We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

COURT OFFICERS BILL, 1926—THIRD STAGE RESUMED.

Contributions 146–290 of 290. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Court Officers Bill, 1926
Enacted

No. 5 of 1926 ›

It is, of course, quite a difficult matter, and the Deputy is quite right in describing it as being very technical. But the position I am seeking is this, that we should hack at this tangled position, withdraw these rights by statute, then find which amongst them are worthy of being resurrected by administrative order, or for which of them a really equitable case can be made on any ground, either on the ground of public expediency or on the ground of private merit, and so on. Such an order can be made under sub-section (3). If there is a feeling that the Dáil would like to know just what right we consider worthy of resurrecting in that manner, it can easily be provided on Report that these administrative orders shall be laid before the Dáil for its approval and that in the absence of a rescinding motion they shall have effect. I do not want to mislead the Deputy. The section, as I see it, removes the right, and a case must be put up for the revival or resurrection of any right which it is considered ought to endure in the future.

Comment on this

It might take the form of compensation. A person might be entitled to compensation for something taken away from him. I quite agree with the Minister that the whole system is rather out-of-date and ought to be dealt with in the way he suggests and as propounded in the Bill. But all I ask is that the Minister shall not be put in the arbitrary position of being able to make an order without appeal to anybody in the case of a person who may have a grievance or who may be damnified without having the right of bringing his case before some other tribunal from any arbitrary decision of the Minister.

Comment on this

I would be always responsible to Deputies by way of questions, and the concurrence of the Minister for Finance is necessary under sub-section (3), for the making of these administrative orders.

Comment on this

Yes, but the Minister for Finance is going to gain money by it.

Comment on this

Sub-section (2) is merely a transition section. Sub-section (1) removes these rights, and sub-section (3) enables us to resurrect by administrative order any of them that are considered worthy of resurrection. Therefore, it is not I who destroy the rights. I am asking the Dáil to destroy them, and then I am asking the Dáil to give administrative discretion to myself and the Minister for Finance to revive such of them as are considered worthy of reviving. If Deputies would like to see which amongst them are considered worthy of revival, then we can make provision that these orders should be laid before the Dáil for its approval. The effect of section 1 is to remove the rights and the concession is granted in sub-section (3).

Comment on this

My objection is to sub-section (1) in that case.

Comment on this

That is before you.

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister in connection with sub-section (1) to recognise that, for instance, where there is inter-departmental transfer of funds that there is not going to be any objection, but where there are private interests, outside bodies, I ask in ordinary justice that the Dáil shall not wipe away something by statutory authority that the people have enjoyed in years past; wipe it away without the right of appeal—in other words, without compensation.

Comment on this

I think there are important question raised in this section. One is if the fines are to be paid into the Central Fund, as I think they must be, the authority to pay them should not be on the head of an administrative order. I think such will have to be sanctioned by statute. I would like to ask the Minister if he has, in considering this whole question of the disposal of the fines, considered having the matter dealt with in the light of the views of the Department of Finance on this matter? The proposal to authorise the payment out of the Central Fund of money by order would be, I think, stretching beyond the authority of the Minister.

Comment on this

I want to raise rather a different point. It is that this section raises the rights of individuals under certain private Acts. For instance, I happen to have a fishery and that fishery is constituted under a private Act of the year 1837. Under that Act all fines levied in prosecutions come to the proprietor of the fishery; in other words, to me. I admit that generally I took proceedings under the Fisheries Act rather than under the private Act, because owing to the unfamiliarity of the justices adjudicating with this private Act I did not get convictions. But there are rights of individuals concerned. I am probably not the only person with a private Act of this kind, and I suggest that the section is one that requires a little consideration before the Report Stage.

Comment on this

On Deputy Johnson's point, I think the answer is that the payments under orders made by the powers asked for in sub-section (3) would be made out of the actual proceeds of the fines and before any payments into the Central Fund had been made.

Comment on this

Of course the constitutional question was raised before and I thought this was intended to meet it. It lies in the proposition that all revenues, from whatever source arising, shall, subject to such exceptions as may be provided by law, form one fund. Whether this is the kind of exception is doubtful, and that is why I press upon the Minister the importance of having the very highest opinion on this question.

Comment on this

We had very full consultation with the Department of Finance on that section.

Comment on this

And the Attorney-General?

Comment on this

I am not sure. I could not say positively that the Attorney-General was consulted on the section. But this section forms one of the outstanding matters in connection with this Bill that we had to discuss with the Department of Finance, and they have been satisfied with the provision in the sub-section. What Deputy Cooper says serves, of course, to emphasise what I have said, that this is a very difficult and tangled matter. These rights have grown up under a variety of statutes, and there are innumerable vested interests in small portions of fines imposed for one offence or another. What the Dáil is really being asked to do is, so to speak, to clear the ground and let us see how many of these are sound, reasonable and worthy of being revived and carried on into the new courts system. People who would consider themselves aggrieved by sub-section (1) are invited, as it were, under sub-section (3) to make their case, the Dáil giving discretion to two Ministers to meet the equitable cases by an administrative order. That is what is being asked. It would be a task of very great difficulty to ask a Department to set to work and examine into all these exceptions and all these petty vested interests that have grown up about fines and to bring them specifically one by one before the Dáil. We are asking power to take the other line of approach, that we withdraw them, see where the outcry comes from and then deal with the claims, taking power under sub-section (3) to deal with the claims and protests that will arise as a result of sub-section (1). I think that the Dáil has very frequently given wider powers than that to Ministers, and I think that it is little short of necessary to give the powers asked for in this section, and to take the step you are asked to take in sub-section (1)—to withdraw these rights, with power to revive such of them as are considered worthy of revival.

Comment on this

I do not attach— and I hope I made it clear—any great importance to my particular rights. So far as I am concerned, sub-section (3) will rest; I shall not assert any claims, because the poacher is not, as a rule, a good mark to levy a fine on, and especially a fine levied by a private individual. But might I suggest to the Minister that the formula there is a somewhat unhappy one—"prosecutor, informer or other person." The word "informer" was so offensive under past conditions, that people would be very slow to associate themselves with that description. I would suggest that "prosecutor or other such person" would be sufficient, and the Minister might consider something on those lines.

Comment on this

We will have a discussion on this matter again on Report, when we get the information from the Minister that he has been asked for, because the more we go into this particular section the more we see what is wrapped up in it, and until we get unfolded some of the particular items that are wrapped up in it and see exactly the extent to which it will interfere with local and other interests, I do not think we can go very much further with the discussion.

Comment on this

Let me be clear as to the Deputy's expectations for Report Stage. I could not undertake to bring before the Dáil by Report Stage an itemised list of these vested interests. I do not believe that I could manage in the time. I could no doubt, bring sample ones, but it would be a very considerable task to investigate all these cases of little portions of fines going to this person and to that body. It is simply practically as a result of the despair of being able to place such an itemised list before the Dáil that this section has taken its present shape, that we are asking the Dáil to withdraw these vested interests in fines, leaving power to us to re-create such of them as are considered worthy of revival. I only want to be clear that the Deputy will not be disappointed on the Report Stage. If the Deputy thinks that I could bring full information as to all the things that are affected by sub-section (1) of Section 43 before the Dáil by the Report Stage, I do not think I could undertake it.

Comment on this

Is the Minister not asking the House to do an extraordinary thing? It now appears that in Section 43 the Minister wants to establish a principle whereby the House is to wipe away something that they do not know the nature of at all. Is that fair to the House, and is it fair legislation? The more we proceed with this section the more it seems to me to be based on very arbitrary lines. I recognise that the object the Minister has in view is a good one, and I think most of the House will agree that the simplification of the existing laws as far as these fines are concerned would be good. But to say: "I am going to sweep away a number of rights; I do not know what they are myself," is something that I think the House should not accept. In other words, we do not know what we are being asked to do. Is that fair?

Comment on this

We swept away a lot of things and we built up a lot of things again. It is true that I do not know what they are in an accurate, precise and itemised way, but I do know the kind they are. I know that there is simply a variety of petty, trifling and little provisions of one kind or another almost negligible in their amounts, and when we proceed to ask for specific power to meet such claims as will arise—many will not arise—it will simply be regarded as a perfectly natural provision, on the establishment of a new court system, that these rights should disappear. Only the substantial ones will show their heads, and we are taking power to deal with those, so that the thing is not just so overwhelmingly revolutionary as Deputy Hewat is inclined to think, or inclined to say.

Comment on this

I am not saying it. I am only trying to develop the point that my ignorance is colossal on this subject on which I am asked to vote. We are asked to vote on an important section of this Bill without having that amount of knowledge that would enable us to come to a proper decision on the matter. The Report Stage will afford us the last opportunity we shall have of dealing with an important section of this kind, and what I am asking is that some substantial information with regard to it should be given to us before then.

Comment on this

I will give the Deputy ample information.

Comment on this

Could not the Minister go further than that?

Comment on this

The Deputy cannot get any further than that. He can put his amendment to a vote. I will bring ample information before the Dáil on Report Stage. I simply am not going to promise a thing that I cannot perform. I am not going to promise exhaustive information, and if Deputy Hewat and Deputy Good, as representatives of the commercial community, recognising the tremendous importance of sixpences, think that exhaustive information was not before them and that they could not support such a proposal as is embodied in Section 43, then they must only vote against the section.

Comment on this

I wonder could the Minister tell us whether he has in draft the kind of order that he proposes to make. For instance, we know that Deputy Good has an interest in the sums which go to the local authorities directly from fines in respect to matters which local authorities administer. We have had knowledge that quite a number of local authorities have expressed some concern in regard to this deprivation of certain of their revenues. If the Minister could give the House a copy of the draft of the order that he proposes to make in regard to these fines which are at present available for local authorities, I think that would give some of us some reassurance, and perhaps Deputy Good amongst us.

Comment on this

I would be glad to hear the Minister's reply to that suggestion.

Comment on this

I can only give the same kind of reply that I gave before, that I shall bring before the Dáil on Report Stage the kind of cases that will be affected by the sub-section. I can tell the Dáil in general what kind of case we might consider it necessary to meet, and what other kind of cases we would have to wait and have a case made for, and so on. I could deal with the matter at large, but I cannot deal with it exhaustively, and I am not going to promise to do what I know well I will not be in a position to perform.

Comment on this

One does not want to press the Minister to do anything that is unreasonable, but before the section is passed we want to know exactly what is included in it. If, under it, you are transferring fines that have in the past accrued to local authorities, then let us know exactly what those fines are. All we want is information. I suggest that to ask us to pass a bald statement of this character without knowing what is in it, is asking us to do what is unreasonable.

Comment on this

If it is a question of the degree of information, I certainly will give information, but I will not give all the information, because I have not got it myself, and because it would take me a considerable time to get it.

Comment on this

We will leave reasonable time for the Report Stage, and in that reasonable time the Minister, I am sure, will give us all the information he can get.

Comment on this

We will leave a week for the Report Stage, and within that week I will get the Deputy all the information that it is possible for me to get, but it will not be exhaustive.

Comment on this

In the meantime the Minister, I hope, will consider the question of safeguarding anybody who might be affected under this section.

Comment on this

I will get both Deputies so much information that I hope they will be able to salve their financial consciences and vote for the section.

Comment on this
AN LEAS CHEANN COMHAIRLE

in the Chair.

Comment on this

I move:—

To insert before Section 46 a new section as follows:—

"(1) No appointment shall be made to the office of under-sheriff after the passing of this Act.

(2) In every county and county borough in which the office of under-sheriff is vacant at the commencement of this Part of this Act all the powers, duties, authorities, rights and obligations of the several undersheriffs of such counties and county boroughs respectively shall as on and from such commencement become and be transferred to and vested in or imposed on the several county registrars of such counties and county boroughs respectively.

(3) In every county and county borough in which the office of under-sheriff is not vacant at the commencement of this Part of this Act all the powers, duties, authorities, rights and obligations of the several under-sheriffs of such counties and county boroughs respectively shall as on and from the respective dates on which the office of under-sheriff in such counties and county boroughs respectively first becomes vacant after the commencement of this Part of this Act become and be transferred to and vested in or imposed on the several county registrars of such counties and county boroughs respectively."

By amendment, this section was taken out of Part 2 of the Bill and it is now inserted in Part 4.

Comment on this
Myles Keogh Dr. MYLES KEOGH Independent

I move:—

To add at end of section a new sub-section as follows:—

"(4) The County Registrar if and when he takes up the duties of the office of under-sheriff shall be empowered to employ the staff of the under-sheriff."

I have been reading Section 46 and I think I see in it the substance of my amendment, which is before the House.

Comment on this

I have considered this amendment, and I am of opinion that it is not really necessary. If the employment of these men is found desirable in the public interest, there would be no difficulty whatever in arranging that without the specific power which the amendment gives. There is no obstacle to the county registrar employing them, and an express provision enabling him to do that is unnecessary. There are other considerations. For instance, the men at present employed by an under-sheriff are the personal selection of the under-sheriff. If they are suitable men, as the vast majority I believe are, there would be no difficulty about a county registrar when he takes on the duties of an under-sheriff simply taking on also the staff of the under-sheriff, and in Dublin, both in the county and in the county borough, the question will not arise for probably fifteen, twenty or twenty-five years. It is not necessary to make special statutory provision to cover the case of a situation that need not be expected to arise for twenty or twenty-five years, and to insert any express provision that the county registrar may employ those men, when there is, in fact, nothing whatever to prevent him, is unnecessary. The Deputy may take it that there is nothing to prevent the staffs of the under-sheriff being simply carried over to the new officer on whom the duties of the under-sheriff will devolve in due course, and it is not necessary to insert an express provision to the effect of his amendment.

Comment on this
Myles Keogh Dr. MYLES KEOGH Independent

Having got the Minister's assurance, I agree to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (4), page 15, line 29, after the word "Finance" to insert the words "and after consultation with the Chief Justice."

The amendment provides that the Chief Justice should also be consulted, he being the judge in whose jurisdiction lunatics' estates are.

Comment on this

I may say it was never intended to fix the fees without such consultation, but it has been thought necessary to insert that expressly in the Bill.

Comment on this

I move:—

Before sub-section (4) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(4) All salaries and pensions heretofore payable out of the Lunacy Fund shall after the closing day, if and so far as they respectively continue to be payable, be paid out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas as part of the expenses incurred in the execution of this Act, and all such expenses (other than salaries and pensions) as have heretofore been defrayed out of the Lunacy Fund shall after the closing day be defrayed either out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas or out of the said percentage charged on the estates of lunatics before the same is paid into the Exchequer as the Minister for Finance after consultation with the Chief Justice shall direct, and all such expenses (other than salaries and pensions) shall be so defrayed on the certificate of the Chief Justice certifying the amount and nature of each expense and that the same was duly incurred by his direction or with his approval."

The effect of the amendment is to make provision for salaries out of lunacy funds and to allow the Chief Justice more power and secrecy, as regards confidential payments, than are usually allowed in regard to payment of public moneys.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

In sub-section (3), line 54, to delete the words "registry was formerly" and substitute the words "fixed place of abode was."

The effect is that where the District Registry, possibly covering several counties, ceases to exist, applications for probate may be lodged with the county registrar for the county in which the deceased person's place of abode was.

Comment on this

I move amendment 66:—

"To add at the end of the section a new sub-section as follows:—

"(4) The Minister may, if and when he so thinks fit, by order make provision for enabling applications for probates of wills and letters of administration in cases in which the testator or intestate (as the case may be) at the time of his death had a fixed place of abode in Saorstát Eireann but not within any of the districts served at the commencement of this Part of this Act by a district probate registry to be lodged with the county registrar for the area in which such fixed place of abode was situate and for the transmission of such application by the county registrar to the principal probate registry and the transmission of the probates and letters of administration (if and when issued) from the principal probate registry to the said county registrar for delivery to the person entitled thereto."

That is really an extension of the idea contained in the previous amendment.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (1), page 15, line 61. after the word "Finance" to insert the words "and the concurrence of the committee with whose concurrence or assistance the rules of the court to which the matter relates are made."

Comment on this

I may say in explanation of that that the view I took originally of the matter was that court fees were not a judicial matter, that they were something that should be fixed by responsible Ministers, by myself in consultation with the Minister for Finance. We could be criticised then if they were too high or too low. There was a certain amount of representation from the legal profession, and this amendment is inserted to make the consent of the rule-making committee a condition precedent to the fixing of these fees. It will probably work all right. If there is a deadlock and failure to get the consent and concurrence of the Committee to fees which are considered reasonable by the Government, that would be a question of approaching the Dáil again for further powers. I am satisfied with the existing provision, and I believe that in consultation and after contact, it would be possible to arrive at a reasonable scale of fees. If I form the opinion that the scale of fees is not, in fact, reasonable, it would be a matter of coming again to the Dáil.

Comment on this

I would like to express a view which I know is very general, and that is, that in exercising such powers as are contained in this section the Minister will endeavour to make the fees as low as possible, and much lower than they are at present. I hope it will not be difficult to get the concurrence of the rule-making authority in that. I am sure that if anyone has been influenced by what is called the economy campaign he will be glad to apply it in the case of the courts, as it will fall very heavily on litigants.

Comment on this

I will bear in mind what the Deputy says. It is an expression of opinion. My own view is that the court fees, as such, are not high and do not form any considerable proportion of the cost of litigation. It is the professional fees rather than the court fees that make litigation expensive. I think that probably I might develop that a little further on Report Stage. It is a very fixed view of mine and of my Department that the court fees, even as they are at present, are not unreasonably high, and constitute a very small proportion of the total cost of litigation.

Comment on this

While I am prepared to accept that view, I think an expression of opinion from the Dáil, that the desire should be to keep down what I may call litigation fees, wherever they may fall, may have some effect on the rule-making authority and the Minister. It is to be hoped that, when we find the rules of the various courts before us for consideration, we shall see that the procedure is intended to be so simplified as to reduce very greatly the cost of litigation. An expression of the view by the Dáil that that is desirable, even in respect to court fees, may have its reflection on the lawyers of one type or another.

Comment on this

I move the following amendment:—

Before Section 49 to insert a new section as follows:—

The several powers, authorities, duties and functions conferred or imposed by Part I. of this Act on the respective officers therein referred to as principal officers and by Part II. of this Act on the county registrars shall be exercised and performed by those officers and registrars with the assistance of the officers and servants employed in the offices under their management respectively, and every such principal officer and county registrar shall arrange for the exercise and performance by officers or servants employed in the office under his management of such of his powers, authorities, duties and functions (other than those which he is for the time being expressly required by statute or rule of court to exercise or perform in person) as he cannot conveniently exercise or perform himself."

The effect of this amendment is, I think, pretty plain. It means that if there are certain functions which must be performed by the principal officer there are other duties and functions of less importance which can be performed by officers under his control.

Comment on this

I move:—

To add at the end of the section two new sub-sections as follows:—

"(4) This section shall not apply to such solicitors, doctors, visitors, and other persons as have heretofore been retained or nominated by the Chief Justice in relation to the exercise of any of the jurisdictions transferred to him by Section 19 of the Courts of Justice Act, 1924 (No. 10 of 1924), and all such persons shall continue to be nominated and retained by him as heretofore.

(5) This section shall not apply to the appointment in any suit or matter by the Judge or by the parties with the approval of the Judge of an auctioneer, receiver, assessor, liquidator, manager, agent, or other like person to render services in relation to the subject matter of such suit or matter where the appointment does not extend to any other suit or matter and either there is no person retained under this section available to render such services or the Judge is of opinion that it is not expedient in the special circumstances of the case to appoint the person or any of the persons so retained."

The original section was drafted so as not to apply to the appointment of any person except those retained to assist the court. Neither was it meant to interfere with the powers of the Chief Justice in lunacy matters, and the amendment is to make certain that it has not that effect.

Comment on this

I move:—

"In page 16, before Section 50, to insert a new section as follows:—

"Save as is otherwise provided in this Act, the Civil Service Regulation Act, 1924 (No. 5 of 1924) shall apply to every office and situation under this Act other than offices and situations for the time being comprised in the Schedule to the said Civil Service Regulation Act, 1924."

The Civil Service Regulation Act applies automatically to every post in the public service and the amendment is merely brought in for the purpose of greater emphasis and to ensure that there can be no doubt on the subject.

Comment on this

I move:—

Before section 50 to insert new section as follows:—

"No person shall be appointed to any position under this Act unless he has a thorough and competent knowledge of the Irish language, but this provision shall not apply to any existing officer who accepts employment, or is re-employed under the provisions of this Act."

The purpose of the amendment is, I think, self-evident. The country has been asking for this for a good number of years in regard to public appointments.

Comment on this

The Civil Service Regulation Act made the Civil Service Commissioners in effect the judges of the extent to which a knowledge of Irish should be demanded as a qualification for any public post. In general, therefore, court officers can be appointed only if they satisfy the Commissioners that they have such a knowledge of Irish as the Commissioners deem necessary for their work. There are three Commissioners. The Department of Justice has constantly endeavoured to secure trained Irish speakers in Irish districts, and it has succeeded in an appreciable degree. In such places as Falcaragh, Galway City, Dingle, Dungarvan and elsewhere, we have succeeded to a large extent in making the court administration Irish-speaking. It is only in a few cases where the appointments are made direct by the Executive Council that the Civil Service Commissioners have not power. Such cases are legal appointments of high standing. The Deputy should know what the supply of Irish-speaking lawyers is. Moreover, if the amendment is good for court officers it should be good for the entire service and good for such persons as police, judges, and even Deputies. To demand here and now that the whole public service must, as from date, be reserved exclusively for Irish speakers, is to demand the impossible. There are not sufficient Irish speakers with sufficient qualifications to perform the work. I venture to say that they are not there to the extent of one-twentieth of the need, and I think the Deputy knows that just as well as I do. I am not, therefore, accepting the amendment.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister's explanation is at all satisfactory. In my amendment, I do not ask that these officials should be Irish speakers; I ask that they have a competent knowledge of Irish. All the inferior officers admitted under the Civil Service Regulations must have such a knowledge of Irish as will satisfy the Commissioners.

Comment on this

Would you apply that to stenographers?

Comment on this

I should apply it to everybody.

Comment on this

You would not recommend any stenographer who had not a competent knowledge of Irish?

Comment on this

I do not know whether I would or not.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy happen to know whether he did or not?

Comment on this

I do not.

Comment on this

In any case it is for the Minister to object.

Comment on this

You can recommend but it will be for me to reject, under your amendment.

Comment on this

I will not object to your rejecting. All the inferior officers at present must have a knowledge of Irish. The superior officers are not to be expected to have a knowledge of Irish. That is really the effect of the Minister's explanation. The gentlemen who are to hold the superior posts under this Bill are all men of education—university men. They are overflowing with the lore of Greece and Rome and I do not see why they should not add one more accomplishment to their various accomplishments. It is ridiculous that the inferior officers should be required to have a knowledge of Irish and that the superior officers should not be expected to have any such qualification. We must be consistent.

Comment on this

I remember one famous occasion in the Dáil when the Minister delivered a perfect speech in Irish. I only want him to carry his convictions straight through to the end. I think the Minister referred to the Gárda Síochána. I think the Gárda should have a knowledge of Irish.

Comment on this

No doubt, in the abstract, we should all have it. But I am dealing with the position as it is. I am dealing with the fact that the supply is not there.

Comment on this

You ought to make the supply.

Comment on this

When such an enthusiast as the Deputy is driven to recommending non-Irish speaking stenographers for the courts, I regard it as proof that the supply is not there.

Comment on this

In so far as my recommendation of a non-Irish-speaking stenographer was concerned, I knew this stenographer who applied for the position, but I did not know whether he had a knowledge of Irish or not.

Comment on this

And you did not care.

Comment on this

I knew him to be a very respectable young man and I knew that he had mastered five or six books of O'Growney, which is supposed to be the standard for most of the positions in the Civil Service.

Comment on this

He must have been concealing his knowledge. He told us he had not any knowledge of Irish. I could not accept the Deputy's amendment. It simply would not be honest, in face of the position as we know it to be. The supply of competent men with the necessary qualifications is not there and we could not bind ourselves in the terms of this amendment. I think on an examination—such an examination as took place by the Gaeltacht Commission—it could be shown that we have made every reasonable effort to find for the Irish-speaking areas Irish-speaking officials and Irish-speaking police. But there is a point at which you cannot sacrifice that reasonable efficiency in the public service which the tax-paying public are entitled to demand. I could not tie myself down to the terms of this amendment. It would be simply an absurdity, a dishonesty, and a hypocrisy. It would be like the resolutions they used to pass long ago at political conventions—"That this time three years the business of this convention shall be transacted in the Irish language and in no other." Everybody there knew—the proposer, the seconder, and the supporters of those resolutions—in their hearts and souls that the thing was an impossibility. It could not take place and it did not take place. There was not even a reasonable effort made to ensure that it would take place. It was a farce. It would be quite as big a farce if I were to accept this amendment and pretend that it would be administratively possible to give effect to it.

We are awaiting the report of the Gaeltacht Commission. I have no doubt it will be a very interesting and a very important report, and I would ask the Deputy simply to take the view that matters such as the principle underlying this amendment may be left over until we have the benefit, the advice, and the assistance that that report will give us. I do not want to deal with this amendment in any hostile spirit at all. I think I could show that in the administration of my Department for the last three years we have made every reasonable effort possible to meet the spirit in which the amendment is put forward. But I could not accept the amendment in the form in which it is and say that no county registrar would be appointed in the country who had not a competent knowledge of Irish. It would be an absurdity. We could not get the competent men, the men with the necessary experience and qualifications, who, in addition, would have that competent knowledge of the Irish language which the Deputy demands. We could not get the stenographers, we could not get the county registrars, we could not get the officials to man the courts of the country, with a knowledge of Irish. The Deputy knows that we could not get the judges and that we could not get the District Justices—though by luck we were able to find a sufficient number of District Justices with a knowledge of Irish to conduct the courts which function in Irish-speaking areas. Even that was a task of some difficulty. Drawing on the two legal professions—barristers and solicitors— we were just barely able to man the Gaeltacht courts with District Justices who knew Irish. In face of that, is it reasonable to go the length that this amendment does and say that under this Bill—which provides, of course, for the appointment of hundreds of officials—no person shall be appointed to any position unless he has a thorough and competent knowledge of the Irish language? If I were to accept that amendment and bind myself by statute in the terms of the amendment, the logical sequence would be the breakdown of the Judiciary system in the country.

Comment on this

I rise to a point of order. We have just passed an amendment which puts these appointments in the hands of the Civil Service Commissioners. Is an amendment in order which would have the effect—if it were effective at all—of putting a restriction upon the Civil Service Commissioners? If any such restriction is to be put upon them, should it not be put by the Act which establishes and regulates the Civil Service Commission?

Comment on this

I should like to suggest to the mover of the amendment that he should postpone it for another generation. By that time, probably, the amendment will be practicable. At the present time—I admit it with a great feeling of regret—I listen to the Minister for Justice giving a speech in Irish without appreciating the merits of the speech. I think the Deputy will serve his purpose a great deal better by allowing things to take their course for a reasonable time, by allowing the people themselves to decide these matters and by having some definite opinion from them on the question.

Comment on this

I would like a ruling upon the point of order I raised.

Comment on this

I think the course taken by the Minister is the only course he could have taken. I am as keen about the language as anybody can be. I have a smattering of many languages, including two dialects of Hindustani. The Irish is a very difficult language to learn, particularly when one is not a juvenile. I have succeeded myself in learning a certain amount of Irish, but I realise that a man beyond a certain age cannot and never will be proficient or what one would call a perfect speaker of Irish, having the language on the tip of his tongue, so that in a court of justice or other place of that sort he would be fit to interpret and to understand clearly everything that was going on. It is quite different with young people. I think for all appointments for which young people are eligible, it should be absolutely necessary that they should know Irish, but in the case of appointments to the higher grade of people over a certain age, that is impossible, and the Minister's attitude is the only reasonable attitude he could adopt as things are.

Comment on this

I fully appreciate the difficulty the Minister has explained. I am quite prepared to wait for the report of the Commission. At the same time, I am not prepared to accept Deputy Hewat's suggestion. There is a certain line of conduct laid out for this State, and that line of conduct is that officials of the State should be Irish-speaking. It does not matter what Deputy Hewat or any other Deputy thinks. He thinks that no man should learn Irish because he does not consider it convenient to do so.

Comment on this

Did I mention that?

Comment on this

No, but you more or less implied it.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy competent to know what I implied?

Comment on this

I have a certain small share of common sense and intelligence and therefore I can appreciate what Deputy Hewat or any other Deputy implies. I am quite prepared to accept the Minister's suggestion.

Comment on this

Could not the Deputy's amendment be met by the Minister in some such fashion as this: that the men who are to receive those appointments, being men of a certain standard of education, should, within a certain period of time, acquire a working knowledge of the language? A condition in which appointments are made to the Indian Civil Service is that candidates are to acquire the dialect of the districts in which they are to function.

Comment on this

What I anticipate is that before the question of making appointments under this Act arises we will have had the report of the Gaeltacht Commission. If a condition of that kind is to be made there is nothing to prevent it. It is not necessary to write it into an Act. I feel that this Bill will probably take a month or six months before it becomes law, and I think it likely that by that time we will have the report of the Gaeltacht Commission. As I say, acceptance of the amendment the Deputy has put down is out of the question. My own view is that to do even what Deputy McCurtain suggests throughout the entire area of the State is scarcely practicable. It will be a matter that will have to be considered very closely, whether you could in counties in which Irish is spoken appoint a person who either is not himself at present a speaker of Irish or who will not undertake within a given time to satisfy some body of persons as to his competency to do business with an Irish speaker and to transact the business attaching to his office with a person who has only one language and that the Irish language.

I would not be prepared to put forward a substituted amendment to the Deputy's, along the lines of Deputy McCurtain's suggestion. I would not be prepared to say that all over the State no person shall be appointed to any office, under this Bill, who will not undertake, within a period of two or three years, to satisfy some tribunal of his competence in the Irish language. I certainly am fully alive to the necessity of keeping the administrative machine, in a given county, in a position in which it can do business with all the residents of that county, but the administration cannot be expected to rush ahead of the actual position in the country amongst the people. After all, our first business is to provide an efficient administrative machine, and other considerations have to come second to that. They would not come second if I were to accept, as applicable all over, the idea that no person was to be appointed to a position under this Bill who did not either—(a) know Irish; or (b) undertake to know it within three years, because the fact is that I would not get the best men for the offices on those terms, and thereby I would be sacrificing efficiency in the public administration to language enthusiasm. I would want very definite intimation from the Dáil that that was imperative before I would be prepared to do it.

Comment on this

I want to speak, with great respect, on Deputy McCurtain's suggestion. I think I speak on behalf of Deputy Hewat and Deputy Thrift as well as myself when I say that I am in agreement with the doctrine that in districts where there are people who know nothing but Irish, the officials and the judges of the courts should be acquainted with Irish, and not be dependent on interpreters. I think that is an absolute necessity, and I hope it will be carried out. There is no doubt whatever that Irish is a very difficult language. I got half way through one book of O'Growney when I was told by Deputy Dr. MacNeill that I was studying the wrong method entirely. I have made an effort to master certain technical terms, but I was up against difficulties. Deputy McCurtain. whom I hope we will hear again, spoke of the Indian Civil Service. The difficulty in that comparison is this: that Indian civil servants or officers of the English Army going to India, find awaiting them a well-equipped teacher, a native speaker accustomed to teaching and to getting people through examinations.

So far as I can discover, the number of native speakers who are teaching and who know how to teach—which is rather a different matter— are comparatively few. Therefore I think that, as the Minister stated, you must proceed gradually in this matter. With the limited number of native-speaking teachers who are competent to teach— the Indian Civil Servant gets individual attention and I have never been able to discover that you can get individual teaching here: you have to go to a class, often at times inconvenient for your occupation—you must proceed slowly. When you have developed the number of teachers then, as Deputy Hewat says, in another generation what Deputy McBride suggests might be practicable. I do not think it is practicable to-day. I must say I would have supported the amendment more fervently if any arguments had been urged in its behalf in Irish.

Comment on this

I move amendment 72:—

In sub-section (1), page 16, line 51, after the word "person" to insert in brackets the words "(whether paid or not paid out of public moneys)," and to delete all from the word "and" in line 52 to the word "office" in line 54.

The section, as it stands, applies only to non-established clerks. The amendment will extend the operation of the section to any non-established whole-time clerk in the Civil Service, such, for instance, as district court clerks.

Comment on this

I move amendment 73:—

In sub-section (2), page 16, line 58, after the word "may" to insert the words "with the consent of the Minister for Finance," and in lines 59 and 60 to delete the words "but not in any case prior to the 1st day of January, 1924."

The meaning of the amendment is that the date on which the certificate of qualification, referred to in sub-section 2, shall take effect is left an open question.

Comment on this

I move amendment 74:—

In sub-section (2) to delete from the word "but," line 59, to the figures "1924," line 60, inclusive, and to add at the end of the sub-section, line 2, page 17, the words: "provided that no such certificate shall be granted to a person heretofore employed in a Crown and Peace Office so as to give that person credit for service for more than one-half of the period that he has been actually employed in such office."

The Courts of Justice Act will greatly increase the responsibilities of the assistants. They will be required in the future to perform duties hitherto carried out by highly-paid High Court officials. A committee appointed by the British Government recommended that they should be made permanent civil servants and given credit for all their past years of service and the then (British) Under-Secretary stated that owing to impending changes in the Government of Ireland the matter would be left to be dealt with by the Provisional Government of Ireland. It is, therefore, almost a certainty that the British Government would have granted their claim many years ago. It is calculated that as credit for past services now claimed for the assistants would apply to approximately 30 men in the whole country, the burden on the Treasury would not be a heavy one and it would not be a charge for many years to come.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The deletion has already been carried out by amendment 73. Therefore the amendment is to add certain words.

Comment on this

The foregoing amendment 73, moved by Deputy Duggan, leaves the date on which the establishment certificate may be granted an open question, and leaves each case to be considered on its merits. Taking the two amendments on their face value, amendment 73, which has just been passed, is better, in fact, than this amendment, which would limit the Minister for Finance to giving half the past services to the particular officials, whereas amendment 73 leaves it open to him to give the whole service, if he thinks fit. I do not think he will think fit, and I do not want to delude the Deputy into the view that he is likely to think fit to give even half; but taking the two amendments simply on paper as they stand, the present amendment has a limiting effect which is absent from amendment 73, which has been accepted by the Dáil. I ask the Deputy to rest satisfied with the fact that the case is not prejudiced by anything in the Bill. It is left an open matter, and each case will have to be considered on its merits. If I were pressed to prophesy, I would say that in my opinion the most that these officers would be likely to get in the way of retrospective consideration would be a matter of three or four years on establishment. But that is not in the Bill, and Deputy Duggan's amendment leaves the matter open in a way in which Deputy Doyle's does not.

Comment on this

I move amendment 75:—

In sub-section (3), to delete from the word "twice," line 11, to the end of the sub-section, and substitute the words: "in the case of a person who has been so employed for a period of less than ten years, twice, and in the case of a person who has been so employed for a longer period than ten years, four times the amount of the salary and emoluments received by such persons from whatsoever source during the last year of his employment."

Under Section 58 of the Government of Ireland Act the assistants in Crown and Peace Offices are "existing officers" within the meaning of that Act, and as such officers are entitled to compensation or annual allowance on resigning office calculated in accordance with the provisions of Schedule 8 of the Act. This section instead of benefiting the assistants offers them much less than they are entitled to receive under the Government of Ireland Act, and it should be amended and the positions of the assistants under the Government of Ireland Act should be defined in the Court Officers Bill.

Comment on this

Sub-section 3 of Section 51 represents the best bargain I have been able to make with the Minister for Finance to meet the case of those officials. After all, the Deputy ought to consider that even sub-section (3) as it stands, represents what is somewhat rare in State Acts—money for nothing. These men, after all, made their bargains with their employers— the Clerks of the Crown and Peace. They were not officials, and they were never left under any illusion about that. It was not a question of entering the State service in any formal way, or by any process of examination, or other form of competition. They were simply the private employees of the Clerks of the Crown and Peace, and they made their bargain. Even sub-section (3) as it stands, though the Deputy may be dissatisfied with it, is a not ungenerous provision on the part of the State. It represents a voluntary and fairly handsome gratuity on retirement to men who really could not claim that they had any very good grounds for expecting a gratuity of that kind at all. If there had been no change in the system, and the old judicial system simply went on, they would remain at work as the employees of the Clerks of the Crown and Peace, and I doubt if, on retirement, they would get any such gratuity as sub-section (3) of this section provides for them. I could not hold out any hope of it being altered or increased. It represents the best terms we have been able to extract from the Finance Department, and I can hold out no hope of reviewing them.

Comment on this

The Minister says these officials made their bargain. Of course they did, but that was at the time they were appointed, with the Clerks of the Crown and Peace. The bargain was then from their point of view probably a life bargain. They were chosen, probably, because they were extremely efficient. In fact, many of them were, so far as the work was concerned, the real Clerks of the Crown and Peace. I know one or two of these officials who gave their whole life to the work. While, of course, a pension could not be claimed, they certainly had employment for life under the old régime. These men are still there, and they are naturally nervous as to what is going to happen to them. I do not know if they would be entitled to get any compensation. Some of them are also extremely nervous that they will be turned out of office at the age of fifty-five. The Minister, I think, said that was a mistake.

Comment on this

And that the age is sixty-five. That nervousness exists and it is only natural, considering the nature of their appointments. They were appointed without any promise of a pension, but on the understanding that if they did not misbehave themselves their employment was for life. It depends now whether they will be re-appointed or not. The Minister, I think, stated that if there was nothing against them they would be reappointed. That will probably reassure them until they receive further information. It will also reassure them as regards the age, to know that they will not be turned out at fifty-five.

Comment on this

I move amendment 76:—

Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(2) Sub-section (1) of this section shall not apply to any person who immediately before the commencement of Part III. of this Act holds the office of district court clerk under the District Justices (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1923 (No. 6 of 1923) or, in the Dublin Metropolitan Area and in the County Borough of Cork, the office of chief or other clerk of the District Court in that area and borough respectively, and no such person shall be an existing officer or servant for the purposes of this section."

The amendment saves District Court clerks from being, even technically, abolished or removed from office under this Bill. There is no necessity to abolish their office for the reason that they are either temporary clerks or ordinary civil servants.

Comment on this

I move amendment 77:—

Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(2) All existing officers and servants who are temporary officers or servants and whose functions are not expressly transferred by this Act to any officer created by this Act shall, notwithstanding the abolition of their respective offices or situations, continue until the Minister otherwise directs to perform the like duties as they respectively performed immediately before such abolition and while so performing such duties shall be entitled to receive remuneration on the same scale as that on which they were remunerated immediately before such abolition."

This sub-section makes it clear that temporary officers in general are not affected by this Bill.

Comment on this

I move amendment 77a:—

In sub-section (2) to insert after the word "employment," line 29, the words: "with tenure not inferior to his present tenure."

The tenure of the present officers of the High Court is not the ordinary tenure of the civil servant. The 65 rule is never applied to them. Their appointments have been for life, so long as they were fit to do their work. Though the Bill does not definitely say so, it may be inferred that it is intended to apply the 65 age limit. If so, it would be an infringement of the tenure of existing officers, many of whom entered the service after competitive examinations for which the age limit was 30 years. As it requires 40 years to qualify for a full pension it would seem to follow that candidates 30 years old at the date of the examination might expect to remain at least to the age of 70, if they are to get a chance of attaining their full pension. The full pension is about two-thirds. I hope the Minister will give the amendment favourable consideration.

Comment on this

The whole underlying principle of this Bill, and its whole object, has, practically, been to define the tenure of court officers as being the same tenure as every other civil servant—that is, the pleasure of the Executive Council. It sounds no doubt a flimsy thing, but the Deputy knows in fact that it is a real and a solid thing. But the people for whom the Deputy is speaking are not satisfied with that. They asked instead for a tenure not inferior to the present tenure.

The question arises, what is their present tenure? I venture to say that in the case of a great many of them the Deputy could not tell me, and the officers themselves could not tell me, but I am to give them by this Bill a tenure not inferior to their present tenure. They do not know what their present tenure is, and I would not be in a position to find out in order to give them the equation of it. I am not simply playing with the idea. It is a fact that in the case of a great many officers serving in the courts no man, whether on or off the Bench, could say what their present tenure is. Under this Bill they will have the same tenure as the entire civil servants of the State, but I cannot undertake to give them some indefinite thing that would be different, and that might be said to fall under the description of not being inferior to their present tenure, which is unascertainable. Under the Judicature Act of 1877, for instance, the tenure of certain officers is described as being such that they may be removed by the person having the right of appointment to the office with the approval of the Lord Chancellor for reasons to be assigned in the order of removal. The person having the right of appointment to the office would be hard to find, and the Lord Chancellor would be still harder. It is not possible to say in any precise terms what is the tenure of those persons who were appointed under the Act of 1877, with that proviso attached to their appointment. I could not undertake to make any discrimination between the tenure of court officers under this Bill, and the tenure of the civil servants who serve in the various departments of State, and it is a very substantial tenure, as everyone knows.

Certain well-defined exceptions to that were arrived at in response to certain protests from the Judiciary. The principal officers are given nominally and theoretically a stronger tenure than Civil Service tenure; that is, the concurrence of the Chief Justice or the President of the High Court, as the case may be, would be necessary as a condition precedent to their removal. There were considerations urged in favour of that, but it was not regarded by me as adding anything in fact or practice to their tenure, because a civil servant would never be removed for reasons that would not command at once the concurrence of two judges. It was thought fit to make that necessary in the case of ten or a dozen principal officers down in the Courts, and I had no hesitation in assenting to the idea that they would not be removed without the concurrence of the President of the High Court or the Chief Justice, but there is no reason for extending that to the court staffs generally, and there is no reason for discriminating as between the tenure they shall have as from the date of the operation of this Bill and the tenure, say, of the Secretary to the Executive Council, or any of the other civil servants who are serving in State departments. That is simply my attitude to the amendment. I cannot accept it, and if I were unwise enough to do so, then I would find it very hard to arrive at a tenure not inferior to some of those officials in the courts, for I do not know what that tenure is.

Comment on this

Owing to the Minister's difficulties, I beg to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move:—

"In sub-section (2), page 17, line 30, to insert the words ‘scale of' before the word ‘salary.'"

This is a very little brother of Deputy Dr. Hennessy's amendment. It seeks to provide for the position of the existing servant who is, say, serving on a scale of salary rising from £400 to £600 a year, and who has reached the £500 mark. Under the Bill as it stands he might be offered a post of which the maximum salary was £500, and he would thereby suffer some loss in his expectations. I do not think the Minister intends that, but I do think that the acceptance of this amendment would help to prevent some of the existing staff taking their pensions and going. I think it is fair and equitable that they should have not only the same salary they have at present when transferred, but also the same prospects of promotion. Therefore, I would ask the Minister to accept this amendment.

Comment on this

There is a certain family likeness between this amendment and its big brother, as Deputy Cooper said. It is an unnecessary amendment. The words "salary carried by the position" would only mean in the context the scale of salary in any case where there is a scale. Take, for example, the case of an officer in the scale of from £700 to £900 a year, by increments of £25, and let us suppose that he happens to be at the point of £775 at the time when this Bill becomes law, then the salary carried by the position might be £700 by £25 to £900, and not £775 as the figure that would remain. The latter is merely the officer's salary at the particular moment of change from one system to another. The Parliamentary draftsman, I may say, fully agrees with this view, and, in fact, is inclined to oppose the amendment on the grounds of unnecessary verbiage. He has no doubt as to the effect of the words in the Bill, but if the Deputy would like me to make assurance doubly sure, I would like to be able to tell him also on Report that that is the view of the Attorney-General.

Comment on this

When I am told that two words are unnecessary verbiage, I begin to look at some of Deputy Duggan's amendments, for there seems to be more unnecessary verbiage there. I am prepared to accept the Minister's assurance, and I think if he consults the Attorney-General before the Report Stage it would reassure people who do not know the Minister as well as I do

Comment on this

I move:—

To add at the end of sub-section (2) the words "Every question which shall arise as to whether any duties are analogous to any other duties shall be determined so far as relates to the Supreme Court by the Chief Justice, and to the High Court by the President of the High Court."

Sub-section (2) provides that any existing officer shall be offered employment under "this Act analogous to and carrying not less salary than the situation held by him as such existing officer or servant at the passing of this Act." The question may arise as to whether the new situation which is being offered is, in fact, analogous to the situation which is being superseded. That question has to be decided. The proposition in the amendment is that the question as to whether the new duties are analogous to the old shall be decided in the case of the Supreme Court by the Chief Justice, and in the case of the High Court by the President of that Court. I do not know whether there is any real objection to that.

Comment on this

I can imagine that the Minister would say that inasmuch as the Bill has provided for the administration to be retained by the Minister, the judicial functions will be held continuously by the judges, and that that is a sufficient answer. If the Minister makes that case I am not going to argue against it, but if he has any other reason or if he has no other reason, or if that reason is not his reason, I would like to press the amendment.

Comment on this

I think that any officer who is lying awake at night wondering just what kind of fight he can put up on the question of analogous duty, had better cut the thing short and decide to go before the new system comes into operation. I would not accept this amendment at all. We will abide by the terms of the Bill as it stands, and offer to each man who comes over into the new judiciary system, analogous duties, so far as conveniently may be, but we simply will not have the position in which it will be open to any man to argue, except in an informal administrative discussion, as to what are and what are not analogous duties. If every such question had to be referred to the President of the High Court or the Chief Justice, as the case might be, the position would be simply intolerable—people remaining on with their Article 10 terms in suspense, and with a view to seeing what kind of duties they might get, and then running to one or other judge to haggle over the question as to whether those duties could be considered analogous or not; in other words, coming into the new system to see how they would fare and with the very full intention of bolting out in case things did not go just so, and not otherwise. That frame of mind is not any use, and people who have that frame of mind should not stand upon the order of their going, but go at once. The judges, to put it on no other grounds, would find it a very considerable infringement of their official hours if, for six months following on this Act coming into operation, they had to listen to high constitutional arguments on the question of whether the duties which this man was asked to perform in the new system could be said to be analogous to those which he performed in the past. It is not really a sound or feasible proposition simply to say that there should be an appeal to the two higher judges of the courts from the administrative decision to put A. B. at such-and-such a work. If any man is gravely troubled about this question of analogous duties, my advice to him is to cut it short, and to go at once, because we are not going to listen to very much talk about analogous duties under the new system to those under the old.

Comment on this

I do not know whether there is any likelihood of any considerable number taking the hint of the Minister to retire under Article X, in view of his statement. The emphasis on duties suggests to the Minister that it is the duties that may come from day to day that are in question; but what is intended by the amendment is that the situation under the new regime may be analogous to the situation under the old regime and that the situation carries a certain general assigned body of duties. I think it is not an unfair proposition that there should be an authority named which will state that such a position under the new conditions is analogous to the old position, and is carrying certain duties in one case as in the other case. I feel as a matter of fact that there is an inherent weakness in the case I am putting forward if it is represented that this is purely an administrative function, that the assignment of duties is administrative and that consequently it is not the business of the judge. That is not the case put forward by the Minister and he has rather argued as though the proposition was that the duties that may come forward day by day or month by month would be referable at somebody's instance to the judge. Certainly that is not the intention, but I think, on the other hand, there is a question as to who is to decide whether one position is analogous to the other, and that, I think, should be considered.

Comment on this

I regret that I can make no advance. I object entirely to this suggestion of appeal from administrative decisions to the judges. I object on a great many grounds and then I can see nothing that can be inserted in substitution to meet the point of view of the Deputy. Officers must just turn over in their minds whether they are going to go into the new system and take their chance in that, or whether they are going out with whatever statutory and Treaty rights attached to them, but the idea of coming in on "spec." to the new system, with an appeal to a judge as a kind of side-line and last resort, does not commend itself to me and I think should not commend itself to the Dáil.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

In sub-section (3), (a), page 17, line 37, to insert the words "or otherwise" after the figures "1921."

This sub-section deals with the rights of those existing servants who accept fresh employment under this Bill, who, in other words, instead of taking any pension to which they may be entitled, are prepared to carry on in office. The section as it stands preserves any rights under the Treaty, but some of those officers in the courts have rights also under the Judicature Act, and my amendment is intended to preserve not only rights under the Treaty but rights under the Judicature Act. It may be that the Minister will say that it is too wide. If so, I am willing and anxious to have it restricted, but I do think on the whole, even at the cost of being told that it is unnecessary verbiage, that the principle of it is a sound one and that we should try to reassure existing officials as far as we can and get them to renew their services instead of going on pension. Unnecessary verbiage costs something, a certain amount of printing and a certain amount of paper, but it does not cost us as much as the pension of one official who might be retained, if his alarms were allayed. I hope the Minister will take the amendment into sympathetic consideration.

Comment on this

I have some doubt as to the idea underlying the Deputy's amendment. I do not know whether it is sought to cover possible rights under the Constitution as well as the Treaty, or rights under the Act of 1877. My advice is that the provisions in the Judicature Act of 1877 applied only to persons who were prejudiced by that Act or by changes immediately pursuant to that Act. The only rights that we acknowledge as existing amongst these officers are their rights, whatever they are or whatever they may be found to be, under the Treaty. That being our view, on two grounds, therefore, I am not inclined to accept the Deputy's amendment. The first ground is that I am of opinion, and am very definitely advised, that these officers have no rights arising from the Judicature Act. My second ground is that we acknowledge such rights as they may be found to have under the Treaty. We acknowledge no rights attaching to them by virtue of legislation in the distant past, prior to the Treaty. On either count I would have to take the position of being against the Deputy's amendment. I think that if these officers look for competent advice they will find that it will coincide with mine and that they have no such rights as they seem to think they have arising from the Judicature Act.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Minister means by competent advice. Does he mean mine was incompetent?

Comment on this

I did not intend to suggest that the Deputy's advice was incompetent. I meant professional advice.

Comment on this

I accept the Minister's explanation. I did not consider it an insult. I suggest to the Minister that the narrow line of legality is not the wisest line to pursue in a matter of this kind where there are people who are frightened—rightly or wrongly frightened—at the effects of this Bill when it becomes an Act. The Minister wants, as he said on Second Reading, to avoid swelling the pensions fund. I suggest it might be desirable to do a few things that may appear to him unnecessary. If his belief that the Judicature Act does not apply to these officials at all is correct, it is unnecessary but it does no harm. It would be better to go a little distance to allay fears and suspicions rather than turn down every safeguard and every proviso that seems to safeguard, even if it does not effectively safeguard, existing officers. I would suggest that. I accept the Minister's view, reinforced as it is by legal authority and expert knowledge, as the official view; but I suggest even if that is so it is far better from the point of view of safeguarding an overburdened pensions list to go a certain distance to meet fears and remove them. I do not believe the insertion of the words "under the Judicature Act of 1877," if the Minister is prepared to insert them, would do any harm.

Comment on this

One does not accept an amendment simply on the grounds that it does not do any harm. When one is considering an amendment one has to see whether it is an improvement on the text as it stands. This amendment would not be an improvement; it would be a complication. The Treaty is something that both parties understand and there is no question but that any of these officials who decide to take the abolition of their office literally and refuse to come under the new system will get their rights under the Treaty. But to complicate the thing by a reference to the Judicature Act of 1877 in face of the advice which I have that that Act confers no right whatever on them, does not seem good business or good legislation. I would be simply making myself a party to a farce if I were to consent to write into this Bill a reference to possible rights of these officers under the Judicature Act of 1877, in face of the authoritative advice I have that they have no such rights. The Deputy must hold me excused in the matter. I could not agree to that amendment.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I think, in fact, the voting is even, but I am giving the amendment as lost.

Comment on this

In moving the following amendment, let me say that here we have a little more unnecessary verbiage:—

In sub-section (3) (c), page 17, line 44, to insert the words "resigning or otherwise" before the word "ceasing."

This is simply to make it clear that a court officer who accepts the new conditions, tries to work them, and finds them—well, I do not want to say not analogous, because that has been already condemned—but finds them uncongenial, shall not forfeit his rights by resigning. I think the draftsman intended the word "ceasing" to cover "resignation"; but where fears of this kind exist it might be well to make it quite clear that "resignation" is included in "ceasing." Therefore, I suggest, without very much hope, that this amendment might commend itself to the Minister.

Comment on this

The Deputy is right—the amendment does not commend itself to the Minister. My objection to it is the objection which he himself anticipated. It is that it is a superfluous amendment; it is unnecessary verbiage with a vengeance. If a man resigns a situation he ceases to hold it. If the Deputy resigns from the Dáil he ceases to be a Deputy.

Comment on this

Is that so?

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Suppose he got himself suspended?

Comment on this

Much the same would apply to court officers. The words in the text—"on his ceasing to hold a situation under this Act he shall be entitled..."—cover, of course, the contingency of resignation and I would not insult the Parliamentary draftsman by accepting the Deputy's amendment. I may say that I talked to him about it.

Comment on this

I wish the Minister would illuminate his remarks by less unlikely hypotheses. I am far too happy here to resign my seat.

Comment on this

It was not a case of the wish being father to the thought.

Comment on this

I will accept the Minister's assurance. I had some feeling of the same kind myself but it was vouched for by a barrister of considerable standing who suggested to me that it was necessary.

Comment on this

I could almost name him.

Comment on this

It is quite possible the Minister could. I would not ask him to do it. The assurance of the Minister is as valuable as the insertion of the amendment. I ask the permission of the Dáil to withdraw it.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Amendment 82 which is contingent on 81 need not be moved:—

In sub-section (3) (c), page 17, line 47, to insert the words "or otherwise" after the word "Article 10."—(Deputy Cooper.)

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

took the Chair.

Comment on this

I beg to move Amendment 82 (a) which reads:—

82a. In sub-section (3) (d) after the word "paragraphs", line 51, to insert the words "in the case of any officers whose age at the passing of this Act, shall not exceed 45 years."

Clause (d) as it stands in the Bill seems to be inconsistent with the foregoing three paragraphs unless it is intended to apply to officers who may look forward to many years' service. Probably that is the intention but if it is so it should be stated definitely. Otherwise, when the Bill becomes law, officers with only a few years' service before them might lose the benefits of clauses (a), (b), and (c), and have clause (d) enforced against them.

Comment on this

The position I would have to take with regard to the Deputy's amendment is simply that I object to writing it into the Bill. We are unwilling to bind ourselves by an Act of the Oireachtas in a matter of this kind. It is possible that certain officers, the Taxing Masters, for instance, and the very senior officials will be allowed to have their Treaty rights cease and kept in suspense during their re-employment. But in that matter we consider that every case must stand on its own merits. Many men of more than 15 years' service in the courts have got no promotion so far, and will be only too glad to waive their Treaty rights in view of the abolition of the patronage system which has kept them as junior clerks for possibly 20 to 25 years. I am not simply standing flatly against the principle of the Deputy's amendment, but I am objecting simply to binding ourselves by statute in the matter. Certain very senior officers and people in the position, say, of the present Taxing Masters, might be considered to be entitled to have that concession applied in their cases. But the reactions of any wide application of that would be bad, administratively. I think it ought to be left simply as a discretionary matter as to the extent to which it would be applied.

Comment on this

I beg to withdraw my amendment.

Comment on this

I have here another amendment, which reads:—

In sub-section (3) (d), page 17, line 52, to insert the words "to any existing officer of less than fifteen years' service" after the word "Act."

Here again I am treading in Deputy Dr. Hennessy's footsteps, and I am afraid these footsteps will lead me to the lion's den, because the principle in my amendment is very much the same as the principle in his amendment. The principle is so much the same that the Minister made a speech referring to my amendment on Deputy Dr. Hennessy's amendment when he talks about 15 years' service.

Comment on this

I have the two amendments grouped together.

Comment on this

I want to save the time of the Minister by asking him if he could, on Report, bring in a formula that would re-assure senior officers. I am not enamoured of 15 years or 45 years of age, but I do not want a large number of senior officers going on pension. I do want, if possible, to persuade them to accept service under the new system for the sake of saving a pension, and also for the sake of retaining a certain number of experienced officials, and not starting absolutely fresh with new men or with men whose services have been only in very junior ranks. I would therefore put it to the Minister, if he could give any shadow of an undertaking to meet the apprehensions felt by senior officials, he would be making his Bill a more workable Bill.

Comment on this

I agree thoroughly with the Deputy that we do not want to see a large number of senior officers going on pension. But perhaps the Deputy will agree with me that there is a limit to the concessions that can be expected to be extracted under threat of going on pension. There must be just reason and moderation in everything.

Comment on this

There is always a limit to everything. The question is: where it is to be drawn.

Comment on this

Reading through some of these amendments I almost expected to come on one providing that under the new judicial system no one should speak unkindly of a court officer because he might, unless he got that guarantee, be inclined to rush out under his Article X rights. Now, we must have a little give and take. No one wants to see an exodus of court officials under Article X. Equally, starting the new system, we must be careful to start right and not allow unsound provisions or unsound principles to creep in, and my problem is, on the one hand, to see that officers get every reasonable assurance, in the event of their deciding to come along into the new system, and, on the other hand, that they do not exploit their Article X position to extract unreasonable terms. If the Deputy wishes, I can have another look at his amendment and at Deputy Dr. Hennessy's amendment, with a view to seeing whether it is possible or proper to insert anything to meet the idea underlying these two amendments.

Comment on this

I beg to withdraw my amendment.

Comment on this

I move:—

"In page 18, to add at the end of sub-section (3) a new paragraph as follows:—

"(h) if he was first appointed to his office in a temporary capacity under the Court Officers (Temporary Appointments) Act, 1924 (No. 2 of 1924) and was subsequently appointed to the same office in a pensionable capacity, he shall be entitled and shall be deemed to have been entitled immediately before the commencement of this Part of this Act to reckon as continuous service in a pensionable capacity for the purposes of the Superannuation Acts, 1834 to 1923, his total period of service in such office from the date of his first appointment thereto in a temporary capacity."

This amendment ensures that where an officer accepted an appointment under the temporary Act on the understanding that he would subsequently be appointed permanently, he should get credit for the period of his temporary service.

Comment on this

I move:—

Before section 53 to insert a new section as follows:—

"Nothing in this Act shall apply to any person who at the passing of this Act is paid by the council of any county or county borough for rendering services to or in relation to any judge, court, or courthouse, and no such person shall for the purposes of this Act be deemed to be attached to a judge or court."

This section is intended to make it clear that people such as courthouse-keepers and county court criers, who are paid by local county councils, are not directly affected by this Bill.

Comment on this

I move:

Before section 53 to insert a new section as follows:—

"(1) Nothing in this Act shall prejudice or affect the control of any judge or justice over the conduct of the business of his court.

(2) When an officer attached to any court is engaged on duties relating to business of that court which is for the time being required by law to be transacted by or before or under or pursuant to the order of a judge or judges of that court he shall observe and obey all directions given to him by such judge or judges.

(3) All proofs and all other documents and papers lodged in or handed in to any court in relation to or in the course of the hearing of any suit or matter shall be held by or at the order and disposal of the judge or the senior of the judges by or before whom such suit or matter is heard."

This amendment is introduced in order to remove any doubt that might exist as to the independence of the judges in judicial matters.

Comment on this

There is a small matter of form to which I would like to draw the attention of the Minister. I would ask him to consider whether it would not be advisable for the purpose of uniformity in our legislation that we should exclude the word "Exchequer" from sections 43 and 46. It has not been usual to use the word "Exchequer" and I think it is unwise to introduce it.

Comment on this

"Central Fund"?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I think they are technically synonymous, and it might be better simply to keep to the old word. I will see about having an amendment for Report. This Bill, I think, might be taken on Report next Friday week, and in view of the fairly long interval between Second Reading and Committee, and between Committee and Report I will probably have a notice down to take the Fifth Stage on that day also.

Comment on this