THE DAIL RESUMES. - THE DAIL IN COMMITTEE.
Contributions 146–290 of 290. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
The Minister has called for politics, and he has got politics. He began in politics and he will end in politics. I do not know whether it is a private matter between the Leas-Cheann Comhairle and myself and my Party; it is a question of a conversation——
Comment on this
I think we had better clear that matter up. The Minister for Agriculture gave me no assurance whatsoever that he would go further in the way of reduction of arrears than what was suggested in the amendment proposed by Deputy Seumas de Burca. I discussed this matter with him, and he said that was the limit that he could go. I do not think that I gave Deputy Gorey or any other member of his party to understand anything else.
Comment on this
The whole matter is this: Deputy O'Máille assured me and the members of our party that the Minister would meet us in those amendments if they were reasonable.
Comment on this
He told us the Minister would go a long way to meet us. When the Committee Stage was over, I asked Deputy O'Máille why did not the Minister meet us, and he said the Minister could not rule his party—could not rule the Government—and that he was only speaking for himself.
Comment on this
You did not say that the Minister for Agriculture could not make arrangements for this matter—that he was not allowed to go the distance he wanted to go?
Comment on this
Very well. There is no use in carrying it very much further. The Minister for Agriculture and the Government may think it a very easy and quite a simple matter to recover these arrears, and they may think that the people who owe them are in splendid financial circumstances, and will be able to meet these bills——
Comment on this
The Minister refrained from mentioning the material part of the only figures we have had—the figures in connection with what the landlords owe. The Minister for Agriculture has always held that no money-lender lent, or should have lent, on an Irish rental more than two-thirds of that rental, that anybody who lent more than that was taking considerable risk. He has never given us any figures in connection with the landlords who had their property mortgaged. I have asked before how many of these landlords had their property mortgaged, how many landlords there are whose rent is in trust for the moneys they owe. We never got these figures. But because a few do happen to have mortgages, the whole body of landlords, who represent the richest element of the community, is going to be paid money that may cripple and bring misery and starvation to a big proportion of the 70,000 tenants. These may be the Minister's figures, but they are not my figures, and they do not fit in with my sense of justice. It is all very well to talk about recovering three years' rent and two and a half years' rent. The Minister can talk very glibly about it. The Minister has other means of living besides the land, and he has not to live on a £16 or £17 valuation. I am glad of that, but it is quite a different case with the men with these small valuations, and I will promise the Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Defence and all the rest of them a pretty stiff job in recovering these arrears——
Comment on this
You have a job to try to keep the Minister in order, and sometimes I have the same job with myself when I am sitting down. In all the previous Bills that we have had only two years' arrears were taken into consideration. In this Bill you propose to take in three years—a thing the people have not got. Because they have not, they will not give it to you. I hope they will not give it to you, and I hope you will have the trouble you are looking for.
Comment on this
And he has not attempted to meet my point that my suggestion was better for the tenants who owe three years' rent than what the Deputy is proposing.
Comment on this
Amendment put.
Do you agree with this result?
I beg to move: In Section 17 (2, page 7, line 19), after the words "cent." to insert the words:—"Provided that any payments made by the tenant after the second gale day in the year 1920; shall be appropriated to the rent which accrued since the first gale day in that year."
Comment on this
I am accepting this amendment. In the congested districts especially there are amongst smaller tenants a large number of hanging gales. That is to say that for years, even from the time of the tenant's father, the rent is paid half-yearly, but appropriated two or three years back. You may have a man paying three years' rent during 1920, 1921 and 1922, and yet he owes three years by reason of the fact that the payments during these years were appropriated to a period before 1920. That state of affairs exists in the Congested Districts especially and amongst small tenants, and it is to meet that, that this amendment is accepted.
Comment on this
I beg to move: To delete Section 17 (3), page 7, and to substitute the following:—
"Compounded arrears of rent shall be discharged as to so much thereof as does not exceed 75 per cent. of the annual rent, by the addition of same to the Purchase Price, and as to the balance, if any, by payment on such date or dates before the appointed day as may be prescribed by the Land Commission."
This is an amendment which seeks to give justice all round. It is not a big demand, but an attempt to go some way, at least, to specify the time of the people who have paid rent and who owe rent. It means the adding of one year, or if a lesser amount is owed, the adding of it to the purchase price. It was not an extraordinary thing at all under the previous Acts that a certain amount was added in voluntary purchase agreements, to the purchase money by agreement. This Bill only provides in a later clause for the adding of one half year, and in its first draft it did not provide for the addition of any at all. For the last twelve months a good many landlords have accepted voluntary reductions of 50 per cent., 45 per cent. and 40 per cent., and if it was a question of a voluntary agreement again between landlord and tenant there would not be any hesitation on the landlord's part in adding that year's purchase price. I think it would be done voluntarily. Therefore I ask the Minister to make this small concession.
Comment on this
I will not accept the amendment, and I will not comment on the statement that landlords have accepted voluntary payments of 50 per cent. during the last year. There is an amendment already down in the Bill providing that half a year be added to the purchase money, and, secondly, that any rent payable within the period 1920 and 1923 shall be appropriated to that period, even though the receipt on its face sets out that the rent was to be paid for the previous year. That does not interest Deputy Gorey, because this concession will not affect large farmers; it will only make a difference to the small tenants in the congested counties. All over the congested districts in counties like that of Mayo and elsewhere the small tenants owe for a long time. There are hundreds of cases where the small tenant pays his rent half-yearly, but gets his receipt dated back for two or three years. This relieves him straight away, and provides that any payments made shall be appropriated. That is as far as I will go. That meets the equities of the case. The Deputy himself stated that previous Bills added two years only. We are adding a half-year. We are making this concession. There is no question about it, the non-payment of rent during the last three years was due not primarily to the tenants not being able to pay, but as a protest against non-purchase. That is the distinction between the question of arrears we have now and the arrears owed in 1881 and subsequently.
Comment on this
Amendment put.
Do you agree with this result?
I beg to move Amendment 15: To add to Section 17, Sub-section (3), the following:—
"Provided that in any case where not less than three years' arrears are due and the tenant so requests in the prescribed manner, one half-year's compounded arrears of rent shall be added to the purchase money and repaid by means of a purchase annuity calculated at the rate of 4¾ per cent. on the amount thereof added to and consolidated with the standard purchase annuity for the holding."
I propose to resist the prevailing tendency or temptation to make an electioneering speech upon this point. I think the amendment is the best solution of this very vexed problem that has been offered so far.
Comment on this
We agree to this amendment, which is in accordance with the promise made by the Minister on the Committee Stage.
Comment on this
I beg to move Amendment 16, to add to Section 17 the following new sub-section:—
"Where any money has been levied or recovered by a landlord after the 28th day of May, 1923, under or in consequence of any judgment or decree in any proceedings against the tenant of a holding to which this Act applies for the recovery of rent or in ejectment, then:—
(a) If such money shall have been levied or recovered prior to the 3rd day of July, 1923, and so much thereof as consisted of rent exceeds the sum to which compounded arrears of rent would have otherwise amounted, or
(b) if such money shall have been so levied or recovered on or after the 3rd day of July, 1923, and the entire amount thereof (including rent, costs and expenses) exceeds the sum to which compounded arrears of rent would have otherwise amounted,
the difference between such levy or such entire amount (including rent, costs and expenses) as the case may be and the sum to which compounded arrears of rent would have otherwise amounted shall be set off against the moneys to become payable by the tenant in lieu of rent as hereinafter provided, and the equivalent payment by the Land Commission shall be proportionately reduced."
I do not need to say much in favour of this amendment, except that I want to make an amendment in the amendment. The word "levy" in the last paragraph is a misprint for the word "rent."
Comment on this
Yes, the word "rent" was in the original amendment, and I would suggest that we have the leave of the Dáil in making this amendment.
Comment on this
I accept the amendment with the change. We discussed the whole question on the Committee Stage, and it was more or less agreed that an amendment upon these lines should be introduced. It was Deputy McGoldrick who spoke upon this particular section, and suggested this amendment. I have only one thing more to say. The Dáil will remember we debated this before for three hours, and that Deputy Gorey said on that occasion that I had promised him that any law costs and expenses levied by the landlord would be set off against arrears of rent due under the Bill, and payments due, under the Bill.
Comment on this
I said nothing of the sort. I said that any rents that would be recovered since the introduction of the Bill would be made good, and that the Minister promised that, but I did not say that the Minister promised me to recover on the question of costs. I said that was the impression I took away from the Minister's attitude, but I never said that I got a definite word from the Minister that he would accept or reject the suggestion.
Comment on this
I ask the indulgence of the Dáil to point out that I have already been accused of being inaccurate, and I now wish to give a line as to the value of these accusations. The Dáil will remember that, on the Committee Stage of the Bill, I got up and accepted the proposition that rent recovered should be set off against rent due either in respect of arrears or in respect of payments in lieu of rent under the Bill, and I put that to Deputy Gorey as a sporting offer. He answered by charging me with having promised him both rent and costs.
Comment on this
Will you please let me finish? In answer to his charge I agreed on that occasion to set off costs as from the 3rd July. He refused to set them off except as from the 28th May. That is within the recollection of every Deputy in the Dáil, and I would like to know what is the recollection of the other members of the Farmers' Party sitting there.
Comment on this
I am not talking of that now, but what I am doing is just pointing out to the Dáil that on the last occasion this matter was debated the Deputy charged me with having promised him that I would include costs as well as rent. The Dáil will now notice that that charge is no longer made.
Comment on this
I did not make that charge. On a point of personal explanation, I desire to say that I do not think the Minister for Agriculture has any right to misrepresent what I said.
Comment on this
I do not think it is desirable that we should go back on what happened when another stage of the Bill was under discussion.
Comment on this
I would like to know, then, what the Deputy did charge me with. I am simply making a statement of what occurred.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, what the Minister said was that he definitely refused this question of costs. He never gave me a definite refusal, but at the same time he never gave me a definite promise, and in the remarks I made at the time I made that quite clear and distinct. He never gave me a refusal and never gave me a promise. The only thing he said was that it would not be quite fair to prevent a man taking advantage of the law because he had the law to avail of.
Comment on this
I would ask Deputies to look up what Deputy Gorey said; he practically called me a liar. I would ask Deputies to look up what he said on that occasion and to take that as a measure of the accuracy of the statements he makes.
Comment on this
I beg to move Amendment 17: In Section 18(1), page 7, line 41, to delete the figures "75" and to substitute therefor the figures "65," and to make the necessary consequential amendments throughout the Bill.
Comment on this
The same ruling will apply on this amendment as on the last, that is, as regards making the necessary consequential amendments throughout the Bill.
Comment on this
This amendment refers to payments in lieu of rent. I suppose the Section is copied from previous Acts, but I am sorry the Minister has not copied more closely some previous precedents with regard to the terms. The previous Acts made a difference of one-quarter per cent. more in payment in lieu of rent than they did in the case of actual annuities to be paid. That operated under the Wyndham and Birrell Acts. Where there was money to be paid in lieu of rent until such time as the vesting order came along one-quarter per cent. more was charged for the money than on an actual annuity under the Wyndham Act. The same also applied to the Birrell Act. There is a bigger distinction made under this Bill, and I would ask the Minister to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I am not accepting this amendment. Deputy Gorey knows this is not interest in lieu of rent. There is no interest-in-lieu-of-rent period under this Bill, because from the date on which an agreement to purchase is entered into the tenant is deemed to be paying for the redemption of his holding. I want to draw the attention of the Dáil to this, that Deputy Gorey apparently adopts the 1903 Act where it suits him but that he does not adopt it where it does not suit him. Under the 1903 Act on a £100 holding, the landlord gets £2,200, and under this the sum he gets is £1,500. If the Deputy would be at least logical and suggest that we should still give the landlord £2,200 and should make this difference, that we should have an interest in lieu of rent period, and only make a difference of a quarter per cent., I agree.
Comment on this
It would not matter what capital sum you gave as long as you have interest to balance it.
Comment on this
We will pay for it. Make it seven per cent. and capitalise it accordingly. I throw you that as a challenge.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
In Section 20 (3), page 8, line 58, after the word "rent" to insert the words "and save that any question as to whether an agreement for an abated rent was in fact an agreement for a new rent or any question as to the amount from which the deduction of 25 per cent. is to be made in ascertaining compounded arrears of rent and payment in lieu of rent shall be determined by the Judicial Commissioner, whose decision shall be final."
This amendment has already been discussed, and I need not waste any further time in discussing it. I put down the amendment because I understand there are many cases in which agreements have been arrived at between the landlord and tenant and abatements have been offered to the tenant in his rent. They were not exceptional abatements. They were granted by the landlord, as he saw there were sound reasons for doing so. I want such tenants to get the full benefits of the present Bill when it becomes law, irrespective of the period. It may be forty years or two years ago when the tenants got those abatements. I think this amendment would cover all such cases.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
In Section 22 (2), page 9, to insert a new paragraph after paragraph (c):—
"Any parcel of untenanted land which consists of or forms part of land which was purchased under the provisions of the Irish Church Act, 1869, for a sum not exceeding two thousand pounds."
The effect of the amendment is to exclude from the operation of Section 22 any such lands.
Comment on this
I think there will be no discussion about this amendment, which I am accepting. This was an oversight in the Bill. The amendment deals with purchasers under the Irish Church Act of 1869. A certain number of tenants of one kind or another purchased under that Act, and they get the benefits of ordinary farmers, which they are.
Comment on this
I ask leave to withdraw the following amendment, which stands in my name:—
In page 9, line 42, Section 22 (2) (d), to add after the word “ground” the words “Provided always that, till the Oireachtas otherwise provides, the status duties privileges disabilities and rights at the option of a tenant of a holding coming under this sub-section shall notwithstanding anything in the contract of tenancy be that of a judicial tenant in and of the holding for a third term with this modification that if any portion or the whole holding be hereinafter required for public purposes or by the local sanitary authority for building or otherwise the price to be paid to landlord and tenant respectively shall be the value of their respective interests in the land as agricultural or farming land.”
Comment on this
I object. I was hopeful that this was one of the amendments that the Minister would be prompted to accept. Am I mistaken?
Comment on this
Oh, yes. It is not really a question of prompting. These amendments which we have down now were envisaged on the Committee Stage and suggested by Deputies of my own Party. This amendment would defeat the Deputy's own purpose. It is making judicial tenants, and our aim is to buy out these tenancies. The effect of the amendment is to make certain tenants judicial tenants. Our aim is to buy them out, whether they be future or not.
Comment on this
My interest in this amendment—I must admit I have not given it careful consideration—is that it might ensure that local authorities would be able to acquire land for building purposes.
Comment on this
I propose it, then. It is the latter part of the amendment that I am concerned with. I was hopeful that it was one of the amendments which the Minister is prepared to accept, and that it was in fulfilment of one of the promises that he might have made. Apparently Deputy McGoldrick has not the assent of the Minister in formulating this amendment. Nevertheless, I think he was well advised in the latter part of it, and I would like some assurance that within the Bill it may be possible for public authorities to obtain portion of a holding, where it is required for public purposes—for building or otherwise—at a price in conformity with the price fixed by the Bill itself. Perhaps Deputy McGoldrick would explain more fully the purpose of the amendment as originally intended, and that then the Minister would explain why it would not be accepted.
Comment on this
I put this amendment on the Paper on account of my knowledge of conditions in a great many cases around large and small towns with regard to lands like these. I was under the impression that the word "holding" in Sub-section (d) meant that if there was a small holding convenient to a town, or even if there was a holding a considerable distance from a town which might abut upon a road which ran from or to the town, and which could be alleged to have potential building possibilities, that holding thereby became a holding that could not be vested in the occupier by the Land Commission on account of Sub-section (d). I came to the conclusion that some town tenants and a good many other small people in towns who occupied or had a little bit of land convenient to the town by which they supplement their scanty earnings and bring up their family and help themselves in that way, were going to be placed at a disadvantage by this Sub-section. I knew that for the last thirty-five or forty years those people have been the backbone of the land war. It was they who fought, or enabled us, in the North at any rate, to keep up an official organisation of any kind to fight the battle of the farming classes. On that account I did not want to see them ostracised by any section of the Bill and prevented from becoming the vested owners of their little bits of land. That was the specific reason for which the amendment was put down. But the Minister has given me to understand, after a critical consultation, that what is set out in Sub-section (d) does not mean that that portion of a holding which is not regarded as eligible for building purposes is going thereby to be ruled out of court, but that it is going to be purchased and vested the same as if it had not any building possibilities. The other proviso as to land becoming useful and necessary for the development of towns and for local sanitary purposes was meant to be fair to all parties. It should be really the agricultural value of the land to the landlord and the tenant that should be taken into account when local authorities want to obtain land for the development of a town or to improve the sanitary condition of the town. The reason I put down this amendment was to serve these two objects. I am led to believe by the Minister in charge, and I assume that the Land Commission will interpret these things in a fairly friendly spirit, although when the trained judicial mind comes to interpret these things it is generally guided by the literal legislation. Such officials interpret Acts of Parliament very strictly, and if this came before a very conscientious official there is a liability to have the legislation interpreted in a way that was not the intention when it was passed. We must trust to the assurance that is being given. With regard to the second part of the amendment, perhaps we might hope that the new Land Commission, in dealing with such matters, will do so in a spirit that will give satisfaction that was not given in the past.
Comment on this
Deputy Johnson wants to provide that a local authority which already has power to take land compulsorily shall take it at a certain price. That is the only effect of the amendment from his point of view. I find it difficult myself to understand the amendment, but I think that is the point of view that the Deputy put forward. The Bill already provides that building ground shall be excluded, or land suitable for building. That is only right, as any other course would be a grave hindrance to the development of towns. It is only right, and I think will be admitted that land suitable for building should be excluded, that no tenant should be made owner of it, and especially a future tenant, who is, in 75 per cent. out of 100 cases, a big shopkeeper in the town who has taken the land any time for the last 20 years up to the last three or four years and who is merely a future tenant should not become owner in fee-simple. It would be grossly unfair if he did. The only purpose served by this amendment is to ensure that if the local sanitary authority want this land afterwards they shall pay for it the value of the land as agricultural or farming land. I do not want to express any opinion whatever on that subject. This is a Land Purchase Act. It professes to deal with agricultural land, and I think it will be generally admitted that the definition of agricultural land and agricultural tenancy is pretty wide. We deal with all agricultural land except certain specified exceptions which we have put down in writing. We have left nothing in general or vague terms. We deal with all genuine tenants, whether present or future, judicial or nonjudicial. This Bill is to deal with agricultural land. It is to take land from one party and give it to another. Where land is not agricultural it is excluded. If it is building ground, or ground suitable for any other purpose, appropriate legislation directed to dealing with that particular problem will have to be invoked. I could not undertake in this Bill, which is intended to deal with the price of land as agricultural land and to exclude land used for other purposes, to lay down a price at which such land shall be taken later on in the event of its being taken under existing legislation, or in the event of an Act being passed to take it for some other purpose. It would not be a sound principle to act upon. I think we have done our duty in this Purchase Bill by excluding such land. We will have to leave it to the laws regulating the acquisition of property compulsorily by a local authority to say what will be the price paid for it. Where land is taken for building purposes the local authorities do not take, I should say, 25 per cent. It is the private owner who does it. This not only safeguards the local authority, but safeguards the private owner who is going to build, which is a matter of policy and good for the State and good for the towns. I see no way out of that position.
Comment on this
I agree with a good deal that has been stated by the Minister, and I realise that what I am mainly interested in in this amendment is not quite fitting in this Bill. I would like it to have been possible to embody it, but it is not being so embodied. I thought perhaps there was an opportunity of doing so in Deputy McGoldrick's amendment, but in view of the statement made by the Minister I beg leave of the Dáil to withdraw Deputy McGoldrick's amendment.
Comment on this
I have only one thing to say, that before long I will probably have a Bill before the Dáil for the purpose of taking land for building near towns. It will apply not only to landowners, but probably to some of the land of large farmers, and in view of the statements that have been made here we will probably be able to get the land at a very cheap price.
Comment on this
I move Amendment 21: "In Section 22 (4), to delete the word ‘landlord's' and insert in lieu thereof the word ‘owner's.'" The effect of the amendment is that the condition shall apply whether the owner of the particular type of land referred to is the landlord or is not.
Comment on this
I am accepting this amendment. It should be "owner," because it might be an owner who, technically, would not be the landlord.
Comment on this
I move: "In page 9 to add a new paragraph after Section 2 (2) (e), as follows:—
"‘Any glebe, as defined by the Act of 38th and 39th Victoria, Chapter 42, which now is, or hereafter shall be, held or occupied by any "ecclesiastical persons" as by the same Act defined.'"
I think that this particular class of land was probably omitted from the exceptions through an oversight. The reason of it is this. Under the Church Act, when the Church was disestablished, the Representative Church Body was allowed to purchase back from the State a limited quantity of land to be attached to the residence of the person who was called an "Ecclesiastical person." He could be a person or a curate or a dean or a bishop, but a strictly limited amount of land was permitted to be purchased from the State as an attachment to these ecclesiastical residences. Cash was paid to the State for it, and that land is occupied now by persons who hold it under leases, and therefore it is plainly tenanted land under the Act. But the present tenants would be put into perpetual occupation of their holdings and would be compelled to purchase under this Act—these particular ecclesiastical persons who happen to hold this land on lease, from their own ecclesiastical superiors. It is extremely improbable that any of them desire to purchase, and it would be very hard, if any of them desired to give up their present callings and take up farming, that they should be allowed to take up these holdings, subtracting them from the Representative Church Body, which holds them more or less in trust for the whole Church, and to take away whatever ecclesiastical residence there was on the holding. I think that this matter was plainly omitted there and is an oversight, and I suggest that this should be accepted.
Comment on this
I have no objection to the amendment at all, but I would like an explanation of one particular portion of it, which we may have an objection to: "Any glebe which now is or hereafter shall be held." I can follow it up to "which now," but what does "or hereafter shall be" mean?
Comment on this
It will be let as tenanted land to other people. Supposing that the particular person who happened to occupy some glebe land were to die or to resign to-morrow, that land would again be let to his successor, and would then again become tenanted land. There is also some of it which may be untenanted land at present owing to a vacancy, and which will be let, as soon as the vacancy is filled, to the future occupants, and therefore, you see, it is pretty clear that the words "hereafter may be" are necessary. They are also taken from the exceptions in the previous Land Acts, and they cannot apply to any land except glebe land, defined by the Act, 38th and 39th Victoria. That glebe land was defined as the land that was bought by the Church Body from the State at the date of Disestablishment.
Comment on this
I accept this amendment. I think it is obvious to the Dáil that these clergymen do not wish to purchase and become farmers. There is no question about it that the amendment should be accepted.
Comment on this
I think it is on this section that I would like to ask for some assurances. It has been put to me that the question of mill holdings is not quite clear, and I am asked to find out—I think it is a reasonable proposition— whether under the Bill the occupiers of mill holdings will have the right to purchase in such cases where they have erected buildings and put in machinery themselves. I think some question on this was raised on the last Reading.
Comment on this
It is absolutely clear that mill holdings are purchased. Clause (b) excepts “any land which is not at the date of the passing of this Act substantially agricultural or pastoral or partly agricultural and partly pastoral in character.” The usual mill holding is generally bigger than the average-size holding. It was let originally as a mill holding, and at the time it was let milling was a profitable business, and a very large percentage of the profits made out of the whole letting came from the mill, and it was decided that it was not agricultural land. At present milling is not such a good business. Mills are, without any question whatever, agricultural, but they were ruled out by reason of a previous decision, and in order to meet it we simply put in “any land which is not at the date of the passing of the Act.” I think I am perfectly safe in giving the Deputy an undertaking that that will cover the case. Of course, it would not cover a mill which was in a backyard in a town. We assume it is a mill holding in the country.
Comment on this
The case in point is a mill holding which is not more than 1 acre and 12 perches. All the buildings were erected by the present tenants who are the owners of the mill, but although they have been in occupation for 100 years, they are still holding as yearly tenants. They are very anxious to extend a certain local industry, but because of the inability to get any permanence they are precluded. That is one case. I am told it illustrates a considerable number, and the assurance is desired that such holdings may be bought under this Bill, even though they are quite small.
Comment on this
Well, of course, I would not like to give the Deputy a decision offhand, without knowing all the circumstances.
Comment on this
But I do know we have ensured that any holding which is even partly agricultural and partly pastoral shall be purchased. We cannot do any more than that, but I think it will cover all the cases of mill holdings that I know.
Comment on this
I think I raised this question of these holdings when the Bill was previously in Committee, and the case I have in mind is not situated near a town. It is probably analogous to the case that Deputy Johnson mentions. If I may, I wish to make a little protest against the Press. It may be due to the bad acoustie properties of this building, but they gave me as saying "milk holdings" instead of "mill holdings." Whatever the Press meant by that I do not know.
Motion made and question put: "That Section 22, as amended, stand part of the Bill."
SECTIONS 26 & 27.
Comment on this
I move: "In Section 26 (2) after the word ‘holding' to insert the words ‘and the additional annuity (if any) in respect of compounded arrears of rent added to the purchase money.'" That amendment is consequential on the amendment that has already been accepted, and is intended to cover cases in which the tenant, instead of paying his arrears in cash, has them added to the purchase money.
Comment on this
I move: "In Section 27 (4), line 23, after the word ‘holding' to insert the words ‘and the additional annuity (if any) in respect of compounded arrears of rent added to the purchase money.'" That is identical with Amendment 33.
Comment on this
"To insert after Section 29 (1) (g), line 29, a new paragraph as follows:—
‘Where the farm of an evicted tenant is in the landlord's possession such evicted tenant should be restored to his own holding, and also where bona fide evicted tenants’ land is in the possession of grabbers who never paid compensation for such holdings, the evicted tenants should be restored to these holdings.' ”
Comment on this
I got this amendment from Deputy Doyle at the last moment. It could not be moved, of course, in the form in which it stands. It would have to be changed if it were to have any force. The word "grabbers," I think, would have to be changed to "persons." I do not know whether the matter is not in itself too vague for any reference in an Act of Parliament, but I will let Deputy Doyle explain himself.
Comment on this
My object in moving this is where a farm is in the landlord's possession unlet, that the bona fide evicted tenant should, in every case, be restored to his own holding. I think the object is quite plain, that where a landlord has evicted a tenant some years ago for non-payment of rent and he still holds that tenant's holding on his own hands, and it is there to be disposed of under the several provisions in the Bill, I do not see any reason why the original owner should not be restored. I know many cases such as I am talking about, where the original holding is in the hands of the landlord, and where if a provision was inserted in the Bill to get back that holding, it would be only a slight concession in the Bill in favour of evicted tenants. The bona fide evicted tenant's holding is in the possession of persons who never paid any compensation to that original evicted tenant or paid anything for the holding. Perhaps it might be five, six or ten years in his possession, and it is still in his possession, and he has had a few fat years out of it. I do not think it would be any hardship to disturb such a man. It was persons such as these grabbing farms who created the land-war, and I do not think they are entitled to any consideration whatever under the Bill. I have, therefore, pleasure in moving the motion.
Comment on this
It will have to be considerably altered before it could be possibly moved, even to get that particular purpose Deputy Doyle speaks of
Comment on this
Provided the Minister accepts the amendment, Deputy Doyle is quite satisfied to have whatever phraseology the Minister suggests.
Comment on this
Except it would be inconsistent with the previous provisions of the Bill it could be accomplished.
Comment on this
Only to this extent; it suggests that the man should be put back in his original holding, but we may be taking that land for the relief of congestion. In the Bill land can be taken compulsorily for the relief of congestion, and there is priority for that purpose; we might be taking that land for the relief of congestion, taking it compulsorily, and it must be made clear whether it is the evicted tenants' claim or the congests' claim is the first to that land.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I do not think that any congest would have a claim to such land. I think the original tenant should be replaced.
Comment on this
I want to get the amendment worded so that if it passes it would accomplish something, and even if rejected it would be taken as trying to accomplish something.
Supposing we word it this way:—
"Where the farm of an evicted tenant is in the landlord's possession such evicted tenant shall be restored to his own holding, and also where bona fide evicted tenants' land is in the possession of persons who never paid compensation to the evicted tenant for such holdings, the evicted tenants shall be restored to these holdings.”
Comment on this
I desire to support this amendment, even though in my opinion it does not go far enough. I think, still, notwithstanding the arguments that were put forward against the case for evicted tenants, that those who were evicted from their lands for non-payment of rent when the land fight was on, have the best right to the land they were evicted from. In many of these cases, as is well known, where tenants were evicted from their holdings, the land from which they were evicted was held for centuries by their people. Now, if the opportunity is there for us to do it, the persons who are best entitled to any of that land are the persons who were evicted from it. They have, I submit, a prior claim, even to the congests, for in their own view, and the general view of the country and of the farming community, they are the persons who have the best title to the farm. In other words, they were the owners. I think that principle ought to be admitted that they have the first claim as they were the original owners of the ground, and they were disturbed owing to the laws that operated at that time, and owing to the rack-rents they had to pay, and to the general system of landlordism. If there is any justice in the case these are the persons who should be put back into their own holdings. Deputy Doyle's amendment only deals with a certain number of those cases where the land is still held by the landlord, but there are other cases, and the Minister has not accepted the principle of putting any of the evicted tenants back on them. This is only a small portion of the matter, but in these particular cases where there will be practically no disturbance he should accept the principle that the persons who were evicted from their farms owing to the landlords of the past and various other causes should be restored to their holdings. These cases could be inquired into by the Land Commission, and their claims met in justice.
Comment on this
I think there is everything in the amendment, especially with the altered wording, that should commend it to the Minister and the Deputies. When speaking the other day on the Flogging Bill, or the Public Safety Bill, the Minister for Home Affairs said he was making a law to meet confiscation with confiscation. I think everybody will agree that the cases of many of the tenants who have been evicted from their holdings were nothing short of confiscation, so that the argument used by the Minister for Home Affairs on that occasion could be applied by the Minister for Agriculture in these cases. I have received communications from evicted tenants, and I will trouble the Dáil by reading an extract from one which I think is provided for under the terms of the amendment, if accepted by the Minister. This is from a man who I believe is a member of Deputy Gorey's union, and in whom in the ordinary course of events I would not be interested, as I do not know the man personally:—
"Our families were evicted (but prior to '80). I remember the eviction myself, from over 200 acres. Firstly, the rent was raised as the then landlord thought my father would not pay the rise, and when he paid the rise of rent at November he was then ordered to leave as the landlord wanted it for himself, and on the 15th of the following month, December, he was on the road without owing even one penny rent, and no compensation whatever, and about the same time my father's father, and brothers, were evicted from another farm after building every house on the place from the ground, roofing and slating; they are there to be seen still within about 12 miles from—— not owing one penny rent, nor never got any compensation."
I think the Minister, even in his wild moments, would admit that is a reasonable case that should be provided for under the terms of this Bill. I just quoted an extract from a letter to show that it is one of the cases that should be met under the terms of the amendment moved by Deputy Doyle. There may be, and I am sure there are, many other such cases. The evicted tenants who have been looking forward to justice under the first Irish Land Bill, will be glad, I am sure, to hear from the Minister that he will make provision for cases of this kind.
Comment on this
As the Deputy has said, in my wild moments I might accept the amendment, but in my sane moments I would not think of doing that. There has been some change of words in the amendment, but as it stands we know the meaning of it. There were more evictions in the congested districts than in any other place in Ireland. We know there were far more. At the present moment, as everyone who takes a real interest in land purchase knows, our difficulty is to find land in the congested districts to relieve congestion. We find thousands of holdings on cut-away bog all over Mayo and Leitrim and every other county which has its congested districts, without any land in the neighbourhood to make them economic, except a certain limited amount of untenanted land. It would be very difficult to get the people to migrate. You can only pick and choose when you are migrating. You have no way in which to deal with the greater number, except to find land in the neighbourhood or the adjoining county. Will anyone suggest that a man living on a holding with a £3 or £4 valuation, who is trying to rear a family and to support his wife and that family, has not a prior claim in equity and justice to anyone else in the neighbourhood? I am surprised at Deputy Davin making such a suggestion.
Comment on this
I quoted an extract from a letter for the purpose of proving that the person who lost a holding has the first right. It is not a case of a person with 200 acres. There are many cases of people with very small holdings.
Comment on this
I understood the Deputy supported the amendment. I am pointing out that under the amendment as it stands the suggestion is that if there were no other land than 200 acres of land in the hands of a landlord, and a farmer had been evicted out of that 30 or 40 years ago, we are to bring back that person now instead of dealing with the congestion that exists in the district. How anyone in his saner moments, not to speak of his wilder moments, could make a proposal of that sort, beats me. That is one aspect of the matter. To take the other aspect, does the Deputy suggest that the man evicted from two or three hundred acres should be put back upon that holding now?
Comment on this
I do not know of any two or three hundred acre holding from which a person was evicted.
Comment on this
I know of none. I know of no places where persons were evicted from three, two or even one hundred acre holdings.
Comment on this
Deputies put down amendments having certain specified cases in their minds, and they are utterly oblivious to the fact that the amendments cover cases for which they were not intended. I know, and Deputy Davin knows, of cases of men evicted from two or three hundred acre holdings. Such cases occurred at Leix. It is suggested that those people are to be put back on their holdings, not withstanding that the whole policy of the Bill is to take any land, even tenanted land if we want it, for the purpose of relieving congestion. If these men were never evicted we might be taking the holdings off them under this Bill. These are the practical difficulties against this amendment. First we would be putting tenants back into the only untenanted land available for the relief of congestion; secondly we would be putting them back into holdings of two or three hundred acres. That is what would happen under the amendment. We never intended to, and we never could, right all the wrongs done under the aegis of English rule for the last 30 or 40 years. It could not be done and the Deputies know it. If farmers are entitled to have righted all the wrongs that they suffered, then the same would apply to other sections of the community. I admit there is a special case with regard to evicted tenants, and we will go a certain distance to meet it. We have provided that tenants evicted since 1878 should be dealt with, and where there is land available, an evicted tenant who does not come under those provisions will be considered as a suitable person. That is doing more for the farming class than is done for any other class, shopkeepers, labourers, or any others. Now it is suggested that because they or their fathers suffered under English rule, we are to right every such case at the expense of the State. That is the issue. Now as regards evicted tenants, I met a few deputations.
Those evicted tenants put forward the suggestion that was put forward to-day in this amendment, and the suggestion put forward by Deputy de Roiste. One was that any man who had left his holding for any reason whatever whether ejected by the landlord or sold out in any other way should be regarded as an evicted tenant. That is to say if a man were too dishonest to pay for his tea and sugar and was sold out by his creditors that that man was to get a holding at the expense of the State. He was to be regarded as a patriot, a wounded soldier of the Land War. Another suggestion was made. An amendment was produced, and it was to the effect that any evicted tenant whatsoever should be brought in. He deleted the words "twenty-five years, before the Act of 1903," and substituted "heretofore.""Heretofore" was to be inserted to provide that people could go back to the time of Brian Boru. In addition, if any evicted tenant or his representative preferred to take the money to getting the holding that he or they should be paid the money. This would have meant that the Bill would cost about one thousand millions, of which five hundred millions would go to New York and Chicago. I met recently a body of evicted tenants and they put forward these suggestions (1) that they are to go back as far as they liked; (2) that anyone who was ejected from his holding for any reason, should be regarded as an evicted tenant, whether he lost the land as a result of being evicted by the landlord, or that the farm was sold out by creditors or anybody else; (3) that they should get back into their full original holdings. The man who put forward the points I have just mentioned, when questioned by me, admitted to me that he was evicted out of his holding, that there was a certain sum due under a family settlement. He refused to pay this money, and as a result of his refusal his relations took action against him and on his refusal to pay he was finally sold out. The next case was the case of a man who told me that his grandfather had lost something like 300 acres and that he wanted that back. I asked him "did you apply under the 1903 Act"? and he said "I did—my father did." I asked him if he got a holding. He said he did. I asked him "where is it"? and he said "We sold it." The fact is that 50 per cent. of the reinstated tenants under the Act of 1903 have sold their holdings. Everyone knows it. We can do no more for the evicted tenants than we are doing, and we could not accept the amendment.
Comment on this
The Minister has told us of his experiences about evicted tenants. I am not asking one-eighth of that. I am only asking what comes under the twenty-five years. If the Minister is so fond of the congests I leave him the congests and ask him to apply the amendment to the outside districts. I leave him the congests as they are. I do not believe you will have a single application for any 300 acres or 200 acres, or even for 100 acres.
Comment on this
The Minister told us a lot that we did not want at all.
Comment on this
The Minister places an exaggrated interpretation on the points and misrepresents the case that I quoted. I read an extract from a letter where an individual was evicted from 200 acres of land, and I did not say what land it was, or in whose possession it is at the present time.
Comment on this
I did not accuse the Deputy of advocating a policy of giving anyone 200 acres at the expense of the State's credit, but I pointed out that that was the effect of the amendment.
Comment on this
The Deputy who moved the amendment had so much confidence in the Minister that he was prepared to leave the wording of the amendment to the Minister himself, if he accepted the principle of it. I quite agree that the word "grabbers" as it was in the original amendment is not Parliamentary and would not in any circumstances be accepted by the Minister. Therefore, that is one reason why Deputy Doyle was going to trust the Minister to re-draft the Clause. However, the Minister has placed a good deal of stress upon the position of people in the congested districts. I put it to him that the evicted tenant or representative of the evicted tenant who has a just claim is in a far worse position than the people in the congested area, and that is the real case I put up to him to make provision for such men as I have cited. There are many others I know who were tenants and who have been evicted during a certain period. That is the reason why I ask the Minister to accept the amendment moved by Deputy Doyle.
Comment on this
The Deputy says that the representatives of the evicted tenants are in a worse plight than the congests living in the congested areas. That is probably because he does not come from the congested areas and does not know anything about their privations. Anyone who knows anything about the question knows that that is not so. With regard to the suggestion to apply the amendment outside the congested areas, I cannot do it. There is congestion outside the congested district areas and there would be plenty of cases cropping up. If the evicted tenant gets State credit and an equivalent holding, he is well done for.
Comment on this
If the Minister does not accept this amendment I think he has not much sympathy with the evicted tenant. I hope he does not accuse me of doing this for electioneering purposes.
Comment on this
I have never accused him of any such thing. I have not a terrible lot of sympathy with a lot of evicted tenants.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Doyle means the bona fide evicted tenant. We do not mean men who have not a bona fide status. He means where bona fide land is in possession of grabbers.
Comment on this
I do not know whether it is or not. It was a good word that everybody understood and attached a certain meaning to.
Comment on this
Anybody who had any sympathy with the grabber in this country was never any good and I do not think that he is any good in any country. If there is any sympathy or fair play for evicted tenants, as there was under previous Acts, they would be restored as far as possible in their own holdings. The whole case has not been met. Land could not be found for them before, but now you are finding land for them. I know the Minister's difficulty in congested areas, and in fact it would not be fair to press him on that matter. The evicted tenants are on a different plane from the congests, because these people have had property taken from them through no fault of their own. It was taken because of a certain system and because of the stand they took. I think the genuine evicted tenant ought to be put back, as far as possible, on his own land, whether it is in the hands of the landlord or grabber. This is nothing new to us under the English Acts—to see grabbers taken from the land they grabbed and the original owner planted on that land. Men were taken from county Wexford and put on land in my own county. I do not see why this Government should not do the same. It is only copying from previous Governments, and they did it.
Comment on this
I think one thing is forgotten by the mover of this amendment. If this amendment were strictly adhered to it would put men back on congested and uneconomic holdings. Would that be an indication of sympathy with the evicted tenant? Would it not be better to put him on an economic holding somewhere else? That, I take it, is the procedure which the Minister hopes will be eventually carried out. I think it is unfair to charge him with lack of sympathy towards the evicted tenants.
Comment on this
No, but it has been implied. If the problems that this Bill purposes to be a solution of are to be met in some sane, effective fashion there will have to be some procedure to find the best economic methods of dealing with them. As was indicated by the Minister at a previous sitting, his procedure was, after the land had been vested, to deal then with the question of congests and after that with the evicted tenants, in so far as can be done. Also an amendment to Section 29 was put in which indicated that the claims of persons to special treatment could go beyond the year indicated in sub-section (c) of Section 29. It is simply a question of dealing with this matter in a business-like manner and doing justice to all, but obviously if this amendment were carried into effect it would be a stumbling block to the securing of that objective.
Comment on this
The frequent reference to the justification of the word "grabber" is rather interesting. I think probably if those who attempt to justify the use of it are right in this, they would be prepared to substitute the word "scab" or "blackleg." It has the same meaning that Deputy Gorey holds in regard to the grabber which other sections of the community hold in regard to the scab or blackleg. I want to ask the Minister— I think this may help to make more harmony on this question—whether the alphabetical order of persons to whom advances may be made under this Section is intended to indicate the order of preference, and is the unit of consideration to be the whole country or to be the estates? For instance, are we to consider that the first persons to be considered through the whole of the area are congests, and only after all the congests have been made holders of economic holdings will the persons under paragraph (c) be considered, and so on? Is the order of preference to be followed by the Land Commission to be in districts? Is the same order to be followed in certain districts or will the people who come under the letter A in one county not be transferred to another county; or will the people who come under (d) in one county have to wait until all the A's throughout the country are fixed in holdings? I think, if that is not the interpretation, there is general agreement. Even Deputy Doyle, I think, has conceded the point that congests ought to be first considered, but, having done that in general and having dealt with those under B, surely it is not to be refused that where it is possible, where there is an evicted tenant to be reinstated or to be given a holding, he should be given a holding on the estate, at any rate, or in the holding where it is possible he was evicted from? You may be evicting the present tenant, but I do not think it would apply universally at all. Personally I would say that some fitness for the job would have to be taken into account, but preference should certainly be given to the evicted tenant for reinstatement in the place he was evicted from, if that place were available. If there can be arrangements made of any kind, even with compulsory eviction of the present tenant if that tenant is not doing full value to the holding, the evicted person ought to be put back into that holding. The claim for the reinstatement into the tenant's old holding is a good one. Where it is possible without doing greater injustice it ought to be conceded, and I would ask the Minister for Agriculture to consult with the Minister for Home Affairs, and to consider whether something in the nature of the Tenants Rent Act, about the greater injustice or the greater hardship, might not be possible in this respect.
Comment on this
With regard to the first point it is stated that congests have the first claim, and that is right. The Land Commission must be sure that they have enough of land to relieve congestion before they give land to anybody else. Immediately congests are dealt with then the other parties come in and there is no particular order of priority. It would vary in every estate according to the special circumstances of each case. A labourer might get a holding as a landless man before an evicted tenant and vice versa on other estates. There is no priority whatever. That meets the first point.
With regard to the second point we could not, of course, put back an evicted tenant on a holding of 100 or 200 acres of land. We could not do it. It is never done and I take it the Dáil does not wish it to be done. Secondly we would not put back the tenant on a congested holding. That also would be the effect of the amendment as it stands. Thirdly, we would not put a tenant back on a holding whether it was inside or outside congested districts if the particular holding was vacant and needed for the relief of congestion, because if the tenant himself were there we might be taking it from him. Deputies must remember where any land exists for the relief of congestion we are to take it. For those three reasons we could not accept that amendment as it stands. It would compel us to do three things which I do not think the Dáil or the Deputy making the suggestion thinks ought to be done. That is No. 1. With regard to the grabber, I know just as much as anyone about him. There have been more evictions in the County Galway than any other county. I know it. There was probably more land law made there than anywhere else. You would have cases like this where a man has been evicted 30 or 40 years ago, and a man came in and took his land. His grandson might be there now with his family and it would be a grave the hardship to make him suffer for his grandfather. I make a present to any Deputies of that argument.
Comment on this
I make another point. There were evicted tenants, sons and grandsons in the various counties—not in Kilkenny who were amongst the very best men in the Irish Volunteers during the last war.
Comment on this
No. I would like there would be more people like that bred. Before I go from those general statements it would be a grave hardship in a great many cases to put out a man like that, a man whose grandfather had taken the holding under circumstances which we cannot picture now. There have been cases of genuine grabbing where holdings have been taken under shocking circumstances, but other cases which are rather on the border line we must examine. However, when you are talking about the land question for any reason except business purposes you talk about grabbers. Anyone knows that the twelve Apostles would evict some percentage of the tenants. I do not expect Deputy Gorey will admit that but I am in a position to admit it. Every responsible person knows that there is a small percentage St. Peter would evict. What would happen? A very large percentage of the evicted tenants reinstated in 1903 sold their holdings. You would have a case where a man was evicted 30 or 40 years ago and someone took his holding in circumstances more or less deplorable, and his grandson may be there now. He may be a married man with a family and perhaps as good an Irishman as the next. He would be put out and the evicted tenant brought back from New York and put in. He would probably sell the holding after a while—there have been plenty of cases of that sort—he would sell the holding immediately, and, one of the neighbours of the tenant ejected would buy it, and you would have the unfortunate man bred, born and reared there, in some other holding in the neighbourhood, looking out at his holding which is now not in the hands of the evicted tenant but of some other person who had never any claim upon it. It would be grossly unfair and unjust, and I for one see no case for it. I will not have the amendment at any cost.