We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Financial Statements 2022: Road Safety Authority

Contributions 503–757 of 757. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

There was the question about insurance and tax. I know I am being a bit of a nuisance but this is useful.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

In relation to insurance and tax, as I said, it will happen once we get the service back to normal. We have already started the process of looking at what we can do. I agree with the Deputy but I am not sure of the legislative basis or how we could bring that to the public. We did it with motor tax in the past and it is certainly something we should be revisiting. At the end of the day, we need to ensure that we have proper roadworthy vehicles on our roads. If there are ways to incentivise customers to keep those vehicles maintained and up to a good spec, I believe that would be a significant step towards our vision zero.

Comment on this

The question I asked is this: is your car insured if you do not have a certificate of roadworthiness?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

As of this moment in time, yes, or that is my understanding, but it is up to the individual insurance company. The reality is that if someone is involved in an accident, through an investigation, that accident may not be deemed to be down to the roadworthiness of the vehicle but to the driver's actions within the vehicle. I imagine there are very grey areas in that space.

Comment on this

It is up to the company.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

It is the requirement of a vehicle owner to keep their car in roadworthy condition at all times. The NCT certificate says that it is roadworthy at the point in time that the driver is required to have an NCT.

Comment on this

I am thrilled that Dr. Walsh came up with that. It is the requirement of the car owner to keep it roadworthy. It is not the requirement of the Department of Transport, it seems, to keep the roads car-worthy. I would like Dr. Walsh to take that back to his line Minister. That is what I have been hearing on the doors for the last two months. Why do cars and other vehicles have to be roadworthy but roads do not have to be car-worthy? That is a significant issue for road safety. Does Mr. Waide agree?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I agree. One of the safe systems is safer roads.

Comment on this

One of the aims of this committee concerns under-resourcing. I have had no correspondence from the RSA that tells me it would like more money - not one piece. We have clarified that I have the right correspondence details for you, have we not?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

The 35 emails did not go to my email address.

Comment on this

I did not say they did. I did not give a number. I just said that I had not received a response from you. We have clarified it.

The issue I have here is not just roads infrastructure. Visibility is also a key factor. When it comes to roads and hedging, particularly in rural Ireland, instead of Mr. Waide going to Sweden, I would rather that he comes down to the south of County Wexford, where, it would appear, we have half of the population of Dublin driving on roads that are not white-lined and where the ditches, not the hedges, have grown out by about a metre. That means the driver of the car, with no white line on the road, is a foot away from the ditch and nearly on the other side of the road. This is a primary consideration for road safety but it is not one I have seen Mr. Waide represent, or if he has, I want him to submit his representations to the committee.

I know extensive reports have gone from the IRHA, which I was party to, whereby if a truck loses its mirror, because of the regulation and despite all of the obligations of county councils on hedge cutting, they are not obliged to cut the ditches to the height of the mirror on a truck or a bus. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Deputy Murphy-----

Comment on this

Is it correct? Please, Mr. Waide. I have limited time and this is important. This is to help you.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

The RSA has continually encouraged the cutting of hedges so junctions are safe. We have run campaigns for hedges to be cut.

Comment on this

Has it made a recommendation of a height?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

We have shared consistently with local councils the importance of hedges being cut.

Comment on this

It is an EU regulation.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

We have worked with the Irish Farmers’ Association to ensure that hedges are cut. There are many farmers-----

Comment on this

I do not want to get tetchy. The issue is not just the cutting; it is the height. The problem we have with the NPWS is that there is no recommendation from the RSA that the height is not sufficient. One cut only brings it to the height of a car, two cuts possibly to the height of a tractor but three are needed for it to be over 1 m.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The point being made is that this is not happening, and we are all aware of that. The truck drivers have to keep out because their mirrors are getting broken, and mirrors cost €300 or €400 in some cases.

Comment on this

It is the cost, the time off the road and the fact that whatever journey they undertake without a mirror is one of extreme danger. My point is that I have seen no recommendation from the Road Safety Authority for that to change. I have asked for it but the RSA has always said that is within the remit of the NPWS. I suggest it is within the remit of the RSA to give the NPWS the advice and recommendations.

We have 6,000 km of hedging in fields that the birds can nest in. Birds do not nest on the side of the road, and that is the primary reason that we are not cutting ditches on the roadside.

I have a question for Mr. Rowland. Is it his contention that Professor Desmond O'Neill is stating that those aged over 70 are not medically sound or are less medically sound than other drivers?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

To clarify, my understanding is that what Professor O'Neill said is that over-70s can be at a greater risk due to their age.

Comment on this

I will read what it says on the Government website. It quotes Professor Desmond O'Neill, from the national office for traffic medicine, as stating:

This change [in extending the medical to 75] is welcome in terms of recognising that older drivers are an exceptionally responsible group of drivers. In addition, the change is supported by international research indicating that routine medical screening of older drivers is not only ineffective but may actually unintentionally increase injury and death among older people as pedestrians.

Does that sound like what Mr. Rowland has said?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

What the Deputy is referencing is in regard to category B car drivers.

Comment on this

It is not relevant.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

It is.

Comment on this

We know medicals are provided for professionals, regardless of their age. Does it sound like he is referring to over-70s in any category?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

What he has differentiated is that drivers of cars can-----

Comment on this

Where has he differentiated that? I have not read anywhere that he differentiates it in that way.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

I will see-----

Comment on this

You will submit it.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

If it is there, I will submit it, but I will clarify it with him.

Comment on this

What do you mean you will clarify it with him?

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

My understanding is that what Professor O'Neill has said is that-----

Comment on this

I will finish reading. It states: “The change in the age-limit is supported by a range of supports for older drivers and healthcare professionals in terms of comprehensive guidelines on medical fitness to drive”.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

That is category B drivers and not category C.

Comment on this

That is buses. Category B is cars, tractors and what else? That applies to more than B.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

I clarified this with my friend at the time and checked the website within the NDLS system. It states that a medical report is required if you are driving a commercial vehicle, which are categories C, D and derivatives. We also call out other areas, one of which is if you are over the age of 75, which brings it into the classification of an A and B licence.

Comment on this

There is a lot more than A and B. There are tractors-----

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

Absolutely. There is a W licence.

Comment on this

There are at least six categories. Regardless of being over 70, there is no research that shows over-70s in any category are less safe than over-70s driving a car. There is no research.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Can we ask for that, because it was suggested? This has come up a lot and is a thorny subject with the public. It will be a thornier one by September when we do not have enough school bus drivers. Will Mr. Rowland come back to the committee with clarification on that? I heard of an office this morning I did not know existed. From the answers given it seems that it was tendered and is contracted to the RSA. We do not want to personalise this. There is a professor-----

Comment on this

It is not personal.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

There is a professor who is not-----

Comment on this

Chair, it is causing untold hardship.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Sorry, Deputy, I am chairing the meeting. There is a professor who is not here this morning, but we need an explanation for this because it is totally unsatisfactory. I agree with the Deputy. I have representations about this as well. Not a month goes by when I do not get them. We will have a pile of them by September because a lot of bus drivers, some of whom are friends of mine, will go over 70, which means they cannot drive the school bus. As Deputy English said, they can bring the kids to the swimming pool one hour later if they want to. It is a real point. The Deputy can have one very quick question because she is way over time.

Comment on this

How many HGV testers do we have, and what is the waiting time for a test?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

Is that test centres or testers?

Comment on this

Testers for HGV licences.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

I will have to come back on the actual number of testers, but from I memory I think it is approximately 70, and of 55 driving test centres, I think 39 of them are equipped to take HGV testing. This is part of our ongoing reviews of how we will improve the curriculum and our education-----

Comment on this

What is the average wait time?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

The average wait time is 15.6 weeks.

Comment on this

For a driving test?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

It is 15.6 weeks against our SLA. However, for commercial vehicles it is between ten and 12 weeks depending on the test centre. As the Deputy is maybe aware, on commercial vehicles we have continued to engage with the Irish Road Haulage Association. I am meeting the new president next week and we have committed to ensuring the national fleet is kept moving by supplying drivers. We have done that and are managing to keep that within the SLA. The 15.6 week waiting list we refer to is for cars, which is obviously the predominant number. For commercial vehicles at the moment, it is between ten and 12 weeks.

Comment on this

What about Georgian driving licences?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

I think the Deputy is referencing the exchange agreements.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

A memorandum of understanding in legislation is in the process of being signed and then the exchanges can begin. We have also continued to engage with North Macedonia. We have recently reviewed our MOU with the UK because of changes it made to its driving curriculum. There are obviously fall-outs over the European Union. We are continuing to engage with Moldovan authorities as well. We are also continuing to work with the remaining provinces in Canada.

Comment on this

What is the timeline for the Georgian licences?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

I think we are in the process of getting the legislation drafted. Dr. Walsh might have an update on that.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

As far as I know, the memorandum of understanding between Ireland and Georgia has been signed and then a ministerial order needs to be drafted and signed to commence that.

Comment on this

How long do they normally take?

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

It should be quick.

Comment on this

Before recess.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

I certainly hope so.

Comment on this

The World Health Organization tells us that cars - not cancer and malnutrition - are the leading killer worldwide of children and young people aged between five and 29. The RSA relies on cars and the drivers of cars for 98% of its income. Does Mr. Waide not see a fundamental problem here?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

If Ireland halved the number of cars tomorrow, then when the new NCT contract is renewed it would be based on a different set of numbers in terms of volume. Hence, the cost to deliver that service would reduce. It is demand driven.

Comment on this

It is, but the witnesses represent the Road Safety Authority. Cars are the reason our roads are unsafe. Will Mr. Waide answer that?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Cars are-----

Comment on this

The reason our roads are unsafe.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

It is not the cars, it is the people who drive the cars. It is the behaviour.

Comment on this

That sounds remarkably like an argument for gun licensing in the US. It is not the guns are the problem, it is the people who use them.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

An Garda Síochána can provide enforcement figures. It is not the cars that cause the collisions, it is the people who drive them.

Comment on this

Earlier on Mr. Waide said that he gets really frustrated at the lack of technology available to the RSA, An Garda Síochána and the Department. Yet, when opportunities arise for the use of that, the RSA is stony silent. Assistant Garda commissioner, Paula Hillman, sat in a room close to this on 4 October 2023 and told us that a dashcam portal system would go live in 2024. We are halfway through 2024 and it is patently obvious it is not going to happen. The RSA is utterly silent on that. We had a red light camera system in Dublin a couple of years ago. In the short time it was operational 1,300 car drivers were fined. They were switched off. The RSA was absolutely silent. The fact is that the RSA is not out there every day advocating for safer roads. It is not the trustworthy and reputable voice we turn to and need, unsullied by all other influences to ensure, when our children, parents, brothers and sisters leave home every morning, that Irish roads are as safe as they possibly can be. That is the fundamental issue. Active travel infrastructure is a way to separate the most vulnerable road users from cars, the very things that kill them. The RSA was silent. The RSA is silent whenever the issue arises, as it has arisen recently in my city of Galway, and in Dublin and Cork. There was a significant public debate covered extensively in the national press on the huge advantages for road safety of a development of a raft of active travel infrastructure. The RSA was utterly silent. We are not hearing it. Does Mr. Waide agree?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I do not agree, and here is why. On technology, in 2020 there was one location that used technology for speed - Dublin Port tunnel. In 2022, technology was used for road safety purposes on the M7. That did not come about through one organisation or one person.

Comment on this

That is two locations.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Will Deputy Cannon let me finish? An Garda Síochána will deploy three more locations in the coming three months. I thank those county councils that have engaged in supporting that. In August there will be a further nine. Next year, the Commissioner has committed to 100 locations across the country. I have not been silent on this. The Deputy referenced assistant commissioner Hilman. She and I are in contact every week to push for these technology-enabled solutions.

I turn to red lights in city centres. Dr. Walsh chairs the partnership board for road safety. The RSA has said consistently, and I have said, that we need to use more technology in city centres and not just for road traffic junctions. I am clear on this. This is not for monitoring traffic flows or volumes, but for monitoring road safety at traffic junctions. I also add that in the first year of the partnership board, and in every year since, I have flagged the need for bus lanes to be monitored. I had the conversation with the Minister, Deputy Eamon Ryan, about the monitoring of bus lanes, not by An Garda Síochána but by a third party. That will free up An Garda Síochána to focus on killer behaviours, not only on the commuted-on roads in city centres, but also outside city centres.

I disagree with Deputy Cannon's view that I have been silent on technology. I also disagree with the view that I and the RSA have been silent on road safety. Ms O'Connor has shared information on a number of campaigns we have continued to deliver-----

Comment on this

I said the RSA is silent on active travel.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

-----putting road safety-----

Comment on this

You are not heard. Your voice is not there.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

In terms of active travel we have provided startling research-----

Comment on this

No, you need to be an advocate.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

-----to influence active travel.

Comment on this

Research is wonderful but you need to be a powerful advocate speaking on the national airwaves every day on behalf of the people who lose brothers, sisters, mothers and daughters.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

We continually advocate for all road users. I want to bring in Ms O'Connor because recently we have been running campaigns to support active travel.

Comment on this

She already admitted she has not even met the HGV stakeholders.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

One Deputy at a time. I invite Ms O'Connor to respond.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I thank the Cathaoirleach.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

With regard to what we have done over the past 12 months on cycling, last year we ran the Imogen Cotter campaign on cycling safety. There was additional spending in November as a result of the funding the Government sanctioned us to spend. There was a significant ramp-up in April and May. We also have an additional sports package to reach younger men in particular with regard to cycling safety to help them understand what it is like to need to overtake, to overtake wide and to slow down. It is an ad campaign that features a cyclist but it is all about the driver doing the right thing. We have had our animated cycling-----

Comment on this

The RSA's work in this area has been superb but the most effective way to protect cyclists is to separate them completely from traffic.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

I agree.

Comment on this

The RSA is utterly silent on this. Whenever a debate arises at national level, and everyone in this room knows the debates that have been had in the past 24 months, the RSA has been nowhere to be heard.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

This is a very broad system with many players engaging in it. An awful lot of people have particular roles-----

Comment on this

You are the Road Safety Authority.

Comment on this
Ms Sarah O'Connor

There are times when people are frustrated with us because we are not doing something that is outside of our remit or outside of our role. We sit with the NTA, other organisations and local authorities.

Comment on this

The RSA needs to be that lone, independent, authoritative, unsullied voice for vulnerable road users and it is not. It is that simple.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I want to revert to the speed limits for a moment. Statistics show that many serious and fatal accidents happen on local roads. An elected representative cannot go up a local road without every second person asking them what can be done to slow down cars on the road. The speed that people drive on local roads is absolutely frightening. It is also the case on regional roads but it is particularly an issue on local roads. I do not have the answer to this with regard to enforcement. It comes up at joint policing committee meetings. There are no speed checks on these roads and people know that. The people who drive like lunatics on them at times are not from outer space. Some of them are local people who live two miles up the road and are in a hurry going to or from school. Politicians, including councillors and TDs, have been out and about a lot in recent months. I have driven in England. I have a HGV licence and I have driven in cities. I thought I had seen everything but in recent months I have seen things on local roads that are incredible. Is this getting a particular focus? What can be done? We will not have gardaí on them. We will not have speed cameras on all of them, although councils have put them at some entries to towns and villages. What can be done to address this?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

One of the actions in the strategy, and we are about to share the recommendation with the Department of Transport and the partnership board, is speed awareness. The Cathaoirleach mentioned England. It is about education but it is about educating people who should know better. They are not in school. The highest number of people who cause collisions are in their 30s, 40s and 50s. The recommendation is for a speed awareness course. Other jurisdictions have adopted this. Rather than giving people a fine and penalty points, they are given a fine but must attend a speed awareness course.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

People are looking for ramps on roads where they cannot be put in. People call for GoSafe vans but we know they will not be put on the roads. They cannot be put on every by-road in the country. I am sure members will agree that the speeds people are driving on local roads are absolutely crazy. I saw one person in a BMW with a child standing in the front driving down a local road covered in water. The road is 3 m or 3.5 m wide. It is not in good condition. I will not say where it is but it is not too far from where I live. What the person driving that car was doing was absolute insanity. This was at approximately 2.30 p.m. They were probably going to pick up another child from the school. You would not believe this stuff.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

The other action in terms of trying to address the problem of speed awareness is the review of the driving curriculum. The Cathaoirleach mentioned speed ramps in towns and villages.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We cannot put them on every road.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

No, we cannot but they are a solution. That is more a question for the Department of Transport to answer because it is linked into local councils.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I know. The problem is that we cannot put them on every road. I want to ask about test centres. Are hotels being used as test centres?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

As driver test centres?

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

Yes, they are. Where we have that, we are looking for alternative solutions.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

There are three driver test centres in County Laois. Where are they?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

Off the top of my head, I cannot give the addresses but I will furnish the information to the Cathaoirleach.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Are they in RSA buildings?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

I do not know. I will have to come back to the Cathaoirleach on that.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I ask Mr. Walsh to do so. Will the RSA also come back to the committee with information on what was spent renting hotels? It is curious that hotels are being used as test centres.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

Yes, we will. We only rent them because, quite simply, we do not have access to facilities. Part of the work of the group I referenced earlier is a facility review on how we can get the business out of the-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It is on a short-term basis and I understand that. Will the RSA come back to the committee with information on how much it has spent on it last year, how many hotels were rented and where are they. I have a specific question on Graiguecullen, which is on the Carlow side of Laois. How many test centres are there between Graiguecullen and Carlow town and where are they?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

I will have to come back to the Cathaoirleach on that.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I ask Mr. Walsh to do so, please.

Phase 1 of an RSA road safety strategy was launched in 2021 with a projected investment of €3.8 million. I presume some of that is for road safety measures. Perhaps Dr. Walsh from the Department might be able to help me with this. There is very scant information on it.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

I believe it is the estimated cost of delivering all of the actions across phase 1, which involves a number of different stakeholders.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Does some of it cover physical works?

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

I believe so, yes.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Dr. Walsh for helping with this. How far into it are we? What period of time is the €3.8 million to cover?

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

Phase 1 of the strategy takes us to the end of this year. It is for 2021 to 2024.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Three years.

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

Yes.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I ask the RSA to come back with a brief update on this. I also ask the witnesses to come back to the committee on the buildings. Who owns buildings used by the RSA? Is it the OPW or the RSA?

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

It is a mixture. Our preferred approach is always the OPW but it is not always possible. We do not own any buildings ourselves. When the OPW cannot find a location that meets our requirements we go to an interim measure of using hotels or leasing or renting ourselves.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank the RSA and departmental officials for their clarification that the AILG will be notified of speed limits and the cathaoirleach of each county council will also be notified.

Comment on this

Members would like an extra 15 minutes, with five minutes each.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I ask members to stick to the time. Each will have three minutes, with Deputy Catherine Murphy first.

Comment on this

We got a statement overnight on the sharing of data, which states it will be done by the end of the year. However, today we have been told it will be done in due course.

When I asked Dr. Walsh, I got an inconclusive answer. There was a changeover yesterday, as we know, and the Minister of State became the Minister for Finance. Could we get something more conclusive on this? The phrase "in due course" does not tell me anything. How long is a piece of string? The phrase "end of the year" tells me something and the inconclusive reply is no good to me. This has been going on for a very long time. Can somebody give me some sort of commitment on this? The former Minister of State, Deputy Jack Chambers, said "the end of the year". Is that what we are working towards?

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

I will deal with that as clearly as I can. The collision data are collected by the Garda and shared with the RSA. What was signed last Friday was a ministerial order-----

Comment on this

I understand that; I am talking about the legislation that is required.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

Yes, and I am going to explain that. What was signed last Friday was a ministerial order that confirms that the RSA has the legislative basis to receive the data from the Garda. It also provides the authority with the legislative basis to share the data with the local authorities. However, local authorities currently do not have a legal basis to receive or process that data because of GDPR issues. The final step – I am answering the Deputy's question-----

Comment on this

Dr. Walsh is only getting to the answer to the question I am asking.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

Yes, but it is important to provide background because there are several stages to this. The final step is that we need to change the Roads Act 1993 to give the local authorities the power to receive and process collision data once they get it from the RSA. We submitted a draft memorandum to our Ministers in the past few days. The intention is to bring that memorandum to the Government sometime before the summer recess, and that will seek approval to draft the legislation. The legislation will be very short, so-----

Comment on this

How come the former Minister of State, Deputy Chambers, could go on RTÉ and say it will be in place by the end of the year, and how come Dr. Walsh cannot tell me that?

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

Maybe he has a better idea of how long it takes legislation to pass through the Oireachtas than I do. I cannot give the Deputy a guarantee of how quickly legislation will pass through the Oireachtas. What I can say is that we have brought the memo to our Ministers. Our Ministers should bring it to the Government this side of the recess. I believe the drafting will be quick because the Bill should not be long.

Comment on this

Considering the amount of money, the carnage and the increases in road fatalities and accidents, a reduction would seem like a national priority.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

It is a priority.

Comment on this

The sharing of data is incredibly important in dealing with that. I would have thought that this was an absolute priority.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

We appreciate that.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The point is well made that there is a sense of urgency about this. It is very frustrating that local authorities tasked with the job of making the roads safe cannot get their hands on basic information. Who has a complaint about that? What happened? How was that stopped? It was not me at the time. Why do the local authorities not get the data?

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

To finish the previous point, we will push the legislation through as quickly as possible, but neither we nor our Ministers can guarantee something will pass through the Oireachtas quickly. Therefore, we would appreciate support from all the Deputies.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Was a complaint made?

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

My understanding is that the local authorities, when considering the data received, became aware that there were GDPR issues. When they looked into the matter further, they felt they did not have a legal basis to receive and process the data. It was a data protection issue. The Data Protection Commission has reviewed the approach we have proposed, including the legislation I was just talking about, and has confirmed that that approach is satisfactory to it.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It sounds like it is not Dr. Walsh's fault, but there is an awful rigmarole just for a piece of information to be transferred and used. We are tied up in knots.

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

The Department received the data, analysed it and shared it with the local authorities. There are 60 road improvement projects this year, planned and funded, based on the analysis of the data at local authority level, so-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That is welcome. I understand it is not the RSA's fault that-----

Comment on this
Dr. Keith Walsh

We are all trying to fix this.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The point being made continuously here this morning is that this needs to be accelerated. I thank Dr. Walsh.

Comment on this

I have two questions, one related to the frustrations the RSA has with technology. Do stakeholders such as insurance companies engage with the RSA and play their part in trying to introduce positive changes? I am aware they did in the past. Does the relationship still exist?

The question of busy spots is a bit like that concerning the sharing of data with local authorities. Frequently, traffic outside schools is a concern of all of us because of the behaviour of everybody, not just children and other young people but also adults, including parents, whose behaviour is no better. There is chaos at many schools. Nobody really seems to own responsibility; it falls between the Department of Education and councils. Does the RSA have an advisory role or an opinion in this regard? Is this matter something it could add to its campaign? We need to see more action on schools but financial responsibility and so on falls between organisations.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

On the schools, we run campaigns, particularly at the start of term in September. We have an annual ministerial campaign and raise the profile with respect to the need for safety outside schools. There needs to be a lead organisation responsible for safety cameras and road safety interventions outside schools. I agree on that point.

Comment on this

Has the RSA a role in that?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

We provide the insight and run campaigns. Deputy Cannon made a point earlier on a single organisation having the funding, remit and statutory duty to do all of what is required. I can see the benefits of that. The agencies went to Scotland and benchmarked Scotland. Scotland has one funding pot to drive road safety interventions, including active travel interventions. Our current system has a number of different pots. I look forward to the review. This is not just about the review of the RSA. I obviously look forward to that review but I feel a deeper, broader review is required for road safety in this country. By producing it, we can have a more joined-up, single approach to road safety.

What was the Deputy's technology question?

Comment on this

It was on insurance companies.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

On more than one occasion, insurance companies have offered the benefits of black-box technology, particularly for young drivers. They already do it. Some insurance companies already do it in Ireland, and some of those operate in both Ireland and the UK. What insurance companies have asked for is some form of support from the Government, or intervention, for want of a better term, to encourage more of that. It is about a more consistent approach. It is not about just a few proactive, disruptive insurance companies; rather, every insurance provider is-----

Comment on this

I recently read comments on learner drivers by two experts: Dr. Elizabeth Box, who works in road safety in the UK, and Dr. Lisa Wundersitz, an Australian. They state that, typically, learner drivers are safer due to the supervised environment. They state recent statistics on unaccompanied learner driver collisions are deeply concerning and highlight a significant deviation from the expected safety norms during the learner period. This was stated at a European conference discussing what I believe were some 155 deaths of learner drivers over a five-year period. Action 27 of the RSA's road safety statement is on the elimination of "the incidence of unaccompanied learner permit drivers". Has it allocated funding for that? I asked in February and was told there was no budget allocated to implement action 27 of the road safety strategy.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

That is correct. We do not at this point in time. I thank the Deputy for the question-----

Comment on this

I know that, but the reality is-----

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

It comes back to funding. The review of the RSA, I hope-----

Comment on this

Could Mr. Waide tell me how much funding is required?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Could the Deputy let me finish? I hope the review of the RSA will address the funding issues.

Comment on this

Why have a road safety strategy if we are not going to have the money to implement it?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

We submitted-----

Comment on this

There is €1 million in legal fees. What is that about?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Deputy Murphy made a point about the road safety strategy.

Comment on this

No my question had moved on-----

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

There were submissions. There was a submission for funding-----

Comment on this

That is grand, but did you get it? No.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

-----from multiple agencies.

Comment on this

There is €1 million in legal fees. What do they pertain to?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

I will ask my finance officer to answer that question.

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

Can I clarify what year the Deputy is referring to?

Comment on this

It is the year that is presented here, which is 2022.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

I would like to further expand on what Mr. Waide has said.

Comment on this

No, you are running down the clock.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

No, I am not.

Comment on this

You can write to me.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

I want to give the Deputy the top line.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will let you in-----

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

We are working with the Department of Transport to look at how our young people are being educated to drive vehicles. This is a priority for me personally because I have two young kids who will enter this service soon. It is a priority for us to ensure there is a correct curriculum of education-----

Comment on this

It is a priority for everyone.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

Of course it is.

Comment on this

That is listed as action 27 of the road safety strategy.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

We are looking at ways through which we can pull levers. We are looking at our driving test and how we are educating. We want to see how the education with our AVIs is carried out. We are looking at all areas.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

All of this is something we are working on.

Comment on this

Will you submit what you are looking at to the committee so we can look at it?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

It is a ministerial priority.

Comment on this

Yes, but will you do that? Will you also submit information on where the 70 HGV testers are located around the country? I do not need their names. This refers to the 39 testers.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

I could not give you their names because of GDPR, but I am happy to provide-----

Comment on this

No, but I need to know how many testers are in each centre.

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

Of course. Absolutely.

Comment on this

I will now go back to Ms Colhoun.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Very briefly, because you are over time.

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

Of the figure of €957,000, €607,000 has been related to external legal advice we have had to receive during 2022. We have just one in-house solicitor in the RSA and therefore we rely heavily on external legal advice.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I call Deputy Cannon-----

Comment on this

I want a breakdown of the areas in which the RSA would need external legal advice.

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

This is for some of our larger procurement exercises, as well as any other contractual legal advice we might need.

Comment on this

Did you not have a procurement issue of €1.7 million?

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

That was over five contracts.

Comment on this

If I am correct, there was an issue with procurement to the tune of-----

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

That was to do with those procurements not being compliant with the relevant guidance.

Comment on this

Was the relevant legal advice-----

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

It was not in relation to that, no.

Comment on this

Sorry Chair-----

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Very briefly.

Comment on this

I want to ask about roadside inspections for foreign registered vehicles. We had a very serious issue, and Mr. Waide may or may not be aware of it, in the road to the port of Rosslare. Seven foreign-registered vehicles with eastern European registrations were pulled for inspection and were deemed to be so unroadworthy that they could not even leave the area to drive to a test centre. If that happens in Europe, for example, if it is an Irish haulier, they are put on a low loader and they will have to pay the cost of getting it there. Yet, these were deemed to be so unsafe that when they were checked by testers, they were told they could not leave and that they were not even roadworthy enough to go on the main road. However, we had no compound in which to hold them. The RSA does not have a compound in which it can hold unsafe, unroadworthy vehicles. What percentage of roadside checks are carried out on foreign-registered vehicles? You will have to submit this-----

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

I do not have that information here.

Comment on this

What is the cost of the roadside check? Where do we bring our testers from? For instance, do they come from Donegal if they are doing an inspection in Rosslare? Is there a strategic approach to keep costs down, such as by having vehicle testers in Rosslare who are from Wexford, etc.?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

To the Deputy’s first point, last year, we carried out 18,900 roadside inspections, 1,900 of which were directly related to foreign vehicles. The RSA does not have the powers to detain a vehicle. That is a matter for An Garda Síochána, which supports us in those roadside checks.

In relation to my staff, there are 38 inspectors across this country. They will go to the checkpoints that we set up with An Garda Síochána. This will be based on their availability, and it will factor in if people are on annual leave or if somebody is sick. We will move people across the country. We feel that is very important because the last thing we want is for there to be familiarisation with a particular area and operators. We therefore mix it up.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Walsh have an average cost for roadside checkpoints?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

We can of course provide that to the Deputy.

Comment on this

What does it yield in revenue from a fines perspective?

Comment on this
Mr. Brendan Walsh

The fines are a matter for the courts and not a matter for us.

Comment on this

Okay. I have one last question for Mr. Waide. Where is his address for work?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

The head office for the RSA in Ballina in County Mayo.

Comment on this

Is that where he is stationed?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

That is my head office, but we have offices all over the country. We are a national service provider. I am stationed across the whole country.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I call Deputy Cannon.

Comment on this

I want to go back to Mr. Waide’s most recent comment on analysing the raison d'etre of the RSA and how it is constituted. I thank him for that comment because that is ultimately what I want to raise here today. I wish to point out that the way in which the RSA is established and funded is fundamentally flawed. I am not questioning for a moment the individual commitment of Mr. Waide and his team to road safety. I am pointing out that because of the way in which the RSA is constituted legally and because of the way in which it is funded, it is never going to be able to get to the heart of what needs to happen here in terms of improving road safety in this country. That is why I am asking this question today. Hopefully that analysis will be as robust as it needs to be, and will arrive at a point at which we will be able to put in place some sort of entity whose sole focus is making Irish roads safer.

I have two final questions. The Newstalk journalist, Eoghan Murphy, did some excellent analysis back in 2022 in which he said that 1,700 cyclists were hospitalised due to crashes in 2021. Nearly 200 of those were children aged under nine. I argue that the causation of road deaths and serious injury needs proper analysis every time by trained in-house statisticians and in-house public health experts. Are the results of coroners’ inquests examined by a medical team in the RSA or those contracted to the RSA to ascribe patterns in causation and to develop strategies to address those patterns and reasons for those incessant injuries, year-in, year-out? Vision Zero in Sweden was actually led by a doctor who was trained in public health. Does the RSA have anybody in its ranks with expertise in public health?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

To answer the Deputy’s question about a health professional in the RSA, the answer is “No”. Regarding the Deputy’s question on who analyses the information, it is Mr. Rowland and his team. It is quite a small team.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Waide. I have a final question. There is research beginning to emanate now from a number of different locations here in Europe and indeed in the US. There is some really good research coming from the US. One particular piece looks at death and injury in the state of Illinois over a period of three years, from 2016 to 2019. All concluded that children are eight times more likely to die when struck by an SUV compared to a passenger car. The higher body weight of SUVs means that fatality and serious injury rates are higher, and that even happens at lower speeds.

In 2021, the RSA and our Government published a ten-year road safety strategy. That strategy is completely silent on the issue of vehicle weight and size as a major contributing factor to road deaths and serious injuries. Was any analysis done on that aspect of road safety. If not, why not?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

In terms of specifics of vehicle weights, my colleague, Mr. Rowland, was key in developing this strategy. It is a ten-year strategy. Over the coming months, there will be the opportunity to address this, including with input from a newly formed road safety advocate forum and the road safety youth forum. This is a good example of an action that could be addressed over the next three years. Does Mr. Rowland want to add anything to that?

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Is it not written in stone? Mr. Rowland may briefly come in.

Comment on this
Mr. Michael Rowland

To follow through on that answer, the second phase is to commence next year. It will include a range of new actions that will address particular areas of concern, as well as what the data are telling us. I am aware of the points the Deputy is making regarding SUVs. Some recent research was done in Belgium as well in relation to bonnet height, weight, etc.

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

It would be remiss of me not to reply to the Deputy’s question about clinical expertise in the RSA. There is not one in the executive team or staff, but two clinicians sit on the board of the RSA, but they are non-executive board members.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

In relation to staff and the structure of the RSA, although Mr. Waide may not have the figures now, if one takes it over a three-year period, how many people were at management grade in 2020, for example, pre-Covid, and how many are at management grade now in the RSA?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Five and seven is the answer.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

In terms of the next tier down, could Mr. Waide supply the committee with a breakdown of the different categories of staff structures from 2020 to 2024? Can Mr. Waide supply just a note, I do not want a whole fog of detail, but only a note setting out the staff structure.

In relation to Atlas, at one stage we had a huge waiting time for NCT tests. It was difficult to get them. You had people driving around without them. There was ambiguity about whether a letter or some evidence from the RSA would cover a person if he or she was stopped by An Garda Síochána. There was difference in how that was being implemented. Were there any penalties of any kind levied on Atlas at that time?

Comment on this
Mr. Sam Waide

Yes.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

What were they?

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

Over the period July 2022 to December 2023, it was €3.8 million.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

There was a penalty. Was that collected?

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

Yes, it was collected. Again, it is a service credit.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Some of us will be back here in the afternoon.

Comment on this

Can I just make one statement?

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Sorry, the Deputy can in a second.

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

To confirm, we refer to them as service credits as per diem.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That €3.8 million was collected.

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

Yes, €3.8 million.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That is fine. I thank Ms Colhoun. I call Deputy Verona Murphy on a brief matter.

Comment on this

It is relevant to the Department more so, and the RSA. In relation to the bus drivers, it is pertinent that many parents are working and instead of a bus driver collecting their children from school - this is all to do with the tender process of Bus Éireann - they have their grandparents collecting them, many of whom are in their 80s. It is craziness. We need to be practical. We need to apply reason. We need to stop giving the tender to Bus Éireann if it is not capable of lifting that rule.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

What is happening as well is that you have 15 cars on the road instead of a minibus with one driver. There are greenhouse gas emissions and road safety issues.

Comment on this

A review should not take long.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Fifteen vehicles on the road create a greater risk.

Comment on this

Prioritise the review.

Comment on this

To be clear, as committee members, we are all responsible. We are not saying that someone who should not be driving is asked to drive. They are driving the same bus five minutes later. That is the issue here.

Comment on this

It is crazy. It is not common sense.

Comment on this

It does not make any sense. It does not seem to be based on science. If it is, we have to accept it.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The point has been made, loud and clear. I would appreciate it if Mr. Waide would come back to the committee on that. It is important.

Comment on this

I ask that it could be prioritised.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It is a subject on which members are passionate. The witnesses can see that in the room this morning. We know it is a difficult job. Any of us who are on the roads can see what is out there every day. The RSA has a role but so has every driver, every local authority, every member of An Garda Síochána and everyone else who has anything to do with this. It is really important.

There is a substantial budget there. It is running up to nearly €100 million a year now, and is mainly self-financing. Approximately €1 million a year comes from the Exchequer.

Comment on this
Ms Kim Colhoun

Just under €1 million.

Comment on this
Brian Stanley An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Just under €1 million. That is as it should be.

There is passion around this and people are very concerned about it. We need to reset the dial because when I started driving, just over 600 a year were being killed on the roads and there was probably one tenth of the number of cars on the road, driving at half the speed. There was a particular reason for that at the time but we have moved away from that. Cars are moving faster now and there have been some particular issues raised here this morning. One, which may seem like a small one, is in relation to trucks. The mirrors are a real issues regarding road safety because truck drivers are being pushed out onto the wrong side of the road. There is a simple solution. Local authorities will have to enforce this. Under the roads legislation, the local authority can serve a notice on the landowner to cut the outside of the hedgerows, so that they do not break mirrors. If they are breaking mirrors, the truck drivers are forced to keep out or they complete the journey with only one mirror on the lorry. That is not satisfactory. Those mirrors are expensive. Most importantly, it creates a hazard in terms of road safety.

The witnesses can come back with the medical advice on the over-70s. The Department has heard it loud and clear here. If there is anything that has to be done by elected members, we should know about it. That really needs to be dealt with.

I thank the witnesses for the evidence provided. I thank the staff of the Road Safety Authority and the Department who attended today and provided a lot of information. I thank the Comptroller and Auditor General, Mr. McCarthy, and Ms Somers and the staff for their assistance.

Is it agreed that the clerk to the committee will seek any follow-up information and carry out any agreed actions arising from the meeting? Agreed. Is it also agreed that we note and publish the opening statements and briefing provided for today's meeting? Agreed. I wish the RSA and the Department well in their work.

The committee will suspend until 1.45 p.m., when we will resume in public session to address correspondence and any other business. Go raibh míle maith agaibh.

Comment on this