We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

COMMITTEE OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS

Financial Statements 2025: Uisce Éireann

Summary

Uisce Éireann reported 2025 revenue of about €1.8 billion and capital investment of €1.43 billion, with profits reinvested in infrastructure; the Comptroller and Auditor General issued a clean audit opinion. The CRU’s €31 million reduction in future allowed revenue for missed leakage and non-domestic collection targets was accepted by the utility, which said it would deliver efficiencies to absorb the impact. Uisce Éireann outlined a €12.2 billion investment programme focused on network upgrades and housing capacity, while acknowledging ongoing service and communication challenges. Committee members also questioned executive pay and performance awards, the funding model, procurement transparency and the pace of local projects.

Contributions 427–645 of 1,084. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 5 parts.

Mr. Niall Gleeson

We do not run a circus the vast majority of the time. I was not aware of this issue. I will certainly look into it and try to understand.

Comment on this

Uisce Éireann is aware of the issue.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Some parts of Uisce Éireann are aware of the issue. It has not been brought to my attention.

Comment on this

Why are these types of issues not escalated?

This is raw sewage that is not being dealt with. It is not good enough.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

It has not been escalated to me at this stage but, as I said, I assure the Deputy that we will look into it and figure out why we are not taking it in charge or why we are not running with it.

Comment on this

It has been transferred to Uisce Éireann. I want to know when it will be resolved.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

I have to-----

Comment on this

Uisce Éireann has already been out to look at it and, again, said it was not its responsibility. This needs to be resolved. It is not good enough.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

All I can do is commit to coming directly back to the Deputy.

Comment on this

I want a response within 24 hours, and I want it dealt with.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

I can definitely get the Deputy a response within 24 hours, and we will deal with it, whether it is ourselves-----

Comment on this

How long will it take to deal with it, if Uisce Éireann eventually accepts responsibility?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

I do not know the situation, so I cannot give the Deputy a date on that.

Comment on this

It is not acceptable that we have raw sewage and Uisce Éireann saying it is not responsible. I want to move on to repeat call-outs and repeat issues, which my colleagues have already raised. Does Uisce Éireann track repeat call-out locations?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

We do. Would Ms Attridge like to take that?

Comment on this

I want a "Yes" or "No" answer.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

Yes.

Comment on this

Can Uisce Éireann pinpoint the locations of its repeat call-outs?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

Yes.

Comment on this

It knows where the top ten, the top 20 and the top 50 call-outs are?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

Yes.

Comment on this

For these repeat network defects, does Uisce Éireann calculate the cumulative cost of the repeated maintenance versus the cost of resolving the issues?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

Yes.

Comment on this

What is that figure?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

May I build a picture for the Deputy?

Comment on this

In about ten seconds.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

We have been through a transformation programme. I told the story earlier about the handheld units. We are building up a knowledge base for assets. This is the first year that everybody is using handheld units, and it is not until we move into 2027 and all employees are Uisce Éireann employees that we will have-----

Comment on this

I am looking for the figure. This is about value for money. I want to know the cost of putting sticking plasters on pipes rather than resolving the issues. Ms Attridge is telling me Uisce Éireann tracks that, which is why I want to know the figures.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

We are mapping hotspots. We know how frequently we are going out to different areas, we are designing technical solutions and we are implementing those technical solutions. On wastewater blockages, we have identified the top 98 repeat blockage call-outs in the country and for those top 98, we have delivered solutions for 84 of them, so people are no longer going out to those. I cannot give the Deputy a national figure.

Comment on this

Ms Attridge is telling me Uisce Éireann is tracking the cost of putting the sticking plaster on versus resolving it, so tell me what the figure is.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

The example I am giving is in Wexford, where there was a call-out 40 times.

Comment on this

Uisce Éireann should have a national figure.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

I can tell the Deputy how many blockages there are nationally and put a cost to it, but we are looking at it on a priority basis.

Comment on this

Does no one have an overall figure for me?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

If we keep looking at things globally, we are not focusing on where the real issues are and where we can deliver the efficiencies.

Comment on this

Uisce Éireann has the detailed issues underneath.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

We are trying to deliver the efficiencies and an improved service in the area. In Wexford, where we had that blockage, somebody was called out 40 times in the past number of years to clear a sewer. Crews are no longer going there, and we have delivered a cost saving on that. We are doing it on a priority basis.

Comment on this

What was that cost saving?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

If crews were going out 40 times at €1,000 each, that would be €40,000.

Comment on this

What was the cost of resolving the issue?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

The remediation was a CCTV survey and removing roots along a section of sewer. It could have been maybe €10,000.

Comment on this

Why was that not dealt with the very first time?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

We did not have the information nationally.

Comment on this

What does Ms Attridge mean by "nationally"?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

Now that we are a national utility, we have all the information coming in centrally. That would previously have been held very locally. We can now put the supports and resources behind resolving these issues. We have technical teams here gathering this information, prioritising and delivering the solution.

Comment on this

I thank Ms Attridge. I have another local issue, where Uisce Éireann is out weekly at an estate, clearing blockages and doing emergency works. It is Mill Hill in Skerries. Skerries needs to be focused on. The workers in Uisce Éireann, fair play to them, are doing their very best, but they have told residents that there are holes in the pipes and design defects, and that one pipe is laid in the wrong direction. Where is the value for money in this? Why is Uisce Éireann not resolving it rather than attending weekly? The public see this, we see this and we have to question the value for money of Uisce Éireann. Where is the value for money when we are seeing a very high payout of bonuses?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

In the short timeframe, we have had the information coming back to us so that we can develop those heat maps and see where those problems are recurring. We have made fantastic progress this year in resolving them, and it means those crews are not going out to deal with repeat issues.

Comment on this

What is the policy? How many times does a crew have to go out to a site before Uisce Éireann will prioritise it?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

Four.

Comment on this

Then this site in Mill Hill should be prioritised.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

It is on the list, and I can give the Deputy an update afterwards. I do not know that one in particular but, if it has blocked more than four times, it is on the list.

Comment on this

Crews are out every week.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

It will be there. There will be a plan in place to address it.

Comment on this

It is ridiculous. We are literally putting money down the pipes with this.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

May I interject? Ultimately, we look after 26,000 km of water and wastewater infrastructure across the country. A lot of the wastewater lines are very old. Some of them are Victorian. We have blockages and breakages all the way across the country, and we prioritise. We might have been out to Mill Hill a number of times, but it is on a list and we are getting to it. There are other places where there is sewage coming up in the streets, and there are pumping stations-----

Comment on this

I already gave an example of that.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

We are fixing it and we are dealing with it on an emergency basis.

Comment on this

Uisce Éireann is not fixing the other example I gave.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

We are dealing with it on an emergency basis, and it will be dealt with on a priority basis. We cannot fix everything, everywhere all at once.

Comment on this

Uisce Éireann is saying it is not responsible for the other one.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

It is impossible. The legacy that we have been left with will require decades of investment.

Comment on this

Uisce Éireann is getting the investment.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

It will require decades of investment. We are getting record investment, but I can tell the Deputy that the long-term funding needs assessment for Uisce Éireann is multiples of what we are getting.

Comment on this

Uisce Éireann is getting the investment. It has increased its employees by 100% in two years. There is a huge amount of investment going into the organisation.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

We are prioritising our work and the spend on the basis of impact.

Comment on this

I want to ask one further question, by way of clarification. I appreciate that Uisce Éireann staff are not subject to incremental pay increases and that it uses a bonus system but, in addition to the bonus system, Mr. McCarthy said he got a 3% pay increase. Does everyone in Uisce Éireann get a pay increase as well as the bonus? How does that work?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

We are currently in the first year of a three-year pay agreement that is based on 3% per annum. That 3% is subject to performance. Someone who underperforms will not get 3% each year.

Comment on this

What percentage of people got the 3% last year?

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Those who meet their objectives. The majority of people, 90% or so, would have got it.

Comment on this

So 90% or so got the 3%, plus the bonus. That was missing. I do not think everyone at this committee appreciated that there is an increase as well as the bonus.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

There is an annual pay increase, like any other organisation, and then there is a PRA system on top, a salary-at-risk portion.

Comment on this

From our interaction last year, we were presented with the position that the bonus was because Uisce Éireann is not subject to incremental pay increases, so it was important to clarify that.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

We do not get increments, but we do get annual pay increases.

Comment on this

So I have just learned.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming before us. I will start with excess usage charges for domestic users of water. Where is Uisce Éireann at with the implementation of those charges?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

They are with the Department, but they are not being implemented at the moment.

Comment on this

I know that, and I welcome it. It seems strange to me, and I wonder whether it is strange to Mr. Gleeson, that Uisce Éireann has a full plan from September 2024 for the implementation of these excess usage charges, approved by the Commission for Regulation of Utilities, and yet it is not implementing them.

Comment on this
Mr. Chris McCarthy

Is the Deputy talking about-----

Comment on this

The Uisce Éireann water charges plan, scheme of approved charges, applicable from 1 October 2024 to 30 September 2025.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

That was always subject to Government approval.

Comment on this

So that plan was not approved by the Government. We have a situation where the public was told that water charges in general, or excess usage charges at the very least, were required under EU law. We have the Water Services Act 2017 which provides for them. We have a plan here, and yet excess usage charges are not happening. As the people set up to collect these charges, which I am obviously against, has Uisce Éireann been asking the Government any questions about what is happening there?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

It is a policy decision, so we are waiting for that decision.

Comment on this

Does Uisce Éireann have a policy from the Government saying not to do it, or does it not have any policy from the Government?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Does Mr. Munnelly have any update on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

No, I do not. Essentially, we cannot carry out something for which there is no policy, so we have no plans to implement it at present.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

There is a representative from the Department here.

Comment on this

Perhaps the representative from the Department could tell me.

Comment on this
Mr. Brían Munnelly

There is a legislative requirement for two statutory instruments that need to be implemented for additional allowances for additional people within households and for medical need.

Currently it is not in the programme for Government and it does not foresee implementation of charges.

Comment on this

It is peculiar, is it not, that a law is passed that says charges are to be implemented yet the Department is not implementing the statutory instrument?

Comment on this
Mr. Brían Munnelly

It is not in the programme for Government so it is not part of the policy at the moment.

Comment on this

This document for 2024 to 2025 refers to a legal framework needing to be in place. Did that legal framework ever come into place or is that precisely what we are talking about?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

That is what Mr. Munnelly just commented on.

Comment on this

The legal framework is effectively missing a couple of statutory instruments.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Yes.

Comment on this

The witnesses spoke earlier about the stress on the water system over the summer and we were fortunate, in this sense at least, that the winter was relatively wet. That means we did not tip over the edge, combined with householders responding positively and responsibly to the call to conserve water. Was there a similar ask made of data centres to conserve water at that time of high stress on our water system?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

The latest data centres are not big consumers of water and there is no fluctuation between colder and warmer weather or drier and wetter weather. We see from the general public that they can respond and make behavioural adjustments. For industry and commercial entities, it is much more difficult. Mr. Laffey may wish to comment on the latest data on data centres.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

The spike in demand during the summer at the start of the drought was domestic in nature. Generally, non-domestic or industrial users are fairly constant in what they require. Across the country-----

Comment on this

These figures come from Uisce Éireann, showing that data centre water usage doubled during the summer months. Is Mr. Laffey is saying that is inaccurate?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

On very warm days they demand a bit more but the most they ever demanded was about 5 megalitres, mostly in the Dublin area.

Comment on this

The Journal has an article titled, "Data centre water use almost doubled during Ireland's long, hot summer months." There is a graph which states the source is Uisce Éireann. It shows water usage went from 100 million litres, presumably per day, in April up to over 200 million litres in July.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

The most the data centres used was 6 million litres of water per day.

Comment on this

This must be per month. Is the usage constant or did it double over the summer?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

It went up substantially in one particular data centre because it is predominantly water cooled. That data centre was in place before Uisce Éireann was in place. Once we came online, we said to incoming data centres that we would no longer supply water for cooling and would only supply water for domestic purposes.

Comment on this

The impact of this one data centre was to double the overall use. Why a minute ago did Mr. Laffey tell me this use was constant?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

It is pretty constant across all of them except for that one.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

It is for all the other data centres. That one data centre-----

Comment on this

So we just do not count the one that uses all the water?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

Putting that in context-----

Comment on this

Mr. Laffey just told me a minute ago that centre usage is constant and now he is telling me it doubled. He got to that conclusion because he excluded the one that actually uses all the water.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

It went up by 1 megalitre.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

It went from 5 megalitres to 6 megalitres.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

I am saying it is not significant in the context of other-----

Comment on this

Sorry, 5 megalitres to 6 megalitres is not doubling. Did it double or did it not double?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Overall data centre consumption went from 5 megalitres to 6 megalitres because one particular-----

Comment on this

These figures suggest a doubling of monthly usage from 100 million litres to 200 million litres.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

We did not see that.

Comment on this

So it is not accurate to say the water use of data centres as a whole, including the one that uses all the water, doubled during the summer months?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

That is not my understanding. We will have to check the Deputy's figures and compare them against ours. They are not adding up to what our understanding is.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

We can check that. In the overall context of Dublin, the data centres are not a burden.

Comment on this

Was there an ask on them to reduce their usage?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

No.

Comment on this

Could there be an ask in the future on them or other big industries such as pharmaceuticals in particular which use a lot of water?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

There might be. Some pharmaceutical companies and other large biotech and technical companies have come to us. We are in active discussions about the reuse of water. Instead of putting it down the drain, they would put in a recycling system.

Comment on this

The article states close to 17 million litres of water per day were used by data centres connected to the public water supply during May, June and July this year compared with 9 million litres of water used by the same data centres during the first four months of this year. Mr. Laffey is saying that is inaccurate.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

The most we saw on any given day was 6 megalitres.

Comment on this

Uisce Éireann might come back to me with the details. If the witnesses could look at this article, that would be helpful. It does say it is based on Uisce Éireann's results.

Does Uisce Éireann have figures for data centre water usage? Can the witnesses tell me a list of all the data centres and how much they use per month, day and year?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

They are all metered. We have that data.

Comment on this

I have seen it reported that only something like 54 data centres are connected to Uisce Éireann. Is that accurate?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

No, there are more than that. I think it is in mid-80s, from memory.

Comment on this

What accounts for the discrepancy between the mid-80s and the at least 123 data centres in the country? I understand lots of them might have closed-loop systems or air cooling. They may not use if for cooling but Mr. Laffey said even most of those 80 do not use it for cooling in any case. Why are 40 not connected at all? Do they not have-----

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

They have their own sources - wells.

Comment on this

Do they use that for potable water as well, for example in the canteen?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Yes.

Comment on this

The whole issue of abstraction is not for Uisce Éireann, it is the EPA.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Correct.

Comment on this

Does Uisce Éireann publish these figures in terms of data centre usage?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

We publish aggregated figures.

Comment on this

Why does it not publish individual figures? I do not think it is required to but Ireland is required to have them publicly available under European directives.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

I would imagine the reason we aggregate everything is if we publish individual figures of the top five or ten large users, it might be commercially sensitive to their operations.

Comment on this

I would ask Uisce Éireann to publish not just the top five or ten but all of them. That is required and I do not think it is fully implemented in Irish law. We have not transposed the directives but it will come.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

We can look at that. If the directive comes in and we are obliged to publish, we will publish. This is billing information. It is commercially sensitive.

Comment on this

Has Uisce Éireann been contacted, communicated with or lobbied by tech companies on this issue of disclosing their usage of water?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

No. This is an internal decision.

Comment on this

There has been no communication.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

The key thing is that because consumption for new data centres is so small, it is non-consequential to us in terms of what we do.

Comment on this

The figure was given during the summer that they used 0.3% of all Uisce Éireann's water. Is that still the accurate figure?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Yes.

Comment on this

Even though at that stage it said 57 data centres were connected to public water supply and it has now gone up to 80-something, Uisce Éireann is still sticking with 0.3%.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

I would imagine the ones above that are very small users. They only use it for canteens and flushing toilets.

Comment on this

Mr. Laffey said there is only one that uses an open-loop systems for cooling which is the big user.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Correct.

Comment on this

In 2021, Uisce Éireann publicly said only 0.13% of drinking water supply was being used by data centres, 810 megalitres, but the Dublin Inquirer reported last year that in 2021, Meta reported that just its data centres in Clonee used 928 megalitres. One data centre said it used more than what Uisce Éireann said all data centres used together. How does Uisce Éireann explain that discrepancy?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

We set up an individual independent water network management directorate under me. We did a thorough survey and investigation of all data centres connected to our network. In some cases meters were under-recording or stopped. We had to replace those meters. We are quite confident the data we have now in 2026 is very accurate.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Laffey saying Meta underpaid for the water it used? Did Uisce Éireann ever chase it up for the money it did not pay if the meter was stopped?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

If a meter is stopped or under-recording, it is very hard to prove what was used before it was fixed.

Comment on this

Did Uisce Éireann ask it to make any contribution?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

No.

Comment on this

Did it use some water that it did not pay for?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

If a meter is broken or under-recording, we make an allowance based on what we thought it was using and it is charged on that basis. Ultimately, if a meter is under-recording or broken, it is up to us to fix it.

Comment on this

Was the meter stopped and not recording anything or was it under-recording?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

I cannot comment on Meta because I am not certain if it was broken or under-recording. I suspect it was not because it is such a large user that we would always have them taped.

Comment on this

If it is not Meta then that does not explain the discrepancy. Mr. Laffey said publicly 810 megalitres, Meta reported 928 megalitres - that is just by one.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Was that in 2021?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

As I said, ultimately, there are other large users. Meta is half of what is used but there are other large users in the area.

Comment on this

Sorry, but Uisce Éireann's figures were wrong then in 2020. Is Mr. Laffey accepting that they were wrong?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Yes. Absolutely.

Comment on this

But Mr. Laffey is confident that the figures he is giving me today are right, even though they are different from what is reported. Is it based on figures provided previously?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

What is in The Journal is incorrect. We never saw nine or 18 in any given day; we saw six.

Comment on this

I will start with the last line of Mr. Gleeson's opening statement: "We welcome today’s discussion as an opportunity to demonstrate how Uisce Éireann is delivering on behalf of the Exchequer, strengthening national water services and using public investment to deliver long-term value for customers, communities and future generations." What we needed here today was transparency, accountability and reassurance on a service that is fit for purpose, not spin from Uisce Éireann on its confidence of delivery when that flies in the face of the residents I represent. I will give the witnesses a whistle-stop tour on water delivery in Drogheda over the last ten years. In 2016, Irish Water decommissioned the Rosehall water treatment plant. In 2017 the Staleen water main burst and there was a water crisis in Drogheda for nine days when 90,000 people had no access to water locally. This spread to low water supply further afield in the north-east region, which affected up to 200,000 people. There were repairs of €3 million done on the Staleen water treatment plant at that time and a further €29 million was invested in the following years to upgrade the Staleen water treatment plant. In 2018, I visited the Staleen water treatment plant with some of my colleagues and I asked questions of Irish Water and Uisce Éireann representatives on that day. I asked if the repair on the pipe and the upgrade works would increase capacity in the treatment plants and I was told repeatedly on that day that it would not increase capacity. At the time the plant was exporting 30,000 cu. m of water a day, which was 1,250 cu. m per hour. All of these figures were provided to us in a presentation by Uisce Éireann's own staff. We were told that this would not increase much further. I raised major concerns at that point in 2017 as we were looking at a population boost of up to 20,000 people in the coming years, with planning permission already granted at that stage for 5,000 to 7,000 houses and more to come with the new ring road, the port access northern route, being delivered. I was told, "Do not worry about it, it is fine." Last November, residents in Termon Abbey estate in Drogheda lost water to the extent that some of these people had to book into hotels over Christmas. None of this is news as it is well documented both to Mr. Gleeson's organisation and in the news. Irish Water has said repeatedly to me that there is no issue with new houses being connected to the mains that was impacted or that this would result in an impact on the water of the residents in Termon Abbey. Yet, I have here a copy of a stage 2 complaint letter that was given to a resident in recent weeks where she was told that the result of the issues with the water was as a result of new houses being connected to the mains. So, somebody is telling mistruths somewhere, either to me or to that resident who has gone 11 months with mostly no water but frequently with a very low water supply.

If we go back to 2017, the residents of Drogheda were using saucepans, buckets and tankers to survive. Nine years later in 2026, the residents in Drogheda are using watering cans to shower and bottled water to flush their toilets. Can Mr. Gleeson tell me, first and foremost, what he will do for the residents in Termon Abbey and surrounding estates who had been living there for 25 to 30 years without any disruption to the water supply until new housing estates were connected to the same line as them? Can he tell me, and guarantee me, that further progression of housing delivery in Drogheda is not going to impact residents further? I wrote to Mr. Gleeson directly this day last week that I was so concerned. I expressed in an e-mail to him that I was requesting an immediate meeting to discuss the issues that are facing the people who have been living 11 months without water. Not only did Mr. Gleeson not have the manners to reply, he did not have the courtesy to facilitate that meeting in any way shape or form. I need answers from Mr. Gleeson today. The people of Drogheda need answers. In particular, the residents of Termon Abbey in Drogheda, who are 11 months with no water, need answers from Mr. Gleeson here today.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

I would apologise to the residents if there was a disruption in the water-----

Comment on this

It is not a disruption, it is 11 months. Did Mr. Gleeson hear anything I just said to him and the magnitude of this problem?

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

I heard-----

Comment on this

This is not a disruption. Get your head out of the sand here. There are children, families, old people and all sorts of cohorts affected since November of last year. The communication and the responses coming from Irish Water are conflicting. I have multiples of folders of emails here where Irish Water told me there is no issue here and there were no problems. Yet Irish Water told the residents in Termon Abbey that there are issues. Where are the mistruths coming from? It is more than an apology that is needed: it is answers, solutions and timelines.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

I was going to start off with an apology and then I was going try to give the Deputy some answers. Ms Attridge knows about this local issue.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

Part of the issue here with supply to the north side of Drogheda was that once we investigated and did camera services in the network to understand what was wrong, we did find a restriction on the trunk main that comes in from Donore Reservoir and into the town, and that was impacting pressure in the town. That has been resolved now in the last few weeks and that restriction has been removed so the pressure in the town from our pressure markers-----

Comment on this

When was that resolved?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

That date I have is that it was resolved on 11 September.

Comment on this

I will just stop Ms Attridge before she goes any further because 48 houses in Limetree Avenue in Termon Abbey were told that this resolution was coming to pass in September. On 14 September, after this was supposedly fixed, there was a survey done by the 48 residents in that street, those who had no water since last November, and 69% of them said there was no change from before, 14% said there was slightly better water pressure, 10% said it seemed to be worse, and only 7% said the problems were fixed. We are now here on 15 October and these issues still exist. I need more than that, to be fair, and these people need more than that.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

They absolutely do and we have a plan to look at laying a new main around the north side of Drogheda, and for laying a trunk main across the River Boyne. In the meantime we have-----

Comment on this

There is no meantime. What is the plan and what is the timeline? Is this the water main to go under the River Boyne, as was suggested in correspondence to our residents? It was the first I had heard of that. There is no knowledge of that. There is no plan of that and there are no timelines around that, so we are talking pie in the sky and years, if not decades, before they see any relief. They cannot sustain this any longer. Not only can they not, all of the other houses around them are going to be impacted. Another housing estate has received planning permission next door to them only last week and there are several more in the pipeline, just yards away from them. This issue is going to get worse so I do not need "We have a plan". We want to know what the plan is.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

From an operations perspective we have extra leakage crews in the area trying to find a fixed leak. That reduces the demand and will improve the pressure. We have also put out extra pressure loggers in the networks so we can understand the performance in the network better. I will guarantee to look into this personally to understand if the leakage repairs we are doing and pressure management we are carrying out will be enough to improve the supply to the people who live in that area.

Comment on this

It is not going to be enough to improve the supply. I flagged this with Irish Water as far back as 2017. I am on the record. I have written to Irish Water umpteen times, as have my colleagues Councillor Kenneth Flood at the time and Deputy Imelda Munster. We have been on this since 2017 since that day we were in Staleen. We actually raised that on site with Irish Water representatives that day. Here we are nine years later and everything I said to Irish Water is coming true. People are suffering on the back of this. Has there been any consideration given to reopening the Rosehall water treatment plant?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

I do not know that answer. I am not sure does anyone-----

Comment on this

I suggest this is the first place that Irish Water would start. There were formal discussions between chiefs of Irish Water and Louth County Council in 2017 during the Staleen fiasco when people were left for nine days with no water. There were serious discussions at that time. I know this because I was a member of the council at that time. There was consideration given to reopening the Rosehall water treatment plant, which we were told at the time could cater to 40% to 80% of the then population of the north of Drogheda. I understand that the population has probably grown by 10,000 people in that period, and it is projected to grow by another 10,000 over the next three to five years, but it could still alleviate some of the capacity to some extent. It may not be the 40% to 89% but it would certainly be a tool. That needs to be Irish Water's first port of call. I ask the witnesses to go away from here today and seriously look at that, and to come back to me and, specifically but more importantly, the residents as to whether this is a runner, and if it is, how soon it can be done.

Second, we need reassurances that there is enough capacity to cope with all the planning that has been granted. Has there been dialogue with Louth County Council? To my knowledge, nothing has been flagged on behalf of Uisce Éireann to say there are concerns about the capacity. A development plan is about to start again, and the councillors and the council need to know if the water cannot be delivered for all the progress as planned.

Lastly, I still want a meeting with Mr. Gleeson to discuss this and nail down finer details, if possible.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

I am very surprised that the Deputy wrote to me. I was on holidays last week but my email-----

Comment on this

It was last Thursday morning.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

-----is monitored 24-7, so if there was a request, we should have responded to it sooner.

Comment on this

I can reforward it now.

Comment on this
John Brady An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Thanks, Deputy Byrne. Deputy Geoghegan is next.

Comment on this

Sorry, Chair. Will Mr Gleeson give a commitment that the Rosehall water treatment plant will be looked at and revert to me?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

We will look into it. The Deputy referred to the issues in Staleen. Significant investment has been made there.

Comment on this

I do not need to know about that. I have asked three questions.

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

It will provide resilience to Drogheda as well. I will come back to the Deputy on it.

Comment on this

One, I ask the witnesses to come back to me on Rosehall. Two, I need reassurances on the capacity for future growth. Serious conversations need to be had with Louth County Council. Three, I still want the meeting specifically on the Termon Abbey issues over the next week or two, please.

Comment on this

I want to close out the data centre line of questioning. What is the percentage share of water usage in Ireland by data centres, according to the latest available data?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

From the latest available data we have, it is 0.22% of all of the water produced daily in the country, or on average 0.8% of all of the water produced daily in the greater Dublin area.

Comment on this

What month is that data point from?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

It is probably from August.

Comment on this

So, that is the most up-to-date figure. Mr. Laffey said it was 0.22%. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Yes, that is correct.

Comment on this

Data centres account for 0.22% of all water usage in Ireland.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Yes.

Comment on this

Ms O'Dwyer called that non-consequential for water use. Would Mr. Laffey agree with that characterisation?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Yes, essentially, because we are looking at perhaps 85 different sites.

Comment on this

What percentage of non-domestic water usage is data centre water usage?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

I do not have that particular statistic, but I will get it for the Deputy.

Comment on this

If Mr. Laffey could get if for me before the end of the questions, that would be even more helpful. Deputy Murphy quoted a figure that he had read in the Dublin InQuirer, which made reference to 928 ML being used by one data centre provider. Dividing that by 365 gives 2.5 ML per day. What is the peak number of megalitres used?

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Six.

Comment on this

To reiterate, right now in Ireland, 0.22% of all water used is used by data centres.

Comment on this
Mr. Sean Laffey

Correct.

Comment on this

This may be a question for Ms. Attridge. In one of the press releases issued by Irish Water in the summer about the hosepipe ban, explicit reference was made to data centres and their low water usage. Is it a concern for Irish Water that a message is being put out there that actually it is not domestic users who are causing the need for a hosepipe ban but data centres?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

We were putting out a message to the public and asking them to conserve water. On a number of houses, we have smart meters, and we can see on a daily basis the jump in usage. The smart meters are telling us that domestic consumption went up by 20%. Engaging with data centres to reduce their water usage was not going to make any significant difference for us. Our appeal had to be to homeowners because that is where we saw the significant increase in water usage.

Comment on this

From what Ms Attridge said earlier, there was a lot of solidarity from homeowners. Homeowners complied with the message. Were data centres explicitly referenced in the press release because of a concern that there is a message out there in relation to them?

Comment on this
Ms Margaret Attridge

No, we do not have a concern. There were so many queries coming into us about the increased use of water by data centres. We were trying to provide some clarity, but it was not because we have a concern. We do also appeal to all non-domestic customers. We engage directly with the large users-----

Comment on this

Sorry. By concern, I mean there is a public misunderstanding that data centres are causing the hosepipe ban.

Comment on this
Mr. Niall Gleeson

We have seen on social media some stuff about data centres taking all the water. Part of that press release was to say data centres were not the issue. It was domestic consumption-.

Comment on this