We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

TREATY (CONFIRMATION OF AMENDING AGREEMENT) BILL, 1925—SECOND STAGE (RESUMED DEBATE).

Contributions 1–164 of 322. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Treaty (Confirmation of Amending Agreement) Bill, 1925
Enacted

No. 51 of 1925 ›

Being the only Deputy on this side of the House who voted for the Treaty on the 7th January, 1922, it would be very undesirable if I were to give a silent vote on this question. I voted for the Treaty, and I have not had any qualms of conscience since then as to whether I did the right thing or not. I listened to Deputy Redmond yesterday evening speaking about the Irish Party. He talked about the associates of the Ministry. When the Treaty was signed, I happened to be one of their associates. The whole tenor of his speech yesterday evening was: "I told you so," and he told us that the Irish Party in 1914 could have got a better settlement than was brought about by the Treaty. If that is so I cannot understand why the Irish Party did not get us that settlement. They had a magnificent opportunity in August, 1914, before Mr. Redmond in the House of Commons pledged this country to England for the war. Deputy Redmond told us that when partition was mentioned then it was only agreed to in a temporary way. But could he have given any guarantee that if partition had then been accepted in a temporary way by both sides, that he would not have had the same position confronting this country as that which confronts it now?

I think it is only fair to myself and to my associates of the time I speak of that I should state my position in that connection. I am absolutely opposed to this Agreement, because I consider that the Executive Council have exceeded their functions in the matter. I consider that the Government has gone as far as to break the Constitution; I consider that the Government has gone as far as to break the Treaty which they have been praising for the past three or four years. Deputy Dr. MacNeill, who was appointed by the Government as a member of the Boundary Commission, told us two or three weeks ago, in the greatest confession of failure I have ever heard a man make, that he pledged himself to secrecy with two men whom he knew very early in the proceedings were absolutely opposed to the aims of the Free State. He told us that early in the proceedings of that Commission it was clear to him that his colleagues were not putting a proper interpretation on the Article in question. I do not care what his conception of honour may be; I believe that he should, there and then, have told them that he considered it his bounden duty to come back and tell this country of that. The honour of Deputy Dr. MacNeill is a very small thing compared with the future of this nation. The honour of Deputy Dr. MacNeill, great as he may think it is, is a very small thing compared with what the Nationalists of Tyrone and Fermanagh have gone through and will go through.

I find it very hard to believe that Deputy Dr. MacNeill kept all this from his colleagues. From every platform upon which members of the Executive Council appeared for the past twelve months we were told: "All goes well with the Boundary Commission." The Nationalists of Tyrone, Fermanagh. Derry City, Newry, and those other places which would have been affected by the Boundary Commission were told, time and time again, that their destinies were safe in the hands of the Executive Council. Deputy Dr. MacNeill resigned from the Boundary Commission after a debate had been initiated here by Deputy McCullough, who seemed to get a little panicky be cause of certain information that had leaked through from the Boundary Commission to the Morning Post. I suppose we may assume that were it not for the fact that East Donegal was about to be taken Deputy McCullough would still be silent and Deputy MacNeill would still be on the Boundary Commission.

When Deputy MacNeill resigned the President was asked here to make a statement, a perfectly reasonable request, I submit, from a representative of the people. The President, in a very irritable manner, told us that he had no policy, but that the question was engaging the attention of the Executive Council and would continue to do so. We asked on Thursday last what was the policy of the Executive Council, and we received the same answer. The first medium through which the policy of the Executive Council was made known to us was through the much-hated British Parliament. Mr. Baldwin, Prime Minister of England, was the first to communicate to this country what the policy of the Free State Executive Council was. Surely the representatives of the people are not children. Surely the representatives of the people on both sides of the House know what their responsibilities are, and are prepared to shoulder them when the time comes. The President told us that this agreement was the best that could be got under the circumstances. What are the circumstances? We have not been told yet what they are. We have not yet been told what happened since the time Dr. MacNeill left the Boundary Commission until the President arrived home on Saturday morning. We know nothing. The President said on Monday last: "You asked me for my policy, here it is"—a Bill, a fait accompli, an agreement, that had been arrived at between the three Governments without the Irish people having a voice in the making of it. I ask the President and the Executive Council is that the proper way of treating the people of the Free State and of Tyrone, Fermanagh, Derry City, Newry, and those people who have suffered so much in the Irish cause for generations?

The President talks about the Feetham-Fisher award. We have not been told yet what the award was. And if we believe what Mr. Baldwin said in the House of Commons the President does not know what that award is. Mr. Baldwin stated yesterday in the British House of Commons that neither of the two Premiers saw the award. If they did not see it what is all the panic about? Why did the President agree to the cancellation of Article V.? I think the House is entitled to know who initiated the discussion on Article V., and to know what representations were made in connection with that Article. We have been asked for an alternative. I can quite understand that it is not easy to give an alternative. It is very hard to suggest any alternative when we are not placed in possession of the facts, and we should have been placed in possession of them prior to an agreement being signed by which the Nationalists of Tyrone and Fermanagh have been sold to Northern Ireland. Deputy Egan said yesterday that it was absolutely necessary that we should find out what our liabilities were under Article V., and that the uncertainty that has prevailed in financial matters was responsible for keeping the country in a stagnant position.

I am prepared to go a long way with him so far as that opinion is concerned, but we can pay too high a price for this also. I think it is too big a price to pay to sacrifice the thousands of Nationalists we are sacrificing in Northern Ireland by this Agreement. I suggest that we do not know what the Feetham-Fisher line is like. The President, as I say, if we take Mr. Baldwin's statement, does not know what it is like, but if we take the forecast of the "Morning Post" as accurate as regards the Boundary line the greater part of Tyrone and Fermanagh were to be transferred to the Free State. If that is the exact position I would like to know what authority we have for refusing to accept the Nationalists of Tyrone and Fermanagh into the Free State? The Minister for Finance is always able to smile at everything, but I daresay if he went back to Monaghan now he would not smile.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Would the Deputy come back to the Morning Post and say definitely that the suggested award gave over a large portion of Tyrone?

Comment on this

The Morning Post forecast was responsible for creating a panic in the Executive Council——

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I have asked the Deputy a question, and I would like if he would answer it.

Comment on this

I have given my answer.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Then the misrepresentation stands.

Comment on this

It is not a question of misrepresentation at all. This House has a right to be told in a statement by the President before the Bill was introduced what the circumstances were that warranted him in making such an agreement. During the discussions in the last two or three days we were threatened with the Feetham-Fisher line, a line which, according to the British Premier, has not been shown at all to the President or the Executive Council.

Comment on this

Quite right.

Comment on this

The Minister for External Affairs said yesterday that the Government were perfectly entitled to do what they did. I do not think anybody with any sense of responsibility should suggest any such thing. It is news to me that members of the Executive Council, or any member of it, can go across to another country and break the Constitution which they represent. That is what has been done in this case. We may say what we like about this Agreement and the Dáil turning it down, but we know that this Bill was approved by the Cumann na nGaedheal, and that there is a majority here to pass it. We have been told that if the Bill is passed we are to have a land of milk and honey, no unemployment, and that everything will run smoothly. Well, we will see how that turns out. Various circumstances have been mentioned in connection with Article V. The President, I think, mentioned £179,000,000 as the amount we are getting off for the payment of a sum of £5,000,000. I notice by to-day's papers that the sum suggested by the Irish representatives which we should pay was £150,000, but the sum we are to pay is shown to be £250,000 for sixty years. The worst part of the Agreement so far as the Article is concerned, the part which I take exception to, and to which I think any right-minded Irishman would take exception, is the part where the Free State takes responsibility for the payment of damages done by the Black and Tans from 1919, the exact date of the establishment of Dáil Eireann. This is tantamount to saying we had no authority for doing what we did between 1919 and 1921.

Comment on this

I would like to hear anybody suggest that to the Ministers during those two years, that we were expected to pay for every act of commandeering which some people called robbery, and for every act done by the Volunteers from 1919 to 1921. Taking up that attitude with regard to Article V., and accepting responsibility for the damage done by the Black and Tans in Balbriggan, Cork, and the rest of the country, is tantamount to saying that everything done by the Black and Tans was legal.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

No; you prefer not to read it that way. There is a suggestion here that the compensation paid to Southern loyalists, whoever they may be, should be increased by 10 per cent.

Comment on this

Where is that?

Comment on this

It is somewhere. It is made perfectly clear in the English and Northern papers that the loyalists are to get that increase.

Comment on this

Where is it in the Agreement?

Comment on this

There is a 10 per cent. increase at any rate.

Comment on this

As I said at the beginning, I am going to oppose the Agreement.

Comment on this

The reasons do not matter.

Comment on this

Of course, not to you, but they matter to me. So long as I reconcile my own conscience to what I am doing I am satisfied. If your conscience can adapt itself to the situation I am sorry for you; mine cannot. So far as Article V. is concerned, I remember distinctly having a conversation with the late President Griffith in the lobby at Earlsfort Terrace, and he told me there that Article V. was not worth the paper it was written on, that it was a sort of agreed cancellation of debt between the two countries. I think he knew what he was talking about, and I think that everybody in the Front Bench had respect for his opinions. Colonel Gretton said distinctly yesterday in the House of Commons that he did not expect Ireland would ever pay a halfpenny under that Article. Mr. Churchill said there could be no doubt when the results are complete that the Government would have to review the whole situation in the light of Ireland's capacity to pay. When that day arrives I think we could put forward our case as to Ireland's capacity to pay, instead of raising the matter now in order to betray the Nationalists of Northern Ireland.

Comment on this

The Deputy said we had broken the Constitution. I submit, in fairness to the Executive Council, that that statement should not be allowed to go uncontradicted. Even if the Agreement contemplated a break in the Constitution that Agreement had to be presented here and the opinion of the Oireachtas taken upon it. Therefore we know that the Deputy is historically incorrect.

Comment on this

And hysterically.

Comment on this

I am as well aware as the President that the Constitution is not broken until the Bill has passed, but it is tentatively so by the Agreement in London.

Comment on this

I had no intention of taking part in this debate, but I think that there has not been quite fair play exercised in the discussion. With regard to Dr. MacNeill, I have on occasions totally disagreed with many of his opinions in matters of education in Ireland. Now, we have all heard it said that in connection with the matter under discussion, Dr. MacNeill had made mistakes. Let us allow it. What then? Is there any man in this House who would have done better if placed in the same position? Our worthy friend, Deputy Johnson, kept us one hour and three-quarters to-day dealing with platitudes. Let us have a little fair play in a matter like this, just as we have in a football match. If we see a man in a football match running towards the goal and, while doing his best to score, he gets tripped and then somebody else comes along, picks up the ball and scores, we do not consider about the man being tripped. All we consider is that our side won.

Comment on this

From a penalty.

Comment on this

No, not from a penalty. Whether we fail or succeed, the great thing is to do our best and try to reach our goal. We have got a mountain to climb, and we are working our way towards the top. The ascent of that mountain means success for the whole of Ireland—not the Free State portion, not the Republican portion, but the whole of Ireland—and we are going to get to the top. Those of us who have climbed mountains have sometimes been tempted to take a short-cut. Some of us have been tempted to take a short-cut in this matter—may I suggest through the Shelbourne Hotel —but we recognise that that short-cut is full of rocks and difficulties. Our friend Deputy Johnson wishes to take that short-cut, but the Free State Government wishes to save him from breaking his ankle. We want to support him, and take him with us on our climb —"Excelsior." This is a chance of getting the whole of Ireland re-united in one assembly.

One of the arguments used by Deputy Johnson was that by passing this Bill we would have no chance of approaching the North. We have every chance of approaching the North but not across the rocks on the short-cut. Deputy Johnson tries to persuade us to follow him, but I believe when the division comes in the end he will follow us. Deputy Gorey says that we should have been informed about this and be informed about that. We are not, apparently, to take the word of our Government. Why is our Government there? We may differ as regards details with them, but as long as we believe in them we should take the word of the Government where we cannot obtain explanations. We would be very foolish, having trusted them, not to take their word on delicate questions of settlement. What does England do? We are told here that even the humblest attendant should be consulted and his opinion sought as to what should be done, but in England Mr. Baldwin signed the Agreement and was not afraid of his country revolting against his signature, though the House of Commons had not the question submitted to them until he had signed the Agreement. Are we to betray the people whom we trust to bring us to the mountain top? If they are no good, get rid of them, but so long as we follow them I believe we are adopting the right course in trusting them. We must be loyal to our side and play the game of football. It does not matter whether one man falls during the course of the game, or whether he makes a mistake, as long as he did his best to help us to win. Is there anyone who could have done better during the great difficulty which arose in the course of our negotiations with England? At present they are saying in England, "We have lost by this," while Deputy Corish thinks that Ireland is ruined by it. Most Deputies, however, do not think that Ireland is ruined. We consider that as we are not yet fully developed we should take two steps instead of one.

Comment on this

The goose step.

Comment on this

If the Deputy thinks that that is so, we would then have two legs to mend instead of one. Deputy Johnson is still too young to recognise the truth of this, but, as we get a little bit older in life, we recognise that our strength is not capable of stepping boldly out, and we must take two steps instead of one. Deputy Egan quite rightly said that we should prove ourselves capable in the eyes of those who suspect us. It is for us to show that we are quite capable to deal with financial and other important questions, and that we intend to put Ireland above every other nation. If we are challenged, it is up to us to prove our bona fides. The Kilkenny cats have gone long ago, and we must not call them back. Let us prove ourselves to be men, as good as any men in the world, and we will soon reach the mountain top. Once we prove ourselves men we will have a united Ireland. These are my opinions upon this question, and I believe they will be fully voiced in the South. Let us back up the power that has organised us. Let us put all myths on one side. I believe, if we do that, the South of Ireland will follow the Government as long as they stand by the Agreement.

Comment on this

I just want to say that I will vote for this Bill as I see a thousand arguments in favour of it and not one against. Outside this House I met no person who is against this Bill. I want, however, to give expression to a growing apprehension, and that is that those who have levied war against the Treaty during the last four years may now start a new war to prevent the alteration of a comma in that same Treaty. I appeal to my colleagues here if they had intended to say anything for the Bill to leave it unsaid. The commonsense people have justified this Bill in advance and every sane element in the country wants it to be passed. Prolonging a debate of this kind and wasting the time of the Dáil in the way it has been wasted for the past two days is only bringing the Dáil into contempt. For that reason I would appeal to Deputies who intend to speak to make their speeches as brief as possible so that we may vote on this measure.

Comment on this

I will try to do what Mrs. Collins-O'Driscoll has asked. I hope I will not be accused of wasting the time of the Dáil if I ask for the privilege of speaking for a few minutes. I do not ask that privilege because I have anything special to add to the arguments already put forward. I do not think that any of the arguments which have been used against this Bill have answered the reasoned statements of the President and Minister for Justice. To my mind the reason is all on one side. We have had, I am sorry to say, recriminations and attempts to place blame, but I do not think we have any use for these. In my opinion it is not a case of blame. The difficulty was inherent in the situation, and there is no advantage to be gained by saying that blame was due to one person or another. I do not think it was. I think that the President and his colleagues have acted through this whole matter with a great degree of wisdom, tact and dignity. The difficulties were, as I say, inherent in the situation. I believe that the more successful the Boundary Commission was from a Free State point of view, the more hopeless it would have made our outlook for the future. If the Commissioners had been wizards and had been able to put on one side everybody who wished to be a Free Stater and on the other side everybody who did not, I ask Deputies to try and form some picture of what the situation would have been. What hope would there have been for that blending and mutual understanding so really essential for that amity and prosperity which we all desire to attain? I think it would have meant that there would have been, not a Boundary, but a barrier which would probably have become more and more difficult to break down. I think, if I may venture a compliment, that the Dáil, under your wise guidance, sir, has shown itself in the main a really practical assembly. I think if ever there was an occasion to show itself a practical assembly, that occasion is to-day. Our Government was faced with a really difficult position. They did not ask how it came about but they set themselves to find out what was the next best move. We have the same practical question to answer to-day and we have to ask ourselves what is our next best move. To my mind our Ministers and those with whom they conferred showed themselves to be real statesmen and not politicians. They went down to bed-rock fundamentals and they sought to build on that basis, the only basis on which a stable structure can be built, the basis of mutual agreement and goodwill.

The very fact that they and the other signatories put their names to the document that we have here before us to-day, is, to me, the strongest proof of the truth of the statements with which that document commences. I hold that that fact itself proves the goodwill which they claim in support of that Agreement. I could, if I wanted to, build my case on an analysis of the Agreement itself. As Deputy Professor O'Sullivan said, that analysis is very simple, so simple that it is obvious. I cannot see any other way. It consists of three points. On each of these points I contend that the Free State is making a gain, in the first place, though I am sorry to say very loose words have been used in this connection, such words as "surrender" and "selling," words that do not fit themselves to the case at all. As it seems to me, there is no case of surrendering and selling. It is simply a case of how many people are there whose aspirations we cannot satisfy. It is a case of choosing between one boundary and another, and the Government have chosen the better of the two.

As regards the second point, the financial point, and a distinct point, I do not think that there are many people, who have not got their heads in the clouds, who did not believe that the upshot of Article V would be that there would be a large financial balance against us. There is no use in going into exact figures. They are not essential to the point at all. When you have a case on which one side claims a large sum and the other side says its contention would balance it, or nearly so, and an arbitrator has to settle, what is the result going to be? I do not think very few people take any other view but that one.

The third point is, we are surrendering the Council of Ireland. We are getting instead a working agreement between two Governments. The Council of Ireland has been represented as an organic link, a bond of unity. There was no organic link about it. It was not to deal with Ireland but with the Six Counties only. It was a bond of unity in the sense in which a handcuff is a bond between a prisoner and his jailer. It could not have any other effect but to act as a constant source of irritation to the Six Counties. Instead of that we have got the promise of cooperation between the two Governments. As I say, I could treat this Agreement as business; it is good business. But I give my approval to it, and I ask approval for it on a higher plane. It is based on essential principles of mutual agreement and goodwill. That, I believe to be the only basis upon which we can hope for the unity that we want.

If history proves anything, it proves to me that the lines upon which we have been working for four years were not bringing us nearer to it. We have got here a chance of a fresh start, and I hope we are going to take it. If, as Sir James Craig said, we make a fresh start with the determination to wipe out memories of the past, to do as he has promised to do, to work for the good of Ireland, I think we will get what we all want. No doubt it will take time, but with that spirit I venture to hope that the time will not be as long as many of us present think is possible. If all take the chance, North and South alike, determined to wipe out memories of the past—I am afraid that even here all have not yet done that, but let us try—if we make agreement between one another our chief aim, I have faith enough to believe that we shall get it.

I come to the real point. A notable characteristic of our debates here has been the absence from those debates of anything like religious intolerance or bad feeling. We are a religious people; we have deep religious feelings. We differ on many points, but we have a common substratum, and, without egotism, I venture to say here we have learned to respect one another, despite those differences. I absolutely and wholly follow the good words—fine words I believe they were, of Deputy Bryan Cooper and Deputy Sir James Craig, my colleague. I would support them completely. I think we have made friendships here that will last. I speak as a Protestant, if you like, as one of the minority, though I have never felt it. I do not feel it. I have not been treated here as if I was in the minority. I venture to say that I voted more frequently with the majority than with the minority. Nevertheless, I am a Protestant and I am proud of it. I speak as a Protestant and as a representative of a University which has for a long time taken as its maxim and its just and proud boast that it offers equality to members of every denomination. I am sure, in speaking for it, I have its support. I am sure, in this matter, I have the support of many of those who think with me. I take the opportunity—I have taken it before— of reminding the House that very early in our debates here the President and the Minister for Justice told us that their object would be in the country to secure fair play and equal treatment for members of all creeds, political and religious. I have borne testimony before to the way in which they have carried out that aim, and similar testimony has been borne, I am glad to say, throughout the country by many Protestants, clergymen and others. I bear it again, and I raise the point in this connection, because I want to stress that we have succeeded in maintaining our own principles, and yet in maintaining that goodwill amongst ourselves and that respect for one another. I refer to the matter for that reason and for one other.

One of the great difficulties of this situation seems to me to be the unfortunate fact that religious and political border-lines coincide to such an extent as they do. It is strange that very often, when that is the case, the religious differences rather tend to embitter feeling rather than that any common substratum of belief should tend to allay bitterness. That is the fact, but it is not necessarily so, and that is why I mentioned the point. We have kept from it here, and I have every hope that we shall find it more general in the future.

I am making no charges or insinuations whatever against anybody, but what I do want to insist on, as the main object throughout the country, north and south, should be religious and political toleration. When we get mutual understanding we are likely to secure that. Without mutual understanding and mutual blending we are not likely to secure it. I feel very much that the sad thing about this agreement is that it means bitter disappointment to many people who had hoped that they were going very quickly to enter the Free State. That is not to be realised. I believe it is not to be realised immediately. I want, if I can, to say something which may replace those hopes by higher hopes. The people who are disappointed may, I think, feel that they have got a work to do which is difficult, but which is high and that it rests and will rest with them to a very large extent to bring about that mutual understanding and that blending to which I have referred. I feel keenly for the disappointment of so many people along the Border-line. I sympathise with them and I regret that they are to have that temporary disappointment. I believe it will be only temporary. At the same time, while they have that disappointment I think they are getting instead of it a big life-work and, after all, it is a big thing to them and a thing that is worth the postponement of the realisation of certain hopes. The respective Governments of North and South have given a lead. I hope strongly that they will make that lead even plainer. It is not for me to suggest how, but I think if they look round and seek for opportunities for removing even, I say, the appearance of any differntial treatment between people of different creeds, political or religious, I say they will find them. I urge that that should be done, and I urge that the Governments should be followed by people in that respect. When we get individuals looking for that, then I think we are well on the road.

As I said, it is not for me to suggest means, but I do say that if across the Border our Protestant brethren can see any way of giving meaning immediately to Sir James Craig's words that any steps that they take would be welcomed by me at least and I believe by those who think with me within the Free State in matters of religion. I want to be quite clear; I make no charges or no insinuations whatever as to the past. As I say, I do not think there is any good now to be gained by looking back. Let us look forward. I say that without knowing what is happening in the North, but I do know that there is deep feeling on this matter and I would ask that every attempt shall be made to remove even an apparent cause of that feeling.

I hope I have said nothing which will appear to cast an imputation on anybody or give any offence. Nothing is further from my mind. I ask that the spirit of my words shall be looked to and not any words that I use which may happen to be unfortunate. Mutual understanding, conciliation, toleration, co-operation, are fine words, but if they are brought into being, if they are put into practice in our lives, they become something far bigger. They become, I venture to say, the very keystone of our moral and national well-being.

Comment on this

I think it would be a happy day for Ireland if a representative of the minority in the Northern Parliament could stand up there and give expression to the views that Deputy Thrift has given expression to here to-day. It would be a happy day if conditions were such in Northern Ireland that the minority there could, through their spokesmen and leaders in the Parliament of that State, say to the world that their treatment by the majority had been fair and just. If they were able to say that, there would be unity here to-day for the passing of this measure. The Deputy who has spoken has told us truths that we know. He has given us facts that we know exist, and whatever may happen elsewhere in this country, or in any other country, I am sure every Deputy wishes that the spirit that exists in this part of Ireland to-day and the toleration and respect for the views of others that obtain here will continue.

Minorities have rights and majorities have rights. My opposition to this measure—I am going to treat the Bill as something apart altogether from the policy of the Executive Council, which preceded it—is based entirely on the fact that, as far as I can see, it is going to mean for this country permanent partition. By being asked to accept this Bill, we are asked to do what no body of Irishmen in any generation so far has agreed to do—to hand over the minority in the North of Ireland into the hands of the majority there. While some things which I have got to say on this point may not be very acceptable to some people, I hold it my duty, in putting my point of view on this matter to speak the truth, to speak of things as they are and as we know them to be. The position of the Northern Nationalists, if this Bill passes and if they are handed over with their destinies and their rights to the Government of Ulster, will be the most intolerable position of any white people on God's earth to-day. What is the position in Northern Ireland at the present time? What rights do the majority enjoy there? There are many Deputies who know what the position is. There are many who do not know what the position is. And there are many who would think it impossible that the conditions should be as they are. The Ministers' case for acceptance of this Bill is based on three points—(1) that the Agreement will mean peace; (2) that the question of Article V. and its implications for this country, one way and another, cease to exist, and (3) that this bargain sows the seed of unity. There is talk about the spirit in which this Treaty was signed. In what spirit was it signed? As far as England and the North of Ireland were concerned, it was signed in the spirit of victory. As far as the Free State was concerned, it was signed in the spirit of defeat and, I am afraid, of despair. Sir James Craig's policy was "Not an inch" and his "Not-an-inch" policy has won. Since his return to Ireland, he has repeated his statement of policy. And what does one of his Ministers in Northern Ireland say? Mr. Pollock, Minister for Finance in Northern Ireland, said that

the Agreement gave promise of new hope, of peace and concord.

Where is the unity there? Mark the words—"peace and concord." They are very significant words—peace and concord between North and South. Mr. Pollock goes on:

It will be observed that the full policy of Ulster has been confirmed to the letter, and that not an inch of territory in Ulster will be taken from under the control of our Government without the consent of the people of Ulster. Apart altogether from the terms of the Agreement, it is infinitely more important that both the Free State and ourselves have come to realise that each is necessary to the other. It is all to the good that friendly relations have been established between the two Governments and that should have far-reaching effects upon the interest of both. There are many matters of mutual accommodation which can be settled between the North and the South without the sacrifice of the independence of either.

"Without the sacrifice of the independence of either." That is where this country stands to-day, or rather, it is where we are heading. Ulster has stood on what she claims as her rights. She has yielded nothing. And Ulster has won. We have yielded up our connection with the people in the North, who stood for Irish nationality through all the ages. We have flung them to the wolves. Will that mean peace? I say it cannot and that there will not be peace. Deputy Thrift has stated that the minority here have been able to live and not yield up their principles. That is the fight that is going on in Ulster. It is a fight between a minority who have principles and who will not yield them up and a majority who want to crush them to the earth, because they will not yield their principles. The minority in Northern Ireland are conscious of their nationality. They have stood for it and they have fought for it—aye, harder even than any man in Southern Ireland has to fight for it or has ever fought for it. The difficulties there are greater than any we have experienced. Now we are asked to abandon them. We are asked to leave them to that majority who have been trampling on them for years, because they have the courage to say that they believe in Irish nationality and are prepared to stand for it. Peace! Could not we here in this part of Ireland have had peace long ago, without striking a blow, if we were prepared to yield up our principles of nationality —if we were prepared to kneel to the conqueror and kiss his heel? I say we could. There will not be peace in Ulster, and there can never be peace in Ulster, with the mentality that exists there to-day, so long as the minority in Ulster are not prepared to yield up their nationality and kiss the heel of the conqueror. I know a little, as an Ulsterman, of what the people of the North feel, and I say that although the Nationalists of the South and West may desert them, the Nationalists of the North will not yield up their nationality. They have fought and they will still hold on. Can we expect peace when such conditions as these exist and will continue to exist?

It may be necessary to examine this problem a little more closely. Some may question the truth of what I say. Now, I would be more pleased even than the President or Vice-President, if I could see hope in the bargain that these Minister have put before us.

Comment on this

May I ask the Deputy a question? It is not for the purpose of interrupting the trend of his argument but for the better understanding of his argument. He has dealt with the position of the minority in the North-East and he has dealt with the minority as a whole. He has described what their position will be in the event of this Bill passing. I would be glad if he would give a few moments of his speech to an attempt to describe what their position will be in the event of this Bill not passing. In other words, would the Deputy say whether in the event of this Bill being rejected, he would stand for the acceptance of the Feetham line? There are 450,000 Nationalists in the North-Eastern area. Some 20,000 of these are affected by the Feetham line. Perhaps, he would give a few moments of his speech to the condition of the remainder.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say what is the Feetham line?

Comment on this

My information from Dr. MacNeill is that the "Morning Post" forecast was substantially accurate. It was inaccurate in details, but, where it was inaccurate, the difference most frequently was against rather than in favour of the hopes of this nation.

Comment on this

Where does the 20,000 come in?

Comment on this

I was informed that in or about 20,000 people were affected by the proposed line. There are, as the Deputy knows, upwards of 400,000 Nationalists in the North-Eastern area. Deputy Baxter spoke as if the passing of this Bill was going to have unfavourable reactions on all the Nationalists in the North-Eastern area and as if its rejection would be, in some way, a boon to all the Nationalists of the North-Eastern area. I want to make it clear that, as between this Agreement and the Feetham line, there is a question of about 20,000 people, and we have been told that we have sold something. If we have sold anything we have sold the Feetham award, which nobody wanted, and I submit that we have sold it dear.

Comment on this

Does the Minister suggest that nobody in Ulster is affected by this except the 20,000 he speaks of? Is there no repercussion on the relations of the others and the sense of triumph over them?

Comment on this

There are only favourable repercussions on the others.

Comment on this

The Vice-President has had his say, and he has had a chance of making a second speech. I will continue my speech and will deal with the point which the Vice-President has raised later. I want to say to the Vice-President that I do not want to be a bit unfair on this question. It is too serious a matter for that. I appreciate the difficulty of the Executive Council; I admit there was a difficulty, and I do not want to be unfair in any way. I am subject to correction in what I say. The matter is too serious, both for present and future generations, for words to be lightly spoken or for matters to be given expression to which we do not thoroughly understand or which we have not grave reason for stating. I was dealing with the point that we could have peace long ago at a price. We could have sold our nationality; we could have yielded to superior force. There could have been peace, and the Irish nation could be dead to-day; we would not be here and there would be no Bill asking us to assent to the partition of the country. Our nationality would be dead and partition one way or the other would not matter. That did not come about. Despite superior forces, subtle means of government, education, and oppression unequalled in any country, nationality lived on. It is the same spirit that is alive in Ulster to-day.

Let us remember that the tyranny that was experienced here is being experienced by the Northern Nationalists to-day, and the worst days of the Black and Tans was a bright page in Irish history compared to the conditions of the Northern Nationalists at present. If I am asked to quote cases, I can quote half a dozen in reference to clergymen. It is not pleasant to have to introduce matters of religion, but it is difficult to separate it from this question. A clergyman from my constituency went across the Border the other day to a neighbouring town, and in the course of that short journey he was held up twelve times and searched by the Specials. Another clergyman was held up half a dozen times. Once he was told that it was lucky he pulled up or he would have been shot. No young Nationalist in the North can go out to a neighbour's house to a ceilidh at night without being liable to be searched half a dozen times by his next-door neighbour with a revolver. Three or four Nationalists cannot stand at a cross-roads together at night without the B Specials coming along to deny them that right.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I have brothers who do all these things without any of this happening.

Comment on this

They must be favoured people.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

They are not; they are quite normal.

Comment on this

I am giving the experience of a man whom I have met, and who was in this House yesterday.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I have met my brothers.

Comment on this

Will the Minister deny what I am saying?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I am denying it as a statement of the conditions prevailing all over the Six Counties— vehemently.

Comment on this

There may be some places better than others. I am giving the general experience in the North of Ireland at present.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy not speaking only of the Border areas?

Comment on this

And Belfast?

Comment on this

I am just coming to Belfast. As to the spirit of good-will that we were to experience after the Minister met in London, what has happened? How many arrests were made in Belfast the other day?

Comment on this
CAPTAIN REDMOND

They would not nominate one Nationalist Senator.

Comment on this

How many men, as stated in reply to Mr. McMullan in the Northern Parliament yesterday, are interned without any trial or charge being brought against them, and for what reason? The one reason, and the old reason. Were our Ministers conscious of these conditions when they went across to London?

Comment on this

I want to hear from them something about the case they put up and about the guarantees they have got that these conditions will cease to exist.

Comment on this

On a point of personal explanation. When one has discussions and conversations of that kind lasting over a week, and there emerges a particular result, I think that it is not open to any of the representatives engaging in these discussions to talk of anything but the result. It is not open to the representatives to come back to their Parliament and say: "This was tried, and that was talked about, but finally we secured this." We are standing over the result. But, it is not open to any of the three or four of us who took part in the discussions to go into an elaborate detailed account as to the course of the discussions. We could not do it. It would not be consistent with the kind of confidence which is necessary and inseparable from discussions of the kind to deal with anything but the result of the discussions. May I suggest to the Deputy that the results will unfold themselves day by day?

Comment on this

As Mr. Baldwin disclosed an item of the settlement under Article 5 which was not communicated to the Dáil, are not members of the Dáil entitled to ask if there are other things to be disclosed in piecemeal fashion in regard to guarantees?

Comment on this

I want to point out the great disadvantage we are at in trying to be fair in this matter and in making a case on the facts before us when the Vice-President comes along and suggests there are other things. We can only go on what is in the Agreement before the Dáil, and on that I am making my case.

Comment on this

We are not at liberty to discuss more than the Agreement that is before the Deputies.

Comment on this

I want to say that it is difficult to pass judgment in a moment on what the Vice-President has given expression to, but in the absence of any guarantees in this Agreement as to what the conduct of affairs in the North of Ireland is to be in future, and the treatment that our compatriots there are to get, we can only assume from what has happened since the Agreement was signed that conditions are not going to change, that the domineering, tyrannical spirit that has continued there so far is not going to change.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not helping to change it.

Comment on this

There was a way to challenge it and make sure that it was changed and that the change would be lived up to, and that was for our representatives to see that there would be guarantees which would be signed by the representatives of the majority Party in the North. When the Treaty was made between the Free State and England, England saw to it that guarantees were given on behalf of her minority here and that those guarantees were carried out. Was not that a lesson for those who left this country to protect the liberties and rights of the people of the Irish nation? I see no signs of that yet.

What we are asked to do here is to commit ourselves to the permanent partition of our country. For what? The phantom gold in Article V.—perhaps our own gold. I say that if we take the rights or bodies of the Nationalists in the North into the market place for barter, if there is any monetary gain, they should get it. The money is not ours. Their rights are their own. It is not for us to give them away. I want to go further and say that when this question of partition arose first, when the representatives of this country were in the British Parliament, even though they were supposed not to be in touch with the people and not to represent their point of view, they had sufficient common sense and respect for the opinions of people whose interests they were working for to come back to Belfast and ask those people what they wanted, and whether they were prepared to commit themselves for a period of six years to a policy of partition. What are we asked to do to-day? Without giving those people any opportunity of expressing their opinions on this bargain, we are asked to commit them to the position of being an oppressed minority in the North for all time to come, and we are asked to take up the attitude of separating ourselves from them. We will have no right, if we agree to this, to interfere or to suggest to the people of the North that they should treat our fellow-countrymen there decently.

The policy of the Government of Northern Ireland is the policy of England. When the Supplemental Agreement Act was going through the Dáil, I urged that our people should recognise that there would not have been partition in Ireland but for British statesmen and British gold. I repeat it now. In the part of Ireland where English influence is removed there is toleration and goodwill; there is a desire amongst all the people to do their best. It was not so when the foreign influence was with us, and it cannot be so in the North of Ireland because the influence of Britain is strong there. Britain wishes to hold this country through the North of Ireland, and we are now asked to agree to the permanent partition of this country to enable those people to set up in the North, what they will succeed in doing within ten years, another separate State—a Dominion. We cut our people off from contact with us; we throw them aside. There will be no great desire even on the part of the Nationalists of the North to come to us who have cast them away. We turn their eyes to Belfast and Westminster definitely, and what does that mean? The fight that we waged in this country—that some of the men on the Government benches waged— was to get the eyes of the people of Ireland turned from Westminster to Ireland as the centre of gravity. Now we are asked to go back on that policy definitely and turn those people's eyes back again. I cannot be a party to that. I question whether the people of the country, if they got an opportunity to consider fully what they are being asked to do, would give it their sanction. Article V. was a very serious matter yesterday—much more serious than it is to-day.

Comment on this

Not a bit.

Comment on this

"Not a bit," the Minister for Finance says. We have not heard him yet. I wonder if the fear that British Ministers would have spoken before this Dáil would have agreed to this Bill had anything to say to the desire that was displayed on Monday to get this matter rushed through the Dáil? It is a very curious thing that the Chancellor of the British Exchequer yesterday took up the very same attitude on Article V. that our Minister for Finance has taken up and did take up heretofore.

When it is suggested that we have thrown the mill-stone from around our necks—I think Deputy Egan suggested that—I would recommend him carefully to read Mr. Churchill's statement, and there he will see how much Britain expected to get from this country under Article V. What party in this State—I put this to the Ministry— could or would undertake the responsibility of running the country if it had to contribute one penny under Article V.? No party in the State would take on the responsibility.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

What would they do?

Comment on this

Britain would then have to consider what they would do. No doubt we would be threatened with terrible and immediate war again.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Would that be the only consequence?

Comment on this

I will refer the Minister to the statement of Mr. Churchill. He has pointed out our capacity to pay. We know what our capacity to pay is. We know what the attitude of Britain has been towards every other country with whom she had financial relations.

We are going to pay under Articles III. and IV. We had to get particulars in that respect from British Ministers. They told us what we would have to pay. No definite statement could be made to the Dáil by our own Ministers as to the amount of our liability under those Articles. We understand that six millions would be our contribution. The payment is to be extended over 60 years. If we paid now it would be six millions; at the end of 60 years we will have contributed fifteen millions. Under Articles III. and IV. we are to pay for damage done by the British authorities here when we were trying to drive them out of the country.

I am in agreement with Deputy Corish when he says that by taking over responsibility to pay that money we are taking on ourselves the moral obligation to pay it that England was under. In other words, it puts us in the position of being responsible for the destruction that England's forces did here; it puts us in the position of having no moral or legal right to do what we did, and it tends to indicate that England was right when she burned down our towns throughout the country.

Comment on this

Anyhow, we have to pay, and I am sure the Ministry are delighted.

Comment on this

If I am allowed to intervene, I would like to tell the Deputy that my wife's house was burned, and amongst other things destroyed were my own books, papers and other property of mine. I made no application in respect to those articles. I certainly did not give a certificate of exculpation to those who burned the house. I bore the loss myself.

Comment on this

Can the President tell us whether we are not now dealing with cases in which responsibility had been admitted, but in regard to which the Minister now comes along and says: "Wait, wipe it out; we will bear it ourselves"?

Comment on this

It is quite a different case altogether. If the Deputy puts it that the British Government leave the country and that we call on them to pay the indemnity, I say that we are not strong enough to do it.

Comment on this

Was there not an agreement that they would pay for the destruction committed by their own forces?

Comment on this

After the Treaty had been signed.

Comment on this

It was an admission, nevertheless.

Comment on this

No, sir; there was no admission.

Comment on this

No; it was in consideration of Article V. being in the Treaty.

Comment on this

Anyhow we are going to pay and I am sure we are quite satisfied.

Comment on this

Quite right.

Comment on this

That is the important thing. The Irish taxpayer is going to pay. The peculiar point about it is that the Press to-day informs us that our own Ministers offered to pay it.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

We should be told why they offered to pay and what we are getting in return.

Comment on this

Article V. wiped out.

Comment on this

It is not wiped out until the Dáil passes this Bill.

Comment on this

That is perfectly right.

Comment on this

The President may be pleased and he may think he has dealt a magnificent blow, but if the people of the country to-day are wise, and if this House is wise, after the statement of British Ministers indicating very clearly what our position is financially and otherwise, they will decide they will not go on.

Comment on this

Let me say, while the Deputy is on that subject, that there is information at my disposal that I will explain when I am winding up.

Comment on this

You kept it very quiet.

Comment on this

I was blindfolded and handcuffed, one might say. I was making the best of the case, the real material issues of which I did not portray.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

It would be much better if Deputy Baxter were allowed to conclude without interruption or explanation of any kind whatever.

Comment on this

We changed Ireland to the Saorstát when the Treaty was signed. What are you going to change the Saorstát to when you sign away one-fifth of the country to the North of Ireland and leave it to them for all time? There has been great play made of the Council of Ireland by the Vice-President particularly. He has no faith whatever in it. Yesterday we had it from British Ministers that if the provisions came into effect the Free State would have complete control of services such as Railways, Fisheries, and Diseases of Animals Acts within the Border of Northern Ireland.

Comment on this

That is the English interpretation of the Article in the Treaty.

Comment on this

Do you think it is true?

Comment on this

Well——

Comment on this

The Vice-President understands as well as I do what the acceptance of the Council of Ireland meant to us, and he realises the position that we were put in by having authority, partial authority, inasmuch as only a certain number of the Council would be from the Saorstát. He realises that the fact that we were in control of services in Northern Ireland established the supremacy of this Parliament, and it showed that we had authority and rights and privileges that we could exercise in Northern Ireland under the Treaty.

Comment on this

Do you think we had control?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Minister should let the Deputy proceed.

Comment on this

We have given all that authority away, and for what? I cannot see anything in exchange for it. I do suggest it was very unwise and very short-sighted that we should have yielded up anything that indicated the unity of this country and the right of our Parliament to interfere in the affairs of Northern Ireland. The Agreement that we are asked to agree to having dealt, or not dealt, with the Border, and having disposed of Article V., compels us to hand over £6,000,000 out of our Exchequer and compels us to abandon the Nationalists of the North for all time.

The case made so far in regard to Article V. has been blown to the winds, to use the words of the Vice-President, by the statement yesterday of the British Chancellor of the Exchequer. I cannot see, nor can any Deputy here see, in the Agreement anything whereby the rights of our people in the North are protected, and whereby any consideration whatever has been given to them. We are asked to consent to the handing over of those people to the Northern Government, and to leave them with the Northern Government.

I would like to touch upon the policy of the Executive Council in dealing with the whole matter of the Boundary Commission. I was never enamoured of the Commission and I never expected much from it. Twelve months ago, when it was going through, I said that what we ought to be engaged on then was considering what the country would do when the Commission failed to give to it what those who stood up for the Commission said it would give. What did those who stood up for the Commission say it would give when they were urging the setting up of the Commission? If a little more foresight had been exercised then, and if the Commission had not been set up, there would be no permanent Border. What ever the rights of the Nationalists in the North might have been, whatever privileges they would have enjoyed, there would not have been on our part consent and agreement and signatures to a permanent Border between the North and the Saorstát.

What was the opinion of the Vice-President when this matter was before the Dáil twelve months ago? Deputy McCabe at that time suggested to the Assembly that we should leave things as they were, that we should leave the Northern Boundary where it was and that we should not interfere. The Vice-President said:

Do not endorse this agreement; do not have the Commission constituted. What then? People in Tyrone and Fermanagh, South Armagh and other places will want to know what then, will want to know very definitely what the alternative policy is of those who are against the confirmation of this Agreement....

Comment on this

They will now also.

Comment on this

What about them now? They do not matter now. What did the Vice-President say in London the other day when Mr. O'Hagan, Chairman of the Newry Council, Mr. O'Neill, M.P., South Down, and Mr. Collins, M.P., South Armagh, sent the following telegram to President Cosgrave:—

The overwhelming majority of the inhabitants of Newry, East Down, South Down and South Armagh protest against any deal settling their destiny behind closed doors. They insist on self-determination. They urge that you demand documents and evidence given by them before Commission and see their expressed rights. Irish nationality is not to be bartered or sold. It is not for the market-place.

What did the Vice-President say to those people then? Did he say what he said to Deputy McCabe when Deputy McCabe made the suggestion in the Dáil twelve months ago? No, the situation has changed.

Comment on this

The Vice-President says now: "What about South Down or South Armagh, Tyrone or Fermanagh?" Why did he not say that twelve months ago?

Comment on this

The situation has changed.

Comment on this

Who changed it? Who was responsible during the last twelve months for the change? Deputy Dr. MacNeill was appointed on the Commission and the Vice-President the other day wanted to impress this House with the fact that Deputy Dr. MacNeill's position to the Executive Council was exactly the position of Mr. Fisher to the Northern Government and Mr. Justice Feetham to—I do not know whether it is the Government of South Africa or the Government of Great Britain. What comparison was there between the position of Deputy MacNeill as a member of the Executive Council and either Fisher or Feetham on the Commission? They had no responsibility. They were not members of an Executive Council nor of a Government in either country. Deputy MacNeill was, and the policy that Deputy MacNeill was pursuing was only the policy of the Executive Council. I say, with Deputy Corish, that it is very difficult to believe that when Deputy Dr. MacNeill came back from the Commission the President did not say to him: "Well, how are you getting on? What do you think?"

Comment on this

Does the Deputy say that he refuses to believe it? We have heard something about fair speaking and plain speaking. Will the Deputy say now that he refuses to believe it?

Comment on this

The Deputy will say that the position that the Executive Council and Deputy Dr. MacNeill occupied in this matter was the most impossible position that any Executive Council could occupy in any country.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Answer the question.

Comment on this

The Deputy is running away from my question.

Comment on this

I am not going to say that Deputy Dr. MacNeill gave information of what was being done in the Commission, but I say that it is astonishing that the President did not ask him what was being done, how it was going on, and what his impressions of the other members of the Commission were. It is an extraordinary position for the Executive Council to place itself in, either from their own point of view or from the point of view of the country. But if they did not do that how was the Minister for Finance, at Clones, on the 5th September, as reported in the Press, able to tell the people in that Border town:

"The Boundary Commission is nearing the end of its labours. I have no doubt about the result, and that its work will be eminently satisfactory, and I think that it is being realised in the North that that will be so—that in the Six Counties it is being realised that it will be satisfactory from our point of view, and not at all satisfactory from their point of view."

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Is that not rather a proof that he did not know?

Comment on this

I do not know what it is a proof of.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That he did not know.

Comment on this

It is not a proof that the Minister did not know what he was talking about. I submit that a statement like that by a member of the Executive Council on a matter of supreme importance to the country was a very serious one to make. It should only be made if the Minister knew that it represented facts that would be justified by events, and the sense of false security that the Nationalists of the Border counties were lulled into by statements like that made by the Minister for Finance at Clones, and statements made elsewhere by other people, is displaying itself in the disappointment of these Nationalists to-day.

Comment on this

When were they lulled into a sense of false security? Did the Deputy ever meet any of them?

Comment on this

I did.

Comment on this

Lulled into a sense of false security?

Comment on this

Yes, believing the representations made by Ministers.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Deputy Baxter must be allowed to continue. We cannot have this debated by question and answer across the House. Deputies who do not like what Deputy Baxter is saying can make speeches about it afterwards.

Comment on this

I have been waiting a long time for them to make speeches. Now they go a little further. I do say that when the President was asked to make a statement more than a week ago, he made a statement that was quite satisfactory to every Deputy here and that, I say, was satisfactory to every Nationalist in Ireland, a statement that would have been backed up by every Nationalist in Ireland, and the President changed his policy without in any way asking the opinion of the House. I do suggest, with all respect to the President and the Executive Council, that if necessary they could have a Secret Session of the Dáil to get the opinions of the representatives who could speak on behalf of the people. That was not done, negotiations were entered into, and now we are up against this proposition. Some say it is a question either of the Feetham line or the Bill, and others add the word "war." I say definitely that that is not the question, that the alternative is not war, that it is not right for anyone, either here or outside, to suggest it. There has been enough of intimidation of Nationalist opinion and of wild threats, and it is time it should be brought to an end. Responsible Ministers should be the last to suggest that we would be going on the road that would lead us to the sword.

Comment on this

What road will you go?

Comment on this

We will be up against an award that nobody seems to know anything about, but that everybody seems to be terribly afraid of. The Vice-President suggests that the award would be a question of the transfer of 20,000 Nationalists. You come to the position that you are facing the publication of that award, of which President Cosgrave said that if it were in accordance with the suggestion of the "Morning Post" it would be very unjust, would be very unfair, and would be a disregarding of all the facts. If you were going to have an award like that imposed would you not have to face it? I say that the country would face it, and that they would stand behind you and help you through, that every Deputy in every party would do so. If the Feetham Award were to be published and were to be pressed who would have the pressing to do? I am not going to question the truth of the statement that legally the British Government would be entitled to carry it through, but I do state this, that there are documents in the possession of the Free State Government that would show unmistakably what the opinions of the signatories to the Treaty, on this side and on the other side, were with regard to the Boundary. I say that if there was to be a new boundary that boundary was to be altered or fixed by two parties. The two parties were the signatories to the Treaty, and both those parties have documents in their possession showing unmistakably that the findings of the Commission were not in accordance with the expressed opinions of the signatories of the Treaty at the time of and after the signing. Will one of the parties come along in face of these documents and put into operation a new Boundary that is unfair and unjust and that both sides could prove unfair and unjust from the point of view of either? Why did you not face that if it had to be faced? Why had you not the courage to face it? No; we are to be asked to surrender, retreat from the Border, pay over our millions, and forget the Nationalists of the North. That is what comes to us of this bargain.

May I say a word now to the Deputies from Tirconaill? They come from a county where it was felt that the new Border would have an injurious effect, that they would lose certain territory. These Deputies were seized with a panic when that was suggested. I do not say that these Deputies were afraid only because they thought that their representation in this House would be reduced, that they would only have two or three representatives where six or seven are elected now, but I will say what I and what they know to be the truth, that they were not prepared to change from the liberty of the Free State to the tyranny beyond the Border. That is why they did not want to go over, and that is what they feared. But there is no protest from them now when it is proposed that the rest of Ireland is to abandon the Nationalists across the Border and leave them to their fate. I hope that a protest will come from these Deputies, that they will have some word to say urging us to stretch out our hands to save these people from the fate that they themselves wanted to be saved from.

Comment on this

Put up a constructive alternative and we will support you.

Comment on this

Deputy White suggests a constructive alternative. When the Government were considering what they ought to do in the very difficult situation that confronted them they did not even ask for a Secret Session so that the collective wisdom of the House might be put at their disposal, and one Deputy is supposed now to fling to the winds an alternative suggestion. When the Government knew the difficulties that confronted them they should have put their cards publicly on the table so that other people would know what they were to do. If the Feetham award were to be put into effect, would it be such a terrible tragedy for the Irish nation? I suggest, with all respect, even to the Tirconaill Deputies, that it would not be the tragedy to the Irish nation that this Treaty will be, and I put it to them that they should think of this question not, as Deputy Gorey said, from a parochial point of view, but from the national point of view, from the point of view of what is best for the whole Irish nation. We are now to think in terms of our own areas, and we are now to forget the Irish nation, one and indivisible. We are now going to do what no body of Irishmen ever did before, to dismember our country. There was handed down to the people of this generation an Irish nation, whole and undivided, and you across there are a party to the policy and are standing for the policy of the men who signed a document between Britain and this country that was a Treaty for the whole of Ireland, and not for a part of it. When you sign this you will never again be in a position to deal with any country and to say: "We stand for the whole Irish nation; we are the representatives of one Ireland." You cannot. You will have given it away in that document, and when you and the Dáil give it away it cannot be recalled.

Comment on this

The work we have to do now arises out of a situation which was a disappointment not merely to the Government and the people in the Free State but to a great number of Nationalists along the Border. It has been suggested by Deputy Baxter and others that that situation arose out of a tangle on the part of the Executive Council. I deny that entirely. I believe that once Judge Feetham was appointed the result of the Boundary Commission was as good as decided. Once we had a man who took a certain point of view—we did not know he would take it—and a certain attitude, it did not matter really what our representative on the Boundary Commission did. I believe it has been suggested that if Dr. MacNeill had been replaced by somebody else there would have been a different result, but I do not believe that in the least. A different representative from the Free State on the Boundary Commission might have left it sooner and under different circumstances, but the problem facing the State would have been essentially the same. When Dr. MacNeill left the Commission, and when we understood the two remaining Commissioners were going to proceed with their work, it was simply a question of alternatives, and it was, as has been said, a question of some such arrangement as this or war.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

War with whom?

Comment on this

War with Britain, presumably, in the end.

Comment on this

Was that ever stated?

Comment on this

I am stating it.

Comment on this

Was it ever stated to you in the negotiations?

Comment on this

No, but I am interpreting the situation. The Feetham award would have the force of law. Whatever one may think of their moral right there can be no doubt that the two remaining Commissioners were technically and legally competent to issue their award, and once they issued it it had the force of law. Areas were to be transferred from the Northern Government. The Northern police could not arrest a man in the area transferred without making themselves liable for an action for damages. They would be excluded from the areas transferred from them. Does anybody think in these circumstances that they would not have proceeded to enter into possession of the areas that were awarded to them? If we attempted to resist that we would certainly have an immediate condition of war, and I think there is very little doubt that we could not have avoided a flare up on the Boundary, even if we had done our best to effect a peaceful transfer, if the Northern people proceeded to enter into the territories awarded to them. A flare up on the Boundary could have no good results for either the Nationalists of the Six Counties or the Free State. I have no doubt that a serious flare up on the Boundary would have resulted in incidents something like those that occurred at Pettigo and Belleek. We might, perhaps, if there had been very great determination in the Free State to avoid any conflict, if there had been a very firm use of the powers of Government to give effect to the Feetham award, much as we dislike it, have succeeded in avoiding a blaze, and in avoiding the national loss and humiliation that I believe would have followed any blaze along the frontier. But would the condition of discontent and contention that would have followed everywhere along the Border have been good for the Nationalists who remained in?

Our first concern in this matter has been for the Nationalists of the Six Counties. We recognised all along that there was a certain risk in going ahead with the Boundary Commission, but we believed we had a duty to the people of the Six Counties. As long as we had any belief that the Boundary Commission was going to transfer a substantial number of people to the Free State who wanted to be transferred, it was our duty to go ahead with it. When the Commission failed, when the Article provided in the Treaty for bringing people under the Government they wished to be brought under failed, we had to consider what was the best thing we could do for them. We did not think it was any good producing a state of war which would damage them and damage us, and damage them more than us, because it is quite possible a blaze along the Border would have reactions and results elsewhere in the Six Counties. It would not have been any good for us to keep this Boundary problem over when there was no hope or possibility of getting the results we hoped for originally. Everyone knows that when there are attacks from outside, any State, any unit of Government, strengthens those in control there and makes their policy more extreme and bitter.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

It does not in this country.

Comment on this

Perhaps there are exceptions. It is not by keeping the Boundary there as a threat that we are going to bring about a reasonable attitude of mind in the North. Deputy Baxter spoke about a certain condition of things. He knows, and I have no hesitation in saying it, that things would never have been so bad in those areas if there had been no question of a change in the Boundary, no question of a transfer from the North. I believe this gerrymandering would not have occurred, or been carried to the extent it was, if there was not a question of transfer in the North. Whatever unsatisfactory conditions there were in the North they were worse in the Boundary areas. Deputy Johnson spoke as if the conditions mentioned by Deputy Baxter were normal in Belfast and neighbourhood. About a year ago I was up there, and I was on the roads day and night and I never was searched. I certainly think there has been exaggeration about these matters and there is nothing to be gained about exaggerating a case. Certain things have been bad in areas, and bad particularly in the Boundary areas. Once these people cannot be got into the Free State, once this provision in the Treaty has failed to have the effect we hoped it would have had, then I say there was nothing better that could have been done for the Nationalists of the Six Counties than to put the whole Boundary problem on one side and to bring to an end the irritation which that Boundary problem had in the North.

I am in agreement with a good deal of what Deputy Johnson said about the attitude of mind by the majority in the North, and I do not look for a great change in that atmosphere very speedily, but I think if we keep the threat of war up, if we keep any sort of threat such as was in the Boundary question hanging over the North continually, then there will be no improvement. We simply consolidate a certain attitude of mind in a certain Party there, and keep the old state of things in existence. I was one of those who had great hopes from this Boundary Commission. I never thought we were going to get Derry City, or some of the extreme things that Northern Nationalists thought, but I thought we would get big things from it, and I was anxious to use the lever the Treaty gave us. That has failed, and I do not believe in hanging on to some broken and useless tool. I am satisfied nothing will serve the people of the North better than to put this Boundary problem right behind us and face the facts. We must do that, and it is folly to refuse to recognise the changed conditions. Although one particular Party in the constituency I represent would have benefited by the Feetham line as compared with the present line, I regarded allowing the Feetham award to go on as a thing that was nationally too dangerous. Even if by a miracle we got through it peacefully it would leave the state of affairs for the Nationalists of the Six Counties generally worse than under the present Agreement.

I feel that the actual crisis that did arise as a result of the proposed award gave us the only opportunity we had of getting out of Article V. In its financial aspects I believe this Agreement is a very good bargain indeed. I remember when we first got the British claim under Article V. I was struck by its ominous moderation. The figure of the British claim was not arrived at on the basis of population. It was a figure, I may say, that might have been disputed from many aspects. It was simply a preliminary claim, and it was arrived at in this way.

The British took our figures on the yield of direct taxation, and they said that the yield of direct taxation might be taken as a rough guide to the taxable capacity of the country. I think that is a thing which, subject to modification, will be generally admitted. Then they took their own yield from direct taxation, income tax, stamps and death duties, and they made certain adjustments in both figures for abnormal features, and for difference of rates. When that was done it would seem that the yield from direct taxation in this country was one and a half per cent. of the British yield. They took then a figure for the National Debt, and they took a capitalised figure to represent the present value of war pensions. A sum, I think, of £850,000,000 was their estimate of the capital value of the war pensions, and they proposed to ask us to pay one and a half per cent. of that debt—the National Debt and the capitalised value of war pensions. That amounted to the figure which I gave yesterday. The estimate given in the House of Commons yesterday differed by a couple of millions. I presume the figures have been further looked into and revised since the demand was furnished to us.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

Would the Minister say on what year was this percentage of one and a half per cent. based?

Comment on this

The year 1923. As I say, allowances were made for abnormal features in it that might be disputed. Instead of 1.5 it might be 1.4, 1.3 or 1.6. It was simply a preliminary demand. It would have been easy for us to put up a much bigger counter-claim than £157,000,000, but I believe that before a neutral arbitrator our counter-claim for over-taxation might either have been wiped out completely or would, certainly, have been very drastically reduced, because the argument that would have been put up to a neutral arbitrator would have been that if there was over-taxation in the past it was reflected in the present taxable capacity of the country, in the impoverishment of the country, and that that was allowed for in the moderateness of the demand. He might not have accepted that and, on the other hand, he might have. My feeling is that while we would have contended that we were liable to pay nothing, I would have been prepared, if it had been my responsibility, when we reached that point, to have paid something, some substantial sum, rather than take the risks of arbitration. We seemed to have had a cast-iron case for the Feetham Commission but it was not accepted, and, however good we might have felt our case to be for exemption from any payment under Article V., we could not have been sure that a mutual arbitrator would have accepted our views. I myself feel that he certainly would have awarded something against us. Deputies should remember that if Mr. Churchill or his representatives had to speak before an arbitration court to determine the amount which was to be paid, they would have spoken in a very different voice than that in which he spoke when the matter was otherwise disposed of.

Comment on this

Does that apply on this side of the water also?

Comment on this

Absolutely. Suppose some sum had been levied against us, and if it had been something we could not pay and which would produce conditions here that would react on the economic conditions of Great Britain, I believe we would not have been pushed to pay. If, however, we were in the position that we were negotiating to get let off the amount awarded against us, we would have been in a disadvantageous position in any negotiations we might have to undertake with the British Government and, owing to the close commercial and economic conditions between the two countries, there was bound to be some financial or commercial point to be settled. Therefore this country, asking that it should be released from paying the sum awarded against it, would not be in a favourable position to keep its end up in any such negotiations. We would not, however, reach the point where there would be an award for some years. The mere completion of the best possible counter-claim which we could make would occupy another year or two.

We would have to bring in the most adverse set of factors, we would have to bring in everything we could possibly find to throw into the balance in our favour, when discussing the British claim. Attempts to get them to reduce it in advance would have to be brought into account. Attempts to show that the necessary expenditure was to be taken into account before the counter-claim arose and that their claim should be reduced, not only in regard to taxable capacity but as to necessary expenditure, would also have to be taken into account. I daresay that after the Feetham affair, we might have difficulty in agreeing on an arbitration, but we could not refuse to agree. We would be in a position of defaulters if a series of suitable names were put up and we refused to accept them. Meantime, once the Boundary question was out of the way, we would have an agitation in Great Britain for making the Free State pay. We have, in fact, had it to some extent in certain newspapers during the past few months. We would have had a much more continuous and vehement campaign for a number of years ahead and that would have injured the credit of this country. National borrowing might, perhaps, have been a half per cent. dearer than it otherwise would have been. That high rate for national borrowing would have its reactions in national life and during the period of negotiations with regard to Article V. we would be losing steadily.

If we came out in the end with nothing to pay under Article V., I believe we would have lost, through the weakening of our national credit and through the result of that weakening in our industrial life, a figure at least as great as that which we are undertaking to pay under this Agreement. There is another aspect of our undertaking to repay this amount which the British have paid for compensation. There was no obligation on the British Government under the Treaty to pay for compensation. They agreed after the Treaty, in which there was provision for our undertaking a part of the debt. They agreed, by way of assistance in a difficult situation, to undertake responsibility for that damage, but they made it clear all along that they were doing that as an act of grace and friendship and that they were paying no indemnity. After a war, it is only an enemy that has been pretty well beaten that pays an indemnity, and nobody can say that the British in the Anglo-Irish war were beaten to the extent that would justify anyone to expect the payment of an indemnity. The wiping out of Article V. would have given that payment, which the British agreed to after the Treaty, an entirely new character. If we did not agree to repay this sum, although they agreed to wipe out Article V., we would have been insisting that they should pay something in the nature of an indemnity. By wiping out Article V. we go back to the position as it was in December, 1921, and we say that it is a case of back to back. The British go out without any claim for money upon us and they go out without undertaking to pay anything to end the struggle. I think that is a very fair arrangement.

Comment on this

What about the ten per cent.?

Comment on this

This agreement will involve, as has been stated elsewhere, a payment of £250,000 a year for a period of sixty years. As, however, at present the British Government is liable for sums of about £900,000 no cash payment will fall due to be made until the 1st April, 1929.

Comment on this

Are we to understand that the cost to this country will be fifteen million pounds?

Comment on this

Will the Minister also explain the statement of Mr. Baldwin that there is to be an immediate payment of £150,000?

Comment on this

Not in cash. That will be a book transaction and will be taken off the amount which the British will be due to pay us within the next year or two under the existing compensation arrangements. It would be quite possible to raise the cash and pay it now, but that represents a rate of interest of about four and three-quarter per cent., and we could not borrow on that, so that it is cheaper to do it this way.

Comment on this

They would prefer to have cash down; so would I.

Comment on this

Now, with regard to the ten per cent., that, I think, will cost nothing like one million. I think it will be two or three hundred thousand pounds less than a million. This is a matter which did not entirely arise from the British side. There have been serious complaints here of the rigidity with which that Damage to Property Act was drawn. It was drawn at a time when we fancied that the civil war damage would amount to a great number of millions. All sorts of figures were suggested. We heard of houses being burned every day and about bridges being blown up, and it was often said that a house was worth £40,000 and that a bridge would cost £10,000 to repair. No exact calculations had been, or could be, made of the total amount of damage, and the most exaggerated views were held in regard to that amount. We thought that the country was in for a payment of a most crushing amount for compensation and in the Act we took the greatest possible care to restrict the claims which would fall on the Government and the amount which might be awarded. We feel that we were more rigid than was politic. I do not say that awards were unjustly small except in a few cases, but they were so small, for instance, that building operations were very greatly delayed. If the awards had been ten per cent. higher there is no doubt that a great deal more building than has been carried out would have been carried out, and that more employment would have been given. There was a claim by the British Government that certain people in whom they were interested had not been fairly treated. That had been a subject of discussion between them and us for some time. Certain types of representation, which were quite proper in themselves, have been received.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say if these representations that have been referred to were made by what is called the Northumberland Committee?

Comment on this

No, by the British Government. We have no connection with the Northumberland Committee. We know nothing about it. It was felt this was a case where we really might now, seeing the position of the country, decide to take a step which, if it had not been actually in contemplation, had been discussed by us before, a step that would lead to the carrying out of reconstruction which was delayed, and which would dispose of the feeling of discontent, and the sense of injustice that existed among our own supporters, as well as amongst people who were supporters of the British. It would also dispose of the claim that the people who were not sympathetic with us had been unjustly and unfairly treated. As a matter of fact, of this estimate of 10 per cent., amounting to about £700,000, only a small fraction really will be given to people who could be called "Southern Loyalists." I do not know what view may be taken of those people who are anxious to proclaim themselves Southern Loyalists, and who go under that name, but, broadly speaking, it will be given to our own citizens.

Comment on this

I want to know if the Minister for Finance will guarantee that the 6d. in the rates for five years under the Compensation Act will not be prolonged to pay this?

Comment on this

Is the Minister also aware that Mr. Baldwin, in the British House of Commons last night, made a statement as follows:—

"The Free State Government estimate that this increase will aggregate approximately to £1,000,000"?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

It would be better if Deputies waited until the Minister finished.

Comment on this

As I have some responsibility in this connection, may I say that I knew that something like £7,000,000 had been awarded already, and cases had not yet been heard. The difference between £700,000—the sum for which we would be responsible in the case of awards already given—and the other cases has arisen. It is reasonable to say that it might come to £1,000,000.

Comment on this

How is this to be adjusted? Is it to apply to every individual case and what is to be the effect upon future awards?

Comment on this

Cases will be considered by the courts in the future exactly as they have been since the Act was passed. The Minister for Finance will shortly introduce a Bill entitling him to issue in respect of every award and report made for property, buildings and furniture——

Comment on this

On reports?

Comment on this

Does that include consequential loss?

Comment on this

No. Within the corners of that Damage to Property Act there is to be 10 per cent. in Compensation Bonds.

Comment on this

That is to say, that the courts will continue to work within the limits of that Act?

Comment on this

And that afterwards the Minister will be directed to add 10 per cent. to every such award?

Comment on this

That will not apply necessarily to reports where there is discretion. The amounts awarded will be increased by 10 per cent. There is this distinction between report cases and awards: A report has been received for, say, £100. There is no appeal in reports, because there is discretion to the Minister for Finance to pay less. There may be a report case in which £100 was awarded, which was reduced in the Department of Finance to £50. What will happen now will be that the Minister for Finance will be given discretion to pay £110, but he will not be compelled to pay more than he has adjudged to be the correct amount. That is as to report cases. As to awards, he had to pay the amount of the awards and he will have to pay 10 per cent. in addition now.

Comment on this