We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Special Committee Value-added Tax Bill, 1971

SECTION 11.

Contributions 1–174 of 353. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

We were discussing amendment No. 7, section 11. You have before you the list which shows the related amendments. The amendment is in the name of Deputy O'Higgins, and Deputy FitzGerald was speaking. We have dealt with some points raised. There are other points to be discussed.

Comment on this

A number of different issues were raised. We had only discussed one of them.

Comment on this

We discussed whether the rates proposed were arithmetically the same as the existing rates.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

We were discussing the whole lot together.

Comment on this

I had read out certain figures. It was said that there was difficulty—understandably—in assimilating them. As I understand the point, if the calculations which have been put to me are correct, a problem arises because the taxes are now levied at a different stage from previously. As VAT is fundamentally a tax on the full value of the goods, collected at different stages, whatever the rate is, it is related ultimately to the retail value.

All the value, added up to and including the retail stage, is taxed at that rate, even where the previous taxes were levied at different rates. The wholesale tax was levied on the wholesale value of the goods. One cannot, therefore, add together the two previous tax rates, one levied at the wholesale stage and one at retail stage, and arrive at a figure and say that figure, if applied in the form of VAT—and consequently applied to the full retail value of the goods—will yield the same amount. It would appear to me it must yield a larger amount, because the new tax which will be applied, which is arithmetically the sum of the two previous tax levels, not alone to the wholesale value of the goods, but you will be applying the whole of this tax to the retail margin which was previously exempt from the wholesale tax.

That seems to me to be the reason why the procedure which appears to be adopted arithmetically in arriving at 16.37 per cent yields a larger amount of tax. This is a point which I failed to explain clearly yesterday. It is this which gives rise to the difficulty. In the example which I mentioned, the cost of the goods at the wholesale stage is, say, £100. We will take that figure as an example. Then, on the wholesale tax basis, on that £100 value 11.11 per cent is payable, which brings the figure to £111.11. If there is a 20 per cent margin at the retail stage that will bring the cost of the goods retailed to £131.1. If you add turnover tax to that at 5.26 per cent, you add another £6.8, which gives a total of £137.9. That means that the tax payable is a total of £17.9 on a retail price of £137.9.

Under the new scheme now proposed, it does not work like that. Take the cost of the goods as £100. You add 20 per cent profit at that stage. That is £120. You add £16.37 and this gives a tax of £19.64 on goods whose cost to consumers is now £139.64. The cost to the consumer is slightly higher by the difference in the tax rate, and the tax paid as a percentage of the retail price is also higher.

Although the retail price is increased by the same amount, when you relate the tax to the retail price, both increased by the same amount, the percentage relationship has been changed. You have a higher tax rate on the retail level, and an increase in the amount of tax on the same article, and an increase in the retail price.

That is the difficulty as I see it. If the various accountants and retailers organisations who have put forward these figures have misunderstood the position I would be glad if it were clarified. On the face of it, it appears that the taxation will be increased quite significantly. The amount of tax paid on the same article goes up from £17.9 to £19.64, which is an increase of about one-tenth. If the retail margin were 50 per cent, as it is on some goods, the increase in the tax to be paid would be as much as one quarter. In another example calculated in exactly a similar way, although there is a 50 per cent retail margin, the tax goes up from £19.5 at present to £24.5, a very big increase.

Comment on this

I accept that, because of applying the rate to the retail level—as distinct from what happens at present, which is one rate at wholesale level and another rate at retail level—there is an increase in taxation involved. But your calculations are that that increase in taxation amounts to approximately £3.5 million a year. This is the amount which will now be repaid to taxpayers, which is not repaid at the moment, on foot of the elimination of the double taxation that exists at present. This is largely on the basis of people being able to claim credits under VAT for tax on their inputs which they cannot do under the existing system. We estimate the amount of tax that will be refunded to the taxpayers under this provision to be approximately £3.5 million which is about the same figure as the increased yield expected, for the reason I have mentioned. Accordingly we expect the yield to be the same, so that, as far as the Exchequer is concerned, the figure works out at virtually the same amount.

Comment on this

It seems to me that different people are involved. It is not much consolation to somebody who has to pay extra tax that somebody else is getting tax back under this procedure. They would, I think, say to the Minister, were they dealing with him directly, " It is a matter between you and the people to whom you are repaying the tax but it is no reason for increasing the tax on us." I am not clear on either of these calculations. It would perhaps be helpful if we could have an indication of how the figures are estimated. It seems to me prima facie that the estimate of the extra revenue is low because, if you take the example I have given, which is a 20 per cent retail margin, there is an increase of one-tenth in the level of taxation in that case. Total taxation at the moment is more than £50 million; in fact it is £90 million. Therefore, if retail margins were 20 per cent, on average, it would seem that the effect would be an extra £9 million if those calculations were correct. If the Minister says it is only £3.5 million it implies a retail margin of something like 8 per cent. My recollection of retail margins is that they are very much more than that. I do not recall any average figure nearly as low as that.

Comment on this

If they are around 20 per cent we are being " done " right, left and centre on income tax.

Comment on this
Mr. FitzGerald

Not necesarily. They are not 20 per cent; I think they are lower but nothing like as low as the Minister's figure would imply. If I had to guess a figure I would say about £7 million or £8 million. The Minister is going to collect twice as much as he is giving back. I would have to check that out.

Comment on this

There is another angle to it. It is a fact that the Minister collects but will the retailer collect also? The retailer will collect quite a lot of tax, perhaps more than he needs to send in——

Comment on this

No. He gets the same amount.

Comment on this

Very well. Then the tax is cumulative even though it is not supposed to be.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

If, as Deputy FitzGerald says, the price includes the tax surely it means more is being collected than should be collected and if he is only entitled to add on the added value—or are you reckoning the additional tax as value also?

Comment on this

No, it is not a tax on the tax.

Comment on this

Is the Minister suggesting that the retailer will say: " This is the price of the article and this is the tax "? Does the Minister recollect that on Second Reading he did say that for handiness sake most retailers would, in fact, have an all-in price particularly on small items? Does it not follow that they will be showing a tax on the tax? They will not go to the trouble of segregating the tax.

Comment on this

No. For simplicity, assume we are dealing with the retailer who deals only in the 5.26 rate of goods. He will have a total amount of turnover. That will be what he received in the two-month period. He will say " 5 per cent of that is the amount of my tax " and 5 per cent represents 5.26 per cent on the price it would have been without the tax. It is not a question of his having charged a price for an item in which he includes tax and then charging tax on top of that again.

Comment on this

What I am trying to get at is that the manufacturer sells to the wholesaler and tax is collected. When the wholesaler sells to the retailer he adds on as part of the price the tax he has paid and on that there must be tax.

Comment on this

No. He shows that separately on the price of the goods.

Comment on this

If he does that, go from the retailer to the final sale to the customer. Is the Minister suggesting that this also will be shown separately on the goods as well as on the accounts?

Comment on this

What I am saying is that, as far as the retailer is concerned, whether he sells on the basis of a price which includes the tax on each item or sells the goods with the price and the tax charged separately—whichever way he does it—the net effect will be that he will have a total amount of money taken in during the two-month period and 5 per cent of that sum will represent 5.26 on a tax exclusive base.

Comment on this

But he is keeping an account and on that account he shows purchases and sales for return purposes and they will not coincide with what the Minister has just said. I should like to know where the difference will go because there must be a difference.

Comment on this

I fear I do not follow Deputy Tully's argument.

Comment on this

The tax is levied at 5 per cent on the final value of the goods.

Comment on this

Levied as far as the retailer is concerned and as far as the Minister is concerned. That is all right but where does the customer come in who will almost certainly be paying more than that?

Comment on this

It cannot be more than that. The retailer may push up the price more than he should and make more profit but as far as the customer is concerned he pays to the retailer exactly 5 per cent of that, no more or no less, and it goes back in tax, some of it having been collected earlier and some of it collected when he makes the return.

Comment on this

The .26 comes in here. It starts at £100 say and the tax is 5 per cent, that is £105 and 5 per cent of £105 becomes £5.26.

Comment on this

That is it. If a man sells goods at £105.26, to assess the amount of tax that he has to pass on to the Revenue Commissioners, he takes 5 per cent of it.

Comment on this

I am clear enough about that but I am not clear about the final transaction when it is broken into smalls. A figure of £100 is easy enough to deal with but something costing a few pence it not.

Comment on this

Divide that into 100 articles.

Comment on this

And retail them at a price.

Comment on this

You are talking about the amount by which the retailer jacks up his price to enable him to pay the turnover tax without reducing his margin. That is a separate question. He may jack up his price more than he should but whatever he jacks it up by, having done that up to 5 per cent, that goes to the Exchequer.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. A. Collins Fine Gael

Why should 5.26 be taken from 105.25? There will be an element in this of tax on tax.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

No. It exists at the moment but VAT will eliminate it.

Comment on this

The Minister has no friend but me here.

Comment on this

Could the Minister not demonstrate one article which costs a figure right down from the manufacturer to the retailer?

Comment on this

That is all right on the £100. We can all follow that but we want to get down to the smalls.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. A. Collins Fine Gael

Why should you charge 5.26 per cent on my sale of an article which I sold at £105.26?

Comment on this

No. We will take 5 per cent from that.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. A. Collins Fine Gael

Why should you take a percentage of the tax element?

Comment on this

Because, by taking 5 per cent of £105.26, we collect precisely the same amount as is collected under turnover tax at the moment which is 5 per cent on a tax-inclusive basis. The VAT is on the tax exclusive basis. That means that if goods are sold at £105.26 and if you take 5 per cent of that as being the amount of the tax, in fact that works out at 5.26, which is 5 per cent. You get the same figure as you do at the moment. There is not an element of tax-on-tax in the value-added tax system.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick (Dublin Central) Fianna Fáil

If you are getting the same amount as you are getting today there is an element of tax in it. There is an element at the moment of tax-on-tax. If I am selling £100 of goods I am paying the tax of 5 per cent, which means I am paying tax twice on that. Is this being carried through to get the 5.26?

Comment on this

Yes, the Minister is raising the tax rate to 5.26 so that he can tell you that he is not collecting tax-on-tax any more.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick (Dublin Central) Fianna Fáil

Is it the very same result?

Comment on this

It is exactly the same result as regards the amount of tax paid on the particular item.

Comment on this

At present turnover tax is 5 per cent. On £100 your turnover becomes £105 because you are adding on the 5 per cent tax. When you come and take 5.26 per cent of £105 that is tax on the actual turnover.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

It is 5 per cent of £105 which is equal to 5.26. Is that not correct?

Comment on this

Another example may help. At present the retail selling price of an article is £100, that is on the tax inclusive basis. Where the article is sold for £100 it means that the £100 includes tax at 5 per cent which is £5, so that, excluding tax, the cost of the item is £95.

Comment on this

The item is sold at £100?

Comment on this

Under turnover tax at the moment. Under the present system, if an item is sold at £100, that means it includes £5 turnover tax. The actual cost of the item is £95 and the tax £5. Now, 5.26 per cent of £95, if anybody wants to work it out, is £5; so VAT gives the same result as at present.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick (Dublin Central) Fianna Fáil

It is exactly the same result. The goods are £95, you are adding £5 and you are paying tax on the last £5.

Comment on this

That is exactly it, so, in fact, you are paying tax on the tax.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

By raising the rate of taxation he will take the same amount of money while telling you that he is not collecting tax on tax.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. A. Collins Fine Gael

I do not see the reason why we should have a complicated rate of tax of 5.26 per cent. Why not leave it at 5 per cent from the point of view of simplicity?

Comment on this

Which amendment are we discussing?

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. A. Collins Fine Gael

Amendment No. 8.

Comment on this

Are we discussing all the amendments together?

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. A. Collins Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting that Deputy Collins is not correct. I had forgotten that we were discussing them together. Are we now discussing all those amendments?

Comment on this

We are discussing all amendments related to amendment No. 7.

Comment on this

Deputy Collins has said if 5 per cent was correct in the turnover tax why was it decided to adopt this more complicated system? It is all right saying on £95 it is exactly the same, but every article which is bought will not be as evenly divided as that. Why was it not possible to say 5 per cent? One thing we could say about it is that everybody could make out exactly what the tax was.

Comment on this

The first thing to understand about it is that the VAT is assessed on a tax-exclusive basis whereas the turnover tax is on a tax-inclusive basis. Therefore, if you are changing from a tax-inclusive basis to a tax-exclusive basis—and you want to get the same result—you have got to change the nominal rate, as we have done by having 5.6 per cent.

Comment on this

Why did you do that if you are saying you are not putting the tax on tax. Calling it exclusive instead of inclusive will not make one bit of difference to the person who is paying the tax because he is paying the same amount.

Comment on this

It is only a technicality.

Comment on this

There is more to it than that. To work the system of VAT at all it has to be on a tax-exclusive basis, but we should not overlook the fact that by having a VAT system, as distinct from the one we have at the moment, it confers benefits on traders, as I outlined earlier, in the way they can get allowances for tax which they could not get under the present system. On the question of the awkwardness of the figure the matter is not as simple as it seems. Whatever figure you pick, it will be awkward. You may say 5 per cent is easy to calculate. This is true, but what happens then when the man is calculating his turnover tax? How does he arrive at that?

Comment on this

He has also only got 5 per cent.

Comment on this

Take it on the VAT basis. If it is 5.26 per cent which is added on to the goods that means 5 per cent for the retailer when calculating his liability for tax. If you make it the 5 per cent rate as suggested, then the calculation which he has to do for his tax is 4.8 per cent. Whichever way you do it, you end up with an odd figure. Making it 5 per cent does not simplify the thing as it would appear to do. Leaving aside the whole question of trying to maintain the rates as they are at present, which I regard as vitally important so as not to provide an opportunity for a number of changes, and therefore almost certainly increases in prices.

Comment on this

That brings me back to the point where I started. The Minister is not maintaining the tax at the same level and is giving every excuse for increases in prices. The Minister admitted that, in fact, 15.37 per cent represented an increase in taxation. He claimed it would only bring in £3.5 million. The Minister claimed that that is equal to the amount that would be repaid to other people through the system. It is an increase in tax. It is no good telling the retailer he has no excuse for increases in prices.

Comment on this

It is not an increase in yield.

Comment on this

The Minister says he does not want to give any excuse for an increase in prices. But what does he do? He tells the retailer he has no excuse for putting up prices because other people, such as builders, will get repayments.

Comment on this

No. Retailers are going to get repayments.

Comment on this

The repayments which the average retailer will get, which he does not get now, will be negligible. He will get repayments for expenditure on fittings, or sporadic expenditure.

Comment on this

It is only part of this. He is also getting a greater degree of liquidity than he has under the present system. On balance, I think the retailer will be at least as well off, or perhaps better off, than he is under the present system.

Comment on this

Has the Minister persuaded any retailer or any retail organisation of that fact?

Comment on this

I am not aware that any of them are seriously contesting it, because it is a fact.

Comment on this

Did the Revenue Commissioners find in any country in the Six this kind of figure of 11.11 per cent? Surely no sensible people would put this kind of thing into legislation? I can see no reason whatever for having a figure like 5.26 per cent.

Comment on this

I understand that France and Sweden have odd figures like that.

Comment on this

To two decimal places?

Comment on this

I do not know off-hand whether they have figures to two decimal places. I must repeat the reason for this. It is to ensure, so far as we can, that the yield and the incidence of tax is kept at the same level as it is at the moment. If we depart from the figures in the Bill, that is not the result which we will get.

Comment on this

I deliberately brought in here the Estimates of receipts and expenditure. The turnover tax was up this year from £50 million to £53.5 million. The wholesale tax was up from £29.6 million to £35.5 million. I know the logic of this thing. It is the logic of the clerks. I was a clerk for long enough and I know all about it. The fact is that inflation is a powerful influence by comparison with this kind of thing. There is a figure of 30.26 here somewhere. The Minister has said that the apparent simplification is not real. It is important for people when there is a complete change in taxation that there should not be too much difficulty with the figures. It is all right for the clerks who are paid to give their time to the job. It is all right for the Revenue Commissioners to make people work as they have been making people work for the last 20 years. They have made people do work which they should have done themselves. They have done this regularly and systematically. I know this to be a fact. I said in the Seanad, when speaking on the income tax system, that more and more people are having to do more and more unpaid work for the Government. What the Minister says may be true—that this 5 per cent or 30 per cent or 10 per cent instead of 11.11 per cent might not be a genuine simplification but it looks simpler. It is surprising how much people are affected by how a thing looks, especially if they are going to have to do a lot of work on it anyway. The Revenue Commissioners may say that there will be ready reckoners. This does not still get rid of the objections. The apparent arguments about keeping taxation equal are all poppycock because of the huge inflation every year.

Comment on this

The question of inflation is irrelevant in this context. For the purpose of trying to ensure that the tax is the same, one must include inflation because, whether you change the rates or not, if you have inflation the yield will be increased.

Comment on this

The Minister is interested in keeping the yield the same. This does not matter a fig because, in fact, there will be an enormous increase in yield through inflation.

Comment on this

The Deputy is looking at this from a different angle. Suppose that instead of having 5.26 per cent and 16.37 per cent that we had a flat rate of 10 per cent would the Deputy consider what will flow from that, not from the point of revenue, but from the point of view of the consumer, and what would happen to the price of goods? This is what is primarily concerning me in this. The effect would be that, on the essential commodities, such as food, the tax charge would go up fairly substantially. We know from experience that not alone would there be an increase directly attributable to the increase in the tax rate but also, by reason of mark-ups and other reasons, more would be put on and the prices of essential commodities would go up very substantially. Nobody could honestly say that he believes that as some form of compensation for that, the reduction from 16.37 per cent to the 10 per cent on the less essential items would result in corresponding reductions in those prices.

Comment on this

That is not what I am suggesting at all.

Comment on this

I am saying this to illustrate why we have chosen these apparently odd figures.

Comment on this

I know why the Minister has chosen them, but I do not accept the arguments.

Comment on this

The Minister said that he did not have any great volume of opinion against the odd figures or that there was not evidence that many people were opposed to them.

Comment on this

I do not think I said that. My recollection is that Deputy FitzGerald asked how many organisations had accepted the argument that there would be an improvement in their liquidity.

Comment on this

No, not exactly. How many have accepted the argument that they would be better off?

Comment on this

Dublin Chamber of Commerce have written in and this is their submission to the Revenue Commissioners. I would like to quote from page 1, paragraphs 4, 5 and 6:

The suggestion to base the tax on a price excluding tax is welcomed. The proposed three rates of tax, 5.26 per cent, 16.37 per cent and 30.26 per cent, are not welcomed. These decimal rates would undoubtedly be awkward for firms who are ill-equipped to deal with such calculations.

The Chamber of Commerce recognises the difficulty of the Revenue Commissioners who wish to substitute the value-added tax precisely for the existing wholesale and turnover taxes. But the value of the precise tax substitution is outweighed by the awkward values of the proposed rates. Of the countries using, or proposing to use, the value-added tax on a price excluding tax (Luxembourg, Belgium, Germany, Italy, Netherlands, Denmark and Norway) only Germany has a rate other than a whole; even the German rate which is not a whole number is a simple fraction, i.e., 5½ per cent.

The impression we were given earlier—perhaps I misunderstood—was that this was a general thing which was being tailored for this purpose and therefore we should not be objecting to the odd numbers. It was stated as a suggestion that:

The rates imposed should be rounded to full numbers in such a way that the revenue is identical to that at present received from the wholesale and turnover taxes.

This has been submitted by the Dublin Chamber of Commerce to the Revenue Commissioners and it gives a very good reason why this is being operated in other countries in a certain way and we are out on our own in this.

Comment on this

In fact, we are not. The Deputy has mentioned Germany and I have already quoted France.

Comment on this

No, sorry. I have quoted Luxembourg, Belgium, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, Denmark and Norway. They are all adopting whole numbers, Germany with 5½ per cent which is not exactly a whole number, but a reasonable fraction.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is missing the point I am making. I never said in relation to these rates that we should have these odd-looking rates because other countries had odd-looking rates. The only reason we have them is because they are, as exactly as we can get, the equivalent of the existing rates.

Comment on this

What purpose is that supposed to serve?

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

As far as I can see the Minister's argument for these decimalised numbers is that it will continue the present system of taxation. Am I right in that?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I do not accept that as a good argument for introducing peculiar numbers. The argument in favour of round simple numbers such as 5 per cent is that it is one-twentieth, 10 per cent is one-tenth and 30 per cent is three-tenths. That seems to me a far more reasonable and realistic approach. You will have many traders, large and small, making out invoices large and small every day, and surely, from the administration point of view, it is far easier to work in round figures. It may marginally affect the incidence of taxation but the administrative effect of round numbers is far more important and should be taken into consideration more than a marginal difference in the incidence of taxation.

Comment on this

The essential point I want to make, and which has not been grasped, is that I am not so much concerned with the yield of the tax. I would, of course, be concerned if there was any major difference in it, but a marginal difference—excluding the element of inflation which would only confuse the argument—a marginal difference in yield to the Exchequer is not my problem. My problem is : what will be the effect—and no Deputy has so far dealt with this point—if you change the rates of existing taxation? Suppose you have one flat rate. This illustrates the point I want to make. What happens to prices if you do that? That is the first thing you must consider. The second thing is that I have indicated that there are a number of continental countries which have peculiar looking rates. That is no reason why we should have them. The fact that other countries have even rates is no reason for it either. The reason we have these odd-looking rates is, as I have said, because they are the nearest we can get to the existing rates. We want to get the nearest equivalent to the existing rates to prevent the kind of things that could happen to prices if we depart from that.

I also want to point out that even in the Netherlands where they have even figures they have to use ready reckoners. One—and not the only—reason for this is the point I mentioned earlier, that when you have an even number as the rate you have a corresponding odd number when you are calculating the tax so that while it may appear to be an advantage to have the even rate, the fact is that if it is even in one place you have it odd in the other. You cannot avoid this. If you are faced with the fact of having an odd percentage is it not reasonable to have the odd percentage in the place where it will, as far as one can achieve it, ensure that there is not a change in the tax and, therefore, not have something that will set up a spiral of increased costs?

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister a question? He mentioned France as not having an even rate. Is it not true that that only applies to two rates out of four?

Comment on this

I think that is correct.

Comment on this

We had better have the facts. Two of them are even and two are not.

Comment on this

This is irrelevant. I am only dealing with this because the point was raised that other countries had even rates. I said that some have even rates but it is irrelevant to us whether they have or not. The reason we have them is the one I have given.

Comment on this

It appears that everybody is out of step except our Johnny.

Comment on this

No. One cannot say that when other countries have uneven rates. It is an irrelevance.

Comment on this

The Minister says the reason we must go into two decimal places is to preserve the existing tax rate and give nobody an excuse to increase prices. But the degree of accuracy of the two decimal places is very high but yet he is so far departing from this principle as to increase one of the rates to a level that will yield him £3.5 million extra which means he is adding on something not involving two decimal places or one decimal place but he is increasing by several places, rather between one and two places, the actual tax rates. It is not correct and is probably misleading to say that the Minister is keeping the tax rates the same even if he must go to two decimal places to do so.

Comment on this

If Deputy FitzGerald or anybody else suggests a better way I will accept it.

Comment on this

First, the Minister's statement is incorrect in that respect and the excuse is invalid. Secondly, I do not accept that if you increase taxation it will inevitably yield higher profit margins, thus causing an increase in prices. This may be believed by politicians in all parties but I did not think the Minister for Finance would fall for it. I was interested to note in the past couple of days here that he has. What evidence is there for it? Take the example of the turnover tax. I know it is believed by politicians in all parties, and my own particularly, that when it was increased prices rocketed. I recall examining with great care the consumer price index in respect of different items, a range of items, in the period immediately after that. I could detect no indication that there had been a disproportionate increase in prices. Certainly, the amounts by which prices rose by more than 2½ per cent was so small that it was less than the amount that one would normally have expected of a price increase at that time had there been no increase in taxation and no introduction of turnover tax. Therefore, there is no evidence of this phenomenon.

So far as the great bulk of the retail trade is concerned very considerable competition exists. It is not universal. There are notable monopolies here and there where particular shops or groups of shops are the only shops in areas but there is a very considerable element of competition. Thirdly, even if the Minister takes the view that there are areas where there is not sufficient competition it is a remarkable admission of failure in price control that we have to have a tax system as complicated as this, going to two decimal places because of inability to control extortionate price increases by cartels and monopolies. If there is not a monopoly situation or agreement of some kind between firms to push up prices more than the increase in taxation justifies then these prices cannot by definition increase.

Is it the case that we are going to have the whole tax system bedevilled by the incompetence and inadequacy of our price control system? I do not think this is the case. I think our price control system is now operating fairly effectively and I am not at all convinced that we are incapable of controlling extortionate price increases following tax increases in the area in which cartels and monopolies exist, which are a small minority of the total area in any event. I think the Minister has fallen for this particular myth and that what he says is incorrect in this respect. Even if it were true, he invalidates his whole case by actually increasing the tax rate in one very important incidence by 16.37. He has admitted today what he denied the last day—I think the record will show this—that this rate, in fact, involves an increase in tax of such an extent that, although only a small minority of the £90 million is coming in the form of money at this rate—the extra 11 per cent on this—nevertheless £3½ million is being brought in by increasing this tax rate. Why is that acceptable in that incidence? Why is it that that will not produce price increases on the type of goods involved but that, in other cases, it is so vital to prevent even a movement from two to one decimal places in the tax rate lest price increases go up? I am afraid the Minister's case is totally inconsistent. Could I ask him, having said that——

Comment on this

Before the Deputy asks me anything would he answer the question I put to him. He has said a great deal but he has not answered the question I put to him. Would he suggest a better way of doing it?

Comment on this

I will come to that now and ask the Minister a question later on. When the Minister says a better way do I understand him to mean a system of tax rates which will have a similar incidence on the standard of living of different groups in the community, one that will not be more regressive?

Comment on this

I take it on the basis that the Deputy believes that a change in the tax rate would not mean any increase in the cost of goods other than that attributable to the increase in tax he could make a suggestion on how this could be done. I doubt if there is any other Deputy around this table who would agree with him.

Comment on this

Is there any Deputy here or anybody who can produce evidence or has seen evidence to the contrary in respect of any tax increase in this country? Has any economic study ever been done that showed this? As far as I am aware the contrary has emerged from any studies carried out so it is no good producing myths here which are believed by politicians. We have great fun with our myths but we are concerned here with realities.

Comment on this

Let us be clear here what Deputy FitzGerald is saying. What he is saying, if I understand him correctly, is that when the turnover tax was increased from 2½ per cent to 5 per cent there was no increase in prices other than the additional 2½ per cent plus normal increases which would otherwise have taken place.

Comment on this

Nothing that was measurable.

Comment on this

Anybody who agreed with that can accept what Deputy FitzGerald is saying.

Comment on this

Yes, and anybody who disagrees with it will, of course, produce the evidence and the information here.

Comment on this

The Deputy is doing a lot of talk and it does not make it clearer.

Comment on this

I would like to complete this particular point, with respect to Deputy O'Donovan.

Comment on this

I hope you hurry up.

Comment on this

I will take my own time.

Comment on this

All right. We will probably be here until Christmas if you do because I can talk too when I want to.

Comment on this

I am well aware of that. The Deputy is almost succeeding in putting me off my stroke. If we look at the census of distribution data there is no evidence whatever of a movement in gross margins that would sustain this belief that every time taxes go up the profit margins go up. There is no evidence anywhere for this thesis. The Minister has well equipped advisers here. If they have told him that there is evidence in some statistical form, census of distribution, in the consumer price index, that sustains his thesis let him give us that information and I will certainly accept it. I do not think we should be " codded " here by having tax going to two decimal places because of politicians' myths unsustained by any economic study or analysis whatever. If I am wrong and there is evidence to show I am let us hear it. If there is not evidence I hope the discussion will not proceed along those lines because it is simply a waste of time. Given, therefore, that there is no evidence to oppose that view, the question the Minister seems to be putting to me is: Is there a way of so arranging these tax rates that the same amount of money globally will be secured and that the incidence of taxation of these expenditure taxes on different social groups in the community would not be significantly changed? Is that the question the Minister is putting?

Comment on this

Substantially that is so.

Comment on this

I believe this is so. I believe by varying the incidence, by increasing the range of goods which are zero-rated in the category of necessities, such as foodstuffs, increasing the overall tax rate to a higher level and having a single tax rate the same result could be achieved. I am almost prepared to challenge the Minister that if I could come back to him with data based on the household budget inquiry showing a system of taxation with a single rate of tax and a range of goods zero-rated which had the same effect substantially on different income groups in the community will he accept that as an alternative?

Comment on this

If the Deputy can show to me as well that the consequence of that will be, for instance, that wage claims will not increase as a result of the proposal that he is suggesting.

Comment on this

If the Minister is asking me to say that workers will not claim increases in wages and that I should stop them in some way I certainly cannot guarantee that.

Comment on this

Will the Minister guarantee if the other thing happens that there will be no necessity for extra wage claims?

Comment on this

If the Minister would rephrase his question and ask me whether I was in a position to show that there would be no increase in wage claims I would be prepared to answer it but I am prepared to deal only in facts not in myths.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not dealing with facts if he is talking about the basis. I am dealing with the fact of what can happen in wage claims—that is a fact—whether they be justified or not.

Comment on this

They are always justified.

Comment on this

If there is a belief that the consequence of this kind of activity is to increase prices then there is a direct effect on wage claims, on the whole economy and on inflation. The Deputy knows that as well as I do and you cannot just excuse that.

Comment on this

The Minister wishes to deal in myths. A myth has been perpetrated already that VAT will increase the cost of living considerably. That myth is widespread and unfortunately the Minister has given substance to it by increasing one of the tax rates to get in extra money. In fact it is believed that prices will rise by much more than the amount involved. We know that kind of myth, from the case of the turnover tax, will be believed even when the evidence comes out afterwards that it is not true. If we are going to have our tax system governed by these kind of myths if we make any change in taxation, no matter how careful we are—as the Minister has been in respect of the 5.26 per cent rate—to do nothing that would justify the myth, if we are still going to have people believing in myths and if we are going to let that go in our tax system we are really in trouble. There is no good deciding that we cannot make any change because somebody somewhere might be so stupid as not to face the facts of it and to believe that although it is designed not to and can be shown not to have increased prices or the cost of living, nevertheless a wage claim is being made. If that is the level on which we are discussing this it is a hopeless discussion.

Comment on this

Deputy FitzGerald said earlier on that when turnover tax came in it only made a marginal difference. That was not the evidence I saw with my own eyes and it was not what I was told by my wife. I do not believe in those statistics which are produced.

Comment on this

Statistics are better than anecdotes. I prefer them any time.

Comment on this

Of course you would. Does anybody in this room believe that the cost of living only went up by 3.26 per cent, which is the calculation Deputy FitzGerald made in 1964, when the turnover tax of 2½ per cent came into operation?

Comment on this

The Deputy is descending to appalling trivialities.

Comment on this

I discussed this with many people.

Comment on this

The myth was widely perpetrated by politicians.

Comment on this

It was not perpetrated by any politicians. I discussed this with people who had no connection with politics and they all told me that there were differences of opinion as to whether the cost of living went up by 5 per cent, 6 per cent or 7 per cent. It certainly went up by at least 5 per cent and I do not care what the Central Statistics Office or Deputy FitzGerald produce.

Comment on this

I would be interested to know if the Minister shares the views of the Central Statistics Office or those of Deputy O'Donovan?

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick (Dublin Central) Fianna Fáil

At the present moment you add 10 per cent on every £100 but with the value-added tax you will now be adding 10 per cent on £89 worth of goods. Up to now you are getting £100 at wholesale level from which you are deducting £10, that is 10 per cent. I think with the VAT you will be calculating 10 per cent on £89.

Comment on this

That is more than compensated by the retail tax having to be imposed on the level of goods after the margin has been added. If the Deputy would look at the first example in that document he will see how the net effect works out.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick (Dublin Central) Fianna Fáil

We see what 5 per cent does. You have to apply 5.26 per cent to get the same because you are applying it on £95.

Comment on this

If the Deputy would look at the example, it would be easier.

Comment on this

It is now on £100.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick (Dublin Central) Fianna Fáil

I am taking today's tax. Every £100 of the wholesale tax takes £10. On the VAT it will be taken on the goods at £89.

Comment on this

If the Deputy would look at the example, it would be easier.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I must say that I disagree with Deputy FitzGerald in what he said about our price surveillance system. I do not think it is as good as he says. The changeover to decimalisation proves this to a certain extent already. I am interested in what was said about broadening the number of items which would be zeroed, especially the necessities of life, and perhaps increasing semi-luxuries and luxuries. I would agree with that concept. Perhaps it is a concept which this Committee should discuss further.

Comment on this

Is it the Deputy's view that if that was done in such a way that the total level of taxation is maintained, and that the actual tax burden on each income group were maintained, whether he would not feel that the psychological effect of food prices going down and other prices going up might not be beneficial in regard to wage claims, rather than otherwise? If you keep complete neutrality, the effect will be beneficial rather than otherwise.

Comment on this

I had a number of amendments suggesting that the top tax could be rounded up in order to zero-rate a number of items, including foodstuffs. I was surprised to see they were ruled out of order.

Comment on this

This is a Committee of the House, and this is in substitution for the Committee Stage of the Bill. I would have assumed that the format of the Bill was decided at the Second Stage—how this was going to work was decided at the Second Reading. It was decided that this would be the method of operating the VAT. If we are to upturn the whole Bill, let us upturn it. I did not realise that we were in this position at all. I would have assumed that the purpose of this Committee was to decide how these various taxation rates would be operated. I still do not understand, in spite of all the talk for the past 40 minutes, the objection to this flat rate. There is a tremendous psychological advantage in it. I stand over my point that, in fact, the inflation, if, in fact, the Minister did not want to alter the rate of tax and wants to get the same yield in spite of his assurance——

Comment on this
Mr. Coffey

I modified that a bit.

Comment on this

——that he was not interested in the yield, but I feel it would be worth a small sacrifice of tax. My point is that inflation is enormous. The small rate of 5.26 per cent is the biggest rate effectively. A reduction of 0.26 per cent to 5 per cent is small. It is about one-twentieth. It is a lowering of yield on that particular figure. Before this becomes law, that will have been dealt with by inflation.

Comment on this

I see the Deputy's point in regard to the amount of yield involved. It would be £2.25 million. Over the whole amount this could be tolerated. The point the Deputy has not grasped is the effect on prices of altering the yield.

Comment on this

And reducing the tax?

Comment on this

Deputy FitzGerald is arguing that there is an increase in yield anyway. He is talking about an increased yield of £3.5 million spread over purchases of about £1,000 million.

Comment on this

£3.5 million on £90 million.

Comment on this

So far as the overall impact on the consumer is concerned I am concerned with what the effect will be on sales amounting approximately to £1,000 million. It represents an increase of £3.5 million. I have pointed out that there is a refund of about £3.5 million involved also in the VAT system. So far as the revenue are concerned there is not an increased yield at all. To say that, because of this factor, spread over £1,000 million, that therefore the principle is conceded, is not realistic. You can not change all the rates without any real effect. It is just a debating point. I am not in the position that I have to argue with Deputy FitzGerald to any great extent on the question of whether or not a change in the rates is going to lead to an increase in the cost of living over and above the actual change in the rates. As Deputy O'Donovan suggested, past experience has shown it did, and Deputy FitzGerald said it did not. It does not matter which argument is correct. The point, so far as I am concerned is—and Deputy FitzGerald has conceded this although he calls it a myth—that it is commonly believed by every man, woman and child in the country that there will be an increase in yield. It is believed by them and if it is, then, of course, it is going to have the effect I talked about in wage claims. Deputy FitzGerald may say that this is reducing the level of discussion to a farce, because it is a myth. If past experience is to be believed, it is a reality. There is an effect on the whole economy.

Comment on this

If not, Frank Sherwin is the most unfortunate man in Ireland.

Comment on this

The Minister asserted it as a fact on several occasions.

Comment on this

I do not need to argue with the Deputy on the point.

Comment on this

Would the Minister let us know the evidence?

Comment on this

Why? How relevant is it to our discussion here?

Comment on this

It is a serious matter if, instead of trying to eliminate a myth whose effect on public policy is clearly so adverse and dangerous, the Minister has attempted to perpetuate the myth by asserting it as a fact, without producing the evidence. I would say that his responsibility as a Minister carrying out his duties is that he should produce evidence, or evidence to the contrary should be produced. Various people have told him that this is true, but the evidence produced to him would be to the contrary. It is the Minister's duty to put that evidence before the nation and maybe the nation will believe him.

Comment on this

I would suggest that it has very little effect on the issue before us here. Some of us do not agree with Deputy FitzGerald. We will not be able to carry the argument along with him, even if he is right.

Comment on this

I conceive my responsibility as a Minister to be such that if this myth to which Deputy FitzGerald has referred—whether it be a fact or a myth, if it is commonly believed, it is something that will affect our whole economic situation—my responsibility as Minister, in my view, is to take account of that fact and avoid a situation in which our whole economy will be affected by this belief whether true or false.

Comment on this

If the Minister accepts that I understand that and if he thinks that it is so widely believed that any increase in taxation will be dangerous from an inflationary point of view, he would be wrong to increase tax. That does not mean that he is right to assert what is false is true and perpetuate and strengthen the myth. That is an act of irresponsibility. That is my point.

Comment on this

May I intrude? Does the Deputy remember the Supplementary Budget of 1968 and the effect it had on prices?—a 1 per cent rise per month in the new index at 100 in 1968.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy's concept of post hoc ergo proptor hoc is not one that most economists would accept.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

May I come back to the point I made originally, that bringing back the rate to units, complete units, would be a great help? I do not think the Minister has dealt with that.

Comment on this

And if it involved reducing the rate it would scarcely have an inflationary impact. I am afraid the Minister will not accept that.

Comment on this