Financial Statements 2022: Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board
Contributions 229–466 of 704. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
That was not my question. Has the HRI negotiated the emergency funding?
Comment on this
We are continuing to support RACE to deliver-----
Comment on this
Is Mr. Osborne aware that RACE let 21 staff go while those negotiations, which I am unaware of but Mr. Osborne says are taking place, have been ongoing? Has the HRI negotiated the emergency funding to keep an accredited training course in place when it does not seem to have an alternative as yet?
Comment on this
Our ambition is to continue to provide jockey training. That is something we have been doing since 1973 and something that the rest of the racing world comes to Ireland to learn about, yet we find ourselves with a campus that is not fit to deliver in the modern day the type of education we have delivered in the past. RACE itself continues to deliver modules under 11 different headings to the industry and we hope-----
Comment on this
Has the HRI provided financial assistance?
Comment on this
RACE continues to operate with our financial assistance.
Comment on this
I do not have the exact number, but I can get it for the Deputy.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Osborne aware of the €1 million required in emergency funding?
Comment on this
The transition has involved many challenges, some of which are financial.
Comment on this
Would Mr. Osborne be able to submit to the committee what assistance the HRI is providing?
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Osborne. I will move on.
Comment on this
I will contribute again later, but I am particularly concerned about the issue of welfare. According to the jockeys I know, there are fewer welfare issues where jockeys have received accredited training.
It is part of all of the welfare issues we are speaking about. Horse Racing Ireland's record states it spent €7 million on welfare last year but I do not see where. I have one question that is pertinent.
Comment on this
There is a best-turned-out league. Is this something Mr. Osborne is familiar with?
Comment on this
Is that paid for under the welfare budget?
Comment on this
What does it have to do with welfare?
Comment on this
It rewards the people who are at the absolute front-line of welfare provision. These are the stable staff who work tirelessly to look after the horses on a daily basis and the evidence-----
Comment on this
How does it work? How do they win?
Comment on this
The evidence of this care is revealed to every racegoer on every race day. All the best-turned-out league does is aggregate the best-turned-out prizes from across the industry. All of the racecourses co-operate with us and report in centrally who won the best-turned-out prizes on any given race day. We create a league of best-turned-out prizes and at the end of the year we award six different categories depending on the size of the yard and how busy it has been.
Comment on this
How much does that cost per annum?
Comment on this
It costs €18,000. There is €3,000 in prize money in six different-----
Comment on this
It sounds more like the best-dressed lady or the best-dressed gentleman at the races. It would not depict anything at all to do with welfare.
Comment on this
I could not disagree more. This is exactly the evidence that we want to see of the horses being cared for by people who care. We reward those people. It is not only the prize, it is the recognition. It also encourages the racecourses themselves to participate in this simple way of rewarding the people who are doing the most work in the context of caring for the horses on a daily basis. I cannot see what is not to like about that.
Comment on this
I cannot see the relevance in relation to welfare.
Comment on this
To come back to the abattoir and the investigation by RTÉ, we have a parcel of land with a farm complex that has a large shed in it. There is an abattoir as part of the complex. This is my understanding of it. It was shut down on Saturday but the horses were moved on Friday. This is my understanding. Did the Department authorise the movement of those horses on Friday and to where? I ask the witnesses to keep their answers brief and I will keep my questions brief.
Comment on this
I was away on holidays and I came back last night. I am aware of exactly what the Cathaoirleach is asking about. I would prefer not to answer the question. We are aware that horses were moved but I would prefer-----
Comment on this
I am not certain of that. I do not think there are but I am not certain of it. I am aware that horses were moved.
Comment on this
In the earlier discussion the adjacent shed was discussed. As I understand it, the shed is up beside the abattoir. I ask Mr. Sheahan to confirm that an inspector from the Department was in the slaughtering facility.
Comment on this
On the day of slaughter, which is usually a Wednesday.
Comment on this
It is on the day of slaughtering. Welfare concerns were expressed. Five official complaints were made and there may have been others made by phone that were not recorded.
Comment on this
Despite the welfare concerns raised about the lands and the fact that a Department official was present in the abattoir, no one thought to have a look in the adjacent shed to see what was happening there.
Comment on this
Typically there is nothing in the shed. Typically, as I understand it, the shed is empty. As I understand it, what happens is the horse slaughter happens on a Wednesday. Typically, as I understand it, on a Tuesday-----
Comment on this
It is a county council vet in the case of beef. I want to be careful in what I say because there is a live Garda investigation. One of the people involved in running the facility has a previous animal welfare conviction.
Comment on this
That is correct. It is from 2012 as I understand it. My understanding is that it was not the Department prosecution but a Garda prosecution in 2012.
Comment on this
I am in difficult position in answering that question because of the-----
Comment on this
For the movement to happen legally the Department would have to authorise it.
Comment on this
What does the Cathaoirleach want me to confirm?
Comment on this
Did the Department authorise the movement of the animals? As with the movement of cattle, the Department has to authorise it. It is the same as moving cattle.
Comment on this
I know the answer to the question but I would prefer not to answer it because of the-----
Comment on this
-----the ongoing legal activity, if the Cathaoirleach understands.
Comment on this
Where was the meat from the plant going?
Comment on this
Yes. It was being slaughtered in the abattoir with Department officials there to oversee it. Where was the meat going? Where was it licensed or certified to go?
Comment on this
Typically all of the meat from the plant was exported either directly or indirectly. There is a small cutting plant that quartered the carcasses or, in some cases, boned out the carcasses prior to export. Typically, as I understand it, all the meat was exported to France, Belgium or Italy. No cutting as such actually took place on the premises in Straffan.
Comment on this
Have the Department staff involved in monitoring the site been interviewed by the Department? Have there been conversations in the Department about it? I do not want the detail of them.
Comment on this
It is with regard to the staff involved in monitoring this one single plant in the State. Have there been examinations of what was happening in terms of speaking with those people and with regard to any records kept?
Comment on this
Absolutely. There is a very active investigation of all aspects of this taking place. We have a separate investigations division in the Department and that division is leading it.
Comment on this
I know it is very rigorous for ordinary farm animals. I know this from farmers in my constituency. I wonder what happened here. The concern here is the horse racing industry is a very valuable industry with a big reputation to be kept and this was going on in the heart of horse racing country in County Kildare. This is of concern. Substantial public funding goes into horse racing every year, with more than €80 million directly and other funds indirectly. This is the concern we have here.
Comment on this
With regard to the horse passport system, I am as confused as I was before the meeting started with regard to the issuing of passports and microchipping and who is responsible. There seem to be several layers. It is very hard to nail down where the buck stops.
Comment on this
Ultimately it stops with the Department of agriculture. We have overall responsibility for issues to do with the identification of horses.
Comment on this
Let me say this to Mr. Sheahan: on 11 July we will have the Accounting Officer in. I do not want to pin Mr. Sheahan down too much this morning because he is a principal officer. He is not the Accounting Officer but he is here in the role of representing the Department. Would it look to Mr. Sheahan, in the first instance from an animal welfare point of view, in light of what has come out in recent weeks, that traceability, microchipping, passports and the whole regulation of the industry may need to be looked at again and simplified so that somebody is in charge?
Comment on this
It definitely needs to be looked at again. It is something we constantly monitor. It improved significantly over the years, particularly over the past ten years. It would be fair to say that 15 years ago the entire issue of the identification of horses was not great. The quality of the passports was poor. People could literally produce one on a photocopier or a printer if they wanted to. Since then things have tightened up considerably.
Security features on passports include holograms and so on. One cannot easily fraudulently produce a fake passport. It is not that simple.
Comment on this
The Department has since 2014, when we brought in a central database. We have a central record of all horses.
Comment on this
Every horse. Everything the seven passport-issuing bodies record is transferred to our central database. Things have tightened up considerably. To be honest, until this programme, if you had asked me three weeks ago how good our horse identification system was now, I would have said it was not perfect but good.
Comment on this
That was the footage apparently showing a microchip being inserted into the horse - that is what it looked like anyway. I am not certain, but apparently, that horse subsequently got through the system.
Comment on this
Apparently, yes. We were contacted by the Dutch authorities two years ago who said they thought there was a problem. They said some horses were being exported from Ireland. They could not beat our system in Ireland and get into the food chain. They were being exported to Holland and finding a way of beating the system in Holland and Romania and places like that. As I said, the number of horses being slaughtered in Ireland is tiny compared with what it was. There was a time when we killed 24,000 horses. That has gradually reduced and now we kill fewer than 2,000 horses. A very small number of horses are getting through the system and getting into the food chain.
Comment on this
Fewer than 2,000 a year, which is a very small number in comparison with the past. I am still not sure how that-----
Comment on this
I have less confidence than I had. We are still not sure how-----
Comment on this
It is not simple. It is not as simple as sticking a microchip in a horse and you get through the system. It does not work like that. The microchip has to be registered on our central database, the microchip has to be a correct microchip and it then has to match the passport. Simply sticking a microchip in a horse will not allow you to beat the system. We are not sure yet how this individual horse apparently beat the system. We have some theories but we are not sure.
Comment on this
To go back to the abattoir, does the company running that have an animal welfare person?
Comment on this
Every slaughter plant legally has to have an animal welfare officer who has to do certain training courses and so on.
Comment on this
No, it is not the person who had the conviction.
Comment on this
I will not push Mr. Sheahan on it. We will take a short break for ten minutes. I will suspend the meeting and we will then resume in public session.
Comment on this
I will allow members to come back in. We will try eight minutes first and see how it goes because other members may arrive later. I call Deputy Catherine Murphy first.
Comment on this
Will Mr. Sheahan provide us with a note on the number of animals slaughtered since January 2023 in that abattoir? Will he provide it by category - those which took part in racing and were excluded from the food chain? Will he provide some details on those animals? I do not expect him to have that information here. We heard about the five complaints made to the Department. Did the Department do any other welfare checks?
Comment on this
Does the Deputy mean other welfare checks on the farm next door?
Comment on this
Not that I am aware of. We did one other inspection which was medicines-related, as I understand, checking for medicines records or something like that.
Comment on this
Did the Department find anything?
Comment on this
I do not think we found anything untoward.
Comment on this
The Department does not do routine checks.
Comment on this
There are roughly 130,000 farms in the country. We do a certain amount of checks.
Comment on this
There are 29,000 farms with horses. Unless there are red flags, it is hard for us to see everything that is happening.
Comment on this
On red flags, there was a conviction previously. There were five complaints. The Department acted on complaints by the public but there were no other welfare checks. Mr. Sheahan has answered my question.
Comment on this
Concerning all the animals slaughtered in our slaughter plants every year - horses, cattle, sheep, etc. - we pay careful attention to what comes in the door. It is the case that in some of our slaughter plants, if we see sheep coming in that are not in as good a condition as they should be, we take note of that and follow up on that.
Comment on this
We are focusing on one particular aspect today.
Comment on this
It is similar if cattle come in from a particular farm to a slaughter plant which are not in as good condition as they should be. In the case of the horse plant, going back over many years of the operation of that slaughter plant, a number of experienced vets have been in that plant. We have never-----
Comment on this
Mr. Sheahan watched that programme and is telling us it was an aberration on the day that the filming took place.
Comment on this
There were lame animals and animals in distress.
Comment on this
On the animals that came into the slaughter plant, going back over many years, many experienced vets have checked every animal. Every animal that comes in is checked by the vet in charge of the plant.
I have talked to our vet who is there at present. He is a vastly experienced equine vet with great experience at home and abroad and he has assured me that in all his time there, all the animals which have come into that plant have been in good condition. Obviously, I cannot explain what happens next door or why they were doing-----
Comment on this
I want to move on to other questions.
What are the respective roles of HRI and the IHRB in respect of the registration and microchipping of horses? Do they have a role? If the answer to this question is "No", just say "No".
Comment on this
I will hand a question over to Dr. Hillyer as our chief veterinary officer.
Comment on this
In terms of the regulation of the integrity of the sport, we regularly and routinely check factsheets. Every time a horse runs in a race and every time we inspect a horse on a licensed premises, we identify it by its microchip and, particularly if it runs for the first time, by its marking. We crosscheck the markings with the microchip.
Comment on this
That is the only role that the Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board plays.
Comment on this
On HRI, I believe we had this discussion before about the structure of HRI and IHRB is then funded by this HRI. This seems an odd way of doing things. Underneath that then there is the jockey welfare fund, which is a charity. Why was that almost a subset of IHRB and what was the magnitude of the money that was in the account? We know how much was transferred from the account and back to the account but what amount of money is in that account at this point in time?
Comment on this
The Jockeys Emergency Fund, JEF, is a registered charity. We provide the administrative services but we do not do the management and control, as such, of the charity. It is not a subsidiary although it is dealt with as a related party in our accounts. I have no official role in the JEF so it is not for me to speak on its behalf. The purpose of the JEF is to provide care, and medical care in particular as well as social care to jockeys who have had catastrophic injuries. We are talking about total paralysis. There are at the moment two beneficiaries and I understand that the JEF had an actuarial report done, which established that it had enough provision in its current resources to provide for the two current beneficiaries for the rest of their lives.
Comment on this
It is audited by a firm of accountants called Hayden Brown.
Comment on this
The Comptroller and Auditor General has no role in the auditing of the charity because the charity is an independent entity with its own board and trustees.
Comment on this
Are there other related parties in addition to this charity?
Comment on this
There is another charity called the Drogheda Memorial Fund, which is a far smaller charity that exists to provide relief from financial hardship for people who have an association with racing. It operates at a much smaller level and then there are two non-charitable accident funds, one for qualified riders, which is essentially non-professional jockeys, and the other for professional jockeys.
Comment on this
Why were they not under the remit of the HRI rather than the IHRB?
Comment on this
The IHRB inherited the provision of administrative services for these entities. It is a long custom and practice. They were originally set up over the decades by the Turf Club and when the Turf Club stepped back from regulating horse racing and the IHRB was established, there was a transfer of undertakings and a business transfer agreement so that all of the relevant assets and personnel came into the IHRB at that time. We inherited this role.
Comment on this
With regard to the governance, does Mr. O'Loughlin not think that a regulatory board should be completely separate and not dependent on HRI, for example? It seems to me that the separation is not ideal. Would Mr. O'Loughlin concur with that and is it something he has concerns about?
Comment on this
The funding model is the funding model and that was established in the legislation. That is way above my pay grade and is for others to consider. On how we implement the arrangements which are currently in place, I would say we have a very respectful relationship of equals with HRI. It understands that we are solely and independently responsible for making and enforcing the rules of racing. HRI has never sought to interfere in any way in any of our regulatory anti-doping or veterinary welfare practices. It has been supportive at all times. We would always argue about money and we would always want more money and there is a limit to what it can provide.
Comment on this
There is a good degree of confusion in being called a regulatory board with the Department being the regulator with regard to most aspects, certainly of animal welfare traceability, so on and so forth. I would say that there is a degree of confusion and we had a bit of a discussion about this, if not on the last appearance of the board before our committee, then during the appearance before that.
I ask now about the microchips. We saw in the programme last week that it is possible to have two microchips in the case of a very small number of horses. What is the Department doing following the programme last week in the context of that particular aspect?
Comment on this
As I said earlier, when it comes to identification, whether it is in cattle or horses, one is always trying to improve the system. Even in cattle where we think we have a world-leading system, we are still making improvements where we only recently brought in electronic identification of cattle in 2022. With horses it has been the same, where we have been on a journey of trying to keep improving the thing with the central database, the security of passports-----
Comment on this
What is the position specifically after last week's programme?
Comment on this
A couple of things arise specifically after last week. Two main things arose from the programme with regard to identification. The biggest issue which came out is that if there is a weakness, it would appear that our central database works very well but in every other country which has a central database, which it is required to have one as per EU law, it would appear that there is a loophole in that in some countries, even though the horse is marked and their database entry has been deemed to be not eligible for the food chain, it appears that those databases do not talk to one another, so-----
Comment on this
I could see that in the programme but I am asking what does the Department-----
Comment on this
We have contacted the European Commission, as this is going to take an EU approach. The Commission is arranging a meeting for next Wednesday as far as I know - we do not have the final details on it yet - to bring the member states together to see what needs to be done to close that loophole, if it is a loophole. There seems to be a loophole in the fact that each country's central database does not talk to the others and this seems to have exposed some bit of a weakness. That is one element.
The second element is that with regard to the individual horse that we saw being implanted with the microchip, we are still not sure how that horse apparently beat the system. It is not just as simple as putting a microchip in as one also has to have a matching passport and to have the horse registered on the database. We have a theory as to how that might have happened but we are not sure yet.
Comment on this
I want to finally ask a question about the deaths of horses. Last year 111 horses died within 48-hours of racing with something like 130 more dying within a month of that. Can Mr. Sheahan tell us what the industry is doing to reduce the rate of deaths following horse racing?
Comment on this
I will take that question and perhaps Mr. Osborne can then join in. We have a relentless focus on the safety and welfare of our participants, both equine and human. I am a vet and Mr. Osborne is a vet and it is very dear to both of us personally and professionally. Every day there is horse racing, we have independent regulatory veterinarians on track and we follow up the horses off track.
This year, in particular, we have implemented a suitability to race programme. Although we started this in earnest last year, we are really gathering momentum this year. We are working with trainers and vets at home to really understand the condition and status of our horses before they get to the track. It is extremely important to ensure they arrive at the track in the best condition possible and suitable to race. Every single fatality on track is investigated fully by our experienced senior team. This would include video review, talking to jockeys, talking to the vets on track and talking to the Blue Cross. All these people have experience and understanding of how these injuries happen. That is very much the operational side.
In parallel with that, in 2022, we formally put together what is called the Equine Injury in Irish Racing Risk Reduction Project. It was actually a continuation of previous work but we formalised it in 2022. This programme is led by two world-leading epidemiologists and experts in this field, Professor Tim Parkin and Dr. Sarah Rosanowski, working with individuals in and beyond our industry. In a nutshell, this project is all about recognising that, as in many sports, horse racing carries a risk. We must and do recognise this fact. What we must do, however, every day and not just in flurries, fits or bursts, is to do what we can to reduce that risk. This project is about identifying risk factors and then doing something about them.
To give the committee a real example, this project yielded several risk factors towards the end of 2022 and into the last year, which we integrated into our practices on the racetrack as soon as we possibly could. We now target the inspections I was talking about, concerning the suitability to race, at the horses we know from the science may be at increased risk of injury. This was a bit of a gallop through the area but there is a lot more I could talk about.
Comment on this
Ms Eade might provide us with a note on those changes that have been introduced.
Comment on this
To come in on that last point, Mr. Osborne might have thought I was trying to get at him, but it is very important that as a country with a history of jockeys developing at a young age, and who leave the academic system in the same way as soccer players, we would encompass their welfare as much as the animals they are riding. By this, I mean they should have a qualified traineeship behind them before they leave the academic system. It is as simple as that. They should be given this option as an alternative. We need to support RACE. I ask Mr. O'Loughlin to ensure that this happens in future. From what we have just heard, and I know that Ms Eade was previously on the board of RACE, it seems we have nothing else in place. We were given a very flowery document, which is lovely but does not tell us anything. There is nothing in it with regard to what a replacement would be or what the criteria would be for accreditation. I ask the witnesses to take this aspect very seriously before they come in here next year and there are any further complaints in this regard.
Comment on this
That is not a question. It is just adding to what Dr. Hillyer has said in relation to the welfare of our young jockeys. I know of two young jockeys injured in the UK who were entitled to nothing when they came home here to their parents with broken backs. They are entitled to virtually nothing, including social welfare because of their age. It is important, therefore, that we minimise any risk and this can only be done through training. Would Mr. Osborne agree with this?
Comment on this
That is all I want to say on the issue. I am conscious of the time. Turning to Mr. O'Loughlin, he said that the JEF is a charity.
Comment on this
I thought it ceased to exist as a charity in 2021 and became a limited company.
Comment on this
It is an easy mistake to make, and one I have made myself. The JEF is the jockey emergency fund, while the JAF is the jockeys accident fund. These are entirely separate. The accident fund is now a CLG. Since the Deputy mentioned the two jockeys who came back from the UK, if they had been riding in Ireland, the JEF exists to prevent them from being left high and dry in the event of injury. It pays out a sort of income continuance to jockeys.
Comment on this
Why would it have changed from being a charity to being a limited company?
Comment on this
Its objectives are not those of a charity. It is closer, in reality, to income continuance insurance.
Comment on this
Okay. I thank Mr. O'Loughlin for providing that clarity. When it comes to the transaction involving the €350,000, has the Charities Regulator been informed as just another part of governance to oversee anything else?
Comment on this
Yes, it absolutely has. When the board of directors of the IHRB became aware of it, this time last year, the trustees of the JEF were immediately made aware and they were in contact and remain in contact with the Charities Regulator.
Comment on this
Has the Charities Regulator completed an investigation?
Comment on this
It is not for me to speak for the regulator or for the trustees. As I said earlier, I do not have a role in that charity. What I do know, however, is that the trustees are engaged with the Charities Regulator on this matter.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Loughlin has no remit over the JEF.
Comment on this
When did he become aware of the transaction involving the movement of moneys from the JEF to the-----
Comment on this
As I told the Deputy last year, I became aware of it two days before I sat in this very room in front of this committee.
Comment on this
In this context, then, who instigated the Mazars report?
Comment on this
It was the board of directors of the IHRB in collaboration with HRI.
Comment on this
Who set the terms of reference for Mazars?
Comment on this
It was the board of directors of the IHRB in collaboration with HRI.
Comment on this
The board did not go to an external body to set the terms of reference. In effect, the IHRB set the terms of reference to investigate itself.
Comment on this
It is the members of the board of directors of any organisation who are ultimately responsible for its governance, so it is absolutely appropriate that they would set the terms of reference for the review, with the assistance of-----
Comment on this
Even when there has been, as Mr. O'Loughlin put it, a correction of an error of €350,000 going from one account to the other and back.
Comment on this
Given the board of directors was not aware of that transfer and its reversal until one year after the fact, it was appropriate that it would establish a review to find out what had happened and to do so with the collaboration of HRI. This means it was not just done internally. We were not marking our own homework, as it were. The HRI has responsibility for overseeing our governance and it was fully involved in setting the terms of reference.
Comment on this
When was a draft report received?
Comment on this
We received a draft text a few weeks ago. It was just in advance of our last board meeting.
Comment on this
When did Mazars begin its review?
Comment on this
It was in August last year. We signed the terms of reference in August 2023 and Mazars commenced work immediately.
Comment on this
Did Mazars give any timeframe for completion?
Comment on this
The company and I had thought that this report would be completed long before now. I tracked-----
Comment on this
I should rephrase my question. Was Mazars asked for a speedy report?
Comment on this
We asked for a speedy report. When the request for documentation came into us, we furnished Mazars with everything it asked for. It has received six years' worth of documentation and financial reference material.
Comment on this
Who is assisting with this undertaking? Who is providing this information?
Comment on this
The request from Mazars would ordinarily come into me and then-----
Comment on this
Mr. O'Loughlin, though, was not there six years ago.
Comment on this
The request for specific information in the form of documents and records would come to me and then I would establish where the documents and records are in the organisation. I made sure those materials went back to Mazars. It received in excess of 1,000 documents and records and it has gone through all of them.
Comment on this
The review being undertaken by Mazars has gone back six years. How long has the CFO been on voluntary leave?
Comment on this
The CFO has been on leave since the day before this committee met last year. He has been on leave since 28 June 2023.
Comment on this
What does "voluntary leave" mean?
Comment on this
He went on voluntary leave at that time. He remains on leave.
Comment on this
This question was asked earlier but I missed it with my hearing. Is he being paid?
Comment on this
He is on voluntary leave, is not suspended, is being paid and has been on leave for almost a year.
Comment on this
Why has he not been suspended or replaced at this stage? Is it just the case that he can stay on voluntary leave forever? How much has he been paid in the 12 months since he took voluntary leave?
Comment on this
As an employer with a duty of care to employees, I am-----
Comment on this
Now, listen. That is not going to wash. How much has he been paid? The figure is going to appear in next year's accounts, so will Mr. O'Loughlin please just give me the figure and not embarrass himself?
Comment on this
I am not embarrassing myself at all, but I am complying with legal advice-----
Comment on this
Mr. O'Loughlin is under privilege here.
Comment on this
-----and with the statutory rights of individuals to privacy in relation to their personal information.
Comment on this
I know that and this is what I am coming to. The CFO would be on a salary.
I presume whatever that salary is will show up in the annual accounts. There will be a figure for that. I asked a question about it earlier and the Deputy has asked a question. It is a peculiar arrangement to say the least. It is accepted. That will be in it. What is the salary of a CFO?
Comment on this
If you were advertising the job, what would the salary be?
Comment on this
If the board was advertising the job, what would the salary be, Mr. O'Loughlin?
Comment on this
It would not be standard for salaries other than the chief officer's salary to be revealed in the financial statements. It would be a charge on the accounts but it would appear with other salaries.
Comment on this
The CEO would be able to tell us. What would be the salary for a CFO in your organisation?
Comment on this
I am not going to answer a question if, by answering the question, I am divulging personal information in relation to an employee. The Payment of Wages Act and GDPR, as we all know, give people an entitlement to privacy, including in relation to their salaries. My salary is a matter of public record, as the Comptroller and Auditor General has said, because it is a condition of my employment that it be a matter of public record.
Comment on this
Mr. O'Loughlin, the question is, if you were advertising for a CFO in the morning, which you may well be soon, what would the salary be?
Comment on this
It would say salary in line with responsibilities and experience of the successful candidate. I would not put a figure in the ad, Deputy.
Comment on this
Will Mr. O’Loughlin send a note to the committee on the pay structures in the organisation in terms of the number of people on more than €200,000, the number on more than €150,000, and the number on more than €120,000?
Comment on this
I draw attention to a note in our accounts. The information is already published in the accounts. There is a table which outlines the number of employees in each band of €10,000.
Comment on this
The bands are in €10,000 in the financial statements.
Comment on this
I have one thing I want clarity on in relation to Mr. O’Loughlin’s predecessor, Mr. Egan. Did the transfer of €350,000 have anything to do with the €385,000 that Mr. Egan received?
Comment on this
The transfer of €350,000 was not directed then to him. All the facts around this that we all want in the public domain, nobody more than myself, will be contained in the Mazars report that is not yet finalised. I would far prefer-----
Comment on this
Is Mazars looking at the fact that Mr. Egan received 58% more for his golden handshake than was the standard?
Comment on this
There was a voluntary redundancy and early retirement scheme that was implemented-----