We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

SEANAD IN COMMITTEE. - LOCAL GOVERNMENT BILL, 1924. THIRD STAGE (RESUMED).

Contributions 1–145 of 280. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Local Government Bill 1924
Withdrawn

No. 18 of 1924 ›

I beg to move:—

Section 46. To add a sub-section as follows:—

(2) No allowance granted under this part of the Act shall be capable of being taken in execution or otherwise alienated by process of law for the payment of any debts or liabilities of the person to whom such allowance was granted.

The section was substantially the same when the Bill was introduced in the Dáil as it will be if this amendment is inserted. For some reason which it is not quite clear, this portion of the section was removed. Personally I think it is very much better that this provision, which I think was inserted in most of the previous Bills of the kind, should be retained. I think it is a mistake that, particularly in the case of the older pensioners, it should be possible to tempt them to enter into debt, and of speedily spending their pensions before a particular instalment is paid. I think a provision of this kind by which instalments due cannot be taken for a debt— which means in effect that they cannot get credit in advance of their pensions —is a very wise provision and I hope it will be agreed to.

Comment on this

This provision was put into the Bill originally. I had not, however, any hard and fast views on the matter and I left it to a free vote of the Dáil. I am in the same position in the Seanad. I do not know how it will go afterwards. Probably the Dáil will uphold their decision. I am just in the same position as I was in the other House.

Comment on this

I oppose this amendment. I think it places pensioners under this Bill in a very privileged position as compared with other people. Not only are they in the enjoyment of a very good salary during their term of office, but when their period of service expires they are provided with a very handsome pension at the expense of the ratepayers. Then, you add to that the further privilege of not being liable to pay their debts with these pensions. That is a privilege, I think, that should not be accorded to them. It is one that the ratepayers would not consent to. Not only do I oppose this amendment, but I also oppose the section in the Bill which provides that their pensions cannot be taken for debt.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Are you speaking of Section 46?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You have no amendment to it.

Comment on this

Not at present.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

If you have not at present, there will be no future for you.

Comment on this

I oppose the present amendment, and I hope to have a further amendment on the Report Stage.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I have already stated that is not the object of the Report Stage at all. The object of the Report Stage is to give a further opportunity of considering matters that have been already dealt with on the Committee Stage. In some assemblies they will not allow a new matter to be sprung on the Report Stage, for the obvious reason that the time has passed for giving it full discussion, and the only exception I have made to that is in cases in which, with the consent of the House, an important question is raised and not fully debated and is allowed to stand over for the purpose of seeing what attitude the Ministry or Senators will take on the Report Stage. If you intended to oppose Section 46, you should have put down an amendment for the purpose.

Comment on this

I understood that each section was to be put to the House and that I was at liberty to oppose the passing of the section when it would be put to the House.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

No, not on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

At the present time?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

At the present time, yes. Even on the Committee Stage, if you intend to move the deletion of a section, in all fairness you should put down an appropriate amendment to that effect. It would be simply that the section should be deleted. Then the Ministers and Senators would be prepared for it. I think they should get notice. It would be very irregular that in an important Bill of this kind, any Senator could get up and oppose the passing of a particular section without notice of any kind. It is an objectionable practice I think in the interests of the House itself. However, you are now speaking on the amendment and you may deal with it.

Comment on this
Earl of Mayo The EARL OF MAYO Independent

I did not quite follow what the Minister said took place in the Dáil.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The Minister said that it had been left to a free vote in the Dáil, that he himself and the Government had an open mind on it and that they preferred to leave it to a free vote and that he was taking up the same attitude here.

Comment on this

I think the amendment restores the section as it stood when originally introduced in the Dáil. It was quite true that objection was taken in the Dáil that the Minister left it to a free vote of the House. I do not believe myself in Senator Linehan's description of the amendment—that it adds a new privilege to pensioners. It does not mean that they shall not continue to pay their debts. It means, as I understand it, that the pension cannot be pledged in advance. It does not mean that once a payment is made you cannot take action against these people to compel them to pay their proper debts.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

To this extent Senator Linehan is right, that if a creditor got a judgment against a pensioner he could not take the pension in satisfaction of that judgment.

Comment on this

I was going to point out that the object was to secure for the pensioner the enjoyment of his pension which, presumably, in most of these cases is not very large and which is necessary to enable him to live. The position, unless I am incorrectly informed, is that under previous Acts a provision of this kind has been inserted, and that so far as most pensioners are concerned they are governed by a section of this kind. I think that it is also in the interests of the trader. You have to consider their position as to what extent they should give credit. And it would be much better to have uniformity in regard to all pensioners. With that object I propose this amendment.

Amendment put and declared carried on a show of hands by 14 votes to 12.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

Section 47, page 23, lines 51-52. To delete the words "any of its employees, other than officers," and to insert in lieu thereof the following words: "to any person in its employment who is not a pensionable officer within the meaning of this part of this Act."

I am afraid this amendment will not have much effect, judging by the fate of my previous amendment on the same subject. At the same time I think it is not desirous that we should have that unjust distinction between officers. I am not sure although my previous amendment was defeated that the word "officer" does not cover employees.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

If that is so it might be better to leave well alone.

Comment on this

I do not think it makes a very material change. I would be prepared to accept it as it stands, but I leave it to the Seanad. It makes practically no difference in the section.

Comment on this

After hearing what the Minister has said, I think it is desirable that it should go in.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You see, Senator, what you want to insert is already there: "any of its employees." You could not have wider terms than that.

Comment on this

I want to substitute "any person in its employment who is not a pensionable officer." I hold they are officers.

Comment on this

I beg to move:

"Section 16 of the Asylum Officers' Superannuation Act, 1909, shall be amended by the substitution of three years for ten years as the period to be taken into account for calculating the average salary and emoluments of an established officer for the purposes of that Act."

I do not think I require to say much in moving this amendment. I think three years as an average is a more equitable arrangement than ten years. If you take ten years you are going over a very erratic period. As things are to-day they are more or less stabilised. Consequently it is my opinion that the period of three years would be much better for all concerned.

Comment on this

I am opposed to this amendment which is somewhat similar to an amendment we had in the Dáil. Officers of asylums are on a different footing altogether from other officers of local authorities and have a superannuation code of their own, based on a contributory basis. The basis of the calculation of their pensions is over three years, whereas the basis for the ordinary officer of a local authority is calculated over ten years. There are also other differences in the positions of officers of lunatic asylums and officers of other local authorities. Certain officers of lunatic asylums automatically become pensionable when they arrive at the age of fifty-five, and the basis of calculation of their pensions is so many fiftieths of their salaries and emoluments, whereas the basis of calculation of the ordinary officers of local authorities is so many sixtieths. The whole thing hangs together; it has been worked out on mathematical lines, and if we are to vary one part of the system we will have to vary the whole system.

It would be a very invidious thing at present to change the basis of calculation from ten years to three years. During the last few years the wages of officers of lunatic asylums have gone up beyond all bounds, in some cases over 100 per cent., and naturally any officer retiring now would, under this amendment, get a much higher pension than if the pension was calculated on a ten years' basis. Perhaps in ten years' time after wages come down to normal a retiring officer will be in a much worse position. This amendment would put the officers at present going out in a very much better position than those who had gone out previously. It is also, of course, inequitable from the point of view of the rates. As I have mentioned before, a Commission is about to inquire into this whole matter of lunatic asylums and poor relief, and I am not prepared to reconsider the code dealing with asylums until this Commission has brought in its report. For these reasons I am opposed to the amendment.

Comment on this

I move to delete the word "ten" and substitute therefor the word "five." Section 49 provides that officers of committees of county infirmaries and county fever hospitals whose posts are abolished may receive compensation by way of an allowance after ten years' service. The amendment seeks to provide that any employee whose post is abolished and who has had five years' continuous service shall receive some allowance by way of compensation. I am merely following the precedent set in the Railways Act, 1924, an Act passed through the Oireachtas as a Government measure. It was very distinctly laid down in the first instance at the instigation of the Government that anybody losing his post who had five years' continuous service was to get some compensation.

If it was right to make a proposal of that kind where private employers were concerned, surely the responsibility of the public to its employees is none the less serious than that of a private employer to his employees. What is right in one cannot be wrong in the other. One can easily visualise the position of employees, such as those people who would come under the amendment, who have got into a particular groove, who have had a specialised form of training and whose training is of no use to them in the outer world. Is it fair after they have given, we will say, five years' service of that kind, service of an exceedingly important character, that from a humane point of view they should be turned adrift at this particular time when unemployment is rife in all industries, and that they should not be given compensation? They may have nine, or nine and a half years' service, and still they are debarred. This is not a case of giving a pension for services rendered; it is merely to give some compensation for taking away the person's employment, for no fault of his own, but because a Bill has been introduced to improve public administration. I suggest that that is elementary justice to people whose positions are abolished, that after they have spent at least five years studying and practising at their callings they must have qualified themselves specially for their employment, and it is not just or equitable to say: "You have got to lose that employment in the public interest; we offer you nothing else; we cannot hold out any guarantee to you that you can get employment elsewhere, because the duties you have been performing are of no use to you in the commercial world, but we will not give you any compensation for the loss of your office. Your sacrifice must be made at our dictates in the interests of the public." If that is the principle underlying this Bill certainly it is not a just or equitable principle, and it is one which the Government themselves said would not be just or equitable to apply to the railways. Under the Railways Act people with less than five years' service are entitled to two months' salary for each year in a lump sum, and if they have five years' service they are entitled to compensation by way of a pension. If it was right in the case of the railways I assert that it is right in this case, and that it is the least we owe to these people whose employment we are filching from them, not because of any fault of theirs.

Comment on this

Are such employees who have less than ten years' service not entitled to compensation when the office is abolished?

Comment on this

No, they are not. I would like the Seanad to understand that these officers at present are not entitled to any pension or gratuity of any kind. If one of these officers was dismissed heretofore, even after fifteen years' service, be could get no pension. Under this Bill we are giving pensionable rights to officers who have had ten years' service. We are not granting that concession to officers with less than ten years' service, because if we did we would open the door to gratuities. You cannot pay a pension to an officer with less than ten years' service, and you would have to pay him a gratuity. A very heavy burden has already been placed on local authorities as a result of these gratuities, and I do not think that there is any great hardship on these officers if they have been in office for less than ten years. It is not the same as if they had devoted their whole time to the work for fifteen or twenty years and were not in a position to take up any other employment. Any man who has devoted only ten years to a certain employment should be quite well able to take up another position.

Comment on this

I do not think that the position as regards employees of local bodies and those of the railway company is on all fours. It might in the case of a certain number of railway employees who had prepared specifically for such employment, clerks who had to undergo an examination and a period of training, and so on. These considerations, I think, would put them in a rather favoured position as compared with the position of employees of local authorities. But apart from that, the Railways Act was a great experiment, and it was essential, I take it, that the good-will of everybody concerned should be secured. There surely must be a limit as to the period for which a man would be justified in getting compensation. I think the ten years prescribed by the Government is thoroughly reasonable, and that the amendment should not be accepted. I do not believe that it is on all fours with the precedent of the Railways Act, and I think the position of any servant of a local authority will not be injured by leaving the Bill as it came from the Dáil.

Comment on this

The position of these people is absolutely on all fours with nineteen-twentieths of the railway employees. With the exception of the clerical and supervisory grades no railwayman is entitled to any pension whatever, and can have his services terminated at any time with a fortnight's or a month's notice, as the case might be. Such men only retain their positions permanently during good conduct on the strength of their industrial power. That may have something to say to the fact that the Government adopted a different policy in the case of the railways from what they do in the case of these people whom they realise have no industrial power. If they had treated the railway employees unfairly they might not have had any railways working, and I think it is a very bad principle to embark on the policy, that simply because people are not able to hit back, or to defend themselves by powers other than Parliamentary, you must sacrifice them in the public interest, as you call it. When a man in this employment has eight years' service he must be fairly well advanced in years from the point of view of getting employment, and the fact that he has been an officer under a local body is certainly no recommendation for him to get employment in the industrial or commercial world. It would be rather against him. I suggest that it is absolutely cruel to take away the employment of these people, tell them that you will not give them any compensation, but simply close your eyes and ears to any sufferings you inflict on them, and say: "No matter what becomes of the children of this man with nine and a half years' service, it is only in the interests of the public and the ratepayers that he should get no compensation." If that is the spirit underlying the Bill I certainly am not prepared to associate myself with it.

Comment on this

It is suggested that a boy of twenty years who goes into the employment of a public body and leaves after five years should get a gratuity. That seems to me to be very unreasonable. Such a young man would be in the prime of life. He has been serving a certain kind of apprenticeship and is fully capable of going out into the world and earning his living at something else, just as if he had been employed in a shop. Pensions are for people who are worn out, not for young men of twenty-five, who are just qualifying themselves for their work in life.

Comment on this

I move:—

Before Section 51 to insert a new section as follows:—

"51.—(1) A county council may, if they think fit, by resolution passed at any annual meeting, direct and prescribe that the Chairman of the Council and his successors in office shall be styled and known as county mayor.

(2) At the first meeting of a county council after the triennial election of members of the council, the council may, if they think fit or, in the case of this power having already been exercised, shall, elect one-fourth (neglecting any fraction when the whole number is not divisible by four) of the whole number of members of the council to the style and dignity of county aldermen, each member voting for a number of members (other than himself) equal to the number to be elected and the persons receiving the highest numbers of votes (subject to the drawing of lots in the case of ties) to be deemed elected.

(3) No proceeding in any court, act in the law, public document, or other matter or thing, shall be invalidated, questioned, or otherwise impaired or affected, by reason only of the description of any person as councillor or chairman, instead of an alderman or mayor, in pursuance of the powers given by this section."

By this amendment I propose that a county council should have the power, if it so desires, to style its chairman county mayor, and also that a fourth of the members of the county council should be called county aldermen. I think that "chairman of the county council" is a rather unwieldy term, and that "county mayor" would be much easier. Apart from that, much more dignity is attached to the word "mayor" than to "chairman." The chairman of a county council is a representative of a large area, and I think the county council, if it wished, ought to be entitled to call its chairman the county mayor. It would mean no expense to the ratepayers, and I am sure many Senators will be glad to hear that. If that is right, I think the other thing follows, that you should have county aldermen. If the amendment is accepted, I think it will be availed of fairly fully.

Comment on this

I am afraid that some confusion might arise in a county that has a borough within it, and also has a mayor. If you had two mayors in one county it might lead to a great deal of confusion. The Senator might be prepared to omit the few counties where there is a corporation. I should certainly support anything that would add dignity to the chairman of the county council and the county council itself. They have done a lot of honorary work since 1899, and if the Senator can hit on another term which will make them even more revered I will agree.

Comment on this

I also represent a county in which there is a borough and a mayor, but I do not see any possibility of confusion, because one is the mayor and the other would be simply the county mayor.

Comment on this

I would suggest to the Senator to withdraw his amendment and to think over it for the Report Stage. I think it a pity at this hour of the day to stabilise titles that are not Irish. Surely if the Senator wants to give these gentlemen titles of a dignified kind, he can easily find Irish titles.

Comment on this

I do not know exactly how this amendment was inspired or whether it was a brain wave from Senator De Loughry. I speak as chairman of a county council and I think it would strengthen the Senator's position if he had submitted this idea to the General Council. I think it would be turned down. I can visualise a number of chairmen of county councils, and I have in mind a number of mayors and as a matter of personality I would put a county council chairman before a mayor in intelligence, dignity, and everything else. I am not disposed to vote in favour of this amendment.

Comment on this

Surely for the sake of the masons that would be required and the Irish silversmiths, the amendment is worth consideration. If the title mayor would not do as it has been associated with urban usage, I suppose "bailie" would do.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Or bailiff.

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 51, sub-section (2). After sub-section (2) to add a new sub-section (3) as follows:—

"(3) The power of a county council to co-opt additional members after a triennial election shall cease after the passing of this Act."

By the 1908 Local Government Act the county councils were empowered, after each triennial election, to co-opt two additional members. I propose that that section be repealed and that that power cease after the passing of this Bill. I think it is desirable that every member of a county council should be elected from the ratepayers, should be in full touch with them, and should know what his responsibilities are. If it is necessary to increase the number of members of a county council, it can be done by adding two members to the number of members elected, and in that way we will get over any difficulty of the number of county councillors being too small for the work they have to do. I observe in sub-section (2), clause 51, that the number of members to be elected to the county council shall be increased by a number equal to twice the number of rural districts in existence in such county on the appointed day. That will more than double the elected members of the county council. If it is necessary to have any new members, I suggest they be added for election purposes and that the system of co-option be done away with. From my experience of co-option, I have found that not the most suitable men were co-opted but rather the most active canvassers. When they got into the council they were the most extravagant in spending the rates.

Comment on this

I support this amendment. I know a case where a man was rejected by the electorate. He had friends on the council, and immediately the election was over he was co-opted and good men rejected. I do not think that ought to be allowed under this Bill if it can be prevented.

Comment on this

I should think that the object of giving power to county councils to co-opt members was so that they might redress any inequalities in representation throughout their area. There are also men of considerable experience who, sometimes, owing to the activities of their opponents at an election, are not elected. Men who gave good service in the county council, because they were not of a particular way of thinking, failed at the elections. You cannot argue by individual cases that the thing is going to be wrong. That does not justify the undermining of the general principle. The principle, I think, was all right, in giving a county this margin that they might secure to themselves men of any special knowledge in any branch of local government or redress some inequality in some part of the area. The principle is sound and should be maintained.

Comment on this

Many a good man and woman could not hope to get into a county council by election, and I think it is giving the county council but a small power to allow them to co-opt two people.

Comment on this

I would be prepared to accept the principle of this amendment, but it is not necessary, because the Senator has amendment 145 down, which does the same thing in a neater form.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The amendment, Senator Linehan, will not carry out your purpose, because it makes no provision for filling up casual vacancies at all.

Comment on this

I do not see that. This section is confined to additional members co-opted after the triennial elections.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

"The power of a county council to co-opt additional members after a triennial election shall cease after the passing of this Act." If you were to say the power conferred by section so and so, sub-section so and so, shall cease, it would be all right, but if you put it in the general way it is in this amendment you make no provision for casual vacancies, nor do I know what the provision is. There must be some provision dealing with casual vacancies on a county council. If your amendment were passed in its present form it would wipe away any such provision without putting anything in its place.

Comment on this

I suggest that amendment 105 should be withdrawn.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The whole thing can be considered when we come to it in the schedule.

Comment on this

Otherwise it would put a tremendous burden on the ratepayers in holding elections for vacancies. We all agree that when casual vacancies occur, the council should have power to co-opt new members.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Yes. They are two quite different things.

Comment on this

I move amendment 106:—

Section 51. To add a new sub-section as follows:—

"(3) No person shall be eligible to be nominated for election to a county council who is not a resident and ratepayer in the county electoral area for which he seeks nomination."

This is a General Council amendment. The chairman of each district council was an ex-officio member of the county council. The R.D.C.'s are done away with, and he no longer exists on the county council. At present, the qualification is to be on the register of the county. In County Waterford there are five electoral divisions. To each is allotted a certain number of vacancies on the county council. At present any man on the register for any part of the whole place can be elected for any division. He need not live even in that area. The aim of this amendment is that, as far as it can secure it, the candidate going up for any particular area shall be at least familiar with his area.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I do not think that this amendment would answer its purpose in the present form, because it would automatically exclude women.

Comment on this

Man embraces woman.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

A woman may not be herself a ratepayer, and there may be every reason why she should be a member of the local authority. A woman may be the wife of a ratepayer, or her family may be ratepayers, and the amendment, in its present form, would do such a lady an injustice.

Comment on this

I am in favour of this amendment in so far as it says that a person, to be eligible for election, shall be resident in the county. But I object to a Senator coming along at this time of day with the proposal that a person, to be eligible for election, shall be a ratepayer. There are very efficient people in this country who have rendered good service on the county councils and who are not ratepayers. It is not every man who is endowed with sufficient of the world's wealth to entitle him to be described as a ratepayer. I am surprised at Senator Kenny bringing forward such an amendment. The amendment would debar the majority of people from seeking election on the county councils. I leave it to the good sense of the Seanad to say whether they are going back to the old system, that nobody except a lord of the manor or someone of that type is eligible to sit on a public board.

Comment on this

I would like to know how this amendment would affect people in Dublin, who do not pay their own rates although they are householders. The landlord is responsible for the rates, and some of these people are as good citizens as can be found. They are really ratepayers, inasmuch as they pay their rates through the rent, but the landlord is made responsible for the rates. The rates are paid in his name. To debar all these people from seeking election for membership of the county council, or other public board, would be a grave injustice, apart from the reactionary and undemocratic character of the amendment, which excludes women who are not ratepayers, although they may be the wives of ratepayers. It would be a step back into the Middle Ages if the Seanad were to adopt such an amendment as this.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You are not quite accurate in your statement, Senator, because I had occasion to consider this matter under the Local Government Act of 1898. The occupier has been held to be responsible for rates in every case, and any contract by which he seeks to get rid of that and to include it in his rent has been held— a decision ultimately affirmed in the House of Lords—to be illegal.

Comment on this

Are we to take it, then, from your statement, A Chathaoirligh, that every person in Ireland is a ratepayer?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

No. Senator Farren has told us that the vast majority are not.

Comment on this

Senator Farren would not set himself up as an authority on a legal matter as against you, A Chathaoirligh.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I will not venture an opinion on the question you put. All I say is that, as I understand the law, the rates have to be paid by the occupier.

Comment on this

According to that interpretation of the law every working man and woman in Ireland are ratepayers?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think there is a limitation in the case of holdings of a certain valuation. I am stating the position generally. The law goes very far, because the case decided was a case in which the landlord had actually agreed by his lease that he would pay the rates in consideration of the tenant paying him a certain fixed rent. It was held that that was illegal, as the Act of Parliament stated that the rates were to be paid by the occupier.

Comment on this

I wanted to have from you, A Chathaoirligh, a definition of the word "ratepayer," because I am absolutely bored listening to people in this House talking about ratepayers during the debate on this Bill. Senators spoke as if ratepayers were a section of the people that could be easily segregated and tabulated, and that the others—the majority of the people—were not ratepayers at all. I would like to have a statement from such an authority as you, A Chathaoirligh, as to whether or not all workers are ratepayers.

Comment on this

I will put a concrete case. There is a member of the Seanad who is chairman of a town commission. He is not a ratepayer, and he is not a householder. He stays in the house of his brother. I refer to Senator Cummins, who is Chairman of the Newbridge Town Commissioners. He is not a ratepayer.

Comment on this

He is a ratepayer.

Comment on this

He is not. He stays in the house of his brother, and his brother is the ratepayer. Under this he is disfranchised. He is not entitled to seek re-election to the town commissioners or to the county council. We would be all in agreement with the amendment if the word "ratepayer" were omitted.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

There is another obvious difficulty about the amendment. A man might be a ratepayer and resident in the area on the day of his election, and he might cease to have these qualifications the next day. If Senator Kenny's amendment is intended to be effective, surely it should apply during the time the person in question purports to act as a member of the council. In other words, no person should be eligible for election or should be eligible to act as a member, if he was not resident and a ratepayer. The Senator's amendment does not cover that case at all.

Comment on this

I do not wish to exclude any man——

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Your amendment, on the face of it, would not prevent a man who was a ratepayer and a resident seeking election and remaining on the council, although he might cease to be a ratepayer and cease to be resident within 24 hours of his election.

Comment on this

The amendment could be amended to that extent, and I would agree with it.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I do not suggest that you should amend it. You may have intended that it should be as it is.

Comment on this

In Ireland, when the Local Government Act came into operation, the previous position was changed and the whole onus was thrown on the occupier. It was open to the occupier to get his rent adjusted accordingly. He could get a certain portion of his rent deducted on account of the payment of the rate. Some occupiers did that and some did not. Every occupier is now a ratepayer or should be a ratepayer. I hold with the amendment, that a candidate should be both resident and a ratepayer in the particular area in which he seeks election. It is the least we may expect that a member of a body which has to do with the levying, collection and expenditure of rates should have some personal interest, as well as representative interest, in the matter. If he is not a ratepayer, he can advocate the most radical departures at the county council and they will have no effect on him personally. I think it is radically wrong that a man without any stake or vested interest in the county should go forward for such an important position. Schemes which would have an effect on the pocket of the ratepayers might be proposed by him, while he would himself remain absolutely unaffected. I hold with the amendment as it stands.

Comment on this

Might I ask how the amendment would affect me? I have been a member of these bodies for a long time. I am a resident but not a ratepayer, though I am the wife of a ratepayer. If I were to go forward for the county council, would I be disqualified?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think the Senator's amendment would not embrace you.

Comment on this

I would like to support the amendment. I think it is very important, especially the provision that a person seeking election should reside in the particular area. There has been a certain amount of ill-feeling in county councils, owing to the contention that persons from one part of the county put undue expenditure on another part. It is only right that a person seeking election should come from the area in which he seeks election. Senator Foran wanted a definition of the word "ratepayer." On a certain occasion a number of aldermen and councillors went to a certain mayor and told him that the ratepayers were becoming indignant at the cost he was putting upon the constituency by litigation and otherwise. He listened very carefully, and then he said: "As regards the ratepayers, I would advise you gentlemen to go home and look up Walker's Dictionary. You will see that ‘ratepayer' is defined as ‘a person who pays rates.' The more rates he pays, the more he is fulfilling his function in life." I think that would apply to a good many of the arguments here.

Comment on this
Joseph Clayton Love Mr. CLAYTON LOVE

Under the Franchise Bill, we heard of cases of tenants who paid rent which was an inclusive rent, but the landlord failed to carry out his duty as regards the payment of rates, and these people, ipso facto, lost their votes. Would people living in tenement houses and paying rates by way of rent be disqualified under this Bill if the landlord failed to pay the rates?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I cannot assume the function of an encyclopaedia, and I cannot answer that question. I would suggest to Senator Kenny that his amendment is very narrow. Would he not be satisfied if the person were a resident and a ratepayer in the county? It seems curious to exclude a man who would be resident in the area but who might be a ratepayer outside the area.

Comment on this

Would not the substitution of the word "or" for "and" meet the case?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Take the case of a woman. This amendment would exclude her if she were not a ratepayer, whereas if you adopted Senator Douglas' suggestion she would be qualified by residence.

Comment on this

I am satisfied to accept that for the particular area, but not for the county.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That would meet the case Senator Farren put up.

Comment on this

I am afraid that particular drafting would not meet the case of a business man who lives in the city and who is resident outside the city— perhaps in a different county.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That is the reason why I suggested that the question of ratepayers should refer to the county.

Comment on this

He might be resident, say, in the County of Kilkenny and have his business in the City of Waterford. He would be a large ratepayer in the City of Waterford. You would rule him out, and give him no rights at all under this section.

Comment on this

Would not that be covered by the substitution of "or" for "and"?

Comment on this

"Resident in the county or ratepayer in the county electoral area"—is that your suggestion?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The suggestion is that it should read this way:

"No person shall be eligible to be nominated for election to a county council who is not a resident or ratepayer in the county electoral area for which he seeks nomination."

That does not cover the point—I do not know whether you wish to cover it or not—that he might cease to have his qualification the day after he was elected.

Comment on this

That could be raised by any citizen or resident in the county. A public informer could raise that.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

It could not be raised at all except there is a statutory provision enabling it to be raised. If the amendment was passed in its present form any resident or ratepayer might cease to have that qualification the next day and still retain his seat.

Comment on this

I am quite prepared to add the words you suggest.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Then it will read:—

"No person shall be eligible to be nominated for election to a county council or to serve as a member of such body who is not a resident or ratepayer in the county electoral area for which he seeks nomination."

Comment on this

Would not that inflict a great hardship on a farmer or labourer who migrated during the course of the year? He would be disqualified the moment he left the county. I do not think that is reasonable. It is very hard that a man should not be allowed to better himself by changing his farm or employment. The law as it stood inflicted no hardship. I never heard it suggested that because a man was not a resident he was not competent for the position. There were men in many councils who were not resident in a particular area and who represented the whole county satisfactorily. I think the law as it stood protected everyone. Everyone in a county who was a householder was entitled to be elected, and I think it worked well. I do not think the change proposed will work better.

Comment on this

There are several rural district councils in the County Waterford, and under the old system each chairman of a rural district council was ex-officio a member of the county council. These men resided in these areas and were ratepayers. Now all that is swept away, and I am trying to secure that there shall be some uniform representation in place of that. The amendment was hurriedly drawn up but, in its amended form, it will effect the object I had in view.

Comment on this

There was, I think, a provision in the Local Government Act under which a member of a local council who ceased to be a burgess automatically became disqualified. I know that in Dublin some years ago one or two members of the Corporation were removed from the burgess roll and ceased automatically to be members.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That might be under the Corporation's special Act. I do not recollect that there was any provision of that kind.

Comment on this

It may have applied specially to the Dublin Corporation.

Comment on this

Senator Kenny very properly suggested that a district should have somebody responsible for the expenditure of money in that district. Under the present Bill I think that is not so essential. Under the previous Act the expenditure on district roads was paid by the district. All the roads now are to be a county charge and, as the road expenditure is the main expenditure in a county, I think the business can be conducted as well by members of a county council, no matter what district they come from.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir J. KEANE Independent

I do not think you can deal with this satisfactorily and justly in the terms of administrative areas because, as mentioned by the Minister, the County Kilkenny goes down to the north bank of the River Suir, and residents on the north bank in the administrative area of Kilkenny are bound up with the city of Waterford. They are outside the boundary, but they use the city of Waterford for their markets and other business. You debar them entirely from representation on the council of the county where they do all their business. I have no doubt there are other cases like that near Dublin. It would not be equitable to exclude residents outside the boundaries from representation on the council. I think it would be much better to allow natural causes to operate and leave the thing as it was.

Comment on this
The EARL of MAYO

I understand that the mover of the amendment has accepted the word "or" and also fallen in with your suggestion, sir, to cover the case of a man who might be elected on a council and, the day after, not be a resident or ratepayer. Therefore, I think that we might either vote on the amendment or agree to it as altered.

Comment on this

I wonder could we get agreement to substitute "local government elector" instead of "resident" so that the amendment would read:—

"No person shall be eligible to be nominated for election to a county council or to serve as a member of such body who is not a local government elector or a ratepayer...."

If we could have "local government elector" instead of "resident," it would be much better for administrative purposes. It might lead to great difficulties if the word "resident" were left in.

Comment on this

A ratepayer in the county electoral area might not live in the area at all. It might be like the old pocket boroughs long ago—he might be living in Timbuctoo.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That is so under the amendment which you have accepted as altered. You have accepted the alteration to change "and" into "or." Therefore, this gentleman living in Timbuctoo, if he were a ratepayer, would be eligible under your own amendment.

Comment on this

I will not recognise my amendment soon. If the amendment is agreed to, I am satisfied.

Comment on this

I think it would be well to abandon the amendment because the electors are the best judges. If they want a man from Timbuctoo, I think they should be allowed to have him.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

Section 53. To add a new sub-section as follows:—

"(2) The amount of any expenses incurred under the Public Health and Local Government (Conferences) Act, 1885, by any local authority other than a sanitary authority shall be paid and charged as part of the general expenses of such local authority in the performance of its duties."

This is largely a drafting amendment, which I put down at the request of the Minister. I understand that under this section as it stands most of the local authorities strike a penny rate for advertising for tourist purposes. The amendment, I am informed, is necessary if the section is to remain part of the Bill, because the section as it stands does not give them power to pay it out of their general expenses, although it does give power to strike a rate. This amendment is necessary if they are to have the power to pay out of the general expenses.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

Does this mean that the expense of advertising watering-places shall be apportioned over the whole county?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

If they are expenses incurred under the Public Health and Local Conferences Act, 1885, it does.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

If so, I would ask the Seanad not to pass the amendment pending further elucidation at least, because there is considerable objection to rural ratepayers bearing the expense of advertising watering-places situate within a county.

Comment on this

The section as it stands has done that already, apart from the amendment.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Under the section as it stands the Minister says that would be the law without this amendment.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

As this matter has escaped notice so far through inadvertence, could it be raised on the Report Stage?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

If on consideration you think there is anything in it, you can bring it up on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 54, sub-section (1), page 26. To delete the word "knowingly" in lines 13 and 14.

This sub-section deals with persons acting on councils whilst disqualified. I think the word "knowingly" which occurs twice weakens the whole object. It would be almost impossible to prove that a man "knowingly" acted while disqualified.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I suppose the idea in using the word "knowingly" is that it means once it is brought to his notice.

Comment on this

That is not quite clear. Sub-section (2) says that if a member is prosecuted it will have to be proved in court that he acted knowingly while he was disqualified.

Comment on this

It is very necessary to have this word "knowingly" in here. There is a rather severe penalty for acting, and in many cases members of local authorities are disqualified without knowing it. For instance, up to quite recently it was not very clearly decided whether a director of a company which had entered into a contract with a local authority would be disqualified from acting on that local authority. He might have acted in that capacity, and would be liable to this severe penalty. For that reason it is necessary to put the word "knowingly" in, and the onus in the particular case is thrown on the defendant to show that he did not act knowingly. In administering the Act, I will do everything in my power to see to it that any member who is disqualified will know that he is disqualified by having a notice hung up in the room where the council meets notifying the conditions under which a person would be disqualified from acting as a Local Government representative. If a great hardship is not to be inflicted, it is necessary to retain the word "knowingly."

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Before we pass from sub-clause (2) I would suggest to the Minister that the last three lines are very awkwardly expressed. Would it not be quite enough to say "the onus of proof shall lie on the defendant"?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That is the legal expression.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That would be omitting everything after the word "proved" to the end of the sub-section, and inserting in lieu thereof "the onus of proof that he did not so act knowingly, shall lie on the defendant."

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 54, sub-section (1), line 13. After the word "member" to insert the words "or as an officer."

This section deals with the disqualification of members. I think an officer of a local body who acts illegally should be liable to the same penalties as a member.

Comment on this

I think the obvious remedy in the case of an officer of a local authority guilty under this section will be to have him removed from office. That is the usual procedure, and I do not think it is fair to impose a double penalty on him. He loses his office, which means his livelihood, and he should not also be subject to this penalty. I think there is a great difference between an officer and a member, and I would ask the Senator not to insist on that amendment.

Comment on this

With regard to the next amendment—Section 54, sub-section (2), to delete the sub-section, we have already dealt with that sub-section and I withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 54. Page 26. To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

"(4) If any person is, after the passing of this Act, convicted of acting as a member or officer of a local authority when disqualified, he shall be disqualified for a period of ten years from the date of such conviction for being elected or appointed to any paid office under or in the gift of any local authority: provided that the disqualification arising under this sub-section may be removed by the Minister certifying under his hand that on full consideration of the circumstances he is satisfied that the disqualification should, either as regards a specified vacant paid office, or generally, not continue, but in any such case as in this proviso mentioned, such certificate as aforesaid shall be forwarded with and form a necessary part of the application of any such person as candidate for any such paid office as aforesaid, and no such person shall be eligible for appointment to any paid office unless such certificate shall have been obtained and forwarded as aforesaid."

As the law stands a member who has been disqualified from membership of a local body may, as far as I know, apply for and be appointed to a paid position on that board. That appears to be a ridiculous position.

Comment on this

I have no objection to accepting the first part of this amendment, but it might, perhaps, require re-drafting. I have a strong objection to accepting the second part, which gives me dispensing power which it would be difficult for me to exercise without criticism. It would be alleged that I acted from all kinds of personal political motives in dispensing people from those conditions, and accordingly I would be strongly opposed to the second part of the amendment. Perhaps the Senator would agree to omitting the second part?

Comment on this

It is the first part I am interested in. I do not think that a person who is disqualified from serving on a public board should be eligible for appointment to a paid position under that Board.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That means the deletion of all the lines in the amendment from the first five lines down, after the word "authority."

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I move:—

Before Section 55 to insert two new sections as follows:—

"55.—No political question unless bearing directly on matters within the jurisdiction of the local authority shall be discussed at any meeting of a county council, board of health, urban district council, borough council, or any committees thereof.

"56.—Should the Minister consider that the provisions of the foregoing section have been contravened at any meeting he shall by order declare the proceedings of such meeting to be null and void but without prejudice to anything done previous to the issue of such order."

I think I am right in saying that a good deal of adverse criticism has been levied at the heads of local government boards, both from within and without the country, owing to the frequent discussion of political matters which have nothing to do with the business of the local authority. If it were possible to put a stop to these discussions, I think the dignity and status of our local bodies would be very much enhanced. I have experienced myself for many years great disquietude by being a member of local bodies where such matters were discussed. So unpleasant was it on many occasions that I quite believe that if only politics could be kept out of local boards far better people would be got to take up the work of local government. To a great extent in the past, and even in the present, these political discussions have been used as a form of pillorying, by which you can brand people's politics in any manner that may be required. It is also used as a form of notoriety or advertisement for any form of political creed. Nothing has a more degrading psychological effect on our local bodies than these political discussions. If an instance were required I would only point to the case last week where the General Council of County Councils, which is supposed to be the corps d'elite of councils, indulged in a discussion of the merits and demerits of certain political prisoners.

If the House would agree with me so far, the only question would be whether an amendment of this kind is likely to be effective, and whether it secures its purpose in the best way. I suggest it would not be wise to prohibit political discussions altogether, simply because the authority of the law would be flouted. They would take place all the same, and you would have to impose special penalties, imprisonment or something of that kind, to enforce the law. That would not be desirable, and would only make martyrs of the people concerned. Under the proposal now before the House the effect would be that if a political resolution, outside matters bearing directly on the business or question within the jurisdiction of their authority is raised, all the other business will be liable to be declared, by the Minister, when he gets the minutes, to be null and void, so that if any political resolution is brought up it will be open to any member to say: "I hope the members present realise that if we pass this resolution we will have to go home, for all the business transacted to-day will be futile and abortive." A wise chairman would say at the beginning of the meeting: "If there are any political resolutions we will take them first, and then we may go home, as nothing further can be done." If a political resolution is not brought up at the beginning of the meeting the chairman could refuse to take it later on. I suggest that the amendment is likely to be effective without making martyrs of these people, who wish to indulge in political propaganda at local boards.

Comment on this

I am quite in favour of the object the Senator has in view, but I have some doubt as to whether the method he has adopted is the most effective. The Ministers, of course, are always politicians, and I think the result may possibly be that if a resolution is in agreement with the Minister's political views he may consider it non-political, whereas if it is against the Government he will declare the proceedings null and void. I think these two sections can be drafted into one by adding at the end of the first section: "Any proceedings at such meeting shall be null and void if any of the members present points out that this is a political resolution." otherwise I am afraid that the political resolution will go if the Minister who is in office at the time is in favour of it.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The same would apply to the individual who points it out. He might have his own political views, too.

Comment on this

In Ireland, unfortunately, in any assembly, however small, there is a diversity of political views. Therefore one man could always nullify the object of the other by pointing out that it was a political matter.

Comment on this

In my opinion it would be very hard for an ordinary public body to define the exact moment when matters, say economic, merged into the political. I think that to put this burden on a local authority would create a great amount of chaos. That is what I am afraid of. If I, personally, were asked at a given moment when a discussion on some economic matter was taking place, to say when it passed into the political sphere, I would find it very hard to decide. While wishing that all political discussion should be taboo at public boards, I think it would be very hard, in a country like Ireland, to enforce a regulation of that kind.

Comment on this

Would not the case be met by passing Section 55 and omitting Section 56? You could then leave it to someone, who wished to do so, to move in the courts to have the matter set aside. I assume that lawyers are not politicians, and that they would decide the matter without animus.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I feel that Section 56 is necessary, because, as Senator Bennett has pointed out, there will be cases on the border line. Some of these cases are obviously outside any local jurisdiction, questions about prisoners and those having to do with the boundary. There are questions dealing with rating and valuations which the local authority has a right to discuss, as well as contemplated legislation in respect of these matters. This amendment gives the Minister power to say whether the subject is outside the jurisdiction, and naturally he will give the benefit of the doubt to the local authority. I think we may trust him to do that. It is only when there has been a flagrant breach of Section 56 that he will act. If, as Senator Dowdall says, the Minister cannot be expected to act impartially, well then, I am afraid it is hopeless to expect any government in the country. Ministers do realise their responsibilities apart from party, and act in a quasi-judicial capacity.

Comment on this

The trouble I have about this amendment is this, that while I sympathise very much with the object Senator Sir John Keane has in view, I do not see exactly how we are going to define the evidence on which the Minister is to act. The amendment says: "No political question shall be discussed." Who is to give evidence as to whether or not a political question has been discussed? If you could define the offence at the stage at which the discussion arrived at a resolution and the resolution was put, it would appear on the minute book of the local authority. Then you might have some sort of evidence on which the Minister could act, but without something of that nature I am afraid it is far too vague, though I entirely sympathise with the object Senator Sir John Keane has in view. I am afraid his amendment will not carry out his ideas.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I expect the Minister will act on the evidence in the minutes. On the minutes which come before him at present from local authorities, the Minister frequently disallows their proceedings as regards appointments and other matters. There is a legal duty imposed on the secretary to the local authority to record the proceedings of the meeting on the minutes. My recollection of local authorities is that these political resolutions are always recorded on the minutes.

Comment on this

Once it becomes a resolution and is recorded on the minutes, then, of course, you have the evidence.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

That is what I contemplate, that it is only when the Minister has the official minutes that he will act. I am quite prepared to accept any form of words which will make that point clear.

Comment on this

I think that anyone who has a knowledge of public affairs in our country must realise that it will be absolutely impossible to carry out in practice an amendment of this kind. Residing as I do in the South of Ireland, in the neighbourhood of the Blarney Stone, I realise quite well that in my own district it would be impossible to put into practice an amendment of this kind. Members of public boards are very fond of indulging in political discussions. I think that in a great measure they act as a sort of safety valve when crises arise from time to time. It would be a dangerous precedent, I think, to try to stifle discussions on public questions that arise from time to time.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Would it meet the case to say that: "It shall be the duty of the chairman of so and so to rule out of order"?

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I should prefer something on the lines suggested by Senator Brown, that any political resolution passed by a public body must go on the minutes and that that would be the evidence on which the Minister would act.

Comment on this