We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

INTOXICATING LIQUOR BILL, 1927. - COMMITTEE (RESUMED).

Contributions 1–150 of 301. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Intoxicating Liquor Bill 1927
Enacted

No. 7 of 1927 ›

Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I propose, as was pointed out yesterday, to take a decision on this amendment by putting the question that the words "between the hours of 3 and 5 in the afternoon" stand part of the sub-section.

Comment on this

On a point of order, if that motion were passed would it preclude me from moving amendment 4 for the insertion of a proviso limiting the acceptance of those hours?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

It would not.

Comment on this

Arising out of the new form motion, I am not sure that it is made clear. When a motion is put in this form, that the words named shall remain part of the Bill, it was stated, in the course of the discussion yesterday, that the merits of any of the alternatives suggested by other amendments are not discussable. I ask your ruling whether that is really implicit in the form of the motion, or whether it is not correct to say that while the motion put is, that the words suggested to be deleted are to remain part of the Bill, persons in whose names the various alternatives appear may argue the merits of their various alternatives against others in the Bill.

Comment on this

On the amendment paper there is no alternative suggestion as regards the hours in this section.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Is not the Deputy's amendment, No. 1. an alternative?

Comment on this

My amendment is to delete, that is, that the words do not stand part of the Bill.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I do not know if it is correct to state that yesterday afternoon any Deputies were precluded from urging hours of opening other than ten o'clock.

Comment on this

I do not want to create a wrong impression—not that they were precluded, but in the course of discussion statements were made that they were prohibited, and I think it is a mistake. I ask that the matter be clarified so that the new procedure may be understood.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Yesterday evening when the opening hours in county boroughs from Monday to Friday were under discussion, the question was that the hour of opening, 10 o'clock, stand part of the section, and the matters that could have been under discussion were the alternative proposals. I think there were two on the paper, one by Deputy Lyons to have publichouses open at 8.30, and the other was an amendment by Deputy Redmond to go back to the present hour, namely, 9 o'clock. The value of putting this question is that it enables all the alternatives to be discussed, but if the words in the Bill are allowed to stand all the alternatives fail. Deputy Thrift's amendment cannot arise if the words are taken out, but it does arise provided the words remain in.

Comment on this

Before I proceed with my amendment, I would like to have a statement as to the effect of the ruling on amendment 5 by Deputy Redmond, for that also deals with the hours 3 to 5. Would not the passing of this motion you suggest, that the hours stand part of the Bill, have the effect of ruling out portion of Deputy Redmond's amendment?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

No. What we are discussing is Section 2, sub-section (1), paragraph (a).

Comment on this

We are only dealing with paragraph (a)?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Yes, and Deputy Redmond's amendment 5 is to paragraph (b).

Comment on this

I understand that this matter is going to be left to a free vote of the House?

Comment on this

Like opponents of the Bill, I have not been idle since the Second Reading. I have been exploring possibilities and impossibilities. I would like to tell the Dáil the conclusions that I have arrived at in regard to this matter of split hours. If the proposal in the Bill that there be a break in the day from 3 to 5 is put to the Dáil on a non-party vote, it will, according to my estimate at any rate, be defeated. On the other hand, I have been able to arrive at an accommodation which I personally am prepared to accept. It is to provide for one hour's complete closing in the four county boroughs, that is, whereas under this proposed two hours' break in the Bill mixed houses would be open for the non-licensed portion of their business, I can put to the Dáil, and I believe I can carry, a proposal for a complete closing of one hour—that the mixed houses be closed equally with the licensed houses pure and simple.

Comment on this

Does that apply all over?

Comment on this

It applies only to the four county boroughs. If this proposal to leave the words of the sub-section stand goes to the Dáil, I would ask the Deputies to vote for it on the understanding that on the Report Stage I will bring forward an amendment providing that the break in the day be a one hour's break, and that it be a completely closed one even for the mixed business—a shut door arrangement.

Comment on this

Has the Minister got any hour on his mind?

Comment on this

I would take either of the hours, but my preference is from 3 to 4. I am fully alive to the fact that reducing the two hours to one hour means still an eleven hours drinking day in the four county boroughs. On the other hand, it is perhaps something of a gain not to have to deal with the administrative difficulties that arise when you have a house opened for the non-licensed portion of its business and closed, or theoretically closed, for the licensed portion. We will have that difficulty even as it is in the morning hour from 9 to 10, but it is not as serious matter then as it might be at a later hour of the day, and I am prepared to put to the Dáil the proposal for a complete closing for one hour in the day for the four county boroughs. If this motion now before the Dáil, that these words stand, be put, I ask for a vote on it on the basis of my promise that I will introduce the amendment I have outlined on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Do I understand from the Minister that he is prepared to reduce the two hours closing to one hour provided all houses, mixed trading and others, shall be closed for that one hour? Is that the proposal?

Comment on this

Would it be possible to give the House an opportunity of considering this before it reaches the next stage?

Comment on this

Of consulting its constituents?

Comment on this

Because the position we are in now is that there is a proposal in the Bill, as originally printed, which suggests closing for two hours, but that is limited, because there is another section which provides that mixed traders shall be allowed to open during those hours for business other than the sale of intoxicating liquor. The Minister now comes along with a further proposal. On the Second Reading he suggested that this original proposal should be left to a free vote, and he now says that he is convinced if there was a free vote the original proposal would go.

Comment on this

I am equally convinced that the new one will carry.

Comment on this

Being convinced of that he is now suggesting that in exchange for the defeat of his original proposal he shall get a complete hour's closing in the middle of the day. I think that that is somewhat of a surprise to spring upon the House at this stage, and I would like to ask the Minister whether, in view of the whole circumstances in regard to this Bill, it is his intention to dispose of it in one Committee Stage, or whether he intends to have a second Committee Stage?

Comment on this

The Bill will almost certainly be recommitted on Report.

Comment on this

I understand now that the Bill will probably——

Comment on this

Almost certainly. I am quite prepared to promise that the Bill will be recommitted, because I will myself have amendments on the Report Stage, which will need greater latitude in discussion than the strict adherence to the procedure of the Report Stage would allow.

Comment on this

On that understanding I take it that we have reached this stage—that if these words are allowed to stand concerning the split hours the Minister will then propose an amendment, or an alteration, or a substitution for these words, that there should be a complete hour's closing, and that the House will have an opportunity of discussing the new proposal in Committee. Is that the situation?

Comment on this

That is what I tried to say.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The suggestion that there will be a second Committee Stage means this: The Bill will be reprinted with the amendments passed during this Committee Stage. Amendments will then be tabled for the Report Stage, and the Dáil will go into Committee for the consideration of these amendments.

Comment on this

I take it that there will be an opportunity then of moving amendments to the recommitted Bill?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Bill will be amended in this Committee; it will be reprinted as amended, and it will come up for consideration on Report. Amendments will come in for that Stage, and, as has happened in cases of other important Bills, the House will go into Committee for the consideration of these amendments. Further amendments of which no notice has been given will be subject to the ordinary rules, that is, they may or they may not be accepted by the Chair. In the case of these words, if they are allowed to stand now and the Minister proposes an amendment subsequently, the words will be first taken out and an attempt will then be made to put other words in. If that proposal is defeated the existing law will stand.

Comment on this

On a point of order. I want to know whether the effect of this announcement nullifies either the proposal or the amendment. It makes no difference whatever whether the proposal or the amendment is passed.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I thought it would be too harsh to point that out. It seemed to me to be clear.

Comment on this

I quite agree.

Comment on this

The Minister contemplates——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Is this on the point of procedure or on the merits?

Comment on this

On the merits. The Minister contemplates defeat if the amendment is pressed. By operation of a free vote of the House the strong man will have met with a check. To avert defeat he proposes a bargain. The bargain is that we should let him carry this point of his Bill to-day and at a later stage he will radically alter his proposals. In Section 3, mixed trading is dealt with, and the words used there are: "the portion of such premises in which such non-licensed business is carried on is not structurally separated from the remainder of such premises," and the remainder of the provision in that section has reference to houses in which mixed trading—licensed and non-licensed—is carried on without structural separation between the two parts. But Section 2, with which we are dealing, is concerned with every type of shop which sells, or exposes for sale, any intoxicating liquor. The broadest and the widest reference possible—"in any county borough to sell or expose for sale any intoxicating liquor or to open or keep open any premises for the sale of intoxicating liquor." The Minister's proposal, which arises in connection with Section 2, will affect such licensed premises as carry on a non-licensed trade as well and which have provided, what is so highly desirable, structural separation between the two. So that when we reach this further stage of dealing with the proposal of the Minister consideration will have to be paid to the difference between these two types of premises. The Minister speaks of making a complete closing for one hour. Such a house as I have referred to, with structural division between the two parts of the premises, will be compulsorily closed for one hour at mid-day as regards its non-licensed trade. It will, therefore, be subjected to that handicap in competition with other houses that are not carrying on a licensed trade as well.

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is the Deputy making a point of order or is he discussing the section?

Comment on this

Deputy Heffernan was asleep when you, sir, put the question to me whether I was on the point of order or on the merits of the case.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Deputy Magennis must give way to Deputy Heffernan on a point of order. What is the point of order?

Comment on this

I want to know if Deputy Magennis is talking on a point of order or if he is discussing Section 2?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Deputy Magennis is discussing amendment 3 to Section 2 in the light of a statement made by the Minister, but I think Deputy Heffernan is entitled to say whether he is insisting upon putting his amendment or not. I will hear Deputy Magennis to the end of his speech and then take Deputy Heffernan.

Comment on this

I submit there is no proposal before the House for the one hour closing.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

That is perfectly sound.

Comment on this

I know that I could take no more unpopular course than to stand between the House and Deputy Heffernan, so that I shall, therefore, merely dwell on the one point which I understood the Minister to make, that his bargain was that he would substitute for the two hours mid-day closing a compulsory one hour total closing. I wish to point out the effect of that in the light of his own illustration of from three to four being the one hour. The shopping public will be at lunch, presumably, or at the mid-day meal, call it what you please, between 1 and 2, or between 2 and 3, and then when they proceed to do their shopping they will find the shops closed compulsorily from 3 to 4. There is a lacuna in the working day for these people, not of two hours, as originally proposed, but of several hours. I suggest that the Minister has not thought out his proposal with sufficient care. It is rather a peculiar situation in which to find himself, that after the long time it took to incubate this measure, in consequence of the report of the Liquor Commission, it was suddenly altered in several respects and that then it has again been altered in this hurried fashion so as to leave these two defects, first its effect on the house carrying on mixed trading with structural alteration between the two parts, and also the inconvenience to the shopping public.

Comment on this

In regard to procedure, suppose I insist on my amendment and it is passed, will it not still be open to the Minister to propose an amendment on the Report Stage to the effect that the houses must be closed for one hour? Is that procedure not open?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Yes; whether the words in sub-section (1), paragraph (a), stand or are deleted, the amendment of which the Minister has spoken will be in order on the next stage.

Comment on this

In view of your ruling, and in view of the method which the Minister has adopted to bring this matter before the House, I feel that I have no alternative but to put the amendment before the House in the manner suggested by you. I take exception to the methods adopted by the Minister in regard to this particular section and the amendment. They are somewhat of the same nature as those adopted by the Minister in regard to the Second Reading of the Bill. We have here before us a Bill on the Committee Stage and we have the extraordinary procedure adopted by the Minister of coming to the House and making a statement with regard to an amendment he proposes to introduce at a later stage and which he had an opportunity of introducing at this stage if he had taken advantage of that opportunity. I say the correct procedure, and the procedure which the Minister should have adopted, if only in courtesy to the mover of the particular amendment, would have been to put down the amendment at this stage or to have a Ministerial amendment put down proposing the method he intends to adopt.

We had the Bill coming before us on Second Reading, and the Minister telling us that we were to pass that Bill, but that that was not the Bill we were to have eventually. He is asking us to pass a Bill which is not before the House at all, a Bill which he is going to amend. We have the same procedure to-day adopted by the Ministers. I take exception to that procedure. I say it is not fair to the members of the House, that when they have prepared particular amendments and prepared any arguments that they may intend to put forward, the Minister comes along with another suggestion which is quite new, which means a reconsideration of the whole section, a reconsideration of the whole position not only in regard to this section but to other sections dealing with another class of trading. In view of that I do not feel that I have the right to withdraw the amendment as there are other Deputies who may still persist in the point of view that the houses should not be closed between 3 and 5.

I want to say, in regard to this amendment and to any other amendment which I put down, that I am not in any sense of the word speaking as official spokesman of the licensed trade. I have not been in close contact with, nor have I been in any way approached by the licensed trade. In putting forward this amendment, I am expressing views and principles which I have held for a considerable time with regard to the whole matter. The underlying principle in my mind in regard to this and my other amendment is that bothersome and vexatious regulations in regard to the hours of opening and the control of licensed premises, are not likely to have the effect of producing less drinking. I fully approve of any method which may be taken to diminish the number of publichouses. I believe that is the only effective clause in the Bill, and were it not for that clause the Bill would have been so much eye-wash and so much a waste of the time of the House in discussing it.

With regard to the suggestion that the licensed houses in the county boroughs should be closed from 3 to 5, the objection that I have is that it will not have any real effect in causing a diminution in the amount of liquor consumed. The Minister dealt with a type of men whom he called "sitters," the men who sit in the public house for hours and who by means of this section would be forced to leave the house between 3 and 5. I do not know what the Minister's knowledge or experience is, but I believe there are very few drinkers of that type in existence in the Saorstát. My view in regard to this particular form of drinking, as in regard to any other form of drinking, is that the greatest influence for temperance we have had in modern times has been the increase in the price of liquor, and that while it remains at its present price there is practically no need for any restrictive legislation of any kind. People certainly are not drinking because they cannot afford it.

Another matter with regard to this question of liquor reform is that it will cause, in my opinion, considerable inconvenience to the ordinary public. I think cognisance should be taken of the fact that in this country we are really an agricultural people, that our cities are distributing centres for the agricultural community and are not industrial centres, and that there is a continual percolation of country people into the cities. They come into Dublin almost every day. They come in in the morning, do their business, as a rule, in the morning hours, get their lunch, and then, between 3 and 4 and 5, just at the hour when a man decides that he might want a drink to keep his spirits up, he finds the publichouses are closed against him.

Comment on this

He can go outside the city boundary.

Comment on this

My experience of the existing regulations in England is that when I felt like having a drink —which is not very often—the idea always seemed to strike me between 3 and 5 o'clock. The Minister has rather complicated the matter by introducing this question of closing for an hour, because that deals with the question of mixed trading and takes away an argument that I intended to use. In view of the possibility that the Minister's amendment on the Report Stage may not be adopted, I want to point out that under the section as it stands there would be very considerable difficulty in regard to supervision of mixed trading. You will have a house where liquor and groceries are sold over the same counter, and between 3 and 5 o'clock, according to this, the liquor cannot be sold. In my opinion, that would make supervision almost impossible, and would add very considerably to the existing difficulties of the Gárda Síochána. In view of the arguments which I have put forward, and in view of the fact that I believe there is no definite demand from any large section of the community that publichouses should be closed between 3 and 5 in the county boroughs, I ask that the question to be put, as suggested by the Ceann Comhairle, that the words "between 3 and 5" stand part of the Bill, be not accepted by the House.

Comment on this

Owing to a little incident that happened yesterday evening ——

Comment on this

A series of incidents.

Comment on this

I can assure the Dáil, particularly the Ceann Comhairle and the Government, that I certainly very much regret if I said anything offensive to any Deputy. Owing to being too much interested in the welfare of the people whom I represent, I may have used words that probably I would not use on another occasion. I hope this will be accepted by the Dáil in all sincerity, because I can assure Deputies that I am very sorry.

I have an amendment on the Paper similar to that moved by Deputy Heffernan. I did not put forward that amendment in the interests of the licensed trade, but as an independent Labour Deputy. I have made inquiries from persons employed in the licensed trade and have been assured that if licensed houses are closed from 3 to 5 in the afternoon it will mean the dismissal of a large number of employees. I am sure the Minister for Justice recognises the necessity for keeping people in employment. On Second Reading he said he was prepared to allow this matter to be decided by a free vote of the Dáil. I hope he has not bound his Party in the meantime, and that a free vote will be allowed. We must appreciate the stand that the Minister for Justice has made against such a powerful organisation as the licensed trade. I, at least, do appreciate it, but I hope that he will adhere to the promise he made to allow this matter to be decided by a free vote of the House.

If this amendment is not accepted the licensed houses in the county boroughs will be compelled to close from 3 to 5 in the afternoon, and that will add considerably to the number of the unemployed. By doing that you will show that you want to cripple the licensed trade, from which the greater portion of the revenue is derived. I think every honest-minded Deputy must recognise that if this proposal is accepted you are going to do a great injustice to a very large number of people.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Deputy must address the Chair, not the House.

Comment on this

Through you, Sir, I address the House. I sincerely hope that the Dáil will recognise the fact that these split hours will impose too much work on the Gárda Síochána, whose hands are already pretty full. There are about 7,700 Guards in the force at present, and 7,000 more would be wanted to see that these split hours are adhered to. I hope the Dáil will accept the amendment and that the Minister has not changed his mind about allowing a free vote on this. I hope every Deputy will vote in accordance with his conscience, and not in accordance with any pressure brought to bear upon him.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

took the Chair.

Comment on this

As the mover of the first amendment on the Paper, which covers the amendments moved by Deputy Heffernan and Deputy Lyons, I desire, at once, to associate myself with Deputy Heffernan in his protest against the manner in which the Vice-President has chosen to treat the House. I do not see the good of having this Bill here at all. Why have the Bill? Why not have a blank sheet of paper? Why not let us meet, say from day to day, and hear the latest report from the mind of the Minister for Justice? On the occasion of the Second Reading he informed us that he was prepared to leave this matter of split hours to a free vote. He certainly did not suggest that he was about to abandon the project that was in his Bill, because I suppose at that moment he had not arrived at that conclusion.

But his proposal now is that he is abandoning the closing of premises for two hours and the permitting of the opening of other premises, namely, mixed premises during these same hours. In fact, he has admitted now that the arguments used on the Second Reading debate against the practicability of allowing houses known as mixed trading houses to keep open for the sale of goods other than intoxicating liquor and expecting them to be closed for the sale of intoxicating liquor were fully justified. Well, then, what is the use discussing, now, the proposals in the Bill regarding the split hours? The Minister has thrown them over. It is like flogging a dead horse. He has said that if these words are allowed to stand in the Bill he will, at the next stage, provide that they will not stand in the Bill and that something else will stand in their stead. Therefore, to discuss the present proposal is mere and sheer waste of time. Similarly, to discuss the question of the position of the mixed traders under these hours, as proposed in the original Bill, is also waste of time, because the Minister has announced that all houses are to be closed—that is the new proposal—the very latest from the Ministerial front—mixed and otherwise, for one hour.

I submit that Deputy Heffernan's attitude is a commendable one and should be adopted by the Minister, when, at the last moment, he has come to see the error of his way in regard to his original proposal.

Comment on this

No, no; the error of your ways.

Comment on this

Deputy Heffernan has asked whether if these hours are now deleted, if this motion is defeated, it will be within the right of the Minister to move, at another stage, a new section providing for his new proposal, and you, sir, have answered in the affirmative. I suggest this is the attitude that ought to have been adopted by the Minister, and for that reason I will support Deputy Heffernan in clearing the path and, at any rate, in doing away with those words in the Bill now and at once, because the Minister himself says that at the next stage he himself is going to do away with them. So I say the proper course for him to adopt now is to accept the essence of this amendment, namely, that the words do not stand part of the Bill at the moment, and it will be open to him, at a subsequent stage, to introduce his new proposal. I do not think there is anything unfair either to him or to the Committee in that. But his idea is so extraordinarily roundabout and complicated that I fail to see how he can press it upon the House. He wants the words kept in the Bill, and then he wants to be given leave to say that they shall not be in the Bill but that something else shall be in the Bill. Why should he not agree to have the words struck out here and now in the Bill and then come along with his fresh proposals? He said, very candidly I admit, that the reason why he is not proceeding with the Bill as originally drafted in respect of this clause is because, having announced that he would leave it to a free vote of the House, he is convinced that it would be defeated. If he is convinced that it would be defeated, if he knows that he himself is not going to insist upon these words at a later stage, but is going to substitute others for them, then I ask, in the name of reason, why he will not now agree to have these words deleted and then let him come forth with his new proposal at a subsequent stage? There is no use, as I said before, now debating this question as originally proposed in the Bill.

That is gone. It is as dead as Queen Anne. The suggestion that houses should open for the sale of one class of commodities and not for the sale of another class at one and the same time and that these houses could be properly supervised by the Gárda Síochána or any other force, was preposterous. It has been seen by the Minister that that suggestion was utterly futile. It has now gone and there is no use in labouring the utter impracticability of it. Similarly, the suggestion in regard to mixed trading has gone. But you have a further point to consider—a point which is covered, it is true, by a subsequent proviso standing in the name of Deputy Thrift. I do not know what the Minister's attitude will be upon that question. The proposal is in regard to houses which are licensed for the consumption of liquor off the premises. The question does not arise immediately under this amendment, and I am not going to deal with it now. But there would be no necessity for that proviso at all if the Minister were to adopt the course I suggest, in company with Deputy Heffernan. There would then be no possibility of these words ever standing part of the Bill. He would agree to have them deleted at once. We could then proceed with the rest of the Bill, and at any future date, when a suitable opportunity offered, the Minister could come forward with his new proposals. There is only one drawback to that suggestion, and it is that when the time came for the Minister to make his new proposals, as outlined to-day, we would probably find a newly-amended new proposal.

Comment on this

The Minister, in presenting this punctured document, has, at every stage of the proceedings, announced another surrender and another compromise. But the surrender and the compromise he has announced on each occasion appear to have been brought about as a result of a mutiny in the ranks of his own supporters.

Comment on this
DEPUTIES

No.

Comment on this

At any rate, the Minister has announced to-day that he has formed a coalition—by private negotiation, I presume—which will enable him to get over the difficulty created by the amendment now before the House. There has, I think, been more discussion of a proposal that is not before the House than there has been of the amendment that Deputy Heffernan has moved. I understand that if this two-hour closing from 3 to 5 is insisted upon by the Minister and carried by the House, it will result in the disemployment of 100 to 150 grocers' assistants in the city of Dublin. The actual figure given to me, and given to the Minister at an interview with representatives of the grocers' assistants, was 133.

Comment on this

The Minister has said nothing and his supporters have said nothing as to what provision will be made for the people who will lose their employment as a result of passing subsection (a) of Section 2 of this Bill. When I spoke of the unemployment of 130 assistants, I referred only to the position in the city of Dublin. I know nothing of the effect of the passage of this section in Cork, Waterford, or Limerick. The Minister may, perhaps, have received information on that question. Sometime ago I had a conversation with a grocer's assistant in this city who was anxious to secure employment. He failed in his efforts. As a result of investigation, I found that there were 300 grocers' assistants on the idle list in the City of Dublin. Those who vote for the proposal in subsection (a) should realise that they are going to add 130 to the number of unemployed in the city. We have heard a good deal of talk outside the House about the impression created upon Deputies by interested parties. I believe that there is very little consideration given to Press reports of that kind by the Deputies themselves. I do not believe that Deputies of any Party are so much subject to the pressure of interested parties—whether it be the temperance party or the publican's party—as the Press would lead the public to believe. The general impression of Deputies of this House is that it is injudicious on the part of this Government, and would be injudicious on the part of a Farmers' Government or a Labour Government, to bring in restrictive legislation of this kind three months before an appeal to the people. If the present Government was as certain as the President appears to be of coming back with a bigger majority, they would have allowed the electors to pronounce judgement on this question, and if they were returned they could pass a measure of this kind, or even a more restrictive measure.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

The Deputy should confine himself to the amendment.

Comment on this

This part of the Bill will not affect my constituency, but I hold that if the House agrees to payment of compensation for abolition of licences a good case can be made for some form of compensation to, or some form of recognition of, the people who will be thrown out of employment, as a result of the passage of this measure in the name of social reform. We are discussing now a proposal to close for two hours. Deputies will have, I presume, an opportunity of expressing their views and voting upon a proposal for one-hour closing later. I believe that if the two-hour closing is made operative it will necessitate far more supervision on the part of the Gárda Síochána than at present, and supervision of a kind which cannot be effective. I believe that you would require to have a policeman at the door of every publichouse from 9 to 10 in in the morning and from 3 to 5 in the evening if this clause is carried, in order to ensure that the publican is not taking undue advantage of the law. That will be especially so in the case of mixed traders. I want to know from the Minister if he has investigated the question regarding the number of people likely to be disemployed and if he is prepared to give compensation to those who will be so disemployed.

On the merits of his reply my vote will depend. But unless the Minister is prepared to give some consideration to those who are thrown out of employment, I will vote against the proposal for the two-hour closing, because it will undoubtedly add to the number of unemployed in the cities, without in any way making for the more effective control of the licensing business of the country.

Comment on this

I should like to get from Deputy Davin some explanation as to how this immense unemployment is to arise as a result of the operation of this clause. The sub-section in question proposes to close publichouses in the cities between the hours of 3 and 5—not the busiest hours of the day, by any means, in the four cities. The publichouse will be staffed not in accordance with the requirements of the whole day's trading but in accordance with the requirements of the busiest hours of the day. How the publican is to reduce his staff because his house is to be closed during two of the quietest hours of the day, is a question I cannot understand without further explanation from the Deputy.

Comment on this

I stated that I was informed that a deputation representing the Grocers Assistants' Association had met the Minister and discussed this matter with him for a considerable time. I gave figures which would show that 130 assistants would be disemployed. The Minister says that the figure is 133.5. That only shows the ridiculous way in which he is treating this serious subject. There are 40 publichouses in the city of Dublin employing three assistants and over. Any businessman can see that the services of one man at least can be dispensed with in each of these 40 houses if this clause is put into operation in its present form.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin suggested that it was a mistake to introduce this Bill in a year in which a General Election is about to take place. I realise that it is going to take twice as long to pass this Bill in the year in which a General Election is about to take place as it would take in any other year. But, even realising that, I think it was wise and sound to introduce a Bill based on the Report of the Intoxicating Liquor Commission——

Comment on this

What Bill?

Comment on this

I will talk about that presently—and not do, as I believe a government composed of any or all of the other parties in this House would do; that is, run away from the report of the Intoxicating Liquor Commission because a general election was due. Deputy Heffernan objects to procedure and Deputy Redmond sonorously endorses his remarks in that connection. It seems to be the point of view that this is the one kind of Bill regarding which there must be no modification. If there is a modification then it is a grievance and the grievance of those who voted against the Second Reading of the Bill——

Comment on this

Deputies are trying to have it every way. Deputies like Deputy Heffernan, who have tried to bestraddle every issue of any importance that arose since their election to the Dáil, having voted against the Second Reading of the Bill, go down the country and parade it as an additional grievance that the Minister is on the run.

Comment on this

Not as a grievance; as a statement of fact.

Comment on this

He does not deny it.

Comment on this

The Deputy has bestraddled or tried to bestraddle every issue of any significance or importance that arose since he came to the Dáil.

Comment on this

I deny that.

Comment on this

His complaint against me is that (a) it was wrong to introduce the Bill, (b) having introduced the Bill it was wrong to agree to modification in any detail whatsoever. There has been overmuch talk about concessions, actual or indicated.

Comment on this

Surrenders.

Comment on this

Deputies voting for the Second Reading knew what they were voting for. Let us take stock since it is necessary. I think it will probably save the time of the Dáil. I indicated on the Second Reading with regard to the endorsement section that I was prepared to bring in an amendment on Committee, enabling a trader with an endorsement to sell a clear licence provided he satisfied the court that that was a bona fide transaction. That is a matter that has no temperance aspect whatsoever. It is a matter of justice, of the soundness of which I was entirely convinced. Without it the endorsement system, and the possibility of endorsement, was injuring the credit of traders, even those who were running their shops on perfectly correct lines. It is not a temperance aspect one way or another. The offer was that if Deputies wished I was prepared to vest in the District Justice that degree of discretion which the original proposal vested in the Circuit Judge, conditional on appeal to the Circuit Judge. With regard to these things Deputies who voted solidly against the Second Reading of the Bill tried to have it every way by suggesting it was a grievance that I should indicate on the Second Reading my willingness to agree to this modification in detail.

This Bill is based on the report of a public Commission, and on that public Commission there sat a member of the Farmers' Party in this House, and a Senator member of the Labour Party. Not a Deputy of the Farmers' Party voted for the Bill. I give the Deputy who signed the report his due in saying that his absence was fully understood by me, and that I believe, were he never a signatory to the report, he would have voted for the Second Reading of the Bill. I also do Deputy Gorey, who is ill, the justice of saying that if a member of his party were never a signatory to the report, I believe he would have voted for the Second Reading of the Bill.

Comment on this

The actual fact is that not a member of the Farmers' Party walked the Lobby in favour of this Bill. Voting against all its principal provisions, then they go down the country and talk about the Minister being on the run from the licensed trade. Who is on the run from the licensed trade?

Comment on this

The Minister.

Comment on this

Is the Minister in order in raising these issues now?

Comment on this

I want to know if the Minister is in order in making an election speech when discussing an amendment?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

I am afraid the Minister has wandered from the amendment.

Comment on this

I have been attacked at great length by succeeding Deputies on this question of the modification of the Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister is answering what I said in the country.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not like that to be answered.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

The Minister will have further opportunities of dealing with the Bill as a whole.

Comment on this

He had the opportunity the other night when he made a speech in Dublin, if he wanted to deal with it.

Comment on this

Deputy Magennis' Party voted solidly against this Bill.

Comment on this

On a point of order, the Minister is not discussing the question before the House. He is presuming on the patience of members to make a Second Reading speech again and a Report Stage speech. I protest against the liberties Ministers take in this House, and I submit that the rules of order are as imperative on a Minister as on a private member.

Comment on this

Deputy Magennis on Committee Stage——

Comment on this

On a point of order, will the Minister allow you, sir, to reply to Deputy Magennis' point of order?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

We are dealing with the question of split hours, 3 to 5 o'clock, and I am afraid a lot of this discussion is foreign to that question.

Comment on this

Deputies have raised an objection to procedure—to the fact that on this stage and on other stages I have indicated that I was not standing rigidly over the text of the Bill. Deputies who voted against the Second Reading—whole Parties have voted against Second Reading—are joining in that protest. Surely I am entitled to point out that Deputies of the Farmers' Party, of the Labour Party, and of Deputy Magennis' Party who voted solidly against the Second Reading of the Bill, ought not to come along on Committee Stage and take up an attitude of being aggrieved. If in any particular I indicate that I am prepared to make concessions to what appears to be a considerable body of opinion in the Dáil——

Comment on this

Behind you.

Comment on this

If this were another kind of Bill the grievance would be that the Minister was standing too rigidly, that he was not prepared to give due consideration to amendments, points of view, and so on. But on this Bill, Deputies want it the other way—"we who stand for temperance," said Deputy Magennis yesterday, having voted against the Second Reading of the Bill. With regard to the proposal for split hours, the Bill in this particular represents a provision which I believe ought, without hesitation, to be passed by the Dáil. I am strongly in favour of the 3-5 break in the day in county boroughs, and I do not consider that there is anything harsh or unreasonable in that. Deputies think otherwise. I am prepared to leave this 3-5 break to a free vote of the Dáil. I have no expectation whatever that Deputies have yet the moral courage and sense of public interest that would bring them into the Lobby in favour of that proposal.

Comment on this

We will see that, Deputy Baxter says "nonsense," but this provision can be put to the Dáil and we can watch the result. It is a provision which, in my view, ought to pass if Deputies were sufficiently emancipated from the influence of a particular section in the community.

Comment on this

The Minister should withdraw that remark.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

The Minister is entitled to his opinion on this question.

Comment on this

It must be to his own supporters he is referring.

Comment on this

I have reason to know that Deputies are not yet sufficiently emancipated, and having compassion on their weakness I hold myself ready to accept accommodation on this matter at a later stage, but if Deputies want this proposal put to a free vote of the Dáil so that the responsibility for its acceptance or rejection may lie on individual Deputies, irrespective of Party, then surely I, who favour the proposal, ought to have no objection. If the proposal in the Bill, as it stands, were carried, then I would not bring in an amendment on Report Stage to delete it, and substitute a one-hour break instead of a two-hour break.

Deputy Redmond referred to the difficulty of administering the two hours' break with the mixed houses open. That is a difficulty we are prepared to undertake, and I am not as pessimistic as the Deputy, nor have I as low an opinion of the licensed trade, in the matter of the observance of the law, as the Deputy seems to have. I think if that provision was passed by the Oireachtas that it would be observed by the great majority of the licensed trade in these county boroughs, and observed strictly and honourably. The few weaker vessels who lapsed would, in due course of time, be detected and dealt with. That represents my position on this matter. I am perfectly willing to allow the proposal as it stands to go to a free vote of the Dáil as I promised on Second Reading. If it were carried I should be very pleased and my opinion of Deputies generally would have improved considerably, but if it is not carried, and I am afraid it will not, then on the Report Stage I will bring forward, as a matter of confidence, a proposal that there be a one hour break in the day, that one hour being a complete closing for mixed houses as for the others.

Comment on this

Will the Minister make it clear whether the effect of his statement is that the one hour break is a kind of second preference with him, but that the first preference which he is prepared now to stand by, but not to make a matter of confidence, is the 3-5 break. The Minister, in his responsible position, recommends the first preference. Is that so?

Comment on this

Yes, distinctly, I recommend the proposal in the Bill. I fear it will not pass, and in that event only will I bring forward, on the Report Stage, the proposal for the one hour complete closing.

Comment on this

I am anxious to know if the complete closing for one hour will apply to wholesalers—to a firm, say, like Findlater's.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy mean an ordinary spirit grocer's licence for consumption off the premises?

Comment on this

I mean a firm doing a wholesale trade.

Comment on this

The wholesaler had no prohibited hours at all in the past.

Comment on this

And he will be open?

Comment on this

I realise that, on Second Reading Stage of this Bill, among the principles which we approved was one limiting facilities for the retail sale of intoxicating liquor. The particular section that we are dealing with proposes to limit the sale of intoxicating liquor during certain hours of the day. I feel bound to justify my vote on this question because of certain statements I made on the Second Reading of the Bill and of certain statements I made elsewhere. I propose to vote for the Bill as it stands, although I have expressed doubts and gave perhaps a reserved promise that I would vote against this provision. I have realised that there are certain defects from the point of view of the trade in the section. It seemed to me to impose certain conditions on the licensed holder without, as it appeared to me, adequate advantage to the social well-being. I have now come to a different conclusion, and I propose to say a few words to justify my attitude on this matter. The Minister has pointed out time and time again, in the course of the discussion, that the Bill is based on the Report of the Liquor Commission. This provision in the Bill was one of the recommendations of that Commission. From my point of view, the Liquor Commission and the Bill proceed along a line which is vitiated by a wrong outlook. The Minister, throughout the Bill, has dealt with it from the point of view of police administration rather than from the point of view of a reduction in the consumption of intoxicating liquor as a beverage.

The Liquor Commission reported and stated certain principles which governed its report, and, no doubt, they are all very good in their own way, when they point out it is not the function of the law to make people good, that the essential function of the law is to maintain justice, preserve order, protect the community, and so on. I think that is only part of the truth and, unfortunately, to my view, it is the acceptance of that as the whole truth, that destroys this measure and even makes the suggested change the Minister has been talking about less valuable as a temperance measure. I think it is quite wrong to assume that the limit or function of the legislature and the law is to prevent people doing wrong. I propose to vote for this provision, which limits the hours during which publichouses should be open, because it is reducing the facilities for drinking.

I think that the justification for that goes beyond the proposition in this Liquor Commission Report and lies beyond the police administration aspect. After all we have to consider the question not merely from the point of view of the trader or even of the consumer. I believe that the attitude in regard to which this has been discussed has been mainly from the economic view-point or the restriction upon the satisfaction of appetites, quite legitimate, within limits, but nevertheless merely animal appetites. We cannot disassociate ourselves from our general knowledge of the effects of intoxicating liquor upon, let us say, five per cent. of the community. We may well talk about the great majority of drinkers being moderate drinkers, that drunkenness is diminished and that the function of the law, in this matter, is merely to prevent disorder, but I am making the plea, and it is on this ground that I am supporting the Bill, that the function of the law in the matter is to limit the facilities for going wrong.

We do, as a matter of fact, in practice limit the facilities for drug-taking. We do not hesitate to impose prohibitions upon gambling, as a practice, when it is pure gambling. I suppose the police would be immediately on the track if, in the central part of O'Connell Street, a shop were to open as a purely gambling saloon, so that we do prohibit what might, in normal circumstances, be called a natural and legitimate appetite. I think our plea should be that, if we find a social evil developing out of the undue facilities for taking intoxicating liquor, just as we would out of undue facilities for the consumption of noxious drugs, we have a right to do more than the Liquor Commission recommends; we have a right to limit these facilities, even when the evil is not as disastrous as drug-taking. After all, we know that to many people these unlimited facilities have the effect of creating a still further appetite in the same way as noxious drugs, what are called habit-forming drugs, create. I think the limitation is justifiable, and I think, further, that the right approach to this matter is that the 95 per cent. of moderate drinkers, who are always masters of their appetites and of their will in this matter, might well be asked to give away something on behalf of the five per cent., or the one per cent. if you like, who we know as a matter of fact are not masters of their appetites, and who give way to undue drinking of intoxicating liquor. One need not go into the evils resulting from it. These are apparent and within the knowledge of everyone, but I am supporting this restriction, with such consequences as may ensue, on the ground that it is desirable to limit the facilities for the consumption of intoxicating liquor. I think it is not too much to ask the great majority of liquor takers to sacrifice something for the common good in this matter, and for the protection of the weak minority who may have been hereditarily inclined to alcoholism but who may be prevented from disaster if, perchance, these restrictions are limited.

Although it is not a matter which, I think, affects the average workman, this three to five opening, I know as a matter of experience that it does affect a considerable number of other classes, the intellectuals, artists, poets and commercial men. I therefore, this evening, am in support of this proposal on the ground that it is limiting the facilities for the taking of intoxicating liquor.

Comment on this

I do not know that I would have felt inclined to engage in this discussion, because I am not situated in a part of the country that is going to be affected, to any extent, whether the amendment is rejected or passed, if the Minister in charge of the measure did not see fit, in his accustomed style, to make an attack on our party and on the motives which inspire this party to action so far. If the Minister had addressed himself to his own party, and lectured them on their want of moral courage, he would have no fear then of the results of the vote which he has put before the House. The Minister is always very self-righteous, a strong man. The combined moral courage of all the Deputies of the House never equals the moral courage of the Minister for Justice. He is going to go into the lobby, if he goes in alone, on this amendment, and his motives are always so worthy that those who oppose him must be always wrong. If every Deputy were as narrow of vision as he, and were inclined to attribute as unworthy motives to others as he is, this would be a very unworthy assembly indeed. There are Deputies in this House just as keen for the promotion of temperance as the Minister. I have not heard one word from the Minister in support of this section that would make me believe he is going to make one man in this country more temperate than he is if it goes through.

I would like to consider this question apart altogether from personalities, by which, I do suggest, I am not influenced in the least. But I am asking myself what effect is this amendment going to have on the cause of temperance? Has any plea been made to satisfy me that less drink is going to be consumed owing to this closing down for two hours in the day in Cork, Waterford, Limerick and Dublin? I am not satisfied on that point. On the other hand, the case has been made, and it is suggested to me by members of my own party who know the conditions in a couple of the four centres which will be affected, that the disadvantage that many people, the rural dwellers, will be at is going to be very great and very considerable. I am referring to the rural dwellers who go into these cities to do their business and buy shop goods of various kinds. It would be a great disadvantage to them to have these places closed for two hours in the evening. We have to consider the disadvantages on the one side against the possible, but very remote, chance of influencing a very limited number of people in the amount of alcohol they are going to take. We have to balance one against the other and to see whether the case made by the Minister is sufficiently strong to justify us in accepting it. I do not think the case is sufficiently strong for the two hours closing. We may be taken to task for that here. The Minister is entitled to take us to task. He is entitled to make charges against Deputies——

Comment on this

Counter-charges.

Comment on this

Counter-charges. I interrupted the Minister. I said if he wanted to reply to anything that Deputy Heffernan had said, he could have done so the other night outside the House when he was speaking in another place.

Comment on this

He did not forget it; he is too careful. He suggests that our Party is influenced by political motives, and that we are prepared to discount altogether the good that may come by an effort to promote temperance. That is not fair to our Party. While the Minister is entitled to select a couple of members of any Party for his applause, mar eadh, while he is prepared to do that, I want to tell him that every member of our Party is as anxious as he is to make social conditions better if we can be satisfied that the efforts of the Minister are tending towards that end. Now, it has come to this—I believe that the Minister is not acting fairly, inasmuch as if he had acted fairly his intention of amending this section would have been down in the Order Paper to-day. That is what he should have done. Be fair to the House.

Comment on this

I wanted to see whether the Dáil would pass this first.

Comment on this

That is not disclosing the intention, or what is going on behind the scenes. If the Minister had his mind made up to go away from the section before he came in here, he should have been honest enough to put it down on the Paper and let the House see what his intentions were. If he did that the House would be satisfied that he was playing straight. The Minister knew before we came to this section at all what the opinion of the House was. But with all his iron will and moral courage and great leadership he does not feel convinced that he is able to command the support of the majority of his own Party to carry this section. And because he is not able to do that he wants to charge all other Parties with cowardice and unworthy motives and want of moral courage. I think the Minister should change his tune.

Comment on this

On a famous occasion Bismarck described his adversary, Lord Salisbury, as a lath painted to look like iron. The admirers of the Minister for Justice—for he has admirers it seems—regard him as the real metal. Yesterday I was foolish enough to think that he was making an honest attempt to play the part of the iron. To-day he goes back to the despicable position he took up on the Second Reading. He is now temporising and compromising in obedience to the pressure from within his own majority ranks. He professed all through, even with regard to the proposal that we are now discussing, to base recommendations on the findings of the Liquor Commission. But the alternative proposal that he puts forward to save himself from defeat upon this is in direct variance with the ideas of the Liquor Commission. Yet he wants to have it both ways. As Deputy Baxter pointed out, he wants to make it appear that he and he alone is the champion of temperance. "Alone I did it" is to be the declaration when the historian of Ireland writes that it has become a sober country. Now, the Minister does himself a great injustice in professing here, as he did in his last speech, to misunderstand why Deputies voted against him on the Second Reading.

If we were to believe his account of the workings of his own mind we should think that he could contemplate no possibilities except these two— (a) temperance advocates who voted for, and (b) drunkenness or intemperance advocates who voted against the Bill. Speaking for myself, I am a temperance advocate, and the Minister knows well I have pursued that course vigorously and consistently from the first hour I had the honour to be a member here. He will remember that when he introduced the Liquor Bill in the Provisional Parliament I was the only member who stood by his Bill, even when he was wobbling and wavering under pressure to surrender the third portion of it. Now I voted against the Second Reading because I did not know what he was asking us to vote for. I shall never, so long as I am a member of this House, give any Minister a blank cheque, and that is what the House was asked to do on the occasion of the Second Reading. The printed Bill was before us, containing the proposal such as this, and others like it for restrictions of facilities for drinking.

We knew from the Press that the meetings of the real Parliament had been held on two successive evenings, that there were ruptures threatened within the ranks of the majority, and that it was under pressure of that and to avoid disruption the Bill was to be re-handled, re-cast, and radically altered. Here we have again a proposal at a later date, a proposal to re-cast it and to introduce further modifications. Are we not entitled to protest against this frivolous conduct of Ministers——

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

Deputy Magennis must confine himself to the subject-matter of the amendment.

Comment on this

I sumbit I am dealing with the conduct of the Minister in regard to this particular proposal. He himself, no less than twice already, has suggested that we are to consider either this or a second best. Surely if he is in order in presenting this alternative of preferential proposals, I am in order, I submit, with all due respect to you, sir, to discuss it. He cannot have it both ways.

Although the Minister has abandoned his design of figuring as the strong man, he still clings to the reputation of being hard-hearted and firm in dealing with humanity, for, notwithstanding the pathetic appeal of Deputy Heffernan, he will not yield altogether.

We had an interesting chapter of the autobiography of Deputy Heffernan. It seems his yearnings, cravings and irresistible longings for refreshment are usually between three and five o'clock. I should have thought that would have weighed with the Minister. There is a famous phrase of President Wilson, that his aim was to make the world safe for democracy. Surely the Minister will make the world safe and convenient for Deputy Heffernan, no matter what the cost to the rest of the public and the welfare of the State.

I submit it is not dealing properly with this House that at every stage of the discussion of a measure the Minister in charge of it should inform the House that if certain contingencies occur, or are likely to occur, in his estimate of them, that he will bring in something else instead. From the first hour of the introduction of this Bill to the present moment, that has been its history. I think the Ministers are not discharging their duty; they are certainly not considering the dignity of the House.

Comment on this

I agree with Deputy Baxter inasmuch as I believe the closing of the publichouses for those two hours will not lessen the amount of drink consumed in those four cities. I am glad to see that the Minister for Justice is about to allow a free vote of the House on this amendment. I am certain that the members of his Party will not be influenced or aggrieved by any of the speeches delivered during the last half hour, but will go out, fairly and squarely, and act on their own opinions. I appeal to the members of the Government Party to do their part freely when they are getting an opportunity of a free vote.

I compliment the Minister for Justice for sticking to his word. I only hope in regard to a few more amendments that are there, that we will get a free vote of the House. I am certain there are a great many Deputies on the right of me who are delighted to get a chance of voting freely this evening. After all, they are bound by a pledge and when they are loosed from that pledge no doubt they feel much easier in their minds. Every one of us, from time to time, has had a pledge, every one of us as well as these men. We are all Irishmen.

I assure you that, unlike Deputy Heffernan, I will not be looking for a drink between three and five. I make no boast of it. I often looked for a drink between those hours. I will draw the Minister's attention to the fact that there will be amendments later on just as important as this. They are brought in by members of the Dáil to assist the Government in trying to regulate the licensed trade. I think the Minister should meet us half way, and if there is any reasonable amendment I hope he will allow a free vote upon it just as he is doing in this case. When we are getting a free vote it should not necessitate all the talk that we have had about it.

Comment on this

I would like to have a ruling on the point whether, if this section is carried, it will be in order to move an amendment on the Report Stage, to substitute an amendment suggesting one hour of closing.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

It will be in order.

Comment on this

If it will be, then I think the position of this Party is very simple, because I shall have pleasure in proposing an amendment to agree to what I consider was a very fair and reasonable offer on the part of the Minister.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Shaw speak for the entire Government Party?

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain the point raised by Deputy Wilson with regard to wholesale licence holders? Will they be entitled to remain open?

Comment on this

Since 1872 there were never any prohibited hours for wholesale dealers.

Comment on this

Is not the proper designation of these people off-licence holders?

Comment on this

There are two classes.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy mean wholesalers or off-licence holders?

Comment on this

Wholesalers.

Comment on this

There were never any prohibited hours since 1872 for wholesalers in the real sense of the word, as distinct from off-licence holders.

Comment on this

The meaning of it is that the privileged class can get their beer or liquor during these hours, and the poorer classes cannot.

Comment on this

If the Deputy, between three and five, wants four and a half gallons of beer, he can get it.

Comment on this

Why not allow the same thing to the retailer?

Comment on this

If a Deputy were a member of a licensed club he could get the drink. Is not that so?

Comment on this

Has the Minister anything to say to the case put up to him by the Grocers Assistants' Organisation as to the unemployment as a result of this? It is not a trivial matter.

Comment on this

I have not anything to say to that.

Comment on this

I think I have the right to ask the Minister, even at the eleventh hour of the debate, to reconsider his decision. I do not think that Deputy Shaw, who represents Westmeath along with me, is voicing the opinions of the Government Party—of the Cumann na nGaedheal members in this House—when he considers that he would be in order in moving an amendment on the Report Stage to close the licensed houses for one hour in the day.

Comment on this

We are not discussing the point raised by Deputy Shaw. We are discussing the question whether we will close for two hours each day or not. There is no other amendment before the House.

Comment on this