We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

COMMITTEE ON FINANCE. - VOTE 3—EXECUTIVE COUNCIL.

Contributions 137–275 of 275. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

One month ago; there were not 71 other officers who had service in other armies demobilised, and of that number 40——

Comment on this

I have no doubt if the President supplies a list of names I will be able to show that the information supplied to him is incorrect; it is not the first time that information supplied to the President on the same matter was incorrect. I do not say for a moment that he is not telling the truth from the information exactly as supplied to him. I know what I am talking about.

Comment on this

Forty of these are in special positions. I think Deputy McGrath called them technical or special posts like that. There are some legal and other professions, and thirty-one outside of that are officers who have not had pre-Truce service with us, but who had pre-truce service in other armies. The average in that case would be over 2 per cent., very nearly 3 per cent., which in all the circumstances is, I think, fair. Now I put it to Deputy McGrath that his criticism of a meeting held in my room is a criticism which many other Ministers could in their capacity also allege. It is not always possible to get every member of the Executive Council into conference. I had not the faintest idea that Deputy McGrath would have been any use at that particular conference, or that he would have desired to be present.

Comment on this

I suggest I would have been of more use than any other Minister.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The President has been speaking since 7.30, and this is the eighth interruption. He must be allowed to continue. These interruptions are merely on points of fact or on points of opinion. They can be made when the President has concluded. They do not serve any good purpose during his speech.

Comment on this

It could be said about other conferences that it would have been far better if I called in other Ministers. That is one of the disadvantages of occupying the position of President of the Executive Council. With regard to what Deputy McGarry said, I have heard countless stories such as he suggested. I sometimes asked for these stories in writing, and if I did not get them in writing I took them down and forwarded them, as a rule, to the Minister in charge of the Department against which a case was made. Only in one case did the man give me all the information I asked for, and in that case I was able to explore the whole story, and bring home to a person in the employment of the State responsibility for a certain act which was sufficient to have him dismissed. It is easy to say, "I heard so-and-so about such-and-such."

All sorts of complaints have been alleged about purchasers and so on, and when I asked for the particulars in writing, and for the names of the persons against whom the charge was made, only in one case did I get information, and in that case I took action. Now, as regards the Contracts Committee, the Contracts Committee was attended for a very considerable time by Deputy McCarthy. I heard many complaints, and had many consultations about it, and the Minister for Finance, if it had not been for his illness, would have set up an entirely new body to deal with that. He had already circulated a document to the Executive Council with regard to putting a certain Department over purchases, and if it were not for his illness that department would have been in operation by this.

I take it that was the case four months ago, and exactly the same complaint might be made against that particular Committee. Now, on the general question, I have very little further to say. Deputy Esmonde suggested that we should bring in experts on finance. I do not know that that was altogether a fair statement to make. Experts on finance! One might just as well say: you should get in experts on medicine or engineering, or anything of that sort. After all, finance is like many other things. It has certain laws which must be obeyed, and no expert that you get in can get you out of obeying these laws. The time comes when you have to draw your cheque, and if you have not got the money to meet it you want credit, and if you have not got the credit you will find yourself in difficulty if you draw the cheque. I have dealt with the matter of the Estimates. In a year or two, possibly next year, if we can get rid of the compensation claims, the Estimates would lend themselves to the treatment desired. I would like very much to see that particular treatment, but I am not so satisfied that some of the items that are complained of as being in a certain compartment, should be capitalised. I refer to some criticism from somebody that the pensions list and so on should be capitalised, and that we should not put in the total amount of them against a particular year.

I rather welcome a motion like this. I would like that a better case was put on record of the faults of the Executive Council. We have, I suppose, many faults. We have struggled in very difficult times to do good work, and if there is one thing upon which, in my opinion, the Executive has done well, it is upon its financial policy.

Comment on this

Is the President in favour of the policy adopted by the Ministry of Fisheries?

Comment on this

All I can say is that that is under consideration at the present moment. It has been under consideration for some time past. It is not easily settled. It is not easy to give them another boat like the "Helga."

Comment on this

Is there any possibility that these things will ever be taken from under consideration?

Comment on this

As soon as the Dáil adjourns, I expect many of these things will get much more consideration than at present.

Comment on this

We have had an exhibition of two lines of military strategy to-day. The Commander-in-Chief of the Irish Army has adopted the policy of stone-walling. He allowed all attacks to expend themselves or he attempted to do that, before he responded. The other line is more interesting to the onlooker. For some time there has been persistent criticism and attack from the small arms, shall I say, continuous and apparently ineffective. But the heavy guns were never available. The tactics that have been adopted by the Commanders of the Army were the decision to have a field day before the adjournment, and an attack upon all fronts, at the same time forgetful of the fact that it is not much use attacking in that manner unless some support is given to the small arms and the people holding the trenches. I think that the attitude of Deputy McGrath and his colleagues deserves criticism from this standpoint. They have come to-day with a motion of no confidence, but for quite a considerable number of weeks they have missed occasion after occasion and opportunity after opportunity to express that lack of confidence both in discussions and in votes upon Estimates, and on Bills, and they have never availed themselves of that opportunity, or only seldom. Now, I suggest to them for their earnest consideration, that if they have no confidence they ought to show it by constant attendance and persistent criticism. In regard to this motion. I am going to support it because I think it would be a very good thing for the country and a very good thing for the Dáil if it were passed and resulted in a complete reorganisation of the Government. The discussion has, in the main, dealt with financial policy and its consequence on the one hand, and an Army crisis on the other. I do not propose to deal with the latter subject at all, except to say this—and it is more concerned with financial policy than the criticism of Deputy Esmonde in respect of the Estimates was criticism in favour of an effective Army for war purposes. His demand was that the Government should set about training an Army for war purposes. He instanced Finland in respect of the course that had been taken regarding a similar army crisis—or a somewhat similar army crisis to that gone through in this country.

I would ask the Dáil on the contrary to refer to Denmark which has also been mentioned to-day in another respect, and to consider whether it would not be better to think of the desirability of following the idea that is being worked out in Denmark to-day instead of organising an efficient army for war purposes: rather to take a referendum on the question of disarmament. That is the policy that the new Labour Government in Denmark has adopted, and is in the course of testing the feeling of the country upon. The matter of financial policy involves a great many other matters, and from what we have heard the President say, and from what has so often been said from the Ministerial benches, everything depends upon our continuance of the financial banking and commercial policy that has been handed down to us by a preceding regime, that is to say, maintaining the financial and commercial policy, the commercial and industrial methods of Great Britain. It is suggested that by maintaining that policy, particularly the financial policy, is the only way we can hope to remedy the social evils that confront the country. I mean to suggest to the Dáil that continuance and reliance upon that policy will never remedy the evils that we are to-day complaining of, never in this country as it has never done in England, Scotland, Germany, France or America. The criticisms that I have to make regarding the contention of the Government that the budget must be balanced are not quite those of Deputy Esmonde, but rather that by attempting to balance the budget and by attempting to follow the old methods of capitalist finance you are ensuring the perpetuation of unemployment and preventing a settlement of that question. The first duty of a Government is not to balance a budget, but rather to ensure that the people will be fed and clothed. I ask the Minister if the Executive Council has considered the consequences that will follow to this country if the policy that is now being canvassed in banking circles in England is adopted here, the policy of deflation and the consequent reduction in the price of commodities in England, with the inevitable consequence of a great decline in productive enterprise in England, because of the sudden lowering of prices which follows a deflation policy. Has the Minister considered how that is going to affect agricultural prices and the agricultural community in this country? Does it not point to this necessary conclusion, that unless we are going to be the plaything of financial policy in England, a policy of deflation or inflation, unless we are content to be the plaything of banking institutions in England it is necessary to develop a distinctive financial policy, perhaps a currency policy, in this country. I say that the absence of any sign from the Executive Council that they are considering the commercial and industrial effects of financial operations in England, and the absence of any sign that they are proposing to strike out a distinctive line commercially and financially for Ireland, is in itself a defect and warrants a vote of no confidence.

Deputy Esmonde quoted the French Premier, and spoke of financial credit as being the equivalent of or simply another way of speaking of general confidence. But, I ask, general confidence in what? Confidence in the ability of the Government to collect taxes, confidence in the ability of the banks to collect deposits, and confidence in the ability of debtors to pay their debts in cash. Is that the kind of confidence upon which credit depends? I suggest that behind all that there should be, and must be, and is, in fact, confidence in the ability of the country and of the people of the country to take out of the country the wealth which is there and is ready waiting to be tapped. Even though there is no confidence in the ability of the banks, or in the ability of the debtors to pay their debts in cash, and even though financial systems fail, we ought to be in the position to bring the wealth producer into touch with the wealth of the country, and even if financial methods fail, and even if this mechanism of distribution of wealth fails to call forth the production of wealth, then I say that we have to go beyond the ordinary commercial methods and to pass by the ordinary financial methods and go direct to the producer, to the workman, the farmer, and the man that owns the machine, and say: "Get to work and we will feed you while you are working." These systems that have grown up through the ages were useful in their time, but the test of their utility lies in this: that they do assist in providing people with food, clothing and shelter, and if they fail in that work then they must be altered and we must not rely upon the old system which has proved futile, but we must attempt to get behind the system and do the actual thing ourselves even if we have to adopt new methods by using the soil, using labour, and using machinery to feed the people. That is what we are failing to do, and there is no sign, notwithstanding the occasional ameliorative measures which the Ministry is bringing forward alongside measures of the other kind, which are removing amelioration—there is no sign that the Government is appreciating, or does appreciate, the state of the country and the needs of the country.

The question of pensions and pensioners has been brought forward, and the great burden that pensions, no doubt, will be upon the country. If you choose to allow large numbers of people to depend upon the chance that an employer will employ them for a livelihood, and you say that it is better to rely upon this system, then you must make provision for the people who will not be employed. You select a certain section of the community who, you say, have done a service, and say they are, therefore, entitled to a pension. All right. I am prepared to support those pensions, because I feel that the men must be given an opportunity to live.

But I will say equally that it is far better to utilise the ability and the labour of these men, and let them do service directly or indirectly for the State. Once you begin to say that a man who is getting a pension, or who is being maintained, must be provided through State auspices with an opportunity of earning what he receives, then you are giving way to the case which I make not only with regard to pensioners but with regard to every other citizen. I say again, as has been said already from these Benches, and as I have said, that there was in January, 1919, a general declaration not merely of Party policy, as has been suggested, but a general declaration which amounted to a promise or bond, that the first duty of the Government would be to see that no child went hungry. It is still the first duty of the Government to see that no child in Ireland goes hungry, and I say that along with that assurance to the public that that would be the policy of the new regime, there follows the assurance that the father of that child will have an opportunity of providing the wherewithal to keep the child from hunger. So far from balancing budgets being the first and only financial duty of the Government, I say that if budgets do not balance it is of less consequence than that children should go hungry. Because I see no sign that the Government has a realisation of its duty in this respect, and because I think there will develop during the next few months, unless the unexpected happens, a very bitter cry. I feel the necessity for a distinct and radical change in the personnel of the Government. I believe that a radical change in the personnel of the Government must accompany a radical change in political and social outlook.

Comment on this

During the earlier part of Deputy Esmonde's speech I thought I was listening to a most admirable oration. The manner was excellent, the diction was perfect, and, best of all, I thought, were the ideas which formed the matter of the speech. But when I came to consider the speech a little more carefully, I realised that it was not very surprising that I admired it, because the two main ideas on which the Deputy based his speech were both borrowed from me, without acknowledgment. More than two months ago I urged the Minister for Finance, in one of the stages of the Finance Bill, not to be too much of a purist about borrowing, that borrowing for reproductive and constructive purposes was not necessarily extravagant and might be most desirable in view of our present position regarding unemployment. That seed seemed to have fallen on stony ground at the time, but I am glad that it fell on the fertile soil of Deputy Esmonde's heart and ripened there. It was worth waiting for. The other idea in his speech that we should call in the services of experts and set up a Geddes Committee to inquire into the expenditure of the State, was even an older child of mine. It was born nearly nine months ago in the debate on the Governor-General's address. I have brought it up here from time to time, and the Minister for Finance has always looked sternly at it and ordered it out. You can imagine my surprise this afternoon when I saw my child reappear in Deputy Esmonde's arms. I forgive him entirely for the fact that he did not quote me as his authority for these two ideas because he added such charm to them. I even forgive him for producing many of the ideas I intended to put forward when the Army Estimates come up. The Estimates for the Army may not come up for a month or two, and I may reproduce those ideas and use them as my own—as indeed they are my own —in the same way as Deputy Esmonde used mine this afternoon.

As to the question of the appointment of experts, when I raised that matter it was dismissed by the President. But the idea is a sound one. There is no derogation from our status or independence as a nation by consulting outside experts on matters of finance. If proof of that is needed, you have only to look at Brazil. Brazil is an independent State absolutely, and yet it has just had a British mission of experts. It is true that the moment the experts left the country a revolution broke out. But that was probably because they were sorry to see them going away, or else it was—and I say this seriously—because the Government did not call them in in time and because the measures that were recommended by the experts were not acted on. After all, matters of finance, as the President says, obey certain laws. But these laws can be wisely or foolishly applied.

Health obeys certain laws, too, but you have from time to time to call in a doctor to advise you as to the best methods by which these laws can be applied. So it is with finance, and I think it is a mistake to go on as the Government have been going on, assuming that the last word in wisdom lies with the officials of the Ministry of Finance. I think we should go outside and try if even more experienced officials in other countries could not help us. There is one point that I wished your ruling, A Chinn Comhairle, had allowed Deputy Esmonde to elaborate—that is the measures passed by the Executive Council, which, he held, turned many people against the State. Because if he had been allowed to elaborate that, he would have explained what the measures were, and he would have told us if the Old Age Pensions Act was amongst them.

Comment on this

Deputy Esmonde could then have explained why he voted for that measure fifteen times, why Deputy McCarthy voted for it seventeen times, and why Deputy Milroy only voted for it once.

Comment on this

It was a question of party obligations.

Comment on this

I did not vote for it at all.

Comment on this

Deputy Milroy can expound his wisdom later on. If the same reason applies, I do not know how Deputy Milroy was so wise above the other Deputies I have mentioned. I pass from Deputy Esmonde to Deputy McGrath. I do not propose to go into all that Deputy McGrath said about the Army Inquiry, because a great deal of it was not directed against the Inquiry but against the measure taken by the Executive Council. It is not my responsibility to defend the Executive Council. That is, perhaps, fortunate for them, because I should probably do it very badly. Like Deputy Esmonde, Deputy McGrath quoted from me, but, unlike Deputy Esmonde, he put my name to the quotations. Whether that was to honour my foresight and wisdom I am not sure. I will say this, that what I have said, and what was quoted by Deputy McGrath, I still hold. I think the form of inquiry originally proposed would have been the best one. It would have stood a better chance of getting, I will not say more completely, at the truth, but of getting at it more quickly than the Inquiry that was set up. But once there was shown a desire in the Dáil, as unquestionably there was, that each party should be represented on the Inquiry, then that original form of Inquiry, consisting only of people who had been in the I.R.A., from the beginning, and had been fully conversant with all that had occurred, became absolutely impossible, because the choice of representatives would have been so restricted as practically not to exist at all. Once the desire appeared and grew, and was forcibly expressed, that the Army Inquiry should contain representatives of all parties, there was no alternative but to abandon the old idea, though I still believe the old idea would have been best. When Deputy McGrath says that the personnel of the Inquiry was deliberately picked, and that we were not serious about the Inquiry, there I join issue with him—not about the deliberate picking, but about not being serious. I do not think I have ever been so serious about anything in my life.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation. I did not mean that any single individual member of the Committee was not serious. I meant that the Government were not serious, and did not help the Inquiry or give it the information they should.

Comment on this

I am very glad that the Deputy has explained this, because I took it the other way. Certainly the Deputy would not have been justified in saying that. Now, as regards information, so far as I can understand Deputy McGrath, he thinks we should have had all the information in the possession of the Government, whether it bore on the Inquiry or not, placed before us to pick for ourselves. We were really not in a position to hunt through the whole of the files of the Ministry of Defence. We could have got them if we had asked for them. We got everything we asked for except one thing, which was a professional opinion given for the information of the Executive Council. Except that we got every file we asked for. Deputy McGrath spoke of the Army Inquiry as a gag—a gag for him and others. I never looked on it in that light before, but if it was a gag it was an ineffectual gag, because before we were half way through our proceedings Deputy McGrath went down to Mayo and made a speech—

Comment on this

Deputy Cooper is in error there. The Committee had finished taking evidence before that. You were actually framing your report.

Comment on this

I said before we were half way through our report. It was before we had fully completed our report.

Comment on this

I hope what I said did not upset you.

Comment on this

Not in the least. Nothing upsets me.

Comment on this

On a point of order—

Comment on this

I withdraw that last statement. Deputy Gorey upsets me.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, I wish to say that before the Committee considered the report at all and before they had finished the evidence a pamphlet was issued and Deputy McGrath's speech was made.

Comment on this

There my recollection is not quite the same as Deputy Gorey's. The pamphlet, by General Tobin, was issued just as we had begun to draft our report. I think Deputy Gorey is right about Deputy McGrath's speech, but not about the pamphlet. I do not remember having seen it until after we had finished taking evidence. I come to another matter which may perhaps relieve Deputy McGrath's mind. I have no papers here. I did not bring even the report of the Army Inquiry with me. Deputy McGrath referred to a statement in that report that the attitude of some of these officers had been a problem to the late General Collins. I can assure him that it was not in my mind to make any reflection on the dead or living in that respect. I considered that paragraph very carefully, and I took it in the sense that in every Army at the end of every war the General responsible for the administration of that Army finds that a problem is presented to him by a certain number of officers who were excellent fighting officers and have given good service but are not suited by temperament to the routine work of administration. I personally had no more meaning in those words than that. They were not intended to give offence to anyone.

I come to the last words—Deputy McGrath's reference to ex-British officers in the Army. As a matter of fact the statistics put before us did not deal with ex-British officers at all. They dealt with officers who had served in any army. The first statement of service I saw on the return handed to us at the Army Inquiry was of a gentleman who had served 25 years in the German Army. Therefore, the figures put before us cover all those who had experience in any army whatsoever. That being so, I do not think that the 3 per cent, the President has referred to is a very large proportion, when you must have a certain number of skilled men for training purposes. I do not want to quarrel with Deputy McGrath at all. I understand his loyalty to his old friends and comrades. I respect that loyalty, but I say that the attitude he is taking up is hopeless with regard to the future. If the Treaty meant anything it did mean that we were going to forget about old quarrels and old squabbles and join together to make Ireland a better place to live in. That spirit should be found in the army as elsewhere. But the attitude of Deputy McGrath leads nowhere. If he had been at Baltimore he would have said that George Washington was an ex-British officer, because he was.

If he had been a prominent figure in the French Revolution he would have rejected Napoleon Bonaparte because he was a royalist officer. If he were in Russia he would object to the number of Czarist ex-officers serving in the Russian Army. If the army is to be as we want it to be, Oglaigh na hEireann, it should be an army in which there would be room for all Irishmen and the cardinal test should be: "Can this man give good service to Ireland?" There should be no other test.

I cannot support the motion to refer back this estimate on the grounds put forward by the National Group. If I intended to bring an indictment against the Executive Council—an indictment that would sound well in the ears of the public—I should pass that estimate and I should take them to the Governor-General's Address and say: "What has become of your pledges?" I had the curiosity to go through the Governor-General's Address and examine the outlined legislation there the other day. I find that nine Bills mentioned in it have been passed. Six have been introduced and not yet passed. That includes important measures like the Local Government Bill and the Liquor Bill. Fourteen Bills have not been yet introduced. Out of 29 measures promised in the Governor-General's Address, only just half have come into being at all.

Comment on this

Have we passed any that we did not promise at all?

Comment on this

You have passed a great many. There is one Bill I found it very difficult to classify—the Local Government Elections Bill. I did not know whether I should count it as two Bills or as one Bill because the Government have passed two Bills. Although they gave us more than we desired or deserved, there were some important measures promised which they did not introduce, such as the Reciprocal Enforcement of Judgments Bill, the Patents Measure, the Copyright Measure, the Merchant Shipping Bill, the Electric Power Bill, and a Bill for regularising Commissions of Inquiry. All these are very important Bills. There is also another Bill which, I think, Deputy Johnson or Deputy O'Connell would like me to call attention to—a Bill for providing medical and dental treatment for school children. That is a measure of some importance. I think we might well ask the Government what has happened those Bills. I do not do that myself for fear that I might be taken at my word and that the Government might immediately introduce these Bills and insist on passing them before the Recess. But I should do that if I wanted to make a paper case against the Government.

The real indictment I have against the Government is not lack of courage, not fear of hard work, but that they have failed in one respect, and failed in a way which is very serious to the country—they have failed to educate the country and failed to educate their constituents about the difficult issues that are before us. Except for the Minister for Justice who, think, has spoken to his constituents twice, it takes a by-election to get a Minister on to a platform. I do not think that is a right state of affairs. We are in a new country and there are all kinds of wild and whirling political ideas about. If the Government and the people who have most information and who can speak with most authority do not go down to the people and explain what they are doing and why they are doing it, then that confused, vague outlook, that readiness to ride off on side issues, that is already a characteristic of politics in Ireland will continue and must continue. Ministers may say that they do not want to justify themselves. They have a false form of courage which prevents them from going down and explaining their position. That breeds what was referred to by the Minister for Justice, a little while ago, as persistent unpopularity which has been found fatal to individuals, and may be found fatal possibly to Governments, but I think it will not be so found to-night. A vote of censure is more than a vote of want of confidence in the Government. It is a vote of confidence in those who move it, and in those who will be called on to replace the Government, if the Government falls. That vote I am not prepared to give. I am not sure that even if Deputy Johnson is taken back from the trench line and put with the big guns, and the position is defended by big guns entirely, that the coalition would be either a popular or practical one. I do not see that we can hope in any alternative administration to have a Finance Minister with more thoroughness and more conscientiousness than the present Minister, nor do I think we can get a Minister for Industry and Commerce with greater ingenuity, a Minister for Justice with greater resolution, or a President with more combative common sense. That being so, I propose to vote against the motion to refer back this vote.

Comment on this

While the President was making his opening observations in a charmingly tactful and courteous manner, my mind went back to certain discussions that took place in this Dáil when the Ministerial opponents of the anti-Treatyites told us they wanted constitutional opposition. They yearned for it, they pined for it, but now that they get a touch of constitutional opposition it does not seem to agree with their temperaments at all. They are going to get constitutional opposition just as much as the situation requires, and just as much as the interests of the nation demand.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I am glad that the Minister for Justice says "hear, hear." By the time we are finished with him he will not be like Oliver Twist, asking for more. Deputy Bryan Cooper has just recited the virtues of the Ministry. Let me picture what I think is the impression of the great majority of the people in Ireland at present in regard to the personnel of the Executive. In the Minister for Education we have an apparent disciple of Rip Van Winkle, whose department, however, makes progress despite his solemn somnambulistic tendency; in the Minister for Justice we have a man whom some regard as a Mussolini, and others regard as a mustard plaster that has exhausted its usefulness; in the Minister for External Affairs we have an amusing, ineffective dilettante Will-o'-the-Wisp, whose sole conception of international diplomacy seems to be not persistent unpopularity but persistent flippancy; and the last, but by no means the least, in the President we have a firm believer in the philosophy of Mark Tapley, that there was no credit in being cheerful except when things were going against us, and, therefore, we should try to keep things going wrong in order to get credit for being cheerful in the worthiest sense of the term. I will say nothing harsh of the Minister for Industry and Commerce; he is a mere tyro, but, as we all are at elections, he is a man of excellent promise. The President, I think, lowered the dignity of this discussion before the adjournment, and at the resumption of the debate. Deputy Esmonde opened this discussion with what every one must have recognised as a reasoned, thought-out statement, adducing facts worthy of consideration even from the present Executive.

Deputy McGrath made an indictment severe in character and serious in its implications, and what was the tone of the rejoinder? The only rejoinder yet from the Ministerial Benches was a series of—I was going to say of flippant sneers, but I do not think they were intended to be sneers—a series of flippant comments and references to this contemptuous and insignificant minority, or group, that are trying to express what they believe to be their duty to their constituents, and that is in speaking out what they believe to be the truth free from the shackles of party or personal interests. Some time ago I initiated a discussion in the Dáil, which I said was not intended to be a vote of no confidence in the Executive. I said on that occasion that if I aimed at such I could easily have found a more vulnerable point of attack, and I think we are confronted with such a point in this discussion. I have no qualms to-night as to how I view the vote which will terminate this debate. It is intended to be a vote of censure, a vote of no confidence in the Government, and I trust that the decision of this Dáil in the matter will be such that if it does not cancel the period of office of the Executive, that it will, at least, arouse the members of that Executive to a realisation of the fact that the symptoms of paralysis which appear to characterise their energies where the vital needs of the country are concerned, may, if not overcome, bring themselves to discredit, and the State to the brink of tragedy. This national group, as it is called, may be an object of derision to the Ministry. Those who compose it tried to support the Government hitherto, and they gave unstinted support to it until recent months, and it may be painful to them, and it certainly is regrettable to myself, that I have found it necessary at present and for some time past to adopt an attitude of a severely critical character towards the Government. But we do this in an entirely impersonal way without any desire to import into such discussions as may ensure from our differences a bitter intransigeant element of personality. We have taken this serious step—at least to us it has been serious; to me it was a very serious and very grave step to sever my connection publicly from the Government Party, and I think that the fact that some of us have taken this action, after grave consideration, ought at least to make members of the Government, and those who support them, realise that there may possibly be serious and deep grounds for criticism, when men who would have wished to stand by them to the end had to take the step that we have taken.

I am aware of the kind of argument that will be put forward, by the Minister for Justice if he intervenes in this discussion, and by the minor supporters or apologists of the Government. I have no doubt the Minister will review the long series of disorders that the Government have been confronted with as a vindication of their present policy, which, to us who stand as their critics, appears to be totally lacking in the elements of progress. Those who support him will assert that to shake the stability of the Government at the present time is to jeopardise the security of the State and to open the gates of the citadel to the forces of anarchy and chaos once more. I find both of these arguments unconvincing and out of contact with realities. The period of disorder has sufficiently receded to enable Ministers to disclose some plan or progresivse, constructive policy. We cannot always have thrown into our face as an argument to justify every elementary lack of a constructive policy the fact that certain of our people threw the country into chaos and bloodshed. That argument has had its place in our politics. To-day that argument should cease to be the thing, and the argument that the Ministers confront us with when they are faced with criticism. I say the period of disorder has receded sufficiently to enable Ministers to disclose some indication of a comprehensive, constructive, economic policy. It has disclosed nothing but what may be termed paralytic negation. It has revealed no Ministerial suggestion that will inspire the people with the belief that what we have gained means really the achievement of a great stride towards their ideals, and the people are now conjecturing if, after all, the freedom we have won means nothing really better than the servitude that we have overcome, and they are being taught by speeches from the Minister the dull and benumbing doctrine that it is doubtful if freedom is a condition which we as a people can sustain. When I hear the argument advanced, as it probably will be advanced if Government supporters intervene, "Do not swop horses when crossing a stream," I answer—what if the horse refuses to cross the stream and merely keeps prancing up and down on the wrong side of the stream. In that case swopping horses becomes a necessity and not a blunder. That seems to me in a rough way to describe very accurately the position we are approaching in the Saorstát at the present time. I, as it may be noticed, have taken a more general survey, or am engaged in taking a more general survey, of the grounds upon which I think this vote of no confidence is justified than previous speakers have taken, because the Army situation was not to me the cause of the break. It was simply an incident in a chain of incidents that brought me to the temper of mind and outlook that I eventually arrived at. I go back to the outlook we had when the evacuation of the British from the Saorstát was in progress, when the people of this country were thrilled with the spectacle of a British Army departing and an Irish Army taking over and occupying the strongholds that had been held for centuries by the foreigner, when control by the Irish people of their own finance, their own education, their own judiciary and administration, had ceased to be the mere idle dream of the enthusiast, and was really being consummated before our eyes. I look back to the ideas we then had in our minds, and what we anticipated would be the speedy and inevitable consequence that must ensue as a result of securing these powers. In looking back on that, in view of the present situation, I entertain a feeling of deep and apprehensive disappointment.

It is not because I expected that miracles would happen, and that they did not happen, but that the obvious practical things which these changes gave us power to effect were either ignored, or if touched upon, were touched upon as lightly and as superficially as, one might say, the touch of the seagull flying over the waves as it skims the ocean and leaves no impression behind. I do not know whether or not the members of this House share the opinions of the Minister that neglect of opportunity and of doing for the country something that would put it on its feet is a matter for smiles or amusement. I guarantee, however, if the Minister goes to his constituents and preaches that doctrine, he will find that it is something other than smiles or cheers that he will get from his hearers. Now, I wonder if the Government were to challenge the verdict of the people at present what plea they would put forward to secure the restoration of that confidence which the electorate so ungrudgingly reposed in them at the last election. I suppose they would put forward the suppression of disorder and, so far as I am concerned, I give them every credit for the policy pursued, and while they were in need of support to pursue that policy I do not think that they can deny that I gave them most unstinted support. The restoration of order, after all, while a vast task and an essential service, is a negative service and people cannot live entirely on service of this kind. I wonder would the Ministers or the Government Party go to the country and expect to get confidence on the Old Age Pension cut; I wonder would they expect that that lamentable slogan of the Minister for Finance, which has been so often alluded to to-night, about balancing the Budget, would repair the confidence shattered, not by the people, not by the supporters of the Government, but by the Executive Council itself. We have had a plethora of inquiries and commissions and I think all, or practically all, certainly the greater portion, remind me of that which Deputy McGarry referred to earlier tonight—the roads made in famine days to relieve distress which led nowhere except to a substantial waste of public money. Then we have had a marvellous pageant of green bills passing through the Oireachtas, or rather, I should say, we have had an avalanche of green paper falling on us. Looking over that amazing output of documents, one must come to the conclusion that the Ministerial mind is obsessed with the idea that the stability of the nation can be built up with paper. One remembers the story of Marie Antoinette, who, when she heard that her people could not get bread, advised them to get cakes.

Now, I think, we have a revision of that story. The Ministers when they hear that people cannot get work say: "We will supply them with plenty of Bills." They expect the people to foot the bills. I have had reason before now to comment very adversely upon the mischievous effect of the professional mind, obtruding itself unduly in the domain of practical affairs, and when I think of the marvellous avalanche of green Bills I am inclined to think that the predominance of the strictly legal mind it seems to indicate, is likely to have contingencies or results equally as undesirable as that of the professors. Arthur Griffith, on more than one occasion, held before us the picture of the paper wall which England had built around this country by which it misrepresented the people of the country and kept us out of contact with other people. We have happily survived that paper wall, but the question now is whether we are going to survive this avalanche of paper which the lawyers and legal advisors are showering upon us. To put it in another way, the Ministers have not time to attend to the real, essential economic needs of the country, because they are struggling helplessly like Laocoön in the coils of green paper which threaten not only to strangle them, but the whole future of the nation. I have no desire to minimise the labours of the Ministry but I say they are labouring with futilities instead of labouring with realities. I am not denying that there may be virtues in every one of these Bills. I am not denying that each and every one which has come before us, or which may be put before us, may help to evolve the perfect constitutional state, but they are not all urgent and there are things more vital to the State, neglect of which spells disaster, and it is these essential things which I contend the Executive Council have overlooked or seem utterly unconscious of. The Army question has been a good deal referred to and I have not a great deal to say on that point, but the few comments I have to make are in the nature of censure. In the controversy which preceded the actual happenings already discussed at great length in the Dáil, I took no side, one way or the other, and I have no desire now to express a partisan view in regard to one side or the other. This much, however, I do say with emphasis, that, on the grounds of the information which has come to light, nothing has come out of it that redounds to the credit of the Executive Council. I do not want to impugn the motives of the members of the Army Inquiry Committee but I must say that the report appeared to me to be a piece of special pleading on behalf of one of the contributing elements to the trouble.

Comment on this

On behalf of which?

Comment on this

The surviving element. I have not made up my mind yet whether it was the survival of the fittest. The whole business has disclosed the Executive Council in a most sorry light, and I say, if there was no other count in the indictment, they have come out of this in a way which deserves an expression of the lack of confidence in their capacity to manage such things, things which were not mere trivial matters of debate, but things on which the very life and existence of this State depended, and which should not be made the playthings of any section of the community, no matter whether it be the rabble in the street or the Ministers holding high executive office. I pass hurriedly to one or two other points I wish to make. I referred some time ago to the Minister for External Affairs. I have one query to address to him. I presume this Minister is in touch with his subordinates, especially those who are responsible for the custody of the honour of this State abroad, and I want to know if his attention has been drawn to a paragraph which appeared in last Saturday's "Freeman," which gives an address from Mr. Vaughan Dempsey, the representative of Saorstát Eireann in France. Addressing the Irish Party at the grave of France's Unknown Soldier, in the course of his observations Mr. Vaughan Dempsey, representative of Saorstát Eireann, said:—

"Ireland having at last found peace within herself, has come, the youngest nation of them all, to prove by this act of homage that she took her stand with loyalty and sacrifice by the great nations in the fight for liberty and civilisation."

That was not referring to some remote war that took place centuries ago in which France took part. Referring to the devastated regions of France, he said:—

"You ex-service men have seen those regions made bleak and barren by the shells of the enemy. And you, men who fought through this last great war, I am sure I express your own thoughts when I say that all your suffering and hardship have left you only a great desire for peace. Having fought, what greater ambition could you now put before yourselves than to work for the ideal of peace, peace within your own shores, peace with your great neighbour, whose flag is represented to-day beside your own, and peace with the whole world."

This, I hope, will not be treated flippantly by the Minister. I have no desire to say one word that would give offence to the people of France or to the ex-service men who fought in the war, but this gentleman, representative of Saorstát Eireann, was not speaking as the spokesman of ex-service men. He was not speaking for those who ranged themselves against Germany in the war. He was speaking for Saorstát Eireann, and so far as I know Germany has never been included in the enemies of Saorstát Eireann, and I think it is highly improper for a representative of the Saorstát to describe it in this way. I trust our Minister will condescend to give attention to that.

The manner in which the Executive Council have approached the economic needs of the State has been lamentable, as short-sighted, and as inefficient as their handling of the Army situation. The only conception that they seem to possess of economic defectiveness in the State is the reluctance of people to provide the finance to equip and run the State. There seems to be no realisation of the grave fact that such reluctance does not spring from a desire to evade the responsibilities of citizenship, but from sheer industrial and commercial depression and its attendant deprivations. That seems to be the last thing that the present Executive visualises at all, the last thing it would appear to contemplate, and I believe a good deal of this depression is the direct outcome and consequence of the cue that commercial and banking institutions have taken from the Minister for Finance's slogan: "Balance your Budget." Overdrafts have been tightened up. Commercial enterprises have to sue their customers for payment of their debts, and credit has been tightened up at a time when this is not a virtue but the reverse of a virtue, and at a time when credit should be relaxed to enable headway to be made in the new State. That may seem to be sheer financial lunacy to the acting Minister for Finance; it may seem to be madness to the Minister for Justice, but whether that be so or not, the one fact they cannot deny is that the country economically is not advancing. It is rather receding, and they hold in their hands as custodians of the State the means whereby the energies of the country that can reproduce wealth can be liberated and stimulated.

If they refuse, whether from disinclination or ignorance of the fact that this is their duty, then the country will have to call them to account. I think there is no better example of a—shall I say—superficial outlook on the economic situation in the country than was revealed in the tariff proposals. I am not going to discuss them, except in a passing sentence, because, as you, sir, indicated, it would be undesirable to discuss proposals that have become law. There was an opportunity there to deal with the matter in a whole-hearted comprehensive way, and in a safe and effective way, which would produce substantial results from the economic standpoint. How was it availed of? It was availed of in a way that seemed to indicate that they were sorry this opportunity had come before them. Though certain things did materialise, which I hope and believe will effect, incidentally, perhaps accidentally, material good, and may illustrate the value of this policy as an instrument of economic liberation still the way in which the question was approached and dealt with was churlish, lop-sided, and ill-thought out. One would almost come to the conclusion that the real desire was not to make use of those powers to advance the nation, but to discredit them as an instrument of economic advancement.

It may be urged that there is nothing very tangible in the charges I have made. (Deputies: Hear, hear.) I am glad that Deputies say "hear, hear." I expected that. That is why I said it —in order to provoke that. The very fact that criticism is of this intangible nature is the damning aspect of this matter. That which has not been done may be always accounted as intangible. But, what if that which has not been done is the very thing that should be done, and the doing of it is of the utmost necessity to the nation, as it is in the present instance? So definitely does the policy of the Executive Council seem to evade the essential and to make great parade of the non-essential or the non-urgent, that one begins to wonder if there is an invisible hand holding up the exercise of those energies which can give life and progress to the State. Anyone who knows what it has cost this country to rid itself of the weight of foreign oppression, who witnesses the present apparently inexplicable impotence to advance, and who views the present impasse, will be filled with the apprehension that there are forces working silently and cunningly under the surface to frustrate the hopes of the nation and nullify what we have won. In drawing attention to this, what I believe to be a really serious factor in the contributing agencies that have brought about the present situation, what I am mainly concerned with is, that the Executive Council shall not become unconscious instruments of these forces.

I am not going to detain the Dáil very much longer, because I wish to give an opportunity to some of the back benchers on the Government side to express their views. I will be very glad if they can convince me that my apprehensions are unfounded—that there is no ground for criticism in the Government policy, and that the Ministers are in Merrion Street and all is right with the world. I think they will have a very difficult task, but I do hope, at least, that they will speak, not merely mumble a few words, parrot-like, in support of the Government. If they believe the policy of the Government requires support, I hope they will express that in an intelligent way and give grounds for the belief that is in them. For my part, I find it very hard —indeed I find it impossible. It would be well if only one speech at a time were delivered in the Dáil; because it is very difficult to have a duet or trio in a deliberative assembly. I hope, for the few remaining observations I have to make, that the gentlemen, the Deputies below me, will defer their conversation until I have concluded. I find it difficult to proceed while Ministers engage in these dialogues.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE (Mr. Hogan) Cumann na nGaedheal

On a point of explanation, the difficulty I am in is that I do not know whether I am referred to, because the Deputy first said "gentlemen" and then withdrew and said "Deputies."

Comment on this

I did not catch that remark.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Deputy Milroy may continue his speech.

Comment on this

I find it hard to fathom the reason for this lack of policy and of statesmanship—this sheer lack of vision concerning the needs and the future of this country in the Executive Council. I wonder is the explanation to be found in the fact that they are suffering from mental exhaustion as a result of their heroic—and I say that without any sense of derision— their heroic and strenuous labours during the last two or three years? Or, is it that they have abandoned the idea of a free and advancing Ireland, and have come to the conclusion that the most we can hope to achieve is simply to stereotype the routine administration that has come within our grasp? That may be their outlook. It is certainly not the outlook of the people. They may regulate their pace, so to speak, to the strains of a dirge or song of defeat, but, if they do so they will be divorcing themselves from the people who have not yet come to the condition of mental or physical exhaustion that will admit of defeat.

To come back to where I started, I began with the President and I am going to conclude with him. I am sorry this discussion has taken place on this particular Estimate, because the greater portion of the items in it are items attaching to the Presidential office, as distinct from the Executive Council proper. I do not consider the Vote excessive. I consider it moderate. Let no one conclude, because it has taken place on this Vote, the discussion is one that has any intention of ranging round the President himself in a personal way. It is intended to discuss the general lines of policy of the Executive Council for which every member of the Executive Council has as much responsibility as the President himself, and in some cases some Ministers must bear the heavier burden of that responsibility of censure and of criticism, whatever it may be. This Estimate gives us the only opportunity before the Recess of reviewing the general outline or scope of Government policy. I think it has been a duty to the country, to ourselves and to the Government itself to place that policy under review. If our criticisms are justified it is time to ventilate them. If they are not justified it gives Ministers an opportunity of vindicating the position that we have attacked. President Cosgrave said that all these grounds of contention had arisen within the past four months. He implied that Deputy Esmonde had not discovered the difference between the Saorstát and Denmark until the last four months. He said that within the last four months, since some of us broke with the Government, that Denmark had got ahead of the Free State. If that is to be typical of the way in which serious criticism is dealt with by responsible Ministers, and above all by the head of the Government, and the first officer of the State, if that is the way in which they meet criticisms not intended to be anything other than criticisms which will affect some public service and throw light upon matters of vital importance to the country, not only is this discussion justified but it is long overdue. Unless a change comes over the spirit and the outlook of Ministers it will not be the last discussion of the kind and a resumption of such discussion will take place at no remote date and possibly with different results than they anticipate.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

A great saint, reviewing the course of his life, felt himself called upon to admit that he had done many things which he ought not to have done and left undone many things which he ought to have done. Judging by the few observations that have escaped from Deputy Milroy one gathers that he feels that the same might be said of the Executive Council. They have done many things which they ought not to have done and left undone much that they ought to have done. Other members of his group, or party, or association, rather elaborated the same thing to such an extent, that one hoped in the course of the debate they might leave that point and state just exactly what their own policy was, what their own programme would be in the event of the Motion which they have down for decision by the Dáil being successful. After all we must take it, as Deputy Johnson suggested, that the moving of a Vote of no confidence in the Government involves that those moving that Vote are prepared to take the responsibilities of Government. It might have been helpful to the Dáil in coming to a decision if there had been less of a plethora of adjectives and more of an attempt to elaborate a constructive alternative policy to that which the Executive Council is pursuing, or is alleged to be pursuing.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

took the Chair at this stage.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I have listened, and I am pretty constant in attendance here, to speeches from Deputy McGrath's group, and I have as yet no clear idea of a policy. Abuse by innuendo of certain civil servants is not a national policy. Even suggestions that particular individuals in the Army, or elsewhere, have not been dealt with according to their deserts, is not a national policy.

The only thing that I am quite clear about is that Deputy McGrath's group would not balance their Budget. But that is merely, again, a negation. It is not a positive or constructive national policy to go before the country and say: "Vote for us; we will not balance our Budget." It is not an attractive policy to put before any thinking electorate. Yet, as I say— and I am not attempting to draw a caricature—that is about the only definite thing I have gathered of the policy of this National Group which has indicted the Executive Council to-night. There were times during Deputy Esmonde's speech when I was wondering whether it was the Dáil or the Executive Council he had lost confidence in. There were portions of the speech which certainly suggested that he has lost confidence in the capacity of the Dáil to think matters out to a clear conclusion. He started by suggesting that in his view the Executive Council was not leading the nation, whatever he means by "leading the nation," and that it was being pushed in various directions by various sections. He went on to speak of credit. Credit, he says, according to the French Premier, is merely the scientific translation of the word "confidence," and having stressed that for some time, he said that any action on the part of the Government which tends to turn any section against the Government tends proportionately to lessen the credit of the State.

Comment on this

Against the State.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

The Deputy cannot have it both ways. On one hand we are to be firm; we are to lead the nation; we are not to be pushed about by various sections, and, on the other hand, if we antagonise anybody, to that extent we are lessening the credit of the State.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I must say that I distinctly said that I was referring to any legislation which tended to turn sections of the people against the State, and not exactly against the Executive Council or the Government.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Well, that is a very subtle distinction.

Comment on this

It is a very important distinction. The State and the Executive Council are not the same.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

People in this country have not yet developed the fine political sense of Deputy Esmonde, and I fear that people in this country throughout the last two years have readily turned against the State because of the action of the Government. The Deputy knows that that is true, knows that the people have not distinguished between an act on the part of the Government, or legitimate criticism, or even hostility to the Government, and hostility to the State fabric. When I saw some time ago a motion down in the simple, bald terms that the Executive Council no longer retains the confidence of the Dáil—no reason stated—I took it that Deputies were to be invited to pool their discontents, even though the causes of these discontents might be conflicting. Deputy Johnson, for instance, who might consider, and, in fact, does consider, as he has stated, the moneys voted for relief schemes inadequate, might pool his discontent with Deputy Good or Deputy Hewat, who possibly think they are excessive, and that we were to have that vague general discussion in which people have a variety of motives and a variety of cases without coherent agreement on a policy amongst themselves and were to throw their dice against the Executive Council. That may be a good idea tactically, and I give the Deputy's Group credit that they may be good tacticians, but I doubt if it is helpful. There ought to be a clear issue. There ought to be reasons set out definitely in black and white so that the discussion might centre round them. This discussion to-night ranged over a variety of topics, and I do not know whether even the Deputies in the Group from which the motion emanates are in agreement with regard to all the topics. Deputy Milroy was at some pains to state that it was not over any Army crisis that he found it necessary to part ways with the Executive Council. I do not know, on the other hand, whether all the Deputies of that Group would swallow Deputy Milroy's industrial policy, his policy of whole-hog and cast-iron protection.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation. In the absence of Deputy Milroy, I understood him to say that it was not on the Army crisis only, but that that was one of the many reasons.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I am sorry if I misrepresented him. We may take it that that was the last straw which broke Deputy Milroy's back. But it is difficult when you are dealing with a Group that has put no policy before the people——

Comment on this

We will do that when we get a chance.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Which has not confided any policy to the Dáil, whose sole policy up to the present has been to criticise the Executive Council and to state that they, if and when returned to power, will not balance their Budget. A certain periodical some time ago referred to people in the Dáil as "inverted Micawbers," always on the look out for something to turn down. Deputy Milroy strikes me as answering the definition perfectly in all its fullness. He denounces the Executive Council and all its works and pomps. He sees no good in it. He wants to know what would we say to the electorate if we had to face the people. I have some curiosity as to what the Deputy will say to the electorate. I have no doubt whatever as to what the Executive Council will have to say to the electorate. It is not two years since the Provisional Parliament met on the 9th September, 1922, and although we have been living in somewhat crowded times, with one nail driving out another, Deputies do not forget the conditions that existed when that Provisional Parliament met. Twenty-four short months, and we have accomplished something in the time despite the pessimism of Deputy Milroy and Deputy Esmonde.

Comment on this

On a point of order, at the beginning of my speech I stated that nobody wished to deny credit to the Executive Council for the work it did in 1922-23.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

The Deputy has a peculiar idea of a point of order, sir. I doubt if you will agree with him. The Deputy suggests that he has no fault to find with us in 1922 or 1923 but that we became suddenly futile and corrupt in 1924.

Comment on this

I never used the words "futile or corrupt." I do not see why they should be attributed to me.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Well, it is rather a free translation of the general volume of criticism which came from the Deputy's benches.

Comment on this

Not corrupt.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

What would we say to the people? I think we would say to the people that a State has been established here; that two years ago their right to establish that State was called in question and called in question by force; that that force which was opposing and challenging their right has been defeated and suppressed; that this State is now established and is theirs absolutely and beyond question ——

Comment on this

And the men who did it were demobilised.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

It is so much theirs that they have the right and the power to destroy it. There are various ways of doing that, easy ways; the electorate can take any one of them. One way, perhaps, might be by returning a party pledged not to balance its Budget. Another way might be by returning a party pledged to "terrible and immediate war" with England. There are a variety of ways, and the electorate voting freely and openly without force or threat of force can take any one of them. As to policy, if we have been unable to ward off from the people all the consequences of the criminal folly of the last two years, the question arises—would any other body of men, would Deputy Milroy or Deputy Esmonde or Deputy McGrath have succeeded in warding off these consequences from the people. If we, in common with the people, have to face the fact that the country cannot eat its cake and have it, it means that we are just buying wisdom a little dearer than need have been the case. We have been taunted about an avalanche of green paper, an avalanche of Bills. What were they? The Land Bill, the Railway Bill, the Dairy Produce Bill— Bills aiming at increased productivity and standardisation of products; Bills aiming at bringing to a standstill that process by which our Continental rivals have for the past two or three years been driving us from our main market. This is the green paper that the Deputy objects to. If the Deputy simply thought a little more about these things and attended perhaps, a little more, and realised day by day the importance of the work that the Dáil is transacting, he would not be quite so verbose and quite so sarcastic on the question of this avalanche of green paper.

Comment on this

On a point of information, does the Minister question my attendance during the ordeal of establishing this State which he has described?

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I refer to the Deputy's attendance on the ordinary routine humdrum matters; attendance day by day or week by week.

Comment on this

I think I attended fairly well.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

I think it would be better if the Deputy would not interrupt.

Comment on this

It would be better if the Minister would not malign the Deputy.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

It is not, in fact, good enough that Deputies should aim at a full dress occasion, and in speeches full of sound and fury, signifying nothing, denounce those who are attempting to administer the country according to their interpretation, at any rate, of what the mass mind of the country would wish. Now Deputies may find a certain absence of excitement about Parliamentary work. The best work is not always done in a heated, excited, electric atmosphere. Deputies may find it just a little dull sitting here through a long summer session, legislating for the various requirements of the country. Deputies, from the difference in position, do not realise as closely as Ministers the extent to which various administrative tangles have to be straightened out by means of legislation and a great deal of legislation.

Comment on this

Is it his own supporters the Minister now refers to?

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I am addressing my remarks, for the most part, to Deputy Milroy, who complained of excessive legislation and the great number of Bills that has been found necessary to bring before the Dáil.

Comment on this

I just want to point out it is not true of the members on the Farmers' or Labour Benches.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Finance, Protection, the Army Crisis and the Contracts Committee which, I think, Deputy McCarthy referred to were the main ground of the attack. Now, I am not going again into this question of the attitude of the Executive Council with regard to the Army trouble. I have expressed the view that I consider the report which the Committee presented was a very fair vindication of the whole attitude of the Government towards these troubles. Deputies may, and Deputies do, I know, differ from that view; that cannot be helped. It is too much to expect that about a matter of that kind you would have a unanimous Dáil. But we had the responsibility of acting, and we acted according to our judgment in a difficult and tense situation. I regard the report of the Inquiry Committee as a very substantial vindication and justification of the line we took. I just leave it at that, and Deputy McGrath is welcome to any capital he may wish to make about meetings which he did not attend. I had my own reasons for going to that meeting. At that meeting I took the line which I told Deputy General Mulcahy I would take. If I did not at the next meeting of the Executive Council report there what had transpired, it was because I regarded my acceptance of the invitation to attend that meeting as having some implication of confidence.

My main object in speaking to-night was to suggest quite seriously that all Parties here in the Dáil ought to have a programme and policy known to the public so that the electorate may generally have an opportunity from time to time of comparing that policy and programme with the policy and programme that is being carried out by the Party actually in power. There is no such satisfactory position at present with regard to the Party from which this particular censure Motion emanates. They took ground at first under the title of a Republican Party.

Comment on this

That is not true. It was a newspaper that attached that label to the Party.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

And subsequently they became——

Comment on this

I ask that the Minister be called upon to withdraw that statement. He said that our Party took refuge behind such-and-such. I contradict that statement and say it is not true.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I did not say that the Deputy took refuge behind anything.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

The Deputy has made his position quite clear.

Comment on this

The implication in the Minister's statement must be withdrawn. The Minister has no more right in this Dáil than any other Deputy.

Comment on this

On a point of order, was not Deputy Milroy still a member of the Government Party when that label was attached?

Comment on this

I have the right to defend my colleagues. Is the expression withdrawn?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

Order, order.

Comment on this

I want to know if the Minister has withdrawn his statement.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

You did not give the Minister a chance of withdrawing it.

Comment on this

I am giving him an opportunity of withdrawing it now.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I did not consider that I had slandered the Deputy or his associates. I was stating what I believed, that they took ground first under the title of a Republican Party.

Comment on this

That is not so and it has been denied. I deny it and the statement must be withdrawn.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

The Minister must be allowed to finish his speech.

Comment on this

He will not be allowed to go on in the way he is going.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I have not the least difficulty or objection in withdrawing the remark that the Deputy's Party first took ground as a Republican Party and then changed their title. I have it now on the authority, I think, of almost every member of the group that that is not so, and I accept that unreservedly.

Comment on this

I am sorry I was not in the House and did not hear what the Minister said.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

The incident is now closed.

Comment on this

Are we to take it that the Party is not a Republican Party?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

We cannot discuss the matter further.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I ask the Deputy to explain.

Comment on this

We will explain the position when we meet the Minister and his Party outside.

Comment on this

I would like to explain that this does not mean that I am not a Republican.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I desire to ask what Deputy McCarthy means by saying that he is quite ready to meet the Minister and his Party outside?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. P. HOGAN (Clare) Labour Party

Would someone define what is a Repulican Party?

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

I hope the Deputy will be better able to explain the position outside than he has explained it inside the House, because it does come down to that. The Dáil is asked to express no confidence in the Executive Council. Neither the President nor any member of the Executive Council would take the line that no mistakes have been made, that everything we have done has been right or that we have done everything which we ought to have done. But those who challenge the Government must put forward an intelligent, alternative policy. They must not just talk negatives about not balancing the Budget. We must know what their general national policy is, what their economic policy is, and whether we are to take it that Deputy Milroy's hide-bound protection policy is the policy of the group or merely the whim of an individual, and, generally, what they are going to do which the Government left undone, and what mistakes of the Government they are going to redress and set right. Deputy Esmonde talked vaguely on finance.

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

Yes, vaguely; but neither Deputy Esmonde nor any other member of his group met the point of the President that some day a cheque has to be drawn, and that if you have not money to meet it you must have credit, and if you have no credit you will get into difficulties by drawing the cheque. The Deputy, surely, ought to recognise that whether you go to the public generally, or whether you go to the banks, a question like that will be asked. Deputies are inclined to forget that either by taxation or by borrowing money must be raised to meet all the high-sounding demands that are put forward here from time to time, and to realise all the wonderful dreams that are recited here. There are complaints about excessive taxation and complaints about high taxation, but I have not heard from any quarter of the Dáil that taxation ought to be increased. The alternative is borrowing, and Deputies should come down to earth and say when and where and at what rate of interest the borrowing is to be done; whether it is to be done at home or abroad. If it is to be done at home, they should ask themselves whether if they had a few hundred or a few thousand pounds that they were anxious to invest securely and reproductively, whether they would invest that in the Home Loan and whether they would advise their mothers or their sisters to do so. It is by facing the position in that way that Deputies will get the proper perspective.

If a five per cent. loan from any other country were floated here to-morrow what questions would we ask ourselves if we as individuals were thinking of investing it? We would want to know what kind of people they were, whether they were hard-working people and whether there were stable conditions or whether they were little politico-military plots and intrigues calculated to bring about a serious eruption at any time. Credit, the Deputy said, is a scientific translation of the word "confidence." I rather agree with Deputy Johnson that credit is simply an intelligent anticipation of future production. Now certain conditions are requisite to steady production and to increase production, conditions of ordinary security, conditions of sanity and conditions in which people who have money lying idle in the banks at present will take it out and use it. We cannot just have it both ways; we cannot have the luxury of being always in semi-revolutionary conditions and at the same time having capital forging full steam ahead to-that the Deputy and his party things that the Deputy and his party ought to chew hard, and ask themselves to what extent they, as individuals, or as public men, have contributed to that lack of confidence in the country: they ought to ask themselves what they can do, what would most contribute to a restoration of confidence in the country. The country pays. Individuals are foolish, but the country pays and will always pay till the end of the chapter, pay in injured credit, pay in compensation as we are paying every day for the fellows who burn farm houses for sport, as one of them said when he was indicted. It is the people that pay, the ordinary people who are not idealists and consequently do not burn houses, wreck railways, or strip the Civic Guard, or do heroic things like that. The ordinary people just pay, and then they are supposed to pat people on the back for their heroics afterwards. Deputy Esmonde had better settle down to the fact that public life is not going to be one round of excitement and melodramatic votes of censure or anything like that, but rather that it is a hard plodding game. It may be a fine thing in the realm of sport to create a difficult situation and then display your agility by vaulting lightly over the balustrades, but in public matters that is not quite so fine.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan MINISTER for INDUSTRY and COMMERCE (Mr. McGilligan)

The Deputy who opened the discussion here to-night is a very romantic figure in this House.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I am glad to have that disagreement early, in view of the remarks I was going to make on his romanticism. I was going to take him back to the days of chivalry and remind him of a knight who saw a turreted castle in every windmill, and of an earlier hero who imagined armies in every flock of sheep. While the one couched his lance and tilted against harmless windmills, the other in his frenzy drew the short stabbing sword and attacked mere passive muttons. What has the Deputy done to-night? Let me take one of the vital arguments in his vote of censure. He objects to the quotation of old Statutes at the head of each estimate, and he sees in this, as Deputy Milroy would say, a serious ground for grave indictment against the President and the Executive Council.

Comment on this

No, I must protest: that is not the case.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The Deputy is full of disagreements to-night, but he put forward as an argument that these quotations were used. I put it to him that he is just the sort of person for whom the quotations are intended— persons who need certain little signposts and guides so that they may know, and realise, what are the statutory purposes for which certain money is vested. That is one of the arguments against us. One of the arguments why this vote should be referred back is because the Executive Council has not taken care to cut out from the heading of the estimates certain references such as the Eighth of George the Fifth and so on.

Comment on this

That is not one of my objections to the Executive Council. I mentioned that incidentally, but it is not one of my objections.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If the Deputy has overstated his case, that is his fault. He has thrown out certain arguments, and it is open to me to attack him on them. However, he seems irritable at having any stress laid upon this particular point, and so I leave it. It has been put that the Executive Council should call in experts to advise the Ministers upon their financial policy. There is, of course, an insinuation and an innuendo there that the people in charge of the finances in this particular Government are not experts.

Comment on this
A DEPUTY

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I am glad to hear that, because one of the Deputies did say that there was nothing derogatory meant in asking for experts to be brought in, so now we see there is disagreement amongst the group.

Comment on this

I think it was Deputy Major Cooper that made that remark.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I assert that there are experts in the Finance Department, and I say further that these men, thinking it in no way derogatory to themselves, and the Minister for Finance without thinking it in any way derogatory to himself, have called on banking men, and business men, and commercial men in this country to advise and state their views about certain points of financial policy under discussion. It may be of interest to the Deputy who raised this point to know that the financial policy of this State has been approved and endorsed by experts, and by financial journals, in the United States and in England and on the Continent. And since the Deputy who introduced this motion built so much upon what the French Premier said, it may be of interest to him to know that a French financial paper has definitely and specifically set out its approval of the financial policy of this Government.

The Deputy has asked that the Budget should be divided into two sections: that there should be what he calls the ordinary Budget charges or ordinary Budget items, and extraordinary Budget items; and certain details were given as to what he meant. This is a rather intricate and long subject to enter into at this hour, but I want to remove one or two misconceptions which the Deputy has in this matter. Certain calculations have been spoken of, and in the calculation of the revenue, as such, there has been included certain items which are not to count as ordinary revenue in this country at all. There is a certain payment —Customs and Excise—for a particular year which was not our money. It was collected here and simply paid over, and that represented a considerable sum of money. On the other side, the questions of pensions has been tackled. Now I put it to the Deputy this way: that there is a big sum paid out and estimated for here as a result of pensions that fall due for payment owing to the Treaty, and, against that, there must be set the fact that for the new Force established, the Civic Guard, the pensions paid there or due to be paid are very, very small, and that there are certain items of expenditure which have not yet reached their height. If we do include at this particular moment a certain sum for pensions, say, which are not a normal item in the country, we must remember that the normal pensions expenditure or charge has not at all reached anything like its height, and that we are not normal in that respect, so that to arrive at normality you must set off one against the other. We have in fact, here, by the actual setting off of these items, arrived at something closely approximating to what the Deputy calls his ordinary Budget.

Comment on this

I specifically excluded pensions from the ordinary Budget which I suggested.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The Deputy left that point to speak of the Geddes Committee which he asked to have set up in order to cut down expenditure and to reduce our future liability under a particular Article of the Treaty. In answer to that I may say that our commitments under Article X. of the Treaty are no great cause of concern at the moment. I cannot understand how the Deputy can reconcile his attitude in regard to this appointment of the Geddes Committee to cut down expenditure, when he also speaks of the extremely stingy financial policy of this State, and of the paltry schemes for the relief of unemployment. The two matters require a certain balancing and I presume the Deputy will give it later.

Take this adjective "paltry" which has been applied to the Government in approaching various problems. Has the Deputy any conception of what money has been voted, and is being voted, and which will eventually go to the relief of unemployment in the country? The sum of £2,000,000 has been voted for the repair of roads, bridges, and drainage schemes.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

resumed the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

A sum of over seven million pounds was voted for property losses, a sum of over a quarter million for housing schemes, a sum of almost £200,000 for works included in the Public Works Vote, almost a quarter of a million was included in the Army Estimates for building, a quarter of a million for relief schemes —ear-marked specially—and the Unemployment Insurance Act which recently was passed and which entails a charge for the moment on the Exchequer of at least another £260,000, while the Fund at the moment is in debt to the Exchequer to the amount of £877,000. The Trades Facilities Bill, at present in the Seanad, involves a commitment to the extent of one million.

Comment on this

Is it one million pounds expenditure?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I did not say the money has been expended. I say a million pounds has been set aside under the Trades Loan Guarantee Bill.

Comment on this

Does the Minister mean to say that seven millions which has been set aside for Property Losses Compensation has anything to do with the Relief of Unemployment? If so, how much of it has to do with it?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I think if the Deputy will get particulars of the extent to which the Reinstatement Conditions apply to these six or seven millions, and if he takes into account, further, that payments to date for Property Losses and Personal Injuries amount to over five millions, he will see that this affects unemployment. I wonder, after that series of Votes, is the Dáil going to agree with Deputy Esmonde that the policy of this Government towards unemployment has been paltry? We are told again that we ought not balance our Budget—

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

No policy is put forward except what Deputy Milroy would call "paralysing negation." Not to balance your Budget is apparently the policy. I wonder does the Dáil realise how paralysing——

Comment on this

The statement has been repeated parrot-like by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Justice, that the policy of the National Group is founded on "We will not balance our Budget." Will the Minister inform us which of the speakers to-night from this Group either advocated that or defined the policy af the National Group as such? If he cannot give the name of the Deputy who stated that, I ask him to withdraw both the implication and the allegation.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The Deputy was responsible for two phrases: "paralysing negation" and "dull benumbing argument." I do not know what more "paralysing negation" there can be than this phrase about the non-balancing of the Budget.

Comment on this

Will the Minister answer me the question: which of the speakers in the National Group has defined our policy as "We will not balance our Budget"?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Deputy Milroy cannot go on interrupting. He made a speech of an hour's duration and that will have to satisfy him. The Minister is in order in using reasonable arguments. The point Deputy Milroy is making is a matter of argument and not of explanation.

Comment on this

It is not; it is a matter of fact.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Deputy should not stand up while I am speaking. He must sit down, and he must accept my definition of these things. When the Minister has concluded, I will allow Deputy Milroy to make a personal explanation, but he cannot keep up a running fire of argument while the Minister is speaking. It would be impossible to conduct a debate in that way.

Comment on this

Perhaps I might intervene with a view to having the business properly conducted in future. Since this debate opened there has been by each of the Ministers, including the President, half a dozen mis-statements or mis-quotations, whether deliberate or otherwise, with the result that the patience of Deputies concerned has been so tried that they must interrupt. I do not believe there has been any debate ——

Comment on this
Mr. O'HIGGINS

On a point of order, sir ——

Comment on this

Mine is a point of order. I do not know any debate where there was such a number of mis-statements, whether it was that Ministers deliberately set out to do it or not, I do not know.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I have said here before that it is in the nature of things that votes of censure should be moved on any Government. It is in the nature of things that Ministers should be criticised, and it is in the nature of things that in an important debate people should quote other Deputies in a way other Deputies do not like. In an Assembly like this, Deputies will have to restrain their tempers and listen to what their opponents have to say, unless it is a matter which concerns a Deputy's personal honour. It is quite open to a Deputy to state that the Executive Council is a most incompetent body. It would be out of order for a Deputy to state that a particular Minister was incompetent in his private affairs or something of that kind. The only real matter of explanation is a personal one.

Comment on this

I would like to know if a Deputy is misrepresented, has he the right to correct the misrepresentation?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Not ad infinitum, so to speak.

Comment on this

But if the misrepresentation is ad infinitum, what happens?

Comment on this

I think I am entitled to ask for the future guidance of the House, if it is right to say that criticism is prompted by corrupt motives.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I was not here to hear that point raised.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I am being interrupted at the moment, and I did not say anything as to corrupt motives.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Minister might as well conclude now, so that he will not be interrupted any more.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move to report progress.

Comment on this