We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

THE DAIL IN COMMITTEE. - LAND BILL, 1923—THIRD STAGE RESUMED.

Contributions 134–267 of 267. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Civic Guard (Acquisitions of Premises) Bill, 1923
Enacted

No. 31 of 1923 ›

Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Well, I can explain that. The amendments which have been circulated are the only amendments which I have accepted so far, and I have refused to accept certain amendments, including amendments from the Minister for Agriculture himself, so that there will not be any more amendments for this Stage. On the other hand, amendments may be moved later which will necessitate a further Committee Stage, but as far as this particular Committee Stage is concerned the only amendments to be moved are on the paper which is in the hands of Deputies. The Bill may be re-committed, either in whole or in part, later on, but as far as this Committee is concerned I think that all the amendments are on the paper.

Comment on this

In point of fact, I think everything points to the necessity for recommitting the Bill for the purpose of some amendments later on.

Comment on this

I am not concerned so much with this Bill. I am rather concerned with the ruling, as to whether it ought to be taken as a precedent that when a Bill, which might be even longer than the Land Bill, is down for Committee Stage on a given date, all amendments should be in hand a certain number of days before the Committee Stage begins, where due notice, provided for in the Standing Orders, could be given, supposing there were a certain number of days before the actual section came under consideration. After all, the course of discussion in Committee might well suggest amendments to the later sections of the Bill, which amendments ought to be received while the Bill is in Committee.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

That is so. I think the strict interpretation of the Standing Order would be that amendments would be in time if they were received in time in relation to the day on which the particular section to which they referred would be before the Committee. But in this case the amendments were mostly to the first twenty sections, which were already down for a particular date. I did not like to confuse that matter by accepting amendments on the spot which were serious. There is actually provision in the Standing Orders for receiving amendments in Committee without notice and Deputies can, of course, avail of that, but with regard to this particular Bill there will be amendments which will necessitate its re-committal for their consideration. With regard to the precedent of considering the Schedule now, the matter that Deputy Johnson mentioned first, namely, whether it might not be a good thing always to take the Schedule immediately after the section in which reference is made to the Schedule, is one which I think should be considered by the Committee on Procedure with a view to making a recommendation if they thought fit. But with regard to the particular happening now on precedent is created beyond that by general consent we allow the Schedule to be taken after Section 22, in which it is mentioned.

Comment on this

Am I to understand that when this Bill is re-committed to Committee we will have power to put up amendments to the particular sections already disposed of?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

That would depend.

Comment on this

What is re-committal for, then?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

That would depend. The whole Bill might be re-committed, in which case we could go through the Bill again and amendments could be offered to every section, but the Bill might be re-committed with a view to considering certain sections which it is proposed to amend, and in that case only the sections which were re-committed could be reconsidered in Committee. If I understand Deputy Gorey's point aright I think this would suit his case. If, on Report, he tables amendments to certain sections, if, on Report, the Minister for Agriculture, or somebody for him, tables amendments to other sections, I think the Minister, while not being obliged, would actually in fact move that the Bill be re-committed to consider these amendments, and this would enable Deputy Gorey's amendments to be considered in Committee.

Comment on this

Yes. There are a few amendments which have been already considered—two of them—but I think on reconsideration some amendments might be suggested.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

An amendment defeated in Committee cannot again be considered.

Comment on this

But amendments to the same section can be?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Oh, yes.

Comment on this

Of course, taking this question of prices out of its order does not affect us very much. I do not want to stand in the way of facilitating business if it is considered that this ought to come on now. Of course it takes us a little bit by surprise, because we did not expect it to be taken this evening, but I do not want to obstruct the business.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

It is agreed then to take Schedule 1 now.

An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair at this stage.

FIRST SCHEDULE.

STANDARD PURCHASE ANNUITY.

Part I.

Holdings subject to Judicial Rents.

The standlard purchase annuity shall in the case of each holding be an annuity of an amount equivalent to a percentage of the judicial rent payable in respect of the holding namely—

(a) in the case of rents fixed before the 16th August, 1911, 65 per cent.

(b) in the case of rents fixed after the 15th August, 1911, 70 per cent.

Part II.

Holdings subject to rents other than Judicial Rents.

1.—The standard purchase annuity in the case of every holding to which this part of this Schedule applies—

(a) Where the landlord and tenant so agree in the prescribed manner and within the prescribed time shall be the amount so agreed upon, and

(b) Where the landlord and tenant do not agree shall be such amount as shall be fixed by the Land Commission (other than the Judicial Commissioner), subpect to an appeal to the Judicial Commissioner whose decision shall be final.

2.—The annuity shall be fixed by the Land Commission on the report of their Inspector and without hearing in Court, regard being had to the nature and situation of the holding, the date of the commencement of the tenancy, the rent payable thereunder, and all the circumstances of the case.

3.—This part of this Schedule applies to every holding which (a) at the date of the passing of this Act is subject to a rent other than a judicial rent, and (b) vests, or will vest, as tenanted land in the Land Commission under this Act.

Amendment by

Comment on this

"To delete Part I, and insert in lieu thereof the following:—

‘HOLDING SUBJECT TO JUDICIAL RENTS.'

The standard purchase annuity shall in the case of each holding be an annuity of an amount equivalent to 60 per cent. of the judicial rent payable in respect of the holding provided that:

(a) where the judicial rent payable in respect of the holding has been adjusted by agreement between the landlord and tenant, the average yearly rent actually paid by the tenant during the period of ten years, up to and including the gale day next preceding the passing of this Act, shall be deemed to be the judicial rent payable in respect of the holding, for the purpose of determining the standard purchase annuity as aforesaid, and

(b) where the judicial rent payable in respect of the holding has been fixed by agreement between the landlord and tenant on the reinstatement of the tenant in his holding after having been evicted, the Land Commission, on the application of the tenant, shall cause the holding to be inspected, and shall fix an annual sum upon the same principles as a judicial rent upon receiving the report of their Inspector and without hearing in Court, and such annual sum shall be deemed to be the judicial rent payable in respect of the holding for the purpose of determining the standard purchase annuity as aforesaid, and the decision of the Land Commission shall be subject to an appeal to the Judicial Commissioner, whose decision shall be final.

(c) where the tenant of any holding in respect of which judicial rent is payable shall apply to the Land Commission for an inspection of the holding, on the ground that the holding is inadequate security for the advance to be made in pursuance of the provisions of this Act. and the Land Commission are satisfied that reasonable ground exist for such application, the Land Commission shall cause such inspection to be made, and on the report of their Inspectors, and without a hearing in Court shall fix the standard purchase annuity in respect of such holding on the same basis and having regard to the circumstances specified in this Act as if the holding were subject to a rent other than a judicial rent, and the decisions of the Land Commission shall be subject to an appeal to the Judicial Commissioner, whose decision shall be final.”

Comment on this

The amendment is to increase the standard reduction from 35 per cent. to 40 per cent. I think the chief things you require are reasons to prove that our contention is right. The Minister asked for some figures yesterday. We intend to make some comparisons that, we hope, will convince him that the price ought to be less than in the Bill. The question is the sale of land, and the value of land. We ought, I think, to take a parallel from the values of land in years gone by, from 1903, 1909, 1918, or 1920, when this question of land was under consideration, and was more or less the subject of agreement with the landlords in legislation, and we must, if we want to ascertain the value of land now, take a present day comparison and deal with the value at the time we are dealing with the case. There are reasons why sentiment makes Irish land more valuable than land in any other country. It is the only means of existence for the agricultural population; they have no other outlet; they have either to settle on the land or go away and the race is to die out. Men want to marry; they want a home and they want to settle down. The natural law urges them to find a home, and you cannot get behind that. Therefore the price of land in this country, what is known as the tenant's interest, brings more than its real value, and the price is not in proportion at all to the actual commercial value of the land. Let us take the nearest country to ourselves for a comparison. Take the sale of English farms, and in doing so, remember that we are measuring things on a standard different altogether from that which can be applied to this country. There is such a thing here as tenant interest and landlord interest. In England you have only the landlord's interest, and when they sell land they sell it absolutely in fee simple. English land in the open market is bringing about eleven years' purchase of the present rental. The holdings are much larger than in this country. There is no comparison at all——

Comment on this

What about the rentals?

Comment on this

The rentals are larger in this country; slightly larger.

Comment on this

So I thought.

Comment on this

The land is fallow in England this year. It is without tenants. They are waiting for somebody to go on and they cannot get them. There is no use in sneering at things at all.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I am not sneering.

Comment on this

You know how sensitive I am.

Comment on this

I am quite happy at the prospect of large tracts of England waiting for landless men in Ireland to take them over for nothing.

Comment on this

The Minister ought not to knock me off my balance. He did not need to interrupt at all, really. If we look at this thing from a commercial and sensible point of view, we must take into account what is done by the English landlord for the land. The English landlord undoubtedly has done much. Deputy O'Shannon speaking here this evening asked what has the Irish landlord done for the land, and he was answered truthfully—"nothing." In England you see farms of three or four or five hundred acres with valuable steadings. What relation do these steadings put up by the landlord bear to the value of the land; what could they be erected for to-day, and how would the value of the average English farm of three or four or five hundred acres compare with the value of the steadings of the land? What would it cost to put up these steadings, what is the value of them to the man who wants them; what would the average English farm come to if it were in Ireland; what would the fencing of the English farm be put up for, and what would its drainage be completed for? These are all valuable commercial assets that have been created by the landlord, and he is selling them at about 11 years' purchase, and is glad to get it, and glad to be relieved of the land at any price. What are the conditions in Ireland? We have small farmers, men with a few acres, men with a small valuation trying to eke a living out of a small patch of land, and these are the men who made the land, the buildings, fences and everything except the space on which the holdings are situated. They created by their labour, or by the lack of the landlord's labour, a tenant's interest in Ireland that is worth something in the open market. Any improvements the landlord ever did in Ireland were valued by the Land Commission, and put on to the tenant who had to pay for them. They were valued as against him. Anything that was done by the landlord was claimed by him, and a price was put on the land equal to the value of these improvements, and they were very few and far between, with the result that the landlord who did improve is now on the same level as the one who did nothing, because his improvement was valued as against the tenant. We are not told the real reason, but we are just told that the reason why the price of land should be the price in the Bill is to give the landlord fair play and justice. Now, if it is justice in England to sell land, the same class of land, or land of better quality and in a higher state of cultivation at a smaller price, why is it equity and justice to demand from a man almost twice the price for the same class of land? I have heard arguments in the Dáil, and I am beginning to think they count for more than the question of justice between the landlord and tenant, and that is the vested interests that have grown up. I think I heard in the Dáil from a semi-official of the Government party some reference to banks, charitable institutions, and other vested interests. Perhaps, it is in order to secure the full 100 per cent. value for the charitable institutions, banks, and other vested interests that this Bill was brought in. I think, probably it would be more in relation to justice had these institutions been put into the Bill than the talk of justice to the landlord or the tenant. I do not think we are asking too much. As a matter of fact we are asking too little; we have come down to a smaller point than has been authorised by our people, in these amendments; they have demanded and believed they ought to get much more. It may be said what is 10s. or £1 per year to the small man. I do not think that is a statesmanlike argument, or that it has anything to recommend it. 10s. or £1 is as much to the small man as £10 or £20 is to the bigger man, and that is no reason why this 10s. or £1 is nothing to the small man, and that the landlord should get more than he is entitled to for the commercial value of his land. It ought to be based on what the land could produce, what could be sold out of it, and what profit could be made out of it, and not on any other question. If it is not based on the value of its produce or its revenue it is not based on justice, and justice cannot be done if it is not based on the commercial value.

Comment on this

The Minister is reserving all his artillery to the end. The case has been put up by Deputy Gorey that land in England situated in close proximity to the best markets in the world is fetching a comparatively cheaper price than the land in Ireland, based on its unimproved value. Land in England has a value produced by the landlord or landowner and the land in Ireland that we are buying is the land in a state of nature, and the improvements on the land in Ireland are improvements produced by the toil of the workers on the land. Leaving that aside I come to compare the terms of this particular Land Bill with the terms of the Land Bill of 1903. The Minister for Agriculture the other night asked us to get out our pencils quickly and calculate how much per cent. better this Bill was than the Bill of 1903. I intended to reply to him, but An Ceann Comhairle did not give me the opportunity, and I reserved my calculations until now. One of the contentions that the Minister set up was that you must take the average as half way between 1903 and 1923. These are the premises which the Minister has set up, and thus you take the average tenant who bought his land between 1903 and 1923, and you are to take the average reduction which that particular tenant got under the 1903 Act, and then on those premises he can prove that this particular Land Bill is ten per cent. better. Now, I want to see how this man will stand. Take a man who is on this side of the ditch paying £100 a year rental. Under the 1903 Act he would get 25 per cent. reduction, and he would pay off his annuities in 69½ years, so that the total sum he would pay at the end of that period would be £5,212 10s These were the premises which the Minister for Agriculture mentioned, and they were the terms mentioned by Lord Dunraven, that is, 25 per cent reduction, which would mean an annuity of £75, and that multiplied by 69½ years gives you the sum of £5,212 10s. Now, let us take the other man on the other side of the ditch waiting for this Bill to come along. He has paid a rental of £100 a year for 10 years past, which amounts to £1,000. Then he comes along to buy, and he pays £65 annuity for 68 years, which makes £4,420. He has already paid £1,000, so that his total is £5,420. Place that against the man who under the 1903 Act paid £5,212 and you will find that the man who buys under this Bill so far from being 10 percent. better than the 1903 Act man has actually paid £200 more remembering that he has paid £100 rental for 10 years past and that it takes £52 to redeem every £1 of rent. It takes £52 out of a man's sweat and toil to redeem £1 in this case, so you can see what a bargain it is that the tenant farmers of Ireland are getting. Now here is the reason why we ask for 40 per cent. If we get a reduction of 40 per cent. or 8s. in the £ under this Bill, then a man who did not buy under the 1903 Act, taking the figures I have previously given as a basis, would pay £132 less than the man who bought under the 1903 Act. If he only gets the reduction provided under the Bill he would pay £200 more than the 1903 man, but if he gets the 8/- he will pay £132 less. Is it too much to ask the Minister to make the price such, that we, who are here to-day legislating 68 years in advance, when we do not know what will happen, whether we shall have a Workers' Republic or not, should be put in a reasonable position by giving us the benefit of this reduction of 8/- in the £? You must remember that the times have changed. What was considered a fair standard of life, on a farm 20 years ago, will not be considered a fair standard to-day. We have got to look at the times in which our children are growing up, and we must remember that they require a better standard than was possible in the past. We must remember we live in a free country, and that we want to enjoy the benefits this Constitution brings. We will not live in poverty, and we do not think we are asking too much when we ask for £132 out of a purchase price of £5,212 by a reduction of 8/- in the £ now. I think that is a fair case. We all heard what was stated about the price of land in England. I had land myself in Africa and I sold it at 10/- an acre fee-simple, but here in Ireland we have to pay £52 to redeem £1 of rental, and not alone that but the State, has consented to spend £50,000 a year to do that. There fore if you think over what you are doing, and look at it from the point of view of giving justice to the citizens, I reckon you are overweighting justice on the side of a minority against justice that should be given to 350,000 people who will be affected under this Act.

Comment on this

I support the amendment on somewhat different grounds. I want to supplement the argument of the last Deputy by the suggestion that the farmers of the country as Deputy Gorey has shown, are justified in expecting that the standard of living for the next generation will be higher than the standard of living in the past generation; that the people living upon the produce of the soil, whether tenant proprietors or labourers employed by tenant proprietors will live at a higher level generally in the future than in the past. If that is not to be so then there is very little virtue in the change here in national status. But if that is so, if we have a fair right to expect that the farmers and their families will live on a higher standard than their fathers then there will be, in succeeding revisions of judicial rentals, or there would be, a considerable reduction because there would be so much less available for rental, and one would imagine that with the new conception of the social standards the Commissioners who would be deciding future rentals, if they were to be revised, as under the old system, would take into account, and must take into account, not merely the profits derivable from the soil and market prices, but also the standards of life which become current, and which were due to the tenant or his labourers who were living upon the produce of the land.

Consequently there would be inevitably a smaller sum available annually for payment for the landlord. That is a reasonable expectation supposing there was no compulsory Purchase Bill and that, I submit, is good ground for looking for a considerable reduction in the amount which is to be paid in annuities, because it will all have to come out of the produce of the soil whether annuities or rental, and it is the balance from it that should be the balance after having provided a reasonable standard of life for those who work the soil, and only that balance, which should be available either for annuity or rental. Then we have to take into consideration also the new situation created by the War. I will take a lesson from Deputy Magennis's lecture, and recognise the facts that are round about us. I will recognise that there has been a war, and I submit that the memory of that fact leads us to this conclusion, not only that the standards of living demanded by the people have been improved and have been raised, but that the expectation of high prices for agricultural produce are not likely to be realised, and that the margin payable to landlords as rental or to the bond holders as annuities will be smaller henceforward than in the past. It is a fair expectation, looking at the future, and taking that expectation into account, the case for a larger reduction than that mentioned in the Bill is a sound one. The Minister told us yesterday that it was quite an easy matter for irresponsible people to make a claim for something higher, no matter how much or how little, than he had found practicable, and because it was easy, there was no need to justify it. There was some force in that. No doubt it is much easier for those who are not responsible to put forward a case, but it is their duty to put forward a case even if it is easier. It is their duty to point out that this imposition upon that very considerable section of the community who are occupiers of the soil, and even that smaller section of the community that will be effected by this Bill are not going to be in as good a position unless at the expense of their comfort, and at the expense of a reasonable standard of living in the future, to pay this annual sum to those possessing these bonds.

There has been no bargain. The demand that has been made on the part of the tenants is for a greater reduction than that which is offered. The case that is made for a greater reduction is based on the price of land in England, according to the arguments that have been adduced by Deputies Gorey and Wilson. There is a further argument, of reasonable expectation, that the amount available for distribution in the form of interest to bond holders or rentals to landlords will be smaller in the future than in the past. Let us bear in mind that the proposition in this Bill is to secure, for all time for the landlords against almost any risk, a settled income in exchange for what may be a problematical income in the succeeding generation. They are making a good exchange if the Bill passes even with the amendment proposed by Deputy Gorey, a very good exchange for something certain: the backing of the State against something problematical which would depend entirely upon the seasons, upon currency variations and upon the standards of life demanded by workmen and farmers against the general standard of life that exists in the country at present. I maintain that, we have a right to hope and expect that henceforth in this country the margin for unearned income will be smaller in the future than in the past. The landlords, too, do expect that in the future the produce of the country will, in an increasing degree, be absorbed and used by the people who help to make the wealth of the country. They have the right to expect that, and they do expect it. They are not expecting that henceforth the landlord element in the country is going to have as easy a time, or would be likely to have as easy a time, in the future as in the past; they have the right to expect that under a National Government the people who do the work of the country will be the people who will get the benefit of the produce of the country, and with that reasonable expectation they are doing very well if they get 60 per cent of their net revenue. The amendment proposed by Deputy Gorey is, I think, easily sustainable in discussion, and would be before a tribunal which was not obsessed by the position that landlords have held in the past—by a tribunal that took into account all the facts of to-day and the prospects of the future; any tribunal that took full regard of these prospects and present facts would, I think, conclude that the suggestion embodied in Deputy Gorey's amendment would be very generous compensation, and is the fullest amount the tenant should be reasonably expected to pay. We want that 10 per cent. and 5 per cent. to be paid to the labourers, where there are any.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

We would like the whole 65 per cent. to be made available for improving the standard of life for the labourers, and we are at one with the farmers in this: an alliance between the farmer and the labourer.

Comment on this

An unholy alliance.

Comment on this

It is a holy alliance between those who work and are owners and those who work and are not owners, against those who do not work but draw rents or annuities. That is a holy alliance which, I hope, we shall see consummated and then have, what Deputy Wilson suggests, a real republic of workers.

Comment on this

I was glad to hear Deputy Gorey's speech, and I assume from it that he will now hand over the interest he draws from his Debenture holdings in railway stock.

Comment on this

I have not got any.

Comment on this

I shall not be surprised if I find members of the Farmers' Party coming along and making an offering to the State of the interest that I hope they draw from the various companies in which they have their money invested. I have stated my reasons so often for this figure of 65 per cent. that I propose to confine myself strictly to the arguments advanced. Deputy Gorey has saved me a lot of trouble, because he has not put forward one single argument against the figure in the Bill. He started with a great flourish with regard to his figure of 40 per cent. He gave a number of what, I suppose, he would call reasons for that figure, but I suggest that all these reasons would apply equally to reductions of 50. 60. 80 or 100 per cent., and his argument would also apply to confiscating the landlords' property. I do not know why he does not advocate that. But he gave no argument, nor did Deputy Johnson, for this 40 per cent. figure, and I am still waiting for their arguments on that. It is true that on the 40 per cent. figure Deputy Wilson came to the rescue, and I must say he was extremely flattering to myself. He pointed out that the effect of this Bill was to place a tenant, whose rent was £100, and whose Poor Law Valuation would be about £120, that is to say a man with about 200 acres of fairly good land, at an advantage. The tenant is in such a magnificent position that he only loses £200 as a result of not having purchased under the 1903 Act. Notwithstanding that he has been twenty years paying rent——

Comment on this

Not twenty years.

Comment on this

Make the time anything you like. But this farmer owning 200 acres of good land, rent £100, Poor Law Valuation £130 or £150, finds that the only disadvantage he is at, as a result of not having purchased for such a long period, is a loss of £200. I accept that position; if I have really succeeded in rescuing all the tenants of Ireland to such a large extent from the loss that they suffered by non-purchase, then I am on the point of making up my mind to go ahead. Having made such a magnificent success of this, certainly we ought now tackle the 400,000 tenants who did purchase under the 1903 Act and compensate them in the same way for not having purchased in 1885——

Comment on this

That proves nothing at all. That is not an argument.

Comment on this

The farmer who owns a holding of 150 valuation and who has 200 acres of good land——

Comment on this

With £100 rent.

Comment on this

I am quoting a member of your own Party. If I can put this farmer in the position that he has only lost £200, in spite of the fact that he has not purchased under the 1903 Act, and in spite of the fact that he is purchasing now when we cannot borrow money on anything like the same terms as a result of the war—having done that I am tempted to go ahead and tackle this problem of the 400,000 tenants who purchased under the 1903 Act and make up their losses because they did not purchase in 1885. In any event, I want to say that I am quite satisfied with Deputy Wilson's figures. If I have saved his particular friend all he has lost except £200 I am satisfied that I have done a very good day's work. That was really the only argument put forward in favour of the forty per cent. All the other arguments would apply equally to fifty, sixty, eighty or one hundred per cent.

We are acquiring property compulsorily. Does Deputy Gorey suggest that we ought to give a price for it which is less than two-thirds of its current value? Deputy Gorey does not hold the same views about property as Deputy Johnson, and I want to try and split this alliance. We are acquiring property compulsorily, and I would like to hear from Deputy Gorey whether he is prepared to subscribe to the principle that we should so acquire it at less than two-thirds of its current value.

Comment on this

Who had the fixing of the current value?

Comment on this

The current value has been fixed by law for a period of over thirty years and has not shared in the inflation of prices due to the war. Let Deputy Gorey take his courage in his hands and enunciate that theory. Remember that we are acquiring not only landlords' property under this Bill, but we are acquiring tenants' property. We are acquiring future tenancies—men who can be put out on six months' notice— men who might have taken their lands two years ago, who have no title to them at all, but who at the same time we are allowing to purchase. Suppose we find we have to resume a number of tenanted holdings and future tenancies in respect of which no improvements were done, will we acquire them at fourteen years' or sixteen years' purchase?

Comment on this

I suggest that you buy the landlords' interest at the figure you mention and then you proceed to buy the tenants' interest.

Comment on this

I am talking of buying the tenants' interest in a future tenancy. You have the case of untenanted land farmed by the landlord, and, remember, the landlord may be another tenant in this case—perhaps a man who has far less land than Deputy Gorey, perhaps fifty or a hundred acres. He may have let thirty acres of it as a future tenancy, four, or five, or ten years ago.

Comment on this

What does all this prove?

Comment on this

We are acquiring, let us say, a future tenancy now. What price will we give for it? If we are acquiring any other tenancy, what price shall we give for it—what number of years' purchase? What is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, perhaps the Minister would tell us whether there is such a thing as tenant proprietorship or tenant interest at all.

Comment on this

I am saying there is a tenant interest. What is that future tenant's interest—the interest of a man who had never to put up any buildings, who probably never did any improvements, who was making a big profit out of the land during the war, and who has no legal interest, and very little moral interest, in it. We may have to acquire those lands for the relief of congestion. What price would we give for them? That is what I want to know. The landlord, in such a case, has a bigger interest than the tenant, if anything. It was, perhaps, untenanted lands fifteen years ago. He let it for temporary convenience at the request of the tenant. The tenant took it to suit his own convenience. He has no tenure there. The landlord's interest, if anything, is greater. I am not talking of present or judicial tenancies. I am talking of future tenancies, of which there are many. Deputy Gorey wants us to acquire the landlord's interest at a certain number of years' purchase—I have not been able to discover whether it is fifteen years, or fourteen years, or twelve years, because his arguments apply equally to all. What I want to know is what are we going to give for the tenant's interest.

Comment on this

We will deal with that when it arises. We are beginning to know where the boot pinches now.

Comment on this

I agree with the Deputy that this is where the boot pinches. People cannot have it both ways. If the Deputy likes to come forward on this, the first occasion when the Free State is acquiring property compulsorily, and, regardless of the fact that the property has been a well-recognised security in the past, and that banking and charitable institutions, and stockbrokers and all sorts of people, are interested in it, suggests terms which eat into the security value of the property, just in order to make a temporary profit, let him do so; but he cannot have it both ways. If that is to be the rule in regard to this sort of property, it will be the rule in regard to future tenancies. When the State wants property in future, it will have to take it at considerably less than two-thirds of its current value.

Comment on this

The Minister has asked for figures as between these and previous purchase figures.

Comment on this

I asked you to justify the 40 per cent.

Comment on this

To come to the first term tenancies under the 1903 Act, we know from the Blue Book figures that the average reduction was just thirty per cent. What the tenant got on an average in the 26 counties was a little short of thirty per cent. By purchasing under that Act in 1909, he would be now purchased for 14 years. On £100 rental, that thirty per cent. for 14 years would be £420. If he bought immediately on the passing of the 1903 Act. he would be purchased now for 20 years, and that would mean £600.

Take the average percentage for a second-term rental under the 1903 Act, at a little less than 24, and multiply 24 by 14 and you get £336. If he bought immediately after the passing of the Act it would be £480. What is £600 now worth to the man who bought under the 1903 Act a first-term rental? He would have a capital sum of £600, and that would be worth £30 at any time. If he did not buy until 1909, when the operations of the Act ended, he could not have less than £420 under a first term tenancy. If he purchased second term, he could not have a lesser sum than £336, and could not have more than £480. How do those figures compare with the case of the man who did not purchase at all? He has paid in the meantime £600 in one case, £480 in another, or £420 in one case and £336 in another. We are asking that you put those on equality. Will 40 per cent. put them in a position of equality?

Comment on this

It would take about 60 per cent. on your figures, and 50 per cent. on Deputy Wilson's.

Comment on this

If you can contradict those figures, well and good. If we put the present man on the same level, regardless of the number of years as between him and the man who purchased 20 years ago, we would have 33 per cent. in the case of the second term man added to the present price offered under the Bill. You cannot put them on the same level short of confiscation. We do not want confiscation. Neither 40 per cent. nor 50 per cent. would be just. We have suggested the lowest figure that we could reasonably ask. We did not think for a moment we were asking too much.

We suggested 40 per cent. because we thought we would have a chance of that figure being accepted by the Government. If we put up 50 per cent. we knew it would be turned down; we put up 40 per cent. in the hope of its being accepted, and we see no reason why it should not be. The amount was made lower than it really should be, so as to make it possible for the Government to do what is right. The great argument in favour of the present price to a landlord is that his estate is encumbered—that many landlords' estates are encumbered, that the rentals are encumbered and other charges have to be met, and that vested interests have grown up that require to be protected. That may be true, but we want to know the facts. There is something between £1,000,000 and £800,000 rental. We want to be sure we are dealing out justice. We want to know how much of that £800,000 or the £1,000,000 is encumbered. How much of this philanthropy, this effort to preserve the public credit, is at stake? How much of this rental is encumbered and how much is not? Are we giving away £45,000 or £50,000 a year as a bonus where, perhaps, 10 or 12 millions would be sufficient? We have not had any figures. If the landlords' case or the Government's case is good we should have those figures. This matter should not be done on assumptions or presumptions. We should also know how much these charitable and banking institutions have advanced, and what rate it bears to the rental. How much is advanced in proportion to each rental? If we had these particulars perhaps we might be able to do justice. I do not want to go into figures. I have always heard that figures can prove anything. Figures in the hands of experts who could juggle with them could prove anything. I try to avoid figures as much as I can, especially in this Assembly. The whole argument in favour of this price is based on justice. We owe justice to every member of the human family. The question of what the people require now and will require in future has been dealt with by Deputy Wilson and others, and there is no occasion to travel over the same ground. The human family in the future will require a higher standard than in the past, and it is time they had it. More than two-thirds of the human family in this country have not a standard as good as an average animal in England.

Comment on this

Or in Ireland.

Comment on this

Or perhaps in Ireland— I quite agree. They certainly have not. They have not as good a house, they have not as good a floor, and they scarcely have as good a bed. It is very doubtful if they have as good food. They certainly have not such abundance of food to meet the requirements of the human being as the animal. The animal is very much better treated than the human being. If this was based on justice it should be based on the profit derived from the use of the land. If you are not able to approach it from that point of view you should leave out the word justice, and deal with it from some other standpoint.

Comment on this

What about the price of these tenancies I asked about?

Comment on this

A Leas-Chinn Comhairle—will you try and control the Minister? He does not like this at all. With regard to the price that ought to be paid for the land to the different interests I would point out that while there is only one interest in England there are two interests in this country. I would be the last to put money into land at the present price that is being paid for tenant's interest. It is ridiculously high; it is madness. It has been madness to pay such a price since the war. I have always held and expressed that view, and I am not going to recant now. But in buying Irish land from the fee-simple up you buy the landlord's interest and the tenant's interest. If you acquire tenanted land the landlord's interest has probably been bought under some previous Bill. You should pay for the tenant's interest at some reasonable rate, not an extravagant or a wild rate-not the rate obtaining at present—but something in proportion to what you are depriving him of.

Comment on this

Twelve years' purchase.

Comment on this

That will be a question for future Governments. If you are going to deprive a man of his living you ought at least to compensate him for it. This Bill is not based on justice. I contend that the word justice does not apply to it at all. It is based on the balance sheets and the incomes of vested interests. Those interests have to be met according to this Bill—and probably according to the great forces behind it—as near one hundred per cent. as possible—as near at least as figures can go, and they can go a long way. Why is it that large farmers for the last three years have lost money in agriculture? There is no doubt that they have lost money. They have lost it because there were no profits to be made out of the land after paying the labour bill.

Comment on this

They do not work themselves.

Comment on this

There is an Agricultural Commission sitting, and you can go there and bring all your witness from all over the country, and prove otherwise if you can. That is your answer. Farming is run at a loss by the bigger men. Why is the small farmer able to exist? Because of his intensive efforts, and of the low standard of comfort that he is content with; because of his natural craving for independence, and because he is satisfied to be under-fed and under-clothed in order to have that independence. If it were not for the intensive efforts of the small farmer and his family they could not exist at all. Not alone is the small farmer doing his duty to the State, but he is doing the duty of three men. Other elements in this country are able to live doing nothing, because of the efforts of the men who work. I saw in the country on Saturday evening last men going home to their supper at 8.30 in the evening (old time), after which they came back and worked until ten o'clock. I know these men are out from 5.30 or 6 o'clock in the morning. That is the sort of thing that makes existence possible— it is not possible without slaving.

Comment on this

Our proposal boiled down into figures means that we intend that the capital sum which should be paid to the landlord would be £1,263 plus 10 per cent. contribution, which would bring him in all £1,389, or 62.5 per cent. of his rental. based on the revenues and securities of the Free State. I think that is a fair proposition. If I were a landlord I would take £62 10s. 0d. safely secured, rather than a nebulous £100. I believe the landlord would be doing a good thing for himself. When we ask for the 40 per cent. reduction, we are not alone trying to do justice to the landlord, but are trying to uphold the security of the State. We are just as much concerned about the welfare, safety, and credit of the State as any of the Ministers. We do not want confiscation or spoliation. We are offering 62.5 out of a suppositious £100 that will not probably eventuate.

Comment on this

I want to ask Deputy Gorey a question, and I hope I will get a straight answer. If we were selling two or three hundred acres of his holding would the price he would ask be less or more than that which the Bill provides for the unpurchased tenants?

Comment on this

In other words, would the Deputy sell his clothes for less than he paid for them?

Comment on this

I would like to press for an answer. If the Deputy was willing to sell any of his present holding would he ask for a lesser or a greater price than that which the Bill provides for the present unpurchased tenants to buy their land?

Comment on this

The question that has been put by Deputy Milroy was the same question that was raised by the Minister for Agriculture, and I want to find out whether Deputy Milroy or the Minister for Agriculture makes any distinction between these two things that are talked about—these two properties. Do they contend that when they are buying the right from the tenant to work certain lands that they are buying the same thing, or anything like the same thing, as when they are buying the right of the landlord, not to work the land, but to draw rent from the land?

Comment on this

Deputy Milroy does not want that at all. That is not what he is sent here for.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I think it is about time for whoever is responsible for the regulation of this assembly to take steps to control this peculiar Deputy who thinks that he has a licence to insult any member of this Assembly. He has made an observation which I will ask you to ask him to withdraw.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

I will ask the Deputy first to withdraw the word "peculiar."

Comment on this

Did I use the word "peculiar"?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

I ask you to withdraw it.

Comment on this

Suppose I substitute "fantastic." I will withdraw the other word.

Comment on this

I think there is a good deal of justice in what Deputy Milroy says. I am peculiar.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Deputy Gorey or any other Deputy should not cast a reflection on other Deputies, and any Deputy who does so must withdraw the insinuation. Deputy Gorey has suggested that Deputy Milroy came here for unworthy motives. It is not fair to make an insinuation of that sort, and I will ask Deputy Gorey to withdraw that expression.

Comment on this

I quite agree. I should not have said it and I apologise.

Comment on this

I am anxious that the Dáil should be made acquainted with the views of Deputy Milroy and of the Minister for Agriculture in regard to these two things that are being purchased or referred to as purchasable. The Minister for Agriculture made it quite clear in introducing this Bill that what was proposed to be purchased was a rental, not the land. It has been generally conceded in the discussions that it was the legal right to draw rent that was being purchased. Is it contended that that is the same thing as the tenants' interest, the tenants' interest being the right to occupy and work that land? I submit there is a very great distinction. You cannot and ought not to treat these two things as though they were parallel, and try to put posers to Deputy Gorey or Deputy Wilson or any other person, in regard to their right to work their land as contrasted with the landlords' right to extract rent from the land. While this may be an academic question it goes right to the heart of this Bill and the proposals in it. It is the right to extract rent which is supposed to be purchased and that may be of very little value in 10, 20 or 30 years' time. As Deputy Wilson said the future value is quite nebulous, and in two or three years' time it may not exist at all. According to some of the statements that are put into the Press the country is going to the dogs and there is not going to be any value at all in the landlord's interest. I ask the Minister for Agriculture if he lays it down that there is no difference in the kind of property that is under consideration—the property of the tenant occupier, the proprietor who works the land and the property which is merely the legal right to draw rent?

Comment on this

The Deputy wants to know whether the right to draw rent is the same as the right of the tenant who works the land, or whether it is more or less. It depends on the nature of the tenancy. If a small tenant lets five acres of his land to a conacre tenant for a year, the right of the tenant at the same time is much greater than the right of the man who takes the conacre, even though this man does the work, and is worth more money. On the other hand the right of a present tenant is undoubtedly more valuable than the right of the landlord. The right of a future tenant is a totally different matter. It was the right of a future tenant I was discussing with Deputy Gorey.

Comment on this

We have had a very interesting discussion this evening, and we on this side have watched the progress of the allies. We heard Deputy Gorey advance principles that were applauded more vehemently on the labour benches than any other principles I heard applauded in the Dáil. Then as a kind of return Deputy Johnson pressed the farmers' interests by advancing arguments that were of the most capitalistic colour. They were at once accepted, and there were gracious bows exchanged between the two parties. They have changed places. If you closed your eyes you would think that what Deputy Johnson was saying was what he should have allowed Deputy Gorey to say, and all that Deputy Gorey should say was put forward by Deputy Johnson in his usual clear and precise style. I am afraid you will see these arguments flung back again with scorn from one side to the other later on. After what we heard about what 9s. a week means to the poor farmer we will be told how much more it means to the poor worker. We also heard about these poor men who are living in bad houses, and who are getting worse feeding than cattle. The debate was very fair and legitimate as a debate. I would not say one word here in favour of encumbered landlords. I felt an echo in my heart for everything that Deputy Gorey said about these gentlemen who piled up big debts on Irish estates, and squandered the money. I have no sympathy for that sort of thing. nor has any man in the Dáil, but what we have to remember is that this is the heel end to a big question, and that it is settling up what was commenced in former Land Acts, and in particular the Act of 1903. Let us do the decent thing, and get this question out of the way. We are not saying that there is justice in giving all this to the landlords. The landlords are there, and as the other landlords got something the present ones should also get something. They are not getting too much, considering all the interests involved. I am sorry that the farmer is not faring better, though the landlord is only getting £1,500 compared to £2,500 that could be got under the 1903 Act. That does not represent a corresponding advantage for the tenant. This Bill considering all things, is a very fair and reasonable Bill, and being so I ask the Dáil to keep that in mind. It is a bargain, an approximation. Deputy Gorey spoke of very real things when he spoke of the small farmer, and the small holding where all the family work, where they start at an early hour in the morning and finish at a late hour in the evening, and whose living is on a very low standard. By such means they carry on. It is in the interests of such men this Bill is introduced, and that the Dáil should pass it. This particular Bill is part and parcel of a certain policy, and the spokesman of that policy made it possible, and say it is the best thing that could be done as a bargain between all interests. The Bill is offered as a fair thing, and gives an opening and a chance in the future to the small man. Do some justice to those who are clearing it. This is your Bill and your bargain, and do not try to upset it, and take the best part of it away. Do not smash the Bill, and do not smash the whole thing. I have sympathy with all those points brought forward, but the fact that it is a bargain must be borne in mind. We have to take the good and the bad. We have to swallow the whole lot as it is.

Comment on this

I was more than pleased to hear the remarks of the last Deputy when he referred to the union that has been created here between the Farmers' Party and the Labourers' Party. I hope in the interests of the country that that unity will continue amongst us. I can, as a Labour man, assure the Dáil it will not be the fault of the Labour Party if a unity like that is broken.

Comment on this

Send him down to Waterford.

Comment on this

Come over here to these benches.

Comment on this

I want to support this amendment, and not simply because it is put forward by Deputy Gorey. If the same amendment is put forward by any of the members in the Government benches I am sure that the Saorstát will rise in the morning and see in the Press where the Labour Party threw in their lot with the Government for this particular amendment. I think it is really necessary that this amendment should be accepted. For surely 60 per cent. is quite enough to give the landlords. Before this Bill was introduced, there were in the country some very large holders of land, who had actually advertised their land for sale. But when they read the terms of the Bill and found they were getting 65 per cent. they removed the posters and said they would wait until the Bill goes through, "Because" said they, "we would not get so much at the auction." Deputy Gorey spoke of the men in an impoverished state, and he also mentioned the amount of good that those particular landlords have done to the country, and the amount of employment they gave on the land and the amount of improvements they carried out while the land was in their possession. That reminds me of a little story I read in a book some years ago. It happened somewhere down in Waterford where a poor man went to a large landowner who owned something like 1,600 or 1,700 acres. The tenant thought to get into the good graces of the landlord and lay down at the hall door and started to eat the grass. The landlord came out and said "my poor man what is the matter with you?" And the tenant replied "I am impoverished and destitute." The landlord said to him "get round to the back of the house, the grass is much finer and sweeter there." These are the men to whom the Saorstát are now asked to give a rent that will cripple the future tenants or the tenants who are already in occupation. I certainly support this amendment not for the interest of the big farmer, the man with the £200 valuation, but for the small man, the man who possibly cannot afford to pay. Furthermore, I think that when we take into account particularly the two classes of farms taking the fee simple holding, say, of a £30 valuation, and take another farm of the same valuation that carries a rent of £12 a year, I think something more should be done for that man who is paying £12 a year, than for the man who is a freeholder more or less. That is why I support this amendment. Deputy Wilson was large in his remarks; He maintained that £200 will be lost by the tenant who will buy under this Act. That £200 will be lost by him. That was gained by the tenant who purchased under the 1903 Act. The Minister for Agriculture wants to know if Deputy Gorey or any citizen had money invested would they hand over the whole sum raised through that money being invested. I think that was a wrong remark thrown at Deputy Gorey and Deputy Wilson. I am not quite sure that the money they had invested was money they earned, but the money you give to the landlord has not been earned by him. They have not done anything in this country to deserve the amount of fairplay given under this particular Clause. I think it is high time that we asked those landlords to hand over to the original owners the land that belongs to the people of Ireland. The land of Ireland has been long enough in the hands of a few. I am sure that the Minister for Agriculture will try the influences he has, when this amendment of Deputy Gorey's will be put to a vote. I am sure notwithstanding the words that have been said in the previous speeches about the Minister for Agriculture throughout the country that he was the only man that could succeed in getting a Bill that could satisfy overbody, that it will be said to-morrow that he got that Bill to satisfy the landlords and that he had no interest in the tenants.

Comment on this
Mr. DOYLE

I support the amendment, and I believe myself that the Minister and Government ought to accept it—for State reasons alone. It has been debated from every point of view except from one, and that is the tenant's. The tenant should not be compelled to pay any higher rate than 60 per cent. of his present rent. At the present state of Agriculture, and the state it has been in for the last three or four years, it is impossible to pay any more. Agriculture has been losing for the last three or four years and everybody engaged in agriculture knows that thoroughly well. How then is a farmer to pay an impossible annuity? I consider that the State will be well advised in making his annuity as low as it possibly can. For this reason—that they will leave him in a position of being able to pay his annuity, and pay his rates and taxes. If they put too big an imposition on him, if they put too high an annuity on him, it will leave him in a condition that he will not be able to meet any of his engagements whatsoever. You know when the 1903 Act was passed, things were very different. Things were very different with regard to the men engaged in agriculture at the time. The cost of production at that time was very little—not more than one third of what it is at present. And then he came along for a number of years at that cost of production. He got a reasonable profit in those particular years. Then the Minister talked about inflated prices. He said nothing was to be had in those years. If he looks at this inflation from a tenant's point of view he will see that the latter had to pay more for every hand's turn he got done on his farm, and so the inflation was not as large as the Minister thinks. There was also inflation on his purchases. The farmer had to pay for any farm implements he purchased during those years four times as much as when the 1903 Act was passed for everything was dear in comparision with then. The inflation of his prices was brought down by the inflation of the purchases he had to make, and this is not a matter which is being taken into consideration at all. I say that the State and Government should try and leave that annuity as low as they possibly can so as to give the tenant purchaser a chance to pay his annuity, his outgoings, and his rates and taxes. If those things are not paid, that is the annuities, rates and taxes, the country will go bankrupt, and I say to the State and the Minister to accept the lowest annuity they can.

Comment on this

Yesterday we were told that there were something like 70,000 tenants, and a rental in the neighbourhood of £800,000 a year. According to that a very large proportion of the persons affected by this Bill would be paying a rental of £10 a year. Now, under the Bill the sum for which they would be liable is this: a person who had to pay a rent of £10 a year would pay £6 10s., and the proposal is to reduce it to £6. We are told from one side of the Dáil that the difference between £6 and £6 10s. will compensate for what is regarded as the normal standard type of life, and put the tenant in the position to enjoy all the advantages of a higher standard. I am in some difficulties to know how this is to be done on 10s. a year. We are told from the other side that this 10s. a year spelt bankruptcy. I have never come across a case in which 10s. a year made a man bankrupt. The Deputies may know of such a case, and in justice to the Dáil they should tell us. There is one order we must admit, in connection with this Bill not represented here. The landlords have no representatives here. The Deputies have an excellent opportunity of pillorying the Government, and saying "you are fine specimens, and you are defenders of this Order that ought to be exterminated."

Comment on this
LABOUR DEPUTIES

No.

Comment on this

Oh yes, you are in that position. You are able to say that. But we have got to strike a fair and even balance. We were not able to strike it in this case, and Deputies know it well. In the one case all that could be afforded was something like 13? years' purchase. If one mentioned that in 1903 what would be said?

Comment on this

It would be the same price if you got the money at 2¾ per cent.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Order, you cannot interrupt.

Comment on this

We have bolstered up that at the cost of the State. I may tell the Dáil that it was only after a very long and careful consideration that I even considered the question of bolstering up that contribution by reason of the fact of the condition of our finances. This particular order that has got no representation here at all has got to have something said for its side of the case. Deputies say it has none. If you say it has none, why then do you give it 60 per cent.? No honest man would stand up and say give them 60 per cent. if he thought that. He should say "give them nothing."

If you presume to give them anything at all you ought to give them what is fair. If we are prepared to give them what is fair then we ought to consider it on a fair basis, and consider how it will effect one and the other. We cannot get an acceptance from those concerned of a 60 per cent. payment of the former rental. We are then faced with the position that there are citizens of this State who are entitled to ask that the machinery of the State be put in motion, and Deputies know what that means. You can if you like at a particular time pass this Bill over the head of the Seanad. You may now—but I doubt it. It will be held up for nine months, and meanwhile the machinery of the State must operate. Suppose it is held up for nine months. How many tenants will be deprived of what you are trying to save them now?

Comment on this

I wish to God it were held up.

Comment on this

You know well it cannot be done, and it is well known that it may not be done.

Comment on this

I hope it will be held up. They will get an opportunity of holding it up.

Comment on this

Well then you are going to justify the holding up of the machinery of the State. The citizen has his rights. Are you going to deprive him of them without having the law to back you?

Comment on this

We will have the law at the next election.

Comment on this

If it be elections that are mentioned it is a new matter. We can deal with that. This is the first time a question of this kind was mentioned in this Dáil. I thought that every member brought in what he could of ability which he contributed towards the solution of urgent, public matters regardless of whether or not he should be returned at the next Election. I may tell the Deputies that there is not any one on those benches here who cares about being in public life. They are here for the country. The majority of the members of this party want to get out. We can only keep them in by the greatest possible persuasion. We keep them in for one reason, and the Deputy knows that reason. You can dissolve this party to-morrow but will the Deputy deal with the difficult situation we are faced with?

Comment on this

If the time comes, we will.

Comment on this

If that be the case we are willing at any moment to give you an opportunity. It is not for love of office we are staying here. It is for one purpose we got into this thing for the last 6 or 7 years, and certainly it was not. our intention at the beginning that public life would be the sport of any parties. I think it will be admitted that Deputies on this side have suffered, and lost a great deal. The real question here is what can you do in justice? You cannot maintain in justice that 10s. difference in a £10 rental is going to bankrupt you, and can it be proved that 10s. a year is going to give a man a higher standard of living.

One case put forward was that the landlords were getting security. Take care whether they are getting security or not. Take care what will be the value of the particular security. Take care how much it may affect very important interests in the State, in which the Deputy's interests are just as much bound up as those of the landlord, and perhaps more so, because I do not believe that there is any larger interest in the country than the agricultural interest. Take care that the industrial, banking and other interests are not lessened in amount, lessened in value, lessened in importance, for upon the security of these depends, to a very great extent, the value of the country's agricultural industry. It was stated that they would get security. I would like to know from the Deputies if we were in a position to say to-morrow, so far as labour is concerned, that they should have a forty per cent. reduction on the rather nebulous incomes that they have derived for some years and that we guarantee them that, would it be accepted?

Comment on this

Tempt us.

Comment on this

This has not been put forward in that way. If Deputies would put forward that, I am inclined to think that a great many of the important industrial interests of the country would accept it, and I am inclined to think that a great many supporters of the Deputies opposite, whom they represent, would not be agreeable to that proposition. Deputies might say "yes," but the men themselves might say "no." Forty per cent. is a very considerable reduction in income in the case of many of these estates. I do not know to what extent they are encumbered. I have been informed that there have been considerable mortgages in certain cases, and I do not think that the Deputy was wise in criticising charitable organisations which had certain mortgages on them. Certainly one must look for some security. Formerly, practically the entire security in a country was in its landed property, its landed estates. That has passed away; the world has changed; the value that formerly affected landed estates has passed away and other securities have been substituted such as War Loan, or things of that sort. People might criticise these charitable organisations, but they were perfectly entitled and justified in taking these mortgages and you are not justified in reducing their value. After all, it may be very much of an accident that Deputy Gorey has a pretty considerable farm and that a man beside him has a very small farm. The time may come when that man may think that that farm is too much for one man and he may attempt to get a slice off it, and other men may come along and take parts of it, and the Deputy might find himself in the position of a small farmer. If the majority of the people of the country are very poor——

Comment on this

That argument is no good.

Comment on this

Perhaps not. I am sure it would take a good deal to assure the Deputy of the danger of it, but the danger is there. Now, I have put it to the Deputies that this is a case for common justice. We approached it from that angle entirely. It would have been a very popular thing for us to have put down the 40 per cent. reduction. It would perhaps have involved the State in consequences in which we did not think we were justified in involving it. From all the information that we have been able to gain we are satisfied that the Bill as it stands is accepted in good faith by the people, who are just in their decisions in such matters. There is nothing in it to commend it to them but common justice, and it is in that spirit that we are putting it forward.

Comment on this

I regret that some of the things mentioned by the President were introduced, because I think they have no bearing whatsoever upon the conduct of this debate so far as we are concerned. If one were to take his speech seriously, one would be led to believe that the whole foundation of the State was trembling in the balance and affected altogether by the landlords' consideration, so far as this Bill was concerned. We were told by the Minister for Agriculture himself that this question is really a simple one because of the small acreage involved, because of the very small number of unpurchased tenants, and because of the very small number of landlords who would be concerned by the Bill, compared with those who had already purchased and settled under previous Acts. Therefore, the matter cannot really be so serious for the State as the Minister for Finance asks us to believe, Deputy Sears taunted Deputies on this side of the Dáil with the unity existing in this matter between the Farmers' Party and ourselves regarding a matter which, I think, concerns the agricultural workers and the small tenant farmers. If that unity—and I say this seriously—is any indication of a greater spirit of co-operation between the two being set up I welcome it most heartily, and, as far as we are concerned, we will do nothing that will impair or break it. The whole thing boils down to what is considered a fair price. In this matter it is very hard to find out who could be the best judge. The Minister for Finance said that the landlords have no representation here, and that therefore they are not able to put up any good case in defence of the attitude adopted by Deputy Gorey and his followers. I am sure that the landlords' side of the case is very well known to the Minister for Agriculture because of the many conferences that he has had with their representatives.

Comment on this

Quite true.

Comment on this

Well then, I take it that the Minister for Agriculture is the defendant on behalf of the landlords on that particular point.

Comment on this

On a point of order, how does the Deputy deduce that from the fact that I happen to know the landlords' side of the case as they put it up to me? I did meet the landlords. I met the unpurchased tenants often. Is it because I met the landlords and heard their side of the case——

Comment on this

Is that a point of order?

Comment on this

That I am the defender of their side of the case here?

Comment on this
AN LEAS-CHEANN-COMHAIRLE

It is a point of personal explanation more than a point of order.

Comment on this

Deputy Sears seemed to think that because the landlords of the larger and different class voluntarily agreed to sell under the 1903 Act, the landlords who have held out against any of the previous Acts are entitled to the same consideration. I may be pardoned for making the distinction between the two classes, and the distinction to me appears to be this, that the landlords who sold under the 1903 Act, or previous Acts, were people who were inspired with some national outlook, with some consideration for the other side, and who made what they considered to be a fair bargain. That class of landlord generally is a landlord who has lived and spent his money within the country and put it in circulation within the country. On the other hand, the landlord who has held out against any previous Act, and who has now been compelled to sell, is the landlord who has drawn rent out of a small number of unpurchased tenants and who has spent the money outside this State. That is a different matter altogether, and to me, at any rate, there is quite a difference between the two classes of landlords. I look upon any person, whether he be a landed proprietor or otherwise, as patriotic in the sense that whatever money he derives, by rent or by other means, he spends within the State. That type of man is a patriotic citizen whether he be a landlord or a worker, and he is the man who keeps this or any other State going.

My concern in regard to the question of price is mostly with the person who has lost the most during the past two or three admittedly very bad years. Deputy Gorey has pleaded very well on behalf of that particular class and the small tenant farmer who, it has been admitted, has been very badly hit because of circumstances over which he has had no control, and who is called upon to pay a price out of the labour of his family, although he has no control over the prices of the produce which he helps to grow. I think that is a very unfair thing so far as the man who helps to produce the food of the country is concerned, and I think that should be taken into consideration.

The Minister for Local Government seems to be amused at some of these statements, and the Bill has been defended by the Minister for Agriculture and the Front Bench in a very amusing way. They apparently believe there is nothing in anything put up except by themselves. Deputy Sears went very far when he said that the people who are responsible for this Bill are the people who are responsible for making it possible for the Dáil to meet and to bring forward the first Irish Land Bill. Let me ask him whether he thinks that the people who are sitting with him on that side of the Dáil are the only people who made it possible for us to meet in the Dáil. The small tenant farmer and the working classes have taken their share of the sacrifices that have made it possible for us to meet here just as much as those of whom Deputy Sears speaks. It appears to me he is inclined to give no credit except to that particular class. I put to the Minister for Finance a fair question which I think has some bearing on the aspect of the case which even he himself put up. Would he be prepared to offer to the labourers of this country 60 per cent. of their present wages while they did no work? That is what he is giving to the landlords who held out against previous Acts, and to whom he is offering this under the terms of this Bill. I ask him that in all fairness, seeing the attitude he has adopted and the case he has put up for the people who have never done any work so far as this country is concerned.

Comment on this

I have reserved some little facts and figures for the last. The Minister for Finance has inspired me with them. I know that the Minister for Finance knows a little about finance. He is a business man, and business was his object in life until he started politics, and his view point ought to be the view point of a business man. I know a little, too, about Land Purchase from its business aspect. Since 1919 and 1920, when money was in the country, twelve estates were sold in my country, voluntary sales between landlords and tenants, and the terms were arrived at by agreement at a round table at which I sat, and all those sales were carried out under a cash transaction. The average price was between 11 and 12½ years for cash. The Minister for Finance talks about 100 per cent. of the landlord's income. If he was a landlord and knew anything about property, or landlordism, or the collection of rents, or even the history of the recent Acts, he would know that that 100 per cent. was never received by any landlord. He would know that he had the cost of collection, that there were legal expenses and other charges incidental to the collection of the rents that could not be got away from. If he read up the report of the Convention held at Trinity College, he would know that the net income of the landlord at that time was voluntarily agreed on as 75 per cent. of his income. That is 25 per cent. gone west, and that he never had. He would have 75 per cent. of his income—if he could collect it. He, as a man who owned a property, got as much as he could collect; he had to meet bad years and good years, and got what he could collect, and no more. What was the average collection of many of the Estate Offices in this city? Go back before the fat years of war and tell us what was the average collection on £1,000. How much of that was collected? I challenge the Minister to get these figures for me.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy was going to give me information, but it appears he is asking for it.

Comment on this

I am giving him the information, and I challenge him to contradict my figures. What was the average collection? According to the Convention Report it was 75 per cent., if he could collect it. How much did he collect in the forties, the fifties, the eighties and the nineties, and even in the tens of this century? Did he collect 75 per cent.? Nothing of the sort; he was entitled to that if he could get it, but he never got it. There were circumstances in every case which made it impossible for him to get it. Deputies smile. I want to tell them that this is not a joke, and it was not a joke when one and a half year's rent had to be forgiven. Deputy Hughes knows nothing about it.

Comment on this

Apparently no one knows anything about it except Deputy Gorey.

Comment on this

Deputy Hughes knows more about trade.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

It would be better if these interruptions would not take place. The Deputy has spoken three times already. The first time fourteen minutes, the second time thirteen minutes, and he must be short now.

Comment on this

The President has spoken of extermination. There is no question of extermination at all; it is a question of offering these landlords a fair business proposition. There is £75, if he can collect it, but there is always a considerable element of doubt about that collection, and about how much of it he can collect. How much would any sensible business man, the President, for instance, accept as an absolute certainty for that sum of considerable uncertainty?

Comment on this

The Deputy has paid rent himself; if he tells us how much he has paid on £100, I will accept that.

Comment on this
AN CEANN-COMHAIRLE

at this stage resumed the Chair.

Comment on this

How much I paid on £100? I owe a few years' rent at present, and my father owed more before I came along. Perhaps some of the Deputies would call him dishonest or immoral, but it never troubled his conscience. I asked the President a question, and he has not answered me. What would he take as a fair equivalent for seventy-five years, an absolutely gilt-edged security, for a security of considerable uncertainty? What would he or any sensible business man take? The landlords in my county agreed to take twelve and a half years' purchase. They agreed to take less than 60 per cent., and they thought they were doing good business; and here we are met by talk of confiscation and extermination when we make a lesser demand. But the men who had property to sell, and did sell it voluntarily within the last three years, were sensible men and knew their business, and knew what certainty was as against uncertainty. There is no use in coming here and talking about extermination and confiscation, and indulging in the histrionics we have heard about the unfortunate landlord. The speech of Deputy Sears a few minutes ago was witty, and there was no malice in it; but if you take the wit out of it there was nothing left. This is a question I think the President, as a business man, or any other business man in the Dáil, ought to answer—how much as a fair proposition would he take for £75 when his chance of recovering it would be very remote? How much as a bulk sum would he take? Would he take £60 or £55? If he was a business man he would, and he would not grumble about it.

Comment on this

I really did not think it was worth my while to rise to answer the points put forward by Deputy Gorey or by any of the other speakers up to the present. There has not been a single attempt by Deputy Gorey to produce a single intelligent argument in favour of the figure he put forward, or a single intelligent argument against the figure that I put forward. We simply have had a lot of hot air from Deputy Gorey and a lot of hot air, more or less, from the Farmers' party.

Comment on this

Hot air on the part of the landlords has been put forward by the Minister.

Comment on this

And we have had all this for 10s. per annum.

Comment on this

Yes, why not?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Order, Order. Deputy Gorey will have to sit quiet and cease from interrupting. I am getting completely tired of Deputy Gorey's interruptions, and I cannot allow him to continue.

Comment on this

Let me now try to bring a little common sense into this debate. We have been here for hours and the proceedings have been a perfect farce so far as the Farmers' party is concerned. We have had plenty of histrionics, plenty of excitement, and there has been a lot of hot air about. For the average tenant 10s. is the figure involved, and that was only arrived at a couple of days ago. It had been 50 per cent.—that was the figure put forward through the organisation; they started at sixty and it reached fifty-four and three-quarters, on one occasion, which was meant, of course, to show how accurately the figure was arrived at. Now the figure is forty per cent. As the President has pointed out, that is for the average tenant 10s. per annum. The business of the Dáil must be held up, in order that the country may be shown how some people's hearts are bleeding and are broken for the unpurchased tenant, and how other people's hearts are not. The very party that Deputy Gorey represents agreed with the landlords to take a twenty-five per cent. reduction in 1920.

Comment on this

Nothing of the sort!

Comment on this

Was there not an agreement between the landlords and the Farmers' Union in 1920 to settle upon a twenty-five per cent. reduction basis?

Comment on this

There was an agreement between the Farmers' Union and the landlords of those days.

Comment on this

What! 1920?

Comment on this

There was an agreement between them in that year to take thirty per cent. reduction on first term rents, and twenty-four per cent. reduction on second term rents. I want to say that the Farmers' Union in those days was a Landlords' union led by a landlord, Colonel O'Callaghan Westropp, and backed up by landlords' men, in the union. They were kicked out of it and then we formed the Unpurchased Tenants' Organisation. They did not represent the unpurchased tenants and never acted for them.

Comment on this

We could all get excited if we wanted to, as well as Deputy Gorey. I take his own figure. They accepted thirty per cent. for first term rents, and twenty-four for second term rents. They accepted the terms of the 1920 Act, which gave an average reduction of 25 per cent. on first and second term rents. I am giving a reduction of 35 per cent. The Farmers' Union accepted the 25 per cent. reduction under the 1920 Act, and, I ask, did Deputy Gorey or any member of the Farmers' Union ever denounce the action of the Union at that time for accepting such a reduction, or write a single letter to a newspaper in Ireland denouncing this betrayal of the interests of the unpurchased tenants by what we are now told was this renegade Farmers' Union.

Comment on this

The price for produce was different then.

Comment on this

Here is a serious question, be it big or small, and as Deputy Davin knows, it is not the number of tenants involved, it is the principle of how much you are going to pay where you acquire property compulsorily. The serious question is, how much you are going to give for it. It is a serious question, even from Deputy Gorey's point of view, the question of how much you are going to pay for property that you acquire compulsorily. How did the Farmers' Union tackle it? They started off with a demand for a 60 per cent. reduction, then they came down to 54¾ per cent., and later to 50 per cent., and now we have a demand for a 40 per cent. reduction. Previously, as I have stated, they were satisfied with a 25 per cent. reduction. I say this is pure casual guess work. I said before that I do not begrudge the farmers or the Labour Party their pic-nic. They have a magnificent opportunity, and if we on these benches had such an opportunity I am sure we have splendid imaginations and would look for a 60 per cent. reduction if we thought we could get it. We could have made tremendous speeches about the poor tenants of Ireland, but we did not talk about land purchase; we did not go around the country when the confusion was at its height and when you had the energies of any man who had the good of the country at heart trying to bring about conditions of peace and security, and trying to do what they could to allay the class war that was developing at the time. We did not go around the country at that time preaching doctrines that we did not believe in in regard to the price at which property should be compulsorily acquired. On the contrary, we tried to see to it, as far as we could, that any man in the country whether a landlord, a tenant or a workman would get his legal rights. We have done that, and we are now introducing this Land Purchase Bill. I have heard a good many speeches from people who were never within half a mile of an unpurchased tenant, and who know nothing about his condition. They talk now about his rights and his wrongs, but I say that 95 per cent. of the unpurchased tenants of the country know perfectly well that the price in this Bill is a tip top one from their point of view. Deputy Gorey knows that, too, just as well as I do, and so does the rank and file of the unpurchased tenants. A reduction of 35 per cent. is considerably more than they ever expected to get, and Deputy Gorey, and every other Deputy in this Dáil, I do not care to what Party he belongs, knows that perfectly well. The unpurchased tenants know that that reduction is a good deal better than they ever expected to get, and that it is more than fair. I explained on the First and Second Reading of the Bill why we arrived at this price. I put forward specific reasons, and I have waited here since to hear one of them deliberately met or to be shown to be inaccurate or unsound in any respect. I have not heard it done. No one has attempted to do it. It was simply histrionics from all Parties when they were not engaged in an academic discussion on the rights of property, histrionics which are about twenty years out of date and which deceive nobody. I said in introducing the Bill that we tried to be just to the landlords and generous to the tenants. These terms are generous to the tenants; the tenants know they are generous and Deputy Gorey knows it also, and if, as a result of any monkey tricks, this Bill was beaten, and that the price in it was not obtained, it would be very bad business for Deputy Gorey and the Deputies sitting with him.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 21
·
Níl 33
Result _

Do you agree with this result?