We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

AGRICULTURAL CREDIT SOCIETIES. - DEPUTY BAXTER'S MOTION (Resumed).

Contributions 1–127 of 251. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Last night I was endeavouring to direct the attention of the House towards, what I would consider, the inconsistency of the Government in connection with the affliction of fluke disease which came upon our cattle. In June last the Minister for Agriculture stated that on account of the abnormal visitation of this disease in various districts he considered that it was his duty to make some advance towards helping farmers who had lost their stock. To make good his efforts a Vote of £100,000 was passed and the Minister for Agriculture advised that that could best be employed by the institution of credit societies in those areas which the disease had ravaged. Four or five months afterwards we are here, in this motion, pointing out that these credit societies have failed to do what the Minister intended they should do. Therefore, we are asking that an alternative method should be used for helping those farmers who have been afflicted.

What is the Government's method? To bring in an amendment which is merely a reiteration of a truism, a reiteration of what we all agree to, in the hope that it will by that means side-track the motion here. That motion of Deputy Baxter's positively asserts what is a fact, and the amendment by Deputy Tierney, on behalf of the Government, is merely a parliamentary trick to side-track the issue. Of course we all agree that credit societies are good. That is not an answer to our motion. We want you to give, at least, good terms to the farmers whose losses are well known. You have yourselves agreed they exist; unless they did exist it would not be the duty of the Government to interfere. We say that you ought effectively to use the money voted by the Dáil and not hold it up indefinitely in the furthering of those schemes of credit societies which undoubtedly will be good, but which will not be effective in the emergency which now exists.

Those are the reasons why I cannot accept the amendment. It is said that the farmers should not be always looking for State aid. I agree. We should not always be looking for State aid; but this is a case where it is admitted by the Government that State aid is necessary. From my own experience I have known other Governments, in cases of drought in other countries, to come to the aid of the farmers. Here is a case where you agree that help is needed. Your method is wrong and we ask you to change your method. Give us these short-term loans which have been so effectively used in the north, and by which means the money voted by the Dáil here may be put into proper use.

A sum of £3,500 has been loaned in four months. The need is there, but the farmers are placed out of employment and there is no hope of their being able to make a living. The period has lapsed when whatever money that could be made on the farm would be available for credit societies. Yet, with all the activities of the Minister and the organisation society at his back, with the help of the Deputies on these Benches, and with the help of the Deputies of the Cumann na nGaedheal, he has been able to start only eight societies and loan them £3,500. Is that able to meet the case that exists and for which the money has been voted?

This is an effort to stop the allocation of money and to give the help needed. If the Government thinks that by this method they are going to escape the blame—for they are blameable for inaction—and if they think that by persevering in this slow-going motion they are going to escape censure, you may take it that they are mistaken. There is a feeling in the country amongst the farmers—I wonder how the farmers on the Government side will counter that feeling— that the Dáil's efforts to help them in their distress have been nullified by the inert action of the Government.

Northern Ireland, with its small resources, can give short-term loans through the banks at 2½ per cent. Why cannot this Government, having voted £100,000, do the same, or better? What is wrong with this Government? We agree that credit societies will help; but they will not help in the emergency which at present faces us, and for that reason I have no hesitation whatever in objecting to and voting against the amendment.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

took the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE (Mr. Hogan) Cumann na nGaedheal

Before going into the general question, which is the need of credit in the country, I would like first to endeavour to clear up a few points. I want to say that I appreciate the spirit in which Deputy Baxter proposed the motion. He proposed it quite moderately, and he put the case from his own point of view quite fairly, I admit. Having said that much, I want to say also, in conjunction with it, that I am a convinced believer that the credit society is the correct method; I am a convinced believer that the loan system is wrong. I will give my reasons for this afterwards. I say that in connection with the way in which the matter was presented.

Deputy Baxter reminded me that if a census had been taken, if the Gárda Síochána had visited every farm in the country for the purpose of ascertaining all about the crops and getting other figures for publication in the statistical reports, these visits might be availed of for the purpose of getting some information as to the magnitude of the problem. He asked me whether I had instructed the Gárda Síochána, in addition to their normal duties, to make definite inquiries at each farm or place they visited as to the losses from fluke. My answer is that I did not give such instructions, and I deliberately refrained from doing that. I deliberately refrained because I am convinced that by that method I would get no accurate information from such a census. Deputy Baxter has more faith in census of that sort than I have. I venture to say he has very much more faith in a census of that sort than the normal farmer has who knows the conditions in the country.

I took considerable pains to ascertain, by methods which I consider sound, the extent of the losses through the fluke last winter and spring. I have nothing to add or subtract from the estimate which I gave the Dáil then, nothing whatever. I do not propose to go into those figures again. I quoted them at length. I do propose to tell the Dáil the methods I adopted. The Department of Agriculture has competent officials, agricultural instructors, live-stock officers, etc. Some of them permanently reside in every county in the Saorstát. They are working in every parish, and the Department of Agriculture has other officials who are constantly going from one county to another. I get reports periodically from every one of these officials. As I pointed out, many of them reside in every county, and the others are visiting, in one way or another, at very short intervals, every part of the Sáorstát. They have no interest except to get the truth. I regard them as quite competent to draw up a programme of accurate information as to the extent of the problem. I have absolute confidence in the results they have given me, and which I have given to the Dáil.

In addition, I took some pains myself to investigate the problem in the county from which I come where there has been, probably, as great a loss from fluke as in any other county. I refer to Galway. I consulted reliable farmers and they are easily found in various districts. I got their opinions for certain typical districts. I consulted farmers who came from districts where you have high, healthy, lively land, and farmers who come from districts where you have low-lying, sodden land. I consulted a great many of these farmers. I have been all over the country in connection with the Live Stock Breeding Act. I took every opportunity to consult practical farmers whom I regard as reliable men, and I got their opinions as to the losses. It was on the information I obtained in that way that I formed my conclusions.

I put it to Deputy Baxter or to any farmer anywhere, whether in the Dáil or outside it, whether that is not a more reliable way to get an approximate estimate, the only approximate estimate you could get of the losses, than by the method of sending around Gárda to each house asking them the naive question: "How many cattle and sheep have died on you through fluke?" with the implication that the Government was going to come along with a free grant, perhaps. The Deputies may be shocked and say I have a very low estimate of Irish human nature and of human nature in general. I have not, but we must take human nature as it is, and, speaking as one man who knows the conditions in the country, I have no doubt that the estimate that I arrived at on that basis is more likely to be accurate than the figures I could get by the crude method of sending out the Gárda Síochána to inquire from every Tom, John and Pat how many cattle died on them from the fluke, with the implication that there was to be a Government grant. That was my method, and I think it is a sound method. That was the way I arrived at my figures. I have always realised that considerable numbers of stock died of fluke. I have equally realised that many more stock died of starvation. I pointed out often in the Dáil that one very serious aspect of Irish agriculture is that stock in the winter-time are under-fed. I will be told that the people have not the feeding; that is not an answer. Some stock died of starvation last winter and last spring. They did not die a year before; but they were under-fed, and, as a rule, they are under-fed, not so much in the poorer counties, but often in the rich counties where there is more feeding, where there are better crops, better land and more money. That aspect of affairs is not explained, and cannot be explained, by poverty, for the simple reason that under-feeding is as much prevalent in the good rich counties, where practically every farmer has an economic holding, as it is in the poorer counties. I have nothing to add to or subtract from the estimate which I gave of this problem last spring.

Now, we were told that this was a pretence of dealing with the problem. I never claimed that this is going to deal with the problem in toto. No man who has given a moment's consideration to the matter can deny that no possible scheme which the Government could put into operation would deal with more than 25 per cent. of the deserving cases. If you consider the figures concerned with this problem, I cannot see how there can be any doubt about it. Last spring I gave the figure of 5 per cent. as being approximately— as being at least a shot—at the losses.

Comment on this

Do you mean 5 per cent. for the whole country?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Yes. Assume that it was only 2½ per cent. That percentage, when applied to 350,000 farmers, would mean about 17,000. If you give each of the 17,000 farmers £50, the total would be £850,000. Deputies have talked about the decimation of flocks and herds. I am talking of a 2½ per cent. loss. Remember that the normal mortality amongst live-stock is close up to that; that is, the normal mortality from old age and one thing or another. I am not talking of flocks or herds being decimated; I am not talking of Egyptian plague, or anything of that sort. I say that if you were to attempt to deal with only 2½ per cent. of the farmers, you would require to put up £850,000 in order to give them a loan of £50 apiece. Addition and subtraction are non-political and nonsectarian. I doubt very much if the figures I have given will be questioned. Let us assume we had £850,000 put up for the purposes of fluke. Deputies will, of course, remember that money comes out of the pockets of the other farmers.

Comment on this

Yes; we know that.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Assume you did that. I am sure, with the exception of Deputy Johnson, who has announced that he proposes to oppose every proposal that comes from the Government benches, not because of its merits, but because of a Labour dispute, you would all agree that it was rather a big sum.

Comment on this

Deputy Johnson said nothing of the kind.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

We will, perhaps, deal with that again. It would be a rather considerable sum. I dare say if £850,000 were put up Deputies would look cheerfully for £1,000,000, and if £500,000 were put up I am sure a little more would be sought. I am trying to face this matter on its merits. I am trying to face the problem in a business way and to give the real reasons that convinced me that the scheme proposed by Deputy Baxter, the loan scheme, is the wrong way to deal with it. As I have said, £850,000 constitutes a big sum which will come out, to a very great extent, of the other farmers' pockets.

Comment on this

They are prepared to pay.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

They are prepared to pay? The money comes out of the pockets of the other farmers, who are working hard trying to make ends meet. Let us say that the money is made available by the Minister for Finance. I wonder how many applications would we have? Would we not have 15 per cent. instead of 2½ per cent.? Deputies will agree, I am sure, that that is the very least we would have. Will any Deputy who faces the problem seriously tell me how any Government Department could institute a scrutiny close enough to get down to the deserving 2½ per cent. out of the 15 per cent. applications? I am trying to use accurate minimum figures.

Comment on this

How did they do it in the North?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I will come to that. That is a rather helpless point of view. I suppose the Northern people are able to think out their own problems. I assume Deputy Wilson would hardly go to the North to find out how they work out their mental processes; he may think himself sufficiently competent to know how they arrived at their figures. I use the figure 15 per cent. as the minimum. You would have fully that percentage applying for the money allocated by the Minister for Finance. Giving 2½ per cent. of the farmers £50 apiece would mean an outlay of £850,000. Will any Deputy tell me how a Government Department would be able to institute a scrutiny close enough to sift that 15 per cent. down to the 2½ per cent. that would represent cases really deserving? Of course, we are blamed for not being infallible. I have never claimed that I am infallible.

Comment on this

God forbid.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

It is the implication to be drawn from Deputy Corish's criticism on a good many occasions. But, looking at this in a business-like way, is there any chance that that would happen? Deputy Wilson and every member on the Farmers' Benches knows what would happen, and it is mere pretence to say that what I have stated would not happen. It is because I do not stand for pretence in dealing with this problem by this loan system that I am against it. Neither do I claim—I would be long sorry to do so—that the system of credit societies is going to meet it in toto, but in time it will.

Comment on this

How many years will it take?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Let me develop the point. I interrupted the Deputy, I agree. That is No. 1. As to No. 2, Deputy Johnson announced to the public the other day that he proposed to do anything and everything he could to bring the present Ministry to an end.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

And, of course, he opposed this. As I hope I am able to draw ordinary deductions from ordinary plain English, I am very well aware that the Deputy opposed this in pursuance of the undertaking which he gave to the country. He did not oppose it on its merits, but merely because of some other dispute which has absolutely nothing whatever to do with this question. He adopted, if I may say so, a superior attitude. He lectured certain members of this party on economics. He told them that really they knew very little about these things.

Comment on this

I was only judging by their speeches.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

He gave the idea that he could teach them a lot on economics. He stated, in a sort of ex cathedra way, and as a sort of infallible economist, that he could give you the latest theories from all the Fabian tracts. He stated everybody knew that, while credit societies could deal with the ordinary credit needs of the farming community, they were never intended by anyone, and could never have been intended by anyone, to deal with a special emergency. That is a very interesting point of view. I want to point out to Deputy Johnson that, even though he may be infallible, I will have to take the liberty of having my own opinions in the matter, and to point out to him further that when we debated this question, as Deputy Wilson reminded us, six months ago, he did not state on that occasion that credit societies, of necessity and of their very nature, were incapable of dealing with an emergency. He only discovered that since the Shannon wages dispute.

Comment on this

I am willing to learn by experience, even from the Minister.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I am glad it is from experience the Deputy learned that. From the way the Deputy announced it he led me to assume it was the fundamental economic doctrine of a great economist who knew all about this. Of course, the ignoramuses— someone referred with a certain amount of amusement to professors— on the Government benches did not know these things. Now the Deputy admits that he is like the rest of us, and that his deductions are not philosophical and abstract, but rather that he deduces from experience. I think, therefore, I may take it that he is not an a priori economist.

Comment on this

What is all this about?

Comment on this

When is the Minister going to talk to the motion?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The point I am making is that you must look at this problem in perspective. There is no use in talking about flocks and herds being decimated. We will not reach any real conclusions until the problem is stated as it really is. In considering the steps to be taken to deal with this problem, any responsible Minister for Finance would have to consider whether he would be entitled to make public funds obtained from taxation on the farmers of the country available to meet this problem, or whether these funds could not be more reasonably spent in another direction. You have, I say, to look at this problem in its proper perspective. I pointed out in the debate on this question before that the annual losses, the unavoidable losses, through contagious abortion were far greater than the losses that have occurred through fluke this year. I wonder are there any dairy farmers here who would venture to disagree with me on that.

Comment on this

I venture to disagree with you to this extent, that the effect would not be the same at all in the two cases. In the one case you lose the offspring, but in this case you lose the cow and all.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Would the Deputy go any further than to say that it will have a different effect? Would he venture to deny that in the bulk—I am not talking now of any particular district but am taking the country as a whole—the losses from contagious abortion are far greater than the losses this year through fluke disease?

Comment on this

Were the losses from fluke additional to the losses from contagious abortion?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Yes. As I have stated already, to consider this problem you must put it in its proper perspective. Deputy Johnson, in answer to the Minister for Justice the other day, boasted that he was proud to say that he stood for a policy whereby a farmer in the country, qua taxpayer, had to pay a far higher wage to labour working outside his own farm than he could pay to labour working on his own farm. The Deputy boasted of that.

Comment on this

What has this got to do with the motion?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I am putting the problem in its perspective. I repeat that Deputy Johnson boasted of that fact, and said he was proud of it. He said it was due to the inefficiency of the farmers, and I want to tell the farmers of the country that if they are really enthusiastic in giving relief to agriculture they have there a problem which it would pay them to tackle, and to tackle seriously.

Comment on this

We will get advice from the P.M.G.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I want to state, speaking for the largest party in this House——

Comment on this

The farmers are keeping very silent on it.

Comment on this

They are not here at all. They are out on the Lobby.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I assure the Deputy that if I was not under the necessity of speaking on this motion I would not do it. With regard to credit generally, I am of opinion that there is too much credit of the wrong kind in the country and not enough credit of the right kind. If you go into any parish in the country, any district you like, you will find there from 60 or 70 per cent. of the farmers who are sound and who, as a rule, are very hardworking, intelligent farmers. They are sound financially and otherwise. Then you will find a balance who are not nearly as well off, with a tail of 15 per cent. that are really badly off. Now credit would be really useful to the 60 per cent., and that is the real credit problem of this country, and every farmer knows it, in so far as there is a need for short-term loans. The real use of agricultural credit is for the 60 per cent. of farmers who know how to use it. I will go further and say in regard to the 30 per cent. or the 15 per cent., that is to say the people who are worst off, that credit is of more harm than good to them unless it is given extremely judiciously and unless it is supervised in the closest possible manner. Now it is 15 per cent. we are dealing with, because everybody knows that if money were made available this 15 per cent. would apply for it. If they are to get credit the credit must be strictly calculated so as to bear some reasonable proportion to their security, and to the possibilities of their handling the money economically when provided with it, and, so far as the great percentage of them is concerned, too much credit too readily obtainable would do them more harm than good. When I state that, I am stating nothing that any farmer, in his heart of hearts, will not agree with. Remember it is that 15 per cent. that is certain to apply. The moment it becomes known that the State is making money available for loan purposes they apply immediately, and become energetic, and make a real good try to obtain it, and use all the influence they know how to obtain it. That type of man is the man always looking to obtain money at a cheap rate and always hoping that, if you like, he will be able to pay it back. These are the sort of people who would apply.

I have shown that £750,000 would not deal with more than 2½ per cent. of those people, and I ask how many of the actual 2½ per cent. who would get it would find it useful unless they got it in very small doses and were very strictly supervised and had a full realisation that they had to pay it back. I put these considerations to the Farmers' Party for what they are worth. I have shown what it would take to deal with only 2½ per cent. of the farmers of the country, giving them only a small loan of £50 each. I tried to show that so far as the farmers of the country are concerned 15 per cent. would apply; that loans would only be useful to them provided they were very small loans that they could reasonably handle, and provided there was the closest possible scrutiny and supervision, and I have shown that no machinery the State could adopt would enable the State so to discriminate as to sift out that 2½ per cent. that would get loans and supervise the spending of the money afterwards. These are the reasons, whether they be good or bad, for which I oppose this loan system, and I oppose it with the full knowledge that one of the big questions agriculturally is this question of credit. I am as anxious as any Deputy to see this very big question of agricultural credit tackled as it should be, but I do not want it to be side-tracked. I do not want the temporary misfortunes of this sort used for the purpose of rushing us into credits that are no good to anybody, and which can only have the effect of increasing taxation and taking money out of the pockets of the hard-worked farmers of the country, and to give it out in such a way that it would be of no use to the men who receive it.

Comment on this

No use to a man to be able to buy a cow if he lost one; that is the problem.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

That is merely, as Deputy Baxter knows, shutting his eyes. If I had £50 to spare, which I have not, and if I wanted to lend it to a neighbour or somebody else that I knew, I could easily pick out a man who lost cows and whom I know would make good use of it. But Deputy Baxter knows that is not the position. The position is where you have something like 40,000 or 50,000 people applying for a loan and the State, through the Department of Agriculture here in Dublin, has to sift them down to 2½ per cent. of that number. It could not be done, and in its results it would do no more than I have said, namely, that the effect of such a scheme would be to take the money out of the pockets of the hard-worked farmers and put it into the pockets of others.

Comment on this

They are all hardworking, even the men who lost their cattle.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Not all, but a good many of them. It would be taking the money out of the pockets of the hard-worked farmer and giving it to people, and so far as 50 per cent. of the people who receive it are concerned, it would do more harm than good. That is the problem, and whether credit societies are the right way of solving the problem or not, the problem is there, and I think I have stated it correctly.

Comment on this

The Minister speaks of 2½ per cent., and that appears to be 2½ per cent. of the stock, but most of his arguments seem to be about 2½ per cent. of the farmers. Would he disentangle this matter?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I am assuming that the number of farmers who would apply would represent, roughly, the amount of stock lost. It will not make much difference.

Comment on this

There is an assumption in all this argument from figures that the loss is spread evenly over the whole country and all the farmers. The case made is that in districts some groups of farmers side by side, neighbours in groups, have lost cattle. In other districts in the country no cattle were lost beyond the normal. Now, to talk of the percentages of farmers, and mix that up with the percentage of stock is quite misleading.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I disagree. It is not misleading to say, first of all, for the purpose of argument, that we propose to deal with only 2½ per cent. of the farmers of the country and that to give them £50 a piece would mean £750,000. There is nothing misleading in that, whether they be in this district or in that district, whether they be spread over the country evenly or whether they be confined to special districts; it is not misleading to say that to give a loan of £50 to 2½ per cent. of the farmers of the country would mean £850,000. That is point number one.

Now, with regard to number two, Deputy Johnson stated that the ravages of fluke were confined to certain districts. To say that it was confined to certain districts would be wrong. They are most serious in some districts than in others. The fact is that there are certain districts in the country that you could schedule as fluke areas, but, on the other hand, there have been losses to a smaller extent in other areas, and all our experience in connection with the applications that have come in regard to the setting up of credit societies showed that cases had been made from practically every district, whether rightly or wrongly, for loans on account of fluke.

Deputies will remember that the Ministry of Finance made it a condition of the scheme that these credit societies should not be organised except in districts where losses from fluke had occurred. Now, in practice, that never stopped us on a single occasion, because you will always, in fact, find people to say, "Well, fluke occurred here." I am not now saying that fluke occurred in every district. I know it did not. I know there are special areas which were more hardly hit, but I am saying that in practice the consideration that fluke did not occur in a certain district is not going to stop a single man from applying and from putting up the case that there was a certain loss one way or another.

Comment on this

You would be no good if you were not able to examine his case and see whether it was sound or not.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

In any event, even if we had scheduled certain districts, the congested districts, Kildare, Cork, counties like Leix, and so on, does any Deputy say that the number of applications which we would receive would not mean applications from 15 per cent. of all the farmers? I have no doubt most of them would, and, what is more——

Comment on this

No, they would not.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I am saying that you would receive applications from 15 per cent. of the farmers. I did not understand that it was the proposal of the Farmers' Party that any county should be precluded from applying. I do not think it is. I am open to contradiction if I am wrong, but I certainly did not understand that the proposal was that certain counties should be excluded. It was not. There was no such proposal, and, in any event, it makes very little difference. You would want to cut down the area to a very small area, or at least 15 per cent. of the farmers would apply.

Comment on this

Had you not already scheduled nine districts?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Yes, and I am saying that afterwards that condition was waived, and it was stated——

Comment on this

Waived! How?

Comment on this

Not to our knowledge.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The Dáil was not sitting.

Comment on this

And you lent £3,500?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

That is not the point. I hope Deputies do not object to the Minister waiving the condition. He waived it, and that was announced to every organiser.

Comment on this

I know that we agreed to this. It was an agreement that these credit societies should be established in nine counties. Until the Minister made his statement now we were unaware that any change was made.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

That may be, but when the Dáil was sitting this matter was discussed, and at that time the application of this scheme was confined to nine counties. Afterwards I approached the Ministry of Finance myself—I hope I was not wrong—and I said I would like them to consider applications from any other county in which losses occurred and the Minister agreed. Surely the Deputy does not quarrel with me for that, but in any event to go back to the point, our experience was that we had applications from practically every county. I do not say that losses occurred there, but you had these applications, and I say, that even if you do in fact confine the areas, limit them in any way you like, you will have to limit it to a very small area indeed or you will have applications from 15 per cent. of the farmers. Then I go and I ask you is it possible to discriminate? How is it possible for any State machinery to get down to the 2½ per cent. who really did lose and further to invesigate so as to discover how much money would be really useful to them and, finally, to superintend the spending of that money? And yet, so far as a very great percentage of these people are concerned, credits are no good to them except small credits and credits given for a specific purpose, and the spending of the money supervised afterwards. If that is the position, I suggest that it is wrong to say that we are making any pretence in this credit scheme. I say the other scheme is a pretence.

Comment on this

A pretence?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I do not say the Deputy means it, but I say it is a pretence in the sense that it is utterly inadequate to meet the problem. I say you would have nothing after it except a very limited number of small farmers more in debt than they were before.

Comment on this

What do you take the small farmers to be? Do you think that if they get money they will throw it into the river?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The Deputy had every opportunity to say what he wanted to say on this thing, and he said it. I am entitled to the same opportunity. I know the small farmers as well as the Deputy. I have pointed out that so far as 60 or 70 per cent. of the farmers are concerned credits would be useful to them, but so far as about 15 per cent. of the remainder are concerned they are people whose present position is this, that credits would not be useful to them except in small amounts for a specific purpose and accompanied by the closest superintendence. No State department can do that.

Comment on this

Except they live over the Border.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I will come to that. I have been told that these credits were made available by the Northern Government. The fact that the Northern Government made these credits available is really not evidence in itself that the considerations which I have put forward are unsound. I told Deputy Gorey that they had lent £37,000 and he said: "Look at that. Compare £37,000 with £5,000."

Comment on this

£3,500.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I would like to know how much of that £37,000 would have been lent if the Northern Government had never come into the scheme. The conditions are that two fully solvent sureties must go to the bank and must guarantee the loan.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

Must they not do the same in the case of the credit society?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Pardon.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

The point is relevant.

Comment on this

The Minister is the only person allowed to interrupt here.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I have had a fair number of interruptions. That is one of the conditions, and I wonder how much of this £37,500 would have been lent by the Northern banks, even if this preliminary form which is sent to the Department of Agriculture in Belfast, were not filled in at all. I have been endeavouring to get some real information on this Northern scheme, and I put it to Deputies that it may mean, as any business man examining the scheme for himself would see, very much less than it means on its face. The farmer does get his money at 2½ per cent., and £37,000, which would give loans of £50 to about 500 farmers, has been given out. But the farmer must go there absolutely solvent himself and with two absolutely solvent sureties. Is that the sort of farmer that the Deputy wants to deal with? It may very well be that this £37,000 would have been lent if the Northern Government had never intervened. No one knows the arrangement between the Northern Government and the banks.

Comment on this

At 2½ per cent.?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

There is the advantage of the 2½ per cent., but it is no advantage to give money at 2½ per cent. to a certain class of people if you are really aiming at giving money to another class. I do not know what the arrangement between the Northern Government and the banks was, and I have been unable to find it out, but I know that on the face of that scheme it is quite possible that most of that £37,000 would have been given out if the Northern Government had never intervened, and that the only thing that has been done is that certain people, who would get the money from the banks in any event as ordinary borowers, are now getting it for two years at 2 per cent. less. If that is so, and I make that suggestion, how does it touch our present position? Deputies do not want to reach people who can get money from the banks. Deputies are not concerned with the sort of farmers whose security is itself sufficient to enable him to get money from the bank and who is able to get two solvent sureties.

Comment on this

I do not want to get the money at 5 or 6 per cent.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Deputies, I pointed out, are not concerned to any great extent with the kind of farmer who is able to get money on his own security, and who is able to get what a bank manager would call two solvent sureties. I understood that Deputies were concerned rather with the other class, the class that could not get credit from the bank at the moment. So far as the Northern scheme is concerned, I do suggest it is possible that every penny of that £37,000 would have come out of the banks if the Government had never intervened. I stated that I did not consider at any time that this loan scheme would deal in toto with the fluke. I never had any such illusions. But I do state that it is the only way at present, the only temporary arrangement, under which you can effectively make credits available to the small farmer who belongs to the class that I have mentioned, not to the 60 or 70 per cent. of people who are sound, but who belongs to the other class, the class that are not security for large loans, the class to whom loans are no good unless they are small loans which they can economically handle, and the class that must be supervised in the spending of these loans. That is really the point of view that I had in the matter, and I see no way of doing that except by the credit societies, and for this reason: assume that a credit society is formed.

Comment on this

Assume it is!

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I will take it now step by step. A credit society is formed in a district. No one wants the big farmers —I want to remind Deputy Johnson of that—to come along and put their money in. The big farmers did not put in their money in Tralee, where there is four or five thousand pounds going out, and it is extending every day. Again, the big farmers did not put their money into the three societies that are formed in the poorest county in Ireland, Leitrim.

Comment on this

Three new societies.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Yes.

Comment on this

And working?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Yes.

Comment on this

Would the Minister name them?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I gave them to the Deputy on question and answer.

Comment on this

They are not new societies.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Certainly. It was not the big farmers who put their money into these new societies in Leitrim and Tralee; it was the small farmers. What happens in a case like that? The small farmer in such a case wants £22 or £23 to buy a cow, or to meet any emergency you like. Such a man is generally able to find £5 or £10. Anyone who knows the economy of the small farmer knows that when an emergency occurs it usually happens that a man is able to find £5, £6, or £10, but not the whole of what he requires. All these people met and pooled their resources, and for every £1 they put in the Government put in £2. That came to something like a couple of thousand pounds. I will give the Deputy the figures. Kiltogher and Eslin Bridge are the new societies in Leitrim. Carrigallen is an old one that is extended.

Comment on this

What amount was paid out to Kiltogher and Eslin Bridge?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Six hundred pounds is the total in Kiltogher. Eslin Bridge is £867; Tralee is £2,685. They have applied to-day for £300 odd and are getting it. There is not a single shopkeeper, I am informed, in the Tralee Society; they are all small farmers, none of them farmers like those you see in Tipperary, Waterford and Kildare, but small farmers, most of whom have to live on uneconomic and miserable holdings, in the case of Leitrim, of £10, £11 and £12 valuation. And they have met, in a county where there was very strong opposition to these credit societies. They started without delay and are going ahead, and we expect further demands immediately from these societies. While I do not anticipate any quick developments in these counties, or in any counties, I anticipate that the fact of these societies being successfully started in a county like Leitrim will bring about other societies also, as there is another society about to be registered in Kerry one of these days. These small farmers met and pooled their little resources. They made up their minds that this agitation for getting free gifts would not come to anything.

Comment on this

Who asked for free gifts?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

If the Deputy asks me the question I will answer him. But Deputy Baxter did not. But a great many branches of the Farmers' Union all over the country sent resolutions to me asking for grants.

Comment on this

We do not want grants, and no Deputy on these benches ever asked for grants.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I can do no more than say that no Deputy on the Farmers' benches asked for grants, but individual branches of the Farmers' Union throughout the country did ask for grants, and undoubtedly the persistent demand for grants and loans in the beginning did a good deal to stop the immediate formation of these societies. These societies were not popular, I agree. People would prefer to get the money directly. It is an unfortunate point of view at the moment, but people do prefer to get the money directly. They do not want to go to all the trouble and organisation that would be entailed in setting up these societies, and for a long time branches of the Farmers' Union, and I will go further and say, branches of the Cumann na nGaedheal—not so many, though—sent in resolution after resolution on this question.

Comment on this

Not so many.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I am perfectly satisfied from reports I have received that probably the principal causes for the delay in making a beginning with these societies was the belief, fostered by organisations, and mainly by branches of the Farmers' Union throughout the country, that they were going to get grants in some cases, and in other cases loans. The people in counties like Leitrim and Kerry made up their minds that they were not going to get them and they formed their societies. They pooled their savings and they are now in a position to make small loans. The societies are extending very slowly, but they are extending. If a man comes up and wants a loan of £18, £20, or £25 that would be useful to him he is known to his neighbours. He knows that he is spending his neighbour's money and that it is not the money of a far-away entity like the State. He knows that he will meet his neighbours going to Mass or at fair or market. Undoubtedly, he will be far more careful how he spends that money and more careful to repay it than if he was getting a grant of £50 which might probably swamp him.

Comment on this

A grant would never swamp anyone.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

A loan. That is the only effective way that I can see for dealing with the problem of the very small farmer in counties like Leitrim, Roscommon and so on, who want, not big loans that are no good to them, but small loans. They realise that they have to spend it carefully as they have to pay it back. That is my method of meeting the problem. I know that these societies will develop very slowly. In the past they developed slowly, mainly because the local authorities, the county councils, and branches of the Farmers' Unions did not give them the chance they were entitled to. I remember that in the first fortnight after the Government's decision five or six resolutions were received from branches of the Farmers' Union in Clare saying: "It is no good; this will not do; we want loans." We got them also from other councils. The people themselves were not anxious. Farmers are not particularly anxious to organise themselves for business purposes. They hoped to get the money by holding up the scheme. But we have got societies started in counties like Leitrim.

Comment on this

I will talk about Leitrim when the Minister is finished and I will ask Deputy Dolan to represent the views there.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I am speaking from information and I say that the people started these societies in Leitrim. These societies are functioning and I expect other societies will function. We have started a society in Tralee in which there is not a single shopkeeper and practically no big farmers. The money was deposited by small farmers in mountainy holdings in Kerry and at present they have practically £3,000. These are facts and in the light of these facts there is no use in saying, in counties like Kilkenny, Tipperary, Waterford and the midlands, that there is not enough money to start these societies. They can be started.

Comment on this

We have not asked for them there. There is no necessity for them.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I am glad to hear that. if they can be started in Leitrim they can be started anywhere in Ireland. I am giving figures and Deputies can challenge them. There is one parish— Kiltogher—where the State subscribed £200 and the people £400. In another parish £867 is subscribed.

Comment on this

How many members have they?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I have not the number. £867 is a small amount, but, spent on really deserving cases, it will do more good than eight thousand times £867 would do if spent without proper supervision and went to the wrong people. I am not making any promise about credit societies. I say that it would be mere pretence for me to ask the Minister for Finance to put up loans amounting to, say, £1,000,000 for farmers for this purpose. I have given my reasons for doing that. I have shown that it would be impossible to get down to the 2½ per cent. of farmers who really need the money. The results you would have would be that a certain number of farmers would be in a worse condition than they were at the beginning. I shall make no comments with regard to small societies. They will develop only very slowly in this country for reasons that everyone is aware of—the slowness of the average farmer to organise for business purposes. The feeling of the Government is that they will develop.

When fluke is forgotten, in two or three years, you will have something there that will meet the needs of the small farmers. They are the ones I am concerned with. I am not concerned with the big farmers, even where there are big losses, as they might be better off to set some of their land rather than restock it. If a big farmer has plenty of land he has fair security. I am not concerned with that problem, though there are hard cases. I am talking about Leitrim, Donegal and Kerry, where the small farmers are concerned, and I see no other effective way of dealing with the fluke problem as it should be dealt with.

The loan system would be a mere pretence, nothing else, and would be waste of money, in my opinion. On the other hand, in County Leitrim, or counties in a similar condition, if the people could be organised, they will be able to make small loans to small farmers. That will go somewhere to meet the losses, and meet them gradually and slowly. When fluke is forgotten you would have these societies functioning. They will be there for the provision of seeds, fertilisers, and for other purposes, and will be doing real education work for farmers, and amongst the farmers who want it badly.

Comment on this

The Minister has made a very interesting and a very clever speech, but he said little about the problem we are discussing for the last six months. He has talked about percentages and averages, but I say that that is misleading, perhaps not deliberately. What is the use of talking about 2½ per cent. of the farmers of the Saorstát? We are not dealing with the farmers of the Saorstát. We are dealing with the farmers in five or six counties who have been, badly hit, who have been thrown down and cannot get up. We are not dealing with the case of a man who wants £22 or £23 to replace one cow. We are dealing with the cases of men who had five or six cows and who have none now, or with men who had ten cows, nine of which died. We are asked to believe that credit societies are going to deal with this problem, that the Minister says will run pretty well into one million pounds if the figures were known. He is asking these societies to deal with this big problem. Nobody with any common sense will deny the usefulness of credit societies in normal times to meet normal losses but, when you are dealing with a plague of this description, it is obviously impossible for credit societies to do so before £1 is subscribed. I do not think any sane man would say that credit societies could deal with this problem at the moment. Even if those societies were societies of long standing they could not deal with it, but to expect you to deal with a problem of this description, without any organisation, without the question ever having been discussed or put to the test, is asking for the utterly impossible. It is not asking for the success of credit societies. It is asking for the death of credit societies at their birth.

Deputy Tierney has said that these societies would help to supply pigs to people. So they could. They could help to supply sows to breed pigs. The cost would be two or three pounds. It might be even £10 or £15, but when you come to deal with £200 to an applicant, what can you do then? Those losses have occurred in townlands. No one was immune. Everyone had a common loss. Where was the money supposed to come from, and where were your credit societies going to get a foundation? What I said yesterday was that the ordinary resident of the district who might not have had much loss and who happened to have a few pounds would be slow to put money into a society of that description, and Deputy Beamish told us that because an individual would not come to the help of his neighbour the State owed the individual nothing. That was the gospel of Deputy Beamish that I and a few others here may have suffered loss. Then if Deputy Beamish refused to go to our assistance the State would be absolved from coming to our assistance.

Comment on this

What I really said was that the farmers, or those who could come to the assistance of the poorer farmers, should do so. That is borne out when the farmers acknowledge that they will pay the £750,000 if they are taxed for it. They are only asked to produce £250,000 under this scheme. Let them produce it and the scheme is a success.

Comment on this

Why should the State come in if the farmers will not help themselves? If the Deputy is not responsible for what he said, then I will not raise the point.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

Deputy Gorey ought not to make a statement of that kind in relation to a Deputy.

Comment on this

The words are there. If he proposes to explain them they are all right.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

I ask Deputy Gorey to withdraw that remark.

Comment on this

I do not know what to withdraw, but I withdraw anything you ask me. Where great losses have occurred in Kerry, in Clare, in Galway, perhaps, and in some of the other counties, it is asking too much from the residents in those districts who have met those losses to put money into societies. If they had another year like last year the whole lot would be swamped. They would have no security. Anyone knowing the country will recognise the slowness of members of the societies to proceed against their neighbours in case they fail to pay. It needs somebody behind them besides local societies to go to the extreme limit in enforcing the law in this connection. People are anxious to avoid a position of this description.

Comment on this

Is not the Government behind those loans? The Government is contributing part of the funds.

Comment on this

The Government are giving £2 where there is £1 and they leave it to the credit societies to recover.

Comment on this

They ask a guarantee of the credit society for the money they give.

Comment on this

The credit society is security for the Government, and the individual is security for the credit society. From whatever cause this problem has occurred, whether it is fluke, starvation or anything else, the problem is there and that problem has to be dealt with or the nation has to pay the loss. There is no getting away from it. I made it my business to visit people in North Kerry and I found people who lost 10 or 11 cows. That occurred to one individual and he has not been able to replace them. He has got in two. There are seven still to be made good which he cannot make good. That is a loss to the individual and to the nation. He cannot pay his annuities or anything else and that is only an example of what is occurring in the counties. I say this scheme of credit societies cannot reasonably be expected to meet the situation. This is an urgent problem. There is only one way to meet it and that is by a generous loan.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE Cumann na nGaedheal

Will that meet it?

Comment on this

I say it will.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE Cumann na nGaedheal

How much?

Comment on this

There is no use in talking about 2½ per cent. of the farmers of the Sáorstát. Some machinery for finding out deserving cases in credit societies is available in the same way as that of finding out deserving cases in the way of a loan. There is nothing to prevent you. You may put credit societies aside as a means of meeting this proposition. You have to deal with the problem by some other means. What is the best means, then? I say this is the only thing that offers. The Minister has talked about undesirables. There is a percentage of undesirables in every community. They have been in this as they have been in any other country.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE Cumann na nGaedheal

I do not think I referred to them as undesirables.

Comment on this

You said they were people to whom it would be undesirable to give money.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan MINISTER for LANDS and AGRICULTURE Cumann na nGaedheal

Except under certain conditions.

Comment on this

Very well. I realise that if loans were available in the morning, and if credit societies were to be formed, the first people coming in would be those who would be considered as undesirable. Machinery must be set up to get rid of the undesirables. We do not want to give money to undesirables; we want to give money to people stricken down, and who cannot get up, and the credit societies will not do it.

There is no use in making the attempt unless it is a real, genuine attempt. I know, with the best wishes in the world, the Minister believes, and some of us were inclined to agree, that this was a genuine attempt, and that it would deal with the question. We now find, however, that it does not, and we have abandoned the idea, knowing its impossibility. If we are determined to deal with the question now, let us do so in the right way, and we maintain that the only way to do it is by loan. It is very easy to ascertain the position. Send round inspectors, if necessary, and let them find out the ordinary number of cows which a farmer had. Let them find out the usual carrying capacity of a farm, and what it is carrying at the moment. If the farmer has a good character in the district, and can get security, give him a loan.

Comment on this

I would be prepared to die at the stake, if Deputy Gorey insists on it, in the belief that the Minister for Agriculture has the rights of this matter as against the Farmers' Party. I never read a speech made by any of the half dozen ex-colonels who controlled the Farmers' Union in which the Government was not denounced for extravagant, wildcat schemes of one kind or another or ill-conceived legislation. Yet the Farmers' Party come forward to the Dáil with the suggestion that they should be enabled to go down the country and tell their friends that there is money in Merrion Street for any of them who lost stock last winter. Then the problem begins to commence, so to speak, and applications pour in. How are they to be dealt with? Deputy Gorey says, "Send round inspectors if necessary." Does he think it would be necessary? Does he think it is a matter that can be dealt with on paper by taking the word of a man who writes up and says: "I lost 9 heifers and 35 young sheep last winter"? How many inspectors would it be necessary to send round, and what would the ex-colonel say at the next meeting?

Comment on this

The ex-colonel is a fine red herring.

Comment on this

What would the ex-colonel say about bloated staffs, about highly-paid officials, about the people who are going round the country poking their noses into the farmer's business by wanting to know whether a man lost 9 cattle and 35 sheep? When proposals of that kind are made you must have some advertence to the overhead and administrative expenses which would be entailed. We are supposed to say: "There is money on tap in the Department of Agriculture, or in the Department of Finance, for people who lost cattle last December," and leave it at that. Then the applications come in. What kind of tribunal would be necessary to sift these applications? Inspectors without local knowledge are to go round.

Comment on this

Use your county instructors.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

How many of them?

Comment on this

The ones who gave you the information already.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

One or two?

Comment on this