We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

[ DAIL IN COMMITTEE. ] - PUBLIC SAFETY (EMERGENCY POWERS) BILL, 1923—THIRD STAGE RESUMED.

Contributions 1–203 of 405. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Public Safety (Emergency Powers) Bill, 1923
Enacted

No. 30 of 1923 ›

I move Amendment No. 18, to insert before Section 4 a new Section as follows:—"It shall not be lawful to detain in custody without trial any person who shall have three or more children under the age of sixteen years wholly or mainly dependent on him."

I think it will be generally agreed that some amendment of this kind is necessary from ordinary motives of humanity. I have had occasion recently, for another purpose, to make some enquiry as to the prevalence of distress in Dublin, and I must say that I have been amazed at the number of cases of large families whose bread-winner is in prison here in this city of Dublin, cases where a man interned leaves three young children, or five, six or even seven practically unprovided for. I do not like to cite actual figures, because I have not got them absolutely accurate, but the Dáil may take it as a fact that there are a large number of such families in this city. In a case like that there are frequently three young-children, and the mother is not able to work; she has to look after the children, and very often the eldest child is not old enough to be earning. The consequence has been that there have been cases of acute distress. I ask the Dáil to observe that the motion is confined to cases of persons imprisoned under suspicion.

I quite recognise that if you are dealing with a criminal against whom you can bring a charge, that man should be proceeded against irrespectively of the number of his dependents, but I think it will be agreed that it is fair when you are passing a law to intern people on suspicion that cases where other persons wholly innocent will be seriously injured or will be liable to be seriously injured by your acting on suspicion against their fathers are cases which should be specially provided for. It seems to me where a man answers the general call from those whom he looks to as his leaders to go out in such a rebellion as we have seen, and where that man in so doing knows that he is risking great hardships for his children it is a great proof of his loyalty and sincerity. I do not think that the State need be apprehensive of such sporadic acts by such a man as that as would be a danger to it. In view of the fact that there are many such men with large families, a fact which I can absolutely vouch for, and that there has been great distress in consequence of their internment, I very earnestly press this amendment. I may say this further fact makes some such amendment all the more necessary, namely, that the Ministry or its agent have thought it necessary to annex very considerable sums of money collected for prisoners' dependents. Those sums have been held for a considerable time on the ground, apparently, that they might be used for some other purpose than the relief of prisoners' dependents, and on the suspicion that they might be so used. I do not know if any such sums have been returned, but, at all events, the fact of the withholding of such large sums has made it very difficult to deal with persons in the category with which this amendment deals. There has been very great distress, but there will be more distress if people who have a large number of dependents are allowed by the Dáil to be interned on mere suspicion.

Comment on this
Kevin Christopher O'Higgins MINISTER for HOME AFFAIRS (Mr. O'Higgins) Sinn Féin

I regret I cannot accept the amendment, nor can I accept the principle that the person with three or more children is entitled to exemption under an Act of this kind. I assume that many persons with three or more children have taken part in the armed revolt against the State within the last year, and I cannot undertake if the opinion is held, and held strongly, that the release of such person would be a danger to the public safety, such persons will be released. The amendment would involve that. Neither can I accept the principle that if a man with three or more children is reasonably suspected of the offences mentioned in Part II. of the Schedule he must go free in the critical conditions of things in the country. It is for those who have called him out and who have applauded from behind in the campaign of the last twelve months to advert to the sacrifices and the hardships that they are plunging people in, both the individuals themselves and their children, and the responsibility lies on them. I think it will be obvious to Deputies that an amendment of that kind, drawing distinction between citizens on the purely accidental circumstance of the numbers of their families, would be impossible of acceptance. I do not propose to stress the matter any further.

Comment on this

I am surprised to hear the Minister for Home Affairs rejecting this amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I was wondering whether Deputy Lyons was not a rather biassed person to speak on this amendment?

Comment on this

He has only ten.

Comment on this

I am going to press the acceptance of the amendment on the Minister for Home Affairs, who has charge of this Bill, and in whose power it is to accept amendments such as this in order to improve the Bill, so that the people of the Saorstát may gain some benefits from it, instead of the Bill, as it at present stands, leading the Saorstát into complete bankruptcy of the worst type. The new Section suggested is a very reasonable one. I wonder does the Minister fully realise the number of men who are at present interned and who have more than three—some of them eight—children under sixteen years of age. What preparations, if any, has the Minister made in connection with the dependents of prisoners who may be taken on pure suspicion and detained without being charged or tried for a week? What is to happen the dependents of those persons? What is to happen the little children during the time their breadwinner is in prison under a false charge? The Minister says he cannot accept the amendment, but he offers no help or no way out for the children of the man who is imprisoned on his signature. The Minister may put his signature to a particular letter simply because some of his captains or somebody in the Saorstát may get in touch with him and tell him that such a person is a dangerous character to have at large. There is no proof that the man is a dangerous character. What the Minister says is, "If you say this man is a dangerous character, it must be so; the man must be dangerous and he must be taken and interned; his children must starve and we will have to make an example of this particular man although he has a family. We must teach the children, and when they are reared they will have the same respect for the Saorstát as we, in our time, had for the English." That is what you will do. Instead of giving the parents an opportunity of rearing the children and educating them so that they may be in a position to assist in the progress and general welfare of the country, you will be working in the contrary direction. You will be so doing if you do not accept the amendment. I am surprised the mover of the amendment did not specify any man who is married and who, if not a father, might be a prospective father. It is a shame and a crime against humanity to arrest and intern without trial or uncharged the father of a helpless family. By doing so you are really allowing children to starve. What will their mothers become? The women whose husband is arrested and interned knows perfectly well that the breadwinner is absolutely innocent, as innocent as the falling dew from heaven. That is the only comparison I can find at the moment; I can find no comparison in any living person, and therefore I must compare it with the dew falling from the heavens, for the dew cannot commit sin. Now I do not stand up here simply to try to prolong the time, as I can see that thought passing in the mind of the Minister for Home Affairs. I can see that he believes that I am standing up here supporting this amendment in order to prevent this Bill passing through before 8 o'clock in the morning. My intention is nothing of the kind. I am supporting it because, to my mind, this amendment is just and honest and perfect. If you want to make citizens have respect for the Saorstát, then you must treat them as citizens. Do not make the young child that is toddling along to school an enemy of the Saorstát. If you reject that amendment, believe me, you cause that child suffering. If you cause that child to go to bed without its supper or to school without its breakfast, if you cause its mother to be penniless, and if you cause her to go with her hand out looking for alms, as she would have no other way of living if her husband is cast into prison by the representatives of the majority of her own people, they are wrong tactics. It is the wrong way to get people to support you. Give the children an opportunity of being educated and brought up as they ought to be. I ask you to accept this amendment, and so prove that there is one soft spot in the heart of the Minister for Home Affairs, a heart which the people say is something like flint. I ask you to accept that amendment. You might possibly think that it is owing to the motion being put forward asking the Dáil to adjourn and because we were defeated that we are standing up here. I can assure the Dáil it is nothing of the kind.

The Minister for Home Affairs knows as well as I do that he has succeeded in getting the majority of this Dáil to pass every Bill he puts forward. He knows in his heart of hearts, if he has such a thing as a heart, that this amendment is one of the most necessary amendments put forward by any Deputy. I know the Minister for Home Affairs has a heart, and that is why, more or less, I am not going contrary to him. I am making what I would call a fatherly appeal. By accepting this amendment I am sure that the Minister for Home Affairs will improve the Bill. I am sure he will change his mind, and that he will prove that he has a heart. Before this amendment is put to the Dáil I hope that every Deputy who answered his name here today will be able to stand up and deliver at least a half an hour's speech on it. If we do we may be able to get the views of the Dáil whether they are against having the fathers of families cast into prison and allowed to remain there until some humbug of a charge shall be made against them. I know myself of three or four particular cases where men have been arrested. I know one man from Edgeworthstown in Longford. I know a man out of the town of Longford and another man from Castletown in County Westmeath. These men are fathers of families. Worse than all, I know some men who are at the present moment without any charge having been made against them. These men were ex-service men. They had a pension from the British Government. As soon as these men were arrested and interned the pensions ceased, and their wives are dependent solely upon the generosity of the locality where they live. What will apply under this particular Section 4 if some such amendment is not accepted? Are you going to have the same thing apply here as applied for the past hundreds of years? They say of a man, "We have knocked all we can out of him, he is no earthly use to the Saorstát; there is a possibility, as somebody has told us, that he is thinking of doing something against the Saorstát, and I am going to arrest him now and allow his children to starve." You punish the innocent for the sake of the guilty. That is the idea the Deputy had in mind when he put forward this amendment. It is put forward to save these little innocent children that we are looking to for the future of the Saorstát, to build it up and to prove that we are a credit, even though the present generation has been such a disgrace. The Dáil should accept this amendment. Let the Deputies say, "We will not allow the fathers of innocent children to be imprisoned. If a man is an innocent man we will not allow his children to starve. We will not allow their mothers to become solely dependent upon the generosity of their neighbours." The idea of this amendment is to save that. I ask the Dáil to accept it. This is an honest amendment. If the Minister does not accept it it will be the worse for the Bill. I hope he will accept it, and if he does I can assure him he will have a more easy passage for the Bill. If he rejects it I can guarantee him having a very rough passage for it.

Comment on this

The motion of Deputy Gavan Duffy in moving this amendment has been treated with a certain amount of levity by the Deputies, and not unnaturally, because of the dramatic way in which Deputy Lyons has emphasised the arguments he puts forward. He is entitled to speak in a matter of this kind. Apart from the fitness of the amendment, in the place where it is intended to be put, I want to ask the Dáil to consider whether some such provision should not be included in the Bill. It asks that there should be some discrimination, and that a person having three or more children dependent upon him under the age of 16 years shall not be imprisoned without trial. I think Deputy Gavan Duffy argued fairly when he said that the very sense of responsibility for children must be somewhat of a deterrent against the commission of acts which might bring a citizen under the provisions of the Bill, and that the very fact that such a citizen has responsibility to children ought to be security against the risk that he is going to be detained for a possible 6 months without trial. After all it is not the desire of the Dáil to visit the sins of the fathers upon the children and surely it is not, at least I hope it is not, the desire of the Dáil to visit upon the children the punishment which is an almost certain consequence of the arrest on suspicious of the father. Deputy Gavan Duffy has cited cases of families whose breadwinners have been in prison for some months and who are in actual physical want. On another occasion when a matter of this kind was mentioned it was said that there had been money provided and that the families of prisoners, the dependants of prisoners, had as a matter of fact been cared for. I happen to know one case, at any rate, where the family of a prisoner has not in fact been provided for, for the simple reason that the family had no connection whatever with any organisation which pretended or professed to take under its charge such prisoners. It is for the consideration of the children of people for whom there is no provision that I ask the Dáil to consider the merits of this amendment. It is no fanciful story or prophecy that Deputy Lyons has put forward for consideration when he says that the children of internees will grow up with a spirit of anger against the State which enforced upon them, on the mere suspicion of a captain of the Army, hunger, perhaps cold, perhaps shortage in many ways and upon their mother actual suffering, physical and mental. The Minister has told us, and it is no doubt his intention, that this Bill is designed to meet the transition period. That being the case, I would urge that there can be no great risk in providing an assurance that the heads of families are going to be immune from arrest and imprisonment without trial. The Minister has minimised the risks of persons being arrested and detained on suspicion, saying that such suspicion will have to be very well grounded before these imprisonments will continue. You are under this amendment asked to provide that the children will be protected against the risk that their father or their mother, who may be the bread-winner, shall be detained for a period of six months merely on suspicion. I personally am not satisfied that the best way to arrive at that end is by this means. I am not sure that the form of the motion or the place in the Bill is the most fitting, but I am sure Deputy Gavan Duffy is not considering the verbal form of this amendment so long as he can get a positive assurance that the children of citizens are not going to be allowed to suffer, and that the parents are not going to be imprisoned on suspicion and their children allowed to suffer. I think it is to his credit, and I hope the Dáil will participate in that credit, that he should have regard to the children of possible suspects, and try to make provision in the Bill for safeguarding their interests. I would ask the Dáil to vote in favour of the insertion of this new section.

Comment on this

It is all right to adopt a humanitarian attitude, and it certainly is very popular on all occasions. This amendment is with regard to the imprisonment on suspicion of parents who are heads of families. I know an occasion where the head of a family happened to be in the National Army. He came home on leave for a few days. He was the father of ten. The mother came out of the infirmary a week or two previously. There had been twins four months previously. A certain party came to his house, nine or ten men, at two o'clock in the morning, and gave him a trial. They took him out from the bed where one of the twins, four months old, was sleeping, and shot him after three hours of a trial and something more than a trial. If he had been shot decently it would have been all right.

Comment on this

Would it?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

On a point of order I am sure that the Deputy would not desire it to go down in the records that it was all right if he had been shot by these persons decently.

Comment on this

It would have been better; but he was not shot decently. Supposing there was another head of a family under suspicion for this offence. Has the Opposition on any occasion advocated that those persons should be brought to justice, or that those who bring them to justice should be facilitated? Have we always to adopt this humanitarian attitude? I want to ask have those who wish to bring culprits to justice been facilitated by the parties who are now humanitarians?

Comment on this

If the Deputy suggests that those of us whom he refers to as the Opposition in any way approve of the act or similar acts to that which he mentioned, he is making an implication that is not only undeserved, but one which we resent. So far as our judgment goes, we have not done anything that would prevent the proper authorities from taking proper action in such cases as that. What we did object to were certain things which we thought improper.

Comment on this
Eoin MacNeill MINISTER for EDUCATION (Prof. MacNeill) Sinn Féin

Is this discussion in order?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Deputy O'Donnell speaks so seldom that I heard him patiently to the end. When he had told his story he spoke two sentences that were relevant to the amendment. Then he went away from the amendment to make a statement that I was not quite sure about, and which Deputy O'Shannon has refuted. I think it is hardly necessary to refute those statements. I do not think that Deputy O'Donnell had in his mind that Deputy O'Shannon or anyone associated with him would not do his best to trace up crimes of that sort.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Donnell's assertion is one of a series of similar statements charging us with condoning crime, and I resent it. The Minister for Education did not call Deputy O'Donnell to order.

Comment on this
Eoin MacNeill Professor MacNEILL Sinn Féin

I have asked if the discussion was in order. If Deputy O'Donnell went out of order, and if Deputy Johnson was of opinion that he did, he should have called attention to it at the time. I now ask if it is in order on the amendment.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

No, the discussion is not in order, but, as I say. Deputy O'Donnell speaks so seldom that I allowed him to develop what I thought possibly might be an argument for or against the amendment. He said something at the end which Deputy O'Shannon interprets that Deputy O'Shannon and all associated with him would not assist in tracing people committing a crime such as Deputy O'Donnell describes. Surely Deputy O'Donnell does not mean that?

Comment on this

No. What I mean is that all parties who come to this Dáil and have any respect for the dignity of this Dáil should always facilitate the parties in every legitimate way who are out to trace up crimes of all kinds.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

That is an excellent statement, with which we all agree, but which has no relevance at all to the amendment. Deputy O'Shannon can now continue on the amendment.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 15
·
Níl 38
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

In Sub-section (1) to insert after the word "experience," the words "and of whom the two others shall be persons well known and distinguished for their integrity, their sense of justice and their impartial judgment."

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Amendment No. 19 is not in order on the ground of vagueness. It is altogether too vague to be inserted in an Act of Parliament.

Comment on this

It is a minor amendment in itself. The purpose of it is to draw attention to the need for some definition. Perhaps its definition is vague. May I amend this by having words put in now or at the next stage?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

No. I told the Deputy several days ago that this amendment was too vague, and I have not received any further word from him since.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I will bear in mind the class of person whom the Deputy thinks ought to be appointed.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

It would be possible on Report to improve the matter.

Amendment (20) by

Comment on this
William O'Brien Messrs. O'BRIEN and NAGLE Labour Party

In Sub-section (2), after the word "authorities," to insert the words "and any person serving a sentence of imprisonment or penal servitude imposed on him by a tribunal established by the military authorities."

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

This amendment follows 16, I think. Amendment 21 next.

Comment on this

Do you rule 20 out of order?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Amendment 20 is the same, it appears to me, as amendment 16.

Comment on this

Yes, but Amendment 16 referred to a person being detained until an Appeal Council, upon a review of his case, reduced or remitted his sentence. Amendment No. 20 says: "any person detained may in the prescribed manner request that an enquiry into the matter of his detention be made by an Appeal Council." One is the case of the application; the other provides for the continuance of the sentence.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Amendment 16 provided for the review by an Appeal Council of sentences imposed by the Military Authorities. That was rejected. Amendment 20 provides an appeal for the same persons to an Appeal Council.

Comment on this

With all respect, Sub-section (3) of Section 3 dealt with the continuation of the sentences until the decision. The amendment proposed that such a decision should come to an end when the tribunal decided to remit sentences. That was rejected but provision was promised for insertion at the next Stage that the sentences should not extend longer than the Act extended.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Was that assurance given?

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

No. I think the Deputy is making a mistake. The assurance given was that words would be added to the Section to provide that persons serving sentences——

Comment on this

I beg the Minister's pardon; I misread my note. The promise was that so long as it is not expired it will be something of this nature: "until such time as such sentence is reviewed by a competent tribunal." The amendment dealt with the period of a sentence. This amendment proposes to give power to the prisoners to appeal.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

"To an Appeal Council established under this Act."

Comment on this

Exactly, and I submit that that is not consequent in any way on amendment No. 16.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

The question of a tribunal to be set up subsequently is not the same as the question of an Appeal Council to be set up under this Act. Amendment 16 said that "Every person who at the date of the passing of this Act is serving a sentence of imprisonment of penal servitude imposed on him by a tribunal established by the Military Authorities shall, whether he is or is not a person ordinarily subject to military law, continue to serve such sentence so long as it is unexpired, or until an Appeal Council, upon review of his case in manner provided by this Act, reduces or remits the sentence imposed by the tribunal." The question debated on that was whether or not a sentenced prisoner should have an Appeal Council established under this Act. Is that correct?

Comment on this

I think that is not correct. I think the question was whether the sentence should continue until it has expired, which may be six months after the passing of the Act. The contention was made that it was indefinite, and the amendment had to do with the indefinite nature of the sentence. That amendment was lost, but there was a promise given that a tribunal would be set up which would review it, but now we are coming to an entirely different proposition. Sub-section 2 says:—"Any person detained in custody under this Act, whether made under an order of an Executive Minister or by the military authorities." And we desire to insert "and any person serving a sentence of imprisonment or penal servitude imposed on him by a tribunal established by the military authorities may request an inquiry into the matter of his detention be made by the Appeal Council." I submit that is an entirely different question from the one respecting the continuation of the sentence until expiry of that sentence.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

The discussion that took place on Amendment 16 made it clear that the acceptance of the amendment would involve a complete change in the character of the tribunal which it is proposed to establish under this Act. There are, as I pointed out, Advisory Departmental Committees, and they are in no sense Courts, still less Courts of Appeal, and, in my opinion, to proceed with the discussion of Amendment No. 20 would be covering precisely the same ground as was covered in the discussion on Amendment No. 16, and to vote on it would be to vote on precisely the same issue.

Comment on this

There is a further point. Whatever discussion has been, I do not for a moment admit it was out of order; if it has been we should have been called to order. The issue is whether the amendment now before us is in order, not whether the discussion would be the same discussion. It is whether the amendment to be discussed is in order, and I submit that it is perfectly in order, notwithstanding what the Minister says about the Appeal Council, for the Council has not yet been set up. It is being set up by the clause we are discussing, and it may be altered radically before the Dáil passes from this section.

Comment on this

The statement the Minister has just made rather backs the case made by Deputy Johnson, for if one kind of Council were contemplated in Amendment No. 16, and later the Minister gave a definition which would not correspond to the kind of Council contemplated in Amendment No. 16, I submit that this amendment is quite in order, because it is an amendment of a particular kind of Council which has now been defined by the Minister.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

I made no suggestion that the discussion of Amendment No. 16 was out of order. The question decided by the vote on Amendment 16 was that certain persons shall not have sentences upon them reviewed by an Appeal Council in manner provided by this Act. If we discussed this amendment we would be asked to take the very same decision and the amendment, therefore, cannot be discussed, because we cannot discuss and decide the same thing twice on Committee, but if it transpires on a further stage that the Appeal Council is substantially altered, and if any amendment is put up, then the amendment would be decided, and the question of the order of the amendment for the next stage will be decided upon, having consideration to all the relevant facts.

Comment on this

With all due deference, might I point out that on Section 3 the Appeal Council had not been reached. It was a tribunal that was referred to in Section 3. The question of an Appeal Council had not been reached or touched at that time. Therefore we were not aware of it in detail.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

That is exactly what I have said. If it transpires that there is any necessity for again discussing this matter, which was discussed on Amendment 16, facilities will be provided for that discussion. Facilities cannot be provided now. The amendment is, consequential on the defeat of Amendment 16, out of order.

Comment on this

I beg to move:

To add to Sub-Section (2) the words, "It shall be lawful for the Governor, or other the person in chief control of any place of detention, to recommend for release any person or persons detained under his charge, and to bring the case of any such person or persons to the notice of an Appeal Council, who shall thereupon enquire into the same."

This amendment deals with a matter of machinery, and I am proposing on the assumption that the Appeal Section will be very considerably modified before it goes through the Dáil. I will reserve what I want to say about the Appeal Council until the proper stage. The object of the amendment is merely this: that the person who is best qualified on behalf of the Executive to judge of the kind of people who are interned, namely the person in charge of internees, should be in a position to recommend internees for release and to bring their case before the Appeal Council. I think the Dáil will realise that that is a very reasonable suggestion. It has always seemed to me a strange thing that Prison Governors at the present time have no right, no authority, no jurisdiction to recommend prisoners for release. I do not think this amendment needs any commendation. It speaks for itself. I trust the Dáil will agree that it should be lawful for the Governor or any other person in control of a place of detention to recommend for release any person or persons detained under his charge, and to bring the case of any such person or persons to the notice of an Appeal Council, who shall thereupon enquire into the same.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

took the Chair at this stage.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I am not accepting this amendment. It is proposed to give to detained persons the right of appeal to this Council. It is not proposed to authorise any person to act as proxy for them in the matter of such appeal. It is not any part of the official duties of the Governor in such a case to make recommendations with regard to release, and it is not proposed to add that particular function to his official duties. If information is required with regard to prisoners it will be asked for from the Governors of such places, and I have no doubt that it will be given. But the amendment proposes to go further and to impose on Governors the duty of recommending persons for release and bringing their cases before the Appeal Council. The amendment contains nothing useful and nothing helpful. If a prisoner wants to appeal to the Council he can surely appeal himself. If he does not want to appeal to the Appeal Council, why is it proposed to put the duty on the Governor to appeal for him?

Comment on this

I am not very enthusiastic about the amendment, because, as the Minister says, it does give a certain new function to the Governor, and I am not sure that this is a particular one that should be given. Perhaps my lack of enthusiasm for the amendment is due more to the form in which it appears than to the intention behind it. I think, for instance, that nothing should be put in the way of a Governor if he thinks fit to take steps to facilitate, either by exercising persuasion on a prisoner or otherwise, an appeal by that prisoner to the Appeal Council. The Amendment, perhaps, goes a little beyond that. I am not quite sure—I have some doubts about the wording of it—but it seems to me that it goes a little beyond that. On the main question, I think that it should be the duty of the Executive Council and of all authorities to facilitate in every possible way the exercising of the right of appeal, and, in any way which may be considered legitimate, to help the discharge of prisoners. I think that that is a general principle that is adopted at the end, or towards the end, of all periods of trouble, and I should not like the Ministry to be acting on the view that it is not their business, but that it is wholly and entirely the business of the prisoner himself, to take such steps as will help him to get out. I think that the duty of a Government is greater and more extensive than the mere negative duty of permitting a prisoner, if he so desires, to do certain things. I think it is its duty rather to help and facilitate in every way the prisoner doing this. If I can be convinced that the amendment does not give more power than I suggest to the Governor, and that the giving of more power would not mean a radical change in the functions of a Governor then I would be inclined to support the amendment. I do not know that I would do so otherwise.

Comment on this

Would the mover of the amendment tell us whether under it it would be possible for the Governor to bring forward the case of a person to the Appeal Council although that particular person may not wish it to be brought forward? That would seem to be so from the wording of the amendment, and if so it would be very undesirable.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I beg to move: To insert after Sub-section (2) a new sub-section as follows:—

"At any inquiry under this Section the Appeal Council shall be furnished with the reports or certificates in virtue of which the person whose case is being inquired into is being detained."

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I will accept that amendment.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputy Davin I desire to move to insert after Sub-section (2) a new sub-section as follows:—

"Not less than ten days before any inquiry under this section the person whose case is to be inquired into shall be furnished with copies of the reports or certificates in virtue of which he is being detained, and with a statement of any charges or allegations against him which it is proposed to lay before the Appeal Council in justification of his detention."

There is, and always has been, a good case on the part of the prisoner for something of this kind. Although the main objection was really to alien government, practically every one of those who were interned from 1916 onwards objected, and rightly objected, on the ground that it was an alien government, that it had no right to detain them, and also on the other ground, the insufficiency of cause shown. They objected to the summary manner in which their liberty was taken away from them for the time. Many members of this Dáil were in that position. They will remember that on the mere order of a Secretary of State they were arrested, detained and interned. In that case there was an Appeal Council, or an Advisory Council, not exactly of the same nature as this particular one, but one whose function in a broad sense was to hear appeals. Now, when internees or detained persons went before that Court, the Court had plenty of material, and the prisoner or internee had no idea in the wide world of what that material was. There was no means by which, the prisoner, if he so desired—many did not take advantage of the privilege or the right at all, and others who went there denied the right of the Court—who went before the Advisory Committee could know what was against him, except that a Secretary of State, under 14B of certain Regulations, had ordered that he should be detained. Now, some of the material came out in the course of questions put by members of the Council to the prisoner. I remember the case of a certain person who was prominent in athletics, and one of the pieces of information that came out, perhaps not against him, but out of the volume of information, was that on a certain date fifteen years previously he had attended a Rugby football match at a certain place. The intention of this amendment is to give the prisoner some chance. On the one side you have the authorities well briefed, and on the other side you have the prisoner completely ignorant of what is going to be used against him, and which will undoubtedly, if the authorities consider it necessary, be brought before the Appeal Council. I think it is fair and reasonable that, before making his appeal to this Council, the prisoner should be entitled and enabled to do what the amendment asks. It is not, I think, too much to ask. As a general rule it is the practice in ordinary common law. It is common even in courtsmartial, where there is at least a preliminary investigation, at which the prisoner has some means of knowing what exactly the prosecution has against him. Something of that kind, to help the prisoner at the Appeal Council, is wanted—something like what the amendment proposes to give.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

In this amendment as in others we come definitely to the question of the character of these Appeal Councils, and a thing I want Deputies to keep well in mind is that these are not Courts. The whole principle of the Bill is to give to the Executive, because of an emergency situation, the power to detain persons without trial and without charge. It is a very big and a very drastic power— one that can only be justified, as I say, by an emergency situation which challenges the very existence of the State. One could, as I said yesterday, talk for hours on the soundness of the principle that a person ought to be assumed innocent until proved guilty. That is a good, sound principle. Almost every State in the world, I suppose, recognises and acts upon it. Equally every State will, in time of great stress, in time of great emergency, ask power from its Parliament to depart from it, and ask power to detain citizens on something short of legal proof; and everything short of legal proof is called suspicion, for want of a better word. It may be a moral certainty, but it is something, at any rate, which could not be supported by strict evidence before a Court. These Appeal Councils are set up to give detained persons an opportunity of showing cause why they should not be further detained, and to show cause why suspicion ought not to rest upon them with regard to particular offences. I have promised, by accepting a previous amendment, that the Appeal Councils themselves will be in possession of such reports and information as is at the disposal of the Executive with regard to the prisoner who appears before them. It is not proposed to put such information before the prisoner. On the Report Stage I would undertake to introduce something to this effect: "That a detained person appealing to the Appeal Councils shall be informed of what offence in the Schedule of this Act he is reasonably suspect." That at least will give him the general grounds on which he can proceed to base his case and his appeal. I would not undertake that prisoners will receive a copy of the specific charges or a statement of specific evidence against them. Yesterday, in dealing with this matter, I pointed out that in a certain situation —in a situation of turmoil and revolt and outrage generally—it is very advisable that the Executive should not disclose or give information that might lead to the disclosure of the source of its information with regard to particular prisoners. It might be a question of life and death upon this prisoner obtaining his release. We are asking power in the Bill to arrest and detain persons whose liberty is held to be prejudicial to the public safety. We will undertake to use that power in the most guarded and conservative fashion, but we cannot allow these Advisory Committees to take on the character of Courts. The prisoner will not be charged. But he can come before the Appeal Council and say: "I see no reason whatsoever why the Executive should think I am a proper person to be detained. I see no reason whatsoever why suspicion should rest upon me with regard to any of these offences, and I adduce here before this Council or Committee certain evidence of my good citizenship, certain references as to character, and so on." But it is not a Court; it is a Committee. We will lay before that Committee the reasons that led to the arrest and detention of the prisoner, and the Committee will hear the prisoner on the question as to why he should not be detained in that fashion. Anything further than that would give to these tribunals the character of Courts. Who would they have to try? Not prisoners. The prisoner is not charged. The whole purport of this Bill is to enable people to be detained without charge or trial, and it seems to me to give any further power than that would constitute a Court of that Committee, and a Court to try the Executive as to its use of the powers given by this Bill. That would be wholly wrong and a wholly anomalous situation. These Councils will be Advisory Departmental Committees. They will have at their disposal, to some extent at all events, the material upon which the arrest and detention of a person is based; they will have in substance the case of the Executive for the detention of that person. They will hear the prisoner on his aspect of the thing, and on the question of why he should not be further detained, and they may examine and cross-question the prisoner, and they will finally make their recommendation to the Executive. But we cannot agree to serve upon the prisoner a specific charge, or to place in his possession the information at our disposal with regard to him. To do so might lead to very grave danger to persons outside.

Comment on this

The Minister's statement rather belies the title he is giving to these Councils. He has decided that the Councils should be called Appeal Councils, but he has told us that they are not to be Appeal Councils at all; they are to be Advisory Committees to the Executive Council. I think it would be much better that the Bill should actually state what it is that the Minister's desire was when drafting the Bill, and that the Dáil should know what it is agreeing to. I think Deputy FitzGibbon rather commended the provisions of this Bill, especially the Appeal Councils, on the ground that it was some movement towards trial by Court. Now the Minister informs us that they are not to be Appeal Councils, and that they are really not to do anything more than has already been done by Ministers themselves. It has been competent, I am glad to acknowledge, for prisoners to make representation to Ministers, and to ask for a release on certain conditions, and Ministers have decided on cases without any Appeal Councils. They have taken the whole responsibility for detaining or releasing; they may have had Advisory Committees or they may not; they may have already in existence Advisory Committees of whom one person at least on each Committee "has legal knowledge and experience." I assume that they have had such Committees, or at least that they have had some such advice. It seems unnecessary to embody in a Bill of this kind a provision setting up Appeal Council Committees, which one may presume are already in existence, or if they are not in existence that the Ministers have already power to set up. But, according to the Minister, it is quite a misnomer to speak of this as an Appeal Council. They have no power except to advise the Minister, and he has claimed the right to refuse that advice if he wishes. That cannot be called an Appeal Council, and it seems rather to tend towards making little of the legal profession to ask them to appear before, or to sit on, a body called an Appeal Council which, in fact, has no right to decide anything, and which is, in fact, a mere Advisory Committee to the Minister, but whose advice need not be taken. I think the draughtsman of the Bill either misinterpreted the original instructions, or the Minister has retrograded since the instructions were given, or he has forgotten what these instructions were. We ask him to go back and think rather of the intentions of the Bill when he gives the name to his Councils of Appeal Councils, and not to confine their functions to that of Advisory Committees.

The amendment surely is not an unreasonable one. I understand that the Sankey Committee was frankly and openly an Advisory Committee, but even as an Advisory Committee the provision there was that the Chairman of such Committee must be a High Court Judge. This Committee is to be of less importance than that, inasmuch as all that is required of one of the members is that he "shall be a person of legal knowledge and experience." That is, however, by the way. If one is purporting to give to a prisoner rights or privileges that he has not hitherto had, to appear before a Council, it is surely not enough simply to tell that prisoner of what offence he has been suspected. It is reasonable, I suggest, to give that prisoner some information which he can reply to and answer, and to make some charge in respect of, not merely the offence, but the time and the circumstances in which it is suspected the prisoner was guilty of such an offence. How can a prisoner prove his innocence of a charge that is not made against him? We have been asked to agree to a Bill which purports to give an opportunity to a prisoner to prove his innocence. That reverses the normal practice, which was to ask the prosecutor to prove the prisoner's guilt? But not only are we now asked to give powers, or to impose upon the prisoner the duty of proving his innocence, but he is to prove his innocence of a charge which is not made, and, having proved his innocence of a charge that is not made, and having been able to convince the Appeal Council that he has proved his innocence of a charge that has not been made, the Minister still reserves to himself the right to refuse the advice of that Advisory Committee. However, that is perhaps going a little too fast, because that matter will come up on a later amendment. I would urge it is only reasonable that the cause which the Appeal Council is to inquire into shall not merely be before the Appeal Council, but that the prisoner himself shall have some knowledge of the case that is made against him, and of the charges, and of some of the circumstances upon which the suspicion has been formed. The Appeal Council will have had under the Bill itself certain information, but unless it is provided that the Appeal Council shall have the duty of examining and cross-examining a prisoner and of inquiring into all the circumstances surrounding the prisoner's activities round about a particular period, unless that duty is mandatory upon the Appeal Council, the prisoner's opportunities of proving his innocence may be nil, because all he is to be informed of is the offence, in a long series of offences, of which he is suspected of being guilty. The prisoner may be suspected of assisting in, or encouraging, the commission of one of many offences. He has been arrested and detained on that charge, and that is all that is to be told to him. He appears before a Court, and has to prove to that Court that he is innocent of assisting in the commission of one or of a dozen or of twenty different offences. I would urge the Minister to think more seriously of the responsibility he is putting upon the Appeal Council, and of how much easier it would be for that Council to inquire into a case if the prisoner is given some knowledge of the case that is made against him.

Comment on this

I desire to support this amendment. I take it the intention of this Bill will be, particularly if the amendment to this section is properly applied, to reduce to a minimum the number of people who are in custody on suspicion or on definite charges. Section 2 of the Bill says: "Any person detained in custody under this Act, whether under an order of the Executive Minister or by the military authorities, may in the prescribed manner request that an inquiry into the matter of his detention be made by an Appeal Council." I have always tried to look at this question from the point of view that there are several classes of people at present detained. There are people who, perhaps from high political motives, may have answered the call of leaders, believing that they were doing right. The number of people who responded to such an appeal, and who had previously done anything during the period of the Anglo-Irish war, may be comparatively small, taking into consideration the very large numbers of people at present detained. I take it that that class of prisoner would be reluctant to make an appeal to any tribunal set up under this or any other section of the Bill for the purpose of obtaining his release. But there is a class of prisoner, the class which has been interned and is being detained on suspicion, which would undoubtedly take advantage of whatever Appeal Tribunal would be set up, and I think it would be an encouragement to that class of prisoner to appeal to the tribunal if he was in possession of the actual charge on which he is being detained. In dealing with this matter of detention and the question of releases the Government and everybody who has an interest in the prisoners, or in the proper administration of the Government, must look at the question not from the point of view of everybody who has an interest in the prisoners, or in the proper administration of the Government, must look at the question not from the point of view of the individual who has a grievance because he feels he is wrongly detained on suspicion. If, for the sake of argument, a brother of the Minister himself was detained on suspicion and interned, and that the Minister and those of his family connections knew quite well that there was no reason, from their knowledge of his movements, why he should be detained, we can see that the opposition to the Government goes right through the family and affects a far greater number than the individual who is personally concerned. I think that is one of the reasons why an amendment of this kind should be accepted in order to minimise the opposition to the Government, and to reduce to a minimum a number of people who are detained or interned longer, at any rate, than they should be.

Comment on this

Speaking a while ago, the Minister said there would be danger, if this amendment were accepted, or if anything like this were done, that the sources of the Government's information might be disclosed, to the personal danger of certain people, perhaps, as well as to the danger of the State. I would not suggest that the sources of information should be disclosed in such a way as to justify the Ministry's fears. Not at all. The intention of the amendment could be quite well achieved without going to the length which the Minister seems to contemplate. The Minister says that the prisoner appealing will be informed of which of the offences mentioned in the Schedule he is suspected.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

As a matter of practice he will probably be informed of a good deal more. I want to draw a distinction between practice and a right. If you set down here that the prisoner shall receive a copy of the charge and all the evidence against him, you make a Court of this Appeal Council, and you give the prisoner an absolute right to be charged and tried. In point of fact, this is an Appeal Council to hear the prisoner on the question as to why he should not be further detained, and as a matter of practice the prisoner will receive all the information that it is considered right or safe to give him on the question of the reason why he is detained. If you set it down here in the Bill, you would make it a matter of absolute right, and you would make of the Advisory Council a Court, and that is where the objection lies.

Comment on this

That is a very important statement of the Minister as to practice. It was the point that I was about to raise. But if we had more information really about the Council we would not be working so much in the dark. I had taken a note to raise the question of the procedure of the Court. The section does not prescribe the procedure of the Court. The Minister now says that the Executive authority in dealing with the Appeal Council will adopt a certain practice. I presume that we can accept the word of the Minister on that. But he may not be the Minister who will exercise the powers given in this at all. For that reason I think it is necessary that there should be some better definition in the section of the rights or, if you like to put it, the privileges of the prisoners. Even if a prisoner is informed that he is suspected of one of these offences, and he is told something more than that, I wonder whether he is going to be told that at a certain time or on a certain occasion a certain one of these offences was committed, and that he was suspected of that? The Minister might say that that may disclose information which he does not want to be disclosed. and which he thinks it would be dangerous to disclose. But the offences, as given down here, are so wide that, taken not as charges, but as matters for suspicion, it would be extremely difficult for any prisoner, unless he has a great deal of information—more than I think is contemplated—to make a case. Some Deputies will remember that formerly one of the grounds on which people were interned was that they were associated with certain other people who were suspected of acting or being about to act—the Deputies will remember the rest of the phraseology. I know a Deputy who is a personal friend of a certain man in his town. That friend was deported and interned along with that particular Deputy. He was kept in detention even after the appeal to the Sankey Committee, although the Deputy's friend had not hand, act or part in any particular activity in the particular Western town to which he belonged. He was suspected, presumably, because of his association with this Deputy. Now, the present situation lends itself to that kind of thing. If, in a case like that, that internee had known the real grounds on which he was suspected, it might have been possible for him to make a case at the Appeal Council. He did not, and he was not able to make a case, and it was extremely difficult for anyone to make a case. Take, for instance, Section 12: "Aiding, abetting, assisting in or encouraging." Take that in conjunction with 10 and 11. It might be claimed that the Appeal Council might feel it was justified in detaining a prisoner because he was associated with somebody whom the Appeal Council had already convinced itself was reasonably suspected of some one of these offences. I think there is a case, if there is not too wide an interpretation given to the amendment, for the acceptance of the amendment, and that it would not go so far in the direction of making a Court with actual powers of release and anything like that, as the Minister seems to think. I will ask the Minister to accept it.

Comment on this

I support this amendment. I think it is only right that the prisoner that you are about to place before a tribunal of justice, or before the Appeal Council, should know the exact nature of what he is supposed to be charged with, and that he should know also every particle of evidence that was in your possession. I think it would be only fair that you should furnish the prisoner with such evidence, so that he may be able to put forward any evidence which he himself possessed or could offer to the Court with a view to proving his innocence.

The Minister has already said the prisoner would be brought before the Appeal Council. The amendment goes a little further and states "not less than ten days before any enquiry under this Section, a person whose case is to be enquired into shall be furnished with copies of the reports or certificates in virtue of which he is being detained." When you have such a large number of prisoners at the present moment, not taking into account the number likely to be interned under this new Act, it is only fair that those persons should get an opportunity of proving their innocence. If you take a man and detain him behind prison walls for a fortnight, three weeks, or a month, and at the end of that time you say to him "You are to be placed on trial to-morrow," it is hardly fair that he should not be given some particulars of the charge preferred against him. If you give him only 24 hours' notice, the man has no chance of getting together any evidence so as to contradict the evidence brought against him by the prosecuting solicitor, or whoever may be in charge on behalf of the Minister for Home Affairs. It is only right that the prisoner should be placed in such a position that he shall have furnished to him the evidence to be brought forward against him.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

As a matter of explanation, I would like to say it is not a trial. There is no charge. A person whose liberty is interfered with under the provisions of the Bill will be told there is an Advisory Committee, an Appeal Council, before which he may appear if he considers that he can show cause why he should not be further detained, and why, in fact, he never should have been arrested. In other words, he may be told, "If you feel you are innocent, you can come before a body of reasonable men and convince them a mistake has been made in your case." There is no use in the Deputy keeping on using such words as trial, and charges, and so on, after I have explained very fully that it is not a trial and this body will not be a Court. We are very emphatic on that. The whole principle of the Bill is to entitle the Executive, in view of a special emergency situation, to detain people without trial.

Comment on this

That is all the more reason why a person who is to be brought forward——

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

He is not to be brought forward; he is to come forward.

Comment on this

You have him in your custody, and if he is not a prisoner, why not release him without setting up any Appeal Council that he is to go before? If what the Minister states is correct, there is all the more reason why the prisoner should be previously furnished with particulars. Take, for example, that I am the prisoner. If I am the victim that you may choose to lay your claw upon, just like a hawk watching for an unfortunate little swallow who might happen to be around, I should have some opportunity of defending myself. Just like the hawk, you and your associates are watching to see what victim may come into your grasp, so that you could sentence that victim to a term, even if it were only a few days, in order that you can show your authority. The explanation of the Minister for Home Affairs proves more clearly why the amendment should be accepted. It is only fair that a prisoner should be given an opportunity to show why he should not be detained, and for this purpose he should be supplied with copies of the evidence brought against him by the Minister for Home Affairs or his servants. It would be only right to furnish him with that evidence ten days before he is to be brought forward. Then he could be in a position to tell you why you must release him. If an innocent man is interned he cannot get an opportunity of explaining why he had been arrested. He is simply told he is arrested on suspicion; he has no knowledge of the evidence that is in the possession of his captors. He is just like a little bird in a cage. The wires are all round him. In this case the place of the wires is taken by the associates of the Minister for Home Affairs. They are so closely around that it is impossible for him to get out unless the Minister opens some avenue, and, in my opinion, the best way to open that avenue is to accept this amendment.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 13
·
Níl 42
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I propose the following amendment:—To insert after Sub-section (2) a new sub-section as follows:—

"Every person whose case is inquired into by an Appeal Council shall be afforded reasonable facilities to obtain legal advice and assistance before the inquiry is held, and may appear before the Appeal Council in person and/or by counsel or solicitor or a friend on his behalf."

I am sure that the Minister in charge of this Bill cannot possibly find an argument to offer against this amendment, or that he does not want to deny the right of a person whose case is to be inquired into of getting in touch with a solicitor or appearing in person before the tribunals. If this amendment is accepted it will certainly go a good way to facilitate some of those persons who will be brought before these Councils. Take, for example, the person who is detained in custody. If the solicitor is notified twenty-four hours before that person is to be taken forward to give an account of himself the whole conversation between the solicitor and client is overheard by a warder or soldier standing by. There is many a thing to be said probably by a solicitor to his client, or a client to his solicitor, which they do not want the soldier, policeman or warder to hear. Furthermore, I am sure the Minister has already explained that the prisoner will appear in person. If so, we can take it for granted that that portion of the amendment is already accepted. I do not think that it is possible for any honest, straightforward and just-minded, thinking man to deny the right of any person whom he may have in his power to procure some legal aid so that he may be able to prove his innocence of any of the charges that have been brought against him. I know it is the duty of the Government to prove a man guilty. Under this Bill it lies with the person himself to prove that he is innocent. If this amendment is accepted you shall give a person whom you have in your power an opportunity of appearing personally before the Appeal Council and of hearing every particle of evidence that is brought against him. You will be also facilitating him by allowing his solicitor to visit him without the aid of one of your soldiers, warders or policemen.

Surely we must for a moment cast our minds back. I am sure every Deputy in this Dáil can well recollect the human cry that went out from the nation that no person could possibly have a conversation with his solicitor simply because there was somebody always standing by to hear the conversation. All the words pronounced by the solicitor to the client or the client to the solicitor were known by the people who were directed to prove against the man a charge of which he was not guilty. I will ask the Minister to accept this amendment. I would like, of course, that the amendment should be accepted, not alone because it may help some of the prisoners already behind the prison walls, but because it will also help some of those persons that are still at prison walls, but because it may help some of those persons that are still at large and honestly watching and waiting for this Bill to get through the Dáil, so that the hawk of the Saorstát might not be able to lay its claw upon its prey and put it inside. The hawk of the Saorstát, to my mind, is a particular class of bird out listening to and watching everything people have to say, and under this Bill persons will be able to give a certain amount of information about many innocent men and women who may have to appear before this Appeal Council. It is for that purpose that I ask the Minister to accept this amendment giving those persons whose cases are to be inquired into by the Appeal Council an opportunity to get legal aid, legal assistance, and appear before the Council in person, so that they may be able to prove their innocence and be set free, and, above all things, that they shall not be kept at the expense of the ratepayers.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I am not accepting this amendment, and my reasons for refusing it are simply the reasons I have given in connection with previous amendments that this body will not be a Court before which prisoners will be tried on a specific charge. It is a body set up to act as much in the interest of the detained persons as in the interest of the State. It will be substantially in possession of the Executive side of the question. With that before it and at its disposal, it will proceed to hear the prisoner on the question of why he should not be further detained. There will be nothing technical about it. It is a body of one legal man and two sensible laymen, and hearing two aspects of the question, they will come to a conclusion and make their recommendation to the Minister. To surround this thing with the trappings and procedure of a Court would be to convey a doubly wrong impression, as I have remarked before. There is a very special situation. Deputies, I think, will not question that, and in that situation the Executive asks Parliament, as it is its duty to ask Parliament, for all the powers which it thinks necessary to deal adequately with that situation. We ask for the very special power of interfering with the liberty of citizens to the extent of detaining them for a period without trial or without making specific charges against them.

Deputies must know that people have been active against the State and against the citizens for ten months who are now detained, and against whom it would be impossible to prove a specific charge in Court. It is simply common knowledge in that vague way that they were leaders of a column perhaps in an area, they were known to have been connected with particular acts of outrage and destruction, but it would be a very different thing to prove that in Court. There would be the difficulty of securing evidence. There is far more physical courage in this country than moral courage, and in a time like the present people are unwilling to come forward and give evidence with regard to offences. We are asking power to detain persons without trial for a period of six months. This body, the Appeal Council, is not a Court, but it is a body set up to deal between the detained person and the Executive, lest mistakes should occur. Mistakes conceivably might occur.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

And the prisoner who feels that, can come before a body of sensible men and put his case to them, give his references, and so on, and the mistake can be rectified. He will get that opportunity. But this is not a Court, and we do not propose to have solicitors appearing on behalf of prisoners in connection with it. If a prisoner is an honest man, with just that average share of intelligence which a normal man has, he can appear before this body and put his case perhaps better than any subtle lawyer could put it, and the very plainness and bluntness and frankness with which he can put his own case would probably be the biggest factor in the minds of this advisory body. I cannot accept the Deputy's amendment, and I stress the point that the members of this Council will be there as much in the interests of the persons who come before them as in the interests of the Executive, and having heard what they have to say for themselves, and weighing that with what has been put at their disposal by the Executive as the reasons for the arrest and detention of the persons who come before them, they will discuss matters between themselves, and come to a conclusion and make their recommendation. That is the conception of the Appeal Council.

Comment on this

I thought when listening to the speech of Deputy Lyons that if his arguments were not sufficient to convince the Minister as to the necessity for this amendment that, at least, the tone of his voice would have struck a very weak chord in the Minister's heart, and would have persuaded him to take a view contrary to the one he has now expressed. I, at least, expected that every Deputy with a legal training would have stood up to back up an amendment of this kind. Paragraph 1 of Clause 4 states "as soon as may be after the passing of this Act there shall be established by the Executive Minister one or more Appeal Councils consisting of not less than three members, of whom one shall be a person certified by the Attorney-General to have legal knowledge and experience."

What is the meaning of having on this Tribunal, if there is nothing technical about its conduct, a person who is certified by the Attorney-General to have legal knowledge and experience? It is either a Court or it is not a Court, and if it be necessary to have a legal gentleman whose knowledge of legal matters cannot be disputed, I think it is very desirable, in the interest of the prisoner, that he should have some legal advice, or somebody to deal with that particular gentleman who may be acting on behalf of the State. I take it that the presence of the legal gentleman on this Court, acting in company with two other commonsense individuals, will be for the purpose of determining any legal quibble that may arise with regard to the conduct of the Court or any argument that may be put up by the prisoner. The prisoner, no matter how intelligent he might be, would not be in a Court of this kind—and it is a Court, there is no use in putting any other complexion upon it, once you have a legal gentleman there on the one side——

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

He is not on the one side. That is where the Deputy is making a mistake. He is acting between the two parties—the Executive and the person whom the Executive has detained.

Comment on this

Who is paying him?

Comment on this

He is certified by the Attorney-General to have legal knowledge and experience, and he is there, I presume, first in the interests of the State and appointed by the State. It is for that reason, and that one alone, that I think this amendment should be open to the consideration or reconsideration of the Minister. No matter how intelligent a prisoner may be, he will not be able to answer or meet the arguments of any legal man. In the interests of the prisoner who recognises this particular Court, and I take it every prisoner is not prepared to do that, I think the Minister might reasonably accept this amendment. The Minister also seems to harp, in every argument he puts up against any amendment from this side, on the fact that these people were active against the State and against the citizens. I am sure the Minister, even in his wildest moments, would not say that every man now detained in prison has been active against the State and its citizens. This Bill makes provision for detention of men on suspicion on any ground, good or otherwise, of aiding and abetting. Deputy Cathal O'Shannon gave a case with regard to a person in the West of Ireland who, because he was associating with a Deputy during the troubled period——

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Long horns!

Comment on this

I could give an instance nearer home.

Comment on this

He was arrested, and in spite of an application to the Committee, which was dealing with cases of that kind, he was still detained. When the whole situation is reviewed, when this trouble is all over, and when all those at present in prison are released, I think it will be found that the action of the Government in imprisoning men on suspicion will have done nothing except throw a cloak of patriotism over a large number of men who did not deserve it—who did nothing for the country, for the Republic, or for anything else. It is recognised that any man who was imprisoned during the British regime in this country, whether on suspicion or for the commission of a political offence, came out a hero. Under an Irish Administration I do not think the Government should be prepared to encourage that. By refusing to give a prisoner an opportunity to prove his innocence they are furnishing him with a pretence of patriotism, when perhaps he has no right to such a clock.

Comment on this

I would like to support this amendment, which I think the Minister should accept. There is nothing in it that I can see which would invest this Court of Appeal with the trappings of an ordinary Court. It simply says that the prisoner shall have the right to consult counsel or a solicitor. The Minister says the prisoners are all of average intelligence. "Average intelligence" is rather a vague term. The Minister knows as well as I do that there are men in prison who would not be able to put their case before a Court. As the last speaker said, there are innocent men in prison who may find it difficult to prove their innocence. If those prisoners who are innocent got an opportunity of consulting a solicitor and stating the reasons to him as to why they should be released, and if he were allowed to put those reasons before the Court, I think it would be only fair to the prisoner, especially when the President of the Court will himself be a legal gentleman.

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister to bear in mind the case of a young country man or a young country boy taken up here and interned. That man will not go before a tribunal; and even if he did, he would not be able to put his case as it should be put. We all know that all country men are more or less nervous when going before a gentleman looking at them, perhaps, through an eye-glass. If that man had the assistance of a legal gentleman he would be able to make a very good case. In fact, I am sure that if the Minister read the case he would let him out at once.

Comment on this

After hearing the argument put forward by the Minister against this amendment, I can assure the Dáil that it has not in the least convinced me. I am well aware that the members of the Appeal Council may be there, as the Minister stated, as much on behalf of the prisoner as of the Government, but I would ask the Dáil to remember that the members of this Council will be employees. I am sure that when their salaries come out of the Exchequer of the Saorstát and are given to them, probably by the would-be boss or will-be boss, the Minister for Home Affairs——

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

The Deputy seems to be assuming that we want to keep innocent men in internment. We do not. The Deputy is assuming too much when he assumes any hostility or juxtaposition on our part to innocent men.

Comment on this

I am not assuming any hostility on your behalf against innocent men. It is the Minister himself who is assuming hostility. By not accepting that amendment he is proving that his intentions and the intentions of the Council are to intern and detain innocent men. As some of my colleagues have already explained, some men have not the courage to go before the Appeal Council. Some men may be nerve-struck owing to all the terrors that have taken place since 1921. If people who have lost their nerve are arrested on suspicion, and are not allowed to get legal advice to put their cases before the Appeal Council, I think it is ridiculous, absolutely ridiculous. If you have a charge against a person, you should give him an opportunity of getting legal aid. The Minister has not even yet stated whether the person concerned will be allowed to appear before the Appeal Council in person. Furthermore, I heard the Minister say that this Bill gave power to arrest, detain, and intern people without charge or trial for six months. The Minister may have made a mistake in using those words a few moments ago when he was answering me on this amendment. He made use of the words, "The Bill gives power to arrest and detain people without charge or trial for six months," although it says here in Section 2: "It shall be lawful for any responsible officer to arrest and detain in custody for any period not exceeding one week"—that is what the clause says—one week.

Comment on this
Eoin MacNeill Professor MacNEILL Sinn Féin

The Deputy is out of order.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

The Deputy must confine himself to the amendment on the Paper.

Comment on this

I am confining myself to the amendment on the Paper. I made use of the same words that the Minister used in arguing against this amendment, and if the Minister was allowed to proceed when he was out of order, then I think the same thing should apply to the Deputy. I would like the Minister to explain whether he really meant those words.

Comment on this
Eoin MacNeill Professor MacNEILL Sinn Féin

I submit that the Deputy is out of order. I am trying to protect the Deputy and keep him in order, although it is not my duty.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

The Deputy cannot go back and discuss a section already passed.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister fully realises the necessity there is for giving a prisoner an opportunity of contradicting any erroneous charges there may be against him. I would ask the Dáil to remember that the events of the past few years have seriously affected the nerves of a great many people. Deputies should also realise the strength of the arm of the law. You place the strength of the law against the weak arm of an individual. Surely he has not the strength or the full courage to stand against the mighty arm of the law without, at least, getting a little protection. He must have some protection, and the protection is given to him in this amendment. I fail to see why the Minister rejected it when he had already accepted the principle of it, at least, in a previous amendment, when he stated that the prisoner would appear before the Appeal Council in person.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

resumed the Chair at this stage.

Comment on this

I was hopeful that the Minister would meet this amendment, at least, part of the way. The case that he has made, in resisting the proposal that facilities should be given to a prisoner who appears before the Appeal Council to have legal advice, is that he does not desire—that it is not the intention—that this appearance before the Appeal Council will be the same as an appearance before a tribunal trying a case, and, consistent with that intention, he says that he does not desire that the prisoner making the appeal shall be confronted with all the legal trappings of a Court, and have around him, to speak for him, solicitors or lawyers, and to treat the court as if it were a court belonging to and siding with the Government. But I think there is force in the argument made by Deputies Davin and Lyons, that many prisoners are not of a capacity, not fitted to make the best of their own case in a court, to put it before even a body of three gentlemen friendly disposed towards the prisoner. One can imagine the session. There is a private room where the three members of the Appeal Council are meeting with the papers before them. I will assume that nobody else is present but the prisoner and the three persons constituting the court, and that they and the prisoner are on friendly terms. I think there is no one but has had experience of an individual appearing before unknown people and having to state his case. Deputy Burke, for instance, will recognise what I am suggesting, that a young man, or an old man, who perhaps has not had many associations with what he might call the gentry, will go into a room and be asked questions, and he is immediately off his guard. He does not know what he is doing. He is not merely off his guard, but his wits are not with him. He is not at home. He feels he is before a tribunal, although he may not be, in the Minister's view, and he cannot state his case. Now, even if he had a non-legal friend, somebody that he could feel was a support to him, a moral support to help in making his case, the case might be very much more effective, simply by the fact that he had his wits about him and he knew that he was not before a court which was out to frighten him and perhaps put him in jail for ten years. I suggest that the case for the next friend, even if he is not a lawyer, to be present with the prisoner when he appears before this council is a very fair suggestion, and not at all an unreasonable one. But, even supposing that that, reasonable as it is, cannot be conceded, surely it is not unreasonable to ask that that prisoner, who knows that he is going to appear before such a tribunal, shall be able to get the assistance and the confidence that a solicitor, or a counsel, or a next friend could give him before he appears before that tribunal. Surely that is not an exceptional or extravagant request that will meet the Minister's objection that he does not want this council to take upon itself the character of a court? There will be no need for that objection to be stressed at all if the prisoner has an opportunity to confer, either with a solicitor or a layman before he appears before the tribunal. He, at least, has the feeling that there is somebody else in the world who is thinking about him besides the prisoners, on the one hand, and the tribunal on the other. I do not think there is anything extravagant in that request, and I would ask the Minister if he cannot meet the desires of the Deputy who moved it in some way, so that the prisoner shall have some facilities for conferring with a solicitor or a friend, either before or at the hearing of the case.

Comment on this

Let me reinforce Deputy Johnson's argument. One Deputy's argument was that there would be a difficulty, perhaps through sensitiveness or something like that, which many prisoners find themselves in when they come before any tribunal like this. I have in mind an instance of one who occupies a very responsible office in the State, a comparatively young man, who had to go before a tribunal like this. He was much younger then, of course, little more than a boy, a boy, though, of more than ordinary intelligence, and whose career since then has shown that he had a brilliancy in certain directions that has been a very great service to the State. He did not know when he was called up before this tribunal what course he ought to take. He did not know what he ought to do. He had no idea of what his position was, and he admitted quite frankly to those of us who happened to be associated with him then that he did not know what to do when he went in. He had no one to advise or direct him, and, of course, the only thing he could do was to turn to those who happened to be prisoners with him. I would urge strongly that the Minister should not leave consultation merely to fellow-prisoners of a man like that, because the purpose that he wants served by the Appeal Council may be defeated by wrongful advice, perhaps wilfully and deliberately given, to prisoners by their fellow-prisoners who take a certain line inside a Court that would not be to the good of the State or the prisoner or anything else. That has happened before, I know, but in quite different circumstances. The circumstances at present ought to be taken into account, and a prisoner should not be left to the mercy of the suggestion merely of his fellow-prisoners, but should have opportunities of consultation and advice with somebody else in whom he would have confidence, and who would give more independent and unprejudiced advice than his fellow-prisoners.

Comment on this

The Minister has mentioned that the majority of the prisoners arrested under this Bill have been arrested on suspicion.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

No prisoners have been arrested under this Bill yet.

Comment on this

They will be, or dealt with under it, and it is to enable people to dispel this suspicion, to enable them to prove that they are innocent, that we are asking him to accept this amendment. Surely that is not too much?

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I regret I cannot make any concession in this matter. It is what a prisoner has to say for himself, and not what his wife, brother or sister has to say for him, we are anxious to get at, and we have set up this body as a medium for his saying that to the Government. That is about what it amounts to. This body is a buffer one between the two parties, the Executive and the person whom the Executive believes it to be necessary to detain for a period in the public safety. He can go before this Council, and he can say what he wants to say for himself. He may endeavour to show that he is not the kind of person that it is at all necessary in the public safety to detain, that he was not connected with outrage or lawlessness generally, or with, possibly, the particular act of outrage that he may be told he is believed to have been connected with. But it is what he has to say for himself, not what some solictor thinks he might stretch a point and say for him, and not what his wife or next relative may say for him or advise him to say, but simply what the man has to say himself to the Government through this body.

Comment on this

But what about what his enemies, who brought him into that position, will say about him? It is to combat that we are trying.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

He has got to make an impression on three impartial men sitting there to hear what he has to say as to why he should no longer be detained, or as to why he should not have been arrested. You may take it, if he puts up a reasonable case, and that at least a recommendation would come along, that the case should be further and very closely scrutinised and inquired into, and there would be of course the possibility of there coming from that body a recommendation that that man should be released. There are amendments that that recommendation should be absolutely mandatory. That would give this tribunal the complexion of a Court. There is no reason to believe that the recommendations of that body would be lightly overruled just because it is not a Court. We do not propose to make these recommendations binding on the Executive.

Comment on this

That would be all very well if we had some experience of the manner in which the Appeal Council was carrying out its duty. We have not had so far that experience. It is all very well for the Minister to say that what they want is to hear what the man has to say for himself. But before any such tribunal, I submit that a good deal will depend on the form in which the man says what he has got to say for himself. Many a prisoner may have a great deal to say for himself, but he may not, for one reason or another, be able to put it in the form most effective and most appealing to the judgment of the tribunal. He may have a great deal to say, and yet may not be able to assemble the different parts of what he has to say in such a way that he would present a reasoned case to a tribunal. I think that the Minister can see that there is point in that. One of the extraordinary things to some of us who had experience of a somewhat similar tribunal was that certain people, whom we knew to be well worth, at all events, an unfavourable decision from the tribunal, were released on the advice of that tribunal; but a great many more, who were much more notoriously to very many of us completely innocent—many were absolutely innocent of any kind of offence except the kind that I mentioned a while ago in dealing with another amendment—were detained for the full duration of detention at that time. Some of us made a rough-and-ready examination to try and arrive at the reasons for this, and we came to two or three conclusions. One was that sometimes a Council might be more, not exactly "getatable," but more lenient or more generous on some days than other days for some reason or another. Perhaps it was because its personnel changed slightly from time to time. But one of the conclusions we came to that seemed to go some distance to explain the decisions of the Court was that certain people, to our knowledge, were able to put their case in a very good form, and in such a way that they were able to put up a convincing case, while others who had a much better case were not able to put their case in a convincing form. There is much more in the form than the Minister seems inclined to agree to, and I would ask him to reconsider that particular point because it is of importance. Many a good case is spoiled by the form in which it is put.

Comment on this

There is another reason, perhaps a reason which concerns the Minister himself or whatever other Minister will be called on to review the report of this tribunal, as to why these cases should be thoroughly inquired into. The clause stipulates that whatever decision the Appeal Tribunal may arrive at is subject to review by the Executive Minister, It says: "... having considered the report of such Council, is of opinion that the public safety would be endangered by such person being set at liberty." If the Minister, by accepting this amendment, agrees that the prisoner who is trying to prove his innocence, and who if things were right, should be treated the other way about, allows a legal representative to appear on behalf of the prisoner, or, on the other hand, acting on behalf of the Government—as I presume they are appointing an individual—there will be two legal men. I take it, in such circumstances, whatever legal quibbles would be at stake or raised by the Council or Appeal Court, would be thrashed out to a conclusion, and the Minister would thereby be relieved of the responsibility or trouble of reviewing the case that would have been thrashed out from the legal and from every other point of view concerning the detention of the prisoner. I think that is an additional reason why the Minister should not persist in refusing to accept an amendment of this kind.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 12
·
Níl 41
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I would suggest, provided the suggestion meets with general approval, that there should be a short adjournment of an hour. It is quite evident that the Minister who is in charge of the Bill, and those of us who are responsible for amendments, are not in a position to leave our places, and therefore I suggest such an adjournment.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

There is no agreement on that.

Comment on this

Amendment 25 is not being moved.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

"In Sub-section (3) to delete all words from the word ‘and,' line 56, page 3, to the word ‘liberty,' inclusive, line 7, page 4, and to substitute therefore the words: ‘and such Council has reported either (a) that the reasons given for the detention of such person are not adequate to justify his detention without trial; or (b) that, having regard to the period during which such person has already been detained, there is not sufficient reason for continuing his detention, then, immediately upon receipt of the report of the Appeal Council, the Executive Minister shall cause such a person to be set at liberty.’”

The object of the Appeal Council in this case would be not even yet to act as a Court, but to consider the case that has been put forward by the Minister, the grounds of suspicion, the grounds of detention, and presumably to examine the prisoner in his own defence. Having satisfied themselves that there is no case for further detention, they shall report such fact that there are no grounds for further detention, or that, supposing there were originally some grounds for detention, that the grounds are so trifling and that the circumstances have changed in such a way as to make detention no longer reasonable. On receipt of such a report the Executive Minister shall cause such a person to be set at liberty. If the Appeal Council is to be composed of three persons, men or women, one of whom shall have had legal experience, and is to have the evidence which originally justified in the mind of the Minister the detention, and an opportunity of hearing what the prisoner had to say for himself, and if that Council has no grounds for recommending continued detention, or, on the other hand, has positive grounds for recommending release, it seems reasonable that such a person should be released. The Minister has described this Council as being something in the nature of a go-between between the Executive and the prisoner. I presume he did not mean to suggest that it was merely a channel of communication, but that it was a body which he intended would have at least common-sense and discretion, and would be capable of forming a judgment as to whether further detention without trial was justifiable. The Minister proposes to reserve to himself the right to say whether the tribunal he has set up is a competent one. He proposes to reserve to himself the right of saying whether he was wise or unwise in setting up that Council. I am going to presume, and I ask the Dáil to presume, that the Minister, when he sets up such a Council, will have satisfied himself that the people constituting that Council will have at least an average amount of discretion, that they will be capable of discriminating as to the case the Minister puts before them regarding the prisoner, and having tested the case by the appearance and bearing and the evidence that the prisoner himself submits to prove his innocence, that they will be competent to declare that this prisoner should no longer be detained, and that thereupon he should be released. Notwithstanding what the Minister has said in regard to earlier amendments, I think he will see the justice and the reasonableness of this proposition.

Comment on this

This amendment covers the two principles that are involved in the next three amendments standing in my name. As I have some doubt whether, if this amendment were defeated, it would be open to me to move the amendments I have put down with the same object, and as I have no desire to waste time in, going twice over the same ground, I propose to support this amendment with the arguments that I had intended to put forward in support of the amendments in my own name. The wording of this amendment differs to some extent from mine, and perhaps goes a little further. The two real principles involved are these, (1) that the onus should not be put on a man who is merely detained on suspicion of proving that there is no reasonable ground for that suspicion; (2) that when the tribunal that has been set up by the Minister to inquire into the question whether there are or are not reasonable grounds for detaining the prisoner has reported that there are none, it does seem to me to go far beyond justice and far beyond the necessities of the case that when, after investigating all the reports that the Minister has placed before him, they come to the conclusion that there is no reasonable ground for detaining a man, that he should nevertheless be kept in custody. The section as it stands does these two things, although they seem to me to be contrary to justice, (1) that a man who is merely suspected should have to prove that there is no reasonable ground for suspicion, (2) that when he has succeeded in doing that he should nevertheless be detained at the option of the Minister. I do think, with every desire to support the Government in all reasonable and even in some unreasonable methods of dealing with the present situation, that this goes too far. I do suggest that when the Appeal Council, having investigated all the facts, finds itself in a position to report that there is no reasonable ground for detaining a man, that that decision ought to be adopted. I think that every word that the Minister said on that amendment with regard to the constitution and modus operandi of this Appeal Council supports the view I am putting forward to the Dáil. They are not to be deluded by the subtleties of lawyers. There are to be three reasonable people appointed by the Government, I have no doubt, with every desire to support the cause of law and order and to maintain regular government in this country. I have no doubt that after the reports that will be put before them—because the previous amendments decided that they were to have the reports upon which men were detained—if they see there is nothing to be found in these reports, and nothing to be found in the statement made to them by the responsible Minister, that, being reasonable men, and coming to the conclusion that there are no reasonable grounds for detaining the prisoner, he ought to be released. The wording of this amendment goes beyond mine in this, because it goes on to provide that if he is detained for a certain period the Council may deem that a proper cause for release. I do not go so far as that, but I would go so far as to say that, as the Minister says the prisoner is in reasonable detention, it would be for the Ministry to say how long he shall be detained, and not the Appeal Council. I am inclined to support that view. But the two vital principles in this amendment, and which induced me to put down my amendment, are that, although we are far from the position that a man is presumed to be innocent until he is proved to be guilty. I think if the people who detain a man can show no reasonable grounds for suspecting him, then he ought to be treated as a person free from all suspicion and therefore ought to be entitled to get out; and if, having failed to discharge the onus of proof that there are some grounds for suspecting him, they ought not to be put in a position of overriding the decision of their own tribunal and declaring that the man must still remain in custody. I support this amendment, and I trust that even if the second clause of it does not meet with the approval of the Minister in charge of the Bill he still may give us some release as regards the first clause, and, secondly, as to the power of the Minister to override the decision of his own tribunal.

Comment on this

I suppose I may be regarded as more or less interested in this matter. I am going to vote against this amendment, because I know the difficulties the military authorities have even in dealing with prisoners. I know there are several prisoners in custody at the present time against whom I could prove several charges of loot, robbery, and arson and other things, and the only reason I do not do it is because I would get somebody else into trouble. That has happened all over the country and in Dublin. People have looted property and stolen motor cars, but the people who know they have done it will not come forward and give evidence in public, and the reason is because they think they would be shot the next day. I know, at the present time, that we have in custody six or seven people against whom I could formulate charges, but I could not conscientiously ask witnesses to come forward and prove them. I simply cannot do it. I am in trouble enough myself, and I do not ask other people to walk into trouble. What is the use of talking about reasonable suspicion? You cannot prove it, and it is not fair to ask people to come forward and prove it. I shall vote therefore against this amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Deputy FitzGibbon said there are really two principles in the amendment, and that is correct. There is the principle of whether we are entitled, in any circumstances, however grave, to put upon detained persons the onus of showing cause why they should not be detained, rather than take upon ourselves the onus of showing why they should. That is a matter that has been referred to over and over again on this Bill, and runs right through the whole Bill: that is, the question of detention upon anything short of legal proof. Now, I would like to meet Deputy Johnson and Deputy FitzGibbon by throwing (a) into a positive, rather than into its present negative form, but on (b) I am afraid I could make no concession. Dealing with (a) first “wherever an Appeal Council has enquired into and reported on the case of any person under this section and either—(a)—such Council has reported such person has failed to show that there is no reasonable ground for suspecting him of having committed or being engaged or concerned in the commission of any of the offences mentioned in the Schedule to this Act.”

That is reading it as it stands now. We must remember that such a person was arrested and detained because an Executive Minister was satisfied that there was reasonable grounds for suspecting him of having committed offences mentioned in the Schedule, and this body is set up with a view of enabling the prisoner to rebut that suspicion and to show that he is not the kind of a person who should reasonably be detained as a matter of public safety. That is why (a) is in its present negative form, because it would amount to reporting from this Council that the detained person had failed to throw off from himself the suspicion on which he was arrested.

Now I would like to meet, as far as I possibly could, the objections that have been urged, and I would be prepared to consider some such reading as this:—

"Whenever an Appeal Council has enquired into and reported on the case of any person under this section and either—

"(a) such Council has reported that there are reasonable grounds for suspecting him of having committed or being engaged or concerned in the committing of any of the offences mentioned in the Schedule to this Act.”

That is, that their report would be positive confirmation of the suspicion upon which a person was arrested rather than a report to the effect that the person did not clear himself of such suspicion. I think myself that the negative form is in the circumstances reasonable. A B has been arrested in a time of crisis because the Executive Council of the country which is responsible for public safety considers him reasonably suspected of having committed certain grave offences, which offences being for the most part the methods by which a campaign against the State and the citizens may be conducted, we set up this body, and we give to detained persons an opportunity of clearing themselves of this suspicion, and I think it is not unreasonable to say that they shall be continued to be detained unless that body reports that they have cleared themselves. That is what it means as it stands.

I would like to go a little further and put a more positive burden on (a), and make the Section read: “Whenever an Appeal Council has inquired into and reported on the case of any person under this section, and either (a) such Council has reported that there are reasonable grounds for suspecting him of having committed or being engaged or concerned in the committing of any of the offences mentioned in the Schedule.” If I put in that positive wording I would insist upon (b) as it stands, and the section would go on to read: “or (b) an Executive Minister having considered the report of such Council, is of opinion that the public safety would be endangered by such person being at liberty, any such person may be detained,” etc.

Deputies may think that that is treating the Appeal Council very lightly, and, of course, there is the obvious point to make that we ourselves set up this Council and selected its personnel, and that it seems a strange thing to refuse to bind ourselves by its recommendations. But there is this: Deputy Johnson the other day spoke of "public safety." He took the two words "public safety" and made play with them, and asked for a definition of them. I did not reply by saying that it was the safety of the public, or anything of that kind. There is this about it, that the Executive Council, for the time being, must be the judge of it, and must be the judge of what it demands in particular cases and in a particular set of circumstances. We could not, even to this Appeal Council, leave the absolute last word on the matter. As I say, I do not really expect that any recommendations from that body would be ignored or overruled, and yet I would not concede the right to overrule them, because to concede that would be to concede to a body that has no mandate from the people, or any responsibility to the people, the right of saying the absolute last word on what the public safety requires. It may be academic or theoretical, but there is just that about it that it ought not to lie with a body of this kind; in such circumstances as we have in the country at the moment, to say absolutely that the public safety does not require the detention of A B. If a change in (a) of that section would meet Deputy Johnson or Deputy FitzGibbon, or both, I will be glad to insert some such change on the Report Stage, but I could not concede the other principle that Deputy FitzGibbon has urged —that we should say, in such a situation as the present, it will lie with some Appeal Council which we will set up to say the ultimate “yes” or “no” on the question of prisoners' releases. It might well be that there would be circumstances which would prevent us from putting before such a Council absolutely all the information that would be at our disposal with regard to a prisoner. It might well be that for sufficient reasons, for very good reasons, we would find it incumbent upon us to withhold and to lay only a partial report, or a partial dossier of evidence, before this Council. There might be an item, and a very grave item, which it would be considered necessary to withhold. In such times as the present Deputies will perhaps understand that point. Deputy McGarry touched on it. The Executive Council for the time being must always be the judge of this vague thing called “public safety.” That is their peculiar function. If they judge it wrongly or unwisely, and consistently show an inability to appreciate what it is and where it lies, then the representatives of the people would take appropriate action; but for the time being, and while in office, they must judge it rightly or wrongly, and they cannot delegate to such a body as this Appeal Council the power or the right to judge it.

Comment on this

The Minister in his speech seems to me to have agreed substantially to accept Amendment No. 28, but he refuses to accept Amendments 27 and 29.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

These would be the exact words if Amendment 28 be accepted.

Comment on this

In regard to what Deputy McGarry said, no one suggested that the Ministry should prove the guilt of any detained prisoner to the Appeal Council. All that they are asked to do is to prove that they have reasonable grounds for suspecting him, which is a very different thing indeed from proving that he is guilty. He has not got to do what the ordinary prisoner in the dock, in the ordinary case, may have to do when a case is established against him, and that is to prove his innocence. He has got to go a good deal further than any criminal was ever asked to go, and that is to prove not only that he is innocent, but much more than that, to prove that no reasonable person ever suspected him of being anything else but innocent. To put that onus on any man seems to me to go far beyond the limits of even the grossest injustice. I am very glad indeed that the Minister has seen his way at any rate to modify Sub-head (a) to the extent that he has outlined. I have no desire to press amendments to divisions merely for the sake of recording my vote one way or the other. But what I want to do is to get as much reasonableness into this Bill as I can, and if I cannot get more than what the Minister has offered I will take that with modified thankfulness. As I say, I am not moving my amendment at present, but I am supporting the amendment moved by Deputy Johnson. When my own amendments come on I will ask leave, if the first amendment is defeated, in view of what the Minister has said, to move Amendment 28.

Comment on this

Deputy McGarry assumes that these Appeal Councils would be Courts where it would be necessary for him or any other person with information at their disposal to bring forward people in order to prove charges against prisoners. There is no necessity to labour that point, because the Minister takes an opposite view in so far that he does not agree that it is a Court. The Minister referred to this vague thing called public safety. That is a thing that I have in my mind all the time when dealing with people detained or interned on suspicion. I know a few people at the present time who are enjoying the hospitality of the Free State Government in Tintown.

As far as I know, and I know one of them very well, they could never be accused of anything more than blowing off a lot of froth and steam. Simply because in their excited moments they may say something they are to be taken up for that. It might not be a crime to say that I am a rotter or a danger to the public safety or a tool of the Government, but it would be a crime if, in his excited moments, an individual said such a thing about the Minister. Possibly it might be set up as a charge against him that he was a danger to the public safety. I think you are placing a rather extravagant interpretation on the patriotism of such a gentleman by detaining him, at the hospitality of the Executive Council, at the Curragh. I know of a few gentlemen who go about shouting their anti-Government ideas and nothing more. I do not think they could be accused of having the courage to go into active opposition to the Government. That is the class of people you have to cater for in the amendment we move, and there should not be any necessity to detain these people, if at all, a day longer than would be necessary to give them the means of being accused by you and an opportunity of defending a charge before the Appeal Tribunal.

Comment on this

It seems to me the Minister must have had some object in putting this Appeal Council into the Bill. He must have expected these Councils would be availed of by those held in detention. If he expects they will be availed of there should be some measure of confidence inculcated in the minds of those detained to the effect that their decisions will carry some weight. If by refusing this amendment and by the statement he has made, the Minister makes it clear at the outset that, no matter what the Appeal Council will decide, he will still retain the right to hold the prisoner——

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

The right.

Comment on this

I foresee that what will happen will be that none of those people detained will approach the Appeal Council. Most of the Deputies know that as regards the Sankey Commission which was set up under the British regime, very few people availed of it, although there was nothing more wrong with it, from the point of view of the people with whom we are dealing appearing before it, than there would be in appearing before this Tribunal from the point of view of the people who will be dealt with under the Bill. In the North of Ireland some of the prisoners who were detained in the "Argenta" did, at the beginning, appear before these Appeal Councils, or somewhat similar bodies that were set up there, and they very soon found that, even though they did appear, nothing came of it. After that had become manifest to those detained, there were no more appeals. I submit it would be just as well that the Minister would omit the Appeal Councils altogether from the Bill and not set up a pretence of a Council, which he is making plain will really have no effect.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Surely the Deputy remembers that I said I did not foresee or anticipate that a single recommendation of this Council would be ignored or overruled, and that it was merely a technical right that had to be preserved of deciding, in a matter of public safety, whether a prisoner would or would not be released.

Comment on this

I am pointing out that it will have no effect, and it will not be availed of, simply because the Minister has said, and is now saying, in effect, that he still retains the right, no matter what the Council decides, to keep the prisoners.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

It is an advisory body.

Comment on this

That is why I say it would be as well to leave the Councils out altogether.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

If the Deputy puts down an amendment to that effect, I will consider it.

Comment on this

It would be, to my mind at all events, a more honest dealing than setting up a Council which he makes by his statement nugatory.

Comment on this

I think this is a point that the Minister on behalf of the Executive cannot concede. I think the Minister is responsible to the Executive, the Executive is responsible to Parliament, Parliament is responsible to the people, and the people have the controlling power. If a certain case of individual hardship should by any possibility arise, it could be brought before the Dáil, and the fact concerning the prisoner's detention could be submitted.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

The Dáil could have submitted to it such particulars as may be required in any case in which there may be some doubt as to hardship imposed on a prisoner. This is not a tribunal that we can exactly describe as the tribunal to which Deputy FitzGibbon referred. Such a tribunal would be based upon juridical status, and would have all the rights to decide as to guilt or innocence. This is merely a tribunal that inquires into how far a person is reasonably suspected of being dangerous to the State. It is not concerned so much with the guilt or innocence of the prisoner as it is with his liability to be dangerous to the State. I think when the Minister has removed the first portion of it, to which I was myself opposed, the second part, in so far as it will not and cannot involve more than a slight percentage, if any percentage, of persons being detained after the Appeal Tribunal has decided that there was not sufficient evidence to justify them in saying there was reasonable ground for suspicion, is satisfactory. It may be there will be cases in which there are facts that cannot be brought forward. These things will arise. The Executive will feel some responsibility in the matter, and their responsibility is to the nation and to Parliament, and they cannot throw away their right to veto in a case of the kind, because some particular control must repose in some head or Executive with regard to special cases like those. Under the circumstances the tribunals are not judicial tribunals in any sense. They are merely inquiry tribunals, and their recommendations would be based on what is put before them, and it may not be possible to put all the facts before them at all. I think the amendment which the Minister has decided to accept will make the clause quite safe for its being accepted by this Dáil. The Dáil will be careful not to sanction anything that is unduly harsh or likely to create hardship on any individual. I am sure that is not the intention, and I am sure the Dáil will take proper steps that these things will be dragged forth.

Comment on this

How?

Comment on this

I am sure that the ordinary conditions that attach to all Parliaments will make it possible for any Deputy to have a case of hardship, if such come under his notice, brought here before this Dáil, the tribunal of the nation.

Comment on this

How will we know about them?

Comment on this

We can demand full particulars at any time by a combined desire on the part of the Oireachtas to inquire into any particular case of hardship that might arise, and inquire why a Minister should maintain a position which would seem impossible to be maintained. I think that is sufficient protection against hardship being inflicted. I think the Executive must hold a veto in this matter.

Comment on this

Deputy McGoldrick has brought, up again the illusory prospect of eliciting facts which neither the Minister in charge of the Bill nor any other Minister is going to disclose to the Dáil any more than to the Appeal Council. Deputy Gavan Duffy dealt yesterday with the illusory nature of the bringing of a case before the Dáil. Supposing the Appeal Council has advised the Minister that a certain prisoner should be released; that the Minister, for the reasons he has stated here several times this evening, has not put that Council in possession of all the information, or perhaps I should say all the suspicion, in his possession, and the Minister, in the face of the Council's recommendation, decides to keep the prisoner, Deputy McGoldrick then seems to think that it would be possible to bring up a case before the Dáil and to get much more satisfaction from the Minister in the Dáil than either the prisoner got when before the Council or than the Council itself got. That shows tremendous faith not only in the ability of the Dáil, but in the ease with which the Minister, or any Minister, will submit information at the request of the Dáil. Those of us who have had occasion from time to time to bring up the cases of prisoners in the Dáil have found that we have been able to get very little information indeed, except "that in the interests of public safety it was not considered advisable to release so-and-so." No more. But the Minister has said that he cannot foresee that these sub-sections which Deputy Johnson is seeking to amend will be applied in all their severity. But we have, none of us, any guarantee that that will be so. The Minister himself has no guarantee. He might have some guarantee, and the Dáil might have some guarantee if the Bill were to complete its course and expire before the General Election, but that is not likely. It may be that the present Ministry will become the new Ministry under the new Dáil. It may not be. It may be strengthened or weakened by combinations with somebody else. It may, on the other hand, even be in a minority, in the new Dáil. None of us know. Therefore, the promise from the Minister now, that certain things will not be done under this Bill, does not hold good, because he can give no promise for an Executive Council which comes in within the next few months. There is no really pertinent argument in turning round and telling Deputy O'Connell that if his opinion is that it would be much better that there was no Appeal Council than that their powers should be so little, he should move an amendment for the deletion of the provisions dealing with the Appeal Courts on the Report Stage. The amendment, as proposed by Deputy Johnson, is a serious amendment, an effort to establish certain principles, and to get practices corresponding to those principles in the administration of the Bill. To some extent the Minister has gone a little way to meet part of the intention. He has not gone the whole way. But I would urge on him and I would urge on the Dáil to consider, not only the case that has been made by the amendment as a whole, but particularly the need, as Deputy O'Connell has pointed out, for imbuing internees and prisoners with the idea that they are going to get at least a fair crack of the whip.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I submit that that is out of order until the next Section.

Comment on this

In the Six-Counties, as Deputy Johnson has said, there is no confidence whatever in the Appeal Council. In the Sankey Committee there was no confidence. If the powers of this Appeal Council are to be so limited as the Minister said, then there can be very little confidence, and there can be no inducement whatever to a prisoner to make an appeal to it. The Minister frankly and fearlessly admits that he may have up his sleeve, information which he cannot give to the Appeal Council. It may be a prisoner meets with the suggestion that he should take his case to one of these Councils. It is presumed that when that suggestion is made to him that he is told all about their powers. He may be told, or if he does not know, he ought to be told, that while they have a good deal of information about him, the Minister may have more information about him, and though even they decide he has made a good case, and recommend that he should be released, yet the Minister, either in virtue of the information which he has not disclosed, or for some other reason, can still decide to keep the prisoner in detention. Can anyone imagine that the bulk of the prisoners faced with a situation like that, could have any confidence whatever in the Appeal Council? No, they will simply say "It is bluff, they are pulling our legs, it is making a pretence of doing something for us without doing anything for us, the best thing for us to do is to ignore this Appeal Council altogether."

Comment on this

I frankly say that it would be much better not to have Section 4 in the Bill at all in its present form. The Bill is far better without it. For one thing, the Section as it stands, unless it is amended in the form desired, simply suggests that the Minister wants an appearance of relieving himself of responsibility. He can at least appear to throw some responsibility for the non-release of prisoners who have appealed to the Committee. There is nothing to show what the report of the Council will be to the Minister, and at least there will be good grounds for thinking that the report was unsatisfactory, even though it may have been satisfactory. The prisoner is damnified having once gone before the Appeal Council, and not having been released the public will have a right to assume that there is more in the charge than they believe. Yet the Council may have said: "No, there is no evidence to connect this man with malpractices or any association with malpractices." The Minister reserves to himself the right to say, notwithstanding what the Advisory Committee may have said, notwithstanding what the Appeals Council may have said: "we are going to detain this man," and nothing more is to be known except the inference is to be drawn that they have something up their sleeve. I wonder whether, when defining the composition of these Councils, the Minister had in his mind the probability that eminent judicial gentlemen would not be likely to serve on Councils of this nature. All he asks is, that one of them is a person certified as having legal knowledge and experience. I take it that the Attorney-General will be expected to have proper consideration for his profession, and he will be sure that the person whom he nominates will be either a qualified solicitor or a practising barrister. He may only be a very minor one waiting for promotion, waiting for experience, and it may be that only minor ones will be willing to serve on a Council which has such limited power and authority, in which neither the public nor the prisoner nor the Minister himself has any confidence. The Minister confesses that, in paragraph (b) which he refuses to alter. I submit that to make this section of any value at all it requires amendment, such as that which is proposed. Not merely is that required to make the section of any value, but if something of that kind is not proposed the section itself would be very much better deleted, very much better for the prisoner and for the public. I think that it would ensure that the Ministers would have to bear the responsibility and not transfer it by inference to the Appeals Council. Deputy McGoldrick repeated his suggestion which he made one day recently, about the reliance upon the Ministry, the check the Dáil might have upon the Ministry, and the check the public will have upon the Dáil.

That is very pleasant, and I am sure that the Minister immediately reminded himself of his famous criticism that he is so used to in the Dáil, and he was eager to call upon Deputy McGoldrick not to deal with theories, but to deal with facts and common practices, facts of life round about us, and not to be thinking of the ultimate responsibility of the electorate for the conduct of their representatives, and of the representatives for the electorate, and the responsibility of the Ministry for their subordinate officials. Undoubtedly, the Minister said "That is a lovely theory, but, in practice, it does not happen," and I ask Deputy McGoldrick how he is going to bring the case of a prisoner, whose case had been heard before the Appeals Council, the Council's decision having been over-ruled by the Minister, before this Dáil? He would need to have access to the prisoner. He has not got that, but is seeking to get that. Only after the expiry of the Act, and the expiry of the period of detention would it be possible for Deputy McGoldrick to bring the case of that prisoner before the Ministry through the operations of the legislative chamber. Of course, it is always possible for a majority to turn out a Ministry. That is very little protection for the innocent prisoner whose innocence has been provable to the Appeals Council, and evidence of whose guilt is alleged to be contained in the archives of the Ministry. There is not much satisfaction to the prisoner in a vote of want of confidence in the Executive Council. One does not want to quote Dr. Stockman and speak of the "damned, compact majority," but one might well think of "the blessed compact majority" which believes that greater evil will result from the effect of want of confidence than from the continued detention of a prisoner. That is quite a reasonable proposition. We ought not to be weighing up the rights to detain a prisoner who may be innocent with the risk of throwing out the Executive Council, and that is the only check that Deputy McGoldrick says that we have. This Bill, when it passes, will not be the Bill or the Act of the Executive Council. but the Act of the Oireachtas. It is not enough for the Ministry to assure us what their intentions are. It is not enough to say, "we intend that such-and-such a thing shall take place." There is no need for a Bill to do that. They have power to release now. There is no need for a Bill to give them power to release. There is no need for Section 4 to set up an Advisory Committee to advise whether a person should be released or not, unless they bind themselves to take the decision of that Committee, and release the prisoner on receiving their judgment that there is no evidence of guilt. The Minister, all through this Bill, has based his case upon the contention that they must have the right to intern without trial. He claims that right, no matter whether there is prima facie evidence of a man's guilt or not. Even though the Advisory Council decides that there is not, still, he wants power to detain a man against whom there is no shadow of evidence. All power to the Ministry! All power to any Executive Minister! Talk about all power to Soviets! Talk about the dictatorship of the proletariat! That is the dictatorship of a single Minister, if you like. He asks the Dáil to agree to the setting up of an Appeals Council, an Advisory Committee. Having set it up, even though he declares there is not a particle of evidence to suspect the prisoner, he says, “I am going to have power to detain and intern that innocent man.” This is supposed to be a transitory period between the period of revolution, of warfare, a period of armed rebellion, and a period of peace. It certainly would be much more frank and much more reasonable to come and ask for power to do anything with a citizen for at least six months, or for at most six months. If you intern a person who is, in effect, proved to be innocent, you may ask anything imaginable. Deputy O'Connell referred to Belfast, but I am pretty confident that they did not dare to go to the Belfast Parliament to ask for any such powers. They may take them. They may use them, but they would not dare to go even to the docile Parliament there to ask for those powers. The Minister has no hesitation, apparently, in coming to this Parliament to ask for those powers, because, feeling confidence in his own integrity, his own bona fides he thinks that is all that is at stake. It is conceivable that others may sit in those seats, and it is conceivable that, once this Oireachtas has embodied this kind of legislation in a Bill, a different Ministry, in a few years time, may say, “here is a precedent for us, and we may ask our docile majority to do the same.” It is not wise for this Dáil to embody this kind of thing in legislation. It would be very much better for them to strike it out and say, “We will use the power that we have, and we will risk the consequences of the use of that power without trying to ride off under the cover of an Appeals Council.”

Comment on this

I had intended to wait until the Section itself was under discussion, and to say nothing upon this series of amendments, for reasons which will be sufficiently obvious to Deputies, but there is one point raised on a statement made by the Minister which should not go by default in connection with this particular amendment. The Minister seeks to justify the procedure of not undertaking to abide by the decision of an Appeal Tribunal, upon the grounds that there may be some confidential report dealing with the case of a prisoner, requiring that prisoner's incarceration, which the Executive Council would not feel justified in placing before an Appeal Council, everyone of whose members they will themselves have selected. I have not been present during the whole of the discussion, but, if I mistake not, the Minister himself accepted Amendment 22.

I think I am right in supposing that the Minister has, accepted Amendment No. 22, and that amendment said that in an inquiry under Section 2 the Appeal Council shall—meaning must—be furnished with reports or certificates in virtue of which the person whose case is being inquired into is being detained. That can only mean that the Minister has agreed that all the grounds for detention of a person detained on suspicion without trial are to be laid before this Appeal Council. He would not be observing the terms of Amendment No. 22 if any material report——

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I did not speak about report.

Comment on this

The Minister used the word "report."

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I used the word "information."

Comment on this

But if he had only used the word "information," the position would be just the same, because the object of Amendment No. 22 is to secure that the Appeal Committee shall know why a man is interned. That is the only object of it—that in an inquiry under that Section the Appeal Council is to be furnished with the reasons for a man's internment. It is expressed in the words, "reports or certificates by virtue of which a person is interned." Surely the Minister for Home Affairs is not going to tell us that some private reason of State, over-riding other reasons, may exist and that he will be justified in the face of that amendment, which he has accepted, in withholding that private reason, and in putting before the Appeal Council reasons which are only partial, and which are not the full grounds upon which the Executive relies. My object in referring to this particular matter is that it seems to me, the Minister's statement is a negation and contradiction of the amendment which he himself accepted. I do not think that he can have it both ways. If it is right that the Appeal Council should be furnished with reasons let them be furnished with reasons and not partial reasons. I hope that the Minister on reflection will realise that the contradiction is quite apparent and quite indefensible.

Comment on this
George Nicolls Mr. GEORGE NICHOLLS Sinn Féin

at this stage took the Chair.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 12
·
Níl 37
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I do not move amendment 27.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it necessary for a Deputy to get the sanction of the Dáil before he withdraws an amendment?

Comment on this

I did not withdraw the Amendment. I did not move it.

Comment on this
George Nicolls ACTING CHAIRMAN (Mr. Nicholls) Sinn Féin

The Deputy himself has answered the question. He has not moved the Amendment.

Comment on this

If the Deputy in whose name the Amendment appears does not move it, can another Deputy move it?

Comment on this
George Nicolls ACTING CHAIRMAN Sinn Féin

Not without authority from the Deputy concerned.

Comment on this

That has not been the ruling.

Comment on this

I beg to move Amendment 28. I have already said all I have to say in connection with this Amendment, and I understood the Minister to say that he was prepared to accept this Amendment, with the exception of the last three or four words. At least, he read out words that seemed to me to be identical with Amendment 28, and the Ceann Comhairle pointed out that the Amendment read out was identical with the terms of this Amendment, with the exception that the word "or" was not to be deleted. That would mean that the Amendment would read "in sub-section (3) (a), lines 57 and 58, to delete the words `such person has failed to show that,' and to delete the word `no,' line 58,” and stop there.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I accept that.

Comment on this

I think the amendment as it stands is one that ought to be submitted to the Dáil. The sub-section, if this amendment were carried, would read:

"Whenever an Appeal Council has inquired into and reported on the case of any person under this Section and either:

(a) such Council has reported that there is reasonable ground for suspecting him of having committed or being engaged or concerned in the commission of any of the offences mentioned in the Schedule of this Act, or,

Then (b) would follow. The case made by the Deputy in the previous discussion seems to me to prove the necessity for having this amendment in the form in which it is, and with the deletion of the word “or” at the end of the paragraph retained. We have not yet come to the next paragraph and we have a right to assume that there is, at least, a chance, despite the opinion already expressed by the Minister, that (b) will not be pressed. If we retain the word “or” now it will assume that there is something following, whereas if the amendment in the form in which it is printed is carried, there is no conjunction and we will be grammatical, at any rate, when we exclude paragraph (b). I would urge that the amendment be put in the form in which it has been placed on the paper.

Comment on this

I would urge the Deputy not to press that. We have got a promise of something, and if the amendment goes to a vote I am afraid we might, while grasping at the shadow lose the substance.

Comment on this

I am of the opinion that there is room in the amendment for improvement, as suggested by Deputy Johnson. I think Deputy FitzGibbon is of the opinion that "a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush." That might be his point of view. But I think the amendment ought to be put to the Dáil as suggested by Deputy Johnson. I do not see why the mover of the amendment should accept half the substance and throw the other half away.

Comment on this

I rise to raise a question on a point of order. If this amendment is about to be put to the Dáil, would I be in order, supposing it were lost, in asking for your leave to move it without the last clause, deleting the word "no"? I think according to the Standing Orders the Ceann Comhairle can give leave for amendments to be moved which are not upon the Order Paper. I could put the matter in another way. Would I be in order now in moving with reference to this amendment the deletion of the last nine words?

Comment on this
George Nicolls ACTING CHAIRMAN Sinn Féin

I said that I was taking the amendment as received, and in that I have the last nine words deleted, and that is the amendment now before the Dáil.

Comment on this

That is all right.

Comment on this

The amendment that was circulated, and which was discussed, was the amendment that was on the Order Paper, and I submit that we have to come to a decision on that amendment, otherwise—I draw your attention to the importance of this—it may be ruled that in consequence a succeeding amendment will not be in order. It is of the greatest importance that the motion shall be put in the form in which it was circulated, because there is a consequential amendment that has to be discussed, and if the amendment is to be in the form which you have now indicated, and different from the form in which it was circulated then, in consequence, it will not be possible to discuss the succeeding amendment.

Comment on this

If it simplifies the matter I may state that I have no intention of moving the succeeding amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. HIGGINS

We might ease matters if I accepted the amendment on the Order Paper, and in the event of the succeeding amendment not being moved I would consent, on the Report Stage, that the word "or" between (a) and (b) should be deleted, because seeing that it governs the word “either” before (a), “or” is necessary and complementary on that if (b) survives. If (b) survives on the Report Stage I will have to add the word “or”; if (b) does not survive, then on the Report Stage I will have to move the deletion of the word “either” before (a). I would be quite willing to accept the amendment as it stands.

Comment on this

I do not move Amendment 29, A Chinn Chomhairle.

Comment on this

With permission I beg to move Amendment No. 29:—"To delete Sub-section (3) (b), on page 4, lines 1 to 3.”

Comment on this

Chair.

Comment on this
George Nicolls ACTING CHAIRMAN (Mr. Nicholls) Sinn Féin

There is no motion before the Dáil and Deputy Johnson is not in order.

Comment on this

I am making a motion.

Comment on this
George Nicolls ACTING CHAIRMAN Sinn Féin

Amendment 29 is not before the Dáil, and nobody has power to move that amendment without the sanction of the Deputy in whose name it stands.

Comment on this

I beg to suggest that your ruling is different from that to which we have been accustomed from the Ceann Comhairle. It has been quite a common practice to accept amendments sent in in the names of certain Deputies and moved by other Deputies. Apart from that, it is quite in order to accept amendments on Committee, even though notice has not been given. I rely upon the practice that the Ceann Comhairle has allowed. It is quite common that a motion, of which notice has been given by one Deputy, and which that Deputy is not prepared to move, should be moved by another Deputy. It has been the practice ever since the Dáil began its sittings and I think it is a desirable practice, and I submit it is not reasonable to change the practice on this occasion.

Comment on this
George Nicolls ACTING CHAIRMAN Sinn Féin

An amendment put in by one Deputy can be moved by another Deputy on his behalf at his request. The Deputy in whose name this amendment appears has refused to move it and therefore I think that Deputy Johnson cannot move it on his behalf.

Comment on this

May I point out that this is not treating the Dáil fairly. I do not mean that your ruling is not doing so, but I mean this practice, if it became the procedure. If an amendment or a motion is put forward by a Deputy then it is before the Dáil. Notice of it has been given and it has either to be withdrawn by leave or it should be subjected to discussion and decision. I think that that is undoubtedly the practice that the Ceann Comhairle has allowed.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

I am prepared to abide by the decision of Acting Chairman as against the interjection of the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this
Daniel McCarthy Mr. D. McCARTHY Sinn Féin

Is it in order for a Deputy to question the ruling of the Chairman and to make two speeches on the ruling of the Chairman? We all know quite well that you must have the permission of the Deputy in whose name the amendment stands.

Comment on this

I wish to draw the attention of the Chairman to——

Comment on this
Daniel McCarthy Mr. D. McCARTHY Sinn Féin

Chair.

Comment on this
George Nicolls ACTING CHAIRMAN Sinn Féin

I gave certain latitude in this matter, but I gave my ruling and nothing that I have heard would make me divert from that ruling. It is quite clear, and has been the constant practice all along, that a Deputy. if absent, in whose name an amendment is down on the Order Paper, can get another Deputy to move it on his behalf, but in this case the Deputy in whose name the amendment stands is in the Dáil and does not move it. Therefore, there is nothing before the Dáil. Amendment 30.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I accept that amendment.

Comment on this

I submit that the amendment has not been moved.

Comment on this

I move that we delete the words "or outside" in Sub-section (3), lines 4 and 5.

Comment on this
Robert Day Messrs. DAY and COLOHAN Labour Party

"To delete Sub-section (4)."

Comment on this
George Nicolls ACTING CHAIRMAN Sinn Féin

That amendment falls consequential on Amendments 16 and 20 being lost. Amendment 32.

Comment on this

I desire to move Amendment 32: "To add at the end of Sub-section (5) the towards:—Any such regulations shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas as soon as may be after they are made, and if either House of the Oireachtas shall pass a resolution annulling or amending the regulations, the regulations shall be annulled or amended accordingly, but without prejudice to the validity of anything already done under them." I think it is obvious why this amendment is moved. It intends to give the Oireachtas an opportunity of discussing any regulations that the Executive Minister may make, and of amending these regulations if it is thought they are too drastic, or even if it is thought they are not drastic enough. I think the Minister should have no hesitation in accepting it.

Comment on this

I think it is very necessary that an amendment of this kind should be accepted in order that it might be seen whether or not the Appeal Council will be a real thing. It will not serve any useful purpose unless it be of such a character as to inspire those in custody with some confidence that they are going to get a square deal, and that the Appeal Council will have authority to give effect to its recommendations. This whole Bill is, quite obviously, founded on the Defence of the Realm Regulations, that many of the Deputies were unpleasantly familiar with in the early days of the European War, and some of the Ministers. The Minister in charge of the Bill, I think, had not the doubtful pleasure of making the acquaintance of the Advisory Committee set up under the jurisdiction of Judge Sankey. But you, Sir, and the Minister for Local Government, and, I think, the Minister for Defence could tell the Minister in charge some very racy stories as to the procedure adopted before Judge Sankey's Committee—which was called the Amusements Committee. I think you will agree it was not taken seriously, and it is possible that this Appeal Council proposed to be set up will not be taken very seriously by those on whose behalf it is to be set up. You will remember many of the prisoners were brought before Judge Sankey, a distance of a couple of hundred miles, to be asked trivial questions as to where they worked, and the number in their family, and so on, and this will turn out to be the same farce unless the people in custody have some idea they will get a square deal. I think it is necessary that these Regulations should be submitted here to see whether or not they faithfully carry out the intentions the Minister states is in his mind when he proposes to set up this tribunal.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

It was rather difficult to come to a decision with regard to this amendment, and I will state quite frankly the arguments or considerations that would weigh towards the rejection. Those bodies that it is proposed to establish are not Courts, they are merely departmental advisory committees. I do not know whether there is any precedent for bringing before the Dáil, still less before both Houses, the instructions that would be given to committees of that kind, and a step such as is suggested in the amendment might give the appearance or suggestion that these were public tribunals. They are not. They are departmental committees. There are departmental committees sitting at the moment. There is, for instance, the Advisory Committee upon Personal Injuries, which is hearing cases and making recommendations to the Ministry of Finance. I am not aware that the instructions of that committee were laid before both Houses and discussed, still less amended, and yet if the Deputy and mover of the amendment were prepared to leave out some words in the amendment, I think we could strain a point and accept it. The words I would ask him to leave out would be the amending powers that are asked for. It is not without good reason I make that request. If these Regulations are to come before both Houses the amendment, as drafted, would leave it in the power of either House to put up and pass amendments. It might be amended differently in both Houses. There might even be conflicting amendments, and the question would arise as to which of these should prevail. If an amendment was passed in the Seanad which could not be reconciled with an amendment passed in the Dáil, what would happen? I would be prepared to accept the amendment minus these words that would involve that the Regulations for these Appeal Councils would be brought before both Houses and members would have an opportunity of discussing them. I have no doubt that, as a result of that discussion, if a strong view was shown to be held with regard to particular portions of the Regulations, the Minister in standing over them— whoever he might happen to be—would ask leave to withdraw them with a view to alteration, but I would ask the Deputy not to insist upon the power of amendment in either House. After all it is an Executive act. If it is wrong it is wrong, and should be rejected absolutely, but the Dáil should not seek itself to draw up these Regulations. Let it criticise them when drawn up. If they are wrong and there is a general feeling to that effect, no doubt the responsible Minister would withdraw them for alteration, but I think the Deputy would be unwise to insist on power of amendment for both Houses, and if he did so insist I would have no alternative but to oppose the amendment absolutely, withdrawing the concession I have offered.

Comment on this

I think the statement of the Minister is fair. I believe that this amendment is based upon the practice already in operation, even with the portion which is to be amended. Nevertheless, I realise the force of the argument that there may be a difficulty if one House desires to amend in one direction and another House desires to amend in another direction, and that there might be considerable time lost in deciding which amendment shall be accepted. A discussion that would take place, if there was a resolution to annul, might well mean that the Minister responsible would prefer to withdraw the regulation and amend it according to the suggestion which takes place on the resolution for annulment. On these grounds, I think I would advise my colleagues to agree to the deletion of the words on line 3, "or amending the regulations," and the later words "or amended." That would probably meet the Minister's objection.

Comment on this

I am quite willing to have the amendment changed to suit the suggestion of the Minister.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I take it that the Deputy has no objection to an improvement in the drafting that would not alter the substance of the amendment? If we consider that the substance could be embodied in a better form of words I take it there would be no objection?

Comment on this

Does the Minister make any suggestion as to an improved form of words?

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I would not be prepared to make a suggestion. It only struck me that the draftsman might care to do a bit of touching up on the wording.

Comment on this

I think this is taken verbatim from a previous Act. If the Minister finds it is not verbally accurate perhaps on the Report Stage he could suggest an amendment.

Comment on this

I am sorry this Section is going into the Bill. I am glad that there are amendments in it as far as they go, but as long as the Minister retains the power to override the decision of his own Appeal Council it is impossible for the appeal to be regarded as otherwise than as a delusion and a snare. I do not think it is sufficiently realised that the intense suspicion to which Deputy Johnson referred yesterday exists both in Executive quarters and among the prisoners. Consequently it is useless to provide an appeal of this kind unless in so doing you make it abundantly clear that the appeal will, in every way, be perfectly fair to the prisoner. You have to start with the fact that you are dealing with men who are naturally and reasonably suspicious of the Executive, and that you are dealing with an Executive that has shown itself to be exceedingly suspicious of those men and in many cases unnecessarily suspicious. If you start with that you will realise that a Section of this kind is really useless. I was struck by the drafting of this Section as it originally stood. I wonder whether the Dáil has realised that under the Section as originally drafted, and under that Section alone, the Executive has a right to order a specified period of detention for an internee, a period which, as I suggested yesterday, might have exceeded the period of the Bill. That, I hope I understood correctly, is to be taken out. But it was under this Section only that there was power given to the Executive to order detention for a specified period. Another curious thing was that in this Section only had you mention of the words "outside the Saorstát." So that it was a condition precedent to being deported to Saint Helena that you should appeal to the Appeal Council. You could not be deported unless you appealed to the Appeal Council to get out. Those being the facts can you blame men in prison that they are suspicious of this Appeal Council? Can any fair and reasonable man, however strongly he may feel against the men in prison, blame them for being suspicious when an Appeal Council of that kind is presented to them as a serious method of seeking release? I think that there is only one way in which an appeal of this kind can be effective and that is to insist that the persons who man the Appeal Councils shall be persons completely independent of the Executive and with legal training. I do not mind whether you call the Council a Court or not as long as you make quite certain in your Bill that the men who compose it will not be mere nominees of an Executive Minister, but will be independent men and men of legal training. That is not what is proposed. One of them is to be a man of legal training, nothing is said as to the others. I put it to the Dáil that it is futile to insert in a Bill provisions for an Appeal Council of this kind in the terms in which the provisions now appear. It has been a humiliating thing for many who believed in the Free State to see the Courts of Justice compelled to declare that there was a state of war in existence at the present moment, apparently basing themselves mainly upon the fact that the arms had not been surrendered, an argument which might apply equally well 12 months hence, if the arms are not surrendered in the meantime. That did not tend to encourage any respect for legal tribunals. How much less respect then will there be for a tribunal of this kind which is a nonlegal tribunal and whose proceedings are to be conducted in secret? The Dáil will recollect that the Minister, after agreeing that the report on which a man is interned is to be placed before the Appeal Council, subsequently said that there might be cases where confidential reports would have to be withheld, notwithstanding the fact that there is now a Section in the Bill ordering the Minister to produce those reports to the Appeal Council. It has always been an honoured principle, and should continue to be even in a time like this, that if once a man gets out by order of a Court or a Tribunal established by the law of the day, nobody should have the right to question that decision. Unless that feature of the Appeal Council is removed, unless the feature whereby a Minister can override his own nominees for secret reasons is removed, unless it is made mandatory that the persons appointed shall be persons wholly independent of the Executive, it is much better not to have an Appeal Council at all, and so long as the Section remains in its present form I shall certainly vote against it.

Comment on this

I want to support the view Deputy Gavan Duffy has expressed, that the Section, by pretending to be something which would facilitate prisoners in their desire for release is really not going to do that with any effectiveness, but is rather going to do greater harm than any good there might be in the desire of the Minister. I do not believe that with the deletion of this Section there would be any less chance of prisoners being released. I believe the Executive Council can find ways and means of making inquiries into the case of a prisoner without the setting up under this Bill of an Appeal Council. It is quite within the province of the Minister even without this Section to call into his assistance three persons, or three times three persons, to advise him as to whether the evidence on which the person has been detained is of any value or not, to meet the prisoner and to examine him with a view to testing the evidence under which he was originally detained. It is better for the prisoner that he should know that the responsibility for his detention is without question in the hands of the Executive Council. The setting up of an Appeal Council, with such limited powers and low status as the Council provided for in this Section, would not be of any merit, and would, as a matter of fact, prejudice the prisoners, because they would feel that there was greater danger in making the appeal to a Council which had no authority to release. They would feel more confident if they were going to appeal to the men who put them in, and had power to retain them, rather than appealing to another Tribunal which had no power either to release or detain, but which would deceive them into thinking that there might be an extra chance of being released if their cases were considered by such an Appeal Council. It is quite illusory. It is no value in the Bill. There is nothing to prevent a Departmental Committee of the same kind being established without the authority of the Bill. Therefore, as I see it, the Bill would be less harmful with this Section deleted than with it in. It is like a false coin which would have the pretence of legitimacy but would not have the value of the real currency. It is better that people should not be deceived into thinking that the currency was valid, even though by chance an odd person were able to pass the false coin. I support the views expressed by Deputy Gavan Duffy against the acceptance of this Section, as I believe it is harmful, and not beneficial.

Comment on this

I should like to support Deputy Gavan Duffy in his view that this Section should not be retained in the Bill for the reasons stated both by him and by Deputy Johnson. The very title given to the Councils in the Bill is misleading. When the British set up a somewhat similar Committee they had at least the decency to declare that it was an Advisory Committee. The Ministry has not done that in this case, but has called these Councils Appeal Councils. In ordinary law and for ordinary offences when a prisoner is convicted by a lower Court he has a certain remedy and can appeal to other Courts. Citizens generally understand that they have such a right of appeal to other courts. So that the very title of the Bill itself, if not from the strict legal sense, at least in the ordinary accepted sense of the word, means that the body so designated can reverse or vary the decision of a body from which an appeal is made. That is not so in this case. The Minister has gone to great pains to show that in no sense of the word are these courts at all. They have no powers and no authority, beyond the power on the request of a prisoner to inquire, not so much I should say into the innocence of the prisoner, but into the reasons which seem good to the Executive why that prisoner should be detained. I submit that the whole thing is deceptive and that it will be fairer to the internees that the deception should not be practised, no matter how good the intention of the Ministry may be in practising that deception. Legal and other fictions have their use and their purpose. I suggest that this particular deception has no purpose except to mislead the prisoners, and not only the prisoners but the ordinary citizen outside, who may think from a surface view that there is something of real value to the internees in these Councils. We are not even informed, although the Minister has thrown some light on the work of the Councils, of their personnel, except that one shall be a qualified legal gentleman. We are not informed either by the Minister of the number that he proposes or suggests to set up. There are I suppose anything from 10,000 to 12,000 prisoners, who under the Bill have the right to request an investigation by one of these Councils, but we have no idea at all, and can form no idea, of the length of time any one of these Councils might reasonably give to the investigation of the case of a particular prisoner.

It is obvious that if you are to do anything to deal with ten thousand prisoners more than one Council will have to be set up. If more than one must be set up, then how many? And what are the regulations by which they should be conducted? If there are more than one it is a fair assumption, I think, to make, that the practice of one Council may differ very considerably from the practice of another Council. We know very little about them except what the Minister has told us, and what little we do know about them has not given us any confidence in them. On the contrary, it has made them appear naked and unashamed. For that reason I beg to support the attitude of Deputy Johnson and Deputy Gavan Duffy in opposition to this Section.

Comment on this

I intend to vote against this Section for the reasons that I have already indicated, speaking on an earlier amendment, namely, that I think the Bill would be quite better without this Section. There is no freedom to the prisoner in these appeals, and I think it would be fairer to the prisoner not to have these Appeal Councils which, in the circumstances and as outlined, could only be farcical in their operations. There are many men whose future position may be determined by the manner in which they are dealt with by these Appeal Councils. A man, for instance, may be in employment and may be interned, and his employer, not knowing these Appeal Councils as we know them, and thinking they are equivalent, in every way, to a regular Court of Inquiry will, and possibly quite naturally, form the opinion, that here you have a Court of Inquiry set up to try the prisoner. If the prisoner fails to appeal to that Court, as some of them will decide not to appeal, the employer may come to the conclusion that the man is, therefore, guilty and not worthy any longer to hold the position he has held, and he will be removed from that position. His guilt will be assumed, and he will be dismissed.

In saying that I am not speaking altogether hypothetically. Deputy William O'Brien, and others, told us how farcical were appeals to the Sankey Commission under the British regime. I think I am right in saying that the Government at the time used that Committee or Commission, or whatever it was called, to remove Civil Servants from their positions. If I remember rightly, the position taken up by the then Government was that any prisoner who failed to appeal to the Sankey Commission, or any prisoner who appealed to the Sankey Commission and whose case was turned down, could not be restored to his position in the Civil Service. His guilt was assumed although, as Deputy O'Brien told us, some of these men, having gone three or four hundred miles to attend the Commission, were asked questions that had nothing to do with their internment or detention. That is the danger I see in these Appeal Councils. If all the amendments that had been moved to this Section were accepted, they might have been of some use, but as the Section now stands, even with some amendments in it, it is more of a danger than otherwise to the prisoner, and therefore I intend to vote against this Section.

Comment on this
Division

The Dáil divided: Tá,

Tá 14
·
Níl 40
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment 33 on the Order Paper.

Comment on this
George Nicolls ACTING CHAIRMAN (Mr. Nicholls) Sinn Féin

On the instructions of the Ceann-Comhairle, this amendment has been altered to read as follows:—

To insert before Section 5 a new Section as follows:—

"(1) From and after the passing of this Act it shall be the duty of every County Council within whose area persons shall be detained in custody without trial under this Act to appoint a Committee consisting of such number of persons of good standing in the locality as the Council shall deem necessary, having regard to the number of persons to be detained in custody without trial in such area.

(2) The members of every such Committee and each of them, shall from time to time and at frequent intervals visit every place of detention for which they are appointed and hear any complaints which may be made to them by persons confined therein, and, if asked, shall do so privately; they shall report to the Minister for Home Affairs and to their Council upon any abuses which they may find and upon any matters of pressing necessity.

(3) Every member of such a Committee shall at all times have free access to every part of the place of detention for which he is appointed, and to every person detained in custody without trial therein, and free access to all the books of every such place of detention.

(4) In this Section the expression `County Council' shall include the Corporation of a County Borough."

Comment on this

I accept the Chairman's ruling with a good grace as always. A rose is as sweet by any other name. When we cannot call a place of internment a Bastile in an Act of Parliament, we certainly can call it so in our ordinary speech. I rather fancy that had this amendment been allowed to go to the Dáil in the original form in which I proposed it, with this naughty French word, that the insertion of that word, that name, would have commended itself to the Executive Council themselves, seeing that they have always told us that they believe in calling a spade a spade. The object of this amendment is a very simple one. It does not depend upon what we call places in our Acts, and I quite willingly omit the appellation from the Section. The object is to let in a little daylight in these places of internment, mainly in the interests of the prisoners, and also in the interests of the Free State. I received, and I suppose other Members have received a copy of a resolution passed on the 5th day of this month by the Waterford County Council. That County Council resolved:—

"That we cannot accept General Mulcahy's statement as sufficient answer to our demand for an independent inquiry into the conditions prevailing in the Free State prisons, and we reiterate our demands for an inquiry with special reference to suspected cases of ill-treatment of individual prisoners, and that copies of this Resolution be sent to the Members of Parliament for Southern Ireland, and to all County Councils."

Comment on this

On a point of Order, what is the Parliament of Southern Ireland? This is not the Parliament of Southern Ireland.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, the statement of mine referred to in that resolution is the report of the Red Cross Committee that visited the different jails or prisons here.

Comment on this

As to the point about Southern Ireland I am merely quoting what the resolution says. As to what the Minister for Defence has stated I did not know what particular enquiry was referred to, and it is immaterial. The point is that a County Council in this country after twelve months of Civil War should pass a resolution of this kind. Deputies have also received the very unpleasant statement issued under the name of Alderman Murphy, containing allegations as to treatment of prisoners recently, after an attempted escape. For a long time past we have been accustomed to receiving various reports as to ill-treatment of prisoners in various places where they are held by the authorities. The immediate question is not whether these reports are true or false, whether they are well founded or utterly groundless. I have myself often refrained from giving publicity to reports of the kind because of the impossibility of verifying them. The important point is that it is very generally credited that prisoners have been subjected to ill-treatment and it is bound to be credited so long as your prisons are Bastiles—so long as your detention camps are kept in such a way that no human being who is not in the employment of the State or who does not receive special permission ad hoc can go inside. This amendment is intended to draw attention to the necessity of getting away from this appalling policy of secrecy which has been the mistake from the beginning in connection with these prisons. I should have thought it would have been obvious to the Ministry, and to those who support them, that a policy of that kind defeats itself and must defeat itself. One was glad to read the report of the Red Cross Committee or rather of the Red Cross delegate who visited the prisons and found them very satisfactory, and stated that allegations that had been brought to his notice were untrue; but, when one came to the paragraph in which the delegate stated that he had not been authorised to question prisoners, one saw at once that the effect and value of his report was thereby very materially decreased. Is there any outside authority whatsoever entitled or to be entitled under this Bill to inspect places of detention or to visit a prisoner there? Or is it the view of the Executive Council that no such thing can be tolerated, otherwise the safety of the State would be endangered?

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

What do you mean by "outside authority"?

Comment on this
Gerald Fitzgibbon Mr. GERALD FITZGIBBON Independent

took the chair at this stage.

Comment on this

I had in mind the delegates from the County Council. I should be glad to know who, if anyone from outside, would have any right to inspect?

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Does the Deputy mean from outside the country?

Comment on this

No; some person outside the Executive and outside the prison; outside the present Government authority, some person such as visiting justices in the old times. I asked the other day that a Committee of Doctors should be allowed to inspect the prisons and prisoners. For technical reasons my amendment fell through, but not before the Minister had stated that this amounted to a vote of censure upon the Executive, and, therefore, should be resisted. That is not the spirit in which a matter of this kind should be approached. We are just as much entitled to believe that the interests of the State, to say nothing of the interests of the prisoners, require daylight as the Minister is to say that the interests of the State require that no persons of this kind should be allowed to visit the prisons. It cannot be to the interests of the State to have numerous stories spread about, and spread about simply because there is no means, when there is a real grievance, of testing it to the satisfaction of the public, and when there is a bogus grievance, there is no means of ascertaining that it is a bogus grievance. It cannot be satisfactory to this Dáil nor to the Executive itself. That is why I asked that a County Council, taking that as a normal representative body, should be authorised to appoint people for the express purpose of visiting the detention camps within the area of the Council. I asked that the Members or Delegates appointed by the Council shall be allowed to inspect and visit these bastiles frequently, and that they shall be entitled to see any person confined therein, and if asked to do so, to see any such person privately; that they shall report to the Minister for Home Affairs and to the Council that sent them, upon any abuses they shall find therein, or upon any matter of pressing necessity. This sub-section is nothing new. This, and indeed the next sub-section are both modelled upon the Section giving express powers to visiting justices under the Prisons Act. The statute about visiting jails expressly says that prisons should be visited, and the prisoners shall be seen privately if that is asked for. It expressly says, as in the next sub-section, that there shall be free access to every part of the prison and to every person detained in the prison and to all the books in the prison. I want the Dáil to realise that this proposal is not revolutionary. If the Minister were to say that for some reason or another the County Council is not a proper body to appoint visiting justices, let us have the matter dealt with in some other way. In the interests of the Executive and the State, it is necessary that someone who is not an Executive servant, and some persons who are not under the authority of the Executive as their officials, and who would in their visits represent the public, should have the authority to visit prisons and prisoners.

I would ask the Deputies to remember that in passing this Bill Dáil Eireann is doing something of a very unprecedented character. You are going to sanction for six months, or perhaps longer, the internment, without any trial whatever, on mere suspicion, of thousands of people. A good many have been in prison for twelve, eleven, ten months, and so on, and I can understand, although I disagree with the Ministry's view, that, during the active period they could not permit people to visit and inspect prisons. I do not think that the same case can be made now for keeping the prisons secret. I want to say quite frankly that a great deal of propaganda has been carried on in connection with the prisons which was unfair, but, as long as prisons are kept secret, that will continue inevitably. At the same time, there have been abuses which the fact of secrecy has made it impossible to go into, and which would have been remedied had some such proposal as this been adopted. I trust in passing this drastic measure, the Dáil will do itself the justice of insisting that some such proposal as this shall be inserted in order to have a little fresh air and daylight in connection with these detention places, when we all know that the opposite policy is an exceedingly bad one.

Comment on this

The Deputy has spoken at some length upon a subject of which, as far as I know, he has no information, he has no experience, and he is not in a position to give to the Dáil anything but a very exaggerated account of the condition of affairs in these internment camps. I was looking around the Dáil to see some person who had had experience of imprisonment, and the Deputy that I had in mind has gone out. I have had some experience of imprisonment. I recollect on one occasion when there had been some relaxation in Lewes, in 1917. There were there, 120 prisoners, and I recollect a song being sung by one of them. The song was, I think, "The Felons of our Land." I have not much knowledge of poetry or music, but, if my recollection is correct, there was some reference in that song to "dungeons deep." All the prisoners there wore convict uniform, and their laughter was loud and derisive when that particular part of the song was reached. Whether that was the song or not, I do not know, but those particular words were used. If the Deputy were there a great deal of his hallucination would, I think, have been dispelled. That was the case when imprisonment was certainly more severe. There had been a relaxation after the prisoners were taken from Portland and Dartmoor to Lewes, and conditions in Lewes were very much better than what they were in the other two places. The Deputy need have no misgivings about the Executive Council. The Executive Council, with great respect to the Deputy, does not require any assistance from the Deputy in so far as the treatment of prisoners is concerned. I am quite sure he means well, but most of the members of the Executive Council have got intimate knowledge of imprisonment, intimate knowledge of the propaganda that is got out of imprisonment, and intimate knowledge of the false, malicious, unfounded and utterly unreliable propaganda that is made, certainly in this case, about the maltreatment of prisoners. I know Alderman Charles Murphy. I know him well, and have known him for many years. I know his family, and he might, at least, have written that complaint to me; and, if there was anything in it, it would have been investigated. He could have written to the Chief of Staff, who was his friend and who did business with him for a long time. Alderman Murphy is, I have no hesitation in saying, an honourable man, but, in internment camps and places like that, one's judgment is certainly not of a sane and sensible character, and it has not that flavour about it that it has when you are not in an internment camp.

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister whether he does not think that particular complaint ought to be investigated, even if Alderman Murphy did not write direct.

Comment on this

I do not promise that I will undertake to investigate a complaint made in that way. First of all, I do not know that Alderman Murphy has made that complaint. I have not had any intimation from him. I saw it on a typewritten sheet, only when I went outside, from a source hostile, and from a source which has no appreciation good, bad or indifferent, of Irish honour. What are we asked to do in this case? Accommodation is to be provided for people who have made their best effort to ruin this country, not to ruin the Free State Government, but to ruin this country; not to ruin the Saorstát, but to drag in the mire the name of Ireland and make it a reproach amongst the nations, and hold up to the whole world a picture of infamy, such as no nation has yet had to hang its head in shame in order to witness. We are asked now to make comfortable happy homes for the people who have destroyed more homes in twelve months than have been destroyed in any other country, in the same period, by the same number, with the same resources as they had got, and who covered themselves with the flag or label that it was a military proposition. We have men serving in the Army of the Saorstát who fought with these men in the old days, who were associated with them in Councils, political organisations, Gaelic League classes, and in every other social, industrial and political movement which has been in operation in this country for a long time. We have ten thousand prisoners, or over that number—prisoners taken when the hot passions of men were aroused, when they saw great national heroes shot before their eyes, and they were the prisoners taken after that. There may have been excesses; I quite admit it. There are bound to be excesses. I have never yet heard of any country in which there were not excesses. I challenge any country to prove that there were less excesses anywhere than there were in this country by troops of the National Army, in any war, in any time, even in the time of the Crusaders.

Comment on this
Gerald Fitzgibbon ACTING CHAIRMAN (Mr. FitzGibbon) Independent

I am loath to interrupt any Deputy most of all, the President, but the question in this amendment is not the excesses alleged to be committed by the Army, but the propriety of having Councils to examine places of detention, and I think the President has wandered away from the subject matter of that amendment.

Comment on this

I was seeking to prove that the people who are guarding the prisoners are soldiers, and that it is alleged against them that, in their sober moments when their passions are not aroused, they are guilty of certain acts calculated to make internment worse than imprisonment and calculated to bring discredit and dishonour on the Army and the Government of the country. I went on to show that even in cases where hot blood was aroused on the field of battle they did not commit these excesses and that in the ordinary course of their duties as soldiers at these places of internment it was asking too much to ask us to believe that in their capacity as jailers, or guards, they would commit the excesses which the Deputy says the representatives of the County Councils should investigate.

Comment on this