ESTIMATES FOR PUBLIC SERVICE. - VOTE 52—OFFICE OF THE MINISTER FOR LANDS AND AGRICULTURE—(DEBATE RESUMED).
Contributions 159–318 of 318. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
The position in regard to this is that here is something which pays the farmer, something that is of vital interest to him, and yet we have to pay him to do it. We give him 4/- per cow for every 3/- that he puts up. That, I suggest, is a huge subsidy in the circumstances. It is an extraordinary thing that in this country, in order to induce farmers to do something that is to their own interest and from which they will make hard cash, we have to give them a subsidy at all. Look at the size of the subsidy we are giving: 4/- for every 3/- that the farmer puts up. There is a point at which we should stop, and I honestly say that we have reached that point in regard to subsidising cow-testing associations.
I want to see these associations developed. Everyone wants to see them developed, but in my opinion the State should not go any further in the way of giving them subsidies. They are getting a very big subsidy as it is. The Deputy referred to the poorer districts. We need not go to the poorer districts at all. Take districts like Cork, Kilkenny, Limerick and Waterford, all of which are well off, where you have really good land, and what do we find? That the cow-testing associations in these districts have not developed to the extent they should have. With regard to the supervisors, they are a fine lot of young men working for a very small salary. The position is not a whole-time one, and the salary is a small one. They are a fine type of young farmers' sons. I have met many of them, and I have the fullest confidence in the accuracy with which they make their records. The Deputy did not suggest that the records were not accurate. I do not think he need feel that there is any danger of the records being cooked.
I know a lot of these supervisors and I have found them to be very enthusiastic, hard-working young fellows. I would like very much indeed to have more money to pay them. We are putting up as much money as we should be asked to put up, 4/- for every 3/- that the farmer puts up, and the people to be blamed if these supervisors are not paid larger salaries are, in the circumstances, the farmers. We are putting up a big subsidy, and the blame should lie on the farmer and not on the Department if the supervisors are not getting a sufficient salary. It is not a question of asking the farmers to increase the number of their cows, but rather to get more of them to join these associations.
Comment on this
I agree with a good deal of what the Minister has said, but he did not deal with one or two points that I had mentioned. As I pointed out earlier, it is much easier to organise these associations in good dairy districts than in parts of the country where the land is poor. Cow-testing associations are pretty numerous in the districts where the people go in for dairying on an intensive scale. A supervisor in a district like that would be able to make a fairly good salary. I agree generally with the Minister that most of the supervisors are fine young men, but there are exceptional cases. I know cases myself where the accuracy of records made by them would be open to doubt. I have seen records in connection with one association which I believe were not accurate. As a matter of fact, I believe that in that particular case the inspectors of the Department found that the records were not accurate. I am glad to say, however, that inaccurate records are very rare. Some of these good young men are really not being paid enough in certain districts to keep the thing going properly. Their job is only a part-time one, and what they make is really very small. Perhaps something could be done in the way of increasing the grant per cow that might result in an increase of salary for the supervisors in districts where at present it is impossible for them to make anything like a reasonable salary.
Comment on this
Is it too much to expect a farmer with ten cows to put up 30/- a year or a farmer who has only three cows to pay 9/- a year?
Comment on this
My point is that in the poorer districts where the supervisors have to work hardest they find it extremly difficult to earn a livelihood at the job. I suggest that the Minister should do something in the way of devising a scheme, whether by more grants or otherwise, that would give these supervisors a bigger salary than they are receiving at present.
Comment on this
With regard to sub-head G 3, there is an item there for the purchase of stock bulls. I am referring to a matter which, I fancy, the Minister anticipates, and that is that prior to the Royal Dublin Society's sale of bulls the Minister sent over to Scotland and purchased there a number of Aberdeen Angus bulls. I think on the broad issue there was considerable justification for doing so, as the Minister thereby got fresh blood into the country, and he got these bulls somewhat cheaper than he would have got them here. The fact remains, however, that the money of the Irish taxpayer, who is in some cases a breeder of bulls, was spent for the benefit of the Scottish breeder of bulls. I do not say the Minister is not justified in going outside the Saorstát if by doing so he can buy bulls at a price at which he could not get them here. I suggest that he should first give the Irish breeders a chance, and see whether at Ballsbridge he can get the type of bull he requires and at the price he requires. There will always be exceptional cases in which the Minister will be justified in bringing in fresh blood. I know the action of the Minister has caused much criticism and feeling amongst breeders of Aberdeen Angus bulls in the Saorstát. I therefore hope that the Minister will give some indication as to his future intentions. I think it would be fair that he should have a look at Ballsbridge before going oversea.
Comment on this
I think breeders should keep quiet about this. There are 200 premiums going a-begging at the moment, and even the ordinary premium-holder cannot get them. Any unfortunate countryman who came up to Ballsbridge this spring could not buy a moderately good yearling premium bull for less than £100. The fact is that breeders are getting really good prices at the moment, so good that while the premium for an Aberdeen Angus is £20, the ordinary farmers cannot touch them, and the result is that in spite of all the bulls we bought in Scotland, there are 200 premiums going a-begging. There is a very limited number of bulls left of the premium standard, and the prices are so high that they are out of range entirely of the small farmer. There is no question whatever of attempting to buy our extra premium bulls in Ireland. We bought, say, 110 Aberdeen Angus bulls in Scotland. If we went to the R.D.S. to buy these 110 bulls the price would have gone up from £70 to £170 for yearlings, and we would have a revolution. What would the unfortunate people who want Aberdeen Angus bulls say to it? If we went to the R.D.S. to buy our extra premium bulls at least £50 apiece extra would have been put on to the price, and that is supposing that we were able to get them, but we could not get them. There is a tremendously fine price at the moment for Aberdeen Angus bulls. They are paying really well, better than for a long time—so well that the unfortunate farmer who has a premium cannot afford to purchase them. It was pitiful to see farmers with a premium going around the Show trying to make a purchase of one of these bulls.
Comment on this
The Minister's figures are somewhat exaggerated. I do not think there were more than 15 Aberdeen-Angus bulls that fetched more than £100 at the March Show.
Comment on this
But I am talking of the March Show. The Department bought them in prior to the March Show.
Comment on this
I was referring to the May Show for the reason that that was the last opportunity we had of buying them, and that was what they had reached at that time. In May we were not able to touch them—I mean the ordinary premium-holder could not touch them. I mention May to show how the prices went up as a result of the demand.
Comment on this
I am talking of the time when the Minister bought the bulls. At that time, at the March Sales in Ballsbridge, bulls fetched on the average £60. I had five of them, and they averaged £75. Included in the five were two prize-winners, so I presume these bulls were not worse than the average, but certainly anyone would have got a very good bull for £100. As a matter of fact, one of my best bulls went for only £50—a March calf that went late in the sales. The Minister should not wait until May to buy bulls. He should try the March sales, and see whether the prices are what the Department can afford to give, and if he cannot get the bulls at the price he wants, then let him go to Scotland, but on this occasion he went to Scotland first.
Comment on this
If the Minister would put that up to the R.D.S. I have no doubt they would have the March sale ante-dated. I should say if he is prepared to spend, say, £1,000 on these sales he could get the sales fixed for the middle of February.
Comment on this
What is the point to be raised before Deputy Johnson's amendment?
Comment on this
May I ask the President if there has been any re-arranging of the time-table? Are we to have the normal discussion on the Land Commission Vote in view of the long discussion on this Vote?
Comment on this
There has not been any re-consideration, and the time-table has been ruthlessly torn to atoms by quite a number of contributors to the discussion this evening, including the Minister, Deputy Cooper, and Deputy Heffernan.
Comment on this
I am aware that the Deputy might have been more ruthless than he has been. We made a certain bargain. I do not know whether it is being kept, but I have kept my part, and Deputy Johnson has kept his.
Comment on this
I am anxious to keep my bargain as far as I can, but I regard this Vote as an exception to the bargain.
Comment on this
I think it would be a pity to pass over this without adequate discussion. As a matter of fact, we are passing over many things on which I think a good deal of time could be spent. Time spent on this can be made up on the Land Commission Vote, as I think the whole question of the Land Commission was fairly threshed out three months ago.
Comment on this
Deputy Heffernan's point on K 2 can be taken up after the adjournment for tea.
Comment on this
Deputy Heffernan asked for an explanation of sub-head K 2. The Estimate is increased by £6,000 this year. I think the idea is that the grant should be £10,000 this year and £8,500 for the following four years. The money appears in my Vote. In that way the question as to how much will be transferred to the I.A.O.S. will rest with the Department of Agriculture, and in that way they will have a check on all the doings of the I.A.O.S., and a certain amount of control will be exercised over them. On the other hand, I fully recognise that the I.A.O.S. is, and should remain, an independent body. I do not think the arrangement we have come to should interfere with its independence in the least. The State is under no obligation to give a grant, but it considers it highly desirable to do so. It is giving it in this way on the Estimates of the Department of Agriculture, with the result that if at any time during the four or five years the work which the grant is given for is not carried out, there will be a way of dealing with the situation. It provides for additional organisers and, above all, for additional accountants who will keep in close touch with the financial side of the work of the creameries, audit accounts, and generally see that the financial side which, to some extent up to the present has been neglected, is properly supervised.
Comment on this
I would like the Minister to make it clear what he means by keeping control. Do I understand him to mean that of the £10,000 we are now voting it will be for the Department to pay out so much of that sum as it thinks well according to the conduct of the Society, or is it in regard to subsequent years it is proposing to keep the check?
Comment on this
What I said in that respect applies not only to the subsequent years but to this year. I think that was always the position. I think while the money was voted it was open to the Department to withhold portion of the Grant if they considered it right to do so, for good and sufficient reasons. I think that is essential. We are, of course, preserving the point of view that the I.A.O.S. is a body for which we have no responsibility, and over whose operations we have no control. The Deputy will understand if the State is giving a Grant on the Estimates of a certain Department— though indirectly—it is possible to see that the work which is being paid for is being done.
Comment on this
That is true, but I think the principle has usually been that the Grant was given if the Department were satisfied that the work to be accomplished by the body receiving the Grant was likely to be carried out to its satisfaction.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is right. While we transfer the amount of money on these Estimates during the year in which it is voted, it would be open to the Department to reconsider the whole case when it would become necessary to put up a new demand to the Department of Finance. I think that is the correct view.
Comment on this
I want to say, on this particular sub-head, that in general while I do not approve, to any great extent, of State contributions to voluntary societies, I think the time has practically come in regard to the I.A.O.S. in which it is necessary to give it a helping hand if it is to continue doing the useful work which it has been doing in the past. I think when the State starts to subsidise a society of this kind it should keep as much of a check as is possible over it in the circumstances. While I have a great deal of praise for the work which has been done in the past by the I.A.O.S., I think there were defects in connection with their methods. In view of this fact I think the Dáil, in some way or another, while making this contribution, ought to have some voice, directly or indirectly, in the actual methods of organisation carried out by this organisation. If I were to criticise the methods of the society I would say that the officials of it were inclined to be theoretical and not sufficiently practical. I would say what they require in the future is to get men into their organisation and to organise for them, men who have a somewhat more practical turn of mind than some of those who have been working for them in the past; not by any means all, because I know some of their organisers and officials are really practical men. I think it should come from this Dáil, now that a very generous contribution is going to the society, that we expect results.
With regard to sub-head M 1 (c)— Allowances to Farmers and others in connection with keeping agricultural costings accounts—I would like to know from the Minister what stage these costings accounts have reached, how long has the Department been carrying on this work in connection with these costings accounts. I know that they carried on that work in the past up to a certain stage. I would like to have a statement of their work in that regard elaborated somewhat by the Minister, and I would like to know from him when we may expect pamphlets to be published by the Department showing the result of this system of costings.
Comment on this
Costings have now been going on for about two years. There is an officer of the Department whose duty it is to collate and digest these costings, and I think it will be possible to issue some publication in connection with them within a short time. I could not name the exact date. It is going on for two years, and there is a special officer of the Department engaged in collating, analysing, and preparing for publication the results of these costings.
Comment on this
Under sub-head M 2 I want to raise a point, if I am in order, though I believe I am not in order. That is with regard to market reports. I refer to market reports coming from England. I think the officers concerned with the market reports in England are really under the Department of External Affairs.
Comment on this
They are under the Department of External Affairs.
Comment on this
In connection with M 4, would the Minister discuss very briefly the conditions under which grants are available for the erection of village halls? I think it is a matter that should be known publicly. It is not known generally that such grants can be made.
Comment on this
In the view of the terms of the sub-head, grants may be made, but in fact they are not being made. I mentioned that a sum of £23,000 is voted this year. There was a Supplementary Estimate, making £30,000 in all. There is being used for stallions, bulls and agricultural implements, £10,000. Then there is an additional £5,000 for implements and an additional £2,000 for stallions, bulls, and sprayers. While there is the power, it is not the intention of the Department to make any advances for village halls. There are other and more urgent needs. At the same time, I do not think the sub-head should be altered, because with better times and more money we might consider making these grants.
Comment on this
Should not the provision for silos come under the Vote for the Office of Public Works?
Comment on this
The Office for Public Works can make advances for silos.
Comment on this
We will not. While it is possible I do not think we will make any advances this year. This is merely to indicate that the money the Dáil is voting can be used for that purpose if in the course of the year we thought it right to make any such advances, but that would depend to a great extent on the terms of the application made and the circumstances surrounding it.
Comment on this
Why should farm buildings be put under this Vote? If money can be advanced I think it should be advanced from the Office of Public Works in the ordinary way. Why should it be put under this heading?
Comment on this
I doubt it. He would want to be very enterprising. The answer is that there are different conditions to start with. We give these loans in the congested districts mostly. A lot of our Department's schemes are schemes for poor areas. We make it a special point to supplement other schemes for poor areas.
Comment on this
In connection with sub-head O (1), in view of the statements appearing in the Press about the prices of Irish eggs in the English markets I would like the Minister to give us some idea as to what the actual position is.
Comment on this
I can answer that quite shortly. I have a statement here showing the prices in London, Liverpool, Manchester, Glasgow and Cardiff. I have in the columns the prices for Irish, Danish, English, Dutch, French, and Swedish. I find that for the twenty weeks beginning with the 2nd January the price of Irish eggs was practically the top quotation of the market. There were only three weeks in which the quotation for Irish eggs was not the top quotation. For seventeen weeks Irish eggs held the top price and for the three weeks commencing 9th January, 27th February, and 26th March, Irish eggs were second best and Danish eggs were first. With these exceptions Irish eggs were consistently at the very top. The very same thing applies to Manchester; with the exception of four out of twenty weeks Irish eggs were at the top.
Comment on this
I think the Minister ought to be congratulated upon that very satisfactory position.
Comment on this
The best test of all probably was when the London Egg Exchange Company, Limited, acting in conformity with the British Board of Trade during the strike, when fixing the price of eggs, put Irish eggs immediately after English new-laid eggs and before all other imported eggs. They did that as a result of their experience.
Comment on this
As regards sub-head O (2), I would like to draw the attention of the Minister for Lands and Agriculture to the delay in appointing a bacteriologist under the Dairy Produce Act, 1924. Almost one and a half years have passed and no bacteriologist has been appointed to carry out the very important administrative functions indicated under this Act. I think the fact that there has been no appointment results in a big loss to the Government. I believe if a bacteriologist were appointed at the commencement there would be a saving of some £5,000 in fees. As it is, there is a very substantial loss.
I am aware an advertisement has been issued for a bacteriologist, but the conditions indicated in the advertisement are such that you will scarcely get any man worthy of the name to accept the post. The salary offered is from £300 to £400, and for that salary a man must have first-class honours, be a Bachelor of Science, and, if he is to know bacteriology, he must have a degree in medicine, and have practically a veterinary diploma. No bachelor of science can know bacteriology without having a knowledge of veterinary practice. We all know that milk and butter are the media of conveying the most virulent diseases. It is bad enough, and unattractive enough, to have this salary ranging from £300 to £400, but there are other conditions. A man to attain the minimum salary must be thirty-five years of age. A man who possesses all the qualifications set out in this advertisement, and who will accept £300 at thirty-five years of age, will not, I think, be a very desirable acquisition.
The commencing age is twenty-five years, and if a young man or woman accepts the post at that age, he or she will be penalised. In the case of a woman, the salary is reduced from £200 to £100 for a person twenty-five years of age. I do not know why a woman should be penalised in connection with this office. Her profession costs her as much as it will cost a man. She is expected to do the work as well as a man, and for that reason she should be paid the same salary. Why a bachelor cannot do the work as well as a married man, I do not know. If he is a bachelor and is twenty-five years of age, he commences at a minimum salary of £100.
This is an important matter, because it affects the whole administration of the Act. These conditions are imposed in such a way that you will get no first-class, second-class, or third-class man to accept the post. I do not attribute the fault to the Minister for Finance; I do attribute it to interference by the Department of Finance. An official fixes these salaries in such a way as to become a public danger, especially where professional work is concerned. I would ask the Committee to consider this matter carefully. One and a half years have passed and we have no bacteriologist. If one is to judge by the advertisement, one does not wonder an appointment has not been made.
Comment on this
It is one and a half years since the Act was passed, but Deputy Doctor Hennessy will understand that the five parts of the Act could not be brought into operation simultaneously. Three parts are in operation, and the five parts must be brought into operation in sequence. In any event it would be impossible to bring the fourth part into operation less than a year after the first part. It would, of course, be useful if we had our bacteriologist, but there are some difficulties in appointing one and fixing up the various details preliminary to filling the position. Undoubtedly a bacteriologist appointed in connection with the Dairy Produce Act will be a very important officer and his work will be extremely useful, not only to the State but to the creameries. A really good man can give invaluable service to the creameries by indicating the root causes affecting butter.
In all these matters we are in a dilemma. We are expected to do things really well, to tackle a big task and place Irish butter at the top of the English market in competition with Denmark and Canada. We are in competition with countries where they do things very well, where they pay for their scientists and spare no expense on their controlled schemes. Undoubtedly they are right in adopting that attitude. Money saved in a matter like this is not money gained. It might be the very worst form of economy, the biggest extravagance in the long run. We are expected to do everything as well as our competitors. We are in a dilemma. On the one side you have people who expect a lot, and people of that type are usually, the most inefficient; the people who expect most will do least themselves, and they are the quickest to blame others. Here we have these people begrudging anything like a decent recompense to a man who does a decent day's work.
Comment on this
I am between the devil and the deep sea and, while I concede it lies with Deputy Johnson to make that point, I make the further point: I am in the dilemma, and the Minister for Finance is in the dilemma, that while we are expected to do things as well as our competitors, the people who expect and are prepared to do less for themselves will see to it, above all else, that the agents we employ for that purpose are paid as little as possible. That is the dilemma we are trying to solve, in our own way, for a very long time. We are trying to solve it on the lines of paying for the work done and I leave it between the Deputy and the Minister for Finance as to whether we are doing it on this occasion.
Comment on this
I think the Minister ought to be fair in this matter. He will remember, he was applauded very generously by the representatives of the agricultural community in regard to the whole of his speech on Friday, and a very important clause of that speech which was applauded very generously by the Farmers' representatives, was this: "It was important to provide, as far as possible, for first-class professorships; and first-class professors, like everybody else, can only be had for first-class salaries."
I say the Minister must give credit where credit is due, and, notwithstanding anything said from the Farmers' benches, in the past, they have now come to the conclusion by their plaudits of that passage in the Minister's speech, that when good work is required, good salaries will have to be paid, and they will no longer in future begrudge high-class salaries for high-class work. I think that should be recognised, and I hope I have the assent of the farmers to that position.
Comment on this
I wonder did the Deputy oppose propositions regarding reductions in those Votes on account of salaries? I think the statement made by Deputy Hennessy rather contradicts the proposition that high-class work can only be called for if fair salaries are paid. I have it in my mind that the work of the bacteriologist is of a very high-class character, and requires a very considerable amount of ability, and unless it is done very carefully and unless you have an able man or woman to fill this post, much of the value of the position will be lost. It surprises me to hear that the Ministry is expecting to get that high-class man, or high-class woman, for the salary mentioned in the statement made by Deputy Doctor Hennessy. I feel with him that it is unfair to expect the quality and the ability, called for for this purpose, for the salary that is offered.
Comment on this
I must congratulate the Minister for Agriculture in having a field-day to-day. He is getting a little back on his economy opponents. Doubtless, the Minister can go to the country and say, "No economy can be effected. The Farmers' Party agree that efficiency must be paid for in good salaries. They have been talking nonsense when they said anything to the contrary all this time." The Farmers' Party never said that good men did not deserve good salaries, but we do not say that there are not some middling men getting good salaries here, and if we compare some of the salaries given here with the salaries paid in other countries——
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy Hennessy and Deputy Johnson that the salary offered to the bacteriologists is not sufficient. I do not believe that that is a matter between the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Agriculture or that the Minister would not get a sufficient sum to pay a good man. Neither do I agree that he is in a dilemma in regard to this salary. This is merely electioneering propaganda.
Comment on this
On Sub-head O (3), I put down this motion, "To reduce Sub-head O (3), by £10, in order to extract from the Minister some information regarding his intention in respect to the black scab Order as it affects the North Louth Area. I am sure the Minister will be able to get first-hand information on this matter from his colleague, the Minister for Defence. A year ago the question was raised as to the possibility of relieving the potato, growers of this area from restrictions, or alternatively, finding some means of allowing the potato growers there to dispose of their crops. I realise that there is a difficulty facing the department in view of the very earnest desire to prevent all risks of black scab spreading through the country. The case as presented to me is like this:
The potato growers there were persuaded to purchase immune varieties, and they had up to a month ago in the case of one district, Bellurgan, five hundred tons of Kerr's pink potatoes for which they could find no sale. That is to say, while they are free to export to England, as far as the Irish Department is concerned, that particular brand of potato was not in demand and there was practically no sale. The case that is put up is that there was, at that time, about six thousand tons of potatoes in the area. Some varieties were being sold for export at fifteen shillings to a pound a ton. But Bellurgan, where they had these Kerr's pink variety, was practically deprived of a market because that variety was not in demand in Great Britain. I was asked to put to the Minister that the risk of spreading disease by virtue of the distribution of any variety of potato from that area is nil at this time of the year, that that will be particularly so, if the potatoes are sent for consumption in a city; that there could be freedom with safety for sale in quantities, under some kind of supervision, to a city or even large town. It has been put to me also that the aim of the Minister is less likely to be achieved if men who are the owners of four, five or six acres find it necessary to dispose of a sack or two for the purpose of exchange, or practically barter them for tea, coffee and sugar in the market. The risk of the disease spreading is greater if men are tempted to dispose of their potatoes in that piecemeal fashion. They get them through and because of that surreptitious method, there is greater danger of the disease spreading. It is suggested that the Department might well and reasonably make some arrangement, now that the time for sowing has passed, to allow the distribution of immune varieties from this district to the cities and towns.
The objection is raised that it is not in the potato alone that the risk lies, but also in the earth attached to it. Against that contention, it is pointed out that from the same field, turnips and cabbage may be transferred, and the risk is just as great if such a movement takes place in that way, as it is in the case of potatoes. It is very strongly urged by the people in that area that their position is a very difficult one, inasmuch as they have grown these potatoes, and have conformed to the advice of the Department with regard to the purchase of immune seed. They have no outlet for their crop. I do not want to make any proposal which would increase the risk of spreading the disease of black scab to other parts of the country, but on behalf of the people in that area, I plead that the Minister should consider in every possible way how he can meet the needs of that community as regards the disposition of their potatoes. I suggest that that could be done, taking into account that the sowing season is over, and that the risk of disease spreading is practically nil at this time of the year.
Comment on this
As Deputy Johnson stated, the position is, that these people can export the potatoes, but they cannot send them from the scheduled area to any other part of the Free State. That is what they want to do. It is a hard case, and I assure the Deputy that we have examined it carefully from the point of view he has expressed. We have examined it from the point of view whether it would be safe to make some arrangement whereby they could sell the potatoes, say, to the Army, or some institution where you would have control of the potatoes and of the refuse afterwards. We decided that it would not be safe to do so. The Deputy will remember that we are in the fortunate position of having black scab only in Louth and Donegal. We are unlike Northern Ireland in this respect, and it would certainly be to our vital interest to see that that state of affairs continues. In Northern Ireland the disease is very widespread. It is in Down, Armagh, Antrim and Derry. We are in the happy position that we have only two areas with black scab. It is undoubtedly to our vital interest to take every precaution, and to see that black scab is controlled. Having considered the question of letting these potatoes out for special purposes, such as for use by the Army or some institution, we came to the conclusion, after a lot of examination, that we could not do it. It would be impossible even there to try and control the refuse.
As Deputy Johnson pointed out, these spores of black scab are taken out not only in the potato—even in immune varieties—but also in the soil adhering to the potatoes. That might get mixed up very easily with manure. It has been known to spread from manure a year afterwards. That is the real trouble and the real risk. As the Deputy stated, the planting season is now over, and it was thought that the potatoes could be let out in the certainty that they would not be used for seed, but for table purposes. The difficulty I have mentioned stands in the way. The refuse could very easily get mixed up through manure, and could very easily infect land into which it was brought. The Deputy mentioned the case of mangolds and turnips, and I have no answer. That was allowed. There is some difficulty in even justifying it. It was allowed to go on, and has not led to any evil results. It would certainly be wrong to extend it. When you consider it, there is less danger from mangolds and turnips. The spores are likely to be taken out with the soil as well as with the potatoes, even in immune varieties.
I do not think we would be justified in making the same regulation for potatoes as is the practice in respect to mangolds and turnips. If black scab spread it would be very hard to defend our position as against the hardship that there is in this small area.
We have done well by Cooley. We induced them to grow immune varieties there. That was the best we could have done for them. We were not able to save them from the fall in prices that has taken place all over Britain and Ireland this year. The potatoes are, in fact, all cleared except in Bellurgan area. On the other hand, I want Deputy Johnson to remember that they could have cleared their stocks at a better price. The price has been falling. In most instances they were offered a much better price at an earlier stage than the price they actually obtained afterwards. It is the old story again of people getting into one way of farming. There are, I know, very special reasons in that district why they should continue that method of farming. It is peculiarly suited to potatoes. They got into that method of farming and they refuse to change it. They adopt the attitude that they must get what they regard as a good price for their potatoes regardless of the state of the market.
In Cooley district they were undoubtedly unwise. They refused a far better price than they took later. In Bellurgan they did that also, and it is the only area where the potatoes are not cleared. Possibly, they will be able to clear them yet. Bellurgan is only a small portion of the entire area. In Cooley district we took the risk of arranging the growing of sugar beet. The arrangements that I have mentioned have been made in respect of manures. We induced the sugar company to give that district special attention. They are getting the full contract price. Notwithstanding that it is outside the area, the sugar company were able to arrange with the railway company for very special terms. These terms are quite reasonable. I think there will be 300 acres of sugar beet grown there, and the growers will be assured of a good price and of cheap transit facilities. In addition, there has been started a credit society. Already a £600 advance has been made to that credit society. If ever there was an area where the financing should be done by a credit society, it is that area. Their operations are small. They are very small farmers. They do not require the large amount of money that would be required for live stock. They require only comparatively small amounts, and a credit society for them is the ideal thing.
We started such a society, and we put in £600. Having regard to all the circumstances—that we have arranged for the growing of sugar beet, that we have arranged a credit society, giving an advance which will probably be followed by more advances one of these days—I think we have done all that could reasonably be expected of us.
Comment on this
Would the Minister explain why there are five temporary Inspectors instead of two last year? I understand that the black scab disease is getting less. We should therefore require fewer inspectors.
Comment on this
These inspectors are not for black scab. They are for potato development generally. We are endeavouring to develop a seed trade in five or six areas, and we have met with a considerable amount of success. We used to import 3,000 tons of seed potatoes into this country. Last year, we produced all our seed except 300 tons. We think this is one of the catch crops we can develop, and we are concentrating on it.
Comment on this
Is it worth while having a special sub-head in order to save the Deputy putting a question?
Comment on this
I maintain that it is worth while. Deputy Cooper has already referred to this matter. Here we have inspectors dealing with production of potatoes for seed, and we have them under the heading of Destructive Insects and Pests Act.
Comment on this
We find it extremely hard to make arrangements to control potatoes from the north. In case there was an outbreak anywhere, these Inspectors would be transferred immediately to that work. We can get simplification up to a point but there is a point beyond which you cannot simplify a complex question.
Comment on this
The potatoes are all good coming from the North. I listened to a good portion of your speech here on Friday afternoon and I read the rest of it yesterday afternoon. I do not often pay compliments but, on this occassion, I congratulate you on the comprehensive and optimistic statement you have given to the Dáil.
Comment on this
I should like to ask you, A Chinn Comhairle, whether Deputy White is addressing his compliments to the Chair, because there is a Standing Order that Deputies must address the Chair.
Comment on this
I was just wondering to whom they were being addressed.
Comment on this
I am addressing them to the Minister for Lands and Agriculture, through the Chair. With regard to these new faculties about to be established——
Comment on this
The Deputy, I am afraid, is late in dealing with the general question. We are now discussing an amendment dealing with Sub-head O (3). If Deputy White has anything to say on that, I shall be glad to hear him.
Comment on this
I must ask your pardon. I had a great rush coming from Innishowen to-day to be in time for the Land Commission Vote. I was under the impression that you, sir, would take a broad view of the points to be raised, seeing that I have only just arrived. However, I bow to your decision with the greatest possible pleasure because you are both a scholar and a gentleman.
Comment on this
On Sub-head O (4), I have on several occasions referred to this question of the Weeds and Seeds Act. I should like if the Minister would state what in his opinion is the measure of usefulness of this Act or what results are derived from the expenditure of this £850 in the 26 counties. My experience of the past three or four years' working of this Act is that it is practically useless in the counties where it has been adopted.
Comment on this
Yes; practically from its inception. As County Meath has been mentioned, I may say that there the Act has been of no particular avail. Land-owners who destroyed the weeds on their lands every year have not, since the adoption of this Act by the Meath County Council, seen an inspector. They ask why. The question can be very simply answered. There is too large an area under the charge of an inspector for him to give attention to the whole lot. It is almost impossible for an inspector attending, say, to Dunshaughlin Rural District, to cover the whole of that district during the period that the weeds are supposed to be destroyed under this Act. There is another point that could be raised in regard to this matter. The Minister does not state in the Estimate the number of temporary inspectors employed at this work. He does not state what salary is paid them. So far as I can gather, the amount paid these inspectors is so small that it does not leave them in a position to be immune from corruption or bribery. To my mind, the same must be utilised and must be working very strongly in many counties in Ireland.
Comment on this
I might be able to give proof of it. The Minister informed me last year, when I tabled a question about a particular estate of some 1,100 acres convinient to the town of Trim, that an inspector had paid a second visit there and had discovered that all the weeds had been destroyed on that estate. I told the Minister that I could give him quite a contrary statement to that which he had received from his inspector, and I state the same now. The weeds were not destroyed, no matter whether the inspector called there or not.
Comment on this
The Minister said an inspector called to see whether the weeds were destroyed or not. The inspector reported to the Minister that the weeds were destroyed. I deduce from that that if that inspector went there and reported to the Minister that the weeds were destroyed, when they were not, that that inspector received some bribe from the owner of the land, because the report was ridiculous and false. There was not as much as 200 acres destroyed out of the whole 1,100. That existed last year, and probably will exist this year.
Comment on this
The Minister has his own way of explaining things; in some cases he explains things to such an extent that no one knows what he is talking about at all. The position is that the money voted under this sub-head had better be withdrawn altogether because no useful purpose is served by it, and I suggest the Minister for Lands and Agriculture should give his consideration to improving the administration of this particular Act by passing it over to the County Committee of Agriculture in the different counties where the Act is adopted and letting the instructors of that Committee do the work, or on the other hand have it passed over to the Gárda Síochána and let them administer the Act, because under the present system there is no administration at all. The Act is a farce. It is of no avail and this not alone applies to the County Meath but to other counties I have been through. Last year when I was travelling with a Deputy on the Farmers' benches I pointed out to him on both sides of the railway approximately two or three hundred acres of thistles. That proves that this Act is hopeless and of no avail, and I ask the Minister to give his consideration to this matter.
I asked him before to reconsider the advisability of introducing legislation to amend this Act and now I ask him again to do the same thing in connection with this matter, and see how it may be better administered. I should like him to give it some consideration with a view to having the Act enforced in the manner in which it should be enforced if it were passed in another Parliament outside this. Then the very numerous people, the farmers down the country, who evade this Act will be brought to realise their responsibility in the matter. It is not fair to allow preferential treatment to one as against another. Take two farmers:—one goes out and destroys weeds, no matter what the cost may be. The other, across the mearing, lets all his weeds grow. The blossom flies away; the seed gets in on the tillage of the first farmer who has thereby as much weeds as the other man who lets his grow.
Comment on this
Deputy Hall has, as far as I gathered from him, given a particular instance of an inspection made, and indicated a particular official, without naming him. The official can easily be identified. Deputy Hall said, that in his judgement, a temporary inspector took a bribe. I do not know whether Deputy Hall realises what he did say. I do not know how these inspectors work, but I am very much concerned with the general level of debate here, and with respect for ourselves. The Deputy, as far as I understand the law in the matter, can say almost anything he pleases in the House with impunity. It is a serious thing, however, to say that a particular person took a bribe and I should like Deputy Hall to withdraw that altogether because it is a statement which he makes under the privilege of the Dáil, and a statement, which, in my judgment, ought not to have been made.
Comment on this
I hope the House does not take me as attempting to make a statement under privilege. The statement would not be made by me only that the Minister intervened, and I withdraw that portion which refers to the official who took the bribe. The Minister put that question deliberately to me, and I made that statement. The Minister informed me last year that an inspector reported to him that the weeds on that particular farm had been destroyed, and I pointed out to the Minister that the statement was false, and that if he received that statement, it was false. However, I withdraw the charge of bribery.
Comment on this
I have come to the conclusion that this Act was administered in a slipshod way. I am forced to that conclusion, partly by a statement of the Minister himself, who informed the House some time ago that on a particular farm in the County Cork, owned by County Councillor O'Gorman, there were more thistles grown practically than in the rest of the County of Cork. If we had an active and efficient weeds officer, that would not have occurred, but the Minister would not have been able to get in a word then at County Councillor O'Gorman. I agree with a great deal of what Deputy Hall said. The Act is not administered properly, and it ought to be administered properly. Take my own case. I employ men each year to cut thistles and crop weeds. My next-door neighbour never cuts a thistle, with the result that he destroys my land each year. I think that ought not to occur. People, especially with large holdings, ought to be compelled to cut weeds.
Comment on this
I am discussing the matter with the Minister for Justice to see whether the police would not be the proper people to administer the Act.
Comment on this
I support the suggestion of Deputy Hall as to the administration of the Weeds and Seeds Act. That could really be performed by the county instructor, and it would not be of very much extra cost to the county. As far as I understand, I do not think many counties in the Saorstát have put this Act into operation at all, and where it is in operation I believe the proper persons to administer the Act in the county are the county instructors.
Comment on this
I voted against it several times in the county council for the reason that we do not want it.
Comment on this
The Deputy is giving advice as to how to administer an Act that he has not adopted in his own county.
Comment on this
I can confirm what the other Deputies have said in regard to the Act being badly administered. In many parts of the country large areas have not been touched. I was glad to hear the Minister say that he was consulting the Minister for Justice in regard to this matter, as something will have to be done. I think there is something in Deputy Doyle's suggestion, and, perhaps, the matter could be met by giving the county instructors supervision over the other officials, as these officials may inspect some districts and ignore others. The good man suffers for the bad man's neglect.
Comment on this
What would be the position of the officer under the Cork County Committee of Agriculture if he had to inspect the farm of his Chairman?
Comment on this
With regard to F (4), I want to draw the Minister's attention to the grant of £1,100 to universities for teaching in agricultural subjects. I hardly see the necessity for this grant, in view of the fact that we are to have faculties in agriculture in Cork and Dublin.
Comment on this
If the faculty is set up, that money will not be expended, but if it is not set up, the money will be used.
Comment on this
In regard to subheads P and Q, which refer to the faculty of general agriculture in University College, Dublin, and the faculty of dairy science in University College, Cork, am I to take it that the amounts mentioned there are subject to the decision regarding the new faculties? Is this the only opportunity which we will have of discussing the provision of capital for the erection of buildings and so forth in connection with these colleges?
Comment on this
The Bill will provide for the transfer of lands and buildings, for instance, in connection with University College, Dublin, and money will be paid annually in lieu of that now paid annually to the universities.
Comment on this
Will this capital expenditure now being voted be spent whether the Bill becomes law or not?
Comment on this
It was intended to proceed as quickly as possible with that capital expenditure, and I do not think that there is anything against that.
Comment on this
I do not want to enter on a discussion now which may be prolonged, but I think it is important that we should understand that we are providing capital expenditure by this Vote, and that we will have no authority over the property to be built subsequently. The general question that is involved in this proposal will. I think, require some discussion, but I do not desire to discuss it now if an opportunity will arise later.
Comment on this
The Bill will provide for an annual sum to be voted for this purpose. At present, under the Universities Act, sums are provided by way of annual grants to the different colleges. New sums will be substituted under the Bill, but they will have to be voted annually and appear on the Estimates. I think when we are discussing the Bill these matters could be raised.
Comment on this
The Bill will raise the question of university endowment generally, but this money will not appear in it. A general discussion, however, on university endowment will be relevant.
Comment on this
Why is it necessary to make this grant, for instance, to the University College in Cork? Should that really not come under the heading of "Education"?
Comment on this
It has been decided as a matter of policy that the money should be voted through the Department, as there will have to be a close arrangement between the Department and the University Colleges. Under the faculty, work will be done which used to be done by the Department. This arrangement will give us an opportunity of discussing matters on somewhat equal terms.
Comment on this
The university will be in control of it. The Dáil will vote the sums annually, and, surely, it is obvious that the Dáil will have a certain amount of indirect control. So far as the faculty is concerned, it will, as in every other self-respecting university, be autonomous.
Comment on this
This faculty is not different from those of medicine and science, for instance, and I think that this grant should come in, in connection with universities and colleges, under the heading of "Education."
Comment on this
I feel that the discussion is developing, and I want to say that, by the process we are now entering on, the work which was done by the Department in Glasnevin and in the Cork Dairy School, for instance, and which was hitherto directed by the Department through one or other of its agencies, will no longer be subject to criticism by the Dáil either by the Farmers' Deputies or any other Deputies, and the whole control will be in the hands of an authority not under the control of the Dáil. I think it is well that we should have that fact in mind when we are handing over to an authority, which has no responsibility to the Dáil, this work of agricultural extension, experiment and education.
Comment on this
No; the work that will be done in that faculty will be university and not secondary work.
Comment on this
Is it not stated that the work, for instance, at Glasnevin farm will be transferred to the university?
Comment on this
No. The farm will be transferred to the university. So far as there was secondary education given in Glasnevin, it will be arranged to have it carried on in some other institute of the Department. It is a matter for discussion as to whether a small proportion could not be done in the university itself as extension work, the same as in other countries. So far as the main work of the faculty is concerned, it will be university work— teaching and research work—and this is not going to be a sort of glorified secondary school.
Comment on this
I am concerned rather with the proposal to hand over this work of the agricultural colleges to the university without a clear understanding of what is being done. When it is all thoroughly plain, I may be able to agree with it, but it has not yet been explained.
Comment on this
I explained it in five pages in my opening statement.
Comment on this
The Minister says that he has explained it in detail. I have not the Official Report by me, but I read the newspaper report, and the clear impression which I got from that report is, that the work of the Department at Glasnevin, and the farm there, will be transferred to the university. "With regard to Dublin, it was proposed that all the technical and experimental work should be done at the Albert College, Glasnevin, which, with the farms attached, would be transferred to University College."
Comment on this
Of course, the farms and the staff will be transferred, but only work of a university standard in animal nutrition and in plant-breeding will be transferred. The Department of Agriculture, of course, does secondary and primary education as well.
Comment on this
Does that mean that the Department of Agriculture will do its primary and secondary work on property and in buildings belonging to the University?
Comment on this
I do not know whether this is a fair report, but perhaps the Minister would excuse me saying that he followed a bad example, and that it was very difficult to understand his statement, which was read very quickly. But the report is clear—"that all the technical and experimental work should be done at the Albert College, Glasnevin, which, with the farms attached, would be transferred to the University College." Is that a correct statement?
Comment on this
Then I think I am right in what I said. If the work of the farms is to be transferred to University College——
Comment on this
It is intended that the University shall carry out research: "With regard to the Agricultural Faculty in University College, Dublin: It is proposed that all the technical and experimental work shall be done at the Albert Agricultural College, Glasnevin—which, with the farms attached, is to be transferred to the University College. That is to say, practically all the work after First Arts will be done there. In the nature of the case practically all the work, including chemistry, bacteriology, botany, animal nutrition, plant breeding, animal breeding, plant pathology, forestry, horticulture, zoology, would have to be done within a convenient distance of, or actually on, the farm. Obviously, it would be inconvenient to have laboratory work, say, in plant or animal breeding, plant pathology, in animal nutrition, agricultural chemistry, in the laboratories at one centre, and then be under the necessity of taking the students to another centre at a considerable distance for purposes of actual demonstration. Moreover, practically all the laboratories required are at present in the Albert College."
The Department of Agriculture used to do research work in the real sense of the word in two matters, animal nutrition and plant breeding. These two are being transferred, but so far as the ordinary technical and secondary education of the Department is concerned, that is not being transferred. The farms and buildings are transferred to the complete control of the College, but the work done on the farms and in the buildings will be research work and education of a university standard. We have four other institutions, and we can continue our ordinary education in them. Afterwards it may be found necessary to make arrangements for special courses for particularly advanced students, but that is a matter than can be discussed.
Comment on this
I take it this matter will arise when the Bill is produced, and I will not try to follow it up now, but I think a good deal of consideration will be required as to whether it is good policy to make this transfer and to lose control of the work done in these buildings.
Comment on this
I take it that the Faculty of Agriculture will be under the same control as any other faculty in the University——
Comment on this
——And that the buildings of the Albert Model Farm will be part of its scope, the same as the equipment of the Anatomy School under the Faculty of Medicine. I desire to draw the Minister's attention to the whole system of awarding county council scholarships.
Comment on this
I think the system should be overhauled in view of these new faculties. I suggest that in future a scheme should be worked out by the Department under which the larger proportion of these University scholarships should be awarded to the sons and daughters of farmers so that they would be enabled to pursue a University course, both in agriculture and in dairy science. I agree with the Minister's statement that until we have an educated people both in agricultural and dairy science we need never hope to achieve the great things that might be expected of us as an agricultural country. Here is a chance for the Department to put into operation a practical scheme which would be of some reproductive benefit to the country. We have a plague of B.A.'s, B.Sc.'s and B.Comm.'s, and now we want an army of Bachelors of Agriculture. The farming community is supplying the greater part of the money for these scholarships, and the farmers' sons and daughters should have first call on them. By the development of these scholarships we expect that something will be done in the remote counties for the scientific and research side of agriculture. I sincerely hope that the Department will seriously consider the suggestion that I have thrown out.
I have had considerable experience of very many officials of the Department in various capacities for the past twenty-five years. I had the honour and distinction of being a member of the Donegal County Council and the Agricultural and Technical Instruction Committee. In these capacities I have come across a considerable number of the officials and I have always found them to be men who were inclined to do their duty without fear or favour. I am not speaking now as a champion either of the Land Commission or of the Department of Agriculture, but I think Deputy Hall made use of a very unhappy expression when he referred to some of them taking bribes.
Comment on this
I would emphasise this matter of the county council scholarships, and I hope that the Department will take it up seriously.
Comment on this
The county councils undoubtedly should adapt their scholarships to this, and scholarships should not be given as they have been given. They should be considered in the light of the fact that these two faculties will be there.
Comment on this
The county councils would be slow to recast their schemes or to take the initiative in a matter of this kind, unless the Department of Agriculture takes up this matter and attacks it strongly.
Comment on this
I want to call the Minister's attention to the very small amount of money that is allocated for the improvement of horse breeding in the matter of thoroughbred stallions which I believe are rather sparse in the country and are badly needed. The breeding of hunters is one of the best industries we have. It has not been quite so good for the past few years, but I believe there is a boom coming. I am sorry to say that there is only £1,000 down for this.
Comment on this
There is £2,000. A Supplementary Estimate is to be introduced.
Comment on this
Even £2,000 is not enough. It is a small amount for such an important industry. I see that the Minister has another scheme for the breeding of agricultural horses, or the Irish draught horse, so-called. For this scheme he has down a very much larger sum. That is a class of horse that I think will never make up the country. It is far less important than the hunter class to Ireland, and the amount of money that is allotted for both schemes does not total more than £4,000, while the administration of these two schemes cost somewhere about £1,200 or £1,300. That is a rather large amount, considering the total amount to be spent.
Comment on this
Where did the Deputy get the £1,200 for administration?
Comment on this
For the inspectors in both schemes. There is a sum of £800, another sum of £250 and a further sum of £140. I think £1,200 is far too large a sum to be spent on a administering a scheme the total cost of which is only £4,000 or less. I think the administration is costing too much. The only fault I have to find is that the Minister is not giving more money for the scheme. At present the Minister gives nothing for nominations to mares except what he gives to Irish draught mares and except the county committees put up something of their own there is no such thing as nominations of mares to thoroughbred stallions. I would like the Minister to increase the subsidy to this industry.
Comment on this
The only answer to that is that it is impossible to do everything at the same time. We are dealing with butter, eggs and livestock.
Comment on this
So were the others, as everyone's goose is a swan. I agree that the breeding of horses requires further development but it has to a certain extent been crowded out. You cannot do everything at the same time. All these things cost money and all this goes to swell the Estimates.
Comment on this
These inspections are in respect of mare nominations. You can add £5,000 more to that scheme for nominations.
Comment on this
It is under the county committees of agriculture. It is not in the Department's Estimates at all.