We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

INTOXICATING LIQUOR BILL, 1927. - COMMITTEE (RESUMED).

Contributions 151–301 of 301. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Intoxicating Liquor Bill 1927
Enacted

No. 7 of 1927 ›

I understand that perfectly well, but I want to make it clear to the House that if this amendment is defeated, it will be defeated on a specific point, simply because the Minister has made a promise that he will accept amendments on the Report Stage of the Bill. That is why this amendment is going to be defeated now by the Government supporters. But for the Minister making this promise, this amendment would have gone through. That is what I want to make clear. I do not think any Deputy has the right to stand up here and indicate what he believes is going to happen on the next stage of the Bill. This amendment is to delete the words from three to five, and I hope Deputies will recognise that if this amendment is not carried, and if this section is inserted in the Bill as it stands, it will mean a very large number of people will be unemployed in the four cities mentioned. I want to make that point quite clear, and, as the drafter of similar amendments, I appeal to the Dáil not to be led astray by any Government supporter in regard to this question.

Comment on this
Martin Conlon Mr. M. CONLON

The position is not altogether clear at the moment. When the Minister spoke earlier in the day I understood from his statement that if the 3 to 5 portion of the section were carried he would bring in on the Report Stage an amendment changing it to a complete one-hour closing. Fortunately I was in the House when he made the second statement. I understand the position now is that if this amendment is carried he would not put forward an amendment confining the closing to one hour. Originally I considered that this closing down was not necessary, and it was a portion of the Bill with which I disagreed, but after hearing the able statement of the Minister on Second Reading and the plea which he made in regard to the long sitter and the possibility of people remaining too long in publichouses, I was converted to the idea that there ought to be split hours. Having been converted to that idea, I thought that the break of two hours would be too long, particularly in the centre of the city, and that one-hour closing would meet the case. As a matter of fact, the Minister pointed out to-day that it would be much easier to carry out the provisions of the law if the arrangement was for a one-hour complete closing. That being the case, I find myself in the position that whether I vote for or against this particular amendment an opportunity will be offered to change it later, if it is carried, to a one-hour complete closing.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

The procedure on Bills is that an amendment defeated in Committee cannot be brought forward again on the Report Stage. There is no definite amendment, as suggested by the Deputy, before the Chair. It will require to be put in writing and submitted to the Ceann Comhairle, who will express an opinion on it. It is, of course, always open to accept on Report an amendment different to one defeated in Committee.

Comment on this

Are we to understand from that ruling, though the motion is that the Bill remain as printed, that that is, in fact, a defeat of the amendment and that this amendment cannot be brought forward on the next stage?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

An amendment defeated on the Committee Stage cannot be brought forward on Report.

Comment on this

My point is that the motion is that the words sought to be deleted remain part of the Bill. That is the motion which will be put to the House, which will appear on the records and which will be accepted or rejected. There is nothing about amendments.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

There is nothing about amendments.

Comment on this

I take it that the printed amendments, inasmuch as they have not been defeated, can be brought forward on Report?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

Yes.

Comment on this

On a point of order, should we not follow this course: that the proposer of the amendment, with the consent of the House, would withdraw it? Otherwise, I submit, that what Deputy Johnson has pointed out is absolutely incontestable; that if the present printed amendment is not withdrawn the House gives a vote in favour of the Bill as drafted; and the amendment is, in fact, negatived and cannot be proposed again at a later stage. It is all very well to get the impression that by agreement we can do it, but the only way to reach such agreement would be by a suspension of Standing Orders.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

If Deputy Heffernan's amendment is defeated now it cannot be brought forward on Report.

Comment on this

My point of order is, that the Ceann Comhairle arranged that instead of debating the amendment we should consider that the motion before the House is that the words of the Bill stand. Therefore, the vote will be on that issue. If on that issue a majority vote carries the wording of the Bill then, in effect, Deputy Heffernan's amendment is negatived and, under the rule of order, cannot be brought forward at a subsequent date.

Comment on this
Martin Conlon Mr. M. CONLON

I understand the motion to be that the 3 to 5 clause stand part of the Bill.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

Yes.

Comment on this
Martin Conlon Mr. M. CONLON

If that be carried it means that the other amendments cannot be moved, but if it is lost they can come forward. I want to make my position clear. I agree with the broken time, but I will vote against this motion so that the Minister will have an opportunity of bringing an amendment forward on the Report Stage making the closing one of one hour.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

There will be no amendemnt before the House, but a different type of amendment may be brought up on Report.

Comment on this

If this particular part of the Bill stands, will the Minister be in order to bring an amendment up on Report?

Comment on this

I do not want to. If the Dáil, voting freely, registers the opinion that the 3 to 5 break should remain part of the provisions of the Bill, I am entirely satisfied. It is a thing which I think ought to stand part of the Bill. If, on the other hand, it is defeated on a free vote, I will bring forward on the Report Stage a proposal that there be a one-hour break and that the provisions with regard to mixed-trading houses be different from the provisions that stood when it was a question of a two-hour break.

Comment on this

"Heads I win, tails you lose."

Comment on this

Is that the proposal which the Minister put before us at the beginning? The proposal he put before us was, as I characterised it, one to avert defeat, that if this were carried he would bring in an amendment on the Report Stage. Now, he has changed his position and says that if the House carries this he is satisfied to let it stand.

Comment on this

That shows exactly the fluctuating mind of the Minister over this proposal.

Comment on this

I think we must endeavour to have a clear understanding about this. As I understand it, the position is that the motion before the House is that the 3 to 5 clause stand part of the Bill. The Minister's undertaking, I understand, is that, if this motion is defeated, he will introduce an amendment providing that the publichouses shall be closed for one hour. I think, in view of the adroit manoeuvres of the Minister, the House should understand that he has violated his promise that the question of split hours be left to a free vote of the Dáil. This is not an open vote. It is an open vote with a stipulation, and I maintain that it is not an honourable or honest parliamentary manoeuvre on the part of the Minister.

Comment on this

That is a very serious charge. Perhaps I may be allowed to say as a matter of personal explanation that my undertaking on the Second Reading was that I would leave the proposal for a break from 3 to 5 to an open vote of the Dáil. That, I believe, is about to take place. If this is eliminated from the Bill then I will bring forward on the Report Stage a proposal for a one-hour break.

Comment on this

Which will not be left to a free vote.

Comment on this

It will not be free, in the sense that if I am defeated on it the Government will resign.

Comment on this

I think we clearly understand where we are now. As far as I am concerned, I am going to put my amendment, or at least I am going to have this sub-section put in the form in which it was intended to be put, and I am going to ask Deputies on the Government Benches to clearly understand the position in which they stand. We were promised an open vote of the House and we are having an open vote with a tail tagged on to it. It is a different class of vote from what we were promised on the Second Reading Stage. That may be regarded by the Minister as clever Party manoeuvring, but I do not regard it as a reasonable or even an honest way of meeting the particular crisis that has arisen in regard to that.

I want to make one or two remarks regarding certain statements by the Minister. He embarked on a platform speech in defence of his attitude, and he took advantage of the opportunity to answer certain statements I made down the country. I would suggest to the Minister that the proper place to answer me is also in the country, and I am sure the Minister is perfectly capable of answering me in the country if he wants to. Instead of that he takes advantage of the House, and in my opinion he went outside the rules of Committee debate in making certain statements. He stated, and I emphatically deny it, that I bestraddled every important principle and issue that came before this House.

Comment on this

May I draw the Deputy's attention to the rules of debate? We are now in Committee.

Comment on this

Draw the Minister's attention to it.

Comment on this

The Minister was allowed to go on.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

It would be better for the Deputy to let the matter rest there now.

Comment on this

The Minister made a certain definite statement in the Dáil, and I maintain that as a matter of personal explanation I am entitled to answer it. He said on every important issue that came before the Dáil I bestraddled the issue. I have no hesitation in saying that statement is a lie.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

The Deputy must withdraw the word "lie." It is not a proper word to use here.

Comment on this

Then I say that it is not true. I would point out, on the question of bestraddling, though the word may be used in a different sense to that in which it was used by the Minister, that as regards bestraddling, or taking both sides of an issue, we have had a clear example of what could be done by the Minister himself regarding the methods used by him in controlling his Party in respect to this Bill. Apart altogether from the question of the Minister's manoeuvring, I maintain we have put forward a reasonable argument in favour of the acceptance of my amendment, and the non-acceptance of the suggestion that the publichouses be closed from 3 to 5. I ask the House to support me; I ask every member of the House not to be misled by the manoeuvring of the Minister; to act on the statement made by the Minister on the Second Reading, and regard this as an open vote and vote accordingly.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

resumed the Chair.

Comment on this

I did not intend to speak on this matter were it not for the explanation of the situation given by the Minister. It is a question as to whether this House can, for the future, accept a statement made by a Minister. On the Second Reading of this Bill the Minister stated that he was prepared to leave this particular section to an absolutely free vote of the House. I suggest, and it is not too strong a word to use after the Minister's explanation of his attitude, and what he proposes to do on the result of this vote, that it is little better than a trick. The Minister tells us that we are to have a free vote on this, but it is a free vote with a big stick over his own Party.

Comment on this

No, the Deputy is wrong.

Comment on this

A free vote, well and good. "If the amendment is defeated I am perfectly satisfied, but if, as a result of the free vote, the amendment is carried, then I am going to bring forward my big stick on the Report Stage, and say to my Party: you vote for that one hour or else there will be a general election." That is the thing in a nutshell.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not want a general election?

Comment on this

I said on a former occasion in reply to a similar question from the President: "I hope you are as easy in your mind about the general election as I am." If it is any information to the Minister I would welcome a general election to-morrow morning, but the fate of the present Bill would not count so far as I personally, or any member of this Party is concerned, one way or the other. As far as I know I would not at any time get more than ten votes from the publicans in the country, and whether I vote for or against the Bill the position would remain the same, so that I am not worried about that. I want to be clear as to whether we can accept a Minister's word in this House. There should be no dissembling about this matter. I say the Minister's attitude on this matter is unworthy of him and unlike him. We are not to have an absolutely free vote of the House. If the Minister were to say it is a free vote, then if the House decides the hours 3 to 5 are to go out of the Bill, let them go out. But he is not going to say that. He promised his own Party, and he told the House, that if the hours 3 to 5 were not left in the Bill he will, on the next stage, make it a matter of confidence that at least one hour will remain. He did not say that on the Second Stage. I suggest that the Minister should think of the House as a whole as well as of his own Party.

Comment on this

Matters are first considered and decided at a Party meeting, and then are presented to the House as accomplished facts—"take them or leave them." It is not what is acceptable to the country but what is acceptable to the Minister's Party—it is a question of expediency. I suggest to the Minister that if he and his Party were in a position to face the country to-morrow there would be an altogether different attitude and frame of mind with regard to this Bill.

Comment on this
A DEPUTY

Undoubtedly.

Comment on this

I am glad to see that there is one member of the Cumann-na-nGaedheal Party who thinks he has a good chance. But I do say that we ought to be clear upon this matter. The Minister has changed his ground considerably. He has shifted his position altogether, in respect of this clause, from the position he took up on Second Reading, and it is little better than a trick to say that it is to be a free vote. It is not to be a free vote, because his Party is told: "If you carry this amendment we will make you vote for at least one hour, or out you go."

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I wonder if we could get general agreement to delete the words "general election" from this debate?

Comment on this

The attitude adopted by the Minister, as stated by the last two speakers, to say the least, is not playing fair by the House. The Minister stated on Second Reading that he would leave the question as to whether there should be closing between the hours of 3 and 5 to a free vote of the House. I understood, I think in common with most Deputies, that what was meant by that was that a vote, if it was to be taken, was to be final and decisive on this question. Certainly that is the way any ordinary person would interpret his pledge. But that is not the position we are in now. The Minister says: "No, if it goes one way, in the direction that I am in favour of, it shall be final, but if it goes the other way it shall not be final, and I shall bring in a further amendment on which I shall ask the members of my Party to obey the crack of the Party Whip." I say that that is not treating the subject or the Dáil fairly. The understanding was—the Minister cannot get away from it—that this question of opening between these hours was to be left to a free vote. Undoubtedly it is not now to be left to a free vote. "Heads I win, tails you lose." That is not my conception of a free expression of opinion. The Minister has now very adroitly manoeuvred himself into the position that if the section as it now stands is passed he will be bound by it and by the decision of the House, but that if it is not passed he will not be bound by the decision of the House. Therefore, it comes to this, that he will not be bound by the free vote of the House in regard to this question. I cannot see how he can get out of that.

Comment on this

I would be bound by every decision of the House, but I do not regard a decision of the House not to have a two-hours break in the day as a decision not to have a one-hour break.

Comment on this

The Minister says that he does not regard a decision on this question of split hours as preventing him from coming along and making a further proposal. That is all very well when the decision goes against him, but if the decision goes in his favour he does regard it as binding. He cannot have it both ways. Will he say, if the decision goes against him, that he will allow the Dáil a free vote upon his suggestion for the one hour closing? I presume he will not do so. He has already stated so. Perhaps he will change his mind again in that respect, but he has already stated that he will not give the Dáil a free vote on the question of one complete hour closing if the decision on this question goes against him.

Comment on this

The Minister could not prevent that. I submit that it is quite within the competence of Deputy Redmond to bring forward an amendment on Report securing a one hour closing in the middle of the day. No question of a charge upon the State would be involved.

Comment on this

Deputy Johnson suggests that if this section is carried in its present form it would be open to myself, or to any other Deputy, on the Report Stage to propose to alter that decision. I am not so sure of that.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

It is quite certain.

Comment on this

So therefore the position we are now in is that if this section is now passed in its present form it is open to anybody, the Minister or otherwise, on a further stage to seek, by way of amendment, to alter that decision. I am very glad to hear that that is the case.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

It would be open to anybody to endeavour to get something less into the Bill, that is, to give something less than two hours— an hour and three-quarters, an hour-and-a-half, or one hour.

Comment on this

I am very glad, indeed, to have that made clear, and I am indebted to Deputy Johnson—because I was not so sure of my ground in that respect—for pointing out that it would be possible for any Deputy, as well as the Minister, to move at a subsequent stage that the decision of the Dáil be altered by way of reducing the closing hours. Be that as it may, the Minister cannot ride away on the quibble that he has endeavoured to put before the House to-night as the means of carrying out the solemn pledge that he gave in his Second Reading speech, that he was prepared to leave to a free vote of the Dáil this question as to whether there should be this two hours' closing or not. I say that he is loading and has loaded the dice in the matter, and that instead of it being a free decision of the House it will be a decision which, no matter what way it goes, he will endeavour to make suit his own particular purpose. I think that that is grossly unfair to the spirit and to the whole system of Ministerial responsibility in this House, and unfair to the House itself. It is inconsistent with anything in the nature of government by responsible men, men who should be responsible for the natural inferences to be drawn from their public statements, and I think it is a pity, from the point of view of the Minister himself, that he has endeavoured to trick the House in this regard. When the time comes to vote on this amendment I hope that every Deputy will realise that what he is voting on is not to decide whether there shall be these opening hours or not, but, in the first place, if the amendment is carried, to give the Minister a further opportunity of making a fresh proposal, and if the amendment is lost, to make the Bill an Act in its original form.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Lest there might be any misconception on the matter, so far as this stage or any further stage of this Bill is concerned, I should like to point out that the Minister is in no better position than any other Deputy from the point of view of moving amendments.

Comment on this

It appears to me that a new point has arisen as a result of the point made by Deputy Johnson and Deputy Redmond; that is, that a private member can move an amendment to alter the decision of the House from two hours to one hour. I am in favour of the one hour closing, and I would ask the Minister, if the two hours closing is carried now, whether there will be a free vote on any amendment by a private Deputy to change that to one hour? I think there would be a good deal less discussion if that point was made clear now.

Comment on this

The Minister has made it clear several times.

Comment on this

I want to have it made clear that if this section is carried it will be on a free vote of the House. It has been stated that later on a private Deputy can put down an amendment for a one hour closing. If any Deputy does so will the Government allow a free vote to be taken on that amendment?

Comment on this

Certainly, as far as I am concerned. I would be rather surprised if the Dáil, having solemnly voted for a two-hour break, were to turn round on the Report Stage and vote to have that reduced to one hour. On the other hand, I would not be surprised—it is a thing I would hope— if the Dáil, having decided that there should not be a two-hours break, were to decide at a later stage of the Bill that there should be a one-hour break.

Comment on this

It is on that point I wanted to get information, because there is a number of Deputies who will vote for a one-hour closing in preference to this two-hours' closing. What we are asked to do now is to close the houses from 3 to 5. A case has been put to me that arises on that point, and we will have no opportunity of putting this point forward if this section is carried. There is a number of licensed houses in Dublin at present doing a luncheon trade. They make provisions and alter their premises in order to do that trade, and they ask that they should be considered in whatever closing hour is agreed upon. It is pointed out that 3 o'clock is rather early to close down houses which have made arrangements to carry on a luncheon trade and that are competing with some of the hotels and restaurants. I think if the Minister would test the feeling of the House on the amendment as regards the two-hour closing, let the one-hour be decided on later on and not fix the closing hour now.

Comment on this

There is no question of a one-hour closing before you now.

Comment on this
Mr. BYRNE

That is the bait that is held out.

Comment on this

I was absent during much of the discussion, and what I have heard is more or less befogging. I am against Deputy Heffernan's amendment, because it provides for no break, and I believe there should be a break. I am, however, against a two-hours break, and I would like to be afforded an opportunity at some stage of this Bill, to vote for a one-hour closing. I intend to vote against Deputy Heffernan's amendment, because I am in total disagreement with it. I am ready to vote for an amendment at a later stage for an hour's break. I might suggest to Deputy Heffernan that he strike a bargain with the Minister and offer to withdraw his amendment, if the Minister said he would himself bring in an amendment providing for an hour's break.

Comment on this
William Norton Mr. NORTON

Deputy Hennessy, apparently, has a very quick and easy way of satisfying his own mind and his desires. He says he will vote against Deputy Heffernan's amendment, which objects to the two-hours closing, but that he will support an hour's closing. But the Minister, who has, no doubt, got a certain responsibility in this matter, states that if Deputy Heffernan's amendment is defeated, Deputy Hennessy is not going to have any opportunity of having a one-hour's closing; the Minister is going to regard this as a final and decisive vote. How Deputy Hennessy, in face of that fact, can console himself, passes my comprehension. I suggest he should put down an amendment himself, and I hope he will have more enthusiasm for it than he has now.

I voted for the Second Reading of the Bill largely because of the fact that I am convinced—and nothing has happened in the meantime to change my conviction—that there are too many publichouses in the country and that a much lesser number of publichouses would satisfy legitimate public demands, but I indicated then that I was not satisfied with the Bill as it stood. I took objection to certain phases of the Bill, and this is one of them. I intend to vote for the amendment, but in doing so I want to say that I am not in the slightest way influenced by the propaganda carried on by an interested party. I am considering the matter from the point of view of the man in the street.

I listened to the case the Minister had to make for the 3 to 5 closing in the county boroughs. He talked on the Second Reading of the "long sitter," but we got no evidence as to what numbers of "long sitters" exist. We got no police statistics to show that a 3 to 5 closing was absolutely desirable or that it was essential from any point of view. The Minister proposes that this 3 to 5 closing should only take place in certain cities, but that elsewhere, where the need may be greater, there is to be no 3 to 5 closing. In making an exception in certain cases one would expect him to prove the need for the 3 to 5 closing in those other places.

The Minister has made no case as to why there should be a 3 to 5 closing in the exempted cities. It seems to me —and I think it is the view of those engaged in the business—that a 3 to 5 closing will not only be an inconvenience to the ordinary man in the street—and I am more concerned about him than anybody else—but that in addition it will mean a certain amount of unemployment in the trade. Such a closing does not necessarily mean that the employees will get off from 3 to 5. It may mean that, although they are not engaged attending at the bar, they will be utilised for some other kind of work, and in that way a publican, who now employs a staff of five or six, may find that he can do with one less. That, together with the fact that I cannot personally observe any particular abuse of publichouses between 3 and 5, induces me to declare that I intend to vote for the amendment.

Comment on this
Division

Question put—"That the words ‘between the hours of 3 o'clock and 5 o'clock in the afternoon' stand part of sub-section (1) (a)."

Tá 44
·
Níl 42
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move:—

In sub-section (1) (a) to insert after the word "evening," line 32, the words "provided that, in the case of premises licensed only for the sale of intoxicating liquor to be consumed off the premises, nothing in this sub-section shall restrict the sale of intoxicating liquor between the hours of three o'clock and five o'clock in the afternoon on any day on which the premises are closed at or before six o'clock in the evening."

I find myself in strong support of the Minister in his wish to restrict the hours of opening of licensed premises, yet I am in the position of having to propose an amendment which has the apparent purpose of going against that. But I think a little explanation will make the discrepancy clear. I do not think that in the wording of the Bill the position of the person who has what is called an off-licence has been fully considered. My attention has been drawn to the fact that if the wording of the Bill were adhered to certain houses, that deal in intoxicating liquor, but have no licence for consumption on the premises, and that are only entitled to sell for consumption off the premises, and do not keep open except between the hours of 10 and 5 o'clock—seldom as late as 6 o'clock—would be very seriously affected. In their case the restriction on an eleven-hour day is already in operation. They are only as a rule selling for eight hours per day. If the further restriction were to be applicable to them—namely, that they could not open between 3 and 5—it would mean that they could only carry on their business between the hours of 10 and 3—that is to say, that business would be restricted to a five-hour day. I do not think that is intended. I have no feeling that the words I have suggested will actually be the words which will be adopted, but in all probability the Minister will be prepared to consider the case I have cited and see whether he really wished to deal with these premises in this way, so as to reside strict their hours to that extent. In actual operation it would mean that these places of business would have every day in the week a half-holiday. Even if they keep open at present from 10 to 6, if they had to close down between 3 and 5, it would probably mean that they would not open for the extra hour after 5 o'clock. Whether they could carry on with this constant half-day in the regular course of things is doubtful. All I want to secure is to get an undertaking from the Minister that he will look into the matter very closely between this and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will look at line 10, page 4, of the Bill, in the definitions, he will see that "licensed premises" there is defined to mean, except in part 4 of the Act, "premises in respect of which a licence for the sale, by retail, of intoxicating liquor has been granted and is in force." As I said a while ago, for a long time, since 1872, there have been no particular prohibited hours prescribed for wholesalers. The retailer, the person with the off-licence, as it is called, has been in a different position, and in the Bill it is proposed that the closing that applies to the ordinary licensed houses shall apply also to the off-licences—that drink be not sold there during these hours. It is not unlikely that without that provision one result might be, that you would have people buying drink from the off-licence holders and drinking it round the streets or in the lanes during the hours in which other premises are closed. If there are special cases, if there are cases in which a distinction can reasonably be drawn, that is a matter that I would be prepared to look into. At the moment you take the three divisions—the wholesaler, the off-licence retailer, and the on-licence retailer; I would not be prepared to say that during the hours which the on-licence retailer is compelled to close, or at any rate, close the licensed portion of his premises, as in the case of a mixed trading house, under the Bill, as it stands, the off-licence holder should be free to sell drink. Consequently the licensed premises mentioned there in line 10 are premises in respect of which a licence for the sale by retail of intoxicating liquor has been granted and all these premises, "on and off," are covered by the provisions of Section 2. If the Deputy can make a case against that, it is something I am prepared to consider, but that is our position under the Bill as it stands.

Comment on this

I am not sure that the Minister has fully apprehended the purposes of this amendment. It is intended to apply only to cases of large wine merchants who sell by retail in bulk. I think in most cases their licences are so limited that they cannot sell less than a dozen bottles of spirits or wine.

These people carry on business within strictly limited hours. There are very few of them open after 5 p.m. It would almost mean paralysis to their business if this provision were inserted in the Bill.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy quite sure that these are not wholesalers?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

They are retailers. I am speaking of firms like Mitchell's and Thompson, D'Olier & Co. I know, because I buy from them by retail myself. I have bought from them one or two dozen bottles of wine at a time. The arrangement proposed in this section will be intensely inconvenient, because they will have to keep their premises closed altogether during this time. A great deal of their trade is done, I am sure, in the country. They have to despatch the wine to the country. I am not a lawyer and the Minister is. Perhaps he would tell us the position as regards delivery. These firms deliver by motor van in the suburbs. Is delivery part of the sale? This question would be a very important one in connection with delivery by motor van. Would these vans have to come back during those hours?

Comment on this

Delivery has been held not to be part of the sale.

Comment on this

There is a case for those firms who retail in considerable quantities and who are not in any sense competitors with ordinary licensees. Perhaps the Minister could arrange the matter with representatives of these firms before the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Delivery is not sale, nor is it any essential part of sale. That has been held.

Comment on this

It seems to me to be an important part of sale.

Comment on this

It may be, but technically, the sale has taken place prior to that and delivery would not be covered by the prohibition. The taking of orders over the 'phone, as between these hours, would be a different matter.

Comment on this

Would the receipt of an order by post be regarded as sale?

Comment on this

The point of sale is the point at which the goods are appropriated to the buyer. If there are difficulties arising under that section, they are difficulties which eminently require investigation between this and the Report Stage. Possibly, the most satisfactory course would be if these people or their representatives came in and discussed their position with me in the Department. The Deputy mentioned that these people are not allowed to sell less than a particular quantity——

Comment on this

I understand that is the case. I once ordered a small quantity and they told me that they could not sell so small a quantity.

Comment on this

I wonder whether that is a matter of practice or whether it is connected with their legal position? I am clear that wholesalers are not covered by the section. The section does cover, and was intended to cover, the off-licence holder. If these people are simply off-licence holders on a larger scale, that certainly is a difficulty. But it is a difficulty I am prepared to discuss in a reasonable spirit with them or their representatives.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied with that. I will withdraw the amendment, with the leave of the Committee.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, Deputy Thrift's amendment covers the cases of off-licence sales on a small scale. If, in the cause of temperance, it be arranged that from 2 to 5 in the afternoon drink is not procurable for consumption on the premises, it will be open always for those who seek to have drink during those hours to have recourse to the house with the off-licence and to buy sufficient stock to drink at home or elsewhere, so that the acceptance of the amendment, precisely as it stands, will not make for the cause of temperance. On the contrary, it will conduce to a particular form of intemperance which is very difficult to eradicate. There is a case, undoubtedly, for the type of trader that Deputy Cooper has in mind, but, then, it requires very careful drafting, so that a door shall not be opened for a form of traffic which would be very deleterious.

Comment on this

The amendment is not being accepted. It has been withdrawn.

Comment on this

If Deputy Magennis had heard what I said, he would have understood that I laid no stress on the form of the amendment. It was drawn for the purpose of directing the Minister's attention to this point, so that he might consider it.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The question that arises on these amendments is the question of opening hour in the morning—whether it should be 10 o'clock as proposed in the Bill, or 8 o'clock as suggested by Deputy Lyons, or 9 o'clock as Deputy Redmond suggests. I think we ought to take that question, as to the morning hour on Saturdays only, first, unless the decision as to 10 o'clock for the other days is taken to cover this.

Comment on this

As far as I am concerned, the House having come to the decision that on an ordinary week-day the hour shall be 10 o'clock in the morning in the future instead of 9 o'clock, as at present, I do not intend to press the point upon the House in regard to Saturday. If it is justifiable to have a 10 o'clock opening in regard to any other week-day, it is justifiable in regard to Saturday. I do not admit it is justifiable in either case.

Comment on this

I am concerned about Saturday more than any other day of the week. A number of speeches dealt with this matter of opening hours. Notwithstanding the fact that Deputy Redmond's amendment was defeated, I think there is still hope that the licensed trade in the country should be allowed to open an hour earlier on Saturdays than on the other week days.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

This amendment refers to county boroughs, not country districts, and concerns Saturdays only.

Comment on this

This trade gives a good deal of employment. If work is not started until 10 o'clock these shops will not be able to supply their customers before 11 o'clock. It would take an hour to get these places ready for business. If houses cannot be opened until 10 o'clock on Saturdays it will be 11 o'clock before any business is done. I want the Minister to give some concession to people who are contributing so largely to the revenue of the country, to enable them to continue to do so. I think it is only right that licensed premises should be allowed to open for the sale of intoxicating drink, and for the necessaries of life from 8 o'clock in the morning. Take the case of a grocer's shop where bacon or sugar is sold, or the case of a green grocer. These premises can be opened at 7 o'clock in the morning, and there is no legislation to stop them, although they do not contribute to the revenue in anything like the same proportion as the licensed trade. I hope the Minister will have some consideration for those in the licensed trade, so that they may be allowed to open at eight o'clock on Saturdays. If a man is a mixed trader he will be unable to sell tea, sugar, wine, tobacco or bacon, until nine o'clock. While there is provision in Section 3 for mixed trading, I am asking that the opening hour should be made 8 o'clock on Saturday.

Comment on this

I do not propose to accept the amendment, that licensed premises should be enabled to open at 8 o'clock on Saturday. I do not see any reason why they should open any earlier on Saturdays than on other days. The Dáil has taken the view that 10 o'clock is sufficiently early for licensed premises to open for the sale and consumption on the premises of intoxicating liquor. In Section 3 there is a proposal to mitigate that to the extent of allowing houses that do a mixed business to open at 9 o'clock, so that between 9 and 10 a.m. the non-licensed portion only of the business may be carried on. In Section 3, sub-section (1) (a) and (b), that provision is made for county boroughs and for urban county districts. I will have a word to say later on Section 3, sub-section 1, and these divisions, where the 9 to 10 facility is given for mixed houses. Dealing now only with county boroughs as covered by Section 2, sub-section 1, I see no case whatever for the Deputy's amendment that licensed premises should open at 8 o'clock on Saturdays, giving incidentally on Saturday, according to the terms of the Bill, over 12 hours of a drinking day. I oppose the amendment.

Comment on this

I would like to say that I am not putting this amendment forward on the instructions of any traders. I put it forward because I consider, as a working man, that it is necessary to have such places open on Saturday a couple of hours earlier than on other week-days. The Bill specifies that Saturday is not to be taken as an ordinary week-day. Saturday is a day on which a large number of people come to the city. Some of them arrive by the 7.30 train in the morning after having, perhaps, travelled most of the night. They cannot get refreshments on arrival unless they can afford to go to hotels. It is not every person can afford to do that and to pay the prices charged in hotels. The Minister should, at least, have some consideration for the ordinary people who come to the cities on Saturday mornings and enable them to get refreshments.

Question—"That the word ‘ten' stand part of the sub-section"—put and declared carried.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The next amendment, No. 5, dealing with the question of a break on Saturday, now arises. What is the intention about that?

Comment on this

We have now taken a decision by a great majority in favour of split hours on week-days. But the matter is not ended there. As we have learned it is open to any Deputy to move a subsequent amendment reducing these closing hours on week-days, and I presume the same will obtain with regard to Saturdays. We have also the assurance of the Minister for Justice that it will be left to the free vote of the House. In view of these considerations I do not intend to advance any argument on the question of split hours on Saturdays.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

We will take it that this amendment is not moved, and leave the question of Saturdays open for next stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment 8:—

In sub-section (1) (b), line 36, to delete the words "half-past nine" and substitute therefor the word "ten."

I am sure that the Minister for Justice will realise that 9.30 on Saturday nights is rather an unreasonable hour to close the houses.

I am not an advocate of drunkenness, and it is not from that point of view that I am moving this amendment. If I had my way I would like to see everyone in the country temperate. In my opinion, closing publichouses on a Saturday night at 9.30 will not mean promoting temperance. I think it will have the contrary effect, because a labouring man obliged to remain at home while his wife is out shopping will not be able to get a drink if he goes out on her return. If the publichouses are closed, or on the point of closing, what he will do is to take a half gallon or a half-dozen of stout to his home and consume it there. I think it would be far better if the publichouses were open until 10 o'clock, and let him consume his drink there rather than in his own home in the presence of his children The Minister is not preventing the capitalist from getting drunk on a Saturday night at 9.30. He can get drink in his club. What I complain of is that workers are prevented from getting a drink on a Saturday night by this 9.30 closing. If the Minister ever had to live in a small house he would be aware of all the jobs that the woman of the house has to do on a Saturday night. The husband, as a rule, goes out when she is doing her work, and where is he to go to if he has not the publichouse? In most cases the publichouse is the drawing-room of the ordinary worker. In these circumstances I think it would be better if the publichouses were allowed to remain open until 10 o'clock, because it would mean that men would not be taking home drink with them. I hope the Minister will accept my amendment.

Comment on this

Deputy Lyons has made an admirable case for early closing. If we are to accept his picture of life among the working classes, then we must regard him as a sort of Irish Maxim Gorki. He has given us a lurid picture of their debased and degraded form of living. I refuse to accept his account as a true picture, that unless we allow a working man to remain for prolonged hours in publichouses on Saturday nights the only alternative is that he should go home and be a nuisance.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy any experience in the matter?

Comment on this

I am merely considering from an outsider's point of view the situation as depicted by our novelist, Deputy Lyons. If the working man is not allowed to remain soaking in liquor in the publichouse, then he will buy quarts or gallons—I do not know which he said—of drink to bring home with him, and he will teach the young idea how to shoot, or, rather, how to drink. Could any evidence be stronger in favour of the temperance crusade than what Deputy Lyons brings forward? Does he not conceive it possible to have temperance halls or some form of decent recreation for working class people in the county boroughs? He has an idea also of class equality.

As an upholder of democracy he believes the workman must be conceded the privilege of getting drunk because those who are wealthy have facilities for it in their clubs. That is a most extraordinary form of reasoning. I am afraid the Deputy is over-impressed with the old saying "drunk as a lord," so that he conceives drunkenness is a privilege, and that there is class inequality unless facilities are provided for the poor as well as the rich. He does not understand that the whole purport of this legislation is to renew the conditions of life in the country and provide for standards of decent living, to try and force those who are not willing to live a proper life to conform to the requirements of society.

Comment on this

A county like Donegal is rather an extraordinary county. The Minister for Finance knows it very well. In connection with this question of extending the hours it would suit us if you allow us from 1 to 8 or 9 instead of from 1 to 7.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I cannot hear the Deputy very well, but this does not either concern Donegal or 8 o'clock closing in the evening.

Comment on this

Deputy Magennis tries to make out that I believe the home of the worker should be saturated in alcohol or that the worker is a perpetual drunkard.

Comment on this

Or a domestic nuisance.

Comment on this

There are more domestic nuisances among professors than among the ordinary working men. I did not put forward this amendment with the intention of degrading the ordinary worker, whom I represent. 9.30 on Saturday night is not at all suitable to the average working man. If Deputy Magennis is lucky enough to be a member of the Kildare Street Club and can get a drink up to 11 o'clock on a Saturday night, the men I represent have not the privilege of being members of such a club. I sin cerely hope that if they could they would not become members. I do not agree with Deputy Magennis that this amendment degrades the worker and makes him a drunkard. It is well known to every Deputy that if liquor is taken home by anyone children in the house are going to get some of it. I am speaking of Dublin, not of Mullingar. I want to prevent that. I want such an individual to be able to get drink until 10 o'clock on Saturday night, and I want to prevent him taking home intoxicating liquor. If he partakes of the beverage before his children those children will long for the taste of the particular form of alcohol that the parent is interested in. If you do not allow the publichouse to be open till 10 o'clock then prevent the aristocrat from having a shebeen in his own house. Furthermore, close down clubs such as the Kildare Street Club, and others, not catering for the interests of the working classes.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I am putting the question that the words "nine-thirty" stand in the Bill.

Comment on this

I should like to ask you and Deputy Lyons to allow amendment No. 10 to be taken before 9.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I am not clear as to what amendment No. 9 means. It proposes to delete paragraph (c) and substitute a new paragraph, and the new paragraph, substituted, appears to make no provision for any closing hour on Sunday and St. Patrick's Day. Therefore the proposal is that the publichouses should be open from 1 o'clock until midnight.

Comment on this

I have to attend an important meeting at Mullingar to-morrow and I wish to finish the amendment now.

Comment on this

I am agreeable.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Deputy Lyons will not move amendment 9, I take it, but will postpone it until the next stage?

Comment on this

No, I do not mean that.

Comment on this

I could get through amendment 10 in ten minutes and could then get away.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Is the Deputy seriously going to put before the Committee that there should be no closing hour on Sundays and St. Patrick's Day? Considering the Bill itself contains a provision for closing publichouses on ordinary week days and Saturdays, is he going to propose an amendment containing no closing hour on St. Patrick's Day and Sundays? The Deputy is strictly within his rights, but moving the amendment sounds very like waste of the Committee's time.

Comment on this

I do not want to waste time. I withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Deputy can reconsider the amendment for a later stage.

Comment on this

I put this amendment down entirely with reference to the bona fide traveller.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

If so, it is in the wrong place. We can discuss it later, on the bona fide section.

Amendment 9.—In sub-section (1) to delete paragraph (c) and substitute a new paragraph as follows:—

"(c) on any Sunday or St. Patrick's Day before the hour of one in the afternoon, or."

Not moved.

Comment on this

The effect of amendment 10 is obvious. It reads:—

In sub-section (2), page 4, line 42, after the word "district" to insert the words "or town," and in line 43, after the word "which" to insert the words "district or town."

The effect of the amendment would be that towns like Mullingar, which has a population of 5,345, would be put on the same footing as urban districts. Obviously the population there is going up, but, under the form of local government under which the town is managed, it would not get the benefit that would be given to an urban council. I daresay the Minister will accept that amendment.

Comment on this

I am prepared to accept this amendment, because, as the Deputy says, the thing that matters is the basis of population. The basis of discrimination is the population, not the exact technical local government administration of the town. I do not want particularly to know why Mullingar, with a population of over 5,000 is not urbanised. It seems to me the difference as between having an urban council or town commission need not be the basis of discrimination against it in the matter of the division the town falls into. In this Bill it is really a division aiming at being based on population. I am prepared to accept the Deputy's amendment without any curiosity as to why they have not an urban council in Mullingar.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I take it these two amendments are governed by the previous decision.

Comment on this

I suppose so.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

That disposes of amendments 11 and 12.

Amendment 13.—In sub-section (2) (b), line 51, to delete the word "ten" and substitute therefor the word "nine"—Deputy Redmond.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Is not amendment 13 again the same thing— the question of opening hours?

Comment on this

In regard to amendments 12 and 13 over my name, I do not intend to occupy the House or to press them, beyond stating that the urban districts or towns are in even a stronger position than the county boroughs in regard to the proposed curtailment of hours, because there are people coming into these towns in early hours in the morning who might possibly not be bona fide travellers. They might not have travelled the requisite distance, and to make the hour ten in the morning instead of nine for these districts is, I submit, even a greater curtailment than in regard to county boroughs. I presume, however, that the Minister will adopt the same attitude in regard to these. I do not think it will be necessary for me to press the matter, except to point out with regard to towns which are not county boroughs that ten o'clock in the morning will certainly be inconvenient to some people who may have to enter the towns from distances which would not render them bona fide travellers.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Amendment 13 deals with Saturday mornings in these particular places.

Comment on this

That is what I was going to say.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Amendment 14 deals with the hour of closing on Saturday in urban districts and towns with a population of over 5,000.

Comment on this

I think this amendment refers only to urban areas.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Yes, this amendment only refers to closing hours on Saturdays in urban areas. Is the Deputy accepting the previous decision?

Comment on this

I suggest the Minister should add the words "during the summer period."

Comment on this

Is the Deputy standing strictly on his amendment?

Comment on this

If the Deputy will withdraw his amendment I will consider it between this and the Report Stage. I would not consider the amendment, but I would consider the proposed half-hour extension confined to the summer period.

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied. Will I have the right to bring that forward again?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Yes.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 15:—

In sub-section (2) to delete paragraph (c) and substitute two new paragraphs as follows:—

(c) on any Sunday before the hour of 1 o'clock in the afternoon, or after the hour of 5 o'clock in the afternoon, or

(d) at any time on Christmas Day, Good Friday, or St. Patrick's Day.

I am asking that publichouses be opened on Sundays from one until five. That would be four hours. If I am allowed to correct it, I would ask to have the opening hours from 1 to 3 o'clock and from 5 to 7, for the following reasons:—From 1 to 3 would suit the agricultural community coming out from last Mass. They could go and have any refreshment they needed in the village, or do any other business they liked in the publichouse. From 5 to 7 would suit hurling or football matches. I am moving this amendment conditional on the 3 mile limit being defeated.

If I could anticipate that the three mile limit will not be allowed to stand, then I think we are entitled to some consideration in the country. A man who is working all the week, and who has to travel three miles to get reasonable refreshment, should be given some consideration. I ask the Minister, if he has made up his mind not to allow us the three mile limit, to consider granting the four hours opening that I am seeking. I understand the Minister would be disposed to give three hours, say from 2 to 5. The difference would not be much. The Minister, I know, is against a long sitting.

Comment on this

In the Dáil?

Comment on this

No, in the publichouse. If the publichouses are open from 1 to 3 and from 5 to 7 it will accommodate the people who may want to do business in the villages, and who may be anxious to meet one another and have an interchange of opinion. By opening from 5 to 7 there will be no such thing as looking for special licences for football matches and other things. All these things cost money. I ask the Minister to consider whether this would not be a good substitute for the three-mile limit, the bona fide traveller difficulty, or the six-mile limit.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

A number of questions arise for decision. The first is, shall there be an opening for any period on Sundays, and, if so, for what period? Then again, shall there be an opening on St. Patrick's Day, and, if so, for what period? I suggest that to get a decision on the first matter, namely, shall there be an opening at any period on Sundays, the first question put should be: "In Section 2 (2) (c) that the words "at any time on any Sunday" should stand. If these words stand, that disposes of any opening on any Sunday. If these words are deleted, the question of what kind of opening on Sundays will be allowed, can be decided. The same will apply with regard to St. Patrick's Day. In order to get a decision as to whether there shall be any opening at any time on Sunday, I will simply put the question: Section 2 (2) (c) that the words "at any time on any Sunday stand." If that is decided in the affirmative, the question of whether they will open on Sundays does not arise at all. The same will apply to St. Patrick's Day. That will dispose of not only Deputy Daly's amendment, but also of amendment 16, which raises the same point, namely, shall there be any opening on Sundays or St. Patrick's Day.

Comment on this

The difficulty is to discuss this proposal apart from the question of the bona fide traffic, which is dealt with in another portion of the Bill. As I said on Second Reading, Sunday is the most difficult day of all to legislate for in this matter of the sale and consumption of intoxicating drink. When we come to the bona fide traffic provisions, I am prepared to listen very attentively and give every consideration to the views that may be expressed from any portion of the House. I am not entirely satisfied with the provisions of the Bill on that question. I am not conscious of any great conviction as to the merits of the proposals, while recognising that it is very hard to find any ideal regulations for that day, and that there is great diversity of view amongst the general public on the matter.

The proposal of Deputy Daly is to have a limited opening in the larger towns. I am not prepared to consider any extension at all of the facilities that exist in the four county boroughs except on a basis of complete abolition of the bona fide traffic. I think it is impossible to discuss the two things apart. I do not want to be understood as saying that, conditional on a complete abolition of the bona fide traffic, I would agree to this extension throughout the State of the 2 to 5 facilities that exist in Dublin, Cork and the other two cities. If there is a substantial volume of opinion in the Dáil in favour of that course, it is something that should be very carefully considered.

The bona fide business is, and has been for a long time, the subject of well-merited condemnation, and the proposal to shift the distance is not really a solution in any degree at all. It has the effect, no doubt, of wiping out one set of vested interests and creating another set of vested interests further on. In so far as it leans against anyone, it leans against the pedestrian, who is, perhaps, the most genuine traveller of the lot, and it makes no substantial difference whatever to the man who travels by train, motor car, motor bicycle, or by the popular bus, which is an increasing feature of the landscape. Therefore, while I put down these provisions in the Bill bearing on the question of Sunday, I am receptive to any reasonable suggestion with regard to that day. I will not consider an extension of such facilities as exist in four of the cities at present, except on the basis of the disappearance, root and branch, of the bona fide traffic. I would not accept, in any ease, the hours which Deputy Daly inserts in his amendment, and my attitude on it now is simply to ask the Dáil to reject it. The entire matter of Sunday trading can be considered when we come to the portion of the Bill dealing with bona fide traffic.

Comment on this

I agree with what the Minister has stated, but I appeal to him to let my amendment stand, or to put me in the position that I can bring the matter forward again on the Report Stage. I would be in a better position to do so then, as I will know the fate of the bona fide traveller. Bearing in mind that I will be at liberty to bring the matter forward on the Report Stage, I ask leave to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

If the Deputy withdraws his amendment he will be in the same position on the Report Stage as he is now. By withdrawing his amendment now, he is preserving his rights to bring the matter up on Report.

Comment on this

May I be at liberty to remind so old a Deputy as Deputy Daly that for years and years and for generations there was a long-sustained fight in Great Britain and Ireland against Sunday opening? The Sunday closing movement was one of the most enthusiastic movements for social reform and it triumphed. I protest, if there is no other voice but mine to protest, against undoing all that social reform and bringing in an amendment sanctioning the opening of publichouses on Sundays.

Comment on this

I am at a loss to know the position of Deputy Magennis this evening. At one time he is attacking the Ministry, and at another time he is attacking the licensed trade. I am between them.

Comment on this

I regret I was not in the Dáil during the discussion on the earlier paragraph. Had I been here, I would have raised a word of protest against the proposal that for the county boroughs St. Patrick's Day should be an open day. I enter the same protest against the proposal in any other sub-section of this section, or in any amendment where it is suggested that there should be retrogression in regard to St. Patrick's Day. Probably, at a later stage, I shall be able to move an amendment to that effect.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I take it that amendment 15 is withdrawn.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

And so much of amendment 16 as concerns Sunday is also withdrawn?

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied.

Comment on this

What about amendment 17?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

That, I take it, is consequential to the other?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Amendment 17 is agreed.

Ordered—"That progress be reported."

Comment on this