We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Vote 13 - Office of Public Works

Contributions 236–475 of 710. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Mr. John Conlon

That is my understanding. We took it on board-----

Comment on this

It is not a natural skill for the OPW if Mr. Conlon does not mind me saying so.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

We are in the construction sector-----

Comment on this

I understand that but to have to navigate the whole situation in relation to people coming into the country. With groundworks and all of that sort of stuff, surely the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage was a more natural fit.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

That is for the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage to answer rather than me at this stage.

Comment on this

It is for the Government to answer. I just wanted to know how the OPW ended up with it.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

We ended up with it because we were asked by the Department of the Taoiseach and the senior officials' group to outline what we could do to develop modular housing capacity in the country.

Comment on this

Okay. Can we get into the costs of the units? The OPW went out to tender and brought in John Sisk. Was it Sisk that won the tender?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

Correct.

Comment on this

From the notes I see it appointed five different contractors.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

Correct. It was a competition.

Comment on this

Yes. Were any of those contractors in any way owned by John Sisk as well?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

I am not aware that there were.

Comment on this

Was there any shareholding in the five of them?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

I will double-check that.

Comment on this

Mr. Fitzsimons might have information on that. Was one of the contractors a subsidiary of the main contractor?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Fitzsimons

We can check that. My recollection is that one of them may have had an association with Sisk.

Comment on this

Would that be normal?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Fitzsimons

Sisk set up a framework of five contractors that could comply with the standards. They were set up at the time.

Comment on this

I want to get into the timelines here. The cost comes to an average of between €130,000 and €160,000 per unit. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

In terms of the modular, that is correct.

Comment on this

When it comes to the overall cost, will Mr. Conlon explain how in the name of God they got to what is now the final figure?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

The huge cost driver on this-----

Comment on this

I know, it is sites.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

-----has been not just sites but also the utility connections. Some of these sites were quite some way from utility connections. The cost to bring utilities to the sites was significant, as was that relating to site clearance. As outlined in the report, various elements of that were significant.

Comment on this

I saw the reports. If the average was coming in at €145,000 and the cost is coming in at-----

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

Four hundred-----

Comment on this

-----€442,0000, that means it is €297,000 for site works per unit. That is absolutely beyond stupid.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

It is very significant.

Comment on this

The differential is €297,000.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

It is very significant.

Comment on this

Significant.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

The Deputy must recall that so many sites-----

Comment on this

How can we go to the public on this matter? For once, I am not blaming the OPW. The fact that the OPW was doing this was wrong. I have gone through all of the replies to my parliamentary questions - I submitted a pile of them on this - and the timelines put out in October 2022 involved a lead-in time of ten weeks for the first phase of 250 units. That is what it said. Did that happen?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

No.

Comment on this

Of course it did not happen. I know it did not happen. I am just confirming it. I asked the Department of children, which had responsibility in this regard. I then asked the Department of public expenditure the same thing at the end of October. It stated that the initial 250 would be installed during January and February 2023. Did that happen?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

Some sites were delivered early, but they took some time to deliver because of the delays in procuring them.

Comment on this

When were the first 250 units finally concluded?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

We can get more detail on this.

Comment on this

I am sure the witnesses have it.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

The first sites were delivered in mid-2023.

Comment on this

From ten weeks in the third quarter of 2022, it ended up, as I understand it, not just in the middle of 2023 but significantly later than that. There were the other 250 after that. What consequences were there for the contractor? Were there any consequences or was it all just blamed on the issues with sites? In other words, were the units delivered?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

I will get some data on that, which might be helpful in the context of the conversation. The Cork city site commenced in October 2022 and was completed in May 2023. The Cavan site started in November 2022 and was completed in August 2023. The Thurles site started in December 2022-----

Comment on this

I know all about the Thurles site.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

-----and was completed in August 2023. The Tullamore site started in January 2023 and was completed in November 2023.

Comment on this

We can check all of those out. For the benefit of members of the public watching these proceedings, a contractor came in to do work for the OPW. What has probably not been in the public domain is the fact that the contracts averaged out at €145,000 but that the actual cost averaged out at €442,000. This means a cost of €297,000 for site works. That is beyond comprehensible for any member of the public watching this.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

We need to learn significant lessons from this. We will do an assessment of it. These sites were far too small in terms of the economies of scale we could achieve.

Comment on this

They should not have been picked.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

We went ahead after discussions with the Department of children and integration, which is the approving authority for this, not the OPW. We are the contracting authority.

Comment on this

I agree with Mr. Conlon on that. The OPW should never have been doing this but that does not save the taxpayers’ money.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

It was developed on that basis. Approvals from Government were received from the Department of integration.

Comment on this

We have the Land Development Agency Where was it in all of this?

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Deputy Kelly’s time is up. I will briefly follow on from that. I remember the OPW being before this committee previously talking about these modular homes before they started. We were told they could be picked up and lifted somewhere else. As has been pointed out, there is a huge amount of money that cannot be picked up and moved elsewhere, such as money spent on site works, enabling works and all the rest of it.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

I did not say that.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

While Mr. Conlon may not have said it, it was said in a previous hearing of this committee when we talked about the prices of these homes going way back.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

To make a quick comment on that, these are now State assets and State-serviced sites. It makes absolutely no sense to lift and put them somewhere else.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

It makes no sense to me either. Do they have planning permission for anything other than their current use? Do they require planning permission if they are being used for something else?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

Not at this stage. My understanding is that the permissions they have will expire when the relevant EU directive expires in 2026. The Department of integration will require planning permission for use beyond that date. That is for the Department to develop, however.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Okay. I now move to Deputy O'Connor.

Comment on this

I thank the Chair. First and foremost, I want to acknowledge that 12 months have passed since Storm Babet. A huge body of work has been undertaken locally by the local authority and in conjunction with the OPW in 2023 in trying to advance the Midleton flood relief scheme, which has been long overdue. I wish to acknowledge that at the start of my remarks. I might come back to Mr. Casey with a few questions on this matter towards the end of my time.

Ultimately, we are here because of two incredibly high-profile sagas, one involving a ridiculous costing for a bike shelter and the other, which we have since learned about, involving an exorbitant amount of money spent on a fancy security hut at the side of Government Buildings. Public outrage has been enormous, and rightly so. I want to establish today, having listened to Mr. Conlon’s last exchange on this matter, the decision-making process in full. Who makes the decision around what infrastructure needs to be built and provided in Leinster House? The public has, obviously, laid the blame at the foot of public representatives. We need to get answers to very important questions. Ultimately, who sought the development of the bike shelter? Can the witnesses please give the committee an insight into how that request came about? Whose idea was it?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

I will ask Ms Collier to respond to that. I will come in later if the Deputy so wishes.

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

As I mentioned earlier, there was a request from a group of Members of the Houses who were cyclists for covered bicycle parking facilities and an improvement in bicycle parking generally, which we provided. We installed a number of the freestanding bicycle facilities and-----

Comment on this

Okay. How many Members requested this work?

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

There were approximately eight to ten signatories on that letter. It was addressed to An Ceann Comhairle and considered by the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission. The OPW attends that meeting every month.

Comment on this

Was the letter issued to the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission, the OPW directly, or was it referred onto them by An Ceann Comhairle?

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

It was issued to An Ceann Comhairle. A copy of the letter was referred to in an email sent to us afterwards.

Comment on this

Right. Does Ms Collier have a copy of that correspondence?

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

I have a copy of the email we received, yes.

Comment on this

Can she provide that letter to me?

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

Yes, of course.

Comment on this

Can Ms Collier provide the names of the Members on that list?

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

I do not have those names to hand but they will be in the email which we will give to the Deputy.

Comment on this

Can Ms Collier find that information for me now?

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

I do not have that email with me. We can get it for the Deputy at the break, for sure.

Comment on this

We need that information before the end of the meeting.

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

No problem.

Comment on this

There needs to be accountability on this. It is hard to know where to start.

For an agency in charge of 2,500 properties across the State, there is an unmerciful amount of what we will call blindfolded trust on the OPW's side of the table. This has done inordinate damage to the reputation of our national Parliament and to the public's perception of what the State is spending hard-earned taxpayers' money on. Ultimately, we need to get a full understanding in that respect.

As for the security hut, has Mr. Conlon gone down to see it? Has he walked it and seen the security hut?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

As I worked in the building beside it for a number of years, I am quite familiar with it.

Comment on this

Has he gone down to see the new building?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

Yes.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Conlon believe it represents value for taxpayers, at a cost of €1.4 million? I do not want to hear any excuses around advanced security features. There are no armed security personnel operating out of it. As I see it, it is a brass roof on a box of glass. I want to understand what are Mr. Conlon's thoughts on spending more than €1.4 million on that piece of infrastructure, which is a glorified container?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

Can I push back a bit? To be fair, in regard to-----

Comment on this

No, Mr. Conlon can answer the question he was asked.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

The detail of the expenditure is quite detailed and covers a huge amount of mechanical and electrical works and ducting. There is a building element, there are six significant security systems, both in terms of IT, presence of technical-----

Comment on this

Is Mr. Conlon referring to a knee-high gate that automatically opens?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

There is an extensive number of mechanical and electrical security systems within that complex.

Comment on this

Is there something like an ejector seat in there? I went down to see it, as I considered that prudent, before I came here today to speak about it. I did not see any of the things Mr. Conlon is talking about. I saw a glass security box with a few CCTV cameras and a ramp to stop vehicles from passing through. I cannot understand how that cost €1.4 million.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

We have set out for the committee in quite some detail what the €1.4 million cost was made up of. As I said-----

Comment on this

For the benefit of the public, will Mr. Conlon outline them again?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

I will go through some of them here. In regard to the mechanical, electrical and security systems, these added up to €558,000. Of that, €80,000 went on scaffolding and setting out the works and preliminaries; €30,000 went on site servicing, heating, ventilation, pipe services and fire suppression equipment; €64,000 went on electrical distribution, general services and lighting-----

Comment on this

How much did Mr. Conlon say was spent on fire safety?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

Data communications and fire safety came to €41,000.

Comment on this

It is an enormous amount of money for a glass square.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

To be fair, Deputy, it is more than a glass square.

Comment on this

It has a brass roof.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

There is a lot of equipment within that brass roof as I indicated earlier. There is a huge amount of equipment in that complex. It is not just a glass square.

Comment on this

Would a smoke detector and a fire extinguisher not suffice instead of €41,000?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

Let us be fair.

Comment on this

I am being very fair.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

We will go back to the original request to get this work done, which came from a Garda security assessment. That was quite detailed.

Comment on this

There are no gardaí in it.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

An Garda Síochána carries out assessments of security for the campus. We did this work in response to that. This work was quite detailed. It is not just a glass security hut.

Comment on this

I do not for one second take away the serious security issues on Merrion Street. Somebody was able to drive around Dublin of an evening and drive into the gates of Áras an Uachtaráin. The same person was then able to come down to Merrion Street and drive into the gates of the Department of the Taoiseach and then into the gates of Leinster House, and get away with it. That says a lot. That is more a policing issue. I do not believe it is for the OPW. However, ultimately, this is a facility that is not manned by An Garda Síochána. I do not for a second believe it merited the spending of €1.4 million on that facility itself. I will give Mr. Conlon a piece of homework from today's meeting and that is to go down and have a look at it, if he has not been down to see it. It is as ridiculous as it looks. The public is right to be angry about it.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

As I said, it is quite an expensive project. I have acknowledged that. A great deal of work has gone into it that is not seen in terms of the mechanical, electrical and security systems, some of which are overground and some are in the roof. It is also integrated into an overall complex. All of that costs money.

Comment on this

We are not getting anywhere. I want us to reflect on the second part.

In regard to the bike shelter, is information available yet on who the requests came from? Do we have to wait until afterwards?

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

I do not have access to my phone. I am not using the phone during the committee meeting. I will get that after the break.

Comment on this

That is perfect. In the final two minutes that remain to me, I am sorry to frustrate other members of the committee about domestic matters in Cork East, but Storm Babet was major. It flooded nearly 700 homes and businesses. I appreciate the amount of time Mr. Casey has spent down there. It has been noticed.

I want the witnesses to keep coming. I do not want to continuously undermine and criticise them. It is good that they have been to visit the community a few times. Where are we at in terms of the main flood relief scheme?

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Casey

Work is progressing on the main Midleton flood relief scheme. We have effectively concluded stage 1, the design stage, and we estimate that we will be going to planning in September of next year.

The Deputy will appreciate that after Storm Babet and the very severe impact it had on the community we had to look very closely at that event, how it unfolded, and whether the scheme we had designed to that stage was going to be effective in mitigating that type of event going forward. We spent some time looking at that. I am happy to confirm that the design we have for the Midleton scheme will be effective in mitigating flood risk to more than 700 properties in Midleton. We are working hard to bring that forward into the planning stage towards September next year.

Comment on this

Does the local authority have the full team of resources on the ground that it needs to do all the advanced scoping on this project? Quite a few requests have come in from John Slattery.

Comment on this
An Leas-Cathaoirleach

The Deputy's time is up.

Comment on this

I will come back to this issue in my second time slot because it is quite important.

Comment on this
Mr. Jim Casey

I am happy to answer that. We have engaged a lot in recent months with Cork County Council about resources. I am pleased to advise that the Minister has approved five additional resources to Cork County Council, to add to the existing four. We have a team of nine engineers, and project management and administrative staff now supporting all of the flood relief schemes in Cork, including the one in Midleton.

Comment on this
An Leas-Cathaoirleach

I thank Mr. Casey. I call Deputy Farrell.

Comment on this

Gabhaim buíochas leis na finnéithe as teacht os comhair an choiste.

I appreciate that Mr. Conlon has come in to answer these questions post the decision-making, although he was not there. It can be difficult to answer for the actions of others but I appreciate that he has come before the committee.

I want to start with the modular homes. Could he confirm to me what the construction sector inflation was for the period from their tendering to the final cost?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

I am not sure if I have that to hand but it is something I could come back with.

Comment on this

Does he agree that it would not be 120%?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

That is correct.

Comment on this

The issue is that it was 120%. I want to get to the bottom of why that is the case. We had the LDA before the committee just two weeks ago. We found out that the production of non-modular units in Shanganagh cost €409,000, which seems like a huge sum of money, but we are talking about modular homes with a lifespan of 50 years to 60 years – rather than permanent structures – that are costing an additional €32,000. Does Mr. Conlon agree that it must seem bizarre to the majority of people?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

I fully agree that it is very difficult for us to explain, but as I indicated on a number of occasions, and as is clearly outlined in a chapter of the Comptroller and Auditor General's report, we were dealing with very poor, small sites and we were not able to achieve the economies of scale we would like to achieve in site development.

Comment on this

We have all said there was an utter disregard of taxpayers' money in this instance. That is what people think. Could Mr. Conlon answer my question on that?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

We did advise the senior officials group that it would be very difficult to achieve this in a cost-effective way, given what we were dealing with.

Comment on this

Then why were we told initially that it would be €200,000? It is a massive increase.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

It is. There was a certain underestimation of those initial costs and then-----

Comment on this

Who was responsible for the underestimation? Was it the contractor?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

Some of the responsibility can be shared with our own teams, which excluded some of the costs at that stage.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

We quickly encountered site development issues over time.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

We had a team in the office that did preliminary costings. This was quite a dynamic project that evolved quickly.

Comment on this

We have the public sector spending code for a reason.

What I understand is that the Department of children and equality did not prepare a strategic assessment report or business case reports, preliminary and final, as required by the code for projects costing more than €100 million. Does that not seem strange?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

I think that is a question for the Department of integration to answer rather than me.

Comment on this

But Mr. Conlon would agree that it is strange.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

I agree that the public spending code is there for a reason, as the Deputy said. There was an emergency situation about this particular project, which it developed.

Comment on this

I understand the difference between what happens in an emergency situation but it is my understanding, and the C and AG might confirm to me, that it was subject to and should have been compliant with the public sector spending code. Am I correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

I am sorry, the-----

Comment on this

I understand sometimes it is different when it comes to emergency procurement - we saw it in Covid and had issues with it - but, in this instance, it should comply with the public sector spending code.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

If there is sufficient time to undertake a procurement competition, it should be undertaken.

Comment on this

In this instance, are we not still awaiting full delivery of all the units?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

Ten sites have been completed. One site in Clonmel is under way.

Comment on this

Okay, so we are still awaiting some of these to be fully given out to-----

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

The last site will be completed by next April.

Comment on this

In my view, if we are still awaiting that completion, there seems to be urgency required in terms of the tendering rather than the urgency in terms of the delivery, and I think that is concerning for people.

Regarding the after-effect, we have all stated on the record that we are deeply concerned about the cost of this. Actually, before I go into that, one of the questions asked by Deputy Murphy was related to solar panels. At this point, I am not fully confident that will not add to the cost of the delivery of these homes. I understand that Mr. Conlon is, but I will be very clear that I am not.

Comment on this
Mr. Seamus McCarthy

My understanding is that the value is included in the figure of €442,000. I think the last estimate that was done by the OPW was for a figure of €436,000 and I think the photovoltaic panels is the extra.

Comment on this

We will find out in due course and that information will be public. We all hope it will be. That is what we would expect.

Regarding the costs being revised, they were revised on multiple occasions. Between July 2023 and January 2024, they were revised on at least four occasions. In seven months, we have four cost revisions. Would that be considered normal for a project?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

No, because this was not a normal project, to be fair. This was a project where we were working on very small, undeveloped and difficult sites.

Comment on this

I appreciate it is not a normal project because it is costing the taxpayer €289 million. I saw from another report that in 2023 the OPW's turnover was approximately €654 million. Is that correct? Therefore, I take it that it is a significant project. However, with cost revisions, is it the taxpayer who takes all the risk? Is it our side that takes all the risk? What risk is there for the contractor?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

Because of the form of contract we used, which was a responsive type of contract to a developing situation, it meant the taxpayer took most of the risk. We felt by using other types of contract, it would have been difficult to procure and develop it along the way because of the dynamic situation.

Comment on this

It is not on the OPW but it seems to me that it is always the taxpayer that ends up bearing the risk when it comes to cost overruns. Again, that is not on the OPW; it is on this House. It is on us to provide the regulation and the legislation to ensure that does not happen in the future. Again, that is not on the OPW.

Regarding going forward with these modular homes, what is the story as regards who will manage them going forward? Is that a private contractor? Surely, there needs to be management of that.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

That is a matter for the Department of integration. We have contracted, we have built them-----

Comment on this

Then it goes on.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

Yes.

Comment on this

I appreciate that is not on the OPW but I definitely would like to see who ends up doing it, where that money is and what the cost will end up being.

Regarding the bike shelter, for those watching, it is important to note that it is not a bike shelter and not a bike shed, as has been reported.

If it was a bike shed, you might understand but it is simply a bike shelter. I note that Mr. Conlon says a measured term maintenance contract was used; that is obviously normal enough. What is the timeline for this particular framework and how many projects are left in that one?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

As for the measured term maintenance contract, our management board made a decision a number of weeks ago that we will re-tender that contract.

Comment on this

That sounds good, okay. That was a good idea after that.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

We have come to the limit of the financial outlays we projected on it so we are-----

Comment on this

Is that because of cost overruns?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

No.

Comment on this

No matter what happened with the bike shelter costing €336,000 and so on, is it correct that the OPW would still at this point have had to tender another framework? I just want to understand it.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

We are coming to the end of the financial outlays on that.

Comment on this

How many projects were in that contract?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

I can give some detail and we can follow up with a note if the Deputy wants.

Comment on this

It is only because I have a minute left so I am sorry that I have to make it urgent.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

There are three types of works we do under the contract, namely, small reactive call-outs, planned maintenance works and small-scale projects. On the small reactive call-outs, we have completed approximately 8,400 different projects. On planned maintenance works, we have completed 2,800 and we have completed approximately 161 small-scale projects.

Comment on this

In general, were there cost overruns on many of them? How many ran over percentage-wise?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

On small reactive call-outs and planned maintenance costs-----

Comment on this

What was the overrun in the totality?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

-----they are, on average, between €380 and €5,800 respectively. On the small-scale works, the average cost is approximately €134,000.

Comment on this

I note the external review of the OPW carried out in 2014. I understand there were two reviews, one of which had 60-plus recommendations while the previous one had 12 or something like that. How many recommendations from the second review related to recommendations that had previously been stated in the previous review? In the 2014 external review it states the "OPW operates largely on personal relationships and experience".

Does Mr. Conlon ensure there is data in relation to that? Does Mr. Conlon ensure there is an examination of how many of those projects had cost overruns, who was responsible for those cost overruns and whether value for money was achieved on these? As we have already figured out, it is the taxpayer who bears the brunt and risk in respect of all this. Have you actioned those reports and reviews?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

To be frank, I am not familiar with the 2014 report. In relation to my response to the bike shelter, I have asked some external partners to do some work with us in relation to strengthening our value-for-money processes, particularly on projects under €500,000.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

That is a critical piece of work we want to finish in the next number of weeks.

Comment on this

Has the OPW looked at that whole issue of data collection in terms of the contractors, the tenders, what costs ran over when the taxpayer takes the risk, that kind of thing?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

Each project has its own data-----

Comment on this

Does the OPW look at that centrally?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

We do and there are project oversight groups. That is something we will work on further but there are project oversight groups overlooking those projects.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

I am actually quite familiar with these modular homes because Backweston is very near to where I live and the biggest development is there. The modular units are very small. They obviously come in pairs. If I was to buy one of those, without the enabling works and all the rest of it, how much would one of those cost?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

It is in the region of €145,000 to €150,000 but I will double-check for the Chair.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

The cost is €145,000. Mr. Conlon reckons the enabling works cost €55,000 or something like that.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

We reckoned that at the very initial stages, before we got sight of all the site conditions, etc.

Comment on this

I welcome Mr. Conlon and all the other witnesses. Turning to the bike shelter for a few minutes, I do not know if Mr. Conlon saw anybody taking photographs with it on his way in. I say that in jest but I say it with a tinge of seriousness because I often see people, through the National Gallery fence, getting selfies with the bike shelter. That shows how serious the cost overruns on this project have been. The OPW has acknowledged that and I welcome that acknowledgement.

For one of his first appearances here at the Committee of Public Accounts in this role, it is good for us to engage with Mr. Conlon but for him to realise the seriousness of the situation at hand.

Deputy McAuliffe referred to the fact that this matter is being raised by the public at large to this day. They are aghast at the cost overrun. An obscene amount of money has been spent. I know Ms Collier said she will furnish us with a copy of the correspondence, which is welcome. That is something we should see because obviously it involves a request from the body politic to the commission, which forwarded it to the OPW. The witnesses highlighted what I think they called "the Dublin team", the group in the OPW that assesses the requests from various "tenants" - for want of a better word - of its buildings. When the witnesses were speaking earlier, I was thinking about all the requests related to Garda stations, including in respect of wiring, works to be done and facilities. For months, if not years, gardaí were looking for works to be done at the station in Kill of the Grange. The week that station was closed – I kid you not – the OPW went in and carried out fire works on the building. You could not make it up. Think of the amount of money spent. I raised this with the OPW a number of years ago at a meeting of this committee because I found it galling that the works were done just before the station was closed. It made no sense. Equally, the cost overrun related to the project under discussion does not make any sense.

Once the request went from the Oireachtas Commission to the Dublin team, who assessed the location required for a covered shelter?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

Ms Collier will take that and then I will come in.

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

There would have been an internal process of options appraisal for locations around the campus, and the team would have considered a number of locations to see where it might find somewhere suitable to locate a shelter. Those options would have been discussed in an iterative way with the facilities management team here in the Houses of the Oireachtas. That is broadly how the process would have worked.

Comment on this

Was any consideration given to another covered shelter on, say, the Kildare Street side of the campus?

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

Initially, the request was to put in covered shelter facilities as near to Leinster House as possible. Our advices for the members and the commission would have been that, to protect the historic fabric of the campus and the presentation of the campus, locating a covered shelter anywhere near the historic buildings would not be suitable or appropriate.

Comment on this

By "near", does Ms Collier mean on the campus near the main building or off the campus, in the public domain?

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

I mean near the building. The request would have been to be near doors, to be very specific.

Comment on this

Was there a subsequent request for another bike shelter to be built before this one was constructed?

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

Not that I am aware of, no. We would have looked at options for locations. Effectively, back of house would have been our preference so there would be no impact on the visuals or vista to Leinster House on either the Kildare Street side or the Merrion Square side. We would have looked at a number of options around the area.

Comment on this

A much-lower-cost project, I would hope, would involve the existing bike shelters beside the security hut. I will get to the other security hut in a second. At the security hut here in Leinster House, there are freestanding bike stands. Was any consideration given to expanding this site and simply attaching a roof to the existing security hut, maybe at a fraction of the cost?

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

On the Merrion Square side?

Comment on this

On the Merrion Square side.

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

Yes. It would have impacted the vista. That was looked at. A number of locations around the Leinster Lawn side were looked at and things that impacted on the vista to Leinster House were ruled out as not appropriate to the setting. Part of the reason the shelter is designed as it is is that when you look straight at Leinster House, you do not have poles, pillars and covered structures blocking the view of it.

Comment on this

It is in a great location for those in the National Gallery of Ireland visitor area. These visitors are getting great photographs of the shelter.

With regard to the location chosen, I made inquiries in the Houses of the Oireachtas because we were not aware of what the excavation works entailed and how long they were going on. It materialised that there was a huge amount of time between the beginning of the works and their end. There was no sign of an ending; there was just excavation for months on end. Could Ms Collier clarify when the excavation began and when it eventually finished?

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

The contractors mobilised on site in August 2023 and did the initial archaeology work and excavation.

There was an issue of historic drains relating to the National Gallery and some other materials that were found in the ground that had to be removed. There were some minor demolitions. We had to-----

Comment on this

When was the infamous granite laid?

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

That would have been laid in March of 2024. Just to be clear, there was a pause. During the summer recess the initial excavation started. We left the compound in place and came off site. That was always part of the plan. We finished out the design in terms of what was required for drainage, underground drains and the base and then we went back in at the start of January and it was completed in April 2024. The actual construction period was really January to April, about three and a half months.

Comment on this

Does the €335,000 incorporate all costs associated with the construction, design and the internal team costs? Is everything included in it?

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

That includes everything, yes.

Comment on this

Although I heard what the witnesses said about the EV charging points, why were they not part and parcel of the cost if they were constructed at the same time? Obviously, if we include them, we are talking about €447,000.

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

That was a separate project that was managed separately. They were developed separately as two separate projects.

Comment on this

Ms Collier mentioned the actual charging points for the bike shelter itself earlier. They have not been switched on and that is a separate contract but is that all included in the cost?

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

Yes. The actual-----

Comment on this

The charging points are not there yet-----

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

No, but the electrical bollards have been procured and are in storage with the OPW. All we have to do is install them when the building regulations allow. All of that was procured during the project and it is all covered in the costs that members have before them.

Comment on this

If it was finished in March 2024, at what point did the cost overruns become apparent? Was that through the public domain, via the media? When was it apparent that this was a runaway train?

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

There were no cost overruns on this project. The initial cost estimate on the project was-----

Comment on this

Okay, but the amount of money that was spent on the project was obviously hugely more than the average Joe punter would give for a bike shelter. In fact, a lot of commercial companies were memeing about the fact that the OPW spent €335,000 on a bike shelter and they could do it for a fraction of that cost. When did it become apparent internally in the OPW that this amount of money had been spent on such a simple, 18-bike stand? It works out at €18,600 per bike.

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

The cost would have been profiled within our capital expenditure throughout the year. We would have had a line of capital expenditure for this project but the total costs were finalised with the final account when it was completed in July.

Comment on this

How much was allocated for the project originally?

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

The order of magnitude of the cost was €350,000.

Comment on this

In theory, somebody signed off knowing that this was going to be a sizeable project, just for a bike stand.

Comment on this
Ms Rosemary Collier

It was approved at the appropriate level within our financial governance structures.

Comment on this

Okay, let us turn to the financial governance. In the context of internal controls it was highlighted that these new plans aim to cover the key controls on a rolling basis over a reasonable period. How often do the internal audit and audit risk committees meet?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

The audit and risk committee meets six times a year.

Comment on this

Did this issue come before that committee? Has it gone before it yet?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

I am not aware that it has.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

Sorry, my review report has been circulated to the committee so it is familiar with the project itself but I am not sure whether it has formally considered it yet.

Comment on this

I acknowledge what Mr. Conlon said in his opening statement about new financial thresholds being put in place of between €200,000 and €500,000. My colleague spoke earlier about the security hut beside Government Buildings. I heard what the witnesses said about all of the various ancillary services it provides and about its necessity. Nobody doubts the necessity of it. Mr. Conlon alluded to the fact that it was constructed on foot of a Garda report. There are many Garda reports but they do not specify the design and I would say that the hut is a little bit more elaborate than is required. A zinc roof is not necessarily essential to accommodate all of the various services. One could have a different type or style of roof without the costs. Does Mr. Conlon appreciate that?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

The roof itself cost €60,000 out of the overall total of €1.4 million. It was designed and procured that way.

I should add that part of the cost of €1.4 million was to provide for a temporary shelter while the other one was being built. That is just to make that point. I know it might not be-----

Comment on this

Does the OPW not have a rolling contract with providers for portacabins and so on when required? It seems strange to me that that would be part of a project cost when, in fact, the OPW is doing this all the time right across the country, as Mr. Conlon said earlier. Would an existing contract not be in place so the OPW does not have additional costs on every single project, either a temporary hut or whatever is required at a given time?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

The way this was procured was all-in, so the contractor was also required to build the temporary shelter while the rest of it was-----

Comment on this

It built a temporary shelter?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

It put one in place, yes.

Comment on this

I will come back to that. I thank the Chair.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Is it true that the bin truck cannot get in with the size of the roof? Is there an impediment with it?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

I do not think there is but we can check that.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

I ask Mr. Conlon to check that out, please.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Deputy Murphy was looking for information on the cost of the planning permission for Hawkins House. Does Mr. Conlon have that?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

We do not have it available yet. We have been trying to get the officials back at base on it. The records go back to 2016 so we do not have them yet, but we are still working on it.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Okay. I hope we will have them before the end of the meeting.

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

I just want to make sure they are accurate.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

I have a number of questions. I asked about buying one of these modular homes. Are we talking about a double unit for €145,000? They come in twos. Is that price per each unit?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

I think it was for each. We can double-check that.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

They are very small. Deputy Farrell asked about the engagement the OPW had with the Department on the cost of these. Presumably it was the Department of children. When did the OPW ask the Department about the cost? Was it well in advance? The OPW was given the go-ahead after that meeting as well. Who gave that go-ahead?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

We raised it not just with the Department but with the senior officials' group overseeing this project in relation to the delivery of it. We pointed out back in June 2022 that the pilot proof-of-concept phase of the modular home programme could only be progressed if sufficient suitable sites were immediately available to the OPW. In the absence of suitable sites the programme was not viable. As the project developed we kept the Department of integration and the senior officials' group informed of the escalating cost of this project over time. It dynamically changed as we were inspecting sites and realising how much these sites were going to cost for the various reasons I have outlined already such as excavation costs, site costs, etc.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Yes, so some of these cost more than others. Were there particular ones the OPW drew attention to that were very significantly over the amount?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

As it developed there would have been some sites that, as the Leas-Chathaoirleach suggests, would have been quite expensive. I think the one in Cork was very expensive because of the topography, etc.

Comment on this
Catherine Murphy An Leas-Chathaoirleach Social Democrats

Will Mr. Conlon give us a note on that?

Comment on this
Mr. John Conlon

We can.

Comment on this