We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

DAIL IN COMMITTEE. - LOCAL GOVERNMENT BILL, 1924.—THIRD STAGE RESUMED.

Contributions 1–151 of 305. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Local Government Bill 1924
Withdrawn

No. 18 of 1924 ›

Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE (Mr. Hogan) Cumann na nGaedheal

I move amendment 50:—

In line 32 to delete the word "person" and to insert in lieu thereof the word "officer," and to delete the words, in lines 32 and 33, "served as an officer," and to insert in lieu thereof the words "devoted the whole of his time to the service."

This is a purely formal amendment to preserve the continuity of wording and to make the Bill, as it were, consistent. The persons concerned are always referred to as "officers." The section, as amended, would read: "and the said expression also includes any officer who has devoted the whole of his time to the service of one or more committees or joint committees appointed for the purpose of the Agricultural and Technical Instruction (Ireland) Act, 1899. for a continuous period of not less than ten years." In view of the discussion yesterday evening, the amendment speaks for itself.

Comment on this

I am in favour of this amendment, which restricts pensions to whole-time officers.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

I move amendment 51:—

In lines 35 and 36 to delete the words "for a continuous period of not less than ten years."

Deputies who scrutinise this section closely will see that before an instructor or any person engaged under the Agriculture and Technical Instruction (Ireland) Act, 1899, becomes pensionable, he must for a continuous period of not less than ten years, serve in a capacity other than pensionable. Deputies will notice that the expression, "pensionable officer," means any permanent officer who devotes the whole of his time to the service of one or more local authorities. We are anxious to find out why there should be this invidious difference in the case of men highly skilled and with high technical qualifications. We want to know why they should be put in an unfavourable position, as compared with men who bring no technical or special qualifications to their work. The Minister spoke last night about county councils, owing to the general poverty of the country, being unable to proceed with some of the technical schemes. That is my recollection of what he said. I hope I misinterpret him, because I think it is a very sad commentary on his administration and on the administration of the councils in the country, if the technical schemes have to go by the board. Remember, that those people who are employed under the Act of 1899, imparting agricultural and technical instruction, are really the best asset the nation possesses. In them, and in them alone-and, without hesitation, I say in them even more than in the Minister for Local Government —is there hope that this nation will pull itself out of the slough. Yet what do we find? That they are to be in an unfavourable position as regards terms and conditions of service.

It is curious that the men whom the nation needs most are to be put in an unfavourable position. They are deterred, as it were—at least the best of them—from finding employment in their own country. While I have every desire for economy in this country, and while I am not anxious to increase the pension list, I feel that the little money that would be given in this instance would be money well spent, and that the opposite course is false economy. Once they are appointed, I contend that these men should become pensionable officers, and that they should have at least equality of status with any official in the Local Government service —any junior clerk, for instance, under a county council. Remember that to become a pensionable officer does not mean that the person will forthwith draw a pension. In other words, this term "pensionable officer" is only a qualifying term. It is a bad thing to put a discount—a very large discount— as the Minister has done, on technical education, which is of the highest economic importance. I ask the Minister to reconsider his attitude, and to make agricultural and technical instructors pensionable from the date of their appointment by the county committees.

Comment on this

I must say that I am astonished to see this particular Deputy come forward, for the first time, I believe, since he entered the Dáil, as the champion of the rights of people who are anxious to make a very liberal use of the ratepayers' money. I do not think the Deputy has a very clear idea of the situation with regard to those particular officers. The ordinary officer of a local authority under this Act and under previous Acts had to fulfil two conditions, in order to become a pensionable officer: he had to be a whole-time officer and he had to be a permanent officer. Those officers, as the the Act stands, are only whole-time officers. They are not permanent officers. If a committee appoints those officers as permanent officers, then they come outside this section altogether. It will no longer apply to them. It is precisely because they are not permanent officers that it is necessary to put in some restriction of this kind, which will enable us to arrive at some definite basis to decide whether or not they are permanent officers. As the law stands at present, those officers are appointed from year to year. Some of them are permanent, but a great number of them are only temporary. If we did not put in some proviso of this kind, it would be open to those officers to come up after a year or two years and claim a gratuity under the Act. They are in no different position from the ordinary civil servant. A civil servant does not acquire pensionable rights until he has given ten years' service. We are putting those officials in exactly the same position. If they are in their positions for ten years, they qualify in the same way as if they were permanent officers. I do not think that can be construed in any way as a hardship on those officers.

There has been considerable activity, I am aware, on the part of those officials to get Deputies to concede this demand. But it would be a very unfair demand. It would put them in a privileged position, if officers who are really temporary were allowed pensionable rights. It would put them in a position which no other officer enjoys at the present moment.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I am surprised that the Minister has resisted this very reasonable amendment. He says it would be unfair and that these men would be put in a privileged position if the requirements of the amendment were conceded. As a matter of fact, it is the other way about. They are only asking what the Minister is giving to all officers of local bodies— even to junior clerks of county councils, as Deputy Hogan has said. They are not asking for any privilege. They are asking merely to be put in the same position as other officers. What is the result of putting in this clause that the amendment seeks to delete? It is that if one of these officers, the importance of whose duties has been so much spoken of, is incapacitated owing to a breakdown in health and has less than ten years' service, he can get no gratuity. There is no question of pension here, because a man under ten years' service does not get a pension; it is a question of gratuity. If a man who is an officer under the Local Government authorities, who is a junior clerk of a county council, for example, breaks down in health after he has given good service—even less than ten years' service—he is entitled to a gratuity. But if he be an officer of a technical committee he gets no gratuity. The Minister has not attempted to defend that position, and surely, the grant of gratuity in these circumstances to these men would not put them in a privileged position.

The gratuity would amount to one-sixth, or one month's salary for each year of service. There is just another possibility that if a man is removed from his office for a cause other than misconduct or incapacity he may be granted a gratuity, but the Minister says it would be open to him to go out after a short service and claim a pension. Surely that is not the case. The Minister founds his arguments entirely on the meaning of the word permanent. The facts are, as the Minister for Lands and Agriculture told us yesterday evening that the officers are, in fact, permanent; everybody knows they are. Technically they have to be reappointed, and the Minister will find that in many cases that technicality is not observed.

There is no question of reappointment year by year, in many cases at all events. That technicality being there, the fact is that the schemes are continuous and have been for the last twenty years with practically no exceptions. We all can see those schemes of technical and agricultural education are and will be permanent, as permanent, at least, as the Minister's provisions in the Bill. I can see no justification for putting these officers in a less favourable position than the less important officers of local authorities. I trust the Minister will see his way to accept this amendment, which is quite a reasonable one.

Comment on this

I have not been approached by any officers of any kind whatever, but I want to give conditional support to the amendment. Though it goes further than I desire, it does get rid of one word in the section that I very much dislike; that is the word "continuous"—for a "continuous period of not less than 10 years." The result of the insertion of the word "continuous" would be to debar from pension or gratuity any of these officers who may have joined the army for service in the European War or for National Army work, even though they did it with the consent of the county committees. Whatever view may be taken of the merits of the European War, I do not think it can be denied that anybody who joined the Army did not do it for their own pleasure or comfort and that they would have a pleasanter and easier life if they remained in their officers. Therefore, I do not think they should be penalised, as this section, unconsciously, I think, might penalise them.

If the Minister will tell me that on Report he will bring in an amendment to meet such hard cases—they are not numerous, I admit—then I will not vote with my friend, Deputy Connor Hogan. I do say this opens rather a wide door to pensions, and I rather wish Deputy White was here in order that we might have his opinion on the subject. In order to get rid of the word "continuous" I shall support the amendment.

Comment on this

There is a further consideration in respect to the phrase, "continuous service." If officers resign from one county and take up service in another county, that cannot be said to be continuous service, I think, under the section. We had better confine ourselves to the question of whether there should be a demand for a ten years' period before making it possible for a local authority to pay to such an officer, who has become unable to carry on his work through sickness, a gratuity. It is not a question of pensions; it is a question of a gratuity limited by the provisions of the Bill, a gratuity which may be granted to a person who ceases to hold office owing to sickness or some other reason which would justify him in claiming consideration, and which would justify the local authority and the Minister in consenting to it. We know from all that has been said, particularly by the Minister for Lands and Agriculture yesterday, the conditions under which many of these men carry on their business. We know the conditions are such as may easily incapacitate them.

Unless this phrase is deleted it will not be possible for a local body to give a gratuity to such a man unless he has had ten years' continuous service. If a man has anything from five to nine years' service, and breaks down in health as a consequence of his work, the local authority would not be able to pay him a gratuity. I think that is decidedly unfair and unreasonable. We should at least leave an officer of that kind in a position to claim some consideration from his employers, even though he has not been in their employment for ten years. I would ask Deputies to think of that aspect of the question.

Comment on this

I agree with previous speakers. It is very unfair to differentiate between this class of officer and other civil servants. If anything, this class of officers should be accorded better treatment. Take the case of county instructors. They have to undergo special training, and have to be highly skilled in the different branches of agriculture and the subjects which they have to teach. It ought to be the Government's aim to attract the very best brains available for this class of work. It is very poor encouragement to ask a young man to take up a position like that with the knowledge that after spending eight or nine years, say, and then having a breakdown in health, he would be discharged without a halfpenny compensation. Some doubt has been expressed as to whether these officers are permanent or not. If they are not, steps should be taken to make them permanent. Otherwise you will not attract the best material to this service.

Comment on this

The Committee can do that.

Comment on this

Yes. I may say, in conclusion, that I thoroughly agree with the previous speakers that this amendment ought to be accepted.

Comment on this

I have tried to make it clear that the committees have power to make officers permanent if they so desire. If they make them permanent they are outside this clause, and they come under a general provision of the section. They are permanent whole-time officers and as such have the same pensionable rights and the same right to a gratuity as any other officer; but there are particular circumstances where a committee may want to appoint an officer. Those schemes are not permanent; they are temporary. Committees may drop the scheme after one or two years. If the amendment is accepted it will mean that whether a local committee desire it or not, they will have to grant a gratuity to this man, even if they have him for only one year. That is what I wish to avoid.

If a man has served with other committees for ten years, then he qualifies for a pension. He is in the same position as if he was recognised as a permanent officer. He qualifies irrespective of whether the committee want him to be a permanent officer or not. That is the sole object of this section. With regard to Deputy Cooper's point, officers of local bodies serving with armies up to the present have been granted special leave, and I am not aware of any circumstances where an officer has not been granted pensionable service, or where the period did not count as pensionable service in cases where he was on active service, whether in the European War or in the National Army. If Deputy Cooper has any particular case——

Comment on this

I have no particular case; I was only apprehensive that it might happen under this section.

Comment on this

Under the law as it stands at present, they get special leave and it counts as service, so I do not think there is anything in that particular point.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I am not quite clear as to the Minister's explanation. He says it is open to any committee to make an officer permanent. If that is the case, was there any necessity for bringing in this at all? Are there any officers permanent, in the sense which the Minister conveys, under these committees? Whatever is done in practice, the theory of the matter is each year those officers are supposed to be appointed as a matter of course. That was the way the law stood from the beginning, when the Act setting up the Department was put in force. If that is the position, what is the point in the Minister's statement about the power of committees to make those officers permanent?

Comment on this

The committees have power to appoint those officers permanently. Their salaries are only from year to year, but if an officer is appointed permanently he will come under the Pensions Act or the gratuity section of that Act in the ordinary way.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say whether, in fact, there is any considerable number of officers under a Department in that category of permanent officers?

Comment on this

There is quite a number.

Comment on this

Does the Minister say the majority, or any big proportion of them, are such?

Comment on this

The big proportion; I could not say majority.

Comment on this

Does that mean then if a scheme were scrapped at the end of a year, as conceivably it might be under regular arrangements, that the officers would be still permanent officers though the scheme is not carried on?

Comment on this

That could be under the present law.

Comment on this

I think the Minister had better make further inquiries.

Comment on this

That is the fact.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 16
·
Níl 24
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Peter Hughes MINISTER for DEFENCE (Mr. P. Hughes) Cumann na nGaedheal

I move on behalf of the Minister for Lands and Agriculture:

"To insert in line 36, page 19, after the word ‘years' the words ‘notwithstanding that such appointment was or is renewable periodically.'"

The meaning of the amendment is to put all those men, whether they are full-time officers or men who are renewed periodically, on the one footing.

Comment on this

Does the amendment mean that it will not be possible to make what is know as a temporary appointment?

Comment on this

It means that there are certain men in certain counties whose offices are renewable, and in other places there are men whose offices are not renewable. In my own county there are men whose offices for the last six or seven years have not been renewed.

Comment on this

Supposing an experimental class was tried for one year and it was decided not to continue the classes, what would be the position of the teacher?

Comment on this

Section 35 says "the expression ‘pensionable officer' also includes any person who has served as an officer of one or more committees or joint committees appointed for the purposes of the Agriculture and Technical Instruction (Ireland) Act, 1899, for a continuous period of not less than ten years and the terms of whose appointment do not expressly preclude him from claiming or receiving a pension." The Committee need not have a pensionable officer if they desire.

Comment on this

It would then be possible under the terms of the appointment to exclude a teacher who would be engaged for one year from the pensions scheme.

Comment on this

Notwithstanding the acceptance of this amendment, I am still doubtful about the position of a person whose appointment ought to be renewed periodically but who may have had a gap of a month or two between his service with one county authority and another. For practical purposes it is continuous service, but legally it is not continuous service. There is a break, and that break would debar a man from being eligible for advantages under this provision. The amendment, so far as it goes, is acceptable, but it does not remove the fault that this phrase "continuous service" involves. I would like to hear from the Minister whether it is his intention to debar from the rights under this Bill an official who may have had a break between one employment and another in technical or agricultural instruction, as between one county employer and another county employer. If there is any break at all, apparently, the effect of this section, even with the amendment, would be to debar him. Is that the intention of the Minister?

Comment on this

If there is a definite break in the service, whether of a week or of a month, it would debar him. We must have certain rules and regulations if we are to carry on with anything like efficiency.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Assuming, for instance, that an officer is a headmaster of a technical school under a county committee, and he severs his connection with that committee at the end of the school year, but takes up duty with another committee, say at the beginning of the next school year, in October, will the period that he is out of service break his continuity of service for the purpose of this regulation?

Comment on this

Deputies are now beginning to narrow the point at which we come to a situation in which we would almost want a judge and jury to adjudicate. In that particular case I do not think that it would constitute a break, because he would be giving service at the time that that service was required. I do not think that it would be necessary for him to remain in the service of the authority during the period when he would not be required to give service.

Comment on this

Could the Minister help us in this? I understand that many technical officers are employed at monthly, not yearly, salaries. If there is a break in the receipt of salaries any time within ten years, and if there is loss of one month's salary for any reason, that is a break and nullifies the man's service so far as the section is concerned. I could understand it if such a man was appointed always at a yearly salary, and became permanently appointed, but we are not dealing with permanent officers, as hitherto understood. We are considering persons who have not been classed hitherto as permanent officers. If there is a break at any period after nine years, if there is a break even of one month, there is not going to be any benefit to that teacher under the Bill. The amendment, although it speaks of renewal periodically, has not covered that fault in the section which is a fault that may involve very grave hardships.

Comment on this

I do not think that it is a fault. It happens in the Civil Service. A break of a month is a considerable break.

Comment on this

They are employed on a yearly salary.

Comment on this

That would not make a difference. It would be a break and would disqualify them for pensionable rights.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

It would not have the same effect, as civil servants are pensionable from the day they are established, and it will only shorten their service by the length of the break. This, however, is a different position, and I would ask the Minister to look into this question between this and the next stage. I quite see that it may not be possible to give a definite assurance on the matter now, but I suggest it is not at all the same position as that of civil servants, because in this case the ten years' continuous service is necessary to qualify for pensions. A man may have ten years' service, and there may be a break of a month. Then he has to go ten years again before he becomes pensionable, and if there is again a break he ceases to become pensionable.

Comment on this

Is it not his own act that disqualifies him?

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Not necessarily. He may have been unavoidably absent for a week.

Comment on this

Is it not a reasonable principle that when a man goes into service as a pensionable officer, he knows whether his office is pensionable? If you broaden it out so that a man is brought in for a temporary purpose, and in the ordinary course of events the temporary position extends over a long time, I say that he never came in with the idea of getting a pension.

Comment on this

Deputy Hewat should try to direct his mind to the section under discussion. We are dealing with the position of employees of a Committee of Agriculture and Technical Instruction, and the whole basis of this discussion is on what has been brought in by the Ministry to allow what might be called a fault in the original purpose to be remedied. When this Act was brought into operation, persons were employed, and it was not known whether they were going to be permanent employees or not. It was purely experimental, and it has been going on in an experimental way for twenty-five years. People have been employed on monthly salaries, say, for a session—employed periodically—but possibly as between one session and another, or one authority and another, and notwithstanding that they have been employed in this national service for quite a long period, there may have been breaks. The fact that there was a break of that kind ought not to disqualify such a person from obtaining whatever benefit it is intended to give under this Bill. Deputy Hewat does not want any benefit to be given, and, therefore, he is against anything giving a pension, gratuity, or allowance, because it is not in the bond. Deputy Hewat will perhaps be reminded of that on some other occasion.

The Dáil has not taken that rigid line. It does not say that because something is not in the bond it cannot consider it. It is agreed, in effect, to bring in these officers of the county committees of agriculture and technical instruction. The proposition before us is to allow benefit to be given to persons whose employment has been renewed periodically, but it still leaves the defect that if there is at any time within a period of ten years a break, perhaps by reason of a change from one authority to another, then there shall be no benefit to be derived. I press the Minister to think of this matter. The period of ten years, surely, is long enough in all conscience, and even if the word "continuous" was crossed out, and the man served fifteen years' non-continuous service, surely you will allow him to be brought in. Under this provision as it stands he will not be brought in.

Comment on this
Peter Hughes MINISTER for DEFENCE (Mr. Hughes) Cumann na nGaedheal

I am puzzled to know how Deputy Johnson's argument would work out in the case of a man appointed by one authority and working with it for three or four years, but then breaks his engagement and after a month or so is employed by another authority. Is the authority with which he was last working obliged to pay his pension for the entire period of service? If there is a break between session and session with one authority, I do not think that that could be considered to be a break in the ordinary sense.

Comment on this

Ask the Minister.

Comment on this

The difficulty I see is in the case of a man working for two authorities and claiming his pension after ten years. Is the authority for which he worked last to pay his full pension?

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I think the Minister for Defence might read the Bill and see the provision made for men who change from one authority to another without any break. The difficulty which he mentions as being likely to arise has already been provided for. The point about which we are speaking is where a break occurs in the service.

Comment on this

I think that the difficulty mentioned by Deputy Johnson is brought about by applying pensions to a system to which it was never intended to apply them. Let me give an instance of that. In every one of these committees there are experimental classes, and additional teachers are brought in each year, and if each one of them is to become a pensionable officer it will be impossible for the committee to continue experimenting.

Comment on this

Ten years' service.

Comment on this

Yes, but if you bring him in for one year, you cannot fairly dispense with his services at the end of a year if he is a whole-time teacher. It is the same with any other official employed by a local authority, as once he comes in and works for a period he achieves certain rights, and the difficulty is to get rid of him, because the moment you do so you deprive him of something to which he is entitled. I think that that is one reason why it was never intended to apply pensions to these officers. It is only within the last few years that that has been done. I think that in working out this proposal and by trying to benefit the officials you will do a serious injury to educational work. I am certain that that will be the result of the action of the Ministry.

Comment on this

Regarding Deputy O'Connell's statement that there is nothing in this amendment that would not apply to any official under a local authority, an officer under a local authority who has a break in his term has no longer pensionable rights. This ten years is only a test of permanency. If he has not ten years' service without a break, he is not a permanent officer and would not be entitled to a pension.

Comment on this

I have not been approached on this matter by anybody, but I was speaking recently to a man in the County Cork whom I knew to be a technical instructor at one time in Belfast, and later under the County Leitrim authority. He is now under a West Cork authority. Within twelve years, these three authorities have employed that man. He has been continuously working under the schemes of the Department of Agriculture, with possibly, breaks as between one employer and another, because he desired to have wider experience in different parts of the country. Such a man as that I can conceive would be debarred under this section, although his whole service for that period has been as a teacher under the Department of Agriculture schemes. If for any reason there is a break in his employment with the Belfast Technical Instruction Committee, the County Leitrim Committee, or the County Cork Committee, of a week or a month, under this clause he would be debarred, and that is an unfair proposition.

Comment on this

I would like to thank Deputy Johnson for his support in a matter that came up earlier. I think the Dáil will remember I suggested that officials of the Department of Technical Instruction should be brought under the Minister for Education. It seems to me that Deputy Johnson's argument has been strongly in favour of that. Where a man is transferred, if he is under a central authority like the Ministry of Education, from one county to another his service is continuous, but by bringing him under this Local Government Bill you create the very difficulty of which Deputy Johnson has given us an instance.

Comment on this

That is a separate question.

Comment on this

It is pertinent, I think, to what Deputy Johnson said in the matter. If I am out of order in dealing with it I am only following the generally good example, though in this case it must be wrong, of Deputy Johnson himself. Obviously in the particular case to which Deputy Johnson has referred it would be great hardship if the man were not pensionable. The remark has been made that I am out against pensions, but that is not right. I am not out against pensions, but I am out against an extension of the pension system beyond the radius which has been laid down as applying to all the Government officials who are permanent officials. When you begin to deal with the question of a man who is brought into the service in a temporary capacity, and you try to establish a permanent status for him without some regulations, I think you are running a very grave danger of going rather far in the matter.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

We are in the peculiar position of discussing an amendment on which there is general agreement, and on that amendment discussing the words "continuous period," which do not occur in the amendment at all. I suggest that we should go on with the amendment, and on the next Stage put up another amendment dealing with these words "continuous period," and on that particular amendment in the Report Stage, come to a conclusion on the different points of view expressed. We cannot get any further now with the discussion on the words "continuous period" apparently.

Comment on this

I move:—

In line 37, after the word "pension," to insert the words "and also includes any employee other than an officer who has been employed by a local body for not less than three years continuously.

The object of this amendment is to give local authorities the right to grant pensions to their employees. Most local authorities would like to give these pensions to employees who spent a lifetime in their service. Some of these authorities have Acts which authorise them to do this. Other local authorities, although they have no special Acts in some cases have given pensions to their employees, and sanction was forthcoming from the old L.G.B., but owing to the new Local Government Department insisting upon the letter of the law in regard to those things, no local authority, even if it wishes to give pensions to old employees, can do so. We all know that in a service such as this men enter the service of local authorities at an early age, and generally work on them some forty or fifty years. At the end of that time, if they leave their employment after a lengthy period of good and faithful service, many of them have to go into the county home. These men who have done their part in building up the country, and have given good service, at the end are forced to go into the county home and associate with perhaps undesirables who were never of much good to the country. That, I think, is a deplorable position. They deserve better treatment than that. We have been discussing pensions for other people for the last couple of days, and I claim that this class of people are as much entitled to pensions as any other official. They do work which is just as necessary as that done by pensionable officials, and give just as good and faithful service. I cannot see why they should be treated in a different manner. Some local authorities such as the Dublin Corporation that was, the Cork Corporation, and a number of others, I think, have a right to give pensions to their employees. The reason that the period of three years is mentioned is that it is necessary to distinguish between merely casual employees and the permanent employees. This three years' period is in practice adopted by the Ministry of Industry and Commerce in granting certificates of exemption under the Unemployment Insurance Act. When that Ministry grants exemption under that Act after three years, I think it is done on the assumption that those exempted can be classed as permanent employees.

I think it is a great hardship on the class of people I have referred to, who give long and faithful service in the employment of public bodies, that they should at the end, perhaps after 40 or 50 years' service, be flung on the scrap heap. Another point of view is that men who grow old in the service of public bodies are not able to give as good a return in work as when they were young. I know that public bodies would like, if it were in their power, to grant pensions to those men, and to take on young men who would be able to give a better return of work. But because they have not a right to do so they retain them as long as they are able to walk. I hope the Minister will see his way to accept the amendment, or, at least, to go so far as he can to meet it.

Comment on this

The Deputy's amendment, and more particularly the words used in introducing it, to some extent amaze me. I think the ordinary workman who is so fortunate as to be able, through influence or otherwise, to get a job under those local authorities is very fortunate. Their terms of service are far better than those of practically any other workman in the country, and I do not see why those people should be put in the privileged position that they could get a pension at the end of their years' service, whether the service happened to be of the best possible kind or otherwise. The ordinary workingman has to take his chance, and so have the ordinary professional man and the farmer. I have no intention of putting an added burden on the ratepayers by accepting a new kind of pensionable officers. If at any future time I wish to do that, it would be necessary to place these pensioners on a contributory basis. That would mean a reduction of the present wages of the employees involving a contribution of, say, five per cent. of their wages. I do not believe that the Deputies on the opposite side would be in favour of that.

Comment on this
LABOUR DEPUTIES

Who told you?

Comment on this

If the Minister will not accept the amendment, would he say that he will bring in a Bill to give pensions to those men on a contributory basis?

Comment on this

Will the Minister say who is to pay all these pensions?

Comment on this

The Minister started off by expressing his amazement of the proposal brought forward by Deputy Morrissey. I could understand him expressing himself like that if we had not been discussing pensions for the past two or three days, and I would like to know how it was that he did not mention the privileged position of officers of public boards during the past few days, just as he now speaks of the unfortunate workingman, and I want to know what more privileged position does he occupy to-day than such officers. I think everyone will agree that his position is a less privileged one. He has not the same salary, week after week, as the officer, and there is very little question at all in this House as to an officer being entitled to a pension. Deputy Morrissey has put it from every point of view, and we are asked who is to provide these pensions. Of course the answer is the ratepayer. Who is to provide the pension for the officer? The ratepayer also. When this Bill was receiving a Second Reading I mentioned the matter of the provision of pensions for the ordinary working-man, and I was told by the President that the council of county councils had turned down that proposal. I made enquiries, and I found that what the President stated was not correct. I drew the attention of the council of county councils to the President's statement, and they immediately contradicted it.

They have since passed a resolution asking the Government to put a clause in this Bill to entitle the workingmen employed by local councils to pensions. Since that the council of municipal councils, which can by no means be looked upon as a Labour body, has asked the Government to permit local authorities to pension their ordinary workers. Deputy Morrissey has spoken on this from every angle, and too much stress cannot be laid upon the point that he made about the provision that should be made for old men who have spent their lives in the service of a municipal authority. You have cases all over the county to-day where old men are employed by municipal authorities. These authorities do not want to throw these men on the scrap heap because of the good service they have given for a number of years, and it would pay the ratepayers better if they were permitted to give them pensions and to employ younger men; it would be found to work out more beneficially to the ratepayers in the end. I do not think that there ought to be any second question about that. The workingman is as much entitled to a pension as an officer, and I do not know what case can be put for the officer that cannot be put for the workingman. I think we ought to ask the Minister to approach it from that point of view, and not to express his amazement at the demand after pensioning all other people who have to do with a public authority for the last two or three days.

Comment on this

I was surprised to hear Deputy Corish speak exactly in that strain, because I gathered from what he had said here from time to time that he has a good deal of experience of the working of local authorities, and he has not shown that same experience on this occasion as we have had from him previously. May I remind him that in the pension scheme we have been considering, a pension is granted when a man becomes incapacitated. There are conditions as to when the pension applies, and these conditions must be fulfilled before the pension does apply. What is the case that is mentioned by Deputy Morrissey? He says that the local authority retains the services of the old men even though they are not able to do the work that they did when they were much younger. It retains them at the full rate. That is quite true. What happens after that? As soon as they are incapacitated the local authority makes a recommendation to the Lord Lieutenant on a medical certificate, that such and such a man is incapacitated. He has been in the service, and he gets his pension, as recommended by the local authority.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

I have known cases of this kind. Let me give you now as a parallel what happens in other walks of life. Deputy Morrissey is aware— and if he is not aware, Deputy Johnson will remind him—that in many agreements—I will not say in all—with the different trades there is a condition whereby old men are allowed to work at a reduced rate. Now you see the advantages that the local authority confers on the old man which is not conferred in the case of ordinary industry.

Comment on this

Do you agree that that is right?

Comment on this

I am not saying anything about that at all now; I am only saying what the practice is at the moment. In ordinary industry there is an agreement, signed by the trade unions, whereby old men are permitted to work at a reduced rate. That is the custom in ordinary industry. But under these local authorities old men are never bound to work at reduced rates. There is a considerable advantage that they have, to start with, and as was pointed out before, in many ways they have many advantages right through the terms of their employment. We need not go into them here; we all know them. So that I think if there is any body of men who have not a grievance —and there are few of them in Ireland —it is the employees under local authorities.

Comment on this

Deputy Good is clearly speaking under a misapprehension, and he has gone far to prove the necessity for the acceptance of this amendment. He pointed out that if a man became incapacitated it was within the power of the local authority to apply to the Lord Lieutenant for leave——

Comment on this

An old man, yes— to pay him a certain gratuity, or allowance, or pension. Strange to say, that was the practice. It is that practice that has been found to be illegal, and it is that practice that we seek to reembody within the powers of a local authority, and which Deputy Good is opposing. Let me give an instance. I am glad that Deputy O'Connor has come back to look after the nation's business, because I want to remind him of a particular case in which he will be interested. A certain man had been in the employment of the Pembroke Council for forty years, and during the last several years has been a skilled workman in that employment. William Cooney is his name, and perhaps Deputy O'Connor and Deputy Good may recollect the case. The Council had representations made to them that he had been obliged under doctor's orders to cease work; he was no longer capable after forty years' service. He was 63 years of age. The Council granted him a pension of £2 8s. 4d. per week in accordance with a practice that they had followed for quite a long time with regard to old, incapacitated servants.

Quite a number are continuing to get pensions under the sanction of the old regime. But in the case of William Cooney, the auditor comes along and draws attention to an apparent defect. At any rate, somebody takes the initiative and asks the law officers their opinion. The law officers inform the Minister for Local Government, who in turn advises all the local councils that such a workman is not an officer within the meaning of the Local Officers Superannuation Act, therefore the Council have no power under the law to grant that pension, and that they cannot say anything at all about the illegalities of the old regime. "Pensions granted by urban district councils were formerly subject to sanction of the Lord Lieutenant. The Minister cannot accept responsibility for pensions previously granted with such sanction." Now what has happened to old pensioners I do not know, but here is the case of a man with forty years' service, who has been granted a pension by the Pembroke Council, which has been refused by the Ministry, and that man with a family, notwithstanding his long service, finds himself unable to carry on, and he writes to me: "We are in a bad way at present. What we have is going out of the house; there is nothing for us only the Union. I hope in God we will never see that." That is the state of things that we want to avoid in the future, and to make it possible for an urban, a town, or a borough council, which has not a special Act, to continue the practice which has been operating for many years past.

The Dublin Council has a special Act which authorises them to do so, and the position as regards Dublin does not apply. Perhaps Cork has a special Act. I do not know. But surely it is desirable, notwithstanding the second part of Deputy Good's speech, to allow a Council to pay off a man who has served a long period and to give him a pension. Why, it is put forward as one of the signs of good employment, humane conditions, things to be appreciated, that the private employer has set aside a sum to pension old employees. But now we are told by the Minister that that should not be considered by a public authority, and forsooth in a Bill which he is fathering to the House—and I do not know how many sections are definitely set out by him to us with the object of paying pensions and superannuation—he says that people ought to be able to save up for their old age from the salaries and wages they receive from the public authorities. He tells us on some occasions that they should not be paid more than 28/- or 30/- a week, but in the Bill, of which about fifteen sections are devoted to making provision for the superannuation of employees of public authorities, he tells us that such employees should be able to save enough out of their salaries or wages. I cannot understand that mentality, unless it is born of prejudice against the manual worker. The facts are that under the advice of the late Attorney-General local authorities have been deprived of what they believed to be their powers in the past. This amendment seeks to recover for them the power of which they believed themselves to have been possessed. Anybody who has ever voted for a pension for an incapacitated servant of a local authority is bound to vote for this amendment.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 13
·
Níl 32
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Might I ask if the Minister would be prepared to introduce a special Bill for superannuation of manual employees on a contributory basis?

Comment on this

Not at the present time, at all events.

Comment on this

Does the Minister say he would be in favour of introducing such a Bill at some future time?

Comment on this

I do not think that is in order.

Comment on this

I move amendment 52a:

"To add after the word ‘accordingly,' line 39, the words ‘and the said expression shall also include that the person holding the office of coroner in the County Borough of Dublin at the time of the passing of this Act shall be deemed to be, and to have been from the time of his appointment, a pensionable officer for the purposes of any Acts relating to the superannuation of local officers.'"

I would ask the Minister to regard this amendment in the same light as he did the amendment touching on compounders of medicine. The present holder of this office has been in it for a quarter of a century, and the number of courts of inquiry that he has held could be ascertained in the Minister's Department. It is no sinecure job by any means, and I do not see any reason why the coroner should not be entitled to a pension. Of course he is a very active man at present and he has no intention of going out or giving up the position. He has the advantage, which I do not suppose the Bill will interfere with, of being able to appoint a deputy if he were ill for a day or two, without any extra expense on the local bodies. He himself understood that under the old regime, as we may call it, he would be a pensionable officer. As he is one of my constituents, I have been asked to put down this amendment. I think it would be only fair to consider the present occupant of this position in the same light as a compounder of medicine.

Comment on this

What were the conditions of his employment? Were they any different from the conditions of employment of the ordinary employee who receives wages and not a salary?

Comment on this

I do not believe he is on the same footing as an ordinary employee in many respects, but I could not accede to this request, even if it were drafted in a form to include all coroners. It would mean creating new pensionable offices, and I could not hear of that under the conditions I have referred to. It makes it doubly difficult when the case is put up for one individual person. It is obviously placing me in a very difficult position to ask me to bring in legislation dealing with a particular case. Although I would like to concede to Deputy Keogh in this matter, under the circumstances it would be in some respects a really ridiculous thing to bring in special legislation for one individual.

Comment on this

May I point out to the Minister there is a special Act of Parliament existing at present that was brought in for this particular man—the Coroners of Dublin Act?

Comment on this

That is not for a particular man; it is for the Coroner of the City of Dublin, irrespective of who he might be.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister whether the Bill as it now stands takes anything from the city coroner that he has secured under any other measure?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I think the amendment is lost.

Comment on this

Division, please.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

How many Deputies are challenging a division? Will those Deputies who are challenging a division stand up?

DeputiesKEOGH and A. BYRNE rose.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Does Deputy Keogh still demand a division?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The amendment is lost.

Amendment 53:—"In lines 46 and 50, after the word ‘salary' to insert the words ‘or wages.'"—(Domhnall O Muirgheasa), not moved.

Comment on this

I want to mention a matter which is of some importance. The officers who have been transferred from the old county infirmaries to the home hospitals have, of course, been transferred to a different body and there is a doubt in the minds of some of those persons that provision is not made for them under this section. I want the Minister to state clearly whether the term of office they have served under the old county infirmaries will count in connection with their pensions since they have been transferred. It is merely a question of assuring those men that their rights have been transferred and that the time they have spent under the old county infirmaries will be counted, so far as their pensions are concerned, in the service they are now entering upon with the home hospitals.

Comment on this

We will make sure of that on the Report Stage. The matter may not be fully covered under Section 48, but that section is intended to cover them. If it does not I will see something is introduced on Report that will ensure that.

Comment on this

On the section as a whole, I want to point out to the Minister one matter that deserves careful reconsideration. There is need for further enlargement of the definition of pensionable officer. Since the introduction of the Bill in its original form, the Minister has consented to add certain officers of the Department of Agriculture and Technical Instruction. He has agreed they should be brought in under the provisions of the section. He has, however, limited their benefit, shall I say, in a manner which appears to me to be quite unjustifiable, and in a manner which will not stand any careful examination if there is any desire to do justice to the persons concerned. I will press on him the necessity for carefully considering, firstly the introduction of the word "continuous"—"a continuous period of not less than ten years"—and secondly the period itself as being altogether too long. I would ask the Minister to consider very favourably between now and Report the acceptance of an amendment or amendments which will be put down touching on those two points.

I want to draw attention then to the fault in the narrowness of the definition which excludes weekly wage-earners, the ordinary manual labourer working for a public body. The intention apparently of the Minister, of Deputy Egan of Cork, Deputy Batt. O'Connor of Dublin, and Deputy Good of Dublin, is to confirm what the Ministry has decided, to change the practices that local authorities have followed in the past, which would allow them to give a pension to an old, incapacitated servant. Those Deputies, and all others who voted against the amendment proposed, have said by their vote that they want to differentiate between the manual worker and the salaried officer, and that they want to prevent the manual worker who has served 30 or 40 years, and has become incapacitated in that service, from receiving a pension. When a case was brought before the Local Government Ministry requesting sanction to a pension granted by the Pembroke Urban Council to an old servant with 40 years' service, who had become incapacitated but who was not yet eligible for the old age pension— following the practice that authority had adopted in respect to previous employees who had gone out incapacitated and to whom a pension was granted —the Minister, relying upon the Law Officer's advice, disallowed the pension, and the explanation lies in this:—

"I am directed by the Minister for Local Government to acknowledge receipt of your letter of the 29th regarding the question of the granting of a pension by the Pembroke Urban Council to William Cooney, lately employed by the Council, and I am to state that the primary authority for the granting of a pension by an urban council is derived from the Local Officers Superannuation (Ireland) Act, 1869. A copy of the Attorney-General's opinion is enclosed relating to a proposal to grant a pension in a similar case. In view of that opinion the Minister is precluded from expressing sanction to the Council's proposals. Pensions granted by urban district councils were formerly subject to the sanction of the Lord Lieutenant. The Minister cannot accept responsibility for pensions previously granted with such sanction."

One would assume from that that the Minister was desirous of sanctioning such pensions in such cases, but it seems he was not desirous and that was only a pretence. He has refused to accept the proposition which would bring such persons within the ambit of the Bill and place it within the power of the local authority to grant a pension to an old servant, who had become incapacitated in the service. Deputies who have voted for such pensions on their local councils in the past now say, by inference, that they were wrong in so doing, that they had no right to do so. But the workman, the manual labourer, is of inferior clay to the salaried officer and is not subject to the same human requirements and should not be treated in the same category in regard to old age. Now, the Attorney-General's opinion reads as follows:—

"Superannuation of weekly wage earners of the labouring class"—I hope that Deputy Egan will note that —"In my opinion X. is not an officer within the meaning of the Local Officers Superannuation (Ireland) Act, 1869. The right of the local authority to grant pensions to its employees depends solely on statute, and it is a question of construction in each case whether that particular case comes within the scope of any statute authorising the granting of a pension or superannuation allowance. In the present case, X's employment, though, in fact, it continued without interruption for a number of years, was, in its nature, merely casual, and had no element of that permanency or continuity of duty which would be essential to make it a legal office, and the remuneration which he received for his services could not in any sense be regarded as salary, which is the term used in the Act. Taking and construing the Act of 1869 as a whole, I am of opinion the Act was only intended to apply, and does only apply, to officials holding permanent and formal appointments, or offices specifically mentioned in the statute, and accordingly X's position does not qualify him for a pension. In my opinion, in the absence of a special statute conferring the right, local authorities cannot grant pensions to weekly wage-earners of the labouring class."

As I said, one would imagine from the communication from the Minister that he was very sorry he could not consent to the granting of a pension, but we have given him an opportunity to express that sorrow in legal language in a statute, and he has refused. The big majority of Deputies have backed him up in the refusal, even Deputies who have sought the support of their constituents on the ground that they were prepared to treat men and women on equal terms, irrespective of their birth, social position, and the influence they might be able to bring to bear on authorities. This section fails because it refuses to bring in within the term "pensionable officer" wage-earners who have served for twenty years, and who have become incapacitated. It refuses the local authority power to pay a weekly wage to a pensioner who has become incapacitated after forty years' service, and Deputies have "the face" to say that they will treat a weekly wage-earner on a level with the salaried officer with regard to human needs. The section fails in that respect, and I hope that between now and the Report Stage Deputies will reconsider their decision.

I hope the Deputies will come to realise that they have done that which they did not wish to do and that they have been misled into doing it, and that they will, if another opportunity is provided, agree that the weekly wage-earner, the manual worker, who has served the local authority for forty years, and has become incapacitated in that service, might be granted a pension if—those are the provisions of the Bill—the local authority so desires, and if the Minister grants his consent. That is what we ask should be done.

Comment on this
Bartholomew O'Connor Mr. B. O'CONNOR

On yesterday, I heard from the Benches opposite that the reason people should be pensioned was that from their weekly wage or salary, there was something kept back that would, in time, lead up to this pension. Reference has been made to the Pembroke Council. The workers mentioned in the Deputy's speech were labouring men, and if the case that was made yesterday holds, the argument would be that those men are working at a lesser rate of wages than is paid to other men who are getting a pension. The reverse of that is the truth. I have men working for me in the same class of work, and they get five or six shillings a week less than those in the Pembroke Council. The workers in the Council have permanent work and no broken time. If they get ill, they are paid. That is so with the workers in my own employment. Builders' labourers work a good deal harder, but they are paid Trade Union wages. There seems to be no pity at all in this country for the ratepayers or for the public boards. They are looked upon as good old milch cows. In casting my vote, I cast it honestly. I had it in my mind that I could not play fast and loose with the ratepayers' money.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy say how he voted in regard to the pension of William Cooney, of Ballsbridge, who was incapacitated after forty years' service? Did he abstain or vote at the time?

Comment on this
Bartholomew O'Connor Mr. B. O'CONNOR

I do not remember that case. As the Pembroke Council was mentioned, I brought it into my discussion. The workers in the Pembroke Council are paid a higher rate of wages than the casual workers in the street.

Comment on this

I want again to refer to the refusal of the Minister to accept the amendment proposed by Deputy Morrissey. He dealt with it in a summary fashion, a fashion which the amendment did not deserve. To my mind, the treatment that anything brought forward here in the interests of the workers receives is absolutely callous.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

We are on the section, not on the amendment.

Comment on this

I understand, but everyone else has been allowed to discuss it. The way in which the Minister treated the last amendment was scandalous, and it is not surprising to me that the Government are losing in elections. They began by cutting down pensions and now the Minister does not think it worth his while to answer questions on the amendment.

Comment on this

As one who has voted on this division I think it only right to pass some comments on Deputy Johnson's remarks. He instanced the case of the employee of the Pembroke Council who had a lengthy service of forty years and said that any one of the Deputies who voted against this amendment deprived that employee of getting a pension. If Deputy Morrissey had this in his mind when he was proposing this amendment, why did he not say "an old employee of forty years' service" instead of a service of three years? We voted against the amendment as it read.

Comment on this

What number of years would the Deputy be satisfied to vote for?

Comment on this

That question does not arise at all. When those allegations are made about Deputies casting their votes why is this forty years' limit put up when three years only are mentioned? It means the employee of every county council is entitled after three years to a pension.

Comment on this

It does not.

Comment on this

The word "may" does not mean "shall," but everyone knows that in practice "may" means "shall."

Comment on this

I think it is necessary that the Minister should explain this section to the Deputies.

Comment on this

With regard to the other question of a pension for urban employees, we know that those appointments are the best class of employment on the market to-day. To get this employment we know that employees have to go and canvass and it is by favour and luck that they get it.

Comment on this

Are you turning down pensions on that account to officers as well?

Comment on this

I am opposed to pensions to any employee.

Comment on this

There are several sections to superannuate officers.

Comment on this

Certain customs have arisen with regard to officers and their terms of employment. The custom has been established, advertisements are published with it, and the appointment is made on those conditions.

Comment on this

What is the Bill for?

Comment on this

You should change it. People accept this employment on the distinct understanding that those conditions exist.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

We are not on the amendment. We are dealing with the section.

Comment on this

I voted against the specific language in the amendment.

Comment on this

The only reason which has been put forward by the Minister as to why he could not include in this section pensions for employees of public bodies, is that they are in a privileged position. Much play was made on that by Deputies Good and Gorey. The Minister was amazed that we should have the audacity to suggest that the employees of public bodies should get a pension owing to their privileged position. In other words, the employees of public bodies should go down on their knees and thank God that they got a job at 27/- a week, as laid down by the Minister. Deputies Good and O'Connor, when speaking of conditions, have in mind conditions obtaining in Dublin where men have many privileges and advantages which they have not in the country. Does Deputy Good or Deputy O'Connor know that the employees of several councils in the country are not paid for broken time? Do they know that employees of county councils in most cases walk three or four miles to their work, and if the day is too wet for work they have to walk home again and they get nothing for the day? There is no sick pay and they are not served out with clothes or even with the ordinary oilskins that would keep the wet off them.

Comment on this
Bartholomew O'Connor Mr. O'CONNOR

Deputy Johnson quoted Pembroke, and that is the reason why I referred to Pembroke.

Comment on this

With regard to what Deputy Gorey has said about his not being able to support the amendment because of the three years' pension, I do not believe for a moment that Deputy Gorey would be in favour of employees of a council being pensioned even if they had forty years' service. I am sure that Deputy Gorey would admit that himself. The net result of the discussion is that so far as the majority of the Deputies are concerned the average wage earners—the members of the labouring class, as they were called in the Attorney-General's report to the Local Government Department —are of different clay and require different treatment. Nobody will deny that that class does give as good service to the public bodies as the officials. I am surprised at the attitude of some Deputies in view of the speeches made on election platforms about equality, and in view of the promises made by a particular Party in this House to have equal regard for the rights of all sections of the community. That is their boast. They say that they represent not one but every section, and we have seen how far that is true so far as the poor are concerned.

Comment on this

Is this in order? I thought we had disposed of Deputy Morrissey's amendment.

Comment on this

You did not try to dispose of it.

Comment on this

I submit that I am perfectly in order. I am speaking against the Minister because he has omitted to provide in the section arrangements to give pensions to employees of local bodies. I submit that I am perfectly in order, and if I am not I am sure that I will be pulled up. Perhaps what I am saying is hurting the Minister and is not suitable to him. The fact remains that the Minister, and the members of his Party, will have to meet that when they go to the country and tell the workers that they will be better represented by the Cumann na nGaedheal than by the Labour or any other Party.

Comment on this

Much has been said by two or three speakers about the question of saving the ratepayers. I think that if the Minister were to give a promise that he would bring in on the Report Stage of the Bill a pension scheme, whereby it would be optional with the local authorities to grant pensions on a contributory basis, the ratepayers' interests would be perfectly safeguarded. I think if the Minister will look over his records he will find that he has received various representations from several councils to be allowed to pension their employees. These representatives know how much the ratepayers burden ought to be. I feel sure that after the next elections, in view of what has been said by the Minister, there will be very capable representatives of the ratepayers on these councils so that there will be no need for the Minister to interfere further with them.

Comment on this

I do not think that it is necessary for me to do that, as I see the cohorts behind the Deputy.

Comment on this

You have not got yours behind you, but they are ready behind the bell.

Comment on this

I am wondering whether the Minister is trying to get the workers back to the state of slavery in which they were some years ago. It does not matter who they are, or what they are, so long as they are not workers or producers, they will be entitled to get pensions. Deputy after Deputy has amendments down trying to secure pensions for everybody, even for the man who probably only lights a candle in a public office, whereas the men who do the important work of the country are to be turned aside and put on the scrap heap, perhaps in a county home or workhouse, while young men, fit and able to work, go round from race course to race course and at the same time draw their pensions. These men never did a day's work for any council, or for anybody else, yet we know that you superannuated a lot of them during the last few years. I say that we should turn them out on the road and make them work for the money they are getting. I say that unless you meet the workers on this point they will turn round and assert their rights independently of the Minister and those behind him.

Comment on this

I have been surprised at the tone of the arguments used by the Minister and those behind him. Some of them in support of the section are prepared to stand up and make statements contrary to facts, and which have no relation to the truth. Deputy O'Connor, in support of the section, told us that the employees of county councils and other local bodies are paid for broken time, and are paid whether they are ill or not. These statements should not be made unless the person making them is prepared to substantiate them by facts. There is no use in any Deputy trying to force such things down our throats by telling deliberate lies. I say that the county council workers are not paid for bad weather or for broken time, nor are they paid while ill, although that illness may be the result of the slavery they have to undergo while working for public bodies. Day after day we hear tenderhearted statements made on the Ministerial Benches regarding the workers, and we hear them outside, particularly in the atmosphere of an election, whether a by or general election. When we get down to earth and try to transact any business in the interests of the toiling masses we find bigotry everywhere on the Benches opposite, and when a Labour Deputy Makes the slightest suggestion or moves an amendment to relieve the distress of the unfortunate workers, whether during his years of toil or after his years of toil, he is turned down, as we are being turned down in reference to this particular section.

All these promises that have been made, and all the propaganda posted on the dead are simply meant to blind the worker, and to make a fool of him in order to bring about, as Deputy Colohan stated, the re-birth of the slave age. If the Minister, or the Party behind the Minister, have the slightest sympathy with the workers employed by local authorities, let us before this section passes ask from the Minister some guarantee that he is going to do something for them in the nature of pensions. We are not tied down to three years, as Deputy Gorey, in his narrow-mindedness, would try to make the Dáil believe.

Of course, he used that as an argument to endeavour to tear from Labour any substantial case made on behalf of the worker. I expect to hear from the Minister before this section passes that he is prepared to give some guarantee that he will, in the near future, bring in legislation whereby pensions, or gratuities of some kind or another, will be given to employees of local authorities when they are passed their period of labour. If he does not do that, I say that all the promises, verbal and otherwise, that have been given, and all the sympathetic utterances that have been made on the Government Benches are all camouflage so far as the workers are concerned. Mark you, although the workers may be branded as being a dark streak of illiteracy and ignorance in the midst of the community, they will realise that the privations and hardships they are suffering during the reign of this Government cannot and will not be allowed to continue.

Comment on this
Bartholomew O'Connor Mr. O'CONNOR

On a point of explanation, may I say that one of the last speakers referred to me as having brought a reference to the county council workers into my speech. I did no such thing. I only referred to Pembroke because Deputy Johnson mentioned Pembroke specially, and mentioned my name in connection with it. I pointed out that the workers of the Pembroke Council are paid a higher rate of wage than the workmen in my own employment, and that no matter how long these workmen worked for me, I am not bound to give them pensions.

Comment on this

I must congratulate the Labour Deputies on the good case they are making, but I should, how ever, point out that the great bulk of the labour men in the country are not entitled to pensions. The great majority of the men working on farms are not entitled to pensions.

Comment on this

We are not dealing with farms.

Comment on this

The case made here is that because a worker happens to be working for a local authority, he is entitled to a pension. It should be remembered that the local authority is administering money contributed by the ratepayers, and when a ratepayer is not able to give his own men, working in his own interests, pensions, how do you make out that a local body paying away the ratepayers' money could do so?

Comment on this

Fifteen sections of the Bill are doing it.

Comment on this

I think the underlying idea is to pension officers. Take, for instance, a public body. Everybody knows the great expense there is with the amount of low-paid labour. Officers, by reason of their special qualifications, are few in number. We all know that it would be a very good thing if circumstances would allow of giving pensions to everybody, even to farmers, after they reach the age of sixty or sixty-five. But, I put it to members on the Labour Benches, would it be just to the ratepayers to give a pension to a man working for them, whereas the ratepayers themselves could not afford to give a man a pension when in their own personal employment? The proportion of officers to workmen is, I should say, about one to ten.

Comment on this

A nice, select few.

Comment on this

The officer is there by reason of his particular qualifications, and the rank and file cannot expect, in the present financial condition of the country, to be put on the same footing as those officers.

Comment on this

Deputies very often, and their spokesmen in newspapers and reviews, wonder why people should ever refer to what is called "class war." Whether there is any truth or value in the theory of class war as a means of social development I am not going to argue, but if they want proof of the existence of class war here you have it frankly and plumply laid down before us. You have a Bill brought in by a Minister, supported by Deputies all round, and spoken to by Deputy Wilson and others, selecting out of a body of workers engaged by public authorities, the officer class, persons who do no manual labour who have had a certain education, a certain training, and who come from the farmer, merchant, or the professional classes. You say: "These are the people to whom we agree to pay pensions, after a certain number of years on certain conditions, but the mass of the people who have not had that advantage of birth or education, who do the hard work, and who serve all those years under these public bodies must not be pensioned. We cannot agree to pension these people; we reserve our favours for the professional class, the salaried class, the educated class, for the people who have the higher salaries." That is the kind of thing that gives support to the contention that you people who are supporting this sort of thing are waging against the working class a class war. That gives support to that contention, and every one of you are giving evidence that you are against the common workman.

Comment on this

I, too, must congra late the Labour Party on the very good fight they have put up, but I think Deputy Johnson stressed the last point a little too much, and I am sure, as a fair and reasonable man, he will admit that. The Minister did not approach this as a new question in the first instance and say: "I will select the officers now, and I am going to give them pensions, but the workmen may go outside the door; they will get no pensions." Deputy Johnson knows that is not the case, and that in handling this question he had to deal with a situation created and handed down by men who gave great consideration to the officer class, and had greater preference for them than we have. That state of things existed, and the only way to remedy that would be to take up the working man and give him a pension also. I sympathise with Deputy Wilson's attitude on this question. We, and Deputy Johnson, must look at our means. We have to consider, as Deputy Wilson considered fairly enough, that in giving pensions to the officers there are only a few men to deal with. If there were only the same number of workers the question would be a simpler one, and we would not be discussing it here at all.

I have the honour of being on public boards, and I voted for pensions, but when we have to go to the extreme step of reducing the old age pension, owing to the extremity of the nation's need, this is not the time when any man, no matter how sympathetic he may feel, could support a wide extension of the pension scheme. Nine out of every ten of the people I represent are living on uneconomic holdings, or are not receiving a living wages. Take the agricultural labourers. They are paying their share, and more than their fair share, of taxes on tobacco, porter, tea, sugar and everything else. The employees of urban councils that Deputy O'Connor has described are better off than the employees of private people.

Comment on this
A LABOUR DEPUTY

Did you tell that to the workers in Cork?

Comment on this

We told the workers of Cork that we would do what is fair for them. I am sure the Deputy from Cork is able to answer on that point or any other point. There is no use in personal references; the question is serious enough without introducing them. If the employees of public bodies received less wages a case might be made for them, but, as a matter of fact, they are receiving better wages than the employees of private employers, and have security of employment, and consideration in other ways. How do the employees of the county councils fare as compared with their comrades who are working for the farmers? They are far better off than the average labourer, and how can you make a case for giving them pensions either?

If the times were better I would say with Deputy Wilson that I would like to see those agricultural workers, and the workers in towns who are not working for public bodies, having their case considered, as I think they are deserving of consideration. A farmer is in a different position from an agricultural labourer. When a labourer has worked for 40 years he is at the end of his toil, and he has no resources, but the farmer who has worked for 40 years, even though he is crippled with rheumatism and confined to bed, still has a farm from which to draw his support. If I were a farmer, like some of the farmers in the Dáil, I would have no sympathy with pensions, for I would not want one. But the labourer, whether in town or country, who lives on his labour, is entitled to some consideration, and the State has made a step towards that. I hope in better times we will do what they are thinking of doing in England, lower the age and increase the amount of pension. To ask to differentiate in the way proposed is very unreasonable, and no man could go down to his constituents and say that he voted for special privileges in that way.

Comment on this

The two classes of labourers we are debating cannot be compared at all. One class, whose advocate is Deputy Hall, is the labourer on the road. When such a man ceases to be able to work, he is told to go away, but the farm labourer, to the credit of the farmers be it said, is kept on if he has been a good worker as long as he is able to crawl about the place, or until he dies, and his wages during that time might be called a pension. The man who is getting his wages from direct labour does not enjoy the little perquisites that the farmer labourers do. He does not get the chance of what I have described as a pension. If he is sick he has no one to make an excuse for him, and he has to stay at home and loses his wages. For that reason, I support the claim that the men who work on the roads are entitled to a pension equal to the pension given by the farmers, especially when they are not looked upon in any favourable way for all the good work they have done during their whole lifetime.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. P. HOGAN (Clare) Labour Party

I do not think there is much use in discussing any matter relative to the working man in this assembly. That conclusion has been forced on me on more occasions than this, for whenever a reasonable provision or amendment is brought forward from any section of the Dáil that would raise the status of the working man, it is met by a stereotyped reply, as if the decision was taken in advance before the reasons could be adduced that induced the putting forward of the proposition. In this case it is proposed to cut out a certain section of employees, and if we admit the principle at all, we must admit it all round.

Comment on this

I think this discussion is altogether out of order, and I would like a ruling on that. There was an amendment to include them, but that question has been disposed of.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

The question of pensionable officers and officers of public bodies has been discussed on the section, and it would be well for Deputies to confine themselves as much as possible to that without going over the ground covered in the debate on the amendment. Of course it is strictly in order to raise the question of the omission of pensions for other employees of councils on the section.

Comment on this

Is it, A Leas-Chinn Comhairle, after that question has been discussed? If that is the case, you could be continually raising the same question all through the Bill.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. HOGAN (Clare) Labour Party

I submit that the Minister raised a point of order on what I said, that if you admit the principle in one case you admit it all round. The principle is admitted for a certain number of people under that section, so, therefore, I submit that I am discussing what is in that section in discussing a principle that was accepted in that section. Some Deputies on the Farmer's Benches seem to be slaves to custom—Deputy Gorey, for instance. He says that it is the custom to pension officers. It is, and we want to establish another custom——

Comment on this

I thought so much.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. HOGAN (Clare) Labour Party

Because it is just as just, just as reasonable, just as fair, and just as equitable.

Comment on this

Pension the ploughmen.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. HOGAN (Clare) Labour Party

Let us consider the two classes that you are contrasting. You say that there are only a select few officers, and therefore there will not be a great deal spent. Will Deputy Wilson tell us if one of these officers does not get ten times as much in the year as one working-man we are asking you to pension? Has he considered that one of these officials gets more salary than the road-worker gets? If he has not he ought to make a calculation, and he would not be long in seeing how far it would get him. I wonder if anybody who has spoken against the inclusion, or the non-exclusion, if that word would be more acceptable to the Minister, of a certain section of people from the terms of the section, understands the real conditions of some of the employees. Have they considered that, after giving 15 or twenty years of hard, laborious work in the service of a public body, they are to be turned out and told that they have no claim upon it? Have they considered the conditions under which that work was done, the housing conditions under which these men have to live, the wretched homes in which they have to live? Yet these are the people who tell us that the working-class is a class not to be relied upon, tell us about the poor standard of education that they achieve.

These are the very conditions that you are seeking to perpetuate, the conditions that are produced, the illiteracy and the desperation that you objected to on other occasions, and that desperation, if driven away further, will find expression, perhaps, in a fashion that will not be agreeable to the Minister or to those who sit behind him. These people are not in a position to fit their families for anything but unskilled labour, therefore you have a surplus on the unskilled labour market to-day, and you have an unemployment problem. That unemployment problem is growing. At one time you said that you would pool the resources of the nation to save the nation. Are you prepared to pool the resources of the nation to save the nation now from the canker that is eating closer to its heart than any Minister that has faced it before knows? The menace of starvation, the menace of want is ten times more wrapped up in the lives of the common people of the country than any other issue, and if you seek to perpetuate the present state of affairs you seek to perpetuate unemployment, and you seek to perpetuate that menace.

Comment on this

The Minister.

Comment on this

The Minister has spoken on that point under the section. He does not wish to traffic on the leniency of An Leas-Cheann Comhairle.

Comment on this

Is the Minister not going to give any explanation in justification of the exclusion of employees of public bodies from the section?

Comment on this

That matter has already been disposed of on the Deputy's amendment.

Comment on this

The exclusion from the section has not been disposed of.

Comment on this

It is precisely because of the exclusion that you moved your amendment.

Comment on this

I move:—In sub-section (2), line 6, page 20, after the word "allowance," to insert the words, "granted after the passing of this Act." This section applies only to officers who remain under the pension provisions of the Local Government Act of 1919, which gives the Minister no control over the award of a pension unless there was a dispute between the pensions officers and the local authority. But under the Local Government (Temporary Provisions) Act of 1923, a new method of raising a dispute was created, and the county councils to which the payment of pensions due to officials losing officer under county schemes was transferred from boards of guardians were invited by the Ministry to dispute the amounts. Moreover, under Section 11 (5) of the Act of 1923, local authorities were debarred from granting new pensions under the 1919 Act in excess of the ordinary scale without the consent of the Minister. The position is, therefore, that all these 1919 Act pensions already paid have either been sanctioned by the Minister, in which case no further opportunities for a revision are called for, or else in a few cases the local authority has no objection to paying the pension originally fixed, although it has had opportunities to object. The amendment is intended to provide a re-examination of cases already settled and I think that the Minister will see that there is good reason for it.

Comment on this

This is a reasonable amendment. As the section stands, it hangs like the sword of Damocles over the heads of officers of local authorities, and it is only reasonable that this amendment should be accepted.

Comment on this