AGRICULTURAL CREDIT SOCIETIES. - DEPUTY BAXTER'S MOTION (Resumed).
Contributions 128–251 of 251. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Deputy Gorey got an opportunity of speaking in the debate and if any Deputy has not already spoken he can speak later.
Comment on this
These officials are to be sent round the country to sift applications and make inquiries whether they are genuine or not, but what form are these inquiries to take? Are they to call on the man, have a talk with him, look at his farm, and call on his neighbour, who, perhaps, wants to do a bit of a turn, and who will not be a bad fellow by letting down poor Tom, and who may say, "If he did not lose the stock itself, God knows he could do with £50," I would like to be the ex-colonel at one or two meetings, and have the criticism of that particular scheme.
Comment on this
He has, and when it comes to paying it back no one would be so dolefully sympathetic as Deputy Baxter about the harsh measures the Government were using to recover this money, and nobody would talk so much about the inequity of sending out the under-sheriffs to collect the money from these poverty-stricken people.
Comment on this
Deputy Baxter can be very sympathetic about things like that. The position is that the Farmers' Party are to have it every way. They are to tell their friends that there is money above in Dublin for those who lost their stock last winter. They are to be at liberty to criticise the expense of the administration of that scheme. They are to be at liberty to talk about the horde of interfering officials who are poking their noses into the business of farmers; they are to be at liberty to talk about extravagance, and to criticise taxation, and to say, "Why on earth is not taxation reduced?" Finally, if there is an attempt to recover any loans, they are to be at liberty to criticise the hardhearted, inhuman Government who sent out the under-sheriffs to collect the money.
Comment on this
I, like my colleagues, thought that if we managed and tried our best to get one or two societies started, others would possibly follow. As Deputy Baxter said last night, I accompanied him to the first meeting of the new County Council in Cavan, expecting to get a fair welcome there, but after a considerable amount of criticism we were told that we might go back to the Government and say that their proposal was of no value. We thought that even if we failed with the county council the publication of the discussion in the local papers would create a certain amount of discussion throughout the country and that inquiries would be made as to the possibility of starting societies. I consequently attended other meetings with Deputy Dr. O'Reilly, but the result was the same. The county organiser attended, and we explained the proposal at length, but it was of no value. We could not get a man to put in a single pound. I am chairman of a creamery society and, knowing the distress that there is in our parish, I introduced the matter at a meeting of the society. Another man and I proposed to head the list in case we got support for the project. In the creamery we had a certain amount of money on hands, and we proposed to add this to the fund so as to raise £100. It was no use, and I was not surprised, for I have known cases where farmers who had lost cows had not a penny to replace them.
I think I may safely say I was the first member of the House to raise this question. I suggested to the Minister for Agriculture that he should make inquiries through the country with the aid of the Civic Guard. He did not do so, and if he had done so, he would give a more sympathetic hearing to the pleading we now put forward. I am aware he made certain inquiries through creamery managers, but men who are not paid for a job are careless about it in many ways, and consequently particulars that might be obtained would not be got. In addition, it must be considered that many of these small farmers would, perhaps, minimise their losses through pride, and there would be cases where dishonest men might try to exaggerate their losses if they thought there was anything to be gained by it. I do not think the inquiries were made in the proper way. I listened with great interest to Deputy Tierney's speech in the hope of hearing what he had done or proposed to do. I waited to hear if it was a fact that there was such a society started, or such a proposal considered by the committee of his County Council, and whether it was turned down as a complete failure. I would like an answer, yes or no, as to that. If he failed in his attempt, what is the use of trying to prolong the agony? Why not admit, as others of us have to admit, that the scheme is not a success, and is not likely to be so. I think the Deputy argued that the farmers must try and help themselves in the future. I agree it is time that the farmers should make a move to do that, but it must be remembered that we had not such a bad season as the last one within the memory of any member of the House, and I would say it is now the real pinch of that bad season. If the Minister will not agree the losses are as severe as have been stated, and as I hold they are, I ask him how does he account for the great number of decrees going out from the Land Commission? If these people had cattle, or even a cow, to sell, it is not likely they would be inviting the sheriffs to their doors. I think in that, even if there were no other evidence, we have sufficient proof in that that the people are in poverty. Deputy Beamish made the very strong point that, because the farmers do not help one another by the way of going security for one another, the Government had no right to do so either. I consider these are two different propositions altogether. The farmers, looking at it from a selfish point of view, have nothing to gain by helping their neighbours, while the Government have everything to gain, because, if the Government assist the farmers in the way the farmers assist them by paying rents, they will get the money back again in a short time. I would suggest that the Government, through the Land Commission, should allow the farmers to raise a small loan in the bank. The Land Commission are in the position of knowing the character of the men who apply for the loan. They will know whether in bygone years they have kept their engagements by the payment of their annuities, and in that way they would have a good idea as to the character of the applicants. It would be a very easy matter for the Government to advance to a small holder a few pounds on his land security. The Land Commission could earmark that land in such a way that it could not be sold or in any way disposed of, and if the loan afterwards was not paid it would be impossible for the farmer to sell the land until the loan had been paid. If the arrears of payment had accrued for a certain number of years, the Land Commission would have the same means of recovering the loan as they would have of recovering the annuity.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy mean that no loan is to be made to any man who is in arrears with his annuities or other charges?
Comment on this
If the arrears are only for a year or two I would not take that into account, but if the arrears are for a number of years past that should be considered. Another matter is that, if the farmers advance this money to a credit society, they would want collateral security, or mortgage on the farm, and that would increase the cost of the loan very considerably. I happen to know a good deal about that. The Minister does not seem to realise that a small loan to farmers would be of great assistance. If the Minister went down the country he would find farmers frequently hanging about around the banks.
Comment on this
I stated expressly that a small loan would be of assistance under certain conditions.
Comment on this
At the same time the Minister does not think that it is of great advantage to farmers to get loans. I wonder does he know that farmers have to struggle at present to pay, as I know, in many cases the exorbitant interest of 20 per cent. It is cases like this the Government should assist. When a man has to pay exorbitant interest on a loan it is difficult for him to repay the loan. If the Government would lend money at 2½ per cent. interest it should be of advantage to the farmers. The Minister has laid great stress on the £750,000—I think this is the figure he calculates will be necessary. Supposing the farmers did borrow £750,000 through the banks, and that the farmer paid 2½ per cent. and the Government paid the balance, it would amount to something less than £200,000, which would be a mere bagatelle in comparison with the value of the land that would be given as security to the Government. In the meantime the Government would have the rents coming in, so that a good deal of the money would be coming back in a short time. I would like to compare the figures of the present loan society with what they would be supposing the Government authorised the bank to advance money at 2½ per cent. on the security of the land. The Government propose to give £200 for every £100 raised, and on the £100 they are willing to pay 4 per cent.—I presume they will be paying 5 per cent. on the other £200 which they would advance. That would be £300, and the cost would be £14. If they would advance the £300 through the banks at 2½ per cent. it would only cost £7 10s.
Comment on this
And the earnings go to the credit society for any purposes they wish to devote them to.
Comment on this
The borrowers, to a great extent, are the members of the society.
Comment on this
Although the Government are giving the £200 free of interest, it must cost them something. I presume they have not got the £200 without first having to apply to the bank. In any case, it is worth 5 per cent.
Comment on this
I will take it in round numbers at 5 per cent. I would measure the £300 given to the society at £14, and in the other case it would be £7 10s. That is the rate at which the Northern Government lent it, and at that rate I think it would be of considerable advantage to the farmers and to the country in general. The Northern Government has lent £37,000, according to the figures of the Minister. That amount does not go over the whole Six Counties; the greater part of it, some £30,000, went to County Fermanagh.
Comment on this
I often heard the Minister for Lands and Agriculture defend a bad case, and I often heard him indulge in special pleadings in defence of a poor case; but I cannot say that I ever heard him make such a forcible attempt at special pleading in defence of an indefensible case as he did this evening. What are the facts in connection with these credit societies and the fluke disease? The scheme of relief put forward by the Government has, to all intents and purposes, completely failed to meet the emergency. What is the use of the Minister telling us a society has been established in Tralee and two societies have been established in Leitrim? How does that deal with the whole problem? Things must be looked at in their proper perspective, and, surely, to say there are established three or four little societies to meet a problem that amounts practically to a national catastrophe is no answer to the case we have made.
Comment on this
We know that some of the societies were concentrated upon, and every effort was made by the Government to render them successful. When the Minister introduced his scheme for dealing with this problem I told him I had no faith in the prospects of its success. I am now sorry to realise that my prophecy was correct. I would have been glad to see the scheme successful, in spite of the fact that even from the outset I had little hopes that it would be. It has completely failed to meet the emergency. There was something wrong about the attitude taken up by the Government to meet this catastrophe, of the fluke disease. It cannot be called anything short of a catastrophe, because it is a thing that did not occur in the country within living memory. We hope it will not occur again for a very long time. It was met by an expedient which should have been reserved for normal times.
I believe that the credit society system is required by the farming community of this country. It is a thing which the farmers and their representatives have been seeking for a long time. The very fact of attempting to foster the further establishment of those credit societies in connection with this emergency has done irretrievable harm to the credit society idea. It will be associated in the minds of the farmers in future with the failure which has occurred in connection with the attempt to establish them. In my opinion that is almost the worst feature of this attempt by the Government to meet this emergency. It has given a black mark, so to speak, to the system of credit societies, and will make it extremely difficult to have them established in the future. It would have been much better if the Government met this emergency by a system of loans, and waited until times were normal and people were in a receptive mood, and farmers were prepared to take up the scheme seriously. That would be the time for the Minister to come forward with his scheme for the fostering of those societies.
The Minister gave us a lot of figures that were not very relevant to the matter under consideration. The question of what percentage of the farmers was composed of good or bad farmers, and what class of farmers would or would not come forward for the loan, was touched upon. We are aware there are bad and middling farmers, but it would not at all follow that those who would look for the loans would be bad farmers, the hopeless ones of the farming community. It has happened that a great many of the people who lost cattle through this disease included some of our best small farmers. Those men are now in the practically hopeless position of not being able to obtain any money to restock their land.
Comment on this
The scheme has failed to work. The position is aggravated by the fact that the banks, as is well known, are slow now to advance money to farmers. I agree with the Minister that this question of advances in this country has been overdone in some cases; but there are other cases in which it has been underdone. Money has been advanced for bad purposes and wrong purposes; but now when money is required for good purposes, it is almost impossible to obtain it. Take the case of a farmer, who has lost practically all or a very large percentage of his cattle, going into a bank. I believe the bank manager would be reluctant, even on good security, to advance money for that man. The bank manager would require that the man himself would be in a sound financial position before he would advance money. The banks are slow to advance money to a poor man, even though there is good security. The banks do not care to have to go back on securities in order to get the money if the principal fails. It is an unpopular thing; it gets them into bad favour with people, perhaps good customers, who may be the securities. In most cases the banks require that the man obtaining the loan is in a fairly sound position. A statement was made by the Minister to the effect that 50 per cent. of the cattle that died, died of starvation. I am sorry that statement was made. It is a reflection on the farmers, and it is not a correct statement of facts.
Comment on this
No figures produced as the result of a door-to-door visit by the Gárda Síochána.
Comment on this
The Gárda Síochána would be the people to ascertain the number of cattle that actually died from fluke. I have it on the authority of no less a person than the chief veterinary officer in the Birkenhead Lairages that 90 per cent. of the Irish cattle in Birkenhead this year have diseased livers, and the veterinary inspector in Aberdeen confirmed this.
Comment on this
The percentage he gave me was much lower. He stated—and so did the Aberdeen man—that the livers of a high percentage of the Irish cattle have been affected for years. I think that is what the Deputy himself stated the other evening.
Comment on this
I stated nothing of the kind. I stated that 90 per cent. of the cattle slaughtered in Birkenhead have diseased livers.
Comment on this
Yes, 90 per cent. of their livers are not hopelessly discased, but they have indications of fluke disease in the livers. Probably as regards a small percentage the livers are completely destroyed by fluke and these have to be cast aside as altogether unfit for human food. That, in my opinion, proves that the greater portion of the cattle in the country did actually contract the fluke disease.
Comment on this
I did not use the word infectious. I know how the disease is contracted as well as the Deputy.
Comment on this
Evidently the line of argument used by the Minister leads up to the fact that farmers starve their cattle and that a great number of the cattle died, not because of this disease, but because of bad treatment.
Comment on this
I said nothing of the kind. We are taking it that 5 per cent. have died and I said that only half of these died through under-feeding.
Comment on this
I never said 50 per cent. of the cattle of the country died. I said 50 per cent., half of the 5 per cent., died through under-feeding.
Comment on this
I understood the Minister to say that 50 per cent. of the cattle of Ireland which died, died of starvation.
Comment on this
I stated that of the 5 per cent. that died, 50 per cent. died of bad treatment.
Comment on this
There is one thing I was glad to hear the Minister acknowledge. That is that if these loans are made the money would have to be put up by the farmers. It simply means taxing one class of farmer to aid the other class. I was glad to hear the Minister acknowledge that.
Comment on this
I do not usually read my own speeches in the Report, but I will read them to-morrow.
Comment on this
There is a rule that Deputies must address the Chair. There is a rule that Deputies must be standing in their places when addressing the Chair. If the Minister for Lands and Agriculture took a note of these statements we would give him an opportunity, at the end of Deputy Heffernan's speech, of correcting all the mistakes made on the other side. That would, perhaps, simplify the procedure. I understand that the Minister himself was very much interrupted when he was speaking.
Comment on this
I was glad to hear that statement made by the Minister. In future we can accept it as a Government pronouncement that, in the final issue, the farmers are responsible for practically all taxation in this country. Anything in the way of bounties or subsidies or grants will eventually fall back upon the farmer taxpayer. Now, the Minister made very light of the attempts of the Northern Government to deal with this matter. The fact remains that the Northern Government has made this attempt and that the attempt has succeeded to the extent of advancing £37,000 over a very small portion of the area. Compare that with the Minister's credit societies, where, so far, only £3,500 has been advanced. It is all very fine to cavil and sneer at the work of the Northern Government, but the simple facts proclaim that they have attempted to deal with the question and that they have found a method for dealing with the question, and that they have not found it impossible, as the Minister in his speech stated.
The Minister stated it would take another Department as big as the Department of Agriculture to administer the scheme successfully. I wonder has the Northern Government instituted a second Department of Agriculture to administer their scheme? I do not think they have. Furthermore, I do not agree with the Minister for Justice, that it would be impossible to get officials to secure this information. I believe it would be easy to get the officials to get that information. I believe that any of the competent instructors could supply the information required. It is all very well to heap objection upon objection, but difficulties are always in the way of every scheme that has to be carried out. The difficulties are not insuperable; they are surmountable. I maintain that there is no difficulty in advancing money to the farmers that could not be surmounted by a proper system of administration. Now, the Minister for Justice took part in this debate.
Comment on this
I certainly think that he did not improve the case of the Minister for Lands and Agriculture by his more or less venomous attack upon the Farmers' Union.
Comment on this
Probably the idea of the Minister for Justice is that the Farmers' Party are not supposed to criticise and that the moment they begin to criticise and say unpleasant things that press hard, whether they are true or otherwise, then they are to be sneered at, and the ex-colonels are to be gibed at. We hear a lot in this House and outside it as to the necessity for an adequate Opposition and for adequate criticism, but the moment the criticism touches a weak spot and becomes a bit unpleasant, then we are not to be tolerated for a moment, but are to be gibed and sneered at by the Minister.
Comment on this
On a point of explanation, I was only pointing out to Farmer Deputies that we ought not to go out of our way to provide further material for the ex-colonels.
Comment on this
It would be as well, I think, to acknowledge at once that the scheme failed and that there is no prospect of it meeting the emergency. Meantime, we have throughout the country numerous farmers who are in a very bad way because of the losses they have sustained from disease in their cattle. Their present condition is very serious indeed. If something is not done to improve their condition they will not be able to pay their Land Commission annuities, their local taxation, or their shop debts. These men are anxious to get a start in life again. If they did get a chance of making a real start they would, in the majority of cases I believe, make a success of it. They have been prevented from making a restart in life because the Government is not meeting the situation as it ought to have met it. I would say to the Minister that it would be better and perhaps more honest for him to acknowledge that the attempt made to meet the present emergency, as it exists in the country, has failed. I cannot see how anyone can say anything else.
I would appeal to the Minister to start anew, and offer a loan that would enable these men to restart in life. Doubtless, the Minister would have the worthless ones coming along if he were to offer loans. That always happens in such cases. We all know that when a new bank manager goes to a district all the worthless ones in that locality are in to him for a loan. But surely in a case like this the Government must have at its disposal adequate machinery to weed out these worthless ones, to see that only worthy persons are selected for the loans given, and that they will get a chance of making good. As one who took a certain amount of interest in the establishment of credit societies, I regret that the attempt to start them was made under such unfavourable auspices as those that obtained in connection with the present emergency. I believe it would be in the interests of the country and the farmers that the present scheme put forward by the Minister should be withdrawn, and that he should come forward with a generous offer of loans to farmers who can prove that they have met with losses.
I deny that it is outside the power of the administration to find out the men who really suffered losses. I would like to point out, too, that we are not asking for a grant. We are asking for a loan, and these men, when they apply for it, will know that they will be bound to pay back the loan, and that all the legal forces at the disposal of the Government can be used for the purpose of forcing them to pay back the money loaned to them. We do not hear of men clamouring for Board of Works loans in the hope that, by some extraordinary happening, they will never be asked to pay them back. The fact is that men only apply for these loans when they require them. Similarly, I believe that only a certain number of people would apply for the loans that we suggest should be given to meet this emergency. People would only apply for them who really require them because of the emergency which has arisen. It is up to the Government to take a risk which banks, for instance, or other people could be expected to take. The emergency is such that the Government ought to be prepared to face a certain small percentage of loss; but my opinion is that, if the Government come forward with loans, the losses they would sustain would be comparatively small.
Comment on this
In order not to expose myself to the rejoinder levelled from the Farmers' benches at Deputy Professor Tierney and Deputy Beamish I might start off by saying that I am a bit of a farmer myself, and therefore might be allowed to express an opinion if only on that account. The Minister for Agriculture seems to be puzzled as to what percentage he will attribute to mortality amongst cattle from fluke and what percentage to starvation. I think that is really immaterial, because the deaths from fluke and the deaths from starvation are primarily due to our wet climate. The wet climate is undoubtedly the cause of fluke—excessive and persistent wet, and another contributory cause was rotten hay. The rotten hay killed the cattle by starving them. That is the position we have to face and it does not matter whether they died from fluke or starvation— they are dead at any rate. The result is that farmers who were unfortunate enough to suffer from mortality amongst their cattle are now in a very precarious position. For that reason I would suggest to the Minister that he should reconsider the whole question. I fear that this motion of Deputy Baxter's has possibly been treated from the Government benches as a political stunt. I do not think it is a political stunt, and if it is a political stunt I would not let the farmers walk away with a clean victory.
Comment on this
The Irish farmers have suffered at all times from want of capital. The English farmer is a capitalist, with the result that he gets the best out of his farm. The Irish farmer is always dragging the devil by the tail. He has to sell his cattle when they are unfit for sale. He has to sell them simply to stop a gap. That is a very common expression in the South of Ireland. It is very expressive and conveys the meaning. Agriculture is our main industry. It is a national asset, and I think it would be well to have the present crisis tided over by following the example given by the Government of Northern Ireland—that is to say, by lending money on somewhat similar terms.
We recognise the administrative difficulty of the Minister. But I say when making a loan it does not matter whether the loss was due to fluke or rotten hay. Look for character in the borrower. If he is an honest man he will give sureties, and he will retrieve himself. I appeal to the Minister to do justice to himself. He has done a lot for Irish farmers and I believe he has the capacity to put this country on a level with Denmark. Possibly the farmers are trying to queer his pitch.
Comment on this
There is really no doubt that the condition of several of these farmers, through no fault of their own, is very bad. Of course, there are farmers in Ireland who are hopeless. Nothing that could be done will get them out of the rut they have got into, and they give a bad reputation to the general body of farmers in the country, and although I have said things very disagreeably of farmers, I know that 30 or 40 per cent. of the Irish farmers are as good farmers as can be found in any country. It is well, in my opinion, to reconsider this question, and I would ask the Minister in his final reply not to shut the door. These credit societies are dead and gone, and that may be due to want of organisation. You can organise nothing in Ireland except you organise it behind the revolver. (Deputies: "Oh!") It is a very powerful weapon, and it does influence organisation. With these remarks I leave things to the Minister.
Comment on this
I am very reluctant to break my long silence in the Dáil, but I feel bound to do so, as my name has been mentioned in connection with some matters raised by Deputy Baxter and Deputy Cole. They stated that I helped in some cases to try and form credit societies. Deputy Cole and I went to one particular place, and during the discussion that took place there the principal thing I heard from people present was this: that if by putting down £5 they could get the Ministry to put down an extra £10 so as to make £15, they would do so. If that was the case credit societies could be formed at once, because they could get any amount of borrowers, while there were very few of their more fortunate neighbours who were ready to come to their assistance. They could get any number of men to come into the credit societies as long as the Government would be prepared to put up the extra £10. The person who was there to explain the workings of the credit societies told them that it would be possible to form credit societies if that could be done, but that that was not the ideal aimed at by the Department. Now, I think when the Government were prepared to put up the £10 extra, even although it was not the ideal they aimed at, they showed a little better spirit than the farmers in the neighbourhood showed who were not prepared to put up anything at all.
It has been said by many Deputies that the credit societies have failed because of this lack of support from the better-off farmers, and from a lack of co-operation with their more unfortunate neighbours. Certainly I believe that lack of financial support is one of the causes that contributed to the failure, but there were possibly other reasons for the failure and one of these would be political reasons. I found at that meeting to which I have alluded, that when it came to the formation of the organisation in various parts of the district in which the credit society was to be formed, the party who named the organisers named them all from one political party. I did not know that because I was not well acquainted with the neighbourhood until I came outside when my attention was called to it by members of the party to which I belong. The members of our party would not be very keen in getting into that society considering that the members of the other party were aiming at making political capital out of any benefit that might accrue from the formation of that society. My reason for thus putting forward this—and it is rather unfortunate that my first entry into the debates in this House should take this form—is, that it shows a great lack of the co-operative spirit on the part of the farmers of the country. I believe that co-operation is going to save the farmers if anything at all is going to save them. I believe that the credit societies were to a great extent damned by this entering of politics into the question, and I believe also that co-operation will be similarly damned. The Farmers' Union Party have always said that they are very desirous of helping the farming community. To my mind, the best way they could attain that end would be by dropping out of politics, or else joining some of the other political associations or organisations in this House. That does not mean that they should join the Cumann na nGaedheal Party.
Comment on this
I agree. There seems to be a great deal of affinity lately between these two parties. At any rate, I believe if politics could be kept out of the question of forming these credit societies and that the matter could be considered on purely non-political lines, credit societies could yet be formed.
Comment on this
May I ask the Deputy is it not a fact and laid down in the constitution of these societies, that no such thing as politics should enter?
Comment on this
But I have shown that they do enter. Deputy Cole and I attended these meetings, and in selecting men who were to organise certain parts of the parish a gentleman got up and named men from one political organisation alone, to the exclusion of men belonging to the organisations that Deputy Cole and I represent. However, I do not think it can be said yet that the credit societies have failed completely. They would not be a failure, I do believe, if politics could be completely dissociated from their formation.
Comment on this
I rise to support the motion moved by Deputy Baxter. Whatever may be said for credit societies in normal times and circumstances, they have proved insufficient, if not altogether useless, in the emergeney with which we are dealing and which, I regret to say, requires immediate serious attention. I am not aware that there are any of these societies in Galway, which I have the honour to represent, but even if they were established and operating there they could not be availed of by the people who require financial assistance because they have lost their live stock through disease. I know personally people who have lost ten, twenty and thirty sheep and who could not comply with the credit society terms in trying to replace them. Take, for instance, a man who lost twenty-five sheep. The credit society may offer him a loan of £2 at 5 per cent. for every pound he himself has on hands, but in most cases it would be all in vain, as the pound per £2 would not be available in present circumstances. The man who requires £100 to replace twenty-five sheep cannot, in most cases, produce a third of that sum, and so qualify him for a loan of two-thirds from the credit societies.
It would be simply cruel to make him such an offer, while if the Government, as has been done elsewhere, provided a loan of the whole £100 at 2½ per cent. all would go well and there need be little doubt as to the repayment of the amount to the Government. I, like Deputy Cole, was quite surprised to hear Deputy Tierney's amendment and his speech in favour of it, and I have no hesitation in saying that he has not expressed the view of the small farmer community. It was only a short time ago since I read a report of a meeting held in the Deputy's native parish—Ballymacward, Co. Galway— calling attention to the fact that the people of the district had lost five per cent. of their sheep and calling upon the Government to assist them in the manner now proposed in the motion before the House. At that meeting, strange to say, it was a respected brother of Deputy Tierney who presided. He had a close personal knowledge of the situation and knew what he was talking about. If the credit societies were the all-powerful benefactors which Deputy Tierney represents, that meeting presided over by his brother need not and would not have been held. I know poor people who, if they were offered loans, of £10 to every £1 they could scrape together themselves, would not be able to comply with the conditions of the credit societies. I should like to hear the views of the other Galway Deputies.
Comment on this
Undoubtedly in many districts very serious losses have been sustained through fluke, but even the farmers themselves who have supported Deputy Baxter's motion must admit that there are considerable administrative difficulties in the way. I know of very poor districts, in the West of Ireland, where serious losses have been sustained. I think there might be a third way of coming to the assistance of these people who have sustained those losses and I wish to make a suggestion to the Minister to consider this third way. Where there are small farmers who could not possibly raise any money, I would suggest that, as was done last year, in certain limited areas, relief works on productive schemes ought to be carried out. These would not be done by loans; they would be done by grants. Farmers' sons would be employed on them. They would do work that would be reproductive to the county in opening bogs, widening roads and work of that kind. The Government has already spent a considerable sum in that way. This Dáil voted £100,000 and most of that was spent on relief works and brought great comfort to the districts where the works were carried out. I would suggest that the Minister should entertain the idea of a scheme in some of these poorer districts that have been hard hit—and there are not so many of them—which would go to the relief of all affected. Once the money was earned they would not have to pay it back, and it would be better than a loan. I would suggest that for the consideration of the Minister and of the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
I might say that Deputy Sears said nothing at all to the amendment. The Government amendment reads:—
To delete all words after the words "Credit Societies" and substitute the words "affords a reasonable method of relieving farmers who have lost stock through fluke, and also considers that the development of these societies will provide a credit system particularly suitable to the permanent needs of small farmers."
May I draw the attention of the House to the fact that although this amendment is moved, I presume, in the name of the Government, the Minister, and the Cumann na nGaedheal Party, the Minister himself stated that he did not intend the credit societies to meet, and they had not met the fluke problem.
Comment on this
Might I be allowed to explain myself? I protest against misquoting me in that fashion. I was careful to say on each occasion on which I repeated that sentence, "to meet it in toto,” and the Deputy knows there is all the difference in the world.
Comment on this
I did not hear one word from the Minister; I did not hear any word from any Farmer Deputy on the Government benches yet; I did not hear any statement at all from the Government Party, and I heard no evidence that would lead this Dáil to believe or to conclude that this amendment should be accepted or could be accepted, or that credit societies would solve the problem. The Minister himself gave us no evidence. Why? Because no evidence was forthcoming; because the facts are all to the contrary. Up to the present, and for the past five months, eight credit societies have been established and £3,500 given out. At the end of the financial year the balance, I presume, will be surrendered to the Exchequer. The Minister tried to prove that in Kerry and Leitrim societies were started. I want the Deputy from Leitrim to say what is the opinion of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party in Leitrim? Not more than six weeks ago, at a meeting in Leitrim, over which Canon Masterson presided, a gentleman who was the Cumann na nGaedheal candidate at the last election, declared that if the Government were not prepared to come forward to assist the farmers in some way other than they were proposing to do by the credit societies, he would never raise his hand for them again. That is the opinion of Leitrim—at least, of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party assembled in Leitrim.
Comment on this
I said the meeting was presided over by Canon Masterson. That is the opinion of Mr. Mooney, the Government candidate at the last election, and it was reported in the "Independent."
Comment on this
I want to draw the Minister's attention to the fact that the figures he has given show that there was £1,457 available there. The figures given by Deputy Dolan, when this matter was discussed here previously, showed us that 4,000 head of cattle were lost in South Leitrim. These were the statistics collected by the Cumann na nGaedheal Party. How far is £1,400 going to replace 4,000 cattle? Deputy O'Reilly, I notice, has left.
There were three Deputies in Cavan, all doing what they could to try to put into operation the credit system advocated by the Minister and accepted by the Dáil. I say we have failed, and I believe we have worked as hard and as honestly in Cavan to bring these societies into existence as any other Deputies elsewhere. I have probably gone to more meetings for this purpose than any other Deputy here, or any Deputy who is not here, and by every means we did what we could in Cavan. I would have liked Deputy O'Reilly to declare what his opinion was about the possibilities of the success of his efforts, of Deputy Cole's, and of mine combined in trying to have these societies established to see whether it was possible, in the conditions that prevailed there, that we could get enough of them established to get sufficient money to enable the farmers to replace their stock. I give it as my opinion that it has not been possible. We tried honestly, and we failed, and we have come to the Dáil to tell it so. I say that Deputy Tierney did not tell us what he had done. I think not one society has been established in Mayo, and I say that not one will be established. If we had evidence that there was a possibility of success we would wait, and I want to say, no matter what the Minister and some others may suggest, that it is not to make political capital out of this that we have moved.
Comment on this
We do not want anyone to suggest it. It has been suggested. We are quite prepared to give all the kudos to the Government. They will take it anyhow, and we may as well give it to them. But let the Minister think of the situation in Cavan, along the Border, the district that I mentioned last night, where in a small parish 400 cattle have died. Across the Border neighbours of the owners of these cattle have been able to get loans from the Northern Government, and the Government of the Saorstát, that makes so much hay about what it will do and has done for the farmers, leaves these men to try to struggle along on unstocked farms, without any possibility of having them stocked, while they demand the payment of rents and taxes.
Comment on this
In parts of a small parish in Cavan 400 head of stock died. The total loans made by the Northern Government are a little over 500 for the whole six counties.
Comment on this
Loans. In part of a small parish in Cavan 400 head have died.
Comment on this
The Minister is misrepresenting the position. Thirty-seven thousand divided by six is 6,000, not 500 —6,000 in one county. The Minister says 500.
Comment on this
Thirty-seven thousand pounds is an approximate figure. The figure I have given for the number of loans made is 500; it is between 500 and 600.
Comment on this
Deputy Cole pointed out that all the loans were in a small portion of the County Fermanagh.
Comment on this
That is not my information. This is in a part of one parish where 400 head of stock have died.
Comment on this
Well, does not that make it all the more serious, and he has done and will do nothing. If these farmers lived across the Border——
Comment on this
When the Deputy asks me do I say that he is not stating the truth, of course, I take it for granted that he believes implicitly in what he says and that his belief is based on a statement made to him, and I doubt its accuracy.
Comment on this
Is the Minister trying to convey to us the fact that part of Cavan is in Northern Ireland?
Comment on this
The Minister comes here without doing anything except talking about certain individual farmers that he met who gave him information. He wants us to accept it that he is the only reliable man, that his statement is the only statement that can be accepted, and when I go to the trouble of going to a district and having figures compiled that I am prepared to swear to, the Minister suggests that the House is to accept it that I am not telling the truth.
Comment on this
All right; once and for all I withdraw any such statement, if I ever made it.
Comment on this
The Minister's attitude is to do nothing, to leave things as they are, that if these farmers cannot find any help he cannot and will not do anything for them. That is exactly what the policy of the Minister and of the Cumann na nGaedheal Party means, and that is what the policy of every farmer Deputy who supports them amounts to. We should be clear on this matter. When it was raised first the Minister accepted the view that this problem existed and that it is not now solved. He further recognised the fact that credit societies would not solve the problem, and yet he has no alternative to offer; he will not do anything; things are to be left as they are. I say that if that is all the encouragement that honest farmers are to get from the Government when they find themselves in difficulties, the Government cannot expect that the farmers will give them allegiance and support. Many Deputies come from constituencies which have not had losses, and these Deputies will have to be asking farmers in such cases, if these loans are made available, to bear their share of them when they are going to poorer counties, and they are prepared to do that. What is done on the Government side? What are their responsibilities or their obligations, and what is the difference between the Minister's position in that matter and Deputy Gorey's? Deputy Gorey's constituents, who have not had losses, will not benefit by these loans, and the same thing applies to Deputies from other constituencies. But take the eight or nine parts of counties where the farmers have suffered so severely that they are practically down and out, so much so that their farms are to-day without stock, that many of them are in the hands of auctioneers and cannot be sold. If you are trying to carry on with men like that as the basis of your State, I ask, is the basis sound, and if it is not sound, what kind of State will you build, how do you expect to carry on, how do you expect to get taxation from men who are not able to carry taxes? You have to give these men a chance. If you do not put them into a position to live and carry on it is not they alone who will suffer, but the State. The State eventually will be the greatest loser. The State has its obligations towards people like these.
I say that from the beginning the Minister did not go about this problem in such a way as would lead one to feel that he meant to solve it. If he was really serious about it he should have tried to collect authentic and definite information as to the magnitude of the problem, the number of cattle lost, and their value. He would then know what the State was really faced with. I say that the machinery for doing this was at his command. What is the use of the Minister telling us that the information that the Gárda would supply would not be authentic and reliable? How will you collect your tillage or your Census returns if these men are not capable of doing it, and how can you expect, if the Gárda, on visiting a farmstead are not able to get correct information from the owner as to what his position is, that they are capable of doing such work at all? I say that the information could very easily have been obtained through the Gárda when they were collecting tillage returns, without in any way creating the impression that loans were to be made available.
I say further that I have the feeling that a good deal of the returns given to the Gárda are not correct. I have been given to understand that very many farmers in some districts disguised their losses when the Gárda went to their farms.
Now nothing is to be done. The farmer can go and help himself, and, if he does not, the State is not going to give him any help. Very good, if that is the policy of the Government in this matter we want to be clear about it and to know that that policy is being backed by Deputies on the Government benches who are farmers. The Minister for Justice had something to say. I suppose he must have been nearly a colonel himself. He might have been an ex-lieutenant. It comes very badly from the Minister for Justice to make any remarks about any organisation. He is one of those who is prepared at all times to stand up and defend the right of every citizen in the State, so long as he is law abiding. I suppose he agrees that that citizen has a right to express his opinion. Sometimes he would like to deny it. The Minister for Justice gave us about five minutes abuse. That is typical of him. In that five minutes the Minister was able to make the objection that if what the farmers wanted were done the farmers would be able to go down the country and tell what they had done. We did not introduce this motion in that spirit, and it is unfair of the Minister for Justice to meet it in that spirit. We know that a problem like this is not going to be solved by any party or in that spirit. We can show some of that spirit if the necessity arises.
The Minister for Lands and Agriculture wants us to accept it, that because eight credit societies have been established in five months, and that £3,500 has been distributed out of £100,000 that was voted, these credit societies are going to replace, by their operations, the thousands and thousands of cattle that have been lost throughout the country. The Minister for Lands and Agriculture is responsible to the Dáil and is outside the Executive Council. I would ask the Minister to leave this question to an open vote of the Dáil to decide. Let the Dáil decide it. After all, it should not be a party question, and, so far, it has not been made a party question. Men from the different parties have done all they could to try and make these credit societies a success. They failed. I say the decision should be left to the Dáil as to whether Deputy Tierney's amendment meets the situation or not. Leave it to the Dáil, and there is no question what the result will be. The Minister will not do that. He will not take that chance.
Comment on this
The Deputy has made a proposal, and I have only to remark that I always find in open voting that every party votes on party lines except the Cumann na nGaedheal Party.
Comment on this
When this proposal was first introduced I said that credit societies would not meet the situation, and that it would confront him again. It will confront him again, and, though the Minister may carry this amendment, I say he is not finished with the problem. Let there be no mistake about it. To the men we have to meet down the country, and who hold us responsible for trying to represent their point of view, we will have to say: "The Government failed to give any help when we put the position before them." The Minister knows the position that many farmers are in—at least, he ought to know it. Their plight is bad enough. How much worse does this make it? What chance is there for thousands of men to carry on if nothing is done for them? If the State does not do something, no one else can. I think it is the duty of Ministers to use the resources of the State in order to assist farmers in their plight. If Ministers do not do that, I say that they are not doing their duty.
Comment on this
At the outset I am glad there is such an unanimity of opinion on this question. Listening to Deputy Tierney I gathered that he seemed to think the credit societies have failed. I have listened to the Minister for Lands and Agriculture very carefully, and, as far as I could gather, credit societies have failed. I listened to Deputies on the Farmers' benches, and I gathered that credit societies have failed. I thought that the Minister for Lands and Agriculture would have told us, if he accepted the view that credit societies have failed to meet the situation, what he proposes to put in their place. He has practically acknowledged a bankruptcy of policy in this matter. I may say that I am unprejudiced. I come from a county that is very severely affected, and I have some reason to say that I understand the position fairly well. I listened to the arguments with an unprejudiced mind, being neither a farmer nor a professor.
Comment on this
I am not, thank God. I approached the matter impartially. Deputy Tierney told us that we were likely to prejudice credit societies if we sided with this motion of Deputy Baxter. Deputy Baxter has stated that credit societies have failed to meet the emergency, which is a very serious one. There is an urgent need to do something to relieve the distress that prevails in some districts.
You cannot get people who have perhaps some money to put it into these credit societies. What about districts where there is no money, where the ravages of fluke were so great that a good many people have no stock and where there are no people to help them to replace stock? The Minister for Lands and Agriculture is a sufficient agriculturist to know the old saying that "You cannot knock blood out of a turnip." There are some districts in West Clare where you cannot get any money out of the people, for the simple reason that they have no money to give. How are small farmers who have met with losses to meet the difficulty? They cannot be got to put money into a society when they have no money. These things are plain and it would be better if a little more consideration was given to them by the Minister than many of the empty platitudes he gave us this evening.
What the Dáil must realise is that in some districts the margin between competency and impoverishment is the margin of a few head of cattle. If these cattle are taken away how does the Minister propose that these people will be able to carry on or meet the expenses of local administration? How does he expect them to pay the Land Commission with that miserable margin in most cases in districts that I know thoroughly? How does he expect them to pay the local rates or to carry on unless the State does something? There are no people in their districts to help them. Who is to help them? Are they to be left to stew in their own juice? That is practically what the Minister has told us this evening. I do not believe that the Minister is anxious that that should happen, but in effect he said that credit societies have not been a success. I do not believe they will solve the fluke problem. The Minister stated that, and I give him credit for being honest about it. If they will not solve the fluke problem and the consequent poverty what will solve it? What are the people to do? What is his solution? He has not told us.
There was another aspect of it, and possibly that attitude of mind should be expressed. It is more or less a matter of psychology that the Irish people do not want to tear open their wounds in the presence of their neighbours. Anyone who knows the Irish people will know that a man will not go into his neighbour's house and say: "I have lost three cattle and I cannot pay my rates and annuities." He hides it and holds up his head. That mentality is there and you have to take account of it. As I fancy I am rather wedged in between Cavan and Leitrim I do not want to delay the proceedings to the extent of keeping Leitrim from speaking. I should like to express to the Minister the necessity for reconsidering this matter, not indeed in the light of all that the Farmer Deputies said. I do not accept all that. I ask him to accept his own statement that the credit societies have not been a success and that he does not expect them to be the immediate solution of the poverty created by the fluke. In the light of that statement I ask him to give us some promise of a solution that will help the people to face the serious propositions that face them.
Comment on this
In discussing this question Deputy Baxter seems to forget that other things were done to assist the farmers. There is an old saying that eaten bread is soon forgotten. The Government, as this Dáil is well aware from the debate, spent quite a large amount of money in productive works in Cavan and a similarly large amount in Meath.
Comment on this
We will have to give Deputy Dolan an opportunity of coming to Deputy Tierney's amendment.
Comment on this
Deputy Baxter has been telling the House of the state of affairs on the other side of the Border, and it has come up in the debate that the sum of £37,000 was advanced by way of a loan to the farmers for relief. We have spent in Leitrim and Cavan, in relieving the fluke by other means than credit societies, £60,000.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy explain by what means capital was reestablished in the hands of the farmers who had lost their cattle by fluke?
Comment on this
Those who suffered are mainly small farmers with an average valuation of about £7, and those men worked at productive works started under the Ministry of Agriculture, such as making bog roads. Drainage schemes and various other works were started in those counties because they were so much affected by the disease. People were glad to earn the money and it gave them capital, because otherwise they would have been doing nothing. Credit societies did not get a decent chance. When the scheme was launched in this House the debate was most damaging because the Deputies on the opposite benches prophesied that it would not be a success. If they had taken up the credit societies scheme, had made the most of it, and endeavoured to work credit societies, things might have been better.
Comment on this
Deputy Baxter referred to the conditions in Leitrim and the statements made at the meeting at which I was present. The greatest arguments used at that meeting were quotations from meetings already held in his county.
Comment on this
At what meetings in my county were those statements made? No statements were made with my knowledge in my county at any period.
Comment on this
Has not the Cumann na nGaedheal Party any means of counteracting the evil influence of the farmers?
Comment on this
I am beginning to get into a frame of mind that whatever the Cumann na nGaedheal Party is or is not doing in the country some people appear to think it has no right to speak in this House. Deputies will have to listen to other Deputies no matter how unpalatable or unpleasant it is or no matter how they may consider other Deputies inaccurate or misleading unless some personal point arises. We are reaching a stage now when points of explanation are going to destroy debate. We are here for the purpose of debate and I am prepared to give every Deputy the fullest opportunity of making himself clear, and of clearing himself of any accusations made against himself or his party. We will let Deputy Dolan proceed on this question generally.
Comment on this
We are at any rate tackling the question. I admit we have not got very far but we are under way and the spirit is there to work credit societies. If you got that spirit in every area I see no reason why the Minister for Agriculture could not continue the good work he did by another scheme of productive works, in the badly affected areas. To my mind the question would be best met in the county I know best, which is referred to here, which is a county of small farmers, by the institution of productive works for the development of the different societies within the county. It would give the people employment through which they could earn a reasonable wage and it would do useful productive work for the country.
To my mind the question can be best met in that particular county by the encouragement of the credit societies by continuing the work that has been started there. Let us not condemn the credit societies, and stop any start that has been made, but let the credit societies work on. When this evil pest has passed, and when we have forgotten about the fluke of 1924-25, then, as the mover of the amendment has pointed out, these societies would be of great assistance to the small farmers in the congested districts. It is said that farmers will not invest their money, and that they have no security. To my mind the farmer should be encouraged to invest his money in credit societies by Deputy Baxter and his colleagues, for the farmer in most cases has his money lying idle in the bank at small interest, and he has not the courage to take it out and invest it where he will get twice the interest, as he would in the case of credit societies. In these societies he has first-class security, for he has his own local committee, and they know the people. Each man who gets a loan has to have guarantors, so that, in that way, there is first-class security for any man who invests his money in a credit society. There is no county so poor that there is not a certain amount of dead money lying in the banks. We would be much better employed in encouraging farmers to co-operate to help themselves than by saying that the farmers are not able to do anything for themselves. Even in the congested districts they are well able to solve their own problems if their leaders would only help them to do so.