COMMITTEE ON FINANCE. - ESTIMATES FOR PUBLIC SERVICES. VOTE 56—POST OFFICE (RESUMED).
Contributions 132–266 of 266. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I would like to know are we still discussing this sub-head, or what exactly are we discussing? This is the third day on which we have taken up a discussion which we should have taken in the first instance. We should have begun with the sub-heads. We did not do so, and we have not yet done so. If we continue at this rate of progress we can count on several more days of discussion. I think we ought to proceed on some definite lines, such as apply to the other Estimates.
Comment on this
We are supposed to go through the different items. I take it there will not be many points touched upon in the general discussion.
Comment on this
We are dealing with a particular sub-head, and I submit, with great respect, that it has been the custom here, on every Estimate that has been considered in this House, that every sub-head has been considered separately. The privileges of Deputies and Ministers have never been curtailed, and the suggestion to curtail them has never come from any other Minister except the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. I refer to the Standing Order in this connection, and the practice of the House, which goes much further. I submit that I am perfectly entitled to discuss and raise matters and speak three times on this sub-head.
Comment on this
That, I will develop. If I were to mention now what points I am going to speak on I would have no occasion to speak at all, because I would have covered the ground I intend to cover. I want to deal with sub-head (a) (3). I will not deal with items 1, 2, or 4 under that sub-head at all. I want to deal with provincial offices. Under the head of provincial establishments I find the figure, for the first time, dealing with boy messengers, and under Scale 2 the number is 94. Under Scale 3 the number is 358. The total is 452. The wages under Scale 2, for 94 messengers, vary from 6s. to 19s., and in Scale 3, for 358 messengers, the wages vary from 6s. to 18s. I am not in a position to contradict the figure of 18s. It may be paid in certain cases; I am sure it is, in the provinces, and that embraces the provincial towns. Constant messengers have to be employed, and not part-time messengers, and for that reason I accept 18s. as obtaining in some cases. If we strike an average, especially for the rural areas, of 10s., we are getting beyond what I think is paid to the rural messengers. Taking the 452 messengers employed in provincial establishments, and giving those 452 an average wage of 10s. a week, which is really more than is actually given, we will find what messengers actually cost the State for the provincial service alone. Multiplying the figure 452, not by 10s., which would mean £26 a year, but by £30, which would, in my opinion, be more than an average, we get a total cost of £13,560. That represents the cost to the State of messengers who deliver telegrams in the Saorstát. I see one of the Minister's officers shaking his head. If I am wrong, I am open to correction, and I hope the figures will be given. As I see it, this service is for messengers. If the cost set out under the head of messengers does not represent what the messengers really cost the Saorstát for their services, I would like to know what it is. Where am I to get the figure?
I am making my assumption on a very conservative estimate, and I find that it takes £13,560 to defray the cost of messengers for the provincial establishments. That gives you in hard figures what the cost of telegrams in provincial establishments means to the State. Perhaps Deputy Johnson will now have a clear indication of what the actual figures are. For that service that is costing thirteen and a half thousand pounds you are recovering £41,000. That is on the Minister's own admission. He is recovering that money from portion of the people that the service is intended for. These are the figures I want the Minister to explain. I hope he will be able to give a satisfactory explanation, some explanation that would satisfy me and ease my mind. I only want to be satisfied. While I see something here distinctly wroig and distinctly as it should not be, you will have me, and every honest member of this Dáil who is not tied body and soul, giving clean votes and straight votes on this question.
Comment on this
Does the Minister finally answer now on sub-head (a), or have we permission to put other questions? Shall I allow him answer now on the other points that have been raised before raising any other question?
Comment on this
Therefore I take it that sub-heads (a) (1) and (a) (2) are finished and that there will be no further question on them?
Comment on this
I want to get information from the Minister in reference to the increase in the staff of the Secretary's office. It has increased from 119 to 136 since 1924, and the salaries have increased from £45,620 to £54,735. This seems to be a greater increase than in any other Department.
Comment on this
I see some Deputies smiling, and I might say that in the Deputy's absence I answered that question. I do not think the Deputy will expect me to answer it again, and I have no intention of answering it again. It was not my fault if the Deputy was not here.
Comment on this
Perhaps we could make some progress if I answered Deputy Johnson's questions, which do not come under any of these sub-heads and we could then advance from sub-head 3. Deputy Johnson draws attention to the fact that we have, in his opinion, more temporary employees than we should have. It is not our desire to retain disproportionate numbers of people, but it will take some time to get through the various Civil Service examinations. Temporary employees increased very much during the war period and up to the institution of the Civil Service Commission. The increase is now largely disappearing and it is our desire that it should disappear as quickly as possible. Auxiliary postmen, otherwise part-time postmen, are taken on with a clear understanding that other sources of employment are available. We employ them, and clearly set forth the conditions, for a certain number of hours per day and per week. Beyond that we have no responsibility. They are not eligible for appointment. Appointments are obtained for boy messengers and temporary hands in urban offices. Auxiliaries were never included in the category of possible appointees, and I do not think that we would be justified in departing from that well and, I suppose, carefully considered headline.
The Deputy also refers to alleged favouritism in the Post Office. I do not admit that there is any favouritism. I may, at the outset, state that one at the head of a Department is largely in the hands of his subordinates in matters of this kind—very largely. One must depend very largely on the advice given by his subordinates, but as far as I can judge—and I am responsible for all appointments in the service, and I go into them very carefully—I do not think my subordinates have ill-advised me in respect of these promotions. Men have been selected for executive offices, over the heads of other men. There are very few who will admit they should have been passed over, but we have to be the judges. We are responsible for the service. We have to discriminate between man and man in a matter of this kind, otherwise we will have a very indifferent service. We have given more promotion in this service since the Treaty than would have been given in the English service in 20 years, largely by virtue of the fact that we have taken from the service for other Departments. That has given an opening to our men that they never anticipated, and I think the number promoted to clerical officers has reached the 300 level, which is only part of the line of promotion.
When statements of this kind are made—I notice that they are bandied round outside pretty much by associations, and I have seen them referred to in the Press from time to time—I would like something more definite than a bald statement. I do not say that Deputy Johnson agrees with the statement. He has merely stated what has been said, but I would like to have something more definite when favouritism is mentioned than the mere fact that it exists. I am entitled to get definite instances, and if I get any I will go into them carefully. I am pretty well sure that it will be found they do not come under that category.
Comment on this
I can give the Minister the names and the numbers of the men on the seniority lists. They are: J.J. Carroll, No. 54; R.J. Daly, No. 91; H.A. Jones, No. 93; T. Gilmore, No. 96; B. O'Reilly, No. 104; W. Keane, No. 227; T. Heffernan, No. 256; J. Griffin, No. 257; S. Maguire, No. 270; J. Cohalane, No. 272, and D.P. Cremin, No. 276. The numbers I have quoted are the numbers in the seniority list. I would like to have some information to my own satisfaction as to what principle in respect of seniority is at work which removes seniority almost out of consideration in view of these numbers.
Comment on this
Seniority and ability —these have been the constituent elements in selections for executive posts, for the higher posts. We have to consider ability as well as seniority and that accounts for the apparent differentiation. No doubt it has given room for grievance to those who have not been selected, but, as I say, on us rests the onus of producing a competent service, and we are doing that. I want further to say here that I have never had any sympathy with the promotion of an official on any grounds other than value. Friendship plays no part in my judgment in matters of this kind; I have never believed that it is possible to get anywhere on the friendship line. There are comparatively few grievances in regard to promotion in the service, very few grievances indeed, and I would be prepared to examine that position minutely with the Deputy at any time if he so desires.
Comment on this
Deputy Gorey has reverted to the delivery charge. He pointed to the fact that four hundred odd messengers have been engaged in this business at wages of from 8/- to 18/- a week.
Comment on this
These are permanent messengers; they constitute a very small part of our force for that work. We have over 2,000 sub-offices alone, apart from salaried offices, and we have at least one messenger for every office. The overwhelming majority of these are casuals, and they are paid so much a mile. If we charge 6d. a mile they are paid 6d. a mile. Therefore, the Deputy's point very largely disappears.
Comment on this
The figures for this particular class of messenger. Where are they to be found in the Estimates?
Comment on this
There is no necessity to have them in the Estimates. A sum is collected for the delivery of a telegram and that sum is paid to the messenger. It does not pass out of the Post Office.
Comment on this
I think that this is the most unsatisfactory answering I have ever heard. We are told that a certain number of people are employed temporarily. They do not appear here at all. I make the statement deliberately that in offices with which I am acquainted there is no second messenger; there is only one, and sometimes there is no messenger at all; the postmistress or the postmaster sends out whoever can be got at the time. This question of boy messengers has not been explained at all; it has been ignored by the Minister. We want to get the exact cost, and the Minister refuses these figures. If there is any truth in figures, or in this Estimate, for goodness sake give us the figures and let us understand it. Do not be telling us that there are costs incurred that do not appear at all. It is not a complete Estimate, and it ought not to have been brought here.
Comment on this
On this point I would like to ask the Minister a question, purely on a matter of explanation. Am I right in understanding that the charge for delivery outside the area is paid to the messenger, and does not appear in any Post Office account?
Comment on this
Where casual messengers are employed we charge 6d. a mile for the delivery of the telegram, and we pay the casual messenger that sum.
Comment on this
How many of these casuals are there? How are we to know whether they are on the staff or not, or whether there are casuals or not?
Comment on this
I would like to try to unravel the differences. The amount which the Minister claims for sub-postmasters for this year is £92,250, and including the boy messengers at £10,000 you have a sum of about £100,000 for the services of the postmasters and the messengers. A sum of £41,000 is collected for the delivery of telegrams, and Deputy Gorey's point is that £41,000 in respect of this service, which only costs the State £100,000 for the sub-postmasters and the messengers, is not a reasonable amount to charge for deliveries in the country. Including the sub-postmasters, the whole all-in costs for that service is only £95,250. That is the point that Deputy Gorey wants to make. Most of those sub-postmasters are paid a salary out of which they have to contribute towards those messengers, but the £41,000 which is collected, and which the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs has in his accounts, is money which has been paid to the credit of the State somewhere, and it cannot have been paid casually; it must have come into the accounts somewhere.
Comment on this
I want to correct the statement I made in reply to Deputy Johnson a few moments ago. This item does pass through the accounts, but it does not alter the fact that we pay out what we receive.
Comment on this
If the Deputy would look at page 231—"Outdoor Supervising Officers, Postmen, Cleaners and Messengers (including Unestablished Force, Allowance for Delivery, Collection, etc.)"——
Comment on this
Does that mean temporary messengers that are not on the established force? Those would not come within the list of what he calls casual messengers.
Comment on this
With regard to sub-head (c), I want to raise a question in connection with the temporary sorting office in Pearse Street. I understand that it is recognised by everybody, even by the Minister himself, as being quite an unfit place. It is said that the premises are damp, unhealthy, and altogether unfit for use as a sorting office. I would like to have some assurance from the Minister that he is expediting the preparations of new premises for this purpose.
Comment on this
Complaints of that kind were made, but I can find no justification for them. I had the premises inspected by the chief medical officer, and I went through them myself to see if I could find anything wrong. I am satisfied that the premises are suitable and that there is no justification for complaints of unsuitability.
Comment on this
I want to call attention to sub-head (h) (2)—Losses by default, accident, etc. The sum of £10,000 which is set down appears to be rather a large one for losses by default and accident, and I want to ask the Minister whether it could not possibly be reduced to a certain extent. If Deputies would refer to the Appropriation Account for the years 1923-24 they will find that under that heading, though there was a greater sum voted, more than double the sum, the bulk of that sum was devoted to meeting losses by raids and losses caused by fire to the Rotunda Rink Post Office, and in that year the compensation for loss and damage to parcels and registered and insured letters came to just over £6,000. In my opinion that is the only charge that ought fairly to come under this sub-head. The Minister for Posts must compensate for registered letters that are lost, and ex gratia he compensates for parcels that are lost or damaged. But I do not think there ought to be a large provision for defaults of other kinds, ranging from deficiency in accounts of various kinds to a sum of 10d. for foreign and spurious coins collected in telephone automatic boxes. I think that the only legitimate charge that can be made under this head is for the loss of registered letters and loss and damage to parcels. That loss was surely greater in the year 1923-24 than it is now. Every Deputy remembers that at that time mails were frequently raided, and no doubt a certain amount of registered letters, and so on, went astray.
I would like to have some details as to how this charge was assessed, and I do not think that embezzlement, funds misappropriated, and things of that kind ought to come under this sub-head at all. I think we ought not to have a general head of £10,000, but that if money is misappropriated from the Post Office we ought to have definite and specific particulars. We do get that eventually in the Appropriation Account, but that is two years late. We ought, I think, to have a Supplementary Estimate dealing with embezzlements and matters of that kind, in order that we might test the financial control that the Minister is able to exercise over his subordinates. This is a large Department, dealing with large sums of money, and it is very important that the financial control in connection with it should be automatic, if I might say so, that there should be a careful and continuous audit, and that no temptation should be placed in the way of these servants that they may embezzle or misappropriate money without being detected. I would like to ask the Minister for a few more details on this point.
Comment on this
This estimate of £10,000 is based on our experiences for the second half of last year, when we had to meet, under this heading, a deficiency of about £8,000. We hope the sum of £10,000 will be sufficient, and we hope we will be able to dispense with the whole of it. Nevertheless, from our recent experience, we are bound to make a provision of this kind.
Comment on this
Do we understand from the Minister that he accepts liability for registered letters, because I had a case where a registered letter was seized by bandits or irregulars? Although the sender of the letter proved definitely that there was money in the letter, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs refused to pay compensation, although he agreed that such a thing could happen. Compensation was refused under some regulation which operated under the British regime. I wonder whether the liability for registered letters is still the same?
Comment on this
It is precisely in the old state, the state laid down by regulations. It would be very dangerous for us to depart from that. Otherwise, people everywhere would be claiming for things that they had not in their possession. Bear that in mind. I do not think there is much chance of a rectification of this item owing to our experience.
Comment on this
As far as I can understand it, the Minister's justification for this vote is, that because his Department lost £10,000 by default last year, they may reasonably be expected to lose it this year. He asks the Dáil to be satisfied with that explanation. I think we should know what steps have been taken to check these defaults, and I think we should know a little more under what sub-heads they come: how much is compensation for loss of registered letters, and how much is for misappropriation or embezzlement of funds. Can the Minister give us more information, and say what steps are being taken to bring this sub-head down?
Comment on this
It is very difficult for me to give the definite items of loss. They cover a rather wide field. It may happen that the sum of two or three thousand pounds has been dispatched from the head to a sub-office and that a raider intercepts it. You could then write down two or three thousand pounds under that head. The next year it would be under some other head. It would not be any guide to show under what particular head it occurred. It varies. The tightening up of our intelligence section will, we hope, reduce the losses which have resulted in that way during the last twelve months.
Comment on this
This is an estimate of what you may expect during next year not on account of last year?
Comment on this
Would the Minister say what exactly is the position with regard to registered letters? If the regulations are such that if I register a letter and enclose money and afterwards am unable to recover it from the Post Office, should it be lost, what is the object of having a letter registered at all? I would ask the Minister for a clearer definition of the regulations, because a statement like what he has just made will certainly have a serious effect on people outside. They can only gather that registration is not a safeguard at all.
Comment on this
All the information that the Deputy requires on this subject is set out in the regulations of the Post Office, and I would advise him, seeing that these are available in the House, to switch his attention on to them. If he wishes, on the other hand, that I should start on these regulations and go right through them I shall be quite pleased to do so.
Comment on this
I rose because the Minister had made a definite statement, in reply to Deputy Wilson, that sometimes people are accustomed to make claims that they are not entitled to make—in other words, to make bogus claims. As the Minister has put it, it can certainly be interpreted that people claim to have put amounts into registered letters that they never put in, and on that assumption that the responsibility on the Post Office lapses. If the Minister is satisfied to let the statement go that there is no responsibility on the part of the Post Office, and that they do not undertake responsibility, and if he is not going to give reasons why they are not responsible, what conclusion is to be drawn as to the benefit or otherwise of registering letters?
Comment on this
Whatever information Deputy Baxter may be able to get from the Post Office guide, I cannot get the information I have asked for either in the Post Office guide or from the Minister. The only inference I can draw from the Minister's reply is that the Department makes up its mind that it will lose £10,000 by default, that if it does not lose it one way it will lose it another, and, as far as the Minister can tell us, no special precautions are taken to prevent default occurring. That is profoundly unsatisfactory. I do not think the Dáil is satisfied with the Minister's explanation, and I move to reduce this sub-head by £2,000. That would give the Minister £1,000 margin, and £7,000 for his registered letters and parcels, and will, perhaps, compel the Department to be a little more careful.
Comment on this
An amendment, to reduce the sub-head by £100, has already been defeated, and any further amendment must be to reduce it by a sum less than £100.
Comment on this
Amendment put.
Do you agree with this result?
As to sub-head (h) (3)—"Incidental Expenses"—I should like some indication as to how the amount is made up. I see the item has decreased since last year, but there is no indication of what the expenses are. Under a similar sub-head (1) (5), "Engineering," details are given more or less. Such a considerable item as this should not be included under the head of incidental expenses without fuller details being given.
Comment on this
I wish to raise a point on sub-head (h) (4). I want to call attention to the very inadequate amount voted for police. While the losses by default are £10,000, only £45 is spent on the police service to try and prevent losses. It seems to me that is out of all proportion. I would willingly pay more for police and less for compensation to people whose property is stolen. That would, at any rate, provide employment, if nothing else. I should like to know how the sum is made up, how many people are employed, and what wages they get, because £45 is ludicrous—less than £1 per week for police. Is it some small extra payment made to the members of the Gárda Síochána for services rendered, or has the Minister a police force of his own, remunerated at what cannot be a trade union rate?
Comment on this
The sum of £1,500 for incidental expenses includes a number of small items that do not properly come under other headings, and are, therefore, grouped under that heading. As to the £45 for police, a policeman is attached for a limited time to our intelligence department, and we consequently pay the expenses incurred.
Comment on this
I respectfully submit that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs has not answered my question. Obviously it is made up of items that could not be included under any other sub-heads, but that gives me no information. I maintain that we are entitled to that information, and we are told that we can get all information connected with the accounts. We asked that a special committee should be appointed to go into the different accounts, as such work could not be done adequately in the Dáil. When I ask a simple question dealing with a considerable amount of money I am told it is made up of items that could not be included under other sub-heads. The only conclusion to come to is that the Minister wants to evade the question and that he thinks I am so soft I will not persist in it.
Comment on this
Under this sub-head there is an item of £45 for police. I take it that the cost of the police is defrayed in the Vote for the Gárda Síochána. If this item consists of expenses for protective work or something of that kind, I take it the amount is a present for someone who is employed at it. I am not satisfied, and I move a reduction of sub-head (3) by £98 10s. 0d.
Comment on this
I think the only difficulty is that the items are over-explanatory. In order to help the Dáil, we dissect the Vote right down to a sum of £1,500, and we explain that. We point out that it includes headings that cannot properly be brought under any other Vote, and that is not accepted.
Comment on this
How do you expect me to give the headings here? I do not carry them about in my pocket. We require the assistance of a policeman in our intelligence department from time to time on investigations. We pay him and make provision for his employment. That amounts to £45, and that explanation ought to be sufficient.
Comment on this
I am dissatisfied, and I am sure the Dáil is not satisfied, with the Minister's explanation. I move a reduction of sub-head (h) (3) by £99.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister could give us an example of some of these expenses. I do not want to make vexatious objections or to ask petty questions, but if one item was explained that comes under the heading of incidental expenses, perhaps it would clear the mind of the Dáil.
Comment on this
I do not want to intervene in the discussion between the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and Deputies, but I may say that amongst the things that are included in incidental expenses in other Votes are such things as washing the office towels and providing the office soap.
Comment on this
To judge from what happens at the Public Accounts Committee, another very frequent item under incidental expenses is the provision of newspapers. Are they included?
Comment on this
I want to point out to the Minister, if he is anxious to get this Vote through, that he is standing in his own light. There is no desire to obstruct him. Rightly or wrongly, I say to the Minister that he has given certain Deputies the impression that he does not want to impart information that obviously should be at his disposal. If he seeks to give that impression to Deputies, he is not doing himself a service nor helping the progress of business.
Comment on this
Amendment put.
Do you agree with this result?
I suggest that the interval mentioned by the President at the commencement of the sitting has now arrived.
Comment on this
We are perfectly satisfied to go on, but if there is to be an interval we could take it now.
Comment on this
I am prepared to meet the views of the House at any time on this motion, but might I make a suggestion? We have now occupied eight or ten hours in discussing this Estimate, and we have forty other Estimates to deal with. There was a wish generally expressed, and an admitted agreement that we should rise on the 26th June. Unless I were to hear to the contrary. I would propose that we shape our business to meet that particular date. The only alternative is that of all-night sittings, but these are unfair to everybody, and they put a severe strain on Deputies who have been attending so long. I would make an appeal for expeditious treatment of the Estimates. I do not mean to gloss over them or to pass them en bloc, but I appeal for some consideration in view of the length of time which we have allowed for their consideration, and of the fact that the time allowed this year—I am not speaking from the actual record—is, I think, longer than we have spent on others. I say no more than that at present. I move that the Dáil adjourns until 7.30 p.m.
Deputy Johnson has asked me when we would have the Estimates of the Ministry of Agriculture and the Land Commission. I anticipate that it will be possible to take these in the second week of June, say, on the tenth of June. I anticipate that it may be possible to take some of the Votes for the Ministry of Industry and Commerce on one of the days.
Comment on this
I rather put forward that question about the Land Commission and Ministry of Agriculture Estimates, as I feared they might be delayed until the 25th June, and there would not be full time to discuss them. I would, perhaps, be permitted to say that I think the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs appears rather to have resented criticism, and, therefore, has been very chary in his answers. That has, perhaps, caused this little blockage in the course of business.
Comment on this
I want to explain to the House the cause of our attitude on this matter. We have, even more than Deputy Johnson seems to think, been irritated by the attitude of the Minister. His attitude is very like that of the first Emperor Napoleon, and we resent it. We thought when electing the Minister to his present office that he was a plain man who could meet us without a lofty, head-in-the-sky manner. It has irritated us, and we do not think that that is either very good business or politics. I do not think that he has met us in a fair way, and because of that we intend to use all the facilities that Standing Orders give us on this Vote.
Comment on this
I want to raise a matter on this sub-head which is typical, I think, of other departments in the Government service, but it comes quite definitely and clearly under this sub-head in respect of the department of Posts and Telegraphs. I refer to the question of the employment of civilian labour, and the refusal to employ men who have not been in the National Army. This matter has arisen on many occasions during the last couple of years. We are aware that an understanding was arrived at, and I think an instruction given by the Executive Council to the departments —an instruction was certainly given to local government authorities—that preferences were to be given to ex-members of the Army. But, I gather that in respect to this branch—the engineering establishment—it has been interpreted, not as a preference, but as a natural barrier against any person being employed who was not a member of the National Army. I do not know how long it is intended that this preference should be given or this barrier imposed. I am going to press for a complete revision of that instruction. I think I am right in saying that in many departments—possibly in this department as much as in any other, if not more than in any other—it will be found that the restriction as to ex-members of the Army—the area of choice is so limited that the best value is not being got for the wages paid.
I would have no very strong objection to preference, other things being equal, within limits, but I think it is not fair to the civilian element of the community to say that they are debarred from employment until every ex-National Army man has been absorbed in the public service. As we have said many a time, men who were in the Army were at least fed and clothed and paid during the time they were in it. They have now had a preference for a year or two years, and I submit that the time has arrived when that preference ought to be withdrawn, or certainly when that embargo upon non-Army men should be abandoned. I could understand the case if it were said that here are fifty men unemployed; twenty of them were members of the National Army, and thirty of them were not; we are going to take men in proportion, so many from amongst the ex-Army men and so many civilians. I maintain that if there is going to be anything like equity in the choice of persons to be employed at labour tasks, preference should be given to the men who have wives and families, and the greatest number of dependents. As it is, what is happening is, that the man who has no dependents is in many cases taken on, while men who have families are left. Many of these men with families have been unemployed for a long time. They have run out of benefit under unemployment insurance, and are left to the mercy of home help, charity or something worse.
I say, if there is going to be preference in the employment given in this branch of the service, it should be for men who have dependents. I suggest, too, it is more likely that the men who have dependents would have had greater experience and be more efficient wage-earners, and that better and more efficient service would be obtained in the department by removing this embargo on civilian labour. I have taken this particular department as an instance. I think it is glaring in this case, because I understand from an official letter that the engineers consider they are bound only to consider applications from candidates who had hitherto been in the Army, and therefor all civilian applicants for employment are brushed aside. The same complaint arises in respect to other departments. I want to press upon the Ministry, without arguing the question as to the rights or the wrongs of it in the past, that the time has arrived when that preference should be modified, and that at least a proportionate number of unemployed men who were not ex-Army men should be taken into employment, and that where there are preferences to be given it ought to be a preference for men who have families and responsibilities, rather than to young men who have no families and no responsibilities.
Comment on this
This is a matter which is not peculiar, as Deputy Johnson indicated, to the Post Office. It applies to all Government departments. I admit at once the point made by Deputy Johnson, that the time must come when we will cease to give the degree of preference, amounting in certain cases to a monopoly, that has been given to ex-members of the National Army. We reached a point when it became safe to demobilise the Army. We had some 55,000 men in the Army, and we turned them out in very large numbers within a very brief period, bringing the strength of the Army down to well under 20,000 men. A great number of the men demobilised were married men with dependents. The unmarried men had, in many cases, the option of remaining on in the Army. We were doing away with dependents' allowances on the scale that we had been giving them, and it became impossible to retain a large number of married men in the Army. That meant that something like 40,000 men who had been in the State service were being turned out on the streets. We tried to reserve for them opportunities for employment in the service of the State. We had several clerical examinations limited to ex-officers, and clerical examinations for Customs officers. We have abandoned the idea of holding any further examinations confined to ex-members of the National Army, or any further examinations reserved to that class, because the results of the more recent examinations have convinced us that we have got all the good material out of them. It may be that in future men who served in the National Army will be given a certain preference by way of service marks, but examinations confined to those men will not be held. So far as temporary employment was concerned, there was also a general instruction issued that in all cases the offices must employ only ex-members of the National Army. Temporary clerks, and workmen, and so forth, were all drawn from the ranks of our ex-soldiers. But the matter was never so rigid that if a department showed that suitable men, for the work to be done, could not be got from the ranks of ex-soldiers, they would not be permitted to go outside the ranks in particular cases.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say whether that was within a given area? I understand there has been something like a ruling that even within a particular area, if men were required and ex-soldiers could not be obtained in that area, it was an obligation upon the official making the engagement to go outside the area and bring in ex-soldiers.
Comment on this
I think it would be. I was really thinking where a particular type of skill or experience seemed to be necessary, if reasonably satisfactory ex-Army candidates could not be got the Departments were allowed to go outside the ranks of ex-service men. I realise very well that that sort of monopolistic preference is not a thing that could be continued indefinitely, and I recognise that it is a matter for consideration whether, very soon, there may not be some relaxation of the rule and whether we might not give people who have not served in the National Army a chance that they have not got at the present time.
I think, therefore, in all the circumstances, we have certainly done no more for the ex-Army men than we should have done. If they have not had the hardships, and all the dangers, perhaps, that soldiers have had to endure in some wars, at any rate, they did come in, and they did do service that saved the fabric of the State, and I do not think, whether the experiences that the soldiers have gone through have been very hard experiences or the reverse, that any State, or any Government, could afford, after what they have done, simply to turn them out on the streets and take no further interest in them.
I think it is really necessary for a reasonable period, after a big batch of men have been demobilised, to use all the resources that we have in employing them in a proper way in the service of the State and for the purpose of meeting the claims that these men have, and, above all, which they feel they have.
I have not gone carefully into the question whether the time has been reached when a change in the general policy should be made, and I, certainly, have not discussed it with other Ministers, but I admit Deputy Johnson's point, that we cannot continue that for years after demobilisation has taken place, and that, at some time, men must be presumed to have gone back to their ordinary avocations in some way, and to be in much the position that they would have been if they had not been in the Army. And the same question must arise in all branches of the public service that has already arisen in the clerical grades. As I have said, the position reached there is that we seem to have exhausted any suitable material that existed amongst the ex-Army men. To some extent the same position is bound to be reached in other branches. It is a matter about which I can only promise that careful consideration will be given to it.
Comment on this
On sub-head (m) I want to make a few remarks and ask some questions regarding telephones. The Minister has said that they are very anxious to develop this service and that it would be a boon to the community. I quite agree that the telephone service is a boon where there are communities, but where there are not communities and where the telephone has to be extended to private houses in rural districts, it is going to be a very expensive item. I doubt if it is ever going to be a service that could economically be availed of by the average rural citizen. I have had information, contained in a letter from the Minister's Department, as I mentioned earlier, where £30 was charged for an installation. Not alone that, but a guarantee was asked for five years to justify the connection. Rural populations will not always be as happy as the population to which Deputy Wolfe refers presumably is, where they have a doctor and a vet——
Comment on this
All these people are a considerable distance from one another. There is only one quite close to me. The others are fairly distant.
Comment on this
Where there is no doctor or vet. within five or six miles, I am afraid the Deputy's idea cannot be carried out. We know that doctors do not populate the country—fortunately for the country—quite so extensively as that and I rather think the results the Minister anticipates will not be realised. I want the rural public to know that £30 is sought for an installation with a guarantee for five years. That is what they have to contemplate for the service which is being dangled before them as something that they may avail themselves of in the future. They can avail themselves of it at a price but that price is going to be prohibitive—whether it is justly prohibitive or not I am not prepared to discuss now. But when this prospect is dangled before the rural population. they had better know what it means in money. I am talking about the case of a man in County Dublin, who is living rather near the lines of communication. It seems to me that this is going to be a very expensive item to the average citizen of the country and one that is not likely to be availed of. I would like to know what the Minister has to say about that and if he is going to charge on the basis of cost or on the basis of distance. He should tell us what the charge is really going to be based upon. That is a question that requires a clear understanding, and I hope the Minister will give us on that, at least, a clear explanation.
Comment on this
I am glad that the telephone service is one of the services in the Department for Posts and Telegraphs that is paying its way. We hope, that being so, that the Minister will see his way to establish more call offices throughout the country. I am quite sure that that would have the effect of bringing more business to the Post Office. Everywhere about my district where there has been an office opened, it has been, so far as I know, a success. There are one or two other matters that I should like to allude to. For a long time, the people of Kilcock have been most anxious to have a telephone office established there. There were considerable difficulties in the way, but the Minister was good enough to say that if there were a certain number of guarantors got—I think eight—he would extend the telephone there. I managed to get the names of fourteen guarantors but I have not yet heard that the telephone is in operation there. I would like to know if it will soon be working. There is no doubt about the guarantors and I am sure it would be a very paying proposition for the Post Office, because there are a certain number of racing men there who would employ it very much.
Comment on this
There are certain places where the call office and the telegraph office are not located together. People who have telephones in their houses cannot have telegrams delivered through the telephone. It would be a great convenience to them to have telegrams delivered through the telephone and dispatched by means of the 'phone. Where the call office and the telegraph office are at different places, as I think is the case at Leixlip, it is a great inconvenience to many people who are under the necessity of sending and receiving telegrams. I was asked if the Minister could be induced to establish trunk call offices on the Great Southern Railway, not at every station, but at important stations where fairs are held. If this were done, it would enable the people attending those fairs to communicate about the dispatch of stock to their own homes, so that it could be met at the trains. Probably it would be a paying proposition for the Post Office, too. Deputy Gorey alluded to the cost of installation. My impression was that when the telephone was installed at my house and at the houses of my neighbours, we did not pay for the installation. At least, I have no recollection of having done so or of having paid anything beyond a certain yearly charge.
Comment on this
I would like to ask if it is the Minister's policy to extend telephonic communication to the small towns and villages throughout the country. I have a case in point. Castledermot, in Kildare, has about 600 inhabitants, and the district about it is fairly populous. They have been making representations there, for some time, to have the telephone installed there, and I would like to ask the Minister if it is his intention to provide telephonic communication to places like that.
Comment on this
Considering the needs of this great horse-racing and betting county, I am sure the Minister will take special care to accommodate Deputy Wolfe and his friends. Deputy Good referred the other day to the amount of betting that was being indulged in and suggested that it ought to be discouraged. Deputy Wolfe seems to take a different point of view.
Comment on this
All the accommodation possible should be given to these horse-racing and betting people, to do with the telephone what Deputy Good said they were doing with the telegraph service—that is, abusing it. I am sure the Minister will take that into consideration and do the best he can for these betting people.
Comment on this
I would like to have an opportunity of refuting Deputy Gorey's suggestion, that it is in the interests of betting people that Deputy Wolfe and myself have been speaking. I understand that Deputy Wolfe wants the telephone for Kilcock, and I want it for Castledermot, at the extreme end of the county and away from racing influence altogether.
Comment on this
I can assure Deputy Conlan that we are most anxious to extend the telephone to even the smallest villages. We have got to cater for the larger ones, in the first instance. Deputy Wolfe wants to know what are we doing about Kilcock. We hope to be operating in that particular quarter within the next three or four months. We are suffering from a shortage of technical staff—a shortage which I see little hope of rectifying—and we do not anticipate being able to cope with this particular job at least for the next three months. Some little time ago it was urged that we should introduce telephones to the important railway stations throughout the country, and erect call offices. That can only be done in co-operation with the railway authorities, because it would not pay us to maintain officials there for that particular purpose. We might, in the case of the Great Southern Railway, be able to co-ordinate the work of our own officials, who at present work the telegraph offices for the railway companies, with the telephone. But that possibility only applies to the Great Southern Railway.
Comment on this
There are other people interested in other lines. There have been representations from the Great Northern, and also from the Midland Great Western section of the Southern Railways. Deputy Gorey complains that we require our pound of flesh for the extension of the telephone, and that in one instance an annual fee of £30, plus a guarantee for five years, was imposed. It was the custom of our predecessors, and it has continued in our time, to charge merely for the cost of capital expenditure, plus interest. Latterly, we have modified that somewhat, and made a sacrifice of State funds in order to expedite the introduction of the 'phone. It must be remembered that the erection of a 'phone over a distance of four or five miles, entails the erection of new poles. Then certain rights have to be got over land. These things involve fairly heavy expenditure. I do not see much hope of calling on unlimited State funds to aid in the installation of the telephone. The hope of the telephone in the rural areas lies, first, in the opening of exchanges in these parts of the country that have even limited compact populations—I mean small villages—and secondly, by the extension of the party line, such as one finds in Scandinavia, the United States and in a few other countries. The idea of extending a direct 'phone to every farmer's house is out of the question. The expense would be too much. We will have to depend, in the first instance, on the opening of exchanges pretty well everywhere; and secondly, on getting the farmers to take on the party lines. We believe they will, and we believe that will be the solution.
Comment on this
On this matter of telephones, I would like, if the Minister, before the debate is finished, would elaborate a little more on the question of the cost. I do not know what the custom has been in the past with regard to charges, or what his intention is. Is the idea that if the line is to be extended, say, to one farmer's house at his request, that that farmer is to bear the expense of the extension— that is, the cost of the extension to the Post Office? If I understand that to be the case, I would suggest that that is not a good policy. It is not a policy that is likely to result in the general utilisation of the telephone. If one or two farmers in a district were anxious to get the telephone to their houses, it should be extended to their houses at the least possible cost, and not at the actual cost of the extension. The very fact of these farmers getting the telephone and making use of it would encourage their neighbours, and where you would have one or two using it at first, you would have nine or ten in a short time. I am a great believer in the use that can be made of the telephone in the country. I differ in that respect from Deputy Gorey, because I have seen the use that can be made of it. From a business point of view, and from the social aspect, great advantages can accrue to the people from the 'phone. Great saving could be made with regard to time and expense if we could open up telephonic communication on a large scale throughout the country. I would suggest to the Minister, if he is going to deal with this matter, that he ought to do it on a broad general plan, and resort to propaganda and publicity. He should let the people know what it will cost and the advantages that will accrue to them if they avail of the telephone. If the Minister has not quite exhausted all he has to say, I would like if he would give us some idea of what the cost would be, and if the cost would vary from district to district, because I think this is a matter of great importance to the future development of the country.
Comment on this
There is one question I asked the Minister, and he forgot to answer it. That was about having the call office in all cases at the post office for the delivery by 'phone of telegrams sent there. I think this is rather an important matter.
Comment on this
It is not always possible to locate a telephone call office and a telegraph office in the same building. It should also be remembered that we have found a certain condition of affairs existing which is not easily changed, and cannot be changed without meeting with resistance. Now, there is no difficulty at any time in utilising the telephone for either the receipt or the despatch of a telegram. Even if the offices are not located in the same building, arrangements can always be made whereby telegrams can be telephoned.
Comment on this
Would there be any charge for sending the telegram from the post office to the call office?
Comment on this
The telephone call office. When a telegram arrives at the post office, would there be any charge for sending it to the call office for transmission by 'phone?
Comment on this
No; we never charge for transmission of a telegram by telephone, for the reason that we save messenger employment by that means. Now, we have a very definite scheme of telephone development. I said at the outset that we are more keen on developing the telephone system than anything else. We believe the country has more to gain through this medium. We have no doubt whatever about that. We regard the telegraph and the postal systems as back numbers, so to speak. We think that the future of communication lies with the telephone. That has been proved to be the case in some of the most progressive nations in the world, and we hope to come within their magic sphere some time.
Before you can really outline a scheme for developing telephones over the rural areas, you have to build up the main channels. We found those channels semi-vacant, practically vacant and undeveloped. There were very few telephones in use in Ireland. We are building up those channels now. The main channels are practically built up and we are getting on to the feeding sources, the smaller rivers, so to speak. From those we will go on to the streamlets and in that way we will go right down through the various stages of development. We have not yet covered all the towns. There are towns in parts of Connaught, for instance, not developed. As a matter of fact, we are only entering that province. We have to deal with the bigger centres before we come to the smaller ones. When we come to the smaller areas we will have to envisage a scheme whereby we will be able to get into the rural parts and so complete the final stages.
There is nothing new in this respect. There is nothing confronting us that has not been done elsewhere. We have a headline for everything, and the farmers need have no doubt about it that we are most anxious to extend the telephone all over the Saorstát. Further, it will be the policy of the Department to subsidise the system from its own finances. In other words, during the coming year we will net £30,000 or £40,000 after the concession that we made in this Budget, and I would rather favour the idea of a further concession. We must make the telephones cheap and general. It is the great channel through which the public business can be done. It is rapid and it is timesaving and it puts us in a position to do our business with the same efficiency and speed as our competitors. That is why we are very keen on this question of telephones, and there need be no doubt that whenever and wherever we get an opportunity of establishing the telephones, we are going to do it with a will.
Comment on this
There are a couple of points that I wish to bring under the attention of the Minister. Deputy Wolfe has referred to those who have the telephones installed and he has touched on the question of having call offices different from Post Offices. Would it be possible for the Minister to arrange that when a wire is sent, even where the call office is not at the Post Office, that a subscriber will be asked if he desires to take the wire by telephone? There is usually a charge for delivery, and it could be avoided in that case. I know many cases of the sort, both personally and otherwise, through friends, and I am sure there are other Deputies who could instance similar cases. I would suggest to the Minister that the number of subscribers considered necessary in small villages, small country districts, would be reduced to a minimum, provided that his Department does not lose by the installation of the telephone in that particular village or district. I do not want to put it that they should not make any profit, but possibly the Minister could see his way to have the number of subscribers reduced somewhat. I know that to reach some fourteen or fifteen subscribers, wires have to be run a considerable distance and poles erected, and possibly, in some cases, rights over lands have to be acquired. and paid for; but in most of the small country towns and villages the telephone would be a decided advantage.
Then, again, you have local creameries. In many of the creameries that exist they have already a telephone. It is most important from their point of view. If the telephone is extended as is suggested, it would be of great benefit, as Deputy Gorey and Deputy Conlan pointed out, to farmers in the country. I happen to know that the telephone is the medium through which practically all the small farmers in Denmark conduct their business. Of course you have more people of that type there than you have in this country, and therefore there is the possibility of securing more subscribers. The 200-acre rancher is not a great asset to the Post Office or to postal authorities, because he would cost too much to give a single installation to. There are so many small farmers in Denmark, it is easier to facilitate them in the matter of the telephone, and they can communicate direct with the bacon factories or the creameries. It is certainly a great advantage to them.
There is another point that I would like to touch upon. It would be advisable on the evening before cattle fairs—I do not refer to markets; they do not count for much except, perhaps, in some areas—to have the telephone office left open for at least one hour longer than usual. You have numbers of buyers coming from different parts of Ireland. They might get into the town about 6 o'clock in the evening, and they might want to telephone at about 8 o'clock. They may want the returns from markets on the other side; they might want to know particulars about the Dublin market on a Thursday, or about Smithfield, Birkenhead, etc. Without the telephone office being left open they cannot get through to their principals in Dublin to ascertain the rates in relation to the cross-Channel markets. They would need all that information in the morning for their business at the fair. Numbers of complaints have been received from different parts of Ireland in regard to that matter. I would ask the Minister to extend the time for telephone calls on the evenings before fairs. I have no doubt the farmers will support me in this matter.
Comment on this
I beg to support Deputy D'Alton as regards the hours for telephone calls. In the town of Cavan, for instance, the telegraph office is not open until 9 a.m. That applies also to fair mornings. Farmers and dealers going to the fairs want to have the earliest possible information in regard to city markets and cross-Channel markets, and 9 o'clock is too late. It is really too late even on an ordinary day, not to speak of a fair day.
Comment on this
I desire to say one thing in connection with this matter. We would very much appreciate and welcome a greater development of the telephone service. We, like the Minister, believe that as far as small messages go, the telephone is going to be the medium of the future. We believe it is going to replace the telegraph service. It may, to some extent, replace the postal service, but I take it the postal service is something you can never abandon; I do not think we can in our time, at least. It must be maintained. Therefore, how this service will affect the postal service is not a matter of much concern now. Where it affects the telegraph service, we come to a big matter. The Minister has told us that the loss of the telegraph service runs into a quarter of a million. That is a thing we cannot look at and pass away from without having some food for thought. Complaints have been made with regard to the delivery of telegrams, and I think a position has been put up that is rather unanswerable from a few points of view. The citizen in the rural districts is placed at an extraordinary disadvantage.
To help the Minister to develop this particular service and to bring more benefit to the rural community we are prepared to co-operate as far as possible in every way with the postal service in regard to the development of this service. That is altogether different from what Deputy Heffernan thinks. I think we are of the same mind, but the question of cost in this individual case has been brought under my notice by a letter. The letter has been sent to me but I have not it here now. It is in order to remedy that state of affairs, to get a better understanding and to have a much better scheme, that I asked the question and I want an explanation about it. If that idea of charging £30 a year for five years got abroad and if it was not going to be remedied and a better system adopted, I have no hesitation in saying that you could bid good-bye to rural development of the telephone for years. I do think the Minister must go further, much further.
I suggest that there have been considerable differences of opinion with regard to how this service is administered in the country and the Minister's viewpoint, considerable differences of opinion. I do not think that an Advisory Committee has been set up in connection with this Ministry. Advisory Committees have been set up in other Ministries, especially extern Ministries. The Minister for Lands and Agriculture—and when we talk about the Minister for Lands and Agriculture I think it will be admitted that we are talking about one of the most efficient Ministers and one of the most efficient Ministries we have—has thought it advisable to set up Advisory Committees under the special Acts. Not alone has he set them up under one special Act but he thought it well in connection with the working of other special Acts to have an Advisory Committee. The Minister for Local Government has also an Advisory Committee. On the question of the roads he has the Roads Advisory Board. I think in order to give the country confidence in this Ministry and in order to have a better working arrangement, a better understanding between the public and the Minister, that the appointment of an Advisory Committee would be something that would bridge over the acute difference of opinion that at present exists.
I can see if arrangements are made, whereby a body of rural citizens can come together and guarantee a call office and deal with that question, that this service of telephones is going to be greatly extended in the very near future. I want to assure the Minister and the Government that although in the early part of this Vote a certain spirit originated—I do not hold it was altogether our fault; there is no use going into it now—we are prepared to co-operate with the Minister if the Minister is prepared to co-operate with the rural population. I say the best move in that direction would be the setting up of an Advisory Committee on which the rural population will be represented. The general public and the different interests will be represented on it and in that case any fault that is to be found will be attributed to that Advisory Committee and will not be so much a fault of the Minister. It will bring about an atmosphere of more confidence and I think that is very desirable in this Ministry for the reasons we have debated earlier in the Vote.
Comment on this
The Deputy rather implies a lack of confidence in the Ministry of Posts and Telegraphs.
Comment on this
I think they have shown more confidence in the particular Minister than in the Deputy, and they have not failed to assert their viewpoint whenever they have got an opportunity.
Comment on this
We do not run Departments by public meetings, and if we bring in the villagers and the townsmen and everybody else to advise us in regard to how we are to run a Department which we are very capable of running, quite capable of running, I do not think we will make much headway. It is pretty much a waste of time. To suggest that you will get an Advisory Committee from people who have no knowledge whatever of Post Office Work——
Comment on this
Which is highly technical work, where a man requires a lifetime's training to know what he is talking about——
Comment on this
To suggest that a Committee of that kind should come along and advise on a service of this kind is very nice, but I do not think it would work. On the other hand, if a citizen requires us to run a private 'phone any number of miles through the country, we are prepared to run it if that citizen pays. The fact of taking an individual of that type, where a payment of £30 annually is called for, as an example of what the telephone system should be or may be, is not, I suggest, fair, and has no bearing on the situation. Our difficulty is not to get users for this system, but to meet the requirements of the users. I do not see much prospect within the next two or three years of our keeping up with the public demand.
Deputy D'Alton has some doubts about the utilisation of 'phone offices for telegraph work. There may be a few cases in the country where it is not possible to bring these two systems into play, but they are very few cases. There is an instance in Foxrock—to take one case—where you have got a telegraph section in one building and, a mile away, a telephone call office. In that case the telegrams are dealt with by the Central Telegraph Office here, direct to the addressee. I quite agree that there is something in the suggestion that exchanges should be kept open in towns or in rural centres on the eve of a market. We may be able to extend the time for an hour or two, and certainly the matter will be carefully considered. It seems to be a very reasonable suggestion. Deputy Cole tells us that some post offices on like occasions are not open until 9 a.m. My information is that there are no such cases. There were up to twelve months ago. No exception was made on a fair or a market day. We, at the request of some Deputies here, introduced a system whereby post offices were opened specially early on those days. If there is any exception I would be very pleased to be made aware of it.
Comment on this
With regard to N 1. I want to ask the Minister for some information with reference to item B—Non-Statutory Allowances. There is an item, Marriage Gratuities, £2,000. I simply want to know if these gratuities are voluntary, if there is any obligation on the Post Office Authorities to make these contributions, and how and on what scale are they based.
Comment on this
These gratuities are in lieu of superannuation allowances. They are of a special type and require the sanction of the Ministry of Finance in each case.
Comment on this
I want a ruling in this matter, because I desire to raise a point which may have been gone into in my absence, and, if so, I do not want to have it dealt with again. It is in regard to the question of the workshops that the Minister spoke about, and the manufacture of electrical appliances. I do not see any other heading under which I can deal with it, except on this of engineering stores, or on the final general Vote.
Comment on this
We have had that first. The general discussion took place first and then we went through the items. The Deputy now wants a general discussion over again.
Comment on this
There is no Deputy, except Deputy Heffernan, who is not perfectly satisfied that this Estimate has been thrashed in and out, up and down.