We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

DAIL IN COMMITTEE. - LAND BILL, 1923—THIRD STAGE RESUMED.

Contributions 132–258 of 258. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Land Bill, 1923
Enacted

No. 24 of 1923 ›

Does the Deputy agree?

Comment on this

That is the Minister's statement. The Minister has brought in a Land Purchase Bill in the Dáil, where 50 or 60 Deputies attend out of 128. He wants to get this passed before the election. We are charged with introducing amendments with a view to the public. I think the charge can be quite fairly thrown at the Minister in view of his own statement that the question of rentals is comparatively small. This matter of land purchase, as the Minister himself said, should be dealt with by a Parliament representative of you all. This was placarded all over the country: "The country should be fully represented in the Parliament of the nation," and that Parliament should deal with this land question. Well, in view of that, I think it does not lie in the Minister's mouth at any rate to make these references to amendments put down with an eye to the public. He has asked why 50 per cent. was put down, why is 25 per cent. put down? I will tell him. Twenty-five per cent. is his figure. It is intended to apply to all those who owe rentals, whether they were men living by their work on the land or whether they were men living by the sale of cattle which were grazed on the land. If it is a fair reduction for a cattle grazier, then at least the tiller of the soil is entitled to double that reduction. Now, the Minister may say that on that argument he is entitled to 60 per cent., 70 per cent., or 80 per cent. I would agree. He is certainly entitled to a greater reduction than the man who simply grazes cattle on the land, and whom he says is entitled to a 25 per cent. reduction. We have been very much familiarised with the contention from those who, if they were present, would be sitting on the Ministerial Benches, that the grazier, the large farmer who grazes his cattle, and the small farmer who works the land should be treated on a different basis. That is true, or it is not true. The echoes come from the Ministerial Benches that it is true. We want to test it. Are they prepared to treat the tiller of the soil on better lines than they would treat the grazier?

Comment on this

The Bill answers that question.

Comment on this

The amendment is put down with a view to eliciting the views of the Ministry on that proposition.

Comment on this

The Bill itself gives them.

Comment on this

The Bill does not on the question of arrears, at any rate. Deputy McGoldrick told us that. I do not suppose there are many Deputies here who have a better knowledge of the position and the condition of the small tenant farmers than Deputy McGoldrick has, and he agrees that there should be a line drawn between the two classes of tenants. He thinks that the £30 mentioned in the amendment is too high, but at any rate it will include all those whose interest he has at heart, so he need not object to the amendment on that account. If he agrees that there is a large number, or any number, who are over £20 valuation or a £10 valuation, that should be included in the 25 per cent. category, well, that is a matter that we can perhaps accommodate him with. At any rate, he agrees with the principle that there should be a distinction drawn between the tenant who is tilling his holding, the small holder who must perforce, if he tills his holding, live out of the proceeds of that holding, and the extensive holder who has not tilled his holding. He got into arrears because of his failure to back the winner in the cattle gamble of 1921-22.

We are prepared to agree with the Minister that a 25 per cent. reduction is sufficient for him. The Minister contends it is a fair proposition that such a holder is entitled to a 25 per cent. reduction of any arrears, and we retort that if he is entitled to such a reduction, then the man who did his duty by the State, the man who fulfilled his trust in his holding, is entitled to a greater reduction than the man who simply used the land for the purpose of a cattle ranch. That is the case for the amendment. The Minister accepts the principle; then the figures may be arranged, and I am sure we will be able to accommodate him either to follow Deputy Lyons's suggestion and wipe out all arrears, or to modify the figures, and, as a matter of fact, to collaborate with the Minister in making this distinction as effective as possible, to give a preference to the land-holder who tills his land as against the land-holder who refuses to till his land. I have a table here in connection with one county. It is not, perhaps, the best illustration, and it was got out for an entirely different purpose. In the county there are 162 holdings, ranches averaging 340 acres and with a total acreage of 55,059. The total number of men employed on all that property was 432, or one man per 128 acres. What proportion of those holdings would come under this Bill I have not the slightest conception of. I do say that kind of land-holding in other counties, and to some extent in this county, ought to be penalised as compared with the tenant tiller of the soil. This amendment will at least test the principle whether it is intended to place the grazier on the same plane in regard to arrears as we are proposing to place the tenant-holder who is a tiller of the soil.

Comment on this

Deputy Johnson does not apparently realise that the answer to his important question is the Bill. If he will look at Section 21, Subsection (3), and at Section 28—sections upon which I dwelt in the Second Reading—he will find the whole spirit of this is to relieve the tenant with whose interests he is so much concerned.

Comment on this

Touching arrears.

Comment on this

Touching the placing of him in a proper economic position.

Comment on this

We are dealing now with the question of arrears.

Comment on this

I know; but Deputy Johnson proclaimed with great rhetorical effect, and with the air of an expectant victor entering into the captured citadel, that this was going to test the whole character of the Bill——

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Whether or not those who propose it meant it for the advantage of the right sort of land occupant or the wrong sort of land occupant, and it is merely with that particular aspect of his argument that I am now standing up to deal. It is quite obvious to anyone who studies the Bill that it was conceived and framed in the spirit of rectifying all the wrongs that are outstanding in regard to the landless men, the agricultural labourer, who is deprived of land because of the operation of previous Purchase Acts, people who have uneconomic holdings, others who were debarred from turbary rights. And then there is a provision dealing with the farmer who has a large holding of untenanted land and who is going to work it. Again, Deputy Johnson ought to note that one of the requirements which the Land Commission is to insist upon in regard to all applicants under Section 28 for advances is the capacity of working the soil.

Comment on this

We are not dealing with that particular character of the Bill. We are dealing with arrears, and only arrears—things that have passed, not things that are to come.

Comment on this

This is logic running mad, because if a Deputy advances a certain doctrine or view in order to support his criticism either of a Section or an amendment to a section, anyone is entitled in any sane assembly to stand up to rebut the argument, whether or not he takes or does not take the view with regard to the other matter out of which this doctrinal disquisition arises. I submit that I am quite in order in attempting to show that this declaration that the amendment has the incalculable value of testing the whole Bill is put forward here, with the recommendation that it is the touchstone, and I suggest to anyone who reads the Bill fairly that the touchstone has already been applied satisfactorily.

Comment on this

I find myself being forced into the position of being the only one to stand up for the unfortunate farmer. Deputy Johnson says he would like to give advantage to the man who performed his trust. It is when you get down to the question of what he means by performing his trust—the trust that the State put in him by giving him this holding—that we begin to differ. Tillage did not pay for the past year. Potatoes are £1 a ton, and a man could not afford to till to the same extent as heretofore for a number of reasons. Are we to penalise a man because he did not till to such an extent as in previous years, because he did not till to a large extent, even though, if he did till to a large extent, the tillage might not pay? That is the doctrine. I am not saying now that a large farmer should not till considerably. The large farmers can and do, but you are not making the measure the amount of tillage. Is that fair, considering that when you go for a certain area of tillage, for reasons which I will not go into now——

Comment on this

May I remind the Minister that there are alternatives—the valuation of the holding or the amount of tillage?

Comment on this

The Deputy did not really defend the amendment so much as the general principle. I am on the same point as Deputy Magennis. This was the touchstone, and the Deputy's test was the amount of tillage that was done. Are you to penalise a man because he did not till to such a very large extent that it would not pay him? I agree that the State is entitled to expect that a man should use his land properly. But, on the other hand, the owner of the land is entitled to take into consideration whether he can make a profit or not.

Comment on this

He is not in it for his health.

Comment on this

He is entitled to take into consideration how much he can till and make a profit. If you make the measure purely and simply the amount of tillage, then you are doing an injustice. I think the Farmers' Party will, at least, bear me out in that. I do say that if you want to draw a line that you cannot do it at a valuation of £30 or £10 or £5. You will get men whose valuations are under £10 not giving value to the State for the land they have got. You will get men whose valuations are over £10 not giving value to the State. You will get men—and plenty of men—whose holdings are under £5 valuation, who are giving full value to the State, and you will, likewise, get men with over £100 valuation giving full value. But what the Deputy suggests is that the Land Commission, immediately this Bill is passed, should set out and examine every holding in Ireland. That is what would have to be done if the Deputy's idea were carried out.

I was twitted with introducing this Bill before the Election. Every Party in the Dáil asked me at least five times across the floor of the Chamber when this Bill was coming. I was pressed by all parties to produce it. If I have one file in my office I have a thousand, from all sorts and conditions of organisations— Back to the Land, Labour, and Unpurchased Tenants—asking when I would bring in this Bill and telling me to bring it in immediately. Now I am told it is introduced for election purposes, and again we are twitted with supporting the landlords.

Comment on this

Do you remember the Governor-General's speech?

Comment on this

I remember it quite well. All the demands made were that we should deal in this Bill with averages. The tenants pointed out—and rightly pointed out—that the old system was slow, and that it was not, for the difference, worth while to have the Land Commission going over all the holdings, examining them and pricing them, Having regard to the fact that we were dealing, to a great extent, with judicial rents, it was urged that we should adopt the system of averages—that we should strike averages and have the operations of the Bill as far as possible automatic. Nobody ever suggested that there should be a line drawn. All these organisations looked for averages. A rough and ready method was what they wanted. The Deputy can make what capital he likes out of that. Rough and ready methods are what they asked for. I have given them the ready methods, and I have given them fine methods as well. Not a single organisation through the country ever asked for anything except an average figure.

Comment on this

Did they ever ask for tillage?

Comment on this

I am not on that at the moment. I cannot deal with two points at the same time. I was blamed by every party for not making one figure apply to First, Second and Third Term rents. I could not see my way to simplify it down to one figure, but I brought it down to two figures, and I think that was rather good. I was rather criticised for that, and we seem to be back at this position now: wherever any average is likely to prejudice the position of the particular people whom a Deputy is interested in at the moment then the Land Commission is to value the holding. Each Deputy is interested in a different class or a different section or a different part of the country, where there are special conditions, and we are gradually getting back to the position under the 1903 Act of handing over the work to the Land Commission and getting them to examine all the estates and go into the circumstances of each holding—getting them to take the special circumstances of each case into consideration and do justice to each case. It would be very nice if we could do that, but it would take at least twenty years, and we would be back to the good old time under the 1903 and 1909 Acts.

I claim that I produce figures which do justice. I claim that it is not as hard a task to do justice by averages in this particular Bill as it would have been before, because we are dealing with figures that have not been inflated, and that are really rock-bottom figures. Most of the tenants went into the Land Courts when they were set up, and a certain standard figure was put on each holding. We can take a line from that figure. Where tenancies are non-judicial we are allowing the Land Commission to value them. As regards the judicial tenants, we can take a line from the standard figure and we can be very accurate. Every farmer knows that it would not be worth while, for the purpose of righting the little injustices that might be done in particular cases, to go back to the old system and to have the Land Commission do everything. We have tried in this Bill to meet the requests and desires of the tenants' organisations and the labour organisations who wrote to me urging me to deal in averages; there is no use at this hour of the day quoting a particular case and suggesting that the Land Commission should be set going again, inspecting holdings and generally inquiring into how the people use their farms. That is the way to hold land purchase up. It would do more harm than good. What the tenants want is expedition. What we want is expedition. We want to get the Bill passed and to see it operating at the earliest possible moment and in the most expeditious way, and we want to make the tenants the owners of their own holdings.

Comment on this

I am of opinion that the Minister for Agriculture did not regard this amendment in a proper light. I think it is an amendment that should meet with the approval of even the Minister for Agriculture. Considering that the amendment is designed to benefit the really poor man, it would be surprising to find that the Minister for Agriculture or any member of the Government would urge its rejection. The amendment says that in a case where the tenant's total rateable value exceeds £30——

Comment on this

Is he a poor man?

Comment on this

He is to get 25 per cent. and in the case of a tenant whose valuation does not exceed £30, or of a tenant of whose holdings not more than one-half is permanent pasture, he is to get 50 per cent. That is one of the most necessary amendments that have been introduced in connection with this Bill. It is not put forward for electioneering purposes. We know that these Benches would be packed after the election, whether or not this amendment was put forward. If the Minister or the Government reject this amendment it will show that it is really a capitalist Government, and out for the big grazier and not for the poor man. The men who can turn out 16 fat bullocks to the market, I can assure the Dáil, are not the men we are seeking to get this 50 per cent. for. I have the honour to represent a county with the best land in Ireland next to that of Meath, and there is no man in my constituency who can fatten and turn out 16 bullocks on a holding under £30 valuation. Take the argument put forward by Deputy Gorey, which I consider was honest. I am sorry to say that Deputy Gorey was misled——

Comment on this

Misled into honesty!

Comment on this

Misled by the Minister for Agriculture when he introduced the Bill. Mr. Gorey, on the second reading of the Bill, said:

Now, with regard to the question of price, the price set out in this Bill falls very far short of the demand we put forward, and that applies to both price and arrears. I will deal with the question of prices first. They are not even as high as the prices demanded by Fr. Maguire on behalf of the unpurchased tenants of Co. Monaghan. These were 45 per cent. on first term rents, 40 per cent. on second term, and 35 per cent. on third term.

I read that out for the purpose of showing to the Dáil the necessity for accepting this amendment. The Farmers' Party at the time accepted those terms, which were the smallest put forward by that particular unpurchased tenants' organisation. It is only right that the Dáil should now accept this amendment for the purpose of benefiting the poor man. I fully realise that in some counties a holding of £30 valuation is a good holding, and one a man can live on. It would be an injustice if we did not do something for the man who tills a good portion of a small holding. We are not penalising by this amendment anybody who really does justice and contributes to the prosperity of the State. I am of opinion that the Farmers' Party, so far as they have gone, have tried to do justice to the people they represent. But we must take into account that, as Deputy McGoldrick said a few moments ago, and as I was sorry to hear mentioned, Deputy Gorey, the leader on the Farmers' benches, was not out for the uneconomic holder or the unpurchased tenant, but was out for the grazier when he wanted to deal with the sporting rights so that everybody could rear greyhounds. Amendment 20 was out for the interests of the small men, and if that amendment was out for the interests of the small man, so is Amendment 21. The Minister for Agriculture said that if a man owed rent amounting to £24, it would be spread over a term of three years. That would be £8 per annum. How could a man with six or seven acres of land, some of which, to my own knowledge, is not worth 2s. 6d. per acre, pay back arrears to the extent of £8 a year? I am surprised at the Minister for Agriculture, at the Dáil, and at the Government, and I would be twice as much surprised if any Teachtai would vote against this amendment, because I hold that this amendment does justice to all classes. You may compromise in the amendment. If it is a decent compromise I am sure the members at this side of the Dáil will not force it to a division. We do not want to show the hands of any Deputy here; we simply want to see that justice is done. When I used the phrase "Showing the hands," I meant we do not want to do them out of votes at the next election. If a tenant at the present time owes £24, I wonder how much profit the landlords have made in the last twenty or thirty years. I can assure this Dáil that in the last twenty or thirty years a lot of the landlords still in Ireland came into the possession of the land not morally or legally, but through grabbing. I do not see why these people should be entitled to get an excessive rent from the original owners of the land.

I said on the occasion of the Second Reading of the Bill that the landlords were worthy of all the names that Deputy Professor Magennis called them. Of course, Deputy Professor Magennis did not mean to call the landlords names, but he tried to interpret what was passing through Deputy Gorey's mind. I say now he was perfectly honest, and that the majority of these men have come into the possession of the land through grabbing, and here we are, one of the legal Assemblies of the Irish people, and we are going to do justice to the men who battered down the homes of our ancestors with the battering-ram and with the help of an enemy Government. Are we going to do justice to these men now by giving them three years' arrears with a slight reduction of 25 per cent.? When you take that into account, that we are going to do justice to those people, I do not see why the Minister for Agriculture or the Government cannot accept this amendment and do justice to the unpurchased tenant. I hope the Minister will accept the amendment, and I hope that, if a division is called for, the Dáil will not have it said that they are out for the grazier and the rancher, and that they have no thought for the unfortunate persons who are the backbone of the nation, the unpurchased tenant, the evicted tenant, and the ordinary worker.

Comment on this

There is just one part of this amendment that I do not agree with. That is the latter portion, where a distinction is made between the man who tills his holding and the man who does not. I do not think that this distinction would be made by the man who knows Ireland. There are portions of it eminently suitable for tillage, and there are vast tracts where tillage could not be carried on—namely, the mountainous and bog districts. With regard to the small farmer, why he should receive better treatment than the large farmer I think it is quite apparent, but we have never been asked anything about divisions on this question of arrears. We are asked to put up figures. Our arguments have been figures enough. For the last three or four years farms have been run at a loss. If the money is not there, where is it to come from? You are asking for money that is not there. I certainly agree with the portion of the amendment that would give some preferential terms to the small farmer, but I cannot agree with the other part, because there are vast tracts of land in Ireland where tillage cannot be carried on. There is no use in trying to make a distinction on those lines, but there is every reason and every justice in making a distinction between the small man and the large man. We have not put down figures, because nobody is able to tender actual figures with regard to tillage and farming generally. The figures must be judged by the profits that come from farming. Anybody who wants to run a farm of fifteen or twenty acres will very easily find out for himself what the profit is.

Anybody who is not acquainted with the circumstances of the small man has no business talking about him. One must live beside the small man before one can get to know the actual circumstances under which he lives; one has to see what he is able to produce, what his revenues are and what his credits before any kind of solid opinion can be formed as to his actual position. Anyone who wants to legislate on behalf of these people must become familiar with all the figures which this knowledge would give before he can deal with the position of the small man.

Comment on this

I would like to know from the Deputy whether the Unpurchased Tenants' Association or the Farmers' Union ever made that distinction before?

Comment on this

I never said so. As I have already stated, my anxiety in dealing with this matter, is to save something from the wreck. Deputy McGoldrick, in his speech, drew a picture of a good little boy, I do not know how many years ago, going away with five years' rent in his pocket, with instructions to pay it like a good little fellow. From what I know of Deputy McGoldrick, as a man, I am not surprised that he went away with five years' rent in his pocket and paid it out cheerfully. That does not surprise me, nor does it surprise me that the good little boy has grown up into a good little man. What I do object to is his complaint that when he went away and paid his five years' rent, in a few months' time an Arrears Bill was introduced whereby his neighbours had all their arrears wiped out. I think he used the word "dishonesty" in regard to these other people.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this

Yes, you did, and I think you also used the word "immoral." According to Deputy McGoldrick all these people were rogues, they were dishonest, and they were immoral and, according to him, the Arrears Bill was introduced in order to relieve the condition of these rogues and dishonest and immoral people.

Comment on this

What I said was that the legislation was immoral.

Comment on this

That will be very interesting reading for the people of Donegal, or, as I believe the Deputy calls it, Tirconaill—very interesting reading indeed for the regues and the dishonest and immoral people of Tirconaill.

Comment on this

They appreciate honesty in Tirconaill.

Comment on this

Deputy McGoldrick told me that I knew nothing about the people of Tirconaill, but I think I know more about them than he does. They have entrusted me to look after their interests, and I want to know from Deputy McGoldrick who instructed him to appear for the Unpurchased Tenants of Tirconaill, or on whose behalf he was speaking? If he shows me any written authority entitling him to speak on behalf of the Unpurchased Tenants of Tirconaill, I am prepared to apologise to him.

Comment on this

I can show abundance of it.

Comment on this

I would like to see it. The Unpurchased Tenants of Tirconaill do not think very much about you.

Comment on this

I am the man who represents them.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

We have nothing to do with what the people of Tirconaill think on that.

Comment on this

They will settle the matter themselves when they get the chance.

Comment on this

Which is Deputy Gorey or Deputy McGoldrick the Deputy for Tirconaill?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

That question does not arise.

Comment on this

Perhaps we may find our way to Sligo yet. You can never tell.

Comment on this

You do not represent it yet, anyway.

Comment on this

I have not said so. I never made the claim that I misrepresented it, as some people are doing at the moment. I again appeal to the Government to take into consideration the claims put forward for this amendment by Deputy Davin and other Deputies. There is no getting away from this fact that, if you want to talk about equity, you must try to divide the equities as between the landlord and the tenant, and do justice between both. The case has not been put up that the landlord has to meet certain payments, but it is only the landlord's case that has been put up. When you talk about the landlord you mean, of course, the greatest wasters in the country; when you talk about the uneconomic and mortgaged landlord you are simply talking about the most disreputable element in the community; you are talking about wasters, men who want medical attendance for something—I will not mention what I have in my mind— men who lived a certain life, and now we are asked to do justice to these people and to make the small men pay off their mortgages for them.

Comment on this

I am afraid that Deputy Gorey places a wrong interpretation upon this amendment. He seems to think it is an amendment giving a preference for the future to the people who till a certain amount of land.

Comment on this

No; I do not.

Comment on this

That is not the position. As I have already pointed out, I presume the Minister will be in a position to enforce the payment of whatever conditions are laid down in this Bill so far as its application to the landlord is concerned. All we ask is that the people who have tilled a certain amount of land or whose valuation is below a certain figure should get the concession which is stipulated in the amendment. The Minister, no matter how polite he may be, and he has been very polite on this matter, cannot deny that at a critical period in the country's history, at a particular time when there was a food shortage, certain people tilled a certain amount of their land, and by doing so they have lost a considerable amount of money, and as a result many of them are now heavily in debt. What we ask is that the situation, so far as these people are concerned, should be relieved by the acceptance of this amendment. The Minister, in turning down this amendment, says he is doing it because of representations that have been made to him by tenants' organisations. If we are seriously to accept the statement of Deputy Gorey here, there is only the one tenants' organisation in the country.

Comment on this

I have not said anything of the sort.

Comment on this

You stated that you represented 70,000 of the unpurchased tenants of the country. I do not claim to represent the unpurchased tenants, but I take a generous view of my responsibilities in this matter. I should like to point out that it is not for electioneering purposes that I support the amendment. In that connection I am not as much concerned as some people, at any rate. The Minister made some reference to my views on the farmers' attitude. I could not exactly catch what he said.

Comment on this

I referred to the costs of production.

Comment on this

All I want to say on that is that I am a farmer's son, and that I worked on the land before I went to school in my bare feet as well as in my boots, and I know the situation exactly.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows very well that I am not referring to whether he worked on a farm or did not work on it. I stated that I was glad to see the Deputy give his allegiance to the costs of production principle as a principle which should guide us in arriving at various things—rent, wages, and things of that kind.

Comment on this

I mentioned that in order that the Minister should not be under any misapprehension as to my knowledge of the conditions of the people on whose behalf I speak. Whether it is a coincidence or not, anyone who knows the local circumstances knows that this particular clause would cater for the class of people who live in the area that I represent. Deputy Gorey knows that too, and, as far as I am concerned, I realise that I am discharging nothing beyond my responsibilities in supporting an amendment of this kind. The Minister also said it would be necessary, if this amendment were accepted, to examine every holding, which means, I presume, every unpurchased holding. I suggest that is not the case, and would not be the case if the Minister accepted an amendment of this kind. He also said that the Bill was drafted in such a way as to make provision for the barley producers. He states, and to a certain extent correctly, that the price of barley has gone down to the pre-war figure. But what is the price of the product of the barley? Has that gone back to pre-war price?

Comment on this

Do you mean pigs?

Comment on this

I am talking of the products produced from the barley.

Comment on this

You mean stout or beer!

Comment on this

I thought you understood what I meant. I meant the difference between the price of the article the barley produced last year and the price of the barley itself. If the price of the barley has gone back to pre-war, it is certain that the price of the product of the barley is not gone back to pre-war. The whole gist of the argument advanced by the Minister is in support of the claim of the pauperised landlords the people who live in Monte Carlo on the interest, not of rents, or of Guinness's shares, but, according to the Minister, on the interest of what they owe. There is no desire, so far as I am concerned, to get the thin end of the wedge in as to the amount of tillage in the future. It is only a question of giving a concession to certain people who, owing to extraordinary circumstances, have suffered, and to the knowledge of the Minister have suffered, and who shall get some consideration over and above the big rancher who is provided for under the terms of the Bill on the same lines as the small farmer.

Comment on this

The Minister has based his opposition to this amendment on the ground that everybody had asked him to deal with this question in averages. Well, I do not know what representations were made to the Minister, but I know that representations by the score had been made to Deputies here on these benches that a difference should be made between the treatment of the grazier and the treatment of the small farmer, who in the great majority of cases tills a fair proportion of his holding; so that the representations made to the Minister are different from the representations made to us, and just as he is claiming to act upon the representations made to him, we are acting upon the representations made to us. I would like to remind the Dáil that, notwithstanding what the Minister said about the effect of this amendment, notwithstanding the plea that he made for those who did not till last year because tillage did not pay, we are not asking that they should be in a worse position than the position which he himself proposes to put them in.

We are not asking that at all. We ask that those who did go to the expense of tilling, and the small holder who is presumed to have tilled, should be placed in a better position than those who did not, and whom the Minister considers are entitled to 25 per cent. reduction. What is the explanation? Deputy Gorey and others have explained that when you are trying to provide sustenance for three people on a certain holding you are at greater expense than if you are trying to provide sustenance only for one, and the cost in connection with operations of tillage are heavier than the cost in connection with the operations on a grazing holding and inasmuch as there are more people to live out of a grazing holding, there is more difficulty in saving money to pay off these arrears.

Now, the Minister thinks he has scored a point by quoting Deputy Davin's reference to the cost of production. But that is not discovery. We at least know, whether the Minister is aware of it or not, that when five men are employed upon a farm it is a cause for a greater output of cash than if only one man were employed upon the farm. That is no new discovery. For we are maintaining, and it is at the back of this amendment, as it is at the back of our attitude to this Bill, that the land is there for people to live upon, and that the more people you can provide sustenance for out of the land the better it is for the country, even if the profits are not so great to the individual holder and if the profits are not so great to the grazier. If the opportunities for saving money to pay off these arrears have been reduced by the fact that he tilled rather than grazed, that is a fair case for advantage to be given to that holder, because he is not in as good a position to pay. More people had to live out of the produce than in the case of the grazier. But the contention of Deputy Magennis that there was any attempt to make this amendment the touchstone of our attitude to the Bill, or the touchstone, rather, of our intention to the Bill was quite a misinterpretation of anything I said.

Quite frankly and clearly I said that we were dealing with the question of arrears and that we wished to make a difference in the treatment of the smallholder or the larger holder who tilled and employed labour on his holding, and the large holder who did not employ labour upon his holding, and that that was the touchstone of the attitude of the Deputies who were always insisting that there should be a distinction drawn between these two classes of land-holders. I admit and acknowledge with gratitude that there are portions of the Bill that quite fall in with that conception, but I want the whole Bill to fall in with that conception, and this amendment is designed to amend this Section dealing with arrears, in that direction.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 18
·
Níl 37
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I beg to move:—

In Sub-Section (2), line 22, to add after the word "made" the words:—

"No proof of the existence of the custom of a hanging gale shall be required other than receipts for any two years' rent prior to the year 1920, or the production of the books of the landlord or his agent in respect of the same period. Such books shall be produced on demand of the tenant."

This amendment at least should not give rise to much contention. The purpose is to deal with the hanging gale. In the case of a good many estates in the country a hanging gale has been customary. In some cases it is a half year, but there are cases where it is a year. That has always obtained on estates. We want to have no further proof necessary of a hanging gale than the producing of the rent receipts to show that the date is a half year or a year hence. I think the amendment is one that the Minister should accept.

Comment on this

Before the Minister agrees to the acceptance of the amendment I would like to draw his attention to the wording of it. The Section deals with estates on which a hanging gale is customary, and the amendment proposes that you should prove that custom by the receipts for any two years prior to the year 1920.

Comment on this

For two years.

Comment on this

Those two years might 1820 or 1821, or any other two years back to the Flood, as far as I can see from the amendment. Therefore, if the amendment, or anything on the principle of the amendment, is going to be accepted, some definiton ought to be given as to the particular two years that are going to be adduced as proof of custom.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, this amendment was sent up from Cork and Limerick at the last moment and I had only time to put it in. I believe it is the custom in these counties to have a hanging gale.

Comment on this

I am not denying that hanging gales are customary on many estates, but that you should prove that custom exists by producing rent receipts of a hundred years ago, which would be admissible under this amendment, does not seem to me to be right.

Comment on this

The word "any" may be left out on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

We are on the Committee Stage now and that is the Stage for getting amendments into proper order. It might become part of my duty in my ordinary professional capacity to argue some case upon this amendment, and it seems to me perfectly clear that if this amendment passes in this form you can prove that the hanging gale was customary on an estate to-day by producing the landlords' books of 100 years ago.

Comment on this

I take the view that the word "any" was not intended at all—I do not know.

Comment on this

I take it that what the Deputy wants to get at is to prove this is the most expeditious manner possible. That is the meaning of the amendment. There is no doubt that the amendment is open to the objection stated by Deputy FitzGibbon, and, I think, that the Bill as it stands is really more satisfactory because Section (19) says:—(1) It shall be the duty of every landlord and of every person receiving rents and profits on his behalf to furnish to the Land Commission within the prescribed time and in the prescribed form such particulars as they may require for the purpose of the collection of compounded arrears of rent and payment in lieu of rent, and the Land Commission shall have power to require any person paying rent to any other person in respect of a holding to give such particulars with respect to the holding as they may so require.

That is to say that the Land Commission have power to compel the landlord to produce his books but we could not agree to the books being produced for any two years.

Comment on this

I do not think the word "any" was meant there.

Comment on this

We could not bind the Land Commission by saying that they shall only look at books for two years and for a particular two years. We could not agree to that. There would be no reason for shutting out any evidence that the Land Commission might like to get. The books of the landlord will, in ninety-nine cases out of one hundred, prove the hanging gale, and in ninety-nine cases out of one hundred there will be absolutely no dispute. There may be one case out of one hundred where there will be a dispute and, in that event, the Land Commission will have to decide the custom. Hence, it is not right that any evidence should be ruled out, especially any evidence that might be as much in the interests of the tenant as that of the landlord. We are proving the custom. In the particular case where there would be a dispute it might be of importance to the tenant to produce other evidence besides the landlords' books. I have convinced myself that the Bill as it stands in Section 19 is better than the amendment. As the Bill stands the landlord must produce his books. Say that the Land Commission rule in 100 cases that there is a hanging gale. One case may be disputed. All the parties, and especially the tenant, should be in the position of bringing any evidence they like. I think the Bill covers the points better than the suggested alteration.

Comment on this

I know that there are specific cases covered by the amendment, but I am not able to give you the details as I am not aware of them. I do not know anything about the wording, as the amendment was drafted in Cork and sent up to me. I do not know the circumstances, but I know that they were sufficient to animate the men who sent up the amendment.

Comment on this

Section 19 gives complete power to the Land Commission to have the books produced. In fact the whole section gives the Land Commission complete power to make the landlords produce anything they wish, and the Deputy knows that the books and the receipts would show if there was a hanging gale. In any case, where there is a dispute why rule out evidence that might be in the interests of the tenant? "Any" two years would be completely out of the question.

Comment on this

I do not like the word "any" myself. I think it would be wrong.

Comment on this

I might say that the Minister's view is right, and I give one instance that has occurred to me at the moment. I rather think that in many cases where a hanging gale was the custom that during the fat years 1918 and 1919 tenants did in fact pay up these hanging gales as they were then able to afford to do so, and did not like to have it hanging over them. It would be rather unfair where there was a hanging gale to allow that to be wiped out by the production by the landlord of receipts for that year showing that a tenant had paid in full and therefore alleging that he was not entitled to the hanging gale. I did not make any comment at all from the point of view of attacking the tenants or protecting the landlords. I only made a comment on the wording of the amendment. The Minister's explanation, I think, gives the tenant all the protection he can possibly want.

Comment on this

If the Minister will not accept the amendment I suppose I had better withdraw it.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey should consider that. The point made by Deputy FitzGibbon did not occur to me. Consider the case where the tenant paid the hanging gale in 1918, the books might show that it was paid up while the custom might be there, and your amendment would rule the tenant out.

Comment on this

I am at a loss for an explanation as the amendment does not concern me personally, or any of my constituents, but some people down in Cork and Limerick.

Comment on this

The amendment might suit certain people, and might be a great injustice to tenants in other parts of the country. Section 19 makes sure that tenants will have the benefit of the books or any other evidence that they like to bring forward.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Amendment No. 23 depends on No. 21, and falls with it. Amendment No. 24 was dependent on Amendment 20 and falls with it.

Comment on this

I move: In Sub-section (4) to insert after the word "Income Tax," line 32, the words "less the usual deduction of one-eighth." I am afraid this amendment is open to criticism of very much the same kind that I ventured to make on the last amendment. I am afraid it does not fit in very well in the place I proposed, and I am not at all sure that it carries out the object I had when putting it down.

The deduction of one-eighth per cent. was allowed, or has hitherto been allowed, in certain cases, and it appears to me possible that it might be contended by the Inland Revenue that the compounded arrears of rent is not really rent at all but is some other form of income and that, therefore, the deduction of one-eighth per cent., which the receiver of that rent would have been allowed, would not be granted to him, because it was not really rent but was some compounded payment in lieu of rent. I put down this amendment rather for the purpose of directing attention to that point and for ascertaining from the Minister whether these compounded arrears were or were not to be treated as if they were the rent that they represent. I could not find any place in the Bill in which the provision for this deduction should be made except in Section 16 and again in Sub-section (4) of Section 17, and therefore I put down the amendment in these two places in order to ascertain from the Minister whether or not it was his intention that this deduction should be allowed in future in the case of compounded arrears of rent. I formally move the amendment in order to get that infortion from him.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

resumed the Chair at this stage.

Comment on this

I can give the Deputy an undertaking that the same deduction will be allowed in respect of compounded arrears of rent as would be allowed in regard to rent. I think also, that the compounded arrears of rent are the same thing, but in any case we will not refuse deductions which would be allowable in respect of the amounts of rents and which is considerably less than the rent.

Comment on this

That satisfies me, and I ask leave to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I formally move this amendment.

Comment on this

I cannot accept this amendment. I do not propose to go into the reasons, which I have stated already on the amendment to Section 16.

Comment on this

That amendment goes along with the other one, and I ask permission to withdraw it.

Comment on this

Since I put down this amendment I have received explanations which have satisfied me that it is unnecessary, and I beg leave to withdraw it also.

Comment on this

I move the amendment, which provides that where a tenant dies, leaving no legal personal representative, or even in the very unlikely event of the tenant disappearing, that the Land Commission may appoint a person to represent the tenant for the purpose of proceedings under the Act.

Comment on this

In the absence of Deputy Sears I beg to move this amendment, which is merely a drafting amendment.

Comment on this

I beg to move that Sub-Section (3) be deleted. Clause 20 allows the reduction which the tenant gets, in case this Bill applies to him, to be passed on to a sub-tenant of his, but it shuts out, in Sub-Section (3), a class of people who are, in my opinion, entitled to get this relief also. In some parts of the country small tenants, tenants of uneconomic holdings especially, take conacre on the farms of larger tenants to a very considerable extent, and these people would be benefitted if this Section were deleted. I think that as the tenant gets a relief himself he should pass on the relief to those who are paying him rent, even though it might be of a temporary nature. In some places, as a matter of fact, although conacre is of a temporary character legally or nominally, still there are cases where small tenants bordering on large farms have conacre year after year, and if the tenant of such a farm purchases his land and gets a reduction I think that benefit should be passed on to these as well as the regular sub-tenant provided for in Sub-Section (2).

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy is alive to the full implications of his amendment. You have a number of temporary lettings for several different reasons and if you pass on this reduction as a general rule, in perhaps the great majority of cases you would be doing a very big hardship to people who make temporary lettings for all sorts of reasons. Take the case of a man who dies and who leaves a wife and young family, none of them able to take up the land. It is a purely commercial transaction. They get the person who takes a temporary letting as a tenancy, a purely commercial transaction, making no claim whatever to the land, having no tenant right, not even a future tenancy, and having it simply because he thinks he can make a profit out of it at the rent. This Bill deals with all tenancies, even future tenancies, but it does not deal with the sort of people who take land in this fashion temporarily as a gamble, as they do in most cases—as a business transaction, in order to make a profit. They look into every aspect of it, and as business men they make their calculations, and make quite sure, as far as they can look forward, to making a reasonable profit out of it. The commonest case of all is the case I have just mentioned, because for one reason or another, perhaps owing to shortage of cash, perhaps the tenant is dead and his wife is unable to run the farm, she makes a temporary letting, and she is probably not able to make nearly as much money as if she were working the farm herself. She lets it to a man who has capital to spare, and who hopes and expects, and probably makes sure, that he takes it at a rent which will leave him a fair profit. It would not be right or fair to apply the provisions in regard to the reduction of rent to such cases. These provisions deal with cases of people who have a certain right to the land over and above the particular agreement which began the tenancy, and it would be most unfair in cases like these that are not being dealt with by the Bill at all to extend the same benefits to them. If the Deputy will think out the cases that are likely to come under that section, then, I think, he will agree that it would be unfair to reduce their rents. They are not tenants and they have no claim anyone can think of, morally or otherwise to the land. There may be a few cases of conacre tenants who have not enough land and who are forced to take land in this fashion. We are trying to deal with them otherwise than by the Bill. We are taking all the powers we can for the relief of congestion, and we hope that will not happen in future. By far the greater number of cases that come in under Sub-section 3 are the kind I mentioned, such as owing to the death of the tenant, his wife is unable to work the land and she lets it to a business man who takes it as business transaction, after going into all the facts and figures, and generally who is able to make a far bigger profit than the tenant who is not able to make anything like as much as she or he would make if in a position to work the land.

Comment on this

I move: "To add after the word ‘land,' Sub-section (1), the words ‘or such land, however owned or held, as may be required for the reinstatement of a former tenant thereof, or his representative, under Section 28."' I desire to be brief in proposing this amendment, and I do not desire to dilate on the hardships suffered by evicted tenants, or to make any appeal to sentiment in this matter. The purpose of the Bill, as I take it, is declared in Section 21, that the land be vested in the Land Commission for the purpose of relieving congestion, and facilitating the purchase of untenanted land. The purpose of my amendment is that power be also given to the Land Commission to deal with cases of evicted tenants. It is the first of a series of amendments. The others follow from this one if it is accepted. The amendment I propose does not mean that automatically the question of the evicted tenants is raised. It means that the power is given to the Land Commission, and the officials connected with the Land Commission, to investigate the cases. If they are fraudulent cases naturally they will be thrown out. If they are genuine cases it is only justice to those who fought the land war in the past that their cases should be considered. That is the purpose of the amendment.

Comment on this

I was wondering whether, on a point of order, it would facilitate matters if my amendment were taken first? It includes the matter in which Deputy de Roiste moves, but mine is of a rather wider nature, and it is certainly intended to include what is covered in Deputy de Roiste's amendment.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

"Or for the development of agriculture or otherwise in the public interest." Deputy O'Connell is going on the assumption that it would be to the public interest to reinstate the former tenant or his representative.

Comment on this

Yes. Provision is made that that may be done under Section 28.

Comment on this

As a matter of order, I think, Deputy O'Connell's amendment should have come first, as his is the wider one. If the wider one is not carried then the narrower one could not be proposed.

Comment on this

I think Deputy de Roiste's is a reasonable amendment.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Wait till we decide the question of which amendment comes first. Will Deputy de Roiste allow his amendment to stand or fall by Deputy O'Connell's?

Comment on this

After his, I am quite satisfied.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

If Deputy O'Connell's amendment is carried Deputy de Roiste's will not be moved?

Comment on this

Yes. If his is carried it covers my amendment. If his is defeated then I propose my amendment.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Then we will take Deputy O'Connell's amendment first.

Comment on this

I move: "In Sub-section (1), to insert after the word ‘land' the words ‘or for the development of agriculture or otherwise in the public interest.'" The Section provides that land may be automatically vested in the Land Commission, but only for the specific purpose of relieving congestion. Section 21 provides that all tenanted land shall be acquired, and it, of course, will be ordinarily sold to the tenant who occupies the land. It provides also that all untenanted land in the Congested Districts themselves will be used to enlarge congested holdings. It also provides that untenanted land in other districts may be acquired, but only, as I say, for the specific purpose of relieving congestion, or facilitating the sale of untenanted land. Land may be acquired for other purposes.

The purpose for which Deputy de Roiste raised amendments is intended for the sale to the evicted tenants or for the provision of holdings for evicted tenants. The provision is made in Section 28 by which advances may be made or provision may be made to provide land for the evicted tenants, and also under Sub-section (1) (d) of Section 28 for labourers. Under (E) any other person may get advances or holdings may be provided for them. There is no provision, however, whereby land could be got except in the rather slow and tedious process provided for under Section 32 I think. There is no provision by which land could be got for this specific purpose. We think that provision should be made under Section 21 by which land could be acquired by the Land Commission for such purposes as are mentioned in Section 28. The land could be automatically acquired under the provisions of this Section. There are other matters too for which it might be highly desirable to acquire land or small portions of land. But the Land Commission may find itself debarred by reason of limitations in this Section. During the Second Reading I mentioned that it would be possible to have in certain areas model farms or small plots which could be used for educational purposes in connection with a scheme that may be developed or introduced for agricultural education in connection with a county or district school or they may require small plots in connection with the National schools. That would be another purpose. That land must be provided for out of the tenanted land that is retained by the Land Commission. Naturally the tenants will object to that. Or that land might be provided for out of untenanted land that will be purchased, and this does not fix the terms of purchase and does not provide for arbitration as to the price and it may not operate compulsorily. The Land Commission may find themselves in this position that they would be able to acquire a large farm of one hundred and fifty to two hundred acres of untenanted land to relieve congestion. But if it wanted a quarter acre plot for experimental purposes or a few acres for a school farm it would have to go through a tedious process set out in Section 32. That is why I suggest that the words set out in the amendment should be inserted in this Section: That is that they have a right to acquire land for the development of agriculture or otherwise in the public interest. The matters which can be included in that would be at the discretion of the Land Commission and I think it would give them a bigger scope than what they have at present under this Section.

Comment on this

The Amendment reads "or for the development of agriculture or otherwise in the public interest" the Land Commission is to have compulsory powers to acquire land not only for the relief of congestion and for facilitating the resale of untenanted land but also for the development of agriculture and in the public interest. That is an extraordinarily wide clause. This is a Land Purchase Bill. It proposes to buy land from the owners and to resell it to tenants for agricultural purposes. Deputies should not endeavour to make this Bill a Bill for the Acquisition of Land for all purposes. That is unsound. When we legislate we should at least know what we intend to do. Apart from any other consideration there would be a great many objections to giving the Land Commission such wide powers. They can acquire land for a railway, and not only could they acquire land for a railway but they could acquire congest holdings and pay the owners in accordance with the terms set out in the Bill. Very probably there would not be the same unanimity about the price then. They can acquire land for any conceivable purposes, public buildings, railways, anything else you like to think of. There is nothing to stop them. All the terms of this Bill would apply to such land regardless of the purposes for which it was acquired; for something never intended in the Bill, and acquire it from people from whom it was never intended to take land. We should confine ourselves to Land Purchase. We should make sure that we have at least a fair general idea of the powers we are giving the Land Commission or any Government Department under them, though the development of agriculture might mean anything else. Remember you are giving these powers over all lands, over the lands of tenants, over lands of landlords and fee farms; all sorts and conditions of land for agricultural development at the discretion of a public department or otherwise in the public interest. Surely that would be giving almost arbitrary powers to the Land Commission and powers that may be capable of being abused. As a general principle it is unsound to legislate in such general terms. I want the Dáil to confine the Bill to Land Purchase, and if you want to take land for railways or any other purpose let us pass an Act. Let us go into the details of the case and know exactly what it is we want to do. Deputy de Roiste is anxious to see that there is sufficient land provided for the evicted tenants. That is strictly one of the purposes of this Bill. He is entitled to be assured that we have made provisions to acquire sufficient land to deal with all genuine cases of evicted tenants within the period which is prescribed in the Bill. I want to make one thing clear in the Bill and that is that it is primarily for the relief of congests. We have been talking all the afternoon and evening about the arrears and about the question of price, and on the question of price we spent a long time, but the real question, the real sore that is to be salved is this of the congests. This problem of the congests is the real question to be dealt with. I am hopeful, not so much that the tenants will find a big difference in their rents, but that they will find themselves in economic holdings as a result of this Bill. If that is done the real difficulty will be solved. It is quite easy to make the tenants the owners of their own holdings and to make advances to landless men, and put them on holdings which will give them a chance of succeeding. But the problem of the congests is one of immense difficulty, and I want to make it clear that it is the problem to which we gave the greatest care. I want to show that the congests have first claim. There are a great many difficulties. There is the difficulty, as I pointed out before, that if you even have the land, you may not have enough of land in the right place to meet that. We are taking the power to take land already purchased. I may say that only in extreme cases will we go to land already purchased, and only where we could get no other. But we are only taking these powers. Even with these powers we will not be able to deal with congestion in the West, or to deal with it in the neighbourhood of particular estates where congestion exists; there will have to be migration. You have the difficulty there that congests are not willing to leave and the second difficulty that you have the landless man and other possible aspirants to land in the neighbourhood to which they are going, hostile to them. We must do everything we can to remove these difficulties, if we are to solve this problem of congestion. I think that we have done a good lot to remove these difficulties, both from the point of view of the migrant difficulties that will be met by migrating the landless men and the tenant in the neighbourhood to which he has been migrated. We must make it perfectly clear in the Dáil that we are going to deal with congests first. Congests have a greater claim than evicted tenants. A large number of evicted tenants have already been dealt with. There are a large number still to be dealt with, but we cannot hope to go back and remedy all those wrongs which were done for the last 30 years. We are not in a position in the country to help every person. We are not in a position to pay consequential damages to people whose property has been destroyed within the last 3 years. We do not pretend that we can. We are not able to remedy all the grievances, even with regard to evicted tenants, that have accumulated for the last 40 years. Further, we have to take the country as we find it. We have to remember that a number of vested interests have grown up around certain holdings. There are cases where tenants were evicted long before '81, and I know that Deputy Liam de Roiste has tabled an amendment asking us to go back long before '81. There are cases where tenants were evicted from holdings at present in the possession of religious orders and public establishments of all kinds. But there were tenancies that changed hands five times between 1870 and 1881. There were people who came in 20 years ago and bought some tenancies for more than their full value, and with the consent of everyone. We could not take those tenancies away without paying compensation. Further, there are evicted tenants' holdings belonging to people who are living or whose representatives are alive, and we could not place those back, because if they were in occupation of those holdings possibly we would have taken them from them to relieve congestion. All sorts of vested interests have grown up within 30 years, and we cannot hope to wipe them out, and make things right as we could 40 or 50 years ago. If we face the country as it is at the moment with the big problem of congestion, with thousands of tenants huddled together on the West Coast of Connaught, and practically in all parts of the country, and if we deal effectively with that, and go on to deal with the resources at our disposal with the evicted man later, we will be taking the problem in its proper sequence. In Clause 21, to give you an idea of the problem, we are automatically taking up every perch of untenanted land in the province of Connaught, in Kerry, in Donegal, part of Cork and Clare, and yet that will not be sufficient to deal with the congestion in those particular areas. We go practically outside those counties because we can acquire the land compulsorily wherever we require it, and we can take up and acquire demesnes or even purchased holdings where we require them, and where we can get no other land. Although we have to take up automatically all the land in the Congested District counties I have named, yet the land will not be sufficient to deal with the congests within the Congested Districts. Nevertheless we will be able to reinstate a considerable number of evicted tenants in those districts on those lands, and we will be able to sell to landless men a considerable number of holdings for this reason. On one estate there will be very little congestion. You buy an estate, you deal with congestion, you may only have 4 or 5 holdings to deal with, and may have 30 parcels of untenanted land. You may bring in a congest there or put in landless men or representatives of the evicted tenants. Take the case of another estate. Here you may have far less land than would relieve congestion. The first case may be at one end of the county, the second at the other end. It may be more convenient to go outside Connaught and migrate the congests to where you find sufficient land in some other parts of the country. In any case congestion is so scattered and variable that you have to buy untenanted land practically everywhere for its relief. The largest percentage of the evicted tenants come from the province of Connaught. Can we do more in that than take up every perch of untenanted land? What else in an Act of Parliament would meet the situation in a better way or give the tenants better terms? Let the Deputies consider that. It is very nice to be putting in big words about the development of agriculture and evicted tenants and all the rest of it in Acts of Parliament. Nothing you could put into that Bill would do any more for the evicted tenants that were evicted from Connaught than we have done already, because we have arranged to take up every perch of untenanted land in Connaught. A somewhat similar process will operate outside if the Bill is taken into operation. Practically everywhere untenanted land will be taken up. We will deal with the congests first, the evicted tenant next, and the landless men after. We cannot take the risk of leaving the congested districts as they are, and we cannot deal with the problem in any other sequence than by dealing with the congests first, then with the evicted tenants, and then the landless men. If I am right practically all the untenanted land will be cleared for the purposes of the Bill. We can do no more. If you agree with me that the sequence is right—congests, evicted tenants, and then genuine landless men— and if you agree with me that we will be able to break up practically all the available land for the relief of congestion, even though when we take it up we will not be able to deal with all landless men, then I cannot see how you can improve the Bill by anything else.

You will merely raise false hopes; you will merely make the difficulties greater; you will make the difficulties of migrating congests greater.

Comment on this

I hope I have misunderstood the argument of the Minister because it seems to lead to this conclusion, that the problem of relieving congestion will eat up all the untenanted land that may be taken in any part of the country.

Comment on this

That is not exactly what I said.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that.

Comment on this

I tried to explain the point. If you take the province of Connaught, where we are taking up every perch of untenanted land first, what is going to happen there? You have an estate where there are three or four congests and you find you are able to deal with them and have hundreds of acres of land over. You must take up the whole estate. You have taken it up automatically and you find you are able to deal with three or four congests. Over and above that you have 7 or 8 parcels of land. It is open to you to bring into that land migrants from other estates. It is also open to the Land Commission to say: "well it would be more suitable to give this land to the landless men of the neighbourhood and to migrate the congests that exist elsewhere in the congested districts to some place outside the congested districts." They might be on the borders and they might go outside. The point I am making is you will have to take up all the land. Congestion is so variable and so widespread; it is more intense in one area, it is less intense in another area. So far as Connaught is concerned you will have to take up all the untenanted land in order to deal with the problem there. Even though you have taken up all the untenanted lands, you will not have sufficient land to deal with all the congests, and you will find it necessary to send some of them outside. You will also find in your rearrangements that it would suit better to give certain holdings to landless men on an estate rather than bring in congests to it, and as a compensation for that to take out congests and put them somewhere else. It is a matter of rearrangement. Outside the congested areas, let us take it that the Land Commission buy 1,000 acres of land and that acreage is held under the one title. They have to buy the whole of it; they are not going to buy 2 or 3 holdings out of it. They may require only 50 acres of that for congests. There may be one congest in the neighbourhood and when he is dealt with, the balance is all for landless men. Though they acquire the land compulsorily for the relief of congestion, they buy it because it is held under one title; it is just one estate, one farm, one parcel of untenanted land. They buy it for the relief of congestion. There may be 1,000 acres in it and they may require only 200 acres for the relief of congestion, but they must buy it all. They dispose of the 200 acres for the relief of congestion and they have the balance for landless men. They have acquired the whole parcel—that is the technical name—the whole estate if you like, for the relief of congestion; but they will find that they have large areas which they do not require for relieving congestion.

Comment on this

I see the point of the Minister more clearly. It seems to me that much of the argument would tend to support the object of the amendment —that there should be power given for such untenanted land to be acquired outside of these parcels on compulsory terms for such purposes as are admittedly in the public interest—if you like in the interests of agriculture, if one likes to confine it to agricultural purposes. That is the general idea underlying the amendment; but there may well be needs which would require the acquisition of land for this purpose even to fit in with the case the Minister has made. Take the sequence in Section 28. In paragraph (e) we find “any other person to whom, in the opinion of the Land Commission, an advance ought to be made.” If the opinion of the Land Commission were that an advance ought to be made to a certain person or persons, and that land could not be acquired under the terms of the Bill in the place where these persons would be convenienced or benefited, then there should be within the Bill provision for the acquisition. under the terms of the Bill, of such untenanted land as they may consider desirable. We have in mind purposes such as has been mentioned by Deputy O'Connell—the school farm, for instance, the case of landless men or labourers, who may well be in the opinion of the Land Commission, persons to whom advances ought to be made. But there may be no untenanted land, at least there may be no land acquired under the scheme for the relief of congestion which may be convenient for the occupancy of those people to whom the Land Commission think advances ought to be made. There is no intention in this amendment, I am sure, to defeat the intentions or desires of the Minister in the administration of the Bill. It is honestly intended as an improvement, and to meet what we conceive to be the intentions of the Minister; but the restriction he has spoken of would deprive the Land Commission of the power to acquire land except at prices which might well be exorbitant inasmuch as they have to be by agreement, and there is no appeal. The case that is made is that the ultimate object of the Bill is to secure land purchase for the development of agriculture. Surely, it is not a very great extension, or is not incompatible with the general intention, that the development of agriculture should be one of the purposes for which land might well be acquired under the Bill in addition to the relief of congestion. I think the amendment is distinctly in accord with the intentions of the Minister, as he has himself outlined, and I am rather astonished that he should resist it, though I think he resisted it because he imagines there is some ulterior purpose in it.

Comment on this

I do not see why this amendment should be passed. If I happened, instead of being what I am, to be a forty-acre freeholder—not a landlord at all, but a person who, by mere accident, happened to be in possession of 40 acres of freehold land, which I farmed and worked in the ordinary way—I see no reason why the Land Commission, at a price to be fixed by themselves, should take my 40 acre farm from me in order to give it to somebody else, or to set up an experimental farm, or to use it for what they themselves might consider to be a public purpose. This amendment would confer power on the Land Commission to take the farm from any man who owned it and farmed it, and whose forbears had owned it and farmed it from time immemorial, at their own price, in order to make it an experimental farm, or to give it to an evicted tenant who never was evicted from it at all, and who never owned it. If a public body are going to take land for public purposes in that way, they ought to take it at the price which the owner would get for it in the market. This amendment might apply to the owner of any plot of land, however small, in any part of the country. It does not seem to me to be the sort of amendment that should be put into a Bill to enable tenants to buy out their holdings, and to provide from persons who have too much land in Congested Districts economic farms for the congested.

Comment on this

In supporting this amendment I would like to ask the Minister if he takes into account the large farms that are outside the province of Connacht. I know a particular farm of 770 acres on which there is a landlord and tenant. The Minister may call that tenanted land, because there is one employé. The owner was prosecuted for the licence of the dog that the man takes with him around the land. Is it really democratic, in any shape or form, to allow a person like that to retain possession of 770 acres of land?

Comment on this

Read the Bill—Section 27.

Comment on this

I have read Section 27. There are many people living in the vicinity of that ranch, and it is but right that it should be divided. I would like to ask the Minister, now that he admits in this Bill that the evicted tenants should be reinstated, does he realise the necessity of giving these evicted tenants compensation for the time they were out of their farms, through being illegally evicted?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

That is another question altogether.

Comment on this

How much would the Deputy give them?

Comment on this

If he gave them as much as he gave the landlords, they would be highly compensated.

Comment on this

Under Section 28 provision is made for advances and holdings for several classes of people. That includes evicted tenants, labourers, landless men and, generally speaking, under 1(e) of that Section, “any other person to whom, in the opinion of the Land Commission, an advance ought to be made.” Power is given to the Land Commission to acquire compulsorily and automatically such land as may be required for the relief of congestion. I unhesitatingly agree with the Minister when he says that the relief of congestion is the most important thing to which this Bill refers, and the most important work it sets out to accomplish. There is no difference whatsoever about that. But suppose the Land Commission finds that it wants to give land to evicted tenants, how is it to proceed? The only way, if it has not enough land to relieve congestion and to give holdings to the evicted tenants, is to provide for the evicted tenants through the operation of Section 32. In that case, it can only acquire the land after agreement with the owner as to price. There is no appeal to arbitration, and if the owner is not agreeable to accept the price offered, or to accept the market price, as Deputy Fitzgibbon mentioned, they cannot compel the owner of this land under Section 32 to hand it over, even though they may want it for the evicted tenants. All that this amendment proposes is that, if such land is wanted for that purpose, or for the other purposes set out in the Bill, there should be power to acquire it.

As a matter of fact, I only suggested one additional use for which the land might be required—school plots or school farms. All the amendment seeks is that power should be taken under Section 21 to acquire land if required for any of these purposes. The Minister read into the amendment—rightly, perhaps—things that were never intended. It was not intended—though the wording might lend itself to that reading— to deal with any purposes outside agricultural purposes, pure and simple. I was not thinking of railways or houses. The only object I had in mind was that the Land Commission should have power to acquire land for the purposes which the Minister has set out in his own Bill.

Comment on this

There is one feature of this question in which I am particularly interested, and that has reference to the evicted tenants. I had intended raising this question under Section 28, but as it has been raised under Section 21, I would like to get an assurance from the Minister in respect of a certain body of evicted tenants in which I am specially interested. The Minister in his statement suggested that congests have a better claim than evicted tenants, that there would not be sufficient available land to deal with congests in the congested counties, and that they would have to go outside these counties to provide for the congested tenants. He quoted certain cases of tenancies which had changed hands five or six times since 1881.

I want to give a case of an estate from which the tenants had been evicted, but the estate is still in the hands of the landlord, and I should like to get an expression of opinion from the Minister for Agriculture as to what exactly is going to happen in the case. I am perfectly satisfied with the Bill as it stands, because the land on that estate will pass into the hands of the Government and the Land Commission, and then the question arises how it will be dealt with. The estate to which I desire particularly to call attention is known as the Adair Estate and from this estate fifty or sixty tenants with their families were evicted wholesale in the year 1860, and the estate was turned into a deer-park by the owner, John Adair. That land is still a deer-park, and the descendants of the tenants, and some of the actual tenants, are alive still and are living round the neighbourhood, others are scattered in foreign countries. Section 28 of this Bill deals with persons evicted 25 years before the passing of the Act of 1903. That does not carry us back to the year 1860. In addition it deals with tenants evicted on ejectment for non-payment of rent. I do not want to go into the history of this case, but anyone who knows anything of the history of the Land War in Ireland will find the record of this case of the Adair Estate. It was really a question of spite on the part of the landlord against the tenants; it attracted great attention at the time, and was well known through out Ireland. It was not a question of non-payment of rent, and, therefore, would not come within paragraph (c) of Section 28; it may come within paragraph (e), but by that time probably there would be no land left when you had dealt with the congests, landless persons, persons evicted from 1878, and labourers, all of whom come within paragraph (e). I do not think there can be any question in a case like that, that the people who have first claim on an estate like the Adair Estate, are those who were flung out on the roadside, and for whom subscriptions had to be raised to ship some of them to Australia to make their way the best they could in life. As I have stated some of these people are living still in the neighbourhood, but possess no land. I do not think you would find even the congests in Donegal would press their claim in a case like this before the claims of the representatives of the tenants who were evicted from this estate at the time of which I speak. This is a question that can be dealt with when the estate passes into the hands of the Land Commission, and I want an expression of opinion from the Minister that he will consider the necessity of bringing within the provisions of the Bill an estate like the Adair Estate, and that he will remember that the descendants of those tenants still claim that that land is theirs.

Comment on this

I am in a position to reassure Deputy Ward that Donegal is one of the counties in which we will take up every perch of untenanted land we can get. We can do no more; and when we take up that land automatically it will be a question for the State Department to divide large farms as between the congests and the evicted tenants. The Deputy will agree we can do no more than take over all the available land, and I hope I will be able to reassure him on the other points when we come to Section 28. Of course, I would have to hear his proposition, and when I hear it I will consider sympathetically any proposition he is prepared to make in regard to any particular case he knows of.

I do not suspect any arriere pensée in regard to Deputy O'Connell's amendment. I am satisfied that the Bill as it stands meets the intention which the Deputy has in mind much more fairly than if the amendment were inserted and if every interest were invited to stake its claim.

Comment on this

I beg to move the following amendment:—To add after the word ‘land' in Sub-section (1), line 60, the words ‘or such land, however owned or held, as may be required for the reinstatement of a former tenant thereof or his representative under section 28.'"

The last case, as I take it, was made for general purposes. The arguments against it were that it was too general. May I now state the particular case of the evicted tenants, and to my mind Deputy Ward has practically made that case. This amendment is directed to give to the Land Commission power to deal with the evicted tenants question. The purpose, as section 21 declares, is for the relief of congestion and to facilitate the re-sale of tenanted land. My amendment is directed so that the Land Commission would have power to take land for the reinstatement of evicted tenants. I must say that I, in common with many persons here and probably throughout the country, was under the impression that this Bill was intended to deal, as far as possible, with every land problem. I infer from the statement of the Minister for Agriculture that it is principally to deal with congestion and to facilitate land purchase and for other particular purposes that he has in mind, but that it was not intended primarily for dealing with other things connected with the land problem. Still, even though we were labouring under a misapprehension in that respect, it surely must be admitted by the Minister for Agriculture that it is the interest of every person to try and make this Bill applicable to every case, so that some of the problems that have been agitating farmers and owners of land in this country for some time past, should come under this Bill and should be met, and that as far as humanly possible, when this matter is first dealt with in an Irish Parliament we should get a settlement of these problems now so that they may not come forward again. I infer from what the Minister said that it may be necessary later on when congestion is relieved and land purchase facilitated to bring in an Evicted Tenants Bill, but as we are dealing with the question now it surely is, as I say, the right of everybody who has an interest in the land question to try and make this Bill applicable to all the other problems. The purpose of the amendment I have already stated.

Comment on this

As the Deputy does not seem to know it already, this Bill deals with other problems besides congestion. It deals with evicted tenants and landless men. It is not a Bill to give everything to everybody, and does not profess to be.

Comment on this

I know myself there are numerous claims by evicted tenants. Some of these claims may be perfectly sound and many of them are, perhaps, unsound. I quite see that the Minister for Agriculture has just as much sympathy for the evicted tenants as any of us, and I know thoroughly well that he will deal with them sympathetically. At all events, there are many cases which the Bill does not provide for, and to my mind these require investigation. As Deputy de Roiste points out, this amendment purports to give certain powers to the Land Commission to investigate all these claims, and I think that, to consider the large number of claims that are in course of preparation it will be essential the moment this Bill becomes law to provide the Land Commission with some such machinery to examine the sound and the unsound claims.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put

Tá 16
·
Níl 35
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I move to report progress until to-morrow.

Agreed.

Comment on this