We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

TREATY (CONFIRMATION OF AMENDING AGREEMENT) BILL, 1925—SECOND STAGE (RESUMED DEBATE).

Contributions 165–322 of 322. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Treaty (Confirmation of Amending Agreement) Bill, 1925
Enacted

No. 51 of 1925 ›

If this Bill passes, in its present form, would not the Minister be bound to pay 10 per cent. on every award?

Comment on this

Yes, on every award.

Comment on this

And on every report?

Comment on this

Every sum of money which comes within the Damage to Property (Compensation) Act must inevitably be increased if this Bill becomes law?

Comment on this

Not every sum paid. Every award and every report must be increased, but the discretion which exists in the Minister for Finance to reduce the amount payable on report is not affected.

Comment on this

Then he may give it with one hand and take it away with the other.

Comment on this

Say that X is the amount in respect of a house, Y the amount in respect of furniture, and Z the amount in respect of the report. The Minister, in considering Z, has a right to review the circumstances. He can pay three-fourths of Z, or half Z, or he may not pay Z at all. Whatever the amount that would discharge his liability in respect of that, 10 per cent. is added automatically.

Comment on this

How will that be known? When the Minister has made his payment, according to his discretion under the Act, then he must, according to this, add 10 per cent.?

Comment on this

Is not all this discussion anticipating the new Bill that must be introduced?

Comment on this

The Minister has not answered me about the 6d. on the rates. Would the Minister for Finance guarantee that this 6d. will not be prolonged?

Comment on this

I would not guarantee anything about that 6d. In fact, I have heard people already advocating the making of that 6d. permanent. I have not any ideas on that either. But the 6d. is not affected by this. I think that there is very little value in the sort of talk that we have heard about the selling of the Six Counties, and about throwing them to the wolves and all that sort of thing.

Comment on this

It was heard in 1918.

Comment on this

In any case, it really is a question of alternatives and no alternative has been suggested. Deputy Magennis suggested a Coalition Government, but that is not an alternative policy.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this

The Deputy suggested that if a man were blindfolded and put at the foot of the stairs to select a Government, he might find himself President.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I did not correct the Minister for External Affairs because I did not want to interrupt him. I spoke, in my speech on the Second Reading, of what could have occurred, when a situation arose out of the chronic ineptitude of the Government with regard to the Feetham Commission. I did not suggest that it was an alternative after the mess had been made by this signed Agreement in London. Now, facts are facts, and nothing is to be gained by perverting statements which are on record.

Comment on this

I should not think of perverting any statements of the Deputy. I like them in their original beauty. Another Deputy suggested the removal of the particular clause of the Treaty which deals with the Oath. I certainly for one do not think that any benefit would accrue to the country from a policy directed along that line. I think that if that clause were removed there would be no gain, and it is not a clause that would be as easy to remove as clauses that have practical importance.

Deputy Baxter said that nobody could be expected to suggest a policy in public here. I know that nobody could be expected to tell all the details of a policy here, but nobody has given even a hint of a policy. I think, in all the opposition to this particular measure, there has been no thought of what could be done instead of it. Deputy Johnson did criticise the clause of it which relates to the abolition of the Council of Ireland. But, certainly, as far as I remember, he gave no time to the suggestion of alternatives to the Agreement as a whole.

With regard to the Council of Ireland, I would just like to say, that for my part, I always thought that once the Boundary Commission and the Boundary issue were disposed of, that, even if we were to get nothing for it, we ought to abandon the Council of Ireland. My position has been that once the Boundary issue was disposed of, we ought to aim, as a National policy, at the cultivation of good relationship with the Government and people of the North. In pursuance of that, I would have been perfectly willing, at any time, once the Boundary question was out of the way, and without any consideration in return being given to us, to give them the Council of Ireland if they desired it, because I believe it was a body which would have done no good and might have done harm. My view certainly is that the Chairman would have been appointed in reality by the British Government. He was to have been appointed by the Lord Lieutenant, on the instructions of His Majesty. I believe that, in existing circumstances, he would probably have been appointed by the King direct. If he were not appointed by the King direct, and if he were appointed by the Governor-General, his appointment would certainly be on directions and instructions from the British Government, which would mean that the appointment would have rested in the hands of the British Government. I believe that the position then would have been that you would have a body half of whose members were Northern representatives, with a Chairman appointed by the British Government dealing solely with Northern matters. I believe that the Chairman, as the Council of Ireland would deal solely and entirely with matters concerning Northern Ireland, would have been obliged to vote for Northern Ireland and would have voted for Northern Ireland on every occasion, even though he had no feelings in regard to either side and was perfectly neutral and impartial.

Comment on this

Does the Minister assume that there would be two compact bodies always in opposition?

Comment on this

Necessarily, because we would have members from a Parliament, in which there were no Northern representatives, going there to interfere in business relating to Northern Ireland. That would have been a thing that anybody in Northern Ireland would resent, and naturally resent. It would be resented in the same way as the interference of Great Britain in the affairs of her Colonies was resented as they grew up. The result would be a Northern phalanx, which would have been kept solid by our members going there. It would have acted, to a small extent, as an irritant but not as an irritant so great that the people of the North would give anything to get rid of it. As to the idea that they would give it additional powers, I think that is wholly chimerical and wholly ridiculous. I think that what would have happened would be that if we did not want to do harm we would ask our representatives never to go there and we would have agreed to making the quorum smaller than the number of Northern representatives, so that the work of this Council would not be made an occasion of mischief.

I do not think it is by this artificial method of imposing certain political machinery on the country that any unity is going to be got. I believe unity is only going to result in two ways— firstly, by letting the Northern people alone, by letting them go their own way, by letting the responsibilities and difficulties of government do their work in breeding a toleration and a moderation greater than exists at present; and, secondly, by doing our business well here, by advancing industry, by having good government, by having a condition of affairs here that they will feel that there is a definite material gain to them in joining us. Somebody said that, perhaps, before long, new powers would be sought by the Northern Government, and that they would be granted, because we were allowing new powers to go to them under this Agreement. I do not object to that in the least. I think that nothing at all is going to be gained in the future by interference, by restrictions, or by crabbing. We have now reached a point when we must look to a sort of process of evolution to work; we must look for the two parts of Ireland to be brought together again by economic and commercial forces and by the operation of the geographic factor. We know that nations like Germany, which were split up, came together in a particular way.

Comment on this

Like Prussia.

Comment on this

No. The union of Germany was begun on certain economic lines. We know that the States of South Africa came together in a certain way. They came together by a certain economic process.

Comment on this

And by equality.

Comment on this

And by equality.

Comment on this

They had a bond.

Comment on this

The old idea which seems to be in Deputy Baxter's mind— the idea of carrying on a struggle, when a struggle is impossible, or of carrying on a process of recrimination when recrimination is ineffectual—will do us no good whatever. We must look at the whole thing now. Whether we have been given reason for being generous or not, we must look at the matter in a generous way. We must trust in the future. We must trust in the factors that have done away, in most parts of the world, with the forces of bigotry and intolerance that existed a century or two centuries ago. I do not believe there is any area which can escape the effect of processes which are working throughout the whole world.

Comment on this

I beg to move that the Dáil adjourn for an hour to hear a deputation from Northern Ireland.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I will accept a motion from the Deputy that the Dáil adjourn for an hour.

Comment on this

To hear a deputation from Northern Ireland.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

If the Deputy had let me put the question, it would have been better. Manifestly the motion is a contradiction in terms.

Comment on this

The events that have taken place for some time in relation to the Boundary problem are certainly not a source of gratification to any of us. Those events and certain phases of the present Agreement certainly give rise to an ardent desire to find an alternative. The point is: can an alternative be found which would be more advantageous to the country than the present Agreement? Any alternative put forward at this juncture should have in it a total abolition of the Boundary and the creation of good will, and should, in a concrete way, show some advantage from the point of view of the future prosperity of the country. The present Agreement certainly does make the unity of the country appear far nearer than if the Boundary was determined by the supposed Feetham-Fisher report. We have heard Deputies opposing this Agreement which was signed by our Ministers in London and they have done it because they stand to-day as supposed patriots. I would put the question to Deputy Baxter, Deputy Johnson, Deputy T. O'Connell and Deputy Magennis: what was their record in the fight for independence? They can come here and give their opinions, just like the men in 1922-23 who stood on the mountains and fired an odd shot at the Free State Army. They stand there firing an odd shot at the Executive Council for entering into the Agreement reached in London, but they do not come down to hard facts, face the position and say what is the alternative to the supposed Feetham-Fisher report, if it had been issued. What is their alternative to that? Their alternative is: "Let us have a fight."

Comment on this

Who said that?

Comment on this

That is the only alternative. Will the Deputy tell me what is the alternative?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Let Deputy Vaughan proceed.

Comment on this

The alternative is: "Let us have a war; let us have a fight." I wonder where will Deputy Johnson, Deputy Magennis, Deputy Baxter and Deputy T. O'Connell go when the fight will start.

Comment on this
A DEPUTY

To Cork.

Comment on this

They will come to Cork for shelter. They will make sure that they will not stand the brunt of their responsibility—they will not stand the fight. They will try and encourage some of the dupes to carry on a fight, to upset the country and bring it into chaos, just as occurred in 1922-23. In last Monday's newspapers I read a statement from the so-called Republicans that the Deputies who would vote for this Agreement were traitors to their country. I can tell you that the traitors to the country are those who say now that we will have permanent partition. In 1921, when the original Treaty was signed, Mr. de Valera stood out and took the opportunity of going through the country, instead of sticking to his post, like the late General Collins, and bringing about unity, which could have been brought about at that time, and prosperity to Ireland.

In voting for this Bill, I believe I am voting for a measure that more than any other will eventually secure the unity and prosperity of Ireland by eliminating friction, inviting co-operation, and creating good-will. As it appears in the Press, it would look to the plain people of the country as if those who have spoken against this Agreement were patriots; that they were people who had a record; who stood out for independence. They always stood as they stand to-day, dictating to the people, but the people know their own business very well.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Deputy must address himself to the Agreement and not to the Deputies who have spoken against it. He will get us into very serious trouble if he continues on that line.

Comment on this

He will if he goes in that direction. He has already gone a good way.

Comment on this

I accept your ruling. The Agreement reached by the Minister is, I think, favoured by the people of Cork county. They see no other alternative. The Deputies who have spoken against it have not put up an alternative to that Agreement, and, therefore, I see no other way out of it but to take it in good will and accept the Agreement, because I feel that nothing further can be got through this generation, either by Republicans, Free Staters, or anybody else. They let down the independence of Ireland when they called a truce in 1921. Mr. de Valera ignored the fact of negotiations going on and he went around the country with the intention of creating disturbance. Whether he was told to do so or not remains to be seen. He went down the country inspecting the flying columns instead of attending to his duties as a leader of the State. Now he turns round and says to the Irish people: "We have permanent partition." I repudiate his statement, and I say we have not permanent partition by any means. The people who oppose this Agreement have said we have permanent partition. I say we have not, and that if an alternative can be found it should have in it the total abolition of the Boundary and the creation of good-will, and should, in a concrete way, show its advantages to the country as regards future prosperity. I am wholeheartedly in support of the Agreement signed by our Ministers in London.

Comment on this

Ceist mhór 'seadh í seo agus baineann sí le muinntear na hEireann, ní híad amhain na daoine atá annso fé lathair ach na daoine a bhéas ann 'san aimsír atá le teacht. Ba choír dúinn an cheist seo do scrúdú go cúramach agus go ciúin, mar ceist a bhaineas leis an tír ar fad 'seadh í. Bhí súil ag muinntear na hEireann ó'n chéad uair—na céadta bliadhain ó shoin—a thainig na Sasanaigh isteach go mbeadh Eire saor agus go mbeadh Eire gan roinn. Do throid siad ar son Eireann agus dibrigheadh thar sáile mór-chuid aca. Tá níos mó eoluis ar na nidhthe seo ag an Teachta ó'n Stát seo a bhí ar an gCoimisiún ná mar atá agam-sa, mar bhí sé 'na shár ollamh ar stair agus seanchas na hEireann.

Fuair cuid de chrainn chosanta na h-Eireann bás agus díbrigheadh cuid eile thar sáile. D'imthigheadhar go dtí an Spáinn agus go dtí an Róimh. Nuair a bhí an t-Uachtarán thall 'san Róimh le déidheanaighe chaith sé seal ag uaige-anna Flatha Thírchonnail agus Thír Eoghain. B'iad náimhde d'ár dtír a dhíbir na daoiní seo thar fairrage agus is iad na náimhde cheudna a rinne an roinn so. Rinneadh é in aghaidh toil na ndaoine. B'fhéidir go bhféadfaidís a rádh ná raibh aon léigheas air agus nach bhfuil an spiorad a bhí ins na daoiní san am atá thart ionnta anois. Ach níl ann ach leith-sgeul. Rinne na Teachtaí a chuaidh anonn go Lonnduin socrú agus is é an rud a dheinfeas an socrú sin ná an tír a roinnt. Rinne siad sin ar a d-toil féin. Is ceart agus is cóir smaininú ar an sgeul so. Deirtear ins an bpáipéir atá os ar gcomhair go bhfuil muinntear. Shasana agus muinntir Uladh cáir-deamhail linn. Ma's fíor an sgeul sin, goidé an fáth nach ndeinnean siad gníomh dá réir? Bhí go leór cainnte 'san tír seo ceithre bliana ó shoin mar gheall ar an gconnradh a rinneadh í lár na h-oidhche an t-sam san. Ach ma bhí locht ar an socrú san i dtaobh ceist na teorann, tá locht seacht n-uaire níos measa ar an socrú so.

Mar adubhradh cheana, de réir an chonnartha so is féidir an dhá Rialtas a thabhairt le chéile. Nílím á rádh nach maith an rud Rialtas Uladh agus Rialtas an t-Saorstáit a thabhairt le chéile. Ach tá fhios ag an domhan mhór anois go raibh lúb ar lár 'san gconnradh a rinneadh ceithre bliana no cúig bliana ó shoin. Goidé an fáth nach ndeárn siad an socrú ceart 'san airtiogal so nuair a bhí an spiorad cho maith in a measg?

Do réir tuarasgbhála Pháirliminte Shasana ar pháipéar an lae indhiu, is dócha go mbéidh ar ar d-Teachtaí dul anonn annsin arís agus módh eile a cheapadh chun muinntear na h-Eireann a thabhairt le chéile.

Deirim fosta go bhfuilim go láidir in aghaidh an rúin seo—airgead a íoc mar gheall ar an sgrios a rinne na Dubh-Chronaigh. Ní raibh aon cheart acu cogadh a dheunamh ar an tír seo agus nuair a chuir siad cogadh orainn ba chóir dóibh íoc as. Bhí an t-airgead san íoctha cheana——

Comment on this

Cuid de; ní raibh an méid uilig ioctha.

Comment on this

Bhí cuid mhaith íoctha ag Muinntir Shasana agus anois támuid chun é a ath-íoc leo. Agus tá taobh eile ar an sgeul. Dubhairt Teachta ó Chonnde na h-Iar Mhidhe go raibh dha mhiliún punt ag teacht isteach 'san tír seo mar phinsuin do na daoinibh a throid san Cogadh. Ach, do réir Uachtarain Phairliminte Shasana, tá tri nó ceithre mhiliún punt le díol ag an tír seo le dhaoiní nach bhfuil in a g-comhnuidhe in Eirinn. Tá cuid mhaith de'n mhéid sin ag dul do na sean-philéirí nó R.I.C. Bhi mé go láidir in agaidh na n-daoine a dhibirt as an tír. Be mo thuairim go mba ceart dearmad a dheunamh ar ar thuit amach nuair a rinneamar an Connradh. Tá a lán de na sean-philéiribh seo in a g-comhnuidhe thall i Sasana agus, do réir mar chluinim, tá cuid acu "ar an run," mar adearfa ó fhiacha a bhí orra ag siopadóirí annseo. Ní shílim gur ceart na daoiní seo a leigint saor, má tá an ceart agam i dtaobh an sgeil.

I did not intend to address the Dáil at such length in Irish, but I got carried away. We want to approach this question in as cool and dispassionate a manner as we possibly can, far away from personalities. I have listened with great anxiety to the speeches that have been delivered on this question. Apart from any feelings I may have on this question, there are two Deputies in this House to whom I would wish to pay a compliment. I refer to Deputies Cooper and Thrift. They showed by their speeches that they have a real and abiding interest in this country, and that they are true patriots. I may differ from them on this question, but that does not lessen the respect I have for them.

There is, however, one particular in which I have to differ with Deputy Cooper. I was very moved by the sentiment of his speech. He stated that he was here, along with the representatives of Trinity College, representing a minority. That is not the case. Deputy Cooper would be elected on his merits in County Dublin regardless of any opinions or associations he may have had in the past. That is also true of the representatives of Trinity College who, even since this Dáil first came together under the Treaty, have been most helpful members of this Assembly. I would not refer to this matter at all were it not that the feeling has gone forth that we who take a strong line on this question are moved by hate. Such is not the case. We are moved to do here and in the country what we think is in the best interests of Ireland, and jibes from Deputies, or misrepresentations inside or outside this Assembly, will not divert us from the course which we think is right.

I wish to refer to the position at the time of this Treaty settlement. The Treaty, as you are aware, was approved by Dáil Eireann, the Constituent Assembly of the Irish people. Technically it was necessary for the Treaty to go before a meeting of the representatives elected for Southern Ireland. The members of the Dáil elected for the Southern constituencies were the same identical men, with a few ladies thrown in, and with the addition of four members representing Trinity College. The oath taken in Dáil Eireann— it is taken from the record of Dáil Eireann, page 151—was as follows:—

I, A.B., do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I do not and shall not yield a voluntary support to any pretended Government, authority or power within Ireland hostile and inimical thereto, and I do further swear (or affirm) that to the best of my knowledge and ability I will support and defend the Irish Republic and the Government of the Irish Republic, which is Dáil Eireann, against all enemies, foreign and domestic, and I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same, and that I take this obligation without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion, so help me, God.

That oath was taken by us, as the representatives of the Irish people at the time. In accepting the Treaty, we did what we considered was the best thing for Ireland. At the first meeting of the Provisional Parliament a member who had not been in Dáil Eireann stated that he would have taken that Republican oath and come into Dáil Eireann for the purpose of approving of the Treaty between Great Britain and Ireland because he thought it was the best thing for Ireland. In order to explain my position in this matter, I will quote the following statement that I made in Dáil Eireann on the 22nd December, 1921: "I support the Treaty because I feel in my heart and soul that to support the Treaty is the best thing for Ireland." I am still of that opinion, but I did not support a Treaty which was to be whittled away either at the dictates of Sir James Craig or of the English people. I supported it on the principle that it was supported by the late Arthur Griffith, "that this Treaty was not a final settlement any more than this was the final generation of Irishmen," or in the words of the late General Collins, that "this Treaty gave us freedom to achieve freedom." When this question arose last week, while the President and the other members of the Executive Council were away in London, I knew, and every Deputy knew, how serious it was. The matter was raised after Questions by Deputy Johnson and was spoken to by different Deputies. Every Deputy who spoke did so in a helpful manner, and Deputies outside the Dáil also spoke in a helpful manner. I, who have no hate in my soul, believe, and I stated it here, that if the Treaty was changed it ought to be made possible for every Deputy elected by the people to be free to come in here and take his place in the Dáil.

Comment on this

Settle the Ulster question first.

Comment on this

We will settle the Ulster question too. As the President well knows, and as every Deputy knows, the best way to bring about a settlement of the Ulster question, of the oath question, or of any other question is to have the people of Ireland behind you. We talk in this settlement of peace, of amity, of good-will, and I see by this day's papers that a further word is added, "concord." but if we are to have concord and peace why should we not have peace all round? As I stated, your strength lies in having the people of Ireland behind you and it should be the effort of every Deputy in this assembly to have the people of Ireland behind it. Reference has been made to what is termed the Feetham line. Evidently no one knows what the Feetham line is. Is it fair to the country to hold an imaginary sword over the heads of the people? Should not the Irish people, whom this concerns intimately, be informed as to what the Feetham line is? It is also beside the question to introduce threats of war.

Comment on this

From friends.

Comment on this

There is no necessity for war. We do not want war, and I do not think the people of England want war, and as it was stated that these people had come together like sucking doves, where is the war to come from?

Comment on this

From our friends.

Comment on this

I am only a plain farmer. I do not know a great deal about high finance, but when I see statements issued from both sides, each claiming this is a good bargain, I think there must be something wrong. If I bought a beast in a fair and said when I got home that I had a good bargain, I would be comfortable enough until the story reached me from the other side: "That man knows nothing about the price of cattle. He gave once and a half times the value of the beast. I had the best of the bargain." Last Thursday I said here that Ireland's claim under this Article V. was far larger than the claim of the British, and that statement has been taken exception to by the Minister for External Affairs. We discussed this thing during the Treaty debates, and my authority for that statement is the late General Collins. A number of Deputies have referred to this payment of four or five million pounds for the settlement of the claims arising out of the excesses of the Black-and-Tans. I protest against a payment of that kind being made on behalf of the Irish nation, because it is an admission that the war of the Black-and-Tans was a just war, that we were in the wrong, and that we have to pay up for its costs. Deputy Shaw says that something like two millions was coming into the country in pensions for people who had served in the European war.

Comment on this

I said three millions— two and a quarter millions, and the administrative costs.

Comment on this

We have to-day, if the "Irish Independent" reports him correctly, a statement from Mr. Baldwin, the Prime Minister of England, that between three and four millions were annually paid by Ireland as an external debt. This sum was made up of Irish land purchase annuities and pensions paid to ex-R.I.C. men and civil servants who had gone out under an Article of the Treaty. I have stated frequently in public that I was strongly opposed to the attitude——

Comment on this

I would like to know if it is in order for a Deputy to repeat in English a speech in Irish in precisely the same terms?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

It is in order.

Comment on this

I have no text of the speech; I am just speaking from memory. I was strongly opposed to the attitude of the men who drove out the ex-R.I.C. men, because I thought when the Treaty was settled that people ought to forgive others for their past political sins, and I realised that the expenditure of the money granted in pensions to these people would be of considerable use and benefit to this country. But I have been given to understand, whether I am rightly informed or not I do not know, that a number of these ex-R.I.C. men who went out of Ireland on the run are resident in England, and that the pensions do not come directly to them but are paid through the Colonial Office. A large number of these men are on the run for reasons other than fear; they are on the run from debts incurred in this country, and it is altogether unfair to business people here that these men are not traced and made to meet their liabilities. We had under the Treaty settlement the unity of Ireland acknowledged, but under the proposed Articles of Agreement we have permanent and definite partition.

Comment on this

And so you had under the Treaty.

Comment on this

No, you had the unity of Ireland acknowledged. It was after the acceptance of the Treaty that the Six Counties opted out. I am opposed also, as were other Deputies, to the increase of 10 per cent. on compensation awards. It was stated by the President that there were pretty general complaints throughout the country at the smallness of the awards in the case of post-truce claims. If the President were a country Deputy he would have heard a far larger volume of complaints against the awards made by the Compensation (Ireland) Commission, and as I am on that matter, I might mention that the amounts of the awards made by that Commission were largely exaggerated in England. It was stated by Lord Carson in the English House of Lords that I received £4,000 compensation when in reality I was only paid £2,217.

Comment on this

Was there a reinstatement decree?

Comment on this

It was all included in that. The granting of this 10 per cent. is an admission by our Government that our judges were biased in giving these awards.

Comment on this

I corrected that before. I do not think it is fair to say that anything in connection with the administration of that Act was wrong. I regret very much having to intervene to correct it again.

Comment on this

I am sorry if I have said anything discourteous to the President.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

It is not a question of discourtesy to the President; it is a question of discourtesy to the judges. The President's explanation, which relieves the judges and relieves the President, is this: that the judges administered the Act as the Act was drawn. The President admits the Act was drawn very tightly. It might be necessary to make that clear so that we would not have criticism of the judges here in the House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. P. HOGAN (An Clár) Labour Party

Are we obliged to refrain from any criticism of the ten per cent. increase in compensation?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Deputy is obliged to refrain from making any comment upon the judges and the judges' awards. Criticism of the President to almost any degree is in order.

Comment on this

I frankly accept that position, but the judgments of the Compensation (Ireland) Commission were also tightly drawn. We are told to be practical men. It is time that we should be practical and not be looking to the green hills far away. In Clause V. of this Agreement it is stated that the Government of Northern Ireland and the Saorstát shall meet, but there is no provision in the wide world by which they are to meet and no arrangement made for their meeting. We heard a lot of denunciation during the last three or four years of the hurried Treaty signed at midnight in London in December, 1921. There was no great hurry about this. You had friendly cooperation. You had amity, goodwill, and concord existing amongst them, and it is strange in the light of the experience of the last Treaty, whereby three or four different interpretations might be placed on different clauses of that Treaty, to send before us a document that is far more vague and more indefinite than any of the clauses in the original Treaty.

This is a matter, whilst we are against most things in the Agreement, that there is no great hurry about. There is peace and goodwill all round. It is important that there should be some definite machinery found for bringing the two Parliaments together, and the place where the Parliaments could meet should be arranged and some definite machinery found. Pious opinion, if it is not put into action, is only simply throwing dust in the eyes of the public. As far as I have seen the settlement, it is no wonder that Sir James Craig should be satisfied. He did not budge an inch and he got everything he wanted. It reminds me a good deal of a rhyme I heard some time ago:

There was a young lady of Niger Who smilingly rode on a tiger;

They returned from the ride With the lady inside

And the smile on the face of the tiger.

You had amity and good-will. I cannot say what about concord. All the gain is on the other side, and the poor lady is done away with. President Cosgrave recently paid a visit to Europe.

Comment on this

I am in it yet.

Comment on this

He visited the shrines in which lie the remains of the Northern Princes who were banished from their native land at one of the saddest periods in Irish history—The Flight of the Earls. They lie there far away from their native land. I call on you, shades of the Great O'Neills and the Great O'Donnells, to watch what we are asked to do to-day in the name of Ireland. There was some time ago a matter which stirred up the minds of the people of this country. I refer to the fight for compulsory Irish. There was a statement made at that time by a distinguished Irishman. He said: "If we are going to have the Confederation of Kilkenny over again, I shall be found on the side of Owen Roe." That is my position in the matter. That is where I stand, because I believe and am firmly convinced that if this Agreement is ratified we will be guilty of the biggest act of national degradation that has occurred in history.

Comment on this

Would you agree to Donegal being cut up?

Comment on this

I do not.

Comment on this

The Deputy is interested in Tyrone, but he does not care whether Donegal is cut up or not.

Comment on this

With my limited vocabulary and lack of facility of expression I have no desire to attempt to emulate those of my colleagues endowed with those gifts, but in the grave question that is presented to An Dáil I cannot content myself with a silent vote. I came to Dublin on Monday morning with an open mind, determined to find out on which side the balance of advantage lay for our country.

I have seen and heard a good deal for the past three days, and, having weighed and balanced what I have seen and heard, I have now no difficulty in casting my vote. I did not come to see on which side the cat was jumping, and I did not come out of mere curiosity. I have come, simply and solely, to do my duty to my longsuffering country to the best of my judgment. Heroics, not uncommon in this country, are generally rather cheap and seldom have much substance in them, and, though not devoid of sentiment, I cannot forget that our people from time immemorial have been hugging shadows and missing the substance, and I should be very sorry to see them continuing this foolish habit. Now for a personal note. I consented, with grave reluctance, to represent the commercial community of Cork city. After stressing the fact that I was not a politician, and that they could easily find a more suitable representative, I failed, unfortunately for myself, to impress my friends, and here I am, and here I have been for the past few years attending as best I could under existing circumstances, but, I regret to say, cutting little ice, to use an expressive phrase. Our Ministry has not yet given serious thought to the vital economic questions that confront them. The first essential to their doing so is to make themselves fully acquainted with the conditions in the country, and this acquaintance cannot be had through minor officials posing as experts in matters with which they have never have had anything to do. On this particular point I will content myself for the present with saying that there are men in this country capable of carrying on successfully the country's business if they only get the support and encouragement which they ought to receive, notwithstanding Ministerial opinion to the contrary. In order to redeem my promise to you, sir, not to occupy the time of the House unduly, I repeat, from what I have seen and heard for the past three days, and especially last evening, from the plain, practical commonsense speech of Deputy Professor O'Sullivan, I could not do violence to my judgment by voting against this Agreement.

Comment on this

I do not like to cast a silent vote in respect to this very unpleasant duty which confronts the whole of us. I would like to point out that I was delighted to see President Cosgrave and Sir James Craig sitting in round-table conference threshing out the destinies of their country. I was also delighted this evening beyond measure, to read in the "Evening Herald" that the first consignment of the fruits of their meeting has arrived. It is stated that the political prisoners in Belfast, or wherever they are, are to have their sentences reviewed by an English Minister. That English Minister has sent them this word as a matter of peace, and, so far as my judgment goes, I think that these prisoners will soon find things going well for them. The report, in addition, mentions that he is very grateful to the B Specials, who rendered great service. Now that he is getting rid of them, that tells us that there is some mutual understanding on some cemented basis between himself and President Cosgrave. There is no natural Boundary in this country. There is only a boundary of misunderstanding, and there has been for years, what I might call, propaganda from one side or the other to keep the people apart. I say that if the people in the twenty-six counties and in the six counties follow the lead of President Cosgrave and Sir James Craig this imaginary Boundary will disappear. Clever men could speak on this subject for three weeks and at the finish it would all fine itself down to a sensible speech of five minutes. Are we going to accept the Feetham line, as pointed out by Deputy O'Maille? Ten or twelve days ago there was a bigger scare in the country over it than there would have been had all the lions in the Zoo got loose. If we do not vote for the arrangement come to last week we will have the Feetham lion at large and we will still have a Boundary. I hold that if we do not vote for the pact entered into between the President and the gentlemen across the pond we will have the Feetham line obtaining and we will have the Six-County area extended into the most fertile parts of Donegal where the best towns and some very important concessions would be taken from us. To avert this danger, I, for one, have made up my mind to support the President's motion. I cannot find anything more to say because during the last three days the whole language has been eaten up.

Comment on this

I will try to follow the example of the last speaker in regard to his brevity, but I cannot hope to follow him as regards his humour. As a rule, I do not trouble the Dáil with statements on higher politics. I confine myself, as a rule, to economics and business matters and leave the questions of higher policy to those who have more experience and greater practice in the examination of such subjects than I. I do not like to give a vote on this matter which might be construed as a vote of full confidence in the Government without explaining my point of view. I might say at the start that I intend to vote for the Agreement, but I give that vote reluctantly, and with many reservations. I give it not in support of the policy which led up to the settlement, but because of three reasons which I have turned over in my mind, and which decided me that the only course open to me is to vote for this settlement. The first reason is, I believe that, in the circumstances—and when I say circumstances I mean the immediate circumstances and not the circumstances as they were spoken of by Deputy Professor O'Sullivan last night, I refer to the circumstances which have surrounded this matter within the last couple of weeks—they have made the best settlement they were able to obtain. I do not say the best settlement which might be obtained, but the best they were able to obtain. In the second place, I am not prepared to face the alternative—the alternative of accepting the Feetham line and the consequent acceptance of Article V., or the other alternative of repudiation of the Treaty. I am not prepared to accept these alternatives. A further reason is that from the information I have gathered I believe it is the opinion and the wish of the majority of my constituents that I should support this Agreement.

I regard the policy of the Government in the past, the policy which led up to the impasse in which they found themselves a couple of weeks ago, as deserving of the greatest condemnation. I was in love at no time with the Boundary Commission, and I did not believe that any good would result from it, but the Government and the members of the Executive Council did. They seemed to believe that eventual benefits would result from it, and that large numbers of the minority in the North would have been saved from the present unsatisfactory position in which they find themselves. Statement after statement was made to that effect by members of the Government. Statements were made that the Government's interpretation of the Treaty appointing the Commission was that the wishes of the inhabitants would be the first and governing clause in the deliberations of the Commission. The people of Ireland and the people of the North were led to believe that the findings of the Commission would be satisfactory, and that those minorities would find themselves in a safe position and that they would be brought under the Government of the Saorstát. The Government appointed Deputy Professor MacNeill to act as their representative on the Boundary Commission. I am not prepared to deal here to-night with his capabilities or his capacity to act on that Commission.

I am not well enough acquainted with Deputy Professor MacNeill to form an estimate of the qualities which he possesses in that direction, but I do state that no matter who was appointed by the Government to act on this Commission they should have seen that there was a definite understanding between the Executive Council and their representative as to the interpretation of the Article he was sent to deal with. It would appear from the development of circumstances since that appointment that there was no understanding whatever between the Executive Council and Deputy Professor MacNeill as to the interpretation of the terms of reference which are contained in Article XII., because if Deputy Professor MacNeill had gone into the Commission and said that the first requirement was that a common understanding should be arrived at between the Commissioners as to the terms of reference, if this common understanding could not be arrived at the Commission could not go on. I say that if the humblest member of the Dáil were sent into a Commission to deal with a matter of that kind his first consideration would be that there should be a common understanding as to the terms of reference. There does not appear to have been an understanding. The Commissioners appear to have been working in different directions. Deputy Professor MacNeill and the others appear to have been working with different ideas as to the powers and rights they had under Article XII.

What would have happened if there had been an attempt to arrive at an understanding? Deputy Professor MacNeill would have said: "My interpretation of Article XII. is that the Boundary is to be fixed according to the wishes of the inhabitants. That is to be the first consideration, and the economic and geographical considerations are to be minor considerations. Secondly, my instructions are that the terms of reference should not be so construed that any portion of the Saorstát can be amalgamated with Northern Ireland." If Deputy Professor MacNeill had taken that stand the inevitable result would have been that the Commission could not have gone on with its business, because the other members apparently had another outlook and a different interpretation of this Article. The result would be that the Commission would not have deliberated and come to findings. They would be faced with the position that nothing had resulted from the Commission, and we would not have established definitely as we now have a Boundary between the North and South.

Great joy has been expressed lately in every quarter as to the Agreement come to between our Ministers, the Ministers of Northern Ireland, and the representatives of the British Government. The greatest joy of all has been expressed by the people of the Northern counties. My interpretation of that great joy is that they have gained all that they wanted and even more than they ever expected. We hear about thanksgiving services being held and about Sir James Craig being presented with a foot rule cut into thirteen pieces. none of the pieces being an inch in length, to indicate, I suppose, that he had not budged one inch. He finished as he started. He was the only representative who could come back to his people and tell them: "I have got for you what I said I would get." I had intended to say a good deal about Article V., but I honestly confess that my ideas with regard to it have been somewhat changed by the explanation given by the Minister for Finance. At the same time, I wish to say that never, in my opinion, was there any great danger that the Saorstát would have to pay anything under that Article. We have the statement of the Minister for Finance to that effect, that in his opinion we would never be called upon to pay anything under Article V. That statement was confirmed yesterday by the British Chancellor of the Exchequer. He introduced a factor into the argument which so far has not been introduced in this House, namely, that of taxable capacity. He allowed that this factor would be taken into consideration—that is, the power of the people of Ireland to pay any impost which might be placed upon them. I feel confident, therefore, that at no time would we be called upon to make any payment under Article V. of the Treaty.

Comment on this

You are an optimist.

Comment on this

I feel that in one aspect our Ministers made a bad bargain, because they did not stand up to their promises. They abandoned people who in the past rendered the greatest assistance to the people of the Saorstát, people who did their part in securing the freedom which we now enjoy. I refer to the Nationalists of the North. When this Agreement was come to in London by our Ministers and the representatives of the other two Governments, we definitely made concessions to the North. We made a concession in regard to the Council of Ireland and the boundary line, and for these concessions we gain nothing but general expressions of goodwill and amity. I suggest it would not have been unreasonable on the part of our Ministers to have asked that the safeguards which we have applied in our case to the minority in the South should have been applied by the Northern Government to the Nationalists of the North. It would not have been unreasonable, I think, to have asked the Northern Government to introduce a measure applying the principle of proportional representation to their elections in the North.

Comment on this

Re-introducing such a measure you mean.

Comment on this

What Deputy Davin reminds me of is correct. We all know what has happened in the North as a result of the gerrymandering in the case of local constituencies that has taken place. In many cases it now takes four Nationalist votes in the North to equal one Unionist vote. I feel that the expressions of goodwill we have heard so much about will mean nothing unless we get a written guarantee that our friends in the North will be protected and also their interests. It may seem, in view of the final Article to the Agreement, that this would not be necessary; but I say in view of the past history of the North and in view of the past history of intolerance shown towards the Nationalists of the North that they had a right to expect that our representatives would demand that they should be protected in the same way that we protect minorities in the South.

We hear a good deal about what may result from the meetings between our Government and the Government of the North of Ireland. I maintain that these meetings can only take place with regard to the three matters which were to be dealt with by the Council of Ireland, namely, fisheries, the Diseases of Animals Acts, and railways, and that no one is authorised to call these meetings for any purpose other than that of dealing with these three reserved services. That is not an aspect of the Article which has been commented on nor has it been noted to any extent. I believe the general feeling with regard to that Article is that in matters of general concern the Governments of the North and South can be brought together. I think a protest should be made against Articles III. and IV. of the Agreement. It is my belief, and that also of many other Deputies as far as I could gather from their speeches, that Article III. gives sanction to the statement that we are prepared to accept responsibility for the doings of the Black-and-Tans in pre-Truce days.

I believe that Article IV. gives sanction and support to statements broadcast from England that certain people had not got their just rights under the Property Losses (Compensation) Act. We know that a campaign has been going on for months and months to prove that unfair discrimination took place in regard to certain people generally described as Southern Unionists in regard to compensation: that they did not get their due or full value for their property. I want to say that I do not believe that such a statement is correct. In fact, I believe that it is far from correct, and if anything the boot is on the other foot, and that in most cases these men did get more than the value of their property and were over-compensated. I believe it is a crying shame when you place side by side for consideration the amount of compensation granted for property losses and the compensation which was granted by the Government for personal injuries during the fight in this country.

There is one other aspect of the Agreement which I think should have got the attention of our Ministers in London. In view of a statement which appears in this evening's papers I believe that it did get the consideration of our Ministers in London, but I think they should have told us that when they made their statement. What I am referring to is the case of the prisoners in the North who are in English prisons. There is a fellow Deputy of mine, a representative elected by the people for the constituency of Tipperary, who has been in an English prison since 1921. I refer to Deputy McCurtin. I think it would be nothing short of a disgrace for this Government if they were to sign an Agreement which professed to work for amity and goodwill between the Free State and the Northern Government if they did not make arrangements for the release of Deputy McCurtin and the other political prisoners at present in the custody of the British Government for the Northern Parliament.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy say what portion of the Agreement he is in favour of?

Comment on this

I have stated that I believe the Agreement arrived at was the only alternative available to the Ministers at the time. I am strongly in favour of it. I am not in favour of many details of it. I believe it is open to criticism, and that it is our right as Deputies to criticise, but I am not prepared, as I told the House and told the Deputy, to face the alternative. I think I am a realist, and I am not prepared to take any action which might have the effect of plunging Ireland back into chaos and disorder once more. In giving my vote to this Agreement, I am not prepared to give my sanction to the policy and actions of the Government which led up to the condition of affairs that made it necessary that this Agreement should have been arrived at.

Comment on this

I am intervening in this debate to express my opinion on two or three matters that have arisen out of the situation we are discussing here. One of the reasons I desire to intervene is because of certain statements made here yesterday in regard to the party or parties who were primarily responsible for the situation that entailed partition. It was said here yesterday, by a Deputy, in this House, that all the responsibility for the partition of this country rested with the Government and that they were the people primarily responsible through the Treaty for partition. I desire to contradict that statement, and while I have no brief for the Government, and while it is, perhaps, not very fitting that a back-bencher like me should intervene in this question of high politics I hold, and many people besides me hold the opinion if they had the courage to express their opinions, that the responsibility for the partition of this country rests with those who handled the destinies of the Nationalists of this country in 1914 and before it.

Comment on this

What about 1920?

Comment on this
Mr. MURPHY

I hold that the people who rigged up a convention in Belfast and cudgelled the Nationalists that are complaining of partition now into acceptance of it and who refused to listen to anybody in this country, who protested that they were selling the country, are the people who led up to the situation aptly described by the late Archbishop Walsh when he said the country was sold.

Comment on this

It is sold now.

Comment on this
Mr. MURPHY

The people who dubbed everybody who had the courage to express their opinions as factionists and traitors to the country are the people who were responsible for it. I regret that I should be the one to introduce this jarring note here, and to express opinions, and to rip up matters that, perhaps, might have been left in the merciful oblivion they deserved. But while I believe the handling of this question by the Government is wrong, and while I disagree with the Government on this question of partition, and while I disagree with their attitude to the class that I represent and characterise their attitude as harsh towards us, this much I can say for them, that they are not the principal sinners in regard to partition, and I say if there was a reference made here last week to Pontius Pilate, while it might be undeserved last week, I think it is well deserved in regard to sentiments expressed yesterday by Deputy Redmond.

There were protests made against partition before, in this country. There was a very extensive protest made against it in the South of Ireland, and there is one long figure, to-day, in Irish politics that would, I hold, be here with us, in this Parliament of our nation, to help us in our work, were it not for the horror that he has of this question of partition. There was a very powerful agitation carried on by the "Irish Independent" of that time, against partition, and, I regret to find that the "Irish Independent" in the last few days has departed from that attitude. There was also, and there is, another prominent figure in our political life, the Governor-General of this State——

Comment on this

Another Corkman.

Comment on this
Mr. MURPHY

And I have yet to be convinced that if we had the privilege of hearing the Governor-General to-day that he would not re-affirm many of the brilliant and caustic things he said in his speeches in his career against partition. Now the whole discussion seems to resolve itself into a question of alternatives. It is perhaps too forward for a mere novice in politics like me to suggest an alternative, but I hold that when we are told all we are told about the goodwill that is coming into the life of this country, and when it is pointed out to us that the people who represented the North at these conferences in London were full of goodwill towards us, then our representatives there had a right to test that goodwill and to put up the claim that the people of the Free State had the right to put up— the claim affirmed by the elections that had taken place in the North— to put up a claim that their attitude towards our endeavours to secure freedom for the Nationalists of the North would be a fair test of all the goodwill that Sir James Craig and his friends have suddenly become possessed of towards us. It is very good to hear that the roaring lions of a short time ago have become the cooing doves. Therefore, I suggest to the President, with all respect to him and with every consideration for the difficulties he has had, and is having that he might have stood on the case of the Free State in regard to avoiding partition and he might have put up to the people of Ulster a fair question as to whether their professions of goodwill towards us were mixed with a sense of justice or with any respect for the undoubtedly irresistible case that the people of this State would have been able to make with regard to avoiding partition in this country.

Some time ago the Treaty was registered with the League of Nations. It was registered after very considerable trouble. I understand—but I am open to correction—that at that time the Treaty was registered with the object of safeguarding the rights of the people under Article XII. The League of Nations was to be the final court of appeal, if there was to be any treachery with regard to the interpretation of this Article, and I suggest when we are asked to consider the prospects of immediate war and other dire consequences for our people that the registering of the Treaty with the League of Nations might provide the alternative that we are asked to suggest here this evening.

There are many things in connection with this Boundary controversy that we might consider, and if there is one thing more than another that must have struck us all it is the absolute failure of the Free State representative on the Boundary Commission. As an absolute novice in politics, I have never listened to a more pathetic confession of failure than the halting explanation made by Deputy Dr. MacNeill when he spoke regarding his action on the Boundary Commission. The Minister for Justice, speaking here last week, asked us to point out where the Executive Council had failed. I suggest that his colleagues on the Executive Council failed lamentably in connection with the Boundary Commission, and that he will have a good deal of trouble to convince the people of this country of the fact that he and his colleagues of the Executive Council did not have some responsibility for that failure. I suggest that you might couple with that some of the amazing speeches made down the country in regard to the course of the Boundary Commission deliberations. I think members of the Executive Council and other Ministers of this Government who made these statements ought to have known what they were talking about before they made them, because I gathered from an interjection of the Minister for Finance this evening that he was quite unaware of what he was talking about when he made the statement that all was going well with the Boundary Commission. It recalled to my mind the public utterances of another gentleman who graces the Northern Parliament with his presence and who, in the old days, when we used to hear of "the no far distant date," was telling the people that he was the watchman on the tower and that all was going well in the cause of Ireland. Events proved that all was not going well in the cause of Ireland and, when the final crash came, Mr. Devlin was not on watch on the tower.

Comment on this

What about O'Brien's gramophone?

Comment on this
Mr. MURPHY

The astute Deputy for North Dublin, who seeks to put me off my track, will have some difficulty in acquitting the Party to which he belonged and himself personally of responsibility for the horrible state of affairs——

Comment on this

I am very proud to have been a member of John Redmond's Party, more proud now than ever I was.

Comment on this
Mr. MURPHY

I am not an expert on financial questions, but it appears to me that the part of the Agreement that pledges the people of this State to a payment of a quarter of a million of money for 60 years is an absolutely amazing proposition. To my mind, and I think to the mind of everybody in this country who will face the facts there can be no question whatever that it is unjust to the people of this country to relieve the British Government of their obligation to foot the bill in regard to what has happened in this country for the time covered by this Agreement.

We have heard here, time after time, of the need for tightening up the purse in regard to expenditure. I ask the Minister for Finance, who is a party to this Agreement, to remember that there are thousands of people in this country, at the present time, who are hungry; that their number is growing every day, and that it is wrong to those people to send that money over to the British Government when their own fellow-countrymen are starving and when the number of people who is starving is growing every day.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce, who is an exceedingly warlike person, lately tells us that the Shannon scheme must be based on a wage of 32/- a week. I understand it has grown to 35/- a week in the last day or two. But if we are asked to enslave our brothers of the working classes for 32/- a week in order that this State may go on, people of this country will be asking why we were so generous as to offer a quarter of a million pounds for 60 years to the British Government for the damage their own agents and servants did in this country.

There is another aspect of the question that I would like to refer to before I finish. That is the action of a certain group of representatives who are outside this House. These people have professed and do profess to love this country, and a great many of them profess to be ready to give up their lives for it. I submit that if as a result of our deliberations here to-day partition becomes an accomplished fact the people who are outside the Dáil, and who are supposed to have a monopoly of all the patriotism that is going in this country, cannot acquit themselves of some of the responsibility for that partition. I say to these people, whose record is a record of absolutely barren failure, who have no alternative now but to suggest that those of us here who are endeavouring to do the best we can for our brothers in the country who are suffering, should leave the Dáil and go out with them into the wilderness, that I, for one, and I am sure I can speak for the members of my Party as well, will not accept that solution of the question. They have never produced one single constructive idea as to how the interests of this country might be served. They are equally responsible with the members and predecessors of this Government in control of the National movement in regard to partition, and I certainly will not be the one who will make easy the way for them to gain Party advantages or to make Party capital out of the difficulties in which the people of this country find themselves.

I am going to vote against partition. It has been said that the people of the country are in favour of this Agreement. I have yet to be convinced of that fact, and out of no desire to bend the knee to the super-patriots who have refused to recognise the Dáil I am going to vote, as I believe I am right in voting, against partition, and I, and those who will vote with me, will be satisfied to be judged by the people who will write and read the history of this period.

Comment on this

I want to express my views on this matter as calmly as I can, and to say no word that will be a jar to the hopes expressed and contained in this Agreement that a new era is going to come into the life of Ireland. If I viewed this Agreement from my position here as Deputy for Tirconnail, recognising the situation which menaced that county recently as a result of the revelations in connection with the Boundary Commission, I would feel compelled to accept it with relief and to give it support. They were menaced with the lopping off of some of the richest parts of their county, to the injury of the whole fabric of their county administration and their whole economic life. They desired to be preserved from that iniquity, and my duty in the Dáil was to use what means I could to save them from that menace and to secure them in the liberties they enjoy. I did what I could——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I would like to point out that in spite of the order of the Ceann Comhairle there is a very large number of visitors standing in the gallery.

Comment on this

Very important.

Comment on this

I do not believe the Ceann Comhairle should trouble about that.

Comment on this
Prof. William E. Thrift ACTING-CHAIRMAN (Prof. Thrift) Independent

It is not a point of order at all.

Comment on this

When faced with that situation, I carried out, as far as I personally could, my duty as a representative in this House, by my representations to the Executive Council and to our President, and by what influence I could bring to bear on the members of my party to impress these representations on the Executive Council. I took the means that were open to me in introducing the motion that I did introduce in this House and which I take the liberty of believing was probably the means of bringing the Executive Council to an immediate realisation of the trend of events in the Boundary Commission. Further, I believe that the net result of that activity was to bring about a break up of that Commission.

Viewing this Agreement as a Tirconnail Deputy, it secures the people there from the menace with which they were faced. It secures them in their territorial integrity, and saves them from having their county carved up and some of their citizens taken under another Government. It secures them in the liberties that they enjoy. Viewing it as a business man, I could not but say that it offers to the Saorstát considerable advantages. It removes one of the uncompleted matters arising out of the Treaty which menaced the security of life, at least of ordered progress and economic life in the country and made for a sense of insecurity on all matters pertaining to the legislative and economic life of the Saorstát.

Further, in eliminating Clause V. it removed the economic life of the country from a further menace which was like a millstone round its neck. I do not put much stock in the argument that we are to lose anything in credit or kudos by undertaking to pay for the destruction done in this country by our enemies. It matters little how the measure of money to be paid was got so long as a definite understanding was arrived at, and the country knew definitely and finally where it was placed financially.

In regard to Clause IV. of the Agreement, I am in complete agreement. I do not hold with those who assume that it is an admission of guilt upon any of our judicial bodies that compensation was paid in a meagre measure to those whose property and interests were destroyed, because I hold the view, not exactly as the President would put it, that the Act was drawn tightly, but that it was one of the meanest financial juggles that I have had experience of; that the measure was one which in a large degree made those who suffered damage —and these were only a small portion of what were called Southern loyalists —made all those who stood beside the Treaty position, and whose property was destroyed as a result, pay in their property for the war made upon the liberties of the country. The Act was so tightly drawn that the very minimum amount of compensation was first determined by the Government valuer and subsequently, when every item was fully vouched, was submitted to a judge who made an award in accordance with his views of the circumstances, in reduced amounts. Consequently I believe it is a simple act of justice to our own people, of whatever kind, that this increased compensation should be paid. These are my views as a Tirconaill Deputy.

Looking upon it as an ordinary citizen and business man of the Saorstát, who had no other consideration or preoccupation in my mind, I would have no difficulty in supporting the Agreement. But from my associations in the past, from my upbringing and my connection with the national movement in the past, I must take another point of view towards this measure. I can only say that it is somewhat in the nature of special pleading to suggest that any contraction of the Boundary now Northwards would not leave the position of the Nationalists in the Six Counties any better. That is a proposition that might be argued with effect, but it is one which we must remember was not in the minds of those who signed the Treaty and who put in that clause as some kind of a charter of liberty for those Nationalists who had worked and fought with them and made sacrifices with them for the liberties enjoyed in the Saorstát.

Those people, rightly or wrongly, and whatever the results are, good or bad for them, put their faith in Article XII., as I say, their charter of liberty, and they depend on us to see it carried out faithfully. After all, the reason for the establishment of the Six-County Government was the plea of self-determination and the plea of no coercion raised in England and repeated in Ireland, first North and then South. Every person was agreed, as I said before in this House, that there should be no coercion for a section of our countrymen in the North-East, and those who signed the Treaty for the Dáil signed it with the view in their minds that if self-determination was conceded in the North-East corner it should be applied to those communities over the Border of the Saorstát who also desired it; that if there was no coercion for the Six-County conclave there should be no coercion for these minorities on their Border.

Deputy Murphy a few moments ago dealt with a matter which, I think, it was right and just for him to raise in this House in regard to the genesis of Partition in Ireland and its beginnings, and I will not trouble the House upon it now, because his words are mere historic facts and will bear no controversion by any statements made in this House.

It seems to me that we argue here for this Agreement considering the interests of all sections but the section most interested; the section for whom all the trouble and worry is; the section for whose protection Article XII. was inserted in the Treaty; the section whose liberties and lives in the future are being determined by our decision in this House. It seems to me very much like the case of a physician who calls in two surgeons and the three sit round to consider the case of a patient. One wants to operate and carve, the other wants to cure by medicinal means. They argue their various points and they decide eventually that they are in perfect agreement. The matter is quite amicably settled; they do nothing but walk away and leave the patient.

It has been asked here what could be done in the situation created. Deputy Murphy says that it is hardly the function of an ordinary member of this House to suggest an alternative policy, but I venture to believe, and I put the belief for what it is worth, that certainly the repudiation of the Treaty was not the only alternative. I hold that belief firmly, faithfully and truly, because I think that statesmanship in Ireland, in England, and in the North of Ireland, was not so bankrupt as that another alternative solution could not have been found. When I say this, I am not suggesting for one moment that those who went from this Assembly to treat in this matter left any avenue unexplored or were prepared to forget any attempt that could be made to find alternative solutions. I do believe, in fact I know, that they explored every avenue that seemed open to them. But, I believe that there were other alternatives that would have found a solution, that would have brought a real peace, a peace for all Ireland, North and South, and for all time, and a peace that would have brought us unity which will be the only lasting peace in Ireland. If I were in the position of the President, which thank God I am not, and had access to all the information and all the data that he perhaps has, as to all the facts in regard to the relations of the Executive Council with the Boundary Commission and all its surrounding data, and knew how far they were committed beyond their public utterances to the findings of that Commission, I would be in a better position to suggest alternatives.

Comment on this

The door was open for the Deputy to ask for every tittle of information that was at my disposal or anyone else's.

Comment on this

The Dáil asked for it and it was refused here.

Comment on this

Here—that is different. I cannot make the affairs of the Executive Council and the affairs of the State public property, and I am not going to do it.

Comment on this

You did not say that.

Comment on this
Prof. William E. Thrift ACTING-CHAIRMAN (Professor Thrift) Independent

Deputy McCullough is in possession.

Comment on this

I venture to suggest one alternative. I venture to suggest that when we found ourselves in the very critical position we were in after the withdrawal of Deputy Professor MacNeill from the Boundary Commission, that we could have adopted a stand fast policy.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy say if that was what he recommended me to do when going to London?

Comment on this

I will tell the House, if the President desires, all the conversations I had with him.

Comment on this

They were not always easy and sometimes were difficult, because, after all, as I say, I was not in possession of all the data and could not be. I am sure the President is reasonable enough to know that it was not possible for one individual, uninformed as one is here on all these highly important matters, some times to suggest a full and complete line.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy say if I refused him any information he asked me for?

Comment on this

I say I suggest an alternative.

Comment on this

It is a pity the Deputy did not do it before.

Comment on this

I could have done it had greater opportunities been offered. If that position were taken up, I do not think, as some person suggested before to-night, that any of the three parties to this matter desired war. I do not think that we desired war or fighting or trouble on the Border. I do not think that England, on the day following the signing of the Locarno Pact, desired war and fighting in Ireland. I do not think that even Sir James Craig desired war on the Border, with all the repercussions and horrors on all sides that would follow. England would not desire to have war because her position was not any stronger than ours in the matter; because I hold and have held, and said so to the President in this House, that she was guilty of an act of explicit bad faith in her dealings with the Boundary Commission. It is not necessary to re-quote in this House the utterances of some of the signatories to the Treaty in poisoning the atmosphere for the consideration of this important question by the Boundary Commission. I have the evidence in my pocket at the moment that they were guilty of explicit and grievous bad faith in the matter.

Comment on this

I hope the Deputy's good faith will be better, anyway.

Comment on this

The Deputy is entitled to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

Our Executive Council expressed themselves satisfied with this Agreement; the English Government expressed themselves satisfied with this Agreement, and the Northern Government expressed themselves satisfied with this Agreement. The only parties who did not express their satisfaction are the Nationalist communities on the Border. I have said that real peace could have been obtained. There is no use talking about peace when there is no peace and I, who know them, was born, reared, and worked amongst them and know their feelings as conveyed to me, know and believe that unless something happens to pacify their minds and satisfy their consciences that this will not bring about peace on the Border. I say, rather than resort to war and fighting it would have been possible for those who commanded the situation from the beginning, the British Government who created it, to induce, force or by whatever means they like to get Sir James Craig to call into conference the people representing those minorities on the Border the same as our leaders called into conference those representing minorities in this country. I believe if he could have been induced in a true spirit of peace and amity to make some gesture to those people and point out, as they pointed out in this House, that the contraction of the Boundary was no completion of faith with the Nationalists in the Six Counties, that they could have been satisfied that their position might have been made such that they could live their lives in peace and ordered progress until better conditions would prevail and a true spirit of unity would arise in the land. That is not asking too much or suggesting an alternative that would outrage the feelings of any man in Ireland.

The Vice-President has spoken of the stock-in-trade of hate being drained out in Ireland. God knows no man has seen more of the operations of hate and sectarian bigotry than I have, and I can afford to speak feelingly and say that it is my honest desire from my heart that hate in Ireland should pass away and never be heard of again. How can it pass away when you leave communities, rightly or wrongly—and I will let them speak for themselves— feeling that they have been treated unjustly and unfairly by all parties in this matter? I say that the solution of this problem is that something should be done to assure to this minority some conditions of life that will guarantee to them the rights of citizenship and the ordinary conditions of living to enable them to bring up their children with equal opportunities in the land to which they belong.

I do not ask for written guarantees. I believe in the spirit of faith and hope. We were asked to put up guarantees. I am not a believer in the written word in those matters. I believe that England has the way and the means, if she has the will, to ensure that such a gesture would be made in the North as would rid us for ever of all this thorny and terrible question.

I take it that eventually unity is the hope of every Party in this House. It is positively accepted by every section of the Dáil and country. I have ventured to believe that this is not leading to the way of unity, because those minorities I have spoken of have gone to great pains to give me expressions of their opinion. They will not be helpful towards unity and will be a body irritant in the life of this country, North and South, for some time to come. For that reason, as I said in the beginning, I desired to say carefully what I had to say in order that no word of mine should give comfort to any person who desired or attempted to say anything that would create further strife or friction in Ireland. I again say that it is in a measure special pleading, perhaps essential to this case, to say that the contraction of the Boundary leaves matters no worse than they were, but that can only be made a belief worth holding when what I have asked for appears and is given. I have accepted the Treaty and worked with a larger vision in the belief, as I said before in the House, of better relations, a growing understanding and mutual progress with England, knowing that her interests largely lay along parallel lines. If I desired it with England it will not be taken that I did not desire it with the North-Eastern Counties of Ireland, with my own countrymen of my own flesh and blood amongst whom I was born and reared. I hoped for it until there would grow a community of interests between us all that would bring about a true union based on equal rights, responsibilities and equal service to our common Motherland. That spirit can be made to grow only if what I have stated here is done. As it is, we have a section of our countrymen on this Border with nothing but bitterness in their hearts, disappointed hopes, and those things will not bring about those devoutly-to-be-wished-for results. In the meantime they are only pious hopes. I feel that I want something more, and I am not expressing here and now any want of faith or hope in what the future may bring out of Sir James Craig and his Parliament, but I want to see some evidence that some attempt some time will be made to placate and satisfy the natural desires and wishes of those people on the wrong side of this Border to bring about the conditions of life which they desire.

It is not a pleasant matter for me to differ from my colleagues in this matter, but every man has to act in a big crisis of this kind as his judgment directs him, independent of associations. I believe that Tirconaill, which I represent in this House, and which is being saved from the menace of being carved up by the possibility of this Agreement, will not ask me, with, as I say, my past, my traditions, and my associations with those on the other side of the Border, my birth, my upbringing and my responsibilities in the past, to cast a vote that would in a measure approve of what has been done in bringing about a crisis that has resulted in this Agreement.

Comment on this

We have listened to the life and death speech of one of the members who happens to represent Donegal. Of the six members who represent that county he does not represent the voice of any decent section of the county. I am sorry to say that, because personally I have a great regard for the Deputy. This is not a question of personality; it is a question of the State. If, to-morrow, the suggestion were put to me—and I am a Donegalbred man—that we should lose part of our territory in the interests of the State, I would pledge the county to it, and I would carry it. This gentlemen, who is a stranger within our gates——

Comment on this

Is an Irishman a stranger in Ireland?

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, in saying the latter part of what I did say, I was speaking for myself; but I would venture to say further that Deputy O'Doherty is not stating the full facts. The only representations I received from Tirconaill asked me to vote against this Agreement.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Deputy if those are the representations that were put before me when he called upon me? It is only fair to me in my position, in my very responsible position here as President, that the public should know the truth about this matter. It is not fair.

Comment on this

I will explain. That was before the Boundary Commission was broken up. I was entitled to do that.

Comment on this

Ah! I see.

Comment on this

This is a new situation.

Comment on this

You are safe now. Is not that the position?

Comment on this

No, sir; I believe it will be made safe in any event.

Comment on this

It is all right now.

Comment on this

I am sorry that this interruption occurred. As I mentioned before the interruption, this is not a question of the personalities of Deputies; it is not even a question of counties or territories; it is a question of the State. In this matter, if the State demands that we should make sacrifices, we ought to make those sacrifices. We shall not even ask Deputy McCullough to endeavour to save us.

Comment on this

He did it once.

Comment on this

So did I.

Comment on this

In my opinion those constant interruptions of Deputies tend to lower the dignity of the Dáil.

Comment on this
Prof. William E. Thrift ACTING-CHAIRMAN (Professor Thrift) Independent

I would ask Deputy O'Doherty to address himself to me. He shall get the same courtesy as every other Deputy and he will be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

I am thankful for the intervention of the leader of the Farmers' Party, a Deputy for whom I have admiration. I will now resume the remarks I was making in regard to this Agreement. I do not care a brass farthing about Deputies or about personalities. The question before us, and let us not forget it——

Comment on this

I find it very difficult to hear the Deputy.

Comment on this

The question before us is: is this settlement proposed in the interests of the State or against those interests? Deputy Johnson has given very cogent reasons—I pay him this tribute—to show that the settlement is not in the interests of the State. I hold a different view. I will address myself to that aspect of the question. There were quite a number of personal and sectional things discussed in this debate within the last few days. The real point we have to decide is, does this Agreement which the President has put before us violate the Constitution and injure the State? If it does, I will vote against it without any trouble. There is not a Deputy around me who would not do the same. In any of the speeches that have been delivered up to the present there has not been a single suggestion made, and there has not been a single alternative policy put forward to the policy that the Executive Council places before the House for adoption. I do not know what Deputies beside me think, but I know fairly well—I am a Border county man—what all this represents.

Deputy Johnson raised a point here which, I think, is of paramount importance. He touched on the question of the Council of Ireland. I must confess that for a long period after the Treaty I could not quite see the importance of that Council. I was convinced by arguments put forward by Deputy Johnson in this House that it was a big and an important thing in the combination of the North and South. I hold that opinion still. Anything that has occurred since, even in this Agreement, has not altered that opinion. The point I put to myself is this: will the abrogation of that Council mean more for a pacification between the North and South? In my opinion it will. I have come to that deliberate opinion and I think, in his calmer moments, when Deputy Johnson consults his own conscience, proud and all as he is of this Council and the work it might do, he will agree the Executive Council have put up a better arrangement for friendly relations between the Governments of the North and South. I would like to labour that point a little further. The Council of Ireland would comprise twenty Deputies who would be elected by the Northern Parliament and twenty by our Parliament. The twenty Deputies elected by the Northern Parliament would be elected en bloc; that is to say, they would all be of the one way of thinking. As Deputy McCullough might say, they would be real true Orangemen. The twenty Deputies we would select would be men already chosen for their position by means of Proportional Representation.

I am of opinion that the proposal put forward by the Executive Council is better than the Act of 1920 and is calculated to bring about more harmonious relations. A great deal has been said, and a great deal of capital has been made, in regard to a betrayal of the North. I come from the North and I know something about it. Some Deputies have spoken here with great feeling, almost with passion. They have quoted history. Amongst the Deputies who have spoken with passion on this subject is Deputy McCullough. He has been in the House for about a year. Other Deputies who spoke are here for fully three years. What steps did they take, how did they try to alleviate the situation in the North, when these oppressions were being placed upon the people in the North? No action was taken; no concrete action was taken in this House for saving the Northern Nationalists from oppression, the oppression we hear so much about time after time and particularly during the last few days. I am sure the Southern men are always sympathetic. Even Deputy O'Shaughnessy, who does not know the North, was exceedingly sympathetic, and, of course, Deputy Beamish is sympathetic in any circumstances.

What have these gentlemen, or what has their sympathy done in the last three years to relieve the situation in the North, as far as our fellow-Nationalists who are oppressed are concerned? Not a single thing. I am only going on what was given expression to here and the arguments that were put forward in opposition to this Agreement. I could give other arguments in support of the arrangement, but I do not desire to delay the Dáil. During the debate, for instance, Deputy Corish, as well as other Deputies, spoke with great feeling and force but with singular ineffectiveness. I put it to the Dáil that it is our duty as sane and sensible men to support the Agreement that has been made by the Executive Council as the best and the only method of getting over the difficulty that was created by that unfortunate Article of the Treaty.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. P. HOGAN (Clare) Labour Party

It was in the rather prosaic atmosphere of a railway compartment that I read some of the statements made by responsible Ministers in defence—because that is what it is—of this pact which they brought across from London. I re-read in that compartment the pact and the defence of it, and while doing so there arose in my mind certain parallels in Irish history which it would be well, perhaps, that those responsible for the pact would also recall to mind. They extend over a considerable period and they start probably with Grattan's Parliament and go back to the time of Dermot MacMurrough. There are also incidents in between that probably Ministers will recollect, and they will understand that, when those entrusted with the heritage and the preservation of Irish nationality, and the superstructure upon which Irish nationhood was built, were false and violated their principles, retribution, swift and sure, followed in their track. I prophesy, and I say deliberately that I will not regret that retribution following in the track of those who made that pact without the consent of, and even without acquainting the Irish people. We have been told that Parliaments cannot negotiate. We have been told that you cannot have two Parliaments coming to an agreement, that you cannot hold public meetings in the Park and try and make an agreement for the Irish nation with the English nation.

What did happen? A crisis arose because of the failure of the representative of the Executive Council to get the provisions of a certain Article of the Treaty between this country and England carried out in the spirit and probably in the letter that was intended. That crisis arose, and when the Executive Council came to the Dáil, from these Benches they were asked for a statement of policy regarding the position. We were told that they would give no statement of policy then. We were told that they would take as much time as they deemed necessary to deal with the matter. What did they do? They made no statement of policy in this country. They went across to England and the first we heard of the policy of the Executive Council was what we read from the English House of Commons. That was the first statement of policy we heard from the Executive Council. They treated this Dáil as if Deputies were a parcel of schoolboys. They did not come to the Dáil and ask what it proposed to do. They did not ask: "What do you intend to do?" No, nor did they say: "We intend to take across your studied and deliberate opinion and put it before the English nation; we will take that across and see what they will say." No; they went across and we know from this morning's newspapers what they offered to the British Government.

Comment on this

If it takes four days to consider it——

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

This is not a matter to be joked about. This is not a matter upon which to base silly puns. It is a matter to be considered deliberately, and, if members of the Executive Council think that nobody is able to give consideration to the matter but themselves, I think they will find out their mistake before they are very much older. I am aware that partition is not a new thing. It is not an innovation in Irish history. It goes back a little further than the Treaty, and it should be stated that, when negotiations were taking place in a certain Royal residence with a prominent Nationalist leader, they offered to the people carrying on negotiations in that Royal residence the strength of a certain minority party to try and secure unmitigated —that word fits, I suppose—Home Rule, unmitigated control for this country and Dominion status. They offered to secure that without partition and to say to those who were endeavouring to parcel out this country that you had a united nation. That leader of the minority party said afterwards that if that had been done, and if the leader who had carried out the negotiations in that Royal residence had given ear to them, the blood which had to be shed to achieve the amount of freedom we have achieved to-day would have been avoided, and partition which has been brought about would also have been avoided.

That is one portion of the history of partition. We heard it stated from opposite benches that Article XII. was the lame and halting way of dealing with partition and dealing with the Boundary crisis. We were told it could not deal with it adequately and that the people in the North would not be so badly off. We were told those roaring lions, Craig's specials, have become the frisking lambs. What is the history of Article XII. as far as the Dáil is concerned? That Article was accepted with the Treaty. You insisted on its provisions being put into operation. England repudiated and denounced the Treaty by refusing to force a subordinate Parliament in Belfast to appoint a Commissioner on the Boundary Commission. That was a repudiation and denunciation of the Treaty. But when that occurred you forced upon the Dáil an Act of Parliament which gave England power to appoint two representatives on that Commission. You appointed your Commissioner, and when that failed you go across to England and make an agreement with them. It would be very interesting, I am sure, to be able to read what the President had to say there regarding the Nationalists in what is now known as Northern Ireland. Speaking on the 12th August, 1924, in the Seanad Chamber, where the Dáil met for the occasion, the President used the following words:

But the dissectors were not satisfied with the cutting off of that portion of our country whose population was politically detached from us. With a grand sweep they gathered into their new province populations united to us by every tie of blood and affection and community of interest. Was the new province established for the ostensible purpose of preventing the coercion of the attached population of the North-East to be used as an instrument of coercion over those thousands who wanted to live and work with the majority of their fellow-countrymen? The Treaty of 1921 offered the greatest possible measure of relief against that form of coercion, which British statesmen could not defend, while the echoes hurled back their battle-cries of the preceding seven years—"Self-determination,""Government by consent of the governed"—and their loud grief for the thraldom and joy for the relief of Alsace. The Treaty gave effect by Article XII. to the principle which had been proclaimed fundamentally in the European War and embodied in the Treaty of Versailles whose very terms are invoked in prescribing that a boundary shall be fixed between Northern Ireland and the rest of the country, according to the wishes of the inhabitants, subject only to the limitations of economic and geographic considerations.

Either the President was mis-stating the condition of affairs then or the condition of affairs has been mis-stated now. Will the Executive Council tell us which is the case? Here is another passage:

The Northern Government had not even the tact to wait for another time, but proceeded with shameless urgency to disfranchise the very people for whom, fortunately, the Treaty gave this protection. They have been made into the hewers of wood and drawers of water that their temporary governors without concealment consider is the proper sphere of people of their race and faith.

Now, sir, these people in the North who turned the Nationalist minority into hewers of wood and drawers of water are going to fall upon the necks of these Nationalists and embrace them, and call them brothers. The Minister for Justice was equally eloquent as to the rights and the privileges of these people in the North. He was equally eloquent in denunciation of anybody who suggested that England denounced the Treaty then and who said that we should not give England an opportunity of appointing two Commissioners. He said:

What does it involve with regard to the six North-Eastern counties? Are they to "go their own course"? If so, quite a large minority there would find one short and simple descriptive phrase for that. The Treaty secured for them certain rights. Our claim, as the President emphasised, has never been a territorial claim. It has been a claim that people would not, by compulsion, be excluded from the jurisdiction of their choice. It has been a claim that areas consisting homogeneously or predominantly of people who wish to be included in the jurisdiction of the Free State Government should have those wishes given effect to.

Again he said:

We are to surrender the rights which we won for the large minority in the Six Counties, considering the Six Counties collectively, because, in fact, they are in a majority in individual counties. We are to surrender the rights which the Treaty, signed by Arthur Griffith and Michael Collins, won for those friends of ours in the North-East area; we are to tear up now the international document which secured those rights for them. We are to put ourselves before the world in the position of being branded and blackguarded from end to end, as people who have broken faith. And all for what?

And all for what? We have torn up this international Agreement now. We have broken faith, and for what? What have we secured for it? What have we got for Article 12 of the Treaty?

Comment on this

What had you got from it?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Why then did they insist that this provision in Article XII. should be put into operation? If it has secured them nothing now what could it have secured them then? Can you consistently urge that that speech is a correct statement of fact, and can you consistently urge now that they will get nothing out of it? If that was so what is said now is a mis-statement. You cannot have it both ways. The Minister for Justice is possessed of a mind so logical that it cannot be understood. We have been always led to believe by the leaders of the minority movement, even before it became the majority movement, that there was a very good balance on our side of the ledger in the matter of taxation. We have been always led to believe that we could claim that England had not governed this country out of her bounty, that she made very well on it, and we were told that under Article V. of the Treaty there was to be a set-off of one debt against another. Then we have the Minister for Finance—it is just as well to quote all three signatories. One thing I can never understand is why these people travel in threes. You had the three Boundary Commissioners and you had the three men who went across to sign the Pact. I suppose it is in emulation of the three wise men who came from the East——

Comment on this

And now they have gone West.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The Minister for Finance said in an interview with the editor of the "Financial Times":—

The matter cannot be settled until the Boundary between ourselves and Ulster is determined, and then it becomes merely an adjustment of offsetting claims. You know we have always contended that there are large sums due to us from over-taxation in the past—

I wonder how long they contended that when they went to 10 Downing Street—

and I do not possibly see how an equitable division can leave us in your debt.

The gentleman who could not see, on the 13th November, 1925, how an equitable division of the position could leave us in England's debt could see, on the 3rd December, how an equitable division could leave us in England's debt.

It is wonderful how these Ministers can change their minds and how they can be convinced very quickly of different points of view in regard to any concrete situation. You have without any consideration of these relative amounts decided you are in the debt of England. You have decided that England is not indebted to you and you propose to pay a certain amount of money. You did not come to this Dáil to discuss whether this Dáil believes that before you went over and made this offer, because we have the words of the English Premier that you did make this offer.

On this matter of Article V. and Article IV. let me say that very few people in this country ever believed in or took much notice of these particular articles. Nobody believes in this country that they owe allegiance to a gentleman named George Windsor in England. I do not; I never will. Nobody believes that we had any share in the carnage, slaughter and devastation that was brought about from Sheerness to Shanghai by the capitalists of England. Nobody believed in that, and yet when there was one important consideration before the country, when there was an opportunity for uniting the country, what did you do? You calculated the cubic content of a square of fog which was the financial relation between yourselves and that country. You did not allow them to become concrete, measure them and give them in definite terms. You calculated in your own subtle fashion, by which you calculate many things, what it was, and you decided against the Irish nation. There was another Article you might have wiped out or considered. You might have said: "There is a large body of Irish opinion which is genuinely honest in its opinions regarding the future Government of this country," for, whatever may be said to the contrary, the greatest earnest any man can give of his convictions is his preparedness to make sacrifices for those convictions. Many of those men have risked their lives and have risked everything in defence of these principles that they hold. They are estranged from a large section of their countrymen by a certain formula that nobody believes in, that nobody acknowledges, and we are told sometimes that it is of no importance; and if it is of little importance why is it embodied in the greatest instrument we have in this country? You got an opportunity of bargaining with that and of knitting the issues in this country so that you could stand up against any subterfuge that might be put up in the North or in England against you. You had an opportunity of knitting the nation and you allowed the opportunity to pass.

You told us that the Treaty was freedom to achieve freedom. How have you carried that precept into practice —freedom to achieve freedom? Freedom in your own words, in the words of the President, freedom to allow the Nationalist inhabitants of a section of the country to be made by the Government ruling in that section hewers of wood and drawers of water; freedom to allow all these people to be disfranchised within that territory; freedom, according to the Minister for Justice, which was secured after struggles, etc. You have allowed these rights of franchise, equality, and co-citizenship to be taken from them. That is as far as your freedom to achieve freedom has gone. You have allowed, further, this Government to give a certificate of good character to the Black and Tans. You said, in effect, that it was not the Black and Tans that burned Cork and sacked Balbriggan. No, sir, you have said it was the Irish people, because if the Irish people had no part in it, why should they pay compensation for it? You said that every house blown up, as a reprisal within this country, has been blown up by the Irish people. Otherwise why should we pay compensation?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

If the Deputy said that "they" have, he would make me feel more comfortable.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I do not suggest that An Ceann Comhairle has said it.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

That is the point.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I will alter it and say that the Executive Council——

Comment on this

On behalf of the Executive Council, I deny it.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

They have said, in effect, sir, that all the burning, the looting, and the sacking that has taken place in this country has been done by the Irish people.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

You have not alone abandoned the Nationalists of the North to their fate——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I have not abandoned them. The Deputy should speak about the Government in the third person.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

There are three persons involved, too, sir. The Executive Council has abandoned the Nationalists of Northern Ireland to their fate, to be hewers of wood and drawers of water. The Executive Council has repudiated the actions of the men who brought about the condition of affairs that procured the Treaty, has repudiated them and has said they were guilty of crimes which were committed by the English forces in this country.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

What provisions have been made by the Executive Council for the Nationalists in Northern Ireland whose homes and whose property have been destroyed? What guarantees have they got that these people will be compensated? Has the Executive Council secured any guarantees for these people? In one case which has come to my knowledge a certain citizen of the Six Counties, whose property was destroyed by the Specials because of his Nationalist activities during the reign of terror in this country, made application before a Northern Court for compensation and it was not listened to for ten minutes. Has the Executive Council made any provision to see that compensation will be paid to these people? So far as we are aware there is no provision in any agreement for these people. There is a provision made that 10 per cent. be added to the compensation that was given here. In other words, the jurisdiction of the Commissions that sat in the Twenty-six Counties is questioned by those who signed the Pact. It is difficult to say anything that has not been already said on this matter.

The matter is so serious that, even at the risk of repetition, I have endeavoured to put my views before the Executive Council and to add my quota of denunciation to the methods they employed. They have not taken the Dáil seriously as a national assembly. They have rather thought that their spiritual home was at 10 Downing Street, and that the lady in Leinster Lawn was more a symbol of their inspiration than Caitlín Ní Houliháin. If the Minister for Justice will pass out towards Kildare Street he will see a statue of the lady to whom I refer. This pact is a denial of all the principles of Irish nationhood. It is an abrogation of all the sacrifices and all the sufferings and all the efforts made for generations, and this abrogation of all these principles is made for nothing. You have given away everything and have got nothing in return. The three signatories to this Pact will go down in Irish history with those other people, from the coming of MacMurrough to the sale of Grattan's Parliament, as people who are false to the principles which were entrusted to them as the custodians of national honour, and history will deal with them in the light of a proper perspective.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

With the leave of the House I move the adjournment of the debate until to-morrow.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

I suggested half an hour ago to the President, in order to expedite the decision on this question, that we should meet to-morrow at eleven o'clock.

Comment on this

I made several applications for accommodation in this matter, which has now occupied the attention of the Dáil for three whole days, and it is only reasonable that we should come to a decision on it. I am in favour of meeting at eleven o'clock in the morning and sitting until the matter is finished to-morrow.

Comment on this

On behalf of Deputies who are not free, and whose hours are not at their own disposal, I protest against this further encroachment on the liberties of the Dáil.

Comment on this

All I can say is that the Deputy Professor made considerable onslaught on time which could have been usefully used.

Comment on this

We had four months' holidays followed by a week's holiday, and now things have become so urgent that those who have duties in the Dáil are to be prevented from attending by arbitrary alterations in our hours of meeting.

Comment on this

Some Deputies, including myself, are members of the Public Accounts Committee, which meets to-morrow morning at eleven o'clock, and for them an eleven o'clock meeting of the Dáil would be very inconvenient.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

I am also a member of the Public Accounts Committee, but as the matter before the Dáil is a most vital question it might be well if that meeting were deferred. To meet the objection of Deputy Professor Magennis, if we meet at eleven to-morrow morning, it could be arranged that a vote would not be taken earlier than three o'clock.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

It being now 10.30 p.m., the House is adjourned, according to Orders, until three o'clock to-morrow.

The Dáil adjourned at 10.30.

Comment on this