Vote 13 - Office of Public Works
Contributions 476–710 of 710. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
The site at Backweston is a flat piece of land, is near services and is a larger one. I presumed that kind of one would have been more viable.
Comment on this
There should have been better economies of scale there because of the-----
Comment on this
It would be useful for us to see that comparison if Mr. Conlon could provide us with the information. Clearly, the Department was more than aware of this and decided to go ahead with it at senior official level.
I move to the children's science museum. There has been quite a lot of money spent on that already given the cost of arbitration. There is a second arbitration. Is there a cost for that available to us? It was not the last time the OPW was in. There is obviously the cost of planning permissions. There were several of those, as well as designs and things like that. Is there a cumulative cost there?
Comment on this
On the second arbitration cost, the final costs for that are not available yet. When we get them we will have to assess them with our legal cost adjudicators, etc.
Comment on this
I cannot for the life of me understand how the OPW was on the hook for this either. Deputy Kelly drew attention to the notion it should not have been on the hook for the modular homes either. There is no sponsoring Department, yet it is the OPW that is dealing with the arbitration. I cannot for the life of me understand how the OPW would have been advised that in 2013, in the middle of the economic crash, when everything was being downsized, services were being cut right, left and centre and the troika was in town, there could not have been an argument made that this was not something the State could afford. I am sure the State said it had no money, but surely the arbitration should have been proceeded with on the basis this was not something the State could viably proceed with. It should have been ended at that stage. Can Mr. Conlon give us a copy of the legal advice the OPW got? I am formally requesting that. There is that and then there is the second thing, which is going into arbitration without a business case and without the costs for fit-out.
This is not like fitting out an office block where one is putting in desks and chairs. One is putting in very expensive museum pieces, which will have to be replaced from time to time, because one will need to keep the space freshened up. I am told that the fit-out would be something in the region of €20 million.
Comment on this
The OPW will not be on the hook for the fit-out costs.
Comment on this
I understand that but there is no point in building a white elephant or building something for tens of millions of euro and then to discover that the people who are insisting that this be built do not have the wherewithal to put that kind of money into fitting it out. I would have thought that kind of clarity, the cost and the longevity of running it, given that this is a charity, would have been part of a business case before one would ever enter into an arbitration because there are two sides to this. How did the OPW not argue that there was an inability to proceed with this, given everything else that was happening?
Comment on this
The 2013 agreement, and my knowledge of this is coming from a review of the files because I was not there at the time, was very much based at the time on legal advice. I know what the Leas-Chathaoirleach-----
Comment on this
I know the Leas-Chathaoirleach has requested the legal advice and we will take that request back for consideration. Normally, we do not share legal advices but I ask that she allow me to take that request back and we can revert to the committee then.
On the 2013 position, it was very much a legal position under an arbitration agreement. The arbitration did not go to the full hearing and the legal advice we received was that we were obliged to sign what was signed at that stage.
The Leas-Chathaoirleach may have noticed that it went back to arbitration in more recent years and there was a more full exposition of the business case during that process but the arbitrator kept his decision very much to the legalities of the contractual position in which we found ourselves in 2013.
Comment on this
Would the arbitrator have been oblivious to the economic situation the State was in? We were under supervision by the troika and every piece of spending was being monitored. Surely, that is an argument which would have been advanced. I cannot figure this out at all.
Comment on this
To respond to the Leas-Chathaoirleach, I find this hard to explain and to understand even though I have read all of the files on this. The fact the project did not develop from that 2013 position was because of the lack of funding available to the OPW and to the State over that period. The promoters then came back in 2020 as things improved and sought further arbitration on it.
Comment on this
As was outlined earlier, it is not the same thing to what it started out as being where the State was not going to cover the cost but it was going to be built as part of a development and was very much a Celtic tiger proposal. It is now double the size that it was originally intended to be. As this charity is making demands, the OPW is acceding to those demands and I cannot understand how the two, with two almost identical facilities, can be viable. I am also concerned about the location. It is mostly school bus tours which will be visiting the existing one. Where will that be accommodated? Is it in or around the National Concert Hall?
Comment on this
That is not clear to me, to be very frank. As was indicated in the earlier discussion on this, I very much want a full value-for-money assessment and risk case to be done on this before funding is applied to this project, if the Government so decides.
Comment on this
-----because the arbitrator has more or less indicated that it has to be built and that there is planning permission. The OPW is saying it has to be built but it is also saying that it has to do a proper business case. I would have thought that would have been done before arbitration. The OPW has to do a proper value-for-money business case. It must then find a sponsoring Department. It is then competing with something that-----
Comment on this
We are in a very awkward position here, to be very frank.
Comment on this
I am not going to give a view on that because if I did, it would be inappropriate. We are in a legal position which arose from the 2003 contract, the 2023 contract and the subsequent arbitration where, contractually, we are the contracting authority, like we were on the modular homes.
Comment on this
A lot of what we talked about earlier, and this is typical of the public accounts committee, is money that has already been spent.
Comment on this
We are in a rare position where some money has been spent, but the bulk of it has not. We are in that rare position where a mistake has not been made that we are back here talking about in five years' time. It does not seem that is the approach being taken here, given the legal advice, how the legal advice was followed, how the OPW is on the hook and that there is no sponsoring Department. It is not in the national development plan. There is no money committed to this by a Department or by the Government. This is daft. I will move on as I have a number of other questions.
I want to stray if Mr. Conlon does not have the responses to these. However, Deputy Kelly asked were there any other issues that should come to light. One issue concerns accommodation, which was supposed to be on Military Road, where the Garda’s Scott House is now located. That moved from Harcourt Square, which they had to vacate. Harcourt Square could accommodate more gardaí. My understanding is that there are two units of the Garda that could not be accommodated in the new facility but are being accommodated in Clyde House where the OPW was leasing a building. If Mr. Conlon does not have the information to hand, he might come back to the committee with the cost of that lease. The other thing is that when they had to vacate, they had to be accommodated somewhere. One of the units was accommodated in a building in St. Stephen's Green that had to be fitted out. They subsequently moved from that. Will he provide us with the fit-out costs?
The other issue concerns Drury Street carpark, where I understand some parking spaces were set aside or leased for the time they were in that building. Will he come back to us with the cost of those?
Comment on this
I do not have the information with me but we can do that.
Comment on this
Mr. Conlon may be back here, but like others, I will not be back after the election. This is one I have pursued constantly. I have been told there was no extra cost for car parking. I think the reply might have been Jesuitical in that it was not associated with Scott House but it was associated with one of the other units not accommodated there and which was previously accommodated-----
Comment on this
We will get back to the Deputy as soon as we can.
Comment on this
That is fine. I turn to Deputy McAuliffe's point about the bike shed. Like everyone else, I echo that is something that comes up routinely. In my area it comes up in the context of wasting that amount of money on a bike shed while the ball was dropped so badly on something of such importance as Castletown House. I have raised this on the past two occasions the OPW has been in. Is it really serious about buying the land in Castletown? People are looking at freedom-of-information responses. The land adjacent to Castletown House is essential for access into the house and its viability. It is the finest house of its type. Its architecture is of international importance and it is successful in attracting visitors, including to the house but predominantly people who visit the land. Should it have been identified as a strategic purchase? It was turned down by the Department when it was offered for sale in 2022. I would have thought that the OPW would have gone back to the Department to state this was of strategic importance.
Was that done? Would it have been pointed out to the Department the risks, which were identified by the OPW, in not buying this land?
Comment on this
The business case that was made to the Department of Public Expenditure, National Development Plan Delivery and Reform at that stage made it quite clear that the OPW wanted to buy this property. The circumstances at that time were that it was a competitive situation with other bidders bidding as well. Unfortunately, the bid made by the OPW was not the highest bid so it went to another bidder.
Comment on this
I understand. I am referring to the one before that, which was in 2022. It was not on open sale at that stage and it was offered for sale to the OPW in advance of it subsequently going on the open market with a closed bid process.
Comment on this
As I have said, the OPW did make a business case to the Department at that stage. For whatever reason, the Department did not sanction what the OPW wanted to bid at that time.
Comment on this
The concern was that there could be a hostile owner, and essentially this is what has subsequently transpired. Looking at the history of it in terms of it being a strategic purchase, would that have changed the valuation on it?
Comment on this
Obviously, the OPW must look at valuations. We are acutely aware of value for money. Would the valuation have been different if it was regarded as a strategic purchase as opposed to land that was zoned for agriculture or for amenity?
Comment on this
I will be frank. I need to be careful of what I say here. We had this discussion the last time I was here on the commercial sensitivity of our position in relation to lands there. The Leas-Chathaoirleach opened her comments with a question on whether we are serious about it. My answer is that we are. We will continue to endeavour to try to reunite that estate insofar as we can, but we are dealing in a property market where there is another owner of adjacent property that we may deal with in time. I do not know. I am very conscious that our medium- and long-term objective is to reunite the lands and get access to lands insofar as we can. There are commercial and property issues that I need to be very careful in commenting on.
Comment on this
I will make one final point on this. It is not clear that the OPW knows what it owns there either, in terms of another access in. Money was spent servicing the area into the farmyard. It is not clear that the OPW has done a huge amount of work in looking at alternatives. I will leave it at that. People are losing faith that the OPW is really serious about finding a solution here.
Comment on this
We are serious but it is a difficult position to be in when one is talking about property leases or purchases. One might be in negotiation positions. I would find disclosing any position at this stage very difficult given what we want to do in the future.
Comment on this
I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach. I apologise for arriving so late to the meeting. I was chairing the meeting of the Select Committee on Education, Further and Higher Education, Research, Innovation and Science. It was unavoidable. I apologise also if I duplicate earlier questions as I was not in a position to follow the meeting.
I am aware that the issue of modular housing has been raised. I will not ask specifically about that. I was trying to get to grips with how much the actual boxes cost, or the actual units. We were given the average cost of €442,000 for delivery of each unit. In Mr. Conlon's briefing note, he said €150,000 was required for remediation of sites, provision of services and connectivity services, and things like that. In a very simplistic way, I took the €442,000 and subtracted the €150,000. I hope I am wrong because that put me at €292,000 for the actual box, the actual modular unit that I am describing. If I am right, the unit is 45 sq. m.
It is that cost I am looking to get at, that is, the average. We have a total overall cost. We are saying the sites were difficult and required a lot of money to get them ready. I want to know how much we paid for the-----
Comment on this
The cost of the ones to which the Deputy is referring was between €145,000 and €150,000 each.
Comment on this
Each modular unit cost €150,000 and is approximately 45 sq. m. That puts the average cost per square metre - I am only running the calculation now - at €3,333. Am I correct?
Comment on this
All the units are the same size. That is the cost and, therefore, is the price per square metre.
Comment on this
Mr. Conlon said that figure is for that particular size of unit.
Comment on this
Most of the modular units we have put in place, with the exception of 12 in Backweston, are of that size. There are some in Backweston that are completely different.
Comment on this
Help me understand the difference. The total cost is €442,000 from which the OPW is saying I should subtract approximately €150,000 for remediation of site works, provision of gas and so forth. When I do that subtraction, I end up at €292,000. The OPW says the box itself costs €150,000. I have, therefore, lost €150,000.
Comment on this
No. When the Deputy says a “box”, I am talking about a modular unit. That is the one thing.
Comment on this
Yes, the modular unit. Mr. Conlon told me the average cost per modular unit is €442,000.
Comment on this
The average cost per unit of developing sites, including connectivity to services such as gas, water and communications, and extensive remediation works on the suboptimal sites available, is in the region of €150,000 compared to initial cost. Mr. Conlon is telling me to subtract €150,000 from the figure of €442,000 for the cost of preparing the site.
Comment on this
It is now more than €150,000 due to all the cost escalations on sites.
Comment on this
That is in the briefing note I have been supplied with. In any case, let us say it costs more than €150,000 and is €160,000 or €170,000. I do not know. The OPW is saying it costs €442,000 in total, with €150,000 of that for site servicing. The actual modular unit, which I am pejoratively calling the box, costs €150,000. I am still missing €150,000.
Comment on this
I am not sure from which briefing note the Deputy is reading. To clarify-----
Comment on this
Does Mr. Conlon disagree that the average cost per modular unit is €442,000?
Comment on this
The figure of €150,000 the Deputy is reading was for preliminary costs, but they escalated further than that.
Comment on this
Let me come at it another way because I am not getting a clear answer. Let us split it the other way because it is €150,000 the other way around also. It is the same amount. The total cost per unit is €442,000. The box itself, that is, the modular unit, costs €150,000. That leaves €292,000. Where is the €292,000? Mr. Conlon is not telling me it costs €292,000 per unit to prepare the site.
Comment on this
There were significant cost escalations in site development, utilities-----
Comment on this
Hang on a second. The €442,000 is an awful figure. I am going to return to the €150,000 because the figure Mr. Conlon gave me comes out at well over €3,000 per square metre. I will come back to that. Mr. Conlon said €442,000 is the total. The actual physical modular unit is costing €150,000. That leaves a hole of €292,000 to fill. Can Mr. Conlon please outline how the taxpayer paid close to €300,000 for the provision of modular units separate from the modular unit?
Comment on this
Significant site development costs developed over the period of this project. As I said earlier during the discussions we had in the first part of this meeting, we faced significant costs with each of those sites because they were all suboptimal sites. Most of them required huge investments in site development costs, including issues with bringing in utilities, site clearance, the presence of rocks, slopey sites, ESB connections and foul sewers. That escalated over time to a significant degree.
Comment on this
Mr. Conlon asked from which briefing document I am speaking. This is the document that was sent to the clerk to the Committee of Public Accounts on 7 October 2024 in preparation for this meeting.
I again quote from that document, which is not paginated, unfortunately.
Comment on this
It states:
A significant level of works is required to bring the site up to standard. The average cost per unit of developing sites, including connectivity to services - gas, water and communications - and extensive remediation works on suboptimal sites available is in the region of €150,000.
I fail to grasp how I have €442,000, and if I subtract €150,000 for the actual modular unit, the difference is €292,000. This document indicates the site preparation costs €150,000, in which case I have lost €150,000 that I cannot account for.
Comment on this
We have undertaken, on foot of a request from Deputy Murphy earlier, to give a breakdown by site. We will do that. That will include some of the costs I am talking about.
Comment on this
I will move on because it does not sound like Mr. Conlon is going to give me an answer. It is entirely unsatisfactory that he said that a unit is €150,000, which is the top-end figure, and I am missing €150,000 in his calculations. I will move on.
In terms of delivering value for money, Mr. Conlon said the cost is approximately €150,000 for 45 sq. m, which according to my calculator is €3,333 per square metre. When the OPW was directing either Sisk or the five contractors that Sisk delivered these modular units through, was any outline price given in terms of cost per square metre? One of the first considerations for anybody building a house in any part of the country is cost per square metre. Was there any indication in the tender documents that we wanted to deliver a certain cost per square metre?
Comment on this
At that stage my understanding is that there was a nascent and undeveloped modular unit capacity in Ireland.
Comment on this
I had a look at Huf Haus, the German company that does really fancy, Dermot Bannon-type houses. They cost €2,000 to €2,500 per square metre. I looked at Shomera. I am not necessarily comparing like for like but, including installation and construction on site, the cost is €2,081 per square metre. Huf Haus produces top-of-the-range units. Mr. Conlon is saying we are paying 150% more per square metre, for 45 sq. m units for four individuals. Were there no criteria applied by the OPW in respect of cost per square metre?
Comment on this
My understanding, and we can double-check this, is that when we went to the market for this-----
Comment on this
Had the OPW gone to Shomera, it would have cost €2,081 per square metre.
Comment on this
To be fair, in regard to what we have, the units have a lifetime of 60 years.
Comment on this
I am flabbergasted by those answers. I had a number of issues to go into by way of contractors' lists but the Chair was very good to let me in when I arrived late.
Comment on this
Mr. Conlon's statement was very ill-informed. Most of the modular builds constructed by Shomera actually exceed the lifetime he mentioned. My question refers to the modular build. What is encompassed in the 45 sq. m, from a living perspective? Does it include toilets, bedrooms, sitting room, kitchen?
Comment on this
That is my understanding. I think there are two bedrooms.
Comment on this
That means there are two bedrooms at €442,000. I do not care if it is the most expensive, worst site in the history of the State. There is not a site in Dublin that has cost €289,000, as Mr. Conlon said in reply to Deputy Kelly, for groundworks. It must be remembered, the same preparation occurs for all constructed houses. It takes less time and it does not come in at that cost. If he made this known, who did he make it known to? Has he a copy of that correspondence? I am not asking for it now.
I want it submitted to the committee. I want Mr. Conlon to tell us who was made aware of it. I refer to what he told Deputy Farrell earlier.
Comment on this
I ask Deputy Murphy to please bear with me for a moment.
Comment on this
Mr. Conlon is running down the clock. Could Mr. Conlon please submit it to the committee?
Comment on this
Yes. We can share with the Deputy papers that were submitted to both the Department of Children, Equality, Disability, Integration and Youth and the senior officials group.
Comment on this
That is fine. Is it correct that it includes the names of those Mr. Conlon made aware of the expected detailed cost overruns, and the non-viability of this project?
Comment on this
It sets out our view that the costs were developing and what that meant.
Comment on this
Will Mr. Conlon please submit that to the committee? Was it a similar contract to that relating to the children's hospital in that there was no actual contract other than saying "Get on with it"? Was it a base contract?
Comment on this
To be frank, I am not familiar with the specific contract.
Comment on this
Could Mr. Conlon get the details for us?
Comment on this
Could he please submit them to the committee as well?
I want to move to coastal erosion. There are very serious issues in Enniscorthy, as Mr. Casey will be aware. Could he please give me the status of the flood relief scheme for Enniscorthy?
Comment on this
Yes. We are bringing forward Enniscorthy in two phases as a result of the refusal of the consent process in early 2022. On foot of that refusal of consent, we had to review the design of the scheme in order to bring forward a scheme for Enniscorthy that will stand a chance of securing consent. We envisage that the scheme will protect up to 326 properties. We propose to go forward in two phases. The first phase will be to mitigate flood risk by the removal of the Séamus Rafter Bridge. We are working on a planning submission for that phase, which we expect to submit for planning in October of next year.
In conjunction with that, we are looking to appoint design consultants to engage on the second phase of the scheme, to undertake the detailed design of the substantive flood relief scheme. As Deputy Murphy may be aware, the removal of the Séamus Rafter Bridge will also require a replacement bridge downstream and the construction of a pedestrian bridge over the River Slaney. That is all coming in under phase 1 and phase 2 will follow that. We also expect phase 2 to go into planning by October of next year.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Casey.
I want to ask about the PR consultant contract in respect of which the tender was withdrawn. Was there a reason for that?
Comment on this
I was not aware on the day that it was being issued. I was concerned about the cost of it and wanted to have sight of the services being offered. That is why I asked for it to be withdrawn.
Comment on this
Is Mr. Conlon going to reappoint the current consultants for another year? I believe that is allowed.
Comment on this
That is not in my thinking at the moment. We want to reissue the tender, but I want to do it in a different way.
Comment on this
Reports in the newspapers this morning indicate that Mr. Conlon was concerned about his reputation. I am sure he knows this already, but from the public's perspective and from our perspective in the context of value for money, it would be much easier to enhance his reputation if the mistakes made by the OPW are not continued. If we learn from them, Mr. Conlon will not need a PR consultant.
Comment on this
Deputy Murphy's time is up. I call Deputy McAuliffe.
Comment on this
I want to return to the discussion we had earlier on the bike shelter. Ms Morrison informed the committee that there was approximately €120,000 for the adjacent EV charging project. Is that correct?
Comment on this
I apologise. I wanted to make sure I got it right.
Comment on this
It was for 12 car-charging facilities.
Comment on this
Is that for 12 sockets or 12 facilities?
Comment on this
It is the infrastructure for 12 EV chargers.
Comment on this
I presume it was for the associated groundworks as well.
Comment on this
The witnesses might forward the details of that project to us as well.
The point I was making earlier is that, at some stage, projects become unviable or no longer provide value for money. The bike shelter is in that territory. A project that was important, well meant, necessary - all those things - got to a point where it just cost so much that it was not viable. My worry is that the same kind of lack of a ceiling that existed with the bike project also exists when it comes to modular housing.
I cannot imagine how a project is presented to Cabinet without knowing the sites involved in the first instance, particularly as we know that a site is often the biggest part of a project. I do not know how an estimate was presented to Cabinet for a project when the sites were not known. That is my first point. Second, when sites were presented, they invariably involved different challenges and costs. There must have been a ceiling whereby the OPW said that a site was not viable beyond that point. Mr. Conlon informed Deputy Farrell that the senior officials groups was informed that there would be a challenge to provide these on a cost-effective basis. Earlier in the year, he informed me - I cannot remember whether it was here or at the housing committee - that this would come in roughly in the range of the market value of a traditional home. The rapid builds were coming in at around the same price, namely at a significant cost. Where is the red flag? Where is the viability ceiling? Where is the point at which or process by means of which the OPW states that no more can be spent on something because it is not viable? Is there a process in that regard?
Comment on this
Regarding the development of this project, I emphasise that we are the contracting authority. The Department of integration was the approving authority.
Comment on this
Did the Department give the OPW an unlimited budget to do it?
Comment on this
We kept it in the loop on the escalating costs of this at all times. We raised our concerns regarding viability.
Comment on this
With the Department of integration and the senior officials group. The decision to proceed was not made by the OPW.
Comment on this
The OPW was instructed by the Department to proceed.
Comment on this
It might be useful, as another Deputy requested, if the witnesses could provide us with the correspondence relating to that. The difficulty is that each side will be complex. The last time I spoke about this with Mr. Conlon, I raised our experience, dating back to when Deputy Kelly was a Minister, with the rapid-build sites in Finglas and Ballymun. At the time, everybody did what everybody does with rapid builds. They took the unit cost - you can buy it off the shelf - and multiplied it by the number of units and stated that was what the cost would be. In reality, however, site works are a significant factor. Does Mr. Conlon accept that the figure that went to Cabinet, or the initial outline for this figure, was woefully and inadequately estimated?
Comment on this
I fully accept that. It was a provision assessment without having regard to any sites, because none had been made available at that stage. I would also point out that a huge number of sites were rejected because of unviability. We were working with very suboptimal sites, to be frank.
Comment on this
Was that known from early on in the process?
Comment on this
Yes. That is why we raised concerns early in the process.
Comment on this
Was Government informed of that?
Comment on this
It would have gone to the senior officials group and to the Department of integration. I can check the memorandum from Government, but I think that issue was raised there.
Comment on this
I imagine part of the calculation was that all of these costs we are talking about are still cheaper or more cost-effective than using hotels and other forms of temporary rented accommodation.
Comment on this
I would prefer it if the Department of integration answered that question because we are the contracting authority. We make our knowledge of the building costs and site development costs available. The decision to proceed was not made by the OPW. The decision to proceed was made by the Department of integration.
Comment on this
Perhaps that is the first question Members of the Thirty-fourth Dáil should ask.
Comment on this
In paragraph 5.31, I draw attention to the memorandum for Government that was submitted. It identified 20 potential sites but, ultimately, only six of those were made available.
Comment on this
To follow on from what the two previous Deputies were talking about, I hear Mr. Conlon's frustration in relation to the site cost. It is clear he was very honest with the officials that this was a substandard site. It seems he was completely ignored. It seems they were willing to write a blank cheque and just get the job done even though Mr. Conlon was clear these were suboptimal sites. We now see this added €289,000 to the site costs. Does Mr. Conlon feel there was huge pressure on the OPW to get it delivered, to get on with the work and to say nothing?
Comment on this
To be very frank, we work with our partners in government. As I said, and have kept on saying, we are the contracting authority. This was an emergency situation that the Department of integration was dealing with. It had to provide as much accommodation as quickly as possible.
Comment on this
Yes but we are still waiting on some of them. We are talking about an emergency situation, and I accept all of that. The point is that Mr. Conlon, to be fair, raised it with the officials and told them to hold on a second. He said these were suboptimal sites and it would be extremely hard to deliver what they wanted to deliver. They told him this was an emergency. He said the sites were suboptimal, that it would take a lot longer and cost a lot more. This is not a question for Mr. Conlon but a question for the officials. Mr. Conlon was ignored in relation to that. We now have a situation where he is in front of this committee explaining modular units, which cost €442,000, that nobody can stand over.
I want to raise a few quick issues. I am unsure if the Leas-Chathaoirleach already touched on them because I came in late for other reasons. I am aware that in the instance of Miesian Plaza, the OPW overpaid rent to the tune of €10 million because it used the wrong standard and it should have used international property measurement standard 3, which was introduced in 2016, but it failed to do so. Have there been any similar incidents where there was a failure to use the correct standard, resulting in an overpayment of rent?
Comment on this
I am not aware of any but I will ask Ms Morrison to address the question.
Comment on this
I am not aware of any similar incidents.
Comment on this
The OPW can assure this committee there were no more mistakes since and there have been no other instances of overpayments.
Comment on this
Not that Ms Morrison is aware of. Has she looked into this? I assume this is something the OPW has ensured does not continue.
Comment on this
On the building the OPW is renting in Smithfield, I have heard it is renting it for between €6 million and €8 million a year. In 2019, it was reported the OPW believed it would serve as a headquarters for two large Government organisations. Can Ms Morrison identify which Government organisations are the current occupants and when they moved in?
Comment on this
This is the distillers building or Smithfield Hall. It is not occupied at the moment.
Comment on this
Is the OPW paying that rent, despite the fact it is not occupied?
Comment on this
For how long has the OPW paid the rent?
Comment on this
The rent kicked in in April of this year.
Comment on this
The rent kicked in this year. It is between €6 million and €8 million at the moment. When does Ms Morrison expect people to move in?
Comment on this
We expect people to move in during quarter 3 of 2025.
Comment on this
A full year's rent will have been paid at that stage.
Comment on this
How much money is the OPW spending on the fitting out?
Comment on this
It is quite a significant building and it will be the headquarters for a number of Government organisations.
Comment on this
It will be the headquarters for Tailte Éireann, which is an amalgamation-----
Comment on this
-----of Ordnance Survey Ireland, the Valuation Office and the Property Registration Authority. It will also consolidate the Chief State Solicitor's Office into one location.
Comment on this
How many people does the OPW expect to work in a building that costs €60 million to fit out?
Comment on this
There will be over 1,000 workstations in this building altogether. There will also be 200 smaller organisations-----
Comment on this
I am concerned because I know at the top of my estate in Mervue in Galway, there is huge concern about the Crowne Plaza site and how much money it will cost to fit that out but that is not for the OPW to discuss here today. That is an issue of concern.
With regard to the office building at Bishop's Square in Dublin 2, I understand the building has six floors. Is the OPW renting all six floors? Can Ms Morrison confirm how much the OPW has paid in rent for the building to date and to whom?
Comment on this
The entire building is a seven-storey over-basement building in Bishop's Square.
Comment on this
There are seven storeys. Are they all occupied?
Comment on this
The OPW leases five and a half of those floors.
Comment on this
It leases five and a half of them.
Comment on this
Yes. The other two and a half or whatever are leased by private sector tenants.
Comment on this
The five and a half storeys the OPW is using are occupied.
Comment on this
How much is the OPW paying for that?
Comment on this
The annual rent is approximately €6.5 million overall.
Comment on this
I cannot think of the name at the moment-----
Comment on this
Ms Morrison can send us an email, if that is okay.
Comment on this
I can, yes, but it is an investment fund.
Comment on this
For clarity, will Ms Morrison send us the details?
Comment on this
Ms Morrison is entirely sure the OPW is not renting any floors that are idle?
Comment on this
I had asked about the correspondence relating to the bike shelter. I acknowledge that we are now in possession of correspondence dated 19 October 2020. I wanted to ask a couple of questions about that. There was a letter to the Ceann Comhairle, which was dated after the general election and which was signed by Deputies Bacik, Cannon, Costello, Carroll MacNeill, Leddin, Matthews, Ó Cathasaigh and Noonan and Senators Higgins, Moynihan and Ward. It related to that correspondence from 19 October and referred to previous correspondence with the commission dating back to July 2018 concerning provision of facilities for bicycles and cyclists in Leinster House. I do not want to go through all of it because it is quite long and has been published. I want to get an insight. Obviously, this letter relating to the need to build a bicycle shelter within the precincts of Leinster House came to the OPW. Did the OPW tell that group of individuals, some of whom are members of this committee, how much the project would cost? The correspondence was sent on 19 October 2020, which was pretty deep into the crisis caused by the Covid-19 pandemic. This matter spans four years of complex planning and everything else that goes with doing the work that the witnesses have outlined. In that time, did the OPW fully inform the Ceann Comhairle and the commission of how expensive the project would be or was the cost hidden from the commission?
Comment on this
I will let Ms Collier come back on that in a second.
Comment on this
I do not want to be personal. I know Mr. Conlon is new to his post. Is he abreast of the details relating to this matter? It is a major policy crisis. Ms Collier has dealt with a lot today, to be fair to her. Mr. Conlon is the boss.
Comment on this
I am. I wrote the review of the price of the bicycle shelter. That is my work. I am abreast of the matter. Ms Collier is very familiar with the history of the project, which is why I referred some questions to her. To answer the Deputy's direct question about whether the OPW made the commission aware of the cost of this project, it did not. One of the recommendations I am making in my review is that the OPW needs to be clear in making the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission aware of the cost of elective projects such as this.
Comment on this
The letter that Mr. Conlon provided states that before the February 2020 election, Senator Bacik and other colleagues had raised this issue on many occasions with the commission, and Senator Bacik had convened a meeting in October 2018 with both Oireachtas Members and staff who were cyclists and passed on the concerns of all those-----
Comment on this
It is, because the OPW is developing it. I want to get an insight. This is correspondence that the OPW has chosen to provide and I want to refer to it. The OPW withheld the cost from the commission. For the people who are listening in, the commission is made up of Members of all parties of all political creeds. These individuals are appointed by their respective party Whips or political groupings if they are Independents. It is not a Government body; it is a stand-alone body that has responsibility. That is important to explain because the public might not be fully aware of that. Did the OPW not take the perspective that this was a very expensive development in the grounds of the national Parliament? We all know the reputational harm that has been caused because what the OPW has done has been exposed by means of freedom-of-information requests. This has turned into a national embarrassment. The story has gone international because it was so badly managed and handled. Did anyone take a step back and say that perhaps it was not wise to build a glass shelter for bicycles that cost the same as a detached house on the grounds of the national Parliament? That is a very fair question to ask of the OPW.
We heard questions about whether this came up at audit and risk. As regards the reputational harm the OPW has done, does Mr. Conlon feel any remorse in his role, on behalf of his organisation? I know he was not there when this decision was taken and I acknowledge that fully-----
Comment on this
-----but does he feel any remorse for the harm he has caused to the reputation of the Parliament of this country?
Comment on this
To be very clear, I fully acknowledge this, and in the review I did, which was my review, under my name, I made it very clear that the overall cost of the delivery of this project was completely unacceptable in the wider context of value for money and value for the taxpayer. I acknowledged that it is an extraordinary cost for the provision of a covered bicycle parking facility and one which the OPW seriously has to reflect on. That is there in black and white. I wrote that down-----
Comment on this
I do not propose to spend much more time on the bike shelter. I want to ask about the siopa at the front of Leinster House. Anybody who does cycle to this campus - and I was one of the signatories to that letter - knows the vast preponderance of the bikes arrive in through Kildare Street, not through the Merrion side, where the bike shelter is. Is there a plan for what is going to happen to the siopa, which was another one of these white elephants?
Comment on this
I am not familiar with a plan at this stage, but may I ask Ms Collier? I know I am deflecting, but the siopa is an old project and I am not sure where it is at now.
Comment on this
The siopa is currently used for broadcasting facilities - for RTÉ, primarily, when it is broadcasting - and-----
Comment on this
That is the outside of it as opposed to the inside.
Comment on this
No, they actually use the inside for equipment, including broadcast equipment, so it is used for broadcast purposes at the moment. I do not see that changing, but, of course, if we were to receive a request from the commission to consider other options, we would do that.
Comment on this
This may seem a facetious question, but I do not intend it facetiously. Did anybody look at the siopa for the provision of bike parking? When the OPW set about a project to say, "We need to build some bike parking", did anybody at any stage say, "The siopa has been chronically underutilised?" Was it factored in anywhere? No. Okay. It would-----
Comment on this
To me, it seems as obvious as the nose on my face, but there we go.
Another thing that is as obvious as the nose on my face is climate change and sea level rise. What sea level rise is the OPW factoring into its forward planning?
Comment on this
May I ask Mr. Mooney to take that question, please?
Comment on this
The OPW has a number of forward scenarios that we look at. There are two for fluvial and we have four for sea level rise. We have a mid-range future scenario, which is 0.5 m, a high end, which is 1 m, a high end-plus, which is 1.5 m, and a high end-plus-plus, which is 2 m.
Comment on this
What is the date on that, may I ask Mr. Mooney?
Comment on this
As the Deputy will know, the IPCC report highlights that towards the end of the century we can expect sea level rise which is very much in line with our mid-range and high-end scenarios, but there is a lot of uncertainty there, which is why we have the additional two scenarios.
Comment on this
But Mr. Mooney is saying 2100. Is that the kind of timeframe within which the OPW is predicting these scenarios?
Comment on this
That is not us; the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has predicted that. There is a lot of uncertainty in this space. We have used a number of scenarios in order to project forward as to how the future might unfold and we take a conservative and a very precautionary approach to stuff like that.
Comment on this
I think most evidence would point towards around a metre by 2100. The witnesses can probably guess my next question. The last major coastal change study the OPW has done does not factor that in. Professor Peter Thorne, in a report from Caroline O'Doherty, said what we were announcing was "a plan to make a plan" in terms of dealing with coastal erosion. Our coastal erosion study does not factor in sea level rise currently.
Comment on this
In terms of coastal erosion, there was a report, as the Deputy has just outlined, produced in October 2023. That report had 15 recommendations, which are being implemented at the moment. The OPW has been designated as the lead body for the technical assessment of coastal hazard.
That work is under way and is, as the Deputy has outlined, to look at what the impacts of climate change on coastal erosion are and what the predictive nature of coastal erosion will be going forward.
Comment on this
The OPW is looking at Inishowen and my part of the world, Tramore.
Comment on this
There is a pilot project at the moment which has been tendered for. That is a key part of kicking off that work. We have been doing a lot of work in terms of ongoing monitoring of various sites around the country. We have a national LiDAR survey under way. All of that is necessary in order to gather information which-----
Comment on this
Sorry. I have a couple of questions on the contractors list in relation to a parliamentary question to which I received the answer yesterday. I refer to the contractors list and the criteria the OPW has set out where contractors are removed, including if they do not match the criteria in the application form. Reference is made to an application form including details such as insurance, Safe Pass training, tax clearance and compliance. There are no issues around that. These are not criteria whereby people are removed from contractor lists used by the OPW.
Comment on this
My understanding is that if the contractor does not comply with all of those, it may be removed from the list. Insurances, for example, are an issue in respect of which a contractor can be removed. In one particular-----
Comment on this
May I ask finally, were any contractors removed from the contractor list due to non-compliant procurement?
Comment on this
Not that I am aware of, but I might need to double-check that.
Comment on this
You might do that and come back to us.
I want to go back on a couple of points. I raised the issue of the two Garda units in Clyde House. Obviously, the OPW is leasing that building. I understand that the building, or part of it, was repurposed. Is it known how long that lease is for?
Comment on this
I think the lease is for ten years, but we can come back to confirm that.
Comment on this
Have there been complaints about the quality of the building that has been leased? I understand that some personnel are housed where there is no light or natural ventilation. I would not have thought that was the kind of standard that would be acceptable.
Comment on this
I am not aware of any complaints at the moment anyway.
Comment on this
Okay, but you might just check that out.
Does the OPW own the site beside Military Road, Walter Scott House? Do you know the site on the corner? It used to be where the compound for cars and so on was.
Comment on this
As the road goes towards Kilmainham and the Royal Hospital?
Comment on this
If you are coming down Military Road towards St. John's Road, on the right-hand side, just beyond Walter Scott House.
Comment on this
Just to be sure, we will check it and come back to you.
Comment on this
There is obviously potential for expansion there, rather than having facilities dotted all over the place. You might come back to me with that other information when you have it.
As regards the national children's science museum, going back to 2008, I understand the operating income was likely to be trading income of 50%, philanthropy of 11% and government support of 39%. Is that ratio still what is being considered? Would the museum pay rent, for example? If it gets a core building, does it have to pay the rent? Would that be part of the business case, or would there be the potential of a risk in terms of state aid if there is competition?
Comment on this
One of the reasons I have indicated on a number of occasions during this meeting that an up-to-date value-for-money assessment and business case will be required is to address some of those issues. Again, the operating side of this will not be for the OPW.
Comment on this
It will not, but in terms of what is required for assessment going forward-----
Comment on this
May I stop you there? The operating side will not be for the OPW. My understanding is that it builds the core and then the museum does the fit-out and runs it. Is your understanding that the museum would require to fund the cost of running it, or is there intended to be a subvention from the Government on that?
Comment on this
I am not aware of any decision on any intention for operating subvention from the Government.
Comment on this
No Department is sponsoring it. I understand that originally the Department of enterprise was the sponsor Department.
Comment on this
Now the OPW is talking to the Department of tourism. It is more in the higher education or education area because of the children and science aspect, but no Department has put its hand up to run this. The Department would have the responsibility rather than the OPW. The OPW is not getting instructions from any Department, so how does it make decisions about what to consider as regards how it will be run, the risks and so on?
Comment on this
As I said in some of the documentation I submitted to the committee, I am anxious that a funding Department be identified for this because the OPW has no funding for it going forward, either on a capital or operating basis. It is not that this is-----
Comment on this
The OPW does not have any money to proceed. That is the bottom line.
Comment on this
If a Department were to sponsor it, the arbitration would follow. It would have to take that on board.
Comment on this
I am anxious that the funding be linked to the decision to proceed or not following the arbitration. Otherwise, I do not see how it can proceed.
Comment on this
Does the cost of €145,000 to €150,000 for modular homes include them being fitted out?
Comment on this
No, the furnishings and so on would be an additional cost. Within the overall costs, I think the fitting-out costs - this is subject to being double-checked - is in the region of €10,000 to €11,000 per unit.
Comment on this
May I clarify or correct an earlier response to Deputy Verona Murphy? She inquired about the phase 2 timeline on Enniscorthy. I mentioned that it was planned for October next year. That is unlikely. The next milestone for phase 2 of the project in Enniscorthy is the appointment of a design consultant by the second quarter of next year and the planning permission will come possibly two or three years after that. I do not have a precise timeline on the planning application for phase 2.
Comment on this
Mr. Casey will be aware of two tranche 2 schemes, in Rathcormac and Castlemartyr. Both have flooded on multiple occasions. I have asked this question of him before. Does he have any update on the prioritisation of those schemes, considering that they have flooded on numerous occasions? They have been in a holding pattern since 2017 and 2018. This came through the catchment-based flood risk assessment, CFRAM, programme in the OPW. We have discussed this and we need to see some progression. Both areas were heavily hit by flooding this month last year.
Comment on this
Both schemes are tranche 2 schemes. Unfortunately, because 100 tranche 1 schemes are being rolled out at the moment and we have a further 50 or so tranche 2 schemes, we are not in a position to bring forward the tranche 2 schemes, given all the challenges and constraints, including resources and so forth. Therefore, we do not envisage bringing forward tranche 2 schemes into tranche 1 at this time. However, we address any urgent or immediate needs in those and other tranche 2 locations through our minor works programme. The Minister recently announced funding of close to €70,000 or €80,000 for Castlemartyr - it was in that order - to bring forward urgent measures to mitigate flood risk in Castlemartyr. I understand Cork County Council is looking at Rathcormac to see what interim measures might be feasible. It may consider submitting a minor works application in the short term.
Comment on this
I thank our witnesses and the staff of the OPW and the Department of Public Expenditure, NDP Delivery and Reform for their work in preparing for today's meeting. I also thank the Comptroller and Auditor General and his staff for attending and assisting the committee.
Is it agreed that the clerk will seek any follow-up information and carry out any agreed actions arising from the meeting? Agreed. Is it also agreed that we note and publish the opening statement and briefing provided for today's meeting? Agreed.