DAIL IN COMMITTEE. - LOCAL GOVERNMENT BILL, 1924.—THIRD STAGE RESUMED.
Contributions 152–305 of 305. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 18 of 1924 ›
On behalf of Deputy Colohan, I move:
To add at the end of sub-section (2) the words "on the occasion of the audit of the accounts for the period in which the allowance is first paid, but not afterwards."
There are two or three amendments that are more or less affected by this. There is a certain minimum scale provided. The original Bill did provide such a scale in the Fifth Schedule, but the revised version fixes simply a maximum of two-thirds of the salary, and gives no indication of what is to be either the normal or minimum scale. Obviously an officer is entitled to know what pension he may expect at the end of his service, but as the Bill stands the local authority might give him, after 40 years' service, a pension of only one-third of his salary. The amendment meets reasonable objections. It does not say that the authority must give a pension, but only if it does that the pension must be at least according to the scale, which is the usual one-sixtieth for each year of service. Provision is also made for cases of unsatisfactory service, where there has been ground for complaint not amounting to cause for dismissal without pension at all. In such a case the authority may reduce the pension below the scale minimum. The whole matter rests under the supervision of the Minister. I think that the Minister will see the reasonableness of this.
Comment on this
I am willing to accept this amendment, but I think that Deputy Johnson has gone astray somewhere in it. I do not think it achieves the purpose which he lays down. It is an amendment somewhat similar to Deputy Nagle's preventing the auditing of accounts with a view to affecting the pension of the local officer detrimentally, which is the same as the other amendment restricting the exercise of the functions of the auditor with regard to the officer of the local authority to a pension fixed after the passing of this Bill. It is quite a reasonable amendment and I agree to it.
Comment on this
I grant at the moment that the Minister showed very great consideration to representations that were made to him with regard to the matter contained in this section. At the same time, it has been suggested to me that I should ask him to make some slight changes which I hope he will do. Officers who would be in office at the time of the passing of the Bill consider that there should be deleted from the section the words "and at that date has more than 10 years' service as an officer of such local body." In other words, an officer who is in office at the date of the passing of this Bill thinks that he should be entitled, if he wishes, to have the right to signify "within three months after the passing of this Act his intention not to avail himself of the provisions of this Part of this Act," so that "this Part of this Act shall not apply to such officer." That is to say, anybody who has over ten years' service who does not wish to remain under the provisions of the Bill when it becomes law may, as it were, place himself outside that and rely upon previous Acts as far as his pension is concerned. Some of the men think that it is not quite fair that after being, say, eight or nine years in the service they should not be allowed to opt out, as other men who have longer service are allowed to do, and I think the case they make is a fairly good case. If there are any better terms in Section 8 of the Local Government Act of 1919, and these better provisions are available for men with 15, 20 or 30 years' service, I think it is hardly fair to place men with a lesser number of years' service in an inferior position.
Another point is with regard to the time during which these men shall have the option of opting out. The time given here is three months; they must make up their minds within three months after the passing of the Bill as to whether they will remain under its provisions or whether they will opt out. It was put up to the Minister, by a deputation when I was present, that they should get six or nine months at least before making up their minds as to which Act they wished to remain under, and as far as I remember, the Minister said that he would consider the matter and that in all probability he would agree to an extension of the time either to six or nine months. I think some of the deputation wanted him to extend it to a year. Those are the two points I want to make, and I hope the Minister will give them favourable consideration.
Comment on this
With regard to this provision disallowing officers with less than ten years' service to opt out, I think it is a very reasonable proposal. Section 8 of the Act of 1919 was a very ill-considered and hastily conceived provision. It had a political origin. At that particular period there was a struggle in this country between the old Dáil and the British Authorities in power at the time. One of the weapons used against the British Authorities was the control of the Local Government bodies in the country. In order to secure the loyalty and support of the officers of these bodies against the National authority, the British Government at the time conceded a very liberal pension scheme. Amongst other things, it granted an extremely extravagant scale of gratuities to officers with less than ten years' service who should lose their offices as a result of their positions being abolished, or for any other reason which might have a political complexion. Under that section, an officer with nine years' service would get a gratuity on the basis of five years' salary. This, of course, was an extremely extravagant concession to make to those officers and we could not, under any circumstances, stand over it at the present time. Provision will be made for them in the Act, but instead of getting this grossly extravagant rate of compensation, they will be only compensated on the basis of one-sixth of their yearly salary and emoluments. There is one particular class of officers in a different position from the others —solicitors. They are expressly mentioned in Section 8 of the Act of 1919. Solicitors who have more than ten years' service can opt out under this section, but those who have not ten years' service cannot opt out under the section. Neither will they be pensionable officers under the Bill. Accordingly they have a grievance, and I undertake to remedy that on the Report Stage. There is no other class of officers that comes under that category. I could not agree to the great burden that might be put on local authorities if officers were allowed to opt out under this Bill and get the huge gratuities they would be entitled to get under the Act of 1919.
Comment on this
I move amendment 56:—
In sub-section (1), line 9, sub-section (2), line 20, sub-section (3), line 33, and sub-section (5), line 60, to delete the word "may" and substitute the word "shall."
I made the point during the Second Stage that if a man is entitled to a pension there should be no doubt whatsoever in his mind or in the mind of the local authority, to whom he would look for the pension, as to the granting of it. With regard to the section of the 1919 Act that the Minister referred to, the word used in that section is "shall"—"an officer shall be entitled..." I should like to see this wording continued so that there would be no misconception on the part of the local bodies in regard to the granting or payment of the pension. Applicants for any position under the local authorities will feel more secure if they know that they will be pensioned at 65 years of age. Another point I desired to make was, I think, being referred to by Deputy Johnson when I was entering the Chamber—that a person upon resigning, or otherwise ceasing to hold office, shall be granted an annual allowance for life of not more than two thirds of his yearly salary. It has been pointed out to me that local authorities, under this clause, might give a pension of any amount provided it did not exceed the sum stated. That seems to the medical officers to be a very retrograde step indeed. I do not think it is right that a maximum amount should be fixed and that there should be no minimum stated. I desire to draw the Minister's attention to these points.
Comment on this
Deputy Sir James Craig has drawn attention to the fact that the word "shall" is used in Section 8 of the Act of 1919. That was an Act, as I have explained, passed in a political emergency and to achieve a political purpose. In no other Act of the Superannuation Code is the word "shall" used in connection with pensions. I should also point out that under this Bill pensionable officers are in a very much better position than they were previously. Heretofore, a pensionable officer had no redress if the local authority did not grant him a fair pension. If, because they had a spite against him, or for any other reason, he was not treated fairly, he had no redress and he had to put up with what he received. Under the present Bill he has an appeal to the Minister. In the circumstances, I think it is not likely that he will be treated unfairly. In case of an appeal, if the Minister should not be disposed to treat the officer fairly, he (the Minister) would be subject to pressure in the Dail, and questions could be raised here about his action. I think that is a sufficient safeguard.
The putting in of the word "shall" would not improve the position of the officer in any way. The officer already has his appeal to the Minister, and accordingly the only person that could be coerced by the word "shall" would be the Minister. It would not help the local officer to have the word "shall" inserted, because it would be quite possible for me, under the present Bill, to grant him only a nominal sum. By doing that, I would be keeping within the scope of the Bill. Deputy Sir James Craig further suggests minimum pensions. That is a principle that has not been adopted in any superannuation code up to the present, and I will have to adopt a very firm stand against accepting any amendment which would give effect to the principle of minimum pensions.
Comment on this
It has been put to me that unless this matter is definitely settled and men are secured these pensions now, it will lead to a great deal of canvassing and corruption and other things which went on in the past and which one would rather see stopped. It is for that reason chiefly that I have put forward this amendment, and I am very sorry indeed, for these reasons particularly, that the Minister will not agree to the substitution of the word "shall" in the Section.
Comment on this
On this amendment, which is in the name of Deputy Davin, I want to refer to a very wonderful thing that happened. The age of miracles is not passed. A few moments ago, on behalf of Deputy Colohan, I moved an amendment. In support of that amendment, which I did not understand, I read certain notes which I had before me. Those notes persuaded the Minister to accept the amendment, but those notes had nothing to do with that particular amendment. Yet the Minister accepted it!
Comment on this
On a point of order, I think I called Deputy Johnson's attention to the fact that it was not the notes that influenced me. Perhaps I was a little bit too discreet and did not take full advantage of the opportunity he gave me. I did not force the thrust home, but insinuated what was in my mind in a very gentle way.
Comment on this
What is the miracle? Is it that there is something which Deputy Johnson does not understand?
Comment on this
The miracle is that the Minister was persuaded to accept an amendment by a speech in favour of another amendment. I acknowledge with gratitude the generosity of the Minister in not thrusting a very palpable point into my ribs.
This amendment, as well as a few other amendments which have been sent in, had reference to the Bill as originally introduced. The fifth schedule was a scale of tabulated allowances, and the amendment, in the form in which it appears, refers to the fifth schedule. It is obviously impossible to have this amendment accepted in its present form. But I would plead for the principle embodied in it—that officers who are pensionable and whose retirement is not due to unsatisfactory service, shall be entitled to a pension on a definite minimum scale. That is the proposition—that the scale shall be fixed on the minimum side, and not merely on the maximum side. I think the scale in the original draft of the Bill is now embodied in the section, and that, therefore, the phraseology of the amendment which I am moving on behalf of Deputy Davin is not fitting. But I would urge upon the Minister the desirability of accepting the principle involved in this amendment and in subsequent amendments dealing with the same matter.
Comment on this
In this amendment is introduced the principle of minimum pensions, which, when speaking on a former amendment, I mentioned I had a strong objection to. "Unless the officer has failed to give continuously satisfactory service." In the ordinary course of events all those matters are taken into consideration, but if you insert that in an amendment it will mean the whole career of an officer in a local service will have to be certified and weighed up in the light of what kind of service he gave the local authority.
The only effect it might have would be, perhaps, to rake up some indiscretions, or some act the officer committed a long time back, that he might be very sorry to have brought into the light of day. It would not help the officer in any way. In actual practice he gets fair treatment from the local authority, and if he does not he can appeal to the Minister. I think his case is amply covered by those two facts. It is a very serious thing to introduce this question of minimum pensions, because it is only right that local authorities and the Minister should be allowed fairly wide discretion as to the compensation an officer would be entitled to receive.
Comment on this
I want to ask a question which is not, perhaps, quite in order on this amendment. Will the Minister say who will be the local body granting the pension? The district councils will be abolished, but is it intended that before they are they will grant the pension, or will it be the county council?
Comment on this
I am not pressing this amendment. Because of its phraseology, it is quite unfitted, and with permission I will withdraw it.
Comment on this
I beg to move the following amendment:—
To add at the end of sub-section (1), page 20, line 19, the words: "This sub-section notwithstanding the date of the passing of this Act may apply to any "existing" officer of a local authority within the meaning of the Local Government (Ireland) Act, 1898, who may have ceased to hold office at any time subsequent to 6th December, 1921."
I have an idea that the Minister is willing to accept this, at least in principle. If that were so, there would be no need to go into the reasons that prompt me to propose it.
Comment on this
I agree to accept this amendment in principle. It is one that will probably have several consequential amendments, and it will have to be re-drafted. I think we will have to find a place for Deputy Nagle in the Parliamentary drafting office, he is so successful in hitting upon amendments that can be accepted.
Comment on this
It is not a very easy thing to explain. In some counties, I think in County Cork, you have officers who are at the same time officials of the county council and the urban council. On a technical point they have been ruled out as whole-time officers; they could not be whole-time for the two offices, although they were doing the same class of work. This has worked out as a very great hardship to a few individuals. They were only very few.
Comment on this
Does it mean now that from each of these bodies individuals will be entitled to a pension? Were they entitled to any pension at all as things stood? What will the alteration be? Will it mean that they will be entitled to a pension from each of the two bodies by whom they were employed?
Comment on this
They can get it from the urban district with respect to their services under that body, as matters stand; but this will enable them to get it from the county council in proportion to the service they gave the county council.
Comment on this
I wish to propose:
"In sub-section (2), line 22, to delete the word ‘ten' and substitute the word ‘twenty.'"
That amendment means, if accepted, that a pension will not be granted to any officer who retires, because of the three reasons stated, unless he has twenty years' service. The idea is to prevent what may be likely to happen. Officers of, perhaps, not more than thirty years of age may desire to retire on a full pension of two-thirds of their emoluments. This question of giving pensions to retiring officers on local bodies is becoming almost a scandal.
Men retire from one position, and in a short time those positions have to be filled by other men; the retiring man has to be paid his pension and full salary has to be given his successor. It is not unreasonable to propose an amendment of this sort. A man of thirty or forty years ought not to expect a pension of this kind. Officers should have at least twenty years' service before a two-thirds pension is granted. I do not know if the amendment meets the case exactly; there may be circumstances not governed by the amendment. If the principle were accepted I am sure it could be afterwards put into some other portion of the Bill.
Comment on this
I do not think it is advisable for the Deputy to press this amendment. It would very likely result in severe hardship to individuals. In practice we would usually give effect to something similar to what the Deputy aims at. Under no circumstances would I grant a two-thirds pension to any officer the Deputy has placed in the category for only a one-third pension—any officer coming under the one-third clause.
If you draw a hard and fast line of demarcation in that way it might result in very severe hardship to cases on the border-line. For instance, a medical officer with nineteen years' service could only have one year added to his service for the purpose of a pension, whereas a medical officer with twenty-one years' service could have nineteen years added, and perhaps that medical officer might be one who had given not nearly quite so valuable service as the medical officer who had only one year added. The Deputy would be well advised to withdraw this amendment and leave it to the discretion of the Ministry, so that service, ability, capacity and all other considerations that weigh in those matters can be taken into consideration when deciding on a pension.
Comment on this
I do not fully understand what the Minister means to convey. My amendment does not make reference to one-third. Is the Minister referring to another amendment further down? My amendment states that unless an officer has twenty years' service he will not be entitled to two-thirds pension. There is an amendment further on dealing with a one-third pension, but I am not taking the two amendments together. At present, as I see it, the Minister has no option but to grant a pension where an officer retires who has more than ten years' service, and who retires because of any of the three reasons given.
Comment on this
I am not under any obligation to grant a two-thirds pension. That is the most I could ever grant, and I do not grant that. It is the maximum.
Comment on this
I took it that in all cases that was granted. In view of what the Minister says, I do not see that my amendment fulfils any useful purpose and I will withdraw it.
Comment on this
In the working out of the Minister's veto, would there be any guiding principle, or is every case to be considered anew and separately without any guiding principle? Is it possible under the section that extraneous influences might be brought to bear, even on the Minister? I can understand the difficulty, but I am inclined to agree some less elastic provision should be made. Ten years' service and two-thirds salary and emoluments are the limit. They are optional to the Minister and the local authority. Conceivably within that option very great extravagance might arise, and as the general opinion seems to be that it is undesirable to allow Ministers and local authorities to have power to grant pensions beyond what they have been in the habit of granting, or, rather, even to restrict what they have been in the habit of exercising, I think some restriction upon the option within which the Minister might agree to a pension should be inserted here. Within this the Minister may grant a pension of two-thirds salary for life to an officer who has had ten years' service.
The Minister says that would not likely happen while he retains his present state of mind; but he may be persuaded against his better judgement. All kinds of influences may be brought to bear. In the case of A, for instance, by virtue of his public service of one kind or another, or private service under the name of public service, he may be entitled to two-thirds pension for a ten years' service. In the case of B, who has not given that particular kind of service, he is only entitled to one-third of his salary as pension for a similar period of service as A. I think the limits are too wide, and I have sympathy with Deputy Heffernan's attempt to restrict those options.
Comment on this
The general principle on which those pensions are paid is on the one-sixtieth scale, that is, an officer gets one-sixtieth of his salary and emoluments for every year of service which he has. That principle is not departed from except in exceptional cases where an officer is injured in the course of his duty, or where he went through particularly hard circumstances in carrying out his duty, or where other exceptional circumstances of one kind or another arise. In those cases a number of years is added on. Those things are governed by Departmental precedents which are never broken away from. I agree that it does open the door to possibilities, but on the other hand, you cannot make everything watertight in matters of this kind. In practice I do not think there has been any abuse of the elasticity which this scheme permits, and Deputies have always an opportunity of raising any matter of this kind if they think there has been any abuse of this power by the Minister. It would be a difficult thing for the Minister to stand over any irregularity when the matter can be raised in this House.
Comment on this
Will the Minister mention the schedule of the number of years' service which are usually added under the precedents heretofore afforded in the case of those officers? Ten years' service at one-sixtieth per year would be one-sixth. The Minister can give two-thirds, which is forty-sixtieths. He says he can add a certain number of years. I want to find out from him under what scale those years are added, or what is the usual number of years to add.
Comment on this
It is practically impossible to answer that question which Deputy Wilson has put, because each case has to be considered on its merits, and without a definite case it is impossible to say what the allowance is to be. Furthermore, an addition to the number of years is recommended by the local authority in practically every case and approved by the Minister. The local authority, in my experience, always considers the case on its merits and makes the recommendation accordingly. As far as I know the working of the Department there is no hard and fast rule there.
Comment on this
Before I finally withdraw my amendment I would like more information on the matter. Deputy Wilson points out that on twenty years of service the pension would only be one-third. The Minister has power to grant two-thirds, and also power to add years of service. My understanding is that the pension is fixed by the local body, and if it is not fixed with the approval of the Minister, there is a row between the local body and the Minister. With regard to the adding of years of service I am not sure that this is the section to discuss that. My little knowledge is that it is not often done at all according to the good services or the ability of the man. I understand they add all the years they are entitled to. I would like to see the power of fixing the pension in the hands of the Minister, subject to the advice of the local council. In actual practice it is in the hands of the local council, subject to the confirmation of the Minister.
Comment on this
The Deputy says there is a kind of tussle in this case between the local authority and the Minister. Local authorities are generous in granting pensions, and they leave the dirty work to the Minister. As a matter of fact, the Minister always wins in those cases, and the Deputy can be reassured on that point.
Comment on this
I move Amendment 60:
In sub-section (2), line 22, after the word "service" to insert the words "and not more than 20 years' service, and who at the time of retirement is less than 40 years of age," and in line 31, after the word "than" to delete the word "two-thirds" and substitute therefor the word "one-third."
The other amendment had somewhat of the same effect. It means that a man may not get his full two-thirds pension unless he is at least forty years of age. I think there is something in the idea that a young man going out and doing work should not get a full two-thirds pension. We should recognise facts as they are in other countries. In our own country a man working in a business house may possibly lose his job when he is about thirty-five years of age, and gets no pension. But this man who gets his job abolished under the local authority gets a pension, then comes out, and is able to earn another income.
Comment on this
I think this is really a question of whether I should have discretion in those matters or not. Often an officer might become infirm for one reason or another, and it is only right that there should be some latitude in those matters to enable a pension to be fixed in cases of particular hardship. In actual practice that would be taken into consideration. If he were a young man and capable of carrying out work he would not have years added.
Comment on this
Sub-section 1 of this section governs that. I did not take that into account. I take it for granted that a man is in a good physical condition. I think it might be well that the Minister should be bound in this regard. It might strengthen his hand. If he accepts this he will have power to prevent any official under forty years of age from getting a full two-thirds pension.
Comment on this
The point raised by Deputy Heffernan is especially important with regard to sub-head (c), whose position has, in the opinion of the Minister, been altered owing to the changes in conditions of employment. It is a common thing for young men from 35 to 45 years of age to have their offices abolished. They will be abolished under this Act. Surely a young man is able to go out and take his share in the battle of life. They get pensions, and in addition, they take on jobs when they go out. Some attention should be paid to the capacity and age of the individual going out. It is quite a different thing for the old men. I think the Minister should take exceptional notice of this amendment.
Comment on this
I will look into this matter, as it is rather different from the other amendments. We can consider it on the Report Stage. I may be able to bring in some amendment that will meet the Deputy's view on that point. I rather like the principle myself.
Comment on this
I move:
In sub-section 3, line 33, page 20, to delete the word "may" and substitute the word "shall."
The object of this amendment is to stop canvassing. I would like to leave it in the power of the Minister either to give the power or not to have it at all.
Comment on this
On a point of order, does it follow necessarily that because an amendment to introduce "shall" instead of "may" in the earlier Stages has been defeated, that to introduce "shall" instead of "may" in a later sub-section also is defeated? The principle may be the same with regard to the preference for "shall," making it mandatory, but surely there must be an opportunity given to allow discussion apart from the merits of the case. I think if "shall" were introduced it would make the section read foolishly.
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy Sears, I move:—
Before sub-section (4) to insert a new sub-section:—
(4) A local body may, with the consent of the Minister, grant to a pensionable officer in their employment who is a woman, and who elects or is compelled by the terms of her appointment to retire on marriage, a gratuity not greater than one-twelfth of her yearly salary and emoluments for each completed year of her service.
In view of Deputy Sears' action on a previous amendment, I would like to move this on his behalf. It is to give power to a local authority to grant to a woman who is a pensionable officer, but who prefers to get married, a gratuity not greater than one-twelfth of her yearly salary.
It is fairly usual. I think it is a Civil Service provision and it will probably be acceptable to the Minister. I would like if Deputy Sears had been here to support this proposal. I urge it upon the Minister for his acceptance.
Comment on this
If the amount were more than one year's salary and emoluments I would be prepared to leave the matter to a free vote. I could not undertake to allow a larger amount than that. I do not think that it would help the romantic object which Deputy Johnson has in view, because, I am afraid, if we allowed ladies with service of thirty or forty years to be pensioned on that service, they would have other objects in marrying than a romantic one. As I say, I will leave it to a free vote, provided the amount is not more than one year's salary and emoluments.
Comment on this
I understand that the proposition is that we should accept the amendment on this Stage. Is that so?
Comment on this
I think that the amendment would have to be withdrawn, and I will produce an amendment on the next Stage in a limited form.
Comment on this
I move:—"In sub-section 4, line 44, after the word "bodies" to insert the words "(including a local body or bodies in any part of Ireland not at present within the jurisdiction of Saorstat Eireann)." The object of this amendment is to secure that service under any local authority will be counted, even though it is a case of service outside the authorities now under the jurisdiction of the Saorstát. I think that this is a reasonable amendment. There may be a few officers who, before 1922, did give service in that portion of Saorstát Eireann which is for the moment outside its jurisdiction. It may be that even still there are officers serving in those counties which a local authority would be glad to appoint. I think it would be well to secure that such officers would not have their pension rights decreased by the fact that they came from the Six County area or northern area.
Comment on this
I am in agreement with the object the Deputy has in view, but I am afraid that the insertion of the amendment in the Bill would not achieve it. Those parts of what formerly was Ireland, which I suppose the Deputy has in view, could not be brought under the scope of this Bill by an amendment of this kind. If those areas became portion of the Saorstát by means of any other Act they would automatically come under this Bill, and there would be no necessity for having such an amendment introduced With regard to officers serving local authorities in what was at that time part of the same country, and has since been separated from it, we could not arrange to have such officers compensated without some convention with Northern Ireland, and I could not undertake to introduce such a matter in a measure of this kind.
Comment on this
The point which I want to secure is that if you have an officer who served, say, in County Antrim for six or seven years, and who served for the remainder of his time, say, in County Cork, the years which he served in County Antrim should be calculated in fixing his pension.
Comment on this
Who is to pay for that? I have no power to compel Antrim to pay for it, and it would not be fair to saddle the expense on Cork.
Comment on this
My point is that Cork should pay, because I assume that Cork in making a selection from a large number of applicants would choose an officer who would have special qualifications, but if they did that they would do so knowing that they would have to pension him, and that his pension would cost them more than if he had served within the twenty-six county area.
Comment on this
Consideration should, of course, be given in granting pensions to the special qualifications of officers, but there is no provision by which an officer can retain his pension rights if he goes from one county authority to another.
Comment on this
Would it be in the power of the local authority with the consent of the Minister to add on a number of years of service, if a man had special qualifications?
Comment on this
I move:
To add at the end of sub-section (4) the words "Provided also that any period immediately prior to the appointment of an officer to a pensionable office during which he acted as clerk or assistant to an officer of a local body and was paid out of moneys provided for the purpose by the local body shall be reckoned as service in a pensionable office."
It is a common thing for a local authority to employ some of its minor staff indirectly. Superior officers are paid an allowance for clerical assistance, and the experience persons acquire in that way and the service they give often result in promotion to established posts. The amendment proposes that in such cases of promotion to established rank the whole period of employment, direct or indirect, should be considered for pension purposes. In Waterford County Borough there are four clerical officers in the Borough Treasurer's office who were brought in in this indirect way. One has twenty years' service, but if he were appointed to a pensionable position, and if he retired in twenty years' time, his service would only be reckoned as twenty years though his actual service was forty years.
Comment on this
I am afraid that the amendment is rather far-fetched. I think that such officers as those mentioned are fortunate in finally becoming established with pensionable rights. It would be impossible for me to decide whether they gave satisfactory service at the time they were not directly employed by the local authority, and I think it would be ridiculous to grant pensions to men in unofficial positions. It would be just the same as if I had a secretary or typist in my private capacity and, if he were afterwards appointed to a position in the Civil Service, that I were to insist that he should be made pensionable from the time during which he was doing private work for me. It is the same with this amendment, which asks that officers of this kind should receive pensions for service given in their private capacity.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not see that the phrase is "paid out of moneys provided by the local authority"?
Comment on this
I suggest to the Minister that the amendment is not at all as far-fetched as he imagines. It would remove a real grievance. I have a case in mind where a man gave eleven years in devoting his whole time to the position of assistant to a clerk of a rural district council and a board of guardians, and after that period in that position was appointed master of the union and served in that capacity for ten years, up to the time of the amalgamation scheme. I think it is a hardship on that man, who entered the service young and gave twenty-one years' service, that his pension should be calculated only on ten years' service. Credit should be given for the eleven years which he spent in the service in his other capacity. I am informed that there is a precedent for this suggestion and that in Baltinglass such service on behalf of an official there was recognised by the old Local Government Board. I am not sure how long ago that happened, but I am informed that it is not more than five or six years ago.
Comment on this
The provisions are sufficiently elastic as they stand to enable such extreme cases to be taken into consideration, but such cases would be exceptionally rare. I do not, in fact, know that there have ever been such cases.
Comment on this
As the section stands, I understand the Minister to say that he will have power in certain extreme cases to allow for the service they had in the unestablished position.
Comment on this
I think it is correct to say that there were cases of a local authority appointing a chief officer at a certain salary, such salary to cover the service of an assistant to the clerk, and it has been quite clearly understood that the officer appointed by the clerk would be his servant. These assistants were directly paid out of the moneys provided by the local authorities. The real difference in the position of a clerk appointed by and serving the chief officer, and a clerk appointed by the council is that one name appears on the pay sheet in the former case instead of two. The amendment rather specifically and clearly points to the position of an officer who was paid out of moneys provided for the purpose by the local bodies, and it is to meet some cases whereby arrangements were made in the past that an officer was to take on a person for special service and have the appointment for the person, but the payment was to come directly out of public funds. To all intents and purposes such assistant was an employee of the local authorities, because he was paid by the local authorities out of moneys provided for the purpose. Such a person is reasonably entitled to be considered an employee of the local authorities, and in such cases as that the amendment would cover and bring them into a category with those who had been appointed more directly, and whose names appear on the books of the council.
Comment on this
Many points have been raised by Deputy Morrissey, but he forgets one important point, and that is that the Local Government Department has power to consider each case on its merits. That is a very valuable point to bear in mind in this discussion on the pensions. If the Minister has to put all this class on a level with the others, it would be an additional burden on the ratepayers. You have cases of an assistant clerk appointed by the clerk and paid out of the clerk's salary. The clerk has brought that assistant into the service of the guardians or district council, as the case may be, and he pays him out of his salary, and after a short time the guardians appoint him as an assistant to help the clerk in doing his work, but he is practically in the employment of the clerk, and are you going to put him in the same position as a man who has been appointed in the usual way by the council? The Minister for Local Government has the power to discriminate, and that power being there, if I were Deputy Morrissey, I would not press the case.
Comment on this
If Deputy D'Alton refers to the amendment he would see that it does not cover the case he puts forward where the clerk is paid by the officer out of a salary which the officer receives. That is not the case provided for by the amendment. It is the case of an assistant to an officer who is paid out of monies provided for the purpose by the local authorities, and not out of the salary of the officer concerned, but out of monies specifically provided for this assistant, although the assistant is, in fact, the servant of the officer himself.
Comment on this
But his years of service as an employee to the clerk should not count for him as pensionable.
Comment on this
Behind this there is a principle which, to my mind, is rather dangerous. Deputy Johnson wants the years of any man while training or getting qualifications to hold a position to be taken into account when pensioning that official. I think no one sees better than the Deputy the danger of the principle he is advocating. If he were to apply that in other respects he might argue that during the time a tradesmen is serving his apprenticeship and qualifying to hold a subsequent position he is on the same basis. Deputy Johnson might fairly argue that his years of apprenticeship should be taken into account in pensioning him. The proposal is far-reaching, and the Minister would be wise to consider it carefully before assenting to it.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy, in putting his case, had in mind the case of an assistant succeeding to the officer. But take the case of the man who spends 11 or 12 years under the clerk of a rural district and who subsequently becomes a master of a union. You would not contend that the 11 years he had given as assistant to the clerk was in preparation for his position as master of the union?
Comment on this
To my mind, the mere fact of appointing an assistant clerk or any other official in a public body makes him part and parcel of a pensionable office, and the years he spent as an assistant should be taken into account when he was afterwards definitely appointed a pensionable officer. I hold that when an assistant clerk of a union spends his time in serving the clerk, who could not carry on with his duties without the help of that assistant, he was really on the same footing as the clerk himself.
Comment on this
I do not think anything has been said in favour of this amendment that would induce me to change my mind. The reason in many cases for not having an assistant was to avoid putting additional pensionable liabilities on the local authorities. That was the object in having these unofficial assistants, and presumably when they decided on having such unofficial assistants when fixing the amount of their salary it was taken into consideration that they would not be pensionable officers. In a good many, if not most, cases they were only part-time officers, and it often suited them to be part-time officers. They went into the matter with their eyes open. It was purely a case of contract between employer and employees, and I think it would be ridiculous to go back on that situation now years after the contract was entered into, and greatly improve the position of the employees to the detriment of the local authorities. I think it would be very detrimental to the interests of the community in general to give way to the principle which this amendment raises.
Comment on this
I move:—
To add at end a new sub-section as follows:—
"Where the officer has prior to his entering the service of a local authority obtained professional or other qualifications not usually acquired in the service of the local authority he shall be entitled to have added to his actual service such further number of years' service not less than five or more than fifteen as the local authority with the consent of the Minister may determine."
I submit that it would be in the public interest to have the amendment accepted. One can easily imagine a number of appointments for which it would be difficult to get suitable men in the locality. Let me take an instance. Supposing that the county councils determined to make concrete roads, as I hope they will some day, they might not be able to get engineers qualified to carry out the work of making these roads in their own service, or in the present Local Government service, whereas outside that service there might be men available who would be very competent for the work. These men would not come perhaps unless they were offered reasonable inducements. Supposing they had spent five or ten years in another employment, and gained the knowledge necessary for that work, if they knew those years would be counted to their credit for pension they would be induced to take up the position. I am giving that only as an instance, but there are other cases which I have in mind at present where men qualify for positions under local councils, and where they get their knowledge outside the service of the local bodies. For the sake of the councils themselves, and in the public interest, I think it would be wise to accept this amendment.
Comment on this
I wish the Deputy would tell us the cases he has in mind, and explain the wording of the amendment. I may be very dense, but the wording seems to me to convey no meaning at all. I cannot read much into the first three lines of it.
Comment on this
I will give an example. Rathmines Council decided upon a public library, and they advertised for a man with experience of librarian's work—which is a very difficult class of work—to take charge of the library. There was no such man in this part of Ireland at the time. They got a man from another part of Ireland, who had experience under another local authority. One can imagine other cases of this kind, and if there is not such a provision as this in the section, you will be depriving the councils of the chance of getting first-class men. I think Deputy Gorey will admit that that is plain.
Comment on this
I do not think this amendment is really necesary. Presumably, when the local authority would be looking for such a man they would take all those facts into consideration in fixing his salary. If they found that they had got an exceptionally qualified man, they would be willing, I am sure, to pay him a higher salary. When adding years, exceptional qualifications—professional and otherwise—are always taken into consideration. A person possessing such qualifications is treated more liberally in regard to "added years" than a person who has no such qualifications. Accordingly, I do not see any necessity for inserting this amendment in the section.
Comment on this
I submit that Amendment 67 deals with a matter altogether different from Amendment 65.
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy T. Murphy, I move amendment 68:—
"In sub-section (1), line 3, before the word ‘granted' to insert the words ‘which was expressed at the time of granting to be.'"
Comment on this
The amendment is not in my name. I am moving it formally on behalf of Deputy Murphy. Perhaps the Minister would give us his reasons for not accepting it.
Comment on this
This is rather an obscure amendment, and I was waiting for some light to be thrown on it before saying what my attitude would be.
Comment on this
I think the question that is raised in this amendment is connected with war bonuses. (Section quoted.) There may be disputes as to whether a bonus was a war bonus intended to meet the increased cost of living or whether it was an increase, irrespective of that question. To avoid possible disputes as to whether a bonus was a war bonus or not, we ask that it should be inserted that such bonus should have been stated at the time to be a war bonus to meet the increased cost of living.
Comment on this
As continuous service under different local authorities will count for pensionable purposes, it is necessary that some provision should be made whereby the whole onus of paying the pension should not rest on the last local authority who had the services of the officer in question. This section is inserted with a view to enabling the last local authority to be recouped a portion of the pension from the local authorities who were previously served by the officer in question.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say whether the contributing body will have any voice in the fixing of the pension? The last local authority which the officer served will have the fixing of the pension, but the other people whom he served will have to pay a share of it. That, I take it, is the meaning of the section. Will those other bodies whom he served have any voice in fixing the amount to which they will be afterwards called upon to contribute?
Comment on this
I presume those pensions will be granted in consultation with my Department, and it will be finally decided by us what the pensions will be and how they shall be allocated.
Comment on this
I did not refer exclusively to the question of the proportion to be borne by the bodies. The question of giving special treatment to a man may arise on a question of pension—added years and so forth.
Comment on this
It seems to me that in this case we are almost forced to consider the whole question of a national civil service for local administration which was once a prominent plank in the platform of Sinn Fein. If there were such a civil service suitable for local authorities, this matter might easily be arranged to the satisfaction of everybody. I think there is something in what Deputy O'Connell urges —that the final authority, which is paying off the employee and which may have had only a few years of his service, may apply for a considerable pension for him and add a certain number of years for special service. The other bodies will be contributing to that pension. Can the Minister give the Dáil an assurance that the other local authorities that are likely to be called upon to contribute will be taken into consultation before finally approving of the pension? It seems to me that unless there is some assurance that that will be done, the local authorities which were the prior employers may have ground for complaint. While I think it is a very good and necessary thing that the services rendered to local authorities outside the immediate paying body should be taken into account in fixing the pension, still unless there is some fixed scale or clear understanding of what the pension rights are, there must be a promise given that the contributing bodies will be taken into consultation before finally deciding what the amount of pension shall be.
Comment on this
I would like to know from the Minister if there are any precedents for such a section as this, and how they have been found to work?
Comment on this
I do not think there is any precedent for this section, but we consider that it will be of very great help to local authorities. I think it is highly desirable that it should be left in the Bill. With regard to Deputy Johnson's point, presumably the ordinary course will be followed, and the last local authority will be the authority to fix the pension. It would come up before me for sanction or on appeal, and, before sanctioning the pension, I will consult with all the local authorities concerned. I can give the Deputy an undertaking to that effect.
Comment on this
In the absence of a formally established Civil Service, to embrace local as well as national authorities, that method may be satisfactory.
Comment on this
I beg to move the following:
In line 31, after the figures "1892" to insert the words "or the office of Superintendent Registrar or Registrar of Marriages."
I think the Minister will accept this amendment. There is nothing revolutionary in it. Obviously you cannot keep a man all his time registering marriages. Therefore, there is no reason, when a man undertakes it as subsidiary employment, he should be done out of his superannuation. This is an occupation usually undertaken by clerks of boards of guardians, or rural district councils, and it is to safeguard their interest, because they are appointed registrars, and because they should not in consequence cease to become pensionable officers, that I am putting forward this amendment. I think the Minister will have very little difficulty in accepting it.
Comment on this
I am agreeable to accepting the amendment, but I think it would be better if the Deputy altered it to read: "Or the office of superintendent registrar of births, deaths and marriages, or the office of registrar of marriages." It would be more inclusive.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—"To delete the section." I consider that this is a ridiculous section and is quite unworkable. When an officer has retired through incapacity his place is filled, or else the office is abolished and it will be impossible, except extraordinary expenditure is involved, to recall a man to his old office; on the other hand, it would be very difficult to find another office for him. One wonders if an officer has to retire at the age of thirty-five years because of incapacity, and someone is appointed to replace him, if that officer is recalled at the age of fifty or fifty-five years, what will become of the man who succeeded him? The evil which the section aims at seems to be the granting of pensions because of a plea of incapacity, but that should be dealt with at the time the pension is granted. All pensions are subject to the sanction of the Ministry. Surely before the Minister sanctions, he makes exhaustive inquiries? That has been the experience of public boards. I think the Minister will find this section unworkable.
Comment on this
It is a section that I was never keen on. It is an attempt to meet a situation where an officer might possibly be pensioned for incapacity or ill-health. Afterwards he might recover, and it would be only right under those circumstances, that he should be taken back into the service. The objections against the section outweigh the arguments in favour of it, and accordingly, I am willing to have it deleted.
Comment on this
I wanted to support the amendment, but as the Minister is going to withdraw the clause I am quite satisfied.
Comment on this
Congratulate me, because that is the first amendment I have succeeded in getting accepted.
Comment on this
This deals with a difficulty that arises occasionally, and there ought to be some provision made. I quite agree it is a difficult matter to legislate for, but there are cases that occasionally arise and it might be useful to have such a clause as this in the Bill. If the Minister, between this and the Report Stage, would see if a clause in some amended form could be incorporated, it might meet the difficulty. I have known cases where very eminent members of the medical profession have certified that such and such an individual could not live more than a few years, and probably only a few months. Accordingly, they suggested that the individual should be pensioned off. One individual I have in mind was so certified and pensioned a number of years ago, and he lived up to a few months ago. Deputy Sir James Craig will tell us there are exceptions to every rule, but it is extraordinary how some of those pensioned officials have continued to live. Whether the changed circumstances or the change of air have prolonged life, I do not know; but it is extraordinary how long they lived after being pensioned.
Comment on this
It is only Providence knows the future—and Deputy Good. Of course, he might probably venture to state what was going to happen a man, even though that man might be in ill-health. Because of Deputy Good's statement, I will now make the points I was going to make on the amendment. It would be almost impossible—even Deputy Good would find it so—to prove that incapacity had disappeared. It would be a far more serious matter if a man who felt he would be pulled up after a time through health were kept trying to do work which he is incapable of doing. Take the case of a doctor; it may be he is attending poor people, and if he were incapacitated and still kept working the poor would suffer accordingly. It would be much better to get rid of a man who would be incapacitated than to keep him at work at a time when he is unable to work. A doctor who found himself incapable of doing the arduous duties attached to a dispensary district would, possibly, on retirement, seek lesser work, and he might recover fairly decent health. It would be, in such cases, very difficult to get anyone to certify that he would be capable of resuming arduous work again. I observe smiles on the faces of several Deputies when I speak of the arduous work of a dispensary doctor, but that does not detract from the fact that the duties are arduous. The dispensary doctor is never sure whether he is going to spend the night in bed; many Deputies now smiling are always secure in having a decent night's rest. The clause would be quite impracticable as far as medical men are concerned.
Comment on this
I assure Deputy Craig that our smiles had no relation whatever to the arguments he was putting forward.
Comment on this
The Minister is willing to have the section deleted.
Comment on this
Amendments 73 and 74 appear to cover the same subject.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 73:—
To add at the end of the section the words: "Provided always that such officer shall be entitled to be paid reasonable remuneration for any new or increased duties that may devolve upon him under this or any subsequent Act."
Section 42 is a very drastic section. It discourages men already in receipt of pensions from taking other positions. I am quite in sympathy with the section, and I wish it were more widely applied. I think, at the same time, it is only fair that if the pensioner who gets another position gets increased duties, reasonable remuneration for any such increased duties should be given him.
Comment on this
I do not think the Deputy and myself see this section in the same light. I think it is a very valuable section, and I do not think it curtails the right of officers in any way. The object is to prevent an officer, who is changing from one local authority to another, from drawing a pension and salary at the same time. If an officer who has a pension under one local authority gets a position from another, and if the salary combined with the pension brings his remuneration to a higher figure than it formerly was under the position he previously held, then his pension has to be deducted until the salary, plus the portion of the pension left him, equals his previous salary. There is no hardship at all. If an officer prefers to retain his pension and not take up a new position, there is no obligation on him to do so. It is unfair that an officer should be pensioned off under one authority, get a position under another, and then draw a salary and pension together, both being greatly in excess of his previous salary. That only deals with the position at the time of the passing of the Act. If more duties are added to his office his salary, of course, will be increased accordingly, irrespective of whether it brings his salary to a higher figure than what he previously had. It only deals with the transition period at the time of the coming into operation of this Act.
Comment on this
This section takes no account of an officer who, instead of getting a pension, receives a lump sum of, say, £600. That is a very considerable sum, and yet he would be entitled to take up a new position under this Bill. There is nothing suggested to make him pay back the £600. Some provision should be made to reduce the amount of his salary in proportion.
Comment on this
If the combined ingenuity of the Farmers' Party could devise a system whereby we would get back the £600, I would be delighted.
Comment on this
Under this section, suppose an officer who receives, say, £300 gets a position under another local authority worth £200, will that amount be deducted from his superannuation? In Westmeath we have a case of a doctor receiving £600 a year as superannuation. He has had that for the last ten or twelve years. Take the case that such a person has another position, how will he be circumstanced? Will the amount of salary a person earns be deducted from the amount of superannuation he receives? If an officer was in receipt of £300 per year, and got a position at £200, would the local authority only give £100 superannuation instead of £300?
Comment on this
I will feel obliged if the Deputy puts up the full particulars of the case. It is an interesting one.
Comment on this
I think the Minister has taken my illustration as a Chinese puzzle. I want to ask the Minister if an officer who is in receipt of a certain amount of superannuation from a local authority only gains the same by working as by walking around, will he do any work? If an officer is in receipt of £400 a year according to the section, will the amount of money he earned from any other local authority be deducted from the superannuation he receives? In connection with Deputy Wilson's argument to pay the £600 back, I would remind him that anyone who gets a gratuity and is out of employment will spend the gratuity.
Comment on this
This is an important section and provides for the funds out of which officers of committees are to be paid. It is a straight section.
Comment on this
Arising out of a discussion which took place here yesterday, I think sub-section 2 ought to be amended so as to make it mandatory that in the case of officers of the technical instruction committee, the allowance or gratuity to be granted shall be raised out of the same fund as that from which their salaries have been paid. It seems to me that in passing this section we can amend an omission of the Bill. Sub-section (2) says that the local bodies, paying the allowances of gratuities, shall raise such monies by means of the same rate to be charged on the same area at the expenses of such committee or joint committee. If we were to amend it so as to allow pensions or gratuities for technical officers to be paid out of the same fund from which their other charges and expenses are paid, then the objection that was raised yesterday against charging those officers' fees out of the local rate will fall. I would like to ask the Minister if he will agree to an amendment being inserted here which will have that object in view. We might do it at this stage by general consent, with the Ceann Comhairle's permission, or we might do it on the Report Stage. If we can get some expression of opinion from the Minister we would know better how to proceed.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy put his suggested amendment in some form of words? I am inclined to think that it would involve more than the consent he says. It would include the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
The words to be inserted in Sub-section (2) are: "Or in the case of officers of any agricultural or technical instruction committee shall be charged out of the same funds as the expenses of such committee." If those words were inserted, I do not think there would be any more obligation on the Exchequer than there is in connection with any other expenses charged on that fund. It would be simply adding to the normal expenses of the technical instruction committee. They were considering those pensions and allowances as deferred pay. An annual recurring sum, paid for wages and salaries would be increased by an annual recurring sum paid for by pensions, and there would be no necessity to come for further permission to the Treasury. It is a local fund once it has reached the local body.
Comment on this
I do not think I can agree to that because it would be anticipating the arrival of a certain fund which varies considerably every year, and which, perhaps, might not arrive at all. I could not anticipate anything of that kind in legislation dealing with local government exclusively.
Comment on this
I am sorry the Minister could not see his way to consider some such proposal as Deputy Johnson put forward, because it is obvious to everyone who heard the discussion here yesterday afternoon, that it is unfair to throw the whole of the pension of the individual on to the local authority when the local authority only pays 25 per cent. of the salary. The local authority at the moment in connection with those technical officials does not pay in many cases even 25 per cent. of the salary. The effect of what has been carried will be that those local authorities will refuse in order to get out of the liability to carry out the Technical Instruction Act. Instead of any advantage accruing from the proposal, a serious injury will be done to education. That will be unfortunate. I am satisfied, as I had an opportunity of consultation with some of them since the debate yesterday, that that will be the line. They say they are empowered to devote so much to technical education. If, as a result of the passing of this measure, that money is all absorbed in providing pensions for officials engaged in technical education, there will be nothing left for technical education.
Comment on this
This is really a matter that should engage the Minister's consideration. It would be a course that would have the approval of the Deputies. The result of yesterday is going to cause grave injury to technical education.
Comment on this
I support this idea and I think every word Deputy Good has said is true. It is unfair to throw the full charge of the pension on the local bodies, and the effect will be that when those pensions are to be paid the fund available will be swamped. You will have all the agricultural officers coming on the local fund, and it is only reasonable that the fund which pays a certain proportion of the salary should pay also the same proportion of the pensions. I think the matter is not understood fully down the country and that the ratepayers do not know that they are liable for this impost at all.
Comment on this
I would also impress the Minister with the necessity of getting this paid out of the joint fund. Those technical committees down the country are apart from the elected bodies, even though they are appointed by them at first. The elected representatives do not know anything of what is going on at the meetings of the joint committee. I believe there will be an outcry all over the country if the local ratepayers are asked to pay those pensions, and I think the Minister should give an assurance to the House that he will consider this on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
This section dealing with technical and agricultural instructors was inserted following the wishes of the Minister for Agriculture. I do not believe he will be responsible for putting forward any suggestion that would militate against the efficient working of those officers, as he has their interests very much at heart. I realise there is a difficulty about the incidence of this particular pension, and between now and the Report Stage I will consult the Minister for Agriculture as to whether any more popular arrangement can be come to. Deputies must be aware, as I mentioned when we were discussing the principle of those officers being made pensionable, that the local authority has a choice in the matter.
Comment on this
It seems to me it is a matter for finance, and I would not like the Minister for Local Government to give a promise that a decision would be come to before the next Stage. It might involve large sums to the Exchequer. If arrangements of this nature were come to hurriedly there might be thousands of pounds expended which need not be expended, if a well-devised scheme was adopted. As far as the Ministry of Finance is concerned, it has had no opportunity of considering pensions which would be largely State-contributed pensions for those teachers.
I presume there are not so many of those going to get pensions immediately and it is not impossible to have the matter considered on another occasion. I think it would be an unsatisfactory procedure if a matter involving large financial considerations was to be put up and if people whose business it is to consider financial proposals did not have an opportunity of considering them. I think this is a matter that can be threshed out on another occasion, but I would not like to bring in a financial resolution at a few days' notice. I know people who want expenditure put through, decide the whole scheme, and send it up to the Department of Finance with the request that sanction should be given within an hour. I resist that, because where a hurried financial sanction is given, larger sums may be involved than were at first intended.
Comment on this
Might I point out in reply to the Minister for Finance that education is a national charge and it has been decided that technical education should become part of the work of the Ministry of Education? Why should the pensions of teachers in one department of education be paid by the State while those in another department of the same system of education are paid by the local authority? The thing is wrong in principle. I agree with the Minister that in the present straitened conditions of the finances of the country one does not want to add to the burdens if it can be avoided, but this, to my mind, is wrong in principle —putting on the local authorities a charge which we all agree should fall on the State.
Comment on this
I think it would be a most undesirable form of procedure to rush a charge like this on to the National Exchequer by, as it were, a side wind without it being considered by itself and found to be satisfactory. There are other teachers also under the Ministry of Education for whom we provide a graded salary scale but for whom we do not, at any rate for the present, provide a pension scheme. I think that everybody would feel that it would be unsatisfactory if in, say, a Compulsory School Attendance Bill some pension scheme for secondary teachers was rushed. I think it would be a sounder procedure to decide that the whole matter of pensions should stand over and be considered fully and completely on its merits and not brought in in this way without consideration. That sort of procedure would make it impossible to keep control over expenditure and over the balance at which we ought to aim.
Comment on this
I think that there is some misapprehension about this matter. As I understand the position it is this. Certain funds coming from the State and certain funds coming from the local authority go to meet the costs of agricultural and technical instruction in particular districts. If it is decided that in those particular districts certain persons should be pensioned, according to the proposal of the Minister it would seem that a new rate would have to be levied in these districts to provide pensions. The natural thing that should occur is that the additional sum of money available would become a burden on the State. I agree with the Minister that it would be foolish to say that the whole expense should be borne by the State.
Comment on this
Will the Minister tell us whether in the case of technical instruction expenditure it is necessary for him to sanction all the items in the same way that he would sanction the expenditure of any other Department? I am surprised if that is so. I am surprised if the Minister for Finance is called upon to sanction the expenditure, say, in salaries of the officers of the Department of Technical Instruction. If that is not so we are not asking him to introduce any new principle or at least, he is asking us to introduce, or he is taking upon himself the power to introduce, a new principle that is to interfere with the expenditure of the joint committee, the local authority, and what was the Department of Agriculture. The proposals in the Bill surely are to be considered in the same light as salaries and payments given to officers of that department, and, if in the apportionment of a scheme of working for a particular year, their salaries, travelling expenses, and various other items that go to make up a scheme of expenditure, and if the addition to that is a certain sum for pensions, surely that would not bring it into the purview of the Ministry of Finance if all the other items have not already been within his purview.
The case for putting down the funds to be locally expended by these authorities seems to me to be unanswerable, and why it should require special sanction by the Minister for Finance, when the salaries themselves do not require that special sanction I cannot understand.
Comment on this
I am not raising the question of the sanction of the Minister for Finance, but I think there ought to be fair consideration allowed to the Minister for Finance for all proposals involving expenditure. It is only by giving such consideration that that expenditure can be controlled. A proposal like this, putting a heavy charge on State funds, ought to be reasonably considered. The endowment of the Department of Agriculture does not meet the expense of the activities that stand against it. That endowment fund has to be supplemented. Any general charges laid on this fund will have to be met ultimately by an increased vote of the Oireachtas. If you have a pension charge there is not going to be a reduction of other expenses, as that charge would be an additional one. I think, as a matter of fact, it would be a much more satisfactory thing to postpone the consideration of pensions altogether, and let this be considered fairly and squarely as a matter by itself, rather than have it prejudiced by having it brought forward as a side line.
Comment on this
I do not think that there will be much discussion on this section. The object is to ensure that where the State finds that there is a servant of a local authority who can give conspicuous service to the State in any capacity, as a result of his experience with the local authority, such officer should be available to the State. The State could take him without depriving him of his pension rights. In many cases it was found that men with such experience would lose their rights to pension if taken over by the central authority, and that that prevented them giving service to the State. I think it is in the interests of all parties that this difficulty should be got over and that officers who leave local authorities to take service under the State should be allowed to get pensions under the local authority. This section provides for that, but, of course, they do not become pensionable until their term of office under the State has expired. Then their pensionable rights under local authorities will be revived.
Comment on this
Will the Minister say why it is thought necessary to put in the limit of the 6th December, 1922? I understand that there are some officers in the service at present who were taken over a few years before that. Is there any reason why these officers would not have the right given to those taken over since the 6th December, 1922? I know that there are two or three agricultural instructors who were taken into the central office before that date.
Comment on this
Does the Minister say that he could not go back further than December, 1922? I do not see that it would be contrary to the Constitution if he did so, and I would like the Ceann Comhairle's opinion on that.
Comment on this
Do I understand that the position is that an officer with long service, before being taken over under this section, will not get any credit for service previous to December, 1922? Does an officer, say, with ten years' service get no credit?
Comment on this
If he is taken over after that date all his previous service would count for pension rights.
Comment on this
There was an argument a little while ago put up by the Minister on the question of a servant under a Northern authority being taken into the service of a Southern authority. The Minister in that case said that the new authority would take into account his qualifications in fixing the salary, but that his service in the Northern authority ought not to be considered in fixing his pension. Surely that will apply in this case? Surely the central authority taking over the service of a man from the local authority will take into account his service with that body?
Comment on this
I think we will leave the Minister to answer that to-morrow.
Progress ordered to be reported.