in the UK, which arranged for the Cork board to make a presentation on the facts. Out of that exercise, it became clear that if we wanted to move ahead of schedule and balance the needs of Cork Airport with the loss of a significant asset to Dublin Airport, the figure of €100 million seemed to be fair.
Comment on this
To answer my question, is the €100 million that has been left with Cork Airport merely prudent accounting rather than a legal accounting requirement of a State company?
Comment on this
No. To separate out Cork Airport, which is conservatively valued at €220 million, Dublin Airport Authority must have €220 million in cash reserves.
Comment on this
We have not seen the final accounts from Dublin Airport but based on the work done over the past six months and on what Cork Airport could bear, there may well be figures available to Dublin Airport to distribute a lesser figure. Is the Deputy with me?
Comment on this
At the moment, the airport has a net debt of €320 million according to its annual report.
Comment on this
I have not seen the final accounts. There are obviously things that have occurred in the past 12 months which changed the overall balance sheet. Clearly, the Dublin Airport Authority will cash in many of its assets because it has such a big task to develop Dublin Airport. I was trying to make a point on whether it would be possible this year for the Dublin Airport Authority to have the cash reserves for all the debt. It clearly is not possible. It is possible to achieve €100 million, with cash reserves of €120 million.
Comment on this
Why did the then Minister for Transport, Deputy Brennan, not establish that four years ago?
Comment on this
Please, Deputy. I have been trying to reach out here. The position of the then Minister, Deputy Brennan, and my position are utterly consistent. It was not I or the Government who put a debt on Cork Airport, which wants to move much quicker than was originally anticipated. While I was not Minister for Transport at the time, Deputy Shortall may well have been spokesperson on transport and participated in those debates. It was made perfectly clear that this was possible—
Comment on this
—that Shannon Airport would be first and that when the distributable reserves were available, Cork Airport would be distributed out. My position is completely consistent with that. The Deputy may ask what has changed. It is very simple. Cork Airport wants to move faster than was originally anticipated. That is legitimate.
Comment on this
What has changed is that somebody let the Minister know he cannot play Monopoly with a company and move things around like Monopoly money, which is what the then Minister, Deputy Brennan, was trying to do.
Comment on this
He set out clearly to the House that to move ahead, a finance lease arrangement would have to be put in place by Cork Airport. He set out all the facts with regard to distributable reserves and so on. That is how we got into—
Comment on this
—this debate, which became a debate about a debt, which has confused the issue. It is about the ability of the Dublin Airport Authority to have distributable reserves in cash terms to the value of the asset—
Comment on this
It is about stroke politics that went wrong. The Minister will pay a price at the election.
Comment on this
If I have any regret in all of this, it is that I moved to facilitate them in the first place. I should have left well enough alone. It is the thanks one gets for trying to be helpful.
Comment on this
Has Deputy Shortall questions with regard to maritime transport? No. We move to subheads F1 and F2, miscellaneous, and subhead G, appropriations-in-aid. Are there any queries? No. Are there any concluding remarks?