We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

SEANAD IN COMMITTEE. - LOCAL GOVERNMENT BILL, 1924. THIRD STAGE (RESUMED).

Contributions 1–142 of 288. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Local Government Bill 1924
Withdrawn

No. 18 of 1924 ›

John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

Would my amendment 71a come under consideration at this stage? I submit it as an amendment that does not impose any charge on the Central Fund and is not governed by the same considerations as were connected with a previous amendment of mine.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I do not think your amendment could be considered now. Its consideration was left over. The idea was that if provision is to be made, as suggested by your previous amendment to an earlier section, as to the distribution of this fund, then this amendment would probably not be in order or not be required.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I agree that would be so if the other amendment were carried.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Therefore it would be a mistake to discuss it now I stated I would give you full liberty to deal with the matter on the Report Stage. You see it would conflict with your previous amendment, if accepted.

SECTION 31.

(1) The Minister may make regulations prescribing:—

(a) the nature and quality of the materials which may be used in the maintenance and construe, on of roads;

(b) the size, shape, colour, and character of the signs to be erected on roads for the purpose of—

(i) indicating the places to which the road leads, and the distances to such places;

(ii) indicating the distances on the road;

(iii) warning persons using the road of dangerous portions thereof;

(iv) guiding traffic on the road with a view to minimising the risk of accidents;

(c) the places at which the several signs hereinbefore mentioned are to be erected;

(d) the conditions upon which such signs as aforesaid may be erected or retained on land adjoining any road by the owner or occupier thereof;

(e) the signals by which persons using roads can indicate their intentions to other such persons.

(2) Every regulation made under this section shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas as soon as may be after it is made, and if a resolution is passed by either House of the Oireachtas within the next subsequent twenty-one days on which such House has sat after the regulation is laid before it annulling the regulation, the regulation shall be annulled accordingly but without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done under such regulation.

(3) The council entrusted by this Act with the maintenance of any road—

(a) shall not use in the maintenance of such road any material of a nature or quality contrary to regulations made under this section, and

(b) shall erect and maintain on such road such and so many of the signs prescribed by the regulations made under this section and in such places as shall be necessary to comply with such regulations, and

(c) shall not erect on such road any sign in contravention of such regulations.

(4) The expenses of a council in erecting any sign in accordance with such regulations as aforesaid on any road and of maintaining such sign shall be part of the expenses of the maintenance of that road.

(5) If it appears to a Justice of the District Court that any sign such as is referred to in this section is erected or retained on land adjoining any road contrary to any regulation made under this section, he may on the application of any police officer or of any officer of the council to whom the maintenance of such road is entrusted by this Act, order the removal of such sign, and, if he thinks it advisable, by such order authorise such officer to enter on such land for the purpose of removing such sign.

(6) If any person without lawful authority, removes, defaces, or otherwise injures any such sign as is mentioned in this section, he shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding ten pounds or, at the discretion of the court, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding one month.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

"Section 31, sub-section (1). To delete paragraph (d)."

It seems to me the meaning of this paragraph is very doubtful. Can the Minister say if it means that the local authority has power to enter on land to erect signs and is the owner compelled to keep them in order, or does it mean the local authority has power to remove any signs erected by the owner?

Comment on this

The object of the section is that if the owner of property wishes to erect any signs, he can only do so if he fulfils those conditions. It is not intended to place any obligation on the owner to put up signs. It is merely a restrictive clause.

Comment on this

I take it the owner is not allowed to put up any signs without authority, including advertisements or anything of that kind?

Comment on this

Not signs of that kind?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Clause (d) only relates to such signs as are enumerated or described in the previous sub-section.

Comment on this

In that case I would ask leave to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 70:—

Section 31. Page 18, line 40.

After sub-section (1) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(2) The Minister shall have power to prescribe, by regulations made under this section, conditions under which any such sign as hereinbefore mentioned may be erected on land adjoining a public road without the consent of the owner or occupier when erection on such adjoining land and not on any part of the road itself is reasonably necessary or desirable for the purposes of any such sign."

The purpose of this amendment is to give the Minister power over the erection of signs on land adjacent to the main road, when it is not possible to erect such signs on the main road. There is no power taken to erect signs without the consent of the owner of the land. I think the Minister should have power to erect such signs when it is not feasible to have them erected on the road. We all recognise nowadays, with a big amount of motor traffic on the roads, it is absolutely necessary that signs warning users of the roads of the danger points, and that sort of thing, should be erected. If it is necessary to erect these signs on the lands adjacent to the main road, I think the Minister should have power to erect them.

Comment on this

In cases like this, I think the owner of the land should not be liable for any damage to the signs. Now, suppose you take a case where a sign was erected, and that sign was damaged by the cattle, I do not see how it can be said that the owner should be liable.

Comment on this

I have not got any decided objection to this amendment. It is a matter entirely for the opinion of the Seanad. I do not think that an occasion will very often arise where it will be necessary to avail of this. It is just possible that the occasion might arise when it would be good to have this power. I am not very particular about it.

Comment on this

I quite appreciate that the occasion will not often arise, but I think that it is just as well the Minister should have this power.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That seems to be the Minister's own view. He has no objection to the amendment, and he thinks it might be useful in isolated cases.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 73 to Section 31, sub-section (6). It reads:—

After this sub-section to insert a new sub-section (7) as follows:—

"(7) The council entrusted by this Act with the maintenance of any road may, with the approval of the Minister, make a by-law regulating the maximum speed of mechanically propelled vehicles travelling on the road, and fix different maximum speeds for vehicles of different weights, and if any owner or driver of a vehicle acts in contravention of such by-law, such owner and driver shall be guilty of an offence under this section, and each shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a penalty not exceeding ten pounds."

In the papers every day, we read of accidents having occurred, deaths taking place, and sometimes serious injuries inflicted, by the speed at which motor cars pass over the country. In my opinion it is very desirable that the body having charge of the roads should have power to make these by-laws. Now, these by-laws will not be effective unless they have the concurrence of the Minister. I cannot see that there should be any objection to that. It is a reasonable section to have inserted in the Bill, and I therefore move it.

Comment on this

I very much doubt whether it would be desirable to give each county council in the country the power of fixing the speed at which the various vehicles are to travel. I am rather of opinion that the Ministry or some Department of the Ministry has the power to define these things. If you leave it to each county council you will have one speed limit in County Dublin and another speed limit in the County Kildare, and the motorist may not know exactly, when he is crossing the border from one county into another, what is the different speed limit fixed, and where it has to be observed. It seems to me undesirable that power should be given to each separate county council to fix the speed limit. It would be very much more desirable if the power were retained in the hands of the Ministry.

Comment on this

I think there is a great deal in what Senator Barrington has said. I think it would be well to have general rules issued with regard to this matter of speed. At the present time we have very ample powers in this respect. We have power to prevent various kinds of traffic on particular roads. We have power to regulate the speed of motor-propelled vehicles on particular roads, and we also have power to lay down regulations as to the speed limits of all vehicles of over two tons. The code is distributed over different Statutes, and it is not very easy at the present time to get at the full implication of the code. No doubt an amendment would be very desirable to the present code, but I think it would be very much better to leave control in the hands of the Ministry rather than in the hands of the local authorities. Perhaps, if an amendment were brought in on the Report Stage we might be able to meet the views of all parties in this matter.

Comment on this

This sub-section which I propose makes it practically impossible for counties to have different speed limits, because none of them can make a bye-law unless with the consent of the Ministry. The Minister can see that the rates of speed in each county will be the same. The Minister says that power already exists for regulating speed. That power exists in the Ministry, but it does not seem to me to have been effectively put into force. If it were, so many serious accidents would not have occurred all over the country. If this new section is inserted it will empower the county councils to initiate bye-laws which may, afterwards, be considered by the Minister and amended, or approved of, as he may think fit. I think the initiative in the matter of making bye-laws ought to be left with the county councils.

Comment on this

As the amendment is drafted, it will mean a considerable overlapping in the present law, and for that reason alone it would be well to leave it over to the Report Stage, when some amendment might be agreed upon with a view to co-ordinating traffic speed.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied with the Minister's undertaking, and the matter can be left over to the RePort Stage.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

In any event you ought to alter the wording of the proposed sub-section. It should read "make by-laws" instead of "make a by-law." It will be very difficult to put all this into one by-law. However, the matter is now being held over until the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

"Section 33, sub-section (3), line 39. After the word "may" to insert the words "on the request of the county council."

The sub-section, if it stands, will give power to the Minister to terminate a direct labour scheme any time he likes or to continue it for ever. I think that if any change has to be made it should be made with the consent of the county council. That is the object of the amendment.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I support the amendment. I think the principle involved in the section is most dangerous, and I would ask Senators who have not read the section to do so very carefully. It gives power to the Minister to continue any scheme in force on the 23rd December to any date he likes. That seems to say that all control of the local authority over direct labour schemes is taken away from them, and, furthermore, as regards any direct labour scheme introduced after the 23rd December, as I read the section, it can be continued in force until such a period as the Minister wishes. Thus, if a new county council comes into power and finds a direct labour scheme which it considered unduly extravagant, it will not have power, except with the consent of the Minister, to put an end to it. It seems to me to be a most arbitrary provision, and it takes away from the local authority control over matters for which it has been elected by the ratepayers.

Comment on this

I would like to put the contrary position to that just put forward. I do not think that it is fair to put into the Minister's hands power to dictate to the county council as to what methods they should adopt in making or maintaining roads. I suggest that the county council in each area will be the best judge as to the best methods. I object to the clause as it stands, and I believe that the county council, on the advice of the surveyors, ought to be the best judge as to whether the roads should be made and maintained by direct labour or by contract.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You are not quite in order, and you are, in fact, a little late. The sub-section with which the amendment deals is sub-section 3, and that assumes that sub-sections 1 and 2 have been passed. If they are passed, the section would sanction the proposal that every direct labour scheme is subject to the approval of the Minister. If you want to raise that point your proper course would be to propose the deletion of the section. We are dealing with sub-section 3, which only deals with the Minister exercising such powers, whereas you are objecting to giving him such powers. That should be challenged in sub-section 1.

Comment on this

I am not very particular about the wording of this section. If Senators Farren and Sir John Keane are in agreement with the amendment, I am willing to accept it. I am not seeking arbitrary powers. In the ordinary course of events I would consult with the councils as to how long such schemes should be kept in force.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

If the amendment is to be adopted I think it will need alteration. It provides that the period appointed by the Minister under the Section may be extended. The amendment is that extension is to be made at the request of a county council. The concluding words of the sub-section gives the Minister power to curtail it. I think the Senator intended to put in the same thing, so that the concluding words would be "any extension thereof under this section may at any time on the like request." The amendment otherwise would be a halting one.

Comment on this

I adopt your suggestion.

Comment on this

On behalf of Senator O'Farrell, I move:—

In line 66, after the word "means" to insert the words "a School Attendance Committee."

The object of the amendment is to give power to local authorities to pension school attendance officers. On a previous occasion this matter was referred to here, and it was pointed out that school attendance officers were being unfairly treated in comparison with other employees of public bodies. I am not familiar with the position in the country, but I am familiar with the position in Dublin, where the school attendance officers are whole-time officers. Some of them have up to 25 years' service, but, as the law stands, there is no power given to the local authority to pension these officers. The local authority pays their salaries but has no power to pension them. I think it is grossly unfair to these officials not to put them in the same position as other employees of the local authorities. Under the 1905 Act, the Dublin Corporation got powers to pension every employee, no matter what his occupation, after a certain number of years' service. Under the special Act dealing with the school attendance officers local authorities have not that power. Their case has been mentioned on several occasions, and we are now taking advantage of the Bill to try and right a wrong. It is wrong that any section of employees should be debarred from receiving superannuation when others are entitled to receive it. In England under an Act of 1922 these officers are made pensionable, and under the Education Act of Northern Ireland they are also made pensionable. I think the same treatment should be meted out to the school attendance officers in this country as in England. So far as I know, there are only thirty people affected by this amendment, and I say that it is unfair to make this invidious distinction between one employee and another.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You are dealing with clause 36, line 66. As it stands at present, the only local body that is excluded is the committee of management of a district lunatic asylum.

Comment on this

It says "except."

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Yes, that is the only body excluded.

Comment on this

Yes, but school attendance officers are employed under a special Act and they have been debarred from receiving pensions. Their salaries, as I have said, are payable by the local authorities who have not power to pension them, and the object of the amendment is to give them power to do so.

Comment on this

I think it would be well that the Seanad would understand that these officers are not employees of local authorities in the same sense as others are. They are appointed by the Schools Committees, composed of different people, some of whom are members of the local authority. They are not really under the local authority. When the School Attendance Act was set up and these positions were made available for men and women, there was no medical or competitive examination attached to the post and there was no age limit. Some of them have been there for 25 years, but there were no pensionable rights attached to the office when they were elected. It may be hard or it may be soft, but there it is; they are entirely different to employees under the local authorities. I think if you begin to pension these people you will have to set up a proper scheme whereby future applicants will be elected, and in that future scheme you will have to have an age limit as well as competitive and medical examinations. So far as Dublin is concerned these little posts have been in the main kept for widows who have fallen on hard times. If you set up a scheme of examination some of these widows would not be eligible for these posts. In my opinion they are the best people for this class of work, and are better probably than people who would pass an examination. For that reason I am anxious that this service should be allowed free to the widows of employees of local authorities and others for whom these posts are a god-send by enabling them to rear their children.

Comment on this

This proposal is, I think, worthy of some consideration. The argument that these appointments when made were not hampered by any conditions as to a medical or competitive examination may be very sound, but there are instances in which other appointments were not pensionable at the time they were made and were made pensionable afterwards by legislation. We have done so ourselves. I understand that there are many truant officers, or school attendance officers, who are part-time officials, and I understand from the proposer that these are not included in his amendment.

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

Senator Farren says that there would be only about thirty people affected. I understand that seventeen of these are functioning in the City and County of Dublin. Although these officers are not appointed by the Corporation they are paid out of Corporation funds. It is generally admitted, especially in the country, that school attendance officers are paid a poor salary. I think £2 a week would be the outside. Most of these officers have large families, and if they were deprived of their position, or if they died, their wives and children would be left destitute. These officers comply in every way with the conditions imposed on civil servants and are whole-time officials. If an investigation was made I think it would be found that they should be brought within the category of officers whose cases deserve consideration for pensions.

The general practice of not allowing public bodies to make some pension provision for their officials is not, I think, to be commended. We have no pension scheme in Waterford, so that the Corporation has to give employees with forty or fifty years' service, and who are physically unfit for work, a broom and tell them to hide themselves in the park and to return with the broom in the evening. That has a very bad moral effect on all the other employees. We cannot discharge all these old officials, or send them out on the streets, and at the same time we have no power to pension them. We tried to keep them on half time or on half pay. It is a humiliating position, both for the Corporation and the employees, whereas if we had the right to give them pensions we could make some provision for them. As only thirty-one existing officers are whole-time officers and will be affected by the amendment I think it deserves consideration by the Minister.

Comment on this

Senator Kenny has drawn a very harrowing picture of these officers. We are told that there are only thirty-one of them who would be pensionable.

Comment on this

They are not all whole-time officers.

Comment on this

I would like to know if they were appointed as whole-time officers, or is it the exigencies of their work that makes them whole-time officers. If that is the case every officer who is appointed a half-time officer will say that his duties will require him for the full time. After a while the amendment would include every school attendance officer. I would like to be informed whether these people were appointed as full-time officers, and if they were not satisfied to go into the position when it did not carry the advantages of superannuation. I agree that superannuation should be given in nearly every case, but these people went into the position with their eyes open and without a pension.

Comment on this

I desire to support the amendment. School attendance officers perform very onerous and responsible public duties. They are engaged on practically the same terms as every public official who is pensionable. They do not understand why they should not receive superannuation allowance. Senator Mrs. Wyse Power said that these officials had not to pass an examination. That is not my information. I have it from some of these officials that they had to go before a medical officer and get a certificate from him. They had also to get testimonials as to character.

Comment on this

They are easily got.

Comment on this

They also have to have some literary ability. Some of the duties that they perform include surprise visits to the homes of the children, visits to the schools, investigation of absentees, preparation of a census of children eligible for attendance at school, serving warning notices on parents, serving summonses on parents to appear before the School Attendance Committee, issuing and applying for summonses to police courts and proving them without any legal assistance whatever, filling up warrants for fines, and attending Children's Street Trading Courts.

These people are full-time officers, and this Bill is only to apply to whole-time officers. Their work in Dublin lasts from 10 in the morning until 5 in the evening, except Saturday, when the hours are from 10 to 1. They perform their duties in very uncongenial surroundings, and unfortunately are brought very much into the slums of Dublin. They have to visit homes where there is squalor and possibly disease. There is no reason, as far as I can see, why these people should not get some pensionable allowance. I agree with Senator Mrs. Wyse Power that the school attendance committees provide this employment for people who would otherwise be destitute. I think that is a blot in the scheme. I think that no person should be appointed to any particular office without that person's qualifications being properly studied. The public service should not be carried on on philanthropic lines. From time to time the school attendance committees have recommended that these officials should receive pensions. The Dublin Corporation made such a recommendation in 1907.

Comment on this

Did it pass?

Comment on this

No, as it was mixed up in a Bill in which there was some contentious question. The Bill was not turned down because they were going to give pensions to these officers. School attendance officers go into the slums and look after the children of the poor to see if they are attending school. They also go before benevolent societies in order to obtain clothes for poor children and in some cases supply clothing, so that school will not be missed. In 1900 the average school attendance of those of school age was 60 per cent. It is now 80 per cent. While these officers may not claim that they were responsible for the improvement in school attendance it is only fair that they should claim portion of the credit. I think the recommendations of the various committees should be considered and that suitable superannuation should be provided for these officers.

Comment on this

If there was a prospect of creating very many potential pensioners I would not support the amendment. As only a limited number of men are involved, men who have been led to consider themselves to some extent part of the machinery of education, inasmuch as they have to pursue small boys who do not go to school and on whose reports prosecutions ensue, I will support it. I think we might leave the matter to the discretion of the Minister. This is an ad miseri-cordiam appeal and it prevents these men having a grievance when grievances should not exist. A man cannot say that he gave his life's work to the duties if he did not do so. I do not think the Minister will object to including these men in a scheme for pensions.

Comment on this
Earl of Kerry The EARL of KERRY Independent

The intention of the amendment, I understand, is to make school attendance officers eligible for pensions, but if it is passed in its present form will it not do a great deal more? It makes school attendance committees local bodies within the meaning of the Bill. I submit that the amendment might do more than is intended by the mover, if school attendance committees were made local bodies.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That seems to be so, but the Minister will probably be able to tell us how the matter stands.

Comment on this

As Senator the Earl of Kerry has pointed out, school attendance committees do not come under the heading of local authorities at all. If there was any question of accepting the amendment it would have to be very carefully considered as to what its effect would be on subsequent and on preceding sections. I have a very strong objection to accepting the amendment. It creates a new type of pensionable officer and brings in those who are not officers of local authorities at all. It is really a matter that ought be dealt with by the Ministry of Education. That Ministry is bringing in a new Bill, I understand, dealing with the whole question of compulsory education, and these officers may become unnecessary under it. As Senator Mrs. Wyse Power pointed out, these are people who, if they had to pass medical and written examinations in the ordinary way, as well as the usual tests that officials of local authorities have to pass before being appointed, would probably have to go out on the day they were accepted owing to old age and infirmity. I consider it would be a very unwise thing to pass this amendment and create a precedent for including other people under it who were never included before. All along I have held out against allowing any new class of pensionable officers to be brought into this Bill. This would be the first breach in that standard that I have taken up, and I would be very sorry if the Senator were to press the amendment.

Comment on this

Some statements have been made that are not correct. The statement has been deliberately made that these people are not whole-time officers. I want to say that the school-attendance officers in Dublin are whole-time officers.

Comment on this

In Dublin.

Comment on this

In reply to the statements of Mrs. Wyse Power and the Minister, to the effect that old people were employed in this particular work, I want to say that at present there are people with twenty-five years' service, so that they could not have been tremendously old when they were appointed. The point I want to put forward is this: The people who were employed are not responsible for the fact that there was no examination. They were employed as a result of a public advertisement, and old people have not been employed. One or two may have been, but the majority of the people in Dublin have up to twenty-five years' service. They got their positions in reply to public advertisements and through worth, and they had to be within a certain age limit. As a matter of fact, on one occasion a person was appointed, and because he was not able to produce a certificate as being under thirty-five years of age, he was disqualified. I believe you are doing a gross injustice to those people. It has been stated that the Corporation has not control of these; that there are other people on the committees. But the Corporation appoints a certain number of its own members, and also appoints the other members, and the Corporation pays the whole of the salaries. Every other employee of the Corporation after serving a certain number of years is entitled under Act of Parliament to a pension, and the citizens of Dublin pay the whole salaries of these people. They are in the same position as any of the other employees, and I think it is a gross injustice to these people to debar them from the same benefits as every other employee.

Comment on this

I move:—

After the word "asylum" to insert the following words: "the expressions ‘office' and ‘officer' have the same meaning as in section 109 of the Local Government (Ireland) Act, 1898."

An office is described as "any office, situation or employment, and ‘officers' shall include such." What I hope to achieve by this amendment is to bring workmen under this definition of an officer, and I do not think it is anything new. I only want this definition in the Local Government Act inserted. Senator Kenny, in dealing with the last amendment, has made my case. I think it is a lamentable thing for local authorities when they have employees who have served them faithfully—such cases have come under my notice and under Senator Kenny's—who have given practically their whole lives to the service, that such local authorities have no power to superannuate them when they are no longer able to work. We have had several cases of that in the Kilkenny Corporation, and from what I have heard I take it that it is general throughout Ireland. It is a humiliating thing. Of course we can give such people some nominal position and tell them, as Senator Kenny said, to go and hide themselves. I do not think that that should be. Local bodies will not dismiss men who have given faithful service, and they should not be expected to do so simply because these men have reached an age when they can no longer work. They will pay them their wages and let them idle their time away when they cannot give them a pension. It is a great mistake to keep these men and give them nominal positions—keepers of parks, or something like that—so as to legalise the payments. I take it that if this definition is inserted the ordinary workman will come in, and that is what I want to achieve.

Comment on this

I am very strongly opposed to this amendment. It would enormously increase the number of pensioners, and it would be an absolutely intolerable burden on the rates. The mover puts it on the ground that that is the definition which is given of an officer in the Local Government Act of 1898, and that therefore, to be consistent and logical, we should carry it on to this Bill. At the time that the Local Government Act of 1898 was passed nobody had any right to a pension. Certain bodies had a right to give a pension at their discretion, but no officer of any local body had a right to a pension; they were all at the discretion of the local body. That being so, there was no harm in putting a definition into the Act of 1898, which included in the definition of the word "officer" a person who is in the employment or has a situation under the local body, because the legislature thought that they might trust the commonsense of the public body, and that in the exercise of their discretion they would not pension a man on the road, or a charwoman.

Comment on this

They do not want anything in their old age!

Comment on this

But it was carried so far that a case was taken to the Court of Appeal. I think they actually pensioned or gave a gratuity, if she was not long enough in the service to earn a pension, to a charwoman. That would put an enormous burden on the rates. Therefore, I very strongly oppose the amendment. It would mean that everybody who was paid a weekly wage would get a pension.

Comment on this

Why not?

Comment on this

The Senator has spoken of putting an enormous burden on the rates. Does he consider that the ratepayer has to pay in any case, whether in the form of a pension, or in the form of relief? If an ordinary employee of a public body falls sick he at once falls on the rates. That is a very serious burden, possibly a greater burden than by allotting a scaled pension to such a man. You cannot get rid of the ratepayer's liability. We are trying to put public bodies in a position to conduct their own affairs with dignity and not to be put into an anomalous and false and invidious position by having to discharge their employees and cast them upon the charity of the public, or on home assistance. Public bodies are not in the same position, as it were, to do these things as a private employer is, because they have to conduct their business in the open and under the very strong light of public opinion. All their proceedings are reported by the Press, and most of their meetings are open to the public. The private employer is in a better position if he should feel so disposed—I may say that he is generally not so disposed—to be so inhuman as to sacrifice his humanity to his profit, and he can, when an employee is no longer a profit to him, tell him to leave.

A public body cannot do that, and under the existing conditions you force them, as Senator Gogarty has very well described it, to connive at—it is really a form of connivance—some means by which they may not be forced to the necessity of openly discharging these people and casting them on the public charge or on home assistance. From the economic point of view—to the ratepayer—it does not really matter. There is scarcely any difference, certainly not any material difference, to the ratepayer as to how that employee who is no longer able physically to carry on his work, and his family, if he has a wife and children, are to be supported for the rest of their lives. A pension preserves a man's dignity and feeling of independence to some extent, because a pension is supposed to be deferred pay. He is supposed during his working period to have given service that was slightly underpaid in consideration of the pension that will ultimately be due to him. It is really immaterial, from the ratepayer's point of view, how that man is to be provided for in the event of sickness or old age. The ratepayers are affected in exactly the same manner.

Comment on this

This amendment would give the local authorities power to put an end to these class distinctions that have been a cause of difference for so many centuries. Under the existing law, and under this Bill, you have power to give pensions to people who, while they are employed, have sufficient salaries to enable them to put by something for a rainy day. But the unfortunate workman, the bottom dog, merely gets a subsistence wage and, if his health breaks down, does not get a pension. Senator Brown thinks it is a horrible thing for any of these people to get pensions. One would imagine that they were made of different clay from the officers. A man who works in a sewer for seven or eight or nine hours in the day and is liable at any moment to lose his life with the foul air, and who does that for thirty or forty years, is not to get a pension. You hold up your hands in holy horror if that is suggested, but the fellow who is sitting with his toes on the mantelpiece in the office with his warm fire may have a thousand a year, and he will get a pension, of course. I suggest to you that if you want to have good citizens you will not have them by continuing this class war—citizens who will respect the Constitution and the State. It is no use trying to make out that the working man is not made of the same clay as anybody else. If he and his wife and children, after he has given forty or fifty years' service, have to go to the workhouse, do not think you are done with him. I tell you that you are making a mistake if you think they will stand it any longer. I am not going to make use of any threats, but I tell you that the working-class people will not stand it any longer. If they do not get fair play they will take the means of getting it for themselves.

Comment on this

A good deal of quite unnecessary heat has been introduced into this question, and probably the real issues have, to a certain extent, been obscured. Senator Farren talked about the man who spends thirty or forty years in the service of a local authority. If these were the people that were to be pensioned, and the only people that were to be pensioned, there probably would not be a word against it. But when you turn to the terms of the Bill, what do you find? As far as I can read, it says: "the expression ‘yearly salary and emoluments' means in relation to an officer who has served for not less than three years." It goes on in the next clause to state how these pensions are to be calculated, and it alludes to a local body that may, with the consent of the Minister, grant a pension to an officer in their employment who has at least ten years' service. So that ten years is apparently the maximum and three years the minimum. I could appreciate Senator Farren's argument if he really put the absolute facts before us. Nobody wants to treat people hardly who have been working for a long time.

It is all very well to talk about the purity of the manner in which things are administered. We all know well that they are not administered purely. We know thousands of cases in which corruption has entered into appointments. We know men who have been appointed simply to be retired in a very short time with pensions, and as this Bill is proposed to be amended, I believe pensions would be given in such a way. Recently while I was at home a man came to see me. He was a fine, strong, hefty man, about twenty-eight or thirty years of age. He had lately got married, and he had a great grievance. In some of the numerous shiftings of positions that have taken place, he had lost his job and he had got a pension. It was not quite as much as he would like to have, and he wanted me to see various people to have it increased. The gravamen of his complaint was that his wife had not got a pension also. I asked him how old his wife was, and he said she was about twenty-four. She had been in the employment of some local authority for a few years and her office was done away with. Because she had not got a pension when she married him, and he had got a pension that was not quite sufficient, his complaint was that it was very hard lines. A very moody picture has been drawn of the poor people who are unable to work and have to be given a sweeping brush to go and hide themselves in a dark corner. But we have not heard one word about the poor ratepayers, and I assure you there are greater cases of hardship among the poor ratepayers, who are billed every day for rates that they cannot afford to pay. These rates arise largely from the extravagance with which these things are administered, and I think if somebody stood up and advocated their case it would do a great deal more good.

Comment on this

With many of the arguments advanced I am in complete accord. I think every man has a right to live and the right to expect reasonable provision in his old age and for infirmity. All men are equal in person and dignity, and by the law of nature and God they are entitled to that. I am afraid this amendment may go further than we intend to go. I would like if I could be assured that the few men employed by local bodies to do various jobs about courthouses and places of that sort, if they are men who have been in regular employment for a number of years, should be entitled to a pension, but what I fear is that men will be employed by local bodies in a more or less temporary capacity and perhaps get a very high wage for a temporary job. They may be employed temporarily for a period extending over three or four years, and it might possibly be argued, under this particular section, that these men would be pensionable. If that could be argued it would be a very grave thing for the community, and I think for that reason we should approach this amendment with great caution. I think it is an amendment that would require to be studied very closely, and for my part I would not like to be asked to vote on this amendment at all, because what I am afraid is that it will possibly be argued that temporary employees are entitled to pensions. I can visualise cases where a number of men are employed by a county council, possibly on roads, temporarily, and it may be argued that these men are servants of the county, and as such are liable to be pensioned. If there were some people who had given whole years of their lives to the service of the Council on roads I would pension them, but many of these men merely give some occasional service, and if they give such service for a period of three or four years then I think it would not be just to the community at large that they should enjoy pensionable rights. They get an extra wage on account of having no pensionable rights and because of occasional employment, and if there is the least danger that any change of this sort would admit people of that character to pensionable rights I think it should be opposed. I am against it.

Comment on this

Like Senator Bennett, I would like more information as to what the probable cost will be if this amendment is carried. I would say in favour of it that I think in very many cases it would make for economy in administration. Very often men are kept in the service of public bodies because these bodies know they cannot pension them. They cannot throw such a man out of employment, and they have to keep him on doing some work which, because of his old age and infirmity, he cannot do in an efficient manner. You cannot blame a public body for doing that. I do not agree with Senator Barrington when he speaks of the inefficient and corrupt manner in which public bodies have carried on their administration. I have a good many years' experience of public bodies in different parts of the country, and with very few exceptions I have never heard of cases of corruption. When these things do occur the newspapers and men like Senator Barrington take good care that they are well known.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I hope the Seanad realises that the effect of this amendment will be to make pensions mandatory for every employee of a local authority. That is a most staggering proposal, and more especially as we have no idea of what it is going to cost. I think the House would be stultifying itself in passing anything like that without the most careful investigation. I should like to take this opportunity of saying that I have very much sympathy with the employees who are excluded simply by virtue of their lower grade or their remuneration from pension, but I cannot see how they can be dealt with satisfactorily in a measure of this kind. The whole method of pensioning requires to be carefully reviewed, and any changes should be introduced gradually. It cannot very well affect these with statutory rights, but it does seem unreasonable that a salaried official should get a pension and a wage-earner should not. I would like to see the whole question reconsidered on the basis of having pensions contributory on all classes of employees. I hope we will have some scheme of that kind, but that cannot fructify except very slowly. It can only be introduced, I think, in the case of new entrants into the service. It will take a generation probably before any arrangement of that kind can take effect. In the meantime, we are dealing with practical realities, and I submit this amendment is not one.

Comment on this

I cannot take the gloomy view of our public bodies put forward by one Senator, nor have I had the happy experience of another, but I agree with Senator Sir John Keane that this is a matter on which we require fuller information. The principle enunciated by Senator Farren is a good sound one, and makes an appeal to our reason. There are some glaring cases. I know of one or two where men were discharged after 30 years' service without pension. I think in such cases if they were put before the Minister there might be some clause introduced which would give public bodies an opportunity of giving such men an ex gratia grant, if not a pension. I welcome the statements of Senator Sir John Keane and Senator Bennett, and also agree with Senator Farren. Perhaps the Minister would bring in himself on Report some provision whereby in future we might be able to deal with this very momentous question.

Comment on this

I would suggest to Senator De Loughry that he should withdraw this amendment for the reason that I think we are all humanitarians in the Seanad. I am one myself in any case. I do not believe in the class distinction Senator Farren speaks of. I do not know whether Senator Farren's threat is a warning or his warning is a threat.

Comment on this

I protested against injustice.

Comment on this

I do not think he intended it to be either a warning or a threat. I think I heard Senator Sir John Keane speaking before about co-ordination of public charitable organisations and public funds, and that there seemed to be waste and overlapping. We have the dole, the poor rate and all these charitable societies. We have the old age pension, too, and all these things require a certain amount of overhead charges and it appears a great deal of waste occurs in the running of these different organisations, in collecting and in other work. I think that the Minister should look into the whole matter to see what could be done to bring about a certain amount of co-ordination between all these activities, and to see that justice should be done to the people for whom Senator De Loughry speaks.

Comment on this

I think the principal objection to this amendment was stressed by Senator Sir John Keane and Senator Barrington. No estimate has been made of what the cost will be to the country or whether the ratepayers, who are at present burdened to the very utmost limit of their capacity, can bear it or not. I believe at present it would be impossible to put this burden on the ratepayers. Senator Farren seems to take exception to the fact that distinction appears to be made between officials of local authorities and employees, but I think there is a very apparent reason for that. The ordinary officers of local authorities are generally men of very high capacity and ability, and when they took up office it was an understood thing that their pensionable rights were more or less arranged on a contributory basis. If they were not given a pension they would have a much higher salary. In addition to what they would get in the ordinary course of events, the pension is left as an inducement to continue on. It would place local authorities in a very difficult position if trained, skilled, experienced and highly capable officers were leaving their employment every couple of months and if they had to substitute officers of very high ability. An ordinary employee is a man for whom a substitute can be got at a moment's notice. I am not at all adverse to bringing in at a later stage some system of superannuation on a contributory basis, but it will have to be a contributory basis just as the superannuation of officers is really on a contributory basis. The whole matter will have to be worked out carefully. It is almost impossible to go into it without an actuary. You cannot deal with this in a slipshod haphazard way without working it out to see what it is going to cost the ratepayers ultimately and what would be a fair proportion for the employee to contribute, and what would be a fair proportion for the local authority. It is a matter that will have to be dealt with very fully, and I ask the Senator not to press the amendment at this stage.

Comment on this

If I get some information as to when the Bill which the Minister foreshadows will be brought in, I may consider withdrawal of the amendment. I would like now to refer to some of the remarks made. You are always at a disadvantage when you have a man like Senator Brown making a case against you. He argues the case of some isolated authority pensioning a charwoman. I do not stand for that at all. I have 20 years' experience of public bodies, and I have been struck with the amount of attention, care and time which men in Ireland devote to the work of local government. I deprecate some of the remarks made here about local authorities. I know in my own area the councillors have a high civic standard, and they ought to get credit for it. When anything comes up here and there is a chance of telling a funny story at the expense of the local authorities it is told.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The point of Senator Brown's observation was that your amendment was mandatory and that, therefore, everyone would come under the definition. He was making a charge against nobody.

Comment on this

I was not referring to Senator Brown. I am seeking to put the employees of public bodies in the same category as officers. I do not see why they should be segregated and why in 1925 there should be a definition of an officer and another definition of employee. I cannot understand why they should be segregated, and I do not think anyone who has given any attention to public bodies can understand it either. It was said that it would put an enormous burden on the rates. I hold the burden is greater as it is. I have no use for the public body that pensions an employee after three or four years, but public bodies who have men 20 or 30 years in their employment will not let them go if they cannot give them pensions. They will keep them on and the expense is greater on the rates. Senator Brown made it clear that at the time of the passing of the Local Government Act of 1898 there was no intention to give a pension to anyone. Therefore the definition did not make so much difference. I think there is a section of that Act imposing a 40/- fine per day for any neglect of duty on the part of an officer. I am sure that would apply to a workman. If an employee neglects his duty I am sure he would come under the category of an officer. I do not see why he should not be an officer when the plums are going.

There is one other point. It struck me during the debate that under the board of guardians we were empowered to superannuate men like masons, carpenters, and so on. I cannot understand, if a board of guardians can pension workmen who do not contribute to their pension, why the Corporation cannot do it. The whole administration of this Act is inconsistent. As I say, if the Minister could tell us when he intends to bring in this Bill dealing with the question of superannuation, we would know where we are.

Comment on this

It is difficult for me to give any promise as to the date of the introduction of this new Bill. There are about a dozen Bills on the tapis, if I could get time to bring them forward. I cannot give a promise for any definite time, but as soon as I get the opportunity I will endeavour to go into the matter and to bring forward a Bill that will meet with Senators' wishes.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 8
·
Níl 27
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Before you come to the next amendment, A Chathaoirligh, might I suggest to the Minister a slight alteration in line 3 of Section 36:—

"The expression ‘pensionable officer' means any permanent officer who either (a) devotes the whole of his time to the service of one or more local bodies, or (b) is required by virtue of his office to be a registered medical practitioner, nurse or midwife."

It is very difficult to know what is meant by "permanent." It is not so difficult to know what is meant by "temporary." I would suggest that a better definition would be: "The expression pensionable officer means any officer other than a temporary officer."

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Have you ever found it easier yourself to explain the difference in that way?

Comment on this

I would like to consider the suggested definition between now and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I have been asked to move Amendment 76a:

Section 36, page 20, line 8, after the word "practitioner" to insert the words "qualified civil engineer."

The section would then read: "... is required by virtue of his office to be a registered medical practitioner, qualified civil engineer, nurse or midwife."

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Are you not bringing him into very curious company? Had you not better put it this way: "is required by virtue of his office to be a qualified civil engineer, a registered medical practitioner, nurse or midwife?

Comment on this

That is what I had in my own draft, but I find it was altered.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think it is better to put it as you originally intended.

Comment on this

I am agreeable.

Amendment altered accordingly.

Comment on this

I am assured that there are a number of these engineers in the service of sanitary authorities throughout the country and that they are practically qualified for a pension. They are doing good work. We have got here pensions for ladies and gentlemen who help to introduce us into the world and also for those who help to usher us out of it. Meantime, there is a class of men working for the lives of the citizens and safeguarding them in every possible way, and they lead busy and useful lives. I plead very strongly that the Minister should take those men into account, and if possible stretch a point so as to bring them within this section and provide them with pensions when the need arises.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think it would be desirable if Senator Sir John Griffith would give an example to the Seanad of this officer. He says, according to his amendment, that he must be a permanent officer who is liable by virtue of his office to be a qualified civil engineer. Can the Senator give us an example of that gentleman?

Comment on this

There are quite a number of them throughout the country. They hold positions as engineers to the sanitary authorities in the various counties. They are required, if I understand the matter rightly, to be qualified engineers.

Comment on this

Are they whole-time officers?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I oppose this amendment. It is getting in the thin end of the wedge in favour of pensions to part-time officers. We have enough pensioners in this country, without creating another army of them. There are a great number of engineers paid for looking after pumps one day in a fortnight or one day in a month by the rural district councils. Are we going to give pensions to men of that kind? The thing is intolerable.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I wanted to have some idea of what this amendment meant and what it covered. I do not know whether those officials to whom Senator Sir John Griffith alludes are at liberty to engage in private practice or not.

Comment on this

They take private practice.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Then they are not whole-time officers?

Comment on this

Their whole time is available to the authorities.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I only desire that the Seanad should have the facts. I am not suggesting that the House should not make the amendment you desire, but I am putting these questions that Senators may know what they are voting for.

Comment on this

These engineers are in the same position as doctors and nurses. They have got freedom of action when their time is not being availed of by the sanitary authorities.

Comment on this

I do not think it is necessary to ask the Seanad not to accept this amendment. A whole-time civil engineer is pensionable under the Bill as it stands, without the addition of this amendment. I think it would be stretching things very far to allow a civil engineer, who can take private practice, to be pensionable under the present Bill. Doctors, midwives and nurses are in a different position, and they have had pensionable rights for a considerable time. That is, no doubt, owing to the fact that their office is so much concerned with the preservation of human life. It is to the interests of the local authority to do everything in its power to keep those medical officers and nurses and midwives and make their offices worth while, so as not to have them changing about from one dispensary district to another. That consideration does not apply to officers of this kind at all. If we include civil engineers, why not include all the other classes of half-time officers employed under local authorities?

Comment on this

I move amendment 77:—"Section 36, after the word ‘fees,' in line 27, to insert the words ‘except franchise fees.'" This amendment deals with the calculation of emoluments for pension purposes. County secretaries draw considerable sums under the head of "franchise fees." When they were given this work some years ago, the franchise extended to only one occupant in each house. Now, there are four or five voters in every house, and the fees have been multiplied four or five times. In an average county, where the fees were £200 or £250 when this work was given first, they are now £1,000. Ten years ago, the county secretary might be able to do this work unaided. Now that is impossible. He has to employ a staff to do it. In fixing his pension, this £1,000 that he pays out to his staff will be considered as part of his salary and his pension will be increased by £600 or £700. County secretaries belong to a class that is pretty well paid. I think that pension based on ordinary salary would be quite sufficient, without making the ratepayers responsible for this £600 or £700, in addition. If a county council were to formulate a scheme of direct labour and hand over to the county surveyor a sum of £20,000 to expend upon it, it would be quite as reasonable to calculate that £20,000 as portion of his salary for the purpose of pension as it is to calculate these fees as portion of the salary of the county secretary. Ten years ago it might be possible for him to do this work unaided but it would be utterly impossible for him to do it now. My amendment would exclude franchise fees from salary for the purpose of calculating pension.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I am in sympathy with the spirit of the amendment, but I think it should rather take the form of deducting, as a set-off, the expenses incurred in preparing these lists. I do not think it would be fair to deprive the officer of the whole of the franchise fees as originally earned by him when, as the Senator says, he could do the work himself. There ought to be a reduction made in respect of payments for any extra work recently rendered necessary.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think that was aimed at in the clause. The words used are "made to an officer as such for his own use." That would appear not to include fees which he had to expend in employing others to do public work. Those fees could hardly be described as fees paid to him for his own use. It may be that the matter requires clearing up.

Comment on this

If the Minister could find some form of words which would meet the case Senator Sir John Keane suggests, I would be agreeable. If the pension of the county secretary were calculated on the salary and fees paid him ten years ago, it would meet the case I have raised.

Comment on this

As you, A Chathaoirligh, pointed out, the wording is clear enough. There is an adequate safeguard in the section as it stands. I might point out that at present it is our policy to give an inclusive salary to all new county secretaries, and the franchise fees will then go to the county council. It is a very serious matter to interfere with existing rights. We cannot very well deprive officers of local authorities of fees which were a condition of their appointment. But in regard to the new appointments the franchise fees will go to the county council and the secretaries will be paid an inclusive salary.

Comment on this

There were some cases in which franchise fees were payable to the clerks of the rural district councils, and now those fees have gone to the secretaries of the county councils, with the result that they enjoy salaries a tithe of which they did not enjoy some years ago. If these fees are included, they mean an enormous addition to the salary. I think some such amendment as Senator O'Rourke has proposed would be merely doing justice.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The matter could be rectified by providing for that portion of the fees which was actual profit being included and not allowing the portion of the fees which were expended in getting assistance to be included.

Comment on this

I know in some counties that, on the falling out of the old clerks of the local authorities, the registration work devolved on the county secretaries, who had already a very large salary. That salary has been greatly appreciated by reason of these men falling out and to calculate pension on that salary, which they have not enjoyed for very long, would seem to be giving too much. I think it would be only reasonable that some arrangement should be made by which the emoluments of these officials for the purposes of pension would be pared down as finely as possible.

Comment on this

Except the clause is amended so as to provide for pension on the basis of the actual salary, the county rates will be at considerable loss. If the Minister is satisfied as to the intention of the amendment, the form of words could be left over until the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I think the ratepayers are amply protected under the section as it stands, and, in regard to all new appointments, we are insisting on the salaries being inclusive. We cannot interfere with the existing rights of officers. The situation that Senator Bennett has dealt with has arisen as the result of the 1898 Act. Of course, we cannot place officers who have rights under that Act in a worse position now than they were in when the Act was passed. But in connection with all new appointments, we are doing away with this anomaly.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

In other words, the position seems to be that, under existing legislation, these officers are entitled to have these fees included in their emoluments. The only way out is by dealing with new appointments. I think that is what the Minister has in mind.

Comment on this

I would like to press this upon the Seanad. The Seanad is an important body, and I think we should decide whether we are satisfied to give these officials such enormous pensions. There is an outcry all over the country as to the immense amount of money county councils have to spend by way of pensions. In my county it amounts to about £3,000 a year, and this provision will add another £1,000 to it. To give a pension of £1,200 a year to one man, while you cannot give a pension to a charwoman or a labourer, seems altogether absurd. I desire to have the amendment put to the Seanad.

Comment on this

I have a great deal of sympathy with the amendment. It is clear to me that the position of a secretary of a county council is not prejudiced by any extra duties put upon him by new legislation, because the new emoluments given to him necessarily must be expended in the payment of salaries to persons who will have to do that extra work. I have been told that some secretaries to county councils who get the fees say they cannot do the work and they get clerical assistance to do it. I have a great deal of sympathy with the outbursts of feeling from the Labour Benches with regard to relatively small things, when hundreds of pounds are added on to the salaries of well-paid officials for things which it was not really intended they should benefit by. I ask the Minister to give us some undertaking, if he cannot accept the amendment, that he will go into the matter before the Report Stage. Otherwise the amendment should be pressed and carried.

Comment on this

I prefer to leave it to the Seanad. I do not wish to take responsibility by accepting the amendment.

Comment on this

I wish to bring up a matter, if I may be allowed to go back to sub-section (2).

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Have you any amendment down?

Comment on this

I want to oppose that sub-section and vote against it.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The only way to do that is to have an amendment down to delete the sub-section. You have not done that.

Comment on this

Surely every sub-section is put?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Not every sub-section. I put every section and put the amendments to it. There is no amendment in your name to sub-section (2).

Comment on this

Might I move now to omit that sub-section?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I will receive that, certainly.

Comment on this

I beg to move to delete sub-section (2).

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

It is a very strong thing to spring an amendment of this kind upon us now, because it is affecting the rights of a number of professional gentlemen who, if they thought the sub-section was going to be attacked, would probably have taken the trouble to explain what it means to certain Senators. It is an unusual thing to have an amendment of this kind brought up without notice.

Comment on this

I was under the impression that the sub-section had to be adopted.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

No. The Minister has not got notice of this, and no Senator has got notice.

Comment on this
Earl of Mayo The EARL of MAYO Independent

The Senator should bring it up on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Whatever you rule.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I will not prevent you from moving if you wish, but I think it would be more reasonable for you to put down an amendment for the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Very well.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

May I ask if there is any statutory definition of a "standing solicitor"?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I do not think so. What it does mean, and what most people understand by it is, that he is appointed and is entitled to receive and transact all the business of that body. That is to say, if they went outside and employed another solicitor they would be violating their agreement with him.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

Is he appointed at a fixed salary, or is he paid the usual statutory fees?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

As a rule I think he is paid by fees. However, that is a matter we can discuss when the Senator brings up the amendment on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

On behalf of Senator O'Farrell I beg to move:

Section 37, sub-section (1). Lines 40-41. To delete all after the word "Act," in line 40, down to and including the word "body" in line 41.

The object of the amendment is to endeavour to get the same terms for the employees of local boards who may lose their employment as was given to the employees of railway companies under the Railways Act.

Comment on this

I take it the object is to enable those officers to get gratuities. Under the 1919 Act, which was calculated on a very unfair basis an officer with less than ten years' service could get a gratuity equal to the amount of his salary for half the number of years he served. That was grossly unfair. We have refused to concede that right under the present Bill. It would be a very unfair burden on local authorities if it were granted, and I ask the Seanad not to agree to it.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 37, sub-section (1), line 42. After the word "writing" to insert the words "within three months after the passing of this Act," and in line 44 to delete the words "within three months after the passing of this Act."

This is merely a drafting amendment, and I hope it will be accepted by the Minister.

Comment on this

I accept that amendment.

Comment on this

I move:—

Section 37, sub-section (1), line 44. To delete the word "three" and to substitute therefor the word "six."

This section gives the right to contract out of the Act, and instead of giving only three months the amendment gives six. I think that seems reasonable, and I expect the Minister will not object to it.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Are you quite sure that is the effect of the amendment?

Comment on this

The section says:—

"If any officer of a local body who is in office at the date of the passing of this Act and at that date has more than ten years' service as an officer of such local body signifies in writing to such local body or if that body has been abolished then to a local body to which its powers and duties have been transferred within three months after the passing of this Act his intention not to avail himself of the provisions of this Part of this Act, this Part of this Act shall not apply to such officer."

This part of the Act deals only with superannuation, and this is to give the option to a man who would rather have section 8 of the Local Government Act of 1919 instead of this.

Comment on this

The object of the amendment is to give six rather than three months' to officers who may transfer under the Act. The only objection to giving six months is, as Senator Brown is very well aware—he has been moving a number of amendments about the appointed day—that the day for transferring these officers to the county councils from rural district councils will be the 1st October. I would like these officers to make up their minds a fair length of time before that day so that the local authorities would have time to decide on which officers to pension or to take on under the board of health. I think six months too much. Perhaps the Senator will agree to four months?

Comment on this

Very well.

Comment on this

Are not these words in line 44 already deleted by the previous amendment?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

No, they have not been deleted at all.

Comment on this

They are not in line 44 now.

Comment on this

They occur in the next line.

Comment on this