We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Financial Statements 2022: Road Safety Authority

Contributions 1–248 of 757. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Apologies have been received from Deputy James O'Connor. Everyone is very welcome. I remind all those in attendance to ensure their mobile phones are on silent mode or switched off.

Before we start, I will explain some limitations to parliamentary privilege and the practice of the Houses as regards reference witnesses may make to other persons in their evidence. The evidence of witnesses physically present or who give evidence from within the parliamentary precincts is protected, pursuant to both the Constitution and statute, by absolute privilege. This means they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Cathaoirleach to ensure this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative they comply with any such direction.

Members and witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not comment on, criticise, or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable. Members are also reminded of the provisions within Standing Order 218 that the committee shall refrain from enquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government, or a Minister of the Government, or the merits of the objectives of such policies.

The Comptroller and Auditor General, Mr. Seamus McCarthy, is a permanent witness to the committee. He is accompanied this morning by Ms Olivia Somers, deputy director at the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General.

This morning we will engage with representatives of the Road Safety Authority, RSA - it is their first attendance at the Committee of Public Accounts - to examine the RSA's 2022 financial statements. We are joined by the following representatives of the RSA: Mr. Sam Waide, chief executive officer; Mr. Brendan Walsh, chief operations officer; Mr. Michael Rowland, director of research, standards and assurance; Ms Kim Colhoun, director of finance and corporate services; Ms Nessa Kelly, director of strategy, performance and transformation; and Ms Sarah O'Connor, director of partnerships and external affairs. We are also joined by the following officials from the Department of Transport: Dr. Keith Walsh, assistant secretary; and Mr. Tomás Campbell, principal officer. They are all very welcome.

I now call the Comptroller and Auditor General, Mr. Seamus McCarthy, to make his opening statement.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

The Road Safety Authority is a statutory public body established pursuant to the Road Safety Authority Act 2006. The authority’s core mission is to save lives and prevent injuries by helping to reduce the number and severity of collisions on Irish roads. The authority has four core lines of business which are the issuing of driving licences and learner driver permits; driver knowledge and competence testing; vehicle testing of passenger and commercial vehicles; and influencing the behaviour of road users through road safety advertising campaigns, promotion, education, awareness-raising and research.

The 2022 financial statements indicate the authority had income of just over €100 million in the year. This was up from €87.8 million in 2021 and represented the authority’s recovery to pre-Covid income levels. Almost all of the authority’s income is generated from fees and charges in respect of the services it provides. In 2022, this included €34.5 million of driver licence fee income and €16.9 million of driver testing fee income. On the vehicle testing side, the authority raised €16.4 million from the testing of commercial vehicles and €25.9 million from national car test, NCT, operations. It should be noted that the NCT is outsourced to a private sector operator, which had a gross turnover of €72.3 million in the year. The authority’s NCT levy income of just under €26 million from the operator in 2022 was down from €27.5 million in 2021 due to a lower number of tests completed and absorption by the authority of a cost indexation impact. The Road Safety Authority received funding of just under €1 million from the Vote for transport in 2022.

The Road Safety Authority incurred expenditure of €95 million in 2022, resulting in a surplus of €5.1 million for the year. The 2021 financial statements received a clear audit opinion. Without qualifying that opinion, I drew attention to non-compliant procurement to the value of €1.75 million in the year.

Members may wish to note that the 2022 financial statements were certified on 26 June 2023. The authority’s financial statements for 2023 have just been certified by me, and will be presented to the Oireachtas Library in due course. Separately, my office is currently undertaking an examination of the driver testing service. This was designed as an update of a previous special report published by my office in 2009 focused on the economy, timeliness and consistency of the testing service. I expect to report on that work in a further special report in due course

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I thank the Chair and Deputies. First, I would like to confirm for the public record that the RSA or I would not refuse to appear before a committee and I apologise if there was any confusion or misinterpretation by members.

I thank the committee members for the opportunity to speak to them today on the Road Safety Authority’s financial statements for 2022 and on a range of topics. Today we will discuss numbers and statistics but at the RSA we are always aware we are talking about tragic loss of life on our roads, life-changing injuries, bereaved families and communities across the country.

In 2022, the RSA received a clean audit opinion from the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General. The total expenditure incurred in that year was €95.4 million. As the RSA has operated as a predominantly self-financing entity since 2014, this expenditure was covered by revenue of €95.8 million generated from the various fees and levies for key services, including the NCT, National Driver Licence Service, NDLS, and commercial vehicle roadworthiness testing, CVRT.

The annual Exchequer allocation via the Department's Vote represents less than 1% of total income. Given the wide remit of the RSA, this expenditure was utilised in key areas such as the operation of the public services, with over 700,000 full licences issued, over 244,000 learner permits issued, over 180,000 driving tests offered and over 2 million cars tested via the NCT. In addition to road safety promotion, awareness, education, enforcement and research, there was investment in other priorities and strategic priorities, especially for the RSA to deliver our own objectives, but also actions the RSA has within the Government's road safety strategy.

I wish to discuss some of the key trends we have seen to date in 2024. Tragically, as of 25 June 2024, there have been 90 fatalities on our roads and there was another one in the last 24 hours. This is an 11% increase in road deaths against this time last year, in addition to over 560 serious injuries in the year to date. In our detailed submission we have highlighted some of the initiatives the RSA undertook in 2023 and has carried into this year to address the current trend. These include an additional €3 million expenditure in 2024 for ongoing radio and digital audio campaigns relating especially to mobile phone use while driving and people taking drugs while driving.

In recent years, the Covid pandemic in particular has created challenges for the NCT service. In quarter 3 of 2022, Applus, which is the provider, has not met some service level agreements, SLAs, and the RSA has applied service credits in line with the terms of the contract. We continue to do so within the agreement. I am pleased to inform the committee that the service is close to returning to the SLA of 12 days for booking a test. The current average time is 13 days. In addition, the number of customers on the priority waiting list for the NCT has reduced from a high point of over 65,000 in February 2023 to just over 6,700 as of the end of May 2024.

With driving tests at unprecedented levels of demand since Covid, at the end August 2023, the waiting time for a driver test was 30.4 weeks. With additional driver testers in place, new scheduling technology and our staff’s commitment to work overtime, including weekends, we have seen a reduction in the waiting time to just over 15 weeks as of the end of May. Our objective is to return the service to the SLA of ten weeks for a driving test. The RSA, with the Department's support, continues to operate the service within the current staffing sanction while the longer term requirements for the service are being assessed. The driver licence service currently is processing 57% of our licensing applications through our online facility and 98% of customers receive their licence within five days.

I am pleased to confirm we have successfully concluded our consultation with the Data Protection Commission, DPC, and secured agreement to advance the necessary legislative amendments to support the sharing of collision data with multiple agencies. This positive outcome is the result of months of dedicated work and extensive collaboration with key organisations to resolve data protection issues and address the DPC's previous queries and concerns. We have just received the ministerial order in that regard and we can discuss that further. Concurrently, the Department is advancing that aspect, including the sharing of full data sets with local authorities. We anticipate that being in place in due course. For the sake of clarity, local authorities had previously received and continue to receive analysis on high collision locations for the national road network. That was through Transport Infrastructure Ireland and the Department of Transport.

In summary, we are deeply concerned about the high level of fatalities and serious injuries to date this year and previously. We require collective actions from the RSA and relevant agencies, parties, stakeholders and communities to achieve this. My staff and I are fully committed to reducing fatalities and serious injuries on our road to vision zero. We acknowledge that reversing the trends of the last two years must be a priority and it will be a challenge. As a society we have done it before, and we can do it again collectively.

The RSA was established in 2006 and there has been a significant reduction since. There were 365 fatalities in 2006 and that figure had reduced to 192 in 2014. In 2021, we achieved one of our lowest numbers of road deaths, at 134. The trajectory of road deaths was steadily in decline until 2022, the Covid pandemic, the return of the full economy and the many things that have come with that, which I hope we can discuss. We in the RSA are calling this out and raising awareness of the concerning evidence of non-compliance by road users - killer behaviours - and the need for enhanced enforcement by An Garda Síochána. Fortunately, thanks to the support of Ministers and the Taoiseach, we have allocated additional spend on campaigns and media awareness. An Garda Síochána has engaged in additional enforcement, including fixed-camera locations, which will be implemented and rolled out this year. These will be transformative in terms of deterrence.

Reducing road deaths requires an all-of-government approach and commitment. It is our primary mission and we remain committed to achieving the ambitious targets set out in the Government's road safety strategy. I am joined by my executive colleagues and we look forward to a constructive discussion.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Mr. Waide. Our first member to speak will be Deputy Catherine Murphy.

Comment on this

I thank the Cathaoirleach. The RSA officials are very welcome. I ask that they keep their responses short because I have a number of questions to get in and we all have limited time.

I thank them for their briefing note which is very useful. Page 10 provides information on the cost. I accept the point made about how the number one issue is the tragic loss of life, but the officials have given us some figures in the briefing note. In cold monetary terms the cost of a fatal collision is estimated at €3.4 million. That was a 2022 figure. A serious injury collision was estimated at €385,000 and the financial cost of road traffic collisions in Ireland was estimated at €1.39 billion for that year. Apart from the life-changing injuries and the tragedy for the families, in cold monetary terms it makes the case for paying close attention to this.

Some of the other information the officials have given relates to the days of the week we are most likely to see fatal accidents happening, which is between Friday and Sunday. The prevalence in rural areas is greater than it is in urban areas, at seven out of ten. There is a lot of very useful information in the briefing. It is against that backdrop that I put my questions.

There was a 72% increase in the road safety programme expenditure. Despite this increase, road fatalities have gone up. Does Mr. Waide think that funding is being targeted appropriately? What metrics does the RSA use for its advertising campaigns? Does it use advertising metrics such as the reach of the advertising and the number of people who viewed it or are they based on improvements in the sense of a reduction in fatal and very serious accidents?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I thank the Deputy for the questions. I will be brief and will also ask my colleague to provide part of the answer. The Deputy is correct that part of our expenditure, as set out in the submission, is spent on delivering services. Our costs have gone up because the demand for all our key services has increased, meaning our costs are going to increase.

I will focus on the Deputy's question on expenditure on the campaigns and their effectiveness. As the CEO, I brought it to my executive team's attention that we needed to measure the effectiveness of those campaigns.

I will ask my colleague, Ms O'Connor, to give an example of how we measure the effectiveness of a particular campaign.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

We ran a campaign just before Christmas. I can use that as an example and tease it out, if that is helpful.

Comment on this

I ask Ms O'Connor to be very brief.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

I can be very brief. We carry out two pieces of analysis. One is a post-campaign analysis, which is done in the immediate weeks following a campaign. It tells us the number of eyeballs that will be on a campaign, or what we call impressions. It will tell us how many people clicked on a link and watched a video through to the end. That is one piece of analysis we do. We do a secondary piece of analysis, where we work with IPSOS on tracking research in the months after a campaign. We look at how many people, unprompted, said they saw the ad. If people said they saw a particular ad, and say they definitely saw it, we then ask them how many times they saw it. We dig into whether the ad made them more likely to slow down, pay more attention or prompt a conversation with family and friends. We have tracked that over the course of the past decade, not only within a campaign but how a campaign performed against particular best-in-practice campaigns that we have run in the past. That is the structure we have at the moment. We also look at the bigger trends with the work Mr. Rowland's research team does.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

It is also important to note that in the past 18 months, the number of road fatalities involving young people, in particular, have doubled. Mr. Rowland has the trends to hand. We prioritised specific campaigns aimed at young persons. We have taken a fundamental shift in how to engage with particular cohorts in campaigns.

Comment on this

I understand ad campaigns can be effective. Unfortunately, road fatalities have increased following those campaigns. We have to question where we put our resources, in terms of whether enforcement plays a greater role. That is an issue for the Garda. There are particular categories. For example, there were 11 fatal crashes in 2023 involving learner drivers. That was a dramatic increase.

Repeated permits are an issue. There has been a commitment to having a requirement for people to have a test. If somebody can repeatedly get a learner permit without doing a test, that may well be a contributory factor to fatalities. What are the plans of the Road Safety Authority in that regard?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I thank Deputy Murphy. As a society and Road Safety Authority, we believe that the issue of multiple learner permits needs to be addressed. I have been consistent in my organisation about addressing this. It is the right thing to do. To answer the Deputy's question, it has been discussed at the partnership board, which includes the Department of Transport and our colleagues here today, as well as other agencies. It is a ministerial priority to address multiple learner permits.

Comment on this

It is outside of what the Road Safety Authority can do, essentially. It is down to-----

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

No, we are working with the Department of Transport to address the matter. I would like to give a fuller answer. Mr. Walsh has a project in place to deliver that ministerial priority. I will pass over to him.

Comment on this

I will ask a parliamentary question on that. I do not have the time to address it now. It is illegal to drive unaccompanied on a learner permit, yet people arrive unaccompanied to NCT centres, for example. What is the Road Safety Authority doing about that? What can it do about that?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

What I have done and can do is continually highlight with An Garda Síochána the need to enforce that particular aspect of the law.

Comment on this

The Garda is being asked to enforce that. People arrive to Road Safety Authority centres. Do staff ring the Garda? Are people advised that they should not arrive unaccompanied? Is the Road Safety Authority taking a particular initiative in this regard?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

When someone arrives unaccompanied, we highlight that to the individual. We have examples of that. I would like to provide an example to give the committee an assurance that we are doing something about it.

Comment on this

I will stop there because I want to use my time for the questions I want to ask, rather than winding my time down in a way that I do not find satisfactory.

I refer to the metrics I described earlier. The Road Safety Authority referred to the lack of sharing of information and the issue with the data commissioner, as well as due course. Does Mr. Waide have a ballpark idea of what we are talking about in terms of what the term "due course" means? There used to be a system whereby a CT68 form was filled out when there was a collision, even those involving material damage to vehicles. That information was mapped by local authorities. A cost-benefit analysis was done in respect of road improvements. The absence of that information in local authorities by virtue of the fact that the information has not been shared has, I presume, had a direct impact on their ability to put a cost-benefit analysis forward for improving roads where there are repeated high level of accidents, injuries and fatalities. When Mr. Waide talks about due course, what is the ballpark? Is legislation required? Will that information be shared? What timeline are we talking about?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I will pass that matter to the Department of Transport. The Deputy is correct; legislation is required.

Comment on this
Mr. Keith Walsh

As Mr. Waide said, a ministerial order was signed last week that permits the Road Safety Authority to receive data from the Garda on collisions. The Garda collects that information and shares it with the Road Safety Authority. That ministerial order will also allow the Road Safety Authority to share the collisions data to local authorities. However, another piece of legislation is required to allow local authorities to receive and process that information in accordance with GDPR. For the final piece to allow the local authorities to do that, we need to make a change to the Roads Act, 1993. We are very keen to bring this forward as quickly as possible. We will bring a proposal to our Ministers to bring a memo to Government to start drafting that legislation. It will be a short and targeted Bill that we hope will be passed as quickly as possible by the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Walsh expect that to happen within the lifetime of this Government?

Comment on this
Mr. Keith Walsh

I do not know what the lifetime of this Government is, but we will progress it as quickly as we can.

I will make a brief additional comment. The Deputy is correct in that there is concern that local authorities do not have access to full data, but local authorities continue to have access to analysis provided by the Department of Transport for locations in their localities. This year alone, a programme of work has been approved and funded for 261 projects across all local authorities for roads improvements. That is based on a combination of the Department's analysis that has been feed to local authorities and local knowledge of local authorities about what is going on in their areas. Notwithstanding the data flow issues, a lot of work is being done based on what is available.

Comment on this

I want to go back to the multiple learner permit issue. This may well be the responsibility of the Department because ministerial priorities have not been followed up on. Multiple learner permits is one such issue, as is a review of the driving test curriculum. What relationship is there between the Department and Road Safety Authority in terms of progressing those issues? Are there issues regarding the adequacy of staffing to focus on those areas?

Comment on this
Mr. Keith Walsh

We have a very good, active and engaged relationship with the Road Safety Authority. On the driver curriculum review, for example, a number of very detailed workshops have been held to scope out what the driver curriculum review should look like.

On the multiple learner permit issue, the position is slightly different. The policy decision has effectively been made. There is an action in the RSA. The Department, together with the RSA, would have agreed on the change that we wanted to make in the legislation. The implementation of that is what we are working through now.

Comment on this

Over 6,000 learners failed to show up for scheduled tests in 2023. They continue to renew their permits. I am not in favour of increasing the price of testing. The most important thing is that we get people tested and that they are not driving on learner permits. Has the RSA a strategy for the slots that are wasted and to make the system more efficient?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

On the number of people who do not show up, let me put the number the Deputy quoted, 6,000, into context. This year, we forecast that we will deliver around 270,000 tests. Therefore, 6,000, as a percentage, is quite low, although it is a concern. Over the past 12 months, we have introduced a series of new technological advances within the testing service that have brought our utilisation of available slots up from 94% to 98%. Where somebody chooses not to attend at test or where we have advance notice that somebody cannot attend, we put it back into the system immediately to allow somebody to log on immediately to avail of it.

Comment on this

Can the RSA identify whether the same people keep failing to show up? Is the system flexible enough to identify that?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

As Dr. Walsh has already referred to, we have engaged in several scoping sessions on multiple learner permits. That is one of the angles we are taking a really good look at. If we see repeat offenders, we want to target them. We are well advanced regarding how we can set out the mechanism for delivering the action on multiple learner permits. My team has actually prepared a proposal, which it will discuss with the Department of Transport in the next week or so, on how to make progress on this. One component is to try to target repeat offenders. The Deputy is correct that if they are not turning up and using that to their advantage to renew their permits, it is wrong and has to be dealt with by us.

Comment on this

Reference was made to post-campaign analysis of whether a campaign has succeeded and resulted in value for money. Is it just post-campaign analysis that is done or are there key performance indicators concerning, for example, the level of seatbelt wearing? Are they available for public scrutiny?

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O’Connor

Mr. Rowland’s team, on the research side of things, analyses a wealth of important data in that regard. The indicators are measured and reported on at European level so we can track how we compare at that level. If the Deputy is interested, Mr. Rowland can take her through those. If any of the measures are off kilter, we ask whether we need to invest in an ad in the space in question and whether the ad we have is good enough. We ask whether the tracking tells us the ad has been working, or whether it has perhaps decayed such that people are not absorbing it in the same way anymore, meaning we might need to do something new. Then we decide on the ad we are going to invest in, brief the agency and do the tracking from there. We examine not only our analysis but also what is happening behaviourally.

The Deputy may be aware from the Safe and Sober Seminar, which Mr. Rowland’s team ran in January, that we are very concerned about the slippage in terms of alcohol levels. From 2019 until now, we have seen peer acceptability of drink-driving rise by 10%. That is very serious and a very big societal shift. Therefore, even though our ad, involving Gillian and her son Ciarán, is amazing and performs very strongly, we believe we need another piece in the conversation regarding alcohol. Part of the funding we have agreed with the Department for later this year is to create a new alcohol ad. It is not a case of using the same ad all the time as one might need something different for a different audience. You go from there. That is the kind of sophistication we bring. At an overarching level, we have a new communications strategy that helps us to identify the top-ten topics, and those are really led by the research, through which Mr. Rowland’s team tells us what it is worried about and the concerns so we can build from there.

Comment on this

I would imagine the same applies to drug driving at this stage.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O’Connor

Yes.

Comment on this

Obviously, Ms O’Connor has seen an increase in that.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O’Connor

The Medical Bureau of Road Safety has informed us about what it is seeing at trend level. It is capturing more drug tests from the Garda. Young people caught under the influence of drugs are more drugged and often under the influence of multiple drugs. That is of great concern. We are not happy that the drug ads we have at the moment are good enough, and that is why there is a new one coming in December. We have had extensive conversations with the Department because we really believed we needed that. I suppose-----

Comment on this

A new ad is not coming until December.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O’Connor

In December.

Comment on this

Is there not a sense of urgency about this?

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O’Connor

There is, but it takes about three months from the get-go to briefing and production. It is not instantaneous.

Comment on this

I suggest urgency.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O’Connor

I agree.

Comment on this

How is seatbelt-wearing gauged? Is there a way of gauging whether a seatbelt campaign has worked or got through to the public?

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O’Connor

There are two components. The first is determining how many people saw the campaign, clicked on the link or listened through to the end of the Spotify ad or whatever they were listening to. Then we ascertain whether people talked to themselves, their friends or family and whether they were more likely to remind somebody else to put a seatbelt on. Then it probably moves over to Mr. Rowland’s overarching piece. His team tracks this year in, year out.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Before we hand over to Mr. Rowland, may I say that this is one of the killer behaviours? Unfortunately, Mr. Rowland and his team in the RSA have flagged an increase in non-seatbelt-wearing. It is extremely concerning. I will pass over to Mr. Rowland to give more detail on it.

Comment on this

Could he be very brief and furnish the committee with information on monitoring over the years, on success and failure, and what works and does not?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

We will do that. On seatbelt-wearing, we do observational surveys whereby we go out to the roadsides and observe. We have seen a decline in the driver seatbelt-wearing rate of 4% and in the passenger seatbelt-wearing rate of 5%. These statistics were recorded in our 2023 observational survey. In addition, between 2019 and 2023, 23% of driver fatalities and 21% of passenger fatalities involved individuals who were not wearing a seatbelt at the time of the collision. This is very concerning. I am referring to people who were killed or injured.

There is a high wearing rate. The wearing rate among the general population is over 90%, but the people who are being killed and seriously injured are not wearing their seatbelts, as I referred to.

Comment on this

Could we be furnished with that information? Those are very interesting statistics. Obviously, Mr. Rowland will continue to monitor the trend and consider means of getting the message out even more.

I want to move on to driver testing. On average, the waiting time for a driver test is 14 weeks to 16 weeks. Among the reasons given for this are a reduced workforce owing to staff retirements and contracted staff reaching the end dates of their contracts. Why would the contracts not be automatically renewed, given the outcry about the waiting times for driving tests? Is there a reason the contracts are not indefinite? What percentage are renewed and what is the reason for contracts not being renewed?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I will answer that question briefly. We can provide more detail. In the RSA, we have 130 permanent driver testers.

Comment on this

We have all that information. Could Mr. Waide just answer the specific questions, please?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

On the Deputy’s question on why contracts are temporary, we received sanction from the Department of Transport to recruit temporary driver testers.

Comment on this

Does the RSA not have permanent ones?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

We have 130 permanent testers but we also have over 30 temporary testers. There was a campaign run to recruit driver testers, but we could recruit only temporary driver testers because that was the sanction.

Comment on this

The Department allowed only temporary ones.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I have said consistently at transport committee meetings that we have a public service that has stable demand, increasing demand.

That is why we are in discussions with the Department.

Comment on this

Have the Department and the Minister not budged on that as yet?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

We are in discussions. I will pass over to the Department. We have submitted a business case for permanent driver testers.

Comment on this

Of the contracts that have not been renewed, what is the reason they have not automatically been renewed, given the shortage and also that the testers have been doing the work for years and, therefore, also have experience?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

As an authority, we would love to retain those individuals but we cannot do so because we need to follow the rules and the law. We cannot retain those individuals.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Waide saying the Department does not even allow the authority renew an existing contract once it comes to an end?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

We are not permitted to do so by law.

Comment on this

That seems ridiculous altogether. That is something to take up with the Minister. As time is of the essence, I will raise another matter.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

Sorry, I think-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We will let Dr. Walsh answer.

Comment on this

I will if I am given extended time.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

Briefly, there are matters of employment law here in terms of how many years a person can be on a contract as well.

Comment on this

If someone applies to renew the contract and is quite happy in the job, is Dr. Walsh saying they are not allowed to have the contract renewed?

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

Up to a certain point, they can.

Comment on this

Is that not fairly insane, given the waiting lists the length and breadth of the State?

I want to move on to another issue - the apt term would be "another farce". People in Drogheda believe the RSA has deemed Drogheda not suitable for a driving test centre. It is the largest town in Ireland with a population of 45,000. Currently, under a northern environs plan, we are preparing for an increase in population of 20,000 in the next five years. This has been going on for six years, during which we got continuous reports. This is a farce. There were 14 sites inspected, according to the RSA. Of those 14 sites, seven were deemed not suitable but no reason was given. In other sites, traffic was given as the reason for not allowing a centre at them. In another one, speed ramps were the reason.

Most people think this beyond insane and are questioning whether the RSA has the capability of seeking an adequate test centre, whether to rent or whatever. I looked through some of the information there. The authority is renting rooms and offices the length and breadth of the country, but Drogheda, the largest town, has been waiting six years for a centre.

Can Mr. Waide give me an example of where he would say with a straight face that a build-up of traffic is a reason not to provide a driving test centre in any town or village in Ireland? I am not aware of anywhere that is traffic free. Traffic is the norm 24-7. For six years, the RSA has been saying it cannot provide a driving test centre in this particular site because there is traffic or there are speed ramps down the road and has listed seven sites as not suitable without giving a reason. Does the RSA have the capability? Is Mr. Waide telling me the RSA does not have the capability to source a driving test centre for the largest town in Ireland? How long more does Mr. Waide reckon we will have to wait for the RSA to get its act together?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

We are fully committed to providing-----

Comment on this

Stop. If I hear that again. We are six years on.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Hold on a second. Please give the Deputy a concise answer.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

-----a driving test service in Drogheda. Mr. Walsh will give the specific reasons and challenges. We as an authority are as frustrated as others are. Let us give the details.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Will Mr. Walsh give me an answer? Is the problem premises? Is it a problem with the road layout? Just give me a concise answer.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

Let me answer as quickly as I can. Deputy Munster has written to me on several occasions on this matter. I can assure the Deputy that, last week, I sat with my team again to look at where we have issues around test centres. We are working with the OPW to try to find a permanent location for the people of Drogheda. It is a town I know very well and visit quite frequently.

In relation to travel, the quickest answer on that is if we cannot treat everybody who is doing a test the same way, we may disadvantage people who are sitting in a very large traffic build-up, maybe for a long period of time. That would mean the subsequent test-----

Comment on this

That is the case in Dublin every day.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

For the Dublin area, the tests take place on the outer part of the city. What we are doing with Drogheda is we are working with the OPW. I have looked at numerous sites in my own personal time to try to find a resolution to this. The Deputy is right. Drogheda is the biggest town in Ireland and we need to have a test centre there. We are working with the OPW and we will try to find a way.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that but Mr. Walsh can understand the frustration of the people of Drogheda six years on.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

Absolutely, I can.

Comment on this

Is he seriously saying there is not an office or a building in Drogheda that is suitable? I pass them every day of the week. The RSA has offices and buildings right around the country.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

It is not just the building. It is where we can build the route from to allow the test to take place in a fair manner for everybody. I would welcome support from the Deputy in this area.

Comment on this

Mr. Walsh is tasked with doing this and I have constantly been in touch with him to express sheer frustration.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

Yes.

Comment on this

Mr. Walsh is tasked with providing a driving test centre.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

I would recommend that we continue to work together to try to find a way to get a test centre in the town of Drogheda.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

If Mr. Walsh would keep the Deputy updated on that, I would appreciate it.

Comment on this

I would appreciate it if he could update me on the most recent developments. He said he was looking at something. Was that yesterday?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

We were looking last week. My driving testing team meets as a collective group. We go through all of the various test centres where we may have issues. We looked at this. Our facilities manager is engaging with the OPW on a continuing basis to try to find a site. I would appreciate Deputy Munster's input on this as well. We really would like to work with the Deputy on this.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Mr. Walsh. I call Deputy Ó Cathasaigh.

Comment on this

I thank the RSA for taking the time to attend. I am glad Mr. Waide provided clarity as regards the RSA's openness to attend the committee. The initial response may have struck the wrong tone and was probably ill judged. I am very glad to see the RSA appear before the Committee of Public Accounts today.

I put the following questions against the backdrop of a fatality in Waterford overnight, of which Mr. Waide will be aware. A teenager lost his life and another young man is fighting for his life, perhaps two miles from my family home. We have a context where we have yet another family grieving and yet another family praying for a good hospital outcome for their child. That provides a sobering context for the questions I will put today.

This is an obvious question but there are questions that follow. Is there a correlation between total car journeys and total car collisions?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

On the headline reasons for collisions, there is an increasing risk. There is an increase in cars in Ireland. There is an unprecedented increase in driving licences in Ireland. That results in an increased risk of collisions.

Comment on this

To cut through, increased car journeys correlates with increased car collisions.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

If I may, I will also say, in a positive way, that there is an increase in active travel.

Comment on this

I am coming to that.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

That is an area that we as a society need to address.

Comment on this

It is one in which the RSA has a particular role.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Yes.

Comment on this

Action 41 of the action plan on road safety strategy is to encourage modal shift to support environmental, safety and health objectives by promoting the use of sustainable and active modes of travel. The lead on this is the Department of Transport but also the support agency, NTA, Irish Rail, Bus Éireann and the RSA. How much money has the RSA assigned to campaigns that encourage modal shift?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I will ask Ms O'Connor to give a sense of the campaigns. If we do not have the information on how much that was in euro, we can certainly provide it.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

Under that action, the Department leads out on the Your Journey Counts campaign. That is led by the Department and it is its funding. We have supported that in a number of ways by sharing all of those assets.

We consider it important that a sub-message in many of our campaigns is about promoting modal shift. That is how we have built it in to the new communications strategy. The Your Journey Counts campaign, which is one of the principal pieces of that action, has been led by the Department financially. That was in conjunction with us but also in terms of discussion to make sure that our piece is the solid road safety piece and that the modal shift piece is led by the Department so that there is no confusion between the two.

Comment on this

The witnesses will know where I am going with this in that they know I have an opinion on where we place the blame for collisions that involve particularly vulnerable road users. Even though we have gone backwards in the past couple of years, since 2006 we have made improvements with regard to the number of deaths on the roads. We have not seen improvements with pedestrians, however. There has been no improvement at all for pedestrians.

Excuse me, there is a reduction in pedestrians. It is with cyclists that there is no change at all. Our progress is not uniform. We are not doing as well on vulnerable road users.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

Deputy-----

Comment on this

I want to return to something my colleague, Deputy Steven Matthews, put to the witnesses at a transport committee meeting about submissions on road safety interventions. At that meeting, it was stated that the RSA had not made any submissions, either on section 38 or Part 8 planning matters. Why?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

When the RSA is asked to put forward a view on any policy or consultation, we will submit our road safety view.

Comment on this

That does not really wash in that these are public consultations. I could point Mr. Waide to many schemes with regard to the weight of the authority of the RSA if the RSA had come in. I believe Ms O'Connor stated in subsequent interviews that it did not want to make submissions on road safety interventions because the RSA did not want to be political. This astounds me. It could be a school street, a cycle lane, a permeability measure or whatever. Let us say it is a school street. If there was a submission made from the RSA that said - it need not necessarily be this specific school street in this specific context - international research shows us that school streets result in better health outcomes for children, that would be significant in the context of the decision being made, either on a Part 8 or a section 38, if that has been discussed in front of a council. However, the RSA has not made any such submissions on any of these. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I accept that RSA has, in the past, made submissions to consultations and I accept-----

Comment on this

Has RSA made submissions on section 38 or Part 8 consultations?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I will ask my colleague, Mr. Rowland, because he knows previous and current submissions we have made in respect of different consultations. More importantly, we share the international research with other agencies around the partnership board, NTA, TII-----

Comment on this

We are talking around the point here. Is it correct that the RSA has not made submissions on Part 8s or section 38s?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

We have made submissions. With regard to the previous committee meeting and Part 8, sometimes the correspondence that comes to us does not identify that is a Part 8. Whenever we are asked to make a submission, we make a submission.

Comment on this

What expertise is there within the RSA to make that submission? Are transport engineers on staff? When a submission is made, who makes that submission and what-----

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

The point I made when this question was asked previously was that we are not road safety engineers. We do not have road safety engineers.

Comment on this

You are the Road Safety Authority.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

Yes but-----

Comment on this

Is Mr. Rowland telling me that the Road Safety Authority does not have any road safety engineers on staff?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

Yes, I am. Our role is education and awareness.

Comment on this

No, it is not. It goes far beyond that. In fact, the Road Safety Authority Act 2006 refers to, “the promotion of public awareness of road safety and of measures, including the advancement of education, relating to the promotion of the safe use of roads, including co-operation with local authorities and other persons in this regard”. Its remit should include that. I am gobsmacked that the RSA does not have a road safety engineer on staff.

I have a short time and I have many questions, some of which hopefully I will get to on a second round. I wish to return to this idea of where we place blame. In 2022, 394,350 hi-vis materials were distributed. What was the cost for that? What was the cost for close to 400,000 hi-vis pieces?

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

It cost €755,000.

Comment on this

What is the cost-benefit analysis the RSA runs on that?

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

I will pass to Ms O'Connor.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

Regarding hi-vis materials, we purchase materials for a number of different road user groups - motorcyclists, cyclists, pedestrians, adults and children.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

The procurement that surrounds that is all done under specialist procurement agreements. From a value-for-money point of view, it is absolutely guaranteed.

Comment on this

Value for money and a cost-benefit analysis are two different things. I understand that hi-vis materials are relatively cheap. Some €750,000 is not a great deal of money. Hi-vis is relatively cheap. We can go down the road and buy it in any shop. We can pick up a hi-vis vest. I am asking about the cost-benefit analysis. A lot of work goes into putting hi-vis vests very often on young children, down to toddlers. What is the cost-benefit analysis in terms of what road safety outcomes are delivered by putting hi-vis material on the back of a four-year-old?

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

We are led by research in this regard. I have referenced some of the research before when speaking about this is. For example, when it comes to the European Transport Safety Council, ETSC, its indications are that if somebody is not wearing a high-visibility vest, either a pedestrian or cyclist, they can be seen at 30 m. With high visibility, they can be seen at 150 m.

Comment on this

During the night or during low-light conditions.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

Yes, absolutely.

Comment on this

How many four-year-olds are out walking at night-time?

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

There is a challenge here. I see crèches and schools all the time having their kids out together collectively in hi-vis materials. Schools and crèches do that to protect themselves and feel like they are doing everything right in that space. However, that is not our advice. Our advice is about low-light conditions and night-time.

Comment on this

I think that is victim-blaming, to be quite honest, because of where responsibility is placed. I believe the going to school booklet is still live on the RSA website.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

It is.

Comment on this

It begins with dodgy research. It states that research shows that children aged under 12 should not cross roads on their own. In fact, the research points to those under ten years old. It has conflated-----

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

Actually we just had a PhD presentation-----

Comment on this

I have the FOI that-----

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

We can provide the Deputy with the PhD presentation we had in recent weeks.

Comment on this

I have the FOI on the research it was based on and it was ten-year-olds.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

We actually followed up on it yesterday with further research.

Comment on this

The second point it states is that children should wear high-visibility clothing when out walking. That firmly and squarely places the blame on parents and young children. We should be engineering our roads so it is safe for our children to walk to school.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

We should be doing all of those things. High-visibility material can play a role and can be very important. For young children-----

Comment on this

Taking into account that it is quite cheap to do, what cost-benefit analysis is done on the hi-vis expenditure? It has an impact on where blame is apportioned for road collisions. Is there an underpinning cost-benefit analysis?

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Please come in briefly. I want to move on.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I absolutely agree with the final point the Deputy made. As a system and as a country, we need to re-engineer our roads. I absolutely agree on that final point he made. Our departmental colleagues are with us. I agree with that point.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

This is Deputy English's first committee meeting. He is very welcome.

Comment on this

I hope it will not be my last.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The Deputy is here for a good while yet.

Comment on this

So I am told. I have a couple of questions to put to the team. If they are not answerable today, I am happy to take them again. I will might come back in if there is a second round of questions.

I compliment the delivery of driver's licence applications and the changes there. Mr. Waide touched on it earlier. There was a delivery time of four or five days. I got mine in two days - appointment booked and licence done. This proves that when we focus on something, we can do it. I met with a very helpful person. I spent an hour of my time and left with the licence. This can be compared with a couple a years ago, when we had to go through misery on behalf of our constituents to get them an appointment to get a licence. It shows that when there is a focus and an effort, we can deal with it.

I am still hearing “post Covid” and “pre-Covid”. We need to move on from excuses about Covid. I hear it everywhere I go; it is still Covid this and Covid that. We have had enough years to recover and catch up in most cases. I am glad that the driver's test waiting time is down to 15 weeks, and I hope we get down to ten soon. When young people are willing to take the test, get involved and are interested in driving, we should be able to respond to their requests, certainly when it comes to those who are trying to work. I know certain classes of worker can be prioritised but in the past some people could not engage in education or work because they could not get a licence and, therefore, I am glad. I hope the effort can be kept up on that, go beyond the ten weeks and drive it down even further. Even ten weeks is not acceptable.

On that, do we have data to compare with other countries? What is the norm across Europe when it comes to waiting time for a test? Applicants are not guaranteed a licence if they take a test.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

I recently attended a conference of our European and global colleagues and many of them are seeing the same trend we have seen, where there is a significant demand. That demand is predominantly driven by the simple fact of population growth in Europe, whether it is through migrant workers or natural population increases. It is a challenge. We engaged with our colleagues in the UK as well and they told us the same thing. We have made significant inroads over the past two years to try to manage the service.

The number of applications we saw in 2023 versus 2022 was up 14%. In the year to date, it is up 10%. Our testing capability over the 2022 to 2023 period increased by 11.6%. This year, it is up 30% on last year. We are starting to turn the curve, but we still have much more work to do. From the number of people who are applying for learner permits or on their essential driver training journeys, we can see there are more people in the pipeline. We are working with the Department on ensuring that we have a properly resourced service to meet the needs of a growing population.

Comment on this

That was my point. If we can see the common trends, I presume a request has to be made for the resources to manage those and upscale the various teams. I appreciate Mr. Walsh’s reply.

During Covid, a decision was made that vehicles did not need to have NCTs or CVRTs in order to be taxed. That requirement never returned. If they do not need it to be taxed, is there a link with vehicles not being tested? Is it intended to restore the requirement? I dealt with someone recently whose vehicle was impounded because it had not been tested. It was right that it was impounded, but people used to get a warning every so often about not being able to tax their cars if they did not have them tested. There were warnings built into the system. Will that link be restored or is it gone forever?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

The service for the NCT is pretty much back to where it needs to be. My team and I have sat down over the past number of weeks and started considering what the next five years will look like, what we will need to do and what changes we will need to make. This is one of the changes we need to consider. We are also considering simple matters like the dental appointment approach, whereby someone who goes to a dentist gets another appointment for a year’s time. In this way, someone would know when he or she should be coming in for an NCT. A reminder might also be sent. We want to try to find ways to ensure that what has happened never happens again. Linking motor tax to the NCT could be one measure we consider, but there will be a suite of other measures as well. My priority is to ensure that people can get NCTs when they want them.

Comment on this

Fair enough.

I am interested in the science behind the ads that are made for, and with, the RSA. Ms O’Connor spoke about the great deal of research that has been done to judge the impact of those ads. We had this conversation many years ago. Lotto ads are successful. They convince us all that we will win the lotto with “It could be you”, so we all go out and do it. Those ads get through to people, but when I speak to any young person, he or she does not believe it will be him or her in the accident. Young people believe it will never happen to them. On the other hand, they will buy lotto tickets and back horses because they expect to win.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

A positivity bias.

Comment on this

Is that analsyed? Attitude is a major issue. We can do all we can in terms of enforcement, but there has been a serious change in attitude in many parts of our lives in recent years. I will not say why, but since that dreaded occasion, people’s attitudes have slipped backwards where road safety is concerned but not where other issues are concerned. Is there science behind this? Who engages in putting the ad campaigns together?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

I will say something and then hand over to Ms O’Connor. The development of our ads is informed by our research and what our observational surveys are telling us. For example, the Deputy will have seen our campaigns targeting seatbelt wearing. The development of the ads is psychology-led. We look at people’s thinking and how to get the message across to the particular road user we are concerned about. Everything we do is evidence-based. We examine the database and the research, and that information is then handed over to Ms O’Connor’s team for developing the ad.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

When we are trying to develop a new ad, we hold focus groups with a target audience to try to ensure we understand what is going on. In April, we held focus groups with young men in rural Ireland who had been driving or had their licences for approximately two years, which is the point at which people come off their novice plates. We can see greater risks being taken then because people are confident and believe they are good drivers. Focus groups can be instrumental in that they are insight-driven by the people in them and can inform not just the specific campaign, which was to do with rural speeding in this case, but other work as well. For example, one of the young men said that he knew his local roads so well, he knew what was coming around the corner and did not need to worry. He said he even knew what cars would be on that road. We will have two brand new radio ads this week. One is called “Speed is a serial killer” and the other is about Darren and Jim. Both ads point out that people do not know what is around the corner. The young person’s positivity bias in believing he or she will win the lotto – fair dues to the young person if that happens – extends to not believing he or she will be hurt or hurt someone in a collision.

Down the years, we have learned that messages about serious injury can land more with young men than messages about fatalities. They may feel that is more likely. Over the past 12 months, we have spent significant money and effort on talking about Ms Imogen Cotter’s ad, which tries to convey what serious injury means. We have reused Ms Siobhán O’Brien’s ad, which had not been used in eight years, to convey the experience of having an acquired brain injury and what that has meant for her and her life. We held a conference on serious injuries last October. This is about building up the messaging.

There is no one intervention or ad that works. It is about the spectrum and having the interventions and ads at the right level for the right audience. Young people think very differently about road safety. They do not necessarily like us being the authority, so we have to find ways to slip into their heads that are slightly different from what would be traditional or normal. They do not want to be given out to, and this is what makes them difficult. Internally in the office, we call them “pistachios”, in that they are hard nuts to find and hard nuts to crack. We spend a great deal of money targeting them and trying to do things differently online to capture their attention. When preparing this morning, for example, I looked at the “30k” campaign. It was interesting. We carried out a wide spectrum of social advertising with that ad. I had to fight hard because there was a funny bit in the ad where the pigeon appeared. Everyone said it was too funny and would not work, but looking at what worked on Meta and TikTok, the ad that young people clicked on and watched through to the very end was the one with the pigeon. There are times when we have to rely on humour or different approaches to our messaging to get it over the line. This has been an important lesson. It involves us being a bit braver and saying it is not only about the scary ad option, but also victim testimonial ads, which are profoundly powerful. Ms Cotter’s ad has really performed, particularly when we have used it during sporting events over the past six or nine weeks to bring home the reality of collision.

Comment on this

I thank Ms O’Connor.

I wish to raise three issues about schools, although I would be happy to get the responses at the end of the meeting.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

There will be a second round anyway.

Comment on this

The RSA is involved in the promotion of road safety around schools. How involved is it with schools? Is that at primary, secondary or third level? Where does the RSA mainly focus and from where is the best benefit derived? Much more can be done in this regard. We cannot expect schools to do everything and there is a role for the RSA. I presume it is engaging with them. What has been the feedback from them?

Road safety outside schools is an issue that we encounter a great deal as public representatives. We are always discussing it with local authorities and the Department of Education, but someone needs to take charge of and lead this conversation. Solving a road safety issue outside the school is being left up to the poor principal.

While I am on the topic of schools, there is an issue with school bus drivers. Over-70s cannot drive school buses on behalf of Bus Éireann, but they can come back in half an hour later and drive the same kids to a football match or a private outing. Who is responsible for this or where does the issue lie, and how do we solve it?

I can get the answers to these questions after the meeting if the Chair wishes to move on. I do not mind.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The witnesses might take them now, please.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Regarding education, engineering and enforcement, I have stated consistently in my time in this post that road safety should be part of the national curriculum. We have worked positively with schools and we have had a meeting with the Minister, Deputy Foley, about refreshing the transition year curriculum, but I remain firm in my belief that we should have road safety as part of the national curriculum, as that would carry through for life.

Could the Deputy clarify his question about buses?

Comment on this

It is an issue that is often raised with Deputies, as there is a demand for buses and bus drivers. Our understanding is that people cannot drive with Bus Éireann if they are aged over 70, yet they can return to the same schools at 9.30 a.m. and drive the same kids in the same buses to football matches on private contracts. They just cannot do the school runs.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I will pass over to the Department to address the issue of policy.

Comment on this

Has the RSA a role in that rule?

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

We can revert to the Deputy with more detail after the meeting, but there is no legal barrier, as far as I am aware, to over-70s driving school buses. My understanding is that it is a Bus Éireann policy.

I am sure it has a research basis for that policy.

Comment on this

That is my question. I want to understand the science behind it.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Mr. Rowland answered about RSA's role and, in particular, the research aspect.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

It concerns the national office of traffic medicine and Professor Desmond O’Neill’s advice. It is my understanding that what Professor O'Neill said was that drivers who are over the age of 70 can self-regulate when they are driving their cars. They can choose to go out or not to go out when it is dark. They can choose not to go out when there are adverse weather conditions. That is different from driving professionally or driving a bus, where you cannot make those choices and you have to go out and drive. There are more complex driving manoeuvres when driving a bus. There is also the added dimension of carrying children and others on the bus. It is for that reason. Bus Éireann makes its own decisions in relation to that. Professor O'Neill is the person who advises on this and it is my understanding that he may have had discussions with Bus Éireann about this particular matter.

Comment on this

I know I am over time, but could Mr. Rowland furnish us with Professor O'Neill's advice or guidance? I thought it was the RSA which-----

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

I will.

Comment on this

On that point, does the same advice not counter the information about going to a football match a half an hour later? I refer to situations where the same driver is employed privately.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

All we can do is provide the advice of Professor O'Neill.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

They are only implementing the policy.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

Yes.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I call Deputy Verona Murphy-----

Comment on this

Does the RSA have a view on this?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

The view is the medical advice that was given by Professor O'Neill.

Comment on this

Please forward that to the committee.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I call Deputy Verona Murphy.

Comment on this

Clearly Mr. Rowland did not tune into the last discussion we had about this with the Department of Transport. I will go to Mr. Walsh and maybe Mr. Rowland will be better informed after this. The criteria for the medical in the NDLS for professional drivers was extended to the age of 75. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

The medical for all drivers-----

Comment on this

The requirement for a medical is now 75 years of age.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

That is for all drivers.

Comment on this

Who advises on that? Contrary to what Professor O'Neill would say, we now have a situation where one cannot drive a school bus under a Bus Éireann tender at the age of 70 because of Professor O'Neill's advice, yet, somebody told the RSA that it was okay to extend the medical to the age of 75.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

I can only go on-----

Comment on this

We can only go on the number of deaths on the road. That is why the RSA is here: to give us answers about why that is happening. We have a situation where we cannot get bus drivers under the Bus Éireann tender. I received a text today that states there are 110 pupils going from Kilmore to Wexford. We will have at least 60 extra cars on the road for the want of two bus drivers. Mr. Rowland is in the Road Safety Authority, so does he not have an opinion on that? Ms O'Connor has told us that the idea was to offer a modal shift, but we cannot because of this rubbish that goes on with contradictions in terms. Can Mr. Rowland tell me how that contradiction has arisen? It is not on medical grounds. The medical evidence is that people over the age of 70 are far more competent drivers.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

That relates to people who are over the age of 70 and who are driving their own cars. Driving a school bus-----

Comment on this

We are not talking about cars.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

Well-----

Comment on this

The medical pertains to driving a bus.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Just give the witness the chance to answer.

Comment on this

Hold on now, Chair. Do not run down the clock on me with rubbish. I put a question about school buses. We are not talking about cars.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will get a concise answer for you. Mr. Rowland, please.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

The advice from Professor O’Neill is that driving a car and driving a bus are two different tasks.

Comment on this

Did you not understand the question? The question is not about what Professor O’Neill advised. It is about why we have a medical at the age of 75. Who advised that?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

It is my understanding that Professor O’Neill from the national office of traffic medicine advocated for that.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

That is advice that was given to the RSA. We can and will commit to getting a second and third opinion in terms of clinical medical advice.

Comment on this

Why have you not committed to doing that already? Why have you appeared here to be told that? Have you not recognised that contradiction up to now?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

You have raised the issue and I will take it away. This is-----

Comment on this

Sorry, I have been raising this for ten years and it is only in the last three years that the RSA has increased the medical to the age of 75. It was since Covid.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

On this day, in this committee room, I am committing to seeking second and third opinions-----

Comment on this

Do you believe-----

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

-----because I am not-----

Comment on this

Do you believe it is a contradiction?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I am not a clinician. There is no clinician in the Road Safety Authority.

Comment on this

Common sense would dictate that there is something, apart from the fact that it is Bus Éireann’s policy, which is a Department of Transport issue.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Bus Éireann sits on the partnership board-----

Comment on this

You can fudge away but the reality here is that we could have two bus drivers taking 110 children to school or we can have 100 cars on the road. Mr. Waide’s objective should be the two bus drivers. It is not up to me to come up with a solution. Mr. Waide is being paid the big salary as the chief executive of the RSA to reduce road deaths. Primary to that is putting in a modal shift, as Ms O’Connor put it, from the perspective of road safety and, particularly, when it comes to our children.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I have committed-----

Comment on this

Your review will take far too long. This subject has been on the cards for ten years. It is Mr. Waide’s first time before the committee in five years. I have written to the Road Safety Authority several times but I have never gotten a response, email-wise-----

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I am sorry. First, I have committed to that action. On the latter point the Deputy has made, she has written to the RSA on 35 occasions and seven of those were in 2024, and the RSA has responded.

Comment on this

They are different matters. I referred to you.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I am happy to share my contact details with the Deputy and I have committed to that action on the bus drivers-----

Comment on this

Do I have the incorrect details? How many emails did you personally receive from me?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

To my email address?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

None. I have checked.

Comment on this

Well, that is fine. I will forward them to you again.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I am very happy to share my details with the Deputy.

Comment on this

As far as I am concerned, I have the details, but I certainly have not received a response, but I will take that. That could be a simple IT issue.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I thank the Deputy.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

I have a point of clarification. All professional drivers have to have a medical every five years.

Comment on this

This has been extended to the age of 75. I am fully aware of that. What I am saying is that the compulsory medical has been extended. It has gone from the age of 75 from 70.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

That is for category B licence holders. If you are passenger car driver you need to have a medical certificate from the age of 75 and above if you are driving a vehicle of any sort.

Comment on this

We are not talking about that. We are talking about the age of 70 here now.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

From the age of 70 you get a free licence. There is a requirement under a category B licence to have a medical certificate if you are above the age of 75. I think the issue we have been discussing here is related to commercial vehicles and these are two separate issues.

Comment on this

Drivers of commercial vehicles who are over the age of 70 would require a medical annually. It is now extended so that it must happen annually, when one is aged 75, then turns 76, then 77, etc. That is the point I am making.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

No, it is not.

Comment on this

Well, that is what the legislation says. It has increased to 75 years of age.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

It is 75 years of age for a category B licence.

Comment on this

I ask the witness to submit that in writing so that we can check the legislation again.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

Okay.

Comment on this

The other question I have regarding road safety is about the IRHA, which is the only licensed representative organisation for HGVs in the country. How many times has Ms O'Connor or the RSA met with it as stakeholders?

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

I participate in road haulage meetings when the topics relate to my directorate. I believe my colleague was due to meet with it approximately ten days ago-----

Comment on this

No, how many times have you met with the Irish Road Haulage Association for engagement on your advertisements, programmes, marketing, etc.?

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

I have not specifically met with it.

Comment on this

You have never met with it. It is the only representative organisation in the country and you have never met with it to engage on how operators of articulated vehicles and HGVs operate on our roads here in Ireland. Did Ms O'Connor not say that she is putting the campaigns together?

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

That is correct, in terms of drivers who drive for work. We have not been in a position to create a new-----

Comment on this

This is not a matter of driving for work. This is road safety.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

Absolutely, but it specifically pertains to people who are driving for work. We are planning a new campaign this year which will take place on the radio and we would like to engage. I think there are further plans for next year which will specifically be for those who drive for work.

Comment on this

How long has Ms O'Connor been in the role?

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

Eighteen months.

Comment on this

How many times has Mr. Waide met the Irish Road Haulage Association?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I met it in the first year of my role. It was an engagement regarding the development of the Government's road safety strategy.

Comment on this

Who was the president at the time?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Eugene.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I subsequently met the association. My colleague, Mr. Walsh, met its representatives about a year ago, I think. It is important-----

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Will the Deputy allow me to answer the question?

Comment on this

How long has Mr. Waide been in the role? I ask the questions.

Comment on this