We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Financial Statements 2023 - Charities Regulatory Authority

Contributions 139–275 of 275. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Ms Madeleine Delaney

This is why it is very important that charity trustees understand that they are the persons legally responsible for the control and management. They do that by putting in place the governance framework, which sets out the boundaries. This is where the work comes in at the outset and then keeping it up to date. We produce a lot of material on this. That sets the boundaries and limits within which the employees operate. It says what decisions are reserved to them, what information they require to make those decisions and then standard reports and the detail of those that have to be produced.

Comment on this

Ms Delaney is outlining the obligations of the directors and the board and I do not take from those.

My point is that many directors find it very difficult to fulfil that because they are entirely dependent for resourcing and expertise and information on the people who work within the organisation. Where it goes wrong, that is often the challenge.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

That is one of the reasons we have the charities governance code. It sets out everything the trustees need to look at, put in place, ask their employees to help them put in place and report on. That is specific guidance for trustees to know how to discharge their obligations and protect themselves. You redress the balance by saying that we have the code of governance; that we know what it means, which is this, this and this; that we are putting this in place; and that you need to report to us on it.

Comment on this

In some cases in community structures, for example, the people involved are very well meaning but perhaps do not have the experience and so on. That is the weakness of corporate governance in Ireland. It is the reason we will have other instances. We are not resourcing the boards. That brings me to my second point, which is the recruitment and retention of board members. Why in God's name would anybody volunteer to be on a board where the responsibility is so onerous and they have no resources to exercise their function, other than those controlled by the CEO and the organisation? We are hanging many directors out to dry. In some cases these bodies are spending almost entirely State money.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

The Deputy's time is up.

Comment on this

We can look at youth centres and community structures across the country. This is the spending of public money and it is governed by volunteers we are not providing sufficient resources to. These are the charities Ms Delaney and her colleagues regulate.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Does Ms Delaney want to respond?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

No.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

I understand exactly where Deputy McAuliffe was going. He focused on the ones with very few resources. What is the profile of the ones that are at the very top? What percentage has significant resources?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

It is a small percentage. Those which have over €5 million are 5.5%.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

What kind of organisations are they?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

Some of those are public bodies, like the HSE and universities. I have a list of them here. We have this information. We conduct as much research as we can and we analyse the information we have in the annual reports, which are on our website.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Ms Delaney might just give us a list.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

Yes, we can send in a list.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

That is fine. Deputy Farrell is next.

Comment on this

Gabhaim buíochas leis an Leas-Chathaoirleach agus leis na finnéithe as teacht os comhair an choiste. In the briefing pack it is mentioned that the Charities Regulator is responsible for the registration and regulation of charities in Ireland. Can I take it that the regulator grants charitable trust ownership structures to companies here as well? In other words, they must apply to have that status.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

If they are operating in Ireland they must apply, yes.

Comment on this

All right. Under the 2009 Act, the regulator is required to ensure and monitor compliance by charitable organisations and to carry out investigations in accordance with the Act. Does that apply to all companies with a charitable ownership structure?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

Yes, all charitable organisations.

Comment on this

Does this include the type of structures that are traded within the IFSC?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

No. There is a specific exclusion there-----

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

-----under section 8 of the Act.

Comment on this

I understand the regulator looked into this in 2017 and I think four companies were identified as using that section 110. Am I correct?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

I am sorry, but I am not aware. I would have to come back to the Deputy on that.

Comment on this

According to a press statement from 2017 that the regulator has on its website:

The Charities Regulator has completed a review of registered charities holding shares in section 110 companies on trust. The purpose of the review was to establish the number of registered Irish charities holding shares in section 110 companies and to determine whether they fell within the remit of the Charities Act 2009.

Two of the main conclusions were that "Four registered charities were identified as holding shares in section 110 companies on trust" and "Of the identified registered charities, one was de-registered because the organisation fell within the scope of section 8 of the Charities Act". My understanding of that is there were three that would not have been deregistered.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

I would have to come back and confirm that further.

Comment on this

It would be fantastic if that could be brought to the committee. I am talking about three structures and obviously I am not aware of what three they were or anything like that, so I am not speaking about them. I am sure they are doing fabulous work. When the regulator is looking at those I assume it looks into the background of them, such as the way they are constituted and if there is a parent company or whatever it may be. All that gets looked at. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

Yes.

Comment on this

That is good. I asked about that because over the last two and a half years there has been significant interest in the IFSC and IFSC-based shell companies that often use charitable trust ownership structures. Some of these firms have billions in assets. We know about some examples from research carried out by academics in Trinity College showing that Russian-connected funds funnelled €118 billion through the IFSC over a 12-year period. Naturally with shell companies it is often very difficult to see what the parent company is and all those things, but some of these were connected to Gazprom and one was related to the Russian military. Of those 122 shell companies, over half had charitable trust ownership. Ms Delaney mentioned that some, under section 8, do not fall under the regulator and that is fine. Some do, as we know from the regulator's press statement. How do companies, structures or whatever one wants to call them acquire this kind of status? There is a concern because in many senses they are as far removed as can be imagined from a charity structure. I understand about section 8, but I would like the regulator to touch on that in general.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

Is the Deputy asking how we go about looking at these structures?

Comment on this

Yes, in order to acquire status.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

To my knowledge, we have not had an application from any of these structures.

Comment on this

Okay, but from the regulator's press statement there was the suggestion there were three that were using section 110. Ms. Delaney may wish to come back on that. I am just asking these questions because it is something I have a long interest in and it has been in the public eye. The Department of Finance did a review of section 110 in its entirety in the last year. Did it at any point ask the regulator to feed into that?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

No.

Comment on this

Okay. On the back of this, I ask the regulator to come back to the committee with detail. It could look back to 2017 and see what the story is with those three structures and whether there have been any others. An Teachta Verona Murphy outlined the concern about the amount of staff the regulator has to look through 11,060 charities and whether it has enough funding to be able to look at these kind of things in their entirety. I ask the regulator to come back to us specifically on that.

Something that stood out to me was that you went from a deficit of €6.3 million to a surplus of €79.1 million. It seems like a massive saving. I am wondering how that turnaround happened.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

Sorry, Deputy, which accounts are you looking at?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

Are these the financial statements for the Charities Regulator or for the charity funds?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

It is €79,000.

Comment on this

It is €79,000. I had just assumed. At least the regulator has moved from having a deficit to a surplus.

I raise the issue of Stewarts Care, which was investigated by the HSE.

I am just wondering what role the Charities Regulator had and why there was no charity regulator involved in any investigation.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

Without wishing to comment specifically on any particular organisation, one of the issues we have in terms of dealing with everything that comes in is that, as the Charities Regulator, we still only look at what is within our remit, so we look at governance matters. We cannot look at service delivery, contracts, employment issues or anything like that. It is simply where there are governance matters that we can get involved. We have a good relationship with the HSE, with which we have a memorandum of understanding. Typically, if another organisation is looking at something substantive, unless there is a need for us to do something urgent, we will not be in there at the same time because, of course, it is very disruptive to the organisation as well. Without talking about specifics, that is how we would approach matters.

Comment on this

At any point does Ms Delaney feel that she would like to have greater powers in that respect? Does Ms Delaney think it would be of benefit if the Charities Regulator had the funding and the resources put into it?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

If there is another organisation, provided that we are working with it and it is working with us, I do not see that we would need to duplicate that.

Comment on this

That is fair.

Following up from my colleague Deputy Brady's query about gathering data on CEO remuneration, obviously we see so many fantastic charities across this State that put huge work in, and so many people are constantly supporting it, but there have been times when people have had concerns about the remuneration of CEOs. That is something that has had quite a focus placed on it, and there is the impact that has had as well on people's confidence and their willingness to put money in it. Does Ms Delaney think it would be good to have a situation whereby we could look at what charities, or what percentage of charities, provide salaries to their CEOs that would place them in the top 1% of income earners?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

We try to keep adding the items of information to the annual report form, which is where we can set out what information needs to be produced, and, obviously, we display that. Besides that, we very much encourage charities to disclose all this information on their websites and more. It is interesting that the Deputy should mention the CEO salaries in relation to trust and confidence, because that is out there, but the top reason for maybe not having as much trust and confidence in charities as they would otherwise that is given by members of the public when we do surveys - we do a biannual survey - is the lack of transparency from charities. Really, the CEO issue is a subset of people feeling overall that charities are not producing the information they want - not just financial. People actually want to know the stories about what has gone on. They really do. That gives them a sense that they are making a difference with their money. It is all tied up in the one. Charities perhaps would benefit more from being very open and transparent about this and taking on board any feedback because in this case people will vote with their money. That is how it will be managed.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Delaney. Just-----

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Thank you. Your time is up, Deputy. There will be time for a second round. I call Deputy Ó Cathasaigh.

Comment on this

To pick up on Ms Delaney's final point, it highlights the importance of the Charities Regulator and its role. When people donate to a charity, they understand that there are administrative costs and staffing costs but they like to think that the money, or a large percentage of it, is doing what it says on the tin. The Charities Regulator is incredibly important in that. We have had a couple of very high-profile instances where people's money was not being used to best effect. The regulator's role as watchdog in that regard is very important.

I have few enough questions. Broadly speaking, we have an organisation here that has two clear audit opinions and is doing what it is supposed to be doing, but I have a couple of questions. First, to draw on the Comptroller and Auditor General's statement at the start, I do not much like this common investment fund. They say sunlight is the best disinfectant. I would like to be able to shed some light on the fund. We do not have oversight of that, as the Committee of Public Accounts, and nor does the Comptroller and Auditor General. I think the stated purpose is to support smaller charities, in particular, to invest collectively charitable funds that were not required for immediate use and to return a balance. That is fine and well - I do not mind the objective - but it is €41.6 million that I cannot have a look at. Is there any material barrier to that being consolidated into the charity funds account properly in order that the Comptroller and Auditor General can have oversight and then, by extension, we can have oversight of it?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

I would have to check that from a legal perspective. These are charitable funds that are owned by these entities that are invested in this way. It is very much a product of its time. It is something we inherited from the Commissioners of Charitable Donations and Bequests. It is something that the board is currently actively looking at. I can certainly ask that we examine the Deputy's request from a legal perspective as regards his getting sight of it. As it stands, I am advised that they are funds of these charities, so in that sense they are private funds. That is why they are not subject to the Comptroller and Auditor General, although the Comptroller and Auditor General obviously checks the ins and outs of what goes through the charity funds account which we hold. However, I understand the Deputy's concerns about it.

Comment on this

It is the one thing that jumped out from the Comptroller and Auditor General's report. I would like to be able to see that money a little more clearly. I am not making any suggestion that there is anything untoward there, but we have seen at this committee other funds that were maybe less than transparent being used for all sorts of interesting items like flip-flops and so on. I do not suspect there are any flip-flops happening here, but we would just like to have a better line of sight.

Comment on this
Ms Colette Drinan

There are audited financial statements available publicly; it is just that the Comptroller and Auditor General does not audit them.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Drinan.

I was involved in the Charities (Amendment) Act, which was passed by the select committee on rural and community development, of which I am a member. Ms Delaney said that some parts of this important Act are not commenced yet. I was going to say "Bill", but it was signed into law on, I think, 10 July. There were earlier questions about staffing and resourcing for the Charities Regulator. This Bill will put extra work on the regulator. A lot of the provisions of the Bill are very good in terms of lessening the onerous workload Deputy McAuliffe talked about, for example. If we are to commence all parts of the Act, which I would like to see happen, will that have an impact on the regulator's resourcing?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

Absolutely, yes, in terms of both the changes required to the IT system and staffing resources.

Comment on this

Are the ICT system changes likely to be contracted out in the way Ms Delaney was describing earlier?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

Yes. We currently have a system and making any changes to it is quite difficult and cumbersome and the end product for the user is not very easy to use. Depending on timing, we are looking at a new digital system which could possibly properly incorporate the changes that are required on foot of the amendment Act. Certainly, in looking at what we can introduce as soon as possible, we are looking at those that have the least amount of IT impact or impact on our resources.

Comment on this

Very good. I suppose that is more a future-facing question so perhaps it is not really properly a question for this committee.

The atomic bomb the regulator can deploy is to have somebody removed from the charities register. Is that a power that is often invoked?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

It was not until very recently. What we have found as part of our special project into annual reporting is that a lot of the charities that have failed to engage with us at all or to file an annual report are inactive. In those situations, once we have taken appropriate steps to ascertain that, we have removed them. They account for the 31 we have removed so far as part of that project.

Comment on this

Okay, and there are eight prosecutions initiated out of the 1,700 charities.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

Yes.

Comment on this

What is the current status of those prosecutions?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

They have all concluded.

Comment on this

Are many more charities being considered? Are there more prosecutions on the way?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

I know the work is ongoing and they are being considered. I do not have precise numbers but a recommendation comes to me for either a removal or a prosecution.

Comment on this

How much of the staffing resource of the Charities Regulator is dedicated towards these kinds of prosecutions or removal from the register?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

We have one staff member at HEO grade who effectively works full time on this project and has done for the best part of a year. Our legal adviser has been working with her. We also ran those prosecutions in-house because we had a previous prosecution that we gave to our external advisers. It has not yet been heard but that is through no fault of theirs or ours. There has just been a number of instances of coming back for dates. That cost us approximately €30,000, without the case being heard. We have run those ones ourselves between either just attending ourselves or getting a local solicitor to attend. It takes a lot of work for our in-house legal adviser.

Comment on this

This is an unusual question for the committee but is the regulator under-resourced in that area? I am surprised the regulator has only one dedicated staff member working on this.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

We had one dedicated staff member who was doing that. We have sought and been granted approval, in principle, for another dedicated legal adviser to do that. We were able to do the work by doing it in-house for less than €10,000 for the eight prosecutions.

Comment on this

That is very good. I will ask a very big question in two minutes and I do not suppose we will get to the bottom of it. Approved housing bodies are becoming a bigger part of housing provision and they are going to become difficult. There are encumbered assets with loans against them. There are unencumbered assets where some of these houses are being bought through fund-raising and have no mortgage attached. We will end up with ostensibly charitable bodies with a very large asset base and income streams derived from the asset base. Is Ms Delaney content that robust systems are in place? We have the Peter McVerry Trust where systems have broken down. There is a special report on that which people can read at their leisure. Is Ms Delaney content that the structures are in place to deal with what is going to be a very large asset base and very large income streams?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

That cohort of the sector is particularly complicated and troublesome. There are 438 approved housing bodies.

Comment on this

Is it open to AHBs to change from charitable status? One of my concerns is that AHBs with charitable status may decide to change their status, which would lead to a complicated question about assets.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

No, it should not be as in their governing document says what they have to do. Again when we are looking at them as part of the registration process, we look at what we call "key standard clauses" to see that they have them, which locks in the property for the charitable purpose. They cannot just stop being a charity and decide to do something else. That is how it works unless people want to go rogue but there should be checks and balances within the organisation to do that and that is the protection. A difficulty might be that most of the AHBs on our register were grandfathered on to the register so they did not have to come through so we were not have able to run the rule over them and make sure that they have all of those clauses in place and I cannot guarantee that they are all protected as they should be. Some of them are quite loose associations.

Comment on this

Has the regulator the power to retrospectively make sure the clauses are in place?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

This is something that we need to do. We will work more closely with the Approving Housing Bodies Regulator on this because it is obviously aware of the connection. We need to start identifying the different cohorts and the AHBR will have more information than we do. That will help us identify ones where maybe we can look at them and check the status of their various governing documents and all of that. However, it may be quite tenuous in some cases because some of them are very old, loose and tenuous. A certain amount of consolidation has occurred, which is probably a good thing, whereby some of the smaller, older entities, with just maybe a few volunteers running them, merging or transferring the property to another approved housing body and that is probably a good thing because, again, when we talk about the governance and the need for trustees to be aware of their obligations, it is as much for their protection as for the good running because they are vulnerable.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

I thank Ms Delaney for answering. It was a very big question that took up two minutes. I have no doubt we will come back to this matter, including for the benefit of myself. I suggest that Deputy O'Connor makes his contribution before we take a break.

Comment on this

I welcome all the witnesses. The Peter McVerry Trust is in the headlines for the wrong reasons, which has prompted a lot of questions that need to be answered around what merits the Charities Regulator getting involved to undertake investigative work. Under Part IV of the Charities Act 2009, the Charities Regulator has the power to appoint investigators to investigate the affairs of any charitable organisation. I am interested in the inspectorate capacity. Where the regulator feels it may merit, because of the period that has elapsed where the Charities Regulator has not undertaken the auditing of accounts of charities, where does the remit lay? I come from a farming family and in that setting, inspections can be carried out by inspectors from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine, the local authority, the county council or the Health and Safety Authority. Inspectors can show up at a premises unannounced. Where the books are concerned, a body can be investigated by Revenue. Any charity the size of the Peter McVerry Trust can have a large amount of cash received from donations, a significant number of assets and so on. Has the Charities Regulator the power to undertake an investigation itself or does an investigation only taken place on foot of a complaint? In the case of the Peter McVerry Trust, the matter was first raised with the regulator by the chief executive highlighting discrepancies.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

We can initiate investigations in our own right. We do not need to have received a complaint in order to do that.

Comment on this

In how many instances has that happened? As the Peter McVerry Trust grew between 2011 and 2022, I understand that it took over nine separate charities. The trust’s remit is supposed to be housing and homelessness, but the purpose of one of those charities was the advancement of religion, which is not one of the trust’s charitable purposes. The trust is in receipt of significant funding. I just want some insight into this matter. The regulator gets a lot of State funding. How often has the regulator stepped in to undertake an investigation on its own merit or where it felt an organisation was so large that it needed to step in?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

Investigation and the appointment of inspectors is the thin end of our powers and we do not use it in all cases, which is why there have been so few investigations overall. The bulk of our activity is done on a one-to-one basis with the charities without appointing inspectors where we can get the information asses it and sort out the issues, and the charities are co-operative and willing to implement whatever measures are needed. This represents the vast majority of the work we do. We closed 654 concerns last year but only appointed one inspector. This gives the committee a flavour of the situation.

I will try to get the Deputy a figure for the number of investigations that we initiate ourselves.

Comment on this

An approximate figure is okay.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

We can come back to the Deputy after the break on that.

Comment on this

The reason I ask is there is a lot of grime on the window of the immigrant investor programme, IIP, which I am concerned about. Nobody is quite sure why it was shut down. A number of charities were involved in the process of obtaining it. There are multiple reasons - "issues occurred" and pressure from the European Commission and other aspects at an international level but looking at the facts and figures, there was nearly exponential growth in the number of applications for IIP funding. Large sums were flowing into organisations beyond charities, in all fairness, but also from a charity angle. Were concerns raised with the Charities Regulator about the IIP system and misuse of funding in that regard? Have any cases come before the Charities Regulator in that respect? Was it discussed in 2023 in the context of media reports on the scheme being closed down or mooted developments that it was going to be shut down, which it was, by the Government?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

I am not aware of any specific concerns raised about the investor programme itself but I will check for the Deputy and come back to him after the break. We looked at perhaps two or three charities - I will come back with a figure - which might have had some funding from that programme but that was not necessarily specifically what we were looking at.

Comment on this

Will Ms Delaney elaborate on that? She said it was not something the Charities Regulator was specifically looking at.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

It might just have been coincidental, if you like, that they had that funding. The complaint we had was not about the funding or that might not have been the issue.

Comment on this

I want to be careful; I am not from a legal profession but I want to ask the question because it is relevant. Is Ms Delaney aware of many charitable bodies accountable to the Charities Regulator from an inspection point of view that left that structure and went into a company limited by guarantee structure or out of the charity structure to obtain funds from the IIP?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

No, I am not aware.

Comment on this

Ms Delaney is not aware of that.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

I am not aware of any specific instances of that happening.

Comment on this

I encourage Ms Delaney to do some digging. It has been brought to my attention as a Member of the Oireachtas. I will not bring it up but it has crossed my desk.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

I hope the Deputy reported it.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

Please do.

Comment on this

I will defer to the second round because I am interested some of the responses. Is that okay, Chairperson?

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Yes. We will take a ten-minute break. The meeting is suspended.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

I welcome the witnesses back. I want to go back to the issue Deputy Ó Cathasaigh raised regarding approved housing bodies. I appreciate that some predate by a considerable distance the existence of the Charities Regulator. I have serious concerns about the asset base of properties for which the mortgage is paid off and that are now unencumbered. A couple of years ago, the Department of housing and AHB representative organisations were before the committee. I pursued this issue and tried to find out who owns the asset when it is unencumbered. Looking back at the minutes of that meeting, I was told that 97% of AHBs are charities and as a result, their assets are charitable assets. I wanted to find out the beneficial owners and, for example, whether the directors own the assets. It was confirmed that was correct. Obviously, somebody has to own them. Is this a red flag for the Charities Regulator? The witnesses mentioned red flags and things they watch for. For example, if a charity changed its status and constitution, that is where the real risk is. Does that jump out at the regulator? Does the charity have to notify the regulator? Can it deregister as a charity? How does that work?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

Currently, it does not have to notify us of changes to its constitution. A lot do but there is a provision in the amendment Act to make sure they do, which is an important protection. They cannot come off the register without contacting us. If they were a charity that came on the register by virtue of having a CHY from Revenue Commissioners, which many have, then they contact the Revenue Commissioners about that, currently. That is how the process works. When we are notified by Revenue, we look at the profile of any charity looking to come off the register and why. If we think there is a risk to the assets, that is where we intervene. Our ability to intervene if we have the information - that is the big point - is contained in section 74 of the Act, which allows us to apply to the High Court. We are concerned with the charitable assets not particularly with the charity. We want the charity to succeed but a lot of what we do is around protecting those charitable assets. The directors hold those but they do so for the benefit of the people using them, the beneficiaries.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

The Charities Regulator is doing a piece of work with the Approved Housing Bodies Regulatory Authority. What is that work?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

We have just started. We have good contacts with the approved bodies regulator. We have a memorandum of understanding in place under which we have operated for the purposes of the recent investigation.

There was a gap between CEOs there as there was in my organisation so I recently got together with the new CEO and we made some plans for how we will work together in the future, but we have to finalise them. We recognise we need to co-operate and share the intelligence we have on the various organisations.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

My attention was drawn to it when someone who was on the board of a small approved housing body was talking about their portfolio of properties. I was absolutely shocked by that. That is what prompted me to start asking questions about this. In theory, an organisation could change its constitution, but there are protections.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

Yes, there are protections, but in theory it could or it could try to.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

That goes to the governance and whoever is on the board of directors.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

Yes, it depends on who the trustees are and what the rules say about making such a fundamental change. Normally, members would have control in that instance. There are some controls on people being able to do such a fundamental thing and it could not be passed without them getting support from their membership. There are a number of different things in place, but in theory an organisation could and we would have to rely on someone telling us that it was trying to do this unbeknownst to us.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

I am trying to envisage a situation. In the way AHBs are set up, there is often co-operation with the local authority. There would be a piece of land and housing would be developed, and that would be important because it brings some affordable housing supply. Some of this goes back decades. The bigger ones are of less concern because they were set up in a modern context and they are professional organisations. Some of the others rely on volunteers. They would have been set up with the intention of people being drawn primarily from the social housing list, though not exclusively - I think it was 75:25 - and the rent would be different depending on what stream the tenants came from. The Charities Regulator does not have a function to look at the how the approved housing bodies operate. They could in theory charge 100% market rents, if you like. There would be a big income and that is not what was intended. That is the remit of the Approved Housing Bodies Regulatory Authority.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

It is in the first instance, but there is a fallback position with the Charities Regulator because those on the register have to have a charitable purpose. If AHBs want to be a charity to access the charitable tax relief and all that comes with it, which is necessary for many of them, they have to stay on our register because that is a prerequisite for Revenue. One of the things we look at to the extent we can is where charities came on to the register but not through our process. Even if they were not operating in a particular way to begin with but perhaps start to operate in a way that brings them outside the definition, we can look at them and take them off the register. In that instance, however, we would also have to protect the assets.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Who would bring that to the attention of the Charities Regulator? Is there something that can be identified in the accounts? Is it a question of a complaint coming to the regulator? Where are the routes from which it would get that information?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

We are reliant a lot on getting information from people, but one of the reasons we need to engage with the Approved Housing Bodies Regulatory Authority is that we need to understand the sector from its perspective. It has more information on the AHBs than we do, including on their make-up. We can try to identify then where we think the greater risks are by virtue of how they are structured, what their constitutions look like and how much they engage with us and engage the register. They are all things we could look at. We can also proactively check whether they have the measures in their constitutions they should have. We can check whether they are applying the model they were intended to apply as opposed to just renting accommodation. It can fall back to us, but the Approved Housing Bodies Regulatory Authority would be best placed to look at it initially.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Some of the 11,000-odd charities are schools and sporting clubs and some charities are public services that, in other jurisdictions, would be public services rather than charities providing services to the public. One of the biggest responsibilities of the Charities Regulator is to make sure the public has trust in the other cohort of more recognised charities, if you like. There have been catastrophic failures. Console would have been a case in point. The Peter McVerry Trust is in a different category, but there were some serious governance issues which the regulator identified in its report, such as the inadequate management of accounts, including basic stuff like the level of debtors and creditors and debt financing. It is documented well in the report. Other than it being brought to the regulator's attention, how would Ms Delaney identify similar failures in other high-profile charities?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

There could be certain issues such as people resigning. The late filing of annual reports is sometimes a flag for us. If an organisation is normally on time and is well funded and resourced, there could be something wrong if that happens. It could be from general intelligence. People talk about stuff and we might look things up. For such things that are not obvious externally, however, we are reliant to a large degree on receiving reports and information from third parties.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Okay. The Department would have had to have provided funding. Homelessness is an escalating problem. I remember the first time I raised the issue of a family sleeping in a car. It was ten years ago. It was 2014 and that kind of thing was unheard of before that. There would have been a cohort of people who would have been rough sleeping who would have had complex issues. It now primarily results from people getting eviction notices, not being able to pay the rent and so on. That is an area that is escalating and chaotic and it is new. It is difficult to forward plan unless the plan is to undo homelessness. Local authorities, in many cases, are partnering with homeless charities or the Dublin Region Homeless Executive has a remit to engage those charities to do the work directly. Is there a conflict of interest with the local authorities in terms of oversight? Does the Charities Regulator have a role in that? As the local authorities are part of the State, does the Charities Regulator anticipate that they do a lot of the regulation?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

As they are the ones that are in a position to know what activities the organisation is engaging in or plans to engage in and as they provide significant funding, I would expect that, like any investor or anyone providing a loan, they would carry out certain due diligence to check that the structures and processes are in place to be able to handle that level of funding. That is an assumption we would make on that side of things.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

On the Department and the Peter McVerry Trust, the Department would have had to provide it with funding or it would have got funding through the Dublin Region Homeless Executive.

It possibly got funding from other local authorities as well. As the local authority in Kildare partners with the Peter McVerry Trust with regard to one of the homeless facilities, there is a direct relationship there. Did the Charities Regulator not pay as much attention by virtue of the fact that it expected the local authorities to have that oversight?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

No, I do not think so. Where it is relevant is when we did become aware of it, we had less of a concern about the assets and the services than we would have had if there was not a funder such as the Department or the Dublin Region Homeless Executive in there. We might have had to look to our powers under section 74 and see whether we needed to intervene to protect those services and assets. In the sense that the Department or the Dublin Region Homeless Executive was in there, we were satisfied that the assets and services were not at risk.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

I will turn to 11.15 of the C and AG's report on page 181, which states:

The checking included one spot check of the Peter McVerry Trust's expenditure, seeking invoices to substantiate expenditure in quarter 1 of €94,206. The [Dublin Region Homeless Executive] explained to the Department that quarter one funding is not invoice based and therefore the Department could [not] exercise the control check on invoices in quarters 2, 3 [and] 4. The Department accepted the [Dublin Region Homeless Executive's] explanation and stated that it would consider a further spot check of invoices in the next quarter, but this was not done.

It all seems very loose. I cannot see where there is that hands-on approach. When people see the Dublin Region Homeless Executive or the Charities Regulator, there is a degree of comfort that somebody has oversight but then it is not complied with. Does the Charities Regulator engage with the Dublin Region Homeless Executive in respect of that or has it any function on that?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

No, we do not.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Okay.

The organisation has 13 members on the board. Do they rotate and how often? Obviously there is a governance issue here.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

They are appointed by the Minister for a five-year term. Some may be reappointed, some are not. The normal process is run through publicjobs.ie to identify candidates. We might have two or three coming off the board in any one year.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Nonetheless, in theory they could all be there for five years and they could be renewed for another five years.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

In theory, they could.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

That would not be good governance practice but that is not down to Ms Delaney, it is down to the Minister. Ms Delaney has identified the number of complaints or concerns of which she was notified and specifically identified 15 on which she is taking further action. What are they?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

The 15 that I referenced in my opening statement concerned charities which did not engage with us voluntarily to provide information so that we could assess what was going on and then engage with them to resolve whatever the issue was. Those are the instances where we have invoked our statutory power to require them to produce the information and if they do not, there is a sanction for that. The purpose of illustrating the 15 was to say that most charities do engage and resolve issues. Most of these issues are around governance.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Is there anything more than that with any of them, that is, other than regarding compliance?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

No, as I say, it is the rare occasion when we feel the situation warrants appointing inspectors, which is a more public-facing and formal aspect of the work. We engage an external party as well. All of the other work is done internally on a one-to-one basis with charities and it can be quite intensive.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Okay. Ms Delaney talked about using intelligence and information, including data. I am curious whether the organisation ever used Benefacts for the information it used to provide?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

We did not use the information. We were obviously aware of the organisation and it might have mined some of our information for its work. Benefacts covered the charity and the not-for-profit sectors. Obviously we are just one subset of that and we never used Benefacts ourselves.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

It was very useful to have the information in one location. I might ask the departmental official about a replacement for Benefacts. That was talked about at the time. I could not for the life of me understand why it would not have that in place before it closed down a valuable source of information. Where is that at the moment?

Comment on this
Mr. Jake Ryan

I thank the Chair. I understand the Department of Taoiseach is looking at national funding platform at the moment. We are continuing to engage and support it with that.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Is it not Mr. Ryan's Department that will be dealing with a replacement for that platform?

Comment on this
Mr. Jake Ryan

Not as far as I know.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

It was my understanding that was the case. I can check that out with the Department of the Taoiseach. I am trying to figure out the information but our witnesses really are scratching around in the dark. Looking at other similar institutions in other jurisdictions, have they a stronger function? Have they more powers or information that is more readily available to them? What are we looking at in terms of what the ideal would be?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

The Chair has hit on the important point of information there. A difference in the other jurisdictions that is of advantage to them is that they supervise all of the charities on their register that apply through them. Therefore, the quality of the information and making sure their governance documents are what is required are all in a better position than it is for us. We are on the back foot in respect of making sure that we have all the information that we need but also that the public should have. That is one thing. The powers are quite similar, with just small differences. In England and Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland, they each have a power to appoint somebody - they call it an interim manager - to go in to an organisation on a short-term basis. That is something they can do themselves. We have to apply to the High Court for that. There is nothing to say we could not go in on an urgent injunctive basis but that is quite a difference between the two.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

To return to Ms Delaney's own organisation, what benefits are staff receiving in terms of health insurance, car allowance or anything like that?

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

None.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

None. Okay, that is fine.

Regarding the positions, Ms Delaney talked about a very small number of vacancies. What kind of expertise does the regulator have and is there anything it has applied for in terms of additional resources for expertise? I presume she looks for resources all of the time. She might give us an idea of what she thinks is needed.

Comment on this
Ms Madeleine Delaney

The vast majority of the very important work of dealing with applications for registration and with the concerns that come in - and indeed that is done in the early stages of processing applications under the charity services Act, which is done at the EO grade - is basically our own training of those people. We are very lucky that we have some really good people that we are managing to retain for a particular time. An accountancy background is another important aspect and there are a number of accountants in the organisation. The director himself is an accountant on the compliance and enforcement side. The one area we realised we needed a bit more support in - and hopefully we are at the start of getting that support - is on the legal side. There is quite a lot of law underpinning much of this, even back before the Charities Act, because it is informed by the common law and the cases that were there before that. There is also the charity services work, which is to do with trusts and properties and all of that.

We need to have enough internal resources to help the others to do their job. We have identified that. It is not something you can buy in. Somebody can help externally to defend proceedings or bring proceedings. However, we need our knowledge and understanding internally to be able to carry out our job effectively. They are two particular areas that we need.

We also have quite a demand on our communications function because we, quite rightly, get a lot of queries from the Oireachtas. We have a dedicated Oireachtas email address. We get a lot of email queries and representative queries and also an awful lot of queries from the public. That is a very important part of what we do. In fact, we are realising we probably need to do more on that because there are many matters that people need to understand and things that need to be explained to them. We do it all day every day and we have to remember that other people do not. We need to do a lot more with explaining and reinforcing our messaging.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

I have no more questions. I thank the witnesses and the staff of the Charities Regulator and the Department of Rural and Community Development for the work involved in preparing for today's meeting. I also thank Ms Colette Drinan and the staff of the Comptroller and Auditor General's office for attending and assisting the committee today.

Is it agreed that the clerk should seek any follow-up information and carry out any agreed actions arising from the meeting? Agreed. Is it also agreed that we note and publish the opening statement and briefing provided for today's meeting? Agreed.

Comment on this