SECTION 11.
Contributions 175–353 of 353. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
The point I want to stress is that invoices will have to be made out daily, millions and millions of them, and it would be far simpler if on those invoices the tax rates were simply one-tenth or one-twentieth or three-tenths. That would help industry enormously.
Comment on this
Wait now, there are two further points I want to make. The first relates to the loss of revenue caused by reducing the 16.37 to 10 per cent which is something around £10 million. I would be in favour of reducing it to 10 per cent and increasing the luxury tax from 30.26 per cent to 33.33 per cent. I should like to know the increased revenue under that heading. That would be one-third. I understand the Minister's main objection is, first, incidence and secondly, that at some point along the line traders would have to recreate different rates anyway. I suggest to the Minister that a trader may change the price marginally. I suggest he should be allowed in calculating profit margins to add the units five, ten or 33 1/3. That would only marginally affect the incidence of taxation and marginally affect prices and in the bulk of the revenue the marginal effect would not be inflationary.
Comment on this
First, I have not the exact figures at hand as to what would compensate us if we made it 5 per cent instead of 5.26 per cent and 10 per cent—I think the Deputy suggests the latter—instead of 16.37 per cent but I understand there would be a loss to the Revenue of about £13 million. There is another aspect and the Deputy can understand why: the base for the lowest rate is much wider than the base for the highest rate. Another point that must be borne in mind, and that is that when you are dealing with a very high rate any increase could well have the effect—one must always examine that when there is any question of changing the rates of tax—of making non-viable some industries, which are just marginally viable at the moment, and closing them down. Offhand I think that an increase in rates at high levels could very well have the danger of producing that result. I do not think the Deputy has adverted to the point I made previously, that even if you have whole numbers you are producing a problem at the other side, of uneven numbers.
The Deputy may say that the operation of calculating the tax will have to be done far less frequently by the trader than when he is putting it on while selling. That would be a reasonable argument. But let us examine it a little more closely. What is the difficulty involved for the trader in operating, say, a 5.26 rate instead of 5 per cent? As we said earlier, he is already issued with a ready reckoner by the Revenue Commissioners which will enable him to see at a glance what the precise figure is in respect of whatever the charge is for the item. We know from experience that, within a very short time, he or his employees will get to know these by heart and in actual practice the difficulties involved in the uneven rates, which I admit appear on the face of it, to be very great, are not merely as great as they seem to be. Speaking offhand, and recollecting the representations made to me by deputations from various groups who made the point about having a whole figure rather than broken percentages, they did not place very great stress on that. Their stress was much more on other aspects of the tax because they recognised that in practice the difficulties inherent in having these uneven numbers are not nearly as great as might appear at first sight.
Comment on this
When people are rendering invoices for goods they are delivering they calculate the tax on the price at which they are selling the goods, is not that right?
Comment on this
Would it not be the case that from the point of view of the work to be done, far more work has to be done in calculating on the invoices that are submitted than in sending in a single figure on your turnover and that, therefore, it is much more important to have the round figure at the level at which you are calculating tax on invoices than it is to have a round figure on the turnover? I should much prefer the position where I had to do my calculations on the basis of 5 per cent on every invoice and not 5.26 per cent and on my total sales I would then do the one calculation at 5.26 per cent.
Comment on this
I am saying that I do not think any retailer will object if, as the Minister has told us, he has to do a single calculation of his turnover at 5.26 per cent and if he gets all those invoices in batches at different rates which are all worked out for him. I think the retailer would be quite prepared to do the 5.26 calculation on the single figure if all the other figures he is dealing with were at 5 per cent and if all the manufacturers and wholesalers had the benefit of the straight 5 per cent. Am I wrong in that?
Comment on this
No. I think if the Deputy continued his argument the rate returned to the Revenue Commissioners could also be 5 per cent. Why not? Take the manufacturer: he can put 5 per cent on his price to the wholesaler. The wholesaler can put 5 per cent on his selling price, which is one-twentieth and he can calculate the figure to the retailer. The retailer has his figure and he can put 5 per cent on to his selling price. Why not have that system of adding 5 per cent at each stage?
Comment on this
The only argument I can see is that this change was made so that it could be said that it was not a tax on a tax which is what was being suggested here. But it comes to the same thing in the end.
Comment on this
If you are to get 5 per cent and you get an invoice for £169.72, 5 per cent of that is got by simply moving the decimal point and dividing by two.
Comment on this
I do not think the Deputy will convince any of us that 5.26 is any easier to calculate than 5 per cent.
Comment on this
May I point out that, at the moment, in dealing with turnover tax a retailer has to calculate 5.26 per cent on the price that he is charging for the goods in order to recover turnover tax?
Comment on this
But the Deputy is telling me about the extreme difficulty this would mean. Actually, the retailer is doing it at the moment.
Comment on this
I put a point to the Minister as to whether there is not a much great simplification by doing it the other way round. Am I right or wrong?
Comment on this
I dealt with that point earlier when I said it could be argued—in response to Deputy Collins—that it is far easier to have the even or the whole number as the figure to be added on to the cost of the item in the shop because you have far more transactions there.
Comment on this
No. Perhaps we are at cross-purposes. I am saying it could be argued that a retailer who, say, has to price 500 items in his shop—let us assume for simplicity that they are all at the lowest rate—each of those 500 items may have a different price and he has to calculate what is the tax on each item. It could be argued, therefore, that he has to make 500 calculations under the present system at 5.26 per cent whereas 500 calculations at 5 per cent would be simpler. If he only had to calculate 4.718 per cent, or whatever it is, to calculate his tax it would really only be one transaction he had to do at this difficult calculation of 4.718 per cent.
Comment on this
I am no more familiar than the Minister with the actual working of the retail trade but his concept of how retailers work surprises me.
Comment on this
I am simplifying the thing to strengthen the argument but Deputy FitzGerald is not listening to me. I am simplyfying it in order to strengthen the argument which Deputy Collins and Deputy FitzGerald made and take the worst possible view of the situation. That is what I was doing when I answered Deputy Collins and said it could be argued in this way. The fact is, and I went on to explain, that in practice this is not how it works out. It does not present the difficulties it appears to present. I pointed out that at the moment the retailer is obliged to calculate 5.26 per cent.
Comment on this
Let us clear that up now because I think that is wrong. Would the Minister explain where this question of 5.26 per cent has arisen now because I do not think the Minister is correct?
Comment on this
If a shopkeeper, as many of them are, is selling goods under turnover tax on a tax-inclusive basis, in other words, if the price is marked, say, 20p, that is the price you pay. It includes the tax.
Comment on this
Many of them operate on that basis. The question is how do they arrive at that figure of 20p.
Comment on this
I am not interested in how they arrive at it, but when I go in to buy anything, except in the case of certain articles which are on a flat price, the turnover tax of 5 per cent is added.
Comment on this
I am talking about a retailer who sells his goods on a tax-inclusive basis, in other words, who does not add on the tax separately.
Comment on this
There is no good in everybody talking together, and there is no good in people stating it does not exist if the person stating it is actually operating it himself. By all means make a statement but there is no good in a person saying it does not exist when the person who says it exists is operating it as he says he is.
Comment on this
First of all let us consider how you run a business. The element of running a business successfully or otherwise is that you have your material, your labour, your overheads and all other costs even if they include taxation, such as turnover tax and wholesale tax. These all go into your liability. You fix your profit at a fixed margin. That is your selling price whether it is in the factory, the wholesale level or the retail level. That is the simple basic principle you adopt. If you send a traveller out on the road selling goods you tell him exactly the margin you have and you give him a degree of flexibility with good customers, bad customers, or dicy customers or depending on the size of the order. When turnover tax first came in I believed it was a simple 2½ per cent turnover tax, that there was no element of tax on tax. When this 5 per cent came in I believed it was an absolute 5 per cent on sales. Now, I find the 5 per cent is contained in the retail price. The Revenue Commissioners come along and say : " There is the price you sold it at, which includes 5 per cent and we want 5 per cent of the total." This is where your 5.26 per cent arrived in the matter. Even the labour involved has been included somewhere in the retailer's, wholesaler's or somebody's overheads already as a normal overhead charge. You cannot get away from the simple factor that there is an economic level necessary in business. If you get below that you will lose the confidence of the banks and you will be liquidated. If you go too far you lose your customers. I hope that is some help in clearing up this matter.
Comment on this
You go into a supermarket and they always add 5 per cent on to the price. Are you telling me that the Revenue Commissioners insist on collecting the 5 per cent on the price?
Comment on this
Take goods costing £60 and add on 35 per cent profit. On £100 I must pay 5 per cent. Would I be getting 35 per cent profit when the Deputy makes up that figure?
Comment on this
Take goods at £60, add on £35 profit and £5 for the turnover tax. Will that yield you 35 per cent?
Comment on this
That is the point I am making. I said at the moment retailers have to calculate 5.26 per cent on the items they are selling. We are being told that this is an impossible problem but I am saying they are doing it at the moment.
Comment on this
Deputy Gallagher's point is that it does not operate like that at all. People do not fix their prices by the process of the original cost of the goods and adding on different things for overheads and then adding on the tax. Anybody who is in business has his costs for labour and materials. He then has to have a profit margin and it is out of the profit margin that tax has to come. The Minister's concept of this does not bear much relation to the ordinary way in which business operates.
Comment on this
Deputy FitzGerald cannot have it both ways. I tried to put it on a simplified basis to illustrate what is involved. If Deputy FitzGerald is now saying that, of course, they do not do this then he cannot say they have to do it under VAT.
Comment on this
The Minister has missed my point. Under VAT they have to write out an invoice and the invoice has to have the VAT shown on it.
Comment on this
We are talking about the manufacturer, the wholesaler and the retailer. Let us look at the whole process under the VAT.
Comment on this
I must not have made myself clear on that. You start off with the manufacturer. He has to have an invoice. That invoice has to have calculated on it 5.26 per cent of the value of the goods. The wholesaler has to add on his margin. The retailer gets the goods and decides on the gross margin he needs to cover his overheads, depreciation and tax, and how much he can get away with. He has to decide on what will be the loss leader. He does not normally go in for figures like 5.25 per cent. He has to ensure that his total business makes money. He is not involved in that calculation. He is involved every two months in writing down the figures for turnover and calculating the figure on that. The question is whether it is more difficult to do that at 5.26 per cent or 5 per cent. On the Minister's basis of doing it, it means that everybody who has to calculate an invoice has to do a difficult job with a figure of 5.26 per cent, so that the retailer should not have to do a terrible job on one figure. The difficulty arises with all the invoicing, not with the retailer.
Comment on this
The Deputy is talking about manufacturers and wholesalers, and not retailers. If we are talking about manufacturers and wholesalers we are talking about them issuing invoices at 5.26 per cent instead of 5 per cent. I am saying that when you analyse what is involved for them in this, the problem is not enormous at all, especially on the basis of what they are doing at present and the fact that they will be equipped with ready-reckoners. Retailers will not issue invoices but they will be calculating how much they have to add on to recover the amount of the VAT which they are going to have to pay to the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
The Deputy misunderstands the point. Either they do it, in which case you have to accept the argument that they are doing it at the moment, or you accept that they will not do it. Let us stop arguing about the terrible job for retailers.
Comment on this
The wholesalers and manufacturers will be involved in a complex operation on every invoice, and the only gain for that is that once every two months the retailer will be able to use 5 per cent instead of 5.26 per cent.
Comment on this
I am not saying that, because I have my name to one amendment and I am not saying we should omit the retailer.
Comment on this
I want to pursue the amendment down in my name. Deputy Collins has a similar amendment down.
Comment on this
A problem will arise for the retailer. By and large, the articles he sells will be repetitive. He will have to do his calculations at 5.26 per cent. Very few traders have a different supply each morning. They stock the same articles.
Comment on this
At the present time if I go into a supermarket I notice that the prices change from day to day. On occasions I have gone into a supermarket with my wife. She buys goods and pays for them at the checkpoint. I am wondering what is likely to happen with regard to the little girl doing the checking, because with the change of prices up and down—the Minister recommended the charge should be on the prices on the shelves but this has been frowned on at the present time—the little girl at the checkpoint will have to calculate not alone the range of prices, but also the range of taxes.
Comment on this
On that basis dealing with the retailer, what difference is there between what the retailers would have to do in the supermarket under VAT and what they do at the moment?
Comment on this
At the moment most of them have a sign up saying " no tax collected ". I will ask the question whether we are going to see " no VAT collected " on the windows of the supermarkets and, if so, what will be the effect of this being done?
Comment on this
The Deputy has argued about what is going to happen at the checkpoints in the supermarkets. I am asking what difference the Deputy sees between what will happen there under the VAT system and what happens at the moment?
Comment on this
The girl who is checking knows there is only one rate of tax and that is 5 per cent, and so far as she is concerned she puts it on. I have checked myself, and it is 5 per cent. What happens to the 0.26 per cent I do not know, but it is 5 per cent at present.
Comment on this
Presently it is 5 per cent turnover tax. The girl goes down through the list and gets a sub-total. She presses a button and has a sub-total, and she presses another button and gets 5 per cent more on that. Presently the consumers are paying turnover tax. The actual money goes into the till. This is what I was trying to get at in the beginning. The £100 becomes £105. It is on the actual turnover.
Comment on this
The girl is getting a sub-total. With the type of machines they have, she presses a button and gets a sub-total and then presses another button and puts 5 per cent on that.
Comment on this
We receive complaints from time to time. People find that 5.25 per cent is added on and they complain about it. They think they should only pay 5 per cent. It is not always just 5 per cent which is added on. If only 5 per cent is added on, either the shopkeeper suffers a loss of 0.26 per cent or he has covered it earlier in the shelf-price.
Comment on this
But if he adds only 5 per cent in the clearly mathematically perfect set up, the trader's margin has been reduced by that 0.26 per cent.
Comment on this
At present a housewife sees a price and she accepts a shelf price and buys at that price and she pays 5 per cent tax on that price. That is how it operates at present. If the 0.26 per cent has been added on she has accepted that price. Under this system the situation will be that the tax will be added on afterwards. Is that the present suggestion?
Comment on this
This will be very important because then she will be accepting a price and then the machine to give the sub-total will have to be altered and beyond the sub-total it will have to be altered to give 5.26 per cent.
Comment on this
On a rate. This is where the difficulty will come in because it is on one range of tax. Earlier the Minister mentioned Sweden as not having an even number.
Comment on this
One. I am not accusing the Minister exactly of giving untruths but he gave two figures here where we only got half the facts.
Comment on this
I said at the time that I did not believe that either the countries that had odd numbers or the countries that had even numbers were relevant to our problem——
Comment on this
Sorry, may I come in to this extent? We have a range of three taxes and we are uneven. Every other country with three taxes or more are even except France where two of them are even and two are not. Sweden has only one tax which is even.
Comment on this
Yes. No retailer will be dealing with more than two rates unless somebody buys a television set at the same time as he buys a 1b of butter.
Comment on this
The Minister has not indicated how the retailer is going to deal with two rates at the checkout.
Comment on this
There are different ways of dealing with it. One of the methods of dealing with it would be that the goods which are at the high rate of 16.37 per cent would have built into them on the shelf the equivalent, 11.11 per cent, and then there is added on at the checkout point only the 5.26 per cent.
Comment on this
Is there anything to prevent a supermarket which is now advertising goods with no turnover tax from advertising no value-added tax?
Comment on this
I think they can still do that and it will still be as accurate or as inaccurate as it is at the moment.
Comment on this
Coming back to the supermarket operator, keeping his tax separate as he is doing today, say he is selling £100 worth of goods and he makes returns on a weekly basis with the tax built in. The supermarket is selling £100 worth of goods and he is separating the tax from it completely. At the end of every day the tax is separate from the goods. This is a supermarket system. That is the tax due on the goods sold without the built-in 5 per cent. This is how the yield is lower. You get a lower yield from that type of system than you get from the system whereby a man makes up his receipts at the end of a week.
Comment on this
At this stage, and it is not that I do not wish to deal with the point raised by Deputy Fitzpatrick, but I wonder could we stop and think where we are getting in relation to the Bill before us? It seems to me——
Comment on this
No, that is not correct because we have a whole bundle of amendments hanging on this point and the decision on this will affect them.
Comment on this
May I suggest that we seem to be spending a good deal of time in discussing whether or not under the present system of turnover tax, for instance, as Deputy Fitzpatrick suggests, there is a loss in revenue or not? May I suggest that while it is interesting it is irrelevant.
Comment on this
I think it is relevant because it is a strengthening of the argument which the Minister is making that this is necessary to ensure that there is no loss of revenue under VAT.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Fitzpatrick is suggesting something that is not relevant to the point made by Deputy Tully.
Comment on this
May I put it, Mr. Chairman, that there are really two issues which arise out of these amendments and which, perhaps, we have not segregated in any way. One is the issue of the rounding-up of the tax to a round figure which we have been discussing recently and the other is the separate point implicit in the major amendment of the elimination of the 16.37 rate. Perhaps we can segregate the two and discuss them in sequence?
Comment on this
We are jumping a bit from one to the other and it is a bit difficult for the Minister and for us all.
Comment on this
I wish we could and then we could make some progress. If we go on tonight as we are now I think we would start from scratch all over again tomorrow. Perhaps we should keep to No. 7 and round it off once and for all.
Comment on this
Perhaps, Mr. Chairman, we could deal at this stage, in relation to Nos. 8 to 14, only with the question of rounding-off.
Comment on this
That would be a good idea. Could we come back to the point I made and would the Minister concentrate on this for a moment? It appears that as most of the work of calculation of the percentage on goods is on the invoices rather than on the making of a tax return at the end of the two-monthly period, it seems prima facie that the rounded rate would be more useful at the invoicing level rather than at the tax return level. That being so, there seems to be a strong case for the amendment, a case which I did not appreciate until I heard the discussion here tonight. Would the Minister be prepared to think about that between now and the next meeting?
Comment on this
No. I am sorry, but I would not. As I understand it Dr. FitzGerald is suggesting that there would be a rounding-off so as to give a whole number in the case of the tax added on by the manufacturer or the wholesaler.
Comment on this
We could substitute, for example, 5 for 5.26, which would have the effect that they would be adding on the 5 per cent when they invoice and not 5.26 per cent and the manufacturer and, indeed, the wholesaler and retailer in making their tax return would make a return on the basis of 4.7 per cent or something like that.
Comment on this
Could I suggest that Deputy Collins for the moment anyway should leave that argument out of it and concentrate on the other?
Comment on this
I suggest the consideration which must be borne in mind in that proposition is, firstly, what is the effect on the revenue and, secondly, what is the effect on prices? Having regard to the argument which I made earlier and repeated, and which has not been accepted by Deputy FitzGerald but which, I think, has been implicitly accepted by most other Deputies who have spoken and which is that a change in the incidence——
Comment on this
No, not even an increase. A change tends to create a situation in which it is believed that prices go up unnecessarily.
Comment on this
I wonder if the Minister is right in saying that any Deputy here believes that if you reduce taxation it will lead to price increases? That is straining our credulity a bit. I could accept the other proposition that many people believe that if you increase taxation it will push up prices proportionately but surely if we are talking of rounding 5.26 down to 5, whatever that does it cannot give an excuse for increasing prices? It is a very strong case for reducing them.
Comment on this
May I suggest to the Deputy that the likely consequence of reducing from 5.26 to 5 per cent in the context in which we are talking is this : as far as the general public are concerned they will say: " It is 5 per cent at the moment so what difference is it?" Some people like Deputy FitzGerald would explain at great length and with great erudition that in fact it was different. The net effect would be that they would believe there was a change in the rate of tax. I regret to say that our experience is that when there is a change in the rate of tax—admittedly this argument is much stronger if the rate is going up—people, not just shopkeepers but others, in the chain of manufacture and distribution, utilise a change in taxation to coincide with a change in their price in order to get rid of some of the odium which they feel might attach to them because of the change in price and pass on as much of the odium as they can to the Government because of the change in the tax rate. I will admit that the argument is much stronger if the rate is going up than if it is going down. I am suggesting that a marginal decrease which comes to the general public as appearing to be 5 per cent, the same as it was before—though they thought there was a change—has this effect.
Comment on this
The essential thing to bear in mind here is if you are talking about rounding the rates you are talking about a change in the incidence of taxation as it is at present. If you are talking about a reduction in the tax, if the reduction is of any substance, then from the point of view of the Exchequer it has to be made up somewhere. My objective here is to change over to value-added tax with the minimum possible change as far as the incidence of tax on the public is concerned. I have pointed out, as far as the £3½ million we talked about arises in the way we discussed, this is £3½ million spread over sales amounting to about £1,000 million and, as far as the Revenue Commissioners are concerned, is not an increase of £3½ million because it is being given back in another way. While it is arguable that there is a change here it is so marginal overall that it will make virtually no difference. If you get to the area where you are making changes which are far more substantial than this then you are running the risk I talked about in regard to prices. If it is substantial enough it means there has to be some other form of taxation to make up the yield to the Exchequer.
Let me put the other side of the argument? Why is it suggested that we do this? For convenience to the manufacturers and to the wholesalers. Analyse the amount of the convenience that they gain by doing this and you will find that while there is some convenience it is marginal. Certainly if you take any reasonably large-scale wholesaler or manufacturer the methods by which they operate, by which they prepare invoices and so on, are such that the difference for them in doing a calculation of 5.26 per cent as against 5 per cent is really minimal. It is a question of either machines or the ready reckoner. There is practically nothing in it. I am talking about manufacturers.
Comment on this
How do you feel on a small item the .26 will be added to the price because the .26 will be in most cases less than the smallest coin we have got. Does it not follow that the smallest coin will be used if a price is to be put up?
Comment on this
I am talking about the case as put forward by Deputy FitzGerald, which is the manufacturers' and the wholesalers', the people who are getting out these invoices. The number of these who will be affected to more than an absolute minimal extent can only be those who are in a small way of business
Comment on this
Would the Minister explain why that is because even if you are doing it with a calculating machine it takes longer to do 5.26 than to do 5? Why does it only affect the small people? To me 5.26 is always more difficult than 5 no matter who is doing it, how big they are or what machines they have.
Comment on this
It is because you have got to type out three figures. The machine takes longer whizzing and whizzing.
Comment on this
I would have thought that was obvious. The larger firms will be equipped with machinery with one key to do this. It is conceivable that the smaller ones may not be so equipped. Therefore, they have a problem. If they are not so equipped they have got the problem of a clerk or clerks operating on this with a ready reckoner, and operating it in a way which gives them the thing at a glance as against the 5 per cent. Remember what I said earlier that in the Netherlands where they have even whole numbers they still had to issue ready reckoners.
Comment on this
It seems to indicate that the margin of advantage that would be involved for manufacturers and wholesalers in rounding the figures is quite small, so small that I do not believe it could be said to outweigh the disadvantages which I have outlined both as regards possible effects on prices and as regards perhaps having to impose some other form of taxation to make up the loss of yield.
Comment on this
I am afraid it is still far too complicated. This is the kernel of the Bill and if we have to spend a long time on it it is well worth while. I believe the remainder of the sections will go reasonably fast.
Comment on this
I do not want to rush the meeting although naturally I want to get it over as soon as possible. As I see it if we could finish tonight with the rounding-off part of it we would have made progress. We are inclined to spend a lot of time on scoring debating points and I think that is a pity.
Comment on this
The Minister has not really dealt with my objection to it, that is that people are frightened off this type of figure of 5.26 and 16.37.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy appreciate that the argument I have been making has been related to manufacturers and wholesalers?
Comment on this
In that case I am sure he will agree with me that those people are unlikely to be frightened off by 5.26 per cent.
Comment on this
Does the Minister agree that it applies to all retailers who are delivering goods on invoice on a credit basis, of whom there are many thousands in this country? I suspect there must be quite a high proportion of total retailers who operate on credit.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Fitzpatrick is right. He may have to calculate, although Deputy FitzGerald says he does not do it that way, but he has to include it in the price he charges but does not have to show it to the unregistered customer.
Comment on this
I should like to deal with the Minister's point about the number of people who will be fully equipped and have the type of mechanisation that will do these calculations. I admit that whilst they exist they are small in number and, indeed, in proportion to the total turnover of the country I would say that the small fellows nearly equal them in volume. Take a manufacturer with five, six or ten people. He will hardly have an accountant much more qualified than somebody who has done bookkeeping and typing. It is all right for other firms who have the mechanised means and who run their business on a proper organised basis. I know from experience, and I do not want to put the case for the Chamber of Commerce here, that traders all over the country subscribe to the simple method of rounding-off figures rather than a difficult calculation, if it has to be done by a leaving certificate person, maybe a girl who is not very good at mathematics and has not done mathematics or by a bookkeeper who has to do a lot of calculations.
I submit that they know what they are talking about and when they recommend a rounding-off they are doing it in the best interests of the operation of this scheme. The alternative is—and I am afraid to say this because I know the Minister will not particularly like it—that they round these figures off to the nearest even and easy to calculate figure. It would be easier to calculate the figures. This will be done upwards, rather than downwards in its application, I would say.
Comment on this
I have to take a question on the adjournment in the Dáil this evening, and would like to prepare for it.