We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Financial Statements 2022: Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board

Contributions 467–704 of 704. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

That was 58% higher than the standard.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

-----in 2021, and that scheme and its implementation overall forms part of the Mazars report.

Comment on this

Is it part of the Mazars report?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Yes.

Comment on this

Is it part of the Mazars report?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Yes. That scheme and the implementation of that scheme in its entirety forms part of the review of financial governance being undertaken by Mazars.

Comment on this

Just one very last thing that is pertinent to Mr. Sheahan with regard to clarity. Did Mr. Sheahan say he was unable or he did not have the remit to actually inspect the farm that was lairing the horses for the abattoir?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

No. I did not say that.

Comment on this

You did not say that.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

No.

Comment on this

So it was within-----

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

We legally would have the power to go into any of the 130,000 farms in the country-----

Comment on this

You just did not.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

We cannot go onto 130,000 farms at any one time. We do go on the basis of information received or if certain factors-----

Comment on this

But you did not inspect this, ever, did you?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

We were on it six times in recent times.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

On the land but not the sheds.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

Not the shed. The shed is empty other than on the day before slaughter. As I understand it, horses arrive onto the farm next door. They are sorted through this shed where we saw the horrific stuff happening and then, the following morning, they move into the lairage of the slaughter plant where our vet on site-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will ask this because this is the curious thing. Were the animals that were being mistreated, which were lame and unable to stand up, on their way through the shed into the abattoir? That is what seems to be indicated.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

The very sick and the horse that died or whatever clearly did not go.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

If they were able to limp in, did they make their way in?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

We have never had horses presented in recent years - I cannot talk for ten years ago - which were sick, emaciated-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Lame?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

That is a good question on the lameness. I specifically asked our vet about that in great detail. He said we have never had seriously lame horses presented. He said occasionally he has had a horse presented that, as a racing vet, he would not allow to race in that it would not be 100% sound but not-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

They would have been in good condition in every other way.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

In good condition in every other way and slightly lame but not in such a way that it was not fit for transport or whatever. I am pretty categoric on that. Whatever horrific stuff-----

Comment on this

Were the six inspections under the animal welfare Act?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

Broadly speaking. I think one was a medicines one but the others would have been under the animal welfare Act.

Comment on this

But you never felt the need to inspect the buildings?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

Typically, there is nothing in the buildings. The buildings are empty normally, except, as I understand, on the day or the evening before the horses are slaughtered.

Comment on this

Would that not be the time to carry out the inspection? Would that not be the most appropriate time? Why would you do an animal welfare inspection if there was nothing there?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

That is a very good question. Again, I personally have done a good bit of soul searching on this on whether there were things we should have done differently. With all exposés, people jump on the bandwagon and say you should have known or whatever-----

Comment on this

I would not like you to accuse me of jumping on a bandwagon. I think it is pretty relevant, Mr. Sheahan, that animal welfare inspections are conducted where animals are and not where places are empty and they are not there.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

I am not accusing the Deputy of jumping on the bandwagon.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I do not think it is a case of anyone jumping on the bandwagon. The Department has the power to go in anywhere - any field, premises, shed or farm facility. We know that is in the agricultural sector, and Mr. Sheahan has clarified that carries across in the very same way to the horse sector. The animals in the fields are inspected. Mr. Sheahan has clarified a number of times, helpfully, that there is a vet on site on the day they are slaughtered they are examined. Committee members are curious that, for whatever period of time the horses were in this shed, whether it is for minutes, hours or a day, nobody looked in there. It is a very legitimate question. I do not think, in fairness, that is jumping on a bandwagon.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

No.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

This is where the brutality was-----

Comment on this

I think Mr. Sheahan should withdraw that remark.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

-----and what people saw was taking place.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

I will clarify-----

Comment on this

No, I think you should withdraw.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

I will withdraw it but I will clarify what I was trying to say. I accept that is a very legitimate question on whether we should have been inspecting this-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Pre-slaughter.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

Pre-slaughter. In any other circumstances when it comes to sheep or cattle slaughter and so on, we do not make a point of going out and examining the feedlots they are coming from before they go for slaughter or whatever. The only time we would do that is if animals arrive in poor condition, which signals there may be a problem at the place of origin. In that case we notify our local office and it makes a point of going out and checking and sometimes they will find there is a problem.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

There were red flags with previous complaints and there was a conviction. I call Deputy O'Connor.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

Yes. Can I just address the point of the bandwagon?

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Briefly, now. I do not want to get into that.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

I certainly was not accusing the Deputy of jumping on a bandwagon. I was making a general point that whenever an exposé comes out, whether it is Áras Attaracta, a charity, the Bóthar scandal or whatever, there is a tendency to say of course you should have known. I would make the point that maybe we should have known, but looking back at every indicator that we might have looked at, nothing was raising significant red flags to us, particularly the fact that the animals coming into the slaughter plant were in good condition. If a slaughter plant-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Thank you. Deputy O'Connor.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Sheahan saying they were just not in good condition the day "Prime Time" was there?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

No. I would imagine the vast majority of horses in that shed were probably in very good condition. I do not know how many days, weeks or months of footage RTÉ has and how it got those cameras, or whatever. I would say-----

Comment on this

I would stop digging the hole if I were you, Mr. Sheahan, to be quite honest.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Deputy O'Connor has the floor.

Comment on this

I will ask my first question quickly as it is something that is bothering me. Mr. Sheahan said something in the last round that one person involved had a Garda complaint made against him for animal cruelty. Is that right?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

Yes. One person involved has a conviction, as I understand it, going back to 2012. As far as I understand it, it was not a Department of agriculture conviction, it was a Garda conviction.

Comment on this

In relation to animal cruelty.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

That is my understanding.

Comment on this

Was Mr. Sheahan aware of that prior to when the inspections took place? I mean the five previous complaints and following inspections. Was he aware of that Garda conviction?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

I have to admit, I personally-----

Comment on this

Was the Department aware?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

I am not 100% sure. I honestly do not know. I certainly was not aware. I do not know this individual.

Comment on this

If it was aware it is an embarrassment to the Government and the Department that that individual was involved in the care and handling-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

There is an investigation now. A Garda investigation.

Comment on this

Hang on a second. I have not even made the point here.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Yes, but just be conscious of language.

Comment on this

He is convicted. It is an embarrassment to the Department of agriculture that that individual was left near an animal. It is actually disgusting. I grew up around animals, horses and cows, and have been around them all my life. That somebody could be convicted and still be allowed work in a setting involving animals is sick. If we put this is a human context, would we have somebody like this in a setting involving hospital care or other things involving healthcare with humans? It is barbaric and an indictment of the Department that was allowed to happen, if that is the case. I wanted to make that point.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

Can I respond to that?

Comment on this

I have no time. I am sorry.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

In fairness now-----

Comment on this

I just wanted to make that point. I am not asking a question, I am making a statement.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

In doing so, do not identify anyone-----

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

I will not identify anyone. In fairness-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

-----because there is a Garda investigation.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

-----when we in the Department bring prosecutions or in this case, as I understand it, when the Garda brings prosecutions, the judge or the court decides what the penalty is. I am not 100% sure, but my understanding is a fine was imposed in this case. We have brought several hundred prosecutions-----

Comment on this

You are digging a JCB-sized hole for yourself here.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

No, I am not.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

I am not.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

Can I just say, the court in some cases-----

Comment on this

You are a Department of agriculture official coming in here and trying to say the courts decide. The point I am making is about somebody with a conviction for animal cruelty being involved in the handling of animals.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

We do not impose the penalty. The court has the ability to ban somebody from having anything to do and sometimes it does that. In this case it did not do that, so I mean people-----

Comment on this

And that is okay.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

I am not saying it is okay, but that is the democracy we live in. That is the legal system. We do not-----

Comment on this

I cannot give Mr. Sheahan any more time. I need to move on to the IHRB, but the first question is for Ms Eade. From HRI's point of view, where does the injured jockeys' fund sit? Who has the money?

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

This is the Jockeys Emergency Fund-----

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

-----rather than the injured jockeys' fund. It is a private charity, but it is handled by the Turf Club. The IHRB does the administration.

Comment on this

Okay. Why was there a transfer of €350,000 to an IHRB bank account in January 2022? It was repaid, but why was it necessary to that?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

It should not have happened. Let us be absolutely clear here. That transfer-----

Comment on this

That is fine, but why was it necessary?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

It is a matter of judgment why it was necessary or even whether it was necessary. It did happen. It is should not have happened and when the Mazars report, which is obviously taking longer than it should and longer than any of us wanted it to take, is complete that will paint a fuller picture of what happened and the circumstances in which it happened.

Comment on this

Okay. I am aware Mr. O'Loughlin does not come from a racing background. He came from the IPU into racing. I have been on many a track where jockeys have been injured. I have seen a lot of things as a racing spectator. It is appalling when a severe injury takes place, and then there are the ramifications. I am sure Mr. O'Loughlin has become very aware of the long-term healthcare ramifications for jockeys who have been paralysed and had other severe injuries. I do not understand how anybody in their right mind could see a pot of money raised with the best of intentions by people in the racing community for people who are desperately in need of it and decide to transfer it into an IHRB account. These are people who have been injured in their line of work, with lifelong consequences and their families must go through hell because people have been injured in the sport they love. My question is why that was necessary. Who made that decision? Why was it necessary to take the €350,000 and put it into a bank account? It was taken out of that charity fund and put into an IHRB account.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

I am not splitting hairs deliberately, but why it appeared necessary or what prompted it are questions I expect Mazars to answer. The answers to those questions could also clearly have implications for the IHRB's disciplinary processes. Much as Mr. Sheahan cannot speak about ongoing investigations in other matters, I am very much circumscribed in what I can say. I cannot say anything or answer any questions that could in any way prejudice any proceedings that may be under way or may get under way at any point in the future. Chairman, I apologise that I cannot be forthcoming about some of this stuff. It is a question of timing.

Comment on this

Mr. O'Loughlin said it was an isolated incident. Has he or HRI been aware of any other transfer of charity money within racing to the IHRB or any other agency involved in racing?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

One of the reasons we asked Mazars to review all six years of financial records for the IHRB in existence was because I wanted to be able to say conclusively whether any other similar transfers had occurred in the past. We are satisfied that no other similar transfers occurred in the past since the IHRB was established on 1 January 2018.

Comment on this

This had no input into the IHRB's decision to refuse a licence for racing at Kilbeggan in April.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

There is no connection whatsoever.

Comment on this

Okay. I thank Mr. O'Loughlin for answering that question.

On the IHRB's system, I note it has had a very senior member of staff on paid leave for 12 months. Does Mr. O'Loughlin agree that is an exceptionally long time to be on paid leave?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Yes.

Comment on this

Has he not come to the conclusion it is best for the IHRB's relationship with the individual to end?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

It is not open to me simply to take a decision like that-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Deputy, that is not for-----

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

-----and as I explained to the Chairman already there are some questions which, unfortunately, I am not in a position to answer without risking processes that may be under way or may get under way and the rights of individuals and the right in particular to fair procedures.

Comment on this

Does Mr. O'Loughlin appreciate the damage this does to the integrity of horse racing in Ireland from horse racing supporters' perspective? Does he understand the ramifications and the damage this does from a reputational perspective? Would it not be best to put this sorry matter to bed now, rather than allow an individual continue on paid leave for over 12 months?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

I absolutely appreciate I am coming across as combative and unhelpful but I could not agree with the Deputy more. We want to draw a line under this. We want to bring this process to an end. We want this Mazars report published as soon as possible. We want to take whatever actions naturally fall out of that report. Far from damaging the integrity of Irish racing, I would say had we not immediately come clean when we became aware of this, there would have been a slow undermining of the integrity. This process and all to do with it is taking longer than I thought it would. It is taking longer than I think it should but it is taking as long as it is taking. However, it is important this be dealt with thoroughly, properly and transparently and that is what we are attempting to do.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Mr. O'Loughlin. In the earlier part of the meeting we started discussing the Mazars report. It is just such a length of time and the IHRB does not seem to have a timeframe for when it may conclude. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

I could speculate as to when it may conclude-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I understand that but-----

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

-----but Chairman, I have been wrong so many times. I have offered a view to HRI, I have offered a view to the Comptroller and Auditor General's office and I have offered a view to the Department and I have been wrong every time because it has taken longer than it should.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Is Mr. O'Loughlin's view that it will conclude within the next couple of months?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Yes, but Chairman, I have been telling you that for months.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Okay. My understanding was Mazars was examining this matter of the €350,000 and that unusual transfer and other things that happened in relation to finance during that time. From what Mr. O'Loughlin said a few minutes ago, it is examining all matters regarding the accounts of the IHRB over the past six years. Is that what he said?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Mazars has been provided with all of our financial statements-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I appreciate that.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

-----and all of our bank statements, so down to transaction level. It has been provided with all of our board agendas and board minutes. It has been provided with everything it wants.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Is that a precautionary thing or did it come to light, maybe, that at the point of where this issue arose regarding this €350,000, there were a number of other matters that looked to be not as they should have been, in terms of financial records, etc.?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

No, it was not specific concerns like that.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It was just a general sweep.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

It was a general sweep. As I said to Ms Eade at the time, I did not want to have to sit in front of a committee, be asked if this was an isolated incident, and say I did not know because we did not look. We have looked at every bank statement since the beginning of 2018 to make sure there are no similar transfers.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Mazars is a very professional outfit. Mr. O'Loughlin must have some indication. It will have advised Mr. O'Loughlin at this point, and I do not want to get him in the wrong, or have him make a statement that he cannot stand over. However, to be fair to him, is it likely that this report will come in the next two or three months?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Yes. I believe so.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Mr. O'Loughlin does not have control over that. I am sure he is urging this matter is progressed.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Almost on a daily basis.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It is important it is concluded and acted on fairly quickly afterwards. Will Ms Eade return to Deputy Cannon's question about the economic figures on the value of the betting tax to HRI?

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

It was Flutter that did a report. It was not something we ever commented on and we have never seen the detail of that report. It was Flutter's statement and comments, not ours.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

In regard to the plant, Mr. Sheahan confirmed that the witnesses can enter any building where horses are being kept. What was shown in the programme is all we know. Obviously there is a live investigation into it by the Department and by An Garda Síochána. In terms of switching microchips or adding a microchip, would there not be a wound on the animal from that?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

It would be fairly small. The needle that is used to insert the microchip is fairly small so there would not be an obvious, visible wound as such. The needle and the microchip are both very small.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

An incision is made.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

It is more an injection rather than an incision.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It would appear from the programme that spray paint was used to camouflage it.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

Yes. So it appears.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It is a very serious matter. It takes apart the traceability.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

It does. We are determined to try to get to the bottom of it. The spray paint is one element but there are three elements that have to pass. There is the microchip itself but that has to match the unique number on the passport as well. It also has to match the number on the database. We have a theory about how it might have happened but we are not sure yet.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Okay. The investigation will reveal more. On the Curragh Racecourse development, there was equity investment of €23 million, a capital grant of €12.5 million and a convertible loan of €9 million and rent of the facility of €500,000. In terms of public funds, am I correct in saying there is €45 million?

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

That is correct.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The share now owned by HRI is around 35%.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

It is 37% in terms of economic share.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That seems like a mismatch. It is running at a loss. HRI is taking a loss. The public purse is taking a loss. The loss recorded in 2022 was €1.4 million. Is that right?

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

That is correct.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

There is a loss of €1.4 million in that year. We are not examining the accounts for 2023 but Ms Eade might be able to help in that matter regarding how 2023 panned out.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

It is equivalent to 2022. It is basically due to depreciation.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It seems a fine facility, from having driven past it, but have not had the pleasure of visiting it. The loss is nearly €3 million in two years.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

Yes. It is primarily driven by depreciation and the interest.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I was always curious about the arrangement whereby the State invested in this public-private partnership with a number of racehorse owners. Will Ms Eade outline for the meeting the structure of the ownership of this? HRI has a 36% share.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

There are two different types of shares. There is the voting share and then there is the economic share. The voting share dates back-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Who owns the place? Keep it simple.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

A third of it is owned by HRI, a third is owned by the Turf Club and a third of it is owned by private investors who come from a range of different-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Mainly from the horse industry?

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

From the bloodstock-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

How many?

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

Both foreign and domestic.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The State seems to have put an inordinate amount of cash into this.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

It is the shop window for Irish flat racing and Irish international racing, so it is a really important facility to the State and to the industry. We have to have a decent place to bring quality horses. The quality of horses and the international money that is coming into Ireland warrant the facilities. Before, the Curragh had not had investment since 1962.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

As the body signing the annual cheque, and bearing in mind the State, through HRI, has slightly more than a 36% share in it, despite putting in 50% of the overall cost to date, which was €92 million, if in a two-year period there is just shy of €3 million of a loss on the investment, obviously Ms Eade will have had projections done, or Ms Rudd, as the finance person, will have them, as to what way this is likely to pan out over the next five years. The question was kind of answered earlier but HRI, as the body responsible for the chequebook, must have a projection of what way this is likely to work. Is this likely to decrease rapidly? Can we expect to see €1.4-€1.5 million loss on the investment every year? I do not take from the fact it is a very important facility in terms of showcasing and all that, but we must look at the finances of it and look at it from a business point of view.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

In terms of governance alone, every year the Curragh must present its budget to the full HRI board and get approval for what it is going to do in the next year.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The board, I am sure, asks questions about what way the graph is likely to run over the next five years. Tell us what happens.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

We have a five-year strategic plan which we could submit to this committee. I do not have it with me today.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It is one of the issues on the agenda for today's meeting. Ms Rudd, what is likely to happen over the next five years? I know you cannot predict the future. There could be another Covid situation or there could be anything. Assuming everything works out okay and there are no major catastrophes, what is likely to happen? What does the projection look like in terms of further losses?

Comment on this
Ms Claire Rudd

The projection for Curragh Racecourse Limited prepared by the Curragh Racecourse Limited and approved by its board is more increasing cash profitability. The EBITDA figure, earnings before interest, tax and depreciation, will continue to increase over the next five years. Depreciation will remain an issue for the Curragh. It is currently running at €4 million a year. The interest figure will actually reduce due to the conversion of the loan. The net profit-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

You are the people handling the public money. In terms of the impact on your finances going forward, what way does it look in terms of the loss incurred by HRI on the public investment?

Comment on this
Ms Claire Rudd

We are expecting a loss for the next number of years, a reducing loss.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Is it in the region of €1.4 - €1.5 million or more?

Comment on this
Ms Claire Rudd

No, less.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Do you expect a sharp reduction over the next three to four years?

Comment on this
Ms Claire Rudd

I am not sure I would say sharp. I would say significant or very significant over the next five years with a view to profitability shortly thereafter.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

It is also important to recognise that the Curragh itself is reinvesting into the industry through prize money. That is really important to HRI and to the wider industry that it is doing that.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Exactly. How often does HRI receive performance reports from the Curragh Racecourse Limited?

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

We provide the financial support-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I know that.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

-----in terms of reporting and management accounts, so we see all the numbers monthly.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Monthly. That is the answer I was looking for. Okay. I will let members back in again. They can take five minutes each if they have some questions left over. Deputy Catherine Murphy is first.

Comment on this

Regarding the licensing system, Mr. Sheahan said that the Department looks back for three years to see whether there was a conviction, if it is going to license someone. With what the Department knows now, will that licensing system change? Will Mr. Sheahan be recommending changes?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

I have to admit that this is not my specialist area of expertise so I might have to come back to the Deputy on that. I am not sure of the legalities and what we can do legally as regards somebody being the director of a company, which is effectively what we would be talking about here.

Comment on this

Will Mr. Sheahan come back to us with some detail on that, please?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Sheahan

I will. I do not know the exact-----

Comment on this

The last thing we want is to be back here talking about this kind of thing again. It seems that the licensing system is pretty key.

Horse Racing Ireland told us about the value of the industry and the number of jobs, and a lot of those are pretty hard jobs as well. Obviously, what we saw last week did not all relate to the horse racing side but it certainly has implications with regard to microchipping, traceability and other aspects. In fact, a number of horses that were slaughtered had recently raced. It knits into several elements of it. Has HRI been in contact with the Department about this? Obviously, there is a reputational risk here. There is reputational risk on a number of levels, including in the food chain, which is one for the Department. What engagement, if any, has HRI had with the Department following this? Has it had engagement with people in the industry contacting it about it? Are they making recommendations? What is happening there?

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

We have had significant engagement between our chairman and the Secretary General. We have been in contact with the Minister, and Mr. Osborne has been working very closely with the veterinary team in the Department of agriculture. There has been a huge amount. It has taken up, as the Deputy can imagine, a significant amount-----

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

Even before then. We have been engaging for a while.

With regard to people in the industry, I think it is fair to say that Mr. Osborne has had a lot of support from different echelons and groups in the industry. They offer support on some of the key issues and ask us to look at things in certain ways. There has been a huge amount of engagement and, yes, we have had inquiries from people inside and outside the industry. Does Mr. Osborne want to say anything further?

Comment on this
Mr. John Osborne

There is a body called the equine liaison group, which has been in existence for many years. It falls under the Department of agriculture and brings together everybody in the horse sector, not just the thoroughbreds. We met in Backweston in May and traceability was widely discussed. Everyone was together on the need for improvements in certain of the protocols around the life cycle of any horse in any sector. I expect great progress in that regard.

In the correspondence we received since last Wednesday, obviously there were many people who were affected by the images but it has been great to see so many positive messages too, and people suggesting various potential solutions and stuff like that. The great thing about this kind of exercise is it produces an energy that can lead to significant improvements. We are aware of that.

Comment on this

What was the total cost of the CCTV project? Has it produced any evidence of improper or prohibited behaviour? I hope it has not but it is a deterrent.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

The full cost of the system across the 25 racecourses, and then linking back into the security unit in our headquarters, is in the region of €1.86 million. For that, we have got more than 500 cameras, 25.5 km of cables, digital network recorders and so on across every permanent racecourse in the country.

On the second part of the Deputy's question, regarding what we have detected with it, I see it more as an extra layer of security with probably more of a deterrent effect than a detection effect, particularly with regard to anti-doping offences. We can see every stable door in every racecourse in the country on race day with this system. The entire industry knows that the system is in place so I do not actually anticipate detecting much in the way of doping activity using this.

It has proved useful in other ways - I will not say smaller ways but ancillary ways such as health and safety. If somebody has had an accident, we have captured that on CCTV, which obviously helps with accident reporting. It could be of benefit, therefore, even with regard to the legal actions that can follow accidents and so on, and helping to establish what has happened. It is useful from that perspective. I think Dr. Hillyer would agree that it is useful from an equine welfare perspective. If Dr. Hillyer receives a query about a horse's suitability to race the day after racing or two days after it, she can go back and watch that horse coming into the stable yard and moving into a stable. She can even watch how the horse was moving and whether it was lame, limping or so on going out onto the track and coming back in off the track.

Comment on this
Dr. Lynn Hillyer

It is absolutely true. The quality of the system has really impressed me. It is usable; it is not just ticking a box. We have used it to review complaints if there have been concerns raised with us about anything that might have happened on a racecourse. We have used it several times for that. We have also used it, as Mr. O'Loughlin said, to make sure we have a second look at a horse if we need to. The clarity, definition and quality have made it invaluable. I thought it was going to be much more of a deterrent but it is an operational tool as well.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses.

Comment on this

I wish to go back to the Mazars report. There are an awful lot of reports being done for different bodies and the cost is often exponential. Can Mr. O'Loughlin tell me if the IHRB agreed a fixed rate for this report over a fixed period of time?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

The report is being done under the supervision of HRI, which has the contract with Mazars.

Comment on this

Can Ms Eade say if there is a cost fixed for this report? Is it fixed for a period of time?

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

Yes, there is an actual cost for delivering the report fully.

Comment on this

If it takes two years-----

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

If it runs over, that is on Mazars' watch.

Comment on this

Okay. That probably is not, when it comes to the extension and the time they put into it, the best methodology in delivering a report in a manner that should be expedited, particularly when it is public moneys. There is no compulsion on Mazars to complete it. There is no urgency.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

I am sure it wants to get on to other pieces of work, to be honest, beyond-----

Comment on this

No, I am not sure. If it takes three years to complete the report, it will get the same money, so it can put little or no effort into it. The question then is, how much is it?

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

I think it is €80,000.

Comment on this

HRI might submit it to the committee. I thank Ms Eade.

The witnesses are probably aware of this matter. At the weekend, I was listening to racing programmes from the UK. Unfortunately, the witnesses' appearance in front of the Committee of Public Accounts was a hot topic of discussion. It is more to do with the controversy and the reputational damage that is happening within the sector. I know Ms McNally is looking at me very seriously but all of the things we discussed here today add up to reputational damage for what is a wonderful sector that employs an awful lot of people in the country. It has been let down, essentially, by programmes that are able to be constructed, such as "RTÉ Investigates", in the same way that money is being transferred and a chief financial officer goes on voluntary leave for 12 months while he is being paid. All of these things do not do much for our reputation, and we are here as a body that tried to keep HRI straight.

I received many representations prior to the meeting regarding the death of Paddy Dunican.

Has Ms Eade taken provision to look into that? I have been asked whether bullying allegations were made to her regarding Mr. Dunican. Has she taken any provision to safeguard HRI against any allegations?

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I ask for caution in this discussion. It is to do with a particular HR-related issue-----

Comment on this

It is a HRI issue for Ms Eade to answer.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I ask her to respond very cautiously on these individual matters.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

The passing of Mr. Dunican was a very sad situation for horse racing; however, in a forum like this to discuss the passing of a man in those circumstances is wholly inappropriate.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Yes, I do not expect-----

Comment on this

No, the question is whether a review is under way.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

I have nothing to do-----

Comment on this

I asked if bullying allegations had been made.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I would ask, Deputy-----

Comment on this

It is a legitimate question because it goes to the heart of whether or not public money will be spent on the issue.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I do not want Ms Eade to refer to a specific individual. If she wants to answer on whether the organisation is looking at procedures to counter bullying, as any other organisation and business would be doing, at the moment, that is as far as I want her to go. I do not want her to go further than that.

Comment on this

There is no accusation. There is a legitimate question based on already controversial reports.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

HRI has a policy on it, I presume.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

We have an anti-bullying and -harassment policy in place.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Does HRI review it regularly?

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

Absolutely, we review that.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Okay. That is as far as I want you to go. There are potential legal matters here and I have to be careful on it.

Comment on this

We do not know that.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

We also have the industry assistance programme, which is available to everybody working in the industry if they have any issues.

Comment on this

Ms Eade did not answer the question she was asked.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

I have not received any bullying-----

Comment on this

That is the question. Chair, just to have that on the record, Ms Eade says she has not received any bullying allegations.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That is all right. Okay. Does Mr. O'Loughlin want to say something before we conclude?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

I thank the Chair and committee for the audience today. The IHRB misses Mr. Dunican as one of our voluntary race day stewards. As I outlined at the beginning of the session, we rely heavily on those stewards to oversee all race meetings in the country and ensure rules are being adhered to. Mr. Dunican was a member of our race day steward panel.

Comment on this

Does Kilbeggan racecourse now have a licence?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

Yes, it does have a licence. We were happy to work closely with Kilbeggan racecourse following the tragic passing of Mr. Dunican. We respected the wishes of the racecourse committee to cancel the meeting due to take place shortly thereafter but we have worked with and supported them in every way we can. We are delighted to have seen two subsequent successful race meetings take place in Kilbeggan.

Comment on this

Is Mr. O'Loughlin aware of any bullying allegations made to the IHRB?

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Just in a general way. Do not refer to a specific individual, please.

Comment on this

In a general way, yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

We have not dealt with anything of that nature.

Comment on this

Has the IHRB not received anything?

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

We have not received anything.

Comment on this

Thank you. Chair, that is it.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

I will respond to the question on the two unfortunate UK jockeys. The Irish Injured Jockeys will support those jockeys. We can give the Deputy contacts who will support them if they are coming back to Ireland.

Comment on this

That is fine. I am aware they had been in touch and had received no support. Maybe they did not contact the right people. I appreciate that.

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

The Irish Injured Jockeys have already been-----

Comment on this

They are working on the English circuit. They were not employed in Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. Darragh O'Loughlin

We have a number of bodies. The Jockeys Accident Fund would not have been in a position to assist them but the Irish Injured Jockeys is another trust. It is completely separate from us.

Comment on this

The information would be welcome. Thank you.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Will the witnesses follow up with the Deputy afterwards on those cases?

Comment on this
Ms Suzanne Eade

Yes.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

To conclude, there are ongoing investigations to establish the facts regarding some of the matters discussed. The committee awaits that and wants to let An Garda Síochána's investigation happen. Mr. Sheahan is being helpful. He is in a difficult position here today, given the Department's investigation. We await the results of that, as I am sure everyone here does.

I thank the witnesses from HRI, IHRB and the Department for attending and for their work in preparing for the meeting. I also thank the Comptroller and Auditor General and his staff for attending and assisting at the meeting. I take it as agreed the clerk will seek any follow-up information and carry out any agreed actions arising from the meeting and that we note and publish the opening statements and briefings provided, unless anybody disagrees. That is agreed.

The meeting is suspended until 1.30 p.m., when we will resume in public session to address correspondence and other business of the meeting. Go raibh míle maith agaibh.

Comment on this