We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

THE DAIL RESUMES. - THE DAIL IN COMMITTEE.

Contributions 1–145 of 290. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I beg to move Amendment 1 as follows:

"In Section 1 (4), page 3, lines 33 and 34, to delete the words "Sinking Fund payments in respect thereof" and to insert in lieu thereof the words "sums required for redemption of Land Bonds in accordance with the foregoing provisions"; and in line 35, after the word "Fund" to insert the words "established under this Act."

This is merely verbal and consequential on the amendment introduced on the Committee Stage.

Comment on this

I am accepting this amendment. It was agreed on the Committee Stage, and Deputy FitzGibbon suggested that these words should be inserted. The Dáil agreed, and I gave an undertaking that on recommittal these words would be inserted.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

"To add at the end of Section 9, page 5, a Sub-section as follows:—

The Purchase Annuity or any part thereof at any time outstanding may be redeemed in whole or in part by the person liable to pay that annuity by payment to the Land Commission in cash of such amount as shall be ascertained in accordance with Rules made by the Minister for Finance."

This amendment gives the purchasing tenant the option of redeeming his annuity which he was entitled to do under the existing Acts.

Comment on this

This amendment is also accepted. It is probable that without this amendment the provisions in regard to redemption in the previous Act would apply, but to make assurance doubly sure a sub-section has been added, providing for redemption of an annuity under the Act in the event of any tenant wishing to redeem before it is paid off in the ordinary way.

Comment on this

I beg to move: "In Section 10, line 30, page 5, to delete the word "dividend" and to insert in lieu thereof the word "interest." This is merely verbal.

Comment on this

This amendment is really to meet Deputy Johnson's suggestion that "interest" looks nicer than "dividends." Personally, I do not think that it makes any difference.

Comment on this

If the Minister's aesthetic views are considered in this matter I do not wish the Dáil to accept the amendment if that is the only question, but it is a question of verbal accuracy.

Comment on this

I beg to move "In Section 11 (2), page 5, line 56, after the word "thereof" to insert the words "together with the addition (if any) in respect of compounded arrears of rent added to the purchase money." This is to cover cases in which the arrears instead of being paid in cash are added to the purchase money.

Comment on this

I am accepting this amendment. There is an amendment at a later stage suggesting that a half year's rent be added to the purchase money which I propose to accept. I do not know if the Dáil will accept it. Possibly the Farmers' Party will not.

Comment on this

In anticipation of the Dáil accepting that amendment, it does not in any way prejudice the question on the following amendment. It merely provides an addition, if any, in respect of the arrears to be added to the purchase money. It does not specify compounded arrears. That question is open.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

"To add a new paragraph (c) after Section II (2) (b), page 6, as follows:—

(c) On the nominal amount of all bonds issued for contribution to price and for the Costs Fund from the date of the issue of such bonds until the same shall be certified by the Minister for Finance to have been repaid.”

Comment on this

That amendment is also accepted. It speaks for itself.

Comment on this

I beg to move the following amendment:—

"To insert a new Sub-section after 11 (2), page 6, line 7, as follows:—

(3) The Land Commission shall pay to the Land Bond Fund in respect of Sinking Fund five shillings per cent. per annum.

(a) On the nominal amount of all bonds issued for the price of sporting rights and fisheries purchased by them under this Act from the date of the issue of such bonds until the same shall be certified by the Minister for Finance to have been repaid.

(b) On the amount of advances made by them to proprietors of parcels of untenanted land in non-congested districts counties and of parcels purchased under the Land Purchase Acts for the redemption of Fee-farm or other rents, superior interests and charges from the date on which land bonds shall be issued in respect of such advantages until the advances have been repaid.

This amendment provides the machinery for the necessary financial adjustments between the Land Commission and the Ministry of Finance.

Comment on this

That amendment is also accepted. It is a necessary financial amendment in order to perfect the machinery.

Comment on this

There are cases where fisheries have been let to tenants by the landlords as part of the farm. Will the tenants be entitled to buy these fishing rights, inasmuch as they have already rented them?

Comment on this

No, they will not, if it is merely a letting from year to year. No one, except a tenant in fee-simple, has fishing rights. If a man is a farmer and a fisherman as well it is a most unlikely contingency that in the first instance the usual procedure would be adopted in the case of fishing rights bought from a landlord. It would be for the Land Commission to say whom the rights would be let to. If a farmer is a genuine fisherman the Land Commission would treat him as such and let him the fishery as the landlord did. The Deputy will have to remember that there are no such things as fishing rights appertaining to land.

Comment on this

I am talking of a landlord letting to a tenant. Will the State step in and prevent the tenant from buying? There are several cases to my knowledge in which fisheries have been rented as part of the farm. Am I to understand that these fishing rights will be acquired by the Land Commission? What will be the result? Will the rent be reduced accordingly or will the tenant be deprived of these rights altogether, or can the tenant step in and buy?

Comment on this

We want to be clear about what the Deputy means. He does not suggest, does he, that any judicial or present tenant has any tenure of fisheries similar to that which he has of his holding? I can imagine a present tenant or a judicial tenant getting yearly lettings of a fishery appertaining to his land. The present tenant would have no tenure. The landlord would take the rights up at the end of the year and, as far as I know, there is no case in existance where the present tenant has a certain amount of rent appropriated to fishery rights. There is no holding that I know of or that exists where the rent of a holding is, say £50, and where the landlord of a present tenancy, or where the Land Commission has fixed £10 of that in respect to fisheries. The rent of a present or judicial tenancy is purely in respect of land, and the tenure of fisheries is a separate thing. The landlord who owns the fisheries lets them to anyone, not necessarily to the tenant, but often to fishermen and outsiders, such as rich men who like to come down to fish. He may, in an odd case, rent them to a tenant, not by reason of owning the land but on conditions on which any outsider would take them.

They will be vested in the Land Commission and paid for separately by them, and it will be for the Land Commission to say who is best entitled to those fishing rights afterwards. Take the first and usual case where fishing rights are appurtenant to land on the Shannon, or on any other big river and are being let to fishermen, and not to men who own the adjoining river at that spot. In that case the Land Commission will let them to men who are making their living out of them. Take the case Deputy Gorey suggested where the tenant took them as a separate letting. It will be open to the Land Commission to consider his title as against any other man in the neighbourhood making his living out of them. In that case the tenant will have no grievance because he never had any tenure.

Comment on this

There are other tenancies besides judicial ones that will be covered with this Bill.

Comment on this

I said judicial and present.

Comment on this

I know. There are small farms where a man is renting fishing rights as part and parcel of the holding. Will the Minister accept proof of that if cases be cited?

Comment on this

Certainly.

Comment on this

Under those conditions, then, he would be entitled to buy the fishing rights?

Comment on this

No. I do not believe there are such cases, but I am open to correction.

Comment on this

Most people are open to correction, even Ministers.

Comment on this

I do not think it is likely that any tenant would have fishing rights and would pay a fee for them with the holding at an inclusive rent. Does the Deputy suggest that?

Comment on this

I understand there are such cases.

Comment on this

That the rent fixed covers both the fishing rights and the rent of his holding?

Comment on this

I never heard of a case of that sort. It would be most unusual. If such a tenant were a present tenant and went into Court the only rent that could be fixed would be purely and simply the bare rent of his holding. If the Deputy takes the case he has in mind and traces the matter to its origin he will find that the inclusive rent now had a distant origin. Part was rent of the land and part of fishing rights, and it is a matter of convenience to pay all the rent on one receipt. I am perfectly certain no one has the same tenure of fishing rights, as he has of a present tenancy. These fishing rights would be paid for separately. If you have a case where a very small farmer is making his living out of fishing it will be open to the Land Commission to let the fishing rights to him when he makes application for it.

Comment on this

I know of a case in the River Blackwater where the tenant got the right of fishing along that river.

Comment on this

We are at cross purposes. I am sure Deputies know cases where tenants have the right to fishing. My point is if they have the right to fishing, they have it as a separate taking. They might have a holding adjoining the river and might also have got from the landlord, fishing rights, but they have not it in connection with the holding; it is a different tenure. There is no difference between the case of a man having fishing rights and having his holding near by, and the case where a man has fishing rights on the river, and lives 20 miles away. Does the Deputy suggest that the fishing rights are part of his holding, and that he has the same tenure as he has of his holding—namely, that it cannot be taken from him?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

It satisfies me.

Comment on this

I do not think that is so.

Comment on this

Have we the Minister's word that he will consider the case of genuine fishermen when giving out the fishing rights—one man one job? You cannot have a farm and fishing rights at the same time.

Comment on this

He cannot be a Deputy and on the railway at the same time.

Comment on this

I move, in Section 11 (6), line 19, page 6, to delete the word "dividends," and to insert in lieu thereof the words "interest and sinking fund."

Comment on this

I move Amendment 8: To delete Section 12 (2), page 6, and to insert in lieu thereof the following Sub-sections:—

(2) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in the Provisional Government Transfer of Functions Order, 1922, all sums collected after the 31st day of March, 1923, in respect of Purchase Annuities in repayment of advances made or to be made in Saorstát Eireann in pursuance of Purchase Agreements under the Purchase of Land (Ireland) Act, 1891, or any later Land Purchase Act other than this Act shall so far as not already paid into the Exchequer be paid into a Fund entitled "The Purchase Annuities Fund" to be established under the control of the Minister for Finance, and there shall from time to time be paid thereout by the Minister for Finance to the appropriate authority for the credit of the Land Purchase Account or the Irish Land Purchase Fund as the case may be an amount equivalent to the purchase annuities accruing due in respect of the aforesaid advances.

For the purposes of this Section purchase annuities shall be deemed to include interest payable in respect of an advance as aforesaid.

(3) The provisions heretofore applicable for making good any deficiency of the Land Purchase Account or of the Irish Land Purchase Fund shall apply as from the 1st day of April, 1923, in the case of the Purchase Annuities Fund in accordance with regulations to be made by the Minister for Finance.

(4) The Minister for Finance shall have power to make any adjustments rendered necessary by this Section in relation to the Exchequer and the Purchase Annuities Fund and the Guarantee Fund in the case of transactions during the period from the 1st day of April, 1923, to the date of the passing of this Act.

Comment on this

This amendment is necessary. It is providing merely a new name for the funds so as not to confuse the funds into which the annuities under the old Acts are paid with the Land Purchase Fund.

Comment on this

I move Amendment 9: To insert before Section 15, page 6, a new Section in Part I. as follows:—

(1) The provisions of Sub-sections (1), (2), and (3) of Section 39 of the Irish Land Act, 1903, providing for the payment to the public trustee of the sum of £5,000 per annum for the account of Trinity College, Dublin, and for the application of the said moneys shall cease to have effect and in lieu thereof the following provisions shall apply:—

(2) There shall be paid to the College out of moneys to be provided by the Oireachtas the sum of £3,000 per annum.

(3) The investments representing accumulations of the moneys so paid to the public trustee which were not required to make good loss of income to the College and accrued interest thereon shall be transferred to the Minister for Finance and such officer of the College as shall be nominated for the purpose by the Governing Body of the College.

(4) The dividends and income arising from the investments so transferred shall be applied by the College in such manner and for such purposes as to the College may seem proper.

(5) The investments so transferred may be varied from time to time with the consent and approval of the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

This amendment was already debated. Trinity College was entitled to £5,000 a year under the Irish Land Act as compensation for any losses which it might sustain by reason of the redemption of head rents. It would sustain further losses under this Act, because head rents will be redeemed, and the arrangement as set out in the amendment is perfectly equitable. It provides that the sum of £3,000 a year should be paid to Trinity as well as the interest on the money which they are entitled to under the old Act.

Comment on this

I beg to move Amendment 10, to insert before Section 16, a new Section as follows:—

"All moneys standing to the credit of the Ireland Development Grant Account at the time of the passing of this Act, shall be paid into the Exchequer."

Comment on this

This amendment is also accepted. The Ireland Development Grant is not to be voted in future. Any money required for the service will be voted directly by the Dáil, including any money required by the Guarantee Fund. There is no occasion now to earmark money for any special provision like this, whereby a special amount of money would have to be set aside for purposes of this sort. Any money required will be voted by the Dáil, and will be subject to the criticism of the Dáil, and any changes that take place the Dáil will be able to take into account, and make the necessary adjustments. I think the Dáil will agree that that is sound in the new circumstances that exist.

Amendment agreed to, and added to the Bill.

SECTION 17 (NEW).

Comment on this

I beg to move Amendment 11. To insert before Section 17 a new Section as follows:—

"For the purposes of this Part of the Act and of the Schedules attached to the Act, rent, whether on a judicial holding or otherwise, shall be understood to mean any abated rent accepted by a landlord for a period of at least 5 years previous to the first gale day of the year 1921, provided that such abatement was not given by way of payment for services."

Comment on this

I suggest to the Deputy and to the Dáil that as this amendment deals with the question of what is rent, whether abated rent, or actual original rent, and as the same question arises on arrears, and in the Schedules, and as there are three or four amendments on arrears and on the Schedules to which exactly the same consideration applies, I suggest that his amendment ought to be adjourned until we come to the others when we might take all together.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

That is, to deal with the matter on the Schedule; that would seem to me to be a proper thing to do.

Comment on this

Would it not be better to have this question of rent defined now?

Comment on this

We will have the same thing on the Schedule.

Comment on this

If we were to postpone this amendment until the Schedule, would it then be possible, at that stage, to come back and introduce this amendment here in this particular clause. Supposing the amendment were agreed to on the Schedule could we then come back and make this amendment here?

Comment on this

With the consent of the Dáil, I take it we could. Exactly the same consideration applies to the Schedule as arises on the Deputy's amendment here, and also in regard to arrears.

Comment on this

They are all rent.

Comment on this

Yes, and in connection with arrears it raises the question what exactly is rent, and the same with regard to prices.

Comment on this

I think if this amendment were discussed it would define the whole question of rent, and govern the whole of the other amendments; because there are rents other than judicial and non-judicial rents. There are agreed rents—rents where reductions were permanently given, not extorted or forced, previous to 1921, but reductions mutually agreed, and these have always been the basis of future purchasing. I think my motion comes in at the right place, and will decide the other amendments.

Comment on this

I agree this will decide the whole question, but you have amendments Nos. 51, 52 and 53 which raise, not exactly the same point, but points within these points dealt with here, and my suggestion was that instead of taking Deputy Gorey's amendment now we should take it at No. 50, and deal with 51, 52 and 53, which all raise somewhat the same point. It would be impossible to deal with one without the other.

Comment on this

It occurs to me that the Minister is pre-supposing the other amendments will be defeated. The question arises whether it would be in order to go back to Clause 17 for the purpose of introducing this new amendment after we had passed on to the Schedules. The object of the Minister would be quite well attained if, on the discussion of amendment 11 he dealt with the arguments affecting the other amendments, and then they could all be discussed later.

Comment on this

That will suit me. The Deputy is wrong in suggesting that I am pre-supposing that they will be defeated. I am quite willing to have them all gone into now.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

If this were merely a definition it could come on later, but I see now that it is a great deal more than a definition.

Comment on this

It is a definition of the word "rent."

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Yes, but it would come under a separate section rather than in a definite section, a section which gives a number of definitions, and for this reason it requires a good deal of discussion, and I do not think it can be inserted in the Schedule as it stands, and, therefore, it would be necessary to go back. If we go on to the Schedule, we could not go back to Clause 17.

Comment on this

If that is so, that finishes it.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

In so far as the arguments are relevant to amendments 51, 52 and 53 they can be used now.

Comment on this

In moving my amendment now I only propose to deal with this particular one and I leave the others to their merits, because they are all minor matters or side-issues of the same question. I ask the Minister to accept this new sub-section because where it has been the custom between landlords and tenants for both mutually to agree to an abated rent, or a first term, then that rent is held to be the second term rent, or if the first and second term rents are fixed and afterwards a mutual arrangement is made and an abated rent is agreed by both parties, then that stands as a third term rent. So, in the case of non-judicial tenants where the owner thought that the tenant would not go into court and where the landlord and tenant mutually agreed to a reduced rent, that reduced rent had to be the basis of purchase, and also with regard to arrears, purchase, and abatement in lieu of rent. This is quite a reasonable and sensible business suggestion. On any properties that I know of, and I know several, especially the estate on which I live, the abated rent was the basis of purchase; the landlord never questioned it; it was a non-judicial estate where the tenants received substantial reductions on the condition that they did not go into court as a supplement to getting a fair rent fixed. That abated rent was the basis of purchase, and in every case I knew it has been the basis of purchase, and the landlords having agreed to it through the abated rent, are not going back to the original rent as the basis of purchase or arrears or in lieu of rent.

An Leas-Cheann Comhairle took the Chair at this stage.

Comment on this

We will have to deal with the amendment as it stands, and to deal with it in connection with the clause to which it has reference. At present we are dealing with arrears and payments in lieu of rent, and we will come to the question of prices afterwards. The Deputy's intention is to ensure that where-ever there was a genuine agreement for an abated rent, that that shall be the rent, but his intention is defeated by his own amendment. His amendment reads: "For the purposes of this Part of the Act and of the Schedules attached to the Act, rent, whether on a judicial holding or otherwise, shall be understood to mean any abated rent accepted by a landlord for a period of at least 5 years previous to the first gale day of the year 1921, provided that such abatement was not given by way of payment for services."

Now, apart from the question of payment for services, I suppose any number of specific reasons could be given as to why a landlord reduced a rent and gave an abatement. The landlord gave an abatement, as the Deputy pointed out, for services rendered. A tenant's holding perhaps may have adjoined a piece of untenanted land, and a landlord may have come to the owner and said, "If you drive in my cows every morning, I will allow you a shilling in the £ off your rent." That, I hold, is not a genuine abatement of rent. Then, there might be a case where you had a reasonable landlord who had been on good terms with a tenant. Let us suppose that the tenant died, and that the landlord went to his widow and said, "I will allow you a 50 per cent. reduction on your arrears if you try and pull up a bit." That, I hold, would not be a genuine abatement either.

In any case it would be quite impossible to cover, by any general rule, the reasons or circumstances under which abatement of rents are given, and it will be quite impossible to provide directions for the Land Commission which would enable them, without having recourse to a judge, to say, in every case, whether abated rent was the real rent or not. Deputy Gorey's amendment states that an abated rent "shall be understood to mean an abated rent accepted by the landlord for a period of at least five years previous to the first gale day of the year 1921, provided that such abatement was not given by way of payment for services." The five years to the first gale day referred to in the amendment would cover the years 1916 to 1921. There were very few abatements in these years; in fact I think abatements were taken off during that period. On the other hand, a man might have got an abatement for 10 years, and yet his rent would not be a real rent; there might be a case of a man who only got an abatement for one year, and in that case the abated rent might be a real rent. It all depends, I say, on circumstances, and whether there was an agreement between the landlord and the tenant for a new rent, an agreement based on the value of his holding for rent purposes. Deputy Gorey's amendment would rule out hundreds of genuine cases, and would let in hundreds of bogus cases. Amendment No. 18 on the Order Paper, in the name of Deputy Hennessy, covers the point much better than Deputy Gorey's amendment, and covers it in the only way in which it can be covered. I am accepting Deputy Hennessy's amendment. Before I read the amendment, perhaps I ought to read the Section. The matter is dealt with in Section 20, Sub-section (3): "Any question arising between a tenant and a landlord regarding the accuracy of any particulars furnished pursuant to this Section shall be determined by the Land Commission in accordance with rules made by them, save that in the case of a holding subject to a judicial rent the record filed in the Land Commission shall be final and conclusive in all matters appearing thereon, except that where the judicial rent was fixed before the 1st day of April, 1899, the adjustment provided for by Section 54 of the Local Government Act, 1898, shall be taken into account in determining the amount of rent."

Deputy Hennessy's amendment, dealing with the matter, reads:—"In Section 20 (3), page 8, line 58, after the word `rent' to insert the words `and save that any question as to whether an agreement for an abated rent was in fact an agreement for a new rent or any question as to the amount from which the deduction of 25 per cent. is to be made in ascertaining compounded arrears of rent and payment in lieu of rent shall be determined by the Judicial Commissioner, whose decision shall be final.' "

That enables the High Court Judge to take the circumstances into account, and to see whether in any particular case the abatement was given by reason of services rendered, or was given gratuitously by the landlord, or as an admission of the fact that the old rent was too high, and that the new rent should be fixed. This is the only possible amendment that would cover all the cases, and that would do justice in all the cases. It would be quite impossible to provide a form of words in an Act of Parliament that would cover all cases, some of which may be extremely complicated and varied. There is no way of doing it except to leave it to a judge to say whether the rent is an abated rent or a real rent. I am accepting Deputy Hennessy's amendment. I could not accept Deputy Gorey's amendment, because it does not carry out the intentions which both of us have in mind, that where there is a genuine agreement for a new rent, that that shall be the new rent.

Comment on this

This is not a question of a genuine agreement. There are cases where you might have genuine agreements without at the same time having them in writing. You could, for instance, have an agreement that had become the practice between the landlord and the tenant for years, and although there was no written document to show that such an agreement was in operation, the agreement would none the less be a genuine agreement. Deputy Hennessy's agreement does not meet my point, because, in my opinion, it is a bit too technical.

Comment on this

Deputy Gorey's amendment reads that the abatement granted in each of the five years preceding the year 1921, is to be taken as the abated rent, and to be the rent of the holding. In one year the abatement might be twenty per cent., in another year fifteen per cent., and, perhaps, in another year twenty-five per cent., but suppose the landlord had, in fact, accepted the abated rent, but that the amount of the abatement had not been the same in all of these five years, the tenant, under Deputy Gorey's amendment, would not be entitled to get any abatement in the rent at all, because there would have been no abatement that would have lasted over the entire period of five years. Under Deputy Hennessy's amendment it would at once become open to the Land Commission to fix what was a fair rent, and the proper abatement to be granted in such a case as that. If Deputy Gorey's amendment became the law of the land, I am afraid the Court that would have to decide a case would say that there had been no abated rent for five years, and, therefore, would refer to the original rent and say "We cannot deal with it in the equitable manner in which we would be entitled to do if Deputy Hennessy's amendment had been accepted." Therefore, to meet Deputy Gorey's view, it seems to me that his amendment would require some alteration in the wording if it is to carry out the intentions he has in mind.

Comment on this

I make the Deputy a present of the particular case he has made. I never heard of such a case in my life, and I do not think that one is likely to arise in the future when this question of the fixing of rents will take place.

Comment on this

The point I made was this, that if an abatement of 25 per cent, were granted in the first four years, and that in the fifth year an abatement of only 20 per cent. was granted, it seems to me that under this amendment the tenant would not be entitled to get any abatement at all.

Comment on this

The real trouble is that Deputy Gorey is under the impression that there is some catch in my amendment.

Comment on this

I am always very suspicious.

Comment on this

The real trouble is that Deputy Gorey thinks no one but himself has the interest of the tenants at heart. I am not accepting this amendment, because it would be unfair to the tenants. I am not accustomed to exhibit my particular love for them in the Dáil. Anyone who thinks about this would see that the five years from 1916 to 1921 would be obviously unfair to choose, as practically all the abatements were taken off. There are hundreds of cases where you would have a genuine agreement, and the Deputy should not jump to the conclusion that the agreement must be in writing. These agreements are never in writing. I venture to say there is not one single agreement in writing in Ireland. The new rent agreement is on the face of the receipt That is the only evidence of an agreement that you have. I should not say evidence of an agreement, as it is not the only evidence, but it is the only writing in connection with this question that you have got. There is never an agreement in writing in these cases. The only writing in connection with the abatement would be on the face of the receipt. So it is not a question of an agreement in writing. As I said, there are a great many reasons for abatement peculiar to every landlord and every tenant. There are a very large number of tenants who have got genuine abatements by reason of the fact that the landlords admitted that the rent was too high, not by reason of the fact that they had performed some service was continuing, or by reason of the fact that a man had met with some misfortune.

Comment on this

I did not refer to these at all.

Comment on this

This would cover it. There might happen to be decent landlord who would say that he would let the tenant off forty or fifty per cent. of the rent for the next five years. It would be most unfair in a case of a decent landlord with a good tenant who had met with some misfortune, and whom the landlord let off with fifty per cent. of the rent for the next three or four or five years, that we should come in and purchase on the basis of the fifty per cent. It would be most unfair and unjust. It would be punishing decency and good treatment. There are hundreds of cases where an abatement for five years went on for a number of years, and it was not a genuine abatement. There are hundreds of cases where an abatement could have only been given for the first time last year, where it was a genuine abatement, and where the tenant would be entitled to have the abated rent regarded as the new rent. The Deputy in putting down these five years, and confining it to any abated rent within that time—except the abatement is in consideration of services—would do gross injustice between tenant and tenant and would rule out a very large number of tenants who would be entitled to come in. I am refusing this amendment, because it would be most unjust to the tenant, and, incidentally, to the particular decent landlord who gave an abatement in the sort of cases I have mentioned.

Comment on this

I am not impressed by the Minister's arguments. The language of Amendment 18 is very precise. It says: "Any question as to whether an agreement for an abated rent, was in fact an agreement for a new rent." In the absence of an agreement for a new rent, how does this apply?

Comment on this

The Judicial Commissioner is to say.

Comment on this

Then the Judicial Commissioner is to have a permanent job? He could do it in one stroke under the amendment that I suggest. Now, you are to have a Commissioner doing the work all over the country for years. I do not see the point of the amendment at all.

Comment on this

If I could find out what is in the Deputy's mind, I would answer it. He has stood up now and made two interruptions which convey nothing to me. What point is he making in regard to the words?

Comment on this

I did not stand up to make an interruption. I stood up when the Minister sat down. My opinion is that he is just as fertile in interruptions as I am.

Comment on this

Not quite; almost.

Comment on this

We will shake hands over it.

Comment on this

Oh, no. I want to know what objection he has to "any question as to whether an agreement for an abated rent was in fact an agreement for a new rent?" What is wrong with that?

Comment on this

I purposely used, in this amendment here, the words, "was not given by way of payment for services," in order to exclude anything like abatement for services rendered. I was not taking into consideration the very exceptional case which the Minister refers to, where a man dies and the landlord is very compassionate in the case of the widow. Such a thing may have happened, but I have not heard of it—not since before 1921. It is really an exception if it has happened. I did not refer to any of these cases that were not genuine reductions. I meant that a genuine case of an abated rent should stand as the ordinary rent.

Comment on this

The real point is that the Deputy's own amendment does not carry out that. He has not attempted to meet Deputy FitzGibbon's point. There are a great many cases in which tenants have only an abatement for two years, which would be entitled to be regarded as a new rent.

Comment on this

Considering the Minister's majority, I withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

For the same reason, I suppose, I can withdraw the next amendment also?

Comment on this

You can.

Comment on this

But I am not withdrawing it.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Before the Deputy moves the amendment, I must say that I can only accept part of the amendment—namely, "To delete the figures `25,' and to substitute therefor the figures `35.' " The remaining portion must come out, because we cannot make consequential changes in Sections we are not dealing with.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—In Section 17 (2), page 7, line 19:—"To delete the figures `25,' and to substitute therefor the figures `35.' " This amendment deals with the question of arrears. An amendment has been put down on the part of the Government later on, adding one-half year's rent to the purchase money in cases where three years' arrears are due. It is only in exceptional cases that there is three years' rent due. Of the 70,000 unpurchased tenants there might not be 2,000 in that position. The men who owe two and a half year's, two years', one and a half years', and one year's rent have paid their rents up to these periods. In my opinion, and in the opinion of the tenants all over the country, the provisions of the Bill in this respect are grossly unjust and unfair. The man who owes three years' rent ought not to be put in a different position from the men who owe two and a half or one year's rent. There is a bigger reason. Certain of the representatives of the unpurchased tenants—myself principally—gave an assurance to the unpurchased tenants, when this Bill was being discussed, that the terms would be raised either by giving a direct cash reduction or by adding so much to the purchase money as would have the same effect as raising it from twenty-five to thirty-five. When I gave that assurance to the unpurchased tenants, I had very definite reasons for doing so.

Comment on this

What were they?

Comment on this

I was not going to refer to them, but if the Minister asks me I will tell him. The Minister's distinct and emphatic assurance was that this 25 per cent. was not his last word at all; that he would be forced up on amendments from our party to 35 per cent., either as a direct cash reduction, or by adding so much to the purchase money, that it would have the same effect. Perhaps the Leas Cheann Comhairle may have some personal knowledge of this question.

Comment on this

On a point of order, if the Deputy has any further knowledge on this question he should speak out openly now in the Dáil, and not be making suggestions.

Comment on this

Time enough when it is needed.

Comment on this

I prefer it now. The Deputy has made a statement about me which is, shall I say, absolutely inaccurate. I prefer when he is making statements that he would not give any hints but state what he has to state openly.

Comment on this

I have made a certain definite statement. I went to the Unpurchased Tenants' Convention, and on the strength of an assurance, I assured the Convention that these terms would be carried out. On the strength of that assurance the Bill was accepted by the Unpurchased Tenants. They now find themselves, and I find myself, in the position that what I believed to be a definite assurance, and what the tenants believed from me, has not been carried out. That is one reason, but the main reason, apart altogether from this promise, is that of justice and equity. It is no reason because a man has paid two years' rent during the last three years, and only owes one year's rent, that he should be deprived of this benefit. It is also no reason because a man owes 2½ years' rent that he should not get this benefit, while a man who owes three years should have a half a year added to the purchase money. People who owe three years' rent and who get a half-year's rent added to the purchase money are thanking the Minister for little or nothing. It is really only throwing dust in their eyes in an attempt to seem generous when he is not generous at all. The Minister has denied that he made this statement or gave me to understand as much. He says that it is inaccurate. I say, distinctly, that the Minister's statement is inaccurate.

Comment on this
Mr. DOYLE

Apart from this promise or otherwise, of which I know nothing, as I got no promise, the Bill on these terms I say is unjust to the tenants. Considering the present state of agriculture, the Minister should do all he could in the case of these arrears. Where the amount of rent owing is one year or two years, such tenants should receive some benefit under the circumstances. As to the inaccuracy or accuracy of the statement that has been made, I know nothing. I heard it from no one else. It may be true or it may be false, but as far as the majority of our party are concerned, we know nothing about it. Apart from that I believe myself that the Minister is entitled to give 35 per cent. on the present arrears, people do not find so much fault with any other part of the Bill as with this. They consider such tenants should be dealt with more liberally under this Section, and that at least 35 per cent. of the arrears should be allowed.

Comment on this

I support this amendment and would ask the Minister to change the figures from 25 per cent. to 35 per cent. If the Minister agrees he will be doing a generous turn to the people on behalf of whom the change is urged. Since the last Stage of the Bill, in parts of the country that I visited, and where the tenants were not able to pay rent for the past three years, they seem to be completely up against the Minister of Agriculture on this point. Probably if the Minister accepted the amendment it may do a little justice to such tenants, over and above the justice that the Bill does to the landlords. Take the case of a small farmer who is in possession of an uneconomic holding, the landlord of which requires a really excessive rent. At a time when everybody else in the Free State was fighting for freedom, such tenants adopted the only means they could of fighting the landlords, by ceasing to pay the rent that was demanded. Where some of these people are not able to pay, the Minister could advise the Minister for Defence to send down military who will probably seize the stock that may be grazing on the holding. That was done recently near Mullingar where three cattle belonging to Mr. Flanagan of Tyrellspass were taken away and sold for £2 a head. I take it that the object was simply to recover the amount that was owing, but as a result this man lost all his stock. Every Deputy is entitled to his opinion on these matters, but it is nearly time that something was done for tenants who are asked to pay excessive rent. As Deputy Gorey has pointed out, the acceptance of this amendment will mean a little justice to the tenants, and I can assure the Minister for Agriculture that the people will be satisfied with it until such time as they will be able to compel the Dáil to give them perfect justice.

Comment on this

The case for this reduction is that there will be a reduction in the rent of 7/- in the £. Having regard to the bad times agriculture has had for the last two years, and to the tremendous disturbance that occurred in various parts of the country, the people were deprived of markets and it was impossible for them to pay their way or turn their produce into cash. The amendment will place, for the last two or three years, those who owe rent in the same position as the Bill will place tenants in the future. That is the whole object of the amendment, and if the Dáil wishes to do justice to the landlords, or enable them to pay their debts, perhaps the Minister for Agriculture would apply the 10 per cent. bonus retrospectively for these two years, in order to enable them to settle this question. That is the sole object.

Comment on this

I want to emphasise what Deputy Wilson has said. The actual terms of the Bill and the question of annuities for the future are not the questions that are exercising the minds of the unpurchased tenants at all. They view that more or less with equanimity, but the fact remains that in many cases they owe three years' rent at the moment, or two and a half, or two years' rent. There is also the fact that annuities under the Bill will be due immediately, or soon. This question of arrears is a greater stumbling block at the moment, seven times greater, than the question of purchase and of annuity. I could not, if I were speaking for half an hour, emphasise it sufficiently, because the people are more or less agreeable to the terms—at least I cannot say that they are agreeable, but they accept them, more or less —but I have heard nobody yet accept the arrears. This is a burning question, a much more burning question than the question of annuity. It will inflict more hardship upon, and will bankrupt the people at the start of the Bill, and in fact it will shake the stability of the State.

It may be that the time is approaching when the State will have to shoulder the responsibilities that they are inflicting in the Act. I think that the State and the Government will be wise to be a bit more just to the tenants on this question of arrears than they have been. It may, perhaps, be a hardship on landlords, but not on many. There may be a small percentage of the landlords who owe mortgages, and owe interest on mortgages, but they are a small number. But you inflict a hardship on a big body of the general community by this question of calling up three years' arrears now. If it could be made something like the terms of the Bill I think the people would meet it agreeably, but if it cannot be met I see nothing but trouble in front of the Government.

Comment on this

It is perfectly obvious that, as the Unpurchased Tenants' Association were unable to quarrel with the terms in regard to the price, in order to justify themselves, and with an eye to the next election, they had to quarrel about something and be in a position to say, "We have got some valuable concessions on the Bill." That is perfectly obvious, and hence we are debating on this question, and we have a campaign on the question. The forces are obviously concentrated on this particular question. I do not intend to pursue Deputy Gorey's statement. I just make one remark. Deputy Gorey's statements are inaccurate, as I said before, perfectly plainly——

Comment on this

To those who believe it, they are perfectly plain.

Comment on this

I will not pursue it any further.

Comment on this

Better not.

Comment on this

I do not believe in this recrimination. I invite the Deputy to bring forward any evidence of that, any evidence he has got, and as he has gone so far, to come forward with the rest of it. I content myself at the moment with saying that his statements are inaccurate Probably there are differences of opinion in the organisation itself.

Comment on this

Not a bit.

Comment on this

On this question of arrears I want to point out first that as far as the tenants who pay three years' arrears are concerned, they are better off by this provision which adds a half-year to the purchase money than if their rent was brought up to 35 per cent., as a simple calculation will show.

Comment on this

Better off than if the three years were not in arrears?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

Order.

Comment on this

I said with regard to the tenants who owe three years' arrears. The Deputy always suffers from the disease that he is not able to listen. That is the cause of a great many misunderstandings and of confusion on his part. With regard to the tenants who owe three years' arrears, these are better off under this provision of a half year added to the purchase money than if their rent were brought up to 35 per cent., that is to say, that they pay less down. Let us take an example. Take £100 rent; deduct 35 per cent., which is £65, and that leaves it £195. That is what would have to be paid. The other is £187 10s. By reducing the rent by 35 per cent. instead of 25 per cent. the tenant has to pay £195 on his £100 rent, and a half year's rent added to the purchase money. But the payment down is £195. By reducing it by 25 per cent. and adding half a year to the purchase money he has only to pay £187. Let us get to business on this question and drop politics in regard to it. I would like this question to be discussed strictly on business lines, and not with a view to the next election.

Comment on this

On a point of personal explanation, I do not think this question of elections ought to be introduced at all, because if the Minister insists on introducing this question of the elections, he will hear more about it before he is finished.

Comment on this

I have extremely good hearing and I invite the Deputy to let me hear anything he likes. I do not want politics in regard to this, and it is obviously politics, as I will show you. I want this discussed as a business proposition, and I point out here and I challenge Deputy Gorey, or any other Deputy who has a knowledge of mathematics—and I believe there are some great mathematicians here—to show that I am wrong, that the payment down by a tenant who owes three years' rent, the payment in cash, if we give him a reduction of 35 per cent. instead of 25 per cent., would be £195, whereas the payment down in cash, if we gave a reduction of 25 per cent. and add half a year to the purchase money, is only £187 10s. There is no doubt about that.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, what is to prevent the Minister from giving a reduction of 35 per cent. and still adding the half-year on?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Sinn Féin

That is not a point of personal explanation. The Deputy can speak afterward on the matter.

Comment on this

Let us drop this nonsense. I hope the time has come when we can discuss land purchase, like any other problem, without going back to the old days of the seventies and the eighties and the nineties. The proposition that was put up was to give a 35 per cent. reduction. Now, I am pointing out that as far as the particular tenants who owe three years' arrears are concerned my proposal is better, and I want to hear any answer to that, and that will give the Dáil a measure of the sincerity of all this thunder. That is number one. Based on my proposition it is £187 and on Deputy Gorey's it is £195 for third year tenants.

Comment on this

But where is he going to get it to pay?

Comment on this

Further, it is open to the Land Commission to give time to a tenant in any case. They have an absolutely free hand. If a tenant for any reason is unable to pay they can give him such time as they like. Take those two circumstances together and tell me whether my proposal for the tenant who owes three years is better than Deputy Gorey's in regard to this amendment. That is the man who owes three years. Now, there is, no doubt, a hardship, an unusual hardship, in regard to the tenant who owes two years' arrears. The Dáil should, I think, approach this in some responsible way. If a landlord is not entitled to rent for these three years, say so. It is open to the Dáil to decide that the landlords should not have got rent.

Comment on this

I would give them nothing.

Comment on this

There is one Deputy who is quite honest about that. There are other Deputies who think that no one should get rent except in a few cases where there are landlords who are extremely anxious to have arrangements made in this Bill by which the people of their own class who happen to be landlords in the old sense of the word, should be purchased and their rents should be redeemed, and the State credit should be used for that purpose.

The thing is a joke. In any event, to come back to the point, let the Dáil decide decently that the landlord should not get rent, and that he is not entitled to it, and that he should not have got it for the last three, five, ten or fifteen years, and go and take his land off him. But do not, in any casual, irresponsible, haphazard fashion, decide that the landlord is entitled to a certain amount of rent, looking at it from the point of view of the tenant solely, and say it does not matter twopence about the landlords; "we will put down this figure." If the landlord should have got any rent he has certain rights in the matter. If he should have got one penny rent he has certain rights, and these rights should be respected. That is not politics, I know, but I find myself saying a lot of things for the last three weeks which are not good politics, and it does not give me much trouble. If the landlord has any right to the land at all this right should be respected, and the question should be decided after examining the whole proposition in a business way, and taking the circumstances on one side and the other into account. In the case of the tenant who owes two years' arrears, it is not as easy for him, as I have pointed out, to pay this two years' rent down as if he paid his rent every year, but we all have to suffer a certain amount of hardship, more or less. Also, the tenants who owe 2½ years' annuity have to suffer a certain amount of hardship. I am just wondering how many tenants withheld their rents for the same reason as the tenant purchasers withheld their annuities. The real objection against the arrears question is not from the small tenant, but from the big tenant. Everyone knows that it was the farmer of 60 or 70 acres who did not pay his rent. He knew the value of money and was doing well.

Comment on this

Politics.

Comment on this

I would advise the Deputy not to draw me on that question.

Comment on this

I am trying to draw you.

Comment on this

Take the farmer whose rent is £20 a year, and that is much above the average of the farms we are dealing with. It is a nice farm, a good, economic holding. The valuation of a £20 holding would be anything between £25 and £30. He has to pay two years' rent, and he gets 25 per cent. reduction, that is a reduction of 5/- in the £ or £5. He pays £15 down, and he has paid nothing for two years. I put it to the Dáil— was there ever such a farce as to pretend that the farmer with a holding of £20 valuation is going to be broken because he makes a payment of £15, and in view of the fact that he made no payment for two years? Is there any reason why there should be all this heat about it, in view of the number of big problems we receive here with a certain amount of quietness and equanimity. It is a farce. To put £15 on the man who has a £30 valuation holding, and who has not paid any rent for years is not a hardship, and no one knows that better than Deputy Gorey. He has another year, or a year and a half, to pay the other £15, and I suggest it would be no trouble to such a tenant to pay £20 down, and he will only have to pay £10 then. These are the reasons, you see, why this is not such a hardship as is pretended in regard to people who owe two years' rent. It is nothing like the hardship that is predicted for the small farmer, and certainly not like what it is for the big farmer, for the bigger the farm the bigger the hardship, but to the big farmer also the hardship is not anything like what is pretended. I have dealt with the case of men who owe three years' rent and I have shown as far as their case goes that my proposal is better than Deputy Gorey's, so far as paying the money down is concerned. That is the hardship to the tenant. I have only one other thing to add with regard to this; we all remember people six months ago who owed 2½ years' annuity, and they were under the impression they need never pay anything again. They took the first opportunity of withholding their annuities, but they did so knowing perfectly well they were making it impossible for us to complete land purchase. But when the Enforcement of Law Act was passed it was not necessary to send the Sheriff to two per cent. of them. There was hardly a case in each county. They all paid it right away, and none of them, so far as I know, got into the Bankruptcy Court. The Farmers' Party, of course, have made a tremendous case of the terrific hardship which existing tenants are suffering as compared with tenants who have purchased. They point out that the purchased tenants were better able to pay. Let us take our old friend with the £20 valuation holding again. I do not know whether the Farmers' Party are interested in that, but let us take the man with the £20 valuation holding. That man was paying £20, and his rent was reduced by £5 a year from 1914 to 1920. This was the year of the strike. His neighbour who did not purchase was paying £20, and he had the same sort of holding, a difference of £5 a year during the war. This difference of £5 a year during the war, to a man who would spend it on pitch and toss at the cross-roads, was supposed to be the terrific hardship they suffered. I want the Dáil to approach this question in a business-like way. These are the figures. Tall talk is easy, but these figures give you the measure of the reality there is in this campaign about the arrears of rent. That is one side. Before I leave that I have this to point out; the Dáil will agree with me that the Land Bill is a contentious Bill, a measure that interests the country pretty largely. I have not seen a Press campaign against the arrears, not even in the local Press.

Comment on this

Who controls the Press?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

The landlords!

Comment on this

I do not know either.

Comment on this

The landlords, someone said. That may be the reason, I do not know as much about the Press as Deputy Gorey, but that may be the reason of it. I have got the local papers, everyone of them, and the Deputy knows as well as I know—he has been more around the country—that there is not an honest tenant in Ireland who would not jump at these terms. The only letters I have seen are in regard to this question of arrears. There are, I understand, two Unpurchased Tenants' Organisations. You will find a letter one day in the paper abusing the Land Bill, and abusing the Farmers' Party for not getting better terms for the farmer, and if you think a little you will know where that comes from—from a gentleman, I will not mention his name, who is running the League of Unpurchased Tenants. A few days afterwards you will find another letter coming from the opposite source, pointing out that the arrears terms and the price terms were not as good as if the Farmers' Party were in power, but that at the same time they had done their best to make it better. I am serious about this. These are the only classes of letters I have seen.

Everyone in the Dáil knows the Land Bill is contentious, that all the small tenants of Ireland are interested in it, that all the local papers are interested in it, and if there was to be this tremendous campaign about arrears or prices, then we would have the papers filled with letters. We have had none; we have had no protests. It was admitted by the Deputy, in a moment when he was off his guard, that the price was right.

Comment on this

I did not say the price was right. They accept it because they cannot get anything better.

Comment on this

It is admitted generally that the price is more than fair. What is the price? It is an accepted fact—I do not think even Deputy Lyons will deny it—amongst the tenants themselves that the price is absolutely fair.

Comment on this

Provided you wipe out the three years' arrears.

Comment on this

The tenants' reduction is 35 per cent., bringing the amount to £65. There is a ten per cent. contribution to the price, and that brings the landlords' income to £67 14s. 0d., just exactly two-thirds of his former income on his second-term judicial rent. Of course any man who has any sense of responsibility would not think of bringing it lower than that by reason of the fact that the Trustee Acts empower Trustees who hold money and who have to invest it, to invest it in Irish rents up to two-thirds of the amount. That is the amount the Trustee Acts set out, which is considered to be absolutely safe. We have gone to the very border line. I need not argue the case, because the tenants admit that it is fair. I am tired pointing out that the landlord will get his purchase money in bonds. Say, for instance, he gets £10,000; he will get interest on that at four and a half per cent. That will be 67 per cent. of his previous income, roughly two-thirds.

Comment on this

Net.

Comment on this

Roughly, two-thirds, net.

Comment on this

That would be more than two-thirds of his net income.

Comment on this

It would be. There is the point again. The reason the Trustee Acts and other Acts prevent a Trustee from investing money without being covered up to the full value of his security, is that they make allowance for things of that sort—for cost of collection in the case of rents, and allowances for any possible expenses and anything they cannot forsee in the way of cutting down the rents either by purchase or otherwise. Take it that the purchase money is £10,000; the landlord gets four and a half per cent. on that. His income, therefore, is 67 per cent. of his previous income. That is the price. In the event of £5,000 worth of that, representing the redemption price of the mortgage, on that £5,000 he receives four and a half per cent. and he pays, probably, five or six per cent. or more. As I explained before, he gets over that difficulty the minute he gets his purchase money by paying off the mortgage. Until he gets his purchase money he must pay his five or six per cent., and if he only got 67 per cent. of his rents he would be only able to pay four and a half per cent. on his mortgages. I think that is perfectly clear. Hence, if the price is fair, we must give him some more. If the price was calculated at £65 in the £100, a reduction of 35 per cent., and if the payment in lieu of rent and arrears were the same, the Bill would be, on the face of it, unfair and unjust. If the price is right, we must give better terms to the landlord in regard to arrears, because until he gets his purchase money, he is paying a higher rate than 4½ per cent. on his mortgages. How much higher are we giving him? We are giving the tenants a reduction of 25 per cent. We are collecting the rents and stopping the cost of collection, which takes five per cent. or thereabouts on an average from the landlord. We are bringing him down to £30, so that the only margin left to him is the difference between £30 and £33. That is the business side of the proposition and I invite the Dáil's attention to it. I invite the Deputies, in the first place, to examine the real size of the problem from the tenants' point of view, and see what difference there would be between my terms and the terms the Farmers' Party suggests. If they do, I think they will find there is nothing in them which would put them into the Bankruptcy Court. I invite them to look at the other side and if they do I think they will find we could not have left a smaller margin, in justice, to enable the landlord to pay the extra interest. Under no circumstances can I accept the amendment, and I will not accept it.

Comment on this

The Minister talked a good deal about figures and he talked a good deal about the benefits he was going to confer on the men with three years' arrears of rent. He did not talk about the benefits being conferred on the men who owed two and a half or two years' arrears. I will take a very fair rental, much more than an average rental, in order to make it more simple.

Comment on this

I thought so.

Comment on this

Take a £50 rental, for instance. If the tenant owes three years' arrears the amount is £150. The Minister proposes that he pays only £125, and that he adds £25 to the purchase money. If he got a reduction of the added ten per cent. on £150, it would be £15. It would mean the difference between £25 and £10 in actual payment at the moment. The Minister, however, refrained from indicating what that would mean to the tenant at the end of the period.

Comment on this

It is 4½ per cent—a little more than £1 per year.

Comment on this

It would work out at £85 6s. 10½d.

Comment on this

Compound interest.

Comment on this

No, plain interest. Perhaps the Minister would be able to contradict these simple figures.

Comment on this

There is no necessity.

Comment on this

The Minister refrained from saying what he was adding to the annuity, or what his payment on 68½ years meant. He was not honest with us in dealing with the matter. He was talking politics. He was trying to throw dust in the eyes of the average men outside by talking of the benefit he was conferring on him. He was talking politics— gross politics, his style of politics. I know there is no use appealing to the Minister on this measure. I know the Minister's view. I know his view of his own Bill. I know what he calls it. Confiscation is what he calls it. The Minister says this Bill of his own is confiscation, and he says he has been forced to it by the action of the unpurchased tenants and their organisation.

Comment on this

Politics!

Comment on this