COURT OFFICERS BILL, 1926—THIRD STAGE RESUMED.
Contributions 1–145 of 290. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 5 of 1926 ›
Yes. Amendments 22, 23 and 24, in fact, hang together, but amendments 22 and 24 deal with practically an identical matter. The suggestion is to restrict the post of Officer for Accounts and Inquiries, and the post of Registrar to the Chief Justice to either practising solicitors or existing officers. The point of view underlying the amendment differs from that of Deputy Johnson and Deputy Cooper, who seem to wish to open more posts to the rank and file of the staff. Deputy Hewat seeks by these amendments to close certain posts to the ordinary competition of the staff. My road is the middle one, and it is rather less generous to the staff than Deputy Johnson and Deputy Cooper would wish, but rather more generous than the point of view of Deputy Hewat. At present you have two chief clerks who would be Examiners of the future, who are promoted officers, and admittedly there is no suggestion of any lack of competence on the part of these two officers. I am not prepared to assume that there may not be more such men in the future. Therefore, I am not prepared to debar, in the ordinary course of promotions, these officers from these positions—that is, the position of Officer for Accounts and Inquiries, or the other position with which Deputy Hewat's amendment deals, that of Registrar to the Chief Justice.
Comment on this
I regret that Deputy Hewat, who is in charge of this matter, is not able to be here at the moment. This amendment was confined to the office of the Examiner, as I understood it. I think it is exceedingly desirable that nominations for appointments to that particular office should be professional.
Comment on this
There is no difference really. It is the Officer of Accounts and Inquiries whom it is now decided to call "Examiner." We are at one as to what Deputy Hewat wishes by his amendment. On consideration, I am not prepared to meet his point of view, but I do not think there is any confusion as to what he seeks.
Comment on this
I am afraid that there is some confusion. As a matter of fact, Deputy Hewat spoke to me about this amendment and as to what was in his mind. He did not desire to exclude the possibility of promoting an existing officer to the position of Examiner. What he had in mind was that if an outsider were being appointed, a solicitor had better qualifications for a position of that kind than a member of the Bar who had no experience of the class of work an Examiner has to do.
Comment on this
I take it that Deputy Duggan, while moving the amendment that stands in the name of Deputy Hewat, does not approve of the proposition that a solicitor is not as capable of filling the post as a barrister. On this question I think it is not inopportune to remind the House that we are discussing an issue between two rival trade unions. It is a demarcation question. We are asked to give statutory authority to one union to the exclusion of the other. I am not going to say whether it is a desirable thing or not, but I am asking the House to bear in mind that they are ratifying a principle which might be brought to their attention on some future occasion.
Comment on this
I would like to correct one statement of Deputy Johnson's. The trade unions he refers to are not rivals.
Comment on this
In this matter one is at some disadvantage because I thought Deputy Hewat would be here. Would there be any objection to allowing this amendment to stand over and to come up on Report Stage, and then the Deputy would have a chance of dealing with it? In the meantime, the Minister might give it a little further consideration.
Comment on this
I do not object to letting the amendment stand over for the attendance of Deputy Hewat, but I want to make it clear that my point of view is that this particular office should be filled by promotion from the staff and not by the introduction of either a barrister or solicitor.
Comment on this
If the amendment be withdrawn it can be proposed at a later stage, but if it be defeated it cannot be proposed later.
Comment on this
There is very little in this amendment, for the reason that as a matter of actual practice the position is nearly always filled by the promotion of an existing officer, who may be neither a barrister nor a solicitor.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
Before Section 23 to insert a new section as follows:—
"No person shall be appointed under this Act to be Registrar to the Chief Justice unless at the time of his appointment he either—
(a) is a barrister of not less than ten years' standing who is then actually practising, or
(b) is a barrister who is then employed in an office established under this Part of this Act and has during the next preceding twelve years been employed in one or more of such offices or of the offices formerly attached to the High Court, the Supreme Court, the former Supreme Court of Judicature, the Chief Justice, the Lord Chancellor for Ireland or the Lord Chief Justice of Ireland or any of them, or
(c) immediately before the commencement of this Part of this Act holds the office of Registrar or of Assistant Registrar in Lunacy or the office of Chief Clerk to the Chief Justice."
I would like to point out to Deputy Johnson that there is absolutely no inconsistency in my moving this amendment and supporting the other because the position is a totally different one and a barrister is best qualified for this position. In the original draft no particular qualification was prescribed for the person appointed to be Registrar, but in the amendment now introduced it has been decided to set out the qualifications which he must possess.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
In sub-sections (1) and (2), before the word "Act" in line 49, and also in line 55, to insert the words "Part of this."
This section was also intended to refer to the Supreme Court and the High Court and not to the Circuit Court or the District Court. The amendment makes that clear.
Comment on this
I beg to move the two following amendments:—
In sub-section (1), to delete lines 51 and 52 and substitute the following words: "Minister shall from time to time determine with the sanction of the Minister for Finance and after consultation with the President of the High Court in the case of an office attached to that court and with the Chief Justice in the case of an office attached to the Supreme Court or the Chief Justice."
In sub-section (2), line 57, after the word "direct" to add the words: "after consultation with the President of the High Court in relation to an office attached to that court and with the Chief Justice in relation to an office attached to the Supreme Court or to the Chief Justice."
The effect of the amendments is that the Judicial Head of the Court has to be consulted as to the number of the staff to be employed.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
In page 8, to delete sub-section (4) and substitute two new sub-sections as follows:—
"(4) No person shall be appointed under this section to be a Deputy Master of the High Court unless at the time of his appointment he either possesses the qualifications prescribed by this Act for persons appointed to be Master of the High Court or is an officer employed in the Central Office who has during the next preceding twelve years been employed in one or more of the offices established by this Part of this Act or of the offices the business of which is transferred by this Act to the offices established by this Part of this Act.
"(5) No person shall be appointed under this section to be a Deputy-Taxing-Master unless at the time of his appointment he possesses the qualifications prescribed by this Act for persons appointed to be Taxing-Master."
The effect of the amendment is that an experienced official can be appointed as deputy for the Master of the High Court during his absence instead of bringing in an outsider. It is felt that an experienced official would make a much more suitable deputy than a practising barrister outside.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
In page 8, to add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:
"(2) In this section the word ‘office' shall in its application to the Bankruptcy Office be construed as meaning a branch of an office."
The reason for the introduction of this amendment is that there are two very distinct branches in the Bankruptcy Office—the Registrar's Office and the Official Assignee's Office. There is nothing in common between the two, and the man who might be quite suitable to act in one capacity would have no experience of the work of the other.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
In sub-section (1), page 8, line 31, after the word "name" to insert the words "or to the account."
Comment on this
I beg to move the following amendments:—
In sub-section (1), page 8, line 35, after the word "Accountant" to insert the words "for the time being."
In sub-section (2), page 8, line 43, and also in line 56, immediately before the word "Assignee" to insert the word "Official," and immediately after the word "Bankruptcy" to insert the words "for the time being."
In sub-section (2), page 8, line 52, after the word "name" to insert the words "or to the account."
These amendments are consequential.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
In page 9, lines 13 and 14, to delete the words "(not being temporary officers or servants)," and in line 16 to add at the end of the section the words "and are pensionable officers or servants."
The effect of the amendment is to exclude temporary and non-pensionable officers from the section. It leaves their status exactly as it was before.
Comment on this
It is really a matter regarding which application of the Civil Service Commission machinery would be very cumbrous if applied to the re-staffing or the staffing of the new court system, inasmuch as we will have on hands all the officers who decide to come into the new system, on this Bill coming into operation. If the processes of the Civil Service Commission were to be adopted that machinery would be overstrained. It is evidently a matter for administrative discretion to fit the existing officers—I say existing officers, meaning the officers who are serving under the present court system—into their proper places in the new system, and it is felt that a period of from a year to eighteen months will be required before that process could be said to be complete. Therefore, the effect of Section 27 is to avert the necessity for troubling the Civil Service Commission in regard to every single appointment that may arise under the new system and to leave my hands and the hands of my Department free to deal administratively with the staffing problem that will arise.
Comment on this
I feel that the statement of the Minister does not make it easier to justify the section. While administrative convenience may well be served by leaving this whole question of promotion and staffing in his hands for eighteen months, I doubt whether it is good policy for the sake of administrative convenience to depart from what has been emphasised in this House as a very necessary provision—that appointments in the Civil Service, appointments under the Government, should be referred to the Civil Service Commission. I think that it is unwise for the sake of administrative convenience to make this very great departure from what has been emphasised here as necessary and desirable.
I would ask the Minister to consider very carefully the question whether this is necessary, having regard to all the circumstances and the public view that the Civil Service Commission is, and should be, a check upon political prejudices. Unless the administrative inconvenience is overwhelmingly great there should not be a departure from the rules that the Civil Service regulations should be applied to appointments in the courts as long as appointments are being retained by the Minister.
Comment on this
That is a point of view I suppose the Deputy felt bound to put just as I feel bound to reject it. It is rather straining the word to refer to these appointments as appointments in the ordinary sense. It is a question of the statutory termination of one system and the statutory commencement of another system, no doubt, but there will be there carrying on the work of the courts some hundreds of officers and the staffing problem consist merely in fitting these various officers into their respective positions in the new system and defining their duties. To suggest that this is in any way usurping the functions of the Civil Service Commission may read very well in the newspapers, but it is very wide of the mark, and I think the Deputy appreciates it is very wide of the mark. There is no question of making new appointments; there is the question only of dealing with the existing personnel of the courts, allocating them to their positions under the new system and defining their duties.
Comment on this
I take it from that explanation the only power that will be exercised by the Minister, apart from the Civil Service Commission, will be the power of formal transfer from one system to the other and that the Minister is not taking under this power to promote or to make appointments to new offices which would involve increased remuneration.
Comment on this
Suppose I were, who promotes, as it is, in the ordinary routine of the Civil Service?
Comment on this
I move:—
To delete all from the word "Land," line 30, to the word "aforesaid" in line 33, and substitute the words "Central Office established under the Local Registration of Title (Ireland) Act, 1891, nor to any Local Office established under that Act which immediately before the commencement of this Part of this Act is under the management and control of a person who is not the Clerk of the Crown and Peace, and neither the said Central Office nor any such Local Office."
The Land Registry consists of a central office in Dublin and 25 provincial offices, of which 22 are managed by Clerks of the Peace and three are managed by outside solicitors. This Bill does not affect the central office or the three outside offices, but it necessarily affects the 22 provincial offices, and the amendment is introduced in order to make it quite clear that that is so. It is merely substituting new words for what is in the wording of the Bill.
Comment on this
I move:—
To insert before Section 30 but in Part 1 (relating to the Supreme Court and the High Court) a new section as follows:—
"Save and except Section 47 (which relates to the closing of district probate registries), nothing in this Act shall apply to the District Probate Registries, and none of those Registries shall for the purposes of this Act be deemed to be or to have been attached to the High Court or to the former Supreme Court of Judicature or any branch or division thereof."
That amendment is introduced to make it clear that until a district probate registry is closed down it is to continue as before. But for the amendment it might appear that these registries automatically closed down.
Amendment agreed to, and new section inserted accordingly.
Comment on this
I beg to move, on behalf of Deputy Hewat:—
In sub-section (2), line 56, page 10, to delete the words "hold office at the pleasure of the Executive Council" and substitute therefor the words "only removable by the Executive Council on the recommendation of the Judge of the Circuit Court to which he is attached."
This section deals with the appointment of county registrars to the Circuit Courts, and the proposal in the Bill is that these county registrars shall be appointed by the Executive Council. The Bill goes further and sets out that the registrars shall also be removable at the will and pleasure of the Executive Council. It has been thought desirable that, as these officials have to discharge duties of a semi-judicial character, not alone should they be placed in a position of some independence but that the judge of the court to which they are attached should have something to say before the services of the official are dispensed with. The amendment lays down that the services of an official can only be dispensed with by the Executive Council on the recommendation of the judge of the court. That maintains a principle that many of us thought was very desirable, and, in fact, very necessary in a Bill of this kind.
Comment on this
I have no objection to the principle underlying the amendment or to what the amendment seeks to achieve. The idea is to give to this semi-judicial officer a semi-judicial tenure, a tenure that would be nominally, and I think only nominally, stronger than the ordinary Civil Service tenure. As I say, I have entire sympathy with the principle underlying the amendment and the object which the amendment aims at. But let us consider the thing in practice. I think Deputy Hewat put down the amendment with an eye rather to the county court system of the past, and the mental picture he had of that, than to the circuit court system as it at present obtains, or rather will obtain in its fullness under the operation of this Bill. In the area of jurisdiction of a given circuit court judge, there may be as many as five or six county registrars. The judge will be absent from a given county, perhaps, as long as three or four months. In that state of affairs is it reasonable to ask the concurrence of the circuit judge in the removal of a particular county registrar? He may say in respect of the matters that are advanced as sufficient cause for such removal that he knows nothing of them. How could he? Let us suppose that it is proposed to remove County Registrar A.B. for not having attended to his office for two months, and that matter is submitted to the circuit judge. He might reasonably reply: "I note that you charge this officer that he did not attend to his office for two months together or perhaps for three months altogether. But at that time I was working hard on compensation cases in another county. I know nothing whatever of it, and if your Act makes my assent necessary to the removal of this officer, I will not give that assent in the absence of positive personal knowledge of the matters with which the officer is charged." That would be a quite fair and reasonable attitude for the judge to take up, but its result administratively would be that as long as a particular officer was able to avoid coming under the unfavourable notice of a circuit judge who might be in his county once in three or four months, he was rooted in his position. Considerations like that make me hesitate to agree to a principle that I would otherwise have complete agreement with—that the concurrence of the circuit judge should be made a necessity and condition precedent to the removal of the county registrar. The judge will be moving around. He will be absent for long periods from a given county. The matters complained of may be matters lying entirely outside his knowledge and experience and he might insist that without positive personal knowledge he would not give his concurrence in the removal. It is because I think the thing would be unworkable in practice that I am not disposed to accept the amendment, while I sympathise with the object the Deputy aims at.
Comment on this
I am sorry that the Minister does not see his way to accept this amendment, because it does appear to one as an exceedingly reasonable amendment. I happen to know something of the genesis of this amendment. It was put forward at a large conference which was held in Dublin to consider the provisions of this particular Bill, and it was felt by practically all those attending that conference that the powers of the Executive Council in connection with this proposed Bill were rather on the strong side, to put it mildly, and that it was desirable that certain limitations should attach to those powers so that they should not be exercised unfairly. As I pointed out when moving this amendment, the idea was that the appointment of these particular officers was left in the hands of the Executive Council as proposed in the original Bill. The removal of these officers in the original Bill was entirely in the hands of the Executive Council. I think every Deputy in the House will agree that that is a section that might be used unfairly, and this amendment seeks to limit the power of the Executive Council under that section only in so far as they must get a recommendation from the judge attached to that particular court before they can remove his assistant. That is desirable. I think one does not like to stress the question. Behind it are a great many principles that we would all approve of. I think it is a highly desirable limitation to put on this particular proposal. With all respect to the Minister, he gives as his reason against this amendment that it is unfair to cast that duty or that obligation on the judge of the court to which this officer is attached. What is the reason that the Minister states why it is unfair to put the obligation on the judge of the court? It is that he is the Circuit Court judge, that he may be called upon to discharge duties away from his own particular court and thereby be absent for long periods—
Comment on this
I pointed out that in the area of the jurisdiction of a given Circuit Court judge there might be four or five counties. The judge cannot be in all these counties at the same time. He must take them in rotation. That means that he will have to be absent from any one of them for three or four months at a stretch. Within that time the county registrar in that county might be guilty of grave misconduct that would warrant his removal, but the judge would not have personal knowledge of that, and might have difficulty in giving his concurrence because of the absence of personal knowledge.
Comment on this
I will take even that case that the Minister has put forward. The Circuit Judge has, say, to attend— and it is an extreme case—four or five courts, and for that reason he would not be able to say whether the senior officer in these courts had a reasonable cause for being absent for a period of two months, which was the case the Minister took. I am only speaking as a layman, but any of us who knows anything of judges who have to discharge somewhat similar duties know that in very few cases is there anything, even of the most minor importance, taking place in any of the four or five courts where they have to exercise jurisdiction that they are not aware of. Such a case is, with all respect to the Minister, scarcely one that any of us could look upon as a reasonable one on which to ground opposition to an amendment of this character. I am quite satisfied that if a case or two of the character mentioned did occur they would be looked upon, certainly by the judiciary, as exceedingly exceptional cases, and not at all as incidents that are likely to occur frequently. It was expressed, and strongly expressed, at that conference that limitations should be attached to the powers of the Executive Council in connection with these officials.
Comment on this
I need not go into details. It was a conference called in Dublin by the Chambers of Commerce to consider this Bill.
Comment on this
Not that I want in any way to take from some of the advantages that would accrue from having the Minister present, but if we wanted to get an impartial view of the Bill I think we would scarcely go to the Minister; much as we all admire his views and his abilities, we would scarcely look upon him as an impartial authority on a Bill for which he is responsible. It is desirable that these officials, who have to discharge duties of a semi-judicial character, should be protected if, in the discharge of their duties, they are brought into conflict with the Executive Council. I think it is up to this House, in the interests of the laws of our country and the good conduct of officials in the duties they are called upon to discharge, to protect these officials. Therefore, I say that it is desirable that limitations should be placed on these powers, and as far as I am concerned, knowing the views of that conference and knowing the force, and, I think, the justice, with which these views were put forward, as expressed in the amendment, I certainly shall have no alternative but to press it to a division if the amendment is not accepted by the Minister.
Comment on this
I think the case made by Deputy Good is a sound one, and I cannot understand how the Minister, while perceiving the principle and desiring to apply it, raises the objection that the judge who is referred to here may not have personal knowledge of the incidents which the Minister would deem to be sufficient to warrant the dismissal of the registrar. The Minister will not have personal knowledge either. The Minister's staff, the people who will report to the Minister, will report matters, presumably, within their knowledge, and he will judge upon those reports. The judge also would do the same. I can see that the Registrar of the High Court, who is not to be removed without the concurrence of the Chief Justice and the President of the High Courts, might commit acts which would warrant calling for his dismissal, such acts not being within the knowledge of the Chief Justice or the President of the High Court. These matters would have to be brought to the notice of the Chief Justice or the President of the High Court, and I do not see any difference in the practical working out of the proposition, which the Minister approves of in principle, with respect to the registrar of the Circuit Court as compared with the registrar of the High Court. The judge would, presumably, be consulted and have presented to him the evidence that had been presented to the Minister, and if the concurrence of that judge were sought he would be forming his judgment on the same evidence as that on which the Minister himself was forming his judgment. I cannot understand, therefore, that while the principle is accepted, there can be any objection to the practice, inasmuch as that practice has already been conceded with respect to the High Courts.
Comment on this
Of course there is a very considerable difference between the position in the higher courts and the position in the circuit courts. In the higher courts the judges have almost daily contact with the officials during the round of the law year. In the circuit court the position, as I have already emphasised to Deputy Good, is very different. Some circuit judges will have as many as six county registrars in their area of jurisdiction. That means that they will have about six weeks contact in the year with an individual county registrar, and we are asked to put upon the circuit judge, in the face of that situation, the burden of assenting to, or refusing to assent to, the discharge of an officer of whom he really knew very little.
Comment on this
I will know more. I will have administrative contact with these officers from January to December, and, as I say, the judge might very well answer: "You propose to remove this officer for unsatisfactory attendance at his office over a given period, for dissatisfaction to the public, and so on. I was in Mayo between these dates and I know nothing." Suppose the position were that the accounts of a particular county registrar were invariably late and, when they did arrive, were utterly unsatisfactory, you might be met with the comment from the circuit judge that he knew nothing of that, that he was not a judge of accounts, and so on. If you had the High Court and the Supreme Court position of almost daily contact between the official and the judge, I would see no objection, but where you have only six weeks in the year contact, then I submit it is unwise to press that the concurrence of the judge should be required in respect of matters of which, in the nature of the case, he could not have direct or personal information. Some judges might be very scrupulous as to the degree of positive personal knowledge they would require before assenting to the removal of an officer. A judge who is out of the county, in which the officer functions, for 46 out of the 52 weeks can have very little in the nature of direct personal knowledge as to the degree of satisfaction a particular officer is giving, either to the public of his county or to the Department of which he is an officer. That is not the High Court position and that is not the Supreme Court position. There is little, if any, analogy. If there was a circuit court for every county, I would fully accept the principle that this semi-judicial officer, or this officer who performs some acts at any rate of a semi-judicial nature, might be given a tenure stronger than that of the civil servant, and that the concurrence of the judge under whom he works should be a condition precedent to his removal; but in the actual case, with the judge absent for ten months of the year from the county in which that officer works, I do object to making the concurrence of the judge a condition precedent to the removal of the county registrar.
Comment on this
Let us take the example of Dublin. There would be close contact between the officer in Dublin and the presiding judge, and the same would also be true of Cork. Are we to deal only with exceptional cases such as the Minister referred to in order to put these officials in Dublin and in Cork entirely into the hands of the Executive Council? Is it wise, I ask, to do that? If the Minister would consider adding some words to this amendment that would meet a particular case in the unusual event of a judge being unable to express any opinion for or against a particular reason why the official was absent and that then the Executive Council should act in order to meet such an unusual emergency, I would be agreeable to that, but to place these officers who, as the Minister admits, have to discharge duties of a semi-judicial character, entirely in the hands of the Executive Council is, I think, exceedingly undesirable. If the Minister would go as far as to agree to accept the amendment and then add to it such words as would cover the case that he refers to, I would be quite willing to accept that.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister will resist this amendment as strongly as possible. In what were called the good old days, the clerk of the Crown and Peace, in certain counties, certainly had a very good time of it. The office, I think, was regarded as a very good one—in fact, a plum. I think, in a great many cases, the attendance of these officers at their offices left a great deal to be desired. I often wondered whether their non-attendance was ever reported to the higher authorities by the judge. Of course I can understand that in many cases it would have been very difficult in the old days for the judge to have to make a report against this official, for the reason that he came into such intimate contact with him, and very often was a great personal friend of his. For that reason I think that the arrangement the Minister is now proposing is a far better one—that the responsibility for removing or remonstrating with an official of the kind should come from headquarters. I am, therefore, in agreement with this arrangement which the Minister proposes.
Comment on this
The principle and the practice have been admitted and adhered to in the High Court. Therefore, I cannot see how Deputy Johnson's argument, as to why they should not also be applied to the circuit courts, can be met. The Minister has said truly that the circuit court judge will not be in constant contact with officials such as these are going to be. He will certainly not be in daily contact with them, and I admit all that the Minister has said in regard to the number of the courts and intervals that elapse between the holding of them. At the same time, the circuit court judge is not, if I may say so, entirely out of touch with these officials. While he is acting elsewhere he is often in communication with them dealing with matters which refer not to the court that the judge is actually attending at the moment, but rather to the court of the official. Though the judge may not have what the Minister described as positive personal knowledge of anything in the nature of misconduct on the part of one of these officials, he certainly could not very well be completely in the dark as to what was going on in the conduct of one of the courts over which it is his duty to preside. I think the case that the Minister has put is a very extreme on and one that would not be likely to arise. Certainly, if a court registrar was not attending to his duties for two months, and even though the circuit judge might not be in his bailiewick during that period, I do not think that could happen without it coming to the knowledge of the judge. He would be the first probably that complaints would be made to about the conduct of this official, and as Deputy Johnson, I think, said, he would be a better judge of the conduct of one of these officials than the Minister himself. If the official's conduct were to be brought into question and were brought before the Minister for Justice, the latter. I venture to suggest, would turn first to the circuit judge to ask for information concerning the conduct of this official. On the grounds of the extreme case put forward by the Minister—the Minister himself admits the soundness of the principle that applies in the High Court—I do not think it would be inadvisable to apply the same principle to the circuit courts.
It is true that the cases are somewhat different and a Circuit Court Judge has to attend to various courts. He cannot be everywhere at once, but at the same time, though he may have to preside over five courts, while he is presiding over one court he inevitably must be in communication with officials in his other courts. I think it is well that should be recognised, as showing the extent and the character of the work that has to be done by the Circuit Judge, because at the time of the passing of the Courts of Justice Act people seemed to regard their task in the future as a light one. I say this is one of the difficulties of the position of a circuit judge, that while he is away from one court he is really never away from it, but is in constant communication with the officials of the court because he has to direct various operations and he has to know generally what is being done. Therefore I do not think the case the Minister has made is altogether an answer to the amendment that has been proposed, especially in view of the fact that the Minister himself says that he accepts the principle, and also in view of the fact that he has not only admitted it but applied it to the High and Supreme Courts.
Comment on this
I wonder would the Minister look favourably upon the suggestion that the concurrence of the Chief Justice should be sought. The point I should like to make in the matter is that we want to remove the possibility of suspicion that other influences than administration and legal efficiency may operate in the dismissal of a registrar.
Comment on this
Such as political friendship—any other factor of the kind that operated in the Minister's mind when he consented to a similar regulation in regard to the High Court and the Supreme Court. Whatever influenced the Minister to accept amendments inserted in the Bill with regard to the officials of the Supreme Court applies—perhaps to some less extent, I do not know—but it applies in respect of the Circuit Courts; the end sought for and the principle embodied in the amendment which the Minister accepts would be met, I think, if the concurrence of the Chief Justice was sought before the registrar was dismissed. All the evidence that would be available for the Minister would be available to be laid before the Chief Justice, and while there is no personal contact in the case and personal knowledge of the faults which might warrant dismissal, the other point of view, that Deputy Wolfe expressed, that the personal friendship of the Circuit Judge to the registrar might influence the Circuit Judge, would be absent. The assurance would be at least that no political influences were at work in leading to the dismissal of any registrar and undoubtedly that is a thing to be desired. I think the Minister might consider reasonably if he cannot accept the judge of the Circuit Court before authorising the dismissal, or announcing the dismissal, of a registrar of a Circuit Court, that the concurrence of the Chief Justice should be obtained.
Comment on this
I move the following amendment:—
"In sub-section (3) (a), page 11, line 3, after the word ‘years' to insert the words ‘and whose age does not exceed fifty years at the time of his appointment.'"
My reason for moving the amendment is that the retiring age, according to Section 31, is 65, and I think the State should get service from a man for fifteen years before it should be burdened with a pension.
Comment on this
I am not inclined to accept the amendment. In general, we look for a man below the age mentioned in the amendment, but there may be exceptional cases. There may, for instance, be cases where competent men below that age are not available, and I would not like to tie my hands, or the hands of the Executive Council, by saying in a hard and fast way that we would not appoint a man over fifty years of age. Deputy O'Connor referred to the retiring age mentioned in Section 31 of the Bill. If Deputies refer to sub-section (5) of that section they will see that every county registrar shall retire at the age of sixty-five. That is the statutory age limit. The sub-section goes on to say—"but such age of retirement may, in the case of any particular county registrar, be extended by the Minister to any age not exceeding sixty-eight years." There may be a question about this on Report, and I will consider in the meantime whether the age of sixty-eight might not be extended by another two years, that is, to the age of seventy. Even, however, leaving it at the age of sixty-eight, a man coming in at the age of fifty, fifty-one or fifty-two, will give sixteen or eighteen years' service, and, as you get on in the fifties, the fact that the pension depends on the number of actual years of service given will tend to deter the older men. We have, for instance, the experience that a man who can only look forward to a short term of office and who, consequently, will not be eligible for a considerable pension on retiring, hesitates to take the position. I do not believe that we will have many applicants for a position of this sort above the age of fifty-five or, at any rate, fifty-six. In general, we will look for men below the age mentioned in the amendment. We should hope to get men very much below the age of 50 years. I do not want to accept in a hard and fast way that, in an exceptional case, we would not appoint a man who would be more than that.
Comment on this
Would the Minister be prepared to extend the age to 55 years?
Comment on this
The Minister's reply to this amendment opens up rather an undesirable vista of irresponsibility. The amendment before us seeks to provide that a person shall not be appointed to a particular post if he be over 50 years of age. The Minister says he is not prepared to put in any age limit. If we were dealing with probability or with likelihood, the Minister would probably be right in saying that it would be unlikely that a man over 55 years would be appointed. But the Minister does not want to have an age limit at all. Up to the age of 68 a man could be appointed. The amendment, I think, is a reasonable one. If you are going to put a man in a permanent position, you must have some regard to his age, since the office is pensionable, and you must have regard to the number of years' service that is going to run. We all recognise that the span of human life has lengthened in recent years. A man of 50 years or 60 years is not now a particularly old man. If I dealt with the matter in detail, I might become personal. At the same time, we must have regard to the age when taking a man into the service of the State to fill a pensionable office. That should not be done at a time when he has expended the greater part of his youthful energy in other directions. I should have imagined that 50 would have been accepted as a reasonable age. Even if that limit were extended, it would be better than to have no limit at all. It is clearly undesirable not to have a limit.
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy's idea of reasonableness is. Supposing there seemed a prospect of getting ten years' good service from a man, in the absence of competent younger men applying for the post, would the Deputy consider it reasonable to employ such a man even on a basis of 10 years' service? He would get ten-sixtieths of his salary—that is one-sixth—as pension, and if he served 15 years he would get fifteen-sixtieths or one-fourth of his salary. It comes down to this in the end: What is it worth to the State to put in a good man—a man who is considered competent—on the basis of a probable ten years' service as against putting in a younger man who is not competent? It would be very difficult to size it up in terms of cash. But that is the problem. That is my objection to tying my hands by saying definitely that a person shall not be appointed above the age of X years.
I do say to the Deputy that in general we would look for a younger man than a man of fifty years, although 50 —if I did agree on Report Stage to fix the age at 70 as the outside age limit for the position—would mean 20 years' service. In general we would look for men considerably under that age. Supposing they were not forthcoming, or supposing that only men under that age were forthcoming that were not really competent to fill the position and perform the duties attaching to the position, where does true economy lie? Does it lie in taking a competent man at 50 years of age or upwards with his prospect of giving ten or fifteen years' good service or taking the incompetent man of 35, 38 or 40 who, no doubt, would give longer service of a kind before he draws his pension? That is the problem. I present it to the Deputy and, if he wishes, both he and I can give mature consideration to it between this and the Report Stage.
Comment on this
In this we are dealing with assumptions. Is the Minister right in assuming that the attraction of the public service, as represented by this post of registrar, will not produce, in the solicitors' profession, not merely a single individual but a number of competitors for the post? If the Minister's assumption is rightly founded, his argument is greatly strengthened, but I am not prepared to accept that as a hypothesis. Knowing the solicitors' profession, as we do, and its competency, this position is one which will have not merely a single suitable applicant, but competitive applicants under 50 years of age. If the position is to be so unattractive as not to appeal to the solicitors, the Minister's argument is well founded. You may not get applications, although the suitable men are there, but I would not like to base any argument upon that assumption.
Comment on this
If the Minister fixes the period as in Section 31, sub-section 3 (a), that the officer must be of eight years' standing, it is only reasonable that the maximum age should also be fixed.
Comment on this
That is for the mover to say. If the amendment is to be decided now I will stand against it.
Comment on this
If the Minister agrees I would say 55 years of age. I do not press the amendment.
Comment on this
The mover of the amendment asks for leave to withdraw it. Has the Deputy the leave of the Committee?
Comment on this
If the amendment is defeated now it cannot be moved on Report. Objection having been taken to allow the amendment to be withdrawn, I shall now put it.
Comment on this
Unanimous leave must be given to allow an amendment to be withdrawn. Deputy Johnson objects and the alternative is to put the amendment.
Comment on this
I move:—
To add to sub-section (3), page 11, a new paragraph as follows:—
"(d) a person who has heretofore acted for not less than ten years as principal assistant to the Clerk of the Crown and Peace or as Senior Clerk in the Office of a County Registrar."
It is submitted that if this provision is adopted it would attract intelligent young men to the office, and after a few years they would be fully qualified.
Comment on this
I could not accept that amendment. The County Registrar is a professional man, and we will endeavour, as far as possible, to see that he is a man of considerable standing in his profession. Of all the court officers he will probably approximate most closely to the position of a junior judge. This proposal is that a member of his office staff shall be eligible for appointment to the position, provided he has served for a sufficient number of years in the office—ten years. I could not accept that. The staffs in the offices of the Clerks of the Crown and Peace are not even of the general education of second-grade civil servants. It is true that in the course of time they acquire a pretty good routine knowledge of the work of the office, just as it might be said that a district court clerk acquires a certain amount of routine knowledge of the duties of the District Justice. We do not propose to appoint a district court clerk to the position of District Justice, or to make him eligible for such an appointment. To do that would be really on a level with saying that an official in the office of the Clerk of the Crown and Peace, or of the County Registrar, shall be eligible in time to be appointed as County Registrar.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister is acting fairly towards clerks who have had long service. Surely these men have as good a knowledge of the duties as some of the persons mentioned in the Bill. These clerks in the Crown and Peace offices are not eligible for pensions. If they serve for thirty or forty years, and then resign through ill-health or for other reasons, they receive no gratuity or pension. Having regard to their service, they should be eligible for these appointments and should be treated like the registrars of the courts as regards pensions.
Comment on this
I think it has been established, or is being established in this Bill, that the Clerk of the Crown and Peace shall be a solicitor of some years' standing. It has not been expected hitherto, I think, that the clerks would have any such qualifications, although a considerable number of them had such qualifications. They have a very great knowledge of legal matters, perhaps even more than their official heads. Still we must consider the legal qualifications of men for such an important position as the registrar of the county. In the past many of the clerks were most efficient men. I have in my mind a particular instance—a more efficient clerk could not be found —still I do not think that he would ever think of aspiring under present circumstances to one of these posts. Although these men have acted for the Clerks of the Crown and Peace in the absence of their principals, I do not think we could take it as a good principle that they should be promoted to these positions when a particular qualification is required. Under the circumstances I do not think the amendment should be pressed. I do not think it is consistent with the Bill, however worthy of compensation these clerks may be in regard to pension or gratuity.
Comment on this
I challenge that ruling. According to the Standing Orders, if an amendment is proposed and then withdrawn by a Deputy, if objection is taken by any Deputy the amendment must be put unless there is unanimity for its withdrawal.
Comment on this
I did not hear any opposition expressed to its withdrawal. I will put the amendment now.
Comment on this
I move:—
In page 11, before sub-section (4), to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"For the purposes of paragraph (a) of the foregoing sub-section, service as a Justice of the District Court shall in the case of a Justice of the District Court who was admitted as a solicitor before he was appointed to be such Justice, be deemed to be practice as a solicitor."
Sub-section 3 (a) provides that one of the persons eligible for county registrar shall be a solicitor of not less than eight years' standing who is then actually practising, or previously practised for not less than eight years. The effect of the amendment is to provide that where a solicitor has been appointed a District Justice the term of service as District Justice shall count as eight years' practice as a solicitor.
Comment on this
I move:—
In sub-section (4), page 11, to delete lines 10 to 13 and substitute the following words—"for the time being in force and there may be granted either to a county registrar on retirement or to his legal personal representative on death such superannuation and other allowances or gratuities as might under the Superannuation Acts for the time being in force have been granted had such county registrar been appointed to the permanent Civil Service of Saorstát Eireann with a certificate from the Civil Service Commissioners."
It provides for the substitution of certain words in lines 10 to 13. It is merely an alteration in the drafting, and it is not intended to alter the sense of the sub-section.
Comment on this
I move amendment 41:—
In sub-section (5), page 11, line 16, after the word "Minister" to insert the words "with the concurrence of the Minister for Finance."
The amendment is to provide that where the retiring age is increased from 65 to 68, the Minister for Finance must be consulted before the extension can be made.
Comment on this
Could the Minister give us a little more information as to his intentions regarding the retiring age? I gather that he is still in doubt, or is leaving it open to representations in the Dáil, as to whether 68 is satisfactory. I should like to record my view that 68 is not enough, when 70 is required in the case of officers of the High Court. If the Master of the High Court and the Taxing-Master may continue in office until the age of 70, I cannot see any good reason why the Registrar of the Circuit Court should be obliged to retire at 65, with the possibility of extension to 68. I think the contention which, if I remember aright, was advanced about the excessive wear and tear upon a judge of the Circuit Court, as compared with a judge of the High Court, does not apply to the case of the Registrar, inasmuch as he is attached to his court and has not to travel, which was alleged to be the reason in the case of judges for an early retiring age. I think that the age of 65 or 68 years might well be extended to 70 in this case, as in the cases of the Master of the High Court and the Taxing-Master. I do not know whether the Minister's doubt applies only to the power of the Minister to extend the age of retirement to 68 years, or whether it also applies to the question of the normal retiring age. I hope that the Minister will favourably consider the proposal that the retiring age should be 70 and not 65.
Comment on this
I am inclined to agree with the Deputy as to the advisability of adding two years to the outside age limit, making it 70 instead of 68. If that were so, then the position you would have really in practice is that, in the absence of some rather marked decline in physical and mental powers, a man would serve until 70, but that as from 65 up to 70, if it were evident that a man were unfit to perform adequately and satisfactorily the duties of his office, it would be in the power of the Minister to intimate to him that that was considered to be the case and that he should retire. So that during the last five years there would be that kind of discretionary elasticity which would be broadly applied and a man would only be asked to retire sooner than 70 if we considered that the public were not really getting value for his salary. It is in that spirit that I believe, either by me or anybody else, the sub-section would be administered and applied: that simply we fix the age of 65 and the outside age limit of 70, and within that period if a man were failing he could be notified that we did not consider he should remain on and try to perform the duties of his office.
Comment on this
I think that is very desirable, especially in view of the opinion expressed by the Minister when introducing this measure that he was particularly anxious to retain the services of as many of the existing officials as he possibly could, and not to extend unduly that list which is already a very long one, known as the pension list. I think from our knowledge of those court officials we are all agreed that there are a great many of the existing officials who, even at the age of 70, are still capable of discharging satisfactorily their many duties. I think that none of us would be in favour of going beyond the age of 70, but I hope that up to that age the Minister will see his way to encourage as many of the existing officers as he possibly can to continue in the service of the Department up to that age.
Comment on this
I move amendment 42:
In page 12 to delete sub-section (4) and substitute a new sub-section as follows:—
"(4) All expenses, fees and allowances heretofore payable or receivable under the Electoral Act, 1923 (No. 12 of 1923), the Local Government Electors Registration Act, 1924 (No. 7 of 1924), or the Juries Acts, 1871 to 1924, to or by the Clerk of the Crown and Peace (whether as registration officer or otherwise) shall be payable to and receivable by the county registrar in the same manner in all respects and at the like rates as the said expenses, fees and allowances were heretofore payable to or receivable by the Clerk of the Crown and Peace, but the Minister for Finance may by order require any county registrar to surrender to the Exchequer so much of such expenses, allowances and fees as is not required by such county registrar to meet disbursements and expenses payable or incurred by him under the said Acts or any of them and not payable out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas."
It is merely a redrafting of the section without any alteration of the sense of it.
Comment on this
I should like to raise a question here that might be dealt with at a later stage. It is whether the constitutional requirements regarding certain of those funds going into the Central Fund have been considered. One or two questions have been raised in the past. The Minister may be aware of the query regarding the Fines Fund, and I am not sure whether the same arguments which applied to that do not apply to some of the fees referred to in this particular section. I would ask the Minister to consider the question as to whether this conforms with the requirements of the Constitution regarding the Central Fund, and whether he will consult the Minister for Finance on the question raised.
Comment on this
I will see whether there are any lurking difficulties. My own impression at the moment is that the section is all right from that angle, but I will ascertain definitely whether the Minister for Finance agrees with that.
Comment on this
A question will arise at a later stage as to transfers to the Central Fund. A number of these fees at present fall into the hands of the local authority, and local funds are to be deprived of that income. One would like to know before the Bill passes the exact nature of these fees which are transferred from the local to the central authority, and the amount, so that we may be in a position to judge whether it is wise to take from the local authorities and throw a charge on the local authorities of an equivalent amount.
Comment on this
I take it that the Minister, at a later stage, will have no objection to give the information asked for.
Comment on this
Certainly not.
SECTION 35.
(1) No appointment shall be made to the office of under-sheriff after the passing of this Act.
(2) In every county and county borough in which the office of under-sheriff is vacant at the commencement of this part of this Act all the powers, duties, authorities, rights, and obligations of the several under-sheriffs of such counties and county boroughs respectively shall as on and from such commencement become and be transferred to and vested in or imposed on the several county registrars of such counties and county boroughs respectively.
(3) In every county and county borough in which the office of under-sheriff is not vacant at the commencement of this Part of this Act all the powers, duties, authorities, rights, and obligations of the several under-sheriffs of such counties and county boroughs respectively shall as on and from the respective dates on which the office of under-sheriff in such counties and county boroughs respectively first becomes vacant after the commencement of this Part of this Act become and be transferred to and vested in or imposed on the several county registrars of such counties and county boroughs respectively.
Comment on this
I move to delete the section. The section is not really being deleted but is being transferred to Part 4, the miscellaneous part of the Bill.
Comment on this
I would like this explained further. Does that mean that they are to be independent of the under-sheriffs? Is there a proposal to amalgamate these two offices?
Comment on this
The portion of the Bill in which the section is deals with the Circuit Courts, and the effect of putting this section into this particular portion of the Bill would mean that it is only particular duties that are being transferred. For that reason the section is being taken out of this part and put into the miscellaneous part.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 44:—
To add at end of section a new sub-section as follows:—
"(4) The County Registrar if and when he takes up the duties of the office of under-sheriff shall be empowered to employ the staff of the under-sheriff."
Comment on this
Might I suggest that Deputy Myles Keogh be permitted to put this amendment down after amendment 62?
Comment on this
Yes, it can be taken subsequent to amendment 62.
SECTION 36.
(1) In the event of the temporary absence or the temporary incapacity through illness of any county registrar or in the event of the office of county registrar for any circuit court office being vacant the Minister may appoint a deputy to execute the office of such county registrar during such absence, incapacity, or vacancy but unless and until the Minister appoints such deputy the office of such country registrar shall (save as is hereinafter provided) be executed during such absence, incapacity, or vacancy by the senior officer in the circuit court office.
(2) A deputy appointed under this section shall, while his appointment continues, have and exercise all the powers and authorities and shall perform and fulfil all the duties and functions of the county registrar whose deputy he is.
(3) Rules of court may provide that specified powers, authorities, duties, and functions of a county registrar shall not be exercised or performed by the senior clerk under this section, and where rules of court so provide the powers, authorities, duties, and functions so specified shall not be exercised or performed by the senior clerk under this section.
(4) Except in the case of the temporary incapacity of a county registrar through illness no office shall be executed by a deputy appointed under this section for any period or periods exceeding in all three months in any year.
(5) No person shall be appointed under this section to be a deputy for a county registrar unless he possesses the qualifications prescribed by this Act for persons appointed to be county registrars.
Comment on this
I move:—
In sub-section (3) to delete in lines 54 and 57 the word "clerk" and in each case to substitute the word "officer."
That is a verbal amendment.
Comment on this
I move:—
To add at the end of the section two new sub-sections as follows:—
"(6) This section shall not operate to authorise the senior officer in a circuit court office to exercise the powers or authorities or perform the duties or functions of the county registrar as registration officer under the Electoral Act, 1923 (No. 12 of 1923) or any Act amending or extending that Act, and Section 10 of that Act shall apply to the exercise and performance of those powers, authorities, duties and functions during any temporary absence or temporary incapacity through illness of the county registrar or any vacancy in the office of county registrar until a deputy is appointed under this section but not thereafter.
(7) After the powers, authorities, duties, and functions of any under-sheriff have become transferred under this Act to a county registrar, the powers, authorities, duties and functions of such under-sheriff as returning officer under the Electoral Act, 1923, shall not be exercisable by the senior officer under this section, and in lieu thereof whenever such county registrar is temporarily absent or incapacitated through illness or his office is vacant the Minister for Local Government and Public Health may if he so thinks fit appoint a fit and proper person to exercise and perform those powers, authorities, duties and functions during such absence, incapacity, or vacancy until a deputy is appointed by the Minister for Justice under this section."
The effect of that amendment is to make it possible for the Minister for Local Government to appoint such a person to carry on the work of a registration officer, and to carry out Parliamentary elections if the county registrar is unable to do the work. The same power exists in regard to the Clerk of the Crown and Peace and the under-sheriff. The intention is to make it clear that the passing of this Act does not put an end to that power.
Comment on this
Before we pass this section I would like to ask who is to appoint the general staff? It says the Minister, with the sanction of the Minister for Finance, shall determine how many officers and terms of service. Will it be the circuit judge, the county registrar, or the Minister who will make the appointments? I think we are entitled to know that.
Comment on this
Formally the Minister will appoint in the same way as I appoint civil servants, perhaps, in my Department, or in a department under that. That has no reference to the exact machinery that will be applied for recruitment.
Comment on this
I should like the Minister to go a little further, and tell me if the appointments will be made on Civil Service terms after an examination, or after some sort of interview by the Selection Board.
Comment on this
They will be appointed through the machinery of the Civil Service Commission. When I say I appoint I mean the mere formal act of appointment.
Comment on this
I move:—
In sub-section (2), line 13, to delete the words "subject to the provisions of this section."
These words are a survival from an earlier draft and have no meaning here. They were included by accident.
Comment on this
I move:—
To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
(3) Every such summons-server shall be and is hereby declared to be competent to serve within the area served by the circuit court office to which he is attached any writ, summons, process, notice or other document issued by or from any court."
That was omitted by mistake from the print of the Bill.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
In sub-section (2), page 13, line 23, before the word "hold" to insert in brackets the words "(unless he is a pensionable officer)."
The ordinary tenure of a pensionable office is at the pleasure of the Executive Council. There is no reason why a pensionable district court clerk should not have the same tenure.
Comment on this
In regard to amendments Nos. 51 and 52 I should point out that if 51 is carried No. 52 falls through.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment No. 51, which is as follows:—
Before sub-section (4) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"(4) Every person who becomes a district court clerk under this Act by virtue of the next preceding sub-section of this section shall, when computing the period of his service for the purposes of the Superannuation Acts, 1834 to 1923, be entitled to reckon as continuous service for those purposes whatever period (if any) of service he was immediately before the commencement of this Part of this Act entitled to reckon as service for those purposes and his period of service as a district court clerk under this Act."
The object of that amendment is to put beyond doubt the fact that the Bill does not in any way break the continuity of service of a pensionable clerk in such a position, say, as clerk of the Dublin Metropolitan Police Court.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
"In line 49, after the word ‘commencement' to insert the words ‘of this Part.'"
The reason it is desired to insert this amendment is that it is possible that different parts of the Act may be put into operation at different times.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
"(2) In addition to the powers, authorities, duties and functions mentioned in the foregoing sub-section, every district court clerk in the Dublin Metropolitan Area shall have, exercise, perform and fulfil, within so much of that Area as is within his district all the powers, authorities, duties and functions vested or imposed by any statutes in force immediately before the commencement of this Part of this Act in or on the chief clerk, or the principal clerk, or any other clerk of the Dublin Metropolitan Police Courts."
Prior to the Courts of Justice Act of 1924 the Chief Clerk of the Dublin Metropolitan Police Court was by statute Registrar in the Dublin Metropolitan area. It is intended that he should continue to act in that capacity, but as there is some doubt on the matter it is considered well to make it clear by the introduction of this amendment.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
In sub-section (1), page 14, to delete all from the word "same," line 1, to the word "paid," line 4, and to substitute the words "invested funds and other moneys for the time being in the hands of the registrar of district court clerks or standing in the name of that registrar either alone or jointly with any other public official," and in line 4, after the word "funds" to insert the words "or moneys."
The purpose of this amendment is to make it clear that out of the funds, the salaries of the District Court Clerks are to be paid pending dissolution of the fund.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
In page 14, to add at the end of sub-section (2) the words "and the expression ‘registrar of district court clerks' means the person appointed under the Petty Sessions Clerk (Ireland) Act, 1858, to discharge the duties prescribed by that Act for the registrar to perform."
This is merely transferring the definition of the Registrar or District Court Clerk.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
"To delete sub-section (1)."
This is merely transferring the definition from one section to another.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—
"(5) Every person who immediately before the appointed day is employed in a pensionable capacity in the office of the Registrar of District Court Clerks shall be deemed to have been paid from moneys provided by Parliament or the Oireachtas within the meaning of Section 17 of the Superannuation Act of 1859, during the whole of his period of service in that office and shall be entitled to reckon as continuous service for the purpose of the Superannuation Acts, 1834 to 1923, the whole of his period of service in a pensionable capacity in the said office and any period of continuous service in a pensionable capacity in the Civil Service of Saorstát Eireann after the appointed day."
The effect of the amendment is to preserve the continuity of service of pensionable officers in the office of the Registrar of District Court Clerks. In fact there is only one such officer.
Comment on this
I would like to have a little more information on this. The new sub-section says: "Every person who immediately before the appointed day is employed in a pensionable capacity in the office of the Registrar of District Court Clerks shall be deemed to have been paid from moneys provided by Parliament or the Oireachtas within the meaning of Section 17 of the Superannuation Act of 1859, during the whole of the period of his service" etc. Is there any change involved or any increased charge upon the State by virtue of this proposal?
Comment on this
There is no increased charge. This is a statutory fund and we are to get all the proceeds of the Fund out of which payments are made by us.
Comment on this
This is the item on which I wanted to get details from the Minister. I take it he will supply them later.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
Before sub-section (3) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"(3) Whenever any fine, amercement, penalty, or forfeited recognisance is remitted in whole or in part after the same has been paid into or disposed for the benefit of the Exchequer under this section, such fine, amercement, penalty or forfeited recognisance or the portion thereof so remitted (as the case may be) shall be repaid out of the Exchequer in such manner as the Minister for Finance shall direct."
The purpose of this amendment is that in cases where a fine is remitted or reduced there may not be any difficulty in providing the necessary funds to repay the entire fine if it is remitted or the reduced portion in case of reduction. There have been cases in which there was some little difficulty.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
"In sub-section (3), line 60, after the word ‘person' to insert the words ‘or into such fund.'"
Fines are sometimes payable into a fund.
Comment on this
Of course we can discuss the individual amount of these fines and as to whether they should be put into the Central Fund or remain in the existing fund when the Minister gives us the information asked for. At the moment we have not got the volume of these fines or what is to be done with them. That can be discussed on the Report Stage, I take it.
Comment on this
There is another question involved which I think may have to be discussed more fully on the Report Stage. That is the principle that is being perpetuated under this Bill of paying over fines to an informer. It is one that has come down to us from the past, from a very long time ago, and I question very much whether it is desirable to perpetuate it —that certain sums that are levied on the prisoner or defendant shall be paid to the informer. I do not think it is at all a desirable practice to encourage that by promise of payment from penalties.
I would like to know whether the Minister has considered the desirability of continuing this practice, or will he consider the limitation of this on the Report Stage of the Bill?
Comment on this
Is not the term "informer" in this particular case rather an objectionable way of expressing what happens? Certain bodies have a right of prosecuting and they become informers. They are not really informers; they are prosecuting for certain acts, and when the court fines they get the money. I take it that is the way the thing operates. I do not think "informer" means actually informing on the part of an individual.
Comment on this
I think that Deputy Johnson is not correct in his interpretation of the effect of the section generally. It is not accurate to say it has the effect of continuing and stereotyping indefinitely this disposal of moneys. It leaves it open to administrative change in future, and one is not bound to continue anything that is considered objectionable.
I do not know whether Deputy Hewat's point could be met. The word is a technical term. It has been used in many statutes, and I think it would create a difficulty to get away from it. The fact that it is used colloquially with a certain amount of odium attaching to it should not make us baulk at it as a technical legal term, and it would require some looking into if we were to amend it.
Comment on this
In sub-section 3 the Minister is taking power to direct that the whole or any specified portion of every fine belonging to certain classes "shall not be paid into the Exchequer under this section and that, in lieu of being so paid, the whole or such specified portion (as the case may be) of every such fine shall be paid to such prosecutor, informer or other person and upon such terms and conditions as shall be specified...." I am raising the matter because it would seem under this new power the Minister is obtaining that fines can be handed over to the informer. It is a fact, I think, that certain classes of prosecutions take place at the instance of the common informer, and any informer might be tempted to take a prosecution with the prospect that he will get the fine or portion of the fine. I think it is quite an undesirable practice to perpetuate.
Comment on this
There were certain prosecutions brought by Boards of Conservators in connection with the fishery regulations, and portions of the fines imposed were in the past, by statute, paid over to the prosecutor. In the course of the Second Reading of this Bill, dealing with Section 43, I explained to the Dáil, in connection with the proposal to abolish the Fines and Fees Fund, that it had been decided to abolish this special fund altogether and to pay the fines and fees into the general Exchequer, and I asked the Dáil to vote annually the necessary money for the pensions, salaries and expenses of district court clerks in the same way as the Dáil votes the money for the pensions, salaries and expenses of the other court officers. I said:
"We propose to enact that in future all court fees and all fines shall go into the Exchequer direct instead of into a fund, and it will be observed that there is a provision for the making of orders under which certain classes of fines may be paid, not into the Exchequer, but in other directions to be specified in the order. The reason for that is that at present under various statutes there are certain persons and bodies having a right to certain fines or portions of certain fines. Local authorities, Gárda Síochána Reward Fund, and Fishery Conservators are just a few examples of that, and I have been informed that there is a regular entanglement or network of provisions of that kind which it would be impossible for any person to expound clearly. The law on this subject ought to be so simple and so clear that every district court clerk in the country might be expected to tell off the list of all the classes of fines in which vested interests of that kind exist. It is not at all clear at this stage that all these various vested interests in fines, whatever their origin and however justified they may have been in their origin, are now justified at all. You have rights of that kind created by statute 50 or 60 years ago, but the circumstances have altered so much in the meantime that there seems no longer any justification for the private right. Therefore, our object is, firstly, to clear up the existing confusion as to who is entitled to these rights irrespective of the merits; and, secondly, to eliminate claims which have ceased to be justifiable in the existing circumstances or claims which are so insignificant in amount as not to deserve a separate existence."
I added that, lest the second portion of our object—the elimination of claims which had ceased to be justifiable or insignificant—might appear menacing or confiscatory in character, in some cases the claims are those of Government Departments, and the present arrangement is merely a bookkeeping one, and merely the taking of money from one pocket and putting it into another. I explained that generally, if any person or body that at present has such a vested interest as has been referred to can put up a case that the abolition of that interest is unjust to individuals, or undesirable to individuals, it would be our duty to consider whether it would be advisable to make any change. The position we are taking up with regard to this is that we are asking the Dáil to say that, having examined into them at leisure, we can by order make such administrative arrangements as shall appear just and proper. That does not commit us to a continuation of the practice to which Deputy Johnson has referred, and which he considers objectionable. We are simply taking a rather wide power, in view of the number of such exceptions there are, to examine them in detail and to make our administrative dispositions by order and get away from the innumerable statutory provisions there are appearing on the subject.
Comment on this
Does not that rather open up a very large question of giving general powers of administration? This House may not realise how far-reaching those powers may be. From the Minister's explanation it would appear that the law is very entangled and the situation wants to be cleared up. At this stage the clearing-up process should be as complete as possible; the clearing-up process is not going to be done by this House but by the authority under this Bill which will give the Minister power to clear up the cases individually. How far is that sacrificing the rights of the people who are concerned in this matter? In other words, supposing an authority has had that right established by law, is it the proposal that the Minister under this Bill can come in and, without the consent of the authority, abolish the perquisites, if I may put it that way, that they have been in receipt of in the past, by statutory authority? It does seem to me that that is treating in a Bill in a very general way a whole heap of details and is taking them out of the decision of anybody but the Minister. We would assume, of course, that the exercise of that authority would be done in order and properly. At the same time, it is in essence taking away the right of the people to something that they had in the law altogether, and leaving them that right at the discretion of a Minister at some future time. I do not know whether that is what the Minister intends by what he said by way of explanation in this matter. But if the Dáil is satisfied to do that they should do it with the recognition that there may be cases involved in this on which the House might wish to express an opinion and be consulted on, but under this proposal they will not be consulted, nor will people have a right to appeal.
Comment on this
I might be able to meet the Deputy to some extent on the Report Stage by providing for the concurrence of the Dáil in any such order. The position really created by the section is that the rights go. But where a case can be established we are prepared by administrative order to meet that case. Where there is any substance or reality in the vested interests we are prepared to meet that case by an order which sub-section (3) of the section enables me to make with the concurrence of the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
Would the Minister make some safeguard for the people on the Report Stage? I think every Deputy here has a difficulty in this matter, because of the fact that it is a technical matter and of our want of knowledge of it. The only knowledge I have of this matter is in connection with the Port and Docks Board. They have something in this direction which is of no value. But it might be of some very considerable value, and I would object to the Minister making an order affecting, say, a body like the Port and Docks Board, leaving no appeal either to the Dáil or to the Court. If that were modified so as to make it possible to have an arrangement mutually come to as between the Ministry and the body concerned, so that that body would have some right of appeal, it would be more satisfactory.