We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Oliver St. John Gogarty

Follow

Former member, 1922–1936

Service

Seanad

SEANAD ELECTIONS.

Before the business of the Seanad is begun, there is a matter to which I desire to call attention. The matter I want to refer to is Article 30 of the Constitution, which sets forth the qualification of Senators. The Article reads:— "Seanad Eireann shall be composed of citizens…

2 contributions in this debate

Seanad

DELAYED DELIVERY OF DOCUMENTS.

I ask leave to bring up on the adjournment the question of the inaccuracy of a document circulated and which affects us all.

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

MATRIMONIAL MATTERS. - IRISH TRANSLATION.

Certain papers were circulated to us dealing with transactions in the Dáil some days before. It is not necessary to supply them to every Senator but they are legally necessary for the sake of records. In one of those which I got, entitled "Proceedings of Dáil Eireann," I am given…

5 contributions in this debate

Seanad

SHANNON ELECTRICITY BILL, 1925.—FIFTH STAGE.

Very well. We will not go into the distance either in kilometres or miles, but I think he used the argument of comparison of ten kilometres as if that was longer than seven and a half miles. One point no one seems to have urged in this scheme for developing the Shannon, and to my…

6 contributions in this debate

Seanad

SEANAD IN COMMITTEE. - SHANNON ELECTRICITY BILL.

I do not think Senator Sir John Keane will be made any easier if this Bill is taken to-day rather than on Thursday. If he is to be decapitated to-day rather than on Thursday, I do not think we will be doing any wrong to him.

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

LAND BOND BILL, 1925—SECOND STAGE.

When I realise the seriousness of the proposal that has been made by Senator Linehan, I am prepared to say that it is not at all extravagant to denounce it as a monstrous one. The idea is to debase security in order that the tenants who are past masters in causing insecurity…

2 contributions in this debate

Seanad

SEANAD IN COMMITTEE. - SHANNON ELECTRICITY BILL, 1925.—THIRD STAGE.

It would be a pity if the Seanad were under the impression that by rejecting Senator Sir John Griffith's amendment the country would be thereby deprived of any future resources of water-power. As far as I remember, in the Shannon Electricity Bill provision is made under the…

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

FIREARMS BILL, 1925.—REPORT STAGE. - SHANNON ELECTRICITY BILL, 1925.—SECOND STAGE.

Is Senator Sir John Keane entitled to reply, inasmuch as his motion is for the rejection of the Bill?

3 contributions in this debate

Seanad

LOCAL AUTHORITIES (COMBINED PURCHASING) BILL, 1925. - COMMITTEE STAGE.

The proposed amendment, in my view, does not tend to improve the Bill, and in the discussion of these groceries we have got away from the main point which the Minister made. As I understand it, the amendment would take away from the Minister that power of fostering discrimination…

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

THE SHANNON SCHEME.

I am sorry that I cannot agree with Senator Sir Thomas Esmonde when he says that the Seanad knows nothing about this proposal. I have taken a great deal of pains and spent a great deal of time in reading up this matter, and I think, out of fairness to the Seanad and to Senator…

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

PRESENTATION OF PETITIONS—QUESTION OF PROCEDURE.

If we accept this petition, what is to prevent the Seanad receiving petitions from all over the country? If this is now accepted, it is quite possible that from different parts of Ireland we may be receiving complaints in regard to roads that are out of order, or some little…

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

COUNTY BOARDS OF HEALTH ACCOUNTS ORDER, 1924. - THE SHANNON SCHEME—MOTION BY SIR JOHN GRIFFITH.

There have been many criticisms of this scheme, both legitimate and in an underhand manner. The underhand manner consists of sending articles to members of this House while this matter is more or less sub judice. None of the critics criticised the experts. They reserved all their…

2 contributions in this debate

Seanad

LOCAL GOVERNMENT BILL, 1924. - MESSAGE FROM THE DÁIL.

It might be instructive if the Minister would tell the Seanad how much money is involved in the proposed pension. Surely we are not expected to have an Act of Parliament for one or two individuals. If the Seanad could be told that the man resigned before 1922, if his service was…

2 contributions in this debate

Seanad

PUBLIC BUSINESS. - MESSAGE FROM THE DAIL.—PRIVATE BILLS RELATING TO MATRIMONIAL MATTERS.

Is the position this, that this House has no right to divest itself of its duties to consider every Private Bill irrespective of its nature and contents, and we have no method, whether we wish or not, to shirk that responsibility?

2 contributions in this debate

Seanad

LOCAL GOVERNMENT BILL, 1924.—REPORT STAGE RESUMED.

I think the Minister told us that the sum of one million was spent over and above the amount given by the Road Fund, so that the amount spent would be near one-and-a-half millions. The Road Fund is only £300,000. On the Committee Stage of this Bill I spoke on this subject and…

2 contributions in this debate

Seanad

PRIVATE BUSINESS. - LOCAL GOVERNMENT BILL, 1924.—REPORT STAGE.

It might enlighten the House to know what really happens at present when the coroner is called into action. The naturalness or not of the death is at his discretion, because a doctor can certify anything he wishes if he were so minded, about a patient's demise. The coroner can…

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

PRIVATE BUSINESS. - DUBLIN UNITED TRAMWAYS (OMNIBUS SERVICES BILL), 1924. REPORT STAGE.

In view of the fact that the Committee only reported one or two days ago I think this procedure of accepting amendments is highly irregular. It might be said by the Tramways Company if this amendment was made compulsory that they have suffered a loss. I move that we ignore the…

3 contributions in this debate

Seanad

PRIVATE BILL PROCEDURE. - MEDICAL BILL, 1924—COMMITTEE STAGE.

It is perfectly evident that the sooner the position of the medical profession in Ireland is defined and legalised the better. This is only a temporary Bill; there are circumstances that make that form of it necessarily so. There are also circumstances that make it unnecessary…

1 contribution in this debate

Seanad

SEANAD IN COMMITTEE. - LOCAL GOVERNMENT BILL, 1924. THIRD STAGE (RESUMED).

It is not so much the imposition of the oath that counts as the putting an end to the position of the hero who wants to have it both ways and the effect the taking of the oath will have on his heroics in various parts of the country. There are, to my own knowledge, one or two men…

4 contributions in this debate

Seanad

SEANAD IN COMMITTEE. - LOCAL GOVERNMENT BILL, 1924. THIRD STAGE (RESUMED).

Is there any way of doing this without making an amendment, because it seems to be an isolated and exceptional case, and a case which, if the amendment were passed, would be based on an understanding that it was to be merely retrospective? I think that the case is a worthy one…

2 contributions in this debate

Seanad

ELECTION OF SENATOR.

Would it be in order for me to offer a personal explanation? Sir Simon Maddock asked me to withdraw his name in order that Dr. Douglas Hyde would be unanimously elected. I wish to say that now, as the election does not appear to take the form of a unanimous election, even though…

1 contribution in this debate