We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Financial Statements 2025: Uisce Éireann

Summary

Uisce Éireann reported 2025 revenue of about €1.8 billion and capital investment of €1.43 billion, with profits reinvested in infrastructure; the Comptroller and Auditor General issued a clean audit opinion. The CRU’s €31 million reduction in future allowed revenue for missed leakage and non-domestic collection targets was accepted by the utility, which said it would deliver efficiencies to absorb the impact. Uisce Éireann outlined a €12.2 billion investment programme focused on network upgrades and housing capacity, while acknowledging ongoing service and communication challenges. Committee members also questioned executive pay and performance awards, the funding model, procurement transparency and the pace of local projects.

Contributions 1–208 of 1,084. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 5 parts.

John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

This morning we will engage with Uisce Éireann. The agenda for the meeting is to discuss the financial statements for 2025. On behalf of the committee I welcome officials from Uisce Éireann: Mr. Niall Gleeson, chief executive officer; Mr. Chris McCarthy, chief financial officer; Mr. Sean Laffey, asset management and sustainability director; Ms Maria O'Dwyer, infrastructure delivery director; and Ms Margaret Attridge, head of water operations. We are also joined by an official from the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage who is attending in a representative capacity: Mr. Brían Munnelly, principal officer. Finally, we are also joined by officials from the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General, including Ms Colette Drinan, the secretary and director of audit, on behalf of the Comptroller and Auditor General who is a permanent witness to the committee; and Ms Maria Reck, audit manager. You are all very welcome here this morning.

Before we begin, I wish to explain some limitations to parliamentary privilege and the practice of the Houses as regards references witnesses may make to other persons in their evidence. The evidence of witnesses physically present, or who give evidence from within the parliamentary precincts, is protected pursuant to both the Constitution and statute by absolute privilege. This means that witnesses have an absolute defence against any defamation action for anything they say at the meeting. However, witnesses are expected not to abuse this privilege. It is my duty as Cathaoirleach to ensure that this privilege is not abused. Therefore, if witnesses' statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, witnesses will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that witnesses comply with any such direction. Witnesses are also reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that might be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity.

I will now call on Ms Drinan to deliver the opening statement on behalf of the Comptroller and Auditor General.

Comment on this
Ms Colette Drinan

I thank the Cathaoirleach. As members are aware, Uisce Éireann is responsible for developing and operating water and wastewater services nationally. The company operates under the aegis of the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage, and is within the remit of the Commission for Regulation of Utilities. The income statement for 2025 indicates that Uisce Éireann had revenue from its continuing operations totalling €1.8 billion. Government subvention funding of over €1.2 billion represented over two thirds of the company's operating revenue. The subvention is related to the company's provision of water services to domestic users. Revenues in 2025 from non-domestic water charges were €333 million.

Fees paid for new connections generated income of €262 million. Uisce Éireann’s operating costs totalled just under €1.2 billion in 2025. A breakdown of the operating costs is provided in note 3 to the financial statements.

Uisce Éireann incurred expenditure totalling €359 million in 2025 for hired and contracted-out services. The company incurred expenditure of €222 million in respect of its own employee costs. A further €103 million was incurred in relation to costs arising from long-standing local authority agreement costs. These comprise payments in respect of local authority staff and other costs associated with the continuing involvement of local authorities in the delivery of water services. Some detail on the arrangement with local authorities is included in note 25, Related Parties. Other costs, including utility charges, materials, ICT, facilities and operating costs, totalled €504 million. Uisce Éireann’s profit after tax and net finance costs was €345 million. This was up from €279 million earned in 2024.

During 2025, Uisce Éireann invested €1.43 billion in capital projects. At the end of 2025, the company held property, plant and equipment assets valued at €9.2 billion. The State’s equity interest in Uisce Éireann at the end of 2025 was just under €7.6 billion. This comprised share capital of €324 million, aggregated retained earnings of €1.9 billion and aggregate non-refundable capital contributions totalling €5.3 billion. The latter included State capital contributions totalling €801 million received in 2025, made up of €287 million from Vote 34 and €514 million issued directly from the Central Fund of the Exchequer. In addition, Uisce Éireann has borrowings of just under €1 billion from the Central Fund.

The Comptroller and Auditor General issued a clear audit opinion on the 2025 financial statements. However, the report on the audit drew attention to a disclosure in the statement on internal control. This outlined the circumstances around a proposal by the Commission for Regulation of Utilities to impose a penalty on Uisce Éireann in the form of a €31 million adjustment of future revenue. The adjustment arose because the commission considered that in the period 2020 to 2024, Uisce Éireann had under performed in achieving its targets for water leakage reduction and the rate of collection of non-domestic revenue. When the audit report was being signed at the end of April this year, Uisce Éireann was still engaging with the commission, whose final determination was awaited. The chief executive officer will be able to update the committee about the outcome of that engagement.

Finally, the committee may wish to note that from 2026, a separate Vote will be used for funding of Uisce Éireann, consolidating the State funding provided. The Secretary General of the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage will be the Accounting Officer for Vote 39 - Uisce Éireann. The published 2026 Estimate for Vote 39 has little detail about the purposes for which the funding is being provided by Dáil Éireann, and limited information about the high-level output measures and performance targets relevant to the funding provision. Over time, development of the information in the Vote Estimate and the related performance measures, and the filling-out of the appropriation account, should allow for more transparency about Exchequer funding of Uisce Éireann and its delivery performance in key areas.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Ms Drinan for that. I now ask the chief executive officer to deliver the opening statement on behalf of Uisce Éireann. As set out in the letter of invitation, he has five minutes to do so.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Good morning, Chairman and members of the committee. Thank you for the invitation to discuss our financial statements for 2025, as laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas and published on our website as part of our annual report.

As Ireland’s national publicly owned water services utility, our purpose is to deliver transformative water services that enable communities to thrive. An infrastructure built for a country of 3.5 million people now caters for a population of 5.5 million and rising. Nevertheless, amid this increasing pressure on our public networks and assets, Uisce Éireann’s 2025 annual report demonstrates the delivery we are continuing to make against our purpose while also recognising the scale of the work still ahead.

Last year, we completed works on several landmark projects and we will continue this momentum in 2026. In our statement and submission sent to the committee, we provided an overview of a number of multimillion euro investments made in 2025 and in the first half of this year, projects that are delivering daily benefits to communities, the environment and the economy. Uisce Éireann has been subject to an annual audit by the C and AG since 2023. We are pleased to have received a clean audit opinion for 2025, the third consecutive such opinion from the C and AG. This reflects the high standard of our financial governance, reporting arrangements, internal controls, policies and processes. We thank our board for its consistent support, guidance and oversight in this regard.

For the financial year 2025, Uisce Éireann recorded revenue of circa €1.8 billion, invested circa €1.4 billion in water and wastewater infrastructure, increased the value of the national asset base to over €10 billion and generated a surplus of €396 million, which was entirely reinvested in critical infrastructure. Separate to the C and AG audit, as a regulated utility, Uisce Éireann operates under the CRU’s revenue control framework, which sets funding and performance targets. In its review of the 2020 to 2024 revenue control period, and notwithstanding an overall positive assessment, the CRU determined that Uisce Éireann had underperformed against leakage and non-domestic billing targets, resulting in a €31 million negative revenue adjustment to future allowed revenue.

On leakage, levels are at their lowest ever, with water loss reduced from 49% in 2014 to 36% nationally and currently less than 30% for the greater Dublin area. We are fixing around 2,000 leaks on average every month across some 65,000 km of water network. The task is sizeable. Nevertheless, we accept the CRU finding. Supported by the Government’s national development plan, with a record capital funding allocation to the water sector, Uisce Éireann is seeking to deliver a multibillion capital investment plan over the RC4 period, continuing to make strides in reducing leakage across the country. The scale of investment now being delivered by Uisce Éireann is unprecedented and is only made possible by the significant commitments from the Government, through both funding and policy supports. We have secured approximately €12.2 billion to invest between 2024 and 2030, including funding specifically to increase water and wastewater capacity to support new homes. This total investment package is essential to reduce leakage, improve resilience, support economic growth, protect the environment and achieve greater compliance with current water and wastewater standards.

This investment is translating into tangible delivery. For example, in 2025, we completed 12 new and upgraded wastewater treatment plants, including a €139 million investment in Arklow wastewater treatment plant, serving a population equivalent of over 24,000 and ending raw sewage discharges into the Avoca river. We laid or rehabilitated 78 km of wastewater network and 195 km of mains, including continuing to progress the largest repair programme to date on major trunk mains around the Ballymore Eustace plant, aimed at tackling some 20 leaks. This has saved over 4.5 million litres of water per day from leakage and ensures security and supply to over 1.7 million people.

Drinking water and urban wastewater treatment compliance remained high, at over 99.8% and 90%, respectively. Meanwhile, capacity for new homes was a top priority in 2025 and is key to supporting the delivery of 300,000 new homes that families and communities need across the country. Funding has been allocated to Uisce Éireann to identify and deliver capacity in priority locations, which will unlock the greatest amount of housing potential to support national targets. These plans are progressing and we recently announced the 72 priority locations where investment will be targeted to achieve these goals. Our connection and developer service continues its critical role in enabling housing delivery, issuing connection offers associated with almost 42,000 housing units and positive responses to pre-connection inquiries associated with over 182,000 housing units throughout 2025.

Ireland is at an inflection point, with a focus on momentum and collaboration across government on investment, co-ordinated planning and legislative reform to address national infrastructure constraints. Uisce Éireann shares its focus and is moving at pace to deliver its programme. However, delivering at this scale will inevitably have a destructive impact on communities. While we know these infrastructure projects are essential for the future of our nation, our economic growth and housing construction, we appreciate that in the short term this can be challenging. We will work closely with local communities and elected representatives to achieve delivery with minimum disruption.

Tools like our free text alert service, website, media engagement and social media channels are all important ways of keeping people informed. We are continuing to improve the timing, accuracy and clarity of our communications so that customers, communities and elected representatives have the information they need as works progress.

We are also actively engaging in the community through public project briefings, working through traffic management plans, taking on board feedback where possible from homeowners, businesses and their elected representatives.

On water supply, leaks, bursts, outages and supply interruptions remain key operational pressures as demand on our networks increases continuously. We are investing in active leakage management, network rehabilitation, asset renewal and improved operational response, but in addressing these issues and improving our networks, the immediate disruptions will persist before the overall benefits are visible.

The same applies to wastewater, where we continue to manage capacity and compliance pressures. Environmental standards, ageing legacy infrastructure, planning and consenting requirements, and the need to keep pace with housing and economic development all require a sustained focus. We are progressing new and upgraded infrastructure as quickly as possible within these processes and constraints while continuing to engage constructively to resolve concerns and maintain momentum. We are also delivering this sizeable capital and operational plan in parallel to and balanced against the ongoing national staffing and service transformation, now in its final year. In brief, we have the funding, we have progress on policy reform and we are focused on delivery of our programme of renewal.

In summary, our 2025 financial statements and annual report show meaningful momentum while also underlining the scale of delivery still required. We welcome today’s discussion as an opportunity to demonstrate how Uisce Éireann is delivering on behalf of the Exchequer, strengthening national water services and using public investment to deliver long-term value for customers, communities and future generations.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Mr. Gleeson. We will suspend the meeting at about 12 o'clock for a short break and then resume after about 15 minutes. The lead speaker today is Deputy Farrelly, who has 15 minutes. All other members have ten minutes. On conclusion, if time allows and with the agreement of our witnesses, we will open up for a short round of supplementary questions. I call Deputy Farrelly.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Gleeson, his colleagues and the witnesses from the Department. The year 2025 was clearly a very busy and profitable one for Uisce Éireann. An important part of that, however, was the determination by the CRU with regard to underperformance. Did Uisce Éireann agree with the regulator about its determination?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

The CRU is our economic regulator. Obviously, there are other regulators that set targets. It is a portion of our deliverables. The regulator set 24 targets for us as part of the five-year revenue control period. We achieved 20 of them, almost achieved another two and failed two on leakage and revenue.

On whether we agreed, we achieved the percentage leakage targets the CRU set out. We did not achieve the net leakage, the absolute amount. We argued that because of population growth and increased demand over that period, it was a very difficult target to achieve. We have accepted the CRU's result. I will ask Mr. McCarthy to follow up.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

We had robust discussions early on with the regulator, especially on the leakage side and, indeed, on the non-domestic collection rate. It is based on the provision in the accounts over total revenue. We are still in discussions with the regulator on the added provision situation. We have a complex model, developed over a number of years. Under the IFRS 9 accounting standard, you are also required to look at macroeconomic factors.

Comment on this

With regard to the question, did Uisce Éireann accept that decision? Was it reluctant acceptance or wholesale? Did Uisce Éireann appeal it?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

We would always engage in robust discussions with the CRU on these targets.

Comment on this

Robust discussions, to me, means that it did not accept it.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

We did accept in the end. We had good discussions and engagement but at the end it held its position and we accepted its decision on those two issues.

Comment on this

How much non-domestic income was lost as part of that determination? What was the sum not received by Uisce Éireann?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

I will let Mr. McCarthy answer that.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

I am not sure if the Deputy understands the regulatory model. Essentially, it is a negative revenue adjustment. It is not a fine in the sense that you pay money over to customers or whatever.

Comment on this

It limits what you-----

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

It limits what you can get in the future. From that perspective, it is €31 million in total, comprising €20 million on leakage and €11 million on the non-domestic side. Combined, that is spread over the next five years' revenue control. You build up your total allowed revenue under revenue control period 4 and deduct the negative adjustment from that. There are other positive ones as well. On a net basis, we were at €84 million. With regard to that €31 million, we are going to have to find efficiencies across the organisation.

Comment on this

Will that come from the profits for 2025?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

No, it will come from delivering real efficiencies, which we will have to deliver over the next five years in line with our allowed revenue on an annual basis from 2025 to 2029.

Comment on this

With regard to pay-related bonuses, where a lot of people have questions is when the CRU says a body in some facets is underperforming, yet certainly in 2024, I think close to 94% of staff received full bonuses. What was the performance related award, PRA, figure for 2025? What percentage of staff received a full PRA?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

These are two different elements. The revenue control is over a five-year period and the annual performance scorecard is done annually, obviously. That bill and the PRA are paid out on the back of that and on the back of achieving both individual and corporate targets.

Comment on this

I did not ask for the rationale, to be fair. I am running out of time. What was the percentage?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

We have a performance related award system, which is basically-----

Comment on this

What percentage got that for 2025?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

I will come back with that. To put it into context, everybody has personal objectives that are either met or not met.

Comment on this

Are they determined internally or is there regulatory oversight?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

It is with each individual-----

Comment on this

Is it just internal?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

There is external as well. If the Deputy will let me finish, internally, everybody has performance objectives. Mr. McCarthy will have some stuff for me that he will achieve this year, for example, but multiplied by that is an overall company objective, based on a performance scorecard, based on external factors like leakage, revenue control and revenue input. If your annual scorecard says you did what we had asked you to do on an individual basis, that is multiplied by the performance of the company. Rarely does anyone get 100%; it is multiplied. Last year, I think the multiplier was around 93%.

Comment on this

That would be on par with the year before. Is that correct? I think it was 93.5% in 2024. The percentage of staff who received a PRA-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

That is a different question.

Comment on this

That is the question I asked a few minutes ago.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

I think it was 97% roughly. I will get the exact number.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Of those people, however, they only received 90% of their potential payout.

Comment on this

The bands of those-----

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

I might just come in on that front because it is important to explain. This is a tried and tested market benchmark model that really drives performance. That needs to be understood. The headline on the €31 million came out from the regulator, which we absolutely accept, but the reality is the regulator has been highly complimentary of our performance in revenue control period 3. I might just quote a few things. The CRU specifically highlighted-----

Comment on this

I am really against the clock.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

-----the following achievements: the construction of 29 new treatment plants, the removal of 62 water supplies, microbiological compliance improvement of 213%, THM compliance improvement of 130% - I can go on if the Deputy wants.

Comment on this

I think this is a bit facetious.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

It is not facetious.

Comment on this

It is a smart remark for Mr. McCarthy to say he can go on if I want. I asked a very specific question. I just asked for a percentage. I did not issue comment or judgment. I just asked for a percentage. Both Mr. McCarthy and Mr. Gleeson, with respect, have tried their best not to answer that question over maybe four minutes.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

That is our model. Our pay model has two elements-----

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

It has a performance related-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

We have answered the question.

Comment on this

Very reluctantly and after context, which took an awful long time to get through. Let me be clear: I commend the vast amount of work Uisce Éireann does. It is really important work but it is now without its flaws or challenges.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

We accept that as well.

Comment on this

Fair enough.

Mr. Gleeson spoke about market rates with regard to performance related awards. What Uisce Éireann does not do, which sets it apart from others, is pay a dividend to the State. That is the way it was established. Have any efforts been made to counter that - to say "look, we've got €345 million worth of profits but also significant Exchequer funding in this company"? Have there been any conversations with the Department and the Minister to correct that and to say that while Exchequer funding is coming, significant salaries are being paid at an executive level and profits are being made, Uisce Éireann will start looking at making a return to the Exchequer?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

The profits are totally reinvested in infrastructure investment. We make a profit but it is reinvested in the capital investment programme.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

That is the funding model within which we operate. If we were to give a dividend back to the State, we would be getting it elsewhere in terms of a capital contribution because we do not have domestic charges.

Comment on this

The company has non-domestic charges that it is not gathering to a sufficient extent, based on what the regulator has said.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

A total of 20% of our revenue comes from non-domestic charges.

Comment on this

That is a significant amount.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Equally, any profits made there are reinvested into capital. We have a €12.2 billion capital requirement in revenue control 4. We could not fund that any other way. We do not have any additional-----

Comment on this

Uisce Éireann has not sought to amend that by way of paying a dividend. News reports cited comments from Uisce Éireann justifying a significant pay increase to the CEO because of market-led demand. The ESB also has a significant salary for the CEO but it is paying a dividend to the State. Uisce Éireann is picking and choosing when it suits it to be a unique entity.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

The ESB does not require any State intervention. It gets no money from the State and, therefore, it pays a dividend back because it is entirely self-funding. We require 80% of our funding to come from the State because we do not bill domestically. They are very different models.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Ultimately, that is a decision for the Government in terms of policy. The policy decision was made back in 2017 to stop domestic charging and as a result of that, we had to find a funding model. We are still regulated. The regulator still has full oversight in the exact same way as ESB, Gas Networks Ireland or any other regulated utility.

Comment on this

The witnesses mentioned Government policy. Who is the Minister responsible here?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

It is the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage.

Comment on this

How often does Uisce Éireann meet him?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

We meet probably every couple of months.

Comment on this

There is no standing meeting with the Minister?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

There is no standing meeting but we meet regularly.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Obviously we have a monthly meeting with-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

I would meet the Department.

Comment on this

To what extent would the Department and the Minister have oversight of or influence over the work programme and day-to-day workings of Uisce Éireann? How involved are they? When elected representatives ask questions in the community, it is often very difficult to get answers. I know Uisce Éireann has an accountability mechanism internally but how involved are the Department and the Minister?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

On an annual basis, they would review and approve our annual business plan. That is a function of the outturn from the regulatory model. When we work with the regulator on revenue control and the capital investment plan we want to do, etc., it signs off and approves that, but that is done with the Department knowing what is involved. The Department meets regularly with the regulator and us.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Gleeson accept that the level of communication with communities regarding unplanned outages happen or reservoir levels go really low could be improved? Is there an intention to try to improve that from a capital perspective, whether that involves increased funding-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Yes. A few things are happening. We are in a transition from the local authority model to the single utility model, which will be completed this year. We recognise that this has created some gaps locally. We have things like our text messaging system, to which 400,000 people have signed up. That goes out with regular updates based on a person's post code. A lot of work is happening. We are trying to create a link between what people are doing on the ground and our contact centre - our national operations centre - so that we can get the right information out to people as quickly as possible. Generally, our system is working quite well but there are issues in the field where we are trying to get information from the field as to what exactly is happening. There might be multiple bursts. Getting all that communication back to our central control and distributing that to customers can be challenging. We have got the feedback from elected representatives and we are looking. We know that some of our answers can be generic and corporate-sounding. We are trying to make that language better. We are trying to come up with a dedicated service for Oireachtas Members. We are taking proposals to our board this month and, hopefully, we will have something to put in front of the Minister in the next couple of months to improve that service. Ms Attridge will talk about the field and how that is working.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

From an operations perspective, we are trying to improve that flow of information. Following changes we have made in the past year to our ways of working, we are seeing a significant improvement. We have 31 different ways of working and trying to get all of that information from the field is critical to be able to inform Members of the Oireachtas and the communities about issues in the field. We need the information coming back from the field. All our crews across the country have hand-held units and work is managed through that. They are supported by a dedicated schedule and dispatch resources, which were not in place across all the local authorities' systems previously. We now have better information coming back from the field, which allows us to provide communities and Members of the Oireachtas with information about outages and to put that information on our website more instantly. We have seen that the number of outages we are reporting has increased but that is because we have better reporting coming back.

We know we have more to do regarding getting clear information on the cause of the outage so that we can keep people informed and also about when issues are resolved. Our first step this year, as we have been going through the transformation programme, has been to get those hand-held units used in the field. We have another programme of work to improve the information coming back from the field but the changes we have made there are delivering improvements.

Another change we have made in operations is that rather than queries coming in through our local representative support desk, LRSD, and going out to all the different individuals in the field, in operations, we have dedicated technical teams in water and wastewater through which we channel those queries, particularly when they are more complicated. The teams look to give a response that gives timelines for solutions as well. It is not just the problem we are looking to resolve.

We measure our turnaround time and despite there being a significant increase in queries coming through, we have reduced the turnaround time, on average, from 17 days to eight days. Our target for next year is five days, on average. Many get closed much quicker but we are constantly improving and listening to feedback from Members of the Oireachtas about how we can do it.

Comment on this

I compliment Uisce Éireann's procurement team and thank it for some of the engagement I have had with it over the past year. It gave me fantastic presentations that were very insightful. A lot of the work that Uisce Éireann does is ultimately procured and contracted out, so it is very important that it manages its suppliers well and recognises that it has to have downward price pressure on suppliers to be able to force positive outcomes. When Uisce Éireann gets a significant uplift in budget, my fear relates to how that capital can be deployed efficiently and effectively. That is a real conversation that I am sure Uisce Éireann has all the time.

I will start with purchase orders. Uisce Éireann publishes its purchase orders in an aggregated format. Could Mr. McCarthy explain why that is the case?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Obviously, we are exempted specifically as a utility from having to go down to the individual level. That is specifically allowed for a utility. We publish categories of our purchase orders. We are very conscious of transparency and the need for transparency but, at the same time, we are fully compliant with our requirements.

Comment on this

I respect that because I am conscious that other utility companies do not publish the purchase order level. I would be interested in finding out whether Uisce Éireann is willing to do that in the future?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

I should say that I went through the Deputy's model and I have to say it is a good piece of work. It is really professionally done and great information and insights can be there.

I also acknowledge that-----

Comment on this

Can Mr. McCarthy see how, if Uisce Éireann was spending a few billion, that could contribute to more transparency if the purchase orders were there?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Absolutely. At the same time, there is a fine line between trying to deliver value for money and providing too much information that could impact, given that Ireland has a small market. Right now, the model the Deputy has goes far enough but not too far in terms of delving into the individual details so that people know exactly the cost of the work.

Comment on this

Uisce Éireann should focus on getting to a point where, in the future, purchase orders can be readily available for the wider public given that the bulk of its spend is procured.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

We are also very conscious that the utilities directive is about to change shortly on the European front.

Comment on this

The European procurement Act will play a big part.

It does not appear on the surface that there are any scandals with Uisce Éireann at the moment, but there are three key issues at the forefront of the public mind when it comes to the company's finances. The three key concerns are the bonuses and the justification for same; CEO pay; and the €31 million fine and how that contrasts with the fact that the bonuses were paid. I do not have any gripe with somebody hitting their targets and getting their bonuses. Will the witnesses explain how somebody hits their target or bonus and how that is decided? Are the bonuses tiered or is there one flat rate of, say, a 10% bonus for everyone? How does that work internally? How many people might have failed to meet those targets?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

We operate a market-based pay model. There are two components to that – base pay and pay at risk, PAR. Naturally enough, the higher up you are in terms of senior management, seniority, accountability, etc., the higher pay at risk you have. It is absolutely tiered.

The way we set it has two components, the corporate component and individual performance. That is right throughout the organisation. I am not sure there is another organisation that has that right down to the nth degree. What we are finding is that this is really driving performance. It has enabled us to deliver under RC3, and even if we look at our score card for 2025, we did well. A lot moved in terms of our funding and multi-annual funding around advancing the major projects, getting projects off the remedial action list, RAL, and the priority action list, PAL, right across the country. It does drive performance.

The other question was how many people did not receive performance-related awards, PRAs. There is a cohort which has opted out of receiving the PRA. These are mostly people who have come across from the local authorities. They will continue to have their increment basis based on time rather than performance.

We operate to a normal distribution curve. Last year there were eight people, I think, who did not receive any PRA and were eligible.

Comment on this

Mr. McCarthy said it was not a fine but a withhold. How does he square that?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Obviously, none of us want to see that negative-----

Comment on this

Why did the CRU say it was holding back €31 million? What was the justification for that decision?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

It was because we did not achieve two of the 24 targets that were outlined. They both had negative revenue adjustments associated with them. One was on the collection rate or the provision and the other was on the leakage side.

Comment on this

I am conscious of time. Uisce Éireann has been given a huge injection of capital to deliver the infrastructure the State needs. Sometimes we can forget about the importance of water, sewage networks and treatment plants. It is vital.

There is one thing I would like to compliment. The Minister for housing, Deputy James Browne, allocated approximately €1 billion to the housing infrastructure fund earlier this year. One project on the list is in a town I represent, Athenry. It is the Raheen sewer network extension. That money was only allocated three or four months ago and Uisce Éireann is on site right now delivering a sewer extension in Athenry, which will lead to the delivery of approximately 800 homes. The witnesses will answer a lot of questions today but it is a good news story that, three months after getting the capital, there are people on the ground delivering the work. If only every State body was able to react as quickly. I want to see that in Irish Rail and Bus Éireann and in the NTA building bus corridors. In fairness to Uisce Éireann, it got on the ground. Is the company confident that it can roll out capital projects swiftly?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Yes, definitely. We will deliver €700 million this year in capital projects. We have small amounts being spent on the water supply project and the greater Dublin drainage. We have lots of smaller projects that are being delivered all around the country.

Going back to the PRA point, as I said, individual performance is multiplied by the company performance. The company performance took a hit so everyone in the company took a hit because leakage rates were not made in that year. We do take a hit.

The other thing on leakage is that we need that water. We are not driven by the CRU's penalties. We need that water in a lot of towns and cities around the country because we just do not have the supplies.

Comment on this

I am conscious I have a minute and a half left. It would be remiss of me not to ask Mr. Laffey about the measure A8 pilots. I am conscious the Government allocated money three or four years ago to five of the local authorities. There was a commitment that by September-October, a consultant would be appointed under the measure A8s. I am talking specifically about Craughwell and Clarinbridge sewerage networks. Has that consultant been appointed? Have the letters of intent been signed by the councils for them to actually go and get this done?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

The memorandum of understanding has been approved by all the directors of the local authorities involved. They are bringing them to CEOs for approval. There will be a signing ceremony of those MOUs in the next two or three weeks, we hope. In parallel with that, we are looking actively for a consultant to take on the work and we hope to appoint them shortly, after the MOUs are signed.

Comment on this

Therefore, that consultant will be responsible for delivering all the sub-projects that €50 million originally funded.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Across all the five local authorities, yes.

Comment on this

When Mr. Laffey says "delivering", the consultant will design it, progress the planning application through the local authority-----

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Yes, and procuring-----

Comment on this

It will procure and everything else.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Yes.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Laffey have a timeline for how long it will take to drive this? For the people in Craughwell, it is heartbreaking that the money was announced three or four years ago and they have not seen anything happen yet. That is a real frustration. I know it was not Uisce Éireann that got the money but we have to see progress.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

There is a mix of projects. The one in Wexford is just a network extension, so there is no difficulty with that and it will be done very quickly. It is public road. Craughwell and Clarinbridge are brand-new wastewater treatment plants. Traditionally, it would take us five to seven years to deliver those because of all the issues. Through the accelerating infrastructure task force and work we are doing with the EPA at the moment on modular treatment plants, we are hopeful, however, that when we get all that stuff organised we will be able to deliver in, perhaps, 12 to 18 months.

Comment on this

I thank Uisce Éireann, Mr. McCarthy and his team, for coming here today. The Government made a substantial forward investment under the NDP in Uisce Éireann. Will the witnesses outline the type of investment the Government is proposing or making for the next five years?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Under revenue control 4, which is managed by the CRU, and our performance is assessed by the CRU, we have laid out how we will spend the €12.2 billion that has been allocated by the State. I might pass over to Ms O'Dwyer for more detail on the plans for infrastructure over the next five years.

Comment on this
Ms Maria O'Dwyer

We had €10.2 billion approved through the Commission for Regulation of Utilities to deliver a capital investment programme from 2025 to 2029. That work would have been pulled together by our colleagues in asset management, looking at what the strategic priorities were, how we protect resilience for the communities we are serving today, how we protect the environment and how we enable and support growth. As we were going through that process, we were working to certain housing targets. However, following that, the Government announced higher housing targets so we then identified that additional investment was required to cater for growth as well.

Then we got awarded the additional €2 billion in funding, which is actually to close the gap in those housing targets, so we are now working on a plan to deliver €12.2 billion of investment, €2 billion of which is very much prioritised in growth. There was an announcement a few weeks ago identifying the 72 key settlements where we were prioritising that growth investment in the first place. We are moving at the moment across a portfolio of water, wastewater and above-ground and below-ground upgrades. As to where we are in the year to date, we are probably driving out work 25% ahead of where we were at this time last year. Our delivery partners - many indigenous contractors - have really stepped up and are working with us in terms of providing the resource and that expertise to support us in delivering on that investment plan. We are on track at the moment to deliver against that.

Does Mr. Laffey want to add anything more?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

That is it. There was some confusion at the last Oireachtas joint committee meeting I was at. The €10.3 billion we got originally for revenue control 4 is driven mainly by health and safety growth and compliance, and that is the way we have always operated, but the additional €2 billion we got is directed fully at growth. Those 72 settlements have been announced. It is a plan-led programme that we have in conjunction with the local authorities and the regional authorities. We have identified all the areas of land that need to be serviced and we now have a programme that is rolling to make sure that all those pieces of ground are serviced and capacity for housing is put into those 72 settlements before 2030.

Comment on this

It is a massive investment. Obviously, housing is the existential issue for this Government. There are other problems in the economy but we can see what is driving this. We can even see that, when public sector workers are asked, rent and housing keep coming up again and again. How confident is Uisce Éireann of delivering on the targets that have been set out for it, given the constraints, for example, the competition for people in this workforce? If we are in a building environment and there is a lot of other infrastructure being built, how confident is Uisce Éireann of reaching those targets? It sounds like it has the money, but how will it deliver?

Comment on this
Ms Maria O'Dwyer

We are a 100% committed to delivering on this and making it happen. That is not to say that it is not a big challenge. It is a massive challenge, and we recognise that there is a resource risk in respect of that. We have done a lot of work in the past few months looking again at our supply chain capability across our different delivery profiles. We have been not only assessing the capacity of our existing supply chain but also looking at the wider supply chain that is available within Ireland. We are endeavouring to reach out to contractors that have not worked with us in the past but have the skills and capabilities to do similar work there. We have a lot of frameworks out there at the moment and we have newer frameworks where we are targeting tier 2 suppliers, smaller contractors. Mica is an area we are trying to grow, but we are aware that there are lots of contractors out there at the moment. I refer to support in the pharmaceutical areas and other industrial areas that just have not worked for us before, but we believe they could. We have a lot of plans in place and some frameworks moving to address those. We are trying to widen the supply chain. We are also working with our existing supply chain. We are trying to give people more visibility of the pipeline of work that is coming with them. It is important for those Irish businesses to have the confidence to be able to invest in their own resources, their equipment, their people. That is where the multi-annual funding from the Government is important, in that we have been able to give that visibility. We also have our own Vote line now, which has helped bring more flexibility to where we are at the end of the year and avoid disruptions. Again, when you are building infrastructure, it is not a one-year business. Many of our projects have a long lead-in in terms of planning and design.

Coming back to housing, we are driving momentum. We are delivering at pace in some of our strategic projects. Looking at the greater Dublin drainage project now, we are on the ground. The water supply project is in planning, but we are also doing procurement there in parallel. We still have a lot of consents to get through there, and that is where the Critical Infrastructure Act is allowing us to have better co-ordination with the different statutory bodies. Those two projects are critical to meeting Government housing targets. It is just a matter of appealing for advocacy here and for all of the agents of the State to work with us to actually allow us to get onto the ground because once we get onto the ground and actually start, we have a really good track record of delivering these projects on time and within the budgets available.

Comment on this

I suppose the question is what the Government has done to enable Uisce Éireann in the past 18 months, since this Government came into position. There have been a number of Acts that would appear to have enabled or accelerated the ability to deliver on projects. Specifically, what are the steps that the Government has taken and what are the things that the witnesses think the Government might still be able to do to help?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

I am on the accelerating infrastructure task force, which has been a really good task force to set up. It is a matter of more interagency-type co-operation. As a good example of that, we saved a year on GDD by getting works accelerated-----

Comment on this

That is the greater Dublin drainage scheme.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

The greater Dublin drainage project, yes.

Comment on this

There was a real concern that that was being held up.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Yes. We have also had other discussions. The licence for the GDD project has been issued by the EPA. That is probably a lot quicker than we would have thought. The most recent approval on approval gate 2 for GDD was turned around within a day from the Department. That would have normally taken six to 12 months. That was both sides working very closely together in order that all of the documents were pre-approved and read and everyone knew what was happening.

A lot of really good work is being done with the accelerating infrastructure task force. However, the Deputy's point on competing projects in the State is well made because we have MetroLink coming on board, EirGrid has a huge programme and the ESB has a huge programme. At the accelerating infrastructure level, we need to look at how many projects will be working in parallel, whether we have enough people in the country to do all of this work and whether we should be looking externally to get people in. That is probably our next focus, and we will work with all of our partners and all of the other utilities to get that. We should not forget that the private sector is doing an awful lot of work as well. There are pharmaceutical companies, AI companies and chipmakers, all of whom are investing in the country at the moment, so an awful lot of work is going on.

Comment on this

One of the big issues for public representatives is communication. We had a situation in my town of Ballygar, County Galway, this year. We get our water supply from Mountbellew. Eighty households were left without water for considerable lengths of time. We know that there was a drought, but it was down to the size of pipes. I am not an engineer, so I will not get into that. The difficulty for public representatives was that we could not get an explanation. Eventually, we got someone from Uisce Éireann who was a tremendous source of simple information. Once the simple explanation was delivered to those houses and the town - the water had to be siphoned off to these 80 households for them to have drinking, washing and wastewater - and went out to that group of people, there was an understanding that there was a problem and an understanding that Uisce Éireann knew what the problem was and that it was going to try to put that problem right. Apparently, there was an old 4 in. pipe that could be found. Again, this is a legacy issue for Uisce Éireann. Just getting a text saying your water is going to be out is not good enough. If there is that communication, either through social media or otherwise, explaining what the problem is in a couple of paragraphs, people understand what is wrong and buy into it if they know it will be fixed and Uisce Éireann knows what the problem is. I ask the witnesses for a comment on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

We have got the feedback that our communication is not where it should be and we are looking at that and taking a lot of initiatives. Does Ms Attridge want to explain that?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

What is great now is that we are building awareness of our text messaging system. I appreciate that only so much information can be contained in that, but we now have 450,000 customers signed up to it. That is a great channel for getting information out. In our text messages, there is a link to our website, so people can click and go directly into where there is more information. It is up to us to update that insofar as possible, as accurately as possible and as timely as possible. It is back to systemising our work, that is, using our systems to get the information back to the field so that that information can then go automatically onto our website to be provided to customers. Not that I want to bring it back to the PRAs, but I have a PRA on timely response to queries, and the guys in the field will have a PRA on the use of their handhelds. We are trying to drive improved performance through our PRA system so that we can constantly improve the information we provide to our customers.

Comment on this

Is Uisce Éireann's revenue about €1.8 billion? Can the witnesses break that down into the three or four major categories?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Yes, I can. The subvention is €1.24 billion and the commercial revenue is €595 million. Within the commercial revenue is €333 million in non-domestic revenue.

Comment on this

Say that again.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Non-domestic revenue is €333 million for 2025.

Comment on this

Commercial revenue.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Non-domestic commercial revenue.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Then new connections is obviously the other portion of that, which brings it up to €595 million.

Comment on this

How much is that?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

It is €260 million.

Comment on this

How much profit did the utility make?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

It was €396 million before tax.

Comment on this

What were the deductions after earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation, EBITDA?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Essentially, that profit goes straight back into capital investment.

Comment on this

I know. I will get to that in a second. What were the deductions? Was the EBITDA €600 million?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Is the Deputy referring to our operational expenditure, opex, or to-----

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

EBITDA was €649 million.

Comment on this

What was the major deduction?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

The major deduction from there was depreciation and amortisation of €242 million.

Comment on this

Uisce Éireann made approximately €600 million in EBITDA terms. How did it make that money? Does it even know?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

We do absolutely. We have a very simple regulatory model and I think-----

Comment on this

Uisce Éireann is getting €1.2 billion on one hand, essentially for free, as a subvention yet it is making €600 million in profit. Where is it making all its money? Is it getting extra money that it does not need or is it making significant funds from the commercial side?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

No, just hear me out on this one. The regulatory model is such that it allows building blocks. We operate towards the regulatory model. We are a regulated utility and everyone accepts that. That was decided, obviously, back in 2017 as part of the future framework for-----

Comment on this

I get that but my question is how the utility can have so much fat.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

The way it works is you get an allowance for your controllable opex-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

I am sorry, but there is no fat. To just ask us-----

Comment on this

The fat is the €600 million-----

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

The Deputy asked us whether we understood where the numbers were from. We have just been audited by the C and AG, so we know exactly where the numbers are from. I will let Mr. McCarthy go back to explaining.

Comment on this

No, there is a big difference between an audit and a commercial assessment of a set of accounts. It is a completely different thing. I am asking why the utility has €600 million left over. Why does it need the €1.2 billion? It is a very logical question from an accounting perspective, Mr. Gleeson. I would say Mr. McCarthy would agree.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

The regulatory model allows for three building blocks. One is the controllable, efficient opex. Opex is covered through the first block. On top of that, there is the return on capital, which is the weighted average cost of capital, WACC. The other element is the depreciation allowance. As an entity's assets deteriorate, it has to get an allowance to cover that. Obviously, the regulatory allowance can be different to the international financial reporting standards, IFRS, allowance. The world over in terms of regulated entities, this is how they have their three building blocks.

Comment on this

Yes, but it is a significant amount on top.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Completely, and that is why when we do make that-----

Comment on this

To clarify, the capital investment that Uisce Éireann is getting is a separate amount. I mean the €12 billion.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Yes, but these profits come off that. These profits come off the amount we get from the Exchequer.

Comment on this

I was going to come to that. That was going to be another question. Mr. McCarthy is saying that Uisce Éireann gets €10 billion but it is also making €600 million in profit, so is the €10 billion less €600 million?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

It is minus €600 million, exactly.

Comment on this

That is something that was not clear. No one would have known that if I had not asked the question.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

And probably would not have anyway, but I suppose-----

Comment on this

No, but that is a fair comment.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Yes.

Comment on this

Mr. McCarthy is essentially saying that the amount of capital investment that Uisce Éireann gets from the Government is deducted by its profit.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Yes. Obviously, our new connections revenue is taken off that and our non-domestic revenue is taken off what we get from the Government.

Comment on this

On the commercial revenue - I would prefer it if the witnesses called it "commercial", but they are calling it "non-domestic" - is it increasing next year?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

No, actually. It increased significantly this year. The tariff review kicked in on 1 October. The tariff year is from 1 October to 30 September. On the non-domestic and the pure water and wastewater charges, there is very little increase, if any. From our perspective, we are not seeing any increase in the tariff that is set. There are obviously tweaks there. However, the trade effluent charge for commercial and industrial waste that applies to approximately 5,500 customers is going to come in.

Comment on this

I have a question on that one. Water goes in and I get that, but the water has to be cleaned and treated by a lot of those companies, and then the water goes out. Are they charged on the water going in and the water going out?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

On the wastewater side? Yes, they are but obviously if they treat it-----

Comment on this

That water is treated to a high specification, which they have to pay for, and then they get charged. They are getting a double charge on the same water.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

No, not necessarily. I might ask Mr. Laffey to come in on this-----

Comment on this

More to the point, are they getting charged on the water going in and the same water going out? Is it categorised the same? A brewery that is using the water is getting charged for the water going in and the water going out while they are using most of the water.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Most of that. A number of years ago, there was a specific case on a brewery and it was very clear that the water coming out had to be measured. The brewery had less water coming out, and that was absolutely the case.

Comment on this

It stands to reason.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

That brewery was only paying for the lesser quantity of water. If entities bring it down to domestic-strength waste, it still has to go through our process.

Comment on this

I have a quick question on executive bands. I do not want to focus on pay, but there has been a significant increase. I think it is 41% on the €175,000 to €200,000 band and a 34% increase on the €150,000 to €175,000 one. Will the officials clarify what those roles are?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

They are senior executive roles.

Comment on this

Is that a new stratum of management?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

It is absolutely management. From an overall perspective, it is not new management. It is just that a lot of people would have moved through pay progression, etc. There is nothing fundamental in that.

Comment on this

Nothing radical.

I will bring it back to north Kildare. We have significant issues with the piping of water. A lot of houses have been built in the area but we have had significant issues with our resources. We have got continuous pipe bursts in Leixlip, Maynooth and Celbridge. We have a reservoir at Allen that does not have enough water. We have €10 billion in funding set aside for the next five years. Will the pipes in Leixlip and elsewhere in north Kildare generally get the benefit of that?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

It is probably best for Ms O'Dwyer to answer on the future investment side of things and maybe Ms Attridge will clarify some of the issues we have had in Leixlip.

Comment on this

There is the 450 mm pipe, I think it is called, coming out of the Leixlip water treatment plant towards Maynooth. It is bursting every few weeks, as we know. I think it burst two Sundays in a row and on the Tuesday in between. Local businesses have to shut. That is a really-----

Comment on this
Ms Maria O'Dwyer

We have plans in place now to address that.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

On short-term measures, the main the Deputy referred to that bursts frequently is a rising main, which means that the houses supplied from it are not fed off storage or reservoir, so they lose supply instantly. We are laying-----

Comment on this

We have had a lot of that in north Kildare.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

Yes. We are laying a new main now alongside that rising main and we will transfer all of those houses onto a new distribution main that will be fed from a reservoir. This means that if that rising main goes, there will be storage to sustain supply while the rising main is being repaired. Following the installation of that trunk main, the rising main will be replaced. That is kind of a short-term measure.

Comment on this

That sounds like a good plan. Ms Attridge is saying that the 450 mm pipe that keeps bursting will be replaced with a new pipe.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

That will be replaced within the next year with a new pipe.

Comment on this

Within the next year. The pipe that is causing all the trouble in Leixlip and has done for the last six or seven years will be replaced within the next year.

Comment on this
Ms Maria O'Dwyer

We intend to start work on the ground on that in quarter 1 and then, as Ms Attridge was saying-----

Comment on this

That is quarter 1 of 2027.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

Yes.

Comment on this
Ms Maria O'Dwyer

We have that project now, so we are working through the design and planning of that. As the Deputy can appreciate, it is a very congested road and a lot of activity has happened there already.

Comment on this

I know. I live just off it.

Comment on this
Ms Maria O'Dwyer

There is an amount of work to get ready to do that and ensure we will be able to deliver that appropriately. We are in the planning phase for that, as in working out the construction details. It is our intention to hit the ground in quarter 1.

Comment on this

It was something I brought up a lot as a councillor and bring up as a TD. I am glad that has been listened to and that the issue is being dealt with. I am glad that there is a plan to resolve that issue because it affects 15,000 people and a lot of businesses every time.

Even in Celbridge, businesses are affected by the same thing, as are houses. We have had issues with Maynooth and the Allen Reservoir. Is there a plan to reduce the issues in Prosperous and Robertstown?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

Yes. In the Newbridge area, as the Deputy is probably aware-----

Comment on this

It all comes down.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

-----the main that frequently bursts downstream of the Allen Reservoir has just been commissioned. That should reduce outages significantly, on the downstream end, into Prosperous, Allenwood and those areas. That main is live and people should see a difference in service downstream but there is a lot of other work to do. We have modelled the network to see what areas are restricted. We have also camera surveyed the whole network because we believe that there is some restriction on the line, maybe a turn valve. We found a few minor things which we will remediate and that will provide a little bit of extra flow. Ultimately, what we need to do in that whole area is look at the whole trunk main network, which we are doing, look at how we can optimise and reroute services, and connect particular district metering areas, DMAs, to trunk mains that have better capacity. We have a fairly significant plan in place for how we can optimise the whole trunk network supplying the Newbridge area. That will be carried out on a phased basis. From an operations perspective, we have achieved significant leakage savings, which does really support having capacity available to supply in the short term.

Comment on this

The operational team has been very effective in coming back to me when there are bursts. On the ground, it is the capital projects that we need to get done and Uisce Éireann is doing it. In the meantime, when the bursts were happening, the team responded directly to me. I developed a good relationship with the team on these issues, but hopefully I will not need to talk about them too much more when they get resolved.

Comment on this

I welcome all our witnesses and thank them for coming here today.

An extraordinary amount of money seems to have been paid out in legal fees over the last few years. Can somebody give me an explanation for that? It is a huge amount of money. In the five years up to last year, there were €9.3 million in legal fees.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

We have a lot of judicial review challenges. A lot of our projects are in the courts quite a lot. Mr. McCarthy will go into some of the detail on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Specifically, the sum of €9.3 million related to our self-insurance over the last five years. That is where we would have claims on property damage or personal injuries such as slips, trips, falls, etc.

Comment on this

What has been done to ensure that does not happen?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

From the perspective of Uisce Éireann, we continually monitor and we have better control now. One of the big things that has happened over the last couple of years is that we have greater control over the network and greater understanding.

Comment on this

How much has there been in legal fees this year so far?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

This year so far, legal fees are probably running at a similar level to last year, to be fair.

Comment on this

Is it nearly €6 million?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

What note is it?

Comment on this

In 2025, legal fees were €5.875 million.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

No. Legal fees were €3.6 million.

Comment on this

Is that so far this year?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

No, in terms of the accounts being talked about. Is the Deputy talking about €5.875 million being the total?

Comment on this

Yes. It is the total amount of legal fees in that year.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Legal fees there are €3.659 million and that is the defending phase.

Comment on this

What is the €5.8 million then?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

The €5.8 million is a combination of settlements. That is settlements on top of legal fees.

Comment on this

A total of €5.8 million has been paid in legal fees.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

It is €5.8 million in total, yes.

Comment on this

How much has Uisce Éireann spent on legal fees this year?

Comment on this