We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Financial Statements 2022: Road Safety Authority

Contributions 249–502 of 757. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Mr. Sam Waide

May I answer the question?

Comment on this

The question I asked is how many times-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Hold on a second. Will Mr. Waide answer briefly? I have to allow the witnesses to answer.

Comment on this

I asked the question-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Will Mr. Waide answer briefly? Deputy Murphy asked the question.

Comment on this

How many times-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will Chair the debate. Mr. Waide to answer, please.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I also met members of the IRHA for different reasons. I met them about technology in commercial vehicles in a positive way. I met them on a number of occasions, for example, members who provide the CVRT service. Most recently, I attended a company that is opening a new test centre. I-----

Comment on this

They are not stakeholders. That is a commercial activity. Somebody opening a CVRT centre is not a representative of the IRHA.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

They are stakeholders in road safety. That is why I met them.

Comment on this

I asked about the IRHA, which is a stakeholder.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I answered that question, I believe.

Comment on this

I asked Mr. Waide how many times he met-----

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

At least twice.

Comment on this

How long has Mr. Waide been in the role?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Three-and-a-half years.

Comment on this

His predecessor had quarterly meetings - four a year.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

We do. As an organisation, we-----

Comment on this

No. The CEO, Mr. Waide's predecessor.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

As an organisation, we meet the IRHA quarterly.

Comment on this

There is only one representative organisation. It is important.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

It is important to confirm on the public record that the RSA meets the IRHA quarterly, at a minimum. There is ongoing engagement outside of those quarterly meetings.

Comment on this

I should hope so. I will be back in, Chair.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for joining us today for an important conversation. Will Mr. Waide outline again what percentage of the income accruing to the RSA arises from driver licensing, vehicle testing and vehicle certification? I know he did in his earlier submission.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Of the 98% revenue, the large majority comes from key services such as NCT, driver licensing and CVRT. Three figures jump out in that split. Ms Colhoun may wish to comment.

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

Is the Deputy looking for the percentages?

Comment on this

Mr. Waide said 98%.

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

I think Mr. Waide was referring to €95 million in 2022, 36% of which related to driver licensing. It was an exceptionally high year for driver licensing because of the roll-over of licences over the Covid period. Some 27% related to NCT, 17% to the CVRT testing levy and 18% to driver testing. That left 2% for the rest of our miscellaneous income.

Comment on this

Does that 2% funding from the State?

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

No. Our funding from the State is less than 1% of our overall total revenue.

Comment on this

On that basis, the vast majority of the RSA's income accrues from the activities mentioned. People lose their lives on our roads and are injured to a serious extent which impacts them for the rest of their lives. Does Mr. Waide not see a conflict of interest? Is it not the case that the more drivers and cars on our roads, the more income accrues to the very authority responsible for maintaining safety on our roads? Is that not a crucial conflict of interest?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

On the question of conflict of interest, one of the RSA's statutory obligations is to provide assurance that vehicles on the road are roadworthy. Hence, we provide the NCT service through a third party and CVRT testing of commercial vehicles. It is not a conflict; it is a demand. Whatever the number of vehicles, we need, for the purposes and benefits of road safety, to make sure those vehicles are safe. We deliver that service. If that demand halved next year or the following year, our costs would reduce exponentially because of the level of activity.

Comment on this

What is at the heart of the work of the RSA? What is the remit of the Road Safety Authority?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

There are three areas. The first is research and information-----

Comment on this

What is the point of the research?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I ask the Deputy to let me answer his question - what is the purpose of the RSA. The purpose----

Comment on this

Why does the RSA exist?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

To provide a statutory obligation to provide research to inform policy in transport, particularly roads. Second, to make sure-----

Comment on this

Does the RSA exist to keep our roads safe?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I ask the Deputy to let me answer the question. Second is to ensure that vehicles comply with vehicle and safety standards. Third is to administer the driver education system. Those are the three basic, fundamental purposes of the RSA.

Comment on this

What is the purpose of those three fundamentals? What is the ultimate aim of the RSA?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Those are three aspects.

Comment on this

What is the point of those three aspects? Why did Mr. Waide outline them in particular?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

To enhance road safety.

Comment on this

To make our roads safer.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

To enhance road safety.

Comment on this

That is fair enough; that is fine. What is the greatest cause of the undermining of road safety in Ireland and across the world? Why are our roads unsafe?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I stated earlier that there is unprecedented deterioration of behaviours on our roads. There is-----

Comment on this

On whose part?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

There is an increase in vehicles and an increase in risk. If the number of vehicles increases, that is outside of my control. It is my job and the job of my organisation to make sure those vehicles are safe.

Comment on this

Mr. Waide does not see the RSA as having any role in working towards a reduction in the number of cars on our roads.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

We can and should have a bigger role. The RSA-----

Comment on this

Bearing in mind, they are the very thing that makes our roads unsafe.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

A review is being conducted of the RSA currently. I look forward to its recommendations. A Deputy made a point earlier about what the RSA should do. I advocate the RSA having a role in road safety which may differ from what it is currently. I cannot pre-empt an independent review of the RSA.

Comment on this

That is my problem. It is not the fault of Mr. Waide nor any of his colleagues who work with him. The very raison d'être of the Road Safety Authority is being called into question. Its sole function should be to make our roads safer. Yet, when Mr. Waide is questioned in this committee and on RTÉ, he lists out all of its other responsibilities, which are onerous. When he was asked by Miriam O'Callaghan on 11 April if the RSA was fit for purpose, his answer was that it was fit for purpose in delivering services - the NCT and driver testing services. That is the real problem. Anybody can deliver those services. The Department of Transport could deliver them or outsource their delivery. The sole focus of Mr. Waide and his colleagues should be to keep our roads safe to ensure there is not day after day of tragic news of people losing their lives and getting life-changing injuries. Unfortunately, its focus is in a plethora of different directions, trying to ensure they juggle these balls every day. The people here from the Department of Transport and all of us as Oireachtas representatives need to question the raison d'être of the RSA and how we can divest it of those other responsibilities.

Then the authority can focus on what should be its key ambition, namely, that when we get up in the morning and open the newspaper we are not seeing those tragic stories day after day and week after week.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I could not agree more with the Deputy that getting up in the morning-----

Comment on this

Is Mr. Waide saying he wants to see the RSA divested of all its other responsibilities?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I cannot pre-empt an independent review. I can only speak for myself. I live and breathe road safety, but I cannot-----

Comment on this

I am not questioning that.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

-----make other agencies do things that are outside my statutory remit.

Comment on this

That leads me to the next question. I agree with Mr. Waide that he cannot do that. He does not have the legislative power or resources. The review is under way, but I have been arguing for the last year or so that we really need to explore the establishment of a road safety commissioner. The authority's chairperson, Liz O'Donnell, was asked by Claire Byrne on 14 March whether there would be merit in looking at the establishment of a road safety commissioner. Her response was "there is some merit in it" and that "it would be better if we had more powers to bring all those actors [in the road safety space] onto the one page". She said she "would like to see a more all-of-government approach, real commitment if we are going to reverse this trend". Would Mr. Waide like to see the establishment of a road safety commissioner with the legislative power and resources to really begin the work of making Ireland's roads safer?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I have worked with other EU member states and there are different models. The review of RSA includes, I believe, looking at those different models. I am here for road safety. I am here for the people-----

Comment on this

Does Mr. Waide have an opinion on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

-----who I have met, the victims and their frustration at all the many different moving parts. There are a lot of different moving parts. I am not going to pre-empt. Do I have a view on an independent commissioner? Whatever the model is, we need to fund road safety in this country adequately. Whatever the model, whatever the entity or organisation and whatever the remit, it needs to be funded adequately from an education, enforcement, campaigns and communications point of view. That is my opinion.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will ask a question before we take a break. Obviously, the commissioner decision will be a policy issue. What is the timeline for the conclusion of the review of the RSA?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

The Cathaoirleach might let the Department answer that question.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

I will very briefly give the background to this. As members probably know, the Department and the RSA agreed late last year to conduct a review of the RSA. We felt it was timely. The RSA is up and running nearly 20 years now and has had additional functions added to its remit in that time. We were also planning a new RSA amendment Bill to make certain changes to legislation and we thought a review would be useful to feed into that. The review is under way. There are five-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Yes, but when will it conclude? I am interested in solutions, Dr. Walsh.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

We have received some very preliminary findings from Indecon, which is doing the review, in the last few days and we are considering those. Our Minister of State up to yesterday, the Minister, Deputy Chambers, gave a commitment to bring the preliminary findings to Government before the summer recess, so that is what we are going to do. The final report will be completed and presented probably in July or August. We will then go to Government with a memorandum for decision in the autumn.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

There will be an Aire nua, a new Minister.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

A new Minister may have new views, of course. Yes.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Dr. Walsh. We will take a ten-minute break.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

In his opening statement Mr. Waide said the RSA is calling out and raising awareness of concerning evidence of non-compliance by road users and the need for enhanced enforcement by An Garda Síochána. Is there an issue with enforcement? Is there frustration in the RSA that the Garda is not doing as much as it should be doing on road safety? The Garda Commissioner recently issued a directive that all gardaí do half an hour of road duty per shift. What is happening there? I ask Mr. Waide to outline it briefly.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

The enhanced enforcement goes back to the trends not only of collisions, serious injuries and fatalities but also the trends of increased population in the country and the increased number of vehicles. This requires enhanced enforcement, as it requires enhanced education.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

My question is whether there is frustration or concern within the RSA that more could be done by An Garda Síochána in terms of enforcement. It is a "Yes" or "No".

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

There is frustration in regard to the pace of enforcement. Enforcement is not only about Garda officers. It is about the increased use of technology. The RSA works on enforcement with An Garda Síochána on the roadside with commercial vehicles. Our frustration is that we need more technology. We need more safety cameras. I welcome the Cathaoirleach's point about the 30-minute rule the Commissioner announced. I welcome it because it has helped.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It has helped.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Absolutely. It will take time to see different outcomes with regard to road safety. I believe professionally, and I have confidence that-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I am on the road a good bit and I regularly see gardaí.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

The increased number of cameras will have a positive effect on behaviour on the roads.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

There is increased visibility of gardaí. I can see it since gardaí have begun to do the half-hour of road safety work during their shift.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

My ask to An Garda Síochána is that the increased enforcement is sustained, not only for the rest of this year but over the next three years for the road safety strategy.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The number of people on the roads checking Facebook to see where Mary or Johnny were last night, the number texting while driving and the number doing all sorts of things such as shaving or doing their hair while driving, particularly in the mornings, is absolutely incredible. What I see is shocking. That is apart from crazy driving with people changing over three lanes without indicating or swerving in and out between cars. The reason I highlight this is that I appreciate the Garda has stepped up what it is doing, and that is welcome, but the emphasis on road safety policing must be stepped up a gear. That is crucial. Mobile phone use while driving is massive, as is doing other things while driving. I want to highlight that.

On speed limits, we have a default position of 80 km/h when we go off the national network. That is absolutely ludicrous. People learning to drive are always told to drive according to the road conditions. This means not driving at 80 km/h on a boreen. Common sense kicks in. I want to cut to my question on speed limits. Is setting speed limits a job for county councillors? That is a "Yes" or "No". Is it a job for the elected members of the local authority?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Yes.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Okay.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Local councils, with the Department of Transport.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Councillors feel they come in over their heads completely. Does this include national roads such as the N80 or regional routes?

On those national roads, it is not the councillors who decide. Who is it?

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

It might be useful for my colleague, Mr. Campbell, to go through it.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I am looking for a brief response.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

There was a detailed speed limits review, which we are in the middle of implementing.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I would like this point clarified because the speed limit review is coming up.

Comment on this
Mr. Tomás Campbell

On the national roads, Transport Infrastructure Ireland sets the limit.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Those are the 120 km/h and 100 km/h limits on motorways.

Comment on this
Mr. Tomás Campbell

Yes.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Can the limit on some sections of the likes of the N80 be reduced to 80 km/h? The limit is 100 km/h the whole way along.

Comment on this
Mr. Tomás Campbell

The limit can be changed through by-laws.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Who can make the change?

Comment on this
Mr. Tomás Campbell

For a national road, Transport Infrastructure Ireland would set the by-laws. The defaults are set in the national-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

For the regional roads that run through all our counties, who sets the limits?

Comment on this
Mr. Tomás Campbell

For the regional roads, it is the local authorities.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The elected members of the chamber would take advice from a roads engineer and the Garda.

Comment on this
Mr. Tomás Campbell

Yes.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

They are then free to set the limit as they see fit.

Comment on this
Mr. Tomás Campbell

They are free within parameters. In the Road Traffic Act 2004, there is a range of allowable limits. Under the Road Traffic Act 2024, the default limit on local roads, for example, is reduced to 60 km/h. That will be commenced in November. Local authorities have the ability to set by-laws that could impose limits of 30 km/h, 50 km/h or 80 km/h.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Certain sections of certain roads would need different limits. That is the point I am making. When will the speed limit reviews come before local authorities? When do the witnesses expect it to happen? It is important that this work is done.

Comment on this
Mr. Tomás Campbell

The Local Government Management Agency is co-ordinating the work of all local authorities to do their individual speed limit reviews across the summer months and to bring proposals around by-laws to the elected members before November. That is the target.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Has the Department spoken to the Association of Irish Local Government, AILG?

Comment on this
Mr. Tomás Campbell

Not that I am aware of.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Will Mr. Campbell check that out and come back to the committee?

Comment on this
Mr. Tomás Campbell

I will.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

If the Department has not done so, why not? New councillors have been elected to important positions to make important decisions. It is important to contact the representative body. Managers are appointed for seven years. They come and go. The members who are elected by the public comprise the legal local authority. It is important that the AILG is contacted on this matter and asked for its input. I ask the witnesses to convey that point to their superiors. I cannot for the life of me figure it out. This issue is not unique to the Department of Transport but also applies to the Department of housing and all other Departments. It seems that the last people who are spoken to, contacted or made aware of anything are the elected councillors and their representative body, the AILG. I ask that the cathaoirleach of each council is informed that this change is coming up. It will be an important job for local authorities and we need councillors to be aware so they can identify roads in their areas where there are accident black spots or problems with speeding. They can liaise with the local gardaí and other bodies as they need to. They can also liaise with the local area engineer. The key people will be the area engineers and local councillors. I want to know. I thank Mr. Campbell.

I will move to driving tests. Why is there a six-month waiting list in Portlaoise? That was the figure in the most recent reply I received to a parliamentary question I asked about driving test waiting times. Why is that happening?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

The Cathaoirleach asked about a specific centre in Portlaoise. I will be able to give him the exact number for Portlaoise in a moment.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That reply came a few months ago.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

I have it here and will look for it as we are speaking.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Tell me.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

I will find out the relevant figure. The national average has dropped from 30 weeks a couple of months ago to 15 weeks. I will furnish the specifics in respect of Portlaoise to the Chair.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Does Mr. Walsh have the timeline there?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

The Cathaoirleach is looking for the timeline for Portlaoise.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I am. Does Mr. Walsh have it handy? Perhaps he could share it before the end of the meeting.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

I will search for it and call out the relevant figure during the meeting.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

How is the allocation of driving test slots prioritised? A number of people have contacted us to say they depend on their cars for work because they live 15 miles from their jobs and there is no public transport. There might be a Local Link bus that comes at 11 a.m. or 12 noon, which is fine and serves another cohort of people - mainly elderly people who are going shopping. People are depending on their cars for work. In rural towns, they might be driving to the county town, for example, Naas, or Kilkenny, Tullamore or wherever else. If a person who requires a licence for work can show that he or she lives a distance from work, does that give him or her any priority?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

No.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It does not.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

It does not. I will answer the question on Portlaoise. The wait is currently 17 weeks, which is approximately three and a half months.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That is a big jump.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

It is, but we need to do better.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will keep raising the issue.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

Please do. The Cathaoirleach can continue to do so. We operate a transparent way of booking because hundreds of thousands of people need to go through a test on an annual basis. The fairest and most equitable way is to allow these individuals to go through a website and then wait for their invites. We have special conditions for front-line workers. They can fill in a form and we will try to prioritise them. I spoke earlier about the efficiencies we have introduced and they are always available to the members of the public. If, for example, my team gets 100 cancellations this week for whatever reason, those slots are immediately put into the system. I always say to people who are looking for a test to check the system daily because slots are added daily on the basis of cancellations.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Mr. Walsh mentioned a forum if someone needs a licence for working reasons.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

That is for front-line workers, including gardaí and ambulance drivers.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That is obviously a huge issue of concern. What is the RSA doing to reduce waiting times? Mr. Walsh has referred to no-shows, cancellations and vacant slots. That is one of the things the RSA is doing. What else is it doing to reduce waiting times?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

As I mentioned, use of our slot levels is currently at 98%, which is a very high level and is up from where it was several years ago, which was a percentage in the mid-90s. We also have additional driving testers. There is also now a facility whereby customers can select a test centre. They can pick a test centre with a shorter waiting time if they so desire. That is what we are doing. To be honest, the way to deal with this is to employ more testers and we are working with our colleagues in the Department to do that.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Mr. Walsh mentioned that there are 130 staff.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

There are 131 permanent staff.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

How many agency staff or staff on short-term contracts are there?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

They are not agency staff.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Are there contractors?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

They are employed as temporary staff. At the moment, there are approximately 34 or 35 such staff.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will turn to the representatives of the Department for a moment. What is the difficulty in getting sanction for more testers? There is a ridiculous situation in respect of experienced testers who finish their terms. What is the length of contracts that staff get? Are they one-year or five-year contracts?

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

I think they are for two years.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

They are for two years.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Staff come in for two years. Perhaps these are people who worked in a school of motoring.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

Perhaps I may explain how we got to the current situation. In March 2023, we were coming out of the Covid-19 pandemic and there was quite a backlog in a number of the services, including driver testing. At that time, the RSA submitted a request to the Department looking for sanction to hire additional driver testers on temporary contracts. A number of options were presented in the RSA business case for 40, 60 or 75 additional testers. The Department considered the matter and agreed to sanction 75 additional tester posts. In conjunction with the 130 permanent testers, the RSA sanction is for 205 driver testers. That sanction is still in place. One of the conditions of the sanction was that we would work with the authority to work out the long-term need for the service.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The population is increasing.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

That is exactly the case.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Why is the Department not giving sanction for more permanent testers? I do not get the logic.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

We gave sanction last year for up to 75 additional testers.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Those were temporary posts.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

We were asked for sanction for temporary posts. Asking for temporary testers last year was the right decision. There was a backlog in March last year but the idea was that if we got the testers in, we would be able to reduce the backlog. However, what has happened over the past year is that the demands on the service have continued to increase much faster than was projected.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

How many applicants are awaiting a test at the moment?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

As of this morning, there are 80,000 people waiting for an invite.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

There are 80,000 people waiting and the officials have it in their hands to sanction permanent ones. I do not get it. Many who were on contract were let go, including in the midlands.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

From the Department's perspective, the authority has sanction to employ 205 testers right now, and that continues be the case. We have been working with the authority in the last few months to establish what is the long-term need for permanent testers. That analysis has been presented in the last few days and the Department is going to go through it.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

How many are needed?

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

We have not assessed the business case. That is what we need to look at. We need to assess that business case.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Roughly, how many? Is it 200 or 300?

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

I would imagine it is probably around the 200 mark.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Will Mr. Walsh put a figure on the number of testers needed?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

We provided a sliding scale based on population and based on what we would see into the future. We would certainly see a starting base of around 200 to be required.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That is 200 permanent testers.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

Yes, 200 permanent testers.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Thank you. We will go to a second round of questions. I call Deputy Murphy.

Comment on this

I want to focus on disqualified drivers. Something like 1,800 learners were disqualified in 2023 and only 3% of them surrendered their permit to the Road Safety Authority. From a parliamentary question reply, I discovered that only one driver out of the 10,000 who were disqualified in court in 2022 and 2023 was then convicted of not surrendering their licence. In the UK, for example, a driver does not leave the court without leaving their licence if they are disqualified. What recommendations is the Road Safety Authority making in that regard? Is this with the Department or is there an engagement between both bodies? Essentially, the whole idea of a disqualification is as much to make the roads safer as it is to punish the person who was disqualified.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I agree. This is an area that needs to be addressed. I know this has been flagged on a number of occasions, including by victims groups. I will pass over to the Department because there is an action in hand with the Department and An Garda Síochána.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

I agree it is unacceptable that people are not surrendering their licence and that is an offence. However, we need to be careful about the importance we attach to that. The real issue is whether people who are disqualified from driving are continuing to drive. If I am disqualified from driving, I know I am disqualified from driving and I know I should not be on the road, regardless of whether I have surrendered my licence or not. Even more importantly, the disqualification information comes into the Department and we share that with gardaí, so gardaí know if someone is on the road with a disqualified licence and they are able to-----

Comment on this

We then come back to the level of enforcement and the data that the Road Safety Authority collects, for example, if somebody is detected as having been driving while disqualified. Data is going to be important. In the case of fatal accidents where people were driving unaccompanied with a learner permit in the last five years, does the Road Safety Authority separate out that information so it can look at it very distinctly? Is the information published with regard to the number of people injured, the circumstances of the accident and all of that kind of stuff?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I will ask Mr. Rowland to outline the information we have.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

In 2023, 15 learner drivers were involved in fatal collisions. In these fatal collisions, a total of 15 people died, which includes six of the 15 learner drivers, and the nine other road users were four pedestrians, three passengers, one motorcyclist and one pedal cyclist. Five other road users were also seriously injured in these fatal collisions.

Comment on this

Thank you for that information. Information is going to be very important, in particular, how the Road Safety Authority is going to apply that information to reduce the number of fatalities.

To move to a different subject, what was the totality of fines for non-adherence to the NCT timelines applied to the company that was outsourced to do that job in the last couple of years?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

There are no fines or penalties. There are service credits, and that is how we refer to them from a contractual perspective.

Comment on this

“Service credits” sounds very positive.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

It does. It is a legal term because we are not allowed to apply penalties within a contract.

Comment on this

Is that how the contract is structured?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

It is the wording the contract was put together with. We were advised that the word “penalties” is not something that can be used. Service credits have the same, let us say, punitive effect. In the case of Applus+, which is the service provider, until the end of quarter 1 of 2023, for non-performance post the Covid era, we have leveraged €3.8 million in service credits against it.

Comment on this

I will move to another topic. In terms of defining the safety of roads, is it solely based on the absence of accidents and fatalities or does the Road Safety Authority look at it from the point of view that they may be used by, for example, children and vulnerable road users? What is the metric used? How does the Road Safety Authority determine that?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Fatalities, collisions and serious injuries are outcomes and those metrics are extremely important. As I said earlier, every loss of life is heartbreaking for the family involved. There are metrics for roads. I am not a road engineer. There are metrics as part of the road safety strategy and Mr. Rowland can answer with regard to the European position and the statistical performance indicators, SPIs.

Comment on this

I do know a little bit about this. I know about road design, the speed for each road and all the rest of it, and I know we have a lot of very old, small rural roads. I would ask the Road Safety Authority to add something on the speed limits. A few years ago, the national lower speed limit was set at 80 km/h to achieve consistency and the local authorities rushed out and bought a load of 80 km/h road signs. The councillors are supposed to have discretion over this but, in fact, they will be told they do not have the expertise to have discretion. As the Chair said, it is getting to the point that they are told they do not have the expertise and that the road engineer is the one who will determine it. Yet, they know their area and its roads very well. They will know where there is a sports centre or a lot of people arriving on foot, and know that an 80 km/h speed limit is inappropriate in that kind of location. They may also have a knowledge of accidents, near misses and so on. However, they do not really have discretion and they end up having rows over a road not being safe. To have this idea of consistency as opposed to actually measuring things, such as the type of user in a particular area, is to look at it from the point of view of a driver as opposed to the point of view of cyclists, pedestrians and so on. I am not convinced that has been properly evaluated.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I will pass over to my colleague shortly. This is an important point for elected members, particularly newly elected members in local communities. One of the Deputies earlier flagged the increase in the number of pedestrian fatalities. I often walk along roads that do not have a footpath. The Road Safety Authority continues to provide research as to what is the impact. Some 29% of pedestrians struck by a vehicle travelling at 50 km/h will be killed. However, if the speed is reduced to 30 km/h, some 5% of pedestrians who are struck will be killed. We have provided and continue to provide the research to councils.

That is our role. The Department mentioned the speed review. We provide that research. That may not necessarily answer the Deputy's question on what level of monitoring is in place if a new speed limit is implemented.

Comment on this

A national speed limit was set and local authorities were supposed to comply with parameters and different types of roads. The speed limit of 80 km/h was routinely used. For example, where locations had a lower speed limit, that was to be increased to 80 km/h. I am not sure that it is-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I think the point is that there has to be realism this time and speed limits have to be appropriate at a local level. Councillors must be involved. They will take expert advice, whether that is from An Garda Síochána or a local area engineer, but the council chamber must have that discretion. When the RSA contacts the AILG this issue needs to be emphasised, so that it can make its membership aware of it. The AILG will determine what it needs in terms of running seminars and different events. It would be very important for the elected members if that happened.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

I think there are training plans as part of the speed limit implementation working group.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Yes, but as Deputy Murphy said, many councillors will be told that speed limits are to be increased by this amount. It is important that councillors are made aware that this is their job.

Comment on this

On that topic, I would be less worried about councillors varying the speed limit down and more worried about them varying it up. I suspect that will be the more problematic issue.

The basic metric in front of us is fatalities on the roads. That is a very important metric and one that we want to drive down. We have seen the number of fatalities decrease from 365 in 2006 to 181 last year, so there have been some losses and gains. What about collisions? I do not have a sense of the number of collisions on the roads. Is the reduction in fatalities due to a reduction in the number of collisions or an improvement in care safety over time? Has there been a reduction in collisions commensurate with the reduction in the number of fatalities or does better car safety mask a lack of progress?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

I think it is both. There has been a reduction. In the better years, such as 2018 and 2021, when we had a reduction in the number of deaths on our roads, there was a reduction in the number of collisions. However, I believe the survivors, the people who have been seriously injured, are probably protected by the advances that have been made in vehicle safety.

Comment on this

I ask Mr. Rowland to furnish the committee with some details.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

I will, yes.

Comment on this

The RSA's briefing note is very good and detailed but I could not see that information anywhere.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

I will get back to the Deputy in relation to the number of collisions.

Comment on this

I want to talk about how accidents are reported. For example, if a middle-aged cyclist is knocked down on a road the report will state what the cyclist was doing, and the age and gender of the cyclist. The report would not tell me that the car was making a right-hand turn manoeuvre, passing through a bike lane or passing through a gap of stationary cars. It would not tell me anything about the bumper height of the car. In these reports we learn a lot about the victim and less about the other aspects involved, particularly in the asymmetric situation where it is a collision with a vulnerable road user.

The child casualty report by the RSA, published in October 2023, gives me a report on the gender, age and movement of the child but does not tell me other details such as the engine size of the car, the type of car or the driver's manoeuvre. The real problem with that is that we learn a lot about the victim and far less about the driver's manoeuvre, type of car, height of the bumper, engine size, etc. Are there plans to change the method of reporting?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

The Deputy has asked a very relevant question. All of the data fields collected by members of An Garda Síochána at the collision scene are being extensively reviewed as part of the data group.

Comment on this

Will the RSA have a proactive input?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Yes.

Comment on this

Has the RSA asked for more information on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

The RSA chairs the multi-agency and multi-Department group. I will hand over to my colleague, Ms Kelly, who can provide insight into all of those variables of which there is a high number. We can provide it.

Comment on this

I have an eye on the clock so I ask Ms Kelly to concentrate on the metrics the RSA is trying to include on, say, the driver's side in respect of an asymmetric collision involving a vulnerable road user.

Comment on this
Ms Nessa Kelly

As Mr. Waide said, we have been working with the Garda to review the 161 data fields that are part of the road traffic collision data set. From that, there is lots of information where a vehicle was involved, in terms of what the vehicle was doing at the time. We receive those fields. We have agreed, through the review, from a data protection perspective what fields we can still receive. Those critical fields continue to be received by the Road Safety Authority. They then feed into our research teams. I ask Mr. Rowland to comment as it is his team that completes the analysis used to inform the research and outcome.

Comment on this

Perhaps the RSA can furnish us with a note. I do not mean to be rude but I only have one minute and 40 seconds to raise a couple of other issues. I am very interested in finding out what data fields are reported, what are the GDPR issues and how we can anonymise that information to better understand, particularly with an asymmetric collision, the movements of the person driving the two tonnes of steel.

Comment on this
Ms Nessa Kelly

Yes, Deputy.

Comment on this

I want to return to the sharing of collision data. The issue arose in 2020. Did Mr. Walsh say a ministerial order was signed last week?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

Yes.

Comment on this

It is amazing the things that happen the week before a meeting of the Committee of Public Accounts.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

There was a long process involved.

Comment on this

I am sure there was. The coincidence always astounds me. The interim period lasted four years. When did the RSA bring this issue to the attention of the Department?

In respect of the legal process, we are talking about ministerial orders but there is a need for legislation. We have had several Bills brought through the Department of Transport, including a miscellaneous provisions Bill. This sounds exactly like a miscellaneous provision. At what stage did the RSA engage with the Department to discuss this issue? I ask because it feels like things started to move very quickly after the airing of a "Prime Time Investigates" programme.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

On the collision data, the RSA first raised this matter with other agencies around the table in 2020. Again, I will pass over to Ms Kelly to confirm the key steps from then until now. It has been a complex and lengthy process and it has been frustrating in terms of the length of time it has taken.

Comment on this
Ms Nessa Kelly

This has been a top priority for the RSA since we identified the issues around data protection with the collision data set. Once the matter came to light, we engaged straightaway with our legal advisers and the Department to identify our route to regularise and put the legal basis in place to be able to receive the data, first and foremost, because we receive it from the Garda, and then to be able to share it onwards with organisations like the local authorities, the NTA, etc. In 2020, we immediately set about that activity of identifying our route forward. We did not just say we need to hold back and wait until we see how we put the legal requirement in place. We also engaged with the Department's roads management support office and our colleagues in the local authorities to say this is critical data that they need to receive in order to be able to make evidence-based decisions on investment in road safety. We actually agreed eight critical data fields from within the data set that we would continue to share with the Department and local authorities, through the LGMA, in the intervening period while we put the legal basis in place. From 2020, to establish that basis, we engaged with the Garda and all stakeholders. We completed a thorough review of each of those 161 data fields. We looked at the proportionality of the data being shared because some of it was special category and personal data, and we then looked to see what legal basis we could establish. We engaged with-----

Comment on this

With the indulgence of the Chair, I would like to ask a final question. Members would be interested in seeing a timeline for the interactions around moving from establishing the problem to resolving it.

In respect of serious collision data, we had relied on the Garda Síochána and now, because of recommendations made by the European Commission, we are starting to take the serious injury data from hospitals, which I assume leads to a greater number of serious casualties being reported. How has that move impacted the €1.3 billion figure that was given for, I think, 2022? Have we underestimated the cost of serious collisions because of the change in methodology?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

We have two data sets on injuries. We are aware that serious injury reporting is understated, especially when we look at the Garda data. There are very good reasons for that. With the approval of the Department, we engaged with the Department of Health, the HSE and Trinity College Dublin to look at hospital inpatient inquiry data, which contemplates serious injuries in particular and medical diagnoses of serious injuries, in order that we could report on that. This tells us that many more serious injuries are happening than are actually reported using Garda-----

Comment on this

Will Mr. Rowland put a percentage figure on that in terms of the difference in reporting using An Garda Síochána's figures and hospital figures? Are we talking about 20% or 50%?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

Approaching twice as many serious injuries are occurring.

Comment on this

So the figure of €1.39 billion could be a serious underestimate.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

Yes, I would imagine it is because the serious injuries are based on Garda data. It is only in recent times that we have been able to get access to-----

Comment on this

It could as much as twice as many.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

Yes, it could be a lot more.

Comment on this

We are here to discuss the figures and the budget and to focus on the bang for our buck. It strikes me that we drive the roads every day, and none of us is a saint. The figures are going the wrong way. Given what we are seeing on the roads, it is amazing that the figures are not a great deal worse. The figures do not capture how serious this is. We are in a really difficult situation in light of the volume of traffic on our roads. Every day of the week, we all witness incidents that could have resulted in crashes. We still call most situations accidents but in my view, most of them are incidents because things are done wrong. They are not necessarily accidents. They are incidents where someone has done something wrong in most cases. The terms "incidents" might capture it better.

On the research and the data, certainly when there are crashes on some of our main roads, and where there was an option to take a different road, for example, a toll road, is there any analysis done as to why the vehicles were on that road at that moment? There are many crashes on the main national routes, be it someone coming up behind, someone not overtaking properly or when someone is turning left or right. The whole idea of building motorways was to make roads safer and have fewer left turns, right turns and so on. Do we analyse why a vehicle was on a particular road in some cases? This might lead us to believe that maybe we should look at our toll roads. I do not need an answer now, but it is something that would be worthwhile to understand to really get behind some of these accidents.

Mr. Walsh mentioned the ideal figure of 200 testers. I presume he is assuming that it is somewhere in the region of 170 to 190 permanent roles, plus some on contract as well. The numbers will go up and down a little but it is best to be in a situation where we can respond to demand. I do not want the witness to answer now as my time will be cut but perhaps he could keep it in mind.

On the dental appointment system, I always cancel my dentist appointment when the year comes up, so I am sure it would be the same with the NCT. I want to go back to the link between tax and insurance. As I understand it, if a person does not have the certificate of roadworthiness and is in an accident the insurance company might not insure and may claim that the person is not insured. Is that true or is it false? If that is the case it is an issue for all insured drivers on the road and for people who think they are insured but are not insured. With the motor tax system, surely to God it is an easier way to link it to tax and insurance in order to make us do it. We are all in danger of putting it off and I am sure I am as guilty as everybody else of putting off appointments when they come. If the witnesses have the magic formula perhaps they could enlighten me more on what they are thinking with an appointment system. I am interested in getting more information on it. It sounds as if we are working to a system but I would like to hear the thinking on that.

With regard to the advocacy role of the Road Safety Authority and its advice to the Government and everybody else, who is in charge of the drive to use technology better? Mr. Waide mentioned this at the start. I got a sense that he is disappointed that technology is not used to its capabilities in managing our roads and our cars. Who can drive that? I sense that Ireland as a country is a good test bed for technology in many cases. Are we missing out on opportunities that other countries are already using when it comes to making our cars safer? Is there more we could do legislatively?

With regard to buses, Dr. Walsh said that driver age is a decision for Bus Éireann. I did not know we had a national office for traffic medicine. This is news to me. Maybe we need to bring that person to the committee too. Is there any chance we could get a solution in respect of this matter before the new school year in September? Can somebody make a decision, because if it is the wrong decision to stop people-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

There were four questions there. Will Deputy English ask Dr. Walsh to respond to the first and the last question on the school bus issue? Let us put this to bed.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

I will try as best I can. As I said earlier, there is a policy and there is legislation around the requirements for medical certificates. It is this policy and legislation that the RSA implements. Colleagues who know this better than I have talked earlier about what happens at the age of 75 and onwards. It is my firm understanding that it is Bus Éireann's policy to apply the cut-off of 70 years of age. I do not know but I assume it has very good reasons for that and it is doing that based on-----

Comment on this

Should it not be on the advice of the RSA? Who is advising whom? That is all I need to know.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

The RSA implements whatever the legislation is. The RSA and the national office for traffic medicine would inform putting in place the legal requirements.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Will Dr. Walsh clarify if the traffic medicine office's Professor O'Neill, gives the advice? I do not want to personalise it for anybody but is it the case that the professor gives the advice on what we are all fit for at the age of 75?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

The national office for traffic medicine is Professor-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Where is that? What is that for?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

The national office for traffic medicine resides within the RSA-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Is it part of the RSA?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

It is funded by the RSA. The national-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Is the person who gives the advice an RSA employee?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

It is an arrangement. It is a tendered contract-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It is a contract.

Comment on this

So it is RSA advice. Let us be clear.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

It is RSA advice based on medical advice.

Comment on this

Mr. Rowland gave the impression that it was not the RSA. The RSA's advice is that someone over the age of 70 should not drive a bus.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

The clinical advice provided by Professor O'Neill was that over 70s are at a greater risk-----

Comment on this

I know that. I am not a medical person. I am not saying Professor O'Neill is right or wrong. I want to know who is making the decision. Where does the buck land? Is it the RSA and not the national office for traffic medicine?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

The decision to not employ drivers over 70 rests with Bus Éireann. That is the company's policy.

Comment on this

Not on RSA advice.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

We do not instruct Bus Éireann on what to do. It gets and interprets advice. We do not instruct it or tell it.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We will move to the replies to the other questions.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I will address the technology question.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Concisely please.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

An Garda Síochána and the RSA want to use more technology. To answer the question on who makes the decision and who is taking the lead, I have consistently advocated for the use of more technology for road safety. An Garda Síochána would welcome being able to use safety cameras, including in the GoSafe vans at the side of the road, to pick up on people not wearing seat belts, which is killer behaviour, people using mobile phones, which is killer behaviour, and people eating a McDonald's while driving, which is killer behaviour. It is all distraction. That technology is used in other EU member countries. I get frustrated when people say "Why are we not doing this here in Ireland?" I ask everyone here to back and support any legislative or regulatory changes to use that technology.

Comment on this

I note that, I appreciate that and I agree with it but what of in-car technology? Are we missing out on the use of technology in the vehicles?

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Could a meter reading be taken, for example?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I will answer this question. It is a very important question and I want to answer it. The committee is made up of elected Members. This is the Committee of Public Accounts. Its members are elected representatives, and I am looking for support. I cannot do this on my own and the RSA cannot do it on its own.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Does it need legislation?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Geofencing for speed is a game-changer. Sweden is one of the leading countries in western Europe and it is trialling geofencing for speed on buses in Stockholm. Rotterdam is trialling geofencing for speed.

It will play a significant role in making our roads safer for road users, given people do not like getting penalty points. It is automating the speed and it will protect vulnerable road users and active travel people. I ask for support in that area.

Comment on this

Is that geofencing available on all roads?

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Deputy Murphy has six minutes. Was Deputy's question answered fully?

Comment on this

No. That is the question.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

It is being trialled in cities and there is a benefit in cities. It is used for-----

Comment on this

It is for the highly dense traffic areas where it is being trialled. It is not happening on rural roads.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

It is not, but it could be. I welcome and invite elected members. I need to go and see this for myself in Stockholm because whether it is in the Phoenix Park or on a rural road, my understanding is that geofencing comes from space and, I believe, from my limited understanding of it, it could be deployed not just in city centres.

Comment on this

I do not want to hog the meeting. Mr. Waide believes that and I sense he is right. My question was who is responsible for driving that? Is it the RSA, the Department or us? Who or where is the responsibility? Nobody has the answer.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Is it the Department that makes the recommendation to the Minister or is it the RSA? How does this happen? The Deputy is trying to get the answer to that question.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

Part of this is that we would always take advice from the RSA on technical areas where it has the expertise. The Department may need to change legislation but there is also an EU element to a lot of this. For a lot of vehicle standards, the law actually comes from EU directives and regulations. That is why it is particularly interesting to hear about things that are happening in Sweden and other member states. I was in Belgium last week for a conference on self-driving cars and safety developments.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The RSA gives advice and the Department makes recommendations. If legislation is needed, the Department prepares that for the Minister. We are a bit clearer on that now.

Comment on this