Financial Statements 2023 - Charities Regulatory Authority
Contributions 1–138 of 275. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I welcome everybody here today. I remind those in attendance to ensure mobile phones are on silent mode or switched off. Before we start I wish to explain some limitations to parliamentary privilege and the practice of the Houses as regards references that may be made to other persons in evidence.
The evidence of witnesses physically present or who give evidence within the parliamentary precincts is protected pursuant to both the Constitution and statute by absolute privilege. This means witnesses have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they may say in the meeting. However, witnesses are expected not to abuse this privilege and it is my duty as Leas-Chathaoirleach to ensure that privilege is not abused. Therefore, if witnesses' statements are potentially defamatory in relation to any identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative they comply with such direction.
Members and witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way that would make him or her identifiable. Members are also reminded of the provisions within Standing Order 218 that the committee shall refrain from enquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government or the merits or objectives of such policies.
We are joined by Ms Colette Drinan, secretary and director of audit at the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General, who is deputising this week for the Comptroller and Auditor General, who is the permanent witness to the committee. She is accompanied by Mr. Leonard McKeown, deputy director at the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General.
This morning we will engage with representatives of the Charities Regulator to examine the financial statements from 2023 of the Charities Regulator and the financial statements 2023 of the charity funds. We are joined by the following representatives from the Charities Regulator: Ms Madeleine Delaney, chief executive officer; Mr. Thomas Mulholland, director of compliance and enforcement; and Mr. Seán O'Connor, head of charity services. We are also joined by the following officials from the Department of Rural and Community Development: Mr. Jake Ryan, principal officer, community and voluntary supports and programmes; and Mr. Kevin Power, assistant principal, community and voluntary supports and programmes. The witnesses are all very welcome.
I call Ms Drinan for her opening statement.
Comment on this
The Charities Regulatory Authority was formally established in 2014 under the Charities Act 2009. It is responsible for the regulation and protection of charitable trusts and organisations. It has a range of statutory powers and duties, including the power to conduct investigations into the affairs of charities.
The 2023 financial statements of the authority recorded total income of €4.8 million, all of which is Oireachtas grant funding from Vote 42 - Rural and Community Development. The authority’s expenditure in 2023 was €4.9 million, which included staff costs of €2.7 million and other administration costs of €2.2 million. The authority reported an operating surplus of €79,000 for the year. A clear audit opinion was given on the 2023 financial statements.
The authority also manages the statutory charity funds account and reports separately on the transactions and balances of the funds account. This account was originally set up to administer assets or funds of any charity that were vested with the predecessor of the Charities Regulatory Authority, that is, the Commissioners of Charitable Donations and Bequests for Ireland. The balance on the charity funds account at the close of 2023 was €1.3 million. Receipts into the funds account during 2023 amounted to €1.67 million, mainly comprising dividends from investments, the proceeds of investment units sold at the direction of participating charities, and administration costs recovered. The payments from the funds account in 2023 mainly represented distribution of those receipts to the charities concerned and the payment of administration costs. A clear audit opinion was given on the 2023 financial statements of this account.
Separate to the charity funds, the authority also operates a common investment fund. This fund was originally set up to support charities, particularly smaller charities, to invest charitable funds collectively that were not required for immediate use and to earn a return on those balances. The common investment fund is separately accounted for and is not subject to audit by the Comptroller and Auditor General. The financial statements of that fund are not presented to the Oireachtas. Access to the investment fund is closed to new members but dividends earned on existing investments can be reinvested. The authority has reported that the value of the investments in the common investment fund at the end of 2023 was €41.6 million.
Comment on this
I thank Ms Drinan for her statement. As set out in the letter of invitation, Ms Delaney has five minutes to make her opening statement.
Comment on this
I thank the Chairman and committee members for the opportunity to address them on the Charities Regulator’s financial statements for 2023. I am joined today by the director of compliance and enforcement, Mr. Thomas Mulholland, and the head of charity services, Mr. Seán O’Connor.
The Charities Regulator was established ten years ago yesterday, on 16 October 2014. It is funded by the Exchequer through a subhead of Vote 42 - Rural and Community Development. Our budget in 2023 was €5 million. Pay accounted for approximately €3 million of our overall budget and non-pay expenditure amounted to approximately €2 million. There are currently 13 members on the board of the Charities Regulator and 47 full-time members of staff. A number of board subcommittees assist the board in carrying out its functions.
At the end of 2023, there were 11,516 charities and more than 75,000 charity trustees. It is a diverse sector that ranges from very small volunteer-only charities to large scale operations with significant numbers of employees. They are supported by hundreds of thousands of volunteers across Ireland, including those who take up the role of charity trustee. In addition, an estimated 281,250 people were employed in charities in 2023, equivalent to almost one in eight workers. The overall financial impact of the charity sector was estimated at €32.1 billion in 2022.
It is important to mention that a charity is only one type of not-for-profit organisation. The word “charity” is generally used to describe a non-profit organisation that helps people. However, "charity" is a protected legal term and the distinguishing feature of a charity is that it must provide a public benefit. This is a key part of the test set out in the legislation and applied by us as part of the registration process. The persons legally responsible for the management and administration of a charity are the directors or committee members, who are referred to as charity trustees.
Charities can come under the remit of a number of regulators and public bodies depending on the services they provide. Our role is grounded solely in the charities Acts, in particular the Charities Act 2009. Our statutory functions include maintaining a register of charities and promoting high standards of governance and accountability in charities. Our guiding function is to increase public trust and confidence in the administration and management of charities. We also deal with applications by charities under the Charities Acts 1961 and 1973 for services and assistance such as approving cy-près schemes, appointing new trustees and authorising the sale of charity property.
These services are provided free of charge and are an alternative to applying to the High Court.
During its first ten years, the Charities Regulator focused on establishing its organisational structures and governance and setting up the register of charities. We have also developed and maintain a wide range of guidance materials and supports to assist charity trustees understand and fulfil their responsibilities in running their organisations. We work with charity trustees, charity representatives and other experts and stakeholders to make sure our guidance and materials are practical and relevant to those volunteering and working in the sector.
Where issues or concerns arise, we seek to take proportionate action. We engage extensively on a one-to-one basis with charities and charity trustees to resolve governance and compliance matters. Most issues are resolved voluntarily without the need for us to use any formal powers. In 2023, for example, we received 632 new concerns. However, during that same year, we issued only 15 statutory directions to provide information or to produce documents.
When the situation requires, we will use our powers, for example, by appointing inspectors to investigate and report on the affairs of a charity. Another example is during 2023 we undertook a targeted initiative to address falling compliance rates with the requirement to file an annual report. The filing of an annual report is a relatively simple task and is an essential part of accountability and transparency. It is also a legal obligation, and one that is complied with by the majority of charities. This initiative has led so far to eight prosecutions in the District Court, and 31 charities have been removed from the register.
We are in the final year of the Charities Regulator’s current statement of strategy and I acknowledge the work of our dedicated, professional staff. During the lifetime of this strategy we have introduced a new registration application form, increased our engagement with stakeholders, established a new stakeholder forum and held trustee events and surveys. We have also enhanced our website, added new guidance, increased the frequency of our e-zine and our webinars, and undertaken focused staff training. We have promoted informed giving and our latest campaign, Click, Check, Give, has helped to increase searches of the register.
We have also worked closely with the Department of Rural and Community Development on amendments to the Charities Act 2009 which will enhance and strengthen the existing regulatory framework. We look forward to working with the Department and the sector on implementation of these provisions.
Our next statement of strategy, which will run to the end of 2027, will focus on fair and effective regulation, deepening our relationships with our stakeholders and developing our organisational capability. We aim to learn from what has worked well over the past decade and also what has not worked as well as we intended, and to bring that knowledge into our engagement with charities.
Our ambition is to develop a regulatory model that is appropriate to the diversity across the sector and that supports good practice in the governance, management and administration of charities. I hope the foregoing gives some sense of our role as regulator in a highly complex and diverse charities sector. I am happy to respond to any questions that the Leas-Cathaoirleach and members may have.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses and wish them a happy anniversary yesterday - ten years. I congratulate them on that.
How many staff are employed with the Charities Regulator?
Comment on this
We have a staff complement of 47 and two vacancies at the moment, which are the director of legal affairs and registration and head of finance.
Comment on this
In June, there were media reports of a funding shortfall. Is that accurate? I refer to funding shortfalls and budgetary constraints. The funding was to ensure the work the Charities Regulator needs to do was carried out.
Comment on this
Those media reports referred to the Estimates process for 2024. We sought funding for specific work, which we did not receive. In the Estimates process that took place this year for next year, we also sought additional staff for a certain type of work, not the same as we sought before, and the indication is that we will receive that funding. Obviously, we have to wait for the Revised Estimates.
Comment on this
The funding that was requested was not forthcoming for the year. It was suggested a draft letter was to be circulated. I think this is from within the minutes of the board of the Charities Regulator. Could Ms Delaney outline some of the services that were impacted by that funding shortfall?
Comment on this
The work we wanted to undertake was primarily additional to the work we were doing. We had identified some projects that we wanted to undertake what we believed would be of value. They were curtailed. In addition, we were doing work on the governance code. We reviewed our work on that and we have a different project related to that now. Overall, we wanted to try to improve the efficiency of our services. Some of them are quite labour-intensive in terms of staff involvement. Therefore, we looked for staff in order to achieve that as well.
Comment on this
There is currently a staff complement of 47 and two vacancies. What is the target? What is the need with regard to the additional work Ms Delaney outlined?
Comment on this
The need that we requested for 2025 and the allocation we requested in respect of people were staff to work at a junior level - case officer level - who carry out the bulk of our work in the registration function, to try to improve timelines, and also in the concerns function. We also sought funding for a legal adviser who would be dedicated to regulatory aspects of the work, namely in compliance and enforcement.
Comment on this
In 2023, €551,485 was spent consultants. Am I correct in saying that?
Comment on this
That is a huge sum of money. Where was that spent? What was the need? Can Ms Delaney outline some of the skill shortfalls within the organisation that requires that level of money to be spent on outside consultants?
Comment on this
Those consultancy costs the Deputy quoted relate to the figures of €500,000 and €51,485. They relate to day-to-day consultancy costs, if you like, where we supplement our own ability to carry out work with consultants. Legal costs would be included in that, as well as the cost of accountancy firms that fill the role of inspector. We also had some exceptional IT costs related to a project for us to procure a new digital platform. The digital platform is basically the system by which we do all our work. It supports the register of charities, it puts the information up there, it is the customer portal where people access it and it is how we do our back office work. It is a very extensive, important and complex strategic project for us. We engaged the services of a project manager and a business analyst to help us do the work for that.
Comment on this
There are 13 board members. Is that correct?
Comment on this
What remuneration do they get for being board members?
Comment on this
The board members get a small fee per meeting. I think the figures are in the statements. There is a range of fees. An ordinary board member is at €7,695 for the year, and in 2023 the chair was at €9,445.
Comment on this
How many of those board members would be members of other boards?
Comment on this
A certain number of them would be. Some would also be employed in the State. We currently have one and they obviously do not get a fee, and we previously had one.
Comment on this
Okay, so some would be members of multiple boards.
Comment on this
That is information the Charities Regulator would hold or have a database on.
Comment on this
Insofar as they may be on the board of a charity, that is information we would hold and that would be purely for the purposes of the executive helping them manage conflicts of interest.
Comment on this
Okay. On the rent for the premises, €343,424 per year is a huge amount of money. It is a high rent. Does Ms Delaney agree?
Comment on this
The rent is actually cheaper than where we moved from in 2017. The rent is approximately 40% less than what it was previously. We have a lease. The lease will be up for renewal and negotiation next year. We are already preparing to carry out an assessment of the market and our needs to see what is there.
Comment on this
We only have to look across the State to see the number of OPW buildings that are vacant and derelict. Has any communication taken place with the OPW in terms of utilising some of its vacant buildings?
Comment on this
We will communicate with it as part of this process.
Comment on this
It seems like an extraordinary amount of rent when there are so many State-owned buildings.
In terms of the charities themselves and the pay for CEOs, it has to be said an awful lot of charities operate on a voluntary basis and there is no remuneration whatsoever. For CEOs who are paid, the average is approximately €70,000. There were some reports in the media that said CEOs were making up to €160,000 and some said that was justifiable. Are salaries and remuneration packages monitored by the regulator?
Comment on this
We monitor the oversight and the process in relation to whether staff need to be recruited and what staff at what grade, whether there is an open recruitment competition with a proper role profile and whether the salaries are benchmarked. That is the guidance we give charities. It is permissible to employ people because you have to deliver services, you might have to buy equipment and materials and you might have to rent space. All of that is allowed. Charities are however expected to make sure they only incur the costs that are strictly necessary and reasonable. They have to look at and examine that.
CEO is a title, but you might ask whether there is a need for the role of CEO in a very small charity with two employees or sometimes even one as opposed to a charity with hundreds of employees and lots of services and complex matters to deal with.
Comment on this
Are there any charities where that remuneration package is deemed excessive or which Ms Delaney has concerns about?
Comment on this
I cannot say specifically but it is something we look at and we draw the attention of charities to it. The main way in which we do this is when charities come to us to register. The registration process is as much teaching charities about what it means to be a charity, what they can expect in running the charity and what the requirements of being a charity are as it is about meeting the requirements of the Act. In that instance, they might talk about having employees from the very start or having a specific numbers of employees. When they have not even started operations, we may question as to whether this is, in fact, necessary at this point in time. We ask them to go away and look at that.
We provide them with the information I have just spoken about there about how to recruit people. It all boils down to that; it is not just in relation to your staff. It is in relation to services and everything you pay for. It is about ensuring you get good value for money, much as we are required to do in the public sector.
Comment on this
We absolutely see the need for the regulator and the work it does in ensuring there is regulation and all the standards are adhered to, but in some cases it is construed that there is heavy-handedness in the approach taken. I do a lot of work with organisations that help the homeless, and I am sure others do as well. There was a brilliant organisation in my constituency that was set up by a local woman, Colette Talbot, called Together for Homeless. They came into the city centre on a weekly basis and helped feed up to 250 homeless people. They were fully compliant with food safety regulations and all of that. They got a letter from the regulator completely out of the blue and were told them to cease operation.
That organisation was not an isolated case; there were a number of other similar organisations carrying out voluntary work and receiving small donations to help feed the homeless. That lady was threatened with imprisonment or a fine of up to €30,000 unless they ceased operation immediately. Unfortunately, they had to cease operation. There are 250 people who were receiving food on a weekly basis now not receiving that service.
The organisation came at it from a very charitable perspective. They saw a need and serviced that need, which is unfortunately still there and growing on a daily basis. Together for Homeless and a number of other organisations like it were forced to cease operating because of what I deem a heavy-handed approach. Could Ms Delaney speak to the approach taken in situations like that?
Comment on this
There are probably two aspects I need to address in relation to that. The first is the communication itself and the tone and content. That is feedback we have received and it is something we will look at and we want to address. Where something is an offence, we are obliged to warn people of the potential consequences but I fully accept there are ways in which you can do that. That is the first point.
Without talking about anybody specifically, we would never tell anybody to shut down. I refer to what would have happened in the type of cases the Deputy is talking about. You cannot call yourself a charity if you are not on the register and you cannot let people believe you are a charity if you are not on the register. If we find that somebody is either deliberately or mistakenly calling themselves a charity, we point this out to them and tell them they cannot do that or they can apply to the register in which case when they are registered, they can call themselves a charity. That is the distinction.
We are not saying these people are not doing good, they are not needed or that there is anything untoward in their behaviour. We are simply saying you cannot call yourself a charity if you are not on the register of charities or you cannot collect money as a charity. What I imagine was said there was that they could not continue to call themselves a charity, not to shut down operations because that is not within our gift-----
Comment on this
I do not want to get into specific cases or anything like that, but they were certainly not masquerading as some charity. They received small donations, similar to many little groups like that. It was a coming together of community activists and people who wanted to do good. I gave the wrong figure. She was threatened with a fine of €300,000 and-or a prison sentence of up to ten years-----
Comment on this
She was told this is the process you need to go through. It is a cumbersome and lengthy process that would frighten the life out of anyone trying to register as a charity. The approach was very heavy-handed and wrong and there needs to be a lot more-----
Comment on this
-----working with small groups like that which see a need to address a serious crisis, which is homelessness. Unfortunately, it was forced to cease operating like many other similar small groups.
Comment on this
Before we move to Deputy Murphy, could Ms Delaney clarify that the consultancy fees were nothing to do with the regulator's core work and it was for exceptional items like the IT project?
Comment on this
The main expenditure that was unique to last year was related to IT.
Comment on this
The other expenditure includes our legal costs for external legal advisers. It includes the cost of inspectors where we use an external firm to help us with inspections.
We have an external data protection officer. That is covered in that as well.
Comment on this
Good morning everyone. The witnesses are all welcome. I will stay with this issue for a minute. To go back to the consultancy costs, IT expenses totalled approximately €475,000.
Comment on this
Fees were incurred for consultancy costs separate to that.
Comment on this
They are included in the figure of €550,000.
Comment on this
There are legal fees totalling €163,000. What type of legal work are they attributed to?
Comment on this
We get some external legal advice. The increase in the fees in 2023 was largely due to legal costs for a judicial review that was taken against us.
Comment on this
As regards the report carried out on the Peter McVerry Trust, a list of recommendations was made, one of which pertains to the Charities Regulator, namely, recommendation No. 32. That recommendation states that fundraising will be receipted appropriately and in accordance with the requirements of the Charities Regulator. That status of that recommendation is in progress. What does that mean?
Comment on this
The first time we became aware of this was through the Comptroller and Auditor General's report. We think it refers to general guidance we have on fundraising from the public.
Comment on this
As I understand it, while it says it is in progress, the first time the Charities Regulator became aware of the action was from the report of the Comptroller and Auditor General.
Comment on this
Has the Charities Regulator had any communication with the trust with regard to action 32?
Comment on this
If I am interpreting this correctly, any money contributed to the Peter McVerry Trust from any member of the public will be receipted. Therefore, if I give €10 to the Peter McVerry Trust, I must receive a receipt. The Charities Regulator does not know whether that is happening.
Comment on this
First, the requirement to be receipted does not mean someone is physically given a receipt. It means the money is accounted for, particularly on receipt by the organisation. The organisation should clearly be able to track where the funds come from, where they go and, if someone did inquire, it should be able to tell them where the money has gone.
Comment on this
Given that this is a recommendation, when will the Charities Regulator inquire as to whether that is actually being carried out?
Comment on this
We will be following up with the charity trustees now that we have received the inspector's report. This will be one of the matters on which we will follow up.
Comment on this
When does Ms Delaney expect to do that?
Comment on this
We will be writing to them either on Friday or Monday.
Comment on this
Ms Delaney stated that the Charities Regulator has 47 employees with two vacancies. In the report from which we are reading, there were 44 employees in 2022 and 2023. There are now 47 with two vacancies. Is that correct?
Comment on this
In 2022 and 2023, when there were 44 staff, there was an increase in salary costs of more than €200,000. What is that due to?
Comment on this
From where is the Deputy getting this figure?
Comment on this
It is from the actual accounts. Maybe the witnesses from the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General can help me in this regard. There is a figure of-----
Comment on this
It is under note 4 of the accounts of renumeration and staff costs.
Comment on this
The figure stood at €2,457,050 in 2022 and increased to €2,683,616 in 2023, with the same levels of staffing.
Comment on this
That is due to pay increases that were agreed and implemented.
Comment on this
Were those increases agreed as part of the public pay talks?
Comment on this
Yes. We adhere to the public service pay scales.
Comment on this
That explains that.
I often receive calls from constituents who are trying to register charities and they find it a pretty arduous process. I am not saying that is the Charities Regulator's fault. For people who want to do good, there is a rigorous process in place. It can be daunting for someone who is not a solicitor or an accountant. What is the average time it takes to register a charity from start to finish?
Comment on this
Is that the time it should take or what it is actually taking?
Comment on this
The Charities Regulator has 44 staff and there are 11,016 charities. That means that if all staff took their fair share, although I assume not all staff deal with inspections, each employee would have to do 267 inspections. I take it the Charities Regulator is not doing random sampling inspections.
Comment on this
Does Ms Delaney consider that a problem? I mean that not as an accusation but from the public perspective. Is it the case that any inspections the Charities Regulator does are brought on the basis of a complaint notified to it?
Comment on this
While I cannot say “Yes” definitively, a lot of the information we act on is brought to us. We pick up things ourselves internally. We have red flags such as circumstances where a number of trustees quickly resign en masse or something like that. By and large, however, most of the information we get is external.
Comment on this
Does the Charities Regulator have any idea what the monetary value is of the 11,016 registered charities? Does it have a ballpark figure? They have to register their accounts with the Charities Regulator.
Comment on this
We have done research and know their value to the sector. I do not believe we have a figure for the total of all of their accounts and what they say they have in assets, income or cash in hand.
Comment on this
I am looking at the Charities Regulator’s budget. We are here to assess value for money. From what I have seen from the figures of the Peter McVerry Trust, it has an asset value of approximately €70 million, although I may be corrected on that.
Comment on this
That is its income, but what is its asset value?
Comment on this
It has charitable status. Does it pay tax?
Comment on this
The whole issue with debt warehousing and such ran into €8 million. That is just one charity. Ms Delaney told us the Charities Regulator's resourcing from the Government is €5 million per year. Ms Delaney probably has an opinion that she may or may not be able to share but if that is just one charity, the Charities Regulator is very under-resourced from a confidence and transparency perspective and the perspective of the public.
My view of charities, which I think everyone shares, is that the money people give to charities should be spent on a charitable basis. We have seen what happened in the Peter McVerry Trust and a few other charities such as Concern whose names crop up. Bóthar is another that comes to mind. People are very giving in Irish society in particular. They are very good. I attend coffee mornings all the time and it never ceases to amaze me. Trust and confidence are paramount. What level of resourcing did the Charities Regulator request over and above the current budget in the 2025 Vote?
Comment on this
We requested an additional €170,000 for 2025.
Comment on this
How much of that was to go towards salaries?
Comment on this
The €170,000 was for salaries for three identified roles. We then sought an increase of €80,000 in non-pay. That was identified for the cost of inspections.
Comment on this
Is it fair to say that the Government gave €30 million odd to bail out the Peter McVerry Trust? I ask the Comptroller and Auditor General's office if that is where we ended up.
Comment on this
Based on the report, there was exceptional funding of €15 million in November 2023. There was also some accelerated advance funding.
Comment on this
I will finish with this but, leaving it at €15 million, it is counterproductive not to resource the regulator when we are providing money and where we can see it is not being spent accordingly. I take it the regulator's investigation into the Peter McVerry Trust is not yet complete.
Comment on this
No, we have the report now. We are looking at it and, as I have said, we plan to contact the charity trustees imminently.
Comment on this
We look forward to having the regulator back on that basis. I thank Ms Delaney.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being here today. I was fortunate enough to head up a charity for almost seven years and I know the value of the work the regulator does in sustaining the public's trust in the charity sector as a whole and allowing charities to continue doing the good work they do. I thank it for that. In May of this year, the regulator issued a statement urging charities to be more vigilant in identifying conflicts of interest. By their nature, such conflicts are sometimes difficult to identify and more difficult to pin down than financial irregularities. The regulator issued guidance to the boards of charities on how to manage such conflicts of interest. Apart from issuing that guidance, is the regulator being proactive in identifying conflicts of interest that have the capacity to seriously undermine the work and credibility of charities? It is a significant area that needs forensic scrutiny. The witnesses have outlined the resources available to the office so I know that may not be possible. However, to restore the public's faith in the charities sector as a whole and to strengthen it into the future, that needs to be central to the work the regulator does. Do the witnesses have any views on that?
Comment on this
We issued that guidance and note in May because we see it as an issue that charities can struggle with. We see it when they are applying for entry to the register. There is very little we can do other than issue guidance. We cover the issue as part of the webinars and training that we run. It is all about the management of the issue. It is a very difficult area. Sometimes, especially in small charities in rural communities, it cannot be avoided so it is about how it is managed and the transparency around it. Some of them are very good at it. It is about having the conversation, being aware and understanding that the perception of a conflict is as dangerous as an actual conflict. It is one of those areas that charities struggle with as part of overall governance. That is probably because of the nature of people coming on board on a volunteer basis. Often, people will bring in somebody they know. That is how you get new trustees to come on. It may be someone you work with or something like that. They may then be a little bit more uncomfortable talking about it. We just want to make it more normal to talk about it, to build it into meeting agendas and to make it routine. We want charities to have a very good policy that they actually adhere to and keep up to date.
Comment on this
In her opening statement, Ms Delaney outlined that the office oversees a very diverse landscape of charities, ranging from small volunteer-led charities, sometimes operating in small communities and perhaps only serving the needs of that particular community, to very large entities with budgets of millions of euro. In her most recent response, she mentioned webinars. Does the regulator undertake any specific work with those smaller charities that are coming under its scrutiny for the first time? On the webinars, I assume, although I could be wrong, that attendance at these webinars is voluntary and that there is no obligation to attend. Has consideration ever been given to making this a mandatory requirement for charities? Perhaps those in their first year or two of operation could be obliged to attend these webinars if they are to remain registered with the regulator. This would allow them to become very familiar with all of the regulatory and governance requirements the regulator imposes.
Comment on this
The Deputy is correct that attendance is voluntary. We have quite good attendance but we are concerned that we are not reaching the volunteer-only very local charities that we really need to reach if we are to help them put in place governance and oversight measures, which is where charities can ultimately be exposed. We are doing a particular campaign or initiative in that regard. We have been working on a project to organise a seminar for those charities that have just registered. A charity may have been registered for three weeks or three months but we will capture that cohort and bring them through some of the basics, particularly pointing them to the guidance they can find on our website. We cannot force them to do it but we will be strongly encouraging them. It is interesting that there is a provision in the amending Act that has not been commenced but that will allow us to impose conditions as part of registration. As the Deputy has said, we can certainly look at imposing a condition requiring a certain amount of attendance at webinars. There is no doubt that charities need help with the mechanisms they need to put in place. They need to have things explained to them and to be given practical examples, which is what we try to provide in these webinars.
Comment on this
The provision Ms Delaney refers to has not yet been enacted. Is the regulator proactively seeking that power to oblige charities, particularly those recently established charities, to attend webinars? I would argue these webinars are very much in their interests as regards their governance, the public's trust in them and their credibility. Would the regulator encourage Government or the Minister to confer that power upon it? Can the regulator assume that power? Does it have the legislative freedom to do so once the amendment is enacted?
Comment on this
We are just waiting for the various provisions of the Act to be commenced. There are quite a lot of amendments in it. We have been engaging with Department officials on it, working out the practical implications of various aspects and trying to ascertain what would be for the very short term, the medium term and the long term. That provision certainly fits into the short-term category.
Comment on this
From Ms Delaney's perspective as CEO, what are the largest challenges facing her organisation right now in late 2024 in doing the work it does? How does she suggest they should be addressed?
Comment on this
It means being more proactive as regards how we deal with matters that arise. It goes back to Deputy Verona Murphy's point. Understandably, in the first years of our establishment, in addition to getting up and running, we have looked at every single concern that has been raised with us. That is because we needed to build an understanding of the sector and the issues and to build our own capacity and ability to know how to deal with these issues. We are now at a point where we will have to be more selective about what we look at on a risk basis. We do risk profiles but we will now have to be more selective. We cannot look at everything. We need to do more proactive supervision. That is one aspect of remaining agile. The other aspect is that, when you have limited resources - and we are not the only body to have limited resources - you constantly look at new, different and better ways of doing things. One of the things we need to look at is the use of information and technology. For some queries in the very early stages of the application process, we may be able to make use of technology such as AI. We are a long way away from that but we are starting the discussion this year. We are having somebody come in to talk to staff about it.
The other thing, which is somewhat connected, is data. Data is key not just for us, but for the public.
Much of how the regulatory framework was set up, the powers given to the regulator and what it can and cannot do was designed around a system whereby the information on the register tells people what they need to know. We will have to keep increasing the amount and accuracy of information on the register and make sure people keep it up to date. Then we need the public looking at that register. When we were established, we inherited 8,000 charities that had a charitable tax exemption, CHY, number from Revenue who never came through our process, some of which have engaged to varying degrees, although some of which have been in existence for years and may be our best-known charities. We have a challenge, particularly regarding that cohort and that data. We are trying to tackle this on a piecemeal basis. We hope the new digital platform will give us a tool but we need to get charities producing the information they should be producing in order that the public, as well as ourselves, can see what is going on.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being here this morning and the Comptroller and Auditor General for putting in the work on the report. I agree with Deputy Cannon that it is a very complex landscape and that we are dealing with charities of different capacities and sizes. I think roughly 11,000 charities are registered. Has their turnover been categorised in any way? How many fall into the very small category of having very small turnover, almost on the point of inactivity?
Comment on this
Possibly 10% are inactive. We have been running a targeted initiative on annual reporting compliance, because it is a basic requirement and organisations should be doing it. We have found a cohort that is effectively inactive. At least this gives us a way to identify them, although it is by literally writing letters, following up and then removing them from the register. A total of 257 or 4% of charities have no income whatsoever. A further 30% have less than €100,000 per year.
Comment on this
Does Ms Delaney have a breakdown for the number of charities that have incomes of less than €10,000 or €5,000 per year?
Comment on this
If a charity has less than €10,000, it is an incredibly small operation. It more than likely does not have any paid staff and is mostly volunteer run. Equally, the auditing requirements are very onerous. Regarding audit fees in some cases, I know of one group with a total income of €2,500 and the cost of auditing is just north of €1,000. Has any consideration been given in that space to how we might be able to address those challenges, or is that just a necessary part of establishing trusts for the larger landscape?
Comment on this
There are some provisions included in the amendment Act and there are thresholds which significantly reduce the obligation on lower income charities, and it is to address that issue. The idea is that it will be a staged categorisation.
Comment on this
I find it very frustrating, as does the group itself, which I will not name, that to carry out charitable work, and it inherited a legacy structure, 50% of its fundraising is to satisfy the Charities Regulator. While that is necessary, and I cannot see any other way around it, there is scope to have a more agile approach for smaller charities, as Ms Delaney mentioned. I will leave that with her as a point. It is a more significant number than I expected when she said 12%.
In those other charities that have staff, active boards and governance structures, you would expect that these obligations are not onerous. The issues at the Peter McVerry Trust came as a surprise to many people. When and how did the Charities Regulator become aware of the issues and what was its immediate response?
Comment on this
We first became aware of it in July 2023, when we received a letter from the former CEO. It was addressed-----
Comment on this
They are identified as chief executive No. 2 in the report.
Comment on this
Yes, that is correct. The letter referred to some cash flow difficulties but not beyond normal ranges and there was nothing to worry about, etc. We had information in our possession because we had been looking at a separate concern regarding the organisation, which is why we had obtained a lot of information. We asked for some specific information relating to a meeting referred to in the letter and a financial sustainability plan they had at that time. We put that together with the other information. We made contact with the Approved Housing Bodies Regulatory Authority, AHBRA, and requested a significant amount of information under our statutory powers.
Comment on this
That is the first concern. Had the cash flow or the financial operational management not become an issue, it is likely that we might not have discovered the many other areas such as the co-mingling of donations, restricted and unrestricted funds, and issues of poor governance decisions by the board and so on. For the Charities Regulator, that must be a lesson in the sense that had the day-to-day operational challenges of cash flow and meeting budgets not been flagged, we would not have known about the other areas. Is that something Ms Delaney has reflected on?
Comment on this
Yes, it is something we have been reflecting on, even before the extent of it has come to light. It goes back to what we have said about needing to be more proactive. We need to try to use some of our resources to be more proactive in our monitoring. The nature of the financial statements that companies and charities have to file now is such that they can tell us little or nothing. Even if we were looking, we might not see it. The idea of the amendments in the amendment Act is that they will introduce, by ministerial regulation, certain requirements in relation to those accounts and they will be akin to the standard required in the UK, which is the charities statements of recommended practice, SORP. That gives much more information. Our ability to act and for the public to see it will be better.
Comment on this
Does Ms Delaney accept that the relationship between CEO and chair is key? The governance issues or the protection of the public interest really rely on the board. When there is an entirely voluntary board and chairperson, however, without the independent resources of the staffing of the organisation, the board can be in a very weak position to monitor what is happening in the organisation.
Comment on this
There is a sense in some charities that we are recognising that the board is weak vis-à-vis the executive but that is completely in the wrong order.
Comment on this
I agree, but does Ms Delaney accept the resourcing of the board is the issue there? I am not speaking about a particular case here, but if there was any attempt by a senior staff member, the CEO or staff in general to mislead the board, it could be incredibly difficult for a board that may meet once a month, whose members perhaps do not know each other very well as board members and who do not have any resourcing to get independent advice and so on. I have served on boards and it is very easy for the staff to create a situation where the board is entirely dependent on the information provided by them.