SEANAD IN COMMITTEE. - LOCAL GOVERNMENT BILL, 1924. THIRD STAGE (RESUMED).
Contributions 143–288 of 288. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 18 of 1924 ›
We will not trouble about the line. The proposal is to alter the word "three" to "four."
Comment on this
I move:—
Section 37, sub-section (1), line 45. Before the words "the provisions" to insert the word "all," and in line 46, before the words "shall not apply," to insert the words and figures "with the exception of Sections 37, 40, 43, 44, 47, 48, 49 and 50."
Comment on this
I would be willing to accept the amendment. Under the Bill as it stands an officer is permitted to contract out of all the sections dealing with superannuation, and if the Senators will look at the sections excluded under this amendment, it will appear that several of them are of a kind that would be unsuitable both for the officer contracting out and the local authorities to have him contract out. Accordingly these particular exceptions have been made.
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied with this amendment?
Comment on this
I move: In Section 37, sub-section (2), before the word "apply" to insert the word "wholly."
Comment on this
That follows as a result of the change already made.
Comment on this
I move:— Section 37, sub-section (2), after the words "this Act" to insert the words "with the exception of the sections specified in sub-section (1) of this section."
Comment on this
On behalf of Senator O'Farrell, I move amendment 84:— Section 37, sub-section (2), to delete all after the word "passed" to the end of the sub-section.
I am not quite clear upon the amendment which was put down by Senator O'Farrell, but I think the object is to prevent disputes arising in regard to pensions already passed.
Comment on this
I cannot agree to accept this amendment. It is another one of the amendments dealing with Section 8 of the 1919 Act. Under that Act the local authority was entitled to pay a pension to an officer, and if the officer was not satisfied with the pension he received he could appeal to the Minister. The Minister had no function in the matter unless a question was raised, and the only person who could raise a question was the officer of the local authority. If the officer was paid an excessive pension the Minister had no power to intervene; but, on the other hand, if the officer was paid too small a pension he could appeal to the Minister and the Minister could adjust the pension so as to be equitable to the officer. It is quite obvious that this was a one-sided arrangement. It is not fair to the local authority that if an officer be dissatisfied with his pension he should be able to raise the matter with the Minister, but if the local authority is dissatisfied it has no power to have the matter submitted to another jurisdiction. This section gives power to the auditor to raise the question, which is a much more equitable arrangement. Senator Farren's amendment would undo all that, and for that reason I think it would be most unjust to accept it.
Comment on this
I do not think it is desirable in the public interest that there should be public objectors in these matters to raise objections that otherwise would not be made.
Comment on this
Under the 1919 Act the auditor had no right to intervene. The matter was left between the parties concerned and the existing officer was held to have his right. Now a third party is introduced and the matter can be raised by the auditor. I think that is an infringement of our already existing rights as I understand them. Of course existing rights are, as the Minister said, sacred things. When discussing this question, the Minister seemed to throw a halo round existing rights, and we were told that it would be a very serious thing to infringe upon them. Here, clearly, this sub-section does interfere with existing rights.
Comment on this
The necessity for this sub-section arises owing to a rather peculiar condition of the law. Under Section 8 of the Local Government Act of 1919 a local body could give pensions which were only limited by a maximum. They could give up to two-thirds of the salary of the officer who had a right to a pension, but in the case of a gratuity they could add a certain number of years to his salary and make it the maximum.
They may give a sum altogether out of proportion to the services and the merits of the man pensioned. If they do that, there is no way of stopping it, because they have the absolute right to fix the pension within these maximum limits. This provision is really to prevent that kind of thing happening. It is to give the local government auditor, if he thinks on finding out the full circumstances of the case—because the payment of a pension would be one of the matters to come before him—that this was an extravagant pension or an extravagant gratuity, the right to object. The matter would then come before the Local Government Department. That is the whole object of the sub-section. It is to prevent what has happened very frequently: an extravagant pension being given. There is a maximum up to which a local authority may go without being obliged to limit it by the number of years that the servant has served.
Comment on this
I think that this is a most valuable provision in the sub-section, because it enables the auditor to protect the ratepayers of a county. Under this sub-section the auditor will be able to raise a matter of this kind, and without it, in the case of an excessive pension being granted, there would be no means of reducing it to its proper amount. I hope, therefore, that the Minister will retain this sub-section in the Bill.
Comment on this
I beg to move the following amendment:—
Section 37. After sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"(3) In this section the expression ‘officer' includes any person duly appointed standing solicitor of a local body before the passing of the Local Government (Ireland) Act, 1919."
This is really consequential. A standing solicitor to a local body is included in the definition of a pensionable officer in the preceding section. If you look at the preceding section (b) (ii) you find that the said expression "pensionable officer" also includes "any person duly appointed standing solicitor of a local body before the passing of the Local Government (Ireland) Act, 1919." It only applies to a standing solicitor of a local body who was such prior to the date of the passing of the Local Government Act of 1919. He is, therefore, an existing officer under this Act. All this amendment does is, that it gives him the right, which all other existing officers have got under Section 37, to contract out. You see that the definition of pensionable officers in Section 37 only applies to that section, and the amendment is, therefore, necessary in this section. It is necessary that the word "officer" in this section shall include solicitor.
Comment on this
I cannot allow this to pass without referring to the question of solicitors. It seems to me to be giving special privileges to law officers and solicitors. I had a motion down which was overruled on account of the persons concerned not being full-time officers. It was argued that under this Bill a person must be a full-time officer, and that if they were not full-time officers it was not proper to bring them in under this Bill. Solicitors as a rule— I know there are some exceptions—do nearly all the work of the public body which employs them in their own office along with their own private work, so that, therefore, they are not full-time officers. In fact their position is enhanced by being a solicitor to a county council or some other public body. The county council work does not interfere very much with their private practice. As a matter of fact, their employment as the county solicitor gives them a certain amount of credit, and helps them along a good deal as far as their private practice is concerned. I do not see why other people, who do not give their full time to the work, should be refused pensions if you are going to give pensions to solicitors for doing some little county council work in their capacity as county solicitors in their own offices.
Comment on this
You see Senator, this is consequential on the assumption that the previous section, to which you objected, remains in the Bill. If the previous section, to which you objected, remained in the Bill this would be purely consequential, but I have reserved liberty to you to move to strike that out on the Report Stage. Therefore, I think it is better that this amendment, moved now by Senator Brown, should also stand over for the Report Stage, because if sub-section (2) to the previous section is struck out then this amendment of Senator Brown's will never arise.
Amendment ordered to be considered on Report.
Comment on this
On behalf of Senator O'Farrell, I beg to move the following amendment:—
In Section 38, sub-section (1), line 62, to delete the word "may" and to substitute therefor the word "shall."
The best argument, I think, that I can use in support of this amendment is to quote the Minister. When we were discussing a former amendment, the Minister told us that, in the case of all these officers, part of their salary, at the time of their appointment, was given towards their superannuation. As he told us that, he cannot, I suggest, have it both ways. The object of this amendment is to say that a local authority shall, with the consent of the Minister, grant a pension to so and so. The Minister told us that these professional gentlemen employed by a local authority, in case they might run away from their jobs and look for other employment, had to be given this guarantee of a pension. Therefore, all I say is, that they "shall" be given pensions with the consent of the Minister.
Comment on this
This is introducing a new principle into the superannuation code, a principle that has not been recognised before. That is the principle of compulsory pensions. It is obvious that in paying a pension, a local authority has a certain amount of control over its officers. That is one of the reasons for paying the pension. If an officer refuses to carry out his duties, or is inefficient, they can refuse to grant him a pension, and in that way they can secure efficiency and good work. The substitution of the word "shall" for "may" does not coerce the local authority at all. The official, at any rate, would have an appeal to the Minister. I do not think it is necessary to insert a word of that kind in order to coerce the Minister. He is all the time very much subject to public opinion. If he were to turn down a man who had a proper right to a pension, he would find it hard to justify his attitude in the Dáil or in the Seanad. The insertion of the word "shall" would not compel the Minister to grant an ample pension. He might give a penny or a shilling, and that would bring him within the terms of the Act. I oppose the amendment.
Comment on this
Generally speaking, it is a very bad principle that a man going into a public service cannot have any fixity of tenure or a definite prospect of getting suitably rewarded for his services. If he is left to the local authority or to the Minister, when the time arrives for him to retire through ill-health or advanced age he may find himself in a peculiar difficulty in regard to his pension or superannuation. The politics of the local authority may form the chief consideration in the matter of granting him a pension, or possibly his own political opinions may be the prime consideration. All these matters may affect the decision of the local authority and may have an important bearing on his application for a pension. If the local body are opposed to him politically, they may be very glad to take advantage of the opportunity and not grant him a pension. These things have been experienced in practice in recent years.
It is a very bad principle and some effort should be made to abolish it. A man from whom was expected good service should not be left in any uncertain frame of mind as to his treatment when the time comes for him to retire. The question of granting him a pension should not be left to the whim of any Minister or local authority whose opinions may change from time to time. The main point is that under existing Acts the men who have entered the service are entitled to a pension, and that privilege has been confirmed by subsequent Acts. Now it is proposed here that the granting of a pension shall assume a more definite form. From what the Minister stated one would gain the impression that existing rights and interests are very sacrosanct; but here we have in subsequent clauses of the Bill, in almost every second line, existing rights interfered with.
There ought to be some definite object in view. As the Bill stands, under this section one does not know whether existing rights are to continue or whether their ultimate future is to be affected. If they are to be interfered with, the principle is radically wrong. If you want good service from men they must, on entering that service, have a guarantee that their future is assured and that no set of circumstances can interfere with their rights. If a man has a good service of ten, twenty or thirty years, he ought to be assured that his pension rights will not be tampered with.
Comment on this
As far as I can read the amendment, it does not propose to interfere with the power of the Minister. It still permits the Minister to grant or refuse a pension. I do not think we ought to pass this amendment. It is purely a matter for the local authority to make a decision in regard to the pension; if they feel their servant is deserving of one they can grant it, and on the other hand, if they think he is not deserving of consideration, a pension may be refused.
Comment on this
Sometimes in this country political passions and prejudices become very strong and there are times when faithful and deserving servants might be refused a pension merely because the local authority may, at the moment, be excited and may become somewhat hostile because of political views. I think it is unfair that the granting of pensions should be subject to political passions and prejudices.
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned that a man might be disemployed because of bad conduct or anything like that. There is nothing in the amendment to prevent a local authority from dismissing any person who does not carry out his duties properly. At the same time any person entering the service should have some guarantee of fair treatment on retiring. In this matter we are bigger-minded than some people. We believe that a person who has given good service and is entitled to fair treatment, should get that treatment. When pensions are guaranteed they ought to be paid. There should be no ambiguity on that matter, and nobody should be prevented from getting what he is entitled to.
Comment on this
The object of this Bill is that certain officials should get pensions. It seems difficult to understand why the word "may" is put in. Of course there is an appeal to the Minister if the local body refuse to grant the pension; but even in that case the Minister is not bound to give the pension. If he thinks the local body were wrong in refusing, he may decide to grant the pension. You will see in Section 37 that under given conditions officials who fulfil those conditions would still be at the mercy of local authorities. I do not know whether that is intended, but whatever the Government's intention is it should be made plain. If it is the intention to give certain conditions under which certain officials have a right to have pensions, the section is not drafted that way. If it is intended, on the other hand, that the local authority, no matter whether the conditions are fulfilled or not, shall always have a discretion, then the section is right.
Comment on this
It is obviously the intention of the section that officers of local authorities shall have the right to a pension under certain conditions. One is that they shall satisfy the local authorities as to the service they render. If they do not do that they are not entitled to a pension. I do not believe it is necessary to make any change in the section.
Comment on this
Where is there any provision about their not being satisfied? It only applies to a man who has not been removed for misconduct or incapacity. If an officer of a council is removed for misconduct or incapacity he has no pension rights at all. I do not see where there is any provision about withholding a pension if they think he has not done good work.
Comment on this
There is a big difference between removing a man who has not performed his duties properly and one who has rendered the continuous and satisfactory service which officers of local bodies are supposed to give. These are in exactly the same position as officers under the civil service, who were also subject to the control of the higher authorities all along. I might point out that under the Bill those officers are in a much better position than before. Heretofore, they could be dismissed by the local authority without any pension and without any appeal to the Minister. Now they have the right of appeal to the Minister and this is a safeguard against victimisation for political or religious reasons, or something of that kind.
Comment on this
I only want to see that whatever object the Government have in view is carried out by legislation. I do not want to interfere with the policy of the Government at all, but it seems to me that we are not dealing here with officers who were dismissed for misconduct or incapacity. If an officer is dismissed for misconduct or incapacity he does not get any pension. An officer who has not been found incapable or guilty of misconduct is not, under the present Bill, secured in his pension. It is still left to the discretion of the local authority to give it or not. That may be the intention of the Government. If it is, they have carried it out. But if it is the intention of the Government that, given certain conditions, a man of certain years' service, who has not been removed for misconduct or incapacity, is to have a vested right, this section does not give that right. It is "may" and not "shall." The Bill says the local authority "may with the consent of the Minister," and so on. That is how sub-sections (2) and (3) of Section 38 read. There is no obligation there upon the local authority to grant a pension to anybody.
Comment on this
The Minister brings up the case of the civil servants. We presume that the Minister will not act unfairly. He is trusted with a certain amount of discretionary power in that matter. But is it quite the same thing to give the discretion to a local body which is subject to passion and prejudice to a certain extent? We are all subject to those things. We are carried away, from time to time, by the most extraordinary prejudices. I think that an officer who has done his work efficiently should get the security that this amendment would give him.
Comment on this
It seems to me, on reading the section, that this only applies to pensionable officers; that is to say, the people entitled to pensions already. Those people are entitled to pensions, and if they have attained the age of 65 years and have become incapable of discharging their duties by reason of infirmities, what right have the local authorities to withhold the pension from them? I think what the Senator proposes is a perfectly fair thing, and I would certainly support the amendment.
Comment on this
I am afraid that Senator Sir Thomas Esmonde is not right in his view of the matter. I take it the idea is that an officer "may" be pensioned, not that an officer "must" be pensioned. Therefore a local body may refuse to give a pension, but the officer is protected by sub-section (6).
Comment on this
Even under that, the Minister is not bound to give him a pension, though he thinks the local authority was wrong. He "may" give it.
Comment on this
Yes, it is "may." The question is whether that is really protection. A local body that is conscious of its duty and conscious of the services of the man who has left, would give that man a pension. If, in the discharge of their duty, they decline to do so, that man can appeal to the Minister.
Comment on this
Under the Local Government Act of 1898, were not existing officers entitled to a pension?
Comment on this
They were. That was the only Act that gave an absolute right of pension, and it gave it because it was passed under peculiar circumstances. It was passed at a time when in this country it was feared that the local bodies would, for political or other reasons, get rid of their officers without pensions. In point of fact, some of them were got rid of. That was the whole object in putting it into the Act of 1898. Therefore, on that account, they did make the giving of a pension compulsory.
Comment on this
Amendments of a somewhat similar kind are down for other parts of the section. I think we may deal with the whole thing on this amendment.
Comment on this
If you read sub-section (6) of Section 38 you will come to the conclusion that it is really immaterial whether the word is "may" or "shall." The sub-section says that the Minister "may" grant such an allowance as he considers should be granted by the local body. He "may" grant it to him, but if the word is altered to "shall," on appeal the Minister may even then consider that no allowance should be granted by the local body. He may say that the word "shall" is qualified by what follows, and he may refuse to give him the pension. The effect is the same whether it is "shall" or "may."
Comment on this
With great respect, I say that is not the case at all. The position is that if the Minister, on appeal, thinks that the officer should get a pension of a certain amount he "may," as the Bill stands at present, give it to him. If the word is altered to "shall," then, if he thinks he ought to get the pension, he is bound to give it to him. That is a difference. and it is a very important difference.
Comment on this
I move:—
In sub-section (1), line 65, to delete the word "twenty" and to substitute therefor the word "thirty."
The amendment provides that every man getting a pension from a public body shall have given thirty years' service. As it stands, the clause provides that a man who joins a local authority at 45 years of age shall remain in employment until he is 65. I do not think that it is proper that a man who has spent a good deal of his life at other employment and who becomes an employee of a local authority at 45 should get a pension at 65. I think the Bill is too liberal. The clause as it stands would mean collecting a large sum of money from the ratepayers, who are unable to pay it. I am in favour of men getting pensions, but they should give long service.
Comment on this
I think the Senator's amendment goes a bit too far, but there is justification for some change, in so far as the age limit has been extended from 60 to 65 years. In practice, I do not think that it will amount to much. When a man comes to the age of 65 he can always be passed by a doctor as being incapable for further work. I would be willing to accept 25 years instead of 30.
Comment on this
On behalf of Senator O'Farrell, I move:—
In sub-section (1) to add at the end of the sub-section the words "and not less than one-sixtieth of his yearly salary and emoluments for each completed year of service."
This amendment provides for a minimum scale of pensions. It does not compel the local authority to give a pension, but where a pension is given it provides for a minimum figure. The usual practice in calculating the amount of a pension is to give one-sixtieth for every year of service. This amendment would simply ensure that a minimum of one-sixtieth for every completed year of service would be the amount of the pension, given.
Comment on this
I do not quite understand this amendment. If you look at sub-section (1) you will find that it has a scale of allowance, not greater than two-thirds of the yearly salary and emoluments. I do not see where this new clause will come in.
Comment on this
Then it would be, "not greater than two-thirds of his yearly salary and emoluments and not less than one-sixtieth."
Comment on this
That is the object. Forty-sixtieths is the usual sum given to a person getting the full terms. I want to have it so that where he does not get that he will not get less than one-sixtieth for each year of service.
Comment on this
We had the thin end of the wedge in the last amendment of Senator O'Farrell, in order to compel the local authorities to pay a pension. This now is to determine the minimum amount of pension they will pay. The other was a simple amendment, but this is much more serious. I am altogether opposed to this principle of minimum pensions. In practice it has worked out very badly. I may instance the case made by Senator O'Rourke with regard to county secretaries whose salaries have been greatly increased as a result of the franchise fees. If we accept the minimum pension scale in the case of an officer whose salary, for some reason or another, may be very greatly increased, his pension will be calculated on his salary for the last three years of his service. If the salary for those three years happened to be swelled it would mean that he would get a very large pension calculated on the one-sixtieth scale. It would be very invidious thing to allow such an amendment to go through. There has been experience in other countries of the application of putting into force minimum pensions. It was found unworkable, and in many cases crippling on local rates. For that reason I am opposed to acceptance of the amendment.
Comment on this
The section provides for a maximum pension for people who are entitled to it, and the amendment provides for a minimum pension for those who are entitled to it. I understand that all pensions are based on one-sixtieth for every year of service.
Comment on this
Are you quite certain that under your amendment the minimum would not sometimes exceed the maximum?
Comment on this
On the other hand, if he is to get not less than one-sixtieth of his yearly salary and emoluments for each completed year of service, that in fact may amount to more than the maximum you have already fixed.
Comment on this
It is provided that a person cannot get more than two-thirds. It is fair that a person should not get less than one-sixtieth. There is nothing sinister in the amendment.
Comment on this
The Seanad has approved of the principle of a mandate to local authorities to grant pensions on specified conditions being fulfilled. In the concluding part of sub-section (6), there is given, if the man is dissatisfied with the pension that must now be given to him, the right of appeal to the Minister. I think you have gone pretty far in protecting him without putting in this provision, which may cause confusion.
Comment on this
It would be impossible to carry out such a proposal. In one case it would be offending the Medes and in the other case the Persians.
Comment on this
I suggest that leave be given to withdraw the amendment, and if Senator O'Farrell desires he can bring it forward on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
The next amendment is as follows:—
Section 38, sub-section (2), line 7.
To delete the word "may" and to substitute therefor the word "shall."
This amendment is the same as one we have just passed.
Comment on this
The next amendment, No. 90, goes out. Amendment No. 91 is as follows:—
Section 38, sub-section (3), line 20.
To delete the word "may" and substitute therefor the word "shall."
Comment on this
I move the following amendment on behalf of Senator The Earl of Wicklow:—
Section 38, sub-section (3). To add at the end of the sub-section the words "provided that such annual allowances granted under this Act, may, with the consent of the Minister, be commuted in accordance with the provisions of section 6 of the Act 63 and 64 Vic., C. 63."
There is nothing compulsory about the amendment. It simply gives power to local authorities if they desire to grant a small pension to commute it for a lump sum of money. It is conceivable that it might be much more useful for a man to get a few pounds than be drawing a very small pension for a series of years. It would also work out conveniently for the local authorities, as instead of paying two or three pounds every year they would commute the pension by paying a lump sum. It is a permissive power.
Comment on this
I do not agree with this principle of commutation of pensions. It is a very serious thing when an officer of a local authority is granted a pension. He is granted it with the object of preventing him from becoming a charge on the rates in any capacity in future years, and if you commute the pension it is quite likely that the officer may become a charge upon the rates. I think that we should safeguard the ratepayers from such a contingency as that. For that reason I would ask the Seanad not to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I do not think that the Minister quite sees the purport of the amendment. It does not make any greater charge upon the rates really than would occur in the normal course of things. It simply deals with the case of a man who gets a small pension, and it is purely permissive.
Comment on this
There is no point in its smallness. The amendment covers all pensions—"provided that such annual allowances granted under this Act." That means, "provided such pensions granted under this Act."
Comment on this
You are quite right, sir, as usual. But Senator the Earl of Wicklow told me that he was anxious to put in a word for the people with small pensions. I would like the Government to look into the matter and see if it could not be met on Report.
Comment on this
Of course the Minister's point would make it a fortiori, in the case of a smaller pension because he says the object of preventing it being commuted is that the man will have something to live on for the rest of his life, and not get a lump sum which he could squander and then throw himself on the rates.
Comment on this
That would be a very sad result of our philanthropic efforts. It is not a matter of any importance, and if the Minister likes to look into it before Report it could be moved again. Anyhow, it leaves full power to Senator the Earl of Wicklow to proceed in any way he considers best.
Comment on this
I move:—
Immediately before sub-section (4) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
(4) If any person to whom an allowance is granted by a local body in pursuance of sub-section (2) of this section, makes within three months from the date of the granting of such allowance an application for a gratuity in lieu of such allowance, such local body may, with the consent of the Minister, grant to such person a gratuity not greater than one-sixth of his yearly salary and emoluments for each completed year of his service and if such person accepts such gratuity his right to receive such allowance shall cease.
This amendment is practically the same as the last. It is to give a person who is entitled to a pension the right to say: "I would rather have a gratuity," and the same objection applies to it.
Comment on this
I suppose the Government is objecting to this too?
Comment on this
I move:—
Immediately before sub-section (4) to insert a new sub-section (4) as follows:—
"Where a pensionable officer qualifying for a life allowance under sub-section (2) of this section died within the year of abolition of his office and prior to the passing of this Act the Minister shall be empowered to allocate to his dependents an annual allowance not exceeding one-half that to which the said officer would have been entitled had he lived and such allowance shall be determined by the Minister on investigation of the circumstances of the dependency and shall cease when the Minister may reasonably assume that the dependency no longer exists."
This amendment is simply brought forward to cover, I believe, one isolated case. I do not think another could have arisen in the whole Twenty-six Counties. I refer to a case in the County Cork where an official filled the position of clerk to a board of guardians and rural district council for over twenty years, and a fortnight before the board of guardians ceased to exist he had to undergo an operation for appendicitis. Though previously in the full vigour of health, he unfortunately died under the operation and left a widow and nine children, the youngest only two months. This family has been greatly respected in the neighbourhood, Macroom, and the surrounding district, and I think this is a case that the Minister might take into very favourable consideration and in which he might grant some pension for the widow and her helpless children in the circumstances. I might further say that it had been decided to withdraw the powers of the guardians a month previously, but for some reason or other it was put off, and in the meantime the poor man died.
Comment on this
Is there any way of doing this without making an amendment, because it seems to be an isolated and exceptional case, and a case which, if the amendment were passed, would be based on an understanding that it was to be merely retrospective? I think that the case is a worthy one, but it is one of those cases that ought to be dealt with in camera, perhaps directly with the Minister; it is hardly a case for special inclusion in a Bill. If there was some middle way, it seems to me that it would get more support, the support it deserves, but it always militates against a case when one has to use the machinery of the law to deal with it, because you would never get away from the precedent. I think it would be better for the Minister to deal with it simply as an isolated case.
Comment on this
It seems to me that if this amendment were adopted it would be putting this person in an extraordinarily favoured position. If that official had been granted a pension and had died, the family would have been in no different position from that in which they are now, except that they would have been drawing the pension for a month or two. It is a pretty hard case, and a case for philanthropic people to assist, but not a case specially for the legislature. The position is very little different from what it would be for the unfortunate woman if her husband had lived another month. The pension would still be gone.
Comment on this
I am afraid I do not know where he would get the money from.
Comment on this
I have not got that power. Senator Haughton has called your attention to a very hard case, but as we have often heard, hard cases make bad law, and it is a very serious step to legislate for an isolated case of this kind. I would be in a much more sympathetic mood if the Senator were looking to me for a subscription to provide for that case, rather than by coming to me as a Minister to put in an amendment to deal with it. I am sure that a great deal of sympathy would be given to that case in the locality concerned. If the local charitable people undertook to open a subscription list, I am sure that there would be a very favourable response.
Comment on this
The Senator will see the tremendous difficulty pointed out by Senator Bennett, because this case is no more hard— in fact, the hardship is scarcely as great as if this unfortunate man had actually got his pension the day before he was operated upon. There may be cases where the recipients of these pensions may die this year. They may only be in receipt of their pensions for a month or two.
Comment on this
Do you not think that it is a strong order to ask them to put into an Act of Parliament a clause that will be there for all time and that only deals with a case that has already occurred and will not arise again? If this was to be done, I think the only safe way to do it would be actually to insert the name in the clause.
Comment on this
You would have to withdraw this particular clause and consider whether you would bring up a clause on the Report Stage which would be directly conversant with the one case, and the one case only. I am not encouraging you to do it, because I do not believe that you will ever get the Seanad to accept it.
Comment on this
In the meantime, perhaps the Minister would communicate with the Minister for Finance on the subject, and they might arrive at some satisfactory conclusion.
Comment on this
I shall put it to the House now if you wish.
Comment on this
I think I should surprise you, sir, if you did. I think I should be able to carry it, but I do not want to press it too much.
Comment on this
If you think you could carry it you should press it now.
Comment on this
No, you have taken your chance now. In view of that decision I would not allow you to bring it up on Report.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
Section 38. After sub-section (6), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"(7) The provision of a gratuity by a local body under this section shall be a purpose for which such local body may borrow in accordance with the enactments relating to borrowing by such local body."
This seems necessary to give local bodies power to borrow. Their borrowing powers are strictly limited and this will give them power to borrow, in the case of an office which has been abolished. It may be an office with a very considerable salary. If the officer has less than ten years' service he is entitled to a gratuity, which is to be measured by so many years of his salary and might mean a very considerable sum. This amendment is to give a local body the power of borrowing a sum like that instead of putting it on the rates for a single year.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
Section 38, after sub-section (6) to add the following new sub-sections:—
(7) It shall be lawful for a local body with the consent of the Minister to grant an employee (who is not a pensionable officer as defined in this Act) who either
(a) has attained the age of 65 years and has at least twenty years' service, or
(b) becomes incapable of discharging the duties of his office with efficiency by reason of permanent infirmity of mind or body or of old age and has not less than ten years' service,
an annual allowance for his life calculated in accordance with the provision of a scheme to be approved by the Minister.
(8) Schemes under this section shall include provision for contributions towards the cost of such allowances from the employees who would benefit thereby.
I think this amendment is in line with the Minister's promise, A Chathaoirligh.
Comment on this
It is generally admitted that some new way of dealing with manual workers under public bodies is needed other than the present way, which is most unsatisfactory.
Comment on this
Have you not received an assurance from the Minister, Senator, that when he gets an opportunity of doing it, he intends to bring in a Bill to deal with this whole question, and in consequence of that assurance I think the other amendment was not pressed. Your amendment is precisely on the same lines. If you look at the end of it, it suggests that pensions should be based on a contributory scale. It seems to me to fall in with the Minister's suggestion that this would be more appropriate in a separate Bill.
Comment on this
It is proposed to include in the Bill power to local authorities to draw up schemes and submit them to the Minister for approval. These schemes would not come into operation until they had his approval. The Dublin Corporation has that power by special Act. The Limerick Corporation has that power. Other Corporations and other bodies would follow suit and in time the present anomalies would be met. It would not impose any undue burden on the Minister to deal with these schemes in his own way in his own time, revise them as he thought best, and only approve of such schemes as he thought applicable. That is the only difference, so that the thing may be put into operation at once. The Minister's Bill can deal with all remaining bodies, those bodies who do not put forward schemes. This amendment gives power to other corporations to draw up a scheme for the Minister's consideration and approval.
Comment on this
I do not think this is the right way to attack this problem at all. It must be dealt with by the central authority. The foundation factor, after all, providing pensions for employees, is one common to the whole country, and it is not affected by local conditions. It would only prejudice the success of any scheme, any valuable scheme, if it is initiated piecemeal and without any concerted plan by the various bodies all over the country. I think something of this kind is most necessary to deal with the whole chaotic condition of public assistance generally, of which pensions form part, and it should form the subject of a special Commission of Inquiry and, following on that, legislation. To deal with it in this manner would be, I submit, impracticable and unbusinesslike, and it would only make any subsequent legislation much more difficult.
Comment on this
This amendment is not open to any of the arguments that were used against the former amendment because it lays down that a person to qualify for a pension must have attained the age of 65 years or have at least twenty years' service. In dealing with the last amendment some Senator referred to the case of people who were only three or four years employed. I think it will have to be admitted by everybody that there is an injustice inflicted on certain sections of the community. People in the same service, after giving a certain number of years' service, are entitled to get pensions and other people are not. The argument of the Minister for giving pensions to officials in the higher grades, professional people or the medical staff, was that they accepted these positions and remained on because they believed that portion of the salaries was being stopped for pensionable purposes. We who have experience of public boards know that is not the case. Anybody who is a member of a public board knows that when an appointment takes place to any of these positions, relations to the fortieth and fiftieth degree are canvassed to bring their influence to bear to get these jobs. Instead of running away from them they are anxious to run into them. I think that statement cannot be contradicted, so the argument of these people being asked to contribute out of their wages to a superannuation fund falls to the ground.
Now, the position at the moment is that certain public authorities in Ireland, by special Act of Parliament, have been given powers to grant pensions to their employees irrespective of whether they are officers or workmen. The Dublin Corporation, by special Act in the British Parliament, got power to pension their employees. I understand from Senator Kenny's remarks that the Limerick Corporation has similar power. The position at present is that in Dublin City a man working in the sewer department or on the roads is entitled to a pension after a certain number of years' service. While I am arguing this question of pensions. I do not want any Senator to think that I am in favour of people being paid pensions who are not entitled to them. I am simply asking for fair play all round. An employee of the Dublin Corporation is entitled, after twenty or thirty years' service, to a pension, while the employee of Dublin County Council, just across the bridge, may be performing the same work for 40 years and not be entitled to a pension. Whatever is done in one case should be done in the other. I agree with Senator Sir John Keane that pensions should be based on a contributory scheme, and if the Minister will undertake to introduce, within a reasonable time, a Bill dealing with that aspect of the case, I will be satisfied.
Comment on this
I have not much more to say on this amendment than I said on the last amendment of a similar kind. I am in favour of dealing with this question of pensions to employees on a contributory basis, but I think raising the matter in a haphazard way like this is not the right way to go about it and, as Senator Sir John Keane pointed out, it would prejudice any scheme that may be proposed later. If local authorities were allowed to put up schemes of their own they would oppose a new scheme when brought into being. The employees might oppose it, and it would create great difficulties in any future scheme. I am altogether in favour of superannuation of employees under a proper superannuation scheme, but I believe if we were to bring in such a scheme it would be of very little service to existing employees, because a local authority taking in employees of that kind who would become pensionable would have to insist on a medical examination. There should also be a rule as to the length of time an officer should serve before becoming pensionable. That would be based on the amount he would contribute towards his own pension. The mere fact of having twenty years' service, if he were not contributing during those twenty years, would not entitle him to a pension. I do not think existing officers have anything to complain about in that respect. I will, at the earliest opportunity, bring forward a Bill of this kind, but I am not in a position to fix a specific date.
Comment on this
I recognise that many matters will have to be gone into before an equitable and proper scheme can be formulated. I quite appreciate the Minister's viewpoint and, having regard to the assurance given, I take the responsibility of withdrawing the amendment, which was suggested by the General Council of County Councils.
Comment on this
I move:—
Section 44, sub-section 1, line 16. To delete all from the words "out of" to the words "may be" in line 17.
Perhaps the Seanad would allow me to explain the necessity for this and the next amendment, which reads:—
Amendment 98.—Section 44, sub-section (2). To delete the sub-section and to substitute therefor a new sub-section as follows:—
"(2) Any sum payable under this part of this Act by a local body in respect of an allowance or gratuity granted to a person who was previously an officer or employee of that local body or of a committee thereof or of a joint committee of that and any other local body shall be raised by means of the same rate and be paid out of the same funds and be charged on the same area as the salary or wages of such person would have been raised by means of and paid out of and charged upon if he had continued to hold the same office or employment under the said local body, committee or joint committee as the case may be, and such sum shall not be reckoned for the purpose of any enactment limiting the amount of such rate."
The necessity for the first amendment is due to the striking out of sub-section (2) and the substitution of another clause for it. The whole of this clause deals with the pensions or gratuities granted to officers of committees of local bodies, and with them only. Sub-section (1) provides that those pensions allowances or gratuities should be paid out of the county, district or borough fund, as the case may be. Proper provision is made for the proper payment of those gratuities and pensions out of a certain fund. As this Bill stands at present, there is no right to strike a rate for the pensions and gratuities that are granted under it. Therefore, what is proposed to be done by the new sub-section (2) is to strike out the existing sub-section (2) and introduce another sub-section which gives the local bodies the necessary right to strike a rate and to make those gratuities payable. (Proposed new sub-section quoted.) That is an absolutely and necessary provision, because under the Bill they had not the power to do this. It is proposed to insert this as a new sub-section of clause 44. That would necessitate striking out in lines 16 and 17 of clause 1 the words "out of the county or district borough fund as the case may be," because those words were inserted to give the local body the power of paying out of those funds an allowance or gratuity to the officer of a committee.
Comment on this
Would the effect of this be that the pension, say, of the clerk of a district council would be charged on the area to which he previously belonged?
Comment on this
That is not quite equitable, because the county council have collared all the assets and the property of these bodies and yet they are charging the pension on the old area. I do not think in actual point of money or relief it would mean very much, but it is not consistent. I do not know whether the Minister has considered the point.
Comment on this
I would like to know whether the pensions provided by this Bill will be paid out of the same funds from which were paid the salaries of the officers previously. Take the case of a public health officer belonging to a district council. Part of his salary was refunded from, I think, the local taxation account, and I would like to know whether any portion of the pension he is entitled to will come out of that fund in future. The same thing will apply to other officers. There are technical and agricultural instructors whose salary was also partly provided from another source. Will any part of their pension be paid out of the same fund that was paying portion of their salaries?
Comment on this
With regard to Senator Sir John Keane's objection, I think if he reads sub-section (3) of Section 68 it will clear up that matter:
If any existing officer of a rural district council is removed from office in consequence of changes effected by or under this Act, the cost of any compensation granted to such officer for such loss of office shall be charged on the area of the county to the council of which the business of such rural district council is transferred by this Act, exclusive of the area of any urban district in such county.
Comment on this
Do you propose that your clause 44 should be an exception to the general rule?
Comment on this
No, it is a general power defining the fund out of which those pensions or gratuities should be paid.
Comment on this
What about the clause which Senator Sir John Keane pointed out? Is it consistent with that?
Comment on this
"It shall be charged on the area of the county to the council."
Comment on this
It is very peculiar. First it says what it is to be charged on, and secondly, to whom it is to be charged. The words are "shall be charged on the area of the county to the council."
Comment on this
We will insert "save as provided by Section 68, sub-section (3)." All these sections can be considered together, and if there is any trouble or ambiguity we can discuss it on Report.
Comment on this
Those duties are to be transferred to the county council. Heretofore one half of the salaries under the Public Health Acts was refunded by the Government. Seemingly now the county council will have to bear the whole salaries under the Public Health Acts. Half should be returned now from the Central Fund.
Comment on this
There is no specific provision in the Bill. The county council would, by the wording of the Bill, bear all the salaries.
Comment on this
There is nothing in it to alter the position.
Comment on this
Amendment 98 is a complicated matter, and I strongly recommend the suggestion that the Minister should look into it.
Comment on this
My present impression is that it is wrong and that the section should be left as it was.
Comment on this
Section 19, sub-section (3), says: "the salary of a county medical officer of health shall be paid by the county council and shall be charged on the area for which he acts." If I have the assurance of the Minister that being a sanitary area under the definition here the old rule regarding contribution shall apply it is all right. It does not say so specifically in the Bill.
Comment on this
That is an important point, and I hope you will call attention to it again on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move:—
Section 45. Immediately before sub-section (2), insert a new sub-section (2) as follows:—
(2) This part of this Act shall apply to any officer of a local body who before the 6th day of December, 1922, resigned his office under such local body for the purpose of taking up any employment under the control of Dáil Eireann, as if such officer had resigned such office after attaining the age of sixty-five years, and having at least 20 years' service, but if such officer is or has been appointed to a permanent situation in the Civil Service of the Government of Saorstát Eireann any allowance granted to him by virtue of this section shall not be payable to such officer during the period when he holds such situation.
I do not know why the 6th December, 1922, is put down because people who were complying with all the rest of this Bill are excluded by that. I know one particular case of an official who was for many years eligible. He served the County Council somewhere in Tipperary and he was brought up from that to the headquarters here. He is now put on to another job. That particular date excludes him, while if he remained in Tipperary he would have been eligible. He was taken up by the Ministry and put on a job here and he is not eligible under the new rule. There may be other people in the same position. This particular person is doing work for the Minister for Defence and he is excluded even though he was eligible and was constantly employed.
Comment on this
As well as I can make out, the Senator wants two new provisions in the section. He wants it to be retrospective beyond the 6th December and he wishes it to apply to officers who have taken on different employment from what they had under the local authority. This section is intended only to apply to men doing the same kind of work as they were doing under the local authority. We have fixed on the 6th December as it is the date on which the Constitution came into operation. We feel we are not responsible for any actions that took place before that date. We have entered into contractual relations with officers taken over by the Central Government from the local authorities after that date and they received an undertaking to the effect that their services under the local authorities would receive consideration when they were taken over by the Central Government.
That condition only applies to those officers who were taken over by our Government after we became a Government under the Constitution. It does not apply to officers who were taken over previous to that date. That is the reason for fixing the 6th December. We have to fix some date.
Comment on this
I did not bring forward the amendment originally, so I am moving it on the spur of the moment. I know of other cases. I do not like to bring up personal cases. It is very disagreeable to do that. I recognise that laws should be made for the majority of the people and not for individual cases. There are other cases similar to the one I referred to. This was a very competent officer employed for years in Tipperary as an agricultural instructor. He was brought up to the Department in Dublin and showed himself to be a very good official. After being employed there for some time he was taken over by the Minister for Defence to look after lands which come under his Department and he is doing that at present. He comes under no other section for a pension.
Comment on this
This section would not help him, because your amendment only affects the date and does not purport to affect the provision that the duties he is now discharging must be similar to those which he discharged before transfer.
Comment on this
According to your original statement, they seem to be wholly different. You say now he is employed by the Minister for Defence in connection with lands.
Comment on this
He is paid by the Department of Agriculture. He is just temporarily looking after these extensive lands near Fermoy and other places where the Government have got a lot of land. He is merely taken from his regular employment and, owing to that, he is cut out of this section. Perhaps the Minister would look into his case and see that he is not unfairly treated.
Comment on this
I cannot give any undertaking in this case. The amendment broadens the section very much. As you, Sir, have pointed out, the duties are not by any means the same under the Minister for Defence. Even though they do happen to be connected with land, they are not the same as his duties as an agricultural instructor under a local authority. If we were to broaden this section so as to include people of that kind, we would not know where it would lead to.
Comment on this
Apart from this, would the Minister look into the case and see that the man is not put under any real disadvantage?
Comment on this
I move:—
"Section 45. Immediately before sub-section. (2) to insert a new sub-section (2) as follows":—
(2) This part of this Act shall apply to any officer of a local body who before the 6th day of December, 1922, resigned his office under such local body for the purpose of taking up any employment under the control of Dáil Eireann, as if such officer had resigned such office after attaining the age of sixty-five years, and having at least 20 years' service, but if such officer is or has been appointed to a permanent situation in the Civil Service of the Government of Saorstát Eireann any allowance granted to him by virtue of this section shall not be payable to such officer during the period when he holds such situation.
There is some similarity between this amendment and the amendment moved by Senator Colonel Moore. The Minister in dealing with Senator Moore's amendment said the Government only took responsibility for employees of local bodies who transferred their services from the local boards to the Government, when they became a Government in December, 1922. I suggest that that is not treating fairly the men who left their positions as employees in public boards, and went into the service of Dáil Eireann. They are making it all right for those who left when it was safe, but they are cutting out the men who took the risk when it was not safe, and became servants of what was called a rabble organisation at the time. I think it is unfair to cut these people out who went into the service of what they believed was the Government of the people. I think this amendment should be accepted.
Comment on this
I think the same arguments apply against this as against Senator Colonel Moore's amendment. It broadens the whole basis of the section, and enables people to get pensions who are performing duties altogether different to what they were performing under the local authorities. I do not know how many people would be included under this, and if we were to put it in it might be a very heavy additional burden on the ratepayers.
Comment on this
Would the Minister undertake to consider this particular amendment, in view of the fact that Senator Farren says that it applies only to two or three people.
Comment on this
What the Senator overlooks is that a precisely similar amendment was discussed in the Dáil, so that it does not come by surprise on the Minister.