We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

ESTIMATES FOR PUBLIC SERVICE. - VOTE 52—OFFICE OF THE MINISTER FOR LANDS AND AGRICULTURE—(DEBATE RESUMED).

Contributions 1–158 of 318. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I want to deal with sub-head A, "Administrative Staff." I see there is an agricultural director with a salary of £750 to £950 who is at present drawing his maximum. The director was not on the staff last year. I would like to know what the functions of the director are.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The agricultural director is a technical officer and also an administrative officer. He ranks next to the assistant secretary.

Comment on this

I presume he was an existing officer of the Department?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Yes.

Comment on this

I wish to deal with E 3 and E 4 under sub-head E. Under E 3 there is down a sum of £600. Last year it was £380. It is with regard to "other organisations" to which the Minister has subscribed or intends to subscribe in the course of this year. We all know the importance of the first item, but we would like to have some information from the Minister as to what are the other organisations to which he has subscribed this year and for which the Vote is increased from last year. With regard to sub-head E 4, I notice there is still down on the Estimates a charge for tobacco experimenters. I am glad to see that this charge is still retained. I do not suppose this is the proper time to raise a discussion on the question of tobacco-growing. I understand an amendment will be proposed to the Finance Bill in the course of a week or two on which we will be able to discuss the report of the Tobacco Committee. I am glad to see that the Minister has not completely stamped out all idea of helping tobacco, and that there is still retained in the Estimates a small sum, much the same as last year, in connection with experiments, although I see a foot-note that this matter may be reviewed. There is one item of £333 for grants to experimenters in the production of tobacco. Could the Minister give us any information as to what exactly that stands for? It is a matter of amazement to me that on this day, the one day of the year when the great agricultural estimates are being discussed in the Dáil, there is an extraordinary absence of the members of the Farmers' Party, including the whole Front Bench.

Comment on this

It is a great compliment to the Minister.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I think these outstanding grants to experimenters of £333 speak for themselves. These are grants in respect to the acreage grown. Certain regulations had to be complied with. It sometimes takes a year to see whether the regulations are complied with. It is, as the Deputy says, only a small sum. The general question with regard to tobacco will come up on another Vote and we will have a debate on it then. The Institutes to which we are subscribing include the International Institute of Agriculture, the International Seed Testing Institute, the International Meteorological Conference and others. I will give the Deputy a list of them.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say if we are increasing our subscriptions?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

No, but we are increasing the number to which we are subscribing.

Comment on this

With regard to the International Institute of Agriculture, perhaps the Minister would give us a longer statement on the advantages derived by the Department from membership of this Institute, or the advantages which we gain from it. I know, of course, we get a certain number of publications—international information with regard to crops and matters of that kind—but I would like to have a fuller justification for the expenditure. I also want to know what the Minister proposes to do with regard to sending delegations. Is there to be an international conference this year? If so, is there to be a delegation, and if so how is that delegation to be composed? I think it was already stated in regard to this matter of sending representatives to the conferences of this Institute that we do not consider the Department's officials are the proper delegates to send to such conferences.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Why?

Comment on this

For the same reason that you do not send officials from the Department of Industry and Commerce to the Labour Conferences in Geneva.

Comment on this

Oh, yes, they do.

Comment on this

Yes, but they would want to send other representatives in this case. The only representatives sent are the Department's officials. I think you would want to get men outside the Department, men with a wider knowledge of agriculture than officials might have whose views are apt to be narrowed down to their particular Department.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The International Institute of Agriculture is, of course, the most important body of its kind. Not only have you the advantage of its publications but you have no other way of getting international statistics in connection with agriculture, and, as the Deputy will agree, that is invaluable. I put forward no justification for subscribing to it apart from that. With regard to the other point that you should send to the Conferences not only officers of the Department but farmers, we are not tied to any particular delegation. We would always, of course, send officers of the Department, but possibly an outsider might be sent, a non-civil servant occasionally. There is no reason why that should not be done, but I want to protest against the use of the adjective "wider" in that connection. Deputy Heffernan should get out of the habit of contrasting officers and civil servants with other people, and saying that other people as a rule have a "wider" outlook. I do not know why other people should have wider knowledge. It would depend on the farmer and on the officer. I could get a farmer with a narrow outlook and an officer with a narrow outlook. You cannot generalise about it. The International Conference is over, and there was a Dairy Congress at Paris last year at which a technical officer of the Department dealing with that particular section was present.

Comment on this

I move to reduce sub-head F (1) by £16,108; that is the cost as shown on the Estimate of the Agricultural Stations at Athenry and Ballyhaise. I referred to this matter on the Vote on Account, but I had not an opportunity then of moving an amendment. I am convinced that in this matter of agricultural education we are travelling in an old rut, and the sooner we get out of that rut the better. The old rut is running stations, which not only do not pay their way, but involve a substantial charge on the taxpayer, and these two stations at Athenry and Ballyhaise are the most striking instances of that situation. In 1925, according to the Estimate, £352 was taken as fees in these stations. Deducting that from the cost shown on the Estimate, they cost £18,063 to run. For that £18,063, nineteen pupils were educated.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Surely the Deputy knows that that £18,000 is not entirely for education and that, therefore, putting the whole cost of the institutes against education is a mistake.

Comment on this

I did not know whether these institutes were entirely educational or not, but when the matter was last raised, the Minister told us that experimental work was being done at Glasnevin and Clonakilty.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

And also in these institutes.

Comment on this

He specified Glasnevin and Clonakilty and ignored these two.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I also explained that livestock were bred there and distributed through the country under the market price.

Comment on this

Anyway, the average cost in these institutions was £950 per head; at Glasnevin it was £219, and Clonakilty £323 per head. As a matter of fact, I saw where a Deputy of the Farmers' Party who, I believe, lives at Clonakilty, and who might know something about it, advocated the abolition of the Clonakilty Station. I do not go as far as that, but I ask the Deputies to contrast that cost of £950 per head at Athenry and Ballyhaise to train a farmer or an agricultural official—which is what these agricultural stations do, very much more than they train farmers—with the cost of training members of highly technical professions elsewhere. A British Naval officer has to be a highly skilled officer.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Would the Deputy give me the figures showing a cost of £950 per head?

Comment on this

I will give the figures. For 1925 the cost was £18,633. Divide that by 19.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

What schools?

Comment on this

Athenry and Ballyhaise.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

What is the £18,000?

Comment on this

The cost on the 1925 Estimates.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Gross?

Comment on this

Less £252 for pupils' fees. The figures were all given to me by the Minister. I may be wrong, but anyway the cost is over £900. A British naval officer costs £300 a year. An officer in the British Air Force costs £500. But it costs £950 to train a farmer in Cavan or Galway. I do not know if the Minister considers that he is getting value for the money. When I raised this matter two months ago the Minister put forward two pleas. The first was that he was breeding high-class animals that were sold at half-price to deserving farmers. That was his interruption just now. The second was that experimental work was carried on. There is one thing that is certain about experimental work, and that is, that it ought to be co-ordinated; it ought to be carried on under a single head and the results chronicled in a single sentence.

Experimental work in Glasnevin is invaluable. It is very valuable because it can be co-ordinated with the Plant Breeding Section and the various sections still working in the College of Science. I do not want to touch one penny of the cost of Glasnevin. The Minister says that experimental work is going on at Clonakilty. I am not proposing to touch Clonakilty, particularly because I respect the powers of self-defence of County Cork and because I do not want to curtail work of an experimental character. But you should not mix up experiments and education. I believe seriously that it is an enormous mistake. Your courses are not university courses; they are short courses of one or two years at the maximum. You get boys coming there with no marked provision of education. I think it must be very difficult to teach them to discriminate between the experiments and what they are supposed to learn.

The Minister told us about two months ago about an experiment at Glasnevin where he saw some cattle in magnificent condition, and he said to the official responsible for the experiment: "These cattle are very good. You will get such a price for them." He said: "I would if I sold them now, but for the purposes of the experiment I have got to keep them two months longer and I do not think I will get such a price then." No doubt there was advantage in that experiment, but to the average student it will produce one of two results. A very stupid man would say, as a result of the experiment: "We always kept these cattle for ten months at the College and I am going to keep my cattle for ten months." The more intelligent pupil would say: "These cattle are not now as good as they were two months ago and the teaching here is all rot."

Unless you have pupils who have gone through an elaborate course of education and have learned to discriminate, it is a very dangerous thing to introduce experiments. I remember when I was learning chemistry my belief in the science of chemistry was shattered when the experiment by which the instructor tried to illustrate the theories he was laying down failed altogether. You should keep the two things in Departments. I think Sir James Craig will agree that medical students are only taught along approved lines and that they are not allowed to indulge in any new avenues of experiment.

As regards selling live stock at half-price, I wonder are we justified in using the public funds to subsidise individuals? That is what it comes to. Are the people who are getting these cattle at half-price selected by the county committees? If so, it may easily happen that one county committee is active and another is sluggish, and one part of the country gets help out of the general taxes in opposition to another part who are paying as many taxes. I do not say that there are not advantages in these stations. There are, but are there sufficient advantages to justify us in running these stations at a loss, because that is what we are doing—at a substantial loss annually. Therefore, when the Farmers' Party say that they desire to see a model farm in every county, I say that once you have paid for the establishment and paid the capital charges the annual running ought not to be a charge on the taxpayer. If it is, it is of no value to the farmer. The farmer does not want to be taught to farm at a loss; he wants to be taught to farm at a profit, and he might well quarrel with the present system of agricultural education, as it leaves out the question of profit and of marketing altogether. Glasnevin College does not market its milk on competitive lines; it has a contract, and until you can teach the farmer marketing as well as production you will not be getting full value out of your agricultural education.

Comment on this

I am not going to support Deputy Cooper in this amendment. At the same time, I think an explanation is due from the Minister as to why the number of pupils at these schools has sunk to such a small number. I think it is an extraordinary thing that these schools, which have, I presume, accommodation for up to 100 students, have such a small number of students. Could the Minister tell me what the accommodation is at Ballyhaise and Athenry?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I will.

Comment on this

I would like if the Minister could tell us why he cannot get the pupils to attend the schools. I believe in provincial agricultural colleges. I think there are reasons which make it useful to have these provincial colleges. I think it would be the case that students would be more anxious to attend these colleges in their own immediate neighbourhood. There is one thing I would like to point out to Deputy Cooper with regard to experiments. That is that I think it is possible to carry out experiments on this basis which are more applicable to the district in which the college is situated than in Glasnevin. In Glasnevin you have one particular type of soil and one particular climate. The same climate does not prevail all over the country and in these other places you will have different conditions, different soil, different rain conditions and other matters of that kind which make it advisable to have those schools in those other places. At the same time I realised that as they stand at present they are not justifying themselves. It is not justifiable to have this expense of over £16,000 and only 19 students attending them. I presume, if the teaching part were done away with altogether, that the experiments could be carried out on these farms at a much lower cost than that which the schools are conducted at now. Officials have to be kept as well as superintendents and housekeepers and other people of that kind who would not be required if these places were simply conducted as experimental farms. Another advantage in connection with these schools—and I hope they are being used for that purpose—is that they are demonstrating places where the people of the surrounding counties are invited to go from time to time to see the work that is being done and the experiments that are being carried out.

I had the advantage a short time ago of going through the Glasnevin Agricultural School and Farm and of seeing the experiments carried out—experiments in crops, in the rearing of live stock and other things. I thought it was most instructive. I think it would be very useful if the people from different counties could be got to visit these institutions in large numbers, if arrangements could be made for delegations from each district and perhaps from farmers' associations of different kinds, and if the superintendent or officials responsible for the establishment were told off to take these people round and to give them all information as to work that is being carried on in these schools. I think it is along these lines that we must get the people to display an interest in these institutions. We must get them to take an interest in the scientific development of agriculture. We could advertise by one means or another, not necessarily in the papers, that these places were there for the people, that the people are invited and welcome to come and that they will be received—I will not say with hospitality—in a manner which shows that the officials are anxious to give them all possible information. I have seen in other places big field days at agricultural schools where the people of the whole surrounding districts, from great distances, were invited to come. Speeches were made, demonstrations were given and all kinds of educational work done, and I think these colleges should be used for the same purpose. I presume they are used to a certain extent for that purpose, but they are not used to as great an extent as I would like to see them, and some explanation is due from the Minister as to why a greater number of students do not attend.

Comment on this
Martin Roddy Mr. RODDY

In connection with Deputy Cooper's amendment, I would like to call the Minister's attention to a report of a meeting of the members of the Farmers' Union in Cork some time ago, when the Chairman, Mr. O'Gorman, called attention to the extraordinary expenditure in connection with the Department's school at Clonakilty. In the course of his remarks he said: "We would like to hear about the gentleman who is getting a pension of £1,200 after three years' service when he would be only entitled to £800 or £900. We would also like to get his birth certificate. The Minister might be also requested to give the names and ages of the six Dáil organisers who are getting £30 per month at the public expense." Merely for the sake of giving the Minister an opportunity of explaining why there is this apparently extraordinary extravagance that is alleged in connection with this particular institution at Clonakilty I am glad that Deputy Cooper put down this amendment. In connection with Athenry, I happen to have some experience of the agricultural station there, and I certainly do think that the experimental work carried on there is of first-rate importance.

After all, if these stations are to carry on experimental work of this kind, and impart information to the farmers, it is impossible, to my mind, for the farms in connection with these stations to be run at a profit. Just take one thing. I remember being a member of a delegation that visited that station three or four years ago. At that time some very interesting experiments in pig feeding with dry foods were carried on. As Deputies know, at that time the practice was to feed pigs on boiled food, and they were not fed very economically on that.

As a result of the experiments carried out in Athenry it was demonstrated that it was possible to feed pigs on dry food more economically than on boiled foods—potatoes, meal, etc.— with the result that a large number of farmers, as a commercial proposition, have adopted dry feeding, and they have found that they are able to feed pigs more economically than by boiling food for them, as was done in the old days. That is one illustration of the advantages to be derived from the experimental work carried on in these stations. Many county committees organised deputations to visit these stations annually, and the instructors explained to the various deputations the nature of the experiments they had been carrying on during the year, the results of experiments in cattle rearing, sheep rearing, and pig breeding, and the growing of different varieties of corn, potatoes, etc. The result is that the farmers take an intelligent interest in these experiments. The farmers are prepared to take advantage of what they have seen in these institutions, and when they carry out these experiments on their own farms they find that the experiments inevitably mean a saving in their own spheres. While I would be anxious that the Minister should run these stations on the most economical lines, I fail to see how it is possible to carry out educational work on the same scale as at present, and at the same time run these places at a profit. There must inevitably be a loss, and my only regret is that the farmers generally and the farmers' sons particularly, do not take proper advantage of these institutions.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I will not congratulate Deputy Cooper on his speech. I certainly say it is most ingenious. He did mix it with a vengeance. He gave us some interesting figures, but I did not think he was quite so naïve. I know he can read estimates and examine them pretty closely. He first of all mixed up in a most beautiful fashion—I do not put it down to stupidity— the work of the farmer, not only this educational work but this experimental work and all this work in connection with the breeding of live stock. These farms are fulfilling three functions. They are educational, they are experimental not only for the benefit of the students but for the purposes of the Departmental leaflets, for the purposes of the instructors, to enable them to give up-to-date advice to farmers throughout the country, and in addition they have a third function, the breeding of live stock for resale at a loss. The Deputy bulked the three together and found that the cost of these two farms last year was £18,000. The Deputy had not sufficient curiosity, even after bulking the three in order to swell the bill, to turn to the Appropriations-in-Aid and make necessary deductions. I suspect that Deputy Cooper knows there are such things as Appropriations-in-Aid at the end of each year's Estimates. Possibly it may be that the procedure of putting the Appropriations-in-Aid at the end of the Estimates has escaped Deputy Cooper's notice up to the present.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Well, something has occurred. If the Deputy did turn to the Appropriations-in-Aid he would find that he could take £8,000 from £18,000 and that would leave him £10,000.

Comment on this

£8,500 is the figure.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I think that is right. Anyhow, roughly speaking, £10,000 would be left. The Deputy after that could explain that this represented the cost to the State of education, experiments and the production of live stock —high-class breeding stock—for the purpose of resale, very often at a loss. The Deputy has indulged in figures and I think he has shown that figures can be made extremely illusory. Perhaps he will allow me to give him a few more figures?

The Deputy stated expressly that the cost of education per pupil is £950. That is the sort of thing that people can remember. I can hear the changes rung on that figure, regardless of any correction, for the next three months. Everyone with a bee in his bonnet, everyone who wants to have a shot at the Department of Agriculture in season and out of season, will shout that the cost of education is £950 per pupil; but there will not be a word of explanation that that is the cost of education, plus the cost of all the experimental work done on the farms, plus the cost of raising high-class breeding stock for resale at a loss. One may be sure these facts will not be added.

What is the cost of education? I am sure the Deputy will allow me to examine the Estimates on the same lines as he has done. I suggest the Deputy ought to put in the housemaster in each case, £200; housekeeper, £50; domestic staff, £82, and a teacher of poultry-keeping, £60, against the educational side. I know these farms very well, and all these officers are required. They have their hands well filled with experimental work and live stock breeding. If the Deputy adds all the figures he will get a total of £6,000 for the two instead of £18,000, and the figure for each pupil will work out at £20.

Comment on this

It would be at least £30.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

About £30 a pupil would be more like it. A moment's consideration will show that it is perfectly incorrect to say it costs £650 to educate a pupil at one of these colleges. It is not a fair statement in view of the uses that can be made of it. It is obvious the statement will get three times as much publicity as the correction. If we were simply making debating points, I could throw the £30 at his £950. The fact is that it is quite impossible to disentangle the educational, experimental and live-stock breeding work. It is when you have people talking about agriculture but meaning something else that these statements are made. I do not accuse the Deputy of anything like that; but you have people outside making debating points and talking about agriculture when their meaning lies elsewhere, and you get agriculture, experiments and live stock breeding debated in this fashion. It is quite impossible to disentangle them.

If I were to take the same line as the Deputy, I could easily say that the average cost per pupil is about £30 and that it is well worth the money. The Deputy ought not to say that the university work should not be done there. University work is not done there. Experimental work of this kind is not University work. There are people who will mix up research and experimental work, but I take it the Deputy knows the distinction. I am sure the Deputy knows perfectly well that the work of hybridising plants that will be done at a Faculty of Agriculture is not experimental work. There is no useful purpose served by mixing up matters.

The functions of these colleges are as follows:—(1) The training of boys and girls in subjects pertaining to agriculture; (2) experimental work; and (3) the production of pure-bred live stock. Deputies will notice that the Appropriations-in-Aid each year about balance the particular item, general expenses of management. I make no point about that. Next year it might be just as much. The Appropriations-in-Aid were somewhat less this year and last year as compared with the general expenses of management; in other words, there was a loss. Perhaps that might change. It proves nothing. Next year, provided there are more experiments, the general expenses of management might be greater. As they are being run, the Appropriations-in-Aid practically balance every year the general expenses of management.

I will take the question of the training of boys and girls in subjects pertaining to agriculture. In reply to Deputy Heffernan, let me say that the numbers at the Albert College remain stationary. Let me take the agricultural students. I am dealing with the years 1921 to 1926 in succession, and the figures are as follows:—18, 20, 25, 21, 12 and 31; that is to say, that in 1925-26 there were 31. That is a higher figure than in 1920. As regards farm apprentices, the figures are:—12, 15. 9 (1923-24), 13, and 17. The figures there are higher also. In regard to horticultural students the figures are:—7, 8, 8, 6, 4, 9. There was a drop during 1922 and 1924 for obvious reasons; people were not thinking of education. As regards Clonakilty, the figures from 1920-1926 were:—26, 7, 19, 7, 26, 26, 26. Now, as regards Athenry:—17, 14, 22, 17, 25. Here are the numbers as regards Ballyhaise:— 26, 16, 7.

Ballyhaise was not open for some time. The intention is to make Ballyhaise a girls' school—a school somewhat similar to the Munster Institute. The figures for the Munster Institute are:—54, 56, 56, 51, and, this year, 53. The Munster Institute is full and cannot take another pupil. We have a long waiting list, and some have been waiting for a long time. It is proposed to make Ballyhaise a girls' school and it is proposed to use the farm as a dairy farm for the purpose of supplying milk to the Institute.

Comment on this

How many can you accommodate at Ballyhaise and Athenry?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I could not give the exact number, but I think it is twenty-six to thirty each. Ballyhaise is not open yet, and, therefore, we are delayed in carying out our intention. The water supply at Athenry went wrong. We were not prepared to take any risks, and we changed the students to Ballyhaise while the engineers of the Board of Works are investigating the pollution of the water supply.

Comment on this

Will Athenry be re-opened?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Certainly it will be reopened. The students are changed to Ballyhaise, and that for the moment has stopped the plan of converting Ballyhaise into a girls' school, but that will come immediately. There is nothing so much needed. As I say, there is a long waiting list for the Munster Institute.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

took the Chair.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The waiting list is over 200, and that state of affairs has existed for a long time. It is our intention to go ahead with the original project and to convert Ballyhaise into a girls' school and the students will go back to Athenry. Again, let me state, the numbers are on the increase and our colleges are, in fact, almost full. Twenty-five to thirty is the most that Athenry would hold.

Comment on this

How are the students selected?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

By examination, and they are taken in in the order in which they appear upon the lists.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider the necessity of sending the results of the examinations to applicants and the number of marks they receive? There is dissatisfaction at the moment with the methods of selection.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I dare say there is, but they get the results of the examinations.

Comment on this

It is not customary to give them.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Every applicant is informed whether he passes or not when he is put upon the list. If they are on the waiting list it shows that they passed, but they do not get supplied with the marks. I am sure there is dissatisfaction, and I am quite sure that there are suggestions made by long-suffering applicants that they might be put higher up on the list. There is a waiting list of 200 for the Munster Institute. Possibly some of those have been waiting for a long while and you can well imagine that after waiting, possibly, for a year a mother would find some other reason for her son or daughter not being called than their actual place on the list. I know a little about this subject and it is a sore subject with a lot of people. People are anxious to get their daughters or sons transferred to higher places and I know it is not an unheard-of thing for suggestions to be made to the Department that people should be called before their time, but I can assure the Deputy that it is the invariable procedure of the Department only to call students according to their order upon the list.

Comment on this

I am aware of that, but I think it would satisfy the parents if they got the results.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

They do get the results by the way in which they are placed on the list.

Comment on this

I remember when I was a Governor of the Munster Institute, there were always applications on the part of some ambitious ladies, especially, to be put ahead of the rank they held, and every excuse was given, but we always treated the matter with absolute silence. There was no use arguing a question with anybody if they misjudged the work of the Governors of the Institute. They did misjudge it, and called attention to it in a way that we were determined to treat with contempt. I think it would be far better, instead of pandering to the erroneous idea of anybody that they are out of their order or that they were not fairly treated, to treat them with the silent contempt which they deserve.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Of course Deputy Nolan did not suggest that there was any favouritism. I only mention that to show that where the dissatisfaction exists it is due, largely, to the fact that there is always a long waiting list, and people get impatient. So far as the colleges are concerned, the numbers have increased, and they are practically full.

Deputy Cooper raised a very big question that it is impossible to discuss without taking a very long time, as to what experiments should or should not be conducted on these farms. He has got to remember that experiments are not done primarily for the pupils at all. It is quite easy to teach a pupil who comes up for one year's course if he is a good farmer's son who has been at a winter class, and who only comes up for a year or two's course. There is no real necessity to do experiments in order to teach him. You teach him ordinary subjects, showing him good cultivation, and the value of seeding and testing. In the Munster Institute they have to deal with poultry, butter-making, and so on, and it is necessary to show them all processes in connection with butter-making, not only the good effect but the result of the bad effect as well. You have to show the varieties of poultry, and that some pay and some do not, and show the effect of wrong treatment on the quality of butter and produce generally, and, in that way, a very large percentage of the material, as, for instance, in the case of butter, goes to the bad. It is a sacrifice for educational purposes, and that is all that is in it.

For instance, again, take the question of milking as one single item of the Munster Institute. Cows have to be milked by different girls, and in such circumstances will not yield their full quantity of milk. Every farmer knows that a cow must be milked regularly by a fairly experienced milker in order to give the best results. In the Munster Institute, where the cows are milked by different sets of girls, you have a loss. These are not the ideal conditions where you want a high yield of milk. The same applies to other items and to other colleges.

Now it is useful to have experiments going on under the noses of the students. These students of 18 or 19 years of age have a great deal of practical experience, and a considerable number of feeding experiments are carried out. I am not a bit afraid that what Deputy Cooper foreshadowed will happen. He quoted a case that I mentioned, where a certain feeding experiment was carried out on 25 or 30 cattle. I spoke to the superintendent at the time and said: "You are going to get a real good price as cattle are going well." He said: "I would if I had not to hold them over. But I must hold them over." Deputy Cooper is afraid, if I may use the word, that a "mug" would go home and tell his father that in future he is to keep the cattle until the price falls. There is not the slightest fear of that. They are not quite as innocent as all that. The experiments are not so terribly complicated that they are likely to disarrange a student's intelligence in that way. It is useful for the students to see these experiments, manurial experiments, cultivation experiments, and the good students take a real interest in them. Remember that these experiments are done for other purposes as well. I have here a short list of the experiments done on these farms last year.

Comment on this

Are these at Athenry and Ballyhaise?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Yes. These are experiments and not research work. There were, in addition to the tests on this list, tests in animal nutrition, the value of green food for pigs and dried sugar beet for fattening cattle and milch cows. A large number of store pigs have to be bought, divided, weighed and kept under conditions that a commercial farmer would not dream of keeping them under. The greatest care must be taken that no extraneous factor interferes with the experiment. The result of the experiment must go out through the country in leaflet form and we must take care that in feeding experiments the results are not vitiated by extraneous circumstances. I dare say most Deputies know that pigs are inclined to take the food from one another. We have to arrange that every pig in the bunch gets the same amount of food. We have also to arrange for weighing. We have to secure that the experiment is not destroyed or injured by reason of the fact that one group of pigs have got cold or less light, or is brought up under less ideal conditions than the others. All that costs money and means capital expenditure. It means supervision. In other words, you cannot make education pay, and this education is not only for 15, 20 or 30 pupils, but is education for farmers, as the result of the experiments will be published in pamphlet form. During the last year experiments were carried out and none of them was in the nature of very abstract research work such as would be done in the plant-breeding laboratory of a university. They were experiments in the interest of the farmers. They were experiments that will give results and make a difference in the way of increased profits or, if you prefer, less losses. I have a list of 100 pamphlets. I do not know if the Deputy reads those pamphlets issued by the Department. If not, I can recommend them to him.

Comment on this

I have looked through the lists, and I read the Monthly Journal. I do not get the pamphlets.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

You ought to. Even though I say it, they are very good, very much on the mark, and extremely well written. I cannot understand why there is not a greater demand for them. An increasing demand is reported during the past year, but I cannot understand why they are not more fully availed of. Remember that these pamphlets are based on experiments carried out at the farms. I think the Deputy said that he understood that experiments should be carried out at the Albert College, but that he did not see the necessity for them at the other institutes. I cannot agree with that. As Deputy Conlan mentioned, we find it necessary to study the different conditions. If a new breed of oats is brought out at the Albert College, it is tested first in small quantities and then sent to other farms and tested under different conditions. Before we open our mouths about it, we test it in about 150 places throughout the country. Otherwise it would be madness to recommend throughout the whole country oats that was grown on a single farm in Dublin. I need not go into the question of breeding high-class live stock for the purpose of resale, sometimes at a loss——

Comment on this

May I ask if the highly-bred live stock is sold in the localities in which the colleges are situated, or is it open to any farmers in the Saorstát to purchase them? I understand these animals are sold on easy terms.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

These animals are sent mainly to the congested districts. The immediate district in which the colleges are get no special advantage. For instance, from Clonakilty, boars would be sent to Mayo. It depends on the needs of the moment. The other question Deputy Cooper raised will also arise on his next amendment. He said that we should seriously consider whether it is good business for the State to subsidise the distribution of live stock to small farmers who are not able to pay for high-class animals. I would like to hear the views of other Deputies on that question. I regard it as not only good business but absolutely essential to send such animals to these districts. Remember that the congested districts—and particularly the western side—constitute a very big area. There are very big numbers of live stock bred there, and it would be a very serious thing indeed, not only for the reputation of the stock within the area, but for the reputation of the stock of the country as a whole, if the stock there deteriorated. There is even a more serious consideration still. The Deputy will remember that in the poorer areas the dividing-line between just-enough and starvation is not very marked. How could a small farmer in Mayo, Donegal, Connemara, parts of Kerry, Leitrim, parts of Kildare, and even other districts outside the congested districts, afford to give £50 for an Aberdeen-Angus bull? And remember that one will only get a third-class Aberdeen-Angus bull, at the moment, for £50. How could he afford to buy even the last bull that we would pass, costing, say, £30? How could he afford to pay £12 for a boar or £10 for a sow?

If we do not continue this policy, especially for the congested districts and the poorer districts, we are going to have deterioration. This is not a new policy. We are doing no more here than we have been doing through the county committees of agriculture. The whole premium system, under the county committees, is based on this policy. That is what has improved our cattle until they are, from the point of view of quality, the best cattle in the world. We will see what the Scotch farmers will say about them in a year or two years. They are already beginning to talk. They already know what difference there is between them and the Canadians. I have not the slightest hesitation in saying that, as a result of these schemes, we have the best live stock, from the point of view of quality, in the world. If we had not, we would have been driven out of the British market long ago. Suppose there are a thousand premiums in the country, and three hundred special term animals. They are all bulls that would average round about £60 or £70 each.

I want to emphasise that that would be the average price. If you take certain breeds, the price would be much higher. You would pay as much as £180 for an Aberdeen-Angus, and you would pay £120 for a middling one. How many people of the 1,300 who keep premium animals could purchase them if they were not helped in this way by the State? You would have no breeders, and you would have no buyers, and you would have fourth-class bulls, with consequent fourth-class stock.

What do our live stock schemes cost on the whole? I suppose about £70,000 a year. There was never £70,000 better spent. I think £140,000 would be well spent in the same way. I say, deliberately, that even if we had to get the money from taxation, and if the country was three times as poor as the most pessimistic person alleges it is, you could not spend money in a better way. When one considers for a moment the amount of money spent on other services, and when one thinks of what has been done at so little cost by the constant introduction into and spreading through the country of first-class breeding stock for the last fifteen years, I marvel that Deputies of all parties, in the House, instead of talking about short cuts to riches in farming, do not press that in future the Estimates of the Department of Agriculture should be increased from £50,000 or £60,000 to something like £100,000 for this work. As far as I am concerned, my aim and object is to extend this side of the Department's work in the way of introducing high-class stock—bulls, boars and sheep—into every county. The Deputy knows what even one good bull will do in a district. The progeny will leave their mark there for generations. You cannot measure what one good animal will do. Multiply the number from one thousand to, say, two thousand, and, at the other end, weed out all the bad animals, and you will have stock that will be of creditable quality—something that you need not be ashamed to market anywhere. I say we ought to continue that. We should not be prevented doing that by anybody with an interest in agriculture. If we continue to do that, the least we might expect—this may, perhaps, be irrelevant—would be that the farmers would do their duty by feeding their stock and marketing them properly.

I have little further to say except to repeat that this fairy tale about £950 per student is not good enough. It does not cost £950. It does not cost £30 per pupil. The number of pupils in these colleges is increasing. As we get back more and more to normal times, the increase will be greater. I want to see more of these colleges. They are expensive, but I want to see more of them, nevertheless. We have five of them at present. I would be glad to see 30 farmers' sons from each county getting this sort of education.

Comment on this

Whilst I do not agree with Deputy Cooper's amendment, I am very pleased that he put it down, because it gave the Minister an opportunity of putting before the House an exposition of the different activities of these agricultural schools. I have a good deal of experience of these schools. I have been through the Athenry, Glasnevin, and Portumna institutions. In my opinion, the money expended on these institutions has been very usefully expended. Anybody who desires information as to what the Department actually did in the improvement of live stock should read the evidence given by Mr. T.P. Gill at the inquiry held in London when the Act for removal of the embargo on the importation of Canadian cattle into England was under consideration. Mr. Gill showed that the value of our cattle had been improved by these live stock schemes from £2 per head to £5 per head in twenty years. Anybody who has occasion to go to our fairs will easily notice the improvement in all classes of live stock that has taken place during the last 20 or 25 years. That is due to the work of the department and particularly to the work carried out in those schools. In saying that, I would like to urge that more could still be done. The pamphlets the Minister referred to are extremely interesting. Any farmer who applies to the office can get copies of them, but I am sorry to say that, up to recently, a great number of our farmers were not aware that the results of the research branches of the Department were available in this way. The English Department of Agriculture is actually carrying out some of the work of which our Department were pioneers. In 1922 I took the following cutting from an English paper:—

Warble Fly.—A Committee of the Ministry of Agriculture has, for some time past, been considering scientifically the various remedies which have been suggested for checking the damage to skins of cattle made by the warble fly pest. In the past, the step most favoured in dealing with the pest has been the squeezing out of the maggots from the backs of cattle during the season when they become ripe—that is, from February to June. This method, however, although efficacious if persisted in, entails much labour. The Committee, therefore, directed their attention to observation of the action of washes or smears which can readily be applied to the backs of cattle ... During last spring an experimental dressing of no fewer than 940 cattle was made with this mixture, under the direction of the Irish Department of Agriculture. Of 4,885 warble maggots found to be present in the cattle 3,990 were destroyed, representing a mortality of over 80 per cent.

This Committee, appointed by the British Ministry of Agriculture, actually suggested that the recommendation of the Irish Department of Agriculture should be carried out in England. I say that is a great tribute to the work of our Department here. They have a very able staff of officials in the English Department and they go in for a lot of research work, as we do here. But in the respect I mentioned, we are ahead of them.

I was pleased to hear from the Minister that Ballyhaise school is going to be opened as a school for girls. I was, I think, one of the first Deputies to suggest that something on those lines should be done. There were a lot of complaints about the difficulty of getting into the Munster Institute, and there was great dissatisfaction in parts of the country, owing to the length of time young ladies had to wait before gaining admission. I am sure this departure will relieve the situation a great deal. I am sorry our boys are not taking as much advantage as they should of schools, like the school at Clonakilty and elsewhere. I should like to know from the Minister—perhaps I had better leave it over until the Vote for veterinary grants, as I may be out of order in asking it now— whether any researches are being carried on in regard to foot and mouth disease at present?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Not here.

Comment on this

I should like to call the Minister's attention to an announcement made the other day, where frozen pigs coming in actually carried the disease; they traced it in Great Britain to those pigs. Some time a consignment of those pigs came into this country.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

The Deputy can raise this matter on another Vote.

Comment on this

I should like some information with regard to the Chantilly stud farm in County Dublin. I presume it is used to breed thoroughbred stock.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

It is a stud farm pure and simple, a sort of clearing house for all the animals coming from the other side. They are kept there until they are sent to the country.

Comment on this

With regard to the Minister's activities in the breeding of stock, I think the House will say "More power to his elbow." He has done a great deal in the breeding of stock, but a great deal has yet to be done. Ask any experienced farmer or cattle dealer and he will tell you that, after a percentage of cattle are taken, the remainder are very poor indeed.

Comment on this

We all recognise the necessity for agricultural education. Last year both Deputy Gorey and myself referred specially to the necessity for bringing home to the people the result of this education. With that idea, we suggested that there should be demonstration farms in the various counties. What is suitable to one county is not suitable to another. Experiments made in Cork will not be of great value in Limerick, and the same would apply as between Tipperary and Kildare. I do not refer to an experimental station. That is quite another matter. If you had one or two demonstration farms in each county they would be very useful. At present I think when land is being taken over in various counties, and where you have in each of the large farms taken over a dwelling-house with out-offices, forty or fifty acres of that land should be given to some young man who had been trained in one of the Department's institutes. That would be better than having an inspector to reside there. The farms could be given under special conditions as to the payment of rent, etc., and could be used to demonstrate successful work. You cannot get farmers to go to model farms. The work must be brought home to them and must be available for the farmers in the various counties. I think the Minister should take notice of this important matter.

Comment on this

The Minister did not deal with my point with regard to using those schools for the purpose of education.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

We do that; they are all welcome.

Comment on this

The only thing I see weak about the Minister's argument is this: he wishes to see an agricultural school in each county with an attendance of thirty pupils. There are only twenty-five in Athenry and seven in Ballyhaise.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Ballyhaise is closed. It contained seven in 1922-23, during the civil war. There is accommodation for twenty-six in Athenry.

Comment on this

With regard to Deputy D'Alton's remarks about demonstration farms, those are becoming, to a certain extent, a hardy annual now. The suggestion was put forward recently by the Farmers' Party, but we are not asking for a demonstration farm. We are asking that, perhaps, more than one farm may be taken up in each county. An official from the Department should be placed on that farm and asked to work it in the most up-to-date manner so as to demonstrate to the people that an official of the Department can put his theories into practice, and show that a farm can be worked and made to pay according to the ideas of the Department of Agriculture. Many people say instructors are only theoretical farmers. To a certain extent there is something in that.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

To what extent?

Comment on this

A man working in Glasnevin, Athenry, or some other place has a fixed salary and no obligation to make his work pay.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

He is under an obligation to carry out his experiments at a certain cost.

Comment on this

I know that.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

That was discussed on the main question already.

Comment on this

I suggest it may be discussed under this as Deputy D'Alton opened it up again. A good deal of the work carried out under the agricultural colleges is experimental and non-instructional. I know there is a dairy at Glasnevin which is used for commercial purposes. Instructors are really engaged in work not altogether experimental. Those men must be given a chance to put those theories into practice. That is somewhat different from Deputy D'Alton's idea.

Comment on this

I had better explain what I have said again. This idea was mentioned five or six years ago by some prominent farmers. Deputy Gorey and I discussed those matters and agreed that it would be better, if possible, not to have an instructor there, because if he carried out certain work, farmers around would say: "The Department is doing it." We consider if such farms were given to a qualified man he could demonstrate there.

Comment on this

I think that the Minister stated last year that he intended to get in touch with practical farmers with a view of seeing that the instructions of the Department were carried out on certain farms in order to prove that the theories propounded by the instructors could be put into practice and made a paying proposition.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Agricultural instructors have been asked to keep in touch with special farms in each district, but it must not be taken for granted that every farmer does what the instructor asks him to do. The instructors do keep in touch with special farms and advise farmers in connection with certain processes. Deputy Roddy reminded me of a statement that has recently been made by Mr. O'Gorman, Chairman of the Cork County Council, in connection with Clonakilty. He stated, first of all, that there were twenty-two teachers there, and secondly, that an officer was employed there who got £1,200 a year and that another officer got a pension of something like £900. That statement is untrue. It is not the first statement of the kind that this particular gentleman has made. The fact is that there are three teachers and twenty-six pupils there. No officer of the Department of Agriculture, except the Secretary, gets a salary of £1,200 a year, not to speak of a pension. I stated here on Friday that owing to the fact that farmers were, to a great extent, unorganised, every mountebank who claimed to be a spokesman for agriculture, got away with it. In this instance you have an excellent example of that. Here you have Cork County, one of the best farming counties in Ireland, but you have as Chairman of the County Council and County Committee of Agriculture, Mr. O'Gorman, a man who grows more thistles within his own area——

Comment on this

I object to that statement. Mr. O'Gorman, whatever be his capacity, was elected to the Cork County Council and is Chairman of that body, as well as being elected Chairman of the County Committee of Agriculture.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Is this in order?

Comment on this

He is there as an elected representative of the people. The people consider him worthy of being put into these positions, and it is unfair of the Minister, availing of his privilege here, to attack Mr. O'Gorman. Let him go outside and attack him, if he wants to do so.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

The Minister is entitled to his point of view, the same as anyone else.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I have something else to do besides going outside and controverting Mr. O'Gorman's lies. I was challenged by Farmer-Deputies when I made that statement. In opening the debate I said deliberately that we were suffering from a minority of disgruntled individuals, people with bees in their bonnets, and I said that as a result of that fact, and also owing to the fact that farmers were, to a large extent, unorganised, every mountebank who called himself a spokesman for agriculture got away with it. That statement was challenged. Here we have the Chairman of the Cork County Council and Chairman of the County Committee of Agriculture as spokesman for the farmers of Cork.

Comment on this

This is not the proper place to make charges against him.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I was challenged on this statement. This gentleman is a farmer who grows the largest crop of thistles between this and where he comes from, and whose bulls are rejected——

Comment on this

That is very low.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

It happens to be true. I cannot understand the point of view that people should be allowed to make untrue statements all over the country, and that no one should be allowed to state the truth, even by way of reply. I did not hear the Deputy getting enthusiastic in his protests when Mr. O'Gorman and others made notoriously false statements about the Department of Agriculture and the Government generally. He is to be allowed to make these statements and get away with them, whereas when I endeavour to put the position accurately, I am told that it is in bad taste. I repeat what I said, and I want the farmers to listen to it. In a county which is one of the best farming counties in the country, you have as chairman of the county council and county committee of agriculture a gentleman whose one point in agricultural policy was to abolish summer-time. That was about three or four years ago. His policy for agriculture now is to abolish the bonus of the instructors—officers who work from dawn to dark, whose salary is from £150 to £350 per annum, and who spent four years in the College of Science. After twenty-five years' service they may get £350 with bonus. These statements were made at the behest, apparently, of the county council and committee of agriculture of a county which is a first-class farming county, and whose schemes are always well done. They were good farmers there, and now there is an attempt to break it up. By whom? By probably the very worst farmer between here and where he comes from, who is notorious for the acreage and weight of thistles he can get, and who breeds perhaps the worst bulls in the district. I want to state that definitely, and I hope every Deputy has heard it, and I make no other claim for it, whether it be in good taste or in bad taste. The people who are abusing us are not so meticulous. I hope that every Deputy has got that, and I make no other claim for it than that that it happens to be an example——

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, I want to say this, as the Minister has made such an elaborate, clear and definite statement, that I do not stand up here to defend some of the things that Mr. D.L. O'Gorman has said.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Would the Deputy shorten it? Would he deny a single statement that I made?

Comment on this

No. My point is this: Mr. O'Gorman has been placed in a certain position by the votes of the people in his county. Evidently the people thought Mr. O'Gorman worthy of having that position. Mr. O'Gorman got up at a public meeting and made these statements, outside of any privilege. I say that this is not the place where the Minister should get up—where Mr. O'Gorman is not present and where he could not answer the Minister—and speak as he has done, protected by the privileges of the House. Mr. O'Gorman cannot take any legal action against the Minister for what he states here. I say in all fairness that if the Minister wants to make statements of that kind he ought to do so outside the House on a political platform. The Minister has information about Mr. O'Gorman having thistles on his farm and having bulls that did not pass. That is just the Minister's opinion. Another man might say that Mr. O'Gorman is a good farmer.

Comment on this

A good judge of bulls.

Comment on this

In any case I want to make it plain that I am not defending what Mr. O'Gorman said about the officials of the Department. I want to say this, that I have the greatest possible respect for the officials of the Department. I say that they are doing very excellent work, and I think in practically all cases they are not being overpaid. I say that without hesitation. I think you will find that the salaries of these officials are probably the lowest, compared with any other staff that appear on the Votes, and they are doing most useful work for the country. There may be exceptional cases, but I would say that these officials are not being overpaid in most cases.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

There is always an exception.

Comment on this

We must have a reservation. They are doing excellent work for the country. But at the same time I do protest against the Minister taking advantage of his position in the House to make these statements.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

I think Mr. O'Gorman has been sufficiently discussed now.

Comment on this

I was about to observe that we were getting a long way from my motion. Deputy Roddy first drew Mr. O'Gorman into the matter. My notice was first drawn to that gentleman about two years ago, when I observed that whenever I made a speech Mr. O'Gorman repeated it about two days later. That apparently made a reputation for him in the County Cork which led to his promotion to various high positions.

Comment on this

Did he repeat them with or without acknowledgment?

Comment on this

Without. But since his attainment to these positions he appears to have taken to thinking for himself, and I am afraid that I cannot return the compliment which he paid me, because whatever my iniquities may be, I do know the difference between six organisers in the Department of Education and the Vote for the Department of Agriculture. I do not go dragging my red herrings like that. To come back to the Minister, I am glad he enjoyed my speech, because I enjoyed his; I would have enjoyed it more if it had been shorter. I do know that there are such things as Appropriations-in-Aid, and I am correct as to the average cost of the pupils. If the Appropriations-in-Aid are calculated, the average cost is £520, but I believe the appropriations account is misleading. I will tell the Minister why I do not believe in his Appropriations-in-Aid. Appropriations-in-Aid of this character are things that vary from year to year. Athenry was closed last financial year; it is now open, but yet the Appropriations-in-Aid to Athenry both this year and last year are set down as £4,000. Whether it is working full capacity or whether it is closed the same appropriation is made.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Of course it is working full capacity as far as the farm is concerned. The farm is not closed.

Comment on this

Then the work the pupils do is valueless?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

If you mean from the point of view of being labourers on the farm, absolutely. On the contrary, we lose. Their work is very seasonable, and they do but an hour a day or so.

Comment on this

That is new light to me, because the Principal of the Albert Agricultural College, Glasnevin, giving evidence before the Food Prices Commission recently, said that the cost of the milk produced there could not be compared with the commercial cost because of the work done by the pupils.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

That is so far as one item is concerned. Supposing the pupils milk the cows they are paid nothing for it, and if you are costing your milk and put nothing down for milking it makes a big difference. But you can take it as a general principle that the work done by the pupils in any properly conducted agricultural school is of no commercial value, and it would be a very bad day indeed if the aim was to commercialise it. You would be doing what the schoolmaster did in Dotheboys Hall, who got a boy to spell "window" and then said: "Go and clean it."

Comment on this

I thought there had to be some differences in the operations of these farms, whether seasonable differences or not. I expected to see some variation, but not very much variation. In the same way, Ballyhaise, which was open and is now closed, has a £4,500 appropriation.

Comment on this

There are no figures. The Appropriations-in-Aid appeared for the first time last year. They have not yet come under review by the Comptroller and Auditor-General. I maintain that they are book-keeping figures, and they lead to confusion.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I do not understand where the confusion is. These are live stock farms, and the live stock operations come in for the purposes of the Appropriation-in-Aid. There are not only pupils there, but the farms are run even if there are no pupils.

Comment on this

I still hold that these are book-keeping figures, and I am not prepared to accept the method unless the Minister can give me actual figures of the Appropriations-in-Aid.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

In Glasnevin there are 50 or 60 dairy cows, 250 pigs, and I should say about 15 or 20 sows. You can work out the number of pigs there would be per annum from these. There are also some sheep, a considerable amount of fowl, and some beef shorthorns. What does the Deputy think the receipts from these would be? We do not keep them in glass cases; we sell them and put them out. I suppose 400 or 500 pigs per annum are sold, or distributed through the country and certain charges made for them. Milk would also be part of it. Obviously the receipts from a huge farm like that would be very big. They could be taken as something less in Clonakilty and Athenry.

Comment on this

The Minister does not know what the receipts are any more than I do. This is a fixed book-keeping figure——

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Will I give the Deputy exact receipts?

Comment on this

I do not want them.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The Deputy has asked for them. Take the receipts from students. There are 57 students. Multiply that number by £20, which is what the fees would about be.

Comment on this

Are these the fees for Athenry and Ballyhaise?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I am giving the particulars of the Albert College.

Comment on this

I am not talking about the Albert College at all.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Let me go on. Here is where you will get the receipts from Clonakilty. There are 26 pupils, and the average fee is about £15. Multiply these two figures and deduct the result from the Appropriations-in-Aid and you will get the exact receipts from live stock and live-stock produce.

Comment on this

In any case the Minister has admitted that the Appropriations-in-Aid will vary from year to year if the pupils' fees are lost.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

It would not be very large. Just a couple of hundred pounds.

Comment on this

It is not a very large sum, but it is quite sufficient to be estimated for.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

So it is. We do estimate for it.

Comment on this

Then why is it, if Athenry was shut and was taking no pupils, the Appropriation-in-Aid was £4,000, and now that it is taking pupils who are bringing in £500 a year, the Appropriation-in-Aid is still the same?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

If it was open it would be, instead of £4,000, £4,000 plus £400 roughly.

Comment on this

We are estimating for the coming year, and the Minister told me that Athenry is now open.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The farm is open, but the school is not.

Comment on this

I think I will leave this point, because I find it as hard to understand the Minister's explanations as his Appropriations-in-Aid. I shall not accept them until I see the Comptroller and Auditor-General's Report for last year. I am satisfied that this is a book-keeping figure. The Minister accused me of having bulked all the objects of these colleges together: research, education, and the sale of live stock. I did not bulk them together; the Minister bulked them together. The Minister shows the cost of these colleges under the one sub-head— F. He has sub-head E, Research, and he elects to put all the cost of these colleges under sub-head F. He has inherited that from the past. I am not blaming him, but it is extremely misleading.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Does the Deputy suggest a change?

Comment on this

I do suggest a change. The Minister himself classified the cost and showed that the cost of education would work out at £30 a head. I suggest that this cost for education should figure under "Education." The Minister tried to deal with research by differentiating between research and abstruse research. I differentiated between research generally and education. Then he justified these colleges being under "Education" because they were the foundation of certain valuable pamphlets. I presume they are educational, but then why did they not figure under that sub-head? Do let us know what we are spending on research, education and the improvement of live-stock. The Minister is one of those who have taunted Deputies who have asked for a Geddes Committee with not criticising the Estimates, but the Estimates themselves are not in a form in which one can criticise them. He has made a great part of his case as far as the improvement of live stock is concerned, but he has not made a case at all for including both these things under the head of Education. A great deal that the Minister has told us is absolutely new.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The heading is not Education.

Comment on this

The heading is "Education and Development," and what "Development" means I do not know.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The heading is "Agricultural Schools and Farms."

Comment on this

The heading of the whole thing is "Agricultural Education and Development." That is F.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

We are discussing F 1. I am only concerned to point out that the heading is not Education.

Comment on this

Yes, but surely in agricultural schools and farms, schools take the first place? Now we are told that education is a very small part of their function. The farm should be subordinate to the school. The whole thing is extraordinarily misleading. I would be very sorry if anything I have said is taken up in the way that the Minister has suggested, and that the changes should be rung on my figures. That is not my intention. But when I am told that my figures are illusory, the person who has eluded and deluded me is the Minister himself, because of the way he has presented his Estimate. He has produced an enormous amount of information this afternoon which was new to every Deputy. They were not told of these items.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

They are there on the face of it.

Comment on this

They are there, but there is a great deal that is not there. A large sum is lumped under the heading "General Expenses of Management." That, I presume, is the purchase of stock, feeding stuffs and seed. They are greater than the Appropriations-in-Aid. But there is a great deal that we do not know, a great deal that this motion elucidated, and, therefore, I hold it has been entirely justified.

Comment on this

I would like to understand where we are in regard to this Vote. We had allotted three hours for the Agricultural Department and eight hours as a whole for the Minister's Votes. I think we have already occupied the eight hours, and I am wondering who is to be robbed of time in respect of future votes, and whether Ministers have had any consultations, as promised, with the President in regard to these matters, because if the whole scheme of the time-table is to be thrown over we shall not know exactly where we are.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

took the Chair.

Comment on this

I did not imagine that this motion would have taken so long. I did not anticipate that the Minister would need to speak half an hour in reply. I am prepared not to move my next two motions, if that would facilitate the Dáil.

Comment on this

In connection with G 1, I want some information, but I do not want to draw a long speech from the Minister.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I will never do it again.

Comment on this

The Minister says that these Estimates are so clear that anyone can understand them. In connection with the improvement of flax-growing, there are apparently nine instructors. Are these men working and giving instruction in the schools and colleges or are they working through the country? Is there any evidence that there is an increased acreage under flax in the southern counties, or is it confined to Cavan, Monaghan, and Donegal? It is £3,400, not a very large item, and I would like to know whether any practical value is being given by this work. I do not want to curtail it, but to know what line is being adopted.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

These instructors are not in the colleges. They work in six or seven counties.

Comment on this

The Northern counties chiefly?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Yes; and in Cork and Waterford also. The area has gone down this year. Of course, prices are extremely low and the prospects of flax look very bad. But the area is far and away less than last year. It is the one crop that has gone down. On the other hand, the Deputy will understand that that is quite a sudden development. In any event it was foreseen that the price of flax would be very bad. I think we would not be justified in discontinuing our schemes because prices fluctuate, and possibly it requires more assistance now than at any other time.

Comment on this

At one time very considerable quantities of flax were grown in some parts of the south of Ireland. I would like to know if the practice of growing flax has died out in Wexford and Cork?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

There is a large area of flax grown in Cork.

Comment on this

But not in Wexford.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

No.

Comment on this

The Minister, in his statement on the Estimates, mentioned that a sum of £900 would be apportioned for an agricultural college at Warrenstown. I would like to know what provision is made in the Estimates for that?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

It is not in the Estimates before the House, but a supplementary Estimate in connection with the matter will be introduced. The amount I had in mind was £970.

Comment on this

I would like to have a little more information from the Minister than he gave us in his opening statement on a matter that comes under sub-head G 2. I attended the annual congress of members of the Dairy Shorthorn Association held at Mallow. Several farmers at that congress put forward the claim that the grant from the Department towards cow-testing associations was not sufficient. Some of the delegates stated that the Minister had expressed the opinion that he was not prepared to increase this grant. I would ask him to reconsider it and see whether something could not be done to increase the grant. In the poorer districts, where the land is not good, the people are not able to maintain good quality cattle, with the result that the milk yield is small. The Department's annual contribution is 4/- to the 3/- put up by the farmer. In districts where the land is poor that contribution might be considered inadequate, and while I would be very slow to ask for more money, still I think this is an exceptional case, and perhaps something might be done in the way I have indicated. The improvement of our dairy herds must be the foundation of our whole agricultural development in the future.

The increase in the number of our cow-testing associations is not as great as it ought to be. I think we should do something to encourage farmers to come forward and join them in greater numbers than they have been doing. What I am anxious about is that the Minister should endeavour to do something to help the people in these backward parts of the country, where they find it very difficult to carry on. One of the difficulties they are up against is to pay the local supervisor. As I pointed out to the Minister on a previous occasion, the districts that the local supervisor can work with the most ease are the prosperous dairy districts. There is a large number of cows in them, and as the area to be covered is not too large, the supervisor is in a position to earn a reasonable salary.

The position is different altogether in the poorer districts. There the area to be covered is very large, and the result is that the local supervisor finds it very hard to get any return for his labours. One of the troubles in connection with this matter is to get good reliable men to carry out the work. If the men who are appointed local supervisors are not honest and reliable, the whole foundation of the work is sapped, and the results given are not trustworthy. The results in connection with cow-testing associations, if they are to be of any use at all, must be absolutely reliable. These supervisors must be honest men, and it is their duty to attend and see the milk weighed. I have heard it stated that some of them allow the owners of the cows to weigh the milk themselves and put down their own weights. I do not say many of them do that. In other cases, it is quite possible that they do not carry out adequately the testing of the milk in regard to better fats. I understand there has been a check in that respect recently, and that now the inspectors of the Department insist that the milk which is taken for test is retained until examined by themselves.

I suggest to the Minister that something ought to be done in the direction of making the job of local supervisor one worth having. It is difficult to do that in the poorer districts for the reasons I have stated. The result is that in these poorer districts men of an inferior type are given the positions. Good men cannot be got to undertake the work because the salary is too small, and they get tired of the work.

Comment on this