We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

[ DAIL IN COMMITTEE. ] - PUBLIC SAFETY (EMERGENCY POWERS) BILL, 1923—THIRD STAGE RESUMED.

Contributions 204–405 of 405. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Public Safety (Emergency Powers) Bill, 1923
Enacted

No. 30 of 1923 ›

On a point of personal explanation I was very far from making any such general charges against the Army as the President has suggested. I said that charges had been made about certain abuses in internment camps, but I made no such sweeping charges as those to which the President has referred.

Comment on this

I was hoping that we were coming to a time in the public life of this country when Deputies, members of the Government, and other people in whom responsibility was reposed by the people would have sufficient moral courage to say "I do not mind that sort of twaddle; I am not going to listen to it." That is my attitude on the question of the prisoners. I have given my reasons for it. I have seen imprisonment. I know, even in the short experience I had, some of the sufferings endured by prisoners—very much greater sufferings than even those alleged by people who have made this propaganda. I know, furthermore, what is an outstanding thing with regard to these sufferings, that the men who went through them were never men to picture them and to draw the attention of the nation to the fact that they had undergone these sufferings. We have come in for considerable criticism by reason of the fact that some deaths occurred. I regret these deaths as much as anybody, as much as any member of any family of any person who has died, but, I submit with great respect, ten thousand men are not kept in any place, in any city, in which deaths do not occur. In the City of Dublin, Deputies know—there are two representatives of the City of Dublin here, an Alderman and a Councillor—what the death rate is in the city. And I know what the conditions are under which certain people in the City of Dublin are living. One person who is now suffering from the effects of imprisonment, and another person who was a prisoner and who is now dead, went with me through the city and visited the nightly lodging-houses, and saw the conditions under which ordinary free citizens live. I know full well that the care and attention which our prisoners are getting at present would be a sort of seventh heaven of delight to those unfortunate persons that I have seen housed under shocking conditions. The Deputy will have to recollect in these cases that the position of the Government is not to say "No," and not to say "Yes" arbitrarily. These unfortunate denizens of these nightly lodging houses have got to pay in their taxes for the upkeep of these prisoners. Yet we are asked to allow inspections by County Councils and County Borough Councils of our jails. I wonder if any of these County Councils or County Borough Councils would take the time to visit the places I mention, and observe the conditions under which free people live in their own bailiwicks and examine their consciences and see what they did to improve these conditions. I know some of them who have done much. I know in the City of Dublin great efforts have been made. I know, furthermore, while great interest has been aroused by propaganda regarding the conditions under which the prisoners are living, that a great many of these prisoners are not to be compared with that other order— I forget the name that Jack London called them, but I think it was the Submerged Tenth. Do these people ever consider that there was a very vast army of people who were unable to help themselves and who were going to be plunged below the submerged tenth down to the submerged twentieth by reason of their activities? I hesitate to believe for a moment that the men at present in the National Army would be guilty of any inhumanity towards prisoners, and I hesitate to believe that the Army Council, constituted as it is, would be guilty of such dereliction of their duty and I am not satisfied that the allegations such as have been made should be noticed to the extent of which they have been noticed. A report has been published from the Red Cross Organisation which makes a claim from their observations that the treatment of these people was all that could be desired. It makes it plain that they did not themselves appreciate their own duties as prisoners. The Deputy will recollect that facilities were afforded for personal cleanliness and that these facilities were not availed of. Is not that an incredible thing to say about idealists? Idealists there are amongst them but any idealists I ever came across were not willing to have posted on the hoardings of the city or published in the columns of the newspapers such slanders on their country, and libels on their own countrymen, to make life easy and comfortable, to make a nation upon which they did such severe wrong liable for making their existence, while in internment, comfortable and happy while they were there.

Comment on this

With all due respect to the President I do not think he has given reasons why the Dáil should not adopt Deputy Gavan Duffy's amendment. Everybody, or almost everybody who has had prison experience, and a great many who have not had that experience will agree that imprisonment does lend itself to various forms of propaganda, and it is just to be expected that the friends of the prisoners of the President should improve if anything on the friends of the prisoners of the recent past. But is that any reason why, when a suggestion is made that the present Executive should re-adopt in another form, certain provisions of certain previous Acts relating to the visiting by authorised people of the prisons and places of detention under their care——

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Authorised by whom?

Comment on this

By responsible public authorities. All that the President says about the conduct and character of the Army and of that portion of the Army to which is entrusted the guarding of prisoners may be all very well true. I am not questioning it for a moment, but if it is all so true what is the reasonable objection then to the admission of a panel of visitors such as is provided for in this amendment? Th re is no objection that I can see to it, none whatever. As I remarked the other day, it is not necessarily a reflection either on the conduct or character of the Executive Council or the military authorities that such Visiting Committees should be set up. It is part of the ordinary procedure under the ordinary prison system before the present and recent strife in Ireland. At various times under the British and other Governments they themselves set up not only Committees something similar to those Committees, but actually ad hoc Commissions to inquire into the conduct of prisons when there were complaints that everything was not quite all that it might be in those prisons. None of them ever suggested, I think, that the making of this inquiry by someone independent of the Executive, not employed by the Executive, even if they reported unfavourably on the conditions of persons, really meant that there was a national or wholesale condemnation of that particular Government's conduct in its prison service. In all those thing, of course, I quite admit time, circumstances and occasion must be taken into consideration, but I submit that if time, circumstances and occasion are taken into consideration in those matters now that the balance of argument will be in favour of something like what is provided for in the amendment. It is really perhaps only a reversion in another form to a practice elsewhere, and in other and quite recent times. The Executive Council should have nothing to fear from an investigation into these matters; on the contrary, it should have everything to hope from it. If the Executive is in a position, as it feels itself to be in a position, to pat itself on the back because certain visitors from the International Red Cross should visit certain prisoners and did not positively condemn the treatment of those prisoners, how much more to the credit of the Executive Council would it not be if such Committees as these were in the position that they would be allowed to go in and report that everything was good and things nice and proper so far as the Executive Council could make them so? Now, the President has touched all our hearts with his contrast between the conditions in the common lodging houses in Dublin and the prisons. When he referred to them he did not say anything that was new to some of the Deputies here, or anything new to people outside. While I admit he was one of those who did his little bit to help, I want him to remember that there are very many people even in the worst slums in Dublin, even in the worst conditions in Dublin— it is not creditable to Dublin or to Ireland that there should be such a thing; it is not creditable to civilisation anywhere that the prisons, the prison services, and the conditions in prisons in any country should be so far above the conditions which prevail amongst those who are referred to as the Submerged Tenth—who would prefer to die in starvation under the worst conditions rather than to live in comparative case and comfort and plenitude without their liberty. The President and every other Deputy who has been in a prison knows that no comforts of prison were able to compensate him or anybody else for the loss of liberty, even if that loss of liberty were only for a time. It is not a good reason why he should not accept this amendment.

Comment on this

We have been urged to pass this Bill a dozen times by references to the desirability of passing from a state of disorder, of armed rebellion, a state of war, to a state of peace, and to make that transit as orderly as possible, and as easy as possible. I submit in accord with that desire that this motion should be supported. During the state of war it was considered necessary by the Executive Council that people should be imprisoned and that there should be no inspection; there should be no access to those prisoners by people outside the prisons, because of the state of war, because of the armed rebellion, because of the danger that would arise from the in-coming and the outgoing of civilians. And let us assume that the Ministry were justified in that contention, in the transit to a state of peace. It is asked that Committees equivalent to Committees which actually exist in time of peace should be established, that some body comparable with the Visiting Justices should be set up by the County Councils to visit internment camps and prisons. That I contend is consistent with the declared intention of the Minister in introducing the Bill to pass as gradually and as easily as possible to a state of normality. The President has emphasised the report of the Red Cross Committees Delegation. While that may be very satisfactory to the President, I really do not think it is a document that ought to give so much satisfaction to him. I would have been much better pleased, and I really expected a much more satisfactory document than that which the President has referred to us, in confirmation of the claim he has made as to the desirable condition of these camps. But really that is not the point. The camps may be perfect; there may not be the shadow of reason for a complaint about the conduct of the camps, but nevertheless it is desirable that the public should have some means of knowing whether that is true or not, even independent of the statement of the Minister. The Minister has just grounds for asking that the public should accept his word, but unfortunately in this imperfect world there is no man whose word is taken absolutely by every person, and in this country there is quite a large proportion of the population doubtful of the statements that have been made on behalf of the Ministry in regard to matters for which the Ministry is responsible. We are all apt to say that the things we are responsible for are all right, that they do not deserve criticism, but rightly or wrongly the public do not take us at our own valuation. And if the Minister wants to have his word in a matter of this kind accepted implicitly, the establishment of Committees of this kind, to confirm his claim, is the way to ensure that the public will have confidence in statements made on behalf of the Executive Council.

No doubt, as Deputy O'Shannon said, there are thousands of people who would be very glad of the accommodation, the attention, the food that is provided to the people in the internment camps, even without going to the people of the abyss, even without going to the Submerged Tenth. There are many people who are giving all their strength for wages, and who are not getting sufficient wages to feed themselves in the way that we are assured the prisoners are fed. But surely that is not the point, surely, it is a reasonable request that in a place where 1,000 prisoners are detained, or 2,000, or 5,000 that somebody representing the public, outside the Executive, should have access to those places, even if only to consider the sanitary conditions. That, too, has been denied, and yet we know that when attention was called here to a glaring cases, immediately remedies were found, but they were found because there had been some publicity. It is with a view to securing and assuring that there shall be publicity of grievances, because then the remedy will speedily follow, that it is desirable to embody such a section in the Bill, so that the public, through their representatives, shall have some right of inspection, and that there shall be some contact between the prisoner and the public by means of which a grievance, if it is a well-founded grievance, can be made public. If it has in normal times been found necessary to appoint Justices to visit prisons, when there has been no overcrowding, when there has been no abnormal circumstances attending the imprisonment, surely it is not unreasonable to claim that in abnormal times when there has been admittedly overcrowding, that there should be some public right of supervision over the conditions under which untried prisoners, uncharged prisoners, innocent prisoners in many cases, have been interned.

That is not an extraordinary charge. It is not a want of confidence in the Ministry. It is a reasonable proposition. and it should commend itself to any Government or any assembly which desires to keep proper contact and proper control over matters under its authority and under its administration. The Dáil applauded Deputy McGoldrick to-day when he referred to his faith in the elected representatives of the people. Here is a chance for Deputy McGoldrick and those who support him in that view of proving their faith in the elected representatives of the people, because the County Councils are also the elected representatives of the people.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Elected for what?

Comment on this

To look after the conditions of life within their area; to look after the sanitation within their area, to protect the public health within their area.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

It is well to know that.

Comment on this

And in the case of the County Borough of Dublin to appoint prison visitors within their area. That is what they were elected for, and I ask the Minister to have faith in the elected representatives of the people.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Deputy if he is aware of any action taken by any of those bodies recently on that particular subject—the election of representatives.

Comment on this

I do now know what the President is referring to.

Comment on this

I am referring to the appointment of Justices by local authorities. Is the Deputy aware that on a recent occasion a local authority refused to appoint those representatives?

Comment on this

I am not aware of it.

Comment on this

It would be well that the Deputy should know something about these bodies before he talks about them.

Comment on this

The Minister is responsible for those bodies more than I am. The Minister has been a member of one of those bodies, and he knows more about them than I do.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The Minister has not yet had the courage to come to the Dáil and say he is going to abolish all the local bodies. They are elected, and the Minister has brought before this Dáil a Franchise Bill which desires that the same people who elect the Members of the the Dáil also elect members of the local bodies.

Comment on this
Gerald Fitzgibbon ACTING CHAIRMAN (Mr. FitzGibbon) Independent

The question of the Franchise Bill cannot arise on this.

Comment on this

I agree, but I think the Minister invited that retort.

Comment on this
George Nicolls ACTING CHAIRMAN Sinn Féin

I am inclined to agree with you.

Comment on this

It was very handy to put in that retort when there was no answer to my question.

Comment on this

I desire to support this amendment to set up Committees to inquire into the state of the prisons and internment camps. I will cite a case that will prove the necessity of these Committees. On the 3rd May last I asked a question of the Minister for Defence about a young lad named Cardwell, 13½ years of age, who was taken out of Naas military barracks, and who was wounded in the neck. The answer I got to that question was:—

"Leo Cardwell was arrested by troops from Naas at his home early on the morning of the 24th April. At the house there were also taken six recently escaped internees, and firearms and ammunition. With the others Cardwell was brought to Naas military barracks at about 9 a.m. on the morning of his arrest. Because of his age, which he gave as 13½ years, it was not intended to detain him and he was kept apart from the others. It would appear that whilst in custody, and some time during the night of the 24th-25th April, he received a slight wound in the neck. In connection with the occurrence a member of the Army is now under arrest awaiting trial by court-martial, for the convening of which steps have already been taken. Pending the result of the trial it is not possible to make a statement as to the facts of the occurrence."

I have received no information as to how the court-martial went. On the 6th of June I wrote "Will you please let me know the result of the court-martial which was held in connection with the wounding of the boy Leo Cardwell. Also if he has yet recovered from his wound, and if he is likely to be affected with a stiff neck, and if he is now at liberty."

I got a formal acknowledgment on the following day, 7th June. I wrote on the 22nd June, and I got another formal acknowledgment on the 23rd.

Now what is the use of the Minister speaking about how the prisoners are treated when this young man could be taken out of the barracks at the dead of night and wounded in the neck by one of the military. Then he says there is no necessity for Committees to be appointed to see that everything is right in these internment camps and prisons. Is he afraid that these Committees will find out that what he is saying is not true? If everything is right I cannot see why he should object to these Committees being set up.

Comment on this

I also wish to support the amendment. Like other Deputies, I suppose, I am every week receiving what is commonly called propaganda. I do not know how much of it is true or how much of it lies, but I would like to know exactly how much of it is true. Some of this propaganda in connection with the Cork Courthouse came before the Public Health Committee in Cork, of which I am a member. There were very grave allegations made as to the conditions under which the prisoners existed. I am very glad to say—although it was not until after consideraable trouble—the medical officer of health in Cork was given permission to visit the place and that he made a fairly satisfactory report as to the conditions. If the medical officer had not been allowed to visit the place and give that report every member of the Public Health Committee, and practically every citizen of Cork would believe that what was contained in that propaganda sheet was the truth. For that reason I say that it is the business of the Government to see that the representatives of the people get at the truth. We want to make the truth heard, and we want to know what amount of truth is contained in this propaganda. There is no member of the Dáil or no member of a County Borough or County Council, I believe, who wishes to know anything but the truth as to the conditions in those places. I myself have got several complaints and I have made application to the General Officer Commanding in Cork for permission to visit those places to find out the truth for myself, as I thought it was my duty to do. That permission was refused to me on every occasion. Therefore I could only come to the conclusion that something was absolutely wrong there. The Corporation appointed a Deputation to visit the prison and when the application was made to the General Officer Commanding that permission was also refused. If there had been nothing to conceal why was this permission refused? As public representatives we simply want to know exactly what is going on inside there and what exactly is the position of the prisoners, and to find out for ourselves what amount of truth is contained in this propaganda that was sent out. I know that that is my position anyway. I simply want to know what is the truth and what is false—the statements made from the Ministerial Benches or the statements contained in these propaganda sheets. For that reason I support the amendment.

Comment on this

I would like also to support the amendment, and I regret that the Minister in charge, or the President, is not prepared to accept at least the principle underlying the suggestion, even if they were not prepared to accept the text itself. It may be quite true, of course, that a great many of the stories circulated with regard to the treatment of prisoners are propaganda, but I would be very slow to believe that a man like Alderman Charles Murphy would make the statement that is being circulated— if he has made it—unless there were good foundation for it. I do not pretend to know Alderman Murphy as well as the President or other Deputies do, but I know him moderately well for eight or ten years, and I have always looked on him as a most honourable and upright man who would be incapable of making a statement which he did not believe to be true. We have had other statements also for which there must be some foundation, and whatever justification the Ministry may have felt in the past for refusing visits when the country was in a state of war, conditions are now considerably changed for the better, and they could well afford to give way on that and allow some visiting committee to go in for the purpose of verifying that statement that the prisoners are well and reasonably treated. The President has referred, quire correctly, to the decision of the Dublin Corporation to defer the appointment of visiting justices. That is perfectly true, and if his objection, and the objection of the Minister in charge, is to the precise proposal that these visiting committees should be appointed by the county or borough councils, perhaps the Minister would agree to the principle of some visiting body, and, at a later stage, bring up a proposal that perhaps he himself would nominate a visiting committee, taking care to see that they were persons in whom the public would repose confidence. I would throw out that suggestion for consideration.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Section 13 of this Bill provides: "That an Executive Minister may make regulations prescribing the prisons, internment camps and other places in which persons detained in custody under this Act may be detained; providing for the efficient management control and guarding of such prisons, camps and other places; providing for the enforcement and preservation of discipline amongst the persons so detained; providing for the prevention of the escape of any such person, and prescribing or providing for any other matter or thing relating to the efficient detention of such persons under this Act." I take it that that Section places very definitely the duty upon an Executive Minister of providing for the general efficiency and management of these places of detention. He will be answerable for that duty here to the representatives of the people, not to the representatives of the people, elected for Local Government purposes, but to the representatives elected with a broad national mandate to deal with matters of this kind. Some interesting expressions were used in the debate. "Somebody representing the public," said Deputy Johnson, and then, noticing the start of surprise on this side, he said, "I mean representing the public, outside the Executive." There seemed certainly to be an undercurrent, or an implication, throughout this debate that everyone represented the public except the Executive Council; that a county council represented the public; that even a body whom the county council might nominate would more amply represent the public than the Executive Council of the State or than the Parliament of the State. That is wrong.

Comment on this

Is it? Is it wrong?

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

It is quite wrong. Responsible government consists in placing upon a Minister or Ministers primary responsibility for a certain thing, responsibility to the elected representatives of the people, sitting in their Parliament. They should answer for all matters committed to their care—answer fully. If they fail to answer to the satisfaction of the representatives of the people, then the duty of the representatives of the people is clear, but instead of having the fullest discussion and the fullest inquiry here——

Comment on this

They never had the means of getting knowledge.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

When did you ever ask for information and not get it?

Comment on this

How can we get the basis of our information without access to the prisons?

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I do not quite follow the Deputy.

Comment on this

The point is that the only kind of information you can get from prisons are these documents, which are alleged to be poisoned. We want to have a chance of getting truthful documents, and then if we find there are grievances we can raise them in the Dáil.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Did you send those documents to the Minister for Defence?

Comment on this
Gerald Fitzgibbon ACTING CHAIRMAN (Mr. FitzGibbon) Independent

These comments back and forward are out of order. The Minister himself invites interruption by putting questions to Deputies.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

The county councils and the local bodies generally, were elected for a specific purpose. I do not know what the general view of the Deputies or of the public is as to the manner in which these duties are being performed but, at any rate, their duties are specified and well defined, and personally, I question greatly the wisdom of adding to their duties what is really the proper function of a responsible Executive Government. Let us consider the county councils and ask ourselves, whether, in the existing conditions, they are proper bodies to entrust this function to. Five-sixths of the County Council of Kerry have been out in arms against the Executive Government of the State, elected by the people and responsible to the people, and they, forsooth, are to appoint a Committee of Inspection. If the county councils and the local bodies generally, concentrate on the particular duties for which they were elected I think that they will win general satisfaction and general approbation from the people. Deputy O'Brien asked for some acceptance of the principle that there should be inspection. Regulations will be made under Section 13. Personally, I see no objection to the principle of selected men, not in a paid capacity, being appointed by the Executive to visit places of this kind, but their appointment should be by the Executive and their reports to the Executive. This matter of the proper care and treatment of prisoners is Executive action, and such inspection of these places that takes place should be on behalf of the Executive. Deputies have insisted on talking as if the position here were what it was four or five years ago; they have persistently in their comments on this amendment, ignored the change; they have said "Whatever the British thought it right or expedient to do you should think it right or expedient to do."

Comment on this

Not except it was right in itself.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

It may have been right in the particular set of conditions then, and it need not be right now. It may have been necessary or advisable in a particular set of conditions, and not necessary or not advisable now. The whole Executive machinery of this country is responsible now to the people of the country, through the people's representatives. There is not a single phase or aspect of administration which you are not entitled to raise, question and criticise here. If the matter of conditions within detention camps were raised here—if it had been raised, say, any time this six months past—do Deputies really believe that the Minister for Defence would have withheld or refused the fullest of full reports thereon?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Surely that is his particular function, amongst other functions for which he was appointed by this Dáil, and for which he is responsible to the Dáil. To suggest you should seek your information, not from him, but from some County Council, some local authority which is appointed, and select people at random from within these areas to visit a detention camp, well, that is simply a reversal of responsible Government, and simply consists in saying that local bodies elected for a very different purpose throughout the country shall, so to speak, be set to act as spies upon your Executive, and report to you as to the result. That is a position which I certainly will not accept in principle, or as it stands in the amendment. I do, as I say, accept this, that responsible citizens selected by the Executive, and not paid by the Executive, shall visit these places and report.

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister would he limit the selection of such persons to supporters of the Government—that is to say would he propose to exclude from such Visiting Committees persons who might not be supporters of the Government?

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I do not know what the Deputy means by "supporters of the Government." Supposing the duty of selection lay on me, I would not think of selecting people who approved of armed revolt against the Government, or of people who approved of outrages such as the burning of homes.

Comment on this

No; but, say, people who believed in the establishment of a Republic, and in whom prisoners have confidence, and who would not approve of the outrages or attacks. Would he approve of the appointment of a Labour member of the Dáil, for example?

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I want to be quite frank with the Deputy. There are certain offences set out in the schedule of this Bill, and I would not dream of appointing any person who I thought had any sympathy whatever with these offences. It is not a political matter, but sympathy with any of these acts or these crimes would, to my mind, automatically exclude for selection any person. But, if the Deputy means this, and I think he does, that a decent law-abiding responsible citizen ought to be eligible for selection utterly regardless of his political views, then I think that that ought to be the case.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Brien has asked the Minister a very definite question as to whether or not he would exclude from such a Committee, a Labour member of the Dáil. That question has not been answered.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

It could not be answered specifically. If persons were being selected they would not be selected qua a Labour member of the Dáil, but would be selected qua responsible law-abiding citizens.

Comment on this

The refusal of the Minister to answer that direct question could be taken that we would be regarded as sympathetic to armed revolt.

Comment on this
George Nicolls ACTING CHAIRMAN Sinn Féin

As a matter of fact, this questioning backwards and forwards to the Minister is quite irregular. It does not arise on this amendment. The Minister, in replying on the motion for the amendment, said that when he came to Section 13 he was quite prepared to appoint a visiting committee. It is quite irregular to cross-examine him now as to what the constitution of that committee would be, and certainly nothing he said was capable of the interpretation that he regarded any Deputy or Deputies as sympathising with crime.

Comment on this

I take it that there is no difference of opinion as to whether or not any member of the Dáil could be regarded as other than a law-abiding citizen. I am one of those persons who have been in receipt of the propaganda referred to, but for obvious reasons I have never mentioned the matter in the Dáil before. The Minister asked did we send this particular class of propaganda to the Minister for Defence. Well, I took it for granted that the propaganda referred to was received by every member of the Dáil, and by the Minister for Defence himself.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I never saw it.

Comment on this

However, even though the propaganda has not been received by the Minister himself, I am sure that he would desire that every possible ground for the removal of such complaints should be put on the one side, and that any such complaint coming to his notice, or to the notice of the Minister for Defence, should be inquired into. It appears to be the case that as every member of the Government party seems to be satisfied with the Minister's explanation, they are in possession of other information, or have access to the places where these complaints are made, and in that way have some information at their disposal, or means of inquiry into these things, that we in these benches have not. We are, as far as I can see, here on sufferance, and can only get statements on these matters out of the Ministry by making a complaint, and in some cases do not succeed in getting the actual information looked for. That complaints are justified is, I think, beyond dispute. We had a case referred to here the other day by Deputy Everett, regarding the treatment of prisoners in Wicklow jail, and it was only as a result of that complaint, and not before, that the actual matter referred to was settled. I understand in that particular case the prisoners have since been removed to a place perhaps somewhat better than the place where they were complaining of their treatment. I would like to say that every reasonable ground for suspicion should be removed, but most of the clauses put a premium on suspicion. Many suggestions have been made in the various amendments for the purpose of having a better check over things such as have happened in the past, but every such suggestion has been turned down by the Ministry, and when made by us is taken as a vote of no confidence in the Executive Council.

Now I think that is not the right spirit in which an amendment with that intention should be received by the Minister. I say that because a case like the Wicklow case has only been dealt with after complaint. I think it is up to the Ministry to make a reasonable provision that such cases should not occur again and by accepting an amendment of this kind they would be making reasonable provision for such cases.

Comment on this

The Minister rather deprecated the appointment of these Committees by such bodies as County Councils rather than by bodies such as would be set up by the Dáil or the Executive Council. He dealt, rather sharply I think, with Deputy Johnson upon that. He does not think it right that the County Councils should be considered as proper bodies for selecting such Committees as this. He instanced a procession of circumstances in connection with County Councils and particularly he quoted the Kerry County Council. Now the Kerry County Council is not a fair case because, unless I am very much mistaken, the Kerry County Council is in suspense and is not functioning owing to the activities of certain of its members. But legally and according to regulations approved and passed by this Dáil the heirs to the Co. Council of Kerry would be empowered by this amendment, if adopted, to appoint such Committees. The same would apply to any other County Council or Borough Council that happened to be suspended by the operations of another Act of the Dáil. Now I suppose that the legitimate heirs to the Kerry County Council, and to other suspended County Councils, would be entitled to make these appointments. There may be some doubt about that, but, at any rate, the argument of the suspended County Councils does not apply at all by any means. It is quite true, as the Minister says, that the circumstances of the times might make it advisable at one time to do a certain thing that may not be possible under the regime to-day. Quite true. Some of us are of opinion that an Act which might have been inadvisable, unwise and not justified six or twelve months ago might be quite advisable and wise enough and, from the point of view of public policy, justified now. I suggest to the Minister that he should take that point into consideration.

Comment on this

I am sure that Ministers who supported the Minister for Home Affairs, and also the Deputies who supported him in asking for an all-night sitting did so in the interests of the passing of this Bill, and they now show that interest by absenting themselves from the Dáil during our discussions. Deputy O'Shannon's last speech on this Bill was not heard by any of the Ministers because they were absent, and was followed by very few Deputies on the Ministerial Benches. I am not going at this hour to criticise those who ask for an all-night sitting, but I want to point cut a few facts in support of this amendment of Deputy Gavan Duffy. It is intended to give power to the County Councils so that the Minister may be able to take into his confidence the duly elected representatives of the people in the County Councils. If the Government are anxious to get the Bill through before morning one would imagine that the Government Benches would be packed with Deputies. We are here on these benches to a man ready to defend any amendment put forward by Deputy Gavan Duffy. Now with regard to the actual subject raised by this amendment the President declared that half the unfortunate people living outside in lodging houses were worse off than the prisoners interned.

Comment on this

Are they not?

Comment on this

There is a great deal of argument for and against. I think it is perfectly right, if Deputies hold that people outside are worse off than the prisoners, that this amendment should be accepted, and that their dwellings should also be inspected by Committees appointed by some such authority as the County Councils. This amendment does not suggest anything that the promoters of the Bill should fear; there should be nothing to fear from the people of the Saorstát if everything is as stated by the President, and by the Minister for Home Affairs. Why then not agree to this amendment? It would look as if there was something to fear, and that there was something wrong.

If the prisoners are treated as explained by the Ministers then there can be nothing to fear. So far as he is concerned he can allow any committee appointed by anybody to inquire into these matters. But we find that the Minister is up against allowing any committee to be appointed, or giving any Committee an opportunity of visiting the prisoners, and of seeing that doctors and sanitary officers and other officers requiring to visit these prisoners have the privilege of doing so.

Surely, the County Councils are bodies of men that could be trusted? If we can possibly get the Minister for Home Affairs to accept any amendment that will improve this Bill I am sure that our night's work here will not be in vain, but we find that the supporters of the Minister are just as hard and unreasonable as the Minister himself. It appears that the Minister will not accept the principle of this amendment unless he is able to assure himself that the persons who will be appointed under it are law-abiding citizens of the Saorstát. Furthermore he is so strongly against the appointment of these County Council Committees that I am of opinion he imagines that the County Councils want to make a job out of these Committees and appoint some people who will have to be paid. I hope that is really not the view of the Minister, and that he will give the members of the County Councils the right to appoint these Committees. I can assure Deputies on the benches opposite, that there are patriotic men among the County Councils of this country. The people selected the County Councillors as they did the members of this Dáil. The members of the Executive seem to think that they are the employers of the people, but they would soon find that the people are really their masters. The people are sovereign and the day will come when they will prove they are the masters of the members of the Executive Council as well as of the members of the Dáil. I support this amendment, because it gives a facility to the County Councils to see to the welfare of the prisoners, and because it classifies them as genuine citizens of the State. It gives them an opportunity to visit prisoners interned in their areas. The amendment provides that it shall be the duty of every County Council within whose area persons are detained in custody without trial under this Bill to appoint a Committee consisting of such number of persons of good standing in the locality as the Council shall deem necessary, etc.; it places a duty upon this Committee and it specifies that duty which amounts to this that it will advise the Minister for Home Affairs or the Minister for Local Government or some other members of the Executive Council with regard to the treatment of prisoners.

That does not in the least take the power out of the hands of the Executive Council. If we are going to classify, or if, in your opinion, you think this amendment ought to classify county councillors as law-abiding citizens, then if you did that you should certainly accept this amendment. In speaking of the County Councils I was going to say you have thirty-two. I am sorry we have only twenty-six, but we are looking forward to the time when we will have thirty-two and when we will be all together again. But out of twenty-six County Councils you mention one Council that seemed to have advised people to take up arms against the Government selected by the majority of the people of this Saorstát——

Comment on this
Gerald Fitzgibbon ACTING CHAIRMAN (Mr. FitzGibbon) Independent

Deputy Lyons has now considerably exceeded his time allowance. He has spoken far beyond the time limit. I thought a little time ago he would finish his peroration.

Comment on this

I want to congratulate the last speaker upon the brevity and lucidity of his speech——

Comment on this

On a point of order I think I have the floor still.

Comment on this
George Nicolls ACTING CHAIRMAN Sinn Féin

The Standing Order says "that in Committee no Deputy shall speak more than ten minutes at a time." You have spoken fifteen minutes.

Comment on this

Well, I will allow Deputy Milroy to go on for the sole purpose of getting another ten minutes later on.

Comment on this

I do not want to interrupt the proceedings, but I simply could not allow the occasion to pass without congratulating the last Deputy upon the brevity of his remarks, in view of the fact that it was he suggested that we should continue our discussion to a late hour to-morrow morning, when he said that the speeches on this side of the Dáil would not in any way impede the progress of legislation.

Comment on this

Neither will they.

Comment on this

I want also to compliment the Deputy upon the lucidity of his remarks. They are so lucid that when he sat down I think a few of us really understood what was the drift of his remarks.

Comment on this

I believe you.

Comment on this

There is one other point I want to make, and it has not been made by anybody else—

Comment on this

By anybody else?

Comment on this

Wait until I make my point. The point I want to make is this:—that the Deputies on the other side of the Dáil seem to fail to realise that they are sitting in an Irish Parliament.

Comment on this

So they might when you have Bills like this.

Comment on this

They seem to think that they are sitting in the benches in the English House of Commons facing Sir Hamar Greenwood instead of facing an Irish Minister. The discussion tonight in regard to this measure, and this amendment, seems to be absolutely in a world apart from realities. The Minister who is in charge of this Bill has only one consideration, that is to preserve the security of life and liberty in this country. Every utterance from the other side of the Dáil seems to be based on the belief that he was concerned with assailing life and liberty in this country. The remarks from the other side of the Dáil would have been very pertinent to a discussion of this kind if they had been confronting the British Ministry in the English House of Commons. Let them remember that they are sitting in an Irish Parliament, and that those whom they are attacking and criticising are the custodians of order and government, of life and liberty in this country, and let them adapt their arguments and their criticism to that fundamental fact.

Comment on this

The Deputies on this side of the Dáil realise the fact quite as well as Deputy Milroy. If I may be allowed to say so they have been directing their criticism and their comments and their suggestions to the Bill before the Dáil, and not at all to the Minister, either as a person or as a Minister, except in so far as he happens to be a Minister who is in charge of the Bill during its course through the Dáil. It is ridiculous nonsense for any Deputy to suggest that we here forget that we are in an Irish Parliament, and that we are not facing the gentleman to whom he refers. But we are not prepared, and I hope that no party and no section that ever gains representation in the Dáil will ever be prepared, to neglect the first duty of public representatives, and that is to give close and careful examination to every measure that comes before the Dáil, and to assist, as we are endeavouring to assist the Ministry of the day, in producing a measure that will be satisfactory. The Deputy's remarks have not at all been addressed to the amendment before the Dáil. I am not going so far as to say that his remarks were quite out of order. But I can quite understand that he felt he had got something to say and he wanted to say it. Now we would have welcomed a reasoned and fair, or even a little beyond fair, criticism of any of the points that have been made on this side in support of the amendment, if that Deputy or any Deputy had made an effort to reply. But no, he did not do anything of the kind. He leaves it all to the Ministry. And then, because some of us have the damnable audacity to attempt to assist the Minister we are accused of something that in certain periods in Irish history were considered not very creditable to Irishmen.

Comment on this

Deputy Milroy has broken the spell. We have been accused on this side of doing something which was only worthy to be done in the British House of Commons, and he reminded us that we were not facing Sir Hamar Greenwood. Sir Hamar Greenwood even with all his enormities did not venture to introduce into the British House of Commons any Bill giving to the Executive, against the people, half of the power which is embodied in this Bill.

Comment on this

Against the people.

Comment on this

Against the people.

Comment on this

This is for the protection of the people.

Comment on this

That is the opinion of the Minister. I am quoting my own opinion—that the power that is given in this Bill to the Minister is against the people.

Comment on this

What people?

Comment on this

The Deputy has one notion of responsible government, and we have heard another theory of responsible government from the Minister, both of which are very interesting and very extraordinary. The Minister has only one consideration—to preserve the life and liberty of the people. Because of that, therefore, the Dáil must say, "ditto." The Dáil must not open its mouth. The Dáil must not utter one word of criticism, because the Minister in charge of the Bill has only one consideration—to preserve the life and liberty of the people.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

It has often been said that the road to hell is paved with those good intentions. I venture to say that Deputies have in the past held the view that their business was to realise they had a responsibility to their constituents, and to express their views even though they were in criticism of the views of the Minister. Surely, we are not at that stage that because the Minister has good intentions, everything that these good intentions leads to must be wise and beneficent? It is an utterly false doctrine. We have a right to assume that the intentions of every member of the Dáil are good and just as well-intentioned as those of the Minister; but if we differ in the practical application of those good intentions, are we to be freed from criticism? The good intentions are not going to save the Minister from criticism, and good intentions are not going to save a Bill from being examined. Deputy Milroy should not pretend that he thinks because one Minister is sacrosanct, every other Deputy must bow down and worship.

Comment on this

I do not think any Minister is sacrosanct.

Comment on this

I am glad you agree with me in that.

Comment on this

The Ministers are quite aware that I have no such delusions about their infallibility——

Comment on this
Gerald Fitzgibbon ACTING CHAIRMAN (Mr. FitzGibbon) Independent

Or sacrosanctity.

Comment on this

There is one thing Deputy Milroy and I can agree upon, and that is that one would hope to hear in this Assembly, the organ of public expression, that those views of Deputy Milroy would occasionally find expression. I want to deal seriously with the question raised by Deputy O'Brien. He suggested as a reasonable modification of this amendment that the Minister might himself nominate a committee of inspection which would have the confidence of the people generally, and the Minister agreed with the principle; he said that such a committee would be required to report to the Minister. I am not sure whether that was intended to be exclusive, or whether it was to be a report to the Minister as a matter of form and order, and that the report would in the normal course of affairs be made public. If the Minister grants that I would advise the Dáil to accept that suggestion, but if, on the contrary, it is not intended to publish these reports, then there is nothing gained. The whole point of this amendment is, as I understand it, to ensure that public confidence shall reside in the conduct of the servants of the State, and especially those who are in charge of the prison camps, and that public confidence can only be ensured when there is some supervision, and when the reports of such supervisors as may be appointed can be made public. I do not want to delay the Dáil by dealing to any extent with the County Councils; but one cannot refrain from asking Deputies when did they lose their faith in the County Councils? I think Deputy Milroy will remember, and surely the President will remember, that the County Councils were to be the units out of which were to be formed the National Council. It was to be the basis of the legislative authority. But now none so poor as do them reverence. I wonder what was the date of this loss of faith. Was it the date of the last election for which Deputies were so closely responsible when they knew from first-hand knowledge what they were doing? I want to say on this that I would not like it to appear even with any stretch of the imagination that there was any desire on these benches to act dilatorily or to delay the Dáil. We are honestly desirous of discussing this measure thoroughly and carefully, and to amend and improve it. The sooner that can be done the better we shall all be pleased, and I think, perhaps, the President can rely on the Deputies sitting on the opposite benches, judging by precedent, and I hope no Deputies sitting on these benches will even give an excuse for Deputies to think that they are acting in a dilatory fashion.

Comment on this

Never, never.

Comment on this

We do desire to amend this Bill. We have put down a series of amendments that have been carefully thought over, that are honestly intended to improve the measure, and I hope the Dáil will give thorough consideration to them. I trust it will not be thought that because Deputies here are obliged in the absence of any contrary argument to continue the discussion for the purpose of enlightening the Dáil, that there is any desire to obstruct the ordinary legislative machine.

Comment on this

Before the Dáil votes on this matter, I should like very briefly to deal with two points made by the Minister for Home Affairs. I need not deal with what the President said because he was very completely disposed of by that other very great artist—Deputy Lyons. The Minister for Home Affairs deprecated the idea of allowing prisons to be visited by persons appointed by the Kerry County Council. This proposal does not speak of the Kerry County Council, but of the County Councils in whose areas these established internment camps are situated, such as Gormanstown, the Curragh, and so forth. My impression is that all these established camps are situated in areas where the Government is very thoroughly in control and in areas where nothing can be said against the County Council, such as has been said by the Minister against the Kerry County Council. The Minister before he volunteered to accept the proposal in principle to a certain degree argued that it was not necessary on the grounds that in this Dáil from the Ministers here we could get all the information necessary. The Minister is under a complete misapprehension if he thinks that the case given by the Labour Benches is unusual. I will give him another. Two or three weeks ago I wrote to the Minister for Defence in connection with the death in prison of a Doctor who was a member of the last Dáil. I wrote privately in order that it should not be said that this was a matter of making propaganda. The circumstances connected with the death as to the non-admission of the wife and relatives were circumstances which required explanation, and I wrote fully to the Minister. I had a very courteous reply to the effect that the matter would receive attention, but I had nothing more. Another Deputy asked a question on the subject in the Dáil a day or two ago, and got a very inadequate and unsatisfactory reply. That is just an instance to add to the other instances that have been given in order the Ministers may realise that if they think they are doing justice to complaints in connection with prisons and detention camps they are labouring under a delusion. Matters of that kind ought to be dealt with promptly. I am unable to get information which one would think would be volunteered very readily, and with all possible speed. The Minister gave an undertaking of a somewhat vague character. I do not profess to know how far he committed himself, but he did not altogether object to inspection from outside, and he contemplated persons who would have a right to go into the prison. If that is the Minister's frame of mind I would invite him to agree to get fit and proper persons to undertake that work. If the County Councils are not allowed to undertake it, it should be the members of this Dáil who are medical men. Yet can I be blamed if I have misunderstood the Minister's undertakings when I recollect that only yesterday a proposal to depute members of this Dáil and of the Seanád who are medical men, nearly all of whom are strong supporters of the the Government, was vehemently objected to by some Ministers? If these are not proper persons to inspect, who are? If these are not proper people to allow to go into the detention camps, whom shall you consider proper persons? In these circumstances and owing to the vague manner in which the Minister dealt with questions from the Labour Benches as to the character of persons he would allow to inspect the prisons, I cannot accept the assurance he has given as being anything like satisfactory.

Comment on this

May I intervene to explain that there are few people in this Dáil or outside of it who have a longer experience of the business of local authorities than I have. I understood that my business in connection with local authorities was concerned with matters which affected local authorities. I would remind the Deputy who has just spoken and who is perhaps the greatest of all artists either in this or any other assembly, that the roads of this country are a very serious consideration for the County Councils and when they master that and if we are lax in our duties and responsibilities and in the particular things which concern us here—

Comment on this

Do I understand the President to suggest that the prisoners will remain in prison until the roads are made right?

Comment on this

I say if we are not capable of discharging the duties of our office it will be for the County Councils to take on the extra work and assume responsibility where we are deficient. Apart from the roads there is the question of rates, and apart from the rates in the County Council which the Deputy instanced there is a grave state of civil commotion. What have been the efforts of the particular County Council in question. Did they concern themselves with matters of vital importance to themselves? If any damage has been done there the County Council, or their successors, will have to levy rates but in the plenitude of their administrative capacity they find time to tell us how to do our work and correct the omissions and incapacity of the Ministry. We do not require it. I have a recollection, Sir, that on the last occasion when I was a member of a local authority a question arose as to the appointment of Visiting Justices—that is what they were called at the time—gentlemen who had taken the oath of allegiance to Deputy Gavan Duffy's friend.

Comment on this

Name.

Comment on this

And the late Minister for Finance, God rest his soul, sent down word that he did not see any objection to appointing them, but the Minister for Home Affairs sent down a message that we might not appoint them. The one, I expect, is reaping the result of his labours; the other is one of our guests; and if he did not consider that the prisoners held by the foreigner should be provided with visitors at that time, what right has he now, or anyone on his behalf, to ask us to appoint visitors to see how he is getting on wherever he is at this moment?

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 13
·
Níl 39
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

William O'Brien Mr. WILLIAM O'BRIEN Labour Party

I move to report progress.

Comment on this

I second that motion.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 13
·
Níl 31
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Ba mhaith liom iarraidh ar an Dáil glachadh leis an leas rúin seo agus na focla "death or" a bhaint amach as. Baineann an rún leis an píonús atá ceapaithe i gcóir coirthe airithe. Is é mo thuairim nach cheart san am seo de'n lá an píonús seo a choimeád san roinn seo. Táim in aghaidh an phíonúis seo san áit seo, ar a lán cúiseanna. B'feidir go bhfuil gádh le pionús mar seo anois agus arís acht, mar sin féin, pionús barbarach atá ann. Ní feidir le duine ar bith a rádh gur cóir nó gur ceart duine a chur chun bháis no iarraidh ar dhuine eile duine a chur chun bháis. Tig beatha ó Dhia agus ní cheart do dhuine beatha a bhaint fhád's nach feidir leis ía chruthú. Mar sin fein, caithfidh mé admháil gur ríachtnach, corr-uair, daoini a chur chun bhais. Acht do réir mo thuairime ní ceart an pionús mór seo a chur ar dhuine fhád agus tá pionús nios lúgha fóirstineach do'n choir. Is é mo thuairim gur maith an prinsipiol é gan nios mó pionúis a chur ar dhuine na an pionús atá fóirstineach do'n choir. Táim cinnte gur leór an pionús eile atá ins an roinn seo agus ar an adhbhar sin nach bhfuil gádh le pionús an bháis. Iarraim ar an Dáil na focla seo a bhaint as an Bhille.

In moving the deletion of the words "death or" in line 18 of sub-section 1, section 5, I am asking the Dáil to remove from the scale of penalties prescribed in the Bill the death penalty. The section, as a whole, lays down the punishment for offences in the Schedule. The first portion lays down the punishment of death or penal servitude for any term, not less than three years, for any person found guilty on indictment of any of the offences mentioned in Part I. of the Schedule. Now, while on principle opposed to the death penalty—the most terrible penalty that can be exacted by any State or community—I admit freely and frankly that there are occasions and there may be offences for which the commonsense or, perhaps, the sense of expediency of society, has found that the death penalty would be, if not the right penalty, at least the advisable penalty.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

at this stage took the Chair.

Comment on this

For all that, I think the penalty on the whole is a relic of barbarism. I am strongly convinced that it can be only justified if no alternative penalty is sufficient to meet the case. If there is an alternative penalty, then that alternative penalty should be applied and not this particular penalty. The same principle, I think, holds good for other penalties. The penalty should not be excessive for any offence. If there is any alternative to the penalty of penal servitude for a particular offence, and if it happens that the penalty of penal servitude is too heavy a penalty, then the lighter penalty is the one which should properly be imposed. Sub-section I prescribes the death penalty for the offences mentioned in Part I of the Schedule. They are all offences connected with armed revolt against the State. There are times when armed revolt against the State results in actions which take away the lives of citizens—perhaps of innocent non-combatant citizens, perhaps of combatant citizens, enrolled for the defence of the State.

There are other times when the offences mentioned in Part I. of the Schedule do not result, and perhaps may not be likely to result in the loss of life. There are known to history, and in the experience of States, insurrections and even rebellions that have not resulted in the loss of life. In such cases I hold that the death penalty should not be exacted. The Sub-section permits the exaction of the death penalty even where life has not been taken by revolvers against the State, and I think that is conceivable even where the loss of life is not threatened, or at all events not immediately or directly threatened by the revolt against the State. For that reason I think it is wrong in policy, and wrong in principle, to keep the death penalty in this Section. I think there is sufficient authority under other Statutes for the exaction of the death penalty when the death penalty is justified. I do not think as yet that it is justified in this particular Section, and I ask the Dáil to remove it from the Section.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I do not propose to accept the amendment which the Deputy has moved. Every State reserves to itself the power of life and death in such circumstances, and to deal with such occurrences as are mentioned in Part I. of the Schedule. It seems to me to be unnecessary to argue the matter. Deputies are aware that we, ourselves, at an early stage of our existence as a State have felt compelled to resort to the death penalty. I think we would be unwise to abandon that power. I merely draw Deputies' attention to the fact that the death penalty in this case is not mandatory but permissive; that on indictment a person found guilty of the offences mentioned in Part I. of the Schedule could be sentenced to death or to any lesser penalty.

Comment on this

There is one point I would like to draw attention to, and it is that all the matters mentioned in Part I. of the Schedule are matters which arise out of, and are incidental to, a state of war existing in the country. This is a Bill giving powers to the civil authorities who will deal with its administration. Whatever argument may be put forward to justify the military authorities in the course of quelling an armed rebellion or an armed revolt in exacting the death penalty, no such argument, I maintain, holds good in this case. If the offences mentioned in Part I. of the Schedule are being committed, then it can be held that a state of war exists in the country, and the military authorities will be competent to deal with that state of war, and to take measures, even the extreme measure of exacting the death penalty, to deal with that particular situation. I think it is extremely objectionable that when the civil authorities come to deal with these cases that this power should be given to them in the Bill for the offences specified.

Comment on this

This section really adds nothing, or practically nothing, to the existing law. The death penalty is applied only to the three offences in Part I. of the Schedule. Every one of these offences is treason against the State, and that is a crime for which the death penalty has always been inflicted. There are no improper or irregular courts to try these cases, because this Clause provides that if any person found guilty on indictment—that means that he is indicted and tried by a jury of his fellow-countrymen—does not deserve the extreme penalty, then in that case if the Judge thinks fit that the extreme penalty ought to be inflicted, I do not know what other punishment we could really impose. If the person was tried, not by indictment for offences under this Bill, but tried on indictment for treason and found guilty of treason against the State, the judge would have no option but to order him to be hanged. But under this Bill you allow him to get off by a lesser penalty if it is thought that a lesser penalty would serve the case, and there is a provision to send a man to penal servitude for three years. It seems to me that this Clause is really an amelioration of the existing law so far as these three offences are concerned. It is to be remembered, too, that the prisoner will be tried by a jury of his own fellow-countrymen, and not by an extraordinary tribunal.

Comment on this

I am sorry I cannot agree with Deputy FitzGibbon in his argument. The offences mentioned in Part I. of the Schedule are undoubtedly of the nature of treason against the State, but it is not, I believe, the fact that treason against the State is always punished by the death penalty. It may be that in many States persons found guilty on the charge of treason against the State are liable to the death penalty. No doubt the Section is per missive, as the Deputy points out, and is not mandatory. But, why then have it inserted in this particular Bill? Sufficient provision is already made elsewhere by other Statutes for the infliction of the death penalty, under Statutes that are in a way permanent Statutes. This Bill, if we accept all the statements of all the Ministers, and of those who support it, is temporary and transitory. Why then is it necessary that it should be provided for here? I do seriously submit that there are times and occasions when a verdict of guilty pronounced by a Judge on the finding of a jury in a case of treason against the State should not be punishable by the death penalty. If there is an alternative that will carry out the purpose of the State, and of the State authorities, I submit that that alternative ought to be adopted, and not the extreme penalty. The only argument in favour of such a penalty is the argument of necessity, and I submit that time, circumstances, and occasions are factors by which we must judge of the necessity. All through the discussions on this Bill I have maintained that if it is to serve any useful purpose whatever, that purpose is to make easy that passage from war, or a kind of war, to peace. For that reason I am strongly of opinion that nothing that is not intended to be done, and nothing that is superfluous or unnecessary, should be brought into the Bill at all, but that everything that is possible should be done to make the transition easier and to help to restore public confidence and public tranquility, and to remove suspicion and distrust. Now, the infliction of the death penalty can only be as a deterrent or as a punishment. I think we have had enough experience in this country to know that, on the whole, the death penalty as a deterrent, or as punishment, has not been a glorious success. It may be claimed that recent executions have crushed an insurrection. I beg still to doubt that. I believe that the insurrection has been crushed largely because of its own inherent wrongness, and not because a particular measure was adopted against certain of its adherents. It is a fact well known in the experience of States, and in political experience generally, that the infliction of the death penalty for political offences, so far from being a deterrent, has rather acted as an irritant, and has helped to continue and to perpetuate actions against States which might otherwise have not been taken. I do seriously submit that in this period, when to a considerable extent, if passions are not exactly dying down, violence against the State is dying down, that it is a wrong time to dangle before the minds of the people this particular penalty.

Comment on this

I wish to draw the attention of the Dáil to what is embodied in this sub-section. "Any person found guilty on indictment of any of the offences may be sentenced to suffer `death.' " Amongst the offences mentioned are attempting to threaten a person in furtherance of armed revolt. I think it is unwise to empower a Judge to inflict the death penalty for that offence, because it is so difficult to prove an attempt to threaten a person in furtherance of an armed revolt. It is almost impossible to prove an attempt to threaten. You might be able to prove the threatening, but to prove an attempt at threatening, I submit that is very difficult. It must be a hidden thing, if it is only an attempt to threaten, and that, I submit, is a matter which it would be difficult to prove. There is also a penalty for attempting to remove any property in furtherance of such revolt. That is much easier to prove than an attempt to threaten, but I submit it is not a crime of such enormity as to warrant the infliction of the death penalty or, the power to inflict the death penalty. The range of offences even in the three paragraphs of Part I. of the Schedule, all of which offences may subject the offender to the death penalty, is so wide that I think the deletion of the two words proposed ought to be accepted. We are not dealing with the Schedule, but inasmuch as the paragraph sought to be amended directs attention to the Schedule and to all the offences in the Schedule, and as some of these offences are of a comparatively minor nature, I would ask the Minister to accept the amendment, and to remove the death penalty from this Bill.

Comment on this

This Bill, as has already been explained, makes provision for dealing with offences during the transition period, the period between the time when the people acted before they thought, and the period we are now passing through, when the people will think before they act again.

It is quite obvious from the action which the Government has taken during the latter stages of the recent trouble when a state of war might have been said to have been going on, and when the Government for any reasons did not carry out the execution policy in the case of some very responsible leaders who fell into their hands, that that was a proof at any rate that the policy of executions was not the best policy in the interests of the Government itself. I think that is one reason why for this short period, when there is some hope that the same thing will not happen again, this thing should not be dangled before the eyes of this country. The Clause is undoubtedly permissive. I think it is a very unwise policy now when we should have some hope of a brighter outlook that this thing should be brought up again. The Minister said it was unnecessary to argue the matter and that it would be unwise to abandon the power, which I take it is maintained in the existing law, in respect of any clause which may be inserted in the Bill which is only for a temporary period. The Minister should take into consideration that many of the things which are mentioned in the First Schedule and defined here are things which were encouraged by themselves during the last four of five years. I think that in the hurry of legislation, people who have done wrong and have admitted that they have done wrong, or whose leaders have admitted the unwisdom of the policy adopted, should be allowed some time to think before it will be assumed that they are going to act again in the same way that they have acted for the last 8 or 9 months. I think it is unwise in the present transition period and when things are said to be normal to bring forward a measure of this kind to deal with the situation when the necessity does not exist for the putting up of such legislation.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 15
·
Níl 34
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I beg to move "in subsection 2, line 22, to substitute the word `may' for the word `shall.' "

The subsection as it stands prescribes one single high water mark of punishment for all the crimes that are in Part II. and whether the person convicted is guilty of the extreme crime of having possession without lawful authority of firearms with intent to use them, arson, or the comparatively trivial offences of aiding and abetting in the sale of illicit liquor, he must get one cast-iron penalty of hard labour for 12 months or of a fine of £50 or in default of payment, hard labour for a further term of six months. It seems to me altogether beyond all reason to ladle out one common penalty which cannot be carried up or down for all the offences in this Schedule in Section 2, from the most guilty down to the most technical crime of aider or abetter. I think some discretion ought to be left to the Court of summary jurisdiction before whom the man is tried, that where they are satisfied the guilt is a technical one they ought not to be compelled to inflict this extreme penalty which they ought to be bound to inflict on the most guilty person or the most hardened criminal. I am sure what was in the mind of the framers of the Bill was a desire to relieve those Courts of Summary Jurisdiction from the responsibility of having to inflict heavy penalties and a desire to place that responsibility upon the shoulders of this Dáil by suggesting that we should state these were to be the penalties and the Judge would say "Then I have no option." It seems to me that that is likely now as in the past to defeat itself and that a man's mind whether he be judge or jury revolts against the penalty the law compels him to impose. He has to salve his conscience one way or the other. We find in the old days when a theft to the value of 5s. was a capital offence, jury after jury found a man guilty of stealing a silver teapot worth 4s. 11d. when everyone knew it was worth £5, £10 or £20. They had to put in that value against their conscience in order that the penalty might not be imposed. Here you will have people brought up and charged for aiding and betting in the same way. Judges before whom they come, if they are people who are so weak that they may not be trusted to give a proper penalty, would be quite weak enough to decline to convict in the case of grave crimes. This compulsory infliction of a grave punishment for light crimes seems to me to be based on a want of confidence in our own Judges. I think they ought to have sufficient confidence in themselves in selecting a man that was sent down to be a District Judge and sufficient confidence in the District Judges whom they send to be able to trust those men to give a proper penalty where the crime is clearly proved before them. I hope the Government will see their way to accept this amendment and if necessary to modify the clause later on. I suggest they ought not to enforce this hard and fast penalty for every crime, no matter how grave or little.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

What happened in regard, to those offences is that the maximum was brought down and merged in what we believed ought to be the minimum. Deputies will agree that those offences, set out under the twelve heads in Part II. of the Schedule, embody largely the kind of crimes that are menacing the life and the future of the country— one no less than the other. There seems to be a tendency to pick out there, as a comparatively minor or trifling offence, the paragraph dealing with poteen. I think that Deputies who so pick out that section fail to appreciate the position that has been reached in certain parts of the country in regard to illicit distillation, and fail to appreciate its results. If you take up the paper any day and find some particularly hideous or revolting crime, you will almost invariably find that it has happened in the poteen area, where children going to and coming from school are reeling round the roads drunk with poteen. What chance have they of developing into decent, self-respecting citizens, when they degrade themselves so young? Man, we are told, is a rational animal. He is sometimes. He is not a rational animal when he gives himself up to the poteen craze. He divests himself of the only thing which distinguished him from the brute creation, and he becomes, in fact, a beast. Every unnatural crime, every bestial crime that is committed will be found within the zone of the illicit still. It does menace the life and the future of the country. No person who appreciates the extent of the evil, who appreciates its re-actions on a future generation, will think that it ought not to have been set out there amongst those other grave offences that are menacing peace and prosperity and stability here. So much for that.

This Bill has a lifetime of six months. We have felt that these coming months are likely to be particularly critical—critical intrinsically and critical in their re-action on the whole trend of affairs here in the future. We have said that that particular penalty ought to be imposed on a person found guilty of any of these crimes within the coming six months. The penalty was not fixed high. One could pick out offences from amongst these for which that particular penalty would be, fairly considered, a low penalty. But we brought down the maximum and merged it in what we believed was the minimum penalty that should be imposed by anyone with a proper sense of the gravity of these crimes, and their re-actions on the country. We made that mandatory rather than permissive. Because if, in the special circumstances, the Executive Council believed that particular crimes ought to be met with particular penalties, then they ought to say so. They ought to take upon themselves the responsibility of that conclusion. Having examined the position in the country, if they believe that particular offences stand out as particularly menacing to the Nation, and that certain penalties ought to be imposed, then they should say so in a mandatory fashion in their legislation, and not leave it simply to such accidental circumstances as the outlook of a magistrate here and a magistrate there to decide. There is something haphazard and casual and fortuitous in that. Deputies may put hypothetical cases and say that one could conceive cases in which these penalties would be harsh. Deputies may picture the case of a man coming home from the fair, perhaps having got a certain amount of stone beer, and finding his house burning. He gets information that it was "A.B." up the road who came down and scattered petrol around the floor, and set fire to the house. He goes up the road and burns "A.B.'s" house in intense provocation. Deputies might say that for this offence, in face of such great provocation, this penalty or the other penalty mentioned in the Bill, would be excessive. The penalty is the penalty which it is felt should normally attach to that particular crime. If a Judge or a Magistrate, having carried out the law by passing the sentence, thinks that it would be right for him to make representations to the Executive to the effect that there were in that particular case, which was heard by him, mitigating circumstances—circumstances that would call for the exercise of the prerogative of mercy—then, no doubt, the Judge or Magistrate will make such representations. But we wish to set out here clearly that these ten or twelve offences are offences which are menacing the very life and future of the country, and we do not discriminate between them. In their own way and in their own proportions they are all equally grave in their effects and in their prospects if they go on unchecked. We set out those and lay down for them one single penalty as mandatory within the six months which constitute the lifetime of the Bill. I think that is a sound thing to do. I think if the Executive Council, having surveyed the situation and examined reports, believes that certain offences do really gravely menace the future of the country, they should take the responsibility on themselves of assigning a penalty which will be at once the maximum and the minimum and leave it to the discretion of the judge or magistrate to make such representations as he thinks it necessary to make in a particular case.

Comment on this

This is a most illuminating speech and it is a most extraordinary doctrine. We have a list of offences of varying enormity and the Executive is to say what the sentence shall be in every case where an offender is found guilty by a Court of Summary Jurisdiction. The sentence is to be fixed before-hand for this long series of varying offences and the Minister cites what, I suppose, is the precedent of capital punishment being the inevitable end, so far as the Judge is concerned, of a verdict of guilty. These offences, by the way, are all supposed to be of equal demerit, requiring the same sentence, such sentence to be imposed before-hand by the Executive Council. One of the offences is the possession of any land mine, or other similar explosive machine within the six months. What has been said about the possession of land mines recently in this Chamber? It is not a case of the possession of a gun or revolver, not even the possession of a bomb, which might have been accidentally left, but the possession of a land mine, punishable even after this Bill becomes an Act, and is in operation, by death at the instigation of the army. But in the transfer—at least in the corresponding powers that the Civil Authority is to take—the possession of a land mine is to be of equal enormity, in the mind of the Executive, with the putting on of a uniform, or any part of a uniform, of a soldier or policeman or having possession of a soldier's cap. If found guilty, the same penalty must inevitably fall upon the offender as if he were found guilty of being in possession of a land mine. Notwithstanding all the Minister says about the evils of poteen and illicit distillation, I do not believe the Dáil thinks for a moment, whatever way it may vote—and I believe in this case the Dáil is going to vote against its convictions, though I would like to be disillusioned—that a person having possession of any illicitly-distilled spirits is guilty of an equal offence with another person who is in possession of a land mine. Is there any Deputy will say that they are equally criminal?

The Minister for Agriculture is capable of a good deal, in this particular sphere, but I challenge him to say whether the possession of a land mine, within the next six months, is not a greater offence than the possession of illicitly-distilled spirits. The punishment that is to fit those crimes is to be the same in any case and there is to be no alternative except, if you please, the Judge who does as he is told may, if he thinks well, make representations to the Executive, say that the law they passed was a very unwise and a very foolish one and pass animadversions on the Dáil or Oireachtas. That of course would be quite outside his authority but he is invited to do it, or at all events invited to tell the Executive that they should not be so foolish as to introduce into the Bill such a Clause and ask them to reconsider it. That is what he is asked to do in the Courts of Summary Jurisdiction. I wonder what is the meaning of this—"the maximum shall be the minimum and the minimum shall be the maximum." Those that are up shall be down and those that are down shall be up. I wonder whether the Minister has considered the application of Article 72 of the Constitution to this sub-section. Should a minor offence be classed as one which should entail imprisonment for twelve months with hard labour or imprisonment for eighteen months, with hard labour, provided the man has not got fifty pounds to spare? Can an offence which is punishable by such a sentence be classed as a "minor" offence? I suppose the Minister will argue that if this Bill becomes law, then these will be minor offences which are triable by law, but in that case I hope the Bill that the Ministers are supposed to be preparing, dealing with the powers of the Courts and the jurisdiction of the Courts, will provide us with some guidance for the future as to what is a minor offence and what kind of punishment is applicable to minor offences and what kind of punishment is applicable to major offences. That by the way.

I hope the Dáil will be enlightened somewhat more fully than they have been as to the real meaning of this grouping of all these offences of such varying quality and providing that they shall each and all be punishable by the same sentence.

I think there must be some more reason in it than that told to us by the Minister. He must have forgotten the essential thing, or can it be that it was merely a sporting leap in the dark; that they had no real reason for it, but thought that perhaps it was an easy way of getting over a difficulty, or that they had not confidence in the Justices they have recently appointed; that these Justices have not experience enough, and that they might be afraid of making mistakes in the infliction of the punishment? Surely there must be some other reason than that vouchsafed to us.

Comment on this

Deputy Johnson is anxious for my opinion on the question as to whether the offence of having a land mine is an offence of equal gravity with having a bottle of poteen in one's possession. I can answer the question simply, and say that it is not. If you consider the two offences in normal circumstances, or in anything like normal circumstances—perhaps I am hardly right in saying normal circumstances, but even in present circumstances, the offence is not the same. Deputy Johnson has evaded, or missed, the real point of the speech of the Minister for Home Affairs if he were serious in putting that conundrum to me. The Minister for Home Affairs was careful to explain that we had tried to impose the minimum penalty. That may offend the Deputy's fine sense of justice, but I think it will not offend the sense of justice of any practical man who takes a look at the present situation, or at the very large number of crimes that have been committed and are being committed every day, and who realises that the Executive must deal with all these crimes as if they were interdependent and connected, as they are. Now, it is not the same offence, and Deputy Johnson can argue from that, even from our point of view, that we are imposing a lesser penalty on certain offences than we could impose, because we consider that twelve months' hard labour is no more than an adequate penalty for the keeping of poteen. He is welcome to all the consolation that he can get out of that. He wants to prove us illogical even from our own point of view. If he wants to prove us illogical in this matter he must show that we are not inflicting, or that we are not asking the magistrates to inflict, a sufficiently heavy penalty on certain offences, because that is what it comes to. If he once admits the contention of the Minister for Home Affairs that the penalty set out here is the minimum penalty for the smallest offences, then our only offence in the matter is this, that we have not inflicted a sufficiently high penalty for other offences. He is welcome to all the kudos and all the consolation he can get out of that, but before he comes to the conclusion that we have committed any great error I would ask him to realise two things. The first is that we have not inflicted the same penalty for all the offences set out in the Schedule.

Comment on this

Nobody said that.

Comment on this

We have not, as I say, inflicted the same penalty for all the offences set out in the Schedule. The Deputy gave me at least the impression that we were inflicting the same penalty, but we are not. We are inflicting one penalty on anyone who is convicted, after summary trial, of any of the offences set out in the Schedule, and another penalty for anyone convicted on indictment. We draw the line there. We put the less serious offences on one side, and the more serious offences on the other, so that our regulations are not so sweeping as one would be led to believe if one came to the conclusion that we were inflicting the same penalty for all offences, whether tried summarily or by indictment. As the Minister for Home Affairs pointed out, it is open to the District Justice to make representations to the Executive to exercise the prerogative of mercy. If there are any cases where the offence is a purely technical offence, and I can readily conceive a man being innocently in possession of a bottle of poteen, and if in such a case a magistrate is of opinion that the offence is merely technical and that there is no moral guilt, he can point that out to the Executive who have undertaken a good many responsibilities and they will undertake this responsibility. There is the prerogative of mercy vested in someone, and it can be exercised. That is my answer to the question as to whether the possession of a bottle of poteen is the same offence as having possession of a land mine. There is another point that goes to the root of the whole thing. The Deputy may not agree with me, but I genuinely believe this, that men who were seizing other people's land, men who are enriching themselves quietly and privately under cover of the Irregulars when the Irregulars were burning houses and generally causing confusion, were just as bad as the Irregulars and morally were worse than them. He is a very poor type of criminal who will go out for no reason to burn his neighbour's house, but the man is as big as criminal morally who will go out while his neighbour's house is burning and steal a cup and saucer out of it. That sort of criminal takes advantage of the fact that some other criminal is burning the house, and while the house is burning he steals perhaps a loaf or a cup and saucer. No one pretends, other things being equal, that it is the same offence to steal a spoon or a cup and saucer as to burn a man's house, but though the law must make a distinction is there any difference, from any honourable or decent point of view, between the man who burns his neighbour's house and the man who takes advantage of the fact that another criminal is burning his neighbour's house to steal a spoon out of it? I put that conundrum to Deputy Johnson, and I invite him to answer it.

That is the kind of thing that is at the bottom of all this, and that is what is behind this Bill. I suggest that that goes to the root of the whole matter. Men who, during the last six or seven months went out, even in the smallest way, to take advantage of the people who were dishonouring themselves and their country, and who, even in a small way, went out to do themselves a good turn and to enrich themselves were, in my opinion, as big criminals as the men who were committing what would be considered far graver offences.

Comment on this

The Minister has put several questions to me. He has stated frankly that the offence of being in possession of poteen is not as grievous an offence as being in possession of a land mine. Nevertheless, he defends the minimum punishment for one offence being the maximum for the other. But there is no discrimination allowed in this Sub-section whether it is a first, a second or a third offence. There is no discrimination allowed in this Sub-section, no matter what the circumstances may be surrounding the commission of the offence. They are all guilty, and being guilty——

Comment on this

The Deputy is hardly quoting me accurately.

Comment on this

I do not pretend to be quoting when I say that I am inferring what I read in the Bill. There is the definite proposition here that a person guilty of any of these offences no matter whether it is a first, a second or a third offence, or even a thirty-first offence, shall be sentenced to a definite term of imprisonment with hard labour for twelve months, and if he has not got £50 to spare he will have to spend an additional six months in gaol. I maintain that the circumstances connected with many of these offences may be of a kind which would warrant a very much smaller punishment than eighteen months' imprisonment with hard labour. Just to illustrate what I mean, I shall give a quotation from a speech delivered by the Attorney-General in the Belfast Parliament. He was defending a Bill much milder than this, and he said "There is no term of hard labour known to the law exceeding two years. Once you exceed two years you go into penal servitude. I have never suffered penal servitude or hard labour in this particular form, but I am told that two years' hard labour is much more severe than five years' penal servitude."

If that gentleman is to be believed, and I have no doubt he was quoting from those who were able to inform him with authority, the punishment that is to be inflicted, and regarding which there is to be no discrimination left to the Justice, on the possessor of illicit spirits or a soldier's cap, is to be greater, if this is true, then the punishment of a person found guilty on indictment who shall be sentenced to suffer penal servitude for a term of three years, and to pay a fine. I say that the whole conception of this Section is bad, because it does not allow any discrimination to the Justice as to the term of imprisonment and the severity of the sentences, even the maximum of which ranges over a variety of offences and puts them under what might be called a flat rate. The Minister has not helped to satisfy my mind about this, and I hope the Dáil will generally agree with the contention of Deputy FitzGibbon that the word `shall' should be altered to read `may.'

Comment on this

In getting up a second time to speak I do not think anyone will say that I am doing so for the mere sake of obstruction. I make the Minister a present of the fact that for almost every offence set down in the Schedule I can conceive the penalty to be a very light one, but there are many of these offences for which I could almost equally conceive any penalty to be too great. Let it be granted that illicit drinking in any form is worthy of any punishment you please, but I am now going to take one case that has nothing to do with illicit drinking. It came within my own knowledge not many weeks ago. It was the case of four small boys who were brought up in the Dublin Police Courts for breaking some windows in a place of worship in York Street, almost opposite the College of Surgeons. That is an offence that would clearly come within Sub-section (8), which deals with unlawful injury and damage to property. I think it will be admitted that I regard any place of worship of any religious body, creed or sect, as a place which it is a sacrilege to touch. It was a grave crime with which these boys were charged, but, in my opinion, when these small boys were brought up in the Dublin Police Courts it would have been a far graver crime to have inflicted on them imprisonment with hard labour for twelve months, and then, in default of their parents being unable to pay £50, which I suppose they could get as easily as if the sum were £50,000, these boys would have to go back to gaol for another six months without any option being given to the magistrate to send them to a reformatory or to an industrial school. The magistrate would be bound to inflict the compulsory punishment that I have mentioned, and it is the gross iniquity of compulsory punishment of that kind that makes me press this amendment. I ask the Minister would be agree to say in this Section that a Court of Summary Jurisdiction "shall" for the offences numbered one to seven, and "may" for the offences eight to twelve, inflict these penalties? The offences numbered one to seven include all the graver crimes, and the offences numbered eight to twelve include pretty well all the crimes that are capable of modification. I do not move that amendment, but if the Minister would consider it between the time that his majority would have defeated this amendment and the time that we would come to the next stage of the Bill it would at least be some relief. The offences numbered one to seven are what would be called major crimes. These include the unlawful possession of lethal firearms, ammunition, bombs, land mines, wrongful possession of land, robbery under arms, arson, and masquerading as members of the Police Force, etc. The offences eight to twelve deal with the lesser crimes, involving unlawful destruction or damage to property. I quite agree that under them there might be crimes which would be lightly treated even with eighteen months' imprisonment, but on the other hand, for the offence of merely injuring property which might only mean the breaking of a window in an empty house, it seems to me to go beyond all reason that this compulsory penalty should be inflicted, and to leave to the chance of the magistrate making a report, and to the chance of the Minister for Home Affairs having sufficient information before him, to say that this is a case in which the prerogative of mercy should be exercised. All that, I say, seems to me to be going beyond all reason.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I will undertake to consider very carefully between now and the next stage of the Bill Deputy FitzGibbon's suggestion to make a discrimination between the last five and the first seven of these offences in the first part of the Schedule. The one that I would be most doubtful about is that dealing with illicit spirits. I think if we agree to treat that penalty as the maximum for that offence that we would also have to consider it advisable to insert a minimum penalty. As I say it is not so much the guilt of the indidual here that has been the decisive factor as the absolute necessity of getting rid, once and for all, of these offences. I would not say there is one of them more than another menacing the life and prosperity of the country. If the country is to live, flourish and regain its prestige among the nations it is necessary that each one of the 12 offences set out there be stamped out.

Comment on this

I am not enough of a lawyer to tell off-hand whether the starting words in No. 10 in Part 2 of the Schedule mean a certain thing or mean some other thing, but I have been thinking of somewhat similar cases to those which Deputy FitzGibbon mentioned when he spoke last. While it was a hypothetical case it was suggested to me by something the Minister said earlier and it seems to me a great hardship. I refer to the case, for instance, of young people, boys or girls requested by parents or someone else to procure from some house illicitly distilled spirits. There will be means and measures taken by traffickers in illicitly distilled spirits to evade the provisions of any Act and the thing may be christened with some other name than that given to it in the country. It is possible, I think, for messengers quite innocently to carry such spirits. I should like to know whether in the opinion of the Minister a case of that kind would be covered by the words "would if in possession or control of any such things."

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I think that guilty knowledge is assumed. There can be no conveyance without such guilty knowledge.

Comment on this

Yes, that would go a considerable distance. It seems to me the case has been completely made out for a change. There is lack of proportion in the offences. I am sorry Deputy FitzGibbon is not here now. I intended to ask him, through you, Sir, to answer a question which arose in my mind when the Minister for Agriculture was speaking. It seemed to me he laid down a rather peculiar principle of jurisprudence. Deputy Johnson referred to it as the flat rate. It seems to me rather like a law of averages. It may be a common thing in law but it seems to me a peculiar and a remarkable thing. May I ask the Minister if we may take it as a rule that previous Statutes imposing penalties for the offences in this Bill will in effect be, if not repealed, in use during the period in which this Bill is in operation?

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

During the lifetime of this Bill the provisions of the Bill will supersede the existing law.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That Section 4, as amended, stand part of the Bill."

Tá 40
·
Níl 13
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I beg to move to Report Progress.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

A similar motion was made at 22 minutes past 12. I shall not take another motion yet.

Comment on this

I beg to move Amendment 36, in Sub-section (2), line 22, after the words "imprisonment with" to insert "or without." The section as it stands at present gives no discretion whatever to the Court. Hard labour is a very severe penalty, and the Court may not wish to impose a penalty on a prisoner who may be in a bad state of health, and there may be other extenuating circumstances. As the clause stands at present they have absolutely no discretion in any case. I think this is a very reasonable amendment, and one which the Minister ought to accept. There are cases such as I say where, owing to bad health or otherwise, it would be grave injustice to inflict hard labour.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Hard labour, the Deputy says, is a very severe sentence. Now, as far as I could ever find out the only difference between a hard labour sentence and any other sentence is that there is a fortnight at the beginning of the hard labour sentence in which the prisoner does not get a mattress. Having got over the fortnight the conditions are very much the same. I would accept the Deputy's amendment with regard to line 25, and in fact I was going to offer in connection with that an additional sentence of a fine or an alternative six months, to make that a permissive thing, so that the Sub-section would read: "that a person shall be sentenced to suffer imprisonment with hard labour for the term of 12 months and in addition may be sentenced to pay a fine of £50 and in default of payment of such fine should suffer imprisonment with or without hard labour a further term of 12 months." I could not accept the Deputy's amendment with regard to the substantial portion of the sentence. That would be the 12 months.

Comment on this

In view of the Minister's assurance that there is no difference except for the first fortnight where the prisoner has not a mattress, will he accept the word "without" instead of "with" in line 22 inasmuch as it would make no practical difference?

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

There is this difference really that the hard labour sentence is rather to indicate the turpitude of the particular offences. There is very little practical difference within the prison in the conditions of a man sentenced to hard labour beyond the first fortnight, but the additional description of a sentence as a hard labour sentence indicates that a serious view was taken of the offence by the Court, and that it was the wish of the Court to brand it as a rather disgraceful type of crime.

Comment on this

It seems to me that that would lead one to conclude that it was wise to put in the two possibilities "with or without." Then it will be clear that if hard labour is, in fact, imposed, it will be a clear expression of opinion by the Justice that he has taken a more serious view of the evidence, inasmuch as he had an option and decided to impose the greater penalty. Even though the greater penalty was only nominally greater, it was, at least, a sign of discrimination, whereas when a Justice is bound to impose hard labour, there is no expression of his discrimination as to the enormity of the offence. I suggest that, following the Minister's own contention, it would be wise to accept the amendment, inasmuch as that would allow that discrimination—though a nominal one— to be given expression to by the magistrate in imposing the sentence.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I would be inclined to accept that amendment. I am satisfied that there is no material difference in the conditions of a prisoner sentenced to hard labour and those of a prisoner not so sentenced, and I have no objection to accepting the amendment. I might as well make the offer I mentioned just now with regard to making the fine portion of the sentence permissive rather than mandatory. The words would then be: "may, in addition, be sentenced to pay a fine." Some discretion can be exercised, then, with regard to the circumstances of the prisoners and so forth.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

The amended sub-section would then read, in part, "shall be sentenced to suffer imprisonment, with or without hard labour, for the term of 12 months."

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

There is an amendment in line 23 to insert after the word "and" the words "may in addition be sentenced," so that the line would read "labour for the term of 12 months and may, in addition, be sentenced to pay a fine of fifty."

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Yes. As we are at it, we might accept that "with or without" again in line 25.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

There is an amendment to line 25 to delete the word "with" and to substitute the word "without." Will that be withdrawn?

Comment on this

No, because the circumstances would be different.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Then we will take this amendment in line 23 to to begin with. Who is moving the amendment in line 23?

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

You can take me as moving it.

Comment on this

I propose Amendment 37, and I do not think the Minister will have any difficulty in accepting it.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I wonder if the Deputy has observed that I agreed to make the fine portion of that Sub-section permissive, and the Sub-section would then read "and may in addition be sentenced to pay a fine of £50." That would leave it open to the magistrate to take into consideration the circumstances of a prisoner, which is practically what the Deputy asks in his amendment.

Comment on this

After the explanation of the Minister that he proposes to embody the principle of this amendment in the section, I agree to accept it.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Is Amendment 37 withdrawn?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I accept this amendment.

Comment on this

I have authority from Deputy FitzGibbon to move this amendment on his behalf——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

I am not quite clear as to whether the option rejected in Amendment 35 does not operate here.

Comment on this

The option that was rejected in the last sub-section had to do with persons convicted by Courts of Summary Jurisdiction. It was decided by the majority of the Dáil that any such person convicted of offences in Part 2 of the Schedule by a Court of Summary Jurisdiction shall be sentenced to a certain term of imprisonment. Sub-section 3 deals with persons found guilty on indictment, and does not deal with persons found guilty by Courts of Summary Jurisdiction. In any such case the object of the amendment is to leave on option as to the extent of the severity of the sentence. In this case the prisoner will be tried by a jury. It has been pointed out very often that where there is the certainty of a particular sentence juries are all apt to decline to find a verdict in accordance with the evidence, because they know beforehand what the sentence is to be, and that the effect of a mandatory provision of this kind will be to defeat the intentions of the Bill. On that ground alone the amendment ought to be accepted. I think it is common ground amongst criminal lawyers, and I think it is even more generally accepted in this country, that juries, where there is no possibility of a small sentence—where, for instance, in a trial for murder the jury does not want to see the capital penalty inflicted—make up their minds to find the prisoner not guilty. Now, that is likely to be the case in any of those other offences.

There are other reasons which may not appeal so surely to the Minister's mentality but which, I think, are really more potent to the average member of the Dáil. The arguments that have been used in regard to the imposition of sentences without question under Sub-section No. 2 apply equally to this Sub-section No. 3. Every person found guilty on indictment of the various offences which we have been considering shall be sentenced to suffer penal servitude for a term of three years, and to pay a fine of not more than £100 nor less than £50, and if he is not able to pay the money he has to suffer imprisonment for another year, or (b) he may be sentenced to suffer imprisonment with hard labour for a term of not more than two years, nor less than one year. There is, as a matter of fact, more option given in this Sub-section than in the last, but I still consider that the advantages lie in every way with the amendment to substitute the word “may” for “shall” in line 2, Sub-section 3.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I ask Deputies to remember that in this Sub-section you are dealing with a particular class of case, a case of a man indicted and tried by a jury, a case which had attendant circumstances so grave that the magistrate considered that it was not a fit case for summary trial and sent it forward for indictment. There may be circumstances in connection, for instance, with the first offence mentioned in the Second Part of the Schedule that would render it extremely grave and bring it outside the scope of mere summary trial. I would be inclined to offer, in connection with this Sub-section, much the same as was offered above—namely to make the fine portion of the sentence a permissive one and to strike out the minimum of the fine so that (a) would read somewhat as follows “Shall be sentenced either to suffer penal servitude for a term of three years?”—I cannot find the right words at the moment, but the effect of it would be, in addition to the sentence, “a fine of not more than £100,” leaving out the following words, “and in default of payment of such fine within one month after sentence to suffer penal servitude for a further term not exceeding one year.” Similar changes would occur in “b.” Without going over again the arguments with regard to “may” and “shall,” I do think that there is less ground for objecting to it in this case than in the case of summary jurisdiction. You will have here a man tried before a jury and the offences set out in Part 2 of the Schedule were selected because it is considered that, in their own way they are all equally menacing to the future of the country.

Comment on this

Does the Minister give no weight to the contention that the fact that the punishment is mandatory has an effect upon the jury's consideration of the case?

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I gave to that point a certain amount of consideration. But that point did not cause me to change my view that there ought to be for these offences a mandatory penalty that would be the minimum.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 13
·
Níl 42
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Then Amendment No. 40, which is to insert in Sub-section (3) (a), line 34, after the the word “sentence,” the words “may if the Court is satisfied that such default is due to contumacy and not to lack of means, be further sentenced,” and Amendment 41 to insert in Sub-section (b), (3), after the word “with,” the word “without,” and Amendment 42 in Sub-section (3) (b), line 42 after the word “sentence” to insert the words “may if the Court is satisfied that such default is due to contumacy and not to lack of means be further sentenced,” and Amendment 43 in Sub-section (3) (b), line 43, to delete the word “with” and to substitute therefore the word “without,” are similar to what we have have had before.

Comment on this

Yes; assuming that the Minister's words are embodied as promised.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Yes; they are the same as we had before, and I was going to ask the Minister would he embody the words now or later on.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

What I propose in connection with this Section, if Deputies will observe, is that I am inclined to introduce amendments:

In Section 5, Sub-section (3) (a) to make the fine portion of the sentence permissive; to delete the words “not less than fifty pounds.”

In line 35, to delete the word "of," and to insert "not exceeding," (b) to make the fine portion permissive.

In lines 40 and 41, to delete the words "nor less than fifty pounds."

In line 43, to delete the word "with," and to substitute the word "without," and delete the word "of," and substitute the words "not exceeding."

Comment on this

Would the Minister not accept an amendment which would add in paragraph (b) the words “with or without hard labour”?

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Do you mean in the first paragraph (b)?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

No, I could not accept that because these are particularly grave cases that will be sent on for indictment. They will be tried before a Judge and a jury, and if the jury finds a man guilty of the offences set out in the Schedule then a hard labour sentence is not excessive.

Comment on this

But inasmuch as there is no material difference, except in the fact that it records the sense of discrimination, and the sense that a Judge has of the relative enormity of the crime, and that though there is no real difference the fact that the Judge can say that this deserves hard labour expresses his views of the relative enormity of the offence—as it stands there is no opportunity of that—and inasmuch as it makes no practical difference in the amount of physical suffering only, and the sense of the Judge's opinion as to the extent of the offence, the Minister might, I suggest, accept that amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I am sorry, but I could not accept that amendment. A person found guilty on indictment of this offence ought to receive hard labour.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Then the Minister's own amendments are agreed to.

Comment on this

I beg to move Amendment 41. In Sub-section (3) (b) after the word “with,” to insert the words “or without.”

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I could not accept that amendment.

Comment on this
Division

The Dáil divided: Tá,

Tá 13
·
Níl 42
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

The next amendment which stands in my name is, I think, consequential on Amendment 40, and I desire to withdraw it.

Comment on this

I move: "In Sub-section (3) (b), line 43, to delete the word `with' and to substitute therefore the word `without' ” I think the Minister has said that he was accepting this amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I accept that.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

I want to point out that the next amendment, No. 44, aims at deleting the whole of Sub-section (4). That is to say to delete the provisions which deal with whipping. Subsequent amendments deal with the endeavours to amend the sub-section should it not be deleted. In dealing with the amendments subsequent to Amendment 44 it will not be possible to enter into an argument for deleting the sub-section, and when we come to the question "that the section as amended stand part of the Bill" it will not be possible to enter into arguments for deleting Sub-section (4).

Comment on this

I would like to ask whether you would take a motion to report progress with a view to the exhibition to the Dáil of the various instruments that are possible to be used in this operation?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

I will not.

Comment on this

I want to ask the Dáil then to agree to this amendment which I propose, namely, "To delete Sub-section (4)." I asked the Dáil to pass this amendment upon the view that the punishment of whipping or flogging is degrading and dehumanising to the flogged and the flogger and to the people responsible for the operation of the flogging. It may interest the Dáil to know that this kind of punishment is confined in European countries to England and Turkey. It was in Russia, but I am not sure if it is now, and in the North African countries to Morocco. All other civilised countries in Europe have long since given up this operation of flogging. I am not going to ask for any leniency to the prisoners. I am not going to base my arguments against the institution of this method of punishment out of sympathy with the prisoners. I believe that even they are human and ought to be treated as human, but I am afraid that the history of the last few years has gone far to harden men's hearts and generally to think that it is quite an ennobling aspiration to treat violence with violence and meet torture with torture. I do base the contention that it is unwise to enter into this method of punishment because it is degrading to the persons engaged in the flogging, and it is a reversal of the process of civilisation and christianisation. We have been told on very good authority that it does not matter so much the distance that people progress so long as the direction of their progress is right. I think in this case it is distinctly retrogressive, and the institution of flogging, the reimposition of flogging, in Ireland will mean distinct retrogression, and is not called for by any of the facts that have been adduced in support of the provisions of this Bill. We have been told, of course, that certain classes of offences have, as a matter of fact, been reduced by the imposition of the lash. That is not proved. It is, in fact, denied on good authority—on the authority of the Judges of the British Courts. The classical case that has so often been mentioned—it was mentioned here on the Second Reading—of the decline in garrotting as a consequence of the lash is quite fallacious, although the Encyclopaedia Britannica quotes it, but other encylopaedias point out more correctly that the decline had taken place six months before the Act was passed. The cases made for this system of punishment, is that it is confined to two classes of offences, and it is thought it would be a special deterrent for these two classes of offences. No reason was given why culprits of this kind will be deterred while other culprits, offenders in other directions, will not be deterred by flogging. It is rather strange, while one class of offence is chosen here in this Bill as a fit subject for the reintroduction of this same fiendish system of punishment, in other places and other times quite other classes of offences are quoted as justifying the reintroduction of flogging. There are two judges whose words I would like to quote—representing two different schools of thought, one might say—Mr. Justice Hawkins and Mr. Justice Matthews of the British Courts. Sir Henry Hawkins wrote in his memoirs, "soon after I became a judge I abstained from applying it (the lash) and in all cases where my attention was directed to the special brutality of any particular case I felt that it was preferable to inflicting whipping to add a longer term of imprisonment."

Comment on this
George Nicolls Mr. GEORGE NICHOLLS Sinn Féin

at this stage took the Chair.

Comment on this

Mr. Justice Matthews said, in criticising the proposals of the Grand Jury at the Birmingham Assizes in 1890, to the effect that there should be an extension of flogging for assaults on women and children, "it would be inhuman to add the lash to the sentence of penal servitude and such savage sentences would tend to defeat their object by creating pity for the criminal." I have no doubt that many judges can be quoted on the other side who are in conflict upon this subject, as they are upon many subjects. Some judges are very fond of heavy sentences for certain classes of crime, while others are favourable to light sentences, and they vary exceedingly in respect of the merits or demerits of the lash as a form of punishment. The contention is, however, that flogging is a deterrent, that it will deter in a special manner Irishmen who are guilty, at this stage in history, of the offences of arson, or Irishmen who are guilty, at this stage of history, of robbery under arms.

I want to ask whether it is intended to impose a flogging sentence out of vengeance upon a person guilty of either of these crimes? Is it intended that because the individual has offended violently and grievously against the State, the State must use its strong arm to violently afflict that person's flesh with a lash? Is it vengeance that it is sought to expend upon the prisoner? If that is the case the Dáil will make, then I have no reply to it except to regret that Deputies are so lost to all that has been taught them from their childhood, as to fall back upon the primal instincts. "An eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth," has a long history as a method of administering justice, but it is not consistent with the Christian Doctrine that Deputies generally have been taught and believe. So I will assume that this punishment is not intended to be imposed as an act of vengeance.

It is presumably claimed that the fear of the lash will deter those who may be tempted to commit those crimes. I think that that is the fairest statement of the case in favour of the imposition of the lash. It is hoped that it will not be necessary to impose it. It is, perhaps, believed that it will not be necessary to inflict whipping penalties, but that the very fear that such a penalty may be inflicted will deter the kind of criminal or potential criminal who might be tempted to commit any of these offences. If that is a fair statement, I want to ask whether it is a right thing to put a person who is not sufficiently brutalised to have no regard for the probable whipping, to put that person, who has at least some remains of a sensitive nature, some remains of a moral sense, to undergo the very degrading punishment that the lash involves? If it is argued that the offender is already brutalised, and that an appeal to that person's social sense is useless, that there is only one way to deter him or to deter others like him, and that is to punish him so viciously, so severely, by physical pain, that the fear will be too great, that he is, in fact, a brute, that he is already dehumanised, and that therefore the only way to treat him is as a brute, as something that is not human—if that be the argument, even then I contend it is better to impose a long period of imprisonment. It is a much more effective safeguard to the public than to allow that brutalised person to be free after a period of imprisonment, and to allow his brutalised nature to have full fling upon the body politic. If, on the other hand, this kind of person is one whose moral sense has not been utterly destroyed, that there is something of humanity left, then I say that the process of whipping is going to lower that man to a level much nearer the brute and to take from him much, if not all, of the human feeling that we are crediting him with.

I do not know whether the Minister has—as I think was his duty before suggesting the imposition of this penalty— made himself acquainted with the procedure connected with whipping under British law in the past. The procedure under this Bill will be that the instrument is to be decided by the Court, and I presume not merely the instrument but the manner of the use of that instrument. No doubt precedent will be quoted, and some reference will be made to the practices in the past, and perhaps the jails which have used the lash for offences against warders—disciplinary offences—may still have within their walls the whips and triangles and the like. I take it that the Minister will have made himself thoroughly acquainted with the procedure. I am going to ask the Dáil to listen to a statement that was made in an earlier discussion upon this question in the British House of Commons. It will be remembered that the Irish representatives of that day did a great deal toward the abolition of the use of the lash in the British Navy and the British Army. It is related in a history of the Irish Parliamentary Party that one terrible day in the House Alexander McDonald, who, by the way, was the first of the Labour members, told the story of his father's cruel shame. He had been a sailor on a ship of war. Some trifling quarrel with a superior had brought him to the courtmartial, and the sentence of 50 lashes of the cat-o'-nine-tails at the hands of the burly boatswain's mates was imposed. Cut to the bone, to the ribs, McDonald's father bore the scars to his dying day.

"I worked as a lad with my father many a day in the pits," McDonald told the House, "and well I remember that no matter what the heat and sweat of work my father always kept wearing a bit of a shirt about his chest and sides. He would not let a fellow workman see the scars of the wounds. I had my personal experience too of those soldier-tragedies. My soldier-nurse, my father's batman, had been a few months before the smartest soldier in the Fighting Fifth. A glass of drink, a word, a blow, a mad struggle with the picket. The court was merciful. The ruined man got `only' 25 lashes! Poor brave McMullan, from the County Down! Shamed to the very death, he drooped and shrank from that awful day. His captain, who liked and respected him, did all he could to hearten and console him. In vain. Before three years were passed from the hour they loosed him from the black triangle, the broken soldier was in his grave."

I do not really want to stress the physical point, but I do want to appeal to the Dáil to realise that there is a moral degradation, a brutalising of the man who has been lashed by another man, and that that brutalising seriously and rapidly tends to make that criminal a much less desirable citizen when he returns to civil life than he was before he went in. You have put him at enmity with the State and with Society, because you have degraded him. You have put him in the position of a slave, of a man whose physical being has been scarified and scored by another and who has been actually put into physical torment at the hands of the State.

I say that the inevitable effect—and it is easily proveable in history—of that kind of torture is to put that man at enmity with the State and with society when he comes out, as you contemplate he will do, because his mind has been brutalised and he has lost real contact with the higher things, by virtue of that real degradation of spirit, and you have actually put him into a wrong relationship if your intention was preservative and beneficent and if you are not, as I hope you are not, out for vengeance. The history of civilisation will surely remind Deputies that the countries and the times in which crime was most prevalent were the countries and the times when flogging was most general. Flogging was general for the minor offences both of men and women, and it was only with the development of a real sense of humanity that crime diminished. When flogging ceased there was a rapid diminution of crime. The history of the British Navy and the British Army in regard to flogging gives ample evidence of that. Everybody who has had experience admits that since the abolition of flogging the general sense of discipline and of good conduct of our crews and of soldiers has been improved to an extraordinary degree, and that since the flogging process was wisely put aside the effects have been immeasurable upon those who were in the habit of committing offences. I would ask the Dáil, and I would appeal to the Minister as seriously and as earnestly as it is possible to do, to withdraw these penalties from this Bill and not let it be said that we are instituting or reviving the system of flogging. I would remind the Dáil that it has been noted with satisfaction that in the past flogging has been very, very lightly indulged in in Ireland and in Scotland, if at all. Now we are asked to institute it in this Bill and to impose it upon certain criminals—to enter, as I think, into a competition with criminality, a competition between the State and the criminal as to who is the most capable of inflicting violence. We have said, and the Minister has said, that recent years have dulled the sense of morality of many people in the country, and that what was looked upon as a terrible thing five years ago is lightly regarded now.

Flogging is merely an institution. The institution of flogging will merely be one other step in the contest of brutality. The criminal is doing an evil thing, a violent thing, and a very disastrous thing to the common well-being, and the State is asked to respond to that by inflicting physical pain with a lash. We are not asked to adopt other methods which are known to history of inflicting pain, but we are asked to strip a man and to use upon that man's body the whipcord, a knotted cord or, perhaps, some other instrument of torture in the form of a lash, and to prescribe that as a cure for the offence of arson. I think it will not be a cure. The utmost that is to be hoped is, if this Bill becomes law with this flogging clause, that there will be no offences of arson, and it may be claimed to the credit of the Bill, if that is the desirable story that can be told at the end of six months. But we will have had placed upon the Statute Book this punishment of flogging, and that in itself will be something to be sorry for in the future. I hope it will be possible for the Minister to say that he is willing to wait at least until he sees that there is an actual increase or a great increase in these two offences and that there is no way of putting them down without corporal punishment. If he comes to the conclusion, after trying other methods, that there is no way of putting them down without threatening corporal punishment, then let him come again to the Dáil and ask for permission to add this penalty to the other penalties; but I would earnestly ask that, until other methods have been tried, and until an extension in the number and ferocity of these offences is revived and continued, that we should not be asked to accept Section 5 in this Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Deputy Johnson has put calmly and rationally one aspect of this question. I wish I could feel that I could put nearly as well the contrary case. This Bill has been nicknamed. The official title has been ignored and it has become known as the Flogging Bill. I think that people would have been wiser to have adhered to the original title, because it is certainly in that spirit of protecting the clean decent people of this country that the Bill was conceived, and it was above and beyond all for the public safety that it was framed. Within the last year Ministers, Deputies, Senators and representative people have had to be guarded, and to be specially guarded. None of them, I take it, liked that, but it was considered necessary. I ask Deputies to remember that the ordinary man and woman in this country have no guard, if the law and the sanctions of the law are not a sufficient protection for them. Time was in this country when a man could leave his door on the latch during the day or the night. That day has passed, and within recent months, within the last eight or ten months, all sense of appreciation of the sanctity of the home, all restraints of human respect, restraints of respect for the moral law, restraints of respect for the law of man, have gone whistling down the wind, because the worst instincts of man have been summoned up, deliberately summoned up in this country, because that criminality which is latent in man everywhere, which is part of his baser nature, has been called up here. The poet Virgil makes one of his characters say "If Heaven denies me, then I'll call on hell." That seems to be very much the stand taken up a year ago by certain people here who professed to be standing for the higher political ideals, who professed to be themselves high-souled patriotic men with no thought of self, ready to sacrifice themselves and all they hold dear on the altar of their country's good. But they said "If heaven fails me I will call on hell; if I fail to get a response from the people of this country to the intrinsic nobility of my cause, then I will turn deliberately and call forth in this country the worst instincts of man; I will play deliberately to their basest passions, and I will tell them the country is theirs for the taking; I will ask them to go out with a gun to rob their neighbours; I will offer them land for nothing; I will tell them they will never have to pay any debts, rent, rates or taxes, and that the millennium is coming for the man with the gun." It was a pleasant call, and it tickled many ears, and met with a surprisingly general response. Men who had never felt themselves called upon to face the British administration, who had never felt themselves called upon to make any particular sacrifice to achieve the object of getting the British out of Ireland, when the British were got out of Ireland turned on the first native administration here with a ferocity and wantonness that was surprising, and the country has had its year of hell in consequence, the hell of what, for want of a better name, we call civil war. It was not civil war, because there was only the irreducible minimum of fighting. For the most part, when the troops came within range, it was easy talk to the men who professed to die rather than to go into the British Empire and all that kind of talk. They conducted a very wanton campaign against the unarmed citizens of the country, and against the economic life of the country. They wrecked and burned and robbed from end to end of Ireland in the name of Irish freedom, and in the name of a political ideal. Irish freedom! Two things stood out, and these were these two offences that have been singled out in this Bill, the crime of arson and the crime of robbery, the robbery of the unarmed man by the man with the gun. The cry was "What is yours is mine, because I have a gun and you have not; your savings, the fruits of your thrift or enterprise, must be handed over to me by virtue of my gun."

Arson is an offence at which the human mind stands appalled, and in men's minds, back to the earliest days, the home and all it stood for, the household goods, have been cherished things, things ranking amongst the most sacred in life. I feel that if the seeds that have been sown in the last year are to perish and die that we must take steps to strip the thin little rag of idealism from these two crimes, the thin little vestige or scrap of that that they may have, because people professing idealism urged their followers to resort to such methods. Deputy Johnson says that this penalty is degrading. It may be necessary to show how degrading these two offences are to attach this penalty, this humiliating penalty. It may be necessary to mark our horror of these two offences and to mark the strength of our convictions that either they or the nation must perish, to attach very signal and very severe penalties to them. I think it is so necessary. I think that the ordinary penalty of imprisonment has its edge blunted for the people who resort to these two crimes, and if I believed that by any other means than the means proposed in this Bill these offences could be checked and stamped out I would not have inserted this penalty of flogging. But I do not believe that you will adequately grapple with and stamp out these offences by imprisonment. This has been called a reversal of progress. Deputy Johnson used another word which I marked. He called it a reversal of Christianisation.

Now, in all reverence let me say that the Lord Himself in righteous anger scoured with a whip of cords the people whom He found desecrating the holy places. The people who have been violating Irish homes in the name of Irish liberty, who have been robbing Irish citizens by virtue of their guns, will not stand checked by the normal sanctions of the law and they will not stand in fear of imprisonment. I say that believing it to be absolutely true, and I say that if any member of the Executive Council believed that imprisonment would be a sufficient deterrent we would not resort to any other method. The situation in the country is known to every Deputy and scarcely needs to be stressed. You have this combination: that you have summoned up here the worst instincts of man, and you have together with that the lethal weapons secreted from one end of Ireland to the other. These two factors will fuse and will produce both of these crimes. The criminal instinct will find the lethal weapon, and people will try to live by their guns in the future as they have lived for the last year. They have got out of the way of work, and out of the wholesome mentality that work develops and preserves in man, and have got into the way of living by crime. Men go on from year to year, very often living humdrum, routine and moderately respectable kind of lives. Some day the bond snaps. There are many bonds, moral bonds, and bonds that could not exactly be described as belonging to the supernatural sphere, bonds of human respect and also the bond of ordinary decency, the kind of decency that a pagan might have. These bonds, I say, go and the man stands a predatory savage prepared to prey on his fellow-man for his living.

That is the kind of problem we have to face here in this insula sanctorum et doctorum. I do not say for a moment that such problems would not arise to the same extent, or to a greater extent, in other countries. They could. I never believed in the theory of the double dose of original sin for Irishmen. I think that probably in other countries similarly situated, much the same might have happened as has happened here. I would be even prepared to concede that much worse things might have happened than have happened here. But we are dealing with a situation that has developed here, and I tell Deputies, solemnly speaking with a more intimate knowledge than most Deputies could have, speaking with a knowledge of police reports from the various counties and statistics in my mind which I do not propose to state to the Dáil, for the obvious reason that they would be distorted and used by political enemies to the discredit of the country, but speaking with these things well in my mind, I say that if these two offences are to be stamped our sufficiently quickly you must have resort to very special and very stringent methods, and the credit of the country demands that they be stamped out in the shortest possible space of time. When I say the credit of the country, I say it in a twofold sense. The financial credit of the country demands that these crimes be ended at once, and the good name and prestige of the country demand that they be ended. I can almost hear Deputy Johnson making a mental comment that the country's prestige will not be improved by resort to the penalties mentioned here in Sub-section (4), and that whatever we gained by checking or diminishing those crimes, we will lose by the fact that we resorted to those penalties. I know that that is his outlook. I have appreciated it from the start in connection with this Bill—that he thinks and he feels that we are wrong, and he believes that he is right. I do not think, however, that it will be held to the discredit of this Government either here or elsewhere that it placed the protection of the decencies of life, the preservation of the decencies of life, and the protection of the plain decent citizens of the country beyond and above the sensibilities of the robber and the man who resorted to arson. It is the duty of a Government to govern. It is the duty of a Government to protect, to give the utmost possible protection to, citizens. The citizens of this country have a right not to be robbed, not to have their houses and property burned, and they have a right to demand from their Executive that ample measures be taken to check those offences. They must not be left at the mercy of the criminal who has lost all sense of right and wrong because he was taught crime as a means of forwarding a political ideal, because crime was introduced to him wrapt round with the trappings of idealism. The responsibility for that lies on the people who resorted to it, but we must deal with the consequences. We must make it very clear to everyone here that the man who robs and the man who burns is not a hero, but a most cowardly coward, that he is not an idealist yielding to an amiable eccentricity, but that he is the lowest form of criminal. On the Second Reading of this Bill a metaphor was used which I did not like. I did not think that it was a good metaphor, but it was said that every sore back in the country would be a monument of our inability to govern. If the sore backs are to be monuments let us inquire closely what they will be monuments of. I differ from the Deputy. I think they will be thought to be monuments to the fact that we appreciate the necessity of ending these two crimes in the shortest possible space of time, monuments to our determination to end them even at the cost of the finer feelings of the robber and the burner, even, mayhap, at the sacrifice of some finer feelings of our own. You see we have had to outrage in the execution of our responsibility certain of our feelings. Deputies know that.

They know we have had to arrest and imprison and even execute people who were our friends and who were our comrades, and Deputies do know, even though at times they talk as if they did not, that that was not a pleasant task for us. Deputies do know that that was undertaken and carried through by us only because we were supported by the feeling that these things were necessary in the proper discharge of our stewardship to the people of Ireland. Deputies get worked up occasionally and they get up and talk as if they believed that members of the Executive Council, or members of the Army Council were blood-thirsty ruffians or flinty-hearted persons devoid of all human feelings. I know that they do not believe that. I know that in calmer moments it has been necessary for us, or we, at least, have considered it necessary to sink and control the natural promptings of our hearts because we consider that those conflict with the due discharge of our responsibilities. It is so in this Bill and so in fact throughout the Bill, and so in truth with regard to this Section. No one likes to have to resort to the penalty of flogging, and, going a step further, no one likes to have it known elsewhere that it was necessary to have to resort to that penalty in this country in order to check certain crimes. We would much sooner it was not necessary, but we do consider it necessary and we do consider it is our duty to tell the Dáil that we believe that the combination of hidden arms and a rather general tendency to crime and to give free play to the lowest instincts will create here these two offences on a scale which the normal sanction of the law would not be sufficient to check. We come here and say that there has been a retrogression from the standards to which civilisation and society had attained and to meet that retrogression you must take a step back also in your penalty and go back to those penalties of corporal punishment which every man would be glad to have laid aside if certain circumstances permitted that they could be laid aside. But it is surely my duty, and it is surely our duty, if we considered that those penalties, and those penalties only, will check these offences, to come here and say that in an open, responsible, straight-forward spirit. Deputies must choose deliberately. I say if you rely on the sanction of mere imprisonment to deal with these two offences you will not stamp them out as quickly as they ought to be if this country is to live and flourish and go forward in peace, progress and reconstruction. Deputies must choose whether they prefer to respect the finer feelings of the criminal and to have robbery and arson rife in this country from end to end, or whether they will figuratively grit their teeth and go through with this thing for six months in the hope that at the end of six months they will have shown adequately that neither of these two crimes is heroic, that they are in fact ignominious offences demanding an ignominious penalty.

Comment on this

The facts as to the late prevalence of arson and robbery under arms, and the likelihood that there will be, perhaps, on an extensive enough scale, a repetition of these offences are all quite admitted, but I respectfully suggest that after he had retold for us the story of all that, the Minister very largely begged the question before us. He gives it as his considered opinion, and the considered opinion of the Executive Council, that the employment of this particular form of punishment is going to achieve the end which he wants to achieve, namely, the suppression of these two offences and the putting of criminals of this kind into a class apart from all other criminals. Now, he has brought no evidence and nothing to show that that opinion of his and of the Executive Council is well founded. Such opinion, at least, the majority of opinion that has been expressed in other countries as to the efficacy of flogging or whipping, or indeed of any form of torture, has been dead against torture because it is torture, and it is just because it is torture that it is objectionable. It is not out of any great consideration for the finer feelings of criminals that one opposes a measure like this. It is out of consideration for the finer feelings of human beings of the whole nation and of civilised beings in general The Minister made a false analogy when he referred, as a kind of parallel, to the driving of the money-changers out of the Temple, but will the Minister say that that particular kind of whipping is the whipping that is going to be inflicted under this Bill? No, it is not. The whipping provisions under this Bill are taken from the ordinary British whipping provisions which are torture. Now, the light use of ordinary whips on animals is not, as far as I know, an offence in law, but the searing of the flesh of animals and the breaking of the skins of animals by excessive beating, is a crime known to the law, and is a punishable offence under the law. There is no analogy at all in what the Minister has said. It is a good many years since one of the most distinguished of Irishmen, a man who would have had no hesitation in punishing in the most drastic way, consonant with humanity and morality, Parnell, said that "flogging is an evil and has been used at all times by tyrants for purposes of their own, and so long as it remains it will continue to be used in an unlawful and cruel manner." Again he denied that even people guilty of the crime of garroting ought to be flogged, for it was a disgusting and inhuman punishment. I agree. There is one, and only one, argument that any Government can produce to justify flogging. It cannot produce the argument that it has been effective, for it has not been effective. At different places and at different times it has been adopted to deal with particular crimes, but the advocates of its use for that class of criminals have always said that it is not necessary to use it for other crimes, but that it is necessary for this particular one or two crimes. It is the same here. The only argument that can be used in justification is that it is one of the instruments of torture necessary to impress the community with the power of the State. I submit that in this case, as in most cases, the use of torture shows and reveals in a Government the very essence of despotism. It is no argument in reply to say that the majority either of this Dáil or the majority of this people approve of a particular measure. That makes it no less despotism, because no Legislature and no Government is invested, or can be invested, with such power and such authority that every act it performs or gives sanction to is therefore a rightful act. Now, the Minister speaks of the decencies of life. We are all agreed with him on that, but we think that the adoption of this measure is a violation of the decencies of life. He thinks—I believe he is mistaken— that these scourged backs will be a monument to the ability and sense of duty of the Government. Well, if it is mere monuments like that that he wants he is welcome to them, but if it is monuments he wants he can have even more effective monuments to show to the people. He might, for instance, brand people convicted of arson with the letter A on their foreheads. That kind of thing has been done on exactly the same argument as the Minister brings forward here. He could brand the robber with the letter R on his forehead, so that everybody might see it.

Comment on this
George Nicolls ACTING CHAIRMAN (Mr. George Nicholls) Sinn Féin

The Deputy has exceeded the ten minutes allowed.

Comment on this

I regret having done so.

Comment on this

In support of the amendment to delete Sub-section (4) I wish to say that I think this amendment should get the sympathy of every member of the Dáil. When we take into account the class of prisoners who will be entitled according to this Bill to receive this punishment I am sure that neither Deputy Johnson nor any Deputy on these benches will have any sympathy. We have no sympathy, for instance, with the man who goes out for the sole purpose of robbing his neighbour by the aid of a revolver or the man who may go out with the full intention in his mind to set fire to his neighbour's dwelling or the man who may lie in wait watching his opportunity to take the life of his fellow-citizen. A certain class of prisoner, however, under this Bill when it becomes law can be sentenced by the Judge to the punishment mentioned. Any prisoner for the slightest offence which he may commit against this Act will be or can be sentenced by the Judge to flogging. Now I do not think that at our time of life in this twentieth century we are going to go back to the year '33. when flogging was first introduced. Surely we are advancing, but if we happen to be more or less of a "Paddy-go-easy" style of people whose desires are to follow in the footsteps of our great-grand or trebly-grand ancestors, and if the promoter of this Bill belongs to that class, I am sure the Saorstát is not going to advance. I think in fact we are taking three steps backwards. Now this Section specifies that in the case of a boy under 16 years of age the Judge can order a whipping to the extent of 25 strokes, but in the case of a person over 16 years of age the number of strokes specified shall be 50. I am sure that the Minister really means that the Judge shall specify 50 strokes.

Comment on this
George Nicolls ACTING CHAIRMAN Sinn Féin

The Bill says (b) in the case of any other person the number of strokes at such whipping shall not exceed 50.

Comment on this

I was taking it for granted that the Justices appointed under the Minister for Home Affairs would inflict the heaviest penalty.

Comment on this
George Nicolls ACTING CHAIRMAN Sinn Féin

The Deputy is not entitled to make such an assumption as that.

Comment on this

It lies with the Judge to specify the number of strokes. In the case of persons whose age does not exceed 16 the number of strokes does not exceed twenty-five, and in the case of other persons the number of strokes specified is between twenty-five and fifty. It is for the Judge to specify the number of strokes between twenty-five and fifty. We realise to the fullest extent the punishment that is to be inflicted under this Bill and the powers which you give to the Judge. To my mind flogging is the most horrible act that can be introduced for any civilised people. If you take a man out to the flog him you have to strip him. You are not going to flog him with a top coat on, especially if it is made of a shoddy material that is being worn by some portions of the Army at the present time. Having stripped a man you tie him to a post, then you get one or two strong men whom may be chosen by the Judge to use an instrument specified by the Judge. It does not say whether it is to be a cat-o'-nine-tails or a birch, and you cut the flesh off the man's bones, he is, of course, helpless, being tied to a stake. I notice that the Minister for Defence shakes his head, which leads me to think that he believes the flesh shall not be cut off a man's bones, but how can you flog a man and give him fifty strokes without cutting him? I can assure this Dáil that I want to see criminals who stoop so low as to rob for their own personal ends, or who burn the homes of their neighbours, punished. But there are other means of punishment than flogging. Flogging is too old a punishment to be adopted by a nation in its infancy as we are.

Comment on this
George Nicolls ACTING CHAIRMAN Sinn Féin

The Deputy has now exceeded his ten minutes.

Comment on this
Eoin MacNeill MINISTER for EDUCATION Sinn Féin

It is, of course, pleasant for certain Deputies here to assume the role of defenders and champions of human feelings and by their criticism directed against this Bill, especially against this particular provision, to convey the idea that members of the Government are lost to a proper sense of humanity and that they are not able to appreciate, as some Deputies can appreciate, all that has been said with regard to this aspect. I think there are two aspects put before us of this punishment of flogging. One aspect is that the punishment itself is degrading to those who receive it, and the other is that it is revolting to the minds of other persons. Now I do not know whether it is necessary for the members of the Government to proclaim that they are made of much the same clay as other people. They have probably quite as much of the average tenderness of feeling about matters of this kind as other people. It is really not a question of susceptibilities or sensibilities. If people allow themselves to be ruled by appeals of this kind it is not only in the treatment of prisoners and of the baser sort of criminals but in the treatment of innocent persons that they would wish to interfere and to impose limits. The surgeon daily in his ordinary operations has to do things which would be revolting to many hundreds and thousands of people if they were spectators of these things. I remember it was put forward at a previous stage that if this punishment were a justifiable one to be inflicted in prisons for these crimes why-then should it not be performed in public? That was the test—the ordinary operations of the surgeon. We were asked to consent to have this flogging in public. If the surgeon were asked to perform his operations in public they would shock the natural feeling, not only of some persons but a very large number of persons, and very probably the majority of persons. The case that we have to deal with is far more grave than the relief of the ailments of individuals.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

at this stage took the Chair.

Comment on this
Eoin MacNeill Professor MacNEILL Sinn Féin

It is a disease, but a disease of the body politic, a disease of the community, and, just as we are supposed to be unfeeling and inhuman in these matters, so it has been suggested that in bringing forward this Bill we have been acting at one time in opposition to the spirit of the Constitution which we have adopted here and at another time in a manner dangerous to the liberty of private citizens. The fact is, and I think the vast majority of the public at all events already recognise it, that the object of this Bill and the object of the severities proposed under it is to make the Constitution possible, to prevent it from being rendered impossible and to bring it into existence. At present it exists as an embryo, and the operation of bringing an embryo into existence and into full life is very often attended with pain and very often attended with circumstances which make people probably regard it as painful to their finer nature. It is the same with regard to the liberty of the individual. It is to make liberty possible for the individual in this country that this measure is proposed, because it is not only for the particular individuals who are threatened by arson or threatened by robbery, but because if these threats are in any measure successful they strike at the liberty of every person in the country without exception. The measures proposed here in this Bill are designed to give effect to the Constitution and to give it reality, to allow the Constitution to get life and breath and to give liberty to every individual. We have had numerous and oft-repeated statements in regard to this particular punishment of flogging. We have been challenged to point out whether we have reasonable ground for supposing that this punishment will act as a deterrent. We have reasonable ground. One of the Deputies who spoke instanced the action of Parnell. Parnell, we know, abolished flogging as a disciplinary measure in the British Army. As we know, Parnell was instrumental in procuring its abolition, I do not remember—I presume the Deputy has taken the trouble to verify what he has said—that Parnell objected also to flogging as a punishment for the crime of garrotting, but I do remember that that punishment was effective in stamping out the crime of garrotting; that, I think, is a fact well known to a very large number of the public.

Comment on this

It is a fiction.

Comment on this
Eoin MacNeill Professor MacNEILL Sinn Féin

It may be denied, I do not know how much the denial amounts to. It was also put forward that the object of this penalty was to create terror in order to give the notion of the power of the State.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

I must remind the Minister for Education that his ten minutes has expired.

Comment on this

I suppose it is in order for me to continue my speech, and that it will be in order for the Minister who has just sat down to resume his speech after I finish. The Minister for Education, I think, is in error like a good many other people, in pleading that flogging had the effect of putting down the prevalence or checking the prevalence of garrotting, particularly in London. It is a fiction that has existed for a good many years and even well recognised authorities have given some colour to it. But it does not happen so far as my information goes—my information may be at fault—to correspond with the fact, because the garrotting outbreak in England was effectively suppressed before certain Acts, particularly the Act of 1863, reintroduced the punishment of flogging unless I am very much mistaken, and one of the authorities testifying to the suppression of a garrotting before the 1863 Act was Mr. H.H. Asquith. I am handed here extracts from a speech delivered by two British Home Secretaries in the House of Commons in March, 1900. Mr. Asquith was Home Secretary from 1892 to 1895, and in 1900 he made this statement:—

"As to garrotting, that crime had been brought to an end as a serious danger before the House, in a fit of panic, due to one of its own members having been garrotted, resorted to legislation. Garrotting was put down without resort to the lash, by a fearless but, I agree, a severe administration of the criminal law."

On the other side of the House there was Lord Ridley, who had been Home Secretary from 1895 to 1900, and he said:—"Reference had been made to the Garrotting Act. He agreed with the history of that Act, at all events so far as London was concerned, given by the Right Hon. Gentleman, Mr. Asquith, and that the rapid and severe action which put down garrotting took place before the passing of the Act of 1863."

As a matter of fact, many of the legal text books and other books of information have put down the particular Act referred to as 1861; it was 1863 as a matter of fact, but I repeat that there is no evidence as to the efficacy of flogging for any of the crimes for which at various stages it has been specifically prescribed, and that most of the evidence is against it as an efficacious method. Reference has been made to what is in fact the Mosaic Law, but we should have kept at this time of day, far away from the Mosaic Law, even though we had as bad a period in the last twelve months as any period in history. One of the great dangers to the State, and to the community, in the introduction of flogging, is that the idea of flogging gets hold of men's minds and is extended from one offence to another, and to many offences. To-day it is advocated for one thing, to-morrow it is advocated for another; its failure in each does not prevent it from being defended, and it is always prescribed for something else when it has failed previously. There were many people who adopted the most severe provisions of the Mosaic Law. English people in America have adopted many of them at various stages in their history, and they have adopted whipping and have extended whipping to many things that no one here at the moment would suggest they should be extended to. They have even gone so far as to prescribe whipping for a breach of the Sabbath, for abusive language, for defamation of character, and so on. Sometime or other it will be quite within the competence of the Government here in Ireland, if we allow these things to be done now, to say that some particular offence, which at the time seemed not particularly odious, should be punished under this measure. I repeat that flogging is torture, and nothing but torture, and it is because it is torture that I object most strongly to it. It would be no use in any sense of the word if it was not for the infliction of physical suffering and the infliction of actual physical suffering must be torture. Now, we know the effect that that will have in two or three directions in Ireland and elsewhere. We remember the effects that were produced by torture on Tom Hales and we know the effect it had upon his comrades. We do not want anything of that kind in Ireland. You have got, or you ought to have got, numerous measures that you could use. From the time flogging is adopted, and from the time it will be adopted, its adoption will be advocated on the very argument and on the very ground that the Ministry here and now are advocating it.

Comment on this
Eoin MacNeill Professor MacNEILL Sinn Féin

The Deputy has undertaken to correct me. He spoke about garrotting having been suppressed before the Act of 1863, and brought forward evidence of two members of the British Legislature on that point. Am I to understand that the Deputy supposes there was no garrotting, no outbreak of garrotting in Britain after that?

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this
Eoin MacNeill Professor MacNEILL Sinn Féin

There was an outbreak of garrotting after that time. It was not in London; it was in Liverpool long after that time, and at a time sufficiently recent for myself to remember it being a matter of conversation, and if I am not mistaken, it certainly was publicly believed at the time—I am not furnished with books of reference on these points—that outbreak of garrotting in Liverpool was put down by flogging.

Now, if corporal punishment inflicting pain be torture, I wonder how many Deputies here have grown up without coming through some experience of it. Of course it belongs to the old world, and it is fashionable for some people to say, nowadays, we have hospitals for dogs and people dying without hospitals. It is fashionable for a certain number of sentimentalists, nowadays, to say that corporal punishment ought to be abolished altogether. If it were in order I would like very much to call for a show of hands here among Deputies to testify, each for himself, who has not been corporally punished over and over again.

Comment on this

On a point of information, may I ask Deputy McNeill if the whipping provided for in the Bill corresponds any way closely to the corporal punishment administered by a school teacher or parent?

Comment on this
Eoin MacNeill Professor MacNEILL Sinn Féin

I understand the Deputy to say flogging is essentially a torture. If it is so, then the flogging of smalls boys is essentially torture.

Comment on this

As prescribed in the Bill.

Comment on this
Eoin MacNeill Professor MacNEILL Sinn Féin

I have corrected the point with regard to garrotting being suppressed before 1863. It broke out afterwards. My information is that when it broke out afterwards it was corrected by the punishment of flogging.

Comment on this

Not so repeatedly.

Comment on this
Eoin MacNeill Professor MacNEILL Sinn Féin

As to the argument that this punishment, if adopted, could be extended to other things and, therefore, should not be resorted to, if we adopt that argument we will stop anything. We will fall back on the Tolstoi system of punishing nobody. That is not our system. What we are proposing here is that for crimes of a certain origin, which have become a mental disease, a very severe and marked deterrent shall be adopted, not to magnify the notion at all of the power of the State. I am certainly not out to magnify the power of the State, but to magnify the rights of the individual Irishman and Irishwoman.

Comment on this

Deputy MacNeill has referred to the recrudescence of the flogging campaign following upon the suppressing of garrotting in London. I think it is undoubtedly true, and I am sure the statements by two Home Secretaries quoted by Deputy O'Shannon will be accepted as a fairly good evidence that at any rate London garrotting was receding if it had not been suppressed before the Garrotting Act was passed. Nobody claims, I think, that robbery with violence has ever been put down by any form of punishment. Nobody claims or has claimed here that arson will be put down by flogging. The utmost that has been claimed by the flagellants is that the epidemic of garrotting or the epidemic of robbery by violence in Liverpool which was followed by the campaign of Mr. Justice Day was put down by flogging. That is the case made by the Minister for Education. He says this is a disease which has broken out and the argument runs that in the same way as the hooligan epidemic in Liverpool which was treated by Mr. Justice Day by the lash was thereby cured, so will the fire and robbery epidemic that has been existing in Ireland recently be put down by this remedy of flogging. It is a very difficult question to decide whether the hooliganism which was attacked by Mr. Justice Day in Liverpool by the lash was as a matter of fact suppressed by the use of the lash. Mr. Justice Hopwood, the Recorder at the same time as Mr. Justice Day was carrying out his campaign, had quite the opposite view. He was the Recorder of Liverpool and took a different view of the effect of the lash. So different was it that his contention was that following the flogging the campaign actually extended for a longer period than normal outbreaks of that kind had been extended by the very use of the lash. People came back and back again for the same offence having had the lash. It is recorded that people asked for the lash rather than be sentenced to long terms of imprisonment. The evidence is not so convincing as the Minister for Education would think. On the contrary it is very unconvincing, and different judges have different notions of the effect of the lash upon crime of this kind. If there is any doubt about the effect in curing a particular form of disease—the Minister has spoken of it as a disease and I agree with that definition— you are not going to check the disease of the mind by application of the lash to the body. I submit that there we have no evidence whatever of the increasing prevalence of those offences, and therefore there is no need adduced which at all convinces one of the necessity of pushing forward extraordinary methods of punishment. The whole case that is made in favour of this is that there may be thrown out into the country men who have been mentally affected, and who will resort to this method of crime. Can we not wait until we see whether that prophecy shows any signs of coming true? It is put forward here as a measure to stop this epidemic of crime from developing, but undoubtedly the crime, though it has been rife, has receded. The President and Ministers tell us that is so. Then, why should we introduce this extraordinary method of treating a disease which is already in the process of being cured? The Minister says you must get your medicine ready for the possibilities of a new outbreak. But I say if that medicine is only a doubtful cure, if it has been ineffective in similar classes of crime, then we should hesitate before prescribing that medicine for a disease already receding. Let us make more inquiry. Let us prepare the Civil Code after inquiry. It is clear that Ministers have not thoroughly examined evidence for and against the revival of this flogging system of punishment. The instrument has not yet been decided upon. It has not been decided whether it is to be a lash which will cut with one stroke, that will wound or hack, or that will only slightly mark the back. No decision has been come to. The Minister has not examined yet into the merits or demerits of this instrument for the purpose of curing this disease. Is it intended to be a whip with thongs? It is not stated; it is left to the discretion of the Judge. Is it intended that it shall be a whip that will take out the flesh, such as the Russian knout? It is not stated. I submit there is not any case being made for urgency for this. The disease is receding. We have no assurance, no reason to believe, that it will necessarily become rife within the next few weeks. Let us wait, and in the meantime make a thorough inquiry as to whether the application of this kind of punishment is likely to be effective, judging by precedent. I am assuming that you are willing, for the sake of immediate gain, to do what I believe to be an irrevocable wrong. We do not believe, as the Minister thought, that he and his colleagues are any less sensitive to human pain and suffering, or have any less humanitarian feeling. It is, in my belief, the fact that Ministers have allowed themselves to suppress those feelings at the call of the intellect. They believe it is desirable to suppress those feelings, to go ahead with the work of punishment and repression, and not to allow their humanitarian feelings to have any play upon what they conceive to be their duty as judged merely by reason. I suggest it is not good politics, let alone sociology or morality, utterly to suppress human feeling.

Comment on this
Desmond FitzGerald Mr. DESMOND FITZGERALD Sinn Féin

There seems to be a great deal of doubt as to the effectiveness of this measure. One opponent suggests that it is abhorrent. Another suggests that the prisoners like it. Reference was made to garrotting. We need not go back to the Garrotting Act to see the effectiveness of this measure. It still exists in the Prison Code for assaulting warders. I have seen prisoners who assaulted warders who after receiving punishment were so cowed they would not answer me when I spoke to them. Its effectiveness is beyond doubt in the prisoner of to-day, and when a man suggests that a prisoner asks for it in preference to imprisonment I do not believe it.

Comment on this

That is corporal punishment. The Minister for Education spoke of flogging.

Comment on this

There is a great deal of sympathy and sentiment expressed by gentlemen on the other side for people who had very little sympathy with others themselves. They started out to show humanity that no matter what laws have been passed or what things have been done, all must be tempered with a superabundance of humanitarian motives. We were told here when we had to take very strong and very severe measures against the Irregulars in the early days that we were going to breed more Irregularism. It has not bred, it has not spread Irregularism. We are dealing with what one might call dying phases of Irregularism, fading to this extent that people are hesitating as to whether they will operate their terror still further by robberies or by burnings or by any other destructive experiments upon a people whose hearts they believe are filled with human kindness, thinking it was all over and that it is moral suasion that has won and not the strong arm of the State asserting authority in spite of their damned stubbornness. We have broken their stubbornness by strength. The best man amongst them admitted first that he never thought they would be executed, and secondly, that he never thought they would be sentenced to death. But he had to deal not with this friends, but with men who realised they had a great deal of responsibility and knew there were times when one must regulate his sentiment and sympathy with his duty. Even if the case were as stated that this particular form of punishment did not stop garrotting there is no use in telling me it will not stop it here. I am perfectly satisfied that it will. I have experience where the sternest and strictest measures brought home to people what we might call the sanity of the situation without eradicating the disease. I have seen people ruined with this particular form of disease. I have known them to have been in such a condition that it was as regular to them as taking their meals that they had to participate in something against society. There are several young men at present in jail. Personally, I do not think they will start this game of burning or robbery under arms. I do think if there is one thing more than another that will lead them to it it is the fact that we are getting more sentimental, that we are getting more sympathy with those poor sufferers who have led themselves into this. In my experience I have had to examine various orders of society. My experience invariably has been that the robber or person out to destroy is an absolute coward. When he came up against his own strength he quailed before it. When he came up against authority that was determined to exercise that authority when that authority was just, he would have had, if he could, his revenge, but he generally realised where the real strength lay, and the real strength in this physiological problem is to be shown in an utter indifference to those people's shrieks. I would like the gentlemen opposite who are as much interested in the stability of the State as we are to realise that those robbers are even more dangerous from the point of view of business and employment than any sort of political disturbance. If they doubt me in that I invite their attention to the balance sheet of the banks.

Comment on this

There is no doubt of that. The only doubt is whether this is efficacious.

Comment on this

Very good. We are on absolutely different lines with regard to that. Particular instances are quoted where Mr. Parnell got credit for abolishing that punishment in the Army. Is that a fair comparison? In one case it was a disciplinary torture that was removed from the Code regulating the British Army or Navy. But in our case what are we dealing with? Is it ordinary crime? is it something that can be explained or excused? It is not, and Deputies know that. The use of the gun has become rather too common, very much too common. I may tell Deputies that at a time when we had very great difficulty in maintaining the struggle against the British this was one of the methods adopted to correct people who committed crimes. I do not know that it was effective. I have no returns to show for it, but I have not heard of a single case of a person who got a corrective of that kind who again came before one of the Courts functioning under the Dáil during the War. I have never heard of a case. I did know of one case of a man who so suffered, and who if he had the opportunity I am perfectly convinced he would not commit the same crime again. Afterwards he called on me. He was a young man who was misled. He was not a coward. He was ordered out of the country, and he came to me to have him allowed back. We feel as much as you do. I will not forget easily the effect of the particular incident described by the Minister for External Affairs. It has been the experience in those cases that a person once corrected in that manner does not commit an offence punishable by the same corrective.

Comment on this

All that the President says may be true but it does not follow from that that this is the only method of correcting a particular kind of disease or removing a particular kind of disorder. I should really like to put the question to the two Ministers who have spoken in connection with a certain prison incident whether their object in making this provision is to prevent offenders who commit one offence from repeating that offence or whether their object is to prevent the prevalence of the disease as a social disease and not merely in an individual? The very fact that so recently as 1916 or 1917 a particular punishment was inflicted as a disciplinary measure in a prison goes to show that despite all that has been inflicted again and again in prisons for attacks on warders, violent and presumably murderous attacks, these attacks occur in those prisons again and again. It may be that a particular prisoner who has been flogged once for making an attack on a warder will not repeat that offence. A good deal depends on the quality of the prisoner just as a good deal depends on the quality and character of the young man whom the President cites as coming to him. I have met prisoners in prisons who suffered disciplinary measures of a much less severe kind for lesser offences and they did not repeat the particular offences. Some time again they might. It is arguing a bit out of the way I think to say that because in certain cases a certain effect was produced that the effect is going to be general. The weight of evidence, as I think we have clearly shown here this morning, is against all that and the very tone of the President's speech shows what I commented on a while ago, that the whole idea behind the thing is terrorism—meeting one ferocious act by an act still more ferocious, so much so that I would be inclined to paraphrase a learned Deputy of the Dáil, who said, in giving his objections to a certain Bill, that the provisions of the Bill were largely an interference with property of a certain kind. This Bill is an interference with persons of a certain kind. That Deputy said he thought that that particular Bill ought to be called a Bill for the outlawry of certain debtors, and the ferocious destruction of the same. This Bill is alternatively popularly titled a Flogging Bill, and might be entitled a Bill for the ferocious punishment of certain offenders.

Comment on this

The Deputy asked me if I believed that any person who had been flogged would not offend again. My answer was given in reply to Deputy Johnson, who stated that there were cases in which people asked for flogging instead of some other punishment. I believe that the very fact that this Bill is passed will limit very much the particular activities that we mean to limit and that it is a deterrent rather than a punishment for particular people.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 13
·
Níl 38
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I beg to move Amendment 45, to delete in Sub-section (4), lines 46 and 47, the words "convicted by a court of summary jurisdiction or."

The effect of the amendment is that the Sub-section shall not apply to cases in which the persons are tried before a court of summary jurisdiction; in other words that the Sub-section will only apply in cases where people are found guilty on indictment, that is where they are tried before a Judge and jury.

Comment on this