We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

INTOXICATING LIQUOR BILL, 1927—COMMITTEE STAGE (RESUMED).

Contributions 1–120 of 227. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Intoxicating Liquor Bill 1927
Enacted

No. 7 of 1927 ›

Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The object of amendment 18, as before us, is simply to leave the position as at present under the existing law. Amendment 19 has a slightly different purpose. I propose to take the amendments as before and decide the question of the morning opening first. After the decision taken yesterday afternoon the morning hour is now deemed to be settled at 10 o'clock, and we can, I suggest, proceed to discuss the other question on Section 2, sub-section (3) (ii). On Section 2, sub-section (3) (ii) the question of the opening hour in the morning arises again on the amendment of Deputy Lyons to make the hour half-past eight. A similar amendment has already been defeated for other areas. I take it we will pass that over. The next question that arises is the closing hour during the non-summer time period, which is nine o'clock in the Bill. Deputy Heffernan has down an amendment to make it ten. We will take that amendment now if it is moved.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

That brings us down to the question of the hours on Saturdays. I think the only question that arises on that sub-section is whether half-past eight in sub-section (3) (b) (ii) should not be made half-past nine or ten. Deputy Redmond is not moving his amendment. That brings us down to sub-section (3) (b) (ii). There is an amendment to make the hour of closing ten o'clock instead of half-past eight.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

Are you passing over amendment No. 26?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

No, I have just reached amendment 26. Deputy Egan can now move that amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

I move:—

In sub-section (3) (b) (ii), page 5, line 17, to delete the word "eight" and substitute the word "nine."

The effect of the amendment is to have the hour of closing 9.30 instead of 8.30. The hour proposed in the Bill is rather early in view of the fact that people may live some distance outside a town and they may desire to purchase other goods. A great many country districts keep what they call old time, which makes it still more difficult.

Comment on this

This amendment deals with the period of the year other than summer time, so that the question of a variation in the rural time from the time that is kept in the towns does not arise. I would not be prepared to accept the Deputy's amendment. I have given a good deal of consideration to it. I recognise that people working up to six o'clock in the country who require to get into town before half-past eight might be somewhat rushed. I would meet the Deputy to the extent of half an hour, but I would not accept his amendment as it stands. I would bring in an amendment on Report to meet him half way in his amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

I am quite satisfied with that.

Comment on this

Would I be in order in making a suggestion to the Minister in regard to line 5 in this section?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I think when the whole section is eventually before the Committee Deputy McBride will be in order, but at the moment we are only discussing the details.

Comment on this

It would be a very great convenience to country people if the hours proposed in the Bill were changed from 9 to 9 instead of from 10 to 10. I think it would have just the same effect, if not a better effect than the arrangement proposed in the Bill. People coming to fairs require to be accommodated.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

That question will arise later.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The agreement made yesterday with regard to previous amendments governs amendment No. 27. That is, therefore, to be postponed to the Report Stage.

Comment on this

There is no occasion to repeat what I have already said in regard to this section, but I would be glad if the Minister would agree to my suggestion to change the hour from 10 in the morning and 10 in the evening to 9 in the morning and 9 in the evening.

Comment on this

I would not. I think 10 o'clock is quite early enough to commence the sale and consumption of intoxicating liquor, but I am prepared on Section 3 to consider whether paragraph (b), instead of being confined to urban areas, should not operate elsewhere, that is to consider whether the house that does a mixed business might not be allowed to open at 9 o'clock for the non-licensed portion of its business, the licensed portion commencing at 10 o'clock. Deputy McBride and others may say it is a hardship on a house with this mixed business—grocery and so on—not to be able to sell its groceries to the early caller who may be coming along about the hour of 9 o'clock and be compelled to keep closed until 10. We have considered in the Department whether it would not be reasonable to extend the facilities set out in paragraphs (a) and (b) of Section 3, sub-section (1), throughout the State, and we can discuss that when we come to it. On the question of drink only, I am not prepared to advance the hour earlier than 10 a.m.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Amendments 33 and 34 seek to effect the same thing. Amendment 34 is the better one.

Comment on this

I move amendment 34:—

In sub-section (1) (b), page 5, lines 51 to 53, to delete all words from the words "in an urban county district" to the words "the last census" and to substitute therefor the word "elsewhere."

I gathered from the observations of the Minister a few moments ago that he accepts the spirit of this amendment, that is to say, there would be permission to sell non-intoxicants.

Comment on this

I accept more than the spirit of the amendment; I think the form of it is all right and I accept it.

Comment on this

Is the Minister in doing that weakening on the point of having the mixed houses separated?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

This is a question of area pure and simple—"elsewhere" in the State.

Comment on this

This rapid progress is rather making some of us giddy. Am I to understand that the section, as amended, differentiates between the four county boroughs of Dublin, Cork, Waterford and Limerick and the whole of the rest of the country? I think we should have it clear in our minds if it does.

Comment on this

Section 3 says:—

(1) Where any business other than the sale of intoxicating liquor (in this section referred to as non-licensed business) is carried on in any licensed premises and the portion of such premises in which such non-licensed business is carried on is not structurally separated from the remainder of such premises, the opening or keeping open of such premises for the purpose of carrying on such non-licensed business shall for the purposes of this Act be deemed to be an opening or keeping open of such premises for the sale of intoxicating liquor, save and except—

(a) in a county borough, on week days between the hours of nine o'clock and ten o'clock in the morning and between the hours of three o'clock and five o'clock in the afternoon."

And as I propose, in accepting Deputy Egan's amendment:

"and elsewhere between the hours of nine o'clock and ten o'clock in the morning on week days."

The net effect of that is this, that whereas we are not prepared to allow a publichouse to do its licensed business before 10 a.m., we are prepared to allow a mixed house, whether in a county borough or elsewhere, to open an hour earlier for the non-licensed portion of its business, lest it be said that we are unduly handicapping the man who has a grocery trade as well as a licensed trade as against his competitor. We will allow him to open at 9, and there will be one hour in which he will be expected to conduct only his non-licensed business.

Comment on this

I use that word advisedly. If the expectation proves unsound, there will be certain consequences to the individual trader.

Comment on this

He would rather keep shut.

Comment on this

In that connection, if there is question on Report of an alteration of the two hours' broken day in the county boroughs to one hour, there will also be question of an alteration in sub-section (1) (a) of Section 3, because what I want to have is a completely closed one hour for mixed houses.

Comment on this

Am I right in thinking that an establishment like Findlaters will be allowed to open for the sale of groceries at 9 a.m., but will not be allowed to sell wine or beer until 10 a.m., and will be allowed to sell groceries between 3 and 5 p.m., or with any altered hours that may be inserted later in the Bill, be allowed to keep open for the sale of groceries, but not for the sale of intoxicating liquor?

Comment on this

The Deputy is right about the morning; he may be wrong about the mid-day, because the two hours' broken period in the day leaves the mixed house open for the non-licensed portion of its business; but if there is question of one hour, then that one hour will have to be a completely closed one hour for the mixed house.

Comment on this

As the Bill stands at present I am right?

Comment on this

In reference to the matter of opening of mixed houses, in my constituency nearly all the licensed houses do a mixed trade. Will there not be considerable difficulty in enforcing the law if they are allowed to open at 9 a.m. for the sale of goods other than intoxicating liquor? Would not it be much better to have a 9 to 9 opening, so that there would not be any chance of a mistake in the matter?

Comment on this

Perhaps I can clear the Deputy's mind by suggesting that, according to the present arrangements—and I think they are temporary —a person will be entitled to sell bananas during those hours, but not "Baby Powers."

Comment on this

Will a club like a golf club come under this section, or are there special rules with reference to clubs? Very often on the licensed portion of the premises they carry on other business to a certain extent.

Comment on this

It is not a licensed premises. It is a registered club as distinct from a licensed premises.

Comment on this

Only licensed in respect of registration?

Comment on this

Technically, for the purpose of our discussion on this Bill, a club is not a licensed premises. We will come to clubs presently in Part V.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that there is no excessive drinking in golf clubs?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

That will arise later.

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain what will be the position of a mixed business house where there is just one door and one counter, the grocery portion, perhaps, being nearest the door and the licensed portion further up? Would a customer be on the licensed premises if he were purchasing groceries, and would that be an offence under this section?

Comment on this

He can be there under this section.

Comment on this

It is not an offence?

Comment on this

During that 9 to 10 hour the trader is expected not to do any licensed business, and if he does, and is detected in doing it, legal penalties will follow.

Comment on this

It is a pious aspiration.

Comment on this

I have a much better opinion of the licensed trade than many of the opponents of the Bill.

Comment on this

Can the licensed trader sell intoxicating liquor during those prohibited hours for the purpose of taking away?

Comment on this

I move:

In sub-section (1) at the end of the sub-section to add the following words: "and such general exemption order may be granted for a period of one year or any lesser period."

The purpose of this amendment is really to save inconvenience and possible cost. I do not think it can be suggested that there is anything controversial in this point; perhaps it is the only amendment in the Bill that is not controversial. According to the section, as it stands, the Justice of a District Court may make an order exempting licensed holders from the provisions of the Act relating to prohibited hours on such days, during such times, and on such terms as may be specified in such order. The purpose of my amendment is that the District Justice may have the power to make a general order over a certain period—I name one year as the period, but I am not bound by that term; six months, or something to that effect, would serve the same purpose—in regard to exemptions for purposes which would recur at stated intervals, as, for instance, fairs. Some District Justices have been inclined to make a general order upon one application, namely, that exemptions shall be granted for, say, any fairs that take place in the district during a certain period, and that order would be granted upon one application. Other District Justices have thought otherwise, and have insisted that there should be a separate application in each case, and in order to clear the matter up and to enable District Justices to make that general order upon one application, and thus save inconvenience and unnecessary cost, I propose that it shall be legal for a District Justice, in future, to grant a general order. I hope the Minister will see his way to accept it.

Comment on this

I agree with the Deputy that this is a non-controversial amendment. The only question that arises is as to its necessity. If the Deputy will read again line 11 in sub-section (1) he will see there that "on such days and during such times and upon such terms as may be specified in such order." My submission is that these words are quite broad enough to meet what the Deputy desires to meet. I understand the Deputy's point perfectly: he fears it will be necessary to apply for a special order for each occasion, say for each market or fair, but, as I read it, there is nothing in the section that would prevent a Justice giving an exemption for a period of one year or more or less. I am prepared to look into the section, and if the Attorney-General, or the draftsman, tells me that there is anything vague, anything that would even give rise to doubts as to the power of the Justice, I will see what will be the best way to make the matter clear. I am quite at one with the Deputy, that it is desirable that the Justice should have a more general power, and should not have to grant, for each specific case, a separate exemption order.

Comment on this

I am perfectly satisfied and ask leave to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I beg to move:

Before Section 5 to insert a new section as follows:—

(1) A Justice of the District Court upon it being proved to his satisfaction that it is necessary or desirable so to do for the accommodation of any considerable number of persons attending any football match or hurling match may grant (if he so thinks fit) to the holders of seven-day on-licences in respect of premises situate in his licensing area an order exempting such holders from the provisions of this Act relating to prohibited hours on any Sunday in respect of such premises and during such times in the afternoon as may be specified in such order.

(2) Every order so made in pursuance of this section shall contain as one of the terms thereof a condition that the holders of on-licences to whom such order is granted shall during such period of exemption supply on the licensed premises food and non-alcoholic drink at reasonable prices to any person demanding same.

(3) The holders of on-licences to whom such exemption order is granted shall if and so long as they comply with the terms of such order be exempt from any penalty for contravention in respect of such premises of the provisions of this Act relating to prohibited hours but not from any other penalty under this or any other Act.

(4) Any person or persons applying for an exemption order in pursuance of this section shall not less than twenty-four hours before making the application serve upon the officer in charge of the Gárda Síochána for the licensing area a notice of his or their intention to apply for the order setting out his or their name and address or names and addresses and the place, occasion and time for which the order is sought.

This new section proposes that where any football match or hurling match is taking place on a Sunday power should be given to the District Justice to make an exemption order in respect of that special day. I do not think that this can be regarded as in any way unreasonable, because many people have to come distances to those matches and, though it may be true in one sense that they would be bona fide travellers, at the same time, as the law is now proposed, that would not assist them in regard to the exempted cities and, also, it would really be of more general convenience to have them permitted openly to partake of refreshments in the ordinary way than to have to go to the door of licensed premises and make general explanations as to where they have come from and as to their qualifications to be served as bona fide travellers.

I have put in a provision that wherever drink is served food also could be obtainable, and I hope that the Minister will favourably consider this. There have been certainly great inconveniences in the past, in relation to huge crowds who have gathered upon those occasions. I have not made the section very wide; I have limited it to the matter of football matches and hurling matches. I have not proposed it for public meetings or anything of that sort. I think it is not asking too much that the Minister should favourably consider this, and make refreshments accompanied by meals or a provision that meals shall be served with them, available for people who come for that purpose to those various centres.

Comment on this

I also would like to urge upon the Minister the advisability of accepting this amendment. I look upon it from the point of view of the impossibility of administering the present licensing laws on such occasions. I have seen a crowd in one of the towns in my county in connection with a very important hurling match, and in actual practice all the publichouses were open to all classes of travellers, bona fide and otherwise. It was quite impossible for the Gárda to supervise or do anything in the way of attempting to enforce the law. As a matter of fact, I really believe there was some kind of understanding, not in actual words, perhaps, to the effect that the Gárda were not going to make any attempt to enforce the law in regard to non-bona fide travellers.

Difficulties arose in connection with the matches in other towns, as the publichouses on the way were obliged to keep their doors open. Some of the publicans were summoned for allowing non-bona fide travellers on their premises. In the circumstances, I would say that it was almost impossible for these publicans to guard against offending in that way. Immense crowds passed through the towns and they were looking for food and drink in the publichouses and hotels. Some of the publicans were actually prosecuted. I think, under such conditions, it would be impossible to administer the present law, and I urge on the Minister the advisability of giving the amendment serious consideration.

Comment on this

The idea of exemption orders was confined, hitherto, to public markets, fairs or occasions for people following some particular trade assembling at unusual hours. The Deputy's proposal seeks to extend the idea to large concourses attending a big football or hurling match on Sunday. I prefer to adhere to the position that, for occasions like that, the provisions of Section 13 of the Bill will have to be relied upon—the bona fide section. I anticipated the objection, that that is very well for the country towns, but that for the four cities some special provision should be made owing to the fact that the Bill has no exemption in favour of bona fide travellers in county boroughs on Sunday. The publichouses in these four cities are allowed to open from two to five, and hotels can supply drink with meals from one to three, and from six to nine. Further, intoxicating liquor is not, so far as I am aware, the only form of sustenance. I am not prepared to accept the amendment. I realise, with Deputy Heffernan, that on occasions on which large crowds of people come to a town there may be some little difficulty and some need for special vigilance on the part of the police to see that the bona fide aspect of the law is adhered to. He suggests that because that is so the remedy is to throw the publichouses fully open to all comers, locals and visitors, a thing that on an occasion like that is most likely to lead to undue crowding of the publichouses, possible excesses, and possible turbulence, and riot. I am not attracted by the amendment and I advise the Committee to reject it.

Comment on this

The net result of the Minister's statement seems to be that, while visitors to areas other than the exempted cities may have some means of procuring intoxicating liquor under the provisions relating to bona fide travellers, similar visitors to the exempted cities will have no such means except within the hours of two and five, and, I may add, if they are able, to go to hotels. I wonder does the Minister realise that the very hours he speaks of, two to five, are the hours during which these football and hurling matches take place.

It is not during the hours, two to five, that refreshments are required, but immediately before and immediately after these hours. The fact that in Dublin, Cork, Limerick and Waterford the citizens can get drink between two and five will be very little consolation to the people who come from the country to Dublin, or go from Dublin to Waterford or Cork, to witness a football or hurling match, which will actually take place within these very hours.

I would submit to the Minister that there is a strong case for something to be done for the exempted cities in this respect. He has mentioned that the people would be entitled to go to hotels under a later section in this Bill, and there partake of a substantial meal, and if they desire, also intoxicating liquor. He knows, as well as I do, that the great bulk of people that go to these football matches are not those who can go to hotels. Very often they take their lunches with them by way of sandwiches, and if they did go to hotels there are not sufficient hotels to accommodate them. There have been, here in Dublin, some 20,000 to 40,000 people present at some of the great finals in the football or hurling field.

It is for the bulk of the people I am asking the Minister to have some regard, people who would not be able to afford to go to hotels and, who, therefore, owing to the present position, if they came to any of the exempted cities would not, in the first place, have the advantage of the bona fide section, and, in the second place, would not be able to get their drinks without leaving the football or hurling field which they actually came to visit. I think there is a strong case on this question, and I would ask the Minister to reconsider the matter. I am not pressing the case from the point of view of areas outside the exempted cities because there they have, it is true, a certain facility in the shape of the existing bona fide provisions. Anyone who goes to the exempted cities of Cork, Waterford, Dublin and Limerick, for the purpose of witnessing a football or hurling match can get no liquid refreshment except during the very hours that the hurling and football match is going on or unless they are able to go to hotels and have a substantial meal. With great respect I would ask the Minister to reconsider his attitude on this and, if possible, make some provision for these people on the next stage of the Bill.

Comment on this

Might I point out that any traveller who has a ticket can get refreshments at the railway termini.

Comment on this

I would like to see Deputy Wilson fighting his way at Amiens Street, or any other railway terminus, trying to get refreshments on a day such as I mention.

Comment on this

I am afraid the amendment is rather wide. Personally, I should not care to see the publichouses flung open on Sundays for every football and hurling match held throughout the country, or even held in the city. But I think the Minister might consider the question of meeting Deputy Redmond with regard to provincial and all-Ireland finals. What Deputy Redmond has said with regard to all-Ireland finals in Dublin is quite correct. It has been a complaint on the part of many people from different parts of the country that not only can they not get drink on these occasions in the city but that they cannot get even food. The great majority of the people attending those finals are not people who can afford to go into hotels, because they are not in a position to pay the prices that would be charged. Many of them are very poor people who take one day off in the year to see an all-Ireland final. They have to put a few shillings together in order to travel on that one day in the year.

I was certainly struck with what happened in Thurles last year—a matter to which Deputy Heffernan has referred. There were two matches played there and in that small town, of 4,000 or 5,000 population, you had 30,000 visitors from all over the country. It was quite obvious to everybody that the publichouses were open as on an ordinary week-day, and that the law was not sought to be enforced. I think the Gárda were quite right in their attitude, because it would have been almost impossible to enforce the law in the circumstances. If the Gárda had insisted on the law being carried out, many of the visitors would have to return—some of them to Cork and Kerry —that night without any refreshment whatsoever. I think the Minister should consider the insertion in this Bill of a provision which would leave it in the discretion of the District Justice to grant an exemption order in the case of a big match, such as a provincial final or an all-Ireland final in Dublin or in the provinces. That would probably meet the desires of most people. I certainly think that we could not expect the Minister to agree that publichouses should be allowed to open freely on Sundays for every football or hurling match held in the country.

Comment on this

If the amendment is withdrawn, without prejudice to the Deputy's right to bring it up again at a later stage, I will consider the points that have been urged, and I will see whether it would be possible to introduce any new provision on Report. If it is not possible to do so, I will notify the Deputies interested in sufficient time to enable them to bring up any amendment they please on Report.

Comment on this

I move:—

Before Section 12 to insert a new section as follows:—

"Nothing in this Act shall operate to prohibit the holder of an on-licence in respect of premises which are for the time being a hotel or restaurant supplying intoxicating liquor to any person on such premises on any week-day, not being a Saturday, between the hours of ten o'clock in the evening and midnight, and on any Saturday between the hours of half-past nine o'clock in the evening and midnight, provided such intoxicating liquor is—

(a) ordered by such person at the same time as a substantial meal is ordered by such person,

(b) is consumed at the same time as and with such meal.

(c) is supplied and consumed in the portion of such premises usually set apart for the supply of such meals, and

(d) is paid for at the same time as such meal is paid for."

This amendment is intended to make provision for the supply of intoxicating liquor with suppers under the conditions already prescribed by the Minister in Section 11: that is to say, that it should be open to the proprietor of a hotel or restaurant, and of no place other than a hotel or restaurant, as defined in Section 1 of the Bill, to supply liquor with a supper, which is in itself a substantial meal, the liquor being ordered at the same time as the meal, being consumed at the same time, and being paid for at the same time. Seventeen years ago I was partly responsible for bringing into law the Hotels and Restaurants (Dublin) Act, which made it possible under definite restrictions for liquor to be supplied with suppers in Dublin. I am glad to see that the Minister has accepted that Act, has embodied it in his Bill, and has even extended it. But there are one or two imperfections in that Act. For instance, in order to take advantage of the Act, it is necessary that application be made in court; it is necessary that a solicitor be instructed; it is necessary that at least 24 hours' notice be given. Though the Act is useful, it only operates in the case of large parties, where it is worth while for the hotel or restaurant proprietor to employ a solicitor and pay his fee for making application in court. It only operates, too, in a case where the supper is premeditated some time ahead, so that it is possible to give the order and give 24 hours' notice. In almost every capital city of the world that I have knowledge of, an individual, without organising a party, can go into a restaurant, order a substantial meal in the form of supper and take alcoholic liquor with it. I should except from that the cities of Canada, Australia and the United States. Ostensibly you cannot do so in those cities. But in London, Paris, Rome and most of the capital cities of the world one can order a substantial meal and have a bottle of wine or a glass of whiskey with it. You do not have to go through all the formulae that you have to go through here—applications and notice and so on. If we are trying to develop our tourist trade, and if we are to put not only Dublin, but Cork, Limerick and even country towns on the same plane in regard to the attraction of visitors as London, Paris and Rome, we might as well harmonise our licensing regulations. The conditions and stipulations laid down in this amendment are those suggested by the Minister himself in regard to the supply of liquor on Sundays and other prohibited days. I do not think that this is a provision which lends itself to abuse. To begin with, "hotels" and "restaurants" are very carefully defined. There are not an immense number of hotels with sleeping accommodation for more than ten persons in any of the small country towns. The amendment applies only to a very limited number of houses. I believe it is a workable amendment, and I would urge its adoption by the Committee.

Comment on this

I support Deputy Cooper's amendment. The Minister has acted so reasonably in the conduct of this Bill that I am sure he will consider Deputy Cooper's arguments. It is only fair and reasonable that this measure of liberty should be given to the owners of hotels and restaurants.

Comment on this

I desire to support the amendment moved by Deputy Cooper. I think the Minister himself, on the Second Reading of the Bill, put forward the idea that a person having a substantial meal in a restaurant or hotel should be entitled to get a drink, and that is what this amendment asks. I think that Deputy Cooper put forward this amendment not on his own behalf, not directly from himself, but from the people who are interested in the hotel and restaurant business, not alone in Dublin but in the other exempted cities. I am quite sure the Deputy did not move the amendment on behalf of two or three or four people, but on behalf of all the entire hotel proprietors in the exempted cities. When the 1923 Bill was before the House the Minister, speaking to an amendment that was then moved by Deputy Cooper, said he was at a loss to know what was the meaning of a substantial meal. It means this: that if a person goes into a hotel or restaurant and orders a substantial meal consisting of eggs and tea—I would call that a substantial meal—and wishes to have a drink with it during prohibited hours for the ordinary licensed trader, he is entitled to have it. I hope that the Minister, taking into account the mover of the amendment, will accept it. It would be quite different if I were the mover of it, or Deputy O'Connell or Deputy Everett. I am sure it will have great weight with the Minister because it is being moved by Deputy Major Cooper. Of course he is a Deputy of this House, and a Major in the British Army.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Deputy will have to discuss the amendment, not the mover of it.

Comment on this

I can discuss the proposer of the amendment.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Certainly not.

Comment on this

For the reasons put forward by the mover of it, I hope this amendment will be accepted by the Minister. I think it is necessary that the proprietors of hotels and restaurants should get the facilities asked for. I think the amendment is a fair one and I support it strongly.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

It is quite improper to say that the Deputy is putting forward the amendment on behalf of a particular interest outside the Dáil. The Deputy is putting forward the amendment himself.

Comment on this

I did not maintain that the Deputy put forward the amendment on instructions from a party. I said that he put forward the amendment not on behalf of two or three people, but on behalf of the general body of proprietors of hotels and restaurants.

Comment on this

Perhaps the personal explanation had better come from me. Like every other Deputy who takes an active part in the proceedings of the Dáil, I am frequently approached with suggestions for amendments to be moved. I reject many more of them than I adopt, and I never adopt any amendment that does not appear to me a sound one. I do not think that I have ever adopted one in the form in which it was suggested to me. I draft every one of my amendments myself, and have never taken up any that I was not prepared to stand over as representing my own opinions and my own views. That is one thing that I will not do. The other thing that I will not do is, to to take up Deputy Lyons' speeches second-hand and repeat them as my own.

Comment on this

I should like to support Deputy Cooper's purpose in moving this amendment, not for the reasons stated by the last speaker, but for some of the reasons stated by the mover. The amendment, as drafted, would appear to facilitate any one in a hotel who was not there on a particular occasion, but who happened to be there on an ordinary week-day or Saturday, in obtaining intoxicating liquor with a meal after prohibited hours and up to midnight. I think that suggestion is both desirable and reasonable.

There are many occasions when exemption orders would not have to be asked for or would not perhaps be granted, when people find themselves away from their home, not necessarily at a sufficient distance to render them bona fide travellers, and it would be only right that they should be able to partake of liquor in the shape of intoxicants with whatever they have in the nature of supper. Many people, young and old, go to dances which may last after the hours for the sale of intoxicating liquor. It may occur in a hotel and they may require supper and something to drink with that supper. Especially in cities like Dublin, there should be some facility in this matter. As Deputy Cooper has said, in practically every other country in the world, at least its capital, is facilitated in this way, but his amendment is not confined, as far as I read it, to Dublin. In that respect I desire to support it, because elsewhere the same state of affairs might well exist in districts, especially pleasure resorts, seaside and others, where people are gathered in hotels, and are not strictly without the limit of the bona fide traveller. There is nothing extraordinary in this proposal. It is in existence in England, and we have been told heretofore throughout the discussion on this Bill of the restrictions——

Comment on this

Did the Deputy say England or London?

Comment on this

I said England.

Comment on this

Is it throughout England?

Comment on this

I could not say. London is in England.

Comment on this

I am aware of that and so is the Deputy.

Comment on this

It is in England and in the capital, which, I presume, is London. The fact that there are other restrictions with regard to the sale of intoxicating liquor in England has been mentioned to us here in support of further restrictions. I submit, on the same lines, that if the sale and consumption are permitted in parts of England certainly there should be no reason why the same should not be permitted here. The conditions are very similiar. Both are capital cities and both are more or less the centre of society, for what it is, in their respective countries. Therefore, I desire to support this proposal, because I believe it is not asking for any further extension in regard to reasonable restrictions, but is merely asking for the application of principles which are recognised everywhere, especially in countries where the restrictions on the sale of liquor are generally greater than they are here.

Comment on this

I should not say that I am not here for the whole of the Saorstát, in common with other Deputies, but I cannot avoid saying that I am particularly interested in the city of Dublin. There is a lot of camouflage about this amendment. To me it appears that it is legislating for the man, citizen or visitor, who has money, against the man or woman who has not, in other words, legislating for the rich and not for the poor, and assisting the rich to get drink in a manner in which the poor man cannot get it.

Comment on this

I would like to support this amendment if it were made general to the Saorstát.

Comment on this

I should like a hotel or restaurant to be clearly defined. I suggest it be left to the superintendent of police to visit a house, with "restaurant" written over it, and see whether there was sufficient accommodation inside it to give substantial meals. This will give rise, from time to time, to an amount of trouble and suspicion, but at the same time there are a great many people coming into towns and villages over the country who would be able to get a substantial meal in a publichouse or hotel that they would not be able to get in a private house as satisfactory or as digestible. I would not like to see it confined to the great cities or the high-class hotels. If I am assured by the Minister that this is going to be made general throughout the country and that it would be left to the discretion of a superintendent to determine when a house is fit to be a restaurant, then I am prepared to support it.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will refuse to accept this amendment for the very reasons Deputy Redmond mentioned about dances. I see nothing objectionable in dances. They will go on to the end of time. But what I see very objectionable is the fact that young people go to a dance and have a sit-down supper where bottles of wine, champagne and intoxicants of other kinds can be ordered and taken by those young people just because the drink is accompanied by a substantial meal. It is within the knowledge of all of us that young people have been ruined by going to those suppers and they have been drawn to the use of intoxicants by having those suppers. I hope the Minister will unhesitatingly refuse to accept this amendment. We know very well that "How oft the sight of means to do ill deeds makes ill deeds done" is true. If they sit down to supper they will partake of intoxicants. The downward path is very easy. I hope the Minister will emphatically refuse to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Deputy one question. Can I? Do you ——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Deputy cannot ask a question in that way.

Comment on this

Can I ask through you?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

No. The Deputy must sit down.

Comment on this

I realise that an amendment which secures the joint support of Deputy Cooper and Deputy Lyons is deserving of the deepest consideration.

Comment on this

When you had the support of Deputy Lyons in 1916 you did not say that.

Comment on this

I forgot that.

Comment on this

You forget that and a lot now.

Comment on this
DEPUTIES

Order, order.

Comment on this

It is all right.

Comment on this

It seems to me that the objection made by Deputy Myles Keogh is a sound one, that in effect this amendment is class legislation. It simply means that whereas we will have one set of laws and one closing hour for the ordinary citizen, for the other different type of citizen to whom 5/-., 6/- or 7/- is a small matter, the closing hour shall be midnight. For the citizen who will turn into a hotel or turn into a restaurant and order what Deputy Cooper, like myself in another section, describes as a substantial meal, there shall be no closing hour until the clock strikes twelve. I know that superficially a case can be made out for the amendment, but, on the other hand, one has to consider just how a section of this kind would work out in practice. What it would mean is that for a preliminary tax of 5/-, 6/- or 7/6 one can buy three additional hours for the consumption of intoxicating liquor. Deputies have to make up their own minds as to the desirability of that, and just how we would like this City and this State of ours to develop. Deputy Cooper holds up the ideal that we should be the giddy competitor of London, Paris and Rome, and that we should develop a night life of our own, and generally we are told that this amendment is one calculated to develop the tourist traffic and throw the other capitals of the world that have hitherto been centres of gaiety, into the shade. I think that this tourist traffic argument can be pressed too far. If it means that we are to mould our social life and our social development here, not so much along the lines of thought of the residents of our own State as along the lines of thought and fancy of hypothetical potential visitors to our own State, I disagree.

At every turn you are told: "Do not do this or you will annoy the tourists," or "Do not do that or you will annoy the tourists." Some seem to suggest that the old Victorian idea that Sunday might be a day different from any other day in the matter of the sale and consumption of intoxicating liquor is to go by the board for fear that the tourists would not come to this country. We might run too far along those lines. All our ideas of restraint, sobriety and temperance and the restrictions which seem necessary or advisable in order to maintain or retain those ideals are to be sacrificed now to some hypothetical tourist who will turn his back on us if he cannot drink until 12 o'clock at night.

I am not prepared to accept the amendment, and I am certaintly not prepared to accept the amendment now in this Bill. This Bill does not exhaust the recommendations of the Intoxicating Liquor Commission. We have put aside and left over for a future Bill certain of the recommendations, amongst which particularly is the question of codifying licences and dealing with hotel licences. Deputy Redmond and Deputy Cooper talked at one moment about the capital, and the desirability of developing a hectic night life in our capital as in other capitals.

They were careful to point out, in order to soothe and comfort Deputy Daly, that the amendment applies to the entire State. Now, what is the hotel in the average provincial town or village? A publichouse with a few spare bedrooms upstairs, in which a chance visitor may be lodged. And with the preliminary tax of a substantial meal, which might be fish and chips, there need not be a closing hour until midnight. If we are to go into this question of hotel licences and of separate licences for hotels and possibly separate regulations for hotels, then we have to define very carefully what we mean and what we do not mean by a hotel for the purpose of any concessions of the kind that are sought here. The position under the Bill is that people staying in a hotel can get a drink at any hour. Section 12 (e) provides that. The point of this amendment is to extend this to people not actually stopping in the hotel, with the limitation that if they are to drink until midnight they have to eat or order and pay for a substantial meal. There are some people who, with no particular appetite, would be prepared to order a substantial meal costing 4/- or 5/- for the sake of an additional two or three hours for the consumption of intoxicating liquor.

Comment on this

Question.

Comment on this

Deputy Lyons does not know any people like that. Possibly Deputy Cooper does, and possibly Deputy Redmond does. I am not accepting the amendment.

Comment on this

It is with great regret that I find myself in disagreement with Deputy Mrs. Collins-O'Driscoll. I would like to point out to her that she has been supporting a Bill, and that under that Bill, which she and others have been supporting, all the evils she deplores at dances are possible. Section 5 of this Bill gives power to grant exemptions in the case of dances. All the dances held in Dublin are getting exemptions. My amendment meets the case of a man and his wife who might motor into the theatre a distance of 20 miles and who might want to get something to eat, possibly a whiskey and soda and a glass of wine. Dances got exemption and can get exemption still.

Comment on this

Might I interrupt— anyone motoring 20 miles into Dublin would be a bona fide traveller and he would be entitled to get a drink.

Comment on this

Very well, I will say nine miles to satisfy Deputy Wilson.

Comment on this

Three miles.

Comment on this

No, nine miles. However, I will not go into that matter. It is almost as rare to find Deputy Myles Keogh and the Minister audibly in agreement as to find Deputy Lyons and myself. I was surprised to find the Minister taking up Deputy Myles Keogh's cry that this was class legislation.

If my amendment can be considered as class legislation, then Section 11 is equally class legislation. Both provide for people who could afford to go to hotels and restaurants and order meals. I am not ashamed to admit to Deputy Myles Keogh that I do want to cater for the rich; I do want to attract rich people to this country. I want to retain the comparatively small number of rich people that we have in the country by offering them similar amenities to those offered in other countries. The people who will benefit most come under two headings. One is a small class—the Minister for Finance— and the other class is the poor. Amongst the latter class are the taxi-drivers and waiters. Any number of trades in the city of Dublin would benefit by visits of the rich. They will not raise any cry of class legislation.

That point of desiring to offer equal amenities with other great cities. I think, covers all the Minister says about starting night life here. I do not suppose there will be any violent or extended night life in Dublin, similar, for instance, to what one would expect in London. I remember the time when London was more or less a dead city after half-past eleven at night. There must be some development in Dublin just as there has been in other cities. In other places that development is noticeable and it is almost inevitable that it will apply here, and if we do not share in that development we shall find ourselves left in a backwater.

About two years ago, in a burst of that candour that occasionally assails Ministers when they get on a public platform, the Minister for Justice informed the world that Ministers always put more into a Bill than they intended to carry. I am quite sure the Minister spoke the truth. More recent observation has persuaded me that Ministers do put more in a Bill than they ever intend or think it possible to carry. Even at the risk of losing Deputy Daly's support, I will say that I put more in my amendment than I thought I would carry.

I suggest a strong case has been made out for the four county boroughs, and if the Minister will accept the four county boroughs, though I shall drop a tear in the Lake of Killarney and possibly another on the slopes of Kilworth mountain, I would accept that as a fair compromise.

Can the Minister give us any date when this system of codification in relation to restaurants is to be brought in? That matter seemed to me to be one of the most important reforms suggested by the Intoxicating Liquor Commission. It is ridiculous to class a large city restaurant, behind which there is a very considerable amount of capital, on the same basis as the country publichouse.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

Well, they do an entirely different class of business. If I went into one of our country publichouses and ordered Vol-au-vent a la Bordelaise, I would be very curious to see what I had got.

Comment on this

You might get as good stuff there as anywhere else.

Comment on this

It is unreasonable for the Minister to put up that defence —to say "Wait for codification and wait for a more definite classification," without indicating when we are to receive it. I believe that that particular matter is an essential part of the report of the Intoxicating Liquor Commission. I believe that all their recommendations were contemplated to be adopted in conjunction with their report. If the Minister says "I will not accept this now because we have not yet proceeded with the codification," I think I am entitled to press that he will give us an idea when he is going to proceed with this codification.

Comment on this

I do not at all agree with Deputy Cooper in his last statement. He is prepared even to accept a compromise with the Minister for Justice to exempt from the Bill all the hotels and restaurants outside the four county boroughs. I do not think that is right. Before one gets a hotel licence one must have, at least, ten bedrooms and not, as the Minister for Justice said a few moments ago, four or five rooms. That is not so. One must have, at least, ten bedrooms, and the place must be capable of accommodating at least ten paying guests before one is entitled to a hotel licence.

Take the case of a man who goes from the city to Mullingar, Athlone, Longford, Clonmel, Carrick-on-Suir, or anywhere else. If he takes a friend in with him to have lunch in any hotel surely that friend should be entitled to get refreshments just the same as the man himself is entitled as a bona fide traveller. Deputy Cooper says that, even suffering the loss of Deputy Daly's support, he is quite agreeable to compromise with the Minister to exempt rural districts from this amendment. If Deputy Cooper put forward this amendment on behalf of the hotel and restaurant proprietors ——

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this

Then he put it forward, not alone on behalf of a certain section of that class, but on behalf of the entire lot in the Saorstát. Surely, Deputy Cooper will do as much for the hotel proprietor in Clonmel as the hotel proprietor who lives in Dublin, or is Deputy Cooper going to be led by the men who live in Dublin, because they are the men who can vote for him while the men in Clonmel cannot? Is that the Deputy's idea?

I would like to be quite clear on this amendment. I intend to support it as it stands, and I hope Deputy Cooper will put it forward in its present terms. If there is an understanding that on the Report Stage the Minister will introduce something that would cover the substance of this amendment, I am quite satisfied, but I would first like to get that assurance.

It is necessary that the hotels and restaurants should have additional hours for supplying intoxicating drink with a substantial meal. Licensed traders, on the whole, do not supply substantial meals. They have their shops open for the sale of intoxicating drink—according to the licensing laws in the Saorstát—from 9 in the morning until 10 at night. The hotel is different. The hotels have a greater interest at stake than the ordinary licensed trade.

Hotel premises are of more value than licensed houses, and it is necessary, if you agree with capitalism as, apparently, the Minister does, to try to facilitate hotel proprietors. The Dáil should, therefore, in my opinion, accept the amendment, or at least replace it by some provision that will cover the point for the whole Saorstát.

Comment on this

My name has been trotted out a few times during the last quarter of an hour, and I would like to point out to the Minister that I have not the slightest sympathy for any man who can get into a hotel, and have a good substantial meal but not get a drink with it. My sympathy is with the poor man who has to trudge along the road and take a drink to enable him to travel, but not to enable him to digest a substantial meal in a hotel.

Comment on this

Deputy Cooper has urged this amendment on the attention of the Dáil, first on the plea that it would be advantageous to the tourist traffic and, secondly, that it would encourage the rich section of the community to remain in the country, giving them leave to spend their money and enjoy themselves in any way they desire. At the risk of expressing a view that will probably meet with a good deal of opposition, I would, at the outset, like to question the value of the tourist traffic as an asset to this country. I think that tourist traffic from abroad would be a very doubtful asset, for one or two reasons. It means that a certain proportion of our population would look forward to deriving their support from, at least to a certain extent, charitable contributions of visitors. It would not be conducive to employment, but would be a demoralising influence. To my mind, if we could induce Irish people to spend their holidays here, we would do far more useful work.

With regard to catering for the rich and keeping pace with developments in Europe, if you cater for the rich in this way are you sure that you can confine it to the rich? The example of rich people enjoying these privileges over people who cannot afford them would, to my mind, be very injurious. The extravagance of the very rich is one of the most corrupting influences in the present social system, especially as regards classes who cannot afford the expenditure of the rich, but who are continually trying to ape their manners and extravagances. If you could segregate the rich, and if you could ensure that their example would not be copied by people who could not afford it, there might be something to be said in favour of Deputy Cooper's amendment. In view of the risk of corrupting a much larger section of the community, I do not think that this amendment would be of benefit in a country like this. For these reasons I oppose it.

Comment on this

I would not enter upon this discussion except for the remarks of Deputy McCurtain. Without desiring to be offensive, I may say that I have not heard during the discussion this evening any remarks displaying more ignorance of the subject matter under discussion than those of Deputy McCurtain, who is one of the men we recognise as an intellectual. The Deputy says that bringing in a foreign influence would corrupt us. In the name of all the eternal verities if we cannot stand a foreign invasion of that kind and make use of it to supply us with cash, our moral standard is not strong. Deputy Cooper told us that the means of accommodation in hotels and restaurants should be free from certain restrictions. I agree with him. The Minister may have different views, but, in my opinion, this is an exceeding reasonable amendment, and if the Deputy pushes it to a division I will support it.

Comment on this

I support this amendment mainly for the one reason given by Deputy Cooper, namely, that we may attempt to cater for the tourist traffic. I am in disagreement with the remarks of the Deputy from my county, deprecating the tourist traffic, because I believe that an influx of tourists can be turned into a very valuable asset for the country. We are all aware that these countries which cater for this particular class of traveller try to provide entertainment and amusement for them, and unless they do so, people will not visit them but will go where such entertainment and amusements are provided. If we ask tourists to come here I think we should try to provide facilities for their enjoyment.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

took the Chair.

Comment on this

It is all very fine to talk about being democratic, but we cannot be democratic in everything, and in this matter we are dealing with a particular class of people who largely come from outside. I think from some of the statements made by Deputy Mrs. Collins-O'Driscoll that she must be under a slight misapprehension, for as I understand the purport of the amendment, its effect would not be that people attending dances could get intoxicating drink at any time during a dance on buying a substantial meal. As I understand the custom at those dances is that one substantial meal is served.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation, that is exactly what I said: The proprietors of hotels need not apply for an exemption for dances if this amendment were carried. If the amendment were adopted people attending the dances could get bottles of wine or intoxicants of any kind with a sit-down supper.

Comment on this

I do not want to misunderstand Deputy Mrs. Collins-O'Driscoll. I appreciate her point of view fully, but I think the amendment would not have the effect she says. It would not be practicable to order a substantial meal at any time during a dance. That would not be likely to happen. What would happen is that one substantial meal would be provided, and at that drink would be available, but not at any other time. I think this amendment has more in favour of it than against it. It is not perhaps desirable from every point of view, but it has certain advantages, and I recommend it to the serious consideration of the Ministry.

Comment on this

Can the Minister give any answer to my question about further legislation dealing with hotels and restaurants, and when he thinks he can introduce that?

Comment on this

I will guarantee to the Deputy that it would not be sooner than a year's time.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

took the Chair.

SECTION 13.

(1) Nothing in this Act shall operate to prohibit—

(a) the holder of an on-licence in respect of premises situate in a county borough from selling intoxicating liquor for consumption on such licensed premises to bona fide travellers at any time on any week day, or

(b) the holder of an on-licence in respect of premises not situate in a county borough from selling intoxicating liquor for consumption on such licensed premises to bona fide travellers

(i) at any time on any week-day, or

(ii) on Saint Patrick's Day between the hours of one o'clock and three o'clock in the afternoon or between the hours of five o'clock and seven o'clock in the afternoon, or

(iii) if his licence is not a six-day licence, on any Sunday between the hours of one o'clock and three o'clock in the afternoon or between the hours of five o'clock and seven o'clock in the afternoon.

(2) Every person who by falsely representing himself to be a bona fide traveller buys or obtains or who attempts by such false representation to buy or obtain on any licensed premises any intoxicating liquor during a period in which the sale of intoxicating liquor on such premises is prohibited by this Act shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding five pounds.

(4) For the purposes of this section a person shall not be a bona fide traveller unless the place where he lodged during the previous night is situate in a county borough and is at the least ten miles (measured by the shortest public thoroughfare) distant from the place where he demands to be supplied with intoxicating liquor, or the place where he lodged during the previous night is situate elsewhere than in a county borough and is at least six miles (similarly measured) distant from the place where he demands to be supplied with intoxicating liquor.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (1) (a), line 38, to add after the words "week day" the words "or at any time on any Sunday save between the hours of seven o'clock in the morning and one o'clock in the afternoon on the latter day."

This amendment refers exclusively to sub-section (1) (a) and that refers exclusively to boroughs. In effect, the Minister proposes by this sub-section as it now stands to alter the existing law in regard to county boroughs and to prevent bona fide traffic on Sundays in those county boroughs. What I propose is that we should revert to the existing law, and that in county boroughs there should be permitted bona fide traffic as at present. I see no reason, and so far the Minister has advanced no reason—I suppose we will hear from him now if he has any reasons to offer—why the law should be altered in regard to exempted cities in this respect. It is true there is no use in blinking the fact that in the city of Dublin, though it was possible to have bona fide traffic on Sundays under the existing law, yet at the same time, for one reason or another, by custom or practice, that has virtually died down, but that state of affairs does not exist in regard to the other county boroughs, namely, Cork, Limerick and Waterford. I do not know whether the Minister is inclined to draw any distinction between the county boroughs in this respect, but I would point out that there is a distinct difference between these cities, inasmuch as cities other than Dublin, which are known as exempted cities, are in reality not great centres of industrial, social, or, if you like, official population. They are largely great county towns, and they have a constant stream of people coming in and out of them from districts which might or might not be covered by the existing bona fide provisions.

I cannot see why the existing state of affairs, certainly in these three cities, should not be allowed to continue. There has not been, as far as I am aware, any special suggestion made by the Liquor Commission that there should be a change in this regard.

Comment on this

In regard to the exempted cities?

Comment on this

At the bottom of page 13. "No bona fide traffic should be permitted in any of the exempted cities."

Comment on this

What I mean to convey is that there has been no particular reference to the exempted cities, as distinguished inter se, and that is the real object of my amendment. As I have already explained, for reasons which I need not enter into, for some time past there has been no bona fide traffic in the city of Dublin. In the other exempted cities, certainly in the one for which I can speak, there has been a certain amount of this traffic, and no special argument has been put forward by the Liquor Commission to show why that particular form of traffic should not be continued. It seems particularly hard to realise why this special portion of the Bill has been suggested. In regard to Dublin there was really no necessity for it, because the state of affairs was as I have explained, and in regard to the other cities, I think that up to this—and, of course, I have to await what the Minister has to say upon the question— no case has been made why the existing provisions for bona fide travellers should not be continued. It is for these reasons that I have tabled this amendment, and I hope that the Minister will give serious consideration to the position of these other cities in this regard, as distinct from that of the city of Dublin.

Comment on this

The effect of the amendment is to enable bona fide travellers to be served in the county boroughs after one o'clock on Sundays, so that these four cities, in addition to having the facilities of a 2 to 5 opening, should be permitted to do a bona fide trade, contrary to the recommendation of the Commission which examined into this matter. The Deputy admitted that bona fide traffic had been eliminated from Dublin, that that was stamped out by the former Recorder of Dublin, probably by extra-legal action, but we are concerned with the fact that he took the view strongly that in the capital, where the 2 to 5 opening was allowed, there should not also be the bona fide system, and by various forms of pressure on members of the licensed trade in the city he did in fact bring about a situation where you had not, coincident with the 2 to 5 opening, a system of bona fide sales. If I may speculate about the reasons for that, I take it that as Dublin was served by so many railways and tramways he felt that it should not be free to people to pour into the city from the outskirts and to figure there for the remainder of the evening as bona fide travellers, when the facilities which the residents of the city enjoyed from 2 to 5 o'clock were adequate to deal also with that influx of visitors that might take place to the city during the course of a Sunday.

It is proposed to apply the same to the other county boroughs that have the 2 to 5 opening, and I consider it a reasonable proposal. Presumably they have the 2 to 5 opening on some such grounds as that the number of people coming into these cities in the course of any given Sunday would be so great that the sensible thing to do was to allow a brief opening rather than try to enforce there the bona fide system that is enforced throughout the rest of the country. I do not know on what grounds there came to be this exemption for the four county boroughs, but it is an exemption of very long standing, and it was once, in fact, a somewhat longer opening than the present three hours; it was reduced, I think, from five hours to three. But it does seem a reasonable and a proper thing to take the view that this opening for three hours in the afternoon should be adequate for these four cities, and that there should not be allowed, over and above that, a provision that, provided one has travelled the statutory distance into these cities, one may figure there up to a late hour in the night as a bona fide traveller. I think the recommendation of the Commission is a sound one, and I am not prepared to accept the amendment.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this