We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

SEANAD IN COMMITTEE. - LOCAL GOVERNMENT BILL, 1924. THIRD STAGE (RESUMED).

Contributions 146–280 of 280. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Local Government Bill 1924
Withdrawn

No. 18 of 1924 ›

Any resolution on a wholly political question.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That would not accomplish your purpose, because they might spend the whole day discussing it and wind up without a resolution.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

They are not very much tied to the resolutions. The resolution goes to the Press and is then supposed to have achieved its purpose. Frequently I have seen a member going in with a resolution written by someone else. I have even seen members unable to read resolutions which they had got dealing with political questions. Senator Haughton's point is a groundless one, because when a meeting is called for a political purpose naturally a discussion could take place. If they liked to summon a special meeting to discuss the release of prisoners, that, of course, would be in order.

Comment on this

I think Senator Sir John Keane would be wise to withdraw this amendment. As regards these political resolutions, we are all glad to recognise that the occasion for them is growing less. It is very seldom that resolutions of the kind now come before public bodies. The position of a chairman is, of course, a peculiar one. He has his standing orders for the conduct of the business of the meeting, just as standing orders are in existence here for the conduct of the business of the Seanad. A member may rise in his place and ask that the standing orders be suspended for the purpose of calling attention to some urgent matter of general public interest. The standing orders are there, and when the member declares the nature of the matter to which he calls attention, if two-thirds of the members present stand up and give their assent the chairman has no option in the matter but to allow the discussion to go on. I think it is rather unfortunate, in this amendment, to be calling attention to matters of this sort. We are now getting into a calmer atmosphere than that in which we lived some time ago, and with the re-election of new bodies this question of political resolutions at meetings will gradually die out. In any case if you were to go up North, I do not think Senator Sir John Keane would rule out a discussion on the boundary question at a meeting of some county council in one of the counties on the border. A discussion on that question would certainly be semi-political. At least, it would be very hard to disintegrate what percentage of it was political and what percentage of it was not. I think, in all the circumstances, it would be a wise thing, and that it would reflect on the credit of the Seanad if we were to say that this was not a time when amendments of this kind should be brought forward here. It would be better, I think, if they were not brought forward and to leave the evil, such as it is, to exhaust itself.

Comment on this

I am in favour of the principle at the back of the amendment, but I am afraid, as several Senators have pointed out, that in practice it would be very difficult to put it into operation. It would place a very awkward responsibility on me in the matter of deciding what was political and what was not political. It might get me into serious difficulties with my own political chiefs in ruling out various matters that they might interpret in a different way from the way I would interpret them. It puts the responsibility on me of making two decisions: first of all, whether it is a political resolution or not, and, secondly, whether it has a bearing directly on matters within the jurisdiction of the local authority or not. It is quite obvious that a great many border line cases would arise on which it would be difficult to adjudicate. Senator Sir John Keane said that the evidence to be placed before me would be the evidence in the minutes of the public meeting. In many cases there is a big delay in the sending on of these minutes. In some cases there is a delay of a month, and occasionally two months. Paying orders may have been issued, and contracts may have been entered into, and perhaps partly fulfilled, before the minutes reach me. Then I may be asked to rule that the whole thing is null and void. That would be a very serious thing for the local authorities and the parties they had entered into contracts with. For that reason I am opposed to accepting the latter part of the amendment. Senator Butler has an amendment down which proposes to effect the same purpose. That is to come on for discussion later, and it may be easier to accept it than this one.

Comment on this

Is the Minister accepting the first part of the amendment?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I understand he says he will be prepared to accept the first part, but not the second part.

Comment on this

I believe that these proposals are perfectly impracticable. How can you prevent people from making speeches if they want to? It seems to me to be quite useless to bring forward an amendment of this kind, because it is simply trying to do a thing that is not practicable. You must allow people to do what they want to do nowadays.

Comment on this

As regards the first part of the amendment, it is, in my opinion, impracticable, because of the definition of politics. In Webster's dictionary, politics is defined as "The science of Government." That is a wide definition enough, unless the Minister invents a new one, and if he does invent a new one I suggest it should be added to the section of definitions in the Bill. The amendment, desirable as it is, will simply give new employment to a set of gentlemen who will proceed to drive a coach-and-four through it, because without moving any resolution at all they can discuss all the politics they want to.

One can always, I believe, break the law and, by following the example of certain exalted and eminent lawyers, keep just within the limit. To pass this amendment will simply act as a sort of challenge to those whose object will be to discuss politics after the new councils are elected and who, perhaps, would not have any great incentive to do that unless this amendment were inserted. I believe that the amendment, if inserted, would act as an incentive and an encouragement to such people and that they would claim it as a triumph over the Oireachtas every time they were able to break through it. Many of them would like to nullify many things done at the meetings by discussing politics or moving a resolution. It is always easy to move a resolution at the end of a meeting, although no previous notice of it had been given. It is easy to foresee the number of ways in which this could be availed of and that quite a lot of chaos could be created. I had hoped that we would have been able to adopt something which would prevent politics being discussed at the meetings of public bodies, but when you come to put that in practice you find it an exceedingly difficult question. There is no reason why a controversy on religious subjects should not also be prohibited. Yet we would never think of putting in an amendment to that effect. I take it that there is a certain code of duties which these bodies are elected to perform, and that it is within the judgment of any chairman to say that a certain resolution is out of order. You must allow him a certain amount of discretion in matters of that kind, and we must have little faith in Irish humanity if we believe that many of these boards are going to be the fiasco that some of them were in the past.

Comment on this

I think the harm some Senators appear to see as coming from political discussions at meetings is greatly exaggerated. On such questions as contemplated legislation, for instance, the medium of expression that could give information would be those very bodies that might have political discussions. There would be such discussions and they would be very useful. But if this amendment is passed the Government of the day would be deprived of a great source of knowledge that would ordinarily come to them through these public representative bodies. I think the harm done by political discussion is greatly exaggerated. Where a proper chairman is elected to such local bodies it should be in his discretionary powers to rule such matters out of order if he thinks they are out of order. If the chairman of such meeting wants the business concluded satisfactorily, and if he is a business man, he will rule anything of an irrelevant character out of order, and will not allow it to be discussed, and the business will be transacted properly. I am quite in sympathy with Senator Sir John Keane on ruling out political discussion if that were possible. But I think it is impossible.

Comment on this

I am very much in sympathy with the amendment and especially the first part of it, because I see, from the change that has come over the country, that there is no longer the same occasion for the number of speeches and debates which in the local bodies were often a complete waste of time. If the powers were placed in the hands of the chairman to decide whether a resolution proposed was political or not, and to refuse to sanction it, if it was political, although he might not, perhaps, have the courage on all occasions to exercise his discretionary powers, he would see at any rate that the country, if this Bill is passed, did not wish to see the local powers conferred on local bodies made use of for purposes other than those for which they were conferred. It is to be hoped that after the next general election of members to local bodies it will be found that the decision of the electors did not depend on what political party the candidates belonged to, but rather that candidates will be chosen for their business efficiency.

In that case there ought to be some way, at any rate, of showing the disapproval of the country, assuming this Bill is approved of by the country, of the waste of time which often happened at these boards in the past in discussions upon matters which were really outside the functions of county councils or boards of guardians or district councils and have frequently occupied the time of such bodies. I certainly will support the first part of the amendment. The suggestion that the Minister should penalise the work of the councils by rendering nugatory all their efforts to do business because what he might consider a political resolution had been passsd would, I think, be a great mistake and would place the Minister in an extremely difficult position.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I am not committed exactly to the form of the amendment. If I cannot get the whole thing, then the suggestion of Senator Sir N. Everard would be better than nothing. I am perplexed that so many should be in sympathy with the object of my amendment who despair of any practical method being discovered to make it effective. I do not believe legislation is quite so bankrupt as all that. We passed legislation recently purporting and claiming to do far more difficult things, the cleaning out and renovating of small dairies in the country and also legislation purporting, if adopted, to give enormously increased revenues to certain industries. I firmly believe that this provision, if tried, would be found to be quite effective. After all, if it was not effective or fully effective it rests entirely with the Minister. He can apply it as strictly or as liberally as he likes. I do not think the Minister should shirk his responsibility. He has taken far greater responsibility and he has attempted more difficult things, such as the dissolution of bodies like corporations and county councils. It should not be difficult for him to exercise a wise discretion in matters of this kind.

Comment on this

We all know that old customs die hard, and this thing of political discussions at public boards is not a matter of to-day or yesterday. They have been handed on to us by people who monopolised those boards in the old days. Opposition and discussion are the principal phases of political life. Consequently, the people to-day who occupy those boards are not so much to blame for remembering that this thing has gone on for generations at public boards, and, as I said, we know that old customs die hard. If to-morrow or any other time any public board introduced a discussion on Protection versus Free Trade I submit that that would be a political discussion. Now, where is the present Minister or his successor going to draw the line between what is political and what is not political? Even Senator Sir John Keane, with all his ability, would find himself taxed to decide where it begins and where it ends. Consequently I believe the thing is impracticable and ought to be withdrawn. It cannot be remedied in the way suggested by the amendment. Every person who thinks at all would like to see more practical discussion and less of the windy man.

Comment on this

While in sympathy with the main object of the amendment, I do not see how it could be carried into practice. The same necessity will not now arise for political discussions as heretofore. Heretofore these political discussions were mainly carried on by boards of guardians and rural district councils, and both these bodies will now be dissolved, and they inherited that very bad practice from the old Grand Juries.

Comment on this
The EARL of MAYO

I agree with what Senator Sir John Keane said, but how it is to be put into practice I cannot see. The Minister has already stated that according to the amendment he would have to decide what is a political question. That will be putting upon him a tremendous responsibility. Senator Sir John Keane said "the Minister is shirking his responsibility." Well, he has got this Bill, which will soon become an Act, and he has got to see it carried out, and I do not envy him that task, if he carries it out in the proper manner. I do not think he will be shirking any responsibility. You may as well try to stop the currents and the tide in Dublin Bay as to stop my countrymen talking politics whenever they are assembled together. As one of the Labour Senators said, other generations have done it and it will continue. I cannot possibly see how, in an Act of Parliament, you are going to prevent people from talking, for that is what it amounts to.

Let them do their business first. If a resolution came forward the chairman could say: "I am bound to accept the resolution if the Standing Orders are suspended." I know if I were chairman of the meeting I would have to accept it. I hope Senator Sir John Keane will not press this amendment, because it looks as if the meaning of it was that we are to hold our tongues about politics. We are not going to hold our tongues about politics. Certainly not. In every generation we talk politics and we are going to talk politics whenever we gather together on any occasion.

Comment on this

If I may say one word to correct what Senator the Earl of Mayo said, as to the impossibility of preventing political discussion, the Irish Agricultural Organisation Society and others that I know of have a rule that no political or sectarian discussion should be allowed at meetings. I have never known that rule broken. Consequently men of all classes and sections in these organisations have met together at friendly meetings and discharged the business of these bodies. We need not look forward to the danger of the chairman's ruling being nullified. I certainly think that it would give the chairman added authority if he could point to a resolution as being against the regulations, and I am sure he would be supported by the majority.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I was wondering whether in view of the general feeling expressed by the House Senators would like to have some useful legislation on that matter that would meet the difficulty. The chairman on these bodies has, I believe, power to rule out discussion, but he is not required to do so. It is an invidious task to put upon him, and he may hesitate about doing it. If a clause of this kind were inserted, it might be useful: "It shall be the duty of the presiding chairman of every county council, public health board, urban district council, borough council or committee thereof to rule out of order any question, discussion or resolution which, in his opinion, is of a political nature and does not bear directly on any matter within the jurisdiction or control of such county council," etc.

Comment on this

He would very soon find himself without a quorum.

Comment on this

I think it very much better to leave this business alone.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think that is very likely, Senator.

Comment on this

I beg to move Amendment 114:—

Section 57, sub-section (2). To delete the words from and including the word "the" up to and including the word "year" in line 13, and to substitute therefor the words "each meeting," and to delete in paragraph (a) all the words from and including the word "at" in line 16 to the word "months" in line 17, and substitute therefor the words "such meeting." To delete all from and including the words "at least" in line 19, paragraph (b), to the end of the paragraph, and to substitute therefor the words "such meeting," and in lines 25-26 to delete the words "during such preceding six months."

Shortly, the meaning of this amendment, which is a General Council's amendment, is that members should be paid, at the close of each meeting or as soon after as possible, the amount provided in Schedule 5 for travelling expenses. Under the Bill as it stands payment appears to be deferred for the whole six months, and a member would have to have attended at least three-fourths of the meetings of such county authorities as shall be held during the preceding six months. You can imagine instances which may arise, that with the very best intentions a member may not succeed in having attended three-fourths of the meetings. It may happen there may be sickness or there may be enforced absence on the part of the members. I think it would be bad, if, in view of these contingencies, he would be debarred from getting the expenses due to him. In selection boards, Departmental Committees or Consultative Committees appointed by the Minister, the practice is that the members attending the meetings send in an account of their expenses and these accounts are dealt with before the next meeting and payments forwarded to them. Why that principle should be departed from here is not very clear to the General Council of County Councils. That is the reason why this amendment is submitted to the Seanad asking that members attending county councils should be paid such expenses as they are entitled to be paid to them straight away, and that the words I have mentioned should be deleted from the Bill so that the members who attend should be paid such expenses as they are entitled to on forwarding their accounts.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Does it not come to this, that you propose that they should be paid for their attendance at each meeting and that the payment should be made as soon as possible after the conclusion of the meeting?

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

There was an amendment somewhat similar to this amendment in the Dáil, and I opposed it. The object of this section, or the principal object of it, is to try to ensure better attendance at the meetings of local bodies. I think, sir, that you in another capacity, delivered a very famous judgment on this matter, in which you used rather strong strictures with regard to non-attendance of members of local bodies. It is common knowledge that in the past, and even at the present time, the attendance at these meetings is very poor. Under this section, payment will not be made to members unless they attend three-quarters of the meetings. Payment will not be made at the end of the six months unless they have attended three-quarters of the meetings. This will ensure that the man who carries out his duties in an honourable and efficient manner will be paid, and the man who neglects his business and who only turns up when appointments are about being made will not be paid. The effect of Senator Kenny's amendment would probably be to stimulate this present tendency to turn up only when matters of a pecuniary interest are involved, and to neglect the ordinary duties of the council. The section as it stands is a very good protection against that kind of conduct, and for that reason I ask the Seanad not to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I wish to say that this matter was brought before the General Council of the County Councils, and when I put the matter before them I was asked why should not the same principle as was in the Bill apply to the personnel of the Dáil and Seanad.

Comment on this

It seems to me on reading Section 6 of the Fifth Schedule that the expenses to which a member would be entitled under this section would rarely exceed 6/8. The member will be paid 4d. for each mile of the journey from his residence to the place of meeting travelled by railway, and 5d. for each mile of journey otherwise travelled. In my opinion, it is a perfect farce. I think it would be much better either to raise these munificent sums or drop the whole thing altogether.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

Section 57, sub-section (2). To add at the end of the sub-section the words "and such further payment in respect of subsistence allowance and loss of remunerative time as is authorised by regulations to be made by the Minister."

This is a rather different proposition from the last amendment, and Senator Bennett has expressed the view already that finds favour with a good many, namely, that the expenses allowed to members of a county council are so trivial that they either should be deleted entirely or increased. That was also the view of the General Council— namely, that the expenses allowed under the Bill as it stands do not represent any appreciable part of the expenses of the members attending these councils and committees. The members of the General Council would much prefer that the expenses should be left out entirely rather than that they should be dealt with in a meagre and halfhearted way. They went further and said: "Why not be allowed, in addition, the same expenses as were allowed to members of Consultative Councils?" I think you will find, already, that members of Consultative Councils are allowed travelling expenses, and subsistence allowance, and some amount to repay for the loss of their time in attending these councils. The members attending the county councils suffer from a similar disability. They pay their railway fare. That part of their expenses from their residence to the place of meeting is to be repaid, but the subsistence allowance is not provided for, nor is there an equivalent for the loss of time in their own business. This is an inconsistency they find fault with. They are doing public business the same as the consultative committees. They are doing the work of the public. The principle is held so far as the members of consultative or selection boards and departmental committees are concerned they should not be at any personal loss for doing the business they are called upon to do. They are unable to understand why that principle is departed from in their case. They are doing not only committee work but administrative work of a very important character. I have been asked to submit this amendment in the hope that the Minister may be brought to accept it.

Comment on this

The provisions in this section for the payment of expenses are not very liberal. I am prepared to admit that. Yet they are something novel. Heretofore those members of local authorities received no out-of-pocket expenses of any kind, and this is a considerable step forward. It is much easier to increase that sum as we go along than to take from it. It is much better to begin quietly, and not to go too far in the beginning. There is a great difference between members attending the Oireachtas or members attending a Consultative Council, and members attending the local council. The latter are within a few hours' journey of the place of meeting. They rarely stay there longer than one day, and there is no reason why they should get subsistence allowance. As a general rule they are able to fit in meetings of their council with business of their own. As a general rule these meetings are held on market days and every possible attempt is made to facilitate members in that way. I think it is a very big thing to get the principle accepted to pay those members at all. If we go too far now the whole principle may collapse. I think it is better to adopt the motto, "Hasten slowly," in this matter.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

Section 57, sub-section (4). To add at the end of the sub-section the words "nor for attendance at any such meeting aforesaid to any member who proposes or votes for any political resolution."

I agree with the provision in this Bill for the payment of members of the county council. As the Bill stands at present it is possible for the county council to call a special meeting for the purpose of considering a political resolution, and, as far as I can gather, the Minister is bound to sanction payment of expenses in such a case. I do not think that was ever intended. I think the Minister should have power to refuse sanction for the payment for attendance at such meetings.

Comment on this

I quite agree. I would think very little of a politician who was not prepared to pay from 1/8 to, say, 6/8 for attending a political meeting. I think the politician who would be impertinent enough to say, "I am not prepared to forfeit 1/8 for my expenses attending a political meeting," is not much good to any Party.

Comment on this

There is one point in this, and that is, that this is rather an assumption that politics are to be discussed at such meetings. Politics should be far from the business of the meeting.

Comment on this

If a councillor comes to attend a meeting of a local body and the ordinary business is transacted, and, during the course of the meeting, somebody springs a political matter, does the member lose his expenses for attending such a meeting?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Yes, if he proposes the resolution.

Comment on this

think this is a small matter.

Comment on this

I am in agreement with the principle of this amendment. There may be some difficulty in ascertaining what is a political resolution and what is not a political resolution. I think we could accept it. Senator Bennett has drawn attention to the fact that it is a very poor politician that would not give 1/8 for his own opinion. Under the section it is quite possible that if a member did not get credit for one particular meeting he may get below the three-fourths necessary and might, therefore, lose all his expenses for the six months. That would be something more than 1/8.

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 59. Page 28. After sub-section (3), line 6, to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(4) The council of any county may arrange with the council of any urban district in such county or of any county borough adjoining such county for the use of all or any of the purposes of the said Acts by the whole or some specified part of the county, of any part of the building or of the library facilities of any public library situate in such urban district or county borough on such terms as may be agreed upon between the council of the urban district or county borough in which such library is situate and the council of such county."

This amendment will enable county councils to arrange with urban district councils or county boroughs for the use of their libraries for the benefit of the rural districts. I do not think that there is any such power in the Bill. In Kilkenny there is a library in the city, and I think it would be desirable that the benefits of that library should be extended to the surrounding rural areas. The county council could give a direction in that connection, and if the library facilities were extended, the people would benefit very much. Perhaps the County Waterford might be in the same position, and in that connection Senator Kenny might have some remarks to make. I am sure it would be very desirable indeed if the people of the rural districts could take advantage of a library in Waterford by arrangement with the county council.

Comment on this

I would like to support this amendment. I think that every attempt should be made to provide library facilities for rural districts.

Comment on this

I am in agreement with the principle of this amendment, but I think it is unnecessary as, under the Bill, people residing in rural areas can arrange for facilities with libraries in urban districts under the Libraries Act. Accordingly, this amendment adds nothing.

Comment on this

In what part of the Bill is that set out?

Comment on this

It is in the section that makes the county council the library authority.

Comment on this

My reading of the Bill is that the county council can absorb the local council and under those circumstances can administer the Libraries Act in urban areas. There are urban councils who have had libraries for many years, and I believe they are quite willing and anxious that the rural districts around should derive advantages from these libraries. I do not see anything in the Bill that would enable surrounding rural areas to get the benefit of those libraries.

Comment on this

In practice I do not think matters work out as the Minister suggests. I live in a rural area and, although I have tried, I could not obtain books from the urban council library one mile away. That is really because I live in the rural district. That system has been in practice hitherto, and I believe that unless this amendment is adopted, we will be debarred from obtaining any privileges such as are suggested.

Comment on this

Section 3 of the Public Libraries Act of 1894 sets out that when the principal Act is adopted for two or more neighbouring districts, the authorities over these districts may by agreement combine for any period for carrying the Act into execution, and the expense shall be defrayed by such authorities in such proportion as may be agreed on by them. Accordingly, any two authorities can combine for that particular purpose, irrespective of whether or not they are urban.

Comment on this

I do not know if that is exactly the same as the case that I make out, where an urban district has a library for years and the rural area immediately surrounding the town might like to take advantage of that library. In such a case as that the county council should be in the position to make terms with the urban district on behalf of the rural area. I take it there would have to be an agreement with the town in which the library is situated. The whole matter would be rendered much clearer if my amendment were adopted.

Comment on this

I understand that that power is contained in this Bill, combined with the Public Libraries Act. To accept the amendment would only lead to overlapping.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

It might be worth your while, Senator, if you are interested in this matter, to look into it further. If necessary I will allow you to bring it up again on Report. At present I am disposed to think that one particular point you have in mind is not provided for. On a very cursory examination, it seems to me that the matter you are anxious to accomplish is not covered by antecedent legislation. Satisfy yourself on that subject between this and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

After Section 60 to insert a new section as follows:—

61. It shall be lawful for the Minister in such cases as he may think fit to grant to any new buildings erected on old disused sites or to any existing factories or warehouses which owing to their dangerous condition are in need of repair, immunity from re-valuation for a period of five years after the erection or rebuilding has been completed.

The effect of this new section would be to reduce the number of sites that are vacant in many parts of the country and it will encourage building. We all admit that it is something of a shame to see the sites in O'Connell Street remaining vacant. No effort is being made to rebuild there. In rural areas there are many sites in a somewhat similar condition and it would be very desirable indeed if building could be encouraged. I believe the effect of this amendment would be to encourage builders to proceed with the erection of houses. We have a precedent for this in the Housing Act, where there is a provision giving relief in the matter of rates over a period of twenty years. In the Westminster Parliament they inserted a clause somewhat similar to mine in the Dublin Reconstruction (Emergency Powers) Act, and it extended over a period of twelve years. I think everything possible should be done to encourage building. What I suggest in this connection might also apply to factories in want of repair. Quite a number of people are at present adverse to spending money on repairs. If, however, they were aware that they would be relieved of rates for some years, they might be induced to proceed with any necessary work.

Comment on this

Senator O'Rourke is misinterpreting the Dublin Reconstruction Act, I think. The Act of 1916, or even any later Act, does not do what he says it does. It gives power to the effect that the valuation shall not be increased for twelve years. It is quite a different thing in the matter of rates. The position is that if the premises were rebuilt they would not be revalued at a higher valuation for a specified number of years.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

There is nothing about relief of rates in Senator O'Rourke's amendment. It deals only with relief from re-valuation. It does not propose relief from rates. The Senator is following the analogy in the Dublin Reconstruction Act in regard to immunity from revaluation. That is all he proposes.

Comment on this

As one who had something to do with the Act of 1916, I would like to point out what actually happened. That Act was, naturally, opposed by the residents of the street, because we wanted a better type of building than the old building and we had to concede something. One of the things we conceded was a total remission of the first year's rates after reconstruction, and a guarantee that for the subsequent eleven years the rating of the premises would not exceed the rating of the destroyed premises; that is, the valuation would not be affected. A good many members in the Council Chamber objected, but I thought it was a good bargain inasmuch as we were building up a huge reserve fund. In a year or two all these premises will be revalued at possibly three times the existing valuation.

Comment on this

I desire to support the amendment. It would be a very good thing if this were adopted, and accepted by the Minister. There are many discouragements nowadays to house-building, the Rent Restriction Act and the Town Tenants' agitation all largely preventing enterprising people from going into building on a large scale. I am aware that in some parts of England and Wales building societies, that were originally started in a small way, have now grown to immense proportions. This is all because an undertaking was given to those about to start building on a substantial scale that there would be no charge for rates whatever over a specified number of years. If that policy were adopted in the twenty-six counties, a great change would take place in the building trade.

Comment on this

I would like also to support the amendment. The primary reason why there is not so much building in progress is that every man who desires to build is terrified because of the enormous cost. We see where all the traders and others in O'Connell Street, though they have got their ex gratia grants, are not doing anything in the matter of building. Reconstruction in that area is absolutely at a standstill. They are faced not only with the cost of the building, a sum which will have to be borrowed from the bank, but they have to face a worse ordeal, and that is that the valuation is raised four or five times higher than it was at the time the building was destroyed. I do not know anything that will have a better effect on the rebuilding of destroyed property than the putting of this amendment into force. You probably, as a result of this amendment, will have the whole of the derelict sites of Dublin rebuilt in the near future and this will hasten the work. These destroyed sites, remaining as they are, unbuilt, are an eyesore to the city, and are simply appalling. These ruined buildings stare us in the face everywhere, even in the main thoroughfare. I believe if the Minister agrees to this amendment that inside five years we will probably have the valuation of the property of the city raised by £500,000. It will take a large sum at least to reconstruct these dilapidated buildings. I do not know a better investment for the Government or better work they could do than to accept this amendment stopping the re-valuation of these sites for ten years or so. Where new buildings are being erected, if the raising of the valuation were delayed for ten years or something like that, it would give a great impetus to work of reconstruction. Suppose I go to rebuild any part of a factory to-day, it would not be a very elaborate one or a very big one that could be built at £10,000. I may not have the money. Then I have to go to the bank to borrow it. The interest on that would be at least £600, that is, if the bank will lend me the money. If the banks do not lend the money then the building cannot be erected at all.

My business is upset during the time of building, and it would be very difficult not only to find the money, but also to meet the extra new demands, three or four times the rates and the taxes that were paid on the old premises. To meet these demands immediately afterwards would be a charge that no business could afford. We want some encouragement to rebuild on these wretched sites, and it should be given at once. I have great pleasure in supporting the amendment.

Comment on this

I would like to support the amendment also. It is left to the discretion of the Minister. It is not mandatory. I think it would be advisable if a time limit were put in; it might have the result of getting the work started during the present year. If the proposal be accepted I would suggest a time limit of twelve months; that unless the work was started within twelve months and completed within two years these concessions should not be granted.

Comment on this

I would like to add to the volume of praise given to this amendment; there is no doubt that it would be very welcome. It would bring about many improvements. The only fault I have to find with it is that the concessions are not proposed to be continued for ten years instead of five.

Comment on this

There may be some little evasion under the amendment, because the time does not begin to run until the building is completed. A person might erect a sufficient portion of the building for the purpose of conducting his business and leave an annexe, or some other part, uncompleted. I think if the word "occupied" were substituted for "completed" it would meet the case.

Comment on this

I would like to hear what is the definition of "an old disused site." This might be an old site vacant for several years with a ridiculous valuation or practically no valuation at all on it. Supposing there was no valuation on record—I do not know whether that could be possible— on an old disused site, what is to be done? There is a lot to be said for the spirit of this amendment, but I wonder how a manufacturer or trader would look upon a position like this. He gets one of these ridiculously cheap old sites, and he sets up as competitor beside another man who is paying higher rates, and he gets off for the first five years with a third or fourth of the rates that his competitor has to pay. How would the existing manufacturer or merchant look upon a proposal of this kind? We have not only to consider those who are setting up in business, but those who are striving to exist. I am not against the spirit of the amendment, but I would like to ask Senators to consider that point of view. When is the five years to start, and who is to say when is the building completed? I think some tightening up in the principle is called for.

Comment on this

I think this is an unnecessary complication by limiting the new buildings to old sites. In America, where growing towns are anxious to bring in business and anxious to increase their rateable capacity, the greatest help is given to prospective builders. I think in Dublin, considering the name we have had for preventing any enterprise, through monstrous rates, that this should be worded to encourage the erecting of factories on any site within the Greater Dublin area, when it will be fixed, irrespective of whether they are old or disused. It is high time something like this were done, and I would extend the period certainly. In some of the American cities the limit is twenty years, as ten years would be too restricted. In answer to Senator O'Farrell's objection, it must be remembered that when a competitor comes in to erect a factory he is putting new business in the country, and the old factories, such as they are— and there are very few—are probably beyond any monetary consideration, because any concern that could sustain the rates in Dublin must be in a position that is practically unbreakable. This is a provision that should be very welcome in view of the volume of very desirable and very much wanted business that may ensue.

Comment on this

I am in entire agreement with the amendment, but I should like to see the period extended to 20 years. I think it would not be too much. I certainly think that anything that is an incentive to building, which will increase building at the moment, in view of the great shortage of houses, will be welcome. Senator O'Farrell's objection is a very cogent one. I think an argument against him would be the fact that a man starting business in competition with a rival whose business has been in existence for some years would be handicapped inasmuch as the rival business man has probably written off his initial debts, while the new man would have to face all the initial charges and would probably have a bank charge on his business. I do not think the amendment will have the application that Senator O'Farrell fears. I think it is very reasonable. If I were asked I think I should make it mandatory on the Minister, and I would certainly extend the period. It is so mild that I think it should have the support of every Senator.

Comment on this

The wording of the amendment seems to be very defective. This is not the first time that such a section has been introduced into an Act in this country. Some three or four years ago when loans were given for the rebuilding of the destroyed areas in Sackville Street and somewhere else in the city there was a section giving relief from rates for a certain period from the rebuilding, a remission for a few years afterwards. The present amendment is very defective in its wording. I agree with Senator O'Farrell that the wording "disused site" is very defective, and I think also that "existing factories" and "warehouses" is a very defective way of describing these. Disused sites might include sites in Sackville Street, which, although they are not occupied, are not in the real sense disused. I would suggest that if the Minister is not now opposed to the amendment, he should leave the matter over for Report and that a section somewhat similar to the one I referred to should be brought in.

Comment on this

The position is that under the Ministers and Secretaries Act this is a matter for the Minister for Finance. I am naturally interested in encouraging building as much as possible and interested in trying to advance building, whether by remission of rates or by stereotyping valuations, but of course the Minister for Finance has to consider it from an altogether different angle, as it involves property tax and the taxpayer generally. At present our Department is in communication with the Minister on this whole matter and I am not in a position to give any definite statement as to how it stands at the moment. I am inclined at the same time to think that the Department of Finance is not in favour of any remission of this kind at the present stage.

Comment on this

I quite understand the objection that the Minister has mentioned. It does affect the Minister ter for Finance inasmuch as it would affect the valuation on which his income tax would be calculated and paid, but if this amendment could be worded in such a way as to avoid that, that instead of immunity from a re-valuation, you could have the rates paid on the old valuation for five years, that is, the municipal rates, under this Bill paid at the old rate during the five years, it might meet the objection.

Comment on this

I do not think that the Minister for Finance is likely to look upon it in the light that has been suggested, because at present the area is unoccupied and pays nothing at all. It must be most disadvantageous to the business of the city that a site on which business might be carried on, and which, if built on, might relieve unemployment, is lying there disused. I think the concession suggested by Senator Brown, that they should not be charged more than the old rate, would be a very fair compromise in the matter, one that probably the Minister for Finance would look favourably on.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Would it not be desirable to leave out the words "old disused," and simply put in "vacant"?

Comment on this

I would leave it over for Report. I will try to redraft it in the meantime, though if I am to meet everybody's suggestions I am afraid I could not.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You never know.

Comment on this

There are so many suggestions that it would be impossible.

Comment on this

Would it not meet the points of objection if the Minister for Local Government were empowered to authorise councils to give a remission of such rates?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That is Senator Brown's suggestion. That is what it would come to. His suggestion is that they should pay rates on the old valuation, that the valuation be raised, but that for a certain period, say for five years, they should only pay rates on the old valuations.

Comment on this

There would be no injustice in that.

Comment on this

That is the intention of the amendment.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

It would be wiser for the Senator to withdraw his amendment for the present.

Comment on this

With your permission I will withdraw.

Comment on this

I beg to move:

Section 61. Before Section 61 to insert a new section as follows:—

"61.—(1) It is hereby declared that the issue or intended issue of an advertisement inviting or affording opportunities of applications for appointment to a paid office under or in the gift of a local authority and appointing a time for election of a person being one of those so applying, casts upon every member of that local authority a duty of being free to exercise his judgment and discretion at the time of such election by voting for such of the applicants as he shall then think fit, and that accordingly the giving by any member, or the soliciting by any person from any member, of any promise or undertaking to vote for any particular candidate or intended candidate at such election constitutes a breach of public duty on the part of such member or person (as the case may be).

(2) Any person who

(i) gives or solicits any such promise or undertaking as aforesaid; or

(ii) with a view to furthering the interests of any candidate for any such appointment as aforesaid, states that any one or more named members of the relevant local authority or any number of unnamed members of such local authority, have given promises to vote for such candidate at such appointment,

shall, on summary conviction, be liable to a fine not exceeding five pounds for a first offence, and in the case of a second or subsequent offence shall be liable to a fine not exceeding twenty pounds, and shall, in addition, be disqualified for being a member of any local authority for a term of three years from the date of such second or subsequent conviction."

The object of this amendment is to make canvassing for paid posts illegal, that is, canvassing definite promises of support from members of public bodies. I am quite conscious that that will not be an easy task. I think we should set down as our opinion that the issuing of advertisements seeking applications for paid posts casts upon every member of a public body the duty of keeping himself free to vote for the person whom he considers the best candidate. Anybody who has any experience of public bodies knows very well that it is the forced promise that is the bane of fair play. I quite realise that you cannot prevent an applicant from coming to a member, stating that he is a candidate, and what his qualifications are. There is no objection to that, but there is an objection to the candidate or his supporters trying to extort promises from the members of a public body. That is being carried on to a terrible extent in many districts in which otherwise administration is clean, and the members, as a whole, are anxious to do their duty. This eternal canvassing by relatives and friends is a terrible difficulty for members who are anxious to do the right thing to get over, and I know most members of local authorities will welcome legislation to save them from this kind of trouble. That is one aspect—extracting a definite promise which, I think, should be set down as illegal. The other is spreading a report that members of a public body are pledged to support a particular candidate. Many members of the Seanad are members of public bodies, and they know that it does a great deal of harm, and that it is very unfair against other candidates. The supporters of a candidate who are active and energetic, spread a report that their friend is promised the support of three-fourths of the members of a body. Probably these members would have given no promise at all. That acts in an unfair way against other candidates. I submit to the members of the Seanad, many of whom are members of public bodies, that it is necessary to do something to secure liberty for other people who are going up for election.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

We heard a good deal about the difficulty of making political resolutions ineffective. I am afraid that anybody who fails to do that will find it far more difficult to effect the purpose of the mover of this amendment. I suffered, as I have no doubt he did, by canvassing, and I finally adopted a method that relieved me. I put every candidate through an informal examination. I had a regular number of questions. One was columns of figures, and I timed the candidate for a clerical position in adding them up, and examined them as to their correctness, and in a very short time I had no more importunate suitors. I think that is the only way of doing it. Intelligence tests are now very much the fashion with psychological experts, and by adopting this system a member of a public body can free himself from any importunate suitors.

Comment on this

I think that if this amendment were carried it would be impossible to carry it out. Anybody who has experience of public boards knows that it is impossible to carry out a regulation like this. But the obvious remedy for canvassing is to set up an Irish Civil Service, so that competitive examinations would be held for any of these posts. Not only for these clerical and administrative posts, but in the selection of competent artisans competitive examinations should be held, and the persons with the best qualifications should get the position without any resort to canvassing. From my experience I say that if you pass this and put it into forty Acts of Parliament it will have no effect. We might as well face the facts, and these are the facts. I think if we could set our minds to devise ways and means whereby these posts should be filled after a competitive examination and that the candidate who has the best qualifications would get the job it would be better.

Comment on this

I would like strongly to support Senator Farren's suggestion. It is one that has been made over and over and over again. I am perfectly certain that it would cure a vast amount of evil that we have been suffering from, and I hope that it will be accepted with favour.

Comment on this

I do not want to increase the loss of time over an impracticable amendment like this, but I would like to say a word about the man who is canvassed. I never realised my public importance until I was approached by certain candidates, and it fills a man with a certain sense of civic spirit which he would otherwise not have. Then it gives you a lively feeling that there is the highest sense of political virtue in the men who are canvassed. If these things were removed, if the publicity were taken away from the exalted heights of civic efficiency there would be a general falling off in the standard of the men seeking election without examination. Of course this thing is perfectly impracticable, and, therefore, I think the least we say about it the better. It is one of the few things that are left us that cannot be legislated for. If they were we would find ourselves in the arid regions of Plato's Republic or More's Utopia—undesirable places.

Comment on this

Unless my memory fails me I think there is some regulation as to canvassing votes, and my recollection of it is that any man who could have been proved to have promised his vote was disqualified from voting in an election. Senators who are members of councils can say if that is the case or not. It is not so much that a man should not obtain support by canvassing, no matter what the regulations may be against it, but very often a candidate goes around and unblushingly tells you that Mr. So-and-So and Mr. So-and-So have promised him their votes. I think the fact that he would be running these friends of his into the risk of paying a fine of £5 each might check that to a certain extent.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

But is there not a remedy in the hands of every county council? All they have to do is simply to state in their advertisement that any candidate proved to have solicited or canvassed for votes shall be, ipso facto, disqualified. That is in the hands of every county council and every public body. As a matter of fact, I may say that for some years past in the great English Civil Service it has been an inflexible rule that outside influence brought to bear for an appointment is a disqualification.

Comment on this

Despite the inclusion of that in the advertisement canvassing goes on.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That is the fault of the public bodies.

Comment on this

If when you make it a condition in your advertisement you cannot stop it, I do not see how its inclusion in an Act of Parliament can stop it.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I agree, but I have never seen an advertisement that did contain that clause.

Comment on this

It is a rule in the Kilkenny County Council that that condition always goes into advertisements.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I did not know that.

Comment on this

The suggestion made by Senator Farren is really the only correct method of dealing with it. The passing of such an amendment as this is impracticable; people will not follow it. Until you have a competitive examination for these things for the whole country you will not stop it.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I might point out that no amendment is down to give effect to that, and it may be very desirable to bring in an amendment applying that principle to all appointments under this Bill.

Comment on this

I think that on Report we might insert an amendment that at all events all clerical appointments should be made by an open competitive examination, as in the Dublin Corporation. That is a very serious omission from the Bill. I quite recognise that there are some high positions that are impossible to fill by competitive examinations, but all clerical appointments could be.

Comment on this

In addition, might we not have an amendment that in advertising a vacancy that is not filled by a competitive examination any candidate who canvasses is disqualified?

Comment on this

Some counties have such a condition already. I had a resolution carried in the Limerick County Council some years ago that there should be examinations for every clerical appointment, and that some knowledge of Irish was necessary. That has always been acted upon since, and the consequence is that they have had practically no new appointments; they have been filled by promotion. I once held a competitive examination for a pensions clerk and I was so harassed by the Local Government Board and by everybody else that they would not give me pen, ink or paper, and I had to bear all the expenses of the examination myself. I got a first class exhibitioner of the Intermediate for the position, and he still enjoys it.

Comment on this

Senator Farren has made a very good suggestion. Originally I intended to have some provision in this Bill whereby all persons appointed to positions under local authorities would have to pass through something like the Civil Service Commission—local selection boards—and where appointments would be by public examination, or examination of some kind. When we went into the matter, and after we had put the provision into some kind of draft shape, we found it ran to a very considerable size. I referred to the same matter when we were discussing the county medical officer, and I found that it would be necessary to have a separate Bill dealing with this whole matter. It is quite a big business, and I do not think we would be able to deal with it thoroughly on the Report Stage. However, we may be able to deal with some specific phases of it, but there is a Bill actually in draft form at the moment. It has not yet passed Finance and the Executive Council.

Comment on this

As the feeling of the House seems to be against the amendment, I wish to withdraw it.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Apparently, then, it is to be considered on Report.

Comment on this

I move:

To delete the words "save with reference to the sanction of the Minister."

The result would be that disqualification will be absolute in reference to the adjoining counties or county boroughs, and that it will not be left to the sanction of the Minister.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I understand that the Minister is satisfied to accept this, Senator.

Comment on this

I move:—

Before Section 62 to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) Where after the passing of this Act a local authority passes a resolution either appointing a person to be an officer of that local authority or increasing the salary or emoluments of an officer of that local authority, such resolution

(a) shall have no effect until such person or officer shall within one month after the date of such resolution have made and subscribed a declaration in accordance with this section, and

(b) shall be wholly void if such person or officer fails to make and subscribe such declaration within such period of one month.

(2) The declaration to be made as aforesaid by such person or officer as aforesaid shall be made and subscribed by him before a Peace Commissioner and shall be in the following form:—

The............................. (set out the name of the local authority) having on the day of 19, passed a resolution appointing me A.B. to the office of........................ (or increasing my salary or emoluments as...............................as the case may require), I, the said A.B., do hereby solemnly and sincerely declare that I will bear allegiance to the Irish Free State and its constitution as by law established and that, in the event of such appointment being (or whether such increase is or is not as the case may require) confirmed by the Minister for Local Government and Public Health I will to the best of my judgment and ability duly and faithfully perform the duties of the (or my as the case may require) said office and will observe and obey such orders and directions in relation to such duties as shall lawfully be given to me.

(3) Nothing in this section shall prejudice or affect the operation of any enactment requiring the sanction or confirmation of any such resolution as aforesaid by the Minister for Local Government and Public Health.

I wish to make a slight alteration in the amendment, after the word "Act" in the first line to put in the words "or within a period of twelve months prior to the passing thereof." I hope that this will commend itself to the Seanad, because very few Senators can be unaware of the number of public officials who are acting in a spirit of hostility to the State, who are doing their utmost to decry and undermine it. In fact, in some parts of the country this amounts to a public scandal. It is one of the causes of the uneasiness and insecurity which prevents the country from making that progress towards stability that we would desire. One of the most damaging effects on the morale of the ordinary people and one that tends to destroy the sense of civic spirit is to see officials occupying prominent positions in the State who are at the same time spouting treason and spreading insidious propaganda against the State. I suggest it is time that some effort was made to curb the activities of these officials and to make them realise that they cannot have it both ways, that they cannot draw salaries from the State and at the same time try to upset it.

Comment on this

I support the amendment, which I think should commend itself to everybody. If at the time a man seeks an appointment he has it in his mind or in his heart to undermine the interests of his employer or to act in a spirit counter to them, it is most dishonourable and dishonest. Even if he had not these intentions at the time of seeking this employment, if afterwards he allows himself to be suborned, and acts in a spirit hostile to his employer, and particularly in such a grave matter as undermining the foundations upon which the State or the Government rests, it is more serious still, and his honest and honourable duty would be, if his convictions or point of view changed, to resign his office and seek employment elsewhere.

To take advantage of holding that office, and having facilities for discovering secrets of Government departments, and making use of those for propaganda outside tending to discredit and undermine the Government, should not be tolerated for one instant. I term that not only dishonest and dishonourable, but almost criminal in the circumstances in which this country finds itself at the moment. I feel confident this amendment will commend itself to the Seanad.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

What words did you propose to insert, Senator McLoughlin?

Comment on this

"Where after the passing of this Act, or within a period of 12 months prior to the passing thereof."

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You will want to change the word "passes" into "has passed." They could not pass now a resolution prior to the 12 months.

Comment on this

I will not insist on the alteration.

Comment on this

I oppose this amendment. We have too many oaths and pledges in this country. We must allow people some freedom of opinion. I am entirely opposed to pledges. The people who make most pledges are those who break most pledges. These pledges have always been a failure. Since they were invented 60 or 70 years ago you have had a series of broken pledges, and the less pledges we have the better. People who take pledges sometimes change their minds and forget them.

Comment on this

I am inclined to agree with Senator Colonel Moore. The British tried this method of imposing oaths of allegiance and everyone will agree that they were a hopeless failure. We have condemned the exacting in Northern Ireland of an oath from people holding public offices. These are not Government positions in the strict sense of the word at all. An oath taken under duress is of very little value, and many a man in order to keep his family will take the oath under duress, but it is not going to bind his conscience afterwards. I do not think people should be put up against a position of that kind. If we are not able to induce allegiance to the State by voluntary methods, we are not going to do it by the imposition of an oath. I think we are virtually passing a vote of no confidence in the stability of the State and its continued existence by proposing an amendment of this kind. The moral effect of it is not going to be in the interests of the State and its direct effect will be absolutely nugatory.

Comment on this

It is not so much the imposition of the oath that counts as the putting an end to the position of the hero who wants to have it both ways and the effect the taking of the oath will have on his heroics in various parts of the country. There are, to my own knowledge, one or two men drawing salaries from the Government who parade themselves in the West of Ireland as people looking for a Republic and doing this as a sort of afterthought. At the same time they are receiving their salaries. If the finger that points at oath-takers can also point at them it will be impossible for them to keep up this deception. There are certain persons who make a great to-do about this matter, as if the oath taken now were not for the benefit of the people of the country.

It is no longer a parallel to speak of the imposition of an oath on that section of people in the North who do not regard themselves as permanently within its borders. This oath taken by the officials employed by the Free State that they will be loyal to the Free State will prevent their undermining the Free State and inflicting injury on everyone in it. That effect we will get by making it incumbent on every official or employee to take an oath to give good service and not to promote insecurity. I am not at all anxious that anyone should take an oath against his will. It is not so much for the sake of the oath as for defining the position of the man employed by the State, who is against the State, that I support Senator McLoughlin. If a man parades as a Republican from any form of confused mentality—arising, perhaps, from the intermediate system —if he parades as one who tries to injure the hand that feeds him, the hypocrisy will be apparent, because it will be in the region of dishonesty.

Comment on this

I am strongly in favour of this amendment, and I think Senator Gogarty has put his finger on the right spot when he says it is not so much aimed at the political views of these people as against their dishonesty. There are a number of people parading in the country as being opponents of the Government and of the system of local authority operating under the Government, and yet they are drawing money which they could not draw but for the fact that the Government is functioning. This will make them come forward and state whether they are in favour of existing conditions or not. They may take the oath and say they take it under duress, but if they do they can only masquerade as a very poor type of hero. A man who masquerades as a hero and is afraid to give up his position in order to support his opinion is not going to get much support. I am placed in a difficult position as Minister for Local Government in sanctioning the appointments of men who all along are trying to obstruct the work of the Government. Take the instance of a county surveyor who happens to be opposed to the present Government. When grants are given, complaints are made to me that the grants are being frittered away and that the county surveyor is not trying to get the best results out of the money granted. I am not in a position to take action against that individual. The same thing applies to rate collectors and others. This will define clearly the position of these people. If they accept a post under the Government and take this oath, they cannot masquerade as great heroes, and that will be to the advantage of the general public.

Comment on this

This declaration is to apply to persons about to be appointed, or a person about to receive some increase of salary, or something else like that. That is not going to meet the case at all. It is only dealing with some people who may be going into the service or who, already in the service, are entitled to some emolument or promotion. I do not believe in those declarations, and I suggest that what is needed in this country more than anything else is a little Christian charity. I think the time has arrived when instead of aggravating the position, we should try to heal the sore, and I say that if you pass this, you will have more trouble. A similar attempt to this was made by the British Government when they were in occupation, and we know the effect of it was that a few men refused to take the oath, but the great bulk of the civil servants took the oath, even though they did not believe in it. A few men did not take the oath, because their conscience would not allow them, but they were very few, and you could count them on the fingers of your hands.

I read last week in connection with the Northern Government that a Catholic chaplain of some hospital, because he refused to make a declaration which was against his conscience, was refused the salary he was entitled to. Somebody says, "Quite right." I say, "Quite wrong." You employ a person to do certain work. You do not employ him because of his particular brand of politics. You employ him because of his efficiency in carrying out certain work, and not because he is prepared to take certain oaths.

I am satisfied, from my experience, that the people who take the oath would not be half as good servants as the people who would not take the oath, and I think that at this time of day there is no use in adding more fuel to the fire. We have had sufficient trouble in this country without coming along and taking a man's bread and butter from him because he differs politically with us.

Comment on this

I do not know whether Senator Farren has read the amendment. It simply declares: "I ... do hereby solemnly and sincerely declare that I will bear allegiance to the Irish Free State and its constitution as by law established." Surely, he does not suggest—and I hope nobody will suggest—that a man who will not sign that declaration should continue to receive money from the State or from a local body. It is very sad that it should be necessary, but I am afraid from what we have heard of the state of affairs in some parts of Ireland, that it is necessary. It is a blot on the Bill for the reason that it must refer to a transitory state of things, but it is necessary in order to prevent various officials from receiving pay and boasting of their disloyalty.

Comment on this

Senator Farren can hardly have read the amendment.

Comment on this

I did.

Comment on this

He talks of depriving a man of his bread and butter. There is nothing in the amendment calling for the dismissal of a man who does not make the declaration. It is not a case of throwing out a man already in a job, but it is designed for the man selected for a new job, and for the man receiving an increase of salary or emoluments. Where a man has done his work very efficiently, he is entitled to an increase. But if the man is plotting against the interests of the State, surely he is not entitled to an increase. You are not depriving a man of his job.

Comment on this

I wish to oppose this amendment on very well defined grounds. To me, the imposition of this declaration on any man is tyrannical and reactionary. A man may be an efficient county surveyor or other servant of the local authority, and may not quite agree with the Free State or the present Government as the be all and end all. As one great man said, "No man can put a boundary to the march of a nation." Consequently, I think the introduction of an amendment on those lines is most reactionary.

The Minister made a great case in connection with a county surveyor who differs with the present Government. He may be a competent county surveyor, but he may not agree with things as they are. I hope the majority will never agree with things as they are, and that they will always look ahead. If a man does not agree with the present condition of things, he is to be branded as an outlaw and denied the emoluments which may be allotted to him by the council in authority over him.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister if it is anticipated that certain people to whom he objects now, and to whom the Senators object, may in a very short time be in a majority here? If you impose a pledge or an oath on people when you are in power, they may impose a pledge, too, when they are in power. In what position would we all be then?

Comment on this

"As by law established."

Comment on this

You will find yourselves in a very unpleasant position. It may be "law established" the other way. I am not prepared to swear one way one minute and another way another minute. I know those oaths have been unsatisfactory and of no use. Probably the first pledge taken in this country was taken about seventy years ago. At a meeting of Irish Members of Parliament they pledged themselves to certain things we need not go into now. One Member said he did not believe in pledges and that they were generally broken. It happened just one year after that he was able to get up and say that the pledge was broken by all except himself. He was the only man who kept the pledge. We are here to make friends with all people and not to make ourselves objectionable to them by forcing our opinions down their throats. The effect of this oath will be the throwing out of honest men and the putting in of dishonest ones. Dishonest men will take oaths of any kind, but honest men will not take them and are left out.

Comment on this

In spite of the dire predictions of Senator Moore, I hope the Seanad will pass the amendment. Nobody listening to Senator Moore and the other Senators opposing the amendment would ever dream that they took an oath themselves. I do not see why others should not follow their good example and take a declaration of allegiance.

The great objection against this declaration is that the British insisted on it and that Northern Ireland insisted on it. The circumstances are quite different. This country repudiated British rule. The Parliament of Northern Ireland is a body which repudiates the idea of an Irish nation. It is an exotic creation, for the establishment of which not a single Irish Member voted, and therefore not a single Irishman owes it allegiance. But it is quite a different proposition when the Free State is the creation of the majority will of the Irish people. In asking these officials to take an oath of allegiance to the Free State, we are only asking them to take an oath to the sovereign authority of the Irish people.

Comment on this

Before the Seanad passes the amendment, as I presume it will, I would ask them to contemplate the absurdity of having one set of officials oath-bound—the people whose fidelity is really questioned—and another set of officials absolutely free. Those officials who are coming in will be oath-bound, but those officials who are in and whose bona fides are questioned will be free.

Comment on this
A SENATOR

Give them an increase.

Comment on this

I would like to know if we could amend the marginal note to Section 62. The note at present is "Power to dissolve a local authority." That is objectionable. I suggest that it should be "Power to hold local inquiries and power to dissolve a local authority." This Section does more than give the Minister power to dissolve a local authority. It gives power to hold a local inquiry and it is not to be assumed that local authorities do not desire inquiries when necessary.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The marginal note, you suggest, should read, "Power to dissolve a local authority and power to hold a local inquiry." My recollection is—I speak subject to the correction of Senator Brown—that the marginal note has been held to be no part of the Act. It is merely an ornament or a disfigurement, as the case may be.

Comment on this

I am satisfied if the Minister will consider the matter.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment by Senator McLoughlin put.

Tá 23
·
Níl 9
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I beg to move:

Section 62, sub-section (5). In line 40 to delete the words "three years" and to substitute therefor the words "one year."

The object of the amendment is, in the event of the Minister having to exercise his powers for the purpose of dissolving a local body, that within a period of one year an election shall be held for the purpose of electing the local authority. I think that is a reasonable amendment. Under the Bill at present if the Minister dissolves a local authority the people are disfranchised for three years, and the duties of the public authority will be carried out by some person appointed by the Minister. For three years the people who are paying the piper are deprived of the privilege of calling the tune. In other words, the people of a local area are deprived for three years of deciding who should conduct their local affairs. That is a reasonable amendment, and ought to be accepted by the Government, unless they have made up their minds that the people are not fitted for self-government. The amendment provides that within one year an election shall be held. If the members of a local board have not carried out their duties properly the people who are paying the rates will get an opportunity of electing other people to carry out their duty. Unless you are going to set up an autocracy, so that the people of the country shall not have any say in local affairs, this amendment ought to be accepted.

Comment on this

I have an amendment down which I think is of a more democratic and popular character than this. I propose that before the Minister holds the new election he has to take a plebiscite of the electors as to whether they would prefer the continuance of the administration of their district by Commissioners or have a new election held. Democratic government has been defined as government in accordance with the wishes of the people, and I do not see any possibility of ascertaining the wishes of the people as to what form of government they wish except by taking a referendum. I am sure every democrat here is going to support the principle I suggest. I should not be surprised if the results would occasionally surprise.

I remember many years ago, a public body in Cork was suppressed by the Local Government Board and Commissioners appointed to carry out their duties. Every local body immediately held meetings to denounce the suppression of this body. At the end of twelve months it was found that the Commissioners had effected a very large saving—something like £60,000 or £70,000. They had put the affairs of the local authority in order. All the local bodies met again and passed resolutions congratulating the Commissioners. When the term of the Commissioners expired, the local bodies came together and they passed a resolution asking the Local Government Board to continue the Commissioners and the L.G.B. had to tell them that they had not the power. I do not want our present Minister to be in that position. If the local people desire a continuance of government by Commissioners, I want the Minister to be in a position to continue them and not have to say that he had no power.

Comment on this

I wish to opposo the amendment. If Senator Farren has read this section, he has not expressed himself very clearly on it. The section does not prevent the Minister from holding an election within twelve months.

Comment on this

If he wants to.

Comment on this

There are other ways by which the public can make their opinion felt. There is the Dáil, and the Seanad and the public Press. It is strange how sensitive Governments become to currents of public opinion if they have any volume. The Corporations of Dublin and Cork have been suppressed. Speaking as a Corkman, and knowing something about the matter, I am certain that the suppression of the Cork Corporation was responsible for winning the pending election for the Government at that time. There was a tremendous amount of inflation—if I might use the word in this connection—in order to create some sort of bogus indignation with regard to the suppression of these Corporations. I never remember anything falling so flat. Those agitations fell flat because the public fully appreciated that the suppression of these Corporations was belated rather than premature. Everybody who was not quite blind recognised that they were inefficient and in many cases corrupt. The Government suppressed these bodies after public inquiry. If there is any volume of opinion in favour of an election, this section gives the Minister power to hold it. I ask the Seanad not to tie his hands by compelling him to do that within twelve months, if the task of the Commissioner is not completed.

Comment on this

I have an amendment, something on the lines of that proposed by Senator Farren. That is an amendment of the General Council of County Councils. The attitude of that council with regard to the suppression of local bodies is that they are affected in their personnel. Each county council dissolved automatically wipes out two or three representatives of the General Council. That is one aspect of the matter. They are losing their representative capacity. To that extent certain counties are not represented on the General Council now.

With regard to the general principle of suppression and the power that the Minister has to dissolve, it is a moot point as to whether the business of local bodies could not be better conducted by thoroughly competent administrators. It is a moot point whether, if a plebiscite were taken in Dublin, it would result in showing there was a keen desire to revert again to a Corporation. That is a matter that has to be tested and tried.

On the broad question of the right of the Minister to dissolve public bodies after inquiry, if he wishes to pursue that policy, which is such a radical change from all that has gone before, I would say that he has not sufficient mandate—that the people should have some voice in that. If the people were asked, in view of their experience of councils already dissolved, and the benefits accruing to the ratepayers through these dissolutions—at least on paper—I do not say that the people might not say that is the correct course to pursue. Then it comes to the point whether the people should not have some voice in the appointment of the Commissioners who are to control their affairs, whether a panel should not be set up, say of thirty— like the Burgomasters in Germany— and from that panel the Minister should select his men. There would be a certain qualification for men wishing to get on the panel. They should be men of a very high standard of administrative and other ability. These men should be elected by the nation. Then you would have the nation as a whole having a voice in local administration, and you would have the most able and most highly qualified men to take up the administration of these councils.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You are travelling a little away from the amendment.

Comment on this

I support that, for practically it means that I can withdraw my own amendment if this is carried. My amendment is at the next election for local bodies that the suppressed bodies shall go in with the others, and that there shall be an election all round. These elections will be held within a year, and that would dispose of my amendment. At the same time I think as the question has been raised we had better know where we are in this matter. I see a way out of it. The people as a whole would possibly support it, for they would still have a voice, though not in the same detailed way as at present, in electing the members of County Councils and Corporations. In that sense I support the amendment.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I do not think this is an appropriate occasion to discuss the relative merits of popularly-elected local authorities and those appointed by the central authority. The whole principle is one that wants to be challenged, but that need not be gone into now. This amendment has a distinctly practical bearing, which I suggest the House should decide. The Minister is not going to dissolve a local body except its affairs have got into a bad way, that rates have got considerably into arrears, and considerable confusion has thereby resulted. It is quite out of the question to expect any body of administrators to clear up a mess like that in one year. Anybody who has an elementary knowledge of administration must know that. It is hard to fix the period required, but I would say that a year is not sufficient. For that reason alone I suggest the amendment should be defeated.

Comment on this

I am not able to support Senator Farren's amendment. I think with Sir John Keane, that a longer term should be allowed to the Commissioners. The question is an important one, especially as regards those districts where the Corporations have ceased to exist, and the Commissioners have been installed. I entirely agree with Senator Dowdall that there is an immense amount of satisfaction in Cork and the neighbourhood because of the fact that the Commissioner is functioning there to the satisfaction of the vast majority of the people, including most of the members of the Corporation itself. Many of those gentlemen who were relieved of the onerous duties that were placed on them were capable public men, and endeavoured conscientiously to carry out their duties. Owing largely to the state of affairs in the country during the last few years, and also because the triennial elections had not taken place, things got into a state that would not have otherwise happened. With regard to Senator Barrington's amendment, may I allude to the question of referendum?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

No, we are not dealing with the question of referendum now.

Comment on this

I should like simply to remind the House that the privilege of elected bodies is a privilege that has been dearly won in past generations, and should not be lightheartedly and thoughtlessly laid aside. I hope when the Commissioner has completed his work that an election will take place, and that possibly there will be new arrangements, by which the Corporation would have the great advantage of having a man like the present Commissioner acting in some official position, such as a managing director.

Comment on this

Before you put the amendment, has the Minister anything to say on it?

Comment on this

I am opposed to it.

Comment on this

With reference to some of the statements made here by Senator Barrington regarding a referendum, I wonder would he be prepared to submit to a referendum the right of the Minister to dissolve these councils. Senator Sir John Keane says this whole question ought to be raised. I am not opposed to a change in the method of local administration. If it means greater efficiency I am in favour of it. What I am opposed to is allowing any individual to set himself up as a dictator, and saying: "I am the only pure person in this country. There are none of the local authorities in this country pure enough to carry on the work for which they were elected, if I say so." It has been said that inquiries were held, but the least said about these inquiries the better. If I wanted to, I could talk about some inquiries, or some people appointed Commissioners, and could make some people ashamed. It was not because of their qualifications for carrying out their duties they were appointed in some cases. Now the people have a right to be consulted on this question as to whether or not the people should elect representatives to manage their affairs. That is the fundamental issue involved in this. I do not think that we should light-heartedly give power to anybody to say the people have no right in the spending of the rates that they have contributed. Make no mistake about it, some people might be prepared to advocate the non-payment of rates if they are to have no say in the manner in which the rates should be spent. That is not beyond the bounds of possibility, and these people would be quite justified in doing so. Senator Sir John Keane spoke about getting into arrears, but in Dublin they were not in arrears. They had a record collection. Ninety-eight per cent. was the collection in Dublin during the past five or six years, and that record, considering what Dublin has gone through in the past few years, is splendid and one that any city could be proud of. I think Senator Mrs. Wyse Power will agree with that. The rates were paid, and it was not because the rates in Dublin were in arrears that the Corporation was suppressed. If the people in Dublin were paying rates that was proof positive that they were satisfied. Senators may say "Oh," but the people have not got an opportunity of expressing their opinion on this matter. Senator Dowdall told us that the Government candidate in Cork won because the Corporation was suppressed. I might just as well use the contrary argument, and say that the Government lost the last election in Dublin because the Corporation was suppressed. You cannot have it both ways. The fundamental question is, should the people who pay the rates have nothing to say in deciding the manner in which the money should be spent. The appointment of local managers may be a success. If I were satisfied that another system is better I would support it. I do not hold any mandate for public boards. It is not because I was a member of a suppressed board I am speaking as I am on this fundamental question, but I am thinking that the Oireachtas will be making a sad mistake in taking away the rights of the people.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 8
·
Níl 19
Result _

Do you agree with this result?