COMMITTEE ON FINANCE. - ESTIMATES FOR PUBLIC SERVICES. VOTE 56—POST OFFICE (RESUMED).
Contributions 1–131 of 266. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
This Vote has been discussed at considerable length on two successive days, and perhaps if the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs would now reply to the points raised by the various speakers it might help to shorten the discussion under the various sub-heads.
Comment on this
I hope the discussion will be closed upon the special points replied to. We are now embarking on the third day's discussion of these Estimates, and I think it is only right that the various points brought out in the previous days' discussions should be replied to, and I hope to be able to reply to them to the satisfaction of the Committee.
One of the earliest points raised in these Estimates bore on the charges collected for the delivery of telegrams in rural areas. This charge was introduced practically two years ago. It had existed in the old British days in a more modified form but during the war it was discontinued. We found after examination that it was necessary for financial reasons and from the point of view of equity to reintroduce it. The amount collected for the porterage of telegrams, in the first year, amounted to about £41,000; the present collection will be somewhat less than that amount £41,000 is not a small sum of money, and, as I pointed out, we are already losing cent. per cent on our telegraph business. The State must try to draw the line, in its losses, somewhere. It may be that a sum of forty or forty one thousand pounds or whatever the figure may be could be lightly glossed over, and worked into the general national finances without being seen. It only takes twenty-five such sums to make a million of money, and a million of money is a big factor in our general finances, and it is by overlooking sums like this that we neglect the millions.
That is one feature. Another, from the same view point, is that this sum of forty thousand pounds could be usefully applied to industry. It would help agriculture, and it might help a variety of things in the State and, certainly, a variety of things that would be more useful to the State than merely parting with it in the way it has been done hitherto. I see no reason whatever, nor did I at any time, why the recipients of telegrams should not pay for the cost of the delivery of them. We are asking for that to-day, and no more. We make no profit on the transaction and certainly we are not prepared to accept anything less. It is just one of those ordinary transactions for which the citizens must pay and there is no reason why they should escape it simply because the State is the agent. If the rural resident desires to have delivered to him some article of ordinary consumption from a neighbouring town, well, I am very sure he would have to pay for it either directly or indirectly. Likewise, if he wants a telegram delivered it is only just that he should pay for it. If he does not wish to have it delivered he can inform the local postmaster that he does not desire that his telegrams should be delivered to him by special messenger, in which case they can be posted and delivered through the medium of the post the following morning. He can have it one way or another. We intend to continue the present charges.
Deputy Hewat has suggested that the present Civil Service bonus should be absorbed in a common wage. I do not know whether the Minister for Finance has gone into that question or not. I have not, at any rate, gone into it. My own view is that it is premature. However, it is a matter for general Governmental policy, not for one particular Department.
Deputy Davin urged the Post Office to extend its insurance business. The Post Office has been doing some insurance business in a limited way, and it does not look at the moment as if it were likely to extend very rapidly. I personally consider that there are grounds for the consideration of this business. The nation is parting with some £4,000,000 to foreign companies just now, and I doubt if it is getting very full value in return. Anyhow, that is a debatable question and one on which many people have different views. However, it is a question that should receive early consideration. Whether a Department like mine should go deeper into this question is a matter on which I do not venture an opinion, though I feel that it is a Department that could extend in that way. I feel that there is room for extension and I would not be averse to it. As a matter of fact I would rather like the idea of the Government taking up consideration of the whole insurance business. As far as the activities of the Post Office in that direction are concerned, they are not very hopeful at the moment. Deputy Davin also seemed to conclude that the Post Office administration had something to say to the retirement of 657 officials from this Department under Article 10 of the Treaty. It had nothing whatever to say to the retirement of these officials. Immediately after the Treaty, practically every one of these applicants for retirement availed of that opportunity—at least gave an intimation of their intention to retire. That decision on their part was come to at a time when they could not have anticipated either good or bad treatment at the hands of the Department. The fact is that a big number of the civil servants were nearing the normal age of retirement and the Treaty Article gave them an opportunity of adding some years to their term of service that would not ordinarily have been included. Besides that, there were at the time a great many people who concluded that the advantage of a substantial pension would make them very much better off in the outside world, seeing that a lot of people thought in the years 1921 and 1922 that we were likely to be in for a kind of El Dorado. That did not materialise. Nevertheless, that was the viewpoint and they concluded that the addition of a pension would simply make them. It has not worked out that way. Many people who went out on pension, and availed of Article 10 of the Treaty, would be very glad to get back again. They now find that they made a serious mistake. That is their own look out. My Department resisted, as far as possible, the extension of the provisions of Article 10 to anyone. We could not see that men who denied that they were Nationalists, had any justification, or that there was any truth in the contention, that they could not serve a native Government. We never believed that story, and we did our best to prevent the extension of the provisions of Article 10 to the overwhelming majority of those people.
Deputy McCullough and a number of other Deputies urged that we should either discontinue the collection of the sixpenny tax on parcels or introduce some kind of clearing house scheme, which would facilitate business people. I take it that the Deputies who spoke on this point were mainly concerned with business people. Very few have sympathy with those who avail of the advertisements in English newspapers to buy articles on the other side, instead of buying them at home. I certainly have very little sympathy with that class of trade, considering that the finances of our Exchequer, and the rates of the country and employment in the country are dependent, to no small extent, on the business that these shopkeepers do. We have a certain amount of sympathy, no doubt, with the shopkeeper who is put to a good deal of inconvenience in these daily collections. If the shopkeepers, or the business people, can see any way by which the charge may be reduced or its collection facilitated, a suggestion from them will be sympathetically considered. I cannot promise more, because on a matter of this kind I am bound up by the regulations of the Ministry of Finance. Certainly, I am prepared to give sympathetic consideration to any proposals that may come from business people. The imposition of this tax has been a useful one to the traders of this country. They are now realising that fact. At first they jumped to the conclusion that it would be of no assistance and give a good deal of trouble. In the interval, the number of incoming parcels annually dropped from 2,900,000 to close on 2,000,000—or a drop of nearly one-third in the space of twelve months. The former import of these parcels was 3,000,000 and the export one million, leaving a margin of 2,000,000 parcels in favour of the exporter on the English side. We had to deliver those 2,000,000 excess parcels. We had practically nothing for the work, except a sum of threepence per parcel for delivery and everybody will agree that threepence would not go any distance in meeting the expense of delivery. The delivery tax of sixpence enables us to go a long way to meet the deficit suffered from the excess import. It has not entirely met it, but it has increased our revenue by £50,000, and it has deflected a considerable trade to Irish shopkeepers, the volume of which can be measured in terms of one million parcels.
These two facts are sufficient justification for the introduction of that charge of 6d. When we have arrived at the stage that the incoming and outgoing parcels balance each other, we may consider whether it will not be possible to remove the collection altogether. If we arrived at such a balance of outgoing and incoming parcels, the removal of the charge could be reasonably considered. I gave that promise at the introduction of this charge, and I have not departed from it.
Deputy Heffernan referred to party-lines for rural telephones. There was no necessity to remind us of the importance of party lines from the standpoint of economy. You cannot have an extensive extension of telephones in rural parts, because of the expense of individual installations. You can do it only through the party line system.
Comment on this
The fault is not on our part. We had not the same complaint to make of any other Minister.
Comment on this
I can assure Deputy Heffernan that the party system, from the point of view of expense, will be fully availed of on every opportunity, now that we are arriving at the stage when we should be able to extend 'phones into farmers' houses. The Deputy also mentioned the hardship suffered by country people through the withdrawal of bank holiday deliveries. That withdrawal was not initiated in our time. It existed long before our time, and if we were to reintroduce deliveries on those days it would cost the tidy sum of £10,000. I ask the Dáil whether we would be justified in letting loose a whole army of postmen through the country on bank holidays for the delivery of a letter or two in some districts. I do not think we would. In rural England, with all their money, they have not thought that an extension of this kind was justified.
Comment on this
Yes. We are always glad to get suggestions for the running of a Department of this kind. When a useful suggestion is made, it is taken up and developed as far as possible. For that reason, I am glad that several Deputies suggested the introduction of the "zone" system for parcels and letters. Without very careful examination, we cannot say whether the "zone" system would be practicable or not, but we will promise to examine it.
Deputy Cooper urged a direct exchange of parcels with France, because of the new silk and other import duties in England. These duties do not affect our trade with France in any way. Our parcels come direct and untouched. In any case, our means of direct communication with that country are too restricted to enable us to concentrate on a parcels business there. Comparisons were made with the more general delivery of letters in Switzerland. We give here—with the exception of a few rural areas—one delivery per day. In a great many towns we give two deliveries and in certain cities we give three deliveries. My own opinion is that in no case should we give more than one delivery to a private house. Any additional number, I believe, is superfluous and a loss of public money. In a number of cases we are giving a second delivery, but whether that second delivery will be wiped out or not I cannot say. Certainly we have no intention of increasing it. It is easy to make comparisons with foreign countries. Switzerland is a large hotel. We are in a very different position. The Swiss people must necessarily spend money in this particular way to get money. We have no intention, at the moment, of making any increase in our deliveries. I believe that this money can be better spent otherwise, and we cannot have deliveries without expenditure of public moneys.
Deputy Heffernan, I think, referred to the increase of expenditure on the headquarters staff by £8,125. Five thousand pounds of this increase is due to increased cost-of-living bonus. The balance is accounted for by ordinary increments. Our headquarters staffs are, in the main, composed of new men consequent on retirements due to Article 10. Their salaries increase from year to year. There is no undue expense incurred in connection with our headquarters, but we find it necessary to keep headquarters strong. We find it is good business. Expenditure at the head is very often expenditure in the right direction. At any rate, we have found it to be so. Deputy Johnson seems to be somewhat alarmed at the proposal that we should part with any of our factory operations——
Comment on this
During the debate on the Shannon Bill somebody—I think it was the Minister for Industry and Commerce—referred to the possibility of some big electrical manufacturing company getting going in this country. In the last year, according to a booklet dealing with trade and shipping statistics, the amount of money sent out of this country for electrical goods reached the formidable figure of £400,000. With the Shannon scheme, and with a growing development in telephones, that figure will be materially augmented in the next three or four years, and it may, perhaps, be doubled. Clearly, there is room here for an electrical industry. Whether it should be run by the State or by private enterprise is a matter on which people hold different views. In either event, it will mean a big expenditure, a very big expenditure, of initial capital.
I do not think that the State ought to embark on a great electrical industry. I do not think it would be able to handle it as effectively as, let us say, some English or foreign electrical people. I cannot conceive how it could. I would be very glad to be told how; but I am not satisfied that we could. At the same time, I am satisfied that we ought to encourage the setting up of an electrical industry. There is really too much money being sent out of this country in this respect. In any case, it is a key industry and we cannot get on without key industries. If a foreign industry is started here, one of the initial requirements will be that the Post Office work, the total Post Office electrical work, outside the area of repairs, should be its monopoly within reasonable prices.
Comment on this
Will the Minister say what would happen supposing two or three such firms start this business? To which of them will he hand over the business?
Comment on this
I am pretty sure, at any rate, that no foreign industry will start here if the Government intends to maintain a rival factory. I do not think it would be justified, from its own viewpoint. Now, there is just one other point that I have to refer to. During the last week I have had a number of discussions with the Minister for Finance on the question of broadcasting. The Minister has agreed to my proposal to run broadcasting by the State. It is intended to erect a main station at Dublin and a subsidiary station at Cork. At a later stage this plant will, no doubt, be supplemented. For the present it is intended to confine ourselves to those two stations. The cost of the main station and the substation—the laying down cost—will, we estimate, reach the figure of £9,000. We anticipate that the mechanical upkeep and the cost of programmes will work out at something like £20,000 a year. We believe—though this is a guess and there is nothing to guide us, not very much anyway—that the first year ought to bring about 10,000 subscribers, at £1 per subscriber. This would leave us in the first year with a loss of about £10,000. In the second year it is thought that the number of subscribers ought to reach 15,000, or perhaps somewhat more, and we have concluded that in the third year the station will pay its way.
Comment on this
Within five years we believe the original loss will be wiped out. Now, there are 20,000 subscribers in the Six Counties. We have endeavoured to ascertain what part of this number is due to the installation of a station there. It will be agreed that the Belfast mind is a little more pro-English than the Dublin mind, and that the development of broadcasting in that city had reached a higher degree at the time of the introduction of the station than has been the case here, where we have had only somewhat over 2,000 people owning up. The number may have been somewhat more.
Comment on this
We have not been able to ascertain that. We are inclined to think the number of non-crystal sets were pretty numerous at the time of the introduction of the broadcasting station.
Comment on this
Anyhow, we have come to the conclusion that these figures which I have quoted fairly well represent the position. Everybody knows you can quote different figures, but you have nothing to support them. At the best, it is a calculation only—a guess. In the course of the debate information was sought regarding the statistical tax authority. Deputy Cooper desired to know whether we had any authority for the introduction of this tax in the first instance. At the time I stated that the Dáil was notified in the previous Estimates that this tax would be introduced. Anybody who takes the trouble to refer to my statement on that occasion will see that it was very definite. I said, subject to the approval of the Minister for Finance—an approval which I anticipated securing—that the tax of 6d. on parcels would be introduced at a certain date.
Comment on this
I propose moving under Standing Order 93 for a reconsideration of this Vote for a certain reason which I propose to set out, very largely following on the statement that the Minister has just made, but largely owing to the very nature of the Vote that we have before us. I suggest to the Dáil that it is quite impossible for the Dáil to give the consideration that a Vote of this kind requires with only one side of the Department's balance sheet before it. We have got before us here the Estimates. I have not intervened in this debate before because I was waiting to get hold of the official report of the Minister's speech in introducing this Vote last Thursday. I have gone through that speech, and I still fail to find in it any statement of some of the essential figures representing the revenue side of the balance sheet. All we have got before us in this Estimate is the expenditure side of the balance sheet. I will touch upon this more fully later on. The Minister has already mentioned certain important decisions which he has taken. He has intimated other decisions that he probably will, or may, take in regard to the delivery of telegrams and the delivery of letters. All these decisions follow upon information at his disposal respecting the balance of revenue as against expenditure.
Those decisions, I suggest, are not Government decisions, under the Constitution. They are the decisions directly of the Minister responsible to the Dáil, and therefore we ought to have this particular service brought before us in a form different from the form that has been adopted for other Departments. It is quite right and perfectly just that the Department of Finance should be brought under the review of the Dáil only in respect to expenditure and in the form of Estimates for expenditure, because there is no revenue on the other hand to balance the matter. It is perfectly correct that the Department of Industry and Commerce, where there is an expenditure but no revenue, should have the expenditure placed before us in the ordinary form of the Estimates. But in the case of the Post Office, I suggest that is not a practicable or a wise course, and particularly that it is an unwise course, having regard to the fact that the Constitution has made this particular Minister who is in charge of the Department so accountable, specifically and deliberately responsible to the Dáil as a whole.
Comment on this
Every other Minister is not. The Executive Ministers are responsible to the Dáil under the Constitution through the Executive Council, and in the general corporate responsibility of the Executive Council.
Comment on this
They are responsible to the Dáil as a body, but they are appointed and nominated by the President himself, and not by the Dáil. These extern Ministers are nominated by the Dáil, and there is a distinction laid down in the Constitution. Apart from that, the Minister for Finance will not deny that the Department of Posts and Telegraphs is different from every other Department in this: that its decision should be very largely motived on questions of economy, and these questions of economy cannot be determined until we know not merely what are the outgoings, but also the Dáil should be able to know what the incoming is. I am not entering on a criticism of this particularly. I know this is a form of estimate that the Minister has received. It is one that has been adopted before in the practice of another country, and we have taken it over. I do not say that the Minister should, on this particular occasion, have introduced his estimates in the form I now suggest. If he had done so——
Comment on this
As Deputy Figgis is so keen on constitutional matters I might remind him that it is not the responsibility of the Minister to bring in estimates. It is the responsibility of the Executive Council.
Comment on this
Very well. if it is the responsibility of the Executive Council to bring in estimates in this particular form, that is simply determined by the precedents that have prevailed in this particular case. I suggest now, for the consideration of the Dáil, that these precedents are not applicable to a Department of this kind, where you have not merely an outgoing but an incoming also, and where you have very important decisions, decisions not taken by the Executive Council, but decisions at least taken on the initiative of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs.
Comment on this
If the Minister for Finance is going to conduct a duologue with me I am quite content to conduct it and to go into matters that he and I discussed before. I might remind the Minister for Finance that it was I who stated originally in the Constituent Assembly that the extern Ministers would be simply digits on the hands of the Executive Council, and that it was the Minister who denied that, and said that these Ministers would be separately and individually responsible. If the Minister is now coming round to the point of view I then held I welcome him as a convert, though I am not particularly glad to see it.
In any case, there are various matters that the Dáil is asked to take a decision in regard to. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, last Thursday, informed us that the Department was now losing less than it did at the beginning. The loss has fallen now to £600,000. I want to make it clear that when I ask that future reports (I will not call them estimates) of this particular Department presented to the Dáil, should be presented in a form showing expenditure on the one hand and revenue on the other, I am not going to urge, what I believe Deputy Hewat has already, that no expenditure should be taken outside the revenue. I am not urging that in the least.
Deputy Johnson last year stated— quite correctly in my judgment, at least he expressed my view in so saying —that there are certain losses which might be incurred by a department that would be quite right and proper for that department to incur and that we could not look at the thing strictly from a business standpoint in that respect. We ought to know where that loss occurs and we ought to have that fulness of information before us by which we can detect: "Here is a loss and here is a gain." We ought to be able to decide whether these losses are justified or whether these gains are justified. Take the case that the Minister mentioned to-day—the question of losses on telegrams to which reference has been made. This is what he said last Thursday: "The charges for delivery are not included in the telegraph revenue. They are treated separately. The telegraph revenue for last year"— and he interposed here—"I have not the figures here, because we are not dealing with a section of the revenue; we are dealing with the whole service —amounted to something in the neighbourhood of £200,000. The expenditure exceeded £400,000. It was something like £420,000." Now I suggest that figures of that kind should not only be set out in that form before this Dáil but that the Minister should not say: "I have not the figures here." We ought to have these figures here.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy referring to the expenses of last year and the receipts for last year, or the estimated receipts for the coming year?"
Comment on this
I am referring to the expenses for the previous year. We ought to have them in order that we might be able to determine on them exactly what policy in particular respects the Department would be justified in adopting for the coming year. The Minister made another statement, for example, in regard to the delivery of letters. There have been complaints. Deputies who live in and who may represent Dublin constituencies are frequently getting complaints with regard to the infrequency of deliveries of letters. The Minister stated that he believed that one delivery for each private house per day was all that would be justified, and he intimated that it was possible that he would come to a decision to restrict deliveries in the future to that one delivery. He takes that decision according to the best knowledge available to him in consultation with his officials, just as he takes the decision with regard to the delivery of telegrams in rural areas in consultation with his officials, and takes it according to the best judgment and wisdom that he has. I am not questioning all that in the least; what I am saying is that these are decisions in respect of which the Dáil ought to be consulted, and before the Dáil can be consulted I think the Dáil should have the revenue figures put before it for each closing year, together with the expenditures for that year. This Department is very largely a business Department, and I guard myself there again by saying that when I describe it as a business Department I do not necessarily mean that the expenditure would always be kept down to the revenue; but fundamentally it is a business Department, different in that regard from other Departments, inasmuch as it is a revenue-earning department, and decisions taken should be decisions taken much in the same way as business decisions generally are taken, that is that the particular person, the managing director of the firm, or whoever it may be who has to take the decision, should report and consult with those to whom he is responsible. I suggest that that would not only be desirable from the point of view—I do not say in every little detail, but on broad lines—of the Dáil, and necessary for its consideration of the estimates of the Department when they are laid before the Dáil each year, but that that is just as necessary and just as wise for the Minister to take in his own interest.
I refer to another statement of his last Thursday, where he was dealing with the parcels tax. He said: "A good deal of agitation has gone on for its removal in the interval, but we feel that we would not be justified in making any change. I do not think that this country can afford to be philanthropic in dealing with surplus incoming traffic. We are merely asking these people who get parcels from abroad to pay part of their way." Then he went on to indicate that there had been a very substantial reduction; the figures which he gave were that parcels had dropped from 2,900,000 to 2,000,000. I suggested when he was speaking last Thursday that I would like to have fuller information in regard to that. It has been said to me that items that previously were sent over in separate parcels are now being sent over in larger parcels, that a reduction actually in the number of parcels is occurring, but that the size of the parcels is larger, and that the reduction in the number of parcels is not commensurate with the number of articles that are sent. Deputy Cooper, at the same time, asked if information would be given to the Dáil, not only in regard to parcels but to show the number of items that were sent over by book post. I suggest to the Dáil that in the matter of this 6d. parcels tax, information of that kind is essential to the taking of a decision. The Dáil took a decision to adopt this parcels delivery tax, and now when we come to the end of the first year of its working I suggest that information of this kind ought to be in the possession of Deputies in order that Deputies might be able to know whether not merely the parcels are dropping but, on the broader aspect of it, that the tax is justifying itself. If I may revert again to the expenditure on letter deliveries, the Minister stated in regard to the reduction in the number of deliveries per day in different districts: "The expenditure under this head is expenditure in the right direction." That may be, but it would be much better for the Dáil if it had before it the figures on the one hand and the figures on the other, so that the Dáil might be able to know whether the expenditure is justifiable expenditure or not, as it cannot take the cost of telegrams, or parcels, or letters, or any of the branches of this service, until it has in its possession information on both sides of the balance sheet. I wish to add this, that the Estimates that are put before us are drawn out in very great and commendable detail. So far as the expenditure is concerned the detail is far ampler and far more complete than for any other Department. But the Minister did himself recognise the substance of the case that I am making. I think it was last year—it might have been the year before, perhaps both years, but one of these two years in any case—before we came to the consideration of the Vote for the Ministry of Post and Telegraphs, Deputies were provided with a very full, a very satisfactory statement by the Minister as to the working of the Department, and it proved of the very greatest possible help and convenience to Deputies in discussing the expenditure that the Dáil was asked to sanction. That practice might have been continued this year. I am urging that that practice should be continued in future, not merely that an innovation should be made——
Comment on this
I think it was. I spoke for an hour and twenty minutes in making my preliminary statement. I suggest that that was a justification of the promise I gave. The Deputy may not have been here.
Comment on this
I was here. I listened to it and I waited to read it when I got a copy of it this morning. But it does not set it out in that form which he gave us, either last year or the year before, and I suggest it is desirable that we should receive it in that form, that obviously when you have a Department that is receiving revenue as well as incurring expenditure we ought to be able to have each side of the balance sheet before we undertake the determination of the particular heads of expenditure for the future, when these particular heads of expenditure involve very important matters determining policy.
Comment on this
We are all children of inconsistency, and I wish to call attention to a little inconsistency on the part of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. He is a standard bearer of protection; no one in the country is such a standard bearer in the cause of protection; and it rather comes as a shock to me when I open the envelope of a telegram and see an advertisement for Beecham's pills, or some tonic from across the water. I am not a protectionist, but I am inclined to throw away the telegram when that happens, until it strikes me that I have paid sixpence to the Minister for this piece of paper advertising a foreign nostrum, or a foreign tonic. I think that the Minister ought to give very serious attention to this. Probably he counts it as one of the revenues which help to meet the enormous expenditure on the Post Office. However, even though it may bring in a considerable amount of revenue, I hope that it will not be continued, that no foreign nostrum or commodity of any description will be advertised by any Government Department. Furthermore, I wish to have the postal communications worked more expeditiously than they are at the present moment. It is a rather curious procedure to have the postal matter from several towns in Mayo brought up to Roscommon, Athlone or Ballmasloe and then sent back the following day to the towns to which they are addressed. This also requires some attention. If the office expenditure would not allow this to be remedied I hope, notwithstanding the great loss coming from stoppage of advertisements of foreign matter, that the Minister will pay attention to that matter.
Comment on this
I am not going to enter into a discussion with regard to advertisements, say of Beecham's pills, on the back of telegram forms. I am not going to deal with that at all. I want to approach this question and to prove logically that the attitude of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs with respect to this item of telegrams is wrong and unjust. I want to put it up to the members of the Dáil that it is unjust, and I want later on to have, by a vote, a clear opinion given here by them as to what their view is with regard to the conduct of this service. The Minister, on Thursday last, told us that his actions were based on the action of the Dáil, and that the Dáil would not do this or that. Therefore he has put it up to every member of the Dáil to consider what they think is right or wrong with respect to this policy. While I am on this I may refer to a speech of Deputy Good, delivered here on Friday last. Deputy Good said, when referring to this telegram service:—
The telegraphic service is, I am afraid, more than any other of the postal services what we might call an abused service. It is used very largely, as was pointed out, for betting and other purposes that cannot by any means be looked upon as national assets. To withdraw charges about which complains have been made would mean that the service would be more largely used for these particular purposes, and that larger use would create very much larger losses.
I want you to take particular note of this, because he referred to the charge for delivery outside a certain radius.
Deputy Heffernan pointed out that it costs 1s. 6d. to deliver a telegram a distance of four miles from a post office. His idea appeared to be, and I think to some extent it is Deputy Johnson's, although he did not express it very clearly, that there should be a flat rate for telegrams. The Deputy advanced in the argument he put forward a little along that road, but he did not go quite as far as Deputy Heffernan. We know that in the West there are places eight, ten or fifteen miles from a post office. In many cases the telegraph service is made use of for purposes that could be dealt with by ordinary letter post.
There were some other references I am not able to trace, but from the one I am able to trace I can adduce an abuse of this particular service, and this particular abuse is connected with betting telegrams. He stated that this abuse is connected with betting telegrams. He stated that this abuse is attributable more to the rural population than to anyone else. I venture to suggest that not one out of one thousand telegrams in connection with betting have been sent from rural areas. It is quite true that telegrams are sent by residents in rural areas, but those residents go to a telegraph office to send them. Thus there is no extra cost to the State and these are received by Deputy Hewat's constituents, by the people who are living within his magic circle and are given free delivery. If any telegrams are sent back it is between the recipient and his agents in towns and villages who are living also within this free delivery circle. Deputy Good wanted to make out by implication that the abuse of those messages was confined to the rural population alone. I say it is not. I say it is a libel on the rural population. There is no extra cost incurred by your rural population in respect to this, because when a man wants to send to a bookmaker he goes to the telegraph office and delivers his telegram. I am sorry Deputy Good is not here. He might have a little more to say on this.
Now we come to deal with the charges for this particular service. The Minister said to-day that £40,000 has been collected last year or the year before for the charges of this particular service for the rural areas.
Comment on this
We will be quite safe in taking £41,000 as a conservative figure. It is not as much this year. There is a total loss on the service of £220,000 or about one quarter of a million. The charge for extra delivery to the country is £41,000. We have not the figures Deputy Figgis asked for but those figures give us something to go on with. Adopting a very conservative attitude with regard to what those services are, let us say there is only a charge of 1/- for each telegram. I know in a considerable amount of instances it comes up to 2/6, especially to creameries. I can name three of them in my own constituency, so that the smallest average is 1/- for each delivery. That will give you the amount of telegrams delivered in rural areas. If there is a loss of 1/- on each telegram it is represented in £220,000. Therefore delivery outside the mile limit would stand in the ratio of 41 to 220.
Something like 5½ telegrams are despatched within the mile radius to one despatched outside. In that way again we get a very fair idea of the number of telegrams despatched and where they are delivered. Everybody who receives a telegram contributes to this loss of £220,000. The Minister puts the loss at one shilling for each telegram. According to the figures I have given, evidently every person living outside the mile radius who receives a telegram almost pays for the entire cost—he certainly pays the extra shilling. £220,000 less £41,000 is the total loss within the mile radius, because most of our population, especially the business population, live within the mile radius. I should like to have authoritative figures from the Minister as to the number of telegrams delivered both inside and outside the mile radius and the two mile radius. Until we get these figures we can only arrive at an approximate calculation. But if you take one shilling as the average charge for delivery, it is easy to arrive at the number of telegrams delivered outside the mile radius. I want to know why people resident outside the mile radius should be asked to make good £41,000 while those inside get off scot free, and the State has to make up for a loss of £180,000 for the service within the mile radius. I should like to hear the Minister answering those figures. I feel sure that the Minister, as well as the Minister for Finance and the President, are broadminded enough not to look at the matter from the point of view of individuals, but from the point of view of the State and the right of every citizen.
Comment on this
It might be better if I corrected a few of the Deputy's figures. He appears to be getting rather deeply into trouble.
Comment on this
I made it clear at the outset that the porterage charges for telegrams are not included one way or the other in the loss on the telegraph service. The loss on the telegraph service is about £220,000, not £180,000. The second point is this: the person who contributes to the porterage of a telegram also receives the advantage of the first mile free, the same as the person who lives within the mile radius.
Comment on this
That makes a big difference. The person outside the mile radius gets precisely the same advantage from the State contribution as the person inside. Therefore, the Deputy has no case.
Comment on this
The Minister has proved his contention to his own satisfaction evidently, but he has not proved it to the satisfaction of anybody else. If he is able to dispute my figures, that £41,000 represents the total for telegrams delivered outside the mile area, I am prepared to admit that my case does not hold water. If he is prepared to prove by figures that more than 41,000 telegrams, or an appreciable number that affects the total, are delivered outside the mile area, I am prepared to accept these figures.
Comment on this
I mean the number of telegrams represented by £41,000. If the Minister's argument is good with regard to the £41,000 it is also good with regard to the £220,000. If £41,000 is received from telegrams delivered outside the mile area, I want to ask the Minister if that sum does not represent the telegrams delivered outside that radius to the extent of a shilling per telegram— 41,000 multiplied by 20.
I am aware that in the rural areas— this may interest Deputy Johnson; probably he knows it already—telegraph messengers are retained as part-time employees at a very small salary. I know of such messengers being paid 5s. per week for part time. In exceptional cases I believe they receive 10s. The general rule is to allow the sub-Postmaster or sub-Postmistress so much for a telegraph messenger. I would be very much surprised if these messengers are paid more than ten shillings per week for part-time work. Such a messenger, paid five shillings a week, would collect at least ten shillings per week in extra charges for delivery. Therefore, the postal service makes 100 per cent. profit. I know of a postal district where the messenger is getting ten shillings per week for part-time work. For delivering telegrams to my house he would receive the whole of that ten shillings, and more, in extra charges for delivery. I have often paid fifteen shillings within a week for delivery, and as much as twenty shillings. Therefore, I paid 100 per cent. more than the boy costs the post office, not to speak of what he is paid for extra charges by other people. He is doing the whole work of that district, both inside and outside the mile radius, for less than he is paid in extra charges for delivery.
I want to discuss the question in a reasonable way. I do not want to approach it from a hostile, personal, or party point of view. I am sure the Minister is as open as I am to discuss it reasonably and with sense and justice. I have very grave doubts if the Minister is not leaving himself open to an action at law by adopting this system. The Constitution, which we hear so much about, guarantees equal rights for all citizens. Where is the equality in this system? It would be just as reasonable to tell me that because I live outside the mile radius I am not entitled to equal service in respect to the Civic Guards, the Army, or any other service, as the man living inside the mile radius. If that is carried to its logical conclusion I would be entitled to reply that if because I live in a rural district I am not entitled to certain State services, therefore I should not be liable for State charges. That argument is as defensible as the other.
Twelve months ago I asked that a Commission should be set up to inquire into this matter. That request was refused. I ask again that a Commission should be set up to inquire into it. Perhaps the Minister and certain Deputies feel that as a result of the recent elections they have the absolute confidence of the country and can do what they like. It is up to Deputies representing rural areas, as the Minister stated on Thursday last, to decide whether the present policy is right or wrong. The Minister very fairly stated that it was the Dáil decided this matter. I ask Deputies from the rural areas: are they prepared to stand for discrimination as to who is to get a free service or who is not? Is the population living outside the mile radius to make good the £41,000 of a loss while those who live inside the mile area, on which the State is losing £180,000 are to be let off scot free, because they happen to be a majority of the population? It may be that the estimable services of these Deputies will weigh more with their constituents than their support of what I call the robbery that is perpetrated by this system in rural areas.
I know creameries that in the ordinary course of business receive from five to ten telegrams every day on which there is a charge of 2/6. I met two people who are connected with creameries on Monday last and both of them mentioned this matter to me. They are supporters of the Government and were present at the recent convention at which the economic policy of the Government was discussed. One of the creameries is at Muckalee, and Mr. Conway, whose name I may mention, stated that 2/6 was paid on every telegram received. At Mountgale and Ballybur creameries 2/6 is also paid for each telegram received. That may be good business from the point of view of trying to make good the loss of £41,000 and also in order to give good service to Deputy Hewat and Deputy Good who live within the charmed circle at Carrickmines, Foxrock, etc.
I heard Deputy Daly say a few days ago that he was perfectly satisfied with the present state of affairs. Of course he is. Deputy Daly's telegrams are delivered free, and of course he thinks of no one outside the mile area. He stated that the service was a tribute to Cork and that it was only a Corkman could do what had been done. I think it is only Corkmen could do so. They can do more than that. We had some historical books written by Corkmen recently. Perhaps they dealt with facts, but perhaps it would be as well if more attention was paid to the Post Office and less to books. The attitude adopted by Deputy Good and Deputy Daly make the people of the Saorstát desperate. The people outside think that they should not be placed on a different plane to the people inside the mile radius. I have a good deal more to say about this Vote, but I would not be able to conclude in the time at my disposal.
Comment on this
Deputy Figgis desires that a balance sheet should be produced on the presentation of this Vote. That is impossible; it is certainly impossible for the previous financial year. At the highest working speed it would take six months to clear up home and foreign accounts. Even with British experience that has not been improved upon. The system has been to present commercial accounts within twelve months or thereabouts after the termination of the financial year. Commercial accounts for 1922-23 are ready and will come before the Public Accounts Committee one of these days.
Comment on this
I do not think the Committee has yet considered those for 1922-23. The 1923-24 accounts are ready and will follow on. It would give us great pleasure to come here annually and present a balance sheet for the past year and an Estimate for the present year. I am sorry that is not possible. It is my desire to give the greatest possible information to every Deputy. It would save a valuable lot of time here, which is, I think, our mutual desire. If I can expedite the introduction of this balance sheet for this service I assure the Dáil that I will do so. I have considered it many a time.
Comment on this
Would it not be possible for the Minister to present, as has been done in the case of some private firms, a provisional balance sheet? Some of the accounts are closed and it is only a few covering remote matters that are not closed. Those not closed could be so indicated.
Comment on this
I am afraid that would be only partially successful. The number of items not closed is greater than the Deputy is aware of, as we are doing business with an increasing number of foreign countries. It takes time to close these accounts, so that to present a partial balance sheet would not be satisfactory and would lead nowhere.
Comment on this
In his statement the Minister gave a number of figures in respect of a saving on charges on postal orders.
Comment on this
At any rate, I do not think we could give a satisfactory balance sheet. It would be a great pleasure to do so if we could discover the means by which it could be done. No one would be more pleased than I would be. I do not think there are any other points to which I have not replied already.
Comment on this
I think I said something that the Minister might reply to. I want to know if the Minister cannot or will not reply.
Comment on this
I have already fully replied to this point, not only last year but also this year, and there is nothing new that I could say about it. As a matter of fact, an ample reply was already given by Deputy Johnson and Deputy Cooper, and I merely supplement it.
Comment on this
I am quite aware that Deputy Good made certain statements here, and it, perhaps, clears the air when we see the Minister hiding under Deputy Good's wing, and adopting his reasons and policy. I have, however, yet to learn that Deputy Johnson favours Deputy Good's argument or the Minister's policy. If he does favour it, I would like to hear him say so, and if he does not, the Minister has maligned Deputy Johnson. A vote will be taken on this question very soon, and the only way that I think I can have a vote on this is to propose that the Estimate be referred back for consideration, as we do not approve of the Minister's policy in that connection. I, therefore, propose that it be referred back.
Comment on this
That motion would be proper in the opening discussion, but we have now entered on a discussion of the Estimate under sub-head (a).
Comment on this
On sub-head (a) I think I am within my right in proposing that the Vote be referred back.
Comment on this
Surely you cannot move a reduction of the Minister's salary, because that is not allowed. We have adopted Standing Order 93 because that was not possible here.
Comment on this
Under sub-head (a) you can move a reduction, but it must be less than £1,000, for Deputy Johnson moved an amendment reducing the Vote by £1,000 on Friday.
Comment on this
If my memory serves me right we have not entered into a discussion of sub-head (a). We are discussing the main question.
Comment on this
There has been a motion moved for a reduction of £1,000. Obviously, when that was rejected, there may be a case for a reduction of a lesser sum. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle is accommodating Deputy Gorey by suggesting a lesser sum. I would submit that having refused to reduce the Estimate by £1,000 there is a prima facie case that the Dáil has accepted the Estimate in so far as it would not reduce the Vote by £1,000. If there is no case for a reduction of £1,000, I submit that it would not be fair to ask the Dáil to refer the whole Estimate back.
Comment on this
That does not follow after the vote taken on the last day. It was a vote taken when there were only a few Deputies here. This is a different matter, and I submit I am entitled to move to refer the matter back.
Comment on this
On a point of procedure, I submit that there is a possibility of referring the Vote back for reconsideration, not necessarily with a view to reduction, but, possibly, with a view to increase. The question of referring back does not necessarily entail a reduction in the Estimate.
Comment on this
This is the same point which I want to make. I do not want the Vote to be reduced, but I want the Government to consider the possibility of adjusting this Estimate. I do not take it as a reflection on the Minister, or the Government, but I want to move that it be referred back for reconsideration.
Comment on this
I cannot accept the motion, as it was not made in the earlier part of the discussion. I will accept a motion for a reduction by a less sum than £1,000.
Comment on this
That is putting us in a false position, as we do not want to take a vote on this particular item but on the question of policy. I submit that we are not being treated fairly in this matter, nor is the Dáil being treated fairly.
Comment on this
I think that Deputy Gorey will admit that sending back an Estimate is really submitting that the Dáil does not approve of policy. The question of policy is a bigger one than a reduction of £1,000, and the bigger thing should be taken first in all fairness to the Minister, to the Government, and to the Dáil. We have now entered on the third day's consideration of this Estimate. Taking into consideration its size, it has taken up in the matter of time much more than any other Estimate. To send it back now after a vote has been taken for a further reduction would, I think, be a reversal of the procedure we have adopted.
Comment on this
I hold a different view. I hold that when the main question is under discussion any Deputy has a right to move any amendment he thinks fit. I do not think that it can be held to be fair to the Dáil, because one Deputy thinks well to move a certain amendment carrying a certain amount of money, that it excludes another Deputy from putting another proposition. I think that a good case has been made for reconsideration by the Government of this Vote, and that they might very well consider it now and not next year.
Comment on this
I submit that Standing Order No. 93 was apparently framed with a view to regulating how these matters should be dealt with. It says: "It shall be in order, before entering on the discussion of the items in a Vote, to move that the Estimate in question be referred back to the Minister in charge of the Department for reconsideration." There was in mind there what the procedure should be on matters of the sort. I submit that having allowed the items to be discussed, almost every detail in the Estimate, and having disposed of an amendment to reduce the Vote by £1,000, to move now that the Estimate be sent back is in contravention of the terms and spirit of the Standing Order.
Comment on this
In that case I accept the explanation, and I accept the ruling of An Leas-Cheann Comhairle in accordance with the President's viewpoint. Therefore, I move that a smaller sum, a sum that will not affect the Vote, because I do not want to hamper the Ministry or to hamper the service in any form, be taken off the Estimate. I propose an insignificant amount, so that the Minister will not be hampered. In order that Deputies listening to me, and they are very few, can be given an opportunity of a clear vote, I propose that the whole Vote be reduced by £100.
Comment on this
Yes, or under whatever sub-head you like. The President has said I cannot move that the total vote be referred back for a greater amount than £1,000. I am selecting a lesser amount. Therefore, I am in order in moving a reduction of £100 in the total vote.
Comment on this
Make it in whatever legal form you like. I am not good at that. In moving this amendment I want a clear vote of the Dáil on this question. The Minister has said that it is not his policy, but the policy of the Dáil. Therefore the policy that is to be decided is the policy of every member of the Dáil. The man who is satisfied with the particular policy as it is should vote against this reduction. That will not really affect the total vote, or the carrying on of the business of the Department, but it is well we should distinctly know what is the attitude of Deputies, especially rural Deputies in this matter. Whatever decision is taken will be their responsibility and not the Ministers', and whatever they do in this matter should be done without hiding behind any party pledge, or being bound by a certain undertaking when elected.
Comment on this
We take it if there is a division that all the Deputies will be in the same position with regard to this amendment as they were the other evening on the occasion of an amendment to the Fisheries Bill, that is that every Deputy will be free to decide against the Minister if he thinks fit to do so. We assume that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs will not place, or seek to place, any Deputy either in his own party or any other party, in a more unfair position than they would be if this were an amendment to the Fisheries Bill, such as I have already referred to, and that if the Minister's policy is not acceptable Deputies will be free to give an open declaration of that fact.
I put it to the Minister that perhaps he sees reasons from the point of view expressed by Deputy Gorey why his own policy ought to be reconsidered. If the Minister recognises that the rural inhabitants have not been treated fairly, and that he is prepared to look into the position and to reconsider the policy that has been pursued by him so far in the light of the case put before him by Deputy Gorey, I think if he is prepared to say he will do that, and will do it honestly, that Deputy Gorey will have achieved the end he seeks to attain.
If the Minister says bluntly that he is not going to do that, but that he will make the rural inhabitant contribute more than his fair proportion as a citizen of the State towards the running and the losses of the Post Office, and that he is to pay an extra charge for facilities afforded by the operations of the postal service, naturally the rural inhabitants must take exception to that. Their representatives here now may not be able to pass a sentence on the Minister that would be satisfactory to them, and may not be able to achieve what they wish, but the fact remains that the treatment of the rural inhabitants is not fair and just as compared with that accorded to those in the towns and cities. That is a policy that can be pursued too far. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs ought to take into account that the collector of taxes will not discriminate between the man living on a hillside and the man living in a town. When it comes to paying up they are treated alike, and if the State comes along to perform any service for the citizens, the man in the country, one and a half miles from the town, should not be expected to contribute more to the maintenance of that service than the man living in the town, when the taxpayers as a whole are bearing the burden of that service. That is the attitude we take up. If the Minister says he is going to carry on that policy, and that he is not going to permit the holding of an inquiry into the whole position, into the administration of the Post Office—if that is to be his policy, and not the open policy of the Dáil, we have to accept it, but the Minister ought to recognise that he has a duty to the Dáil and to the rural inhabitants, and to the people in Athy, to whom he was talking the other day, as to the citizens in Cork city.
Comment on this
We have been invited to leave this to open vote. What are we going to get in return? Is it going to be an open vote on the Farmers' benches?
Comment on this
On the Labour benches, and on the Independent benches? And if it is to be an open vote what are we going to get? Deputies, in asking for an open vote, are going to invite people who represent rural areas to vote against us in this. That is one of the most cordial and praiseworthy invitations I have ever received. I am personally in the same position as Deputies on the Farmers' benches, and so far as Deputies on the Labour benches are concerned. I am 400 yards outside the limit and am therefore deprived of whatever advantages there are within the mile limit.
Comment on this
As a matter of fact, it was put in four or five years ago, but I have no recollection of the disbursements made.
Comment on this
About £3 or £4 a quarter, I believe. On one occasion I paid twice, and the Postmaster-General very honestly told me he would place the second payment to my credit.
Comment on this
Would the President be surprised to know in regard to this matter that an official letter was sent out by the Postal authorities to a citizen near Dublin saying in effect that they would consider his application for a 'phone if he was prepared to pay a rental of £30 a year, and that he should give a five years' guarantee?
Comment on this
I can understand something like that arising. In some cases it may happen that a particular switchboard is full, and that means that another board has to be put in. They may not be able to get another customer in that direction, and therefore the installation is occasioned by reason of a single application. In that case, is it right that in order to convenience one particular person the whole cost——
Comment on this
In order to end all this it would be well to have the position stated. This telephone service has been held out to the public as a great boon, and I want the public to know what the exact position is. It is going to mean a charge of £30 a year with a five years' guarantee. I do not know where the boon to the public comes in there.
Comment on this
There are special circumstances in connection with particular applications which impose extra costs on the Post Office and which, I think, ought to fall on the person occasioning them. I know that in a particular case—I cannot remember whether it was my own or not, but I believe it was—I had to pay something more by reason of the fact that the "board" was full. I was outside this line, and if I were to take this in a personal way I suppose I should vote with the Deputy. On the occasion of an entertainment given by my wife, five people from the country, who were unable to attend, sent telegrams which cost her one shilling each. I think, if people want this sort of convenience, they have got to pay for it.
This is an Estimate for a total sum of £2,551,540. In a sense it is unfair to ask the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs to allow this to be an open vote, after having agreed with the Minister for Finance—in this case the Minister for Finance is the Executive Council— that this is the amount of money that is to be found in respect of this service. It becomes a Government matter so far as that is concerned. Of course that does not prevent the Minister from examining the service. He has examined it during the last two or three years to see where economies could be effected and to see where an uneconomic branch of the service could be made economic.
In the case of the telephone service, anyone who has been accustomed to using it during the last four or five years will, I think, admit, and generously admit, that there has been an enormous improvement in it. I think it is due to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs that reference should be made to that improvement. It is one of the services that has been remedied. At one time I thought it would be necessary to call in an expert from some other country to see how its defects could be remedied. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, with the officials in his Department, took the matter in hand, and the result is, as I have said, that there has been an enormous improvement in this service. As regards the particular service to which Deputy Gorey refers, it is an expensive one, and I have no doubt that the Minister will consider it, but he cannot consider it in the light of a loss of £40,000 to the State.
Comment on this
This particular thing would mean a loss of £40,000. As far as the £180,000 is concerned, that deals with a much larger number than the proportionate number involved in the £40,000. Deputy Gorey is engaged in farming and he knows that if he has to send to a fair ten miles away to buy one particular animal that the cost to him in respect of the purchase of that particular animal will be relatively greater than if he had to buy 40 cattle. The same number of men could as easily take the 40 cattle on the single journey as they could the one beast, so that the cost of the transport is relatively greater in the case of the purchase of the one animal than it would be in that of the purchase of the 40. I am sure the Deputy will admit that.
Comment on this
If Deputy Gorey will not admit it, then I think that the smile on Deputy Baxter's face convinces me that he admits it.
Comment on this
That is the question: large business and small profits, small business and extra expense. We all know that establishment charges are high against the small business and that they are relatively lower in the case of large undertakings. There are many business concerns all over the country which could turn over three or four times the amount of money they do without incurring any extra establishment charges, for the lower the turn over is the higher proportionately the establishment charges are. That is the position of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. As far as I am concerned, I am against this reduction and I think that the Minister has made a fairly good case for the retention of the charges until the service becomes a more economic one.
Comment on this
The President's usual smoke screen has been emitted. He has cleverly tried to cloud the issue. I think that Deputy Gorey has not made clear what his desire is in this matter. If he is contending that there should be no extra charge at all for the delivery of telegrams, no matter what the distance is from the telegraph office, then I am against him. The practice of making a delivery charge is not a new one. Last year this matter was discussed. It was then pointed out that a reduction had been made in the distance, and that for over a mile from the office there would be no delivery fee charged. I think it is necessary, under present circumstances, that a delivery fee should be charged after a certain distance. Otherwise, the cost of delivery would be very excessive, indeed. I think that limit has to be fixed more or less on the judgment of the Minister. A compromise is inevitable there, I suppose, as to what would be strict justice. I think, however, that a free delivery area of one mile from the telegraph office is altogether too short.
Cities, as Deputy Gorey pointed out, are undoubtedly specially well served in this matter. In the city area you have free delivery within a distance of two miles, but from the office in the small town free delivery is limited to a distance of one mile. That, I think, is an unfair proposition. The zone which Deputy Heffernan suggested as worthy of consideration is too narrow in the case of the delivery of telegrams. I think that the Minister ought to have given further consideration and more sympathetic consideration to the proposal to extend the free delivery area.
I am prepared to support the motion, which aims at impressing on the Minister the view of the House that there should be an extension of the free delivery area. Such an extension will not cost £40,000. We have no estimate as to what it will cost. It possibly may cost £10,000, but I am inclined to the view, inasmuch as the telegraph service as a whole is looked upon as an expense and as a loss to the Treasury, that the extra charge for an extended delivery area could be met by an increase in the cost of the telegrams. The number of persons within the free delivery area ought to be increased, and it is on that account that I feel that the Deputy is justified in asking the views of members of the Dáil to be expressed on this matter. The only way it can be expressed apparently is by requesting a reduction in the Vote. There is no implication in the carrying of this motion, other than that it is the view of the Dáil that the free delivery area should be increased, leaving it to the Minister to decide the extent of that increase. I think I am expressing the views of Deputies on the Farmers' benches. If I am not, and if they are contending that there should be a free delivery any distance, then I would be obliged to vote against this, but if they are contending for an extension of the free delivery area, and that the vote will be simply to prove to the Minister that that is the wish of the Dáil, then I shall certainly vote in favour of this amendment.
Comment on this
Whatever the President does he does not generally miss the psychological point, but he missed it in this case. He does not realise the irritation caused by a charge over which you have no control. You cannot prevent people sending you telegrams. The President, as he told us himself, could not prevent five people sending him telegrams. You can only refuse to accept the telegrams. But human nature and human curiosity are too strong for that. A telegram may contain vital matter or it may only contain the name of a winner—out of deference to Deputy Gorey I will say the winner of the Waterloo Cup. But the average person does not like to send away a telegram from his door. At the same time if it is opened, and contains trivial matter, people feel great irritation, not only with the sender, but also with the Government. There is no means of stopping this, and that is what annoys people, and makes them discontented. You cannot tell everybody not to send you telegrams. I remember the case of certain people living a long way from a post office putting on their notepaper: "Telegraph office so far away, porterage 5/-," as a hint to people not to send them telegrams. But it would be almost impossible for people to do that now. These things that you cannot control are very irritating and they are bad policy for the State. I agree if Deputy Gorey's amendment is intended to express the view that there should be a wider area of delivery it should receive the support of the Dáil.
Comment on this
It has always seemed astonishing to me that people who live in rural areas and have to pay porterage, perhaps a considerable sum, and who get a considerable number of telegrams in the year, do not go in for the party telephone system. I have some experience of that for a good many years. In my district, to the people who live around me the cost of porterage would be fairly considerable and the farmers and doctors and some veterinary surgeons and others in our district put their heads together and persuaded the Post Office to extend to us the party telephone system and we found it a most wonderful convenience. We send telegrams and receive them through this system. Of course people say that in the party-system there is no privacy. I do not think that any of us ever found the least inconvenience in that connection. There are fourteen of us on the two lines that come into our district. They are connected together and there never was the least difficulty or unpleasantness, or anything of that kind, arising out of it, nothing but the utmost convenience, and no one of us would give it up. We get our telegrams delivered at once and sent on without any trouble about them. I should recommend all people who do a lot of telegraph work to club together and have the party system established amongst them. I can say, speaking from experience, that the convenience of that system is beyond measure. But, apart from that, if people do not wish to pay for their telegrams delivered by messenger they can leave word with the Post Office to have them sent on by post. I do not think that there is any grievance in the complaints that have been brought forward. I think people have only themselves to blame if they do not come and make things better for themselves by having the party-system at their doors; and it is cheap also. I only pay £1 12s. 0d. a quarter. It was cheaper a few years ago when it was only £4 a year. Now it is £6 8s. 0d.
Comment on this
I cannot accept the proposals put forward by Deputy Johnson for a reconsideration of this matter. Before introducing it, I gave it the utmost consideration. Since then I thought it over, and I have satisfied myself that there is no alternative that is likely to give satisfaction. If you increase the limit of a mile to two miles the people beyond the two miles will howl, and so on; if you increase the limit beyond two miles, the people three miles distant will complain. You are not going to get rid of these complaints by a proposal of that kind. Again, it is not too much to expect people to pay their way. The argument comes badly from people who shout on public platforms that the State is recklessly over-spending, and who now ask for another trifle of £40,000. You must draw the line somewhere. I am out for economy.
Comment on this
In endeavouring to effect economies here I find justification because I do not feel that we are doing any injustice or inflicting any hardship upon those people by asking them to pay for the delivery of telegrams they receive. Rural telegrams may be classed under three categories. You have: "Mother going home to-morrow." Next you have the racing element—farmers who, instead of farming the land, spend their time chasing winners in England.
Comment on this
Can the Minister give us any comparison between the number of telegrams on betting sent from rural districts and from towns?
Comment on this
You have the third category, the business people. Business people must be aware that if they want to send telegrams they must be prepared to pay for them.
Comment on this
Oh, I mean not honest in the sense of avoiding the facts. Of course I know the Minister is, personally, the most honest man in the world.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows the Minister, apparently, better than he knows himself. Business people who send telegrams can afford to pay for them. I have no sympathy with their desire to shift the payment on to other shoulders. Wherever we find a cooperative society or a creamery hard hit by these payments we endeavour to extend the telephone service to them, and we have done that in a great many cases this year with a very substantial loss to the State, and we will continue to do it. Let us further examine this alleged grievance. In the year 1923-24 we netted £78,000 in post office work in the city of Dublin, and similar sums in other cities and towns, varying according to business. We made a profit in the working of this service running into some hundreds of thousands of pounds through urban work, and we lost that profit and £700,000 in addition in doing Deputy Gorey's work in the country. Now, in contributing to these rural services, are we acting impartially? If we acted impartially we would spend in proportion to our returns in rural areas. It will have to come to that. That is the position at the moment. I see no justification whatever for this further expenditure, and I regret that any Deputies should suggest that we should lightly handle a sum of £40,000 in doing this.
Comment on this
I wonder has the Minister weighed the consequences of the statement he has made, and that is, that there may be a necessity to reconsider the administration of these services, and I presume, every other service in the State, from the point of view of what any particular body of the citizens are prepared to contribute to the maintenance of the State service. That is the way the Minister has put his case. If it comes to that we will have to divide our Exchequer into five or six or perhaps a dozen different compartments. Into each of them and out of each of them certain sums will come and go. A certain service will get a certain contribution from each, and a certain body of people will be served. That, I do not think, is the aim of the Minister in some respects. If it is to be decentralised like that, the sooner we make up our minds to dispense with such services the better. That is the point of view the Minister expresses when he says that Dublin contributes so much to the maintenance of the Post Office and so much is lost because that service is extended down through the rural districts. He goes on, further, to say that he will have to consider whether this can be continued in the future or not, or whether in the rural districts we may not have to pay a higher postal rate, a higher telephone rate and a higher charge for delivery of telegrams than the people who live in the cities and towns, simply because we live in the country. If that is the way the Minister wants to put it, it is just as well that we should have it marked out definitely and clearly. We accept that statement from the Minister.
Comment on this
I will now put the question. An amendment has been proposed to reduce sub-head (a) of the Vote by £100.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I take it that the motion is that a certain sum in gross shall be voted. We do not, in the motion, allocate the sums to particular sub-heads. I submit that the amendment will have to take the form of a reduction of the gross sum by £100, irrespective of the sub-head.
Comment on this
Amendment put.
Do you agree with this result?
Under sub-head (a) there are one or two matters of detail that have not been raised. We have been dealing with the question of Departmental policy as far as the public are concerned. There are one or two matters in connection with the administration of the Department internally to which I would like to draw attention. The first is the excessively large number of temporary clerks, telegraphists, and postmen, and I want to urge that as many as possible of these should be as quickly as possible absorbed into the established branches. I think there have been a few recently absorbed from the temporary and auxiliary postal service. Some six or seven months ago there was an announcement of an examination for temporary sorting clerks and telegraphists, to be held early in 1925. So far no intimation has been given to the public as to when that examination is to take place. I want to urge that the number of persons in these lists who are described as "temporary employees" is altogether excessive. In some cases the temporary employees are not denoted. I see on page 231 of the Estimates an item which shows that there are "5,443 outdoor supervising officers, postmen, cleaners and messengers, including unestablished force." I think that that number "including unestablished force" is excessive. I want to urge that there should be a reduction in the number of unestablished men by a very large proportion, that their position should be regularised, and that they should become members of the established branches. There is, as has been suggested, a large number of persons employed in the Post Office as temporary employees who are very much underpaid. The effect of that is not good for the service, not good for the public, and is not good in any way except from the point of view of cheap-and-nastiness. I would press upon the Minister the necessity of absorbing into the established branches a very large number of those who are at present, and have been for a long time, temporary. The same remark applies to auxiliary postmen. The number at present in the service is about 2,500. They are working from eighteen to thirtyfive hours a week. It is suggested, of course, that these men are employed part-time in the Post Office and that they can obtain other employment. But the hours and conditions under which auxiliary postmen work, make it, in very many cases, impossible for them to obtain other work to fit in. The effect is that the auxiliary postman's sole employment is as a postman at wages which are entirely unsatisfactory, and not sufficient to enable a man to keep a proper standard of life. I understand that there is a considerable number of vacancies in the established classes, and I urge that there should be opportunities now for including amongst the establishment a large number of those who are at present employed as auxiliaries.
There is then a matter that is not easy to deal with unless one has details. It is, I suppose, known to every Deputy who has followed public matters for years, that in the Post Office, as in some of the other public services, there have been charges pretty freely floating of favouritism in matters of promotion. It was a long-established grievance in the postal service under the old regime, and I am quite sure the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs knows something about it. Complaints of favouritism in matters of promotion were sought to be remedied by a general understanding —perhaps not very rigid—that seniority would play the greater part, and that seniority, given regular, satisfactory qualifications, would be depended upon in respect of promotion. It is undoubtedly true to say that, whether well or ill-founded, there is a very strong belief throughout the service that favouritism in matters of promotion is rifer to-day than it was even under the old regime. Part of that suspicion, no doubt, is due to conditions which prevailed during the last two years. That suspicion was rife throughout the country, and many charges of a general kind arising out of prejudice, envy, or malice, accounted to some extent for the general suspicion of favouritism.
I think there is necessity for a facing of the fact that this suspicion and belief is very widespread at the present time, and it is not declining with the decline in the general dissatisfaction and dissension within the country. To give an illustration, I am told that in respect of sorting clerks and telegraphists in Dublin, so far from the seniority list being relied upon in making selections for appointments, qualified officers have been passed over to the extent of 200 to 250 behind in the lists. In the case of, say, 5 or 6 particular officers who came in long after the earlier ones on the list, to the extent of the numbers 227 to 276, these men have been placed ahead of Nos. 1, 2, 3, 4 and so on. That is to say, preferences have been given to people who came into the service last over other qualified officers who had been in the service for a long time and who were their seniors. There may be a defence of that on the part of the Minister when he may say those particular officers had long service in the British Postal Department.
I am told it has become quite a practice that in the case of transferred officers, officers transferred from London, it is almost inevitable that they will be given preference when promotion is in question. This preference to transferred officers from London is one item in the general charge of favouritism. The preferences do not apply only to officers who have been transferred from London; but those seem to be the cases on which stress is laid. I think it is desirable that the Minister should face this general dissatisfaction in the service and give some clear statement of the policy of the Department in respect to this matter of promotion and indicate what part seniority plays when the question of promotions arise. I have raised these matters because I think it is desirable that they should be raised in public so that a public explanation and defence on the part of the Minister can be made. This will give him an opportunity to make that explanation.