We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

DAIL IN COMMITTEE. - LAND BILL, 1923—THIRD STAGE RESUMED.

Contributions 1–131 of 258. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Land Bill, 1923
Enacted

No. 24 of 1923 ›

I beg to move the following amendment to Section 16:—

In Sub-section (2), line 19, to substitute for the figures "1920," the figures "1921," and in the same line to substitute for figures and words "25 per cent." the figures and words "40 per cent.," and to make the consequential amendments throughout the Act.

This amendment to the section means to take two years' arrears into consideration instead of three years. It would also mean raising the 25 per cent. reduction to 40 per cent. This amendment is put up to meet the actual facts that obtain in the country. 25 per cent. on three years, if three years are to be considered at all, is really of no good to the unpurchased tenants of the country. The last three years have been three lean years. They have been three years when agriculture did not pay, and when agriculture could not pay considering the prices that were got for agricultural produce, and everybody who knows anything about farming knows that. The result is that the people who owe three years' rent have no money. But the small tenants in the West and the small tenants in the South, it must be apparent to anybody, have for the last three years carried on their business without profits. There is no surplus there. It cannot be got. I do not believe that with the most powerful machinery of the law you can recover it, because it is not there to recover. We propose to take two years only into consideration, and that these two years be subject to a 40 per cent. reduction. We also suggest that one of these two years be paid in cash, and that the other be added to the purchase money. For the moment I will say no more. Let the case develop.

Comment on this

I wish to support the arguments of Deputy Gorey. I know from experience that in the Co. Cork, owing to the disturbance of the last three years that it was impossible for the tenant farmers to make their rent, and not only the tenant farmers suffered from the condition of things that prevailed, but very many landlords themselves, because they had their places taken over. I know cases near the City of Cork where tenants owed last year three years' rent, and the landlords came forward willingly and offered to take a half-year's rent and give them 40 per cent. on that half-year's rent and to take on future gales a reduction of 40 per cent. until the Land Bill be passed. I know very well that there are landlords in the Co. Cork who try to get their full pound of flesh. I know of a landlord who processed a tenant for 1½ years' rent, and the tenant has to pay every penny up to the last half-year, including almost £60 in costs.

Comment on this
Mr. DOYLE

I quite agree with the two Deputies who have spoken as to the necessity for the amendment. I agree with Deputy Gorey in his remarks about how hard hit agriculture has been within the past three years. There has not been anything got out of it; it is a non-profitable business as far as the last two or three years are concerned. To anyone engaged in agriculture there is no need to press home this fact. People know it to their own cost. As regards former land Acts, I do not think that under them three years' arrears were ever asked for. At a time like the present, when depression is so pronounced in agriculture, why should the tenants be compelled to pay three years' arrears? I think it is really more than any of the tenants who owe three years' arrears can do. There is no use in suggesting impossibilities.

I believe the Minister would be well advised to accept this amendment in its entirety. We are told over and over again that the tenants who are purchasing under this present Bill are going to be better off than the tenants who purchased formerly. I cannot see how that can be, no matter how I look at the provisions of the Bill. The tenants who are purchasing now will be hit to the extent of £300 or £400 more in the entire cost of their purchase money than the tenants who purchased 15 years ago. By the time the two annuities terminate the man who is trying to pay on a £100 rental, even taking the largest reduction the Bill offers (35 per cent.), will be several hundred pounds worse off than the man who purchased 15 years ago.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for AGRICULTURE (Mr. Hogan) Sinn Féin

If we could approach this question on the lines of considering that a certain man owes a certain sum of money, and ask ourselves what is the most favourable arrangement we could make for that man, it would be easy. If we could approach the matter on those lines it would be much simpler. If it were open to us to say: "He shall pay nothing," that would suit and would save us a lot of trouble. If it were open to us to say: "He shall pay one quarter or one half, or whatever fraction you like to take," there would be no difficulty whatever. In short, if we could simply consider the man himself, and consider no other circumstance of any kind—if we had that wide range of choice—there would be no difficulty in making arrangements. But this is another question that you cannot legislate about without taking into account all other relevant considerations. There was reference made to previous arrears Acts. The last was in 1881. I pointed out on the Second Reading, and I do not think that anybody who knows the fact will deny it, that there is a radical difference between the arrears problem of to-day and the arrears problem of 1881. I am talking now in general terms.

In 1881, or, to be more accurate, before 1881, and before the Act was passed, the tenant paid whatever rent the landlord liked to charge him for his holding, and practically all the tenants were rack-rented. There was nothing to stop the landlord from increasing the rent as much as he liked, and in a great percentage of cases the landlord took advantage of that right. The tenants were rack-rented— there is no doubt of that. The rents were higher. On the average they were more than 50 per cent. higher than they are at the present moment; and remember that they were higher notwithstanding prices have doubled. I do not say the profits have doubled, but prices have doubled. The actual figure before 1881 was considerably more than 50 per cent. higher than at present, after more than forty years and after the European War. The fact is that in 1881 the real reason for the Arrears Act was that the tenants were utterly unable to pay their rents—very high rack-rents.

You could not get blood out of a turnip, and the tenants could not pay. They were being evicted on a very large scale and, as a result of legitimate agitation in Ireland, the Act of 1881 was passed and the Fair Rent Courts set up. Since then most of the tenants have got two decadal reductions—most of the tenants with whom we are dealing—and the rent has been kept strictly within bounds. The present strike against rents was only indirectly a strike in regard to amount. It was really a protest against the fact that the tenants had not purchased. I think that is a fair statement of the case. The present strike against rent is directly, anyway, a protest against the fact of the non-purchase by the tenants.

Comment on this

Not the real reason.

Comment on this

Not the only reason, perhaps, but that was the direct reason for this strike. It began in 1920, at a time when we could not complain that conditions were as bad as they are now, and when it began the reason, as expressed by the tenants through all their organisations, was the fact of non-purchase. That is the radical difference between this arrears problem and the arrears problem of 1881. Everyone in the country knows that, and everyone who has read the manifestoes and the utterances of the tenants' organisations will agree that that is the state of affairs. If the landlord is entitled to £67 14s. as the interest on the purchase money of this land, then he is entitled to something more in regard to arrears. If the figure of £67 14s. is right——

Comment on this

It is not right.

Comment on this

We can argue that when the time comes, but if the figure is right then the landlord is undoubtedly entitled to something more on arrears. Whether you agree that it is right or not you must admit the principle that the landlord who has, until he gets this £67 14s., or whatever sum you like, to pay his own head rents and interests in full without any abatement, must get something more. You must admit that whatever annuity he gets as a result of the price he receives, he must get something more on arrears. During the last three years we had to face the facts that the particular landlords with whom we have been dealing had to pay their head rents. They had also to pay their mortgage charges. A man who owes interest to a mortgagee is in a totally different position from the man who owes rent to a landlord. Everyone knows enough about the country to understand that. The mortgagee has remedies easily enforcible, and there is no public opinion, and never has been any, against such enforcement. In fact they always have enforced, and they are ready to enforce, for the very good reason that nothing suits the mortgagee of an encumbered estate more than to foreclose. He will get the whole estate, and he stands a very good chance of getting more than his mortgage as the owner. He stands a chance of getting considerably more than his mortgage. The fact is landlords have had to pay their full rent and interest charges during the last three years and to do so without any abatement. They had to pay the usual rate during the war for a safe mortgage. That means 6 per cent., and it ran during the last three years. We are dealing with estates which are heavily encumbered; at least a very great proportion of the particular estates are heavily encumbered. If the landlord gets his purchase money, or £5,000 of these encumbrances attached to the purchase money, and if you take £100 of that purchase money which represents £100 owed by the landlord on foot of a mortgage, the position will be like this: On that £100 he gets 4½ per cent., whereas on that £100 he is liable for 6 or 7 percent.

Comment on this

It must be a Jew he is dealing with.

Comment on this

He is liable for 6, or perhaps 7, per cent. to the ordinary Banking House, the ordinary Insurance Company or to the Jews if you like. He is in a position to get over that difficulty the moment he gets his purchase money, because he can pay off the capital money in bonds. Until he gets his purchase money he must meet those interests in full and you cannot ask him to remain from this date until the appointed day in the position of getting only 4½ per cent. out of the rent, which is the same thing as out of the purchase money, and paying 6 per cent. on it. That is the reason why you must give more to the landlord, and why you must give a greater income to him in respect of arrears and payment in lieu of rent until the appointed day then you need to ask the tenant to pay afterwards. It is clear that in equity if X is the annuity, or half X is the income which the landlord is entitled to receive after the appointed day, after receiving his bonds, he must receive something more than X up to that date if he is to meet his rent and charges. I am using the letter X so as not to complicate the question. Whatever the price or annuities may be, he must receive more. We fixed the landlord's income at £67.14, and I daresay we will have a very interesting debate on that when we come to the question of price.

I have already defended it on the First Reading, and on the Second Reading. We fixed his income in respect of arrears and in respect of payment in lieu of rent until the Appointed Day, at £75. He is not going to get that £75 in full. The cost of collection will be deducted. The amount he will get will probably be nearer £70. We are leaving an extremely small margin—the margin between something like £70 and £67.14—to meet this big difference in outlay which the landlord has up to the appointed day.

With regard to arrears, we have not been told why we should write off this extra year's arrears. It has not been suggested that during that year the vendor will be allowed by the owners of his head rents, and by his mortgagees to write off their interest. Everybody knows that they will do nothing of the kind. For that year he will have to pay his interest and his head rents just in the same way as he has to pay them for the two following years. In a great many cases he will probably have to borrow money for that purpose. As regards the tenant who has not paid any rent for the last three years, what has he done with the money?

Comment on this

Squandered it on motor cars.

Comment on this

He should not have done that, but I do not think he did it.

Comment on this

I do not think he did either.

Comment on this

He is not in the same position as if he had paid his rent every year. He has a certain amount of that money. He has paid nothing in respect of rent for three years—nothing whatever. The amount of money which he set aside for rent has not dissolved or evaporated. This is really a question of trying to do the fair thing. I know perfectly well that it is different to pay a lump sum down, and to pay the same sum by easy instalments over a period of three years. A tenant who has to pay £24 now can hardly pay it as rapidly as the tenant who had to pay £12 each year for the last two years. That is the reason we have given a reduction at all. We have given this 25 per cent. reduction, and in doing that remember we are putting these tenants who owed these arrears in exactly the same position as if they were paying annuity. Perhaps I am wrong in saying exactly the same position. They are really in a slightly better position than if they were paying annuity. The average reduction under the 1903 Act was less than 25 per cent.

Comment on this

On Second Term rents.

Comment on this

On First and Second Term. We are dealing with First and Second Term now. We can get the returns any time.

Comment on this

We are always asking for them.

Comment on this

They are on sale. The average reduction to First and Second Term tenants under the 1903 Act was something less than 25 per cent. We are giving this reduction now straight away in regard to arrears, so that the effect will be that from the year 1920 the tenants will be paying the same amount as if they had purchased. This is a question of a bargain. On the one side you have the fact that the landlord has to pay interest and has to pay his head rents, and on the other side we have to remember that the tenants who have to pay a lump sum down are in a different position from tenants who paid in instalments over a period of three years. We tried to strike a bargain. On the one side you have the very relevant consideration that you cannot afford to give the same reduction to the tenant as you could even in regard to annuity, because the interest the landlord must pay out of his rents is considerably more.

Take a tenant with two years' arrears. He gets 25 per cent. off each year. That is a half-year's rent written off, and remember that we have also written off any rent due before 1920. Now, that man has not paid anything for two years. It is not a great hardship on him to pay a year down. He got notice of that on the 1st May, when this Bill was introduced. And it is not a great hardship on him to pay a half-year between this day and the Appointed Day, as well as interest in lieu of rent, subject also to 25 per cent. reduction. The man who owes three years' arrears has saved more than that. He has saved an extra year. When we commenced collecting annuities there was no difficulty in collecting two years' annuities from tenants who had purchased. There was a certain amount of loud talk in the beginning, a certain amount of complaint about hardship, but they nevertheless paid up cheerfully. We are putting these men in exactly the same position as if they were purchasers. They will be paying the same amount as their neighbours who have purchased. The reduction we give in regard to arrears is exactly the reduction they would have got if they had purchased. I notice that the figure the Deputy has set down is 40 per cent. He has also made the same claim in regard to price. Now, I put it to him that, even admitting his own figure—which I do not admit—of 40 per cent. reduction in regard to price, is it fair in the circumstances to ask the same reduction in regard to arrears? Let us get at it step by step. I want the Dáil to examine the question and to say whether they think we should give the same reduction in regard to arrears as in regard to price. I would like to hear the Farmers' Party on that point. If they say we should give the same reduction I would like to hear their reasons. We must treat this question as a business proposition, and we must have reasons for what we urge. I would like to hear also why this extra year's rent should be written off, having regard to the fact that all the charges which the landlord must pay were running in this year. And then, why should the figure be 40 per cent.? I have explained exactly why we have fixed 25 per cent. I have shown that a 25 per cent. reduction leaves an income of £75, less the cost of collection. That would bring it down to about £70, and we have only about 5 per cent. to cover the high rate of interest which the landlord must pay, and in regard to which he can get no abatements and has no remedy until he pays off the capital.

Comment on this

Let me first deal with the last point raised by the Minister. Everybody who had any connection with the Convention of 1918 knows, from the figures put before that Convention, that the landlord's income of 100 per cent. was only nominal. His real income was about 75 per cent. The cost of collection, estate charges and bad debts amounted to 25 per cent. Seventy-five per cent. and, in a few cases, 77½ per cent. fairly represented what the landlord actually received net. In making this 25 per cent. reduction and collecting arrears for the landlord, you are putting him in the same position as he was before; nothing worse.

The question has been asked, what the tenants have been doing with the money that accumulated for the last three years. We know that the average valuation of unpurchased tenants' holdings through the country is from £10 to £15. It does not require any great stretch of imagination to realise the small amount of money that must pass through the hands of occupiers of these holdings and the small amount of profit they could have made in that period. In many cases there could have been nothing left. The tenant has to contend with the lean years, and we know the state of agriculture recently. I do hope the tenant has not gone down to Kilkee or Tramore for the week-ends, as some of us do. He has not, I think, squandered his money like that. The 1918 Convention and the 1920 Bill took two years arrears into consideration. That was by way of agreement between the two sides. In this Bill we are going outside of what the landlord agreed to in 1918 and again agreed to in 1920. There is a new line now being struck, and I do not know what is the reason. We have been also asked why we demand this reduction now. For the last two or three years we have not had normal times. We have not had facilities for marketing. We have not had a rail service. There is no use in shutting our eyes to these facts. The tenants could not get their produce to the markets, and some of it has been lying there for six or seven months. It is only during the past few months that it was got away in some districts. During all that time it was only a question of home consumption. The times were not normal. We are asked, why make a difference in respect of annuity and arrears? We have arrived at more or less normal times. Railway services are being carried on. We expect that in future years men will be able to do their business in a proper way. During the past three years they did not get a return for their work, owing to the conditions. We are dealing with certainties for the years to come. During the past few years there was no certainty in regard to a return for the work done.

We are not comparing the present position with the 1881 position. We are comparing it with the 1920 and the 1918 position, and when two years were agreed on in 1918 and 1920, certainly two years ought to be able to be agreed on in 1923. We cannot shut our eyes to these facts. We cannot get over them. The landlords' case has been put up very well. The condition they are in might be true; I am not in a position to dispute it. I know nothing about the landlords' end of the stick, but I do know a little about the tenants' end of it. I know that the average man in the country has very little return for his work. He had to live up to some kind of standard; not alone that, but he had to support an Irregular army who were quartered on him for months—almost for a year—and who robbed him, who took away his food and everything he had, and who broke down his roads and bridges. It is not a question that he will not, but he cannot afford to pay. There were a few counties, such as Dublin, with easy access to makets and with a fair rail service. These might be in a favoured position; but if you go to the West or to South Leinster, they were living in a condition of almost impossibility. I want you to realise the tenants' position, and not be giving too much attention to the position of the landlord. Try to realise the position of both, and try to do justice to both. There is no use doing justice to one and injustice to another. I am not speaking on my own behalf or on behalf of any party, or on behalf of a few people. I am speaking on behalf of the whole 70,000 unpurchased tenants. I am taking the average man, and I do say with all sincerity that the Government will not be able to recover these three years' arrears. Another thing that I think I mentioned on the Second Reading: If you add a year's purchase or a half-year's purchase to the purchase money, it will be very serious. A half-year at 4½ per cent. will almost mean one or two years under the Wyndham Act, where the interest was, I think, 2¾ per cent., whereas it is now 4½ per cent. You can very easily put a millstone around the tenants' necks in that way. Although the Minister has made a good case as regards the landlords' position, I do not think that he has made a case whereby he should make it impossible for the tenant in the future, or put him in an intolerable position, or put the country in the position that it will have to be security for his failure.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey puzzles me a little bit with some of the figures he has given. I take it, first of all, that the average rent that is paid by the tenant under this amounts to £10.

Comment on this

Ten to fifteen pounds would be the average.

Comment on this

The Deputy told us we were going to hamstring these men and make it impossible for them to live in the future, and prejudice the physique of the race if a year's purchase at £10 at 4½ per cent. be added to the rent. That sum of £10 at 4½ per cent. will be 9s. per annum. I do not know if I understood the Deputy correctly. Did he infer that that 9s. is going to prejudice the future of this country?

Comment on this

I think that argument would work at the landlords' end as well as at the other.

Comment on this

The position with regard to the landlord is that he has not got the money.

Comment on this

Begin at something else, Mr. President.

Comment on this

I will take it another way. The Deputy states that there have been three lean years. I understand that 1920-21 was a lean year. I can give the Deputy painful evidence of the fact that it was a perfectly normal year. I do not know whether he questions the fact that it was a normal year.

Comment on this

I question it.

Comment on this

I know a particular case during the period where sixteen head of cattle were sold at 80s. per cwt. That is a fairly good price, and it is not evidence of the fact that there was a lean year there. The Deputy ought to be in a position to give us figures. If he makes the case, he is justified; if he does not make the case, he needs justification; and I am afraid in this case the Deputy will need more than justification.

Comment on this

What time was it?

Comment on this

The months of February and July. The sum in question was £420 for sixteen head of cattle; the price was 80s. per cwt. I say that was a perfectly normal year, and £100 rental in that year was made by the tenant. He profited by the fruits of his work in that particular period. In the normal course of events if it had not been for the interruption of the National movement he would have the money, and he would have paid it. If we then take the three years it is fairly obvious that there was that one year in which he was perfectly well able to pay that rent, and the sum according to this clause in the Bill for the three years is £225. Therefore, what he is asked to pay, if we are to take the Deputy's information that there were two lean years, is an average of £62 10s. —in other words, there is a deduction of £37 10s. in two lean years. The Deputy knows, I suppose, as well as anybody the force of the point that has been made by the Minister for Agriculture that mortgages have had to be met, that the interest has had to be met, and these three lean years that the Deputy has spoken of must have been exceedingly lean years for the landlord, and that, whatever the tenants' position was, the landlords, who did not get any rent for three years, must have been in a very precarious position. Some of these have a life interest only, and they benefit only to the extent of whatever these arrears amount to. As regards the Deputy's suggestion of a 40 per cent. reduction for two years and the other year to go, the sum of £120 that the landlord is to be paid for three years would be an actual reduction of 60 per cent. in respect of the three years. I suggest to the Deputy that he ought not to insist upon this Bill at all, that it would be far better value if he could get over three years, and at the end of every three years, say, we will compound the arrears by paying 40 per cent. reduction in respect of two years, and that will settle the case. There will be no necessity for the Bill.

Comment on this

I do not know anything much about the landlord's end of the stick, as Deputy Gorey calls it, but I have come across a little of the farmer's end of the stick in the ordinary course of my trade. I find myself occasionally called upon to advise some farmer who is purchasing a farm upon the title of the farm he is going to buy, and I have come across cases not before the war or in the early days of the war, but during the last twelve or eighteen months in which a farmer who owned one farm, so far from finding agriculture a losing business, was willing to purchase another farm on forty, fifty and sixty years' purchase of the annuity of the farm he was going to buy. Whatever the opinion one may form here of the farmers of Ireland, they are not such fools as to put enormous sums of money into the business that their own experience has proved to them to be a losing job. When you find any farm put up in this country for sale it is purchased at an enormous price by people who are in the same business and who want to continue it in a new farm, I do not think that the business of agriculture is quite so hopeless as Deputy Gorey would lead us to believe.

Comment on this

You are talking about the graziers.

Comment on this

I am not talking about the graziers; I am speaking of the ordinary rich farms through the country. My business, so far as it goes, does not run in the grazing counties. I have very few clients, if any, in Meath or Kildare. So far as I get business from the country it mostly comes from the South and South-West. In the year 1920-21, this year that this amendment proposes to wipe out of consideration altogether, the deposits in the Joint Stock Banks in this country went up by twenty-three million pounds. There was one hundred and sixty-three millions deposit in the Joint Stock Banks at the end of 1920, and in 1921 it had gone up to one hundred and eighty-six and a half million pounds. The main increase in this case was in those banks which operate through the present Irish Free State, and that money was not the banking by landlords of exorbitant rents they had extracted from their tenants, because they were not getting anything. Therefore, that £23,000,000 came from somewhere. It did not come out of the landlords' pockets, and I do not think it came out of the profit of those industries that have not yet been started in the Saorstát, but that we hope now to see springing up. Looking to the sources from which that money came, the only place I can see it came from is this losing business of agriculture. Twenty-three millions, added to the one hundred and sixty millions that were already on deposit receipt in Joint Stock Banks, must have come from somewhere. Where could it have come from except from practically the only business that is carried on in the Saorstát, the business of agriculture? That is not a flea bite of twenty-three millions, because at the outbreak of the war there was only about sixty million pounds on deposit receipt, and the amount on deposit receipt since then has gone up from sixty millions to one hundred and eighty-six millions. Eighty-four millions of that has come in since the year 1918, and that in the Saorstát must have come from agriculture and nothing else. Therefore, it does not seem to me, from the return of the banks, that the trade is a very losing one. In the year Deputy Gorey seeks to strike out of consideration agriculture was not the least profitable, because the increase during that twelve months was the biggest increase since the return of the Joint Stock Banks was first issued.

Comment on this

In the year 1920 the harvest was late, and oats were sold in October by those who were fortunate enough to have it thrashed. Towards the end of that year prices began to come down, and they were down by a big percentage in February of 1921. Before May fairs could not be held, and by May certain classes of stock had reduced in price by half what they were in 1919 and part 1920. The cattle bought in the middle of 1920 had to be sold for 40 per cent. less than what they were bought for. It was the greatest slump in one year that the agricultural industry ever experienced in Ireland, and many energetic, industrious and enterprising persons came to grief and were unable to pay their creditors.

Comment on this

I was very much struck by the President's speech and by Deputy Fitzgibbon's. Now, the President told us a nice little tale about sixteen bullocks that cost £4 or £4 10s. per cwt. I am not quite sure which, but there is no dispute certainly about the sixteen bullocks. Probably there were sixteen or twenty more where these sixteen came from. Now, the man that has sixteen bullocks and is farming in the ordinary way must have a huge farm. Probably they were three-year olds. Now, I do not think, when the President was referring to these sixteen bullocks, that that would apply to ten out of the seventy thousand unpurchased tenants in Ireland. He had some friend who was a grazier in Meath, or Dublin, or somewhere, who had these sixteen bullocks, and when he instanced this case he did not explain at all that this tale of the sixteen bullocks would not apply to ten out of the seventy thousand men we are discussing in this Bill. That disposes of that argument. Deputy Fitzgibbon talks about the huge reserves that were in the banks and that were accumulating in the banks, and no doubt he wants to infer that all these millions were put up by the seventy thousand unpurchased tenants with an average valuation of £15 a year. He wanted to infer that, and that the four hundred thousand purchased tenants in the country would have little to say to it. He wanted also to infer that the other interests, what is known as the "trade" in Ireland, and that all the other industries and professions had nothing at all to say to these millions. He wanted the Dáil to infer that all these millions were put up by these tenants, who were rolling in riches. Perhaps it would be nearer the mark to say that these millions were the portion that the purchased tenants made during the war, as compared with the unpurchased tenants, and that was made by the different businesses that were living out of Irish agriculture. There are a few trades living out of Irish agriculture.

Comment on this

Guinness.

Comment on this

Yes, there are a few trades; Guinness and other interests down from Guinness. Deputy Fitzgibbon made a very nice case for his friends, but I would be more impressed by his speech if he would put his hand upon half a million of all this money that was accumulated by these seventy thousand unpurchased tenants. If he could do any definite thing like that I would be inclined to listen to him with greater attention. Even if he showed me any figures I would listen to him. I really think the State will have to put up some millions to meet the losses that these people have suffered. He is talking about what 9s. in the year would mean to the average tenant. Now, the same argument applied to my friend the landlord. It will cut both ways.

Comment on this

In the order I stated.

Comment on this

When you come to talk about "bobs" like that you arrive at very little. The only point that is plain is that a few shillings mean a lot to poor men. It means the difference between existence and starvation. I will not say it means the difference between existence and comfort, for it never did. It is up to this Dáil and it is up to the Government on behalf of the nation to do what is right. We consider that they have not done what is right. We consider that where other agreements have been come to in recent years between two parties concerned—where the landlords have agreed to take two years into consideration—that it is beyond the limits of justice and fair play to take three years into consideration. I made that clear in previous speeches, and the point has not been answered.

Comment on this

If I might personally explain, I would say it is only fair to the unpurchased tenants to say that I did not charge, and I did not intend to be understood as charging, that all this money had come from them. My argument was that a great deal of it must have come from agriculture in which they were engaged.

Comment on this

The Deputy has not dealt with the question whether or not the year 1920-21 was a lean year. That was my case, and the reason why I introduced the particular bullocks to which he takes exception. He states that it is on this matter of 9s. a year that the danger really lies. Nine shillings a year means 2d. a week. If the Deputy can explain to me that seventy thousand unpurchased tenants are necessarily going to be starved by having to bear this 2d. a week, I am prepared to reconsider my position.

Comment on this
Mr. DOYLE

The President is talking about 1921.

Comment on this

No, 1920-21.

Comment on this
Mr. DOYLE

I think it was for 1921 you quoted us the story of the bullocks.

Comment on this

1920-21.

Comment on this
Mr. DOYLE

You spoke of selling in February and July.

Comment on this

No, I spoke of a purchase.

Comment on this
Mr. DOYLE

When?

Comment on this

February and July.

Comment on this
Mr. DOYLE

As far as the year 1921 is concerned, I say it is one of the leanest years that the farmer ever met in Ireland. I know that the few pounds he made in the war was all lost by him in 1921. He talks of cattle in July, 1921, being worth £4 a cwt. Why, there were not cattle in July, 1921, worth £4 a cwt. With all due respect to the President I say that, and I would like to see the quotations from the cattle market for July, 1921. It was a time when fat cattle could not be sold. I have reason to know well that in July, 1921, fat cattle could not be sold. Moreover, the Minister for Agriculture has told us that he is putting the unpurchased tenants for these three years on a par with the purchased tenants by giving them this reduction of 25 per cent. That is so for three years. What about the 15 years previous, when they were paying 25 per cent. more than the purchased tenants? Where a tenant's rental was £100 he paid in those fifteen or sixteen years £300 by reason of not being purchased. The reason why we are asking 40 per cent. on the purchase price is that these tenants may be put on something of a par with the tenants who purchased previously. Of course, the Minister made a statement all through that his prices were going to put the tenants in a better position than those who had purchased. I cannot find how they are going to be in a better position in any shape or form. He also dwelt on mortgages. I do not think that the tenants are responsible for that. I do not think that the tenants should be called on to pay exorbitant prices because the cost of living of the landlords has gone up.

Comment on this

I am sorry Deputy Gorey did not tell us where in the 1920 Bill his provision about the two years' arrears appears. I have the Bill here. There is no such provision in it about limiting the arrears to two years.

Comment on this

I can show you the agreement between the two parties.

Comment on this

I have the Bill here, and I would be anxious to see it.

Comment on this

I was one of the men who made the agreement.

Comment on this

The Deputy stated that the 1920 Bill allowed the landlords two years' arrears. I have the Bill here, and that is not in it.

Comment on this

I made the agreement. Do you deny the agreement?

Comment on this

I know nothing about the agreement that the Deputy made with the landlords.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Before we go any further with this I would point out that it is a question of the 1920 Bill, not any agreement made by Deputy Gorey.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows the agreement is not the point. There was no arrears problem in 1920. There were derelict holdings where rent was due, but there was not ten per cent. due all over the country. There was no arrears problem, comparatively. The problem we have now is not a problem in the same sense as that of 1881. If farmers were making £10,000 a year on a £20 holding some farmers would owe some landlords arrears. The tenants who owed rent for years and years came in and paid it during the war, in the good years. Deputy Doyle admitted that this twenty-five per cent. reduction brought present tenants purchasing under this Bill to the position of tenants who had purchased under the 1903 Act.

Comment on this
Mr. DOYLE

For three years.

Comment on this

For three years; that is exactly what I said. If you reduce tenants' rent by 25 per cent., you are putting them in the same position as if they were paying an annuity for three years. That is the fact. He explains that this 25 per cent. was made during the war. On a £20 holding, 2s. a week is £5 a year. That was during the war.

Comment on this
Mr. DOYLE

It was during twenty years. We had not the war for twenty years.

Comment on this

The war lasted from 1914 to 1918. I would like to ask how many hens would lay £5 worth of eggs per year. One good hen would do it.

Comment on this

The Minister's hens. I want to put in a claim for a sitting of the Minister's eggs. I have the first claim.

Comment on this

One good hen, let us be strictly accurate, would lay the difference, £5 a year, and £15 a year on a £100 holding was simply the price of one very bad bullock during the war.

Comment on this
Mr. DOYLE

It was during fifteen years previously. I did not mention the war period alone.

Comment on this

Please allow me to approach the subject in my own way. I am talking of the year 1920-21. Deputy Gorey said we should keep away from shillings and pence. I can quite understand that, because he knows perfectly well that this rent and arrears question is an artificial one. Rents at present are the smallest part of a farmer's outgoings.

Comment on this

Not the small man.

Comment on this

The small man especially. There are 70,000 holdings at £12 a year for the average holding. It is the smallest part of his outlay. We all know this rent question has attained an importance out of all relation to its economic importance, and I can quite see the reason why Deputies Gorey and Doyle would like to keep away from the figures. Take the £100 holding. The loss to the tenant who did not purchase during the war was £15 a year, the price of a very bad yearling during the war. Take the average holding, the £12 holding, the difference in the year between the annuity and the rent is £3. On the average £20 holding, a first-class economic holding, the difference is £5 a year. It is on those figures that all those diatribes are based. We ought to treat it as a business proposition. We ought to remember if we take over estates as they stand that it will affect the country's credit if we do not pay a price both for arrears and rent itself which will be at least the price which a banking institution would give for these. If we are prepared to sell the country's credit, and if now the time has come when we must sell and injure the country's credit, let us at least get value for our money. This advantage of £3 on the £12 holding, and the £5 on the £20 holding, and £15 on the £100 holding is hardly worth it. That is a serious aspect of the problem which the Dáil would do well to take into account. Is it worth while to injure the country's credit for such trivial advantages to one particular class?

Comment on this

Níl puinn agam le rádh. I think that this amendment of Deputy Gorey's, which we are asked to accept here falls very short of the requirements of the nation. He states here that he represents the Unpurchased Tenants, and that it is in their interest the Bill is made. If that is so, he is equally bound to add to his amendment that the rent paid during all those three years by those unpurchased tenants should be refunded. I think, in equity, he cannot dispute that contention, and that is the claim he puts before the Government. That is obviously the case he represents.

Comment on this

There are two points I should like to put before the Minister with regard to the question of arrears. The first is that whatever those men had done with the land for the last three years, there was one thing I would ask them not to believe—that is, that those men had that amount of money in the bank or have it at their command. The people in their circumstances found the money slipping away from them, and it is not possible for them to hold it. Another point he should give more consideration to is made by Deputies here, and that is that fairs and markets were for a while held up, and they suffered considerably. Taking those two points into consideration, I think it would be very difficult for tenants who are three years in arrears to meet the case. If he could, I would like to make a greater demand upon him; but, in view of the case he has made, and of the fact that his whole aim in this Bill is to strike a fair bargain, I would suggest that in connection with those three years in arrears he would take off half a year of the purchase money. That would to some extent serve to meet their case.

Comment on this

I think the suggestion put forward by Deputy Sears is an admirable one, and perhaps one that would meet the case made by Deputy Gorey to some extent. If Deputy Gorey sees his way to accept that suggestion, I think pressure could be brought on the Minister to accept it. I am sure, if it is the unanimous opinion of the Dáil that that should be done, I would ask the members of the Party on my left seriously to consider that proposition, and perhaps it would end the controversy over the arrears.

Comment on this

I am an unpurchased tenant myself, and I speak for many other unpurchased tenants. I do not believe there is any problem with regard to arrears of rent during the period mentioned, because those were years when people had a flush of money, and they ought to pay up the arrears. If we passed this amendment as it is, it might be brought to bear upon us later. We recollect the time when we were fighting the Local Government Board, and when a certain organisation sent round organisers to tell the people to pay no rates.

Comment on this

We will be at it again very soon.

Comment on this

rose——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Deputy Gorey has already spoken three times. Perhaps he would not like to hear how often he has interrupted. However, I will allow him one more speech.

Comment on this

I am impressed by the helpful suggestions of Deputy O'Donnell, and I have also listened to the helpful suggestions of Deputy McGoldrick. I know they were meant to help us in this amendment. Deputy Hughes and Deputy Sears have taken a very sane and helpful view. I am sorry, representing the people I do, that I cannot accept that view. The people I represent have adopted a certain attitude; I am only their instrument, and have to carry out their instructions. One thing that appears from this is that it affords a great ray of hope, especially to the West of Ireland, and I do think the West has a chance of getting on the right track and on the road to prosperity. I have heard it queried here: "What does ten shillings mean to the small man?" It means a lot. When you talk about ten shillings or a pound, it means a big lot to the small man. How much has the small man to give away? How much is he likely to make with his small valuation? You must try to look at the matter from the small man's point of view. Take into consideration his method of living and his home comforts, or his lack of them. Ten shillings mean a lot. We are told, too that it was only the price of a bullock, or a "screw," perhaps, in the years of the war that had made a difference to the man who did not purchase land and the man who did for the 14, 15, or 16 years between the operations of the last Act and the beginning of this Act. This is a bigger problem than many who are dealing with it lightly are inclined to think. If ten shillings are not taken into consideration in the life of a small man, then what are you going to base your calculations on? You must begin to realise that he has very little income and very little to derive from the soil. Ten shillings may mean more to him than twenty pounds to a big man. I cannot withdraw this amendment, because it is the considered judgment of the people I represent. If this fails—I suppose it will, for I see no other signs—it will probably mean that there is nothing to prevent the suggestions made by our friends taking effect at a later stage. I must put this to a division.

Comment on this

As an unpurchased tenant, I want to thank you, A Chinn Chomhairle, for permitting Deputy Gorey to make another speech, if for no other reason than that it has been exceedingly helpful. I thoroughly agree with what seems to underlie the arguments that he and his colleagues have put forward. Ten shillings seems a very small amount stated absolutely, but in conjunction with a variety of other things which go to make the conditions of life for the small holder it means an enormous amount. It means more than we, perhaps, can altogether realise. What I think is so particularly helpful is Deputy Gorey's declaration that he is speaking on this matter purely as a delegate. His position is one in which some of us occasionally find ourselves when we express on some particular matters not quite our own views or our own convictions, but rather those arrived at by the people whom we undertook to represent. It seems to me a compromise could be arrived at on this matter if an opportunity were given to Deputy Gorey to consult those who have instructed him to make this case. That 1921 was a bad year, for instance, is one of the alleged facts controverted. We all, surely, remember what the summer of 1921 was like—the hurtful effect of it upon 1922, the absolute absence of rain for months, the particularly torrid weather—weather almost semi-tropical—and we know it was most hurtful to the farming interests, and made the following year much more hurtful still.

Now, the want of markets, the general social upheaval, the insecurity, all combined, tended to make farming unprofitable in the years following. I think, as a matter of equity, we ought to take that into account. I do not think there is provided a sufficient basis for the demand to have arrears reduced by 40 per cent. I must say candidly that while I am advocating in a way what Deputy Doyle and others of the Farmers' Party advocated, they have not made a case for a reduction of 40 per cent., but they have made a case for making it easy for those who have a burden of arrears to shoulder, and that ease might be supplied in the fashion indicated by Deputy Sears—instead of calling for the payment of a lump sum, to allow it to be distributed over a number of years. There was a fallacy underlying some of the arguments, at least it seems so to me, with regard to those arrears. The question was put, "What had the farmer done with the rent?" Why, that assumes he had it. Otherwise, it is pretty much like the question asked by Lord Dundreary of the lady for whom he was manufacturing small talk. He asked her: "Does your brother like tea?""Do you know, Lord Dundreary," she replied, "that I have no brother?" He said, "Quite so, but do you think if you had a brother that he would like tea?" What did the tenant do with the rent that he is not able to pay? That is an unanswerable question. While I cannot, therefore, vote for Deputy Gorey's amendment as it stands, I yet feel that there is a great deal that ought to be met in the case put forward insufficiently in support of it. I would ask Deputy Gorey to withdraw the amendment, notwithstanding his instructions, and to allow this matter to be dealt with on the lines of distribution of certain arrears over the annuity payment.

Comment on this

In my view, in any case, the real reason for this strike or failure or inability to pay was the fact of non-purchase. That meets the point Deputy Magennis makes with regard to the question, "What has the farmer done with the rent?" It is not a case of the farmer in general not having the rent, but of a farmer withholding the rent as a protest against non-purchase. I tried to take into account the bad markets, the confusion, the hot summer of 1921, and all the other relevant circumstances when we fixed the 25 per cent. I tried to take into account the circumstances on the other side too, and we endeavoured to come to something which we considered would be reasonable, having regard to the interests on both sides. I am ready to consider the suggestion of Deputy Sears, but unless Deputy Gorey withdraws his amendment and accepts this amendment, which could be prepared on the lines suggested by Deputy Sears, I can do nothing, and there is no alternative except to let the matter go to a division.

Comment on this

I do not know what this suggestion means in actual figures.

Comment on this

I am prepared to consider Deputy Sears' suggestion, namely, in the case where a tenant owes three years' arrears that a half-year should be added to the purchase money.

Comment on this

What about the tenant with 2½ or 2 years' arrears?

Comment on this

That would reduce the payment to 2½, and the half-year would be added to the purchase money. If Deputy Gorey is not prepared to accept that, then at present there is no alternative except to let Deputy Gorey's amendment go to a division.

Comment on this

If the Minister can see his way to add in every case a half-year to the purchase money——

Comment on this

I would not agree to that. Take the case of a man who owes two years' arrears. He gets 25 per cent. per annum off, and that is a half-year's rent on two years, and he only owes 1½ years' rent. It is not a hardship to ask him to pay in those circumstances. I do admit there is a slight difference in the case where a man owes three years' arrears. There may be a certain amount of hardship, and to meet that I am willing to accept Deputy Sears' suggestion that in the case of three years' arrears a half-year is to be added to the purchase money.

Comment on this

A man with two years' arrears has already paid full rent for one year, and he is to get nothing but 25 per cent. off. Then the man who did not pay at all and who owed three years' rent will be treated as you suggest?

Comment on this

Exactly

Comment on this

We could not accept the proposal; it is too ridiculous.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 19
·
Níl 39
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I beg to move Amendment 21:—

In Sub-Section (2), line 19, to insert after the word "cent." the words:—"In the case of a tenant the total rateable value of whose holdings exceeds thirty pounds, and 50 per cent. in the case of a tenant the total rateable value of whose holdings does not exceed thirty pounds, or of a tenant of whose holdings not more than one-half is permanent pasture."

The object of this amendment is to secure that a large farmer or grazier who does not till half his land does not get the same benefit by the reduction as a small farmer or a large farmer who does till his land. The figure, £30 valuation, is selected as a reasonable dividing line.

Comment on this

I am neither an unpurchased tenant myself, nor do I claim, like Deputy Gorey, to represent 70,000 unpurchased tenants. I have been wondering whether Deputy Gorey, if there were 70,001 unpurchased tenants, would make the same claim. My support in this case is on behalf of the small tenant farmer who tills his land. He is the greatest asset to this nation, in so far as he is a member of a body that produces the food for the nation. The Minister for Agriculture wanted to know what these people did with their money, and Deputy Gorey said he hoped that they did not go to Kilkee or Tramore, or some other watering place. I am sure Deputy Gorey would not go so far as to say that the small tillage farmer who works hard for the benefit of the people is not entitled to a fortnight's holidays at Tramore.

Comment on this

He is, if he could get them; but he never could.

Comment on this

He did not get them last year, but that was not due to the clerk of the weather, but to the high political atmosphere prevailing at the time. If the small tenant farmer cannot get his holiday at Tramore or Kilkee, there is one thing certain, that the landlord will get his holiday at Monte Carlo, or some other such place, at the expense of the man who pays the rent. I would ask the Minister to approach the consideration of this amendment by enquiring into the conditions in which barley and other crops were produced during the last three years. Up to the year 1920 there was, generally speaking, no reason to complain with regard to the price for barley or other products. In 1920 the price ranged from 45s. to 52s. In 1921 it was from 18s. to 28s. 6d., and last year it was considered lucky to sell at from 11s. to 18s. We are told that the small farmer generally tills his land with the assistance of his own family. But are they not entitled to some return for their labour? In any event, in order to meet the cost of production, exclusive of any price for the use of his land, the price would require to be from 18s. to 28s. 6d. Therefore in selling barley, if he was lucky enough to sell it, he sold it at less than one cost of production, making no allowance or consideration for the use of the labour that was employed or the use of the land that produced this particular commodity. Against that you have the landlords' interests represented by Guinness's brewery, who sold the product of that particular commodity at the same price last year as it did three years ago, when the price of barley was 52s. a barrel. Perhaps the Minister would explain where the difference goes, or whether the two million five hundred thousand that Guinness handed out to their shareholders not very long ago, was at the expense of the tenant farmers of this country. As well as sowing barley, the tenant farmer usually produces whatever food is necessary to feed pigs, and I think that the price for the last couple of years is very low in regard to them, notwithstanding the fact that there is very little reduction for those who have to buy the finished article over the counter. The Minister said yesterday that the small landlord or the small estate was more likely to be encumbered than the large one. I suggest that the same argument applies in regard to the unpurchased tenant, and that he would be less able to bear the burden for reasons, some of which I have already given, and that the Minister himself has pleaded on behalf of the landlord.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

at this stage took the Chair.

Comment on this

The President in dealing with the points put up by Deputy Gorey referred to the fact that sixteen head of cattle were sold at 80s. per cwt. at a certain time. I would like the Minister to make enquiries, and I would like to learn, as a result of the enquiries, the number of unpurchased tenants of valuations of less than £30 who were able to put sixteen head of cattle on the market at 80s. per cwt.

Comment on this

Not one.

Comment on this

Very few at any rate. The Minister also dealt very exhaustively with the position of the tenant—the position he will be in under this Bill as compared with the tenant who purchased under previous Acts. When the previous Land Bills, not compulsory, certainly, were passed, and when the tenant took advantage of them, money on the market was stationary at that particular time, prices were generally the same from one year to another; they were not affected in the way they have been affected in the last six years or since the outbreak of the European War. Money could also be borrowed at a very much lower rate than it is being borrowed at the present time. The position around the country at the moment, so far as I can gather, is that the small farmer owes money to the shopkeeper, the shopkeeper owes money to the wholesaler; very few of them owe money to Guinness, at any rate. The whole thing, as far as I can see it, is carried on on paper credit. There is one thing certain, and that is the two classes of people in the country who are suffering are the producer of the food and the consumer, who has nothing else to fall back upon except his weekly wage or salary. There is somebody in between these two who is getting a good whack out of it, at any rate. The Minister said you cannot take blood out of a turnip. If he could imagine that argument being applied as an excuse, it could by a stretch of the imagination be applied to the small farmer who owes two or three years' rent. I suggest it is an impossible proposition for him, even with the assistance of the Sheriff, to collect the arrears of rent, and he had better try to meet the situation by something in the nature of the amendment which I am supporting. I think it was Deputy Gorey referred to the cost of carriage. I have seen cases where a bag of potatoes or a bag of barley cost more in freight over eighty miles of Irish railway than you would have actually to pay for them at the pit. I do not know exactly what he meant by bringing it into a question of this kind, but I suppose it was for the purpose of showing that the man who produced the article is getting the least out of it. The Minister also seems to take the view that the non-payment of rent for the last couple of years is merely a protest on behalf of unpurchased tenants in so far as the landlords were not willing to sell.

Comment on this

The Deputy should try to quote me properly. I stated my view on that question at least three times. The Deputy knows it. I do not want to state it again.

Comment on this

I am sorry if I misinterpreted the Minister, but I did not take down what he said in shorthand. I took it that was the view he put up. If it is, I certainly do not agree with his statement.

Comment on this

If I did not say it, you do not agree with it?

Comment on this

There is nobody—at least I am not, at any rate—supporting an amendment of this kind in order to injure the country's credit. Landlords, generally speaking, will not depend on rents for a livelihood. You will find that anything worth anything in this country is owned by a very small number of people, and the landlord who lives in Monte Carlo out of the rents he gets from the tenant-farmers of this country generally gets something else out of big establishments such as Guinness's brewery. You can take it for granted that you are not actually going to send the landlords into bankruptcy or into any Home in this country, at any rate, as paupers if this amendment is carried. I think if the Government are not prepared to meet in some way the barley growers and other small farmers of the country, they will drive them out of existence. The amendment, if the Minister is prepared to accept it, I think will meet the present case of the very small farmer, who, generally speaking, is the food-producer, and is Ireland's greatest asset at the moment.

Comment on this

I am wholly in sympathy with the principle that underlies the amendment, but I think that the line at which the barrier is drawn between the two classes is not a line that can be accepted. I represent a county in which the average valuation of holdings is £8.

Comment on this

You represent!

Comment on this

I represent a county in which the average valuation of the holdings is £8, and with the men on these holdings men like Deputy Gorey have very little sympathy or very little knowledge of what their economic requirements are, because he lives in a different atmosphere. He is accustomed to big farms and big grazing problems, but he does not know anything about the conditions that apply to holdings in a county such as I represent. With all due respect to the pretentions he makes here of representing the community generally, in this respect, I submit, he is not properly qualified to understand these things. I think if the partition between these two classes were regularised in some way, this amendment could be accepted. I could not possibly vote for it as it stands. There are forty thousand holdings in Tirconnaill with a population of two hundred thousand. These people are labouring in the general interests of agriculture. They are not gambling on big prices or small prices; they are applying themselves to the best interests of agriculture, and they are a class that ought to be supported. They have something in common with the people of the West of Ireland, though in the West of Ireland tillage is not engaged in to the same extent as it is in Tirconnaill. They represent, I suppose, 6,000 of the unpurchased tenants, and the money that would be involved in a remission with regard to these men would be very small, and to the landlord generally it would not amount to anything very much. In the case of big farms and big ranches it would amount to a good deal, but it does not amount to very much in the case of the small land-holder, who is working in the best spirit of agricultural development, and who only ekes out a bare living despite his arduous work. What would apply to him would not apply generally to the farming community more or less represented here by Deputy Gorey. I submit that it would be well if the Dáil would find some dividing line here. It is absolutely essential in the interests of those who are struggling. The man in the high-rated holding, generally speaking, is practically a landlord himself. I do not draw much distinction between the large tenant and the landlord. They are both engaged in speculation—the landlord as to how much he can make out of his estate, and the tenant as to how much he can make for applying to his own specific purposes. I think that this amendment should be considered in a further stage of the Bill, and it is one, if properly drawn, that could be supported. Much money will not be involved; it will take very little from the landlord, while it will mean a great deal to these small land-holders. Generally speaking, these people have always met their obligations, and the amount of their arrears will bear no proportion to the arrears in the case of large holdings, where there has been a cessation of payments of rents for a considerable time back. Although these people have not been very well able to meet their engagements, they have at the same time made a struggle to meet them, and they should get encouragement. I have a recollection myself—and it extends further back than even Deputy Gorey's recollection— when, as a little boy, the landlord of one of the farms we held died, and for five years no person was in a position to collect rent. At the end of five years I was sent with five years' rent, whereas in the case of others who did not pay the arrears they were allowed off with a half-year's rent. The man who paid got no consideration, but the man who did not meet his obligations was the man, I think, that was looked after by the Act of Parliament. I think that was immoral, and if we are to do things as we ought to do, we should look at it in that way, and not as a matter of expediency. These things are matters of equity, and they may be dealt with under those principles. A margin should be drawn between the small tenant and the large one, and in this case it can be done, but the margin here is too wide. I cannot support the amendment unless the margin is drawn.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy suggest a reasonable figure?

Comment on this

He does not want to be dishonest.

Comment on this

£10 instead of £30.

Comment on this

There would be an easy way for Deputy McGoldrick to support that. If the Dáil accepts the amendment as it stands, it would be possible for Deputy Gorey to reduce the figure by a further amendment.

Comment on this

I am not accepting the amendment. Deputy Sears made a suggestion on the last amendment in regard to the question of arrears. I expressed my own view of it. That is as far as I am prepared to go. We are reminded that we must be equitable in those matters. We cannot have casual figures or haphazard ones. So far we have had no reasons given by the opposition. I want to know how this figure of 50 per cent. was arrived at. We have not got a single reason yet for any figure suggested by the opposition either from the Labour Party or the Farmers' Party. It seems to be simply a question of putting down whatever figure one happens on. I showed very clearly how we arrived at this figure. I showed its exact bearing on the price, but we have not got a single reason for a single figure put forward by the other party. I congratulate the Farmers' and the Labour Party on the happy position they are in. They are not in charge of the Bill, and are not responsible for it. The land question is a very old question, and everyone almost is interested in it. The opposition is in the happy position of being able to suggest any figure, either 50 per cent. or 60 per cent. If the labour Party suggested 50 per cent., the Farmers would suggest 70 per cent.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, may I say that we had no knowledge of the Farmers' amendment at all when we put forward ours.

Comment on this

No one suggested you had. If the Farmers say 40, they say 50. The two parties are having a picnic. I do not envy them their position. Some day I may be put in that position myself. This debate is appearing daily in the Press. There is an election coming on in a short time, and without very much cost, without making themselves responsible for any of the consequences of those amendments, they can go down to the country and talk about 50 or 60 per cent. Deputy Davin can tell his constituency about the small farmers in whom he is so very much interested.

Comment on this

Why did you not keep the Bill until after the elections?

Comment on this

I do not begrudge either the Farmers' Party or the Labour Party their present position. I wish I was in it myself. We can all make allowances for a thing of that kind. I do not think anyone is going to be deceived by this tremendous interest in agriculture in general. We, however, who are responsible must give reasons for our figures. We must consider what reactions they will have on the credit of the country. We must see that the figures square with justice, because I hope this Bill will pass and be put into operation, and that in two, three, four or five years time we will not have any reason to be ashamed of it. We have to put in figures accurately, realising that we are responsible for the Bill. I would like to hear this 50 per cent. defended. I am not good at mathematics, but I think I could prophesy that I could defend 60 per cent. by exactly the same reasons as I could 70 per cent. I do not know why Deputy Davin, having regard to the price of barley, did not put in an amendment that no arrears be paid.

Comment on this

That is justice.

Comment on this

Why was it not put in?

Comment on this

I spoke in support of my own amendment, and the Minister should answer the arguments that I put up then.

Comment on this

I hope Deputy Gorey will take notice that there is a division also in the Labour Party.

Comment on this

Those benches should take notice too.

Comment on this

We do not blame any one for not wasting time listening to the arguments that have just been heard, because no one takes them seriously. Deputy Lyons suggested 100 per cent. Does Deputy Davin agree with that? If he does, why does he not stand up for it?

Comment on this

We did not like to embarrass you.

Comment on this

Thanks very much, I will accept that reason, as it is the only one available in those circumstances. Barley is practically down to pre-war figures. We are bringing rents down to pre-war figures. We are dealing with pre-war figures. Remember that. Wherever there was inflation as a result of the War, and wherever the tenant got a benefit as a result of that inflation, we are not taking it into account. We set out expressly to deal with the tenant's position as if prices were exactly pre-war, and that is the reason we gave this 10 per cent. contribution in order to lend the money at the price at which we could borrow and lend money before the War. You are to deal with the tenant in pre-war prices as if the European War had never occurred, and as if those conditions were exactly the same as pre-war. When people talk about the price of barley, barley is down to pre-war price, and in some cases below it, but we are dealing with the tenant as we would pre-war, and we are giving the tenant between 10 and 15 per cent. better terms than pre-war. Deputy Doyle admitted that 25 per cent. deduction would bring it down to the 1903 Act. Now we are giving 35 per cent.

Comment on this
Mr. DOYLE

I want to say that I admitted no such thing that you were putting them on a better basis than the former tenants. You are putting them on a worse basis. Take the rental of £100——

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

You are not allowed to make a speech.

Comment on this
Mr. DOYLE

He made a statement and attributed it to me. I say there is no such thing as better terms, and that the price the Minister is offering in this Bill is worse.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Deputy Doyle will have an opportunity of speaking after the Minister.

Comment on this

I think the Dáil heard the Deputy admit that if we reduced the rent by 25 per cent. the reduced rent would be equal to the average annuity that would be paid by the tenant who had purchased. Is that correct?

Comment on this
Mr. DOYLE

No; I qualified that statement considerably.

Comment on this

He admits having made it, but he qualified it. Statements can be made, but when you see to what they lead you can qualify them. I do not think Deputy Doyle is the sort of man who would run away from statements which he makes. The reduction of 25 per cent. would bring the tenant's annuity down to exactly what was paid before the war under the 1903 Act. He admitted that. We give the tenant in this Bill 35 per cent. reduction, so that not only are we saving him from the inflation in prices as a result of the war and from the dearness of money, but we are giving him better terms as far as his annuity is concerned than if he had purchased pre-war. We are giving him 10 to 15 per cent. better terms. When Deputies talk of barley being back to pre-war price they must remember that. They must remember that we took that into account, that that was the reason why we fixed this reduction, or at least one of the reasons. We are not saying anything about the things that are not down to pre-war prices, but which are much above pre-war prices. We are not making any allowance for that, but we are certainly allowing the tenant for everything that is back to pre-war by this 35 per cent., and we are giving him 10 to 15 per cent. better terms with regard to prices. Deputies should remember that when they are talking of the price of barley. We took all these considerations which I have heard now into account. We worked out our figures with very considerable thought, and after, I hope, giving the question the time and attention that such serious questions are entitled to get. Having done that, we are entitled to get from a responsible opposition how they defend this figure of 50 per cent. Apart from the reasons that I referred to at the beginning, I think they ought at least to make a show of defending these figures. I heard Deputy Davin talk on the cost of production, basing a number of interesting arguments on it. I had a look at the farmers' benches and I was hoping that Deputy Gorey would rise to the occasion and point out that this cost of production argument cuts both ways. There is an item called labour—surely labour has something to do with it.

Comment on this

These people do not employ labour.

Comment on this

That is the reason that the cost of production is used here. The cost of production argument is one that I am glad the Labour Party have definitely given their allegiance to. I certainly will not advise the Dáil to accept this amendment and to accept any amendment on these lines. I have stated what I had to say to Deputy Sears' suggestion, and I would not go any further.

Comment on this
Mr. DOYLE

The Minister for Agriculture stated that I agreed that he gave the same reduction in the Bill to the unpurchased tenants. He gave the same reduction for three years. In stating that, I asked the Minister what amount did tenants pay in excess for fifteen years previously. Would the Minister answer that? He began then telling us about a bullock paying the difference. But that meant fifteen bullocks. Five pounds meant five times fifteen pounds. I admit that you gave it to the unpurchased tenants for three years, but what about the fifteen years previous when they got nothing? What about the case where the £100 tenant was compelled to pay £300 more than the unpurchased tenant beside him? It is all very well for the Minister to say that we are using this for propaganda. Possibly the Government will go down and use something else for propaganda, about the sectional attitude we are taking up here.

Comment on this

This point that Deputy Doyle refers to is most amusing when one bears in mind what the Minister said a while ago, when he said that this question of rent is a comparatively small matter to the tenant farmer today.

Comment on this