THE DAIL IN COMMITTEE. - LAND BILL, 1923—THIRD STAGE RESUMED.
Contributions 1–133 of 267. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 31 of 1923 ›
I beg to move: "In Section 21, in Sub-section (2), to delete paragraph (b)”. The paragraph reads:—
"Any land which is not substantially agricultural or pastoral or partly agricultural and partly pastoral in character, or any land comprised in a holding the main object of the letting of which was for a residence."
The object of the amendment is to find out from the Minister what his intention is with regard to land which may be within the region of a town, for instance, which may be held to be building land, but which as a matter of fact is agricultural land. If such lands were acquired under the Bill, the Land Commission would be in a position either to re-sell it to the tenants—and this quite conceivably should be brought in under a special Bill—or they might retain it, and so secure for the State the unearned increment which otherwise might be appropriated by the owner. That is the good reason, I think, for urging that lands which may be said to be not strictly agricultural in the sense that is defined, but which, being held out of use, should be taken with a view, if it is brought into building purposes, that such increased value as the development of the town would give to that land should accrue rather to the Land Commission, that is the State, than to the present owner. The amendment is moved with a view to finding from the Minister whether such an amendment to the Bill is not within the plan that he has set out.
Comment on this
I think I can reassure Deputy Johnson on probably most matters which he has in mind in connection with this amendment. The fact that land is near a town or adjoins a town does not necessarily make it non-agricultural. Any tenancy, no matter how near a town, vests. It vests in the Land Commission, and afterwards in the tenant. The fact that a tenant is living in the town and is a trader or tradesman of any kind, or any man who has land on a future tenancy outside a town, does not make a difference. A future tenancy vests. That covers all the cases that the Deputy might be interested in, where people living in towns have agricultural lands outside the town they vest in the Land Commission and afterwards in the tenants. These are probably the bulk of the cases the Deputy has in mind. Of course, it is quite clear we should not buy non-agricultural land. That expression covers the town itself. We could not, for example, buy the market square or any sort of non-agricultural or non-pastural land. He raises another question of land which perhaps has potential value as building land, and he suggests that land should be acquired by the Land Commission because it has such a value. We need not agree to that for the moment. Anybody might hold 50 acres of land which he is farming as an ordinary farmer near the town. He is farming that as a good farmer should, but part of it may be valuable by reason of the fact that the town is extending in that direction. He owns the land. He paid for it the full price. He may have bought it as a fee simple, but the mere fact that the town or city is extending should not give the Land Commission the right to buy it out and take all the profits he might have gained by his good luck in having land there. Such an amendment as that would be injuring not only the large landowners, but the small landowners, both tenants and proprietors living near the town. There may be conceptions of the ownership of land which would contemplate that, no matter how a man owns land or no matter how he farms it, that he should not get any benefit that would accrue by reason of the fact that it happens to be in a position where a certain potential and additional value accrues to it by reason of the fact that the town is extending in that direction. We can argue that question for a long time, but we would never agree on it. This is hardly the time to argue such a question on a Bill like this, but in any case the possible effect is that you will have a small farmer having 50 acres or a landowner living near the town farming his land properly, and if it is his good luck that the land should become valuable by reason of the fact that the town is extending I do not see why the State should step in and take that land, no more than why the State should step in and take a house built in a particular part of the city towards which business is spreading and which is becoming more valuable.
Comment on this
The Minister has made it clear that he does not support the view that the additional values of land created by the work of the community should become the property of that community. He throws over all the views of the older generation of land reformers, and says that the chance ownership of a piece of land near a town gives the owner all the advantages, no matter who may create the new values. Values that are to be created may be created through circumstances over which the holder has no control, but all that increased value is accruing to the agricultural holder. The position of land which is agricultural in practice, and perhaps might have been agricultural for a generation or two, near a small town or a large town would be affected by this amendment. If the Agricultural Commission thought that such land might some day possess a value as a building site, then it could not be brought in. I think that is the defect. I think the opportunity should be availed of in this Bill for the Land Commission to acquire such agricultural land, such land as is at present agricultural but may not be wholly agricultural. I would like to know whether grazings outside Dublin City, for instance, are ruled out by the provisions of the Bill as it stands. Take accommodation land, as they call it. Where near the smaller towns there are patches let out in plots for townsmen who are what one might call only conveniently more or less temporarily permanent or permanently temporal agricultural. They are temporary holdings for tillage purposes, and are going on from year to year. Apparently these are to be ruled out, and I think that is the defect. I think lands of this kind which are being held by the owners as agricultural land—so far as the owner is concerned it is only agricultural land, and it is only by the action of other people that it may at some future time become building land—should be brought within the confines of the Bill. I am sorry the Minister is not able to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I venture to say the Deputy would be very much surprised if I agreed to it. He talks of chance owners. A man may have bought land and may have paid for it, and generally does, a very considerable sum by reason of the fact that it is near the town. He may have bought the chances, and bought them dear. We have got to take that into account. Further, if we do take up the land, what are we to do with it? If the land has a potential value as building ground, are we to take it up for building purposes? Surely it is not suggested that we ought to do that sort of thing under a Land Purchase Act. It is an interesting question as to whether the additional value of land by reason of circumstances over which the owner of the land has no control or responsibility should not be acquired for the State, and that question could be argued very nicely and properly on a Bill which provided for the taking up of land in the neighbourhood of towns for housing; but surely not under this Bill. If we took up such land we would have to build on it, and it could not be done. With regard to grazing outside towns, if there is a tenancy it vests in the tenant; if there is a subtenancy it vests in the sub-tenant.
We have ample power to make advances to trustees for the purpose of holding land near towns for forestry, tillage, plots, pasturage, and other purposes of that sort. We have ample powers under this Bill to do what the Deputy wants us to do, but we have not the power to take a letting for temporary convenience, and to make the man who would take that letting the tenant for the moment regardless of circumstances. We argued that question yesterday on another section. Deputy O'Connell wished to strike out Sub-section (3) of Section 20. I went into the reasons why we could not undertake anything in that respect. It would create far more hardship than do good.
Comment on this
If I understand correctly the effect of this amendment of Deputy Johnson's, he wishes to confiscate any property people may have convenient to towns and cities. I do not know if the Deputy understands what the amendment would mean in effect. I happen to know a little about the tenure of land around towns, and I do know that people who are, perhaps, unfortunate enough to hold land around towns have to pay very dearly for it. They have to pay an increased rent, and, if they were fortunate enough to get the Land Commission to fix a rent, there was always a proximity value which they had to pay, whether they liked it or not. If those people had the same facilities as people holding land 10 or 20 miles away from a town, there might be something in the Deputy's argument. As matters stand, it would be preposterous to have an amendment of that sort inserted in the Bill. I really think the Deputy has a misconception of what is meant by the amendment, and if he thinks it over properly he will not, I believe, insist on pressing it.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, I would like to ask the Minister if he would be prepared to take that part of the Curragh called the Little Curragh, situate north of the Great Southern and Western Railway line, and apportion it amongst the landless men in the towns of Newbridge and Kildare. There are about 200 or 300 acres there, and beyond serving as a gallop for racehorses and as a means of recreation for golfers, I do not see what use it is. It would meet a long-felt want if the land were divided amongst the landless men of Newbridge and Kildare.
Comment on this
The Deputy is really asking me what is the scope of the Bill. The answer is Sections 20 to 26, Sections 28, 29, and 32, all of which we have in front of us. If he refers to those sections his question is answered.
Amendment put and negatived.
Comment on this
I beg to move the following amendment standing in the name of Deputy FitzGibbon:—
In Sub-section (2) (b), line 12, to insert after the word “not” the words “at the date of the passing of this Act.”
I have not had an opportunity of speaking about this to the Deputy, but the amendment seems to me to be very reasonable, and one which just has the effect of making clear what is, I think, intended by the Bill. I am glad to say I am not a lawyer, but I think it might be contended that if some explanatory words were not added to the Bill, the term "is" would refer to the time when any particular case comes under discussion. What I think is meant is land at the time of the passing of the Act.
Comment on this
I desire to support the amendment. Notwithstanding the pharisaical declaration of my friend, Deputy Thrift, thanking his God he is not a lawyer, it would have been some advantage to him, I think, in the present instance. The purpose of this amendment is to do justice to a particular class of land occupier who has been particularly badly hit by previous Acts. Unless this stipulation is put in, it is possible that leaseholders, lessees, in whose instrument granting the lease there are words constituting them tenants of mills, for example, and of similar holdings, would be shut out as they have been since the Acts of 1881, and shut out especially from the benefit of land purchase. Many of these holdings have completely changed; they have undergone a transformation through the alteration in the economic life of the country. The possession of a mill, for instance, upon one's land in most places outside of the immediate proximity of a city, and sometimes not even then, is the possession of a white elephant, or worse. A great deal of land which is declared in the lease to be not of an agricultural character, so as to bring it under the application of the Land Acts, has in the interval of years become of that type. Now, unless this stipulation is included in Sub-section (b)—“any land which is not at the time of the passing of this Act”—the benefit of the present land purchase would not be secured for that type of holder, because this section is a section vesting land in the Land Commission on an appointed day. The sub-section excludes from the application of that, land of this particular type. Consequently, if there be lessees working the land irrespective of what may be in their original instrument as agricultural holdings, then these holdings vest in the Land Commission from the appointed day, and those people then receive the benefits of the Act. The ground which Deputy Fitzgibbon's amendment covers is to a large extent that covered by a subsequent amendment by Deputy Gorey—“Provided also that, notwithstanding the description contained in any lease or other document, lands which have been used in a manner substantially agricultural or pastoral during the six years preceding the passing of this Act shall be deemed agricultural or pastoral land.” By the introduction of Deputy FitzGibbon's amendment it is not a question of deeming them at all. They are, by virtue of being substantially used as agricultural or pastoral holdings, to come under the vesting power of the Land Commission under this section. That is the great benefit which is secured.
Comment on this
I am accepting the amendment. The words are absolutely necessary. It is necessary to show that whether the lands are agricultural or pastoral, or whether they are not, is to be decided by reference to the present condition of the land. That is absolutely essential.
Comment on this
I beg to move the following amendment:
In Sub-section (2) (b), line 15, to add after the word “residence” the words “provided, however, that where the Poor Law valuation of the land exceeds half the Poor Law valuation of the buildings, it shall be deemed that the main object of the letting was not for a residence: Provided also that notwithstanding the description contained in any lease or other document, lands which have been used in a manner substantially agricultural or pastoral during the six years preceding the passing of this Act shall be deemed agricultural or pastoral land.”
I do not know what the effect of the previous amendment will be on this, but this amendment was introduced to try and make more definite—to bring down to some definite level—what is meant by residential holding. This question of residential holdings will be a very contentious one-extremely contentious with regard to the working of this Act. Where there is a distinct understanding between the lessee and the lessor that the holding was a residential holding at the time of the letting, I and everybody else can understand that being distinctly a residential holding. Where there is no such understanding, that is where the object of the amendment comes in. I, and the people with me, think that where the Poor Law valuation of the land exceeds half the Poor Law valuation of the buildings and is farmed agriculturally, it ought to be considered an agricultural holding and should come under the terms of the Bill.
Comment on this
There are two parts to this amendment. The first tends to define the term "residential holding." Of course, I could not accept that definition.
Comment on this
Yes, the first definition. Whether a holding is residential or not is purely a matter of fact; the Judge must find on the facts and on the evidence, and it would be fatal to the Bill to lay down a rigid line like that. It would probably do a grievous injustice. It would mean probably that where people had built fairly substantial houses, and had spent £5,000 or £6,000 on the building, and had then let to a tenant pending the time the son or the daughter, if she got married, would go into it, the yearly tenant would come in now and purchase, possibly at a price under the Act which would be far less than what the house was built for. That is quite possible under this amendment. I put it no farther than that. You cannot define those things in an Act of Parliament. Whether a holding is residential or not, or is let for the purpose of a residence or not, is a question of fact. Quite a good many considerations are bearing on it, and leave it open to the Land Commission, with an appeal to the Judicial Commissioner, to try the case and to do justice. If you do injustice under this Clause you do grave injustice. You put a man to perhaps five, six or ten thousand pounds expense, and you cannot afford to do any averaging on questions like that. The issues are too important for the individual, and it must be left to the Land Commission, and the Land Commission must be free to take all the relevant circumstances into consideration. With regard to the second part, the amendment I have just accepted covers it. "Any land which is not, at the date of the passing of this Act, substantially agricultural or pastoral does not vest." That is to say any land which, at the date of the passing of the Act, is substantially pastoral or agricultural vests. It vests in the Land Commission, and it is for the Land Commission to say whether they are going to regard the particular lessee as a tenant or merely a temporary tenant, and hence not entitled to purchase, or whether, even though they regard him as a tenant, they are not going to take away his tenancy and use the land for the relief of congestion, or, finally, whether they are not going to sell it back to the owner as essentially a case where there should be a re-sale to the owner. You must leave all these things to the Land Commission. It does not matter what is in a lease. It does not matter how long the lease is, or how short the lease is. The land vests in the Land Commission in the first instance, and when it does vest in the Land Commission then the Land Commission are entitled to advert to the lease to see what they are going to do with the land. If the Deputy's purpose is to ensure that the land shall vest in the Land Commission, then Deputy FitzGibbon's amendment makes it unnecessary. I am perfectly sure that the Deputy does not wish to interfere with cases in which the land was let on behalf of minors. Take the old case, where a letting is made for five or six years during minority——
Comment on this
If the Deputy's amendment were accepted containing the words "provided also that notwithstanding the description contained in any lease or document," it would be at least doubtful if the Land Commission would not be coerced to ignore any circumstances set out in the lease, and to vest it in this temporary tenant. I think the Deputy will find that the words which have been added do all he wants.
Comment on this
Will the Minister give us an undertaking that the Land Commission, in deciding upon matters like this, will not be guided by the same conditions that guided them in these affairs in the past? We have had numerous instances of holdings which were ruled out as non-agricultural on account of the house being the principal part of the holding, and I do not know on what basis this was done. However, I know a great many cases of serious grievance where the holding was so ruled out. If, under the present Bill, the decision as to the nature of the land was to be arrived at in the same way serious injustice might be done. I hope that in whatever arrangement is made to decide these things the Land Commission will not be hampered by the conditions which prevented them doing justice in the past owing to some technical provisions contained in previous Land Acts.
Comment on this
I would like to ask the Minister for Agriculture if he has taken into consideration the question of a mill holding with reference to this sub-section?
Comment on this
Let us take a specific case—a house, large or small, and twenty or thirty acres of land around it. Deputy McGoldrick wants to know on what principles the Land Commission will decide the question whether this is an agricultural or pastoral holding. I think that is his point. What we do here is decide that they will have regard to the state of the holding at the date of the passing of the Act. That is the first decision. If a holding was used twenty or thirty years ago for a different purpose, and was gradually allowed to drift into becoming an agricultural or pastoral holding, the Land Commission would not take cognisance of what the holding was ten or fifteen years ago—they might have to take two or three years into consideration—but would consider what the holding is now. Take the case, then, of the holding used twenty or thirty or forty years ago in connection with the working of a mill. At that time a mill was a valuable asset. Probably 75 per cent. of the income of the farm was the result of the working of the mill, and for that reason it was not substantially an agricultural holding. Since then mills have fallen into disuse. Probably it was decided in most of those cases—perhaps when the tenant was going into Court, or perhaps in a dispute over a marriage settlement—that ten or twenty years ago this was not an agricultural holding, and under the previous Acts that decision ruled the case. The Land Commission could not go behind it, although at the moment the holding is purely agricultural, because all the profits are derived from agricultural operations and not from the mill. Nevertheless, if the case went into Court heretofore, and the Judge was called upon to decide whether it was an agricultural holding or not, someone would get up and quote a previous decision on a mill holding, and that ended it. We altered that. We say that it is the condition of the holding at the passing of the Act which will decide the question. That is made as plain as the English language can make it in the Bill.
Comment on this
The case I have in mind happens to be quite contrary to that which the Minister deals with. It is only a small parcel of land. Originally it was let as agricultural land, but the tenants of it used part of their residence as a mill and they developed a mill holding. I do not know how the Act will affect such a case. It is quite contrary to the case that the Minister has dealt with.
Comment on this
I wonder does the Dáil agree that, in deciding a case whether a holding is agricultural or pastoral, the decision should be taken with regard to the present condition of the holding?
Comment on this
That is agreed. I assure Deputies that I could not put myself into the position of a Judge, with a Bar before him stating the pros and cons. and all the circumstances of a particular case, and decide whether such a case comes within the definition. I am asked by the Deputy as to whether some particular case which he has in his own mind, and which I have not got all the facts of, comes within the definition which we are all agreed is the right definition. I cannot do that.
Comment on this
With regard to the first part of this amendment, I do agree that it might raise a barrier if accepted and passed in its present form. But with regard to the second part of the amendment dealing with documents, I have seen some of them, and they are very peculiar. Some of them have clauses excluding the holding from any benefit under any Act I have one of the documents here. This amendment was not meant to interfere with the rights of children or anything like that. I am satisfied that the previous amendment meets to a considerable extent the requirements of mine, and for that reason I beg leave to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I move Amendment 37:—
In Sub-section (2), paragraph (c), line 16, to insert after the word “is” the words “and has been for a period of not less than ten years before the passing of this Act.”
It has been the custom to exclude from the operations of the Land Acts in the past demesne lands and home farms, parks and gardens, and so forth. It is just possible—I believe there have been cases of it—that landlords with an intelligent anticipation of things to come will extend the area of their demesne or home farms in order to get the advantages of certain provisions in this Act. The object of the amendment is to provide that only demesne lands which have been so classified during the past ten years will come under the section.
Comment on this
It does not seem to me that this is a very reasonable amendment. It is rather against what we have already agreed to in connection with the previous sub-section. I would like to suggest to the Minister whether it really would not be necessary after the word "is" in this section to insert the words "at the date of the passing of this Act." That seems to be required in the same way that it was required in a previous sub-section. I do not think that Deputy O'Connell's amendment is reasonable. I not like to make legislation retrospective. The Minister has already, during the debate on this Bill, drawn attention to the fact that when a definite figure is suggested a definite reason should be adduced for the selection of that figure. Ten is the figure suggested here. Ten is an arbitrary figure. It might as well be eleven or eight or nine. I do not like arbitrary figures of that kind, and I do not think the Minister does either. I hope that, instead of accepting this amendment the Minister will consider the advisability of adding the words that we added to the previous sub-section.
Comment on this
The clause, if amended, would read: "Any parcel of untenanted land which is and has been for a period of not less than ten years before the passing of this Act a demesne, home farm, park, garden, or pleasure ground, or any holding usually occupied by a person regularly employed on such demesne, home farm, park, garden, or pleasure ground." Applying this term of ten years to all these classes of land would give rise to a tremendous amount of litigation. I do not believe myself that it would make the slightest difference in regard to demesne land. It would probably affect home farms, gardens, pleasure grounds, and holdings usually occupied by a person regularly employed on such lands. It would probably make sufficient difference in these cases to create a lot of litigation. The Court would have to decide whether in fact certain lands had been parks or gardens or pleasure grounds, or holdings usually occupied by a person regularly employed in connection with these places for the past ten years. While it would do a certain amount of justice in some cases, it would do grave injustice in others. A home farm is a farm used in connection with the owner's house. It is a sort of glorified kitchen garden. The definition of home farm fills about twenty pages of Cherry. I do not propose to read it out. There is hardly any other expression there has been so much litigation about. There are hundreds of cases on the question. I shudder to think what would happen if we complicated the issue, so that the Judges would have to decide, not what they have always found tremendous difficulty in deciding—whether such a farm is a home farm at the moment— but whether such a farm has been a home farm for the past ten years. As I have said, there are at least twenty pages of cases in Cherry on the specific question, "Is such a farm a home farm at the moment." If Judges had to decide not alone whether this is a home farm at present, but whether it had been a home farm for the last ten years, it would certainly be a good job for the lawyers, but I do not think it would be to the advantage of anybody else. The same applies, I should say, to pleasure ground, and probably to a lesser extent to other things. I do not think it would make the slightest difference in practice. In the case of the demesne particularly, it would help to do the right thing in certain cases; it would do grave injustice in others. I can conceive a case where, let us say, a business man or a shopkeeper in a local town buys a house outside the town with ten acres of land, probably a division of 150 acres that was tenanted land five years ago, and he works it now as a home farm. It is a farm appertaining to and worked for the convenience of his residence, and not purely for profit. There may be no doubt about that case; it may be quite certain that seven or eight years ago it was not a home farm; now it is. It would be to that class of case this expression "home farm" relates. The man with a big demesne generally has not a home farm. His demesne is big enough. The demesne can be used, and is generally used, for purposes connected with his residence. He has his tillage inside it, he has his cows, and so on. A man with anything like a substantial demesne generally has not a home farm within the definition of the expression. "Home farm" is strictly a legal term. "Home farm" is a farm used by the landlord for the convenience of his residence and not worked purely for profit As I pointed out, there has been a tremendous amount of litigation in connection with the question. As a rule, it is not the big landowner who has a home farm. He has untenanted land outside the demesne, but that is not a home farm. It is generally the case of a small shopkeeper or retired business man—a man who, say, retires after forty years, buys a farm, and is now an ordinary farmer. It is not right to take up his land compulsorily, because it may have been untenanted land five years ago. I think Deputies will agree that there would be a great many cases where hardship would be done by this ten years' clause You have the proviso whereby wrongs would be righted: "Notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing subsections, where the Land Commission before the appointed day declare in the prescribed manner that any land wherever situated, hereinbefore excluded from the operation of this section (other than land which comes within the description in Clause (e) of Sub-section (2) of this section), is required for the purpose of relieving congestion, then such land shall vest in the Land Commission pursuant to this section.”
Comment on this
The intention of this amendment is more particularly to apply to demesnes. I was hoping that when the Minister was giving us the benefit of his experience in this matter he would have defined demesne, because, as far as I have been able to enquire, I have not been able to find any definition of the name. I also had the hope that Deputy McBride would have been able to come to our assistance in this case, which has been put forward in view of special representations that were made, and which were thought might be typical of other cases where outside Westport the Marquis of Sligo is alleged to have retained within recent years thousands of acres which are included now in what is known as his demesne. That is the case which is put forward. It may be a single exception. It may be typical of many cases. If it is, then it surely is unfair. Surely it is time to avoid by anticipation the effects of the Act. I do not think that the proviso (paragraph 3) would meet the case, because that only provides for the exception where the land may be required for the purposes of relieving congestion. I do not know whether the grievances expressed by the people in Westport district would be met by this proviso clause. Probably the Minister is familiar with the complaints that have been made. He may be able to say it is the only case in the country, and that he can find a way of meeting the Westport example. Perhaps the Minister would help us.
Comment on this
I have no hesitation in stating that not only have the Land Commission power to take that part of that demesne, but I know that they will require it for the relief of congestion. The Congested Districts Board have been for decades looking for that particular land.
Comment on this
Perhaps Deputy O'Connell is remembering the "Deserted Village:
"... The man of wealth and pride,
Takes up a space that many poor supplied;
Space for his lake, his park's extended bounds,
Space for his horses, equipage and hounds."
If we could redress the wrongs of past centuries by any legislation effected to-day it would be highly desirable. On the other hand, we may ourselves, as the Minister pointed out, by our haste to do good, create new wrongs. Suppose a case of a man who has bought and paid for land the price which the vendor demanded, and has bought it to secure greater privacy for his own house, or for some other purpose of convenience, would it be fair now, merely because within the last ten years this transaction took place, and what is now a pleasure ground or something of that nature was before under tillage, that it should be wrested away again from the legitimate purchaser? It is quite easy to put in this spirit of reform and humanity clauses which are directed to secure the humanitarian result, but when these come into another atmosphere less permeated by sentiment and spirituality, the prosaic, dingy Law court, Judges and lawyers, unfortunately, refuse to consider what was the intention of the Legislature. They say, "What are the words of the Act?" and they interpret these with the utmost rigidity. So, while I am absolutely with Deputy O'Connell in this matter, with particular reference to demesnes and pleasure grounds, I realise that the words of limitation which he puts in would not meet the case, even if ten years were made fifty years or one hundred years. It would not have the all-impressing character which would be necessary to effect his purpose. So it seems to me, since we cannot do everything which is desirable, since the unfortunate logic of life presses upon us, the fact that not every reform that ought to be made is feasible or capable of being made, and certainly not every reform of past wrongs, can be effected merely through the operation of one sub-clause in a Land Purchase Act, we had better not run the risk of doing evil in the spirit of good.
Comment on this
This amendment was intended chiefly to deal with demesne lands, and possibly was coloured to a large extent by what took place in this particular instance referred to by Deputy Johnson, but, in view of the very satisfactory statement that has been made by the Minister with regard to that particular estate, I do not intend to press the amendment. I beg leave to withdraw it.
Comment on this
Would the Minister consider the desirability of inserting after the word "is" the words "at the date of the passing of this Act"?
Comment on this
I think the best thing we can do is just to leave it as it now stands. Let well enough alone.
Comment on this
The arguments that were adduced in favour of Amendment 34 need no be repeated, and I simply move Amendment 39: "To delete paragraph (d) in Sub-section (2).”
Comment on this
A Chinn Chomhairle, is maith liom an leas-rún so do chur os bhúr gcomhair agus is doigh liom go bhfuil sé an-tabhtach.
I wish to propose this amendment. I think it is a very necessary amendment, as far as many public authorities through the country are concerned. There are a large number of public bodies that hold plots or land around public buildings. If they do not hold those plots of land in fee-simple, if this amendment is not carried, they cannot purchase under the Act. I do not think there is any Deputy in the Dáil who would be opposed to this amendment. It would empower Boards of Guardians and hospitals to purchase under the Act. No further argument is necessary as to why this amendment should be adopted. I, therefore, ask the Dáil to pass it.
Comment on this
I move:—To add at the end of Sub-section (2) (e), line 30, page 8, the following:—“Provided that such exception shall not apply to land of which the former tenant or his representative applies for reinstatement, and such application is approved by the Land Commission after investigation in the prescribed manner.”
Comment on this
In this amendment does Deputy de Roiste include Sub-section (2), or merely Sub-section (2), paragraph (e)?
Comment on this
Yes. This is another effort to try to get the Land Commission Court to deal with the cases of evicted tenants generally. As far as I read, the general purpose of the Bill is that the Land Commission is given power to deal with land for the purpose of the relief of congestion, which everybody believes is a most desirable purpose within the congested districts to deal with the cases of evicted tenants. The purpose of this is to enable the Land Commission to deal with evicted tenants in other cases as well. As I said, I make no appeal whatever to sentiment, because it is a case of justice where there are good claims that persons be reinstated in their former holdings, and therefore it seems to me there is no reason why the Land Commission should not have powers to investigate such cases, and if the cases are just, reasonable and fair ones, the Land Commission should have power to reinstate the evicted persons upon their holdings. That is the purpose of this and of the amendment I previously proposed. There was an argument put forward that it was giving too much power to the Land Commission to investigate those cases or to disturb persons now on the land. But that argument would equally apply to the other purposes for which the Bill is intended— for the relief of congestion. We are giving power to the Land Commission to disturb people for certain purposes. I maintain there is no reason why we should not give power to them to give justice to people who made possible the previous Land Acts and made possible the placing on the soil within certain limits of congests and other classes, such as landless men.
Comment on this
The Deputy should not jump to the conclusion that evicted tenants are all to be reinstated. A great many of them—the greater percentage of them—have been reinstated, and there will be ample power within the four corners of this Bill to reinstate without taking over land which is not substantially agricultural. The amendment asks us to take up land which is not substantially agricultural or pastural land, such as land in the City of Dublin and land in the towns through the country. Paragraph (c) mentions any parcel of untenanted land which forms a demesne, home farm, park, garden, or pleasure ground. Since 1881 there has not been one holding cleared for the purpose of being made into a demesne, nor one present tenancy. We are to take up land for the relief of such evicted tenants to whom the Land Commission may advance money. But it is quite possible that if an evicted tenant was never evicted, and if he was using his holding at the present moment, that we would be taking that holding from him for the relief of congestion and migrating him elsewhere. Therefore we cannot admit the principle that because he is an evicted tenant we must put him back. That is common-sense.
Comment on this
The comment upon that is that it may be common-sense, but it means taking advantage of this Bill and displacing a man who is entitled to land in order to put somebody else in his place. With regard to the comment that the amendment deals with A, B, C, D, and so on, Sub-section 3 gives power to the Land Commission to deal with any land, notwithstanding anything done in the foregoing sub-sections. It does give potential power to the Land Commission to deal with any land for a purpose such as the relief of congestion. Therefore I maintain that the Land Commission should be given the same power for the reinstatement of the evicted tenants.
Comment on this
I did not hear that. We had this question arising before. If a Deputy cannot make himself sufficiently clear when calling for a division, and the motion is declared lost or carried, the matter cannot be reopened.
Comment on this
There is a method of remedying that, perhaps.
Amendment 42: In Sub-Section (3), line 37, to insert after the word "congestion" the words "or for the development of agriculture, or otherwise in the public interest."
Comment on this
Amendment 42 would have the same effect as Amendment 33, which has been negatived. It is not moved therefore.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
"To add after Sub-section (4) a new Sub-section as follows:—‘For the purposes of this Section, the County of Cavan shall be deemed to be a Congested Districts County.'"
I move this amendment on behalf of a county which has one of the smallest average tenancy valuations in any county in Ireland. I think the average valuation is about £8. There is a big agricultural population, and I do not see any reason why it should not be put on the same footing as Donegal, Galway, and the other counties. It has been sent down here to me from Cavan to propose it. I am sure Deputy Milroy. who is just rising, will support this amendment.
Comment on this
Deputy Gorey always reminds me of a blend of Ancient Pistol and Don Quixote. He makes a terrific noise which means nothing. He is tilting, like Don Quixote, at windmills. This is one of his windmills. It is quite clear that the Deputy knows very little about this matter. Otherwise we would have been treated to a much longer and much more frantic discourse. I want to know exactly what this means.
Comment on this
The Deputy in his amendment asks that Cavan should be scheduled as a Congested Districts County. I want to know for what purpose. Is it considered by him that this is a speedier way to relieve congestion in Cavan? There is no question whatever about the fact of the serious aspect which congestion presents in this agricultural problem, probably vital and more important than even the price or annuity. This amendment, if carried, would not add to the powers that you are to bring into being one scrap more power of relieving congestion than the Bill already gives.
Comment on this
Why object to it? The people of Cavan are very sensible people. They have shown that by electing me The people of Cavan know what they want, and know what they do not want. One of the things they do not want is to be made the raw material of one of Deputy Gorey's electioneering stunts. That is what is behind it. I happen to be one of the representatives of Cavan. I got a copy from the Secretary of the Farmers' Union to-day of this amendment, but not a single scrap of information as to the grounds on which it was passed. I got this amendment the day it was to be moved. What was the idea of that? If the people in Cavan wished that this matter should be brought before the Dáil, their representative was the proper person to do so. I was never consulted on the matter, and neither was I acquainted with it. Simply I was furnished with a bare amendment to-day and told to toe the line and follow Deputy Gorey. I am not going to follow Deputy Gorey, and I am not going to allow the County Cavan to be made an electioneering platform for Deputy Gorey in this Dáil. I have a few more pearls to throw before Deputy Gorey. The Bill gives every scrap of power necessary to deal with congestion in Cavan and elsewhere. As Deputy Gorey is so keen for the relief of congestion, would he be willing to part with a few of his own large acres to relieve this congestion?
Comment on this
I have based my reasons as to how to deal with congestion, and before I sit down I want to ask the Minister if my interpretation is a correct one, for, after all, he is the man responsible for the interpretation of this Bill, and I want to ask him to give me guarantees that what I have said is correct, that there is within this Bill, as already drafted, the power to deal fully and successfully with the congestion in Cavan. After all, the main thing is not the question of scheduling districts as congested areas, but rather the question of solving congestion. The problem of congestion, too, is not going to be affected by indulging in political stunts here or elsewhere.
Comment on this
I heard great applause with respect to the reference to political stunts. Coming from Deputy Milroy, that certainly is very refreshing. This amendment was sent down to me from Cavan, and has been put up by me, and to my great astonishment I heard to-day publicly, and yesterday privately, that this was an election stunt. If this amendment is wrong, it has not been pointed out what is wrong about it, and why it is a political stunt.
Comment on this
Because it is unnecessary it is a political stunt. I thought that the Deputy stood up here to give us some explanation of the amendment. He has not done that. He stood up to tell us what the amendment was, and sat down without doing so. The only thing he has made clear is that it is an electioneering stunt. I do not see what bearing it has on an election. I would be very happy to hear it, but so far I have not heard the explanation. Would the Deputy please tell us what it means?
Comment on this
I shall. This amendment was put forward in the expectation that I would vote against it, and therefore become unpopular with my constituents in Cavan. I am going to vote against it, and face that unpopularity.
Comment on this
The question really at issue is, does congestion exist in Cavan, and would the constituents of Deputy Milroy be benefitted by having Cavan scheduled as a congested area? It is not a question of whether it is an election stunt or not, or whether he is to represent Cavan. The real question at issue is whether the constituents of Deputy Milroy in Cavan would be benefitted by the amendment.
Comment on this
That is the real question, and the answer is they would not. As every Deputy in the Dáil knows, adding Cavan to the congested districts counties would not give us the smallest scrap of additional power for the relief of congestion which we have not got already. By the powers we have already we can take every perch of untenanted land in Cavan for the relief of congests, and we cannot do more. We have that power, even though it is not a congested county. If it were made a congested county it would not make the slightest difference.
Comment on this
Will it not give you quicker machinery and more expedition? Is not that a difference?
Comment on this
The objection is that the amendment is superfluous, and it is an extraordinary thing that we should reach Clause 21 without knowing the terms in it.
Comment on this
The question, then, may be asked: Why were there congested areas for any of the counties? Why is there a distinction in the Bill? Several counties in Ireland were scheduled as congested areas. The valuation is quoted. This county of Cavan comes down to the same rateable value as the other counties in the schedule. They come down to a smaller farming area. What, then, is the objection? One effect of being scheduled as a congested area is it will give you quicker machinery and more expedition. Will not that be in favour of getting the county schedules?
Comment on this
We have not been answered that, and the answer has been kept to the last. Will not the date be an earlier date, and will it not be definite? I cannot follow Deputy Milroy at all. The bald assertion that it is a political stunt is the only thing that is clear. Judging from the look of the Deputy, it certainly is the only thing that is clear.
Comment on this
It is not at all necessary or essential, or does not follow from the Bill, that the land in the congested county should be taken first. Whatever land is convenient will be taken first. We found the Congested Districts Board there and left it there. These districts were explored, and it has been found that all the land available in those districts will be necessary. Hence we acquired them as a matter of course. One should be clear on that point. We are yet to explore all the other counties, and we are taking full powers to take any land we require to take in County Cavan when we have our explorations completed.
Comment on this
The Bill provides that all untenanted land in the congested districts taken, and any other untenanted land which, in the opinion of the Land Commission, will be required before a certain date, has to be declared before an appointed date. Would it not be better if this particular congested area were scheduled? You would have all untenanted land in Cavan ready for parcelling out among the people who require it. Would not that be an advantage to the Bill, would it not help along this burning question of congestion, and would it not place the Minister for Agriculture, or the man in charge of the Land Commission, in a better position to have it decided then and there, that all the untenanted lands in Cavan were ready for parcelling?
Comment on this
It was intended to take up untenanted land in the County Cavan before any other untenanted land in Ireland, and that is the real reason why I am resisting this amendment.
Comment on this
I think that instead of adding additional congested counties, we should move to abolish congestion in all counties. I do not see the object of this amendment at all, because in the Bill, as the Minister for Agriculture has stated, all untenanted land can be taken up for distribution amongst the tenants, and I thoroughly agree with the attitude taken up by Deputy Milroy towards this question. It is not improving the position of the unpurchased tenants in Cavan a single bit. Their cases can be dealt with equally well under the provisions of the Bill as if this amendment were adopted. I think the amendment is altogether unnecessary, and that it should not be adopted.
Comment on this
The Dáil divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I move: In Sub-Section (1) to delete the words "together with a contribution by the State to the price, calculated at 10 per cent. on, and added to, the standard price." The matter dealt with in this amendment was discussed to some extent on the Resolution, and I suppose it will be considered waste of time to go very far into the discussion a second time. But I think it necessary to re-state shortly the objections to adding 10 per cent. for the benefit of the landlords. I think it was Deputy Magennis who tried to draw comparison between the bonus to the landlords and State contribution to the Unemployment Fund, and his friends of the Freeman's Journal took the cue and asked were we prepared to agree to the cancellation of the Unemployment Fund, as we demanded the cancellation of this bonus to the landlord. On the same terms we are. If the unemployment Fund, as we demanded the cancellation of this bonus to the landlord. On the same terms we are. If the unemployed workman, as I said, wishes to be put in as good a position as the unemployed landlord, then it would be a very fair exchange for the abolition of the Unemployment Insurance Fund. The proposal of this Bill is to relieve the present landlords of their responsibilities as administrators of their estates, and they are to be recompensed for that disemployment by a payment in perpetuity of 65 per cent. of their present income from the land. I think they are making a very good bargain, and that they are being treated very generously, and if it could be afforded to every other citizen who was compulsorily disemployed then I would have no objection to giving the same kind of treatment to landlords. Unless we are thinking of the landlord as doing something for the rent he is drawing we can only think of him as having had a privilege conferred by the law which allows him to draw from the producer of wealth from the soil the annual toll of privately-imposed taxes. If that is the position, if that is the privilege, and it is that privilege which is being purchased from him by the State, then I repeat, what I said the other day, that what is being considered by the promoters of the Bill to be a fair sum to be paid annually for a number of years by the occupier should be the sum which is to be paid over to the landlord, and no more.
If, on the other hand, we are to conceive of the landlord as having given something in exchange for his rental, if, in fact, he has been a useful citizen, and is fulfilling useful functions as a landlord, but that you no longer require his services, then he is in the position of an employed man who has lost his job, and it is not usual to pay to an employed man who has lost his job 65 per cent., plus something as compensation, in perpetuity. I do not know whether anyone will say in this Dáil I should the landlord has fulfilled a useful function and that his payment by way of rent is payment for services rendered. If there is such a one in the Dáil I should like to hear his defence of the landlord, and some explanation of what his service is. On the other hand, if he has not given any service, if this thing we are buying is merely the legal right to draw rent, then again I contend that the figure which has been deemed to be a fair charge upon the working occupier should not be exceeded in the payment to the landlord. The small sum, which was described as round about £40,000 or £50,000 a year, if that is an accurate estimate of the amount that will be called for, might do very much better service, and might be very much more usefully expended for the next generation or two than by paying it over to the landlords, even though those landlords may be people in America who invested money or may be charitable institutions or any public bodies. They took the risk with the purchase; they knew the position of Irish land; they knew the probabilities in regard to land purchase; they knew that there was a risk, and they had no right even to expect that the State would add to what the tenant might be deemed to be capable of paying. Notwithstanding all that was said upon the Resolution empowering this money to be paid, I still contend that there is no case, no satisfactory case, put forward to make a charge upon the State of this 10 per cent. to be added to the standard price, and I therefore move the deletion of these words: "together with the contribution by the State to the price, calculated at 10 per cent., to be added to the standard price."
Comment on this
It has been said several times during this debate that this Bill is in the nature of a bargain——
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture has been congratulated upon striking a happy medium between the terms asked for on the one side and the other. If I mistake not, Deputy Johnson, himself, on the last day admitted it was in the nature of a bargain and that being so, it is waste of time to trouble the Dáil with disquisitions on first principles. Now, anyone considering the completion of Land Purchase in Ireland would certainly have that consideration governed by what took place under the former Purchase Acts. Under the 1903 Act there was a bonus. There was a considerable amount of money sanctioned by the State and approved by the people generally and by all classes of taxpayers, as a useful and necessary gift, in the phrase used then "to bridge the gap." Now we have argued on the tenants' side that the policy of 1903 should be continued and should be carried out to completion, and if we argued that on the tenants' side, as it not fair that the policy pursued under the 1903 Act on the landlords' side should also be carried to completion? Is there no necessity for a bonus under this Act? Now, take £100 rental; under the 1903 Act the average price paid for that was £2,585. Under this Act the tenant is only giving the landlord for the purchase of £100 rental £1,360, and, with the addition of the bonus, that only comes to £1,580 or £1,570, I am not quite certain. Certainly if you compare the price £2,585 with the figure £1,580, you must admit there is a great disparity. If there was a bonus necessary in 1903 to make the 1903 Act function, then much more so is a bonus necessary under this Act, and if the principle was fair in 1903, and was sanctioned by the Nation, what reason is there now for objecting to it? I say there is no reason. We are in justice bound to it. There is a national consideration—to heal a great wound and to bring a long quarrel to an end. All classes are interested in bringing that quarrel to an end. Even the humblest worker in Ireland, whether a worker in the town or in the country, is vitally interested in this question, and he is vitally interested in seeing peace established. It means a better chance for the future for him to have this Act passed, and passed as satisfactorily as possible. I cannot imagine the humblest agricultural labourer in the country, seeing the landlords and tenants about to come to an arrangement, and, then, seeing Deputy Johnson coming on the scene striving to break up the bargain, to drive them asunder again, trying to delay the completion of this arrangement suggested by the Minister for Agriculture in this Bill. I cannot imagine him saying that Deputy Johnson was speaking for him.
I think we should take the Bill as a whole; it is a fair bargain. It follows on the lines of the Act of 1903, and it makes a very good attempt to do justice to both sides, as far as justice can be done. We would all agree with Deputy Johnson if we were dealing with virgin soil and could wipe away all the old claims, all those claims and all those precedents and rights which have accumulated, and which cannot be wiped out so easily. I think this Bill makes a fair attempt at justice and this amendment should not be accepted, as it would destroy the Bill and throw us back into the melting pot and defeat the intentions of all sides.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Sears will find that when the agricultural labourer makes himself vocal he will be found voting with Deputy Johnson, particularly as regards this amendment. The analogy between the 1903 Act and this Act does not stand at all. I am sure Deputy Sears knows perfectly well that there was not the unanimous sanction of the nation, or even of the taxpayers of Ireland, in 1903 to the bonus to the landlords. The conditions then were quite different to what they are now. In the first place, it was the British Parliament that brought in that voluntary purchase and sale Act. The credit behind it was not merely Irish, but British. That brings me to the question of the credit behind this particular Act, but I am not going to deal with that now. A good many people in Ireland were fooled into the belief that it was the British who in the long run were actually paying for the purchase of the Irish tenancies. That, of course, was not true. This, on the other hand is an Irish Parliament which is dealing with an Irish problem. The money involved is Irish money, and nobody, as Deputy Johnson says, in this Dáil, whatever about other places, will get up and say that the landlords, as a class, did real service to the nation in the past, or, as a matter of fact, fulfilled the duties that were fulfilled by landlords in other countries. They did not do that, and they have not done anything that makes them deserving of special treatment in this case, even in the small matter of improvements. It is notorious that, whereas English landlords looked after the improvements on the holdings of their tenants, and in many cases helped to capitalise their tenancies, there is not anything like that in the records of landlordism in Ireland. With the exception of a few who used to be called good and decent landlords, there is nothing creditable, decent, or serviceable in the whole record of landlordism in Ireland. If there was there might be something to be said for this bonus. Deputy Megennis and some others the other day advanced a rather ingenious theory that this 10 per cent. is really not in relief of the landlord at all, but in relief of the tenant; that the position of the tenants is so bad that they are not able to pay a fair price to the landlord, and because of that the community as a whole must make up what the tenants cannot pay. Apply that—and it is a logical thing for any man to do—apply the principle anyway generally and you will find that the Minister for Finance, at all events, will not be prepared to carry out that theory in other respects. You have certain disputes at the moment. There is one, for instance, in Waterford, where farmers say that they are not in a position to meet the demands that are made upon them by certain of their employees. If that is the case, why, then, should the Ministry of Finance not come along and put down what the farmers are not able to pay their employees. It will be said, I suppose, "Oh, in that case it is the labourers who are concerned, but in this case it is the landlords who are concerned, and that makes all the difference in the world." It is a surprising thing to me that Deputy Sears, above any man in the Dáil, should stand up in defence of the landlords. He knows better than I know, because he was in the movement at the time and I was not, that there was a good deal of dispute about the bonus under the 1903 Act, and he says this Act is merely to complete that. I do not think it is. It is an Act for the completion of land purchase, and in his really serious moments Deputy Sears would not, I think, agree that the 1903 Act was an Act such as an Irish Parliament, had there been an Irish Parliament at the time, would have passed. No, because there were other parties concerned; but now you have no parties concerned except three—the tenants, the landlords, and the Irish people. With Deputy Johnson, I object to pay the landlords out of the pockets of the Irish people.
Comment on this
I am afraid I must disclaim the credit for affording Deputy Johnson a text upon which to hang a disquisition on property, on rights, and on the relation of the State with regard to both of these. It was not I who suggested this false parallel, as he called it, between the labourers and the land question.
Comment on this
There is really nothing to regret on the part of Deputy Johnson, although there may be something on my part. Some people have very peculiar notions with regard to property. A man rang up a pawnbroker between the hours of 12 midnight and 1 a.m., and when the pawnbroker at last appeared at the window the disturber of his peace asked, "What o'clock is it?" The pawnbroker said, "Did you take me out of bed merely for that?" and the other replied as well as he could, "Well, you have got my watch." Evidently some extraordinarily fantastic doctrine of the rights of man, the rights of a State, or the rights of people has got possession of Deputy Johnson's mind. We have in his speech, and in the speech of Deputy O'Shannon, all sorts of misleading analogies. I remember on a previous occasion Deputy Wilson and I crossed swords with regard to the imaginative character of the people and as to the desirability of training and developing the imagination. Imagination to-day runs riot in analogies. The first and most misleading of them is that by which a landlord is made to appear an employee who is now to be discharged. That is a delightful example of begging the question. Deputy Johnson is, of course, covertly formulating a doctrine which is one of the very latest put forward by a Law Professor in France, the substitution of the idea that rights are the corelative of duties, that rights are the corelative of functions, and only in so far as a man does some work for the community, has he any rights against the community, and that the measure of his right is the measure of the value of the functions which he discharges. Now, that may be a perfectly sound doctrine but it is not the doctrine that the world at large has accepted.
Comment on this
Under cover of an amendment to the Land Purchase Act, to attempt the initiation of a new crusade is certainly not unambitious. There is such a thing as reasonable expectation. The doctrine of this has been already developed by Deputy Johnson himself. Therefore, I think I am right in regarding him as believing in it, for I am sure he would not teach any doctrine which he had not himself accepted. It is one of the foundations in all social intercourse in all steady institutions of society, that where a man is encouraged to entertain certain reasonable expectations in regard to life, it would be unjust, immoral, that is to say, to defeat these expectations. That no one knows better than Deputy Johnson, is the basis of a great many things that are the source of convenience in social life. For example, the whole law of estoppel is based upon it. If I permit a man to begin building a hotel on a piece of land, the title deeds of which are in my possession without his knowledge, and I look on and allow him to put up this huge fabric, I cannot then subsequently go into Court, having looked on and allowed him to do this thing; in technical jargon I am estopped. Suppose we were to take an analogy which has escaped the imagination of those Deputies, that landlordism was piracy——
Comment on this
I am delighted to know there is one member of the Labour Party who is not afraid to put it into explicit language. Suppose the pirate is retiring from business compulsorily——
Comment on this
Is society obliged to compensate him for the loss? Obviously not, because, in the opinion of all right-minded men, the trade in which he was engaged was anti-social and immoral. Now, it has not yet been accepted by any reasonable body of men that private property, more particularly private property in land, is immoral, and until the Irish people who, as Deputy O'Shannon rightly says, are those concerned in this transaction, and the only people concerned, have been convinced that property, which is a necessary appanage to the development of personality, is an immoral and unrighteous thing, a doctrinaire is not to come and make his peculiar doctrine an absolute bar to the solution of a great problem, which brings peace and security to the whole Nation. As Deputy O'Shannon is so keen about logic, let us have some logic; I mean let us have some of his peculiar brand of logic, namely, deduce conclusions that you have first of all made up your mind to draw, by arranging to have premises from which these conclusions can be drawn. That is the conception of logic to which I am referring. The nation owns the land——
Comment on this
When I quoted that a few days ago, Deputy Johnson said "hear, hear." Some of his henchmen say "hear, hear" again. Therefore, I am entitled to regard that as the accepted doctrine of the occupants of the benches on the left. Is there any meaning in ownership?
Comment on this
Control of the disposition and use; either ownership involves that; and if it does not involve that it is an idle word.
Comment on this
The owners of the land are the Irish Nation, and in this Parliament, representative of them, they decide, for peace and future expansion, to convey to the tenant-occupier such control as is conventionally called ownership for the most beneficial use of the land, and, according to these Deputies, that is not legitimate.
Comment on this
Pardon me. I allowed you to develop your argument. It has become a set practice amongst the occupants of the benches on the left, from the moment I begin to speak until I sit down, to attempt to cultivate dialogue.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, I do not desire to interrupt the Deputy, or to prevent him developing his argument, but he has made a statement interpreting things we said which is certainly not correct.
Comment on this
It must be an exceptionally serious misrepresentation when it escapes the memory of the offended Deputy within the thousandth part of a second.
Comment on this
Very good. I was speaking about this 10 per cent. bonus being contributed by the State, and I had got thus far in the argument, that according to Deputy O'Shannon and Deputy Johnson the Nation is the owner of the land. According to Deputy O'Shannon nobody but the Irish people is concerned in this matter, which is dealing with the land that is theirs. I argued if that were so, any real exercise of ownership on the part of the Nation involved so dealing with the land as to secure the utmost production from it by way of benefit.
Comment on this
That was accepted by Deputy Johnson. I was invited to preach that doctrine to the Farmers' Party behind me—preach to those who already hold that, and have held nothing else but that for generations. I argued that when it becomes a question of the machinery by which this transfer of the lands to such men as would make the most of it for the benefit of the Nation as a totality, that this Parliament was entitled, in the name of the Irish Nation, whose legislative agent it is, to make such terms or such arrangements as render that feasible. Now, that is the stage at which I have arrived.
One of the obstacles to the feasibility of that arrangement is that there are other citizens in the Free State who hold a different doctrine with regard to the ownership of the soil and its disposition from what is generally entertained by the Irish people, that, as Deputy Sears put it, we are not in fact dealing with virgin soil, we are not, as I put it the other day, legislating in a vacuum. We are not theorists. We are dealing with facts as we find them, and as we find them we have a class of men who for centuries have been regarded as the land owners. Nobody ever declared that immoral. Many people have thought it undesirable and the sentiment of the Irish people, traditional and otherwise, is against it. Most progressive communities are in favour of peasant proprietorship, but the fundamental fact that we have to reckon with is that this class is the recognised—conventionally recognised —owner of the land. Unless an arrangement can be come to with that class, this Purchase Act becomes impossible. That is the situation as I envisage it. We could have no Land Purchase Bill without the condition precedent of an agreement with the landowners. That agreement was come to. I allege that as a fact. If it is not a fact it can be controverted. If it is a fact that an agreement was come to, and that that agreement is the basis of this proposed legislation, then what is the defence for a proposition that we who are always vocal with regard to the Gaelic tradition, the revival of our Gaelic past, and all the rest of it, that we should proceed to break covenants, to turn our back upon arrangements entered into, and to say—"Now, we are going to deal with this just as we please. We have a different view of proprietary rights from what you entertained, and what you have been accustomed to accept." In other words, what we are doing here is what practical men do. A man comes along and creates a nuisance by playing a barrel organ in front of my house when I want quiet. It is easier to pay him something to go round the corner—much easier——
Comment on this
Bribery; that is the word. It is easier to do that than to expostulate with him about rights, and to enter into a long disquisition showing that his is an unnecessary function, that a right-ordered community has no room for an Italian barrel organ player there, and that if there was need for recreative music we should have a Gaelic piper instead of a barrel organ player. It is much easier to come to an arrangement with him than to do that. That is what practical people do. The arrangement that is come to here is an arrangement to pay a 10 per cent. bonus. Deputy O'Shannon, whose party is so sensitive about a quotation from them not being verbatim, and so sensitive about the drawing of obvious conclusions from their own statements, put into my mouth a statement which I did not use. If it had supported any argument of his I could have forgiven him, but he simply makes the gratuitous statement. I declared that the proper way to look at the payment of a 10 per cent. bonus was that that was done in relief of the farmer. That is not the same thing as saying it is paying money which the farmer cannot pay. It means that the State is paying money in order to bring about agreement between two clashing interests, between two antagonistic demands, and as our interests is in the farmer and in the setting up of peasant proprietorship, naturally I consider that the money I am paying as a taxpayer, in this regard, is money paid for the sake of a settlement. If somebody chooses to prejudice the situation by saying it is the landlord walks away with it in his pocket, he is welcome to do so. There is hardly a single transaction in life that could not be parodied by anybody who would give his ingenuity to the purpose. It is a complete parody of this transaction to say that 10 per cent. is being extracted from the pockets of the Irish people to fill the pockets of the landlords who have exacted so much from us already. I grant the exaction, I grant the iniquity of the past but I am not dealing with the affairs of the past. I am dealing with the present as it shapes the future. The money has to be paid by the State for the advantage which accrues to the State from the bargain thus secured. That is the common sense of the thing. That is the equity of the thing.
Comment on this
The statement of Deputy Magennis which I objected to—I was momentarily confused by his magnetic powers—was that we objected to the State transferring the land to such men as would make the best use of it. That I deny absolutely. We make no such objection in any shape or form. On the contrary, what we desire is to ensure that the State will transfer the land to those who will make the best use of it, and, if necessary, take it from those who refuse to make good use of it. So far as I am concerned, State ownership means the right and duty of the State to find the best means of making use of it, and I am prepared to admit even the claim that the best use that can be made of land in this period of history in Ireland is by peasant proprietorship. But there is not the slightest justification for the Deputy saying that we object to the State transferring the land to such men as would make the best use of it. The Deputy has said that this Land Purchase Bill would not have seen the light without an agreement with the landlords. Deputy Magennis may know more about these things than the Dáil. But the Dáil does not know that there has been any agreement with the landlords to pay 10 per cent. bonus over and above what the tenants can pay as annuity. No such agreement has seen the light and the Deputy is not justified in saying that this Land Bill would not have seen the light if there had not been previously an agreement with the landlords. So far as the public know, no such agreement was found possible.
Therefore the Bill was brought in in the way in which it has been brought in. So that there is no agreement with the landlords, and all the arguments of the Deputy regarding breach of covenants therefore fall to the ground. There has been no covenant. The Dáil, on behalf of the nation, has not yet made any covenant with the landlords to pay a ten per cent. bonus, or to add 10 per cent. to the price. Therefore, there is no breach of agreement or any throwing over of covenants by the acceptance of this amendment. So that part, too, of the Deputy's argument falls to the ground. The proposition is that the barrel organ player shall be removed. When the outraged resident with the musical ear, who is being disturbed, asks the barrel organ player to go away, and when the latter refuses calls a policeman, the policeman says "Please go away, here is 6d." The policeman has to pay the bonus to the barrel organ player. That is Professor Magennis's argument—that the disturbed resident who desires the barrel organ player to be sent to another neighbour shall be recompensed by the policeman. Deputy Magennis says there is such a thing as reasonable expectation, that because the landlords built upon a reasonable expectation it is not right of the Dáil to refuse to levy a tax of ten per cent. of the price upon the community. I want to know what grounds the landlords have for reasonably expecting that this 10 per cent. was to be put into this Bill? Not the slightest; not the semblance of a shadow of ground for reasonably expecting, or unreasonably expecting, or expecting in any degree, that this Section was to be put in the Bill.
Comment on this
The landlord contends that this is not a reasonable price that is being offered to him. Was the reasonable expectation something that the landlord says is reasonable? Is that the argument?
Comment on this
Then it is not what the landlord expected to be reasonable that is the expectation which is to be satisfied. The reasonable expectation was an expectation that the landlord had in his mind. If not that, who had this expectation? I assert that the expectation may well have been that such sum as a tenant might reasonably be expected to be able to pay in the next fifty years should be the sum which the landlord might reasonably be expected to draw, but nothing more. Deputy Magennis talked about dissertations on private property. Private property was not thought to be immoral in Ireland. He went on to say that it was a necessary appanage of personality. I accept that proposition, and, with that definition, I am prepared to uphold private property to the uttermost. But I deny that any of these landlords' rights spoken of were necessary appanages of personality. It is simply a legal right to draw rent, which legal right is being interfered with by this Bill. To what extent is it to be interfered with? That is the whole question. There is no question of rights, no question of morality, it is a question of degree of interference. Then we come down to a practical question. What is the degree of interference? The proposal is that there should be a certain income guaranteed. The Ministry think that that income can only be made up by an annuity paid by the occupier, with the addition of 10 per cent. I deny that there is any necessity for the 10 per cent. There is no question or morality, no question of private property. No question of landlordism, as a matter of fact, enters into it in this respect at any rate. It is a question as to whether the extent of the interference with these property rights, with these legal rights to draw rent, is of such a nature that it cannot be met by the payment over of the sum drawn in annuities from the tenant. I say that that should be quite enough, and I am prepared to accept the view of the Minister that the amount that the tenants are able to pay, or are likely to be able to pay, is the amount which is embodied in the Bill. Consequently I deny the equity of adding this sum of 10 per cent., and I ask the Dáil to vote against the proposal in the Bill, and to vote for the amendment.
Comment on this
Deputy Johnson is undoubtedly right in saying that if I attribute to him the declaration that he is opposed to peasant proprietary, then I am uttering what certainly is not true. But surely one so versed, so proficient in disputation as the Deputy, is aware that one may show the falsity of an adversary's position by drawing from the conclusions to which his argument commits him. The Deputy interrupted me, as I pointed out at the time, before I had developed my argument completely. I was engaged in showing that if he refused the 10 per cent. bonus then he put up a barrier to the settlement—in other words, he was opposing the transfer of the land to the tenant. I see no incompatability between these two things. All that I accuse Deputy Johnson of is inconsistency in argument. While he proclaims, and rightly so, that he is an advocate of such transfer of the land as secures the best usage of it, yet my contention is that if he were allowed his way, what he proposes to do would make it impossible to secure that best usage. As regards my argument about reasonable expectations, I thought it unnecessary to develop that in full and that the Deputy would see the application of it. But I have completely misled him. He thought that when I spoke of reasonable expectation it was a reasonable expectation on the part of the landlord of 10 per cent. That was not the application of it. I was arguing against the view—no matter how hostile one may be to landlordism as we knew it in Ireland—that landlordism and piracy were identifiable in any view of society. I pointed out that when men are allowed to engage, by the sense of the community, in an occupation generation after generation, that reasonable expectations are created. That is a wholly different thing. There are promises which a man may make and which are not enforcible in a court of law. There is no valuable consideration. Yet, in the law court of conscience they would be enforcible if there were any external sanction applicable. There is a reasonable expectation among men, in their intercourse from day to day with other men, that promises will be kept, although there is no legal sanction to enforce the keeping of the promises. I said that all our life, the life of intercourse, is based to a large extent upon the non-defeating of reasonable expectations which conduct and custom have created in a body of men. That is a different thing altogether from alleging that the landlords had a reasonable expectation created for them of receiving 10 per cent. I had no intention of suggesting any such thing. With regard to agreement, if I said anything that purported to declare that a specific agreement, a date and an hour for which could be given, was the basis of this Land Purchase Bill then I must withdraw it because it would be untrue. What I am referring to is the long line of negotiations of which we are all more or less cognisant—as regards myself, less cognisant—the long line of negotiations between landlord and tenant and various interveners between them. We know that before the Partition Act of 1920 there was an attempt at creating an understanding. We know—if we had no other authority we had the excellent authority of Deputy Gorey yesterday— that there were attempts at agreement, and we all know perfectly well that the attempt to reach something like perfect agreement antecedent to the introduction of this measure broke down. Deputy Gorey was one of the protagonists in the effort to reach agreement. I am not ignorant of all that. I am ignorant of a great many things, but I have a vague knowledge that that is the fact. Again let us not deal with things in a vacuum. It is enough for me that I deal with abstractions as a lecturer on metaphysics, but am I to be haunted with abstract discussions, spectres of the abstract, in every department of life? This position taken up by the landlord and that position taken up by the tenant, each of them has a history. All these have antecedents, and what they are can only be understood by considering them in relation to their antecedents. Take the whole concrete, complex as it is. Therefore I say, and I repeat it without fear of being contradicted, that no Land Purchase Bill capable of being put into intelligible words, and of being reasonably adopted by any reasonable body of men would be possible at all if it were not for these historical antecedents that have led up to and made the thing possible. That is a very different thing from alleging that there is something in the nature of a bargain—vague and indefinite, perhaps, but still something in the nature of a bargain. There is to great a tendency I say, with all respect to Deputy Johnson, to take the literal meaning of words without considering the context that gives them their colour and value. I am not going to repeat even by way of refutation of Deputy Johnson any doctrine about private property. The fact that we have to deal with is simpler than to come to a conclusion about private property. These landlords may be regarded as the enemy. Suppose we look upon them for convenience in that light. Although they are and will be I hope citizens of the Saorstát, let us call them the enemy. Now, in all disputes there are only three ways of reaching a conclusion. One is by war or by force, to use words that are not international in significance. Another is by law, the exercise of right reason, and the third is by one of the parties surrendering absolutely. That is to say, the dispute is settled by the dispute removing itself out of existence altogether. Neither of the disputants in the present case will resort to that easy solution, and consequently we have either to settle this dispute by force or by law. Force was tried from time to time. I am old enough to remember the moonlighters. I remember the land war. I also know that force was tried from the other side. I have read about the clearances of Westmeath, and I know what the plantings were in my own county. The time has arrived for compromise, for arrangement. "Compromise and barter," says Burke, "are the source of all the enjoyment in life.""We give and we take and we choose," he says, "rather to be happy citizens than to be subtle disputants." When that choice is forced upon me by my friends on my left, to be a happy citizen or the subtle disputant, I prefer to be the subtle disputant only in the lecture room.
Comment on this
I have nothing to add to what has been said. I want to point out, however, that we are not discussing price on this amendment. What we are discussing is whether a contribution should be paid or not. That has really got nothing to do with the question of price. Whether the price is big or small the same question arises. Deputy Johnson has altered his position from that which he took up on the discussion that took place on the Money Resolution. His position then was that if £1,500 was a fair price the tenant should pay the whole of it, and if £1,368 was a fair price then that is all that should be paid. I said that I accepted that position, and we need not, I repeat, now go into the question of price. It will come up later on the Schedule. What Deputy Johnson has forgotten is that we have got to borrow the money to pay the price. Assume, for the sake of argument, that £1,505 is a fair price. As I say we have to borrow the money at 4½ per cent. We could borrow it before at 2¾ or 3 per cent. We made up our minds that we would save the tenants from the consequences of dearer money, and that is why we pay this contribution. That is a very simple explanation, and it is the long and the short of it. The same argument would hold good whether the price were £1,368 or £1,500. We would be equally wrong and equally right in either case. What we did make up our minds to in any event, whatever the price was, we would save the tenant from the increase in the price of money that resulted from the European War.
There is not one single argument that existed in 1903 that could justify the bonus or what we call the bonus in 1903, and there is not one of these arguments now advanced. If the only arguments to justify the bonus were the arguments to justify it for 1903, then we would not have defended it. I am giving away on the point of bonuses. If the circumstances were the same, if the European War had never occurred, there would have been absolutely no reason whatever for the State paying a single penny, and Deputy Johnson's dilemma would have been unanswerable. There is only one argument in favour of this contribution which was not in existence in 1903, and which is in existence now notwithstanding all the arguments about 1903. That is that the European War has occurred and money has reached 4½ per cent., and having regard to the fact that the tenants were unlucky in not purchasing under the 1903 Act, and before the war broke out, we came to the conclusion that we would save them from the consequences of this dear money, and we paid them this bonus, and it is upon that basis that we are justifying it.
Comment on this
Before we pass away from Section 22 might I make a suggestion? It deals with price, and we have disposed of the only amendment on the paper to that particular Section. It refers, however, to the Schedule. There is an amendment 96 to the Schedule, and I would suggest for the consideration of the Dáil that the most suitable time to deal with that particular amendment would be now immediately following this discussion on the 10 per cent. so as to deal with the whole question of price together. I would suggest it would be the most convenient and suitable thing to dispose of this question of price and of all the amendments, and that all the amendments on price be taken at the same time. It would necessitate going on to the Schedule and dealing with Amendment 96. The Schedule, however, is referred to in the Section we are dealing with. Though it might be unusual it would be more convenient for the Deputies, and such a procedure would be more likely to get full consideration for the whole question of price than if we were to deal with one part of the question now and another later on. I suggest we should deal with the whole Section before we pass away from this.
Comment on this
That is a procedure which is unusual, and if we were to take it I think we would need unanimity.
Comment on this
I think that suggestion is a very sensible one and might be well made a regular practice where the Schedule is appertaining to a particular section only. The only doubt in my mind is whether there might possibly be further amendments allowable which have not yet been sent in and which might be considered desirable in the minds of the Deputies in the course of the discussion.