Vote 13 - Office of Public Works
Contributions 1–235 of 710. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No apologies have been received.
You are all very welcome. I remind all those in attendance to ensure that your mobile phones are on silent or switched off.
I wish to explain some limitations to parliamentary privilege and the practice of the Houses as regards references witnesses may make to other persons in their evidence. The evidence of witnesses physically present or who give evidence from within the parliamentary precincts is protected, pursuant to both the Constitution and statute, by absolute privilege. This means they have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at the meeting. However, they are expected not to abuse this privilege, and it is my duty as Leas-Chathaoirleach to ensure that this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if their statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that they comply with any such direction.
Members and witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the Houses or an official either by name or in such a way that makes him or her identifiable. Members are also reminded of the provisions of Standing Order 218, that the committee shall refrain from inquiring into the merits of a policy or policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government or the merits of the objectives of such policies.
The Comptroller and Auditor General, Mr. Seamus McCarthy, is a permanent witness to the committee. He is accompanied by Ms Irena Grzebieniak, deputy director of the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General.
This morning, we will engage with representatives from the Office of Public Works to examine the appropriation accounts of 2023, Vote 13, and the Report on the Accounts of the Public Services 2023 - chapter 4, adapting flood risk management to climate change impacts, and chapter 5, delivery of rapid-build housing.
We are joined by the following representatives from the Office of Public Works: Mr. John Conlon, chairman; Mr. Robert Mooney, head of planning and climate adaptation; Mr. Jim Casey, head of flood risk management; Ms Cathleen Morrison, head of estate management; Ms Rosemary Collier, head of heritage services; and Mr. Pat Fitzsimons, head of corporate services. We are also joined by Ms Ciara Morgan, principal officer, OPW Vote, Department of Public Expenditure, National Development Plan Delivery and Reform. You are all very welcome.
I now call the Comptroller and Auditor General, Mr. Seamus McCarthy, to make his opening statement.
Comment on this
The 2023 appropriation account for Vote 13, Office of Public Works, records gross expenditure of €657.5 million. Appropriations-in-aid of the Vote amounted to €27.3 million.
The account is presented under two programme headings. Just under €546 million, or 83% of gross expenditure, was spent on the estate management programme. Almost €112 million, or 17% of the total, was spent on the flood risk management programme.
The OPW provides office and other types of accommodation to other central government Departments and offices, using a combination of leased and State-owned property. The associated costs are a direct charge to the estate management programme. This includes rent payments totalling €105.5 million, property maintenance and supply payments of almost €74 million and public private partnership unitary payments amounting to just over €24 million. Costs associated with the OPW's portfolio of heritage properties amounted to €52.6 million in 2023.
Separate from the building activity charged to Vote 13, the OPW also acts on an agency basis on behalf of other Government Departments and agencies. This mainly relates to the carrying out of major capital works, property maintenance and the leasing of accommodation. The expenditure associated with this agency activity is reflected in the appropriation accounts of the client Departments and agencies.
As indicated in note 2.14, expenditure incurred by the OPW on an agency basis, and not reflected in Vote 13, amounted to €315 million in 2023. The surplus on the vote at the year-end was €16.6 million, which was surrendered back to the Exchequer. I issued a clear audit opinion on the appropriation account, but drew attention to two matters disclosed by the Accounting Officer in the statement on internal financial controls: procurements to the value of €9.3 million in 2023 that were not compliant with public procurement rules and an overpayment of VAT liability of €3.2 million to the Revenue Commissioners that occurred as a result of an error in calculating the November-December 2023 payment. The OPW identified the error shortly after the overpayment occurred, and the full amount was recouped from Revenue in January 2024.
It is generally accepted that many adaptations in infrastructure planning and delivery will be required for Ireland to prepare for and respond to the impacts of climate changes. Chapter 4 of my report on the accounts of the public services for 2023 assesses the progress made in implementing the climate change sectoral adaptation plan for flood risk management, for which the OPW is the lead agency. The report also reviews the governance structure in place in the area of climate change adaptation in Ireland, with the focus on flood risk management.
The adaptation plan for flood risk management includes 21 actions, with 15 groups and organisations responsible for implementing these actions. The OPW is responsible solely or jointly for implementing the highest number of actions.
The 2018 national adaptation framework identified the development of appropriate indicators of climate change adaptation as a priority to enable the monitoring and assessment of progress. The flood risk management adaptation plan identified five interim indicators to be used to measure implementation progress. Two of the selected interim indicators relating to flood risk mapping demonstrate full implementation. However, two other interim indicators related to adaptation planning for individual flood risk management projects reflect very little or no progress between 2019 and 2023. Definitive national adaptation indicators had not yet been defined for Ireland as at June 2024.
The report makes recommendations in the areas of formal reporting mechanisms for progress updates on actions, developing process-based indicators to allow meaningful monitoring of progress and consideration of indicators relating to disaster risk reduction and resilience.
Chapter 5 of my report reviews progress in the delivery of the rapid build programme undertaken to provide accommodation for beneficiaries of temporary protection fleeing from the war in Ukraine. The OPW was tasked with delivering the programme, on an agency basis, on behalf of the Department of Children, Equality, Disability, Integration and Youth. The programme, which commenced on a pilot basis, set out initially to deliver 500 modular units to accommodate 2,000 persons by February 2023 at an estimated cost of €100 million, or €200,000 per unit. The number of units for delivery was subsequently adjusted, eventually settling at 654 units.
There were significant difficulties in identifying sufficient suitable sites in public ownership to locate the developments and delivery of the units took longer than initially envisaged. The original target of 500 units was achieved in early August 2024, some 17 months later than planned. Approximately 87% of the final revised programme of units has now been delivered at ten sites throughout the country, with the completion of units at the final site now expected around April 2025.
Significant cost overruns have also occurred. Between July 2023 and January 2024, the estimated programme delivery cost was revised at least four times. Latest cost projections at the time of finalisation of my report indicate a final projected average cost per unit of approximately €442,000, an overall increase of approximately 120% in the unit price.
Combined with the increased number of units, this represents overall programme expenditure of €289 million.
A cost-reimbursable contract is being used by the OPW to deliver the programme. Under this, the State bears most of the project risk. The OPW has indicated that an assessment of the feasibility of the rapid-build delivery model for future use, including the use of the cost-reimbursable contract, will be carried out on completion of the programme and that any lessons learned will be shared with the Office of Government Procurement. Go raibh maith agat, a Leas-Chathaoirligh.
Comment on this
I thank the Comptroller and Auditor General. As set out in the letter of invitation, I invite Mr. Conlon to make his opening statement. He has five minutes.
Comment on this
I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach for the invitation to attend. As she outlined earlier, I am joined by the members of the OPW management board.
The Comptroller and Auditor General has outlined the main areas of expenditure in our Vote. In addition to dealing with our accounts, the committee also raised a number of topics for discussion. I will address these in my opening statement.
Beginning with flood relief and climate change adaptation, the OPW implements a range of measures to mitigate the impact of flooding. Some 55 flood relief schemes have been completed, while more than 100 others are under way nationwide. The OPW’s climate change sectoral adaptation plan to ensure that communities are protected against increasing flood risk includes: publication of national flood maps for future climate change scenarios, and also for current risk, in respect of river and coastal flooding; inclusion of adaptation plans for all new flood relief scheme projects since 2019 which ensure that climate change is considered in the design process; and implementing a national programme to develop scheme adaptation plans for pre-existing flood relief schemes.
The Comptroller and Auditor General's report contains a chapter on modular homes. The cost of modular homes is higher than forecast. This is because of the emergency nature of the pilot scheme, complications around sites, access issues and problems with utility connections. However, the homes are a State asset with a lifespan of 60 years. They provide shelter for 2,640 people who fled the war in Ukraine and can be used for social housing in the future. The report also states that the cost of the modular homes project is the equivalent of providing rooms in hotels for five years. By any assessment, it is better to have this new State asset than to be renting hotel rooms for five years. This State asset will be available for a further 55 years.
The report acknowledged that the procurement process was compliant. Some 90% of the programme is complete with 2,300 Ukrainians living at ten sites. These families were accommodated within 13 months, which is a relatively short timeframe for housing delivery. An assessment of the delivery of this project will begin shortly and will consider all of the factors.
On the National Children’s Science Centre, planning permission in respect of a site next to the National Concert Hall was granted in March 2024. This project is the subject of arbitration between the Irish Children’s Museum Limited and the OPW. An interim decision in June 2022 found in favour of the Irish Children’s Museum Limited. No financial provision for this project was made in the national development plan due to the ongoing arbitration process and the uncertainty about the timing of the project.
While there is a legal contract, the OPW is conscious that this project should be subject to robust value-for-money analysis before funding is committed. The delivery of the project will require a Government decision involving considerations including: value for money in a business case; funding for the project and a sponsoring Department; governance arrangements for the delivery; and oversight of the facility when opened. The cost predominantly relates to the restoration of the existing building, which is around 58% of the overall cost, and the sustainable reuse of a protected structure already owned by the State.
In regard to the bicycle shelter in Leinster House, I have taken immediate steps to address value-for-money concerns. The OPW’s audit partner is conducting an independent audit of the project and will recommend measures to strengthen the value for money obtained in respect of future projects. I have already introduced new approval financial thresholds in order that all projects valued at between €200,000 and €500,000 will include cost and value-for-money assessments and management board sign-off. These significant changes will improve governance in our project management process and ensure that value for money is central to how we manage taxpayers' money.
The security pavilion at Government Buildings is critical infrastructure for the security of the campus. It is the main access point for vehicles and the vetting area for several critical locations in the complex. While I acknowledge concerns about the high cost of the pavilion, the works undertaken were on foot of a Garda security review of the campus that highlighted real security threats. We are all aware of these threats and of the need to have the highest security standards in place.
Key features of the project include the following. All lighting, heating, and ventilation control systems are located in the roof to maximise efficiency of space in the pavilion. This accounts for the roof thickness. There is integration of power, communications, data, life safety, security and CCTV systems with the rest of the campus. Special security measures include presence detection, access control, physical anti-ram barriers and a rising ramp and the necessary rerouting of existing underground services.
Arising from the report of the forum on a family-friendly and inclusive Parliament in 2021, the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission is considering whether to use the reading room as a second chamber or committee room. The OPW was asked to scope out what this means in practical terms. A decision on the future of the room is a matter for the Dáil reform committee and the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission. I understand that no decision has been taken, and the OPW is not taking any further action at this time.
In relation to procurement, though the Comptroller and Auditor General has reported non-compliance in the OPW, I am committed to improving this area. To address legacy issues, the OPW has already put in place new frameworks to ensure that goods and services are procured compliantly. Furthermore, a new framework for maintenance services valued above €200,000 is almost complete. From 2025 onwards, all new tender competitions for relevant contracts under this framework will be fully compliant with the new rules. I am committed to establishing a procurement advisory unit and will prioritise intensive procurement training for all staff.
I am happy to expand on these and any other matters the committee wishes to discuss. Before I conclude, I want to mention the staff of the OPW, who work hard to deliver for the State. While the organisation has been under considerable scrutiny of late, it is important not to lose sight of the valuable work being done across the country. We cater for 15 million visitors annually to our heritage sites and we deliver projects under the national development plan to the value of almost €4 billion. None of this work would be possible without our people, who are our greatest asset.
I thank the Chairperson for her time. I consider this engagement with the committee and the Comptroller and Auditor General as essential to good governance and accountability and I welcome it.
Comment on this
The lead speaker today is Deputy Verona Murphy, who will have 15 minutes. All other speakers will have ten minutes. I will allow members back in for a second round of questions and we will take a short break at 12.30 p.m.
Comment on this
I will start with Mr. Conlon's remarks about OPW staff. I agree that we have great staff around the country but, unfortunately, it appears that some staff in Dublin have let those staff down. I do not think the issues we are facing around the precincts of Leinster House actually occur around the country. The disregard seems to be Dublin based. I know several OPW staff who carry out their work very diligently.
Regarding the bike shelter, I note Mr. Conlon's comments on what he is doing going forward and I also note that he was not in the position of chair at the time this was being carried out. I welcome the fact that Mr. Conlon is in the position now. However, it is a bit like closing the door when the horse has bolted, unfortunately. This applies not just to the bike shelter but to many projects going forward. Does the OPW prepare its own estimates on jobs such as the bike shelter before they go out to tender?
Comment on this
Yes, as part of any project we deliver, assessments are made of the projected costs for projects.
Comment on this
What was the projected cost, pre-tender, for the bike shelter?
Comment on this
There was an order-of-magnitude costing of €350,000, I believe.
Comment on this
It actually came at less than that.
Comment on this
Yes, less than that order-of magnitude cost.
Comment on this
That did not raise any red flags. Okay. The problem is the excuses given for that type of elaborate structure. I have no doubt that the materials in it warrant the cost. However, the question is whether the bike shelter warranted such materials and this question has not been answered. It appears that the answer from everybody is "No" except for Mr. Conlon and the OPW. Nobody is taking responsibility. The Oireachtas Commission has not done so. The Minister has stated unequivocally that it had nothing to do with him. At the committee last week, Mr. Conlon said that the OPW did not want to point the finger at any one individual. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Mr. Conlon was not even in position.
Comment on this
I am aware of that but I am the accountable officer now. In my review that was prepared and published on, I think, 24 September, I was quite candid in saying the level of expenditure on this project was not consistent with the scale of the project under consideration, that is, a covered bicycle facility, so I was quite candid in that respect.
Comment on this
Mr. Conlon said there was a heritage prospect to the whole project because it was in the confines of Leinster House and it had to be looked at from that perspective. How much did that cost?
Comment on this
It drove the costs that were realised in this project because due regard was had by the team to the conservation aspects of the area they were working in, that is, the historic buildings of Leinster House.
Comment on this
Were those conservation aspects given to the two RoanKabins outside the back door of Leinster House? It looks to me like they are two very ordinary RoanKabins you would get in the middle of any haulier's yard in the country. I do not see the correlation between the RoanKabins and this bike shelter.
Comment on this
I am not sure what the Deputy is referring to.
Comment on this
At the back door, on the opposite side. They are ordinary RoanKabins. Has Mr. Conlon seen them?
Comment on this
The context of the bike shelter was the Merrion Square side.
Comment on this
This is the Merrion Square side. It is the same side. It is the back door of this building. It is right outside the back door.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Conlon familiar with those cabins?
Comment on this
Mr. Conlon is familiar with the portacabins. Yet, he persists in telling us there was a heritage element to the bike shelter. Does he believe that?
Comment on this
When I conducted my review of that project, I spoke to all the officials involved and people on the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission. It developed the way it did because of the conservation aspects and I reported that in my review.
Comment on this
It is beginning to sound very much just like an excuse. I suggest the OPW is running out of excuses. The problem with not having accountability is that this is likely to happen again and again, which is the history of the OPW, as far as I have researched, going back 30 years. There has not been much improvement. Mr. Conlon is in a position to cure it. He will be back here next year. I may or may not be but if I am, I will remind him and check everything that has come under his remit. If we do not get accountability, this whole committee is pointless.
Comment on this
I will move on. With regard to the OPW's land banks and modular builds, how much land for building houses does the OPW own or is within the OPW?
Comment on this
Properties and land for housing is quite limited. I ask Ms Morrison to address that and then I can come back in.
Comment on this
We have very few vacant sites available that would be suitable for building houses. At all times, we support other Departments like the Department of integration, the Land Development Agency and agencies like that that have more direct responsibility for the provision of housing. If we identify any surplus lands, they are made available to other State agencies under the protocols laid out by the Department of public expenditure. We have quite a good track record in making lands and buildings available to other agencies in that regard over the past number of years.
Comment on this
Why then did the planning permission lapse on the former Department of Health headquarters this year?
Comment on this
In relation to Hawkins House, the previous building was demolished in 2021. We have-----
Comment on this
I apologise to Mr. Conlon but on the basis of time, the question is: why did the OPW allow the planning permission to lapse? Why did the OPW not look for an extension?
Comment on this
We will consider future planning for that site.
Comment on this
How much did it cost to submit the planning application for the site?
Comment on this
I need that figure. I am surprised Mr. Conlon does not have that figure. It is fundamental to what we are talking about in a housing crisis. Will Mr. Conlon provide that figure? Before the break, somebody could submit it. I put the question again: why did the OPW allow the planning permission to lapse and not seek an extension?
Usually, planning of this scale runs into the hundreds of thousands. It is not a difficult process to have it extended.
Comment on this
I acknowledge that. In the context of the future use of Hawkins House-----
Comment on this
Will Mr. Conlon answer the question I asked, please? If he does not, I will ask the Chair to intervene. Why did Mr. Conlon not seek an extension?
Comment on this
I was not in office at that time. I think it was a mere oversight.
Comment on this
Maybe Ms Morrison is aware of why an extension was not sought. Is there anybody present who understands why the planning was not extended?
Comment on this
I can come in on that. The planning permission we obtained in 2017 was for an office block on the site of the-----
Comment on this
It was not just for an office block.
Comment on this
An application to alter the permission could have been made.
Comment on this
That was under consideration in April 2021 and into 2022 when we had the planning.
Comment on this
We will have to get it for the Deputy.
Comment on this
The witnesses will get that figure. Does the fact that Mr. Conlon was not in the position make asking questions a pointless exercise?
Comment on this
Why was the site not sold with planning permission?
Comment on this
We will consider future use of that site. It is a valuable site in the city centre that will require due consideration. We are not going to make a decision to sell it without due regard to our future portfolio requirements.
Comment on this
The OPW had planning permission in respect of it for nearly eight years.
Comment on this
However, nobody ever entertained the idea of allowing somebody else to build on that site.
Comment on this
No, but we will consider future uses for that site.
Comment on this
I should hope so, because, given the OPW's record on modular builds, it is probably not something we should consider for the taxpayer's sake.
Let us go to the modular build. This committee was previously informed, as the C and AG pointed out, that it was estimated that 500 units would cost €100 million. We are at nearly three times that figure. I recall asking about the sites that were being used. I was told that the sites being provided were not suitable to build houses on.
Comment on this
That is correct. However., Mr. Conlon is now saying that these are State assets and can be used in the future for social housing.
Comment on this
Are these modular builds part M compliant? I am reliably informed that they are not, even though I see Ms Collier nodding her head. Does Mr. Conlon know what part M is?
Comment on this
Does Mr. Conlon know which regulation part M pertains to?
Comment on this
Not specifically, but I am advised they are fully compliant with building regulations.
Comment on this
They are not compliant when it comes to wheelchair accessibility apparently. Is there anyone here who can categorically say that they are? Ms Collier was nodding her head but she has stopped doing so. Does that mean she cannot categorically state that they are compliant in the context of wheelchair accessibility?
Comment on this
I concur with Mr. Conlon. We understand them to meet the building regulations, including part M.
Comment on this
Who inspected them? I am reliably informed that they are not compliant. I am also reliably informed that they are not compliant with parts N or Z. Can the witnesses state whether or not they are compliant? The BER is significantly lower than would be the case for a three-bed house that meets the regulations. What is the BER for the modular builds?
Comment on this
Existing modular builds that are in place are rated C1. They are designed to be A2. Once we get the PV facilities in, they will be A2. That work-----
Comment on this
These are to allow the photovoltaic solar panels to be installed. When that happens, they will be rated A2.
Comment on this
Is that cost included or is it additional to the €442,000?
Comment on this
That is under negotiation with the contractor. We expect-----
Comment on this
Will Mr. Conlon hold on and not go too fast? When he says it is under consideration, that would mean it is on top of the €442,000.
Comment on this
We expect it to be met within the project cost of €285 million.
Comment on this
That does not sound like confidence to me. It means it is under negotiation. There seems to be a discussion or a disagreement. Is there?
Comment on this
Now is the time to give us the facts.
Comment on this
We are consulting with the contractor to install these across all the units, beginning with the Clonmel site in the near future, with the cost to be met from within the €285 million budget for the project.
Comment on this
We were at €289 million. Is this the same person who was contracted to provide the modular build? Is a different contractor providing the solar panels?
Comment on this
John Sisk is the contractor and it will provide the facilities for the PV panels.
Comment on this
Mr. Conlon, as chair of the OPW, is telling this committee and the public in general that the final cost of the modular build at an A1 rating, including solar panels fitted, is €442,000.
Comment on this
It will be A2 rated. We expect the overall project estimate to be €285 million.
Comment on this
That is not the question. The cost per unit is currently €442,000. Is Mr. Conlon saying that is without the fitting of solar panels? Is it the case that when that is completed, the cost is not going to change?
Comment on this
We expect the solar panels to cost approximately €5,800 per unit.
Comment on this
Will the cost change from €442,000 per unit?
Comment on this
I do not expect it to go above that figure.
Comment on this
Mr. Conlon expects it to stay the same.
Comment on this
That is an undertaking that we have, even though the project is three times over the initial budget. What exactly happened that meant an estimate of €100 million ended up nearly three times that?
Comment on this
The Comptroller and Auditor General has outlined that in his report. It was an initial estimate. We must remember that this was a very dynamic process in an emergency response situation.
Comment on this
It did not turn out to be much of an emergency response. It took nearly 20 months longer to put the units in place. As for the sites, were they ever zoned for housing or serviced in any shape or form? Was the figure of €100 million a cost that went out to tender to Sisk or did Sisk come in with that price?
Comment on this
In terms of zoning, I am not clear. In terms of the serviced sites, very few of the sites were adequately serviced, which gave rise to the huge cost escalation due to poor site conditions and servicing. We had to develop these sites to a state whereby they could be serviced properly, which gave rise to the significant cost escalation.
Comment on this
Was the figure of €100 million an amount that was tendered or was it the proposed cost of the project given to Sisk?
Comment on this
Did Sisk tender for €100 million?
Comment on this
As I understand it, when the tender went out it gave rise to a figure not of €100 million but higher costs subsequently. It was tendered in such a way that it was kind of a dynamic environment whereby we used a particular form of contract which allowed Sisk to develop and bill us. As the costs increased for various reasons outlined, that happened.
Comment on this
I will allow the Deputy back in. I am sure others will pick up on this point as well.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being here this morning and wish Mr. Conlon every success in his role. I want to focus on one element of the work in the ten minutes I have, namely, the proposed development of the National Children's Science Centre. What Mr. Conlon has presented to us is a debacle. If this goes ahead, it will dwarf bike sheds and security huts in terms of the commitment the taxpayer will make to developing the National Children's Science Centre as currently proposed and constituted.
The original idea and concept behind all of this was quite simple. The OPW owned a site near Heuston Station, which would be sold to a developer. As part of the sale, the developer would agree to develop, at no charge to the State, the National Children's Science Centre in that location. From a public transport point of view, that would be a very positive development. That agreement was entered into during the height of the Celtic tiger.
Post the crash, I am mystified as are many others as to why that arrangement still somehow seems to garner some degree of respect and has obliged the OPW, in essence, to continue on the road to expending a very significant amount of money on a National Children's Science Centre. Why does Mr. Conlon believe that the original contract is still valid if its entire basis no longer stands? Has the OPW done a cost-benefit analysis on the project and if so, what is the current cost it is attributing to its investment - the State's investment - in the National Children's Science Centre at the location currently proposed, which is adjacent to the National Concert Hall?
Comment on this
As regards the legal position we are in, the Deputy is correct in stating it dates back to a 2003 initiative. The real legal conundrum that I have as Accounting Officer is a 2013 agreement that the OPW entered into with the National Children’s Science Centre, which gave rise to the legal commitment we have now. That was done following the initiation of arbitration proceedings by the company - the National Children's Science Centre - and following legal advices received during the 2013 negotiation, that agreement was signed. That gives rise to the legal position I as Accounting Officer find myself in now.
Comment on this
Has there been a cost-benefit analysis carried out on the development of the project?
Comment on this
No. As I have indicated in my opening statement and in the material I submitted to the committee, we still have to find a funder for this project. I have had some discussions with the Secretary General of the Department of Tourism, Culture, Arts, Gaeltacht, Sport and Media in respect of that Department stepping in to be a funder of this project. The Department will consider that in due course and at that stage, I consider that a value-for-money business case to underpin the whole project needs to be done by that funding Department to seek agreement on the funding and to move forward on that basis. There will also have to be regard to the governance arrangements for the project moving on. The OPW finds itself in a position where it is contracted to build but not to manage or to be the funder of this facility, even though the legal position is that we have to build it, unfortunately.
Comment on this
Bearing in mind that when many of us who are involved with communities across the country which have been subjected to serious flooding in the last couple of decades approach the OPW as an entity to begin working with them and developing flood relief projects, and that these projects quite rightly are subjected to a rigorous and robust cost-benefit analysis process, I am at a loss to understand why this process has not been employed at some point during the 11 years since the contract was signed. Is Mr. Conlon aware of any analysis that was ever carried out of what this might cost? What are the current estimates circulating within the OPW as to what it might cost? I am hearing something in the order of €80 million to €100 million.
Comment on this
In respect of the Deputy’s first point, I am aware that some business cases were submitted by the proposer of this project. However, I am in a position where I would like to see a current, up-to-date value-for-money assessment being done on this.
Comment on this
The OPW does not have that right now?
Comment on this
Not at this stage. As regards ongoing discussions with the Department of tourism, that will be part of those discussions. Regarding the OPW’s current projected costs of this project, they are in the region of €70 million, not the figures the Deputy suggested.
Comment on this
The OPW was asked to provide a note on the failure to disclose the legally binding commitment in the appropriation accounts for 2022. Its response at the time was that the OPW was liaising with the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General on this issue in the context of finalising the 2023 appropriation accounts. Why is that commitment still not included in that 2023 appropriation account?
Comment on this
We have had discussions with the Comptroller and Auditor General on this and we have included some text in the appropriation account to that effect. We can get that out. When that arbitration decision is fully crystallised, it then becomes a full contingent liability. Maybe the Comptroller and Auditor General would like to make some comment on that?
Comment on this
I can read the text, which is in note 2.13:
In addition the OPW has a commitment to deliver the National Children's Science Museum. As the project is subject to an arbitration process that is not yet finalised, the estimated value of this commitment has not been included in this account.
Comment on this
Let us take the OPW's estimate of €70 million, bearing in mind how inaccurate some estimates have proven to be within the OPW recently in developing much smaller developments. Does it not cause Mr. Conlon a great degree of concern that the OPW is proposing to spend €70 million, at a minimum, on a national children's science centre in the middle of Dublin, a very busy city, which makes it immensely difficult to get to for the children from across the country I assume we are hoping to serve? Furthermore, there is a facility called Explorium 10 km away which offers in excess of 350 interactive exhibits, a 120-seat theatre and 11,000 sq. m of ample space for future growth. It has 20 acres of car and bus parking and is a five-minute drive from the M50. It is 10 km from the site the OPW is currently proposing to develop. Has anyone from the OPW ever visited that facility and done an analysis of the likely costs associated with acquiring and, if necessary, upgrading that facility for it to serve as the national children's science centre?
Comment on this
I accept very much that Explorium, which has been in contact with me recently to open discussions, may feel quite threatened by the development of a national children's science centre in-----
Comment on this
It is not a question of it feeling threatened. I am suggesting it should become the national children's science centre, bearing in mind it is already there and is visited by up to 250,000 children every year. With an investment of a fraction of the €70 million of taxpayers' money we are proposing to spend, which I still think is a very conservative estimate, it could and should become a world-class science centre that we as a nation can be proud of.
Comment on this
I have mentioned already in response to some of the Deputy's questions that I would like, in conjunction with the Department of tourism if it is a funder, to get a full business case value-for-money assessment done on this. I expect any assessment done in that context would have regard to-----
Comment on this
Has anyone from the OPW ever visited Explorium to see the facilities there?
Comment on this
I think the previous chairman and other officials visited it some time ago.
Comment on this
Did the chairman and his officials publish any internal documents, report or correspondence engaging with other colleagues on the pros and cons of such a development?
Comment on this
No. We must remember in the context of where we find ourselves that we are contracted to build this. We are not contracted to-----
Comment on this
I get the sense Mr. Conlon is not happy to find himself in this particular position.
Comment on this
To be very honest, I am uneasy because I have reviewed all the files on this since 2003. Being frank, it is a difficult position for me to explain.
Comment on this
In terms of where this may go, it is going to involve, in my view, further consideration of Government, having regard to what I have outlined in terms of value-for-money assessments, business cases and the impact it may have on other businesses. If I did not say that and it was not done, it would look very odd for me.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for being here on a day the Committee of Public Accounts does not normally sit. This speaks to the importance of why we are here. This committee supervises our audits and the billions of euro that are spent. The idea that an expenditure of €336,000 would draw our attention speaks to the point as regards this issue, namely, that many people cannot get their heads around how anyone could sign off on bike parking facilities costing that sum of money.
My colleague, Deputy Verona Murphy, said that we may or may not be here next year when the witnesses come back to present next year's accounts but I can tell them that every single time any of us is on a canvass, somebody mentions the bike shed. We are being held to account for the actions the OPW has taken. It has fundamentally undermined the trust and confidence the public has in all public spending. I cannot tell Mr. Conlon the damage the OPW has caused to really important public projects. When local authorities transform a park, people are going to ask how much it cost. I am really frustrated that we are here for such a small amount of money but an incredible amount of waste.
I will ask for some facts first before I go any further on that. The OPW is the owner of the Leinster House building but the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission represents those who occupy it. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Therefore, requests to improve the building and so on come from the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission.
Comment on this
Is there any process for auditing whether requests are reasonable or unreasonable?
Comment on this
In terms of our management of the campus, we have staff on site here and we are constantly monitoring the fabric and-----
Comment on this
The question was – and I imagine this applies to all buildings in which the OPW has people who occupy – does the OPW have a protocol for auditing requests?
Comment on this
I outlined this in the report I subsequently wrote for the Minister on this. Where the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission requests us to do elective works for it, we identified a weakness in that we were not providing costings in that-----
Comment on this
There is regular engagement between our team-----
Comment on this
Therefore there is no formal process?
Comment on this
I think the regular engagement is a process in itself.
Comment on this
Mr. Conlon can call it that. That is fine. Let us move to the next point. Who in the Office of Public Works received the request from the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission?
Comment on this
May I ask Ms Collier to address this and I will come back in?
Comment on this
The Houses of the Oireachtas Commission received communications from a group of cycling enthusiasts-----
Comment on this
I accept that. Who in the OPW received a request from the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission?
Comment on this
It was conveyed, as I said, first verbally at a Houses of the Oireachtas Commission meeting and then it came from the facilities management unit in the Houses of the Oireachtas across to the OPW.
Comment on this
The question was: who in the OPW received it?
Comment on this
The team in Dublin conservation received it.
Comment on this
Therefore the Dublin conservation team are the people who received it.
Comment on this
Who look after Leinster House, correct.
Comment on this
And it would also have been responsible for carrying out the estimate?
Comment on this
And having overall project management of the project as it developed.
Comment on this
The team that looks after Leinster House.
Comment on this
The Dublin conservation team is the group of people who are responsible for this project, is that correct?
Comment on this
They look after everything in Leinster House.
Comment on this
That is fine. How many people make up that Dublin conservation team?
Comment on this
The team reports to the chairman so it is the chairman, myself as a board member, there is a PO or PO equivalent who heads up the team, there is a senior architect and an architect-----
Comment on this
How many people sit within the Dublin conservation team?
Comment on this
It is a relatively small team. It looks after 110 stone buildings in Dublin. I think there are probably about 21 people in that whole team who look after the whole of Dublin.
Comment on this
There are 21 people. What grades exist within that team?
Comment on this
As with all Civil Service structures, there is a PO or PO equivalent-----
Comment on this
Who is the most senior person in the team?
Comment on this
I accept that. That is the organisation chart. What is the most senior grade?
Comment on this
A PO or PO equivalent heads up all teams.
Comment on this
The principal officer is the most senior grade in that team.
Comment on this
There are 21 people. Is there a technical staff there too, as well as administrative staff?
Comment on this
Yes. There is a senior architect and there are architects.
Comment on this
Is there any formal process within that team which evaluates requests that come in from people who occupy the OPW’s buildings?
Comment on this
Again, as the chairman said, there is an ongoing process of engagement with the Houses of the Oireachtas – I mean daily engagement – between our team on the ground here and-----
Comment on this
Dunsink Observatory is one of the OPW’s properties. If Dunsink Observatory and DIAS, which I know well, asked for a gold-plated train to bring it to the city centre I am sure the OPW would reject that, right? What are the criteria by which the OPW assesses requests?
Comment on this
Obviously we have responsibility for the building and the fabric of the building. A request such as a covered bicycle shelter facility is a natural request, I would suggest-----
Comment on this
-----in terms of providing facilities for Members. We would not have considered that request unusual. In fact, we had put in a number of bike parking facilities around the campus. The Deputy will see them – they are the freestanding-----
Comment on this
Has the OPW provided bike-parking facilities in other office buildings for other Departments?
Comment on this
Yes. We had increased capacity for up to 70 different bike stalls around the location, so this request would not have been considered unusual.
Comment on this
Then comes the opportunity to spec it. There is approximately €120,000 for steelwork and glass; around €50,000 for groundworks; and around €40,000 for the granite paving. Then there are two figures for preliminaries and day works. As Deputy Murphy said, I can somewhat justify that the materials in the glass and the steel could come to that figure but I have a real question about the granite paving. Who decided that granite paving was essential for the project?
Given that it cost half the price of the structure, would that have been decided solely by the Dublin conservation team?
Comment on this
In terms of how we look after the Leinster House complex, we try to use the appropriate materials for the historic setting.
Comment on this
It is our national Parliament. We were trying to deal with the historic setting of the Leinster Lawn side of the house. Leinster Lawn is a protected area-----
Comment on this
I park my car every day on perfectly good tarmac in Leinster Lawn; it does not detract from the building. Who decided that granite paving was essential?
Comment on this
It was deemed appropriate as a material finish.
Comment on this
By the Dublin conservation team.
Comment on this
The team responsible for the project, correct. From a design perspective and from a conservation-----
Comment on this
That was one of the areas where there is a glaring waste of money when the paving was half the cost of the structure above it. I ask Ms Collier to bear with me. We then get to the groundworks. What did the groundworks entail?
Comment on this
On a project like this, we would be digging out the base for the structure. We went to our archaeology first. We always do archaeology on the grounds of Leinster House. It is good practice in terms of the conservation area.
Comment on this
No, I think it was less than that - €2,952, including VAT. We would have undertaken the archaeology. We had to consider the historic drains that are located in that area and we had to consider the wall of the National Gallery.
Comment on this
On site, it would appear that some of the groundworks we have seen carried out are connected for EV chargers that are immediately adjoining it. Is that correct?
Comment on this
No, they were two separate projects. There is EV charging in this particular project for EV bikes in time so the ducting and power-----
Comment on this
Did the groundworks connect them to those EV chargers?
Comment on this
No, the EV chargers for the cars is a separate project.
Comment on this
Looking at the works, several trenches connect the EV charger points with the bike shelter.
Comment on this
In that area, there would be ducting for power to be connected.
Comment on this
Therefore, the EV chargers is a separate project.
Comment on this
I think that project was €112,000, excluding VAT-----
Comment on this
Who owns them? There is a contract. There was a-----
Comment on this
Are they owned by the OPW or by the company?
Comment on this
I think the OPW owns the fitting but there is a continuing licence to maintain it and operate it. We own the structure.
Comment on this
Is the charging that happens in the bike shelter connected somehow to the EV chargers?
Comment on this
They are separate companies - separate supplies.
Comment on this
It is not installed. The final install of the chargers provides there is an install but the building regulations do not allow for it in that location at the moment.
Comment on this
They will be separate entities in time, yes.
Comment on this
I am still grappling with the €50,000 for groundworks, which is somehow a separate project from the €112,000. It is remarkable that a project that we thought was €350,000 has an adjoining project of €120,000. The real problem here is that people expect that when something happens in this building, we have some line of sight and supervision, and we know in some way the costs. Is Ms Collier essentially telling me that no elected Member of the House knew anything about the price of this project?
Comment on this
That was the directive in being at the time.
Comment on this
That is the problem. The public believe that we run this building. Whether we do or do not, the public believe that we run this building. The idea that money can be spent in such an outlandish way without any elected Member of this House knowing about it is a clear failure of the process. The fact that there is no audit of the requests in a formalised process is a clear lack of process and is a clear problem.
Comment on this
In my review report, I have been very clear on my recommendation that on all elective projects requested by the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission, full and open transparency by the OPW on the costings of those be made at the regular monthly meetings and that is now in place.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, we are closing the door after the horse has bolted on this.
Comment on this
I will briefly return to the bike shelter and I echo my colleagues' comments. The Leas-Chathaoirleach and I have been around this committee the longest. The biggest issue we have ever dealt with is the national children's hospital. As regards commentary among the public, a €2.2 billion project is put in the ha'penny place by a bike shed out at the back of this building when it comes to the public's consciousness. All of us feel that because it is constantly brought up. It was brought up with me yesterday. It is brought up all the time.
Fundamentally, the OPW has undermined the public service and the way in which the public service spends money, when the public sees a bike shed and sees how much it should cost. There are contractors who have publicly said they could have done eight of them for the same price. It is not comprehensible to people who are trying to manage budgets. There is an ongoing detrimental issue in public spending because of this where the public now must second-guess projects all the bloody time. That is the impact of it. In some cases the works being done on projects are very valuable and very worthwhile. In some cases, they come in under what had been estimated, but this is the impact it has had. There is also the famous security hut.
My first question is: are there any other projects we need to know about? Let us clean the slate here. Is there anything else, or projects like this, that we need to know about as the Committee of Public Accounts? My colleague spoke about the science museum, which I am well aware of, because it came up during the last term in a previous committee I was on. Are there any other projects that jump out that we need to be aware of? If not, then we will just move on.
Comment on this
On that point, which Deputy McAuliffe also made, I fully acknowledged the anger this has caused. It is something that, as a member of the community, I feel as well. People come up to me and give out to me about this. I am fully aware of the real anger that members face on this. I have acknowledged that in my review. I am being quite upfront. It was an extraordinary cost for the provision of an ordinary bike shelter. It is something that we in the OPW need to reflect on seriously. I fully acknowledge that.
With regard to other projects, I do not believe there is anything of this dimension-----
Comment on this
So there is nothing we need to be aware of. It is really an opportunity for Mr. Conlon because this is the Committee of Public Accounts. There is nothing-----
Comment on this
Some things may arise that I am not aware of at this stage.
Comment on this
In fairness to the three previous speakers, they have asked Mr. Conlon a number of questions and they have given him the opportunity and he said, as is his right, that he was not in position then. However, Mr. Conlon has been in position now for a while. Mr. Conlon has made it clear that he is not aware of anything else. That is fine.
I find the situation with the modular homes astonishing. I will start at the very beginning before we get into the actual details of the spend here. How did the OPW end up with this? For me it was bizarre that the OPW ended up doing this work in the first place. Did the OPW fight back? I believe it logically would have been the Department of housing, given the local authority nature of what was required since it is over housing. How did the OPW end up with this and did it fight back against it?
Comment on this
If there is someone else here who can answer that and who was there previous to Mr. Conlon, then that is fine.
Comment on this
I will take it first, if the Deputy does not mind. With the response to the Ukrainian situation at that particular time a senior officials' group was meeting under the aegis of the Department of the Taoiseach. At that stage the senior officials' group asked the OPW to come forward with some proposals in relation to the development of modular home capacity in the country. The OPW took on that task. I am not clear why the Department of housing did not.
Comment on this
From the OPW perspective, it took on a project-----
Comment on this
So was it a case of sharing the workload?