Financial Statements 2022: Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board
Contributions 1–228 of 704. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
Apologies have been received from Deputies Imelda Munster, Marc Ó Cathasaigh and Cormac Devlin. I welcome everyone. I remind all in attendance to ensure their mobile phones are switched off or are on silent mode. Before we start, I wish to explain some limitations to parliamentary privilege and the practice of the Houses as regards references witnesses may make to other persons in their evidence. The evidence of witnesses physically present or who give evidence from within the parliamentary precincts is protected, pursuant to both the Constitution and statute, by absolute privilege. This means that witnesses have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty, as Cathaoirleach, to ensure it is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
Members and witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Members are also reminded of the provisions of Standing Order 218, that the committee shall refrain from inquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government or the merits of the objectives of such policies. Furthermore, it is not the role of the committee to make findings of fact about a person who is not a Member of the Oireachtas that could impinge on their good name or reputation. I ask members to be mindful of this in their examination of the issues in question this morning. Members and witnesses should also refrain from commenting on matters that may now be subject of a live criminal investigation.
The Comptroller and Auditor General, Mr. Seamus McCarthy, is a permanent witness to the committee. He is accompanied this morning by Mr. Mark Brady, deputy director at the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General. This morning we are engaging with representatives from Horse Racing Ireland and the Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board to examine the following matters: financial statements 2022 - Horse Racing Ireland; and financial statements 2022 - Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board. We are joined by the following representatives from Horse Racing Ireland: Ms Suzanne Eade, chief executive officer; Mr. John Osborne, director of equine welfare and blood stock; and Ms Claire Rudd, head of risk and compliance. We are joined by the following representatives from the Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board: Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin, chief executive officer; and Dr. Lynn Hillyer, chief veterinary officer and head of equine anti-doping. We are also joined by the following officials from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine: Mr. Gordon Conroy, assistant secretary, finance and central procurement; Mr. Michael Sheahan, deputy chief veterinary officer; and Ms Annamarie McNally, assistant principal horse and greyhound racing and Teagasc. The witnesses are very welcome.
I call the Comptroller and Auditor General, Mr. Seamus McCarthy, for his opening statement.
Comment on this
Go raibh maith agat a Chathaoirligh.
Horse Racing Ireland was established as a statutory agency for the control, regulation and development of the horse racing industry in Ireland. It operates racing and tote activities through eight active subsidiary companies and licenses horse racing at other privately owned tracks. HRI also has a minority shareholding in Curragh Racecourse Limited.
HRI received State funding of €70.4 million in 2022, sourced from the horse and greyhound racing fund. Its other main sources of income in the year were: race entry fees and sponsorships earmarked for racing prize money, totalling €25.6 million; media payments of €7 million; registration fees totalling €2.6 million; and net income from racing arising from tote and HRI-owned racecourses of €1.6 million.
On the expenditure side in 2022, HRI paid out €68.2 million in prize money. Expenditure of €16.7 million was incurred on "integrity and racecourse services", mainly representing grants to the Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board. Overall, the HRI group incurred a deficit for 2022 of €5.7 million. Its net assets amounted to €111 million as at the end of that year.
The 2022 financial statements received an unqualified opinion, but I drew attention to the disclosure in the group statement of income and expenditure of a loss of €1.4 million in 2022, relating to Horse Racing Ireland’s investment in Curragh Racecourse Limited. CRL was established to provide for the redevelopment and management of the Curragh racecourse, in a joint venture involving HRI, the Turf Club and a number of private investors. As at 31 December 2022, HRI held a 35.29% economic share in the racecourse. As explained in notes 36 and 38 of the group financial statements, HRI has provided equity investment and grant funding totalling almost €36 million to CRL up to the end of 2022. A further €0.5 million was paid for the right to use a hospitality suite at the Curragh for 30 years and there were two small loans from HRI outstanding at the year end.
In 2020, HRI entered into a new €9 million convertible loan agreement with CRL. As at 31 December 2022, €8.24 million had been transferred to CRL. The maturity date on the loan was 31 January 2024 and under the terms of the loan agreement, the loan was convertible into shares on that date, at CRL's discretion. That option was exercised by CRL and HRI's economic interest in the company increased to 37.4%, from that conversion.
The Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board is a company limited by guarantee. The board was established by the Turf Club and the Irish National Hunt Steeplechase Committee, with effect from 1 January 2018, for the purpose of carrying out the regulatory and licensing functions for Irish horse racing, as provided for in the Horse Racing Ireland Act 2016. The members of the board are appointed by the Turf Club and the Irish National Hunt Steeplechase Committee. The board has a number of statutory functions, including: responsibility for making and enforcing of the rules of racing, provision of integrity services for horse racing; licensing of all participants in horse racing in Ireland; and doping control, forensic testing and handicapping in respect of horse racing.
The board received funding of €12.3 million from HRI in 2022. This accounted for 88% of its income in the year. The board also received €1.3 million in licensing income, collected on its behalf by HRI from trainers and jockeys. Overall, IHRB operates on a financial break-even basis. In 2022, it expended €8.5 million on integrity services and €3.8 million on administrative expenses.
The 2022 financial statements received a clear audit opinion. Without qualifying that opinion, I drew attention in my report to a financial governance issue disclosed in note 18 to the financial statements, which deals with related party transactions. The note discloses that €350,000 was transferred from the jockeys' emergency fund, a charity bank account under the control of the Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board, to the board’s own bank account in January 2022. The funds were subsequently repaid by the board to the same charity account in April 2022.
Note 24 and the statement on internal control report that concerns arose in June 2023 about the financial governance of those transactions and that an independent external review of those concerns and certain other matters was ongoing in March 2024 when the board's audited financial statements for 2022 were being finalised. The board's chief executive officer will be able to update the committee on progress with that review.
Comment on this
I thank the Chair and members of the committee. I am grateful to be given the opportunity to appear before the Committee of Public Accounts to assist with its examination of the 2022 financial statements of Horse Racing Ireland. I am the chief executive of HRI. Joining me today are Ms Claire Rudd, HRI’s head of risk and compliance, and Mr. John Osborne, HRI’s director of equine welfare and bloodstock.
HRI is a commercial semi-State body responsible to the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, having been established under the Horse and Greyhound Racing Act 2001. HRI is responsible for the overall administration, governance, development, and promotion of the Irish horseracing industry and we proudly do so on an all-island basis. The industry generates €2.4 billion for the economy annually and supports over 30,000 jobs directly and indirectly, the majority of which are based in rural Ireland. This means that the Government’s annual investment in the industry provides a 35-fold return to the Irish economy.
Ireland is seen internationally as a global leader in horse racing and breeding, and thoroughbreds owned, bred and trained in Ireland compete at the highest level on the world stage. We saw an example of this earlier in the month when Irish-trained horses prevailed in two of the world’s greatest races, the Derby and the Oaks at Epsom. This came just weeks after incredible Irish success at Cheltenham and Aintree. Our champion trainer, Willie Mullins, became the first non-British-based trainer since Vincent O'Brien 70 years ago to be crowned Britain’s champion national hunt trainer, a measure of Ireland’s success on both sides of the Irish Sea.
Government policy and legislation over many decades has put structures in place which have not only protected this 32-county industry but have also allowed Ireland to compete at the highest levels in world racing, while enabling vital and sustainable rural-based employment throughout the country. HRI and the entire horse racing and breeding industry are very grateful to successive Governments and the Oireachtas for their continued support through the horse and greyhound fund.
Before I come to the financial statements, it is very important to address the "RTÉ Investigates" programmes which were broadcast last week. On behalf of HRI, its board, the chairman and all our staff, I would like to say how deeply disgusted and appalled we are at what we saw in the programmes. The behaviour depicted was abhorrent and is absolutely not the experience of those working directly in the horse racing and breeding industry. We welcome the swift response from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine. We will fully support any Garda and Department of agriculture investigations, and we eagerly await their conclusion.
Equine safety and care is our top priority. Our budget accounts for €7 million annual expenditure on welfare for 2024. This is in addition to our welfare-related capital projects in recent years, such as CCTV provision on our 25 racecourses, traceability enhancements within our racing system, RÁS, together with grant aid for racecourses for welfare measures. In May, we announced a further €1 million funding in the next phase of a capital development scheme to further enhance equine safety at our racecourses. We also fund IHRB’s integrity services, which includes both raceday and out of competition veterinary inspections, and the IHRB’s best-practice anti-doping programme.
We work with organisations such as the Irish Horse Welfare Trust and Treo Eile which connect, support and promote thoroughbreds as they transition after their racing career. We provide education and training to industry participants, and held our first welfare symposium in May, which brought together stakeholders from across the sector to discuss the way ahead for equine safety and care. We consider the sharing of information, experiences and best practice across the entire industry to be key to achieving excellence in equine welfare.
The topic of traceability was also covered in the "RTÉ Investigates" programmes, and meaningful progress has been made in recent years. In 2021, Ireland was the first country in the EU to implement e-passports for thoroughbreds. These e-passports are a digital lifetime document which track the horse’s vaccines and medical records, ownership and movement. They contain five layers of identification, including the horse’s microchip number and, since 2001, DNA analysis. The first phase of a central traceability system for thoroughbreds has been built by Weatherbys, the organisation authorised to issue thoroughbred passports in Ireland and the UK. The next phase, which will go live next year, will connect different strands of data in one central database so that we can identify a horse’s whereabouts at key life cycle events. In addition, we are working with the equine liaison group, organised through the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine, on joined-up process mapping of all horse management, movement and control to enhance traceability and identify any potential data gaps. Whole-of-life traceability is an ongoing priority and we will continue to work with our colleagues in the Department and across the industry to enhance our systems and protocols.
In December 2023, we published HRI’s sustainability strategy, Racing towards a better world, which will continue to deliver on our responsibilities in respect of climate change concerns in line with the Government’s climate action plan. HRI is committed to fostering an industry-wide culture of sustainability. We also want to support the industry to increase its understanding and delivery of sustainability priorities through practical measures and financial supports, where possible. To achieve this, HRI will continuously share our learnings with industry stakeholders.
This April, we launched the strategic plan 2024-28 which outlines the ambition we have for the industry. This strategy provides the industry with a roadmap which will support people both working and investing into our industry. Beyond that, this strategy protects our horses, our environment and Ireland’s position as the epicentre of the thoroughbred industry well into the future. Our remit is to develop racing and breeding in Ireland, and our aim is to grow the contribution the industry makes to Irish communities from €2.4 billion currently to €3 billion by 2028. Driving long-term financial sustainability for the industry will stimulate expenditure and grow job opportunities, particularly in rural Ireland, and achieving this €3 billion figure is very much within reach by maximising all revenue streams. To nurture success, we aim to deliver on major capital projects within the lifetime of the strategic plan, which includes a people campus – an education and training facility with programmes and expertise designed to upskill those aspiring to a career in the wider thoroughbred industry. The targets in our strategic plan foresee a growing industry, one which will seek not just to attract the best talent from Ireland, but also to develop the country as a global centre of excellence for industry education and training.
The development of a new all-weather track at Tipperary Racecourse will create domestic opportunities at all levels of the industry as well as providing the marketplace for Irish racing to grow its annual foreign direct investment, which is currently estimated to be more than €550 million per annum. With only one all-weather track currently, Irish racing lags behind its international competitors. Given that almost half of the 550 licensed trainers in Ireland are based within neighbouring counties to Tipperary, this facility when developed will provide much-needed regional balance.
Our industry statistics from 2023 point to a stable industry. The number of horses in training increased. This is a key figure when it comes to assessing rural employment in the industry. Attendances in 2023 were marginally down on 2022, with minor reductions also recorded in the number of entries, figures that might have been expected in light of the cost-of-living crisis prevailing throughout that year. That said, racing continues to deliver superb sporting occasions showcasing the best of our industry and sport.
Finally, I wish to share with the committee that we have worked collaboratively with the IHRB over the past 12 months on significant transformational change within the IHRB in the areas of HR, IT and financial governance. This will allow the IHRB to focus on its core functions as a regulator and will provide HRI and the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine reassurance that the governance matters as highlighted by IHRB will be adequately resourced and addressed. We take governance maters relating to Exchequer funding very seriously and we are satisfied that adequate governance and compliance processes and systems have been developed and are being implemented. I thank the committee for the invitation to appear, and we look forward to taking questions on the accounts or any other maters concerning the racing and breeding industry.
Comment on this
On behalf of the Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board, I thank members for the invitation to appear before the Committee of Public Accounts to discuss our 2022 financial statements, alongside our colleagues from Horse Racing Ireland and the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine. I am joined by my colleague Dr. Lynn Hillyer, IHRB's chief veterinary officer.
The IHRB is the independent, internationally recognised racing regulatory body for horse racing across the island of Ireland, an industry that supports more than 30,000 jobs and contributes €2.46 billion to the economy. Under the Horse Racing Ireland Act 2016, the IHRB is solely and independently responsible for making and enforcing the rules of racing, licensing all participants and regulating horse racing, including anti-doping and handicapping. The IHRB provides professional officials and volunteer race day stewards for all race meetings in Ireland to ensure that the rules are properly observed, and the integrity of the sport is maintained. In 2022, the IHRB oversaw a combined 482 race fixtures across the 32 counties in flat, national hunt and point-to-point racing, with 39,825 runners in total. The corresponding figures for 2023 were 38,601 runners across 483 fixtures.
Governance is a key pillar of the IHRB’s strategy for 2024 to 2027, published late last year. The strategy commits us to consistently applying a robust governance framework and rigorous probity regime. The board of the IHRB is made up of eight directors, currently four male and four female. To improve board diversity and independence, the IHRB amended its constitution in 2022 to provide for the appointment of independent directors. Following an extensive recruitment process, two independent directors were appointed at year end and took office at the beginning of 2023.
The IHRB’s horse racing integrity services funding comes via Horse Racing Ireland, HRI, and we meet with them at least quarterly to ensure transparency and oversight of spending under the agreed budget. In mid-2023, a significantly revised and strengthened service level agreement, governing the provision and use of funding for horse racing integrity services was agreed between HRI and the IHRB and we continue to operate within the funding parameters agreed with HRI. Any reallocation of funding must be agreed with HRI and disclosed in the IHRB financial statements, as must severance scheme proposals prior to the circulation of terms to staff or representatives. The IHRB believes that our funding ought to be directed, as far as possible, towards our core functions of integrity, rider safety, equine welfare and licensing. However, other obligations relating to governance and probity must be met. These require significant resourcing to ensure they are delivered and reported to the expected standard. The IHRB is committed to effective joint working with HRI and efficient delivery of shared objectives. To that end, we have put in place a joint IT strategy and are exploring a shared services approach to key support functions such as finance, HR, procurement and compliance. This will realise gains in capacity, effectiveness and resilience, and eliminate key person dependencies.
As the committee will recall, the board became aware on 28 June 2023 of an issue relating to financial governance which had occurred in early 2022. This was immediately disclosed to the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, the Comptroller and Auditor General and Horse Racing Ireland. The issue concerned a transfer of €350,000 which was made in January 2022 from the jockeys emergency fund, a charity bank account administered by the IHRB, to the IHRB’s bank account. This was subsequently reversed in April 2022. The transfer is disclosed in the notes to the financial statements. The professional services firm Mazars was engaged to carry out an independent review of this and other financial governance matters. The review, which involves detailed scrutiny of six years’ worth of financial and other records as well as interviews with relevant individuals, commenced at the end of August 2023 and a final report is expected shortly. Pending receipt of the Mazars report, the auditors examined banking transactions for the financial year 2022 and confirmed that the highlighted transfer of €350,000 was an isolated incident. When the final report is received from Mazars, it is the intention of the directors of the IHRB that the findings will be published and the recommendations will be acted on.
In the meantime, formal agreements are being put in place between the IHRB and the various charitable and non-profit entities for which administrative support is provided, along with written policies and procedures clearly defining roles and responsibilities, strict transaction approval controls and segregation of accounts access. We will also implement any further measures which are identified by Mazars to ensure the necessary governance structures and policies are put in place and financial controls enhanced.
The equine anti-doping programme remains a top priority for the IHRB and, after payroll, is our most significant area of expenditure. Our equine anti-doping strategy continues to evolve and operates on a sophisticated risk and intelligence basis, backed by rigorous processes of investigation and follow-through in the event of an adverse analytical finding. IHRB teams took 5,403 samples from horses in 2022 and 5,866 in 2023. These were analysed at LGC Labs in Newmarket, England, one of only six International Federation of Horseracing Authorities, IFHA, recognised reference laboratories worldwide, and resulted in 11 adverse findings in 2022 and six in 2023. This year, we also launched a joint anti-doping initiative with the British Horseracing Authority, which saw approximately 250 samples, both blood and hair, taken from more than 120 horses across 14 premises in advance of the Cheltenham festival. An independent review of the anti-doping programme by renowned global expert Dr. Craig Suann, published in April 2022, confirmed that the IHRB programme at least matches international best practice, and it made recommendations to enhance it further.
The Suann review recommended that CCTV cameras be installed in the sampling units of each racecourse. The IHRB accepted that recommendation and installed CCTV in sampling units with the roll-out of CCTV across Ireland’s 25 permanent racecourses. The other recommendations are in the process of being implemented, subject to availability of resources.
In October 2022, we established the equine injury in Irish racing risk reduction project to identify, understand and mitigate risk factors for racing-related equine injuries. The aim of the project is to identify and implement measures to reduce the risk of injury to horses in racing.
To enhance transparency, we will shortly begin monthly publication of anti-doping activity on our website, including details of horses which have been the subject of an adverse finding.
I again thank the Chair for the invitation to appear and for the committee's attention this morning. Dr. Hillyer and I are happy to answer any questions members may have.
Comment on this
We have two people from the IHRB, Mr. O'Loughlin and the chief veterinary officer. We do not have a chief financial officer. Why is that?
Comment on this
That is correct. The chief financial officer remains on leave. We have had the support of the head of finance of HRI, who has been seconded over the course of the past year. He is on annual leave with his family. Our CFO remains on leave and is unavailable to us.
Comment on this
As I recall, the IHRB was before this committee on 29 June 2023. The CFO was due in and cancelled the night before. We got notice the night before. Is my memory correct on that?
Comment on this
Okay. There was a no-show 12 months ago and there is a no-show again today. Who is the current financial officer?
Comment on this
The individual remains in our employment as CFO but, in his absence, we have had the support of-----
Comment on this
As an employer, we have a duty of care to our employees not to divulge personal information.
Comment on this
I do not want Mr. O'Loughlin to go into great detail; I just want to know the type of leave.
Comment on this
I have been advised that as an employer, it would be divulging personal information if I were to answer that question.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for joining us. My first question is for Ms Eade, if that is appropriate, and is on the overall health and well-being of HRI.
Has Horse Racing Ireland's income fully recovered at this point in the post-Covid era when compared with its pre-Covid income?
Comment on this
In overall terms, with people attending racing again, entries are strong and sponsorship has started to come back. The year 2022 was the first more normalised year for us as regards income streams. In 2024, the hardest thing is media rights. There is gambling legislation in the UK and the affordability checks and international revenues related to that have been more of a challenge to us in the current year but we are on track.
Comment on this
Has there been any legacy long-term reduction in the general number attending race meetings across the country arising from the Covid pandemic? Are those numbers fully recovered at this point?
Comment on this
We have had to work very hard. From a marketing point of view, we put a lot more investment into getting people to come back to racing. People got very comfortable watching racing on TV. All our fixtures are televised. The team has definitely had to work harder to encourage having a great day out. It has not quite hit the peak we were at. There was a slight dip last year. Things like the weather for flat racing are also a factor. When people are choosing whether to go to a race, they take a look at the weather first. On the jump side, people go in all weathers but they are a bit more choosy on the flat side.
Comment on this
Approximately what element of Horse Racing Ireland's annual revenue accrues from gambling?
Comment on this
We run the Tote business, which effectively provides the ability to do pool betting at the track. Tote Ireland's topline turnover is €68 million but it is quite expensive to deliver that service with people at the track. The other funding that comes into HRI is linked to media rights rather than actual betting. We do not get anything directly. Any funding that we collect on-track through the betting levy goes to the racecourses.
Comment on this
Is the proliferation of online gambling on various devices and its ongoing increase beginning to impact on HRI's bottom line as an organisation?
Comment on this
With regard to the Tote, yes. Online availability is a growing element of where people are placing their bets. The Tote is not able to compete with some of the bigger bookmakers, which have a lot more resources to invest in that side of things. A couple of years ago, we created an alliance with the UK Tote to provide good platforms for people who might want to bet carefully online with our Tote products.
Comment on this
In recent times, HRI has consistently cited a report by Frontier Economics that outlines that the Gambling Regulation Bill could lead to a €30 million reduction in its revenue over a five-year period. Does HRI still stand over that figure? How does it intend to deal with that reduction in revenue? It is inevitable that the legislation will pass. It is important legislation for public health. How does HRI intend to deal with it? In media reports, it has consistently cited this research by a third party, Frontier Economics. While one might argue it is somewhat biased in forming its opinions, it has concluded that there is going to be a €30 million reduction in revenue to HRI over a five-year period. Does HRI still stand over that figure and how does it intend to deal with that reduction in revenue?
Comment on this
I will have to find out about that. I have never quoted that research by Frontier Economics. I will get some information on that.
Comment on this
Moving quickly on to the Curragh Racecourse, at what point does HRI expect Curragh Racecourse Limited to become profitable?
Comment on this
On the occasions when I have appeared before the Committee of Public Accounts and the Oireachtas joint committee, I have said it is going to be difficult for it to be profitable in the next few years with the level of investment in the infrastructure. However, I am pleased to say that, with the plans that have been put in place, it is generating a cash profit so there is no drain on HRI from the racecourse. The racecourse itself has delivered a magnificent facility for the industry, for flat racing and for international visitors. I am also really happy with the work the company has done and how it is contributing to the local community. In the short term, cash profits will continue to grow. The work the company has done in getting investment from the World Pool has been very important for its big races. It is bringing in more foreign direct income for the Curragh. The problem is that the building, the facilities, the plant and the equipment on site have depreciated greatly. That is hard to turn around in the short term. I see there being a comment in our accounts for the next few years as to the Curragh's profits. With the ambitions the CEO has for the Curragh Racecourse, I expect to see the cash profit growing. The important thing to note about the Curragh is that every race run there is sponsored. The racecourse CEO is investing money back into the industry by contributing a far larger amount to prize money. HRI and the industry are gaining a lot from how it is choosing to invest its funding. There are swings and roundabouts. It is disappointing that we are not seeing profits in the short term but we are seeing cash profits and lots of investment back into the industry.
Comment on this
Ms Eade does not expect it to become profitable for quite a few years to come.
Comment on this
Is the ongoing financial support HRI is making available to the racecourse in order for it to continue functioning at the expense of other racecourses? For example, by-----
Comment on this
No. The last element of the investment into the Curragh Racecourse was the conversion of the loan, which we signalled would convert into shares. I do not expect any drain on HRI. The racecourse will get the same opportunities when we run welfare programmes or capital investment programmes. We will treat every racecourse equally in that respect.
Comment on this
We were all deeply disturbed by the excellent "RTÉ Investigates" documentary on the horrific maltreatment of innocent animals and the fraudulent moving of identities for profit and gain. I believe I am representative of the public in general in being somewhat confused as to the roles, responsibilities and remits of Horse Racing Ireland, the IHRB and the Department of agriculture. Will Ms Eade quickly outline where the responsibility for protecting equine welfare resides? From a legislative perspective, it ultimately resides within the Department but how does that translate into the work and responsibilities of HRI and the IHRB? I would just like the public to be aware of how the triumvirate works as regards equine welfare.
Comment on this
If the Deputy does not mind, I will ask Mr. O'Loughlin to talk about the role of the IHRB and then I will ask Mr. Osborne to talk about HRI's role. He can bring a lot more colour to it than I can. Perhaps the Department will respond on its side, if that is okay.
Comment on this
The IHRB has responsibility for the welfare and safety of all participants in racing during their racing careers. That includes the horses. From the time a horse first enters training and begins its racing career, it is notified on the official racing system, RÁS, as being in training. A trainer registers that horse as being in training with him. From that point until the end of the horse's racing career, when it has run its last race and is no longer being trained for subsequent races, the IHRB has responsibility for its welfare and safety.
For that period, the IHRB has responsibility for the welfare and safety of that horse. We carry out our obligations under this responsibility through pre-race examinations of horses on the racecourse, through our suitability to race programme, which involves examination or inspection of horses on the owner's own premises. Our chief veterinary office, Dr. Hillyer, and her team, check every horse on race day. They trot them up and observe them before they run in a race. When it is not race day, that is, during out-of-competition days, Dr. Hillyer's team inspects trainers' licensed premises. While the team is there, it will overlook all of the horses. It will identify them to make sure that the horses that should be there are in fact there and it will make sure that every horse that is there has been registered as being there.
Does Dr. Hillyer want to expand on that?
Comment on this
The role of the IHRB is specifically during the racing career of the animal. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Once that concludes, the IHRB has no further role in equine welfare?
Comment on this
It is not open to us to take on a role outside of what is provided for in the legislation and our mandate.
Comment on this
Okay, I thank Mr. O'Loughlin. When does HRI's remit begin and when does it conclude?
Comment on this
Our role is the promotion and development of horse racing on the island of Ireland. Our direct involvement in the care of the horses relies largely on the responsibility which the owners have to their horses. We have developed an ecosystem which attracts investment and rewards success. We still rely on owners to take responsibility for their animals throughout their lives, which can-----
Comment on this
Can I just stop Mr. Osborne there? Is he saying that HRI relies almost wholly on the owners to act responsibly and that HRI has no oversight?
Comment on this
It is not oversight, as such. We have encouraged investment but we have not stepped into the breach in respect of the care and responsibility for individual horses on a day-to-day basis. We are not in a position to be that organisation. Some owners may take ill of the old slogan about a puppy being for life, not just for Christmas. In the case of horses, the responsibility for care on a day-to-day basis is down to the owner. We have tried to assist with this. Our function in the welfare space relies on the three pillars that we work towards. These are traceability, standards and safety nets. The Deputy will be familiar with traceability. We are very confident about our standards of care in the context of the care of racehorses throughout their lives from birth to the end of their racing careers. The safety-nets element considers what can happen to racehorses when their racing careers are over. That is why we have been so active in supporting Treo Eile, a not-for-profit organisation which promotes and facilitates second careers for racehorses. We also support the Irish Horse Welfare Trust, IHWT, which positions itself to rescue the small number of animals. At the moment it has ten thoroughbreds in its care out of a population of some 40,000 thoroughbreds on the island.
Comment on this
To be clear, does HRI legally have a remit in terms of animal welfare? From his response, Mr. Osborne seems to be trying to keep this at arm's length from his organisation. He has said that it is the responsibility of the owners and HRI has no real oversight in the matter. If that is the case, so be it, but it is not my understanding. As a member of the public and the Oireachtas, I would have imagined that Horse Racing Ireland - the entity responsible for the industry and positioning Ireland, quite rightly, as a global exemplar in managing the equine industry - should have a far more hands-on approach to equine welfare, rather than just saying it is the owners' responsibility and that it funds a charity for the end of life of horses. What is the function of the microchipping and the passporting of horses if it does not have, at some point, a role in welfare? Are these just animals to be taken into the industry?
Comment on this
I am just a bit mystified as to what exactly the role of HRI is in this regard.
Comment on this
Just a minute, Deputy, your are over time. We want to try to get a response to this. Mr. Osborne gave his response. The best thing is to ask Mr. Sheahan from the Department.
Comment on this
Okay, if Mr. Sheahan can bring some clarity that would be wonderful.
Comment on this
He is the deputy chief veterinary officer. Mr. Sheahan might answer briefly, please.
Comment on this
As some of the earlier speakers have said, various people have responsibility, individual owners and the IHRB in the case of horses. In the greyhound world, Greyhound Racing Ireland has certain responsibilities. Ultimately, the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine is the Department with overall responsibility for animal welfare from a legal and enforcement point of view. Much of our animal welfare legislation comes from the EU but a certain amount of it is national legislation, including the Animal Health and Welfare Act 2013. Many people have responsibility but ultimately, we in the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine have overall policy responsibility when it comes to animal welfare.
Comment on this
Yes, oversight and enforcement. Obviously there are others as well, such as the Garda, but ultimately it is the responsibility of the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Sheahan saying that HRI has no remit for equine welfare?
Comment on this
I am not saying it has no remit. In my experience of working with HRI over the last number of years, it has played a very progressive role in trying to promote improved animal welfare in the industry. It does not have a role, as such, in enforcing legislation.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses. I remember the last day they appeared before the committee. It was very unsatisfactory in that we were expecting the chief financial officer and we were told that there was an issue at that stage. Subsequently, we see that €350,000 was transferred from the Jockeys Emergency Fund, which was under the auspices of the Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board. A review of this is now taking place with Mazars. What controls were part of that? Were there double signatures? What controls were in place and what controls are in place now in relation to that?
Comment on this
At the time we had controls involving two signatures being required for any transaction to be processed through the bank. We had payment, transaction and financial management policies and so on in the IHRB for our staff to comply with. We had an expectation-----
Comment on this
Sorry, Mr. O'Loughlin, please give me a very short reply because I have little time.
Comment on this
Since then, we have tightened up on our financial controls. We have implemented transaction limits such that any payment must now be signed off by two members of senior management. For any payment above €25,000, one of the signatories must be the head of finance or me, the CEO. The CEO must sign off on any sums larger than €100,000.
Comment on this
Why was this money transferred? What was the purpose of transferring this into the account? Was there a shortage of working capital or something like that?
Comment on this
I am conscious of the fact that the report from Mazars has not yet been provided to us in final form. It will deal with all of those issues.
Comment on this
Has the IHRB received a preliminary version?
Comment on this
I would only be speculating if I was to answer questions before Mazars had provided us with the answers.
Comment on this
Has there been a preliminary response from Mazars on that?
Comment on this
We have had draft reports from the firm as a way of keeping track of the progress of the review but we have not yet been provided with the final report.
Comment on this
Again, we will have another hearing today that is unsatisfactory because we cannot get responses to a glaring issue in the accounts. The Mazars report is looking into this particular issue and other financial governance matters. What are they?
Comment on this
As the committee knows, when this issue arose, I only found out about it two days before the committee meeting. The board of the IHRB discussed it only the day before the last committee meeting. I share the Deputy's frustration and I am equally dissatisfied.
Comment on this
What are the governance issues?
Comment on this
Because this had arisen, naturally I wanted to be satisfied, as did the board, that all of our financial governance was appropriate since the organisation came into being at the beginning of 2018. Mazars has been tasked with examining all of our financial governance controls and all of our transactions and financial records going all the way back to the first day of operation of the IHRB.
Comment on this
Has the CFO been on continuous leave since then?
Comment on this
Okay. I want to move on to Conor Ryan's "RTÉ Investigates" report. What checks does the Department do before it provides a licence? We only had this one equine abattoir. What background checks does the Department do given that this industry is, obviously, more than the horse racing industry. What checks does the Department do in relation to people who would run a facility like that?
Comment on this
The same procedure applies for any anybody wanting to operate any food business in Ireland. They make an application to the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine. In the case of a slaughter plant they would have to provide drawings and outlines of the process-----
Comment on this
What of their own background? Does the Department check their background?
Comment on this
It is my understanding that for most activities to do with slaughter plants somebody cannot have had a conviction in the previous three years. That is my understanding of it.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Sheahan aware there was a conviction in 2012? There was a conviction in Gort District Court in 2012 for cruelty to two horses.
Comment on this
I am aware of that. There was a prosecution brought by the Garda, as I understand it in 2012.
Comment on this
Would this have raised a flag in relation to this particular-----
Comment on this
It may have raised a flag but it would not legally prevent somebody from being a director of a company. That is my understanding. Again, I am not a legal expert.
Comment on this
Knowing that this was the case, what was the Department's role? We have been told that this side of this industry is a very financially important industry and a lot of people - I would say most people in the industry - are acutely aware of animal welfare and will be horrified by what they saw. Given that there had been a previous conviction for animal welfare what measures were put in place by the Department to monitor this facility? It was not as if there was one in every county. This was one equine abattoir that happens to be in my constituency. People have contacted me since who had made complaints to the Department about concerns around welfare. They told me that they had raised complaints with the Department. Would there not have been a rigorous kind of oversight of this facility? It is not as if there was one in every county. It was one.
Comment on this
I will not be able to give a quick answer to this. Perhaps the Chairman might indulge me and allow me time to answer. This is probably a kind of question that lots of people-----
Comment on this
If the Chairman allows extra time-----
Comment on this
I put it to Mr. Sheahan that the question is straightforward. The Deputy is asking if, in view of the fact that there were historical incidents that may have had a bearing on some of this, was the Department not on high alert? What was the Department doing and what measures was it putting in place? I believe this is what the Deputy is asking.
Comment on this
I will try to answer as briefly as I can. If you were to ask me even three weeks ago what were standards like within the slaughter plant in Straffan I would say that standards were very good within this slaughter plant in Straffan. The plant operates one day a week. We have a veterinary presence and technical officers present on the day when slaughter happens. The animals come into the plant-----
Comment on this
Did Mr. Sheahan watch this programme?
Comment on this
Did Mr. Sheahan think that was a once-off event or was it routine behaviour?
Comment on this
No. I will just clarify and for the avoidance of any doubt, I watched the programme. I was actually on holidays abroad when I watched it. It was one of the most sickening things I have ever seen. This is just for the avoidance of any doubt. It was horrific. For clarity, what was shown on the programme did not happen within the slaughter plant. For some people that is a technicality but it is an important point. The horrific footage happened on the farm beside the plant.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Sheahan saying that the only thing that matters-----
Comment on this
-----within this slaughter plant-----
Comment on this
No. I am just saying that within the slaughter plant that is the plant under our supervision - whether people like to hear this or not - our experience over many years of dealing with this plant is that the horses that arrive into this plant are in good condition. This is not a plant that processes sick, dying or badly lame animals. Despite the impression one might get from the programme that is not the case. What happened next door was terrible. Without the excellent work done by RTÉ, to be honest we would not have known that this was happening-----
Comment on this
It was made at the plant where-----
Comment on this
-----people had made complaints. They were not inside the slaughterhouse. They were looking at what was happening outside. In fact there were two horses that were damaged and died as a consequence of being damaged on fencing.
Comment on this
With all due respect we have had five complaints over the recent years about horses on the farm next door. In all cases we have gone out and investigated those complaints, which typically were along the lines of there being thin horses or a lame horse in the field next door. We have never had a complaint about this shed because unfortunately, it is hidden and nobody was aware.
Comment on this
The reality is that the Department is the regulator-----
Comment on this
There is a responsibility here on the regulator.
Comment on this
Between the microchipping, the double microchipping, the animal cruelty, and the food safety issues that report made it looked like there was a lot of gangsters involved in this industry and the Department has-----
Comment on this
The Department has a-----
Comment on this
Yes there will be an investigation.
Comment on this
But there is an impression and the Department is the regulator.
Comment on this
Absolutely. I am not trying in any way to shirk responsibility. We have done a lot of soul searching about it and the questions have been asked by many people. Should we have known what was happening in that shed next door and could we have known, and were there red flags raised? We looked back at any of the complaints we got. We cannot be in 130,000 premises. We rely-----
Comment on this
We had one equine abattoir.
Comment on this
Absolutely and we are there. As I have said, the standard of animals coming into the plant were in good condition. Despite the impression that might have been given in the programme of sick and dying animals coming in, they were not. Should we have known about the horrific stuff we saw in the footage and should we have known that this was happening? I would love to say that we should have. We typically rely on people ringing us up or tipping us off on the help line. Unfortunately we had complaints about the occasional thin horse or the occasional lame horse. We sent an experienced vet out to examine. We did not come across anything that merited serving a welfare notice or bringing a prosecution or anything like that.
Comment on this
Mr. Sheahan has outlined that. I understand that this area was all part of the one complex of one yard, shed, abattoir and farm. It was all the one.
Comment on this
It is a farm and a shed adjacent to it.
Comment on this
Before I start I know that Mr. O'Loughlin has had a bereavement and I offer my sympathies to him and his family at this time.
It is no secret that my family are involved in horse racing. I have no stake or claim to it but I have an interest in the sport. I will follow on from what Deputy Murphy has raised. What was seen in the "RTÉ Investigates" programme was the barbaric treatment of animals. The entire racing community is disgusted by what was seen. From people I have spoken to within the racing community, including those within my own constituency of Cork East and nationally across the island with hundreds of families involved in racing outside of the cities, it is clear that the whole industry took a belt from what I perceive to be failures by the Department of agriculture.
Mr. Sheahan has just said that five complaints were made. That is highly irregular for any facility and I assume that even a single complaint would raise alarm bells. The fact there were five is troubling. Given what they have done, the people involved should never be left near an animal again. Anyone involved in racing knows the animals are cared for exceptionally well and at huge cost, and that is because of people's love and passion. Most people involved in racing do not make a penny from it. It is about the love of racing and the animals involved. I am sickened by what I saw on that investigative programme and I want to put that on the record. The Department of agriculture’s inspection methods need serious evaluation. Perhaps on-site CCTV is needed where there is a complaint, even if it is struck down, or where there is a mandatory requirement over a period of time, and that is where a single complaint comes in, never mind five.
Does Mr. Sheahan accept the damage this has done to everybody in racing? It is incredibly unfair to everybody involved with animals, not just for horseracing but farming and everything else, given the public perception that this is the cruelty that is taking place when that is not the case. It happened in this instance and has been highlighted, and well done to RTÉ for that. Does Mr. Sheahan accept the damage that has been done to the industry overall by the failure of the Department to act appropriately when it got a single complaint, never mind five?
Comment on this
With regard to the five complaints, to clarify, there were no complaints about the slaughter facility itself. We are there when slaughter takes place and I am quite happy to-----
Comment on this
Do not give me that nonsense. I am not going to accept that.
Comment on this
One second, Chairman, this is a very valid point. I am talking about the facility that was shown on the recordings from RTÉ. Mr. Sheahan should not go down the line of talking to me about the abattoir.
Comment on this
I am just trying to clarify. For the avoidance of any doubt, nobody was more sickened and disgusted by what they saw on that programme than I was. I mentioned there were five complaints and, looking back, one was in 2018, one in 2019, one in 2020, two in 2021 and one in 2023. Those were not complaints that somebody was beating horses horrifically.
Comment on this
They were welfare complaints concerning the animals.
Comment on this
They were welfare complaints but they were not complaints that were upheld. They were things along the lines of somebody saying there is a lame horse in a field. We get over 1,000 complaints on our animal welfare helpline. We investigate every single one of them every year and 300 or 400 of them tend to be related to horses because horses are quite visible as they are out in a field. We examine them. We go out and look at every single complaint we get. To be fair, in the case of all of the five complaints we got, we did not find something that merited prosecution or even the serving of a notice. A complaint is one thing. Horses can be very visible if they are standing out in a muddy field and it can look bad to somebody. That does not mean that somebody is breaking the law or that they have done something wrong. Just because somebody makes a complaint about horses in a very visible place does not mean we will find something wrong. If we had found something wrong, of course, we would have acted.
Comment on this
On the point I made in my first contribution, does Mr. Sheahan not accept that could be looked at? It is a very appropriate step where multiple complaints are made and, in this case, we know there were five.
Comment on this
That should raise alarm bells. As somebody who lives on a farm where we have dairy and horses, I think five complaints is an extraordinarily high number. Would the Department not consider putting in monitoring or something else on a long-term basis whereby that analysis is done over time? We now know that following the five complaints, the Department was saying there was no problem but the work of “RTÉ Investigates” has debunked that.
Comment on this
What of the damage that has been done?
Comment on this
As I said, we have done plenty of soul-searching about what we could do differently in future. We cannot-----
Comment on this
I also highlight the ecosystem involved here, where there was one single facility adjacent to or apart from the rest - whatever the structuring was is their own business. The Department has now put that out of action through its own work. What is happening in the absence of that? Mr. Sheahan should think about that and the damage that has been done. Animals will potentially be exported off the island for processing.
Comment on this
It is a very valid point. On behalf of the racing community, I express that as a concern.
Comment on this
It is a very valid point. We have seen the experience abroad, in particular in the United States, where there was a campaign for many years to shut down horse slaughter facilities. Eventually, that campaign succeeded and, arguably, it has made the situation worse because horses are being exported to Mexico and Canada, going on long journeys and so on. There are sometimes unintended consequences.
In the grand scheme of things, this is a very small plant. It is killing fewer than 2,000 animals a year. The scale of the horse slaughter industry in Ireland is now very small compared to what it was back in 2013. At one stage, there were four slaughter plants killing horses and, at a peak, we killed 24,000 horses. In line with a significant decrease in the horse population, there has been a significant decline in the number of horses being slaughtered and it is now fewer than 2,000 a year. Of course, that is still significant and just because it is smaller, I am not saying it is insignificant. In an ideal world, it should be possible to slaughter horses in humane conditions.
Again, I know the Deputy will say I am splitting hairs with regard to what was happening within the slaughter plant. I have been there myself and I saw the horses being killed. It was being done in a very competent manner by people who knew what they were doing. I had no idea what had happened the day before 100 yd. or 200 yd. away but within the plant, to be fair to the workers who were doing the job, things were being done very well - as well as is in any other slaughter plant in the country. It is important to make that point.
A plant being shut down has unintended consequences.
Comment on this
They are massive from a welfare perspective.
Comment on this
We have the initial exposure, the consequential reaction at Government level and the public reaction to it, but the unforeseen consequences are the latter part of the three phases, in my view. That is more concerning than anything. We might have animals being put onto boats and the Department will know well in the context of calf exports how precarious that is.
Comment on this
Does the Department have an intention to deal with it?
Comment on this
We cannot come up with an alternative slaughter plant. That is not our business. If somebody comes up with a proposal, and if it is decided that the right thing to do is that there should be a slaughter plant facility for horses in this country-----
Comment on this
I accept the Department cannot come up with something but it has responsibility and it cannot escape that. A much more interventionist approach initially would have been helpful, as we now know. That is not an acceptable answer. The Department needs to have an answer to this within weeks.
Comment on this
I am not sure that it is appropriate for the Department of agriculture to encourage somebody else to start slaughtering horses.
Comment on this
I am not talking about somebody else. The Department should directly intervene in the situation.
Comment on this
We have intervened in the short term with regard to shutting it down for various reasons.
Comment on this
What of the unintended consequence that animals will leave the island?
Comment on this
The unintended consequence is that, in the short term at least, there is no other facility to slaughter horses. I am not certain that the Department is going to be able to pull a rabbit out of a hat and come up with a solution to that in the short term. There are other operators who have in the past killed horses in slaughter facilities here. Perhaps somebody might think that an opportunity exists. On the other hand, this whole thing has become toxic because of what has been seen and I am not sure people will be rushing into it. I go back to the point that it is possible-----
Comment on this
With all due respect, five complaints were made and the Department made a determination that it was not worthy of concern for the reasons that Mr. Sheahan has outlined. That is why it is now toxic.
Comment on this
I did not say there was no concern. I said that our experienced vets who went out to look at the complaint determined that there was no case for prosecution, the law had not been broken and there was not even a need to serve a welfare notice.
Comment on this
I will come back with a second round of questions.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses. Why did the Department close the plant? The witnesses stated this morning that there was no issue whatsoever with the abattoir and there were no complaints. Is that correct?
Comment on this
There were no welfare issues with the operation of the abattoir.
Comment on this
I prefer not to get into the legal reasons for it being closed. It was not closed because of any welfare concerns over what happened in the abattoir.
Comment on this
Why is it closed? I am not interested in the legalities. Did the Department close it?
Comment on this
The Department of agriculture has suspended the abattoir’s operations.
Comment on this
I cannot get into the legal reasons for that.
Comment on this
Hold on a second. What we all saw was horrific and Mr. Sheahan has stated clearly that that did not happen within the abattoir, but within the lairage, over which the Department does not have a remit. That last is astounding in itself. The relevant department in every other country seemingly has that remit. When someone delivers calves to a lairage in France, there are vets present on a welfare basis. Why is the abattoir closed?
Comment on this
It is closed not because of welfare reasons, but because of other reasons.
Comment on this
It is suspended over traceability issues.
Comment on this
They came to light as a result of the RTÉ programme.
Comment on this
Then the Department’s oversight was lax. The Department did not really have any oversight of the abattoir, did it? Issues arose on foot of the programme. They were not welfare issues but there were many other issues. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Welfare issues at the place next door were highlighted by the programme.
Comment on this
Mr. Sheahan said the Department had no remit over that and that it would not have found those issues anyway. The Department’s remit was as an AO or veterinary inspector within the abattoir.
Comment on this
Why did the traceability issues under the Department’s remit not come to light? Why did it take “RTÉ Investigates” to uncover them? I am a farmer’s daughter. A farmer can get inspected at the drop of a hat. Farmers are put to the pin of their collars around the country. In most instances, their whole lives are made miserable by the Department, yet Mr. Sheahan is telling me that this situation is not a welfare issue, but a traceability issue. We have one abattoir killing horses in the country and the Department could not oversee it enough.
I will move on. When Mr. O’Loughlin last appeared before us nearly a year ago, Deputy Ó Cathasaigh questioned him and Mr. O’Loughlin stated that he did not have much clue about horse racing. Has he learned anything about it since?
Comment on this
Was it about the sport or the governance?
Comment on this
The governance of horse racing and the governance of us as the regulatory body for horse racing are two areas where I would like to think I have learned a great deal. As we are the regulator for horse racing, our job is to ensure the integrity of racing and we as an organisation need to have that governance-----
Comment on this
Does that mean the IHRB has taken its eye off the ball as regards governance? The integrity of horse racing is one thing, but the issue that has arisen in terms of the transfer of moneys is another. Ms Angela Flanagan was appointed to the board as the Minister’s appointee. Is that correct?
Comment on this
It is correct that Ms Flanagan is a member of our board. She is not an appointee of the Minister.
Comment on this
What position does she hold on the board? If I recall correctly, the advertisement was for a governance director and a financial director. Was she appointed to one of those two positions?
Comment on this
Ms Flanagan was not appointed to our board by the Minister. The Minister does not appoint directors to the IHRB. Ms Flanagan is one of our two independent directors.
Comment on this
The report stated that she was an appointee of the Minister.
Comment on this
That is fine, but is she in a governance role? Am I correct in saying that the two roles advertised were a governance director and a financial director?
Comment on this
The advertisement was for a director with experience in finance and a director with experience in governance, but the responsibilities do not sit with individual directors in that delineated way. All directors are responsible jointly and severally for the governance of the organisation.
Comment on this
She is a director, a member of the board.
Comment on this
I wish to revert to the welfare issue. Is Mr. Osborne the head of welfare?
Comment on this
Does welfare encompass jockey training and such issues?
Comment on this
I am talking about jockeys being trained.
Comment on this
The Racing Academy and Centre of Education, RACE, has been the jockey training establishment. It is something that we support financially and have done over the years.
Comment on this
HRI still supports RACE to run-----
Comment on this
My information was different. I thought that-----
Comment on this
It is going through a period of transition.
Comment on this
It would appear so. Either my information is incorrect or Mr. Osborne’s is. RACE has not undertaken any training course funded by the HRI.
Comment on this
RACE has approximately 11 strands of education under way at the moment.
Comment on this
As I said, it is going through a transitional-----
Comment on this
It looked for capital to assist it, but that was not forthcoming from the HRI.
Comment on this
Its major component had a residential element. The residential part of the campus was deemed to require considerable investment for it to continue.
Comment on this
Is the HRI setting up an accredited jockey training programme of its own?
Comment on this
We see jockey training as an essential part of the industry and we want to ensure that it continues to be so.
Comment on this
Is the HRI setting up a training programme?
Comment on this
We are working with the existing facilities in RACE to try to re-establish jockey training as similar to what went before-----
Comment on this
Does the HRI have a training course?
Comment on this
RACE is operating currently and has 11 strands of education ongoing but that is different to what went before insofar as there is not a residential element to it.
Comment on this
Is it the case that RACE cannot continue without the capital investment?
Comment on this
RACE cannot continue to do what it used to do on the campus it has at its disposal. It will require further investment to modernise and get to where it would like to be.
Comment on this
It has let 21 staff go. My information is that it is unable to continue with the training programme and that the HRI will set one up. What will the accreditation be for any such programme and who is accrediting it?
Comment on this
All those matters are being considered at the moment. We have worked with all of the agencies in that space, including the Kildare and Wicklow Education and Training Board and the SETU.
Comment on this
The facility was no longer fit for purpose as a residential premises.
Comment on this
RACE asked for the HRI’s assistance. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Our assistance is forthcoming and the transition is under way.
Comment on this
Those matters are being discussed and deliberated upon.
Comment on this
RACE wanted €1 million in emergency capital funding. Has the HRI negotiated that?
Comment on this
The facility is still providing some element of service to the industry.